Master Plan 2012 For CLAREMONT CAMPUS Prepared: November 21, 2012 Approved : Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 I Table of Contents Executive Summary 1) 2) 3) 4) 5) 6) Introduction Purpose & Goals Existing Conditions Future Needs Development Capacity Campus Master Plan Elements Page (s) 1 1 2 2 3 3 Campus Master Plan Chapter 1 - History & Culture Chapter 2 - Master Plan Goals A) CGU Vision B) Planning Process C) Goals Chapter 3 - Existing Campus Conditions A) B) C) D) E) F) G) H) I) Campus Character Campus Land Holdings & Boundaries Land Use Campus Perimeter - Edges & Gateways Open Space & Landscape Pedestrian Circulation Vehicular Circulation Parking Zoning Factors Chapter 4 - Future Campus Requirements A) Student Enrollment & Faculty-Staff Projections B) Development Capacity C) Parking Capacity D) Campus Infrastructure Projections Chapter 5 - Master Plan Description A) B) C) D) Overall Campus Design Interface with Surrounding Community Building Pattern, Massing & Physical Characteristics Conceptual Design Guidelines 1. Setbacks 2. Building Height 3. Building Materials 4. Building Design and Sustainability Commitment E) Temporary Facilities Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 9 10 10 11 11 13 13 14 14 18 21 21 21 21 22 28 28 28 29 32 34 34 35 35 37 37 39 42 42 44 I Page F) Building Relocation G) Open Space & Pedestrian Circulation 1. Open Space 2. Landscape 3. Courtyards 4. Pedestrian Circulation 5. Mid-Block Pedestrian Crossings 6. Site Lighting 7. Site Signage & Furnishings H) Traffic Circulation & Parking 1. Vehicle Circulation 2. Private Streets/Alleys 3. Campus Parking Layout 4. Bicycle Circulation / Connections 5. Public Transportation I) Master Plan Description 1. Campus Master Plan Elements Chapter 6 - Administrative Procedures 44 45 45 45 47 47 52 52 53 53 53 55 55 57 58 58 58 62 List of Diagrams Aerial Photograph Illustrative Master Plan D-1 Existing Campus Diagram D-2 Existing Land Holdings & Boundaries Diagram D-3 Existing Use Diagram D-4 Existing Building Names & Addresses Diagram D-5 Existing Campus Edges & Gateways Diagram D-6 Existing Open Space & Landscape Diagram D-7 Existing Pedestrian Circulation Diagram D-8 Existing Vehicular Access Circulation Diagram D-9 Existing Parking Capacity Matrix D-10 Existing Park Capacity Map D-11 Development Capacity Diagram D-12 Parking Capacity Compliance Diagram D-13 Building Pattern & Use Diagram D-14 Building Height & Setback Diagram D-15 Site-Section Diagrams D-16 Parking Deck Setback Diagram D-17 Open Space Diagram D-18 Pedestrian Circulation Diagram D-19 Campus Vehicular Access Diagram D-20 Street Designations Diagram D-21 Illustrative Master Plan Diagram Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 6 7 15 16 17 19 20 23 24 25 26 27 30 31 36 38 40 41 46 49 54 56 61 II Appendices Appendices may be added following initial review of this Master Plan by the City of Claremont and as a part of the final approved document. Appendices may include: Environmental documents Campus Tree Survey Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 III Acknowledgements The Claremont Graduate University (CGU) Campus Master Plan 2012 represents the dedicated efforts of numerous individuals and associated organizations and groups over the span of several years. These individuals and groups actively participated in meetings, forums, gatherings, and presentations that resulted in having “conversations that matter” to create a vision for the future development of CGU. These efforts were essential in compiling the data contained in this Master Plan to outline the future facilities and growth and that will allow CGU to remain a premier institution delivering graduate education degree programs. Special recognition and thanks are extended to the members of the CGU Campus Physical Planning Committee (CPPC) whose members are representatives of the Board of Trustees, Executive Cabinet, academic deans, students, faculty, and staff. This committee’s tireless efforts to collect and synthesize the information to more clearly define our functional facility requirements are greatly appreciated. This plan especially benefitted from the extensive information provided by the CGU academic deans who articulated their facility needs to accommodate planned academic program and enrollment growth for CGU. We would also like to thank the following for participating and providing thoughtful feedback throughout the process: CGU Board of Trustees CGU Executive Cabinet CGU Faculty Executive Committee CGU Students, Faculty, and Staff Claremont University Consortium BOT, Facilities and Infrastructure Committee CGU Academic Deans CGU Graduate Student Council City of Claremont The Claremont Colleges The following professional consultants and organizations which have been instrumental in data collection, analysis, research, and presentations of the vision for CGU are also recognized for their contributions to this Master Plan. HMC Architects Robert Sabbatini, AICP FASLA MGT of America Linscott Law & Greenspan Davis Langdon Finally, we acknowledge the professional institutional planning approach of Brian R. Bloom Architect. Their guidance in identifying effective ways to transform the vision and information that was essential for meeting functional facility requirements that support the academic mission of the University was extremely helpful. This team exhibited great skill in combining the requirements into an integrated plan for CGU, which shows defined projects and allows for an incremental approach to execute a complete plan These individual projects provide the basis for establishing a capital fundraising plan to achieve the implementation of the plan. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 IV Executive Summary ES-1 Introduction The Claremont Graduate University (CGU) 2012 Master Plan for the Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus (CGU-CC) was developed with the participation of CGU Board of Trustees, administration, faculty, students and staff. The Master Plan proposes a method of maintaining and enhancing the overall qualities of the CGU-CC campus while simultaneously addressing CGU’s desires to enhance the physical campus and position CGU to be highly competitive among institutions offering similar academic programs. ES-2 Purpose & Goals The purpose of this Master Plan is to develop the campus to reflect the strategic vision and educational program of CGU during the 20 year life of the Master Plan for the CGU-CC. The master planning process took place during a 24 month period. The process began with academic planning that engaged the CGU administration, faculty, staff, and students. Work sessions solicited campus community input and discussion, focusing on the goals, student enrollment projections, space needs, development of alternative concepts and preparation of a master plan document. Goals a. To effectively use existing and future campus facilities to meet the current and future needs of the students and faculty. b. To enhance the relationship between the CGU-CC campus, the neighboring Claremont Colleges, and the larger Claremont community. c. To provide a creative approach for upgrading or replacing existing facilities to improve campus functionality while creating a positive interface with adjacent residential neighborhood and college campuses. d. To create a framework for the placement and form of future facilities. e. To re-organize vehicle and bicycle circulation, and parking, to support a pedestrianoriented campus that emphasizes open space and collegial interaction. f. To develop a cohesive development pattern with an efficient use of land. g. To embrace and practice sustainability in the renovation, construction, management, and maintenance of the campus. h. To improve the general safety and circulation within and about the campus by providing well-defined vehicle access to parking and safe pedestrian and bicycle circulation. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 1 ES-3 Existing Conditions The character of the CGU-CC campus is shaped by the long-narrow configuration of the current land holdings and the mix of academic and residential-scale buildings interspersed across the campus. The campus boundaries are not currently well-defined. The campus edges vary from block to block with the use of various landscape/hardscape themes. Pedestrian circulation primarily uses city sidewalks for access from parking lots and street parking to the academic buildings. Current campus vehicular traffic patterns take advantage of the local residential streets for access, circulation and street parking. Street parking is not controlled and campus related parking tends to encroach into the surrounding neighborhood streets at peak use times, such as the late afternoon and early evening hours. ES-4 Future Needs Student, Faculty and Staff Population Projections (20 years) A key factor in projecting space needs is student enrollment. The university plans to increase the number of masters-level students while holding the number of Ph.D. students constant or possibly making small reductions in some areas. Population projections of the various degree candidates directly affect the amount and type of facilities needed to support education, research and administration. The following information applies to the Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus (CGU-CC) only. Student population currently equals 1,420 Projected Student population equals 1,800 (which is a total increase of 380 students representing a 26.8% growth). Faculty & Staff population currently equals 334 Projected Faculty & Staff population equals 420 (which is a total increase of 86 faculty/staff representing a 25.7% growth). Space Needs Projections Current building area equals 227,786 assignable square feet (ASF) and 335,870 gross square feet (GSF). Based upon campus growth required to satisfy current and future programmatic needs and future population growth, the proposed building area will increase approximately 200,000 ASF to 427,786 ASF which will require up to 626,933 GSF excluding square footage required for parking decks and subterranean parking structures. Parking Capacity The current parking capacity at the campus and adjacent streets equals 747 parking spaces. Based upon current City standards the required parking capacity should equal 898 parking spaces; consequently, an additional 151 parking spaces will need to be constructed to bring the CGU-CC campus into compliance with current City standards. Planned future growth will require a minimum of 212 additional parking spaces to be added to the campus, bringing the total parking spaces to at least 1,110 spaces. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 2 ES-5 Development Capacity Floor Area Ratio The maximum allowable development capacity for the campus may be calculated using the Floor Area Ratio (FAR) as defined by the City’s zoning code. Under the City’s zoning code, the total building area is not permitted to exceed the land area of the total campus. The campus is 1,395,239 square feet in area. The campus includes all areas within the boundaries depicted in Diagram D-2, Existing Land Holdings. Based on FAR requirements this number also represents the maximum allowable building area that can be constructed on the current campus. Total constructed building area for the existing campus equals 335,870 GSF. The Master Plan would include 626,933 GSF, which results in a .45:1 FAR. Consequently, the Master Plan results in a build out that is less than half of what is allowed by City code. Maximum Lot Coverage Another constraint that affects development capacity is determined by the Maximum Lot Coverage, as defined by City code. Lot Coverage is defined as the total of the areas of the footprints of buildings, surface parking areas, and driveways. Per the City’s zoning code the Maximum Lot Coverage cannot exceed 60% of the total campus land. Because the total campus land area equals 1,395,239 SF, the Maximum Lot Coverage equals 837,143 SF. The proposed Lot Coverage for this Master Plan is 476,760 SF, which represents 34% of the total campus land. ES-6 Campus Master Plan Elements This Master Plan will include the following elements: The following elements are not presented in sequential order or phasing. Sequencing of the elements of the Master plan will be based on requirements of this Master Plan, operational needs of the University, and financial constraints and opportunities. 