IIIIII
IIIIIIII
IIII
IIIII
III
IIIII
IIIII
IIIII
lUl
IIIIII
IIIII
IIIII
IIIII
IIII
IIIIII
IIIII
IIII
IIII
USFC2006-1168-08
{D97D4B66-3EF0-4389-B5B8-55F210133203}
{70883}{32-060622
181051}{061206}
JOINT
APPENDIX
Volume
III, Pages
JA0730
- JA1052
06-1168
UNITED
STATES
COURT
OF
APPEALS
DESA
FOR
THE
FEDERAL
CIRCUIT
IP, LLC
Plaintiff-Appellant
V.
and
COSTCO
dUN.
WHOLESALE
CORPORATION
j_,
Defendants-Appellees
APPEAL
MIDDLE
FROM
THE UNITED
DISTRICT
STATES
OF TENNESSEE
JUDGE
ALETA
JOINT
DISTRICT
IN CASE
A. TRAUGER
APPENDIX
COURT
NO.
FOR
3:04-CV-0160
'/_b_o_
_ 2 2006
F
THE
TABLE
OF CONTENTS
PAGE
CERTIFIED
U.S.
DOCKET
PATENT
NO.
STIPULATION
TRANSCRIPT
MASTER
RULING
.......................................................
..........................................................................
MARKMAN
HEARING
.......................................
.................................................................................................
TO COMPLAINT
CORPORATION
ANSWER
LLC
STATEMENT
OF STEVEN
STATEMENT
OF MARK
STATEMENT
STATEMENT
JA0016
JA0028
JA0032
JA0059
JA0066
JA0081
JA0082
JA0092
BY
........................................................................
B. CARLSON
JA0099
..................................................
JA0106
J. PATTERSON
..................................................
JA0135
OF WILLIAM
C. RAPER
.....................................................
JA0151
OF THOMAS
J. PAULUS
.....................................................
JA0164
OF FILING
JOINT
..................................................
TO COMPLAINT
TECHNOLOGIES
JA0001
BY
WHOLESALE
AMENDED
WITH
................................................................
................................................................................................
ANSWER
NOTICE
......................................................................
CHART
FOLLOWING
COSTCO
...................................................................
OF JUDGMENT
CLAIM
COMPLAINT
EML
5,598,066
OF JUDGE'S
SCHEMATIC
ORDER
SHEET
OF THE
APPENDIX
JOINT
APPENDIX
.............................................................................
JA0190
EVANS
JA0730
STATEMENT
OF SCOTT
STATEMENT
OF J. MICHAEL
...............................................................
THESZ
......................................................
JA0736
STATEMENT
MARKMAN
OF PROFESSOR
HEARING
LLOYD
TRANSCRIPT
MASSENGILL
..........................
.......................................................
JA0748
JA0781
U.S. PATENT
NO. 3,177,399
........................................................................
JA0951
U.S. PATENT
NO. 4,225,808
........................................................................
JA0955
U.S. PATENT
NO. 4,233,545
.............. :.........................................................
JA0963
U.S. PATENT
NO. 4,604,524
........................................................................
JA0974
U.S. PATENT
NO. 4,800,278
........................................................................
JA0985
U.S. PATENT
NO. 4,823,051
........................................................................
JA0998
U.S. PATENT
NO. 4,843,283
........................................................................
JA1027
U.S. PATENT
NO. 4,943,712
........................................................................
JA1034
U.S. PATENT
NO. 4,982,176
........................................................................
JA1042
U.S. PATENT
NO. 5,015,994
........................................................................
JA1053
U.S. PATENT
NO. 5,231,373
........................................................................
JAI064
U.S. PATENT
NO. 5,293,097
........................................................................
JA1075
U.S. PATENT
NO. 5,349,330
........................................................................
JA1093
JAPANESE
CLAIM
PATENT
NO. 6-90995
..............................................................
JA1102
KEY ...................................................................................................
JA 1110
TEXT KEY .....................................................................................................
JA 1112
SPICE
SIMULATION
EXCERPTS
FROM
SIGNAL
STEVEN
PLOT
RESULTS
B. CARLSON
- "SIGNALS"
DEPOSITION
..............
.......................
JA1118
JA1119
DEPOSITION OF STEVEN B. CARLSON .................................................. JA1154
DERENIAK
et al., Infrared
Detectors
and Systems,
pp. 86-7 .......................
SPICE
SIMULATION
SIGNAL
PLOT RESULTS
- "TRIGGER"
SPICE
SIMULATION
SIGNAL
PLOT RESULTS
- "NO TRIGGER"
.............. JA 1179
....... JA1180
EVANS'
TEST CIRCUIT
SCHEMATIC
DIAGRAM,
PART
EVANS'
TEST
SCHEMATIC
DIAGRAM,
PART 2 ...................
CIRCUIT
EXCERPTS
FROM
MODERN
EXCERPTS
FROM
MERRIAM-WEBSTER
CURRICULUM
VIDEO
VITAE
OF WILLIAM
OF LLOYD
C. RAPER
CASE MANAGEMENT
COMPARISON
DICTIONARY
PLAN
SCHEMATIC
1...................
OF ELECTRONICS
ONLINE
MASSENGILL,
PhD ........................
DIAGRAMS
JA1182
...... JA 1200
.............................
AND ORDER .............................................
CIRCUIT
JAI 181
......... JA1183
DICTIONARY
DEMONSTRATION
JA1175
JA 1215
JA1242
JA 1243
...............................
JA1255
TEXT KEY .....................................................................................................
JA1270
PRODUCT
FOR PIRs ...........................................................
JA1277
HEATH ZENITH INSTRUCTION
MANUAL
FOR THE REFLEX
SL-5315-A
PULSE COUNT MOTION SENSOR LIGHT CONTROL
........ JA1334
LITERATURE
NIPPON CERAMIC
INSTRUCTION
MANUAL
FOR PIR PASSIVE
INFRARED
ENERGY CONTROL
SWITCH ...............................................
JA1342
JENSEN
JA1343
AND McCAVIT
EXCERPT
RELEVANT
OF RAPER
CLAIMS
DECLARATION
DEPOSITION
................................................
..........................................................
OF U.S. PATENT
Ill
NO. 5,598,066
............................
JA1359
JA1367
EXCERPT OF LANDIS ON MECHANICS
OF PATENT CLAIM DRAFTING
................................................................
JA 1374
COLOR-CODED
CHART DEPICTING
THE TRIAL
COURT'S
FINDINGS
FOR CORRESPONDING
STRUCTURE
OF "[FIRST]
AND "CONTROL
CIRCUIT
U.S. PATENT
Nilssen
SENSOR MEANS"
MEANS" ........................................................
JA1383
........................................................................
JA1385
NO. 6,225,748
v. Magnetek,
Inc.,
1999 WL 982966
(N.D. Ill. 1999) ........................
JA1394
Applied Medical Reources
Corporation
v. United States
Surgical Corporation,__
F.3d __, 2006 WL 132504
(May 15, 2006) ................................................................................................
JA 1403
EXCERPTS
JA 1421
OF U.S. PATENT
NO. 5,598,066
IV
.............................................
UNITED
STATES
MIDDLE
DISTRICT
NASHVILLE
DESA
DISTRICT
COURT
OF TENNESSEE
DIVISION
_,LLC,
Cwd
Plamhff,
Action
No. 3-04-0160
Judge Aleta A. Trauger
Maglstrate
Judge Joe B Brown
V,
t
EML TECHNOLOGIES,
LLC and COSTCO
WHOLESALE
CORPORATION,
Defendants
STATEMENT
OF SCOTT
EVANS
PURSUANT
JA 0730
TO LOCAL
RULE
12(C)(6)(C)
I.
Personal
and Professional
Background
1 have a Bachelors of Science m Electrical and Electronic
from California State Polytechnic University in 1978
Engineering,
which I earned
I am currently employed at Agilent Technologies
in Fort Collins, Colorado (formerly part
of Hewlett Packard) as an Integrated Circuit design engineer deslgrang full custom CMOS chips.
In this capacity, I have worked with a 100-person team deslgrtmg Hewlett Packard workstation
rmcroprocessors.
I have also designed many other circuits including Verilog digital control
systems, software (kshell Perl C ) for Spice generation, clrcuit testing and data processing,
Application
Specific Integrated Cixcmts (ASICs) with hundreds of milhons transistors used in
mtemet routers and hagh-speed microcomputer
boards, differential drivers and recelvers
operating
at over 1 GHz
In addatlon to my work at Agdent, I presently act as an independent consultant.
I have
worked for Intclectron, de'velopmg a low cost Passive Irtffared Motion Detector and a battery
powered Passive Infrared Motion Detector design for them. Some of the novel improvements
to
Intelectron's
Passive Infrared Motion Detector resulted in a patent for motion detector with
improved signal discrimination.
I have also worked with EML m developing a Passwe Infi-ared
Motion Detector with an adjustable two level lighting system. This resulted m a patent being
issued for mohon-detector
circuitry with adjustable background lighting level I also worked
with ElVIL on the design of multiple Passwe Infrared Motlon Detectors including the design that
Desa accuses of mfi'ingang a Desa patent.
H.
TERMINOLOGY
A.
"Passive
Infrared
Motion
Detector;"
"PIR
Motion
Detector."
When I use the terms "Passive Infrared Motion Detector" or "PIR motaon dctcctor," I
mean a motion detector which incorporates a "PIR sensor" (somettmes also referred to simply as
a "PIR") together with circuitry which selects among the signals received from the PIR to which
correspond to motion of a person or other object sought to be detected, and disregard those
signals recewed from the PIP, which do not have the proper electrical frequency or amphtude
characteristics.
This is the type ofclrcmts that I have helped design for [ntelectron and EML.
B.
"PIR
Sensor;"
"PIR."
When I use the term "PIR sensor," or the term "PIR" without any further qu',difier, I mean
a passive infrared sensor which consists ofa pyroelectnc element. Thas electrical element as
sensitive to changes m temperature and produces an electrical cunent m response to changes in
temperature
Current from the element is converted into a voltage and amplified, therefore a
rapid change m temperature will produce a charactenstlc
brief pulse of negatave-going
then
positive-going
(or positave-going than negatwe-going)
electrical voltage
The oscilloscope
trace
shown in the screen capture at the bottom of page 6 of Mr. Raper's testimony (which begins at a
particular background level of voltage, goes negatave for a few m_lliseconds, then positive for a
few more mflliscconds,
and then returns to the background level) is characteristic of the signal
produced when a PIP, is exposed to a change in infrared radiation
It should be noted that
JA 0731
typxcally a low cost PIR sensor is packaged with the small amount of circuitry
the current into a usable voltage (one resistor and one field effect transistor).
needed to convert
HI.
Does Not
A Person of Ordinary Skill in the Art to Which
Require Lighting Expertise.
the Patent Pertains
I have been asked to comment upon statements m the written testimony of Desa
witnesses, including Mr. Carlson, that a person of ordinary skill in the art to which U.S. Patent
No 5,598,066 (the "'066 patent") pertains requires experience m the "lighting" field. In my
opinion, a person of ordinary skill m the art to which the patent pertains does not require
experience m the "hghting" field.
For one thing, the patent &sclosure is devoted to concepts familiar to any electrical
engineer. For example, the patent is not concerned with topics typically reserved for lighting
engineers, such as specifying how much light is required at various points in the field of interest.
Also, the patent claims only concern with the amount of light is whether a "first level of
xllummahon" and a "second level of illumination substantially greater than said first level of
illumination"
are provaded depending upon whether or not a "predetermined
condttlon" is
detected by a "sensor means .". Any electrical
di£fcrence between two levels ofillumination.
Moreover,
in my experience,
electrical
engineer
engineers
and is capable
make significant
of understanding
contributions
the
in this
field. For example, I am named as an inventor on six issued patents and one pending applicahon
Two of those patents are on security lights, at least one of which is currently owned by Desa.
Copies of these patents and patent applications are attached as Defendants' Exhibits 63 and 64,
respectively, l I am an electrical engineer, not a lighting engineer. By the same token, in his
deposition, Mr. Raper testified that he is an electrical enganeer, not a hghtmg engineer, and that
his 10 years of industry experaence belbrejoinmg
Desa was as an electrical engineer in a field
not related to lighting. See Raper deposition, pages 28"20-29:12, which are attached as
Defendants' Extubit 65 Mr Raper also testified that it is always Desa's customers who specify
how much light Desa's lamps should deliver to various points in the field of interest. See, Id.,
pages 35:24-36:12.
Also, hke me, despite the fact that he is not a hghting enganeer, M.r Raper is
named as inventor on several Desa patents. See, Id., pages 73:20-74.25
Also see copies of
patent and patent applications on winch Raper is a named inventor, attached as Defendants'
Exh_its 66 and 67, respectively
IV.
Evans
Built and Tested the Circuitry
Disclosed
in the '066 Patent.
In preparation for my testmaony herein, I built and operated the circuit disclosed
'066 patent.
m the
To do this, I studied the patent and the circmt diagrams (Fig. 2A and Fig 2B)
i All exhibits are attached to the Declarataon of Roger L Cook In Support
Written Markman Testimony ("Cook Decl ), filed herewith
JA 0732
Of Defendants'
I
then used
my knowledge
of electronics
and, more
specifically
my years
of expenence
in
deslgmng
low cost Passive Infrared Motion Detectors,
to come up with a "first pass" set of
values to be used in the design.
My intent was to find values that would implement
the design
features
in the patent
It was not my intent
did not do a worst-case
analysis
values
work
it would
always
and implement
the design
What
low power
quad
and ensure
I did was bmld
features
For the eight operational
LM324
to find a set of production-worthy
of the circuit
values.
that for all comer
a typical
circuit
cases
That is, I
of component
with typical
values
that work
in the '066 patent
amplifiers
amplifier
that are dmclosed
This allowed
in the patent,
I decided
me to use only two packages
to use an
to get all eight
operational
amplifiers
Since the patent shows a 5-volt power supply to the op amps, the patent
must be referring
to a low voltage capable op amp
In addition,
since the first gain stage gets Its
positive
common
Input from the source of the PIR (Q2), the op amp for the first stage must have a
mode range that includes
voltages near ground
All these features
are available
m the
LM324.
Since
wanted
cost is always
a concern
to use all of the op amps
all eight
op amps.
The LM324
two decades.
I also notmed
same
of mverters
number
CD4069
hex inverter
Since
circuitry,
has been
that comes
the circuit
it seems
hkely
that the inventors
two quad packages
consumer
shows
PIP, based
allows
designs
the use of rex lnverters
m an inexpensive
any CMOS
to be able to isolate
to build
PIR's,
and using
used in many
that the '066 patent
IC, although
I wanted
I decided
in consumer
in one package
package
hex inverter
AC voltage
First,
for the past
This (sax) Is the
mverters
that can run at 5 volts
the 110V main
ua two sections
of CMOS
one to use
I picked
the
is appropriate
from the low voltage
I built the power
supply
section
that
would have the high voltage
110V circuit elements
along with the 5V supply
Then, I built a
board with the mare functmns,
including
the op amps and the mverters
This allowed for a much
safer test environment
PIR's
with all the high voltage
P1P,.'s typically work at the focal point of a fresnel
(Q1 and Q2)
I was able to pick up the Heath/Zenith
Depot.
Tins model looks like the drawing
Heath/Zenith
model, I saw that the model
patent
However,
alignment
fresnel
block
lens
for the PIR's
to ensure
a small
the power
pc board,
in Figure
no longer
I was able to use the fresnel
I then built
I built
copper
colnponents
supply
drilling
I would
printed
board
clrcmt
lens,
from
human
touch
lens. The '066 patent shows two
2 SL-5630 model at a local Home
1 of the patent
When I opened the
uses the circuitry
disclosed
m the '066
its plastic
have
board
mounting,
two PIR's
(PCB)
on a PCB by photo
out the holes
isolated
for the components
and the plastic
mounted
to mount
etching
at the focal
point
of the
the two PIR's.
a single
sided
and then soldering
photosensitive
the electrical
components.
I initially
get the response
hand.
Then
2 1 understand
built the main board
I expected
I designed
that Desa
on a solderless
and so I could
a PCB and built
owns
Heath
use values
it using
breadboard
so I could
of resistors
and capacitors
a single
Zenith
JA 0733
sided
photosensitive
vary clrcmt
values
that I had on
copper
pc board
to
using
photo-etching
components
clear
techniques.
from
I drilled
the solderless
out holes
breadboard
for the components.
to the PCB and soldered
I transferred
them
I built a clear acrylic box for the power supply board. I mounted
acrylic sheet along with the power supply, PIR unit mad a 100-watt
w_red all the components
With
Defendants'
In testing
bright
relatively
the circuit
falling
distant
of the circuit
noted
that using
I would
than
within
move
produce
count
nodes
of interest
are marked
as
my circuit
allows
would
I could
comparator
hght the lamp
indicative
move
would
to dusk or
at a relatively
output
will cause
for a single
change
pulses
close
into the field
produce
very wide pulse
of view
radiation
of false
the first of those
comparator
pulses
to light the lamp.
(very
large
at
but
to me that,
in infrared
the likelihood
in which
to a
an output,
from the window
the circuitry
dim
the lamp
This indicated
of a change
did its job by reducing
time interval,
minimum
values
which
token,
Successive
a predetermined
a predetermined
(correspondmg
light a lamp
into the field of view in relatively
would
slgnal
circuitry
pulse.
would
an output,
the window
which
an output
spurious
which
By the same
an output
the PIR, the pulse
greater
the test circuit
that in a low hght environment
would
had produced
due to a single
width
to build
an output
from the P/R,
did not produce
upon
portion
when
level of illumination.
the PIRs
triggering
Then,
produce
to the PIR, the circuit
a location
all the intermediate
as intended.
m order
I observed
would
level of illumination.
although
I prepared
the circmt,
relatwely
I
68 and 69, respectively.
the circuit
proximity
] was able to probe
that they worked
diagrams
Exhibits
nighttime),
together,
and observed
The circuit
the main board on a
Halogen
lamp holder.
together
the components
in the circuit
the
in place
signal)
had a
I also
to
satisfy the pulse counter clrcmtry
and hght up the lamp. I beheve that this is not unexpected
or
undesired
from the users point ofwew.
A user would like the lamp to respond
qmckly without
having
to wmt for a second
Date:
April
Roger
L. Cook
pulse
if the first pulse
Scott Evans
12, 2005
(CA Bar No. 55208)
(admitted
Angus M. MacDonald
(CA Bar No. 212526)
TOWNSEND
and TOWNSEND
and CREW
Two Embarcadero
Center,
San Francisco,
CA 94111
Tel:
(415)
576-0200
Fax.
(415)
576-0300
Attorneys
is very long.
pro hac vice)
(admitted
LLP
8th Floor
for Defendants
EML Technologies
Costco Wholesale
LLC and
Corporation
JA 0734
pro
hac vice)
PROOF
I, Susan
Baker-Lehne,
am a citizen
OF SERVICE
of the United
States
and an employee
County of San Francisco,
State of California.
I am over the age of eighteen
within action.
My business
address is Two Embarcadero
Center, 8 th Floor,
94111.
EVANS
I am "readily
correspondence
Postal
Service
California,
served,
more
5fo).
familiar"
for mailing.
Express:
processmg
deposited
course
the date of deposit
correspondence
San Francisco,
By Facsimile:
California,
On the same
By E-mall:
I caused
hsted below.
Robb S Harvey
Waller Lansden
Dortch
Nashville
City Center
511 Union Street, Suite
Nashville,
TN 37219
FAX: 615-244-6804
E-mail:
machine
such documents
rharvey@wallerlaw.com
PLLC
number
AND
date is
Fed. Rule
prachce
Civ. Proe.
of collection
that practice
it would
thereon
was also transmitted
(415)
576-0300
to be sent by electronic
and
be
fully prepaid
to the following
persons
mail to the e-mail
Middleton
Reuthnger,
PSC
2500 Brown and Williamson
401 South Fourth Avenue
Tower
jhlggins@middreut.com
rtheuerkauf@rniddreut.com
AND
FEDEX
L. Carnal
Department
of ECE, Box 5004
Tennessee
Technological
University
Cookeville,
TN 38505-0001
E-mail:
clcee@charter.net
BY E-MAIL
foregoing
AND
U.S.
MAlL
I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of Califorma
that the
is true and correct.
Executed
on April 8, 2005, at San Francisco,
Cahfornia.
Susan
JA 0735
Baker-Lehne
at
addresses
Lomsvllle,
KY 40202-3410
FAX: 502-561-0442
FEDEX
at
by facsimile
James R. Hlggms,
Jr.
Robert J. Theuerkauf
BY E-MAIL
Dr. Charles
of the party
meter
of business
E-mail:
BY E-MAIL
in affidavit.
Under
course
date the document
2100
that on motion
w_th the firm's
Express.
with the U.S.
at San Francisco,
date or postage
on that same day with postage
in the ordinary
& Davis,
I am aware
cancellahon
and processing
be deposited
fully prepaid
for malhng
familiar"
for Federal
Express
transmission
from facsimile
the below fax numbers.
(X)
if postal
of collection
it would
thereon
of business.
invalid
I am "readily
with Federal
practice
that practice
day with postage
is presumed
than one day after
with the firm's
Under
on that same
in the ordinary
service
By Federal
()
and not a party to the
San Francisco,
CA
On April 8, 2005, I served the following
document(s):
STATEMENT
OF SCOTT
PURSUANT
TO LOCAL
RULE
12(C)(6)(C)
on the parties in this action
By Mail:
(x)
in the City and
UNITED
STATES
MIDDLE
DISTRICT
NASHVILLE
DESA
DISTRICT
COURT
OF TENNESSEE
DIVISION
IP, LLC,
Plaintiff,
V.
Civil Action
No. 3-04-0160
Judge
A. Trauger
Aleta
Magistrate
Judge
Joe B. Brow;p, L2 "_g_ _':_,i"_""- _,
EML TECHNOLOGIES,
LLC and COSTCO
WHOLESALE
CORPORATION,
A_
I _ 2_05
Defendants.
31-..2_-
STATEMENT
OF J. MICHAEL
THESZ
PURSUANT
JA 0736
TO LOCAL
RULE
12(C)(6)(C)
TABLE
I.
II.
Personal
Topics
A.
and Professional
OF CONTENTS
Backgrotmd
...............................................................................
Addressed
...................................................................................................
Exammahon
Under 35 U S.C. §112, Paragraph
6 ..............................................
B.
The Claims
C.
A Patent
in U S. Patent
Applicant
No. 5,598,066
May Disclaim
..........................................................
A Particular
Claim
Interpretation
Prosecuhon
in the PTO, Particularly
When Distinguishing
Prior Art ..................................................................................................
D.
3
In Distinguishing
Disclaimed
Counting
Its Claims
Any Interpretation
from the Nippon
of Its Claims
Ceramic
6
During
the
8
Prior
Art, Heath
That Does Not Require
................................................................................................
JA 0737
Over
4
4
Pulse
9
I.
Personal
and Professional
My name
is J. Michael
Background
Thesz.
I am self-employed
as a patent
law consultant
My office
address is 600 Water Street, SW, Washmgton,
D.C, 20024. I have been engaged as a patent
consultant
by the law firm of Townsend
and Townsend
and Crew LLP on behalfofEML
Technologies,
LLC on issues
and Trademark
'066 patent).
the relevant
office
("PTO")
before
apphcatlons,
concerning
PTO
practice
from
U.S. Patent
vitae
is attached
at the PTO in 1968
Exammer
to work
as a Patent
Commissioner
revolved
I served
as a Patent
Examiner.
recognihon
of Science
m 1982.
as a Senior
1982
and procedures
During
recognition
to
and the
of patent
degree
witness
in Electrical
degree
to 1996.
from
inventorsh_p
petitions,
as well as preparing
such as Information
Disclosure
Statements
over
a
I continued
of the Assistant
1,000 patent
apphcations,
mechanical
Commissioner
for
m the decision-making
official
for
I became
Examiner.
or strictly
of the Assistant
I participated
I was the deciding
applications
inventions.
on the staff
to chemical
m the Office
As such,
patent
as a Senior
for a position
as opposed
Advisor
issues.
I examined
this time, I examined
inventions
Legal
of
as an officer in the United States
programs
A true and correct
and data processing
until I was selected
electrical
at the PTO from
PTO policy
a Bachelor
(the
I am registered
as an expert
in 1965 and Juris Doctor
in 1974, and, in 1977, I earned
Examiner
5,598,066
of Columbia
I also serve
patent
and my review
on the prosecution
arts.
States
hereto.
character
for Patents
all of which
inventions.
Dame
Number
and experience,
in 1973. From 1965 to 1968, I served
as a project engineer for missile testing
electro-mechanical,
Primary
has focused
I received
of Notre
the Umted
law for over 35 years
in the electrical
and procedures.
the University
of my curriculum
] started
in patent
before
to the bars of the District
My law practice
for inventions
Georgetown
University
Army, including
work
Patents
and procedure
the patent-in-suit,
I am admitted
of Virginia.
primarily
Engineering
electrical,
regarding
who has specialized
the PTO.
Commonwealth
copy
prachce
I base the following
on my personal
knowledge
documents
in this case as listed below.
I am an attorney
practice
concerning
law
process
on filing date and correction
on
of
and reviewing
decisions
on a variety of other matters,
I was also responsible
for PTO commumcations
with the Patent Bar and members
of the pubhc, presented
lectures, on a variety of patent law
topics, in the United States and Japan, and lectured at the PTO Patent Academy.
I also drafted
and Jmplemented
and to define
practice,
provides
rule changes
the duty to disclose
In January
Procedure
patent
including
reformation
1991, I was appointed
(MPEP).
The MPEP,
the PTO a user-fee
to the PTO that is material
the Editor
comprising
to make
of the Manual
over
1,400 pages,
funded
agency
to patentability.
of Patent
Examining
is the reference
work
on PTO
procedure,
and patent law for the patent professionals
m the PTO
The MPEP also
guidance
for patent attorneys
and agents in how to proceed in dealing with the PTO.
The MPEP
is looked
to by the Federal
courts
I left the PTO in 1996 and entered
the law firms
firms,
those
of Morgan,
my practice
Lew_s
consJsted
& Bockms
primarily
and others
private
as the official
practice
LLP and Hogan
of prosecuting
From
1996 to 2002,
& Hartson
and supervising
JA 0738
statement
LLP
ofPTO
pohcy.
I worked
with
At both of these
the prosecution
of patent
applications
consultant.
in the electrical
I am a member
practice
before
Trademark
Since
of the bars
the United
Office.
arts.
States
I am a member
Topics
Addressed
A.
Examination
I have
been
with 35 U.S.C.
Heath
prior
Chairman,
Under
have
art and winch
lnc.,
16 F.3d
6. I base
wanted
the Patent
(Fed.
Property
application
Law
Office
to interpret
limited
Thus,
Circuit
have been
on several
have found
stand
decided
reasonable
would
to be allowable.
up in court
have
to the corresponding
the PTO
actions
was required
As a result,
court,
more
described
narrowly
such
Circuit
limitations
sixth paragraph,
structure
as reading
Company,
plus function
than elements
in the specification
elements
in claims
and equivalents
limitation
thereof.
Thus,
in a claim
and equivalents
plus function
of such
in claims
art structure
and that the PTO was required
means
limitations
are construed,
that are not limited
35
from the
claims in a
to whether the prior art
described
in the specification.
in the specification
to be the same as the mterpretatmn
also
on
to mterpret
on any pnor
plus function
§112, sixth paragraph,
the
would
based
in In re Donaldson
was improper,
means
described
of 35 U.S.C.
means
for a
avoided
Heath
to any challenge
that the PTO was required
that this PTO practice
§112,
the interpretation
for
Society
factors.
to the PTO which
of the Federal
which
interpreting
decided
a 35 U.S.C.
and
6.
which performed
the function
specified
in the claim without regard
structure
was the same or equivalent
to the corresponding
structure
The Federal
to
Association,
and Trademark
or not it would
claims
would
decision
Cir. 1994)
had been
'_
and the U S. Patent
U.S C. § 112, sixth paragraph,
means plus function
limitations
in a manner different
way those limitations
had been interpreted
for many years. _ The PTO in examining
patent
law
and am admitted
C_rcuit
Paragraph
my opinion
to present
Examiner
of the en banc
1189
Intellectual
§112,
on whether
have wanted to obtain a patent which would
invalidity
of the patent over prior art.
As a result
and Virginia
for the Federal
and of the Patent
35 U.S.C.
as a patent
position
to have sought examination
under 35 U.S C. §112, paragraph
have been entirely reasonable
for Heath to draft claims in accordance
§112, paragraph
would
self-employed
of Columbia
of Appeals
of the American
asked to comment
patent applicant in Heath's
6. In my opinion, it would
I have been
of the District
Court
which I have served as a Committee
of which I am a past President
II.
2002,
thereof.
limitations
had been
in the PTO
to the corresponding
means
plus function
as
in
in court
and in
structure
claims
have
a
i The sixth paragraph
of 35 U.S.C. §112 states: An element in a claim for a combination
may be
expressed
as a means or step for performing
a specified
function without the recital of structure,
material,
or acts in support thereof, and such claim shall be construed
to cover the corresponding
structure,
material,
or acts described
in the specification
and eqmvalents
thereof.
JA 0739
better
chance
litigation
as vahd
that patents
patent
of being
obvious
to a person
broad
relevant
single
enough
mvention
Heath
patent
prior
to literally
unfamiliar
would
coverage.
art also included
Instruction
Manual".
&scussion
of that prior
during
sustained
are often
patent
in
surprised
litigation
to learn
if 1) the
the prior art, or 2) the &fferenees
that the clauned
not have had any reasonable
prosecution
invention
expectation
file history
at the time of the application.
hghtmg
of being
with patents
as invalid
read upon
As the patent
art in existence
level security
chance
between
would
have
been
skill in the art at the time that it was made.
system,
'066 Patent as prior art considered
Reflex SL-5315
-- A Pulse Count
prior
Persons
a better
and the prior art are so minor
of ordinary
In this case,
vahd
and have
by the PTO can be challenged
are broad
the claimed
in the PTO,
over the prior art.
issued
claims
allowed
the instruction
manual
of being
shows,
The prior
art included
for which
Is hsted
by the patent examiner.
See Heath Zenith
Motion Sensor Light Control", Defendants'
the Nippon
Ceramic
"PIR Passive
See Nippon
Ceramic
Instruction
art in the Declaration
Infrared
Manual,
of Jensen
Energy
very
Heath's
own
on the face of the
"Instructions
for the
Exhibit 56. 2 The
Control
Defendants'
and McCavit,
able to obtain
there was
Switch
Extubit
Defendants'
57; the
Exhibit
58,
and the Aronson Declaration
dated September
9, 2004, previously
filed in this action and
attached
as Defendants'
Exhibit 59 to the Cook Deck Also, Professor
Paulus has testified
that all
of the mdwidual
2A and
B] were
circuit
conventional
textbooks.
60.
purchased
of the circuit
that could
of Paulus
since retail
by competitors
"reverse
products
circuits
See transcript
Further,
so-called
elements
can be qmte
valuable
by simply
As a result
products
of these
valid
factors,
at page
and their circuitry
the patent
in my opimon,
competitors
holder's
it would
Figures
or electronic
0018, Defendants'
consideration
revealed
§112, paragraph
since they prevent
['066 patent,
engineering
deposition
of the type under
35 U.S.C.
duplicating
of the patent
in electrical
31, 2005
in the open market,
engineenng,"
in the marketplace
be found
March
electromc
diagram
6, patent
from gaining
Exhibit
here can be easdy
by close inspection
claims
or
for such
an unfair
advantage
circuitry.
have been
eminently
reasonable
for a
person in Heath's position to have sought patent claims in accordance
with 35 U.S.C. §112,
paragraph
6 While such clmms are not given a broad range of coverage,
a person in Heath's
position
ought not to have expected
valid broad coverage
m view of the closeness
of the prior
On the other
competitor
circmtry,
terms
hand,
from
which
such claims
gaining
is readily
are less likely
an unfair
accessible
advantage
to be held invahd
by duplicating
to competitors
in litigation
the patent
and can prevent
holder's
art.
a
electrical
in the marketplace.
In paragraph
30 of his Statement,
Mr. Patterson
states "the practice o fusing
'means'
in patent claims has been somewhat
different
m electronics
as compared
to mechanical
technologies."
no exception
I do not agree.
The statutory provision
for electronic
inventions.
Further, based
2 All extubits are attached to the "Declaration
Written Markman
Testimony"
("Cook Decl.")
(35 U.S.C. § 112, sixth paragraph)
makes
on my years of experience,
1 do not
of Roger L. Cook In Support
submitted
herewith.
JA 0740
of Defendants'
believe
that Patent
electronic
inventions
B.
in a way
The Claims
The claim
Defendants'
A claim
Examiners
elements
Markman
limitation
attorneys
different
from
in U.S. Patent
m dispute
briefs,
using
or patent
raises
the word
treat those
other
limitations
inventions,
in claims
nor should
they
"means"
which,
directed
to
No. 5,598,066
here all include
a presumption
"means"
the word
that 35 U.S.C.
combined
as set out in
§ 112, sixth paragraph,
with a function
invokes
35 U.S.C.
applies.
§ 112,
sixth paragraph,
unless modified
by sufficmnt
definite structure
to achieve entirely the stated
function 3. The recitation
of some structure
in the means plus function
element does not preclude
the apphcabthty
of 35 U.S.C.
For example,
tending
dictate
to avoid
which
wluch performs
sixth paragraph.
I have
have
use of the structural
to keep the door closed"
of 35 U S.C § 112, sixth
not required
structure
§ 112, sixth paragraph.
found
the ambit
of 35 U.S.C.
has a reasonably
the specified
6
set forth below
that a claim
language
in the limitation
§ 112, sixth paragraph
well understood
function,
a table
element
"spring"
did not take the limitation
out of the ambit
paragraph.
4 However,
recitahon
of precise
using
meamng
can be sufficient
comparing
the word
claim
"means"
5, but rather
to one of ordinary
to avoid
language
the ambit
from cases
combined
"spring
means
of the construction
physical
structure
a term naming
is
a
skill in the art, and
of 35 U.S.C.
in whmh
wath a function
§ 112,
the courts
1) recites
3 Cole v Kzmberly-Clark
Corp., 102 F.3d 524 (Fed. Cir. 1996) (Element
"perforation
means
extending
from the leg band means to the waist band means through the outer impermeable
layer
means for tearing"
_s not means-plus-function
element
under 35 U.S C. § 112, sixth paragraph,
because
the perforations
constitute
the structure
supporting
the tearing function,
and the claim
also recites its location (extending
from the leg band to the waist band) and extent ( extending
through the outer impermeable
layer) )
4 Umdynamtcs
Corp v. AutomatzcProductslnternatzonalLtd,
157 F.3d 1311, 1319 (Fed. Cir
1998) (The Court noted that the spec_ficatmn
said that "The spnng 46 is an example
of spring
means.);
cf TurboCare
Dtviszon of Demag Delaval
Turbomachmery
Corp. v. General Electrtc
Co., 264 F.3d 1111 (Fed. Cir. 2001) ("Compressed
spring means" is not means-plus-function
phrase, but a particular
kind of spring.)
5 CCSFttness,
Inc. v. Brunswick
would understand
"reciprocating
structures.
)
Corp., 288 F.3d 1359 (Fed. Cir. 2002)(one
of ordinary
skill
member"
to have ordinary
meaning
and to connote beam-hke
6 Greenberg
v. Ethmon Endo-Surgery,
lnc, 91 F.3d 1580 (Fed. Cir. 1996)("detent
mechanism"
is
not subject to the ambit of 35 U.S.C. § 112, mxth paragraph);
PersonahzedMedm
Communicattons
LLC v US. Int "l Trade Comm "n, 161 F.3d 696 (Fed. Cir. 1998) ("digital
detector"
is sufficiently
definite
structure
to avoid the ambit of 35 U.S.C. § 112, sixth
paragraph);
Apex, lnc v Rantan
Computer,
Inc., 325 F.3d 1364 (Fed. Cir. 2003) ("Circuit"
itself
may not connote
structure,
but it does connote
at least some structure when used with appropriate
modifier
like "interface
circuit for receiving...signals
. .")
JA 0741
sufficientstructureto performthe statedfunction,thusprecludingthe apphcablhtyof 35U S.C.
§112,sixth paragraph,or 2) recitesinsufficientstructureto performtbe statedfunctionso that35
U S.C §112,sixth paragraph,applies In eachof the claim elements,I havefollowed thesame
conventionasthe MasterClaim Chart,AppendixA to the Statementof Massengilt,identifying
"means" (including "for") in BOLD; "structure"(including location and response) by
UNDERLINE,
Held:
and the function
Sufficient
Structure"
In a clmm
for training
"perforation
means
band
to the waist
means
the outer
by 1TALICS
Held:
pants,
In a clmm
extending
from the leg
band
impermeable
means
the training
acczdent
by the user''
bnef
for
[for]
Untdynamlcs
Intert, atzonal
Lid,
machine,
tending
Corp
to keep the door
v Automatic
157 F 3d 1311 (Fed
1001 (Fed
Ctr
In a claim for a motorized
riding
fimshing
a concrete
surface,
Corp ,
trowel
In a claim
for
for a slot-draw
attenuator
a web of thermoplastic
"gearbox
means
for rotating sa_d blade means,
said gearbox means comprising
a pair of
"corona
means
rotatable
charging
sald frame
prolectlng
means
downwardly
and defining
Allen Engineering
Corp
1336 (Fed Clr 2002)
froln
a blaxlal
plane"
v Bartell lnd , hlc , 299 F 3d
attenuator
cooperating
and pomtioned
the filaments
with said
for electrostatically
so that
are reduced in the filaments
spread the filaments
before
on sam
collection
fimshing
for a motorized
a concrete
riding
trowel
for
In a claim
surface,
surface
progralnmed
control
"flexible
gearbox
means
drive shaft means
means m response
thereby
revolvmg
for actuating
to said motor
sam
rotor
means,
flexible drive shaft means comprising
individual
shaft sections axmll,/linked
by friction
disk means
Allen Engineering
Corp
1336 (Fed C_r 2002)
for a digital
said
said
together
for facdltatlng
bending"
v Bartell [nd, bin,
299 F 3d
to perform
used to
filaments,
repelhngforces
to more umformly
they are deposited
to form
a web"
Nonwovens
Stmpsonmlle,
Ine v Superior
LLC, 303 F 3d 1332 (Fed Clr 2002)
In a claim
1998)
1996)
produce
shafts
Products
Clr
m case of an
Cole v Km_berly-Clark
102 F 3d 524, 41 USPQ2d
closed"
Structure
for a vending
"s p____g
r
means
through
layer me,ms
removing
Insufficient
computer
system
the method
of the boot procedure
BBA
Nonwovens,
ofgmmng
of a digital
computer,
"means
for bootmg sam chgztal computer,
said
means of booting including
a first set of
commands,
said first set of commands
resident
on said storage device of said digital computer
for bootmg sam digital computer,
and a
second
set of commands
dewce
external
resident
on a storage
to said d_gital computer
for
booting sam chgttal computer"
Altms, Inc v
S vmanuec Corp, 318 F 3d 1363 (Fed Clr 2003)
In paragraph
26 of his Statement,
Mr Patterson
states that 35 U.S C. § 112, sixth
paragraph,
does not apply ifa means plus function term "connotes
structure".
This Js not a
correct
statement
of the law, and IS not helpfill
in the analysis
JA 0742
of the apphcablhty
of 35 U S C
§ 112, sixth paragraph to a means plus function element
In fact, 35 U.S C. § 112, sixth
paragraph, means plus functton limitations always connote sla'ucture, z e., the corresponding
structure disclosed in the specification.
One of ordinary skill m the art could clearly recognize
that structure was being claimed, but that no specific structure was being recited.
In preparing this Statement, I have revxewed the prosecution history ofU S Patent
Number 5,598,066 (the '066 patent), the Statements of Mark J. Patterson, William C. Raper and
Steven B. Carlson, and the Markman briefs of the parties. I agree, in general, with Mr.
Patterson's
description of the patent application process in paragraphs 5-25 of his statement.
However, I will be prepared to expand on his description, if called upon to do so.
Co
Corp,
A Patent Applicant May Disclaim A Particular Claim Interpretation
During
Prosecution in the PrO, Particularly
When Distinguishing
Over the Prior
Art.
The Federal Circmt had this to say in Ballard Medical
60 USPQ2d 1493 (Fed. Cir 2001),
Products
v. Allegiance
An inventor may use the specification and prosecution history to
define what his invention m and what it is not--partlculaxly
when
dlstinguistung
the inventaon over prior art. "[J]ust as prosecutaon
history estoppel may act to estop an eqmvalence argument under
the doctrine of equivalents, positions taken before the PTO may
bar an mconslstent position on claim construction under § 112, ¶
6." Cybor Corp v. FAS Techs , Inc., 138 F.3d 1454, 1457, 46
USPQ2d 1169, l175(Fed
Cir. 1998)(quotmgAlpex
Computer Corp
v. Nmtendo Co, 102 F 3d 1214, 1221, 40 USPQ2d 1667, 1673(Fed
Cir. 1996)) Statements detailing the shortcomings of the relevant
prior art have often proved useful in construing means-plusfunction claims. For example, in Stgntech USA, Ltd. v Vutek, Inc ,
174 F 3d 1352, 50 USPQ2d 1372 (Fed Cir. 1999), the patentee,
which had used means-plus-function
claun format, noted that the
structure used by certmn pnor art was "incapable" ofacluevmg
the
desired results of the invention. That was held to be an "explicit
disavowal of prior art structure," which was properly used in
construing the means-plus-function
claims. See 174 F.3d at 1357,
50 USPQ2d at 1375. When a patentee advises the examaner (and
the public after patent issuance) that a particular structure is not
wittun his invention, the patentee is not permitted to assert m a
subsequent infi-mgement action that the same structure is
equivalent to the structure described in the patent's specification
for purposes of section 112 paragraph 6
Similarly,
the Federal
Circmt has said,
That exphc_t arguments made dunng prosecution
prior art can lead to narrow claim interpretations
JA 0743
to overcome
makes sense,
Healthcare
because '[t]he public has a fight to rely on such definitive
statements made during prosecution.'
Spectrum Int 7, Inc. v. Stenlite Corp., 164 F.3d 1372, 1378-79 (Fed. Cir. 1998) (quofmg Digital
Biometrtcs v Identix, Inc., 149 F.3d 1335, 1347 (Fed. Cir. 1998))
In Distinguishing
Do
Disclaimed
Counting.
Its Claims
from the Nippon
Any Interpretation
Ceramic
Prior Art, Heath
of Its Claims That Does Not Require
Pulse
In my opinion, in distinguishing
its claims from the Nippon Ceramic pnor art during
prosecution of the '066 patent application, tfeath Co. (at the time, the owner of the applieanon)
disclmmed any interpretation
that does not require pulse counting, in a declarataon filed in the
PTO on Apnl 29, 1996, and signed by Heath employees Jensen and McCavlt, McCavit had this
to say"
In the foregoing,
the key statement
_s
"[F]urther testing demonstrated
that the energy control sw_teh in
accordance with the instruction manual did not have apulse
counting feature to reduce false operatton of the sw_tch as
generally disclosed and claimed in the instant application or
other features as recited m the claims as amended m a Preliminary
Amendment
being filed herewith." (Emphas_s added).
Declarations
such the one stgned by Jensen and McCavit are normally drafted by the
patent attomey, and that appears to be what happened here The Jensen and McCavit declaration
is over the law firm's name and address and contains a word processing document number wl'nch
is consistent with other papers prepared by the patent attorney
Thus, I believe that the wording
of the declaration was chosen w_th care
JA 0744
Heath's patent attorney filed a preliminary amendment concurrently with the. Jensen and
McCavit declarahon.
At that tame, claims 1-3, 5, 9-17 were pending.
In the preliminary
amendment, Heath's patent attorney reformed the patent examiner about Heath's discovery of the
Nippon Ceramic prior art, directed the exarmner's attenhon to the Jensen and McCavit
declaration,
and made a number of characterizations
and representations
regarding the manual
override claims (amended claims 1, 3, 5, new claimsl5, 16, 17 and non-amended
claims 9, 13
and 14). However, as to the non-manual override claims (amended claims 2, 10, 1 l and 12), the
patent attorney merely stud, "In addition, clamas 2, 10, 11 and 12 are directed to features clearly
not disclosed or suggested m the instruction manual "
The only specific feature that Heath pointed out to distinguish its non-manual-override
claims was McCavit's statement that the Nippon Cerarmc umt lacked "[the] pulse counting
feature to reduce false operahon of the switch as generally disclosed and clamaed in the instant
application."
The language "pulse counlang feature to reduce false operation of the switch" is
actually underlined by hand m the file history copy of McCavit's declaration.
Most likely, this
underhning was done by the Patent Examiner, indicating to all persons who inspect the file
tustory (including competitors '_astung to know what they can and cannot do to avoid infringing
the patent) that the Patent Exanmner considered this statement particularly notable -- as it plainly
would be if the claims are construed under § 112, sixth paragraph.
I have considered whether or not Mr. McCavit's statement is reasonably construed to
mean that all pending claims were hmited to pulse counting, as would be true if the clmms were
construed m accordance with § t 12, sixth paragraph, rather than construed to mean only that a
single claim [apphcation
claim 16; '066 patent claim 12] was limited to pulse counting, as would
only be true if the claims were not construed m accordance with §112, sixth paragraph.
In my
view, and as a matter of grammar, the former is an eminently reasonable interpretation
oflVlr.
McCavWs statement. Under conventional rules of grammar, where a word such as "generally" is
intended to qualify two succeeding words joined by the conjunction
"and," the qualifier is
placed immediately in front of the conjunctive phrase. In that event, and the words joined by the
conjunction are given a parallel constmchon. See Shertzer, Elements of Grammar, pp. 45-46,
Defendants' Exhibit 61 Thus, m the phrase "generally disclosed and claimed," "disclosed" and
"clmmed" are gaven parallel constructions.
Thus, "generally" is understood to quahfy both
"dlsclosed" and "claimed. ''7 So understood, McCavlt is understood to be saying, "pulse
counting" is "generally disclosed and [generally] clazmed in the instant apphcation."
I interpret
"generally" to mean "in a reasonably reclusive manner".
Since pulse counting was expressly set
forth m only one of the pending claims, tins statement would be untrue unless, as EML contends,
the claims are construed in accordance with §112, sixth paragraph._l:has
interpretation
is also
supported by McCavit's statement in the same paragraph where the manual override ftmctlon,
which was included m some but not all of the pending clamas, is amply referred to as "disclosed
and clmmed in the instant application," rather than as "generally disclosed and claimed"
7 Compare, for example, "generally disclosed and also claimed,"
normally be understood to only quahfy "disclosed "
JA 0745
m which "generally"
would
Here,
I would
("sensor
means..."
cotmtlng
circuitry.
part
Although,
of the "sensor
whichever
party
Date:
April
Roger
L. Cook
note that all claims
and "control
means..."
is correct,
circuit
contain
means...")
as advised,
the parties
or part of the "control
pulse
counting
would
(admtttedpro
Tel:
Fax:
(415)
(415)
Center,
CA
hac vice)
(admtttedpro
LLP
8th Floor
94111
576-0200
576-0300
Wholesale
in view
still be included.
Attorneys
for Defendants
EML Technologies
LLC and
Costco
claim
Corporation
JA 0746
hac race)
elements
encompass
as to whether
means...,"
J. Michael
(CA Bar No. 55208)
Embarcadero
San Francisco,
disagree
circuit
plus function
could potentially
12, 2005
Angus M. MacDonald
(CA Bar No. 212526)
TOWNSEND
and TOWNSEND
and CREW
Two
two means
which
Thesz
"pulse
the pulse
counting"
of the disclaimer
is
PROOF
1, Susan
Baker-Lehne,
am a citizen
OF SERVICE
of the United
States
and an employee
County of San Francisco,
State of California.
I am over the age of eighteen
within action.
My business
address is Two Embarcadero
Center, 8 th Floor,
94111.
On April 12, 2005, I served
MICHAEL
THESZ PURSUANT
By Mail:
I am "readily
correspondence
Postal
served,
more
familiar"
for mailing.
Service
Califorma,
the following
TO LOCAL
on that same
in the ordinary
service
is presumed
fully prepaid
cancellation
for mailing
and processing
be deposited
I am aware
if postal
than one day after the date of deposit
of collection
it would
thereon
of business.
invahd
practice
that practice
day with postage
course
and
document(s):
STATENIENT
OF 3.
RULE
12(C)(6)(C)
on the parhes in this actmn
with the firm's
Under
in the City
and not a party to the
San Francisco,
CA
with the U.S.
at San Francisco,
that on motion
date or postage
in affidavit.
of the party
meter
date is
Fed. Rule
Civ. Proc.
5(b).
(x)
By Federal
Express:
2005, with postage
course of business.
()
By Facsimile:
The document
thereon
On the same
By E-mad
listed below
I caused
Robb S. Harvey
Waller Lansden
Dortch
Nashville
City Center
511 Union Street, Suite
Nashville,
TN 37219
FAX- 615-244-6804
E-mail:
such
machine
documents
& Davis,
number
was
(415)
576-0300
2100
FEDEX
persons
mail to the e-mall
AND
Tower
corn
FEDEX
L. Carnal
I declare
foregoing
AND
under
U.S. MAIL
penalty
is true and correct.
ofpeoury
Executed
under
on April
the laws of the State of California
12, 2005,
at San Francisco,
Susan
JA 0747
that the
California.
Baker-Lehne
at
addresses
Department
of ECE, Box 5004
Tennessee
Technological
University
Cookevllle,
TN 38505-0001
E-marl:
clcee@charter.net
BY E-MAIL
13,
by facsimile
to the following
j higgins@middreut.com
rtheuerkauf@middreut
BY E-MAIL
Dr. Charles
on April
in the ordinary
James R. Higgins, Jr.
Robert J Theuerkauf
Middleton
Reutlmger,
PSC
2500 Brown and Williamson
401 South Fourth Avenue
Louisville,
KY 40202-3410
FAX: 502-561-0442
PLLC
E-mail:
AND
Express
California,
also transmitted
to be sent by electronic
rharvey@wallerlaw.com
BY E-MAIL
with Federal
at San Francisco,
date the document
transmission
from facmmile
the below fax numbers
(x)
will be deposited
fully prepaid
UNITED
STATES
MIDDLE
DISTRICT
DISTRICT
NASHVILLE
DESA
COURT
OF TENNESSEE
DIVISION
_,LLC,
Plaintiff,
Cwil
Achon
No. 3-04-0160
Judge Aleta A. Trauger
MagJstrate
Judge JoeB,
Vo
Brown
RECE
EML TECHNOLOGIES,
LLC and COSTCO
WHOLESALE
CORPORATION,
lAPP,1 4 2005
Defendants.
STATEMENT
OF PROFESSOR
UNDER
LOCAL
LLOYD
MASSENGILL
UNDER
LLOYD
RULE
JA 0748
STATEMENT
OF PROFESSOR
CAqF NO 3-04-016,0
P20
L R 12(C )6(C)
MASSENGILI,
12(C)(6)(C)
.....
TABLE
I.
Personal
II.
Topics
Addressed
A.
Topics
Addressed
B.
Basis
for Opinions
Charts
and Graphics
A.
Appendix
A: Master
B.
Appendix
B: Comparison
C.
Appendix
C. Claim
D.
Appendix
D: Text Key ............................................................................
HI.
BackGround
IV.
A.
W.
and basis
..................................................................................
1
..............................................................................
1
for opinions
........................................................................................
2
............................................................................................
Claim
2
Chart ..........................................................................
Diagrams
2
.............................................................................
3
Key ..................................................................................
3
3
Tutorial
1.
Photosensor
2.
PIN Sensor
3.
Operahonal
3
................................................................................
3
....................................................................................
3
..........................................................................................
Amphfier
("Op
The '066 patent
C.
Claims
6, 9, 10 and 11 Of the'066
D.
SPICE
Simulation
1.
Preparing
2.
The SPICE Simulation
Circmtry,
and Control
Amp")
4
..........................................................
4
............
of the '066 Patent
the SPICE
5
Patent ..............................................
5
Circuit ....................................................
Simulation
6
.............................................................
6
of the PINs, Their Selection
Logic .............................................................
In the Means Plus Function
Claim Elements
in '066 Patent
10 and 11, The Recited Structure
Is Insufficient
to Perform
Function .......................................................................................................
6
Claims 6, 9,
the Stated
7
Claim Elements
A and I ("Sensor Means" and "First Sensor
Means") Recite Insufficient
Structure
To Avoid Interpretation
under § 112 ¶ 6 ................................................................................
8
Claim Element J ("Second
Sensor
Structure
To Avoid Interpretation
9
OF PROFESSOR
3-04-0160
1
............................................
B.
B.
STATEMENT
Background
..........................
Techmcal
A.
CASENO
and Profesmonal
OF CONTENTS
LLOYD
MASSENGILL
UNDER
Means") Recites Insufficient
under §112 ¶ 6 ...............................................
-i-
L R 12(C )6(C_
JA
0749
TABLE
Claim
Avoid
C_
D°
E)
Fo
G.
H.
Sub-Element
Interpretation
cont'd
C(1) Recites Insufficient
Structnre
To
under § 112 ¶ 6 ...............................................................
10
Claim Sub-Element
C(2) (" Switching
Means") Recites
Insufficient
Structure
To Avoid Interpretation
under §I 12 ¶ 6 .....................................
11
Claim
Means
Avoid
12
Sub-Element
C(3) ("Means for Causing Switching
to Be Actuated")
Recites Insufficient
Structure To
Interpretation
under §112 ¶ 6 ........................
......................
Claim Sub-Element
C(4) ("Means Causing Threshold
to Have
Third Value") Recites Insufficient
Structure To Avoid
Interpretation
under §112 ¶ 6 .........................................................................
12
Claim Element E ("Means for Producing Ramp Waveform")
Recites Insufficient
Structure
To Avoid Interpretation
under
§11276
.................................................................................
13
Claim Element G ("Means for Causing Threshold
to Have First
and Second Values") Recites Insufficmnt
Structure To Avoid
Interpretahon
under §112 ¶ 6 .........................................................................
13
Clmm Element H ("Light Sensing
Structure
To Avoid Interpretahon
14
Means") Recites Insufficient
under §112 ¶ 6 .............................................
Claim Element K(I) ("Means for Causing Lamp to Emit Light
at First and Second Levels") Recites Insufficient
Structure To
Avoid Interpretation
under § 112 ¶ 6 .......................................................
15
Claim Element K(2) ("Means Responswe
to Detectxon of First
Predetermined
Condihon")
Recites Insufficient
Structure To
Avoid lnterpretahon
under § 112 ¶ 6 .......................................................
15
Structure
Whmh Defines the Means Plus Function
Claim Elements
of
Claims 6, 9, 10and
11 ...................................................................................................
16
A.
16
K,
VI.
OF CONTENTS_
Structure
Defining
Claim
Element
A "Sensor
Means".
........................................
1.
Predetermined
Conditions
Involving
the Photocell
2
Predetermined
Conditions
Involwng
the PIRs
Element
A Refers
.
4.
The "Sensor
Claim
17
.................................
17
to the
PIRs and Their Associated
"Selecnon
Circmtry,"
But
Not to the Photocell
and Its Associated
"Selection
Circuitry.".
....................................................................................
17
The "Carlson"
19
a)
STATEMEN'I
OF PROFESSOR
CASE NO 3-04-0160
Means"
................................
LLOYD
Structure
The Photocell
MASSENGILL
UNDER
Does
Not Define
Does Not Define
LR
12(C )6(C)
JA 0750
Element
Element
A .............................
A .............................
19
- U -
TABLE
b)
(2)
C.
D
E°
Structure
Defining
Structure
Switching
Defining
Means
Structure
Threshold
Defining
to Have
....................................
9
PIP, Selection
Circuitry
Must Be
Included .........................................................................
20
Photocell
21
Selection
Circuitry
..................................................
The Structure
Defining
Claim Element
C(1) ("Control
Means")
..........................................................................................
B°
Sub-Element
C(2) ("Switching
Circmt
21
Means")
..........................................
Sub-Element
C(3) ("Means for Causing
to Be Actuated")
...................................................................
22
22
Sub-Element
C(4) ("Means Causing
Tturd Value") .................................................................
23
Structure
Defimng
Claim Element
E ("Means for Producing
Ramp Wave form")
.....................................................................................
23
Structure
Threshold
Defining
to Have
Claim Element
G ("Means for Causing
First and Second Values") ......................................................
24
H.
Structure
Defining
Claim
Element
H ("Light
24
I.
Structure
Defining
Claim
Element
I ("First
J.
Structure
Defining
Claim
Element
J ("Second
K.
Structure
Means")
Defining
Claim Element K(1) ("Control
Circuit
............................................................................................................
G.
Sensing
Sensor
Means")
Means")
Sensor
.................................
.....................................
Means")
Structure
Defining
Claim Sub-Element
K(2)("Means
Responsive
to Detection
of First Predetermined
Condition")
g.
...........................
OF PROFESSOR
NO 3-04-0160
LLOYD
MASSENGILL
UNDER
L R |2(C
JA
)6(C)
0751
25
25
25
..................................
Alternatively,
If The Sensor Means Claim Elements
A and I
Were Construed
To Not Include The Pulse Counting
Selection
Circuitry,
Pulse Countmg
Would Be Part Of The Control
Circuit Means Claim Elements
C(I) and K(1)
.....................................................
M°
CASE
cont'd
The {}112 ¶6 Definition
Of Element A Must
Include Selection
Circuitry ....................
(1)
STATEMENT
OF CONTENTS,
26
26
- ili -
I.
PERSONAL
AND
I am a professor
University
in Nashville,
Vanderbilt
Institute for
modeling,
analysis,
and
achvities.
I am a Fellow
PROFESSIONAL
BACKGROUND
of Electrical
Engmeenng
and Computer
Engineering
at Vanderbilt
Tennessee.
I am also the founding Director of Engineering
for the
Space and Defense Electromcs
(ISDE), where I &rect all electromc
design for various govemmentand corporate-funded
engineering
of the Institute of Electrical
and Electromcs
Engineers.
I hold Ph.D., M.S., and B S degrees in Electrical
Engineenng
from North Carolina
State University
and have worked at Vanderbllt
University
since 1987. I have taught
undergraduate
and graduate courses in microelectronic
circuit analysis, analog circuit design,
digital logic, digital circuit design, computer-aided
design, and basic electrical
engineering
theory.
I have performed
research in microelectromc
circuit analysis and design for mihtary
and space systems,
including
the U S Navy, U S. Air Force, the Defense
Threat Reduction
Agency,
DARPA,
and NASA, I have worked on commercial
electronics
design with BAE
system, Compaq Computer,
Boeing Aerospace,
Hughes Aerospace,
Harris Semiconductor,
Lockheed
Martin Aerospace,
and Texas Instruments;
and I have over 100 technical
publications
in electromc
theory,
A copy of my curriculum
analysis,
vitae
and design.
is provided,
I hold a DOD
as Defendants'
I have been asked to study the Wlesemann
patent (U.S.