1. Relocate existing program building at 135 Twelfth Street, and remove/relocate other program buildings north of Twelfth Street as required to make way for new parking lot and new multi-purpose buildings. 2. Construct a new parking lot (maximum of 162 parking spaces) between Foothill Blvd. and Twelfth Street along the eastern side of the north-south alleyway, including the privatization of N. Dartmouth Place alley, which will be converted to a driveway. 3. Construct two (2) new multi-purpose buildings (combined GSF not to exceed 10,000 SF) to replace and supplement existing program buildings located between Twelfth Street and Foothill Blvd. 4. Create a central pedestrian circulation spine (Campus Walk) connecting parking to campus buildings and functions. The Campus Walk would extend midblock from Dartmouth Place alley south to Eighth Street. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 3 5. Privatize Twelfth Street, between the alley east of N. College Ave. and N. Dartmouth Ave. and add a mid-block pedestrian crossing. 6. Construct a new academic building, which will be a maximum of 3 stories in height plus basement level, 65 feet in height above grade, and which is not more than 80,000 GSF in size. The academic building may be served by a combination of surface parking and subterranean parking providing a maximum of 100 new parking spaces. 7. Remodel existing surface parking between Twelfth Street and Eleventh Street/Drucker Way to provide for a parking deck, providing a maximum of 102 new parking spaces. Combined total maximum of new and existing parking spaces to be 201 spaces. 8. Privatize Drucker Way (Eleventh Street), between the alley east of N. College Ave. and N. Dartmouth Ave. and add a mid-block pedestrian crossing. 9. Construct a new academic building at the Jagels Building site, which will be a maximum of 3 stories in height plus basement, 50 feet in height above grade and which is not more than 55,000 GSF in size. Existing facility is 12,000 SF, resulting in a maximum net add of 43,000 SF. 10.Privatize Tenth Street, between N. College Ave. and N. Dartmouth Ave. and add a midblock pedestrian crossing. 11. Renovate Harper Hall and Harper East-McManus Hall to consolidate university administrative functions and create a new Campus Commons including student services center. 12. Renovation of the DesCombes Quadrangle in the existing open space between Harper East, McManus Hall and Stauffer Hall to create a new Campus Commons courtyard. 13. Renovate Stauffer-Albrecht Building removing Albrecht portion of building and replacing with a new building addition, which will be a maximum of 2 stories in height plus basement, building height of 35 feet to approximately match existing Stauffer portion, and which is not more than a combined GSF of 28,000 SF. Existing Stauffer-Albrecht Building equals 15,177 GSF resulting in a maximum net add of 12,823 GSF. 14. Create an opening between Harper Hall and McManus with cascading stairs, elevator, and ramps to extend the central pedestrian circulation spine (Campus Walk) south to Eighth Street and improve site access. 15. Acquire the Huntley Bookstore site to consolidate the contiguous campus land holdings and enhance the campus center concept. Renovate existing building and/or construct a new academic building, which will be a maximum of 3 stories in height plus basement, 75 feet in height above grade, and which is not more than 90,000 GSF in size. The academic building may be served by a combination of surface parking and subterranean parking providing a maximum of 100 new parking spaces. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 4 16. Construct a new academic building at the northeast corner of N. College Ave. and Eighth Streets, which will be a maximum of 3 stories in height plus basement, maximum 50 feet in height above grade to match Academic Computing Building, and which is not more than 60,000 GSF in size. The academic building may be served by a combination of surface parking and subterranean parking providing a maximum of 100 new parking spaces. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 5 Aerial Photograph of Claremont Graduate University and surrounding vicinity with Boundary Overlay Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 6 Illustrative Master Plan Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 7 Claremont Campus Master Plan Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 8 Chapter 1 - History & Culture CGU is a unique, independent university devoted exclusively to graduate study, comprising five academic schools. CGU awards both M.A. and Ph.D. degrees in 22 disciplines. Claremont Graduate University was established in 1925 and is a member of the Claremont University Consortium (CUC) and the Claremont Colleges. The hallmarks of CGU-CC are the intimate scale of both its physical campus and its academic curriculum. CGU-CC students and faculty enjoy small classes and close working relationships within the context of a research institution. A majority of the CGU-CC students attend classes in the late afternoon and early evenings, while administrative staff work on the campus during regular business hours. This pattern of use has a significant impact upon the way the campus functions. The pattern of use is a particularly important factor in planning for parking, pedestrian circulation, student amenities, safety features, and impacts on the community. Claremont Graduate University possesses many strengths and a wonderful legacy. CGU is America’s sole graduate-only, research-intensive university. The CGU community is characterized by diversity, collegiality, and environmental beauty. CGU is one of the seven Claremont Colleges, a consortium built on the Oxford model that The Fiske Guide has called “the most extraordinary assemblage of educational excellence in the nation.” Over two hundred professors from the other Claremont Colleges and from the Claremont School of Theology collaborate in our teaching and research. Southern California, the most ethnically diverse region in the United States, provides CGU with a living laboratory for the study of important social trends, problems, and possibilities. Our tradition says, “follow the problem.” This means that our research and teaching transcend academic boundaries. Our University disregards artificial divides between theory and application. We believe that academic rigor and addressing big questions can go together. CGU’s first president, James Blaisdell, once said, “The center of a college is in great conversation, and out of the talk of college life springs everything else.” Our tradition values talking and listening across the disciplines, and taking on the big issues of our times. In our seminar rooms and through our research, our University catalyzes great conversations that matter. We educate superb economists and artists, mathematicians and managers—to name a few— who can engage in great conversations that matter. Conversations that are civil and humane, and value diversity in many dimensions. Conversations that aim to foster a better world. We want our graduates to have expertise, to appreciate diverse perspectives, to reframe problems, and to be able to work in teams. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 9 Chapter 2 - Master Plan Goals 2.A CGU Vision CGU is a member of the Claremont Colleges, which are represented by the Claremont University Consortium (CUC). CGU is unlike any other graduate-level university in the United States. Founded in 1925, CGU is an independent institution devoted entirely to graduate studies and extensive research. Five schools currently comprise the university: 1. Arts and Humanities 2. Behavioral and Organizational Sciences, Politics and Economics 3. Community and Global Health 4. Management and Sciences (includes) • Drucker-Ito School of Management • Information Systems and Technology • Mathematical Sciences 5. Educational Studies As expressed in "Great Conversations That Matter: A Strategic Plan for Claremont Graduate University, May 2008," CGU takes pride in providing an education that is intimate, transdisciplinary, and globally engaged." In preparing the Master Plan document the following guiding academic principals were identified and addressed: What is our ultimate goal? CGU's ultimate goal is to advance knowledge and contribute to a better world. Who we are? Claremont Graduate University is an intimate, student-focused center of graduate education that emphasizes a trans-disciplinary learning environment and a focus on both applied learning and research in its selected academic fields. What do we do? CGU prepares diverse students for critical, creative leadership responsibilities in an ever changing world that requires broad experience and sound judgment. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 10 How do we do it? CGU fulfills Its mission through leadership in graduate-level education and innovative research focusing on some of the world's most pressing problems. 2.B Planning Process The planning process involved assembling and reviewing available documentation regarding the University's history, philosophy, and current operations. In addition, documents describing the physical campus were gathered and reviewed including previous master plans, needs assessment studies, and infrastructure drawings. A study was undertaken by the campus provost that used historic enrollment information, fall 2008 enrollment and staffing information, and guidance provided by CGU senior leadership to develop a projected on-campus population of students, faculty, and staff. The planning process solicited the broadest range of viewpoints from all members of the campus community. The discussions focused on how the campus currently functions, its historical legacy, its current strengths and relative weaknesses, and its unique and defining characteristics. These discussions included the opinions of the campus community about the appropriate vision of the campus for the future. The planning process included presentations that captured the most representative views about current conditions and operating processes of the physical campus. With the existing condition overview, the campus community was able to review and critique various future options and provide insights and suggestions for the development of the Master Plan. 2.C Goals The following goals are intended to guide the development of the Master Plan and to provide the framework for translating the University's needs and values into the physical campus components of the Master Plan. The primary goals of the Master Plan are: Goals a. To effectively use existing and future campus facilities to meet the current and future needs of the students and faculty. b. To enhance the relationship between the CGU-CC campus, the neighboring Claremont Colleges, and the larger Claremont community. c. To provide a creative approach for upgrading or replacing existing facilities to improve campus functionality while creating a positive interface with adjacent residential neighborhood and college campuses. d. To create a framework for the placement and form of future facilities. e. To re-organize vehicle and bicycle circulation, and parking, to support a pedestrianoriented campus that emphasizes open space and collegial interaction. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 11 f. To develop a cohesive development pattern with an efficient use of land. g. To embrace and practice sustainability in the renovation, construction, management, and maintenance of the campus. h. To improve the general safety and circulation within and about the campus by providing well-defined vehicle access to parking and safe pedestrian and bicycle circulation. The following actions are intended to assist CGU in achieving the goals of this Master Plan. 1. Proposing a building pattern and massing of development that is sensitive to the existing character and scale of the campus and is consistent with that of the surrounding colleges and residential communities. 2. Identifying potential building and parking sites and proposing a strategy for making them available in a manner that develops and maintains open spaces and the pedestrian circulation spine. 3. Concentrating parking within the campus interior to reduce the number of automobile access points. 4. Minimizing vehicle traffic on adjacent residential streets by redirecting traffic to Dartmouth Ave. and then into designated parking areas with enhanced signage and access policies. 5. Creating a continuous pedestrian circulation spine within the campus interior, connecting buildings, parking areas, and gathering spaces. 6. Proposing the privatization of Tenth Street and portions of Eleventh, and Twelfth Streets, between College Ave. and Dartmouth Ave. to facilitate the installation of mid-block pedestrian crossings and traffic calming measures to further enhance the campus pedestrian experience and safety. 7. Demonstrating the viability and benefits of sustainable design and planning through implementation of the Master Plan. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 12 Chapter 3 - Existing Campus Conditions 3.A Campus Character CGU-CC has a unique campus character. The compact scale of the campus, the one-block width of the campus, and the residential scale of many of its existing buildings, contributes to an intimate campus setting. (Existing Campus Diagram D-1) The ceremonial and functional center of the campus is located in the block between N. College Ave. and N Dartmouth Ave. and between Eighth and Tenth Streets. The main administrative activities of the campus are housed in the historic Harper Hall and Harper Hall East. A significant percentage of campus classroom space is housed in McManus Hall, the Academic Computing Building, Stauffer / Albrecht Building, Harper Hall and the Burkle Building, making the blocks between Eighth to Eleventh Streets the center of the greatest academic and pedestrian activity. The existing buildings on campus can be characterized as a mixture of one, two and three-story academic and administration buildings. Examples are the 3 story Academic Computing Building and the 2 story Burkle Building, and single family residential structures dating from the 1920s that have been converted to program uses. The existing buildings range in age from the historical Harper Hall, circa 1926, to the newest Graduate Student Housing, completed in 2008. The scale and style of these structures, combined with the well-articulated massing of Harper Hall, the mature trees, and the small scale of the open spaces between many of the buildings, give the campus its distinctive and inviting character. Harper Hall Nov. 21, 2012 Graduate Student Housing Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 13 1237 Dartmouth Ave. Burkle Building 3.B Campus Land Holdings & Boundaries The main portion of the existing campus is bordered on the east by N. Dartmouth Ave., by Seventh Street on the south, and by Foothill Blvd. to the north. N. College Ave. bounds the campus on the west from Seventh to just north of Eleventh Street/Drucker Way, where the western boundary shifts eastward to the north/south alley midway between N. Dartmouth Ave. and N. College Ave. A portion of the campus area lies north of Foothill Blvd. and includes several undeveloped acres of land for future use not contemplated by this Master Plan and the graduate student housing completed in 2008. CGU-CC shares its western boundary with a residential neighborhood of single family houses. On the east are the larger-scale academic buildings of Scripps College and Harvey Mudd College and to the South lies Pomona College. To the north and east are additional land holdings of CUC and the Rancho Santa Ana Botanical Garden. The exhibit Existing Land Holdings & Boundaries (Diagram D-2) shows the CGU-CC land holdings and property boundaries. The CGU art program is housed in a building that is not contiguous to the rest of the campus. It is currently located one block east of N. Dartmouth Ave. on the south side of Eleventh Street, surrounded by Scripps College campus. 3.C Land Use The land use exhibit (Existing Use Diagram D-3) shows the distribution of functions on CGU-CC property. The portion of the campus between N. College Ave and N. Dartmouth Ave. and between Eighth and Eleventh Streets forms the core of CGU-CC and houses the greatest concentration of academic, administrative and service facilities, including those used by a majority of students from all disciplines. On the blocks north of Twelfth Street the structures are predominately residential in character. Many of these were former homes converted to house Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 14 D-1. Existing Campus Diagram Legend: CGU Building Non− CGU Buildings Campus Areas Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 15 D-2. Existing Land Holdings Diagram Legend: CGU Building Possible Future Acquisition Non− CGU Buildings Campus Areas Campus Boundary Line Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 16 D-3. Existing Use Diagram Legend: Academic Research (Program Building) Administration Student Services Student Housing Residential Dot Indicates Secondary use within building Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 17 administrative and program research functions for the campus. Similarly, residential structures owned by CGU south of Eighth Street have been converted for academic and administrative uses. These former homes are generally referred to as Program Buildings throughout this Master Plan. (Building Names & Addresses Diagram D-4). A series of surface parking lots are interspersed among the existing campus buildings. Automobile parking occupies land south of the Academic Computing Building, south of McManus Hall, west of the Burkle Building, a shared lot located off of Seventh Street, and a lot located between Drucker Way and Twelfth Street. 3.D Campus Perimeter - Edges & Gateways Due to the mixed character of the CGU-CC campus, the proximity of the residential neighborhood to the west and the Colleges to the south and east, the CGU-CC campus edges are varied and indistinct. The perceived edges of the CGU-CC campus are not always consistent with the actual campus boundaries. See Existing Campus Edges & Gateways Diagram D-5. Automobile parking is dispersed around the perimeter and throughout the campus allowing students, staff and visitors to enter from a number of locations. The benefit of this distribution of parking is that a relatively low concentration of pedestrians and automobiles occur at any one location. The major disadvantage to this method of parking distribution is that drivers are often left to circle blocks using public and private streets, and parking lots in search of open parking spaces. The parking oval and DeCombs Gateway on College Ave. south of Harper Hall currently function as the main ceremonial entrance and gateway to the CGU-CC campus. The recently installed vehicular and pedestrian scaled signage program has contributed to a new sense of campus with better defined entry points and improved way finding. Examples of these signs are shown below. DeCombs Gateway Nov. 21, 2012 Monument Sign Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 18 D-4. Existing Building Names & Addresses Diagram Legend: CGU Building Campus Boundary Line Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 19 D-5. Existing Campus Edge & Gateways Diagram Legend: University Scale Edge Residential Scale Edge Landscaped Edge Campus Gateway Campus Boundary Line Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 20 3.E Open Space & Landscape Open space is distributed throughout the CGU-CC campus. (Existing Open Space & Landscape Diagram D-6). Open space on the campus typically falls into one of three categories: parking lots with boarder landscaping, courtyards and plazas with dispersed landscaping, and boundary landscaping as large lawn areas or smaller planters between buildings. The smaller planters between buildings is an inheritance of the original residential lot parceling of the campus land. University-scale buildings along N. College Ave. have been set back from the street with a mixture of lawns and planting beds. Setbacks along N. Dartmouth Ave. and the cross streets have lawns and planting beds, but with a smaller dimension than the set backs on N. College Ave. The CGU-CC campus is surrounded by mature street trees along N. College Ave, N. Dartmouth Ave. and the cross-streets. A variety of mature specimen trees and plantings, including some flowering trees and vines are located within the campus itself. The large-scale trees and plantings adjacent to the University's buildings, along with the generous lawn areas and setbacks along N. Campus Ave. help the campus to blend with its residential neighbors to the west. The large-scale trees and plantings adjacent to the University's buildings and varying setbacks and landscape schemes along N. Dartmouth Ave. and cross streets helps the campus to blend with the Colleges to the south and east. CGU intends to preserve such trees, as possible, as described in Section 5.G.2 Landscape of this Master Plan. 3.F Pedestrian Circulation Academic programs are scattered across the campus, and parking is dispersed. Pedestrian trips tend to be of very short distances, often not more than a single block. For the most part, pedestrians use the sidewalks along N. College and N. Dartmouth Avenues as routes to classrooms and offices from on-street parking spaces. Pedestrian circulation within the campus often occurs through the parking lots that currently occupy the center of the campus. The east/ west cross streets, especially Tenth Street, are typically crossed mid-block. (Existing Pedestrian Circulation Diagram D-7). 3.G Vehicular Circulation N. College Ave. and N. Dartmouth Ave. currently carry significant portions of campus-bound traffic from Foothill Blvd. and the 210 Freeway on the north and from Arrow Route and the Interstate 10 Freeway to the south. Both of these streets are used for on-street parking for students. Four east-west cross streets, Eighth, Tenth, Eleventh / Drucker Way, and Twelfth Streets run through the campus providing on-street parking spaces and allowing vehicular circulation through CGU-CC to the other campuses to the east. Some traffic is generated between the Campus area to the south of Foothill Blvd. and the Graduate Student Housing located to the north of Foothill Blvd. (Existing Vehicular Access Circulation Diagram D-8). 