'"066" patent) m order to contribute
to what has been explamed
or claim construction.
If.
TOPICS
A.
provided
ADDRESSED
Topics
AND
BASIS
FOR
Secret
Exhibit
security
clearance.
43}
Patent Number
5,598,066
- the
to me as Markman
proceedings
OPINIONS.
Addressed.
My presentation
is divided
by other witnesses.
into three
sections
First,
I supplement
the technical
tutorials
Second, I address whether or not the structural
language
in each of the twelve claim
elements
which contain the word "means" followed by a statement
of function ("means plus
fimction"
format) recite sufficient
structure
to perform the function stated in the claim element.
As advised, this is the test for determining
whether or not those "means plus funchon"
claim
elements
must be interpreted
in accordance
with 35 U S.C. §112 ¶6. In my opinion, none of the
twelve claim elements
recite sufficient
structure
to perform the recited function..
My opinion
here is largely consistent
wath Desa's expert witness Steven Carlson, who only found one claim
element that recited sufficient
structure to pcrform the recited function.
Third, as advised, claim elements construed
m accordance
with §112 ¶6 are interpreted
to mean the corresponding
structure
set forth m the written descriphon
(including
drawings)
of
the patent, and equivalents
thereof.
Accordingly,
as to the claim elements which 1 have
concluded
must be interpreted
m accordance
with §112 ¶6, I have determined
and identified
All exhthits are attached
to the Declaration
Testimony
("Cook Decl ") filed herewith.
STATEMENT
OF PROFESSOR
CASE NO 3-04-0160
LLOYD
MASSENGILL
UNDER
of Roger
L. Cook In Support
L R 12(C )6(C)
JA 0752
Of Written
Markman
which portions
elements.
of the written
description
correspond
to, and therefore
define,
those
claim
In this respect, as advised, and as is evident from my reading of the corresponding
written
statements
of Desa witnesses
Carlson, Raper and Paulus, there is a sharp dispute
between
the parties as to whether the term "sensor means for detecting
a predetermined
condition
external
to set apparatus"
(or "first sensor means for detecting
a first predetermined
condition
external
to said apparatus"),
as relates to the use of passive infrared sensors ("PIRs")
in the detection
of motion, should be interpreted
to mean just the PIRs (Desa's interpretation)
or
to mean the PIRs in combination
with what I refer to as the "selection"
circuitry
(the detector
43, turn on inhibit 46, amplified
and filter 47, window comparator
48 and pulse count 51)
which determines
which signals output by the PIRs are the result of a "predetermined
condition"
I.e. a preselected
change in infrared radiation
incident upon the PIRs.
For reasons I shall explain in greater detail herein, I am of the opinion that Defendants'
"sensor means..."
and "first sensor means.."
interpretations
are correct; however,
even ffDesa
were correct that the selection circuitry
is not part of the "sensor means," but instead is part of
the "control circuit means," the net result would be the same, i.e that the "selection"
circuit
elements
are necessarily
included
in each of the asserted claims 6, 9, 10 and 11, since "control
circuit means" claim elements
are present
m each of clatms 6, 9, 10 and 11.
Finally, I will comment
on points of disagreement
between my analysis and that of
Desa's witnesses.
In particular,
I will explain why I believe I have correctly
identified
the
circuit elements
which support the various means plus function claim elements
and subelements
and, to the extent we differ, why I believe the clrcmt elements
selected by Mr.
Carlson (on behalfofDesa)
are incorrect.
B.
Basis
for Opinions.
In the following
analysis,
my opinions,
including
whether or not the claim elements
recite sufficient
structure
to avoid §112 ¶ 6, and as to what constitutes
the supporting
structure
for each of the claim elements,
are based upon 1) my understanding
of the '066 patent including
its textual written description,
claims and drawings,
particularly
including
the schematic
circuit
diagram
of Figures 2A and 2B; 2) portions of the deposition
testimony
and exhibits in this case;
3) the wntten
statements
of the witnesses
m this case, Messrs. Raper, Carlson, Panlus,
Patterson,
Evans, and Thesz; 4) my review of the Markman
briefs in this case, and some of the
supporting
exhibits;
5) my examination
and operation
of Mr. Evans test circuit built in
accordance
with the disclosure
of the '066 patent; 6) my simulation
of the '066 patent circuit
prepared
in accordance
experience
particularly
III.
CHARTS
A.
with the disclosure
of the '066 patent; and 7) my skill, training
including
my 23 years of experience
as an electrical
engineer.
AND
GRAPHICS.
Appendix
A: Master
Claim
and
Chart.
For ease of reference,
Appendix A is a Master Claim Chart (marked as Defendants'
Exhibit 44) which assigns each claim element and sub-element
in dispute a reference
letter (A,
B, C, etc.) and a reference
name (Sensor Means, etc), identifies
the structural
and functional
language
in each "means plus function"
claim element
and sub-element,
and states my opinion
as to whether
or not the structural
language
recites sufficient
structure
to perform
the stated
functmn,
in order to overcome
the presumption
that 35 U S C. §I 12 ¶6 applies.
STATEMENT
OF PROFESSOR
CASENO 3-04-0)60
LLOYD
MASSENGII
I I INDFR
I.R
17((" _6,(("1
JA 0753
-2-
B.
Appendix
B: Comparison
Diagrams.
For ease of reference,
and to highlight the area of dispute, as to each claim element and
sub-element
which I believe is governed
by 35 U S.C. §112 ¶6, Appendix
B (marked as
Defendants'
Exhibit 45) is a set of schematic
circuit diagrams (copies of Figures 2A ,and 2B of
the '066 Patent) marked to show which portions of the '066 circuit diagram, Mr. Carlson (for
Desa) and I (for EML) contend correspond
to each claim element and sub-element.
C.
Appendix
C: Claim
Key.
For ease of reference,
Appen&x C (marked as Defendants'
the '066 Patent claims, with each claim element and sub-element
11 marked and labeled with the appropriate
reference
letter from
D.
Appendix
D: Text
Exhibit 46) is a photocopy
of
of disputed claims 6, 9, 10 and
the Master Claim Chart.
Key.
For ease of reference,
Appendix D (marked as Defendants'
Exhibit 47) is a photocopy
of the '066 Patent text, with the text ] believe corresponds
to each claim element and subelement marked and labeled with the appropriate
reference
letter from the Master Claim Chart.
I have marked the text ] have selected in red To highlight the points where Mr. Carlson and I
differ, the text Mr. Carlson has selected for each claim element and sub-element
is marked in
blue.
IV.
BACKGROUND.
A.
Technical
This supplements
Tutorial.
the technical
tutorial
informahon
provided
by Dr. Paulus
and Mr.
Carlson.
1.
Photosensor
A photosensor
consists of a material (such as cadmium
sulfide -- CdS) which changes
its electrical
resmtance
when exposed to photons (light). Within its range of sensitivity,
a
photosensor
will have a relatively
high resistance
in complete
darkness.
That resistance
will
decline continuously
in response
to increasing
levels of illumination,
and have a relatively
low
resistance
when exposed
to bright illumination.
In Figure
STATEMENT
CASE
2 of the '066 patent
OF PROFESSOR
LLOYD
drawings,
the symbol
for the photosensor
is as follows:
-3-
MASSENGILI
NO 3-0d-0160
JA 0754
2.
PlRSensor
A passive
infrared ("PIR") sensor consists of an insulator
material
which has a
particular
polarity,
which polarity rapidly switches
back and forth by 180 ° when exposed to
changes in infrared radiation.
This rapid change in polarity produces
a characteristic
brief pulse
of negative-going
then positive-going
(or positive-going
than negative-going)
electrical
voltage
(or current)
The oscilloscope
trace shown in the screen capture at the bottom of page 6 of Mr.
Raper's testimony
(which begins at a particular
background
level of voltage,
goes negative
for a
few milliseconds,
then positive for a few more milliseconds,
and then returns to the background
level) is characteristic
of the signal produced
when a P]R is exposed
to a change in infrared
radiation.
3.
Operational
Amplifier
("Op
Amp")
An operational
amplifier
can be used either as an amphfier
or a digitizer.
As an
amplifier,
one can produce
a large output signal in response
to a small input signal.
Nonetheless,
because its output signal cannot exceed the voltage to which it is connected,
an op
amp can also be used as a digitizer.
In other words, if its input signal is below a certain level, it
will produce
an output signal of zero volts whereas,
if its input signal is above that level it will
produce an output signal equal to the voltage to which it is connected.
Where, as in some of
the circuits of the patent, an op amp is eonnected
to a constant voltage of 5 volts (sometimes
referred
to as the "rail voltage"),
the output of the op amp will be either 0 volts or 5 volts,
thereby providing
a "digital" output signal which can be used to represent
"yes" or "no" in a
logic circuit.
STATEMENTOF PROFESSORLLOYDMASSENGILLUNDERL R 12(C)6(C)
CASENO 3-04-0160
JA 0755
-4-
B.
The '066 patent
The '066 patent describes
a security lighting system that xs sensitive to prescribed
motion (e.g. a person) but insensitive
to non-prescribed
motion (e g background
interference,
trees, small animals, etc) and actuates a security light in response.
The patent describes
various
operational
features such as a dim illumination
(or "accent")
baseline mode and a bright
illumination
activated
mode, the use of passive infrared (PIR) sensors for motion sensing, a
user-selectable
dim versus offbackground
mode, a user-controlled
manual override feature to
force bright illumination,
a timing feature to maintain
bright dlummation
for a period of time
following
activation,
and an automatic
photosensor-based
ovemde
funehon to disable
illumination
during the day.
C.
Claims
The claims
below,
these
claims
6, 9, 10 and 11 Of the'066
under
considerahon
are claims
of various
combinations
consist
Patent.
6, 9, 10 and 11. As set forth
of 15 different
claim
in the table
elements:
Claim 11, with nine claim elements,
contains the largest number of common
elements.
The elements
winch make up claims 9 and 10 are subsets of the elements
11. Accordingly,
claim 11 is a convenient
starting point for analysis
A- K(2).
claim
of claim
Claim 6 consists of four elements,
none of which are identical to any of the elements
of
claims 9, 10 and 11. On the other hand, claim 6 element I is nearly identical
to claim element
A in claims 9, 10 and 11; and claim clement K(1) is quite similar to clalm element
C(1) of
claims 9, l0 and 11, since elements A and I include the common phrase "sensor means for
detecting
a ... predetermined
condition
external to said apparatus",
and elements
C(1) and K(I)
include the common
phrase "control circuit means ... for causing saJd lamp to emit [bright
light] in response
to detection
of said predetermmed
condition."
As advised, these two pairs of nearly identical claim elements, A/I mad C(1)/K(1),
underlined
in the table below, have generated
the greatest debate m the Markman
bnefing
and
testimony.
Part of the debate is whether or not these two pairs of claim elements must be
construed
in accordance
with 35 U.S.C
§112 ¶6 I have expressed
element by element
opimons
on this issue m Section V herein.
The means plus function claim elements
are
Mentified
with bold typeface
in the table below
The other part of the debate is, if the means plus function claim elements
must be
construed
in accordance
with §112 ¶6, what is the corresponding
structure
in the patent which
defines those claim elements.
I have expressed
element by element opinions on this subject m
Section VI herein.
All of my opinions
are summarized
Comparison
Diagrams,
Appendix
B.
STATEMENT
OF PROFESSOR
CASE NO 3-04-0160
LLOYD
MASSENGILL
in the Master
UNDER
L R 12(C )6(C)
JA
0756
Claim
Chart,
Appendix
A, and the
-5-
CLAIM ELEMENTS
CLAIM
NO.
A
B
(2(1) C(2)
C(3)
C(4)
D
E
F
G
H
11
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
10
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
9
x
x
x
x
x
6
D.
SPICE
Simulation
1.
Preparing
of the
'066 Patent
the SPICE
I_
J
_
K(2)
x
x
x
x
Circuit.
Simulation.
I have carefully
studied the '066 patent drawing
from my knowledge
of basic electrical
circuit design and clrcmt operation.
I have also implemented
portions of the '066 circuit
structure
of'066
Fig 2 using the industry-standard
circuit simulahon
soRware PSPICE v8.0
from Cadence
Design Systems
Inc. This software is a preeminent
analysis tool used by circuit
designers
worldwide
to verify expected
circuit operation
and to simulate the impact of design
modifications.
I use (or direct the use of) this tool on a frequent basis in my Vanderbilt
classes,
in my research
activities
with government
sponsors,
as well as in my engineering
oversight
duties at the Vanderbilt
Institute for Space and Defense Electronics.
SPICE provides
a highlyaccurate
representation
of the operation
of a circuit.
I have also examined
the test board constructed
by Scott Evans, including
his circuit
schematics,
and the Statement
of Scott Evans Under Local Rule 12(C)(6)(C)
("Evans
Statement").
.
The SPICE Simulation
Control Logic.
of the PIRs,
Their
Selection
Circuitry,
and
Defendants'
Exhibit 48 shows signal plot results of my SPICE circuit simulation
of the
'066 Fig 2 clrcmt from the PIR input devices through the voltage threshold
at Node 61. The
simulations
were performed
using representative
P/R input signals of Q 1 and Q2 as described
by Mr. Raper's
oscilloscope
trace of what he described
as a "Heimann
model LHI-778"
PIR.
of some
The first signal
plot shows the PIR signals at Q1 and Q2 representative
of the detection
change m external IR ra&ahon,
such as a person walking before the apparatus.
The second signal plot shows the output of the Detector
(block 43 in the '066 Fig 2
circuit).
Note that the detector signal is qmte small as it has not yet been significantly
amplified.
The larger signal is the output of the Amplify and Filter (block 47 in the '066 Fig 2
circuit).
Here the signal has been amplified
and further filtered as part of the circuit's
"selection"
process for "predetermined"
mohon.
Also note that both of these signals are analog
(continuously
variable)
STATEMENT
CASE
OF PROFESSOR
NO 3-04-0160
LLOYD
MASSENGILL
UNDER
LR
12(C )6(C)
JA
0757
-6-
The third signal plot shows the output of the window comparator
(block 48 m the '066
Fig 2 circuit).
Note that, as described
in the '066 patent description,
the window
comparator
output manifests
as negative-going
pulses in response
to the analog signal emanating
from the
Amphfy-Fllter
block.
The third sigfial plot also shows the output of the pulse count block
(block 51 in the '066 Fig 2 circmt, labeled "Node A" in Figure 1, mfra)
As described
m the
'066 patent description,
the pulse count clrcuitry responds
to multiple pulses m such a way as to
reduce the probabdity
of false triggering
by motion that is not prescribed.
The output of the
pulse count block (Node A) is a diglhzed
signal which is HIGH when no prescribed
motion is
detected and LOW when prescribed
motion is detected.
In the simulation
plots, we see a
HIGH-to-LOW
transition
(signifying
that the circmt has "selected"
prescribed
motion) at about
3.8 second in response
to the second window comparator
pulse
The fourth signal plot shows the output of the timer block (block 52 m the '066 Fig 2
circuit).
This is a digital (HIGH or LOW) signal representing
when the lamp should be in the
BRIGHT
mode following
prescribed
mohon detection.
Note that the signal remains
HIGH
even after the mohon has ceased.
As described
by the '066 patent, the length of time this signal
will remain high (and thus, the lamp will be m BRIGHT
mode) is user selectable
via the multiposition
switch shown in block 52.
The fourth signal plot also shows the s_gnal voltage at Node 61 m the '066 Fig 2 circuit.
This signal is described
in the '066 patent as the "voltage threshold"
which, in combination
with
the ramp generator
and the phase angle blocks, appropriately
gates the current to the lamp so
that a "DIM mode" and a "BRIGHT
mode" are established.
Vo
IN THE MEANS
PLUS
FUNCTION
CLAIM
CLAIMS
6, 9, 10 AND 11, THE RECITED
PERFORM
THE STATED
FUNCTION.
ELEMENTS
STRUCTURE
IN '066 PATENT
IS INSUFFICIENT
TO
I have been asked to address the "means plus function"
claim elements.
As advised
those are the claim elements
which include the word "means"
followed by a statement
of
function,
usually introduced
by the word "for." Thus, the means plus function claim elements
in the asserted claims 6, 9, 10 and 11 are the claim elements identified
by reference
letters A,
C(1), C(2), C(3), C(4), E, G, H, 1, J, K(1), K(2) in the Master Claim Chart, Appendix
A.
As advised,
a patent applicant
who submits a clmm element in "means plus function"
format is presumed
to have invoked examination
of that claim element under §112 ¶6; this
presumption
can only be overcome
ffthe recited structure
is sufficient
to perform the entire
stated function;
and the party seeking to overcome
the presumption
(in this case, Desa) has the
burden of proof.
In my opinion,
applying the foregoing
rules to the means plus function claim elements
in claims 6, 9, 10 and 11, all of those claim elements fad to recite sufficient
structure
to
perform the entire stated function.
The reason for my opmion is set forth in the following
discussion.
STATEMENTOFPROFESSORLLOYDMASSENGILL
UNDERL R 12(C)6(C)
CASENO 3-04-o160
JA 0758
-7-
A.
Claim
Claim
Recite
Element
Elements
A and I ("Sensor
Means"
and "First
Insufficient
Structure
To Avoid Interpretation
A is as follows:
sensor means
said apparatus;
and Claim
Sensor Means")
under §112 ¶ 6.
Element
for detecting
2
a predetermined
condition
external
to
I is
first sensor means for detecting
afirstpredetermmed
condttion
external
to said apparatus,
said first predetermined
condttion
being motion relative to said first sensor means of a person or an
object separate from said apparatus
See APPENDIX
A, Master
Claim
Chart.
In his deposition,
Mr. Carlson conceded
that, as to Claim Element
I, the word "sensor"
[or "sensor means"] did not recite sufficient
structure
to perform the stated function
of the claim
clement
(in italics).
Defendants'
Exhibit 49, deposition
page 42, line 6-page 47, line 3. See
also Defendants'
Exhibit 50 at page 14. According
to Mr. Carlson, not just any sensor would be
sufficient
to perform the stated fnnctlon:
"There are many types of sensors:
L_ght, heat,
temperature,
pressure,
rotation,
position,
voltage, current, magnetic
field, too many to
enumerate."
Id., Exhibit 49 at page 42, lines 6-14. Not all of these would serve.
Id. at
deposition
page 42, line 21, page 43, line 1. Instead, "[y]ou would need a sensor that had an
output that could be correlated
to motion in some way." Id.
I agree with the foregoing
statements
by Mr. Carlson.
There are any number of
structures
which might meet the structural
language
recited by this claim element; however,
few of those structures
would perform the entire stated fimction of this claim element.
Accordingly,
I agree with Mr. Carlson that the term "first sensor means" does not recite
sufficient
structure
to perform
the stated function of Claim Element
I.
My opinion in this respect is further supported
by the statement
of Michael
Thesz,
which I understand
is being filed contemporaneously
with this statement.
On page __ of his
statement,
Mr. Thesz provides
a table of examples
of patent claim elements which have been
held to have sufficient
structure
and insufficient
structure.
I note that, as a general rule, the
structural
language
in the clmm elements
which were held to have sufficient
structure
allowed
2 In the quoted means plus function claim elements,
the words "means" and "for" are in
boldface
type; the words which relate to structure
[including
location and response]
are
underlined;
and the functional
statements
are italicized.
This coding of the means plus function
language
has been provided
by counsel and, as advised, corresponds
to the coding of relevant
parts of these claim elements
employed
in the PowerPomt
attached to the Statement
on Steven
B. Carlson under Local Rule 12(c)(6)(c)
("Statement").
As advised, a copy of the Carlson
Statement
was marked as Defendants'
Exhibit 11 to the Carlson depomtion
and, during the
deposition,
for ease of reference,
page numbers
were apphed to previously
unnumbered
pages
of Mr. Carlson's
PowerPoint
presentation
which had been attached to the end of Mr. Carlson's
Statement
As advised, Defendants'
Exhibit 50 is a copy of the marked-up
version of Mr.
Carlson's
statement.
STATEMENTOFPROFESSORLLOYDMASSENGILLUNDERLR 12(C)6(C)
CASENO 3-04_160
JA 0759
-8-
me to envision a specific
pants, the claim element
structure
For example,
in Mr
Thesz's
example
of a claim
for training
"perforation
means extending
from the leg band means to the
waistband
means through the outer impermeable
layer means for
removing
the tramingpants
in case of an acctdent
by the user,"
which was held
structure
for the
which were held
For example,
in
to have sufficient
structure,
allows me to'envision
a specific perforation
training pants. By comparison,
the structural language
m the claim elements
to have msufficient
structure
dld not allow me to envision a specific structure.
Mr Thesz's example of a claim for a vending machme, the claim element
"spnnz
means
[for] tending
to keep the door closed,"
which was held to have insufficient
structure,
does not allow me to envision a specific spring
structure.
When I compare
those exemplary
claim elements to claim element A of the '066
Patent, I find that the phrase "sensor meaa_s" is not analogous
to the sufficient
structure
claim
elements
in the left-hand
column of Mr. Thesz's table in that it does not permit me to envision a
specific structure.
Instead, I find Claim Element A, "Sensor Means" directly analogous
to the
claim element
"spring means tending to keep the door closed" which was held to have
insufficient
structure.
As advised, in his deposition,
Mr. Carlson stated that his defimtlons
m claim 6 for both
the "first and second sensor [means]"
would apply in the ["sensor means" claim elements of
claims] 9, 10 and 11, thereby mdicating
that the "sensor means" element A of claims 9, 10 and
11 lack sufficient
structure
for the same reason as element I of claim 6. I am also of the
opinion that the term "sensor me,ms" does not recite sufficient structure
to perform the stated
function
of Claim Element A, regardless
of whether detecting the "predetermined
condition"
requires use of a PIP, or a photocell.
If detecting
the "predetermined
condition"
requires use of
a PIR, then "sensor means" does not recite sufficient
structure to perform the stated function of
Claim Element A, for the identical
reasons given above for Claim Element
I.
If detecting
the "predetermined
condition"
reqmres use of a photocell,
then "sensor
means" does not recite sufficient
structure
to perform the stated function of Claim Element
for the identical
reasons gwen below for Claim Element J, "Second Sensor Means."
B°
Claim
Claim Element
J ("Second
Sensor Means")
To Avoid Interpretation
under §112 ¶ 6.
Element
Recites
Insufficient
A
Structure
J is as follows:
Second sensor means for detecting
a secondpredetermmed
condition,
said second predetermined
condttlon being a
predetermined
level of light external to said apparatus
See APPENDIX
A, Master
Clmm
Chart.
In his deposition,
Mr. Carlson conceded
that, as to Claim Element J, for the same
reasons as Claim Element I, the phrase "second Sensor means" did not recite sufficient
structure
to perform the stated function of claim element J (in italics).
Defendants'
Exhibit
deposition
page 50, line 6 -page 52, line 7. See also, defendants'
Exhibit 50 at page 15.
49,
I agree w_th Mr. Carlson,
for the same reasons.
There are any number of structures
which might meet the structural
language
recited in th_s claim element; however,
few of those
structures
would perform
the entire stated function of this claim element.
In addition, the
STATEMENT
OF PROFESSOR
CASE NO 3-04-0160
LLOYD
MASSENGILL
UNDER
L R 12(C )6(C)
JA 0760
-9-
structurallanguageof Claim ElementJ doesnot allow me to envisiona specificstructure.
Similarly, Claim ElementJ is far moreanalogousto Mr. Thesz'sexamplesof claim elements
which havebeenheld to havelnsufficmntstructure,thanto his examplesof claim elements
which havebeenheld to havesufficientstructure.
Claim Sub-Element
C(1) Recites
Interpretation
under §112 ¶ 6.
Co
Claim
Element
C(1)
Insufficient
Structure
To Avoid
is as follows"
control circmt means coupled to said lamp and responsive
to said
sensor means for causing satd lamp to emtt hght at said first
level of illumination
m the absence of satd predetermined
condition,
and for causing said lamp to emzt light at said second
level of illumination
in response
to detection
of said
predetermined
condition,
whereto said control circuit means is
powered by an AC voltages,
and
See APPENDIX
A, Master
Claim
Chart.
In his deposition,
Mr. Carlson conceded
that Claim Element K(I) recited insufficmnt
structure
to perform the stated function.
Defendants'
Exhibit 49, deposition
page 47, line 4 page 50, line 5. I agree with Mr. Carlson for the same reasons gwen by Mr. Carlson.
While Mr. Carlson &d not specifically
comment
"sufficient
structure"
analysis,
for reasons given below,
between
Claim Element K(1) and claim element C(1).
Claim
Element
K(1)
on element
C(1), 3 for purposes
there are no material
differences
is as follows"
control circuit means coupled to said lamp and
first and second sensor means for causing said
at said first level of illuminatton
in response
to
predetermined
condition
in the absence of satd
predetermined
condition,
and for causing said
at satd second level of dluminatwn
m response
said first predetermined
conditton,
One difference
expressly
refers
which
of the
responsive
to said
lamp to emtt light
said second
first
lamp to emit hght
to detection
of
between Claim Elements
K(1) and C(1) is that Claim Element
to the second predetermined
condit10n (mghttime) 4, expressly
3 Mr. Carlson did not construe
Power Point.
See Defendants'
comments
on element K(1) to
"sufficient
structure"
analysm,
C(1),
calls for
or comment
on element
C(1) in his Statement,
mchiding
in his
Exhibit 50. Presumably
he intended his construction
and
apply to element
C(1)
As explained
herein, for purposes
of
elements
C(1) and K(I) are equivalent.
4 In the Markman
briefing
Defendants
construed
the second predetermined
condition
to mean
daylight,
based on the dictionary
definition
of "light."
As advised, to minimize
disputes,
Defendants
withdraw
that contention
and agree with Desa's interpretation
of"second
predetermined
condition"
as "mghttime."
As a result, as advmed, Defendants
withdraw
their
contention
that claim element C(1) is fatally indefinite.
As advised, to avoid confusion
and
Continued
STATEMENT
CASE
on the next page
OF PROFESSOR
NO 3-04-0160
LLOYD
MASSENOILL
UNDER
L R 12(C )6(C)
JA
0761
-10-
the first (dim) level of illumination
given offby the lamp to be in "response
to [detechon
of the]
second predetermmed
condition
[nighttime]"
by the photocell,
whereas Claim Element K(1),
which does not refer to the second predetermmed
condition,
assumes that the photocell
has
detected nighttime.
As a result, m this respect, for purposes
ofth_s analysis,
Claim Elements
K(1) and C(1) are eqmvalent.
The other &fference
between
elements K(1) and C(1) is that C(1) calls for the control
circuit to be powered
by an AC voltage.
Here again, this difference
does not affect the
outcome
of the "sufficient
structure"
analysis since it is the control circuit which lacks
sufficient
structure,
not its power source.
Accordingly,
for the same reasons that I agree with Mr. Carlson that Claim Element
K(I) does not recite sufficient
structure
to perform the stated function, I am of the opinion that
Claim Element
C(1) does not recite suffiment
structure
to perform the stated function.
There
are any number of structures
which might meet the structural
language recited by this claim
element;
however,
few of those structures
would perform the entire stated function of this claim
element.
In ad&tion,
the structural
language
of Claim Element C(I) is quite general, and does
not allow me to envision
a specific structure.
Similarly,
Claim Element C(1) is far more
analogous
to Mr. Thesz's examples
of claim elements which have been held to have insufficient
structure,
than to his examples
of claim elements
which have been held to have sufficient
structure.
Claim Sub-Element
Structure
To Avoid
Do
Claim
Element
C(2) (" Switching
Means") Recites
Interpretation
under §112 ¶ 6.
C(2) is as follows:
wherein said control
selecttvely
permitting
voltage to said lamp
See APPENDIX
Insufficient
A, Master
Claim
circuit means includes switching
means for
and preventing
the application
of said A C
Chart.
In his deposition,
Mr. Carlson conceded
that Claim Element C(2) did not recite
sufficient
structure
to perform the stated function of claun element C(2). Defendants'
Exhibit
49, deposition
page 56, line 20 - page 59, line 3. See also, defendants'
Exhibxt 50 at page 23
According
to Mr. Carlson,
there are a vast array of switches.
Id. Not just any switch would be
sufficient
to perform
the stated function of the claim element.
Id. Accordingly,
Mr Carlson is
of the opinion that the structural
language
of this claim element does not recite sufficmnt
structure
to perform
the stated function.
Id
I agree with Mr Carlson,
for the same reasons.
There are any number of structures
which might meet the structural
language
recited by this claim element; however,
few of those
structures
would perform
the entire stated function of this claim element.
In addition, the
structural
language
of Claim Element C(2) is quite general, and does not allow me to enwsmn
a
Continued
from
the prevmus
page
minimize
dispute,
to the extent
by Defendants,
the interpretation
STATEMENT
OF PROFESSOR
CASE NO 3-04-0160
LLOYD
this Statement
is inconsJstent
herein shall supercede.
MASSENGJLL
UNDER
L R ! 2(C )6(C)
dA
0762
with any prior clmm
interpretation
-11-
specificstructure.Similarly, Claim ElementC(2) is farmore analogousto
examples
examples
of claim
of claim
elements
elements
which
which
Claim Sub-Element
Actuated")
Recites
§112¶6.
Eo
Claim
Element
have
have
been
been
held to have
held to have
Mr
insufficient
structure,
sufficient
structure.
Thesz's
than to his
C(3) ("Means
for Causing
Switching
Means
Insufficient
Structure
To Avoid Interpretation
to Be
under
C(3) is as follows:
[wherein
said control circuit includes]
means for causing said
switching
means to be actuated for a selectedportion
of each half
wave cycle of said AC voltage, said portion of said half waves
being greater for said second level of illumination
than for said
first level of illumination
See APPENDIX
A, Master
Claim
Chart.
In his deposition,
Mr. Carlson conceded
that Claim Element
C(3) did not recite
sufficient
structure
to perform the stated function.
Defendants'
Exhibit 49, deposition
page 59,
line 3 - page 60, line 24 See also, Defendants'
Exhibit 50 at page 24. According
to Mr.
Carlson, there are an "infinite number
of [control
circuits]
" Id. Not all of these control circuits
would perform the stated function.
Id. "Control
circuit means" encompasses
an lnfimte
number
of structures,
but by itself does not recite sufficient
to perform the stated function.
Id.
I agree with Mr. Carlson, for the reasons he has given.
There are any number of
structures
which might meet the structural
language
recited by this claim element;
however,
few of those structures
would perform
the entire stated function
of this claim element.
In
addition,
the structural
language
of Claim Element
C(3) is quite general, and does not allow
to envision a specific structure.
Similarly,
Claim Element C(3) is far more analogous
to
examples
of claim elements
which have been held to have insufficient
structure,
than to
examples
of claim elements
which have been held to have sufficient
structure.
Claim Sub-Element
C(4) ("Means
Causing
Threshold
to Have
Value")
Recites Insufficient
Structure
To Avoid Interpretation
¶6.
Fo
Claim
Element
[stud
light
thtrd
light
See APPENDIX
Third
under
me
§112
C(4) is as follows:
control cJrcmt
sensing means
value different
sensing means
A, Master
Claim
means including]
means responsive
to said
for causing sam threshold
voltage to have a
from said first and second values when satd
ts detecting
daylight
Chart.
In his deposition,
Mr. Carlson conceded
that, Claim Element
C(4) did not recite
sufficmnt
structure
to perform the stated fimction.
Defendants'
Exhibit 49, deposition
page
line 10 - page 76, hne 14. See also, defendants'
Exhibit 50 at page 28.
74,
According
to Mr. Carlson,
there are a "variety of different
structures" described
by the
structural
language,
however,
not all of those structures
perform
the stated funchon.
Id. Mr.
Carlson
is of the opimon that this clmm element recites insufficient
structure
to perform
the
stated function.
Id.
STATEMENT
CASE
OF PROFESSOR
NO 3-04-0160
LLOYD
MASSENGILL
UNDER
JA
L R 12(C
0763
)6(C)
-12-
I agreewith Mr. Carlson,for the reasonshehasgiven. Thereareanynumberof
structureswhich might meetthestructurallanguagerecitedin this claim element;however,few
of thosestructureswould performthe entirestatedfunchonof this claim element.In addition,
the structurallanguageof Claim ElementC(4) quitegeneral,anddoesnot allow me to envision
a specificstructure.Similarly, Claim ElementC(4) is far moreanalogousto examplesof claim
elementswhich havebeenheldto haveinsufficient structure,thanto examplesof claim
elementswhich havebeenheld to havesufficientstructure.
Go
Claim
Claim Element
E ("Means
for Producing
Ramp Waveform")
Recites
Insufficient
Structure
To Avoid Interpretation
under §112 ¶ 6.
Element
E is as follows:
means for producing
ramp waveform having for each half wave
of said AC voltage a ramppulse
which is mitmted
m response
to
detection
of the zero crossing point for the half wave
See APPENDIX
A, Master
In his deposition,
Claim
Chart.
Mr. Carlson
conceded
that Claim
structure
to perform
the stated function.
Defendants'
Exhibit
page 61, line 5. See also, defendants'
Exhibit 50 at page 25.
structural
I agree with Mr. Carlson.
There
language
recited by this claim
Element
E did not recite
49, deposition
page
are any number of structures
which might
element;
however,
few of those structures
sufficient
60, line 25 -
meet the
would
perform the entire stated function of this claim element.
In addition,
the structural
language
of
Claim Element
E is quite general, and does not allow me to envision a specific structure.
Similarly,
Claim Element
E is far more analogous
to examples
of claim elements
which have
been held to have insufficient
structure,
than to examples
of claim elements
which have been
held to have sufficmnt
structure.
H°
Claim Element
G ("Means
for Causing
Values")
Recites Insufficient
Structure
Threshold
To Avoid
to Have First
Interpretation
and Second
under §112
¶6.
Claim
Element
G is as follows:
[claim 10] means responsive
to said sensor means for causing
said first threshold
voltage to have a first value in the absence
of
said predetermined
condition,
and a second value in response
to
detection
of said predetermined
condition;
[claim 11] means response
(sic) to said sensor means for causing
said threshold
to have a first value in the absence of said
5 In claim 10 phrase corresponding
to claim 11 's "said threshold"
is "saidfirst
threshold
voltage."
These phrases mean the Identical thing. In claim 11, the omitted word "voltage"
is
implicit,
since "sam threshold"
refers back to "threshold
voltage"
in the pnor clause F.
Similarly,
in clmm 10, the added word "first" is surplusage,
since there is only one threshold
voltage mentioned
in claim 10, at clause F Accordingly,
claim elements
G [10] and G [11]
Continued
STATEMENT
CASE
on the next page
OF PROFESSOR
NO 3-044)160
LLOYD
MASSENGILL
UNDER
L R 12(C _6(C_
,JA
0764
-13-
predetermined
condition,
and a second value
detection
of satd predetermmed
eondit:on
See APPENDIX
A, Master
Claim
in response
to
Chart.
In his deposition,
Mr. Carlson conceded
that Claim Element
G does not recite sufficient
structure
to perform the stated function.
Defendants'
Exhthit 49, deposition
page 66, line 11 page 68, line 1 See also, Defendants'
Exhibit 50 at page 26.
I agree with Mr. Carlson
There are any number of structures
which might meet the
structural
language
recited by this claim element; however,
few of those structures
would
perform the entire stated function
of this claim element.
In addition, the structural
language
of
Claim Element
G is qmte general, and does not allow me to envision a specific structure.
Sirmlarly,
Claim Element
G is far more analogous
to examples
of claim elements
which have
been held to have insufficient
structure,
than to examples
of claim elements
which have been
held to have sufficient
structure.
Claim Element
H ("Light Sensing
Means")
To Avoid Interpretation
under §112 ¶ 6.
Io
Claim
Element
Insufficient
Structure
H is as follows:
hght sensmg
for detecting
See APPENDIX
Recites
A, Master
means responsive
to light external to said apparatus
the presence
and absence of daylight
Claim
Chart.
In his deposition,
Mr. Carlson stated that, unlike the other means plus function
claim
elements,
Claim Element
H dlcl recite sufficient
structure
to perform the stated function of
claim element H. Defendants'
Exhibit 49, deposition
page 72, line 2 - page 74, line 9. See also,
Defendants'
Exhibit 50 at page 27.
I do not agree with him here. The phrase "light sensing"
suggests photon detection.
There are three basic types of photon detectors:
1) photoconductors,
2) photoemltters,
and
3) photovoltmc
conductors.
See Defendants'
Exhibit 51, Dereniak
et al., Infrared Detectors
and Systems, pp. 86-87.
Photon detection
involves the concept of converting
a photon of light
into electrical
energy lid.], and electrical
energy is what is required for operation
of the circuit
of the patent.
For purposes
of this analysis,
I will assume that all three of these photon
detectors
would be equally useful in the patented
circuit.
This seems to be what Mr. Carlson
was suggesting
when he said the structural
language
of this claim element is sufficient
to
perform the stated function.
The reason that I disagree with Mr. Carlson's
conclusion
as to sufficient
structure
is that,
by themselves,
none of these photon detectors.is
sufficmnt
to perform the "entire" stated
function which, as I understand
Mr. Thesz's statement,
is what is specifically
required to avoid
§ 112 ¶ 6 The structural
language
of the patent refers to "hght," whereas
the functional
Continued
have
from
the prewous
idenhcal
page
meanings
STATEMENTOF PROFESSORLLOYDMASSENG1LL
UNDERL R 12(C)6(C)
CASENO 3-04-0160
JA
0765
-14-
languagerequires"detectingthepresenceandabsenceofdayhght." It seemsfair to assume
thattheterms"light" and"daylight" wereintendedto meandifferentthings,sincethey appear
in the sameclaim element. Accordingly,
I interpret
"dayhght"
to mean not just "light," but a
predetermined
quantity of light falling on a unit area of the photon detector at any given
moment.
By itself, w_thout additional
selection
circmtry the photon detector has no means for
assessing
whether this predetermined
condmon
is met or not. For this reason, in my opinion,
the structural
language
of claim element H is not sufficient to perform the entire function,
and
thus ought not avoid apphcation
of§112
¶6.
J,
Claim Element
K(I) ("Means
for Causing Lamp to Emit Light at First
Second Levels")
Recites Insufficient
Structure
To Avoid Interpretation
under {}112 ¶ 6.
Claim
Element
K(1)
is as follows
control circuit means coupled to said lamp and
first and second sensor means for causing said
at satd first level of illummanon
m response to
predetermined
condition
in the absence of said
predetermined
condttton,
and for causing said
at said second level of illummation
in response
said first predetermined
conditton
See APPENDIX
A, Master
and
Claim
responsive
to said
lamp to emit light
said second
first
lamp to emit light
to detecnon
of
Chart
In his deposition,
Mr. Carlson conceded
that Claim Element K(1) recited insufficient
structure
to perform
the stated functmn.
Defendants'
Exhibit 49, deposition
page 47, line 4 page 50, line 5.
I agree with Mr. Carlson.
There are any number of structures
which might meet the
structural
language
recited by this claim element; however,
few of those structures
would
perform the entire stated function of this claim element.
In addition, the structural
language
of
Claim Element K(1) is qmte general, and does not allow me to envision a specific structure.
Similarly,
Claim Element K(1) is far more analogous
to examples
of claim elements
which
have been held to have insufficient
structure,
than to examples
of claim elements
which have
been held to have sufficient
structure.
Claim Element
Predetermined
Interpretation
K.
Claim
Element
K(2)
K(2) ("Means
Responsive
to Detection
of First
Condition")
Recites Insufficient
Structure
To Avoid
under {}112 ¶ 6.
is as follows"
wherein stud control c]rcmt means includes means responsive
to
detection
of said first predetermined
condition
for minating
measurement
of a predetermined
time interval, and responsive
to
expiration
of said time interval for causmg satd lamp to
thereafter
emit light at satd first level of dlumination
m response
STATEMENTOFPROFESSORLLOYDMASSENGILLUNDERL.R 12(C"D6(C'D
CASE/_o 3-04-o_6o
JA 0766
-15-
to said second predetermmed
condition
in the absence
recurrence
of sald first predetermined
condalon
See APPENDIX
A, Master
Claim
of a
Chart.
Mr. Carlson did not construe
or cornfiaent upon claim _lement K(2). 6 Assuming
that
this was an oversight,
I will state my opinion that this claim element recites insufficient
structure
to perform
its stated function and, therefore,
does not avoid interpretation
under § 112
¶6. My opinion is based on the fact that there are avast array of different
control circuits which
could "respon[d]"
to detection
of said "first predetermined
condition"
(i e. respond
to detection
of"motion
of a person or other object"), some of which would perform the stated function but
most of which would not. Such a control circuit need not be used to turn on a lamp from dim to
bright for a specified
period of time. Instead, it could be used to sound an alarm; open a gate;
unlock or lock a door; turn on any electrical
appliance
such as a coffee pot, radio or heater;
activate a surveillance
camera;
etc In addition, the structural
language
of Claim Element
K(2)
is general, and does not allow me to envision a specific structure.
Claim Element K(2) is far
more analogous
to examples
of claim elements
which have been held to have insufficient
structure,
than to examples
of claim elements
which have been held to have sufficient
structure.
Accordingly,
in my opinion, the claim element K(2) does not recite sufficient
structure
to
perform the stated function
To my knowledge,
no Desa witness has expressed
an opinion to
the contrary.
gI°
STRUCTURE
ELEMENTS
The
Comparison
D.
A.
Claim
WHICH
DEFINES
THE MEANS
OF CLAIMS
6, 9, 10 AND 11.
following
analysis
Circmt Diagrams,
Structure
Element
incorporates
by reference
Appendix
B; Claim Key,
Defining
Claim
FUNCTION
CLAIM
the Master Claim Chart, Appendix
A;
Appendix
C; and Text Key, Appendix
A "Sensor
Means"
A is as follows:
sensor means for detecting
said apparatus,
external
Element
PLUS
The written description
to said apparatus. ''7
a predetermined
of the patent
identifies
condition
two types
external
to
of"predetermined
condition[s]
6 As with elements
A and C(I), Mr. Carlson did not construe
or comment
upon element
K(2).
Unhke elements
A and C(1), there is not other analogous
claim element which Mr. Carlson did
construe
or comment
upon.
7 Here, "said apparatus"
assembly
of all elements
refers to the preamble
hsted in the claim.
("An
apparatus
STATEMENTOFPROFESSOR.LLOYD
MASSENG1LLUNDERL R 12(C)6(C)
CASENO 3-04-0160
JA 0767
comprising"),
whmh
refers
to the
-16-
1.
Predetermined
Conditions
Involving
the Photocell.
One "predetermined condltion" is the preselected level of light incident upon a
photocell (shown in block 56 of'066 Patent Figure 2B) above which the lamp wiU be "off"
(which can be described as "daytime"), and below which the lamp will be "on" (which can be
described as "nighttime").
It is important to recognize that the circuit could be de,signed to switch the lamp "off' as
soon as any light falls upon the photocell. However, tlaJs is not how the circult of the patent
works. Instead, the circuit does not switch the lamp "off' until the light falling upon the
photoeell reaches some preselected level e.g. the level at which the circuit designers have
decided correspondence
to the arrival of "daytime" i c the end of"mghttime"
This level could
be selected to be any level of light between full darkness and full dayhght, depending upon
what the eircmt designer may wish to accomphsh.
In the patent, the "selechon curcultry" which selects the preselected level of photocell
output current in response to which the clrcmt will swltch the lamp from "on" to "off" a voltage
divider consisting of two resistors on either side of the photocell in photocell block 56 of'066
Patent Figure 2B.
2.
Predetermined
Conditions
Involving
the PIRs.
The other "predetermined
condthon" is the preselccted level cfehange
in infi'arcd
radiation incident upon a pan" of PIRs (shown as QI and Q 2 in '066 Patent Figure 2A) which
v,'dl cause the lamp to switch from "on dim" to "on bright."
As with the photocell, It is important to recognize that the c_rcuit could be designed to
switch that lamp from "on dim" to "on bright" as soon as the PIRs detect any change in infrared
radiation.
However, as with the photocell, this ts not how the circuit of the patent works
Instead, the clrcmt does not switch the lamp from "on d_m" to "on bright" untd the change in
infrared radiation detected by the PIRs meets certain preselected conditions e.g. the condmons
_,hich the circuit designers have decided correspond to _vhatever _t is they wish to detect
In the patent, the "selection circuitry" selects the particular preseleeted PIP,. output m
response to which the circuit will switch the lamp from "on dim" to "on bright." Tlus
"selection circuitry" consists of the "detector" circuit 43, "turn on inhibit" circuit 46, "amplify
and filter" circuit 47, "window comparator" circuit 48 and "pulse count" circmt 51
,
The "Sensor Means" Claim Element A Refers to the PIRs and Their
Associated "Selection
Circuitry," But Not to the Photocell and Its
Associated "Selection Circuitry."
Once it is understood what is meant by "predetermined
condition," we can see that the
written descnpUon of the patent describes two structures which potentially support the "Sensor
Means" claim element A of claims 9, l0 and 11: 1) the photocell and its associated selection
circuitry; and 2) the PIRs and their associated selection circuitry.
Nonetheless,
m claim 11, claim element A "Sensor Means"
with or without its selection circuitry, for several reasons For one
the photocell, this would duplicate that portion of claim clement H
wtuch provides that the "light sensing means [must be] responsivc
apparatus."
STATEMENT
OF PROFESSOR
CASE NO 3-04-0160
LLOYD MASSENGILL
UNDER
LR
Jg
12(C )6(C)
0768
cannot be the photocell,
thing, if element A included
"Light Sensing Means"
to light external to said
-17-
Moreover,
In all claims where it appears (claims 9, 10 and 11), if claim element A
"Sensor Means" were construed
to encompass
the predetermined
condition
of the photocell
(nighttime),
with or without its selection
circuitry,
this would be inconsistent
with claim
element C(1) which provides
that the lamp "emit[s] light at said first level of illumination
in the
absence of said predetermined
condition
and .. emlt [s] hght at said second level of illumination
in response
to detection
of said predetermined
condition
." If tins clause were construed
to
apply to the photocell,
the "first level of the illumination"
would be "lamp off," however,
tins
would not satisfy the claim since, when the lamp is off, it does not "emit hght" as required by
claim element
C(1) which appears in each of the claims 9, 10 and 11.
element
As a result,
A "Sensor
the photocell
when construed
in accordance
with §112 ¶ 6, it is my conclusion
Means" refers to the P[Rs and their associated
selection
circuitry,
and its associated
selection
that claim
but not to
circuitry
The structure
which, in my opinion, defines claim element A "Sensor Means" in
accordance
with §112 ¶ 6 is marked in red on circuit diagram A of Appendix
B. The structure
which, as understood,
Mr Carlson contends
defines this claim element A is marked in blue,
also on circuit diagram A. 8
As shown m Diagram
A, the "Massenglll"
structure
encompasses
the portion of the '066
Fig 2 circmt which monitors
external infrared radiation,
detects changes in infrared energy,
and selects those changes that m IR are representative
of motion, as manifested
by a HIGH or
LOW output condition
at Node A See Figure 1 below Specifically,
the output of the selection
circuitry
associated
with the PIRs Q1 and Q2 (labeled Node A) is a signal that is either a HIGH
or a LOW voltage -- LOW representing
the detechon
of the predetermined
condition
and HIGH
representing
the absence of the predetermined
condition.
8 As to most claim elements,
Mr Carlson has identified
the structure
which he contends
defines
the claim element in accordance
with § 112 ¶ 6 (if applied) in the PowerPolnt
attached to his
written testimony.
See Defendants'
Exhibit 50. As mentioned
earlier, Mr. Carlson's
PowerPolnt
does not provide any definition
for clmm element A "Sensor Means," although
it
does provide a definition
for claim element I, "First Sensor Means " When this was brought to
Mr. Carlson's
attention during his deposition,
Mr Carlson said this was an oversight
and that he
meant to construe
claim element A "Sensor Means" ofclalms
9, 10 and 1 l to mean the same
thing as "either" the first sensor of claim 6 (which he construes
to cover just the PIRs, without
their selection
circuitry),
"or" the second Sensor of claim 6 (whmh he construes
to cover just
the photocell,
without its selection circuitry),
"or both."
See Defendants'
Exhibit 49 [Carlson
deposition,
page 32, hne 19 to page 33, line 9, page 34, lines 13-24 ] Circuit diagram
A is
marked
according
to this testimony
of Mr. Carlson.
STATEMENT
CASE
NO
OF PROFESSOR
3-04-0160
LLOYD
IvlASSENOILL
UNDER
L R 12(C )6(C)
JA
0769
-18-
.
,
,,,,_%'WJ'lle,__P.b.,'ltff..._Cn,_
...........
:
Node
_._._
A
/
To Control Circuit C(1)-(4).
HIGH or LOW'deos_gn"
lhal a condd_onof mol_on
of a person or other ob]ed
........
:.............
, ,..............................
exits
l
(LOW=yes,
HlGH=nol)
Daylight d_sable
Figure
the PIRs
circuitry
l
"Massengill"
Circuit
Structure
of Claim
Element
A
By comparison,
also as shown in Diagram A, the "Carlson"
structure
encompasses
QI and Q2, and the photocell
shown m block 56 without any associated
selection
for either the PIRs or the photocell
4.
The
a)
"Carlson"
Structure
The Photocell
Does
Does
Not Define
Not Define
Element
Element
only
A.
A.
i disagree
with Mr. Carlson's
contention
that the structure defining element A includes
the photocell
for several the reasons.
For example,
as indicated above, inclusion
of the
photocell
in element
A would be inconsistent
with claim element C(I) which requires that the
lamp "emit light" in response
to the presence
and absence of the "predetermined
condmon"
whereas,
In the absence
of the predetermined
condition
associated
with the photocell
(nighttime),
the lamp remains off In addition, also as indicated above, if element A were to
Include the photocell,
this would duplicate that portion of claim element H "Light Sensing
Means" which provides
that the "light sensing means [must be] responsive
to light external to
said apparatus
" Even though element H appears only in claim 11, and not m claims 10 and 9,
claim element A, which is quite lengthy, is identical in all three claims, which makes it appear
that the same meaning
is intended for element A in all three claims.
b)
The §112 _6 Definition
Of Element
A Must
Include
Selection
Circuitry.
I also disagree
with Mr Carlson's
contention
that claim element A could include
the PIRs or photocell
without mcludlng
the selection circuitry
associated
wlth those
components,
since neither of these components,
by themselves,
detect a "predetermined
condition
"
either
STATEMENT
-19-
OF PROFESSOR
CASE NO 3-04-0160
LLOYDMASSENGILL
UNDER L R 12(C)6(C)
JA
0770
Mr. Carlson defines the term "predetermined
condition" to have the same meaning in
claam 9, 10 and l 1 as "first predetermined
conchtion" and "second predetermined
condition" m
claim 6. Defendants' ExbSblt 49 [Carlson deposition, page 32, line 19 - page 33, line 9]. Claim
6 expressly defmes "first predetermined
condation" to mean "motion relative to said first sensor
means of a person or object separate fi:om said apparatus," and "second predetenmned
condition" to mean "a predetermined
level of light external to said apparatus."
However, as
explained m greater detad below, PIRs detect changes in infrared radiation, not "motion," and
photocells detect light, not "predetermined
level[s] of hght.
(1)
PIR Selection
Circuitry
Must Be Included.
That PIPs detect changes in infrared radiation, not motion, cannot be seriously dasputed.
As indicated in my tutorial section above,, a PIR sensor consists of an insulator material having
a polarity which rapidly switches back and forth by 180 ° wheo exposed to changes in infrared '
radiation, producing a characteristic
brief pulse of negative-going
then positive-going
(or the
reverse) electrical voltage or current, as shown in Mr. Raper's oscilloscope trace at the bottom
of page 6 of his testimony. T_s pulse may or may not be caused by the motion of a person or
object.
Moreover, in the patented circuit, not all pulses produced by a PIR trigger the lamp
Instead, the selection circuitry only tuggers the lamp for those PIlL signals which have been
preselected
by the circuit designer to represent whatever it is that the eircmt designer intends
the circuit to detect
Using my SPICE simulation, I have generated a pair of signal plots which illustrate
operation of the PIPs in the circuit of the '066 patent The first signal plot, marked as
Defendants' Exhibit 52 ["Trigger"] illustrates simulated use of the PIRs to turn on the lamp.
Here, the top signals (labeled "PIR 1" and "PIR 2") show representative
PIP, voltages of Q1
and Q2 responswe to external stimuh, as described by Mr. Raper's oscilloscope trace of the
"Helmann model LHI-778" P1R. In this simulation, the PIR signals amve within 2 seconds of
each other. The bottom signal plot shows SPICE simulation results of analysis of the '066
patent Fig. 2 circmt in response to those two PIP, signals.
The bottom plot in Defendants' Exl-nbtt 52 shows signals at the output of the window
comparator ('066 Fig 2 block 48) and at the output of the pulse count ('066 Fig. 2 block 51)
measured at Node A m Fig. 1 above Note that the HIGH to LOW transition in the pulse
counter output (Node A) in response the arrival of the second pulse signifies that predetermined
mot.ton has been detected
Tins LOW stgnal at Node A then propagates into the logic and lamp
control circuitry to cause the appropnate actmn on the lamp (BRIGHT mode if it is NIGHT).
The other signal plot, marked as Defendants' Extubit 53 ["No Trigger"], illustrates
simulated use of the PIRs to detect a change ofinfi'ared radiation that does not turn on the
lamp. Here, the top signals (labeled "PIR 1" and "PIR 2") show representative
PIP, voltages of
Q 1 and Q2 responsive to external stimuh, as described by Mr Raper's oscilloscope trace of the
"Helmann model LHI-778" PIR. In this simulation, the PIP, signals arrive wathin 4 seconds of
each other The bottom signal plot shows SPICE simulation results of analysis of the 066
Patent Fig. 2 circuit in response to these two PIR signals. Note that the individual PIP, signals
in this simulation are IDENTICAL
to the previous simulation, however they arrive fiLrther apart
in time.
In the bottom signal plot of defendants Exhibit 53, we see that the window comparator
responds to the PIP, signals as indicated by the negative pulses at the output of the comparator
('066 Fig 2 block 48), however, this particular sequence of PER.signals is outside the bounds of
STATEMENT
OF PROFESSOR
CASE NO 3-04-0160
LLOYD
MASSENG1LL
UNDER
L R 12(C _(C)
JA
0771
- 20 -
what the circuit was designed
to interpret
as the "first predetermined
condition,"
i.e. "motion
of a person or object."
Because these P/R signals do not amve within the preselected
time
interval,
the circuit does not regard them as representing
the prescribed
"motion
"As a result,
the pulse counter output (Node A) does not change (is not triggered),
and the lamp control
circuitry
will not respond.
These two simulahon
expenments
show that there are PIR signals in
detechon
that are "selected"
by the '066 Fig. 2 circuitry m blocks 43, 46, 47,
representative
of prescribed
motion (the "Trigger"
signal plots of Exhibit 52)
signals in response
to IR detection that are NOT "selected"
as representative
motion (the "No Trigger"
signal plots of Exhibit 53).
..
response
to IR
48, and 51 as
and other PIR
of prescribed
Because of the clear delineation
in fimction between PIRs (which detect changes m
infrared
radiation)
and PIRs with appropriate
selection
circmtry (which detect motion) I would
be surprised
to see industry usage referring
to PIRs as "motion detectors."
Material
collected
from various web sttes bears this out Defendants'
Exhibit 54 is a collection
of product
literature
for PIRs, which illustrate the PIRs as electrical
circuit components
and refer to PIRs
only as infrared radiation
detectors
but not motion detectors
On the other hand, Defendants'
Exhibit 55 is a collection
of product
literature for PIR-based
mohon detectors,
whmh are not
circuit components,
but completed
circuits contained
in housings,
containing
not just PIRs but
associated
electrical
circmtry
--a number of which are also said to employ pulse counting.
(2)
Photocell
Selection
Circuitry.
If element A were construed
to include a photocell
expressed
in section VI. A. 4. a) above -- element A must
photocelrs
associated
selection circuitry.
As discussed
m
presence
of the term "predetermined
condmon"
in Element
particular
levels of hght by a photocell,
reqmres additional
Photocells
only detect light, whereas selection circmtry
is
light.
B.
Claim
The
Structure
Element
Defining
Claim
Element
-- which it should not be for reasons
also be defined to mchide the
greater detail elsewhere
herein, the
A, as applied to the detection
of
circuitry, not just a photocell.
needed to detect a particular
level of
C(1) ("Control
Circuit
Means")
C(1) is as follows:
control circmt means coupled to said lamp and responsive
to said
sensor means for causing said lamp to emit hght at satd first
level of dlumination
in the absence of said predetermined
condttion,
and for causing said lamp to emtt light at said second
level of dlumination
in response to detection
of said
predetermined
condition,
wherein said control circuit means is
powered
by an AC voltages (sic), and
The structure
which, in my opinion, defines CImm Element C(1) "Control
Circuit
Means Responding
to First sensor Means and" Js marked in read at diagram C(1) of the
Comparative
Diagrams,
Appendix
B.
The structure
which 1 have selected is the portion of the '066 Fig. 2 circuit that is
connected
to the mohon selechon
circuitry
and to the lamp, this circuitry performing
the
function of the logical determination
of desired lamp output state (i.e. Dim or Bright) along
with the circuitry
that implements
the lamp state by appropriately
gating current to the lamp,
required
to perform the function "causing
said lamp to emit light at said first level in the
STATEMENTOF PROFESSORLLOYDMASSENGILLUNDERL.R 12(C)6(C)
CASENO 3-o4-o16o
JA
0772
-21
as
-
absence
response
of said predetermined
condition
... and at said second
to detection
of said predetermined
condition..."
level of illumination
in
As previously
noted, Mr. Carlson does not address element C(1); however,
I believe this
was (as with Element
A) unintentional
and for purposes of this Statement,
will assume that he
intended
to define Element
C([) the same as K(1), except with the addition of the power
supply.
Diagram
C(1) is marked with a broken blue hne indicating
the structure
which I
believe Mr. Carlson intended
to define Element
C(1).
As shown by the blue markings
in Diagram
C(1), the assumed Carlson definition
of
Element
C(1) fails to include the logic circuitry
which I believe is necessary
to determine
"off,"
"dim," or "bright" operation.
The structure
I have selected includes that logic circmtry,
i e. the
circuit components
necessary
to establish threshold
voltages needed to perform the function of
"causing
said lamp to emit hght at said first level of illumination
... and for causing sa_d lamp
to emit hght at said second level of illumination."
C.
Structure
Claim
Element
Defining
marked
C(2)
("Switching
Means").