3.H Parking Parking for students, faculty, staff and visitors is available within campus parking lots and on surface streets. Total current parking at the campus is 747 parking spaces, including street Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 21 parking. The exhibit Diagram D-9, Existing Parking Capacity Matrix and Diagram D-10, Existing Parking Capacity Map illustrates the currently available parking as presented in the Claremont Colleges Parking Inventory Annual Report submitted November 15, 2011. 3.I Zoning Factors Setbacks & Building Heights The Institutional Zone of the Claremont Zoning Code currently requires a 25 foot minimum building setback from a property boundary abutting a single-family residential district or separated by a street or alley. Under the City’s Code, a building abutting residential district that is located 25 feet from the property line/face of curb is restricted to 25 feet in height. Each additional one-foot of setback from the 25 foot minimum allows a one-foot additional increment in height, up to a maximum building height of 30 feet within the first hundred feet of setback. Between 100 feet of setback and 200 hundred feet of set back the maximum building height is 45 feet. Beyond 200 feet of setback building, height is maximum 100 feet. All the allowable building heights can be modified by a Conditional Use Permit. There are no setback requirements for projects in institutional zones in which the project does not abut a Residential District. All height limits set forth this Master Plan shall be subject to the exceptions set forth in Section 16.130.60 (B) of City Code Floor Area Ratio The development capacity for the campus is calculated using the Floor Area Ratio as defined by the zoning code. The zoning code states that the Floor Area Ratio (FAR) of the total campus site area may not exceed 1.0. Total constructed building area for the existing campus equals 335,870 GSF. At full build-out the Master Plan would include 626,933 GSF, which results in a .45:1 FAR. Consequently, the Master Plan results in a build-out that is less than half of what is allowed by City code. Maximum Lot Coverage Buildings, surface parking areas and driveways may not exceed 60% of the total campus site area. Because the total campus land area equals 1,395,239 SF, the Maximum Lot Coverage equals 837,143 SF. The proposed Lot Coverage for this Master Plan is 476,760 SF, which represents 34% of the total campus land. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 22 D-6. Existing Open Space & Landscape Trees are shown diagrammatically only - actual tree locations are indicated on campus wide tree survey. Legend: Campus Open Space Specimen Trees Street Trees Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 23 D-7. Existing Pedestrian Circulation Diagram Legend: Public Sidewalks Campus Walks Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 24 D-8. Existing Vehicular Access Circulation Diagram Legend: Service Access Campus Parking Lots Access Route Campus Circulation Internal Circulation Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 25 Diagram extracted from The Claremont Colleges Parking Inventory 2011 Annual Report Nov. 21, 2012 D-9. Existing Parking Capacity Matrix Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 26 Diagram extracted from The Claremont Colleges Parking Inventory 2011 Annual Report D-10. Existing Parking Capacity Map Legend: Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 32 Lot Parking 11 Street Parking 27 Chapter 4 - Future Campus Requirements 4.A Student Enrollment & Faculty Staff Projections One factor in projecting space needs is student enrollment. CGU plans to increase the number of masters-level students while holding the number of Ph.D. students mostly constant. Increases in enrollment generates the need for additional faculty and staff. Because of CGU's low student-faculty ratio and small class sizes, any change in enrollment will have a direct affect on the number of faculty and staff. The following tabulations present projected growth for students, faculty and staff as applies to the Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus (CGU-CC) only. Campus Population Projections Existing Conditions 20-Year Projection 2011 (2031) 1,420 Faculty Staff & Research Student Enrollment Totals Increase % Increase 1,800 380 26.8% 124 160 36 29.0% 210 260 50 23.8% 1,754 2,220 466 26.6% 4.B Development Capacity Floor Area Ratio The development capacity for the campus is controlled in part by allowable Floor Area Ratio (FAR). FAR is defined by the City’s zoning code as the ratio of building floor area to total campus land area. Under the zoning code the FAR for a campus may not exceed 1.0. The total campus land area equals 1,395,239 SF. Because under the zoning code the maximum FAR is 1:1, the maximum allowable building area that can be constructed on the current campus is 1,395,239 SF. The total existing building area currently equals 335,870 GSF, which equals 24% of the maximum allowable area. The proposed building area under this Master Plan equals 626,933 GSF, which equals 45% of maximum allowable area, excluding square footage required for parking deck or subterranean parking. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 28 Maximum Lot Coverage Another constraint that affects development capacity is determined by the Maximum Lot Coverage, as defined by City code. Lot Coverage is defined as the total of the areas of the footprints of buildings, surface parking areas, and driveways. Per the City’s zoning code the Maximum Lot Coverage cannot exceed 60% of the total campus land. Because the total campus land area equals 1,395,239 SF, the Maximum Lot Coverage equals 837,143 SF. The proposed Lot Coverage for this Master Plan is 476,760 SF, which represents 34% of the total campus land. (Development Capacity Diagram D-11) 4.C Parking Capacity In accordance with current City parking requirements, CGU must increase it current parking space by 151 spaces to accommodate the existing student enrollment and faculty/staff population at the CGU-CC campus. The additional parking will be located between Twelfth Street and Foothill Blvd. behind the existing program buildings and adjacent to the north-south alley. One program house will be relocated to a site on Foothill Blvd. and the other program buildings will be relocated, as possible, or demolished to make way for the proposed surface parking lot. (Parking Capacity Diagram D-12). Parking Tabulations: (Indicates revisions to bring campus into compliance) On-Site Surface Parking 352 Street Parking 164 Parking at Student Housing 231 Subtotal-Existing Parking 747 Added - (N) Surface Parking (Twelfth & Foothill) 162 Lost - (E) Street Parking (2) Lost - (E) Surface Parking (9) Subtotal Additional Parking 151 Total Parking Provided 898 Total Parking Required 898 Future parking demands, based on the student enrollment & faculty staff projections, a minimum 212 new parking spaces will be required to be added incrementally as CGU-CC expands bringing the minimum parking spaces to 1,110 spaces. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 29 D-11. Development Capacity Diagram Legend: CGU Owned Bldgs. Future CGU Bldg./Addition Relocated CGU Bldg. Non−C.G.U. Bldgs. Campus Boundary Line Future Development Area Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 30 D-12. Parking Capacity Compliance Diagram This diagram shows the revised parking configurations to bring CGU-CC parking in compliance with current City parking requirements. Parking Tabulations: On-site Surface Parking Street Parking Parking @ Student Housing Subtotal– Existing Parking 352 164 231 747 Add (N) Surface Parking (Twelfth & Foothill) Lose (E) Street Parking Lose (E) Surface Parking Sub-total—Added Parking 162 Total Parking Provided Total Parking Required 898 898 -2 -9 151 Alternatives to meet future parking capacity are shown on Diagram D-21 Illustrative Master Plan Diagram. Legend: Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 32 Lot Parking 11 Street Parking 31 4.D Campus Infrastructure Projections As the proposed development projects are undertaken, improvements to some utilities and campus infrastructure will be required. All existing sewer and natural gas distribution systems are adequate to support the proposed development. The existing campus telephone and data networks will have to be extended and their capacities upgraded to accommodate future growth. Some improvements to electrical power distribution and the storm water drainage system, as described below, may also be required. Power & Telephone Distribution A majority of the CGU-CC campus buildings/facilities are served by a private under ground power distribution and telephone distribution network as a part of the larger CUC power and telephone grid. Existing buildings currently served by overhead utilities may be converted, as possible, to underground distribution systems served either by the CUC power and telephone grid or from public utilities. New development will receive power and telephone from underground distribution systems served either by the CUC power and telephone grid or from public utilities. New development and alterations or additions to existing facilities may require various upgrades to the existing distribution systems including addition of conduits and vaults, cabling/wiring and equipment. Campus Data Distribution The existing data distribution network is currently run through an underground distribution network as a part of the larger CUC grid. Data distribution on campus currently consists of several different types of data cabling and interfaces, which is typical of a system that has developed incrementally with the rapid development of the associated technologies. Continued development of the campus and technologies will require an extension of the existing campus data and communication networks that will be accomplished during each phase of the proposed Master Plan. Potable Water The existing buildings are currently serviced by a variety of water lines including 2" and 4" mains. As the Master Plan is implemented, water distribution systems will be upgraded to serve new buildings. Water Mains Upgrades to water mains may be required to support existing and future proposed development including building services, fire sprinkler systems, and fire water systems to support on-site fire hydrants. Natural Gas Existing capacity and distribution networks are adequate to accommodate the development proposed in the Master Plan. New construction will require installation of new gas line laterals from existing mains. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 32 Sanitary Sewer Existing sewer line capacity is adequate to accommodate the development proposed in the Master Plan. New construction will require installation of new laterals from existing mains. Storm water Rain falling on the CGU-CC campus generally drains south and west across the campus. Storm water east of Dartmouth Ave. drains south along Dartmouth and enters a new Sixth Street storm drain extension at the intersection of Dartmouth Ave. and Eighth Street. The recently constructed extension reduced storm water impacts on College Ave. from CGU-CC, Foothill Blvd. and the Colleges to the east. Implementation of the Master Plan may further improve conditions along College Ave. by increasing permeable landscape planting and the use of bio-swales. New surface parking will incorporate sustainable site improvements to manage storm water discharge from the campus site to acceptable pre-project levels. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 33 Chapter 5 - Master Plan Description Claremont Graduate University wishes to create a Master Plan that provides for new facilities and enhances the existing Claremont Campus. The Master Plan has been developed to embody the University's values and goals. It addresses functional shortcomings of the existing campus, and works towards fulfillment of the CGU's high academic standards. The Master Plan outlines a vision for implementing changes to the Claremont campus in a thoughtful and pro-active manner that respects the neighboring community while permitting reasonable development to support and enhance CGU's stature as a prominent, global graduate institution. The CGU-CC campus has many positive attributes that the CGU community wishes to maintain. The campus's pleasant, small-scale atmosphere is the most often cited attribute. The Master Plan proposes a method for maintaining and enhancing the campus’s scale and unique qualities while simultaneously positioning CGU to be competitive among other global institutions offering similar academic programs. The form of the Master Plan is based on the assumption that the future development of the campus will be a function of the phased renovation of existing facilities and development of future new projects. Therefore, the Master Plan has been designed to be flexible enough to accommodate a variety of future circumstances while maintaining the stated goals and values of the University. 5.A Overall Campus Design The overall campus design will continue to respect the central location of the academic and administrative functions that are currently housed in Harper, McManus, ACB, Stauffer/Albrecht Halls, and the Burkle Building located in the blocks between Eighth and Eleventh Streets. CGU will reinforce the centralization of its academic and administrative campus functions by consolidating student services and upgrading food service at the renovated Harper EastMcManus Halls. With the acquisition of the Huntley Bookstore building and property, CGU will hold control of the entire block between Eighth and Tenth Streets, which will allow additional academic buildings and parking to be developed to further enhance the central campus concept. The acquisition of the Huntley Bookstore property will allow CGU to create a well-defined southern boundary for its campus, and permit CGU to enhance the campus’s visual identity with appropriately scaled buildings, adequate parking, open spaces, and campus gateways. As CGU-CC programs and space requirements continue to grow, expansion, remodeling and replacement of current facilities will continue northward along N. Dartmouth Ave. The proposed sites will support academic program buildings and requisite parking. The creation of a central pedestrian circulation spine (Campus Walk) will connect parking to existing and new campus Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 34 buildings and functions. The Campus Walk would extend midblock from Dartmouth Place alley south to Eighth Street. The overall concept for this Master Plan will be one of consolidation, centralization and improvement of existing facilities to emphasize the heart of the campus and promote CGU’s goals for the future. 5.B Interface with Surrounding Community CGU will respect the current scale of buildings facing N. College Ave with well-landscaped setbacks, equaling or exceeding current minimum setbacks, and appropriately-scaled buildings that do not exceed the current height of the adjacent Academic Computing Building which is 50 feet. At the north-south alley adjacent to residential properties, setbacks will be provided for parking areas and parking decks with well-landscaped areas to provide visual screening. CGU will respect the adjacent college campuses with appropriate setbacks, building heights and massing, and scale of building elements for development along N. Dartmouth Ave. 5.C Building Pattern & Massing New buildings will respect the scale and massing of the existing CGU-CC campus buildings, the surrounding college campuses and the adjacent residential neighborhoods. Building Pattern The building placement for future academic development will be concentrated in the block between Eighth and Tenth Streets to reinforce the goal of creating a campus core. Less concentrated development will occur north of Tenth Street along N. Dartmouth Ave. The building configurations and parking areas will be organized to reinforce the pedestrian circulation spine. The pedestrian circulation spine will link open courtyards to enhance and promote informal gatherings and collegiality. (Building Pattern & Use Diagram D-13). Building Scale & Massing Building mass will be relieved by breaking up large uniform facades with variations in setbacks and offsets at floor lines. Use of divided roof configurations, roof slopes and shapes, and the introduction of arcades and covered walks at the base of buildings will be used, as appropriate, to soften the mass of the academic buildings. Placement of program functions such as auditoriums, larger classrooms and laboratories can have significant impact on building scale and massing and their locations within buildings shall be carefully considered to enhance human and academic scale along streets, drive aisles and pedestrian walks. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 35 D-13. Building Pattern & Use Diagram Legend: Academic Parking Lots Administration Student Services Student Housing Research (Program Building) Future Development Area Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 36 Future academic-scale buildings will vary in height depending on location. The building height will be determined using the average grade across the building foot print as the baseline elevation. Academic buildings ranging in size from 25,000 - 90,000 GSF will front to adjacent streets with a pedestrian-scaled entry on the campus interior facing the campus walk. Although some relocation will occur to enhance parking, existing residential-scale buildings will continue to be used as program buildings between Twelfth Street and Foothill Blvd. The overall scale of future buildings will be compatible with existing academic and administrative buildings such as Harper Hall, Academic Computing Building, Burkle Building, and the Honnold Library, Garrison Theater and Steele Hall to the east. The buildings will be one to four stories in height with appropriate setbacks to contribute to the existing campus environment. 5.D Conceptual Design Guidelines 5.D.1 Setbacks Future building setbacks will be generally consistent with and respect the existing building setbacks along N. Dartmouth and N. College Avenues and along the east-west streets intended to remain as public right-of-ways. Unless otherwise noted, setbacks shall be taken from property line along public streets and from face of curb along private streets that remain open for automobile traffic. Vacated alleys that remain open for automobile traffic shall be treated as private drive aisles. Smaller structures including information kiosks, shade structures, gateways, monument signs, direction signage and other similar structures may be located within setbacks. Planters and decorative pavement may be utilized to enhance visual experience and provide traffic calming affects along private streets, and may be located within setbacks. Basements, subterranean parking and similar underground structures may extend into setbacks (below the surface) provided that exposed surfaces, visible from streets and sidewalks, comply with landscape and hardscape criteria for setback areas including provisions for trees and larger shrubs. Average Building Setback In lieu of a stagnant 25 foot building setback an average building setback of 25 feet will be maintained to allow some building mass and architectural projections to intrude and recede from the standard setback. In no case, will the setback of a building be less than 20 feet from property lines or face of curb as noted above. See Building Height & Setback Diagram D-14 Figure 1 Condition “A” shows an example of the affects when a standard 25 foot setback is applied to a building façade. Figure 2 - Condition “B” demonstrates the advantages that an average setback can have to encourage variations to massing and scale and create exterior spaces. Figure 3 illustrates average set-backs applied in plan view. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 37 D-14. Building Height & Setback Diagram Figure 1. Typ. Building Height & Setback—Condition ‘A’ Figure 2. Typical Building Height & Setback—Condition ‘B’ Figure 3. Typical Building Setbacks Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 38 Diagram D-15, Site-Section Diagrams, Figures 1 through 3, illustrate relationship of setbacks to proposed building heights for 3 of the major new academic buildings proposed in this Master Plan. Setback exception - proposed remodel addition to Stauffer Hall will match the existing setback at Stauffer Hall which is less than the 20 foot minimum. Parking Lot / Parking Deck Setbacks Parking lots and parking decks shall maintain a 10’-0” landscaped setback from any property line or curb. A parking deck for the purposes of this Master Plan is described as a parking lot with no more than a single structural deck over surface parking. (Parking Deck Setback Diagram D-15) 5.D.2 Building Height Future academic-scale buildings will vary in height depending on location from 1 to 4 stories. The building height will be determined using the average grade across the building footprint as the baseline elevation. Building heights for each proposed development location are indicated in the Campus Master Plan Elements and the Illustrative Master Plan Diagram D-21. As a general guideline the following shall apply: One-story buildings shall not exceed 30 feet in height Two-story buildings shall not exceed 45 feet in height Three-story buildings shall not exceed 60 feet in height Four-story buildings shall not exceed 75 feet in height Parking decks shall not exceed 16 feet in height above the adjacent natural grade including guardrails. Light standards and required handicapped and directional signage may not exceed 15 feet in height as measured from the top of the parking deck. (Parking Deck Setback Diagram D-16) Building additions: unless otherwise indicated the maximum height for additions to existing buildings shall equal the existing building. Diagram D-15, Site-Section Diagrams - Figures 1 through 3 illustrate relationship of setbacks to proposed building heights for 3 of the major New Academic Buildings proposed in this Master Plan. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 39 D-15. Site-Section Diagrams Figure 1. Site Section - NEW ACADEMIC BUILDING N. DARTMOUTH Ave.. between Eleventh Street (Drucker Way) and Twelfth Street. Figure 2. Site Section - NEW ACADEMIC BUILDING North/West corner of Eighth Street and N. Dartmouth Ave. Figure 3. Site Section - NEW ACADEMIC BUILDING North/East corner of Eighth Street and N. College Ave. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 40 D-16. Parking Deck Setback Diagram Figure 1. Parking Deck Set Back section—Condition ‘A’ at South end of parking near Eleventh Street/Drucker Way Figure 2. Parking Deck Set Back section—Condition ‘B’ at North end of property near Twelfth Street. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 41 5.D.3 Building Materials The overall physical characteristics of new and renovated buildings will complement the existing architectural vocabulary already present at the campus. The vocabulary will allow for interpretation of the classical historical forms, materials, and configurations while selectively incorporating modern design elements and materials. Exterior building finish materials will be complementary to the palette present in existing buildings. Approved building materials include exposed brick or stone, exposed concrete masonry, and exposed architectural concrete. Exterior cement plaster (stucco) over structural backing may also be used for building exteriors. Colors should be compatible or complimentary with the existing academic and administrative buildings including the Academic Computing Building, Burkle Hall and Harper Hall will be encouraged. Visible roof surfaces will be clay or concrete tile (flat or shaped), pre-finished standing seam metal or naturally weathering metal roof systems such as copper or zinc. Academic Computing Building Burkle Building 5.D.4 Building Design and Sustainability Commitment CGU is committed to reducing environmental impacts and creating a sustainable environment. Building renovations and new building construction will promote sustainable building design, technologies and materials. CGU will strive to meet the standards set forth in the City of Claremont Sustainability City Plan, State of California Energy compliance program (Cal-Green) and the principles set forth in the United States Green Building Council’s Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design (LEED). New buildings and renovation projects to existing buildings will utilize sustainable building design practices that promote indoor air quality, harvesting of natural daylight, use of high efficiency and Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 42 well designed mechanical, plumbing, and electrical systems, and the use of energy and fuel efficient equipment and appliances. CGU is equally committed to applying the principles of sustainability in its daily operations and maintenance programs. To assist the City with meetings its sustainability goals CGU will promote: reduction of energy consumption including gas and electric, increase in use of renewable energy, decrease in water consumption, diverting of solid waste from landfills, use of public transportation, energy free transportation including improvements to circulation for pedestrian and bicycle transportation and reduction in carbon emissions (Carbon Footprint). REDUCING ENERGY USE: A large proportion of the power that we consume is wasted energy that is not essential to our actual needs. Ways to reduce nonessential consumption include use of Energy Star Compliant appliances and similar high efficiency appliances and fixtures. Also better control of lighting providing light only when and where needed including automatic diming systems, lighting control systems, motion sensors and task lighting can all reduce power without noticeable changes to ambient conditions. Increased use of natural lighting, also known as daylight harvesting, is an important component of an energy savings strategy. Building envelope design impacts power consumption and attention to solar orientation and building insulation can significantly reduce energy consumption. Heating and cooling systems can significantly impact our energy consumption. Integration of passive solar design techniques including use of heavy masonry and concrete walls to improve building mass and window shading to reduce internal solar heat gains can reduce power consumption and improve natural lighting savings. Use of renewable energy including solar heating and solar electric can be valuable tools in reducing carbon impacts. WATER CONSERVATION: Reduction in water consumption will come from several areas including use of low-flow toilets, waterless urinals, low-flow showers and sinks, automatic valves at lavatories and careful monitoring of systems for incidental use including faulty valves and minor leaks. Reduction in landscape water consumption as discussed throughout this Master Plan is key to an overall decrease in water consumption on campus. DIVERTING SOLID WASTE: The easiest way to divert solid waste is not to create the waste in the first place. The easiest approach is best summed up in the current approach of Reduce, Re-use, Recycle. CGU is working towards a more paperless approach to higher education and encourages the use of the Campus-wide computer network. Recycling efforts will further divert solid waste and help to promote a sustainable lifestyle. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 43 TRANSPORTATION: CGU has looked at many ways to reduce dependency on the automobile. Virtual classrooms are one way to reduce transportation impacts. Bicycle transportation is another popular way on campus to reduce energy consumption and carbon footprint. Public transportation is encouraged as well as ride sharing. Campus development will implement landscape practices that promote water conservation, use of drought-resistant plantings and trees, properly designed irrigation systems, and pervious materials for paving areas as well as the use of bio-swales and storm water retention systems. See additional information in 5.G.2 Landscape. Consideration to placement of trees and plant materials can reduce solar heat gains on buildings from both reflected heat and through shading. 5.E Temporary Facilities During the course of implementing the components of this Master Plan temporary facilities may be utilized to create necessary interim space. Temporary facilities may be used for a variety of campus functions during renovation and new construction projects. They will also be used to support construction activities. Temporary facilities may include modular buildings, interim buildings, and temporary parking. Temporary facilities will generally comply with the standards of the Master Plan however adjustments to setbacks and screening may be necessary. Temporary modular buildings will be allowed on all building site locations and parking areas to fulfill the program requirements as required by CGU-CC building and renovation implementation plan. A Special Use and Development Permit is required for any temporary facility. Parking areas and parking counts impacted by temporary facilities must be mitigated to keep CGU-CC in compliance with parking requirements of this Master Plan and City code. Approval of temporary facilities including temporary buildings will be tied to specific building projects and campus program build out. 5.F Building Relocation CGU is committed to saving and/or relocating existing buildings as reasonably possible. As a part of the implementation of the Master Plan the Existing Program Building at 143 Tenth Street will be relocated to 121 Tenth Street and the Program Building at 135 Twelfth Street will be relocated to a site along Foothill Blvd. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 44 5.G Open Space & Pedestrian Circulation 5.G.1 Open Space The Campus will consist of a series of open spaces connected by the Campus Walk. Open spaces around and between buildings and parking areas will be designed to complement the academic and residential scale of the adjacent neighborhoods. Open spaces will be defined by future building placement and associated parking areas. The open spaces will be scaled to be consistent with the character of the existing campus and create the opportunity for informal and spontaneous interaction between students, faculty and staff. (Open Space Diagram D-17). The large open space at the North campus site located north of Foothill Blvd. adjacent to N. College Ave is reserved for Future Development by the University including buildings, parking and landscaping consistent with Institutional Land Uses. 5.G.2 Landscape The plant palette will consist primarily of drought tolerant landscape material to minimize the use of material that require high levels of maintenance or irrigation. Formal and ornamental landscape and plant material that require higher levels of maintenance or irrigation will be limited to the pedestrian circulation spine, and selected gardens and courts. Shade trees will be planted as necessary to provide summer shade. Sample Plant Pallet Trees California Live Oak Holly Oak Black oak Cork Oak Crepe Myrtle London Plane Tree Liquid Amber Pine(s) Arbutus Marina Flame Tree Red Maple Coast Redwood Western Redbud Eastern Redbud Dwarf Southern Magnolia Phoenix Palms Sago Palm Paper Bark Tree Red Flowering Gum Gold Medallon Tree Purple Leaf Baileyana Smoke Tree Mimosa tree Hakea Laurina Shrubs Manzanita Camilla New Zealand Flax Indian Hawthorne Cardinal Cordyline Red fringe Flower Azalea Shaw agave Lilly(s) Western Redbud Sierra Snow California Lilac Red-Leaf Japanese Barberry Bird of Paradise Juniper(s) Coyote bush Ground Cover Yellow Lantana White Lilly Turf Star Jasmine Rockrose Rosemary Berkley sedge Mahonia Snow in Summer Sephyranthus White The potential visual impact of parking lots and decks will be reduced by landscape screening with evergreen trees and shrubs in combination with earthen slopes and screen walls. Trees will be Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 45 Area reserved for Future Development by University D-17. Open Space Diagram Campus Walk Renovation of DesCombes Quadrangle Legend: Campus Open Space Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 46 utilized in parking and parking borders to provide visual relief from large expanses of paving and to reduce excessive solar heat gain. Existing mature specimen trees will be preserved throughout the campus wherever possible. When cross-streets are vacated or privatized, the existing street trees will be incorporated into the campus planting scheme wherever appropriate and safe. CGU will conform to the City of Claremont Water Efficient Landscape Ordinance. 5.G.3 Courtyards Currently the campus does not have any formal courtyards for large assembly functions and informal gatherings. It does have some small intimate patios and courtyards that are situated between existing buildings. CGU proposes to centralize student services in the heart of the campus adjacent to the main administrative functions located in Harper and Harper East-McManus Halls. A formal courtyard is proposed for the open space currently existing between Harper East-McManus and Stauffer Hall to enhance the student services and strengthen the heart of the campus. This courtyard will provide outdoor seating for formal assemblies and informal seating for outdoor dining and small group dialogue. Courtyards will be added along the Campus Walk and integrated into open spaces between buildings as additional academic buildings are constructed. To reduce the visual and spatial impacts that small scattered surface parking areas have on the pedestrian experience, courtyards may be introduced to replace existing surface parking as new permanent parking is developed. 5.G.4 Pedestrian Circulation The primary north/south pedestrian circulation will be located between College and Dartmouth Avenues, shifting the balance of pedestrian traffic away from these streets. This centralized campus walkway location will better connect each area of the campus and support a more cohesive campus environment. (Pedestrian Circulation Diagram D-18) The campus walk and other primary pedestrian connections will be of varying widths with a minimum width of 6 feet, with secondary paths, of varying widths, with a minimum width of 4 feet. The walks will be an important pedestrian connection throughout the campus. The use of special pavement, such as enhanced integral color concrete with a consistent scoring pattern, varied paving surfaces, such as concrete pavers, bricks or decomposed granite is proposed for key focal points and gathering spaces. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 47 Courtyards Concept drawings for remodel of the DesCombes Quadrangle to reinforce the Harper Hall, Harper East, McManus Hall complex as the central core to the campus as a Campus Commons . Arial View looking north over the Harper Hall, Harper East, McManus Hall with Bell tower to the left towards the DesCombes Quadrangle. Concept drawing for the renovation of the DesCombes Quadrangle showing the integration of stone, heavy timbers and decorative paving consistent with features found throughout the campus. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 48 D-18. Pedestrian Circulation Diagram Mid-street Crossing Mid-street Crossing Mid-street Crossing Renovation to open space between Harper Hall and McManus Hall Legend: Public Sidewalks Campus Walks Campus Pedestrian Spine Mid−Block Crossing Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 49 Pedestrian Circulation View looking south from Tenth Street between Harper Hall and Harper East Examples of pedestrian walks on campus. View looking south from Harper Hall, Harper East towards Academic Computing building. Courtyards will serve as nodes along campus walk to encourage interaction between students, faculty, and staff. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 50 Pedestrian Circulation Pedestrian circulation - concept drawings for remodeling of existing spaces between buildings to enhance the campus walk through the addition of decorative paving materials, lighting, seating and landscape improvements. View looking south from Tenth Street between Harper Hall and Harper East View looking south from Harper Hall, Harper East towards Academic Computing building. Concept drawing to remove portions of additions to Harper Hall to allow for Campus Walk to flow through complex and add to the concept of the Harper Hall, Harper East, McManus Hall complex as the central core. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 51 5.G.5 Mid-Block Pedestrian Crossings This Master Plan proposes to enhance pedestrian safety and the Campus Walk experience by creating mid-block pedestrian crossings at Tenth, Eleventh and Twelfth Streets. Following privatization of these streets, the mid-block crossings will be created using enhanced paving materials, small-scale signage markers and/or pedestrian gateways to provide pedestrian crosswalks. In addition to enhanced paving other traffic calming measures, including finger planters, will be implemented in phases to provide greater sight lines between vehicles and pedestrians, lower traffic speeds and improve overall safety. Mid-block pedestrian crossings will generally result in a loss of four parking spaces per street. Sequencing of mid-street crossing will be timed with availability of surplus parking spaces elsewhere on campus. Final designs may impact parking space replacement figures. 5.G.6 Site Lighting Appropriate lighting is particularly important for the CGU-CC campus because so many of its students attend classes in the late afternoon and evenings. As parking is concentrated in the north and south portions of the campus, a well lit pedestrian walkway will create an opportunity for students and faculty to travel safely between classrooms and parking. Proper lighting lends ambiance to the campus pedestrian walkway and courts. Lighting is a good psychological reinforcement for pedestrians, encouraging use of the pathways during the evenings and provides a significant crime deterrent, thus increasing safety for the CGU community. Lighting in parking areas will generally be provided by pole mounted lighting with a maximum 15 foot mounting height to comply with City Standards. All pedestrian connections and building entries will be lighted during hours of darkness. Low level, pedestrian-scaled light standards are encouraged using either bollards or fixtures on poles with heights of 12 feet or less. In no case should pole heights exceed the 15 foot allowed for parking areas. Light fixture styles will be reflective of a campus environment and sensitive to the surrounding neighborhoods. The campus should be uniformly illuminated for safety along walkways and within plazas and parking areas. A footcandle standard will be established for all campus lighting. Where no codes or “best practice” standards exist the following standards shall apply: Pedestrian walkways and gathering spaces Minimum 1 horizontal footcandle at ground plane. Open areas and parking Minimum 0.5 horizontal footcandle at ground plane. Lighting adjacent to Residential areas Maximum 0.5 horizontal footcandle at property line ground plane. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 52 Site lighting will generally take advantage of fixtures that comply with sustainable standards for night sky light pollution and light spill-over. 5.G.7 Site Signage & Furnishings A unified system of street furniture, including benches, tables and chairs, and trash receptacles, will be utilized on the campus. The character of these elements will be reflective of the academic architecture on the campus. CGU will develop a uniform signage program for the campus to reinforce a sense of place and improve way finding. The signage program will consist of several elements including directional signage along streets and parking areas, directional signage along pedestrian walkways and monument signs designating major entries and buildings. Monument and building signage will generally follow the current signage program shown in Chapter 3-D, Campus Perimeter– Edges and Gateways. 5.H Traffic Circulation & Parking 5.H.1 Vehicle Circulation This Master Plan proposes to modify the campus traffic flows by encouraging students, staff and faculty to use Dartmouth Ave as the main vehicular thoroughfare into the campus. The main access to campus parking will be along Twelfth Street and Drucker Way via Dartmouth Ave. This strategy facilitates several of the University's goals: • Vehicular traffic on all streets surrounding the campus will be decreased due to the concentration of adequate on-site parking areas, eliminating the need for drivers to unnecessarily travel those streets in search of parking spaces. • The concentrating of parking also enables automobile entrances to be clearly marked with appropriate scale signage, increasing both the identification of the campus to first-time or infrequent visitors, as well as convenience for faculty, staff, and students. • Relocating parking from the perimeter areas including streets and remote parking areas strengthens the central pedestrian circulation spine. This has the effect of concentrating the number of people who walk through campus, enabling an increased level of interaction among the campus community, and improving the safety of the pedestrians through improved lighting and signage on the more travelled walkways. (Vehicular Circulation Diagram D-19) Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 53 D-19. Campus Vehicular Access Circulation Diagram Legend: Main Entry Point Campus Entry Point Major Access Route Campus Circulation Internal Circulation Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 54 5.H.2 Private Streets / Alleys The Master Plan proposes to privatize Tenth Street between N. College Ave. and N. Dartmouth Ave. and Eleventh and Twelfth Streets between the alley East of N. College Ave. and N. Dartmouth Ave. in order to allow for the construction of mid-block pedestrian crossing to enhance pedestrian safety and encourage use of the central campus walk. (Street Designations Diagram D-20) The Master Plan proposes to privatize the alley known as N. Dartmouth Place to convert the access into a private driveway. (Street Designations Diagram D-20) As a part of privatizing streets, traffic calming measures including enhanced paving, finger planters and improved lighting will be constructed in phases, as resources permit, to slow traffic and reinforce the pedestrian character of the central campus area. Street improvements will be timed with other parking projects on campus to insure proper parking space counts are maintained in accordance with other provisions of this Master Plan. Traffic coming measures including are primarily proposed at mid-street crossings but may also be implemented in the form of finger islands along streets and at intersections. 5.H.3 Campus Parking Layout It is CGU's intent to meet City parking requirements as a part of the implementation of the Master Plan. CGU will increase current parking by 151 spaces to accommodate the current CGU-CC student enrollment and faculty/staff population by constructing surface parking located between Twelfth Street and Foothill west of the existing bungalow buildings and adjacent to the northsouth alley. Additional parking will be added as a component of future projects on the CGU-CC campus to maintain compliance with City parking requirements. Diagram 21 Illustrative Master Plan Diagram indicates a variety of locations for future parking. As new parking facilities are constructed in conjunction with new academic buildings, existing surface parking areas may be repurposed as building sites (including secondary structures), plaza/open spaces, walkways, and courtyards, provided the total parking space tabulations remain in compliance with City standards. Temporary parking may be required during implementation of the Master Plan and may consist of temporary parking on-site and off-site including remote lots and short term agreements with adjacent institutions. Concentrated on-site campus parking will be shifted to the interior portions of the campus, typically located behind the street-facing academic and administrative buildings along Dartmouth Ave.. Parking will generally be visible from cross streets running east/west to provide visibility for Campus Safety as well a encourage visibility for new arrivals to campus to reduce tendency to use street parking. Since the campus is relatively compact, even the most remote parking areas will be within a five-minute walk to the campus center. One strategy for providing additional parking will be using a structural deck over surface parking Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 55 D-20. Street Designation Diagram Legend: Public Street Existing Private Street New Private Street Vacate Alley Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 56 concept on the existing lot located between Eleventh Street/Drucker Way and Twelfth Street. Utilizing the natural north-to-south slope of the site, lower level parking can be accessed from the south end at grade terminating at the north end approximately 10 feet below grade. Upper level parking can be accessed from north end at grade and continuing south on a parking deck over the lower level parking terminating at the south end approximately 10 feet above adjacent grade. See D-15. Parking Deck Setback Diagram. There is ample space for the Campus to provide additional capacity to comply with City parking space requirements, utilizing a combination of surface parking, the deck over surface parking concept and subterranean parking structures. Parking required for construction related activities will not impact required parking counts. Parking for construction will be provided within construction sites or at remote locations. Where construction parking utilizes on-site University parking, CGU will acquire short term parking agreements with adjacent institutions to offset construction parking impacts. Non-designated off campus construction parking, including parking on surrounding public streets, shall be prohibited in all contracts for construction. 