C(2) is as follows:
wherein said control
selecttvely
permztting
voltage to said lamp
See APPENDIX
Sub-Element
A, Master
Claim
circuit means includes swatching
and preventmg
the applicatton
means for
of satd A C
Chart.
The structure
which, in my oplmon,
in read at diagram
C(2) of Appendix
defines Sub-Element
C(2) "Switching
B, Comparative
Diagrams.
Means"
is
The structure
which I have selected is the portion of the '066 Fig 2 circuit which
controls
the "on/off'
current switching
to the lamp. This includes the tnac device Q3 and the
associated
driver pnp transistor
and resistors that level-shift
the output voltage of the phase
angle comparator
so that it can properly
trigger the triac. Mr. Carlson construes
this element
as
only the trlac device.
The trlac alone is'insufficient
to perform the fimctlon of"selectively
permitting
and preventing
the application
of said AC voltage"
because
the output voltage
drive IC2d is insufficient
to trigger the triac. The level-shift
circuitry
included an the structure
I
have selected
is necessary
to perform
the claim function.
Structure
Defining
Sub-Element
Means
to Be Actuated")
Do
Claim
Element
C(3)
("Means
for Causing
Switching
C(3) is as follows:
[wherein
said control circuit includes]
means for causing said
swatching
means to be actuated for a selected portion of each half
wave cycle of said A C voltage, saidportion
of said half waves
being greater for said second level of illuminatton
than for satd
first level of illumination
See APPENDIX
Means"
STATEMENT
CASE
A, Master
Claim
Chart.
The structure
which, an nay opinion, defines Claim Sub-Element
is marked in red at diagram
C(3) of Appendix
B, Comparative
OF PROFESSOR
NO 34)4-0160
LLOYD
MASSENGILL
UNDER
LR
12(C )6(C)
JA
0773
C(3) "Switching
Diagrams.
- 22 -
Thereis no differencebetweenMassengillandCarlsonconstruction,so we agreeon
this structuraldefinition
Structure
Defining
Third Value").
E°
Claim
Element
[said
light
third
hght
See APPENDIX
Threshold
Diagrams.
Sub-Element
C(4) ("Means
Causing
Threshold
to Have
C(4) is as follows"
control circmt
sensing means
value dtfferent
sensing means
A, Master
Claim
means including]
means responsive
to said
for causing sam threshold
voltage to have a
from said first and second values when said
is detecting
daylight
Chart.
The structure
which, in my opinion,
to Have Third Value "is marked
defines Claim Sub-Element
C(4) "Means Causing
in red at diagram C(4) of Appendix
B, Comparative
The structure
Mr. Carlson has selected includes the photocell,
voltage divider circuitry,
and logic circuitry responsive
to daylight.
The Carlson construed
circuitry
generates
a digital
(yes/no) output and is not capable of generating
three threshold
voltage values.
The structure
I
have selected includes the Carlson portion (without the photocell
and voltage divider, which is
captured in Element H below) plus the circuitry necessary
to generate the threshold
voltages
described
in the claim element.
D14, D15, R34, and R58 are used in a voltage divider
arrangement
to created three distinct voltage levels (thresholds)
at Node 61 and thus are
necessary
elements to perform
the function of the claim element "causing
said threshold
voltage
to have a third value different
from said first and second values.."
Structure
Defining
Waveform").
F°
Claim
Element
Claim
Element
E ("Means
for Producing
Ramp
E is as follows:
means for producmg
ramp waveform
havmgfor
each half wave
of said A C voltage a ramp pulse which ts inmated
m response to
detectzon
of the zero crossing pomt for the half wave
See APPENDIX
Ramp
A, Master
The structure
which,
Waveform"
is marked
Claim
Chart.
in my opinion, defines Clmm Element E "Means
in red at diagram E of Appendix
B, Comparative
for Producing
Diagrams.
The structure
Mr. Carlson has selected includes the ramp-generating
elements
and the
zero-crossing-detect
circuit elements.
The structure
I have selected tncludes only the rampgenerating
circuit elements
since the zero-crossing
detect function is claimed in the clause "a
zero crossing detect circuit for detecting
zero crossing points of said AC voltage"
immediately
preceding
element E; therefore,
inclusion
of the zero-crossing
detect circuitry
in element
E
would be redundant.
STATEMENT
CASE
OF PROFESSOR
NO 3-04-0160
LLOYD
MASSENGILL
UNDER
L R 12((? )6(C)
JA
0774
- 23 -
Structure
Defining
Claim Element
Have First and Second Values").
G.
Claim
Element
G ("Means
for Causing
Threshold
to
G is as follows:
[claim 10] means responsive
to said sensor means for causing
said first threshold
voltage to have a first value in the absence
of
said predetermined
condition,
and a second value in response
to
detection
of said predetermined
conditions;
[claim 11] means response
(sic) to said sensor means for causing
said threshold"
to have a first value m the absence of said
predetermined
condition,
and a second value in response
to
detection
of said predetermined
condttions
See APPENDIX
A, Master
Claim
Chart.
The structure which, in my opinion, defines Claim Element
G "Means for Causing
Threshold
to Have First and Second Values" is marked in red at diagram G of Appendix
B,
Comparative
Diagrams
The structure Mr. Carlson has selected
The structure
I have selected encompasses
the
HIGH/LOW
decision
of the motion selection
voltage
(threshold)
at Node 61. This structure
said threshold
voltage
to have a first value..,
'066 Fig 2 circmt at Node 61.
H.
Structure
Claim
Element
Defining
Element
H ("Light
Sensing
Means").
H is as follows:
light sensing
for detecting
See APPENDIX
Claim
encompasses
the window comparator
circuit.
circuitry necessary
to respond to the
circuitry
(Node A) and generate
a corresponding
is necessary
to perform the function "causing
and a second value...,"
which only occurs in the
A, Master
means responsive
to light external to stud apparatus
the presence
and absence of daylight
Claim
Chart.
The structure
which, in my opinion,
is marked in red at diagram H of Appendix
defines Claim
B, Comparahve
Element H "Light
Diagrams.
Sensing
Means
The structure
Mr. Carlson has selected includes only the photocell
light-sensitive
device.
The structure
I have selected includes the photocell
as well as the resistors necessary
form a voltage-divider
circuit that can be tuned (by the designer)
to output an appropriate
"
to
9 In claim 10 phrase corresponding
to claim 1l's "said threshold"
is "saidfirst
threshold
voltage."
These phrases mean the identical thing. In claim 11, the omitted word "voltage"
is
implicit,
since "said threshold"
refers back to "threshold
voltage" in the prior clause F.
Similarly,
m claim 10, the added word "first" is surplusage,
since there is only one threshold
voltage mentioned
in claim 10, at clause F. Accordingly,
claim elements
G [claim 10] and G
[claim 11] have identical
meanings.
STATEMENT
OF PROFESSOR
CASENO 3-o4-ol60
LLOYD
MASSENGILL
UNDFR
1 !q' , 9tr" "_tc'_
JA 0775
- 24 -
HIGH or LOW voltagerepresentativeof daylightversusnighttime,respectively.Thevoltagedivider structureis necessaryto performthe function"presenceandabsenceof daylight."
I.
Structure
Claim
Defining
Element
I, which
Claim
Element
I ("First
appears only in claim
Sensor
Means").
6, is as follows:
first sensor means for detectmg
afirstpredetermmed
condttton
external
to sazd apparatus,
sald first predetermined
conditton
being motton relative to said first sensor means of a person
or an
object separate from sam apparatus
See APPENDIX
marked
A, Master
Claim
Chart.
The structure
which, in my opinion, defines Claim Element I "First
in read at diagram
I of Appendix
B, Comparative
Diagrams.
Sensor
Means"
is
The structure
Mr. Carlson has selected includes only the PIP, sensor devices,
which will
respond
to infrared radiation
but have no ability to selectively
distinguish
motion.
The
structure
I have selected mcludes the portions of the '066 Fig 2 circuit which monitors
external
infrared
radiation,
detects changes in infrared energy, and selects those changes in IR that are
representative
of motion, as manifested
by a HIGH or LOW output condition
at Node A. This
structure
is necessary
to perform the function "predetermined
condihon
being motion ... of a
person
or object"
J.
Structure
Claim
Element
Defining
J, which
Claim
Element
also appears
J ("Second
only in claim
Sensor
Means").
6, _s as follows:
Second sensor means for detectmg
a second predetermined
condttion,
satd second predetermmed
condttion being a
predetermined
level of light external to said apparatus
See APPENDIX
marked
A, Master
Claim
Chart.
The structure
which, in my oplmon, defines Claim Element
in red at diagram
J of Appendix
B, Comparative
Diagrams.
J "Second
Sensor
Means"
is
The structure
Mr. Carlson has selected includes only the photocell
light-sensitive
device.
The structure
I have selected includes the photocell
as well as the resistors
necessary
to
form a voltage-divider
circuit that can be tuned (by the designer)
to output an appropriate
HIGH or LOW voltage representative
of daylight versus nighttime,
respectively.
The voltagedivider structure
is necessary
to perform the function "predetermined
level of light."
K.
Structure
Claim
Element
Defining
K(1),
which
Claim
Element
appears
K(1) ("Control
only in claim
Circuit
Means").
6, is as follows:
.control circmt means coupled to said lamp and responsive
to said first and second
sensor means for causing said lamp to emit light at satd first level of illumination
in response
to said second predetermmed
condition
m the absence of said first predetermined
condition,
and for causing said lamp to emit hght at said second level of dlummatton
m response to
detection
of said first predetermined
condttion,
STATEMENT
CASENO
OF PROFESSOR
3-04-0160
LLOYD
MASSENGILL
UNDF'R
I.R
17(C' _¢C_
JA
0776
- 25 -
diagram
The structure
which, in my opinion,
K(1) of Appendix
B, Comparative
defines claim
Diagrams.
element
K(1)
is marked
in red at
The structure
wtuch Mr. Carlson has selected fails to include the logic circuitry
which I
beheve
is necessary
to determine
"off," "dim" or "bright" operation.
The structure
which I have
selected
includes that logic circuitry,
mcludes circuit components
necessary
to establish
threshold
voltages needed to perform the function of"causing
said lamp to emit light at said
first level ofHlummatton.,
and for causing said lamp to emit hght at said second level of
tllummatlon."
Structure
Detection
L.
Claim
Element
Defining
Claim Sub-Element
K(2)("Means
of First Predetermined
Condition").
K(2)
Responsive
to
is as follows:
wherein said control circuit means includes
means responsive
to
detection
of said first predetermined
condition
for initiating
measurement
of a predetermined
time interval, and responstve
to
expiration
of said tzme interval for causing said lamp to
thereafter
emit light at said first level of dluminatton
in response
to satd second predetermined
condition
in the absence of a
recurrence
of said first predetermined
condition
diagram
The structure
which, in my opimon,
K(2) of Appendix
B, Comparative
regard
Mr Carlson has selected
to which structure
defines
Alternatively,
M)
Construed
defines claim
Diagrams.
the same structure.
Accordingly
claim element K(2).
If The Sensor
To Not
Counting
Would
C(1) and K(1).
element
Include
Be Part
Means
Claim
The Pulse
Circuit
is marked
Mr. Carlson
Elements
Counting
Of The Control
K(2)
in red at
and I agree
with
A and I Were
Selection
Means
Circuitry,
Claim
Pulse
Elements
In its Markman
briefs, Desa has contended
that the pulse counting
circuitry
of the '066
patent is part of the "control circuit," rather than part of the detection
circuitry
defined by claim
elements
A and I of the asserted claims 6, 9, 10 and 11 because pulse counting
is expressly
called out as a part of the control means in non-asserted
claim 12. Moreover,
Desa contends
that, because
pulse counting is expressly
called out as part of the control circuit means in claim
12, the legal doctrine of"claim
differentiation"
precludes
it from being included as part of the
control circuit means elements
of claims 6, 9, 10 and 11. I have been asked to consider
and
comment
upon these two contentions
by Desa.
As to Desa's first contention,
it seems odd to me the patent claims would call out pulse
counting
as part of the control circuit, in view of the way that the schematic
diagram in Figure
2 of the patent is presented.
Circuit designers
often arrange schematic
diagrams
in a logical
way that mimics the high-level
functional
topology
of a design (especially
when "teaching"
presenting
a design to others).
When I read the claims of this patent, and then study the
schematic
dmgram,
I see parallelism
between the functional
structure of the claims and the
graphic layout of the schematic.
funchons
STATEMENT
CASENO
The claims describe (broadly
speaking
of detecting
one or two predetermined
OF PROFESSOR
3-04-0160
LLOYD
MASSENGILL
UNDER
from a circuit design perspective)
conditions
(e.g. motion and/or
l-R
12(C
JA
)6(C)
0777
or
the design
daylight),
- 26 -
performingsomelogictochooseamodeforthelamp(eg.off, dim,bright)basedona
combination
of detected
events,andthenimplementing
thatmodewith appropriate
lamp
controlcircuitry. Thesethreefunctionaldivisionsseemtobepurposefully
capturedm the
schematic
diagram.
In theschematic,
thedetection/selectaon
circuitryis setoutin thetoprowofcircuat
blocks,thelogiccircmtryis setoutin themiddlerowofcircuitblocks(perhaps
includingthe
timer(block52)above),andallof thelampmodulation
andoverridecontrolcircuitryis setout
in thebottomrowof circuitblocks.I thinktinswouldbeapparent
toanyelectricalengineer.
Thepulsecountingctrcmtis locatedmtheupperrowalongwith therestof the
detection/selection
circuitry(includingthephotocellcircuitryofblock56),winchsuggests
that
thiswasexactlythefuncttonal
arrangement
mtended
by thedesigners,
andthatinclusionof
pulsecountingin thecontrolclrcmtmeansclmmelementofclaim12is ananomaly,andthatit
belongsin thesensormeanselementinstead.As advised,
the'066patentfile historyshowsthat
neitherclaim12noranyotherclmmelementexpressly
limitedtopulsecountingwerewas
includedamongtheoriginalclaimswhenthepatentapplication
wasfiled. Claim12wasonly
addedby newattorneysin anewlawfirmafterthefiling wascomplete.Perhaps
tinswasthe
sourceof whatotherwise
seemstometobea fairlyobviouserrormclaim12
As to Desa's second contention -- that pulse counting cannot be part of the control
circmt means of claims 6, 9, 10 and 11 by operation of§112 ¶ 6 because pulse counting is
expressly called out as a hmitatlon of the control circuit means in claim 12 -- I wish to point out
that the mere existence of claim 3 among the '066 patent cIaims _s entirely mconszstent with this
contention.
Claam 3 is as follows. "An apparatus according to claim 1, whereto said sensor
means mcludes a passive znfrared detector." IfDesa's contentaon is correct as to claim 12, then
the "first sensor means" claim element of claim 1 -- which is defined as "means for detecting ..
motion relative to said first sensor means of a person or an object.." -- would not include a
PIR. Tlus would be logacally impossible since a passive infrared detector is the only sensor
which the patent discloses as part of the means for detecting motion
Moreover, ffclaim dffferentiataon were a compelling argument for excluding pulse
counting from the control circuit means elements of claims 6, 9, 10 and 11, the existence of
claim 3 among the '066 patent claims would provide an even more a compelhng argument
against Mr. Carlson's contention that the sensor means claun elements do not include the
selection circuitry assoclated w_th the sensors. Unltke claim 12, if the first sensor means of
claim 1 did not include the PIR selection circuitry, claim 3 would be wholly redundant of claim
1.
Further, as adwsed, the '066 patent file history shows that claam 3 was among the clamas
filed with the original '066 patent applicatmn
The logical inconsistency between the existence
of claim 3 m the patent, and inclusmn of pulse counting as part of the control circmt means m
claim 12, underscores the likelthood that the latter was an error.
In ad&tlon, with regard to Desa's "claim differentiataon" argument, I also note that the
language of the primary control circuit means claam elements, C(I) and K(1), are broadly
limited to the function of causing the lamp to emit bright light when the [first] predetermined
condition is detected, and to emit dim light when the [first] predetermined
condition is absent
All of the subsequent control circuit claim elements, C(2)-C(4) and K(2), are subordinate to
primary elements C(2) and K(2); and those subordinate claim elements are all qualified by the
phrase "wherein stud control cn-cuit means zncludes." By the same token, the stated fimctions of
the subordinate control circuit clatm elements are subordinate to the main functaon of causing
the lamp to emit bright hght when the [first] predetermined condinon is detected, and to emit
dlm light when the [first] predetermined condition is absent As a result, it cannot be stud that
the express provision of the subordinate clmm elements C(2)-C(4) and K(2) in the claims
STATEMENT
OFPROFESSOR
LLOYDMASSENG1LL
UNDERL,R.!2(C)6(C_
CASENO3-o_-0160
JA 0778
- 27 -
necessarily
excludes
any one or more of those subordinate
elements
in the primary
claim
elements
C(t) and K(1). In fact, as a matter of grammar,
the recitation
ofspemfic
things
included in a general category usually only makes it clear that the general category
encompasses
at least those specific things and possibly
others -- not that other mentions
of the
general category
necessarily
exclude those specific things
In any event, I note that Mr. Thesz is of the oplmon that, by filing the McCavit
declaration
in the Patent Office to distinguish
its claims from the Nippon Ceramic prior art, any
interpretation
of the patent claims that does not require pulse counting
has been &sclmmed
This would be a further reason to conclude
that, if pulse counting
is not included
as a limitation
of the sensor means claim elements A and I, it would be included as a limitation
o f the primary
control circuit means claim elements
C(1) and K(1)
Date.
April
12, 2005
Lloyd
W Massenglll
Roger L Cook (CA Bar No 55208) (admzttedpro
hac vine)
Angus M. MacDonald
(CA Bar No 212526) (admzttedpro
hac vice)
TOWNSEND
and TOWNSEND
and CREW LLP
Two Embarcadero
Center, 8th Floor
San Francisco,
CA 94111
Tel
(415) 576-0200
Fax:
(415) 576-0300
Attorneys for Defendants
EML Technologies
LLC and
Costco Wholesale
Corporation
60463529
v3
STATEMENT
CASE
OF PROFESSOR
NO 3-04-0160
LLOYD
MASSENGHI
UN DER
L R 12(C )6(C)
JA
0779
-28 -
PROOF
OF SERVICE
I, Susan Baker-Lehne,
am a citizen of the Umted States and an employee
in the City and
County of San Francisco,
State of California.
I am over the age of eighteen
and not a party to
the within action.
My business address is Two Embarcadero
Center, 8 tn Floor, San Francisco,
CA 94111.
On April 12, 2005, I served the following
document(s):
STATEMENT
OF
PROFESSOR
LLOYD
MASSENGILL
UNDER
LOCAL
RULE
12(C)(6)(C)
on the parties
in this action
0
By Mail: I am
correspondence
Postal Service
California,
in
served, service
more than one
Proc 5(lo).
(x)
By Federal Express"
The document
will be deposited
with Federal Express on April
2005, with postage thereon fully prepaid at San Francisco,
California,
in the ordinary
course of business.
()
By FacsJmile" On the same
transmission
from facsimde
at the below fax numbers.
(X)
By E-mail:
I caused such documents
to be sent by electromc
addresses
listed below on April 12, 2005
"readily familiar" with the firm's practice of collection
and processing
for mailing.
Under that practice it would be deposited
with the U.S.
on that same day with postage thereon fully prepaid at San Francisco,
the ordinary course of business.
I am aware that on motion of the party
is presumed
mvahd if postal cancellation
date or postage meter date is
day after the date of deposit for mailing in affidavit.
Fed. Rule Cir.
Robb S. Harvey
Waller Lansden
Dortch
Nashville
City Center
511 Union Street, Suite
Nashville,
TN 37219
FAX:
615-244-6804
E-mall.
& Davis,
AND
Middleton
Reutlinger,
PSC
2500 Brown and Williamson
Tower
401 South Fourth Avenue
Lomsville,
KY 40202-3410
FAX: 502-561-0442
E-mail: jhlggins@middreut.com
rtheuerkauf@middreut.com
corn
FEDEX
BY E-MAlL
Dr
Charles
mail to the e-marl
James R. Hlggins, Jr.
Robert J. Theuerkauf
PLLC
2100
rharvey@wallerlaw
BY E-MAIL
date the document
was also transmitted
by facsimile
machine
number_(415)
576-0300
to the following
persons
AND
FEDEX
U Carnal
Department
of ECE, Box 5004
Tennessee
Technological
University
Cookeville,
TN 38505-0001
E-mail:
clcee@charter.net
BY E-MAIL
foregoing
AND
U.S. MAIL
I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California
that the
is true and correct
Executed
on April 12, 2005, at San Francisco,
California.
Susan
STATEMENT
CASE
NO
OF PROFESSOR
3-04-0160
LLOYD
MASSENGILL
UNDER
LR
Baker-Lehne
12(C )6(C)
_J_t
0780
13,
00001
OOOO2
I
UNITED
FOR
STATES
DISTRICT
THE MIDDLE
NASHVILLE
2
COURT
DISTRICT
DIVISION
APPEAKANCP.S
I
OF TENNESSEE
FOR
3
4 DESA
IP, LLC,
THE
PLAINTIFF
ROBFRT
MIddlct
oa Reudmget
2500 Bro_ n & Wdhamson
Loulsxflle
K_
40202
)
)
5
Plmmlff,
JAMES
R IilGG]NS
I TtIEULRKAUF
)
JR
Tower
)
6
vs
) CASENO
304-0160
)
F2dL
g
TECHNOLOGIES,
COSTCO
FOR
) VOLUME
LLC and
7
WHOLESALE
THE
I
DEFI2ffDANTS
IRIS SOCKEL
)
CORPORATION,
)
)
9
Dcfmtdams
ROGER
L COOK
MITRAKOS
Townsend
and Tovmsend
Two Embascadcro
Center
E_ghtb Floor
San Francisco
)
CA
mad Crew
94111
10
TRANSCRIPT
OF PROCEEDINGS
17
18
BE]:ORE
19
DATE
20
TIME.
THE
HONORABLEAEETA
OCTOBES
25
A
TRAUGER
2005
9_OAM
21
22
23
REPORTED
BY
24
BEVERLY
COURT
OFFICIAL
E- "BECKy"
REPORTER
COLE,
RPR
CCR
A-837 U S COURTHOUSE
NASHVILLE,
TN 37203
25
(615)726_,893tkman
Hearing
10/25/05
Page
Markman
I
INDEX
2
WITNESSES
4
5
6
10/25105
Page
2
Page
4
OOO04
OOOO3
I
3
Heanng
MARK
PATIERSON
7 Direct
Testimony
8
Direct
Exarml_auon
9
Cr_-Exatmnaoon
by Mark
Patterson
byMr
Htggms
by Ms
Mitrakos
9O
III
WIIX£AM
12
Direct
RAPER
Testamo_y
13
Direct
14
C:cas-Exmnmatton
Er.ammznon
by Wdham
R alz_r
THOMAS
17
Dareet
T,_maony
18
Direct
Exammauonby
19
Crms-F.aammaUon
Costco
3
04 CV-I60
6
_om
161
J PAULUS
Good
Good
COURT
W¢ ha'_c
4
MR.
g
TIIECOURT
Good
MR
HARVEY
II
THE
cOLrRT
MR
THEUERKAUF
Yom
HonOr
15
you?
Do'ag
morning,
16
Tc,chology
Good
Rolxrt
THECOURT
RohreL
"HIECOURT
Cook
2O7
19
Honor
Cook
morning
Thcuerkauf
Theuerkauf
Loms_dle
V_ce
Good
mommg,
Whotsslttmgv.Rh
President
ROHILER
of Dexdopmcnt
and
Goodmormng.
And
for
thedefcrtse
weha_eRoger
fvem Saa Fratosco
20
20
NllL
21
21
"IT"IECOURT
22
22
MS
23
23
THECOURT
24
24
MR
25
25
THECOURT
COOK
Good
morning
MITRAKOS
RILEY
Your
Gvodmommg
Good
Yes
Your
Okay
Hono_
AndJrtsMitrakos
morning
St_.eRfley
fromBo_en
Rdey'_
Honor
We're
Markman
JA 0781
Your
Ro_Har_eyfmm
for DESA
MR
3
and
tg civil C2_¢
- thts
Goodmommg
10
18
Page
Technologies
Wallet
17
10/25/05
Honor
EML
theplaanttffJa_esHIggtr_,Jr
HIGGINS
169
Heanng
We'rehnrcon-Yore
_s
plalniaff
Wchavefor
2O6
Markman
- DESA
for the
Htggtm
Paulm,
morning
mornmg,
Lomsvllle
7
14
Higgms
Cook
by Mr
THE
13
byMr
Mr
3
12
by blr
by Thomas
COUNSEL
134
159
15
16
THECOURT
2
9
126
|0
II
I
here
on the hngmnlng
Hearing
10/25/05
O90O5
OOOO6
I ofaMalkmanheannf_
2
will tell you _
3
you
4
intend
offand
Weha_esctomthesmeture
I want
you to be prepared
say I don't
need
to do regularly
I
to hear
hcze today
any o f that, "_hmh
and
I
for me Io cut
the next couple
2
We
MR
4
THE COURT
5
(Laughter)
8 clerk
He*saprofel_c,
9 has been
ozalTennes.seeTechmCookevln©and
;LsststJng the corot,
I0
the ¢.oal's
I1
Are
mo_l grateful
there
any
paM
to have
thal
prchmma_y
and
before
wc g¢1
12 stancd_
13
14
MR
your
15
16
RILEY
mt_ducmg
Ycs,
my two
THE
COURT
repr_,cnr._xe
MR
COOK
18
THE
COURT
MR
RILEY
max_duce
yore
party
and they
mthede_a_Lsofthtsmatlcr,
22
rcaso_
23
from
w*th your
during
I'm ava_abl¢
think thai I can
MiWabosare
arc
I would
these
al my office
fine
add any assL_ce
and I'm lgJr_
COURT
sVstmt,
4 able
to succe_fully
$
om _
use
having
I have
MIL
of thts
12
hghts
became
t3
tha_ _
thfficuh
we
won'l
excased
MR
RILEY
15
THE COURT
MR
I'll also make
with
dunng
the
the
tbe Courl's
the coral
presence
f_ce IO pull you
Thank
you,
w_sh_
rotgut
back
Your
Anything
m
be of
Otherwtsc,
Honor
ctsc7
Yes.YourHonor
video
eqmpment
Wcwantto
ts scl up according
it to be set up
23
Pore1
May
IO
I approach
the
25
Wc
cou_
Smc
HIGGINS
thsp]ayed
24
10/25/05
Ifwegettoa
coumcls'
HIGGINS
gmc that the
we wt[I Ix: presenting
necd
and with
DLuang
a power
on the
screen
to make
sure
Dr
Carnal
the plaintiff's
Point
And
opening.
you scc the Power
o_ er there
thai
thal'S okay with
before
we
the
proceed
Markman
Page5
see the screen,
are -
I do#l
compute?
were not
thah
t t when
an - a shde
so much
Okay
HIGGINS
16
ts ores Io the coua'rs
17
eqmprramlSet
Ig
s_
Tbon
left.
Hearing
some
tbe otho"
bye
10/25/05
Page
6
dunng
the resin'rainy
21
andMt
22
tha v tdeo won't
S¢oaEvans
axe
from
3
Wdham
thc defendant.
Other
So the vldeo
Okay
Thal would
ts not on now and R wdl
you ate dorng
Markman
Ileanng
his
demo
13
wdl
_d¢o
16
17
the plamhff
thanthal.
be what
l would
nol be on
a I_ ¢ demonstration
12
that
10/25/05
Page
7
way
you can
componcnls
and
thc court and
Rapcrlsdolng
actually
sc¢ cverythmg
thai he
be doing.
THE
lablc
COURT
or do you
MR
havc
Arc
you going
another
HIGGINS
to do tt on ctmmcl
labte7
We're going
to do it on cotmsc]
table.
I_
THE
COURT
19
MR
HIGGINg
20
_ idcngTapber
21
ts being
And
will be wdcomg
presented
THE
COURT
23
M]L
HIGGINS
24
the demonstration
25
cerlam
All right
dunng
That's
fine
that ttmc Is when
the actual
demot_trabon
I requ_t
Ix'nm_on
the
thai
on the table
22
things,
Okay
Okay
And
to rcqm_t
thc
vldengraphar
dunng
to focus
on
if I may
Markman
JA 0782
In
OUl certain
thai w¢ mvtt¢
CamaldowntocounscltablewhflcMr
15
s
sugg¢_tton
Dr
That
thc
pm on, it wdl rcqutrc
IO sprcnd
II
thing
wall be presemed
fz_
them elecuontcalty
t4
demo_Swalmr,
Rap_
9
II is our
wdl
Ilonzontaltabtes_f_cc
hc'_ gmng
I0
the
Honm"
Sore© whaP
8 othcr word_,
then connect
Yous
mad thai _ dunng
surface
HIGGINS
exhthlt
have
table
MR
be rL_xmng
THECOURT
for when
of Mr
homonta]
7
Tt_vldeoeqmpm¢_tLs
technolngy
some
record'7
the plan,
thing,
Rap_
that's
al_d¢
Ingtsucal
demonstraltons
5
thai Mr
COURT
hghl
you wdl see thai wc
the technolngy
20
_a'ntaent
demot_tratton
THE
to dtm
of an unusual
4
to be m thc
That's
other InglstJCal
6
Thalwon*tbealnobtcra.
ttpmtbecourtroom
up to record
courl
one
not be able
HIGGINS
f
you
wall be one shd¢.
1 will ask the
MR
3 Now,
fine
s_c
would
2
v.e could
to see anylhmg
be t_mg
I othervas©
know
systems
so thai
to make
There
to see wnh
MR
2.5 excepl
you
both
have
you
have
THI_COURT
hka
all ca_
our system
wbet¢
15
24
maybe
HIGGINS
14
23
reason
- we'll
pr_'.¢alauon,
And
arc both
22
wdncss_
II
19
you
Io adjttst tt for m_y wamess
I0
you
14
Io be excused
m Urns proceeding
go th_
8 on the S{TC¢'A. maybe
9
13
v, cql feel
MR
but I don't
but I c_m s¢¢ thai p¢_ reedy
I guess
7 we need
Wall,
thai for some
compmer
6
Honor,
ttmc IO tlrc_
O0008
THE
3 whc6e
assistance,
"IVIE COURT
(X_O7
2
12
21
Heanng
Your
with
I9 Icctem7
m_ olved
proccndmgs
if ne_
Hono_
to conrad
from
Verygood
local
Fo*th_
I_e
Markman
I
that I feel
20
mmn_ely
andlamnol_
pcrmlsston,
the cota_occn
THECOURT
I I p_ttlon
18 how
CookandMs
Your
lawy_
to be excused
10
17 make
Okay
Mr
21
from San
but rll _k
16
YomHonor
Franc_co,
lawyers
25
1 &_'t
Wedon'thaveone,
20
24
AM
lapprcclate
here
Youdon*lhaveapany_rab_e_'
17
19
YomHonof
cocotms¢l
I'lJ be bere
less
9 Ix'rmlsslon?
_lstance
maaers
No obJccUon,
One
HARVEY
reques!
8 hemlng,
for by the parues,
HIGGINS
MR
7 $;_3¢
law
DOeSlhaplamt]ffobJcct
excused7
3
6
box with my
Okay
Rdey
I
have with us alsoto exSlslthe coral Dr
7 Charles Carnal, who's sltung m tbepay
Mr
of
5 days
6
THECOURT
to having
Heanng
10/25/05
Page
8
OOOO9
1
THECOURT
00010
2
M_HIGGINS
3 v.hen
Mr
4 d_e.s
Cook
li_at's
with
5 cec_n
compa_ent5
have
coucse,
oftbelr
COURT
8
MR.
H[GGINS
9
THECOURT
12
THECOURT
want
15
L_
No,
we.
on
of
Okay
v.ell.
Your
Hooor
Good
bmdc_s'_
Mr
THE
COURT
18
MR
HIGGINS
pcobably
be best
22
them.
fo¢ Mr
24
been submt_.d
25
expert
Cvok
COURT
arc
with
the
m them
and ! think
what
_t _d
they are
m ',he front
of
and
wlth
the
10/25/05
Page
both
through
th© briefs,
the
_t's
w_e.ss
thstoncs
pa_es
of the patcnL_
intend
to bc
them
our pte_entat_on_
docmnents
w¢11
m the binder
be
by tab number
on the record.
COURT
Okay,
ve_
helpful
Thank
you
there's
one
Okay
MR
aspect
H1GGINg
and
Dr
name
Your
cxh_bl_
Carnal's
Hc_0r,
that I v, ould
attention
Sir,
am
I_c
to call
I pronotmcmg
cortecl]y'_
DR
CARNAL
18
hiP.
H]GGINS
!9
_ the
coon
20
has been
2f
cafiedlom|Apgendt×
22
to d_rmg
ha_
been
THE
Pa_donme
_
v, _11, with
-
COURT
Mr
these
Andthat
D_
Camel
iv, o black
bmdc_
_s whalwchaver!fcrrnd
Markman
Cook,
a httle bet so tt s picking
9
I beheve
_nts
_s the joint
document
Tnank_,ou
_d
I of 2
Imefing
this
Carnal
pre_cn_nd,
pre_¢mted
And
m_e
And,
to the JOint
17
25
include
_nclude
tbe lilt
thai
to dl tTetent
24
12 -
or is it just
to
THE
23
Heanng
appendix
can
you rndtrcct
-- the mike
Markman
on the
that
pathmn,
I't_eanng
10_5_05
Page
I0
Page
12
00012
yea_
I
Exct_em¢
3
THE
COURT
Pea tt a little
you
cl_cr
to v, here
me spaakmg.
S
MR.
Honor
andMr
THE
COURT
MR
H]GGINS
LMck one,
10
That'sUS
I!
referred
! 2
Can
Tbe first
to m; the '066
m mattev_
binder,
0fthc
the
patvat
m suet
Bates
the c_¢
are
HIGGINS
m the patent
so tha_ everyone
o fllce,
the
MR
COOK
And
that's
Tbcy
21
MR.
HIGGINS
22
sm_ller
23
o f _,hat'$
of the tv, o black
called
24
a second
patent.
25
th*
They
no¢ included
m tbe
aremclndedmthe
should
Yes
And
bmde_
a ¢outmuatlo_
6
to the
7
bench
8
273
_xamplc,
so when
the
bc,
yes
so the _ec:ond
;s the pros¢cmlon
apphca_on
A_dthat_,econdpatent
and
htstor/
that t_sultnd
_not
antsm.,cm
c_se
THE
M_rkrnan
Heanng
10/25/05
Page
Mr
you
MR
H]GGINS
TttE
COURT
m _
bzndcrs
JA
)783
And 1i
a pagc
that is thA
or" making
you
wtl_ ha_ • at the
Ms
Mitlak_
_ paint
v, dl have
J-A
ha_ _ J A 273
And
have
what
numb_
gl_cn
will that appear
me _
]11 have
to ask
_s_st,x_cc
to _k
you
of
coims¢l
_
15
a big tht!k
!6
the binders
bucket
I'm going
m.t _cnd
here,
and
17
MS
M1TRAKOS
18
THE
COURT
19
hLR. HIGGINS
20
MS
for your
THE
_3
rcfernng
24
within
to the
COURT
it well
be !as_er
YourHonov,
thal'_ m
to find it m
that ts tab 74
74?
Tab--
MITP.AKOS
conv_lence,
to refer to
of to thai because
74
start
WeB,
tab numbers
and
the V,ltness
statements
at tab 77
I woald
and
apprcclat•
the'n, or" course,
yore
th_ pages
it
And
th• s¢c oe,d black
binder,
Markman
11
bmdct
on it
here
and
appel_lx
beg thtck
a wlu'._s
Cook
should
COURT
as m the binders
t_
25
number
to J-A 273,
Carnal
to Joint
the
I ha_ • marked
J-A 273,
_2
m
Bates
if ] point
and Dr
_4
21
from
] tan mte_ogatmg
!ore%
13
wjJJ be working
COrTeCt9
20
2'/3,
appenthx
a particular
For
5
12
mimbet
THECOURT
bmdet_.
wall have
9
btndet_7
MR
3
"._¢ _ dl be re femng
the Markman
I I
dmang
that _ed
15
18
and
l0
pattmt
the paints
t$ prese2_ed
!6
Yore
OIlentrmcsttwlllbe
] 4 _oml _d_x
the sam!
black
ore h_stoty
pat_t$,.598,066
refcmng
that better,
Fm *ore_
t$ th= prt_ecutt
So that wh_l¢
from
you he_
H_ggms?
8
9
So mosdy
2
4
HIGGINS
7
19
it mclndcs
exhibits
idem=fy
your
of the past
HIGGINS
17
and
to yot_
m the briefing
comse
MR
13
10
16
mctex
2
6
re f•mng
ha_ c bncf'_
It doesn't
II does
So as we go
9
15
000|1
4
rcfemng
are jolw.
_far[cman
I
7
Do they
COOK
_hlb_ts
al_ the
a_e _ese9
m explain
tbe _pens
danng
and
other
Andthese_re_ematmal_thathav¢
s tam'acres
statement_
6
14
_¢m.
_
5
12
Okay
T_re_s
YourHor_r
You
h_s-th_cwe'_prcparndby
_.fi_. COOK
23
_ey
r_w_-wed
the
13
up here,
Ar.d t_ll m_ whO's
We have
THE
AllnghL
binders
bmde_
Y¢_
s_mp]y
II
openings?
HIGGINS
de fe_L_.n_.
YomHonor
COURT
stalt'rncnL_
MR
4
8
Cook.do
Ve_ygoo&
me three
Wh_¢
17
2_
wedon'l.
your
the_¢
MR.
20
And
fine
Okay
wl_
m_ ask,
Joint
t_
d_or_on
Very
16
9
3
_elr
m focus
_o that
That's
COOK
to proceed
th_¢
!_¢esemmg
v_eograpb_
THE
2 the v, tmc_
_ythmS'_
MR
14
arc
_e
AllnghL
I!
t3
_k
no objeccma
THE
youha_c
A_]_,esumethal
has _.tm_es
be n_y
7
I0
1
"]'h_a_yo_
v-,it_o_ L_t
6
fine.
the
thlrmer
tlearmg
one,
tbe
10/25/05
00014
t
C¢O13
I ¢ot_o,u_tton paL¢_ -2
MR
HIOGIHS
3
THE COURT
Yes
2
anywhere
MS
MITRAKOS
7
THE
COURT
5
8
MR
HIGGINS
76 '7
7
COURT
[ I joint appendix
'_
12
HIGOINS
MR
13 to dunng
Was
THE
COURT
15
MR
COOK
THE
COURT
17
MS
MITRAKOS
you
Appendt_
19
MR
20 number
zs U S patcrfl
21
THE
tho_e
HIGOINS
Yeah
number
COURT
¢onhnuatlon
And
palent
23
MS
24
THE
COURT
25
MR
HIGGINS
And
that
yoo
said thai
docuracnts
MITKAKOS
follow
on patcm
contmUallon
--
are tab 76"_
Thal'S
correct
Okay
Your
Honor
good
morning
Hearing
10/25/05
Page
ts the 1794
2 [hepatem,
14 1994, grantcdioElyWhLtacy
3 coRon
4
and
March
|ames
your
mom,ng,
Wecsc
Honor
morning
Mr
And
as you have
been
]6
Rohrer
ts the VICe prc$ldant
17
He well
be at counsel
Weese
ts the prcstdant
and
THE
COURT
21
MR
HIGGINS
22
Hotmt_
Thtsts
23
the plaintiff
And
pr_entatlon
Mr
and
DoUR
[echnoJogy
the prcsentattons
representallve
[ proceed _
May
25
already.
wtth us dunng
corporate
20
24
reformed
ofdave]opmcnt
table
and
Yes
Well
the M m'km,m
may I ask the court
of[he
nexl
_'e we
why
here, Your
pTo¢ctthng
pttsentatton
to thin
lights
the
slide '_ _'v'h4t you
IHnrkman
patent
That's
of OESA,
for the
ate wLmcSsmg
Ilearmg
10/25/05
I v, ewdlbctaiklngalmuhpa_agraph6ofSectlon
[he date of
2
for [he
Page
14
a}lentton
6
stalutc
if I am
that
Patenls
the owner
has mfnnged
do I persuade
my Patcm
_ed
to be expressed.
patcrtt
of that Patcm.
[hat
and
I
[he court that the accused
de_ tee
when all [he entirety of the patent
Is
Beginning
light.
16 patent
17
Yo_
Statute
And
USC
of[he
statute
in vanotu_
17
and
tl_
of the '066 patctlt
1535
I paragraph
P,|arkman
2.
5 and paragraph
is the st3tute
Hearing
6
that
paragraph
19
p_lcularly
20
su_ect
pointing
23
than
10/25/05
Page
15
Page
16
time to
or thffcrent
aspects
|h_t the
cont4m
[he best
IO a_ the preferred
patent
document,
embodiment
2 Is the pofllon
shall conc}ude
which
the rcqulrcmen|
dcsenpllon
out and
deahng
wl[h
the apphcanl
iLs_lf, it ts often
of the palenl
with
one
dtstmctly
the claims
or more
clatmmg
tegard_
,a'e the portion
out and thstmctly
c]aammg
cha ras
the
as his
invent{on
pat_t¢ul_r]y
thai which
is different
,u_
why m'e we hcre_
in_ngetacnl
We are here
is a Iwo step
Mnrkman
JA 0784
invention
tO from
-- the ¢lazms
the pno_
go
paten1
of[he
Thebestmodals
in the
pointing
maucr
This
22
25
that [he COtL,1-- [he
lenas
tO as d speClI_C
The speczficatlon
24
of
And
18
21
You
this
includes
-- the wnlten
First, It is t¢_rred
of claims
Paragraph
I also
contain
of the statutenow, but _ e
4. paragraph
{ult¢llon.
Paragraph
ter¢_Tcd
amc_td
Co_grcss
law
Paten1
expressed
1 know [he coati has had lots of expressions
I ] 2/6 or reCaP3 plus
of[he
14
Sc¢[Ion112
2,. paragraph
9
not*co
of the patent
13
to the
or
the court's
wd] h¢ rc letted
modeconlemplatcdby[hemvemor
Scc[Ionll21sdwldcdmtoslxparagraphs
paragrilph
tzmc as the sp¢¢lficatton
of the patent
dlrcel
descnpl_On
12
that re fcr_ to claims
22 will sc¢ them on the screen
8
16
In t&36,
] and
for a Wntlen
that ts whal
cmbodlmenl
the clatm$
tO mt¢rpret
And
15
a rcqulremCnl
to mcluda
[he clalms arc _
are bore today
19 The porhon
Beg_sm_ag
to paragraph
portion
Pl¢&sc
does nol in fnuge
m 1836 -- and you may now return
Honor
with
l I patent
the p21cnl?
14
not the only
m fnnger.
tf I represent the accused
12 how do I prcscnl a de lense [hat my product
[hat's
calls
I0
on that documenf_
Con_ e_ely,
But
7
patent, and I go IO
ll2,
_12/6
5
ts the way
Now,
I I
25
HIGGENg
Thts
10 v, hat's shown
24
MR
thai we are daabng
9 m fnng¢_
23
ts Mr
CEOofOESA
4
8 court, how
21
Good
3
7 bchev© someone
20
Good
COURT
gm
[hl{LS the enttr¢
6
I_
Wouldyou
tS the chteffin_mctal
COOl6
I here, Your Honor
IS
Hyden[ha{
13
OOO15
13
TomHyden[ha]
WEF.SE
19
5,747.937
Markman
$
next to Mr
18 as the company
18 C
22
Seated
15
appcn[hx
It's Jolnl
Carnal
arc here In the courtroom
Hydcntha]
THE
14
Your Honor
Mr
Hydentha]_
MR
13
Thank
ts Mr
Mr
12
As _1,_?
the)omt
cbenl who
[ I
by the parl,cs
Ifs,n
16
Dr
hkc to introduce o[her
{0 (phoneh¢)
as part of the
Iesmtherecord_refen'ed
the briefings
}4
,I already
Before I begin, [ would
oFDESA
9
THE
mommg
Goodmommg,
ln the courtroom
stand
8 omcer
It's In the record _ c-ell,your
9 Honor
I0
Good
today
6
That's lab 76
That's
HIGGINS
4 rcpresenlatlvc_of my
or ts
5 [halJ_t m the blnd£rs?
6
COURT
MR
3 counsel
-- ts that a part of the )OLin
4 upben[hx or _ that m the record _Ir_dy
THE
today
became
inquiry
Ilearmg
10/25/05
Pa¢©]_
Pagel_
OOO19
O0O2O
L
_
_ent
olSce fi]cs pal_
_1(_ _ whe_ ths ]_[ef_ n_
hcs p;_cl_bLc
_cc_d:n_
dc_n_mcs
to U_o_c,
if the _llC;_Dcn
sub_ec[ u_,[t _" IL looks zcco_dm_ I_ ¢1_._
4 _'_ci _Jb_
$
"_¢ rcCc(cnccs c_tcd _:[Jon
_
- LSwh¢_c _hc
6 p_=aL ORi¢¢ de_mm_i
wh¢_'_ to pul thc pno_ aft t_
7 paine o_fl¢¢ o0ns_da_
in _smn S the _aL-'nL
!
And tb_s is _hc prior _'I tb_t L5bcf_c
9 offi_
I0
m d_e I_._n
prior m _
the
the Ip_J_t
066 pe._ _ The ne'.v p_ec_ o(
(ouml _d
pr¢_u_f_d _s the N_p_
w_
co of d_
Ce+amJc
14 z_ 5tzn[ Cx_rnln¢'tS _0 m,1_¢ $_¢ Lh_ the pz_'nL 01_cc dc._
16
]7
18
And _
m_c_o_
_c d_c,dmmcys who _cp_cnLo3
Th_ next p_t
19 _I_¢a¢10(the
LSd_¢ _s_r_:t
patcnl I.t _ _n
20 ol5¢e h_ n_qu_fcd d_ _opl_c _t
;2
[ d_r_ n_ Impo_(
_.3 _pph¢_t
_4
Pn[e
19
p¢cse_¢d L_
of _
)785
p_cc_-
_'-] c_fwh_
T_c
the p_c_l
_o do to summ._,_c Lt'e
t_ ,m&"_t._d
how t_¢
__nm _"y _d how (he _Jcn_ Office
_.cc_'_tcd LPc ;L_mmary
Marl_nau
JA
the
to ob._m lh_ p_Le_L
H_nu_
10/25f05
page20
00O21
0O022
I photocell,
a pa_swe
m fr_ed
to a scctu3_,
hght
2
cxtcma]
3
qu,_,rtz I_oge'n
4
_ghu3c_
5
to opcr_e
lamp
a195
7 motion
time
at mght
dctcctrD8
9
[o ope_te
percent
for dctcclmg
and a clTcm[
In the absence
6 predetermined
8
f,e_m
at about
of detection
interval
PIc_¢
note
Andtlc_d]soutapholoccn
Well,
invt_uon
what
to deicer;on
of
6
_
p_.r_
Wtlham
19
to wbal he could
wdl set: a dcm_nsw,
20
of the patent
Raper,
I0
Thuds
for th_
p_cm7
a back_
read
17
t-mbodunenl
part
21 r¢_ons]ve
It's what
the statute,
25
Secoon
112, par_
I. rcf_
to as the
b_l
Markman
Ileanng
for
25
10/25/05
Page
for causing sald switching means
fo_ producing a ramp
I0
2 producing
3 means
_
to b¢ _uated,
a ramp wavefofr_
means
WeatcmClatm
Control c=rcuelmeans, swltchmg
to f*ard sensor
I includes
a means
2 cotmtmg
s_ld pulses
3
for causing studthrt_hold Eo have a firstvalue m
5 pqls¢ counting
6 tmpropcr
means
for
10/25/05
Page22
aLsohay© h_t StTamg
me=m
7
and
$ Coq>onmon
9
thee
9 we think i1'$ so tmporta_t
are an of the as*erred claims m the
I0 case. ClaSh 6.9, 10and
II am
theon]yclatms
10 You".]
thatare
I I
II being asaert_d against gm deftndants' d_v_ce.
And by the way, the defmdants
- EML.
I2
as a
13 d= fendant,ts accused of m fnngea'mmt because they make
14 prod_t
15 th= product mto the Umted
Cosmo
tsbemg
17 they =ellthe product
Amlcl
briefs
17
vs AWH
the Phdhps
Corporal)on
filed d_rmg
th_s cozc
property organtzal]on
J_l
filed a bncfm
l"hosearetheactsofmfnngcm_nlset
19 fmlh m 35 U S C
Scctmn 271
19
the appropriate
way to deal with Mad(man
[ would
is now _yathcs_zcd
m the Phtlllps
hkc Io pOml oul al paSe 1311
20
_cfi h,t_d coh._nn
21
cla_mlng
Me3nsplttsftmctton=sthcsamca.sll2/6
no[ic_ thalnov,here m C[atrn 6,9. I0 and I I ts the Icnn
22
the cite -
0to quotahon
purse corralrecRed
23 apphes only (o purely
Now,
having shown
you Cl=0m.s6. 9, I0 ;rod II, you
22
23
Youmayhavc
Pulse cotmt tsrecltedonly m Cla_m 12
And
24 provide
it's
25
25 reciteda_ part of the controlclrcmt meat=, where it
Marknmn
lleanng
10/25/05
Page
23
the st_ctmc
Phdhp;
thscuss_s
_s mea_
ftmct;o.al
Th¢1"¢ a_¢ many other
mcans pl_
hmltahons
pOlnLS
dcCSSlOtl
m the
ftmct]on
An_
plu_ ftmctmn
that per forms
Markman
JA )786
an
We th=nk tha= by and la_8© the law ofcla=m
18 theUmtedStates
havehadalotofbneFtngaboutpubecotmt.
36
about every
and claim construcuon
18 constractton
21
case, b¢causc
[o the court's t_sk al hand here.
to assts! Lh¢ fedora] ctrcmt m how to go through
16 hearings
And lhey, hkc-v,x_ import itinto
6. 9, 10 o_ I I axe
nottc¢ first that it's an _n banc decision
I $ and determine
became
We
The second thing, plc_sc no(e Ihat thcre'wcre
14 attempt
Stat_
accttsedof m fnngermmt
Honor'
at tc.m pes to incorporate
[o go through
case, Phdhps
13 mtellccmaJ
the
and they scH the Ivoduct toCostco. and they import
sm [home, You_
r¢ctted m anothcr clazm
And now I'm going
to sard hgh[ sc'nfan8 meara
Now.
e pulse and a me._ns for
m c*.n.s into the Cla*ms,
because thcy'rc
g r_pormv¢
24
mcam.
He=ring
that all of the dcfcndants'
5 vaJue m response todetcct=o, of sa_d pru_te*mtned
We
for generating
Back to our cardinal
4 bchcv¢
and a Second
6 condmon
20
are sbn
II now, Your Honor
Markmao
rncms fo_
responswc
4 the absence oi"studpredetezmltxcd con&tm_,
16
We
0O024
I causing stud swttciung
12
to be
wave form. me'_ts
sen.sormeans, predetermined conthtton -
21
00O23
7
Io be actuated.
Sen.sormeans,
now we ate m cla*m - excu3¢ mc
24 exeusem¢
mode
10
[osaid scraor meam
And
23 an Clam
Is the prefc_:d
"066 patent.
_rc SltllIn Chum
sa_d swl[chm 8 meam
we ate m C3a=m
19 mcalXS, means
And then
oflh¢
We
18 predetermined conthtton, contzollcdctrCuilretard _vatch]r_
ar..corthn 8
of the mvcnbon
Now
22
d_m_on
Sensor means, prcdctermmed
Controlled clrcu=lmeans, a switching means, m_d
16 m c-3nsfor cauamg
wgmc_scs,
he budt the dcwcc
9
14 9
bcc.a_e
of DF_A*s
we're in Clmm
20 actu&ted, mea_
_'_Icd
24
Now.
15
from tl_c smnmary
responstv e [o
13 conthoon, controlled clrcullmeans
of the
LSimpoTtant
tb on from one
'x ho says thai
Contzol clrcmt means, means
12
th_s c&sc.
me thole
The thaw rags o f the palcnt _Jc dot, or thcd.
_
S¢conds_rmcar_
I [ delccOon ofsa*d firstpredetermined cond_tlon
thefts the detmled desmpuorL
23
Wea:emC1a_m6now
9 hghl
for detectJng mOLiOn.
mvcnoon
of _
18
For example, firslsensor mcaJ_s firstpredetermined
7 conthuon
Thc_¢*sasmnma_oft_¢mvcntlon
yo_
the claim lenns thal are before
5 you tobe Interpreted
The;earelhesc'r_0tal
a field of mvemlol__
17
22
4 thlspoint, l'm htghhghtmg
m the vt_zy _uact
m fi'a_cd sc_so_
Tt=e s_
21
3 IO go through these very qulckly because what I ha_ e done at
the photocell
12 you wdl hear so much about du_ng
16
of fun
a[ night,
for a
in _'csponsc
thai the pat_Xl
II
15
50 percent
out the mven_on
Thor3 wc gel l_maJ]yIo the clallm; And I'm going
8 second prt:dctermmcd condition, prede[erm]rted levelof
with a p_wc
Tl',crc's
I canymg
2
the
dayhf_ht
bcguts
14
cattsf_
of motion
of full bnghmc_
and to bc offwhde
10
13
which
motion
cla_rmng
that do not
the recited ftmcuon
[ S¢¢ [hat tl_
Hearing
court
10/25/05
Page
24
OOO26
I m _ lew
OOO25
I h.xsacopyofPhdhpabeforelL
hhasalrcadystuthud
2 tt.
2 Usually
3
THE
3
4
F.W. HtGGINS
5 points
COURT
white
I have
stu&ed
Phdhps
So Icl mcmsl
get you
to the
I dunk that we want to rnakc special
¢'mphasts
With
respeCl
8 ¢ouTi permits
9 claim
to our cardmal
sm theme,
;un accused m fnnger
begin
to thn meamng
4
The
5
a_propnate,
thai zr¢ not actuaOy prt_ent,
the Supreme
to include
elements
8
into a
Court
nol menUoned
m the clmm
apptopnale
dcfinlltom
v, hen
14
14
thcttonary
dcfmllton
15
fotmd
16
documents
Thai
will
15 dus heanng.
16
be a rceumng
Your
theme from
Is thai you kcgtn
18 and th¢_ you mtc_p'tet
19 ¢murcpamm.
20
Thaes
ts a principal
vath the words
lesson
17
of the claim
be a useful grade m unde_tanthng
22
claim terms
23
pointed
That's
why
what
]9
called
among the clam_
20
rcudmg
the me;ruing
we pointed
out that the pulse cotmtmg
can also
mere=
are m Clam112
Again,
a theme from
Phllhps.
c_ms
Markraan
must
be read
Hearing
10/25105
Page
23
Now,
crabodtment
2 describes
only
be corammd
4
And
focm
sm,
25
below
$o long
as the
any definmon
of tbe patcmt
on v, bat Ph;lhps
says about
sin,
actually
iL_cif
and
that LSthe
flora
the specl
ropealed]y
v, amud
Phd]lpS
danger
of
ficatton
into the c]mm
ngamst
confimng
the
m the patent
particular
m the '066
the empha_Lzcd
the
on thcllona_
terms
case,
patcah
phra._
there's
but
only one
the emphamzud
The court
Markmaa
as betng hmzted
_
I
a palc'm
to that embodunenL
thai will be prt_entcd
the Phflhps
that if
the clmms of the patent
.Ac bebe-, • that the defendants'
5 mte=prtlatzora
6 Agmn.
reJeCted the content=on
a single embod=menL
3 must
emphastz_d
the
3
word
4
ptolx_ed
says,
phrase
-
in particular,
Hearing
Page26
10/25/05
6
the v. ords
"meara"
applies
at pngc 1327, the
there ts the Supreme
10 stud v. ith respecl to patenm that the court
Court
9
has
14 through phdlrps,
15 yom
Hono¢
16 prmopa]
17 tbe '066
the patent, hawng
which we beh¢'.¢
wtll
largely
dues for the rest of dus beanng,
gone
control
19 "066patent.
ernbodunent
Ore. m-awer
With
reopea
toboth
tc_.sof
to _rate
_ mt='ptct
23
a claim
for a combmatmn
quesm_rLs ts no
24
stop for per formmg
25
of StTuctme,
marcia!
ts paragraph
6
ptus
An dement
a sp¢ofied
ftmct*on
vathout
}learmg
c_e,
pr¢_tmlptton
say "_ As we stud
,._hat
EML
_
that actually
ftmetzonal
15
rises
that
I 12]6
a moment
ago,
hmflaDons
and Costco
'_.e say ts the presumpoc_
term connotes
14
Either
15
the ayt,cspe.clallym cl_cU'O_I_
structme
comcnd
16
ztsalf goes
tS nebutted
for one
the t_rm tL_eif connot_ist]_ctute
on to elabora[e
Reracmbo',
Phdhps
pro'ely fumct_onal
What
We say
ra
quote*
from
or a
23
things
are quotes
24
(phonetic)
25
The
Page
Why')
do we
22
the r¢_ta]
10/25/05
to
had the
_ the
L_ not rebutted.
What
2l
or acts m Support ther ¢o1"
Markn_n
Phflhps
to purely
20 [c'm_ m th_ ca._
thts ts
may be expr t_sed as a means
*s a rehnttabl¢
the clmm
19
me.ms
that
is a presttri3plton
hmffatton
[3
I8
the clatrn,s o f the
to the I 12J6 tssm:, etther
terms
b¢caose
of two te_sons
tooneofskdl
cases,
and/or
m
the clmm
sufllctent
stntctme
or acts
says
] ] 2/6 claffo5
to
t7 perform tlm 6mcuon
examples
or 112/6. thn terms are imerchangeable,
22 what the statute says. Thts
what
we say the
t.¢._ms are. does 112/6 apglytoalimcam
patenL and ts It n¢_-_sat7
18 fzorn th= prefer_d
funetton
tl_ongh
does
So m this
12
gone
that th_r_
that a clmm
apph_
I I _esumpUon
of patcms thd lus duty and did not LSSUC
So having
What
II only
10
had - prt_tm',¢s
12 =m trc, ahd patenL
t3
do recognize
the danger of importing
8
the _loner
We
_s vet-/important
clalm
in them
here
HonoL
9 pro1 that 1 ha_ e emphasmed
"means"
operating
into the clasma
here, Youx
the v, ord "wtthom"
in its task to corat_umg
5
8
down
bebewe
courl
arc dumg jo.¢t that.