5.H.4 Bicycle Circulation / Connections The City has created designated bikeways along Foothill Blvd. and along College Ave from Foothill to Sixth Street. These existing bikeways currently connect the north and south portions of the CGU-CC campus. All CGU-CC on-campus housing is located north of Foothill Blvd. Pedestrian and bicycle circulation is available along N. College Ave, across the Foothill Blvd. north frontage road to the intersection of Foothill Blvd. and Dartmouth Ave. The access Effective placement of bicycle racks encourages more participation in bicycle ridership programs. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 57 continues south along Dartmouth Ave. There are also designated bike routes along Twelfth street. In addition to the designated bike routes indicated above the area of the Campus south of Foothill Blvd. falls within the City’s Bicycle Priority Zone. CGU will encourage bicycle transportation with the strategic placement of bike racks adjacent to campus buildings throughout campus. 5.H.5 Public Transportation The University is committed to the use and development of public transportation. CGU will work with the Claremont Consortium and the surrounding Colleges to promote public transportation including use of the bus routes along Foothill Blvd. and the nearby Claremont Transit Center. 5.I Master Plan Description - (Diagram 21. Illustrative Master Plan Diagram) 5.I.1 Campus Master Plan Elements This Master Plan will include the following elements: The following elements are not presented in sequential order or phasing. Sequencing of the elements of the Master Plan will be based on requirements of this Master Plan, operational needs of the University, and financial constraints and opportunities. 1. Relocate existing program building at 135 Twelfth Street, and remove/relocate other program buildings north of Twelfth Street as required to make way for new parking lot and new multi-purpose buildings. 2. Construct a new parking lot (maximum of 162 parking spaces) between Foothill Blvd. and Twelfth Street along the eastern side of the north-south alleyway, including the privatization of N. Dartmouth Place alley, which will be converted to a driveway. 3. Construct two (2) new multi-purpose buildings (combined GSF not to exceed 10,000 SF) to replace and supplement existing program buildings located between Twelfth Street and Foothill Blvd. 4. Create a central pedestrian circulation spine (Campus Walk) connecting parking to campus buildings and functions. The Campus Walk would extend midblock from Dartmouth Place alley south to Eighth Street. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 58 5. Privatize Twelfth Street, between the alley east of N. College Ave. and N. Dartmouth Ave. and add a mid-block pedestrian crossing. 6. Construct a new academic building which, will be a maximum of 3 stories in height plus basement level, 65 feet in height above grade, and which is not more than 80,000 GSF in size. The academic building may be served by a combination of surface parking and subterranean parking providing a maximum of 100 new parking spaces. 7. Remodel existing surface parking between Twelfth Street and Eleventh Street/Drucker Way to provide for a parking deck, providing a maximum of 102 new parking spaces. Combined total maximum of new and existing parking spaces to be 201 spaces. 8. Privatize Drucker Way (Eleventh Street), between the alley east of N. College Ave. and N. Dartmouth Ave. and add a mid-block pedestrian crossing. 9. Construct a new academic building at the Jagels Building site, which will be a maximum of 3 stories in height plus basement, 50 feet in height above grade and which is not more than 55,000 GSF in size. Existing facility is 12,000 SF, resulting in a maximum net add of 43,000 SF. 10.Privatize Tenth Street, between N. College Ave. and N. Dartmouth Ave. and add a midblock pedestrian crossing. 11. Renovate Harper Hall and Harper East-McManus Hall to consolidate university administrative functions and create a new Campus Commons including student services center. 12. Renovation of the DesCombes Quadrangle in the existing open space between Harper East, McManus Hall and Stauffer Hall to create a new Campus Commons courtyard. 13. Renovate Stauffer-Albrecht Building removing Albrecht portion of building and replacing with a new building addition, which will be a maximum of 2 stories in height plus basement, building height of 35 feet to approximately match existing Stauffer portion, and which is not more than a combined GSF of 28,000 SF. Existing Stauffer-Albrecht Building equals 15,177 GSF resulting in a maximum net add of 12,823 GSF. 14. Create an opening between Harper Hall and McManus with cascading stairs, elevator and ramps to extend the central pedestrian circulation spine (Campus Walk) south to Eighth Street and improve site access. 15. Acquire the Huntley Bookstore site to consolidate the contiguous campus land holdings and enhance the campus center concept. Renovate existing building and/or construct a new academic building, which will be a maximum of 3 stories in height plus basement, 75 feet in height above grade, and which is not more than 90,000 GSF in size. The academic building may be served by a combination of surface parking and subterranean parking providing a maximum of 100 new parking spaces. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 59 16. Construct a new academic building at the northeast corner of N. College Ave. and Eighth Streets, which will be a maximum of 3 stories in height plus basement, maximum 50 feet in height above grade to match Academic Computing Building, and which is not more than 60,000 GSF in size. The academic building may be served by a combination of surface parking and subterranean parking providing a maximum of 100 new parking spaces. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 60 D-21. Illustrative Master Plan Diagram Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 61 Chapter 6 - Administrative Procedures The following administrative provisions shall govern the implementation of the Claremont Graduate University - Claremont Campus Master Plan: A. USES AND DEVELOPMENT PERMITTED WITHIN THE Claremont Graduate University – Claremont Campus MASTER PLAN BOUNDARIES 1. Relationship of the Claremont Graduate University - Claremont Campus Master Plan to the Claremont Municipal Code Approval Process. The permitted uses and development within the Master Plan boundaries are governed by the provision set forth in the City's Municipal Code for the Institutional District (as such Code may be amended in accordance with this Master Plan), the City's General Plan (as such General Plan may be amended in accordance with this Master Plan), this Master Plan, and any applicable development agreement. 2. Additional Uses and Development Which May Be Permitted Without an Amendment to the Claremont Graduate University –Claremont Campus Master Plan. In addition to the permitted uses outlined in (1) above, special uses or development which are listed in 16.306 of the Municipal Code as permitted in an Institutional District subject to the issuance of a special use and development permit may be permitted within the Master Plan boundaries in accordance with the appropriate review procedures in the Municipal Code. B. DEVELOPMENT REVIEW PROCEDURES 1. Review Requirements Unless plans for buildings and structures and all signs, luminaries, landscaping, irrigation and other features of the site for buildings, parking lots, or other structures, have been approved pursuant to the review procedures established in the Municipal Code, no building permits will be issued. 2. Review Responsibilities All new construction, modifications, and site changes shall be reviewed as set forth in Section 16.300 of the Claremont Municipal Code, as amended from time to time. 3. Scope of Review for Projects Implementing this Master Plan The City's review of specific projects implementing components of the Claremont Graduate University Master Plan (including parking) shall be limited to the projects' architectural elements, layout, massing, landscaping, lighting, and compliance with Title 16 of the Claremont Municipal Code, the provisions of the Claremont Graduate University Master Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 62 Plan, and any development agreement. Provisions of the Claremont Graduate University Master Plan and any development agreement shall take precedence over the provisions of Title 16 of the Claremont Municipal Code in case of conflict. Environmental review of specific projects shall rely on the CEQA documents adopted with the Claremont Graduate University - Claremont Campus Master Plan. Any subsequent environmental review of a specific project shall be limited to impacts that would occur as a result of the project and which were not examined as part of the CEQA documents adopted with the Claremont Graduate University –Claremont Campus Master Plan or are more significant than described in the CEQA documents adopted with the Claremont Graduate University – Claremont Campus Master Plan. C. ADMINISTRATION OF THE Claremont Graduate University –Claremont Campus MASTER PLAN 1. Administrative Adjustments The Director of Community Development may administratively approve the following minor adjustments to explicit provisions in the Claremont Graduate University - Claremont Campus Master Plan: a) The addition of new information to the Claremont Graduate University –Claremont Campus Master Plan maps or text that does not change the effect of any regulations or guidelines. b) Minor expansion in the boundaries of the Claremont Graduate University Master Plan area, provided the area of the expansions does not exceed 5% of the total Master Plan area. c) Modifications to the layout or location of structures, parking or other programmatic usages, which do not have the effect of increasing student enrollment or staffing and/or creating environmental impacts greater than previously analyzed. 2. Claremont Graduate University –Claremont Campus Master Plan Amendments If an amendment does not qualify as an Administrative Adjustment, then this plan may be amended in accordance with the plan review provision of Municipal Code Section 16.069.030. Each amendment shall include all sections or portions of the Claremont Graduate University –Claremont Campus Master Plan that are affected by the change. All amendments shall be required to be consistent with the General Plan. 3. Enforcement The Claremont Graduate University - Claremont Campus Master Plan, and/or conditions of approval shall be administered and enforced by the City of Claremont, Community Development Department and subject to the administrative fines program of Chapter 1.14 of the Claremont Municipal Code. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 63 4. Duration The Claremont Graduate University - Claremont Campus Master Plan shall be valid for 20 years from the date of final approval by the City. At the conclusion of the 20-year period, the Claremont Graduate University - Claremont Campus Master Plan will expire unless the approval of the Master Plan is formally extended. Once the Master Plan expires, all planned improvements on private property which were not implemented prior to the Master Plan's expiration shall not be constructed unless such improvements are approved pursuant to a new Master Plan or other applicable City regulations in effect at the time. If there are remaining public improvements for which permits have been issued and bonds collected but not constructed prior to expiration, then these improvements shall be completed in a timely manner. Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 64 Appendices To be added following City Review Nov. 21, 2012 Claremont Graduate University-Claremont Campus Master Plan 2012 i