7 hint ta_oxLs fi'orn tbe sp¢caficallon
One paint
We
2
7
21
wc wd]
m this
rely
by a teathng
to the embodiments
24
undersumd
also
not contradict
the c_thnal
have
may
OOO28
I wc have exprer=sly
20
the
and technical
the cLam
doe_
25
00027
II
Io preclude
to betle_
comtymng
h mRaUor_
claims
_ here
That's
ts thal you are - the
and
it the catthnal
We
22
12 and
now
we call
21
of parucudar
out to you Claim
and not m any other claim.
23
And
IS
at page 1313
At pag© 1314, thfference;
lechnology
m or _certmncd
m the comcxt o f the
the clatm
21
24
us thronghoul
Honc¢
The second theme thai _ c have
17 of Pktlhpe.
v. here IO
thct_ona_es
dlCttortarl_
at any Ume m order
13
er know
use of dictionaries
not intend
of course,
13 stop
v. ¢ should r._
we do
cauUon,
m3derlylng
order IO hmzt _uch claim,
grade
! 3] 8
1322,
12
]2
the
techmcal
COtWl IS free IOCOnSull
l I tr eatzse_
m
single
use ofthcttonane_,
The
10
v,e
(_x'cta]ty
are a part
Is the best
term
court dOeS permit
At page
9
sa_d
cohn'nn, t fonc¢
of v, hmh they
itself,
of a disputed
out at page
7
a
to tmport wor¢_
10 long ago, at pngc 1312 on the right-hand
II
once
sp¢czficatton
the spect ficauon,
6 pomtud
6 to the com_
7
of the
cases
from
from
This
the Apex
[he fedt:_tl
lc'rra "clrCUll"
JA 0787
ate
to thc
V,'_al we mean
means
by that arc
ts a quot©
These
_s
Computer
Rantan
two
]no
Clr_UIL
ttsel f Connot_
Markman
27
not apply
Bccattse It cottr#OlC5stntctui¢
mean by that9
cctlam
e_se
that
l l 2/6 does
stn_ctur¢
Hearing
tO one
10/25/05
Page28
O0029
OOO30
I O f orthna.P]shdl inthe an to per form the funcuon
1
2 idcnldled by each hmnauon
2
3
3 somcthmg
The term "clrcmt" with an appropriate moth tier
4 such as Interface,programming+
5 are mscned
4 art
logm -- now the brackets
6 we say ifratertheeorcult connotes structure,If
6
7 pro_q'amm mg circuit
7
8 conb-ols structure,
then
if logic circuit
we say ceThalnly control
9 connotes structure And that'sthe Apsx
10
The Lmc_" Technology
II
circuit
the courl
What
circuit?
will
nn, thcymc,mthesa,
II
recaps,
swRch,
switching
13 It can bc -- you can use both
14 term connotes struclurc
14 can use both re_ons
15
term iscoup)ed
17 stnlclu,_tl
mcarung
will
bc convcycd
tO pcrsons
I$ skillm the art That's the Linear Technology
of Oi'thnd_
We
21
The
22 thai those skilled
m the arl would
understand
the term
llght$cnsmg
an an_or
mdepcndcnlly
or you
- that we say that the
sufficient
structure
for
that t$ recited
hear Ic,sumony
19 that the claims
also pout to you Cwo dLStnCI court C_CS
rc_ons
on to elaborate
OUt the function
YOU wdl
m the
Ltghtscnsor,
with each other
18 wKncsscs that when
firstts the CeIINct case where LIS3yS the court finds
there isu't
second reason -- and this =s really
t tscl f goes
17
case from
]9 the federalclrcult
20
claim
6 C_lng
Our
means
13 persons of skdl m the iechmeal ,trtindicate thatthat
Thus, when the structurcconnolmg
retards?
[o people skdlcd
methmg
[2
16 wlth a dcscnptlon ofthc clrcun's operation suffictcnl
orcuzl
you to that
or sensor means
12 In a tCC_lllCal the Uorv_Jy, thci_ thai IS cvzdence that [he
15
Sensor _ Of course
Yes
tscontrol
dcmonswate
l0
Our
You bo[you
Swflch7
circuit
Sensor
tlmay look to lcChnlcaldlclzonant* bocnttse tf a tcnn IS
or mean
about -- Is there a d_lTercnc¢ v, hcn the Icrm
9
that
our Ji_Jt qucP_
to persons shdled in the ¢lectronlca
Yes
of control
8 wlmcs$cs
case
case mstructs
Control[cd
instead
Well,
mg terms connote structure
s[n_ctural
5 Ltghlsensor?
by us - controlor control --in other words,
colmOlCS Structure,
So 'Ahal do we me,m fu_heft
Is. do the follov,
from our technical
they read the claims
thcmsc[_
es connote
m their
stnJct_c
enllreW,
under this --
20
these C_eS. $O that it'S
they don't read them as means
21
£unctlonclaims
22
And
the C,LSe tS Sage
Products
We
both cite
Sage
23 "clrcmt means" as a stmclural llmltatlonrather than a
23 PrOductS m OU¢ bnels
The quote IS Important
24 m_ts
24 claim rccltC_ a function
b_t then gocs on 1o claboratc
plus funcuon
25
Wc
25 su_ctcnt
alsoha_ c cztcdIO you the M agne-Tek case
Mnrkmnn
Hearing
10/25/05
Page
Markman
tO pet ['on_ ¢nttraly
[he recited
2 zSnol m means pluS ftmCtton
3
So our wlmcsscs
4 statements
Dr
6 either connotes
7 SU_ClCnl
8
sccumy
hgh0sg
13
this palcm
14
r_ponse
w_
apphcd
10/25/05
Page
30
And
there's
spocllledtlme
timer then
to you thai the claim
6
8
9
I0
whal
II
patent
a unique
they v, cTc kno_
n when
level of hght,
14
were known
dmk
They
t_cd
the
m our patent
The photocell,
23
acccnl mode
instead
24
lth© the prior art thd
items of the control
because there'sa unique control
wc
we arc not here
arc here
are other
THECOURT
Hlggms
cta_m is the umque
what
you're
MR
HIGGINS
19
all of the shdcs
Car=you
[o make sure I*m clearly
20
I will hand
Yes,
ma'am
that at the conclusion
control
to you
to Dr
We have
cop_cs
of
of the presentation
C:m_al
and to counsel,
Okay
Okay
pnntouts
of the shdcs
COURT
24
arc In the patent
25
commercial
Thankyou
that -- these
embodiment,
features
Go,_hcad
Othcrfeaturcsthat
arc m the
m the preferred
Markman
)788
of the
circuit
HIGGINS
JA
Mr
16 tmde=tanthng
MR
Page3Z
but
feat_c
ovemde
[ want
THE
10/25/05
art
m the preferred
F-xcuseme,
23
Ilearmg
vahdl(y
IS wh*tt the technology
features
22
Markman
never In any prior
to talk about
There $ a manual
of all thc way to bnghk
circuit t UrT,S the
clrC_ll [n their
were
to talk about
first I[ [ L_llS [he lamps on [o an
sensor, the control
The
is detected
zs
There
21 of all
hkc mOSt do
motion
bc fore
embodiment
18
in the _ ay that this '066
if no further
15 go back to thai last s]lde i
l?
ABofthosetechnologtcswcreknov.nbut
{0 keep the lamps .it bnght
In the *066 patent
Now
12
tO _JI li'1LP.,tS
t 0 n. mOLlOn
"_as put together
The motion
Wc say R'S the marna_¢
13
together
dewce
1"hal
rc_t3xts the timer
circuit
reoccurs
times out only
These
to produce
a timer that keeps the lamps on ['or a
had put them
as motion
IS detected
of_ce
The llmcr the conffo]
4 so long
h turns the tamps on Ln
for
sensor, they
2t
25
the
product
they are known,
20 _lent
22
3
their
from
was new to the palcn[
7 combination
tccboolo$1cs
lamps on In N_pOR,_
ctrcmt
gwmg
questions
OF it goes on [o e]3bor_le
tO a predclcrmmcd
Molton
19 nobody
answcnng
to you IOdayq
of known
Pholceell,
17
- when they're
wdl exptmn
stz_Clure
(o demonstrate
12
]8
the claim
Ilearmg
I lamps from accent to bright when motion
2
what tSthe '066 patent technology thatwe're
and control
15
Carnal
the claim
sB1Jc[ure o_-acts
Well,
9 going
will
fUnCltOn,
format
and when they're
5 COUrt or from
16
Where a
OOO32
I t_elf
II
or acts within
matcnH
29
ooo31
]0
structure,
plus
embodiment
Hearing
as well,
10/25/05
Page
32
00¢D3
OOO34
the manual ovem_e
fem-_e, the p*_lsecount f_ture,
zero ¢a-n_mg dtt t¢[ t_e.
mad _l [Ttrmzt c_J;
the
5 t= pll_r_
pztem mchtde &ffereaZl o f ti-ez.e fca_'_
Manual
t;_
o_¢='nd:. for example,
5, 7, 8. 12 ax[ 13
ts m Clam_
that include
9 cl_xt
'I'F_ COrJRT
10 arid I I
S
m thzs cz_c
four¢lun_bemszttettecih_a'eareallmde_
14
MR_ H[GGINS
1-_
"1_2 COURT"
12
you re._ly hzve r,otl o f four &fftaz_t
&ffctt"_t
20
M_.
21
"Vz-IECOURT
I_GGZ_"_S
1_;
dcvtcc
20 morton
That _ corrct't
or cc*Jld market?
cl_zly
some thm_
2_ msomcclams_pdn_zmeJudcdmcthe_.
21
7. of ptt_ntth'ht7
3
4
]Q£L_/0S
Page
_
THE COU'RT
sea.rate
mv_tton.
lidcsmb_
a=d the
and _c t_n¢_
z_
cros_n8 dct_t.
Andat
ff_t _omc _'nm you only nccd one *_or
to perform
A nd d_ _m be
24 e_t_"
the photc_:LI _" the PII_, _s v_e _re _.;Im _ xL
25
_
etch pateat _ e_ct_c
me_ Each cha_ _e;
M_rkmmn
Hearing
10/25R$
Page34
_tTczen_ort
2
"UdB COU_T'
Goco.
"_Idmwillt_commmn_
b.,_'or
e
9
M_
tO _m¢
rm ready _tym$
sorncwhat
d_c
{_-_fm,m.b
• .*_mm_ dctmpuo_
of
L of $¢o_o_
9 Cxpla_
And In m_ny st_a_om..
16
b_l
n_
{7
A_dyou'll_emthed_f_m_r_oa
18
u'_al _e _
19
all o f the fe.m_es
20
_{1
be _t_nbed
_cktd¢
22
Anal
23 cl_n
o_Jy _¢
t_crc_rc,
bt_
th_
"Una_ _h_
l{
fcalme
Lt_t dt c pn¢_
to
_'_ dc4_ n't h_ve.
that clmm _s stiU patemtabIe,
t_e c_._ t;w ¢:a_t th_ do¢_m=
Hctnng
10t2_d0S
cttctuc, the cen_'ot ¢_cmc,
wfl{ k_e
JA 0789
mg_ne_
a _cod
_e
the:_ £idu_
pn_tclpk_,
W,_,_a_
_
undertl_dm8
so
of
them fll
PhlJlL_ C_.S_
We belpn wnth _e words
t_¢ c]a_'_
to be mtcr_w_'d.
3ad we derive
as _d_e¢_d
of dx cLmr_ We commie
to one_ skilled
m thc a_
Wc
the cleJr_ In corAcx * orethe CqLlm pat cY_L
We _4_:,re_tate tl_ &ffer_c
Markman
Page35
t c_mok_'_
the photocell,
about,
_y UESA
we propose
_m
25
•f
_
,It
24 ¢or_r_e
th* other cl:ur_
Markm_n
Nov..
t_cse are our gtu_n_
23
chum
thaL
20
22
znd ffttt
a_d dlou]d bc mtr-xl_r ctt:d
the factthat¢_h
ttlkcd
t_er
_e'x_or, _e
{ 7 that yG_t _nd Dr C_al
o f our palem does cordon
sa'g an m_c_ucn
motion
_lLl
SL_IC_¢
Now) o_r _d_[ymg
tl_tt wcJ_t
! 6 they wall be demor_tratcd
R._p_wdld_
hts ,u_m_
a dmra :rod the W efevered
Okay
HIGGh'4S
of the fcamms
t| whywe
_nvcntlon
THE COURT
I_ _e
o_e, the
bceaus*:
Itw_'11a]xoexp_mn
15
1_
ezra be mt..'rp't_d
2_ _ffc_atly
d_
_1 of ti'e f_'_
dutlMr
embo&trg_t
BUt tt _. nevctthfless,
21
_d'"_'_g
contemn8
_,s_snott,_eqr_x
And _,t
b¢_vge_
12
14
14 lrlV¢_tzoa OUL
15
statement
l I _et_ f_rth a _pzratc
for carzTmJ_ the
I
Mary. PaJ1erlon Io _3_Jc you to
the dt f_
I0 cmbo_enL
112"7 Andth¢
wdl,
p.M_mt_laone_
8 m Ms w _ux_
112 aL_o rcq_u_e_ tl_
to $ct forth Ll'.¢bert r_¢
M__HICGINS
ttmewehavebadtoaddr_sthtsp_
? brought
you wt_m rap/rag?
[l-|_mgoback(oS_.uot3
12 p_L--_ m p_
I3 ap#tr_t
6
e"_h ¢{_um L_Z
whtch t* what l _u_ht
A _
LPctr_¢'_Uoa.
5
from ¢lam_ to c'_
9ut yo_'re {ayes
I-HGGI3_S
t_ml_L
¢om;l_g
POtJust a & ffer_'_ way ofdesmbm8
8 I_1csame mvcn_oa,
25
w_ll p_nt out that
that_ in the paiem d_.cn_es a
lt_:;m'tx:;wpvL_eco_t,
And tt dcst_s
t_o36
1 clam
I
In
I0 be 5re thml_
s _emem
33
znd Ihcy rts¢ or fail m tcrma
,*why tern
,:e_em_arj
to th= _k
the_e cLl?n t_
6
II
Hunng
:hffe_
yc_ tod_y to cor,_wtm tPe cf_JWJ of the paL"_tt m a m_er
S w_e
7
_e mclm]rd
o0m
the _Uo_
23 sore©thin S _zt tho prior _'t r_ver d_-
or uaG'mscmcmt on then ow_.
._+_d
_
_aw-ycr_ do _ th_
And thee m,ght be _ve thm_
F_U_:_'n
s_n._
22 t_-_'b_
Ijt_
[sttamod_?
MarY.re.In
00035
1 fo-Lh a $c_z.qt¢ mvt2men,
m3vclty,_tdzty
to the prior an.
19 the se:_ov; coon_na_ed both for the _ot_¢e.][
And dc<_ dzat d_ m'oc &ffcrcnt
¢fl_=r_ berau_
_
c.omp_l
there hap;xn_[
Bm Mr
I_; nma_ovcm(k
- Lheoats ax t._ue
23 don't q,me tmderIt.zr_ the d;ffe_'mce b_tv. cca L_
74 mdclzadeza
Ear, hinverd;onm_tmee_
17 _c _rc fated e_bo_m_nt
vartatao_ of the pattmL
22 mode LI of tial that you m_kct
c_tmm of an Ls_ed _tte;'.t
_tremv_n_on
the p_ot _'t
I_ thu _e
A.,zd from my mathnS, tt _ecrrd as
law _; Io
_vays
I_w _; thin _'y
A_d _o tha_ what _,_'_
I._ th_
yes. ma'm'_
toth¢
pit_t
m (hffcrrnt
13 £_=_ch for the on_ thing that rn_es
17 or zp0Lt'ara& thax beca_z c you ht.v¢ got i_dcpctxdem daura
19 huc zre sort o£ f_
_c Inv_i_on
t ! _nd rmn obvtou._l_
Ycu
Pa_ent
mven_on_d_o
10 thccon_uo_ofFat_-b_Y
clatmz?
16 0zough Cam though you hrtc a pazcat for a p,_l_ttr
It
,,_r._ t_
9 se_ forthzs_
Cotdd you - one ¢oa¢cpt that I'm
13 all zgree Ihcy are tade_cat
tndth_'.wllb¢
o1_¢e tad t_v m get paiene; for their chmts, ore
7 be 1_[¢ to d_nt3e
11 hz,lz_8 a re.al M,xi umo Setta_ mY _-'x_-*armmd ts that tze
t2
etth_tt
by our w_t_e_;, Mark P-_Icr_t_9
6 of L_ skill s=_ o['a permn who p_:nce_
Andtheyzrethc
'fire zrc t_mg _sttted
10
$ ptt_t
so pul;a comic, no mara_l
8 o_¢rndetztClm,z_6,9.10_d[I
m de_}
4 a_tomey_ wht._theydr.©mtoan
I
Pt_e cotm_ tt s only m C_,m
12. Zc*O ¢rc_zng detect tt m Clmr_
The cI_z_
Wh,_:t_s,
2 Yo_Hc_r
0 f th_
_ctwctm
_© pr_ f_cd
Hearing
10J_$/05
Pnge36
0_t37
I
embodm.emmdtheclasms.._t._thauwhzt
2 )ml
focttsed ¢m. each cI_m
J
We 6_ _1
4
[nntut30_
_-peoa_l/Icchnu:al
!
l_:v,
9 _c_cs
2 :ta_hhc_ BOon to c_o:'_
and smport
3 Tnzrs
c_bo_mcrd
4
into the
to _
t3_J u thc protocol
I!
tm.p/y
I)
pzt:r t by ones _kdl_l
I :_ b_c_t
t$
be C_'a#L
19
Unit
2C* tt2/6
ccr64et
ttc_J
m _
?.5 _
12
t| dctecbn_
c_.
lfy_,
_
17
m_
me_J_ _
sb_c_u'e
m :c_ _L_d_et.=pply
20
Tcch c_c,
And
o¢"
fo_6_u_u_,_a_
_emor
m e,_z_ f0t de_e_tms,
rnc_z
the
_tvc
tO
And then _
25
10/2_'0_
etmtcttal or a_a to p_'f_xa
'rmt_
Now, [ nnut remind the ecru't, rm
wdl. tlmt _f.e
fhncuce
_
imc ff I d_n%
_._t thzt tt pe_m'mt
$opleaseammd_zdyJtde,
to ray "_i_n:
_
thoS_oPmductsc._e.
the
ifyou_dl,
flmclmn"
Markmaa
Page37
1 ore" client wz_
to bc mccsTnctcd
ot_
t_c claum _o on m clabomtc
_
C_k
24 eni_
apphed c_rccJI me:ms as
Of f,_d Ltr_e
IO_xpt_l_on
ttt _= O'O'O'O'O'O'O'O'O'O.mct:ora
tt'_ we v_t It be t_cu_xs
_u(t'[eac_
Mr
Hearln_
me3Ils I_lve
_t
2l
to t p*_,o_
t t _6
thcu the chc'n u_mt
ernploycd-
far c,_smg
21 ftmc_on.
the
11.7.'6 _Jd not apply
tf)_a,
flftcdor
m _la_m 6
19
co _'01d
112/6_-_#_cr_t_
In the Masnt
ihe c_u_
pan of the c_c
Ict'_ look It it m tefn_
fLm_on_
the zecon_
m
Thc _c_c_ f_ winch a
'D_o f_tr.e'z_mt_m
15 m[c_al
= t;_ c.k_cs of Linear
M_rkmao
to do to _u
Hearth8
_ hrr_t some
10,25/05
Peze
38
PaCe
40
of thc dz._putc
2 m thss ce_.
the 112_6
Hems_ I tza'n#l
$
Chm_6
I J tlli_lalmg, _
the Icrm iL_cJrCormote
Hcctor, may bc cnot_h
I=mtaa_
la Cel_Cl
_: c,ed_
of chc _ure
_s the
fi_
thts is L_e
an6 "v_c-_f
u:mc_b_,_sy_,
corot oo.q_b_cd t nvc_f
0OC_9
I
m the t 8_6
13 coarxo_led ¢_rcult means for czmta_,
axcloolu_g
r_c "w_y ", your
21 pan:l/t'a._c
24
r_cu_n
tl
I_
p_,dhgu,
23 _lled
m co_cxl
bc fort: the CmaL dca
R_,wc
17 "rcr-he_inJD', Apex,
v*_
A _ctz_
It'$tr_R._ttl_
9 pc_cn_a*hmst_parucularty
m the zn
lezXt_L _xl we recognize
_
s_c_'ure?
22
ten'as th21 _rc m thut p_t,
my ihey rJ_eM be comu_.d
"]_e _
t6
_¢
I 0 once we te_entt _y _:
The ncm-me;_t
14
wbat _sa func_0n7
H e_c's anc{h_ _cfinltmn_
Ihtl our
b_ve ttsed _md will _se for &e rc_ of th_
ot actt'_
for which a p_t on m "thlall _t specify
7 M_ufy
&ctmp,mc_.
bcrc u.
t_'_l_ a fiJ_CUOn
n_tl:n_
pact ot'ot_ l_ck-mt=.t_or_
6 Ltt_d.O_ forw_tchthct_m_¢tlsL_
where ap_opnzle.
hr_.rm$
II
Bythewzy,
_
I ufficl_t
the Sase Products
a_x_
&c_ona_c_
9
Ot_ |ecOnd point D d04:_ _
m_tmn
m_ctcth
Wc _c
]0
Oe C:u'cLm_ gn
from thc p_cfe_rcd
tim u bc_g
6
c_=at
I
L_c cotn'_h._
L_a Jep_fzte
of how ore"wlmc_
3
w.tll
be
Thcy my that the tint
level of dhmunzUon
mc_L_
#
4 presett_n_Ou_
toyou,
4 reJat]vely _ m hsM campe_ed to • served
lntbetc_m-mOaun6.
cm_o_ ccrcmt wt_t I _ve l_c've
- t_s _ _'n
6 p,_enl d_lr.
7
_
I have tt_e_mcd
_d_
,1..,_f g & ffc'_:_t _
G_ act_
9 con_otcs sm_c_r c Welt _
'7
m Otc _L_
the c/a_rnthengo an to
ttr_p _ trot
I._
t]
C_nwolc]mmt,
fcacttomofstr_au_
_d
9 dc _li0.q
WaS_(r_.m.
12
pz_uctd,_r c_.m_, wc hzvc t_=c
14 _t's_vct_th_t_'.te_"
I $ detectton.
thai _
i_p'_t
I_d
the acre of _e clam
but we_
_t
_r otg_t.
O_
re._ly okay w_
th_
cc_th_ort, they f_ty
Wc_ayno
d'= ('.':.t Ftc&+.c_
n tlc c_m
mc_'_
level
Ira6 the '_lded
_'eb'sot_'tttobec_tc_"ted"
4 d=fir_6
term _
to d_c rtr_
_[ow. the rtr_ prcd_cr_mcd
13 no? Be_=_c
coc_lcdtoal_zp
[t_ttmt_Ua
16 It_m _ere e,vlCC- tn G'tC
z_
Well.
we'ce Ckt_ web
of I_t_m|tlcm
ItV._l com_red
11 tl'S moron o f a pc_on
tif.t._.
So m _
I_ey _y
8 _J_vcly
I 0
l0 cln_r_Jes_ttct_cof zc_? The funcbo_ _ c.msm_ _=
it
_t
6 dut
eve_v term in tins pttem
s_l_ct u.'c to on= skilled
wt,.u we p_
lave]
n_
cc_l_ltoz
Phrase
Whydowcszy
u
-..If
i_cl_"
hl#tt -
of - now th_'g_
17 alft
19
And ot_ c_'_d_o_
_ th21112J6 docs not tplPly t0
20 c_.._1
clam ptmuc.
ZI
Well
what _
wc fig]ran|
abom C_a_m 6_
gores to do here _ set forthEM].'S _mposed
23
t _
- we _
_a w© _'cp_mg
2[ boci
Wh.u rm
And
25
oee o f _ut Lkm._p that I u.'ant to d_ to yo_ _m6
M_trkm:_
Wc_cA_y_
there's = _ot of
24
25
t]l
co_m_'ucZuo_.
He=nng
10/'2@0_
Pa_e39
JA 0790
Th=t_
_h_t _
Acd
_'y.
th_ rc_0n
e_d e,o
I_l
-/_drc
p,_ay v_th t/-:u.
_vc _/._c
,:re ok3y
Marka_n
Hmrmg
wt_h _tzt _
lOt2SlOS
OO042
0004l
I that
2 Claim
3
thai
6. is defined
5
Well.
conthuon,
I
the exact
2 j.mlmed
6 _
the
can rettt.m
$
call that m our hnefs
and
level
of hghl
to firsl pred¢lermmed
firsl predetermined
We think
conthtlon
so v. • wonder
second
ts defined
_ hy they
predetermined
conthtlon
one
_ld
that
self-defined
The
to said
Ks predetermine
exlernal
14
otherhghtthatmakesvtstonpossthle
15
are ambivalent
Id
apparatt_,
ab_ul
I tell you
18
We also
20
the defimtlon
really
-- _
22
okay
It's a caution,
you see.
nol sus¢cplthle
stnaclua-e
thmk
that
or
2
ft's
in the
3
Tennessee
4
ts evidence
$
6
question
'_.hal
of tntcrpreldtlon
cited m eases
Technological
they
really
the passl'.
have
9
examine
10
II
tbeseQI
12
They
13
the
14
1_
importing
16
claim
17
the
20
lmporhng
hul we*re
i$ thai
there
21
il is
t$ no
10/25/05
Page
that
we say that's
e to said
separate
from
from
ts there
h o'.', ones
21
PIR
IO enable
22
You
wtfi hea r a lot about
23
beanng
say selection
that
a complete
because
23
Elcctromcs
first
said
24
_all
25
arts
2
3 _
that
the first sensor
Q I and
Q2
They
What
sensors
says
6
pass_emfraredPIRsensors
Qt
and
4
hne24
parL
13
QI andQ2
Ihe cottrl to do
14
the
block,
the
such
and
preferred
m the
the motion
selecllon
teaching
ot'the
part
rnttsl
' The
entire
Ilearlng
understand
18
thmgagamatcolumn6
] 9
n says
20
motion
42
a PIR sensor
In column
17
4
sensors
QI
and Q2
this
patent
23
sensors
are
24
sources
e'_tetnal
25
technic.ally
3, bnen
each
_ensor
24
The
through
sensors
respons_;e
and
disagree
with
I don
Q2
Page
44
Column
sensors
andQ2
itsays
detect
motion
people
skdled
fiat
that _s
m this
5aystbesame
[n the abslract
is for detecting
39
_t descrthes
are each
to infrared
to the Idmp
g, sensors
hne3
mcolumn6
QI
Column
hne
Column6
that
_s
andQ2
sensorsQI
infrared
v, orks
to
I[
you
a PIR
hncs34and35
that p:_sl_c
22
hghl
t tthnk
how
- the PIR
produced
anyone
by
will
that
51arkman
JA 0791
Page
Theword
,mdQ2detectmot_on
In this
43
are referred
abslt_acl
that tells
Cohunn
andQ2
read
thatsensorsQI
21
Page
and
4, hne
the sensors
_ho
P[Rs
'_.hat
Q2
point
people
because
understand
Column6
arl
10125105
10/25/05
tv, o conventional
sensorsQl
oh, bythe_ay
17
of to hov.
25
QI
And,
dlSpule
patent
eleclromcs
Ilearmg
In the
hne30
Column
lelhng
Io the
m the
QI andQ2
sensorsQI
to be detecled
for the understanding
_larkman
Q2
16
be added
circuitry
sensors
some
mlO the
24
m the an
15
an would
sought
of
[co much
embothmenl
a th fferencc
skdled
context
that
that
of
is a
sensor
is tmportam
Ateolurnn3
hne 34,
D_ctlonary
people
by thai _ The
3 lines
skdled
12
block,
for
claim
119.2/6 claim
of Electromcs
in the patent
infrared
In column
I I
part of the
Modem
by
Into the
a non
Dictionary
_ e mean
nine times
3
h's-+
we say
const_ctton
embothmenl
by the
book
bnghl
in the claim
motion
do
a p,t_Sl_e
people
beforehand
are
sin Of chain
is
to be
to emit
words
we say that5
Modem
5
8
ffyou
first scoot
the lamp
preferred
reference
7 "con_enllonal"
don't
conlend
sought
put this in ted becal_e
c_ffdlndt
Is defined
recognt2ed
first
deterTnmed
of those
from
The
or object
cause
means
sensor
10
:$ the
circuitry
it to detect
We say that
22
to define
the defendants
51arkman
at
and a Is somethmg
detectors
_kmg
a P[R works
prowdes
ha_-e
say ts that
first
ralatt_
has been
None
Pffs[ sensor
9
say
how
25
the
court need
_lfi
elements
00044
I a PIR deicers
the bookstore
that
41
to you
ca.se
centers
24
Itself
_ What
which
- .rod we
4
we say
i e motion
We say
In this
19
They
detected
commltlmg
12/6 posIIton
18
20
that you
motion
of a person
their
meara9
pan of the
around
15
n's thc motion
19
thosearethepasst;emfrateddetectors
why
that
the
18
briefs
that
14
t_ ould
with
sensor
of things
Well
left m
We
V_nat we
or object
conthtton
By
stick
or st_ctu_
is x', bat they
andQ2,
And
from
else
predetermined
be foreh_d
say
'.,,• rated
What
13
x_ hen delecled
say about
say tt includes
block,
that
¢ mfrated
they
a non-I
their
This
of a person
light
Ilearlng
Umverslty,
of meaning
So '.'. hat do
g
no structure
issues
being
Io he of the type
we should
hecat_¢
avadahle
Or, tf I 12/6 applies,
7
ha;e
of hand
In the claim
17
mark
means.
books(o,re,
_s merely
means
they
of firs1
Andwesayno
condition
conthtton
16
OOO43
I1 s been
sensor
Because
de finllton
clrcult
construcltou
to us
Makes
it's rlol a red no. it's nol a green
51arkman
I
the term is defined
_
their
say there's
slight
tCs too vague
it
determined
so wc
circuit
25
aboul
ts in our sel of de findloll$
21
24
le_ el of daylight
"_ Youknow.
hke been
And
thai
Control
so they
-- control
prlmalv
predetermined
12
of light
Andwereally--we
we don t like
don't
for whal_
level
a specl fled
To,horn
whom
into
first predetermined
g
10
this
what
17 vtslonpossthle
19
are
9
nol
m the claims
And
means
So the
7 here
sel f
no structure
I [ appa]'altL_
fifth term
13
23
terms
mcarm
6
in
accept
control
12
is there
the conlrol
for the
I 1 should
_.by
all of the structure
sensor
A predetermined
first
I0
Wefi
4
well.
8 definition
v. ords
3
tfI
the
Itself by
apparatus
[o said
7 Clmm
9
m the claim
they jUSl put down
4 external
g
ifyou'filookal
thesecondpredelCr'mmedconthtton
llearll|g
10125105
0OO45
I
h goes
2 each
on to say tha| the Set.ors
coupled
3 detects
to a dctcclor
_my $._zficant
porbon
change
QI
and Q2
43 of the cncml
m the cutpul
00046
I
ate
you
will see the domonstralzon
do. and zt will show
7 m output,
zs doleCted
8
by the way,
And
9
pomon
d_
that the r.er,sors.
II
porboo
43
Tbey
13
the
14
ct_cuth
say
_cnsof
15
Yore
the control
17
there*$ no sense
18
But you'll
phras¢_
m_y
arc each
-
I point
8 t_
_ Note.
Rlsays
9
to a dotcclor
I0
43
ts slln
And
the PIR
those
them
th¢_
_ety
qmck
Rapor.orce
24
sensor
has completed
25
which
:1 has sensed
rnear_
c,rcml
blocks
17
by the symbol
S
talked
about
tbe Pig
th_
wall be explained
serzor
somcthzng
sktged
people
procct*s mg the ¢_cnt
10/25/05
czrcul_
It's all of those
that they
say that's not tcchn,cally
through
24 object
Page
We'U
Mt
Carnal,
23 does detect monon
the
or .n formal.on
Hearing
claim ,nlc_ctatlons
circuit cannot d_tect mouon
m the c:rcull thagrarn
We
25
Mark'nan
_n
clrcmlP/
22 sure, and you, Dr
arts,
skdled
of the PIR
ts based upon the opmzon of
thai a PIR
2 i dcrnonstratton
by
m tbesc
we say
say are part oftbe
19 sensor
m the
has pmducedanoutp_t.
to people
up with completing
W_al'S s¢lccuon
18 hlocks
om
And
means
Mass¢_gdl
20
Mr
us technologzcally
IO be detected tmuI
nol_cc on the dra_, mg, the output of
16 wlthoul select*on
because
that I'm bubbhng
I have just
teghmcally,
output
,f you'll
,s mthcated
Tbelr mlc:rpretat]on
15 Dr
ztc._
egaln
place
beTe _ where
23
all o£those
So v*e _
14
h_re is .lUSt v. hcr¢
to go over
22
through
13 for first s¢_so_
cncmL
s¢¢ cvc_
And note,
between
v* hen the PIR scusor has an output that's -- :t's done
]2
t5 pan of
that ,I'S parl of the
20
appropriate
Ou_
Raper wlII satlsPy the COUTt, I'm
that the PIR by ,Iself can and
relat lye to said sensor of a person of
do so_c
person scn_,ng,
and we_l
do some
object sensing
Markman
45
Ilearmg
10/25/05
Page
0C_48
00047
I
Now,
al thts
point,
2 Inttle forgwene_s
3
to be se_ed
4
baseball
5
trgcctm8
6
because
I just
the conlcxt
8
therefore
9
concCl
and should
detected
13
pro fcrred embodnnem
14
there
15
of firsl
17
malysts
18
by fc<_mg
t9
be_tuse
I have
_uc
dotu:
on thts oe_
wall be om
21
have
Mr
all prodoced
23
gomgtode_cdb¢
24
it contains
25
Mr
Paztcr_o_
cou, lt, from the
done
for ag o f tbe clam_
one
Yore
patent
8 to hEs rule
the
on Claim
the e_t_re
fmyouandDr
_ semor
szmplc control
Honor
The
6
patent
firsl
attorney,
Is
and be'$
Markman
Hearing
And
w_th a
the objects of the
theauthorofthetexthook
has
been
of Terms;see,
hc wtn, m turn. describe
some
a IrL_U'.J¢tor al
will describe
commcnt_
for you the way
on Mr Ralx*ds
demot_s_rat
ion and
for you the logic of how cox3uo}
Stev¢'_ Caalson,
16
Speed
17
destgn,
18
.nclu_ng
19
prov,do
Design,
protocol
22
Carlson
Page
47
[nc.
comm_
some
have
Raper's
fro" tie
you ve:y
domor_tratlon,
an a]U_na_w¢
and a_so
clar_l _t]o_
llTJ6apph_.Mr
that
much,
Okay
Your
Hooof
lthmkwe'lltakejusta
sbeforcwedotherextupenmgstatement
Markman
JA 0792
products
aspects,
corot.
Ifthe¢ot_tdoctdosthat
wdl prescrd
THECOURT
of hts own High
the t_thnlcai
o_ Mr
dcfinzttom
we a_
Thank
shortrecct,
who's pres_dcnl
30 plus y carJ; In hghtmg
and he will d_cnbe
A_d
21
25
gore 8
10/25/05
Pau]us,
13
24
HeS
TJ
Elect_om_.
that - make
23
Camalapa_cntandwhat
t'n_n_
c_rctm to produce
12
20
They
12 statement
_
Dr
Applied
15
pamcul_
and a b,_c PIR
14 c_'cmts a_e bmh
mtcrprct_on
ts htghhght
wdru-_ses,
a local
and,
photoceD
the outpul of those two bare scnso_
pa_enL
; I University
to be
12 mto the clam,
rule 12 statements
He's
accc4_n
Rap_
pot_e
here
that "_ e have
orgy
sought
be :c_ceted.
I think tt's exemplar/fo_
22
8
I0
into the claim
clam
have a b_e
7 ve_
ts
ts
that EML and Costco'_
should
He wdl
- and
says
m¢3ns
to
o f thLS p31ertt, hut
go,n 8 to do a dr:mons warren ofthe
6 he wdl many
mtcrwclat,on
a lun,ta_on,
n*¢ar_
what
Thc_
5
and he's a[so going
crnbothmelll
Icclmolog_
w,th
9
EML'S
an_
we suggest
sensor
4 underlying
conststent
Ptulhps
the term
and ,mpo_ng
Now,
20
_hal
a cot'nrncrcial
3 be's pnma_ly
slugger
thts bearm 8
of firs[ scn$o_
ts d_l
12
i6
into
tha_
_'1 mVoetm8
fore,
2 demonstrate
be accepted.
posztmn
prcrnmul
I to 8_ve you the dcmonsWattolk
brought
Lou_vdlc
ts wholly
ou¢ mtt:l_¢tatton
Om
that I have
help mysclfwxthout
mlelVreLahon
-
for a
the corm
_ a rmntat_c
couldo't
of patter
to ask
the object
a httl¢ btl of home
$o o_¢
IO
I have
fo_ mouon
bat
7
It
so tt
to the evenl
as long as the c_ cnl or in fom_t_on
BuJ the mare dxffe_ence
7 _fs gone
out the
coupled
thai block
ztself says
I'm gomJg to skip over
21
component,
] I the an call that the source componcn_
NOW. v* hal I have
these
scusor
an output analogous
6 Is that they say there ,$ no motion
ctrcmt.
that sectmn
occur
5
Rap_
thai change
It ty'&qalat es to mollon
Honor.
undcrhnedh_'e
The patch!
16
19
and how
QI and Q2,
of the
that Mr
you how thai output,
lha_¢Just
10
12
Wovldc
4 occurrlng
Now.
6 will
continuously
3 o¢ m formal,on
of cttbeT
4 SelLSOr
5
Ye_, the Pig t$ an analog
2 wll}
which
We'll
Hearing
10/25/05
Page48
46
00O49
}
OOO50
]5-mlnulefec_
takea
2
O3_ak
3
MR
4 bcglm,
)
HIGGINS
I ha_ • one
hott_kcepmg
5
THE COURT
6
MR
7 allde$,
and
8 a copy
tfl
the court
to you azld to Dr
I0
MR
them
HIGGINS
COURT
MR
HIGGINS
mote
than
15
THE
glxeone
',*ould
Okay,
be fine
already
handed
a copy
of
CODRT
MR
THE COURT
19
a paml
copies
I f you ha_ e aaoth_
HIGGIHS
_
tfyou
wix_et
Irma] maRt't,
you
need
Io move'_
MR.
HIGGINS
24
THE
COURT
25
IvlR.COOK
Thank
I mo_¢
to
Ccok_
you
ymt
Mr
Cook7
Thank you, Yam
Markman
Honor
Tnts
Hearing
10/25/05
Page
Bm
m 1996
2
m - the original
3
Michigan,
a fitt
patent
IX wrote
tv, o feral
a new
4
the
5
tt. he _ as tepl_nd
palem
attorney
hghmlg
anamey
was
the patent
ur.enuc,
and filed
tt for
after he
m a & ffereat
filed
And
that
atlomey
8 thee
v, as lmot
art on
9
10
Ceramtc
At thai
acqmred.
urne
THECOURT
M_.
the Nvpa
patent
a.qorney
and th_
It was
abo_t
about
19
p_edece_ot
And
21
tt was two
22
mode,
art.
kamnd
they had 2n actual
hafate
gus
they
were
th_
he abandoned
9
Ltghtmg
And
thzs ts what
it, he also
the
new
uaderstaod
back
that
al Heath,
was
lughly
relcv_t
tt had an a¢cem
the anginal
23
conunuauou
apphcaacra,
24
a de¢l_
of two mthwdua_
which
pnc_
mode
apphcaaon,
thc
the
ts at tab 75, and then
from Heath,
a Mr
filed
I I how
the in_ entlon
McCavlL
Markman
Heanng
10/25/05
Page
51
JA 0793
of the patent
282.986.
Io a
July 29,
1994
thai
v, as the original
was filed
In thts
elmded
ca_c.
Two
and
Level
it
Sectulty
m the fiont
part of the patcat,
tt talks
about
tht having
two
le_ els of
thai
is an aeeenl
mode
along
tix pathway
of yore
is a system
hghtmg
TIXr e's a first
14
can
15
then
Ix kept
tm
a bright
msttal
Ig
m_ entlon.
fexal
at mghl
mode
It doesn't
17
when
Now.
aboul
21
But--
patent
22
THE
COURT
23
MR
COOK
24
nouce
-- thole
25
tt was
palemable
-- that is what
It says
apphcatton
office
They
filed
was
eventually
had located
Eveat
ually.
it was
_t was
3
expIamed
why
4
patentable
m _ew
The
Now.
6
you
7
again,
why
of the
exammos
thts was
done
m 1996
ofth¢
patent,
you
wall see this
you can do '._ hen
file. a primary
14
that v._
patent
filed
When
¢ontmuat_n.
17
thsclosure
18
back
m 1994.
19
have
been
hack
stmply
Page
52
_f
1996
from
the
-- contmuahon
apphcatton,
there
you have
apphcatton
abandon
using
Tncy
are
patent
a variety
a parent apphcatton
And
tt they
the same
get
made
rn the
Ixcame
that
was the
fihng
clmn_s
except
of the
on
parenl
it as a
same
sar_
filing
date
hy InvenUora
that
interim
a contmt_t,
has new
refile
apphcat_on
not antt¢lpated
fihng
to the 1994
It's essenbally
can
palcnl
the benefit
so they're
to the same
apphcauon
agmn.
m 1994
they
16
nov.
Felnuar/13.
is tab 75
of things
23
if-
which
13
50
is the '066 patent,
filed
you file a patent
12
22
And
apphcallon,
ot a thvtslonal
So this
was
that rtsuhed
apphcatlon
entailed
invention
patent
wl'ml
Page
otpfamed
Andthey
this
was then
II
21
they
ra the actual
ctmtmual_on
Now.
and
10/25/05
clam_
look al the face
So this
felt that
at Hcath
theft
new
_ hat'_
llearmg
product
ii was -
th_ t_o
allou, ed
Tixrewasa
declarauon,
thts
a_td
the
proscculed
llw_allowed.
a single
that they
home
thai thai Is the
and
w as an alloy, ance
2
that
t$ detected
anyffang
talks
thai patent
years m the
mollOn
mtmtlon
thsclosur¢
20
25
face
System
And
24
Jet, sen
the patent
the
a reference
apphcallon
it _as
I0
20
art,
aad Imghl
filed
number
that
- cventuaJly
15
of DF_A
fev¢l hghnng,
was
When
cm_ see on
to -* there's
that palent
apphcaUon
IO 1994
you
of serial
Now.
8
9
w_
that7
s_ur_ple of the produ_
so because
was abandoned
$
N_ppon
_themsln_uonmanualfo_
fearned
18
20
he
That
pnct
5
IO
Wh_*s
n Ceramic
When
andM_
pradtet
tt was Heafl_
COOK
17
25
m fact
syst era,
Sohewas-
14
16
that
hghang
of DE.SA
13
15
du;co_ ered
a i',vo I_, ¢1 hghtm8
m the poss4y_on
II
12
had
then
the two level
contmoatmn
5
firm from
6 Chicago
7
4
OOO52
I
had come
n, but shortly
by an am:,mey
that It points
patenl
back
Markman
from Kalmn&zoo,
applmatton
document
7
dates
49
I
I
3
19
Whydon'lyoumove
Thank
Okay,
may
of Mr
Certmrdy
was filed,
16
you.
I can see the presentatton
THECOURT
23
tree, we'll
Wedo
One
really
13
wt_
race
Thank
HIGGINS
"_here
21
extra
Th_wouldbe
appheauon
12
thank you
We have
Io mycled_
18
0005
to bnr_
one
17
22
offi¢_
thspute
2
6
Point
to the de fendan_
THE
20
of the Power
security
I have
13
16
copt_
CarnalO
That
12
]4
Cook
matter
I ha_e
can ask
THE COURT
beforeMr
Okay
HIGGIN$
9
II
YourHonot
1
date
date
as the
on
original
for purposes
and a further
the same
you're
on apphcatt
as the
of prior
It*s
h dat_
art
It
prosecuuon
original
permitted
to ha_ c new
Marlonan
Ilearing
cLamas,
10/25/05
and
I I_UCflC_ITGI_tlzl
chdnolhzvcapul_cotmdo8
2
reduce Msc opcz_Jon
3
and cbn_cd
4
rc_ccd m the d_
$
6
m thc uutznt
$o w_t
mvc_tt0n
7 cLums w_
S by _uo
app]lcauon
thc7 wc_c say_
- th_ this
a_zl
ovcmdc
AM
at_d chined,
pall=
11
cl_oscd
_d
m _¢ in_t_l
c._[u_d
I_ow. D_A
lm
out pu_c c_u_La_
14
IZ bet notspc_Ec_lydznu_J
15
wtuch
_c
_c a_crt¢d
"l_s
Mr _az_ur_r.
(I
g_crally
19
h_vc rnc_
_ I_
No,
_u'_
_
_ccr'_'.t.b_w_l
_d
clz[atcd
_
/cr_cn
is _vhy _uc
dcd.u-_co
8
_
C_3UR'I _ Ok_
9
[_.
CO0_
_xancnm
12 !:umcds;_
13 au_l
c, _k_l_u_
£n_'_ t_
w_
s
Ii wzs m Ckc _e h_ry
hr, c a h_t
whoa th_
_d
w-ant to b_ _th_
oC m_u_
aM _._
5 In n_ ,cxt _£Lhc
10/ZSlOS
Pale
Sd
Page
56
whe_ you wwc cL_mm 8 _e_
tt'e lmlz:nl ol_c_
wiW
_ _s
somc_h_8 _s
noted by d_
ot noto t_¢
L;/_ wbx_ t_
I0
ev_y,
thou,_,/_ _
II
thin,p; th_ z_c z_Iso p_n_3cd,
12
thu_S that wzs _:lc_
13 d_
=re
_
_
So _x'_ly
I_e hxsk_'y
re_s_.zMc
Io bc_,.cv¢ t/_
t/_ w_
th_ w_
th:s is whxX _c_¢_
a_d McCav_
_
Hca_
a _y
w_rl_g
20 Ccr_czc F_O_ z_-
cxxmuz_r
_owcd
_l_uson
Ov_ dz© p_or
tbc cl_,
c_
a_. thc
c:_c_o _ro _e
clams
¢c_ss
pc'r_cd
to covcr thc su_ctu_c
20
specs tic.on
21
I/_e_cadnn_s
But _
22
_U
bcm_ :_s=_c_ _by
2_ =_o,t_¢mm_rysccbc_
,,ray to d3_m
to ZC_L_Iy claim
the si_c,flc
23
co_sl_¢d.
24
_'s
the
thml
aboul whclher womb
mc_
spcczEc
plus flc-,cL_c_
wl_n
zl_ct
ttl _
tb_ we_
w_
or ms_l
d_clo;cd
Iste_ly
_ thc ._r_c_'c
pl_
how _osc
z_If.
z_._
S _ _c
or oc_ m _ho
zn_, eqmv_cnce
d_ms
G_;t's &sclo._cl
in t,_c p_e'_l _p[icad_n
y_u todd
pl_J_ •
18 Cu_cil_, _nd thin d'_ w_uld bc c_cz_.d
s_d
19 _ut_c
So wtLh _cl
decided
convc_cnt
17 do t*. You could only do II If_Ou _
18 impol_dy,
pc_plc Io
the 2ung.
16 _Jalmms, and _¢y wezc vc_
pul 0"n
to _t
_o_xc_
m thepme_
_lhoul
t5
$o _
CoalF_=s n:f_
In a z'uncnon_d f_luc_
15 h_ck md look st _e
23 _
Hc_rlng
no1 I1_111tled by Ihe _
So ml:._lly
d_c_i_
22
Of = PC_W._nOr
6 lo h _c_
9 cl_wo _
14 _d
21
Cot _dC_rr_n_ z
pc_,o_s, u_c'n k_t _ .Izu_ would :c_l m
14 work_n 8 on it or by s_'r _oM m _e pt.Mlc when they come
l_
they
7 Lho In'_¢_lut of dlc ox c_1 ncv_ Invc_tc_
"; H_
11
ll's
bec=_.e
wb:ch u G_CmOL_
pits _on,
$ I_r I_lz_'_ld_ll
_,._tCs 1t
I1,
_s _ay_ng.
In the _Xl
t_ +¢r_cr _e_r'_
3 znd you cln ',mll_ue
a
m Cb_n
10a_d
thcy rnc_
0005_
I wh_'_ m_
zthc-_-_$_c_)_
Th_
Markausu
wE.:t _yc_aL_r3
6,9,
dm_
cc_L_oo,
2 £_cbon_,lly,
3 _:_lc:_3o_e
- k's c_lid0y
_ s i.,c_ i'¢.7._ clmn_l
plus £Lmcuon clmm_
Tlsc _c:tc_.
23
_ scna-zlly
thcsoa_cm_,nspl_iXtncts0ncl_ms,
ch_dosed
s_l_cmzn_
o_
[ca_
m _amu
Pn_e
THE_'RT
m
fcz_
apphc.;lloo.
wzs code to thc ccammcr
t7
21
coun_
_oin_l
pomtcd
24
OOO55
1
_
whzl they suy hem ts that _zwus gmcruily
13
2S
Cc_ntc
zr,d d'e p_dsc counu_
d_xdosccl
20
wt_ LI_ new
ove_ the N_pon
9
16
_s
was Lhsl thc - d_ar
10
12
cl_clo_
o_ od_cr fc_u:c_
- now the mvcntlon
d_nn_ush_
_
_ui_.to
_vxlch _ g_.cl_lly
of _
o£
zn: _ be
m the _o_uct
the _ra_
or the
It_i_dClo+Cmc
Mzrlm_n
He=r_a8
I0/7._A)5
Pn_e
Marlunau
55
JA 0794
Heal-lag
10/251_
O0O58
0OO57
I
In adthtlon,
2 there's
the
the York
3
m_erpret2tton
4
word
case, at page
bn¢ f, thai
6
that
you're
It's mttmded
7 c farmed
8 _vtsedly
socking
-
m order
would
Well,
II
narrowex_nmallon
12
clc_e
13
prior _,
prior
14
that had
15
should
16
and off
17
to accent
w_
detector
mode
hght
instead
up to full
_ cry close
prior
attorney
would
tt's not just
because
there
addition
21
but _lso
22
out m the marketplace,
23
it and copy
it very reathly
24
uncong_aon
wtth
when you
And
produce
10
a
Ceramic
n prior
In_ entlon
producl.
I
There
claim
w_s gcod
tl narro_
mtght
of this sorl,
that
ts not an accusatKon
Markman
Ilearmg
file
2 flied m '96b which
3
Is the '066
So tn this palent,
17
al tab 41 m your
1_
apphcation
This
o['coursc,
whether
_ as this the _ ay
seen
m Ibe briefs
It's done
kaew
t_o
of a claim
tbe _ay
or nol
that tt s
DESA
the dllTer_nce
apphca_lon
24
the Same
binder
bet_
has argued
ecn
c[atmm_
at issue
"_6, the thvlslonal
This
Ifyou
based
upon
tab -- [
li]c hi_tory
States
patent
patent
_t was
basctJ on the _anle
You can
5 747
Here _t is
is Umt_d
the '066
fook
this is tbe dl_ _slonal
is the patent
th=rtk it w_
25
kmd
fonct_onchtrnsandregt_[o-reh=ms
23
Page
Heath
meansplus
see it relates
937
Agatn
p_ent
back
to the -- it h,,_
the
it's a
ICxt
It relalcd
U S apphcat_on
_
Markman
57
fonctmn
claims,
"means"
they simply
m there
$ motlonsensor
2 that
of using
claimed
means plus function
Then
a ¢onbrol
for c,u_mg
11
the ¢onacctlng
means
12
lt'_ not COntrol
¢lreutt means
That's
Again
T4
mc'mls plus thnctton
15
e_amlnauon.
¢)alm
_ 1_6
sa_d
They
coverage
Now
you _¢t orthnary
I$
Sensmgmotloa
19
settsor ts co_ ered by that cfausc
20
Control
Hearmg
10/25/05
Page
58
th_se things
22
would
Th¢_¢ claims
to the things
and d,ra_ rags of dt¢ patent
25
Patent
attorneys
do things
pull
out the ,_ctu_[ chart since
Th]ststheor*glnal
Of motlor_ sensor
for
Anymolma
dt$¢1os¢_
Hearing
left
16
mc.ms
17
means
hght
I_
means,
me,ms
19
aetuateable
20
mtans
hand
m tbe text
some
24
or hght
tbere's
Page
60
JA 0795
Costco
btadcr
at
be best
to
easy
to
formal
Sensor
means,
sel¢ct_
for ,_utomaltcally
stnlctt_[
language
_en_lng
Nov,
means
control
There's
ovemdc
m_.ans for
m the
f_ont
v, h,_t was going
mcan_
causing
14 of them
no_lc,, have
j_t
o', cnrde
s¢:lectl',¢ly
you'll
otbers
c_rcult
actuatcahle
ac_uateab[¢
deactuatm_
of those
that are m
means,
ely
in
This
elements
actuatgtg
selectively
,rod so forlh
some
T_eseare
m the patents
14 ol'them
sensm_
means
Nov,,
elements
hke
the
swttcfong
ha_ c
means
say me.ms
on ber_. i Why
Markman
59
_sn't very
_un¢llon
It'*el
23
P,_ge
m your
tt _ould
hs_s all the claim
for automatically
to be [inut_
10/_5/05
column
plus
22
25
claim
Andyoucanseethat
15
2L second
way_
this
and
19 clalmelements
]4
112/6
In more
read
seeking
an alternate
so
Ihcy
Th_s isn t
EM[
thts is -- and ptob._bly
Claln_s
It's an ahcraat e _ ay to do II
Markman
9
Whal
the palest
atcnol
In ahcmate
tab 44
nanox',
Others
a_scrted
_ga_n_t
IhtS is a chart th,ll appea_s
13
v, ould not be construed
24
$
tt very
that will _coop
ts not being
this ts not 4
be co_ cred by the clarke
things
Now
because
has asseaed
plus fonctlon
_,ly control circuit that does
-- the specific
DESA
make
on xahthty
products
'937 patent
patent
Some
attack
can _ct
the means
Thal'$$b_¢tt_althnguagc
circuit,
a5 ;hey
any
12
control
This ts simply
mt'anmg
the claims
ln_ngmg
This
the
make
as broad
II
t 6 way to do It
17
potentlllly
10
connccttng
th_s ts the control CffCUlL
a Signal Io the eXmlllner
get
4
7
there
It's straply
3
6
no
Therels
etrcutt for electrically
They
they can stuvt*e
5
system
Nome,ms
a housing
language
plus
_t _s a hghtm$
Meansforconncclmgthclamp
9 some
look
me.u_
fotsensmgmotlon
A lamp
10
3 circuit
[
patenL
fostead
6 comprtstr_gamotlon$¢nsor
7 word
Thepatcntappheallonwa_
tf you look at the claims,
4 wh_t they thd m this one
23
Well
16
is not
10/25/05
) You've
this isj_l
,xtl] pro_ect
O0060
I continuattonofthe'$23
21
doae
hke
0_59
5
that, ','*ell
the circuitry
claims
So there's
this
a question
ak_ays
22
of EM L
there*s
want
shtppmg
the
duphcal¢
AOd they
14
21
of tht$ sorl
mtght
smlply
plus _nct_on
of the clrCUltt)
13
g
that
r¢ _ cry specific
Now
from
and having
means
v, as tfos just a happenstance,
_0
people
the product
to ha_c
12
t9
fo
duplicate
v, hy you
look at
send
It apart
Thts is something
products
ly
be prior axl.
can break
tenons
I_
dark
to pre_ eat
to a m,mufactuter
duphcahOn
11
th;_t jusl p. ent on
_
a product
people
by the way,
want
o;¢r
They
9 a[;alnst
_
bngfo
'._ _
20
might
exammntlon
Thalargument
here
tt's _cry hclpfol
8
I 1 _6
of a thte_ stage
a patent
why
o_
m,ide
the product
[tdoesa'tt_e
h'squltcdl/Tercnt
But In order
7
Nippoa
or Heath's
*sn'l being
6 manufacturer
thcremtghtbcvery
detector
re.on
you
3
did so
a n_'Tow
hght -- their pnot
a mouon
19
25
why
thesa_qlc¢lrcu_try
_ho
under
want
In this ¢3_c
dark to full hnght
So there
you
reasons
w¢]l as D ESA_s
a morton
claims
EAIL'sproduztdoesntcopytheclrcultry
2
5
examtrtatlon
an examination
Foroncthmg,
say. was
18
function
would
are good
_rl. as there
_
clam
[
4
to the
that the person
ph_
Why
¢ cfalm
with the
Io sign31
a 11 _6
to trigger
there
file claims
g's a_sum_J
thai bc_
10
you
mltmded
-- put in the means
and thts is --
I 0 of o_ r rc$ponst_
_ hen
"m _,1s _ m It, that's
5 examiner
9 Why
COLLrL_
ha_ e held,
v, as the palcnt
Ilearmg
10/25/05
00061
OOO62
] aNofncy
putbng some structural
2
Wull,
Orbed')
3 Because
metals
some
of them,
for autornattcally
? ovemde
means,
8 tbeclmrm
9
only bcmg
tefcrred
I_e
number
act_alfftg
to once
They
that long
II
to a claim
never
4 -- the clanrm also include
5 circuit,
actuate
on at. and they
tdcntffy
and say stud and then
element
2, r_d
hght scmmg
ovt_'nde
acmatcable
17
So wtth
18 htde
ulemt fi_
I
later
m the
m from
19
lyamm - zt v, as a clatm
20
later on
21
m the c_m
tier
14 I_e
saul selectively
wherever
thai _
of this number
24
full
The
clmm
they me
that
bcmg
[ mean.
13¢ umcadable
cz_zer IOsay saul
re fcm_
to
THE COURT
2
MR.
3
You
4
a contmuatl_3
Okay,
stmply
COOK
copy
cttctut
&ffctt_cc
between
tLsmg zt dc rtgucw,
means
as DESA
patent
"ongmaP
patent, they n.mmt
Page
filed
+t, jUSl
tt
Whenyousaymtheongmal
lerws
th¢_e
are m the
tht_e
Yes,
you look
apphcatto_$,
I9
1996
apphcatton_
zre the ones that are
at the otaglnal clattm
you
elemcaLs
wdl
of the -
see* thai there's
a
m there
COURT
MR
25
1o claim
I 1.7J6. they named
R_ght,
but the*c
arc not - the*¢
tell me what
means
24
10/25/05
tf tbey wanted
and avoid
COOK
THE
23
mear_
COOK
These
wnth the o_gma]
are
the claims
pattmt apphcatton
that were
hack
Markman
Hearing
the Phdhps
c_sc hasn't
61
conuntmtton,
8
o_sthatwentwJththeongmalpamnt_
9
_
those
ortgmal
10
wholeslntctm'e
II
be wro_
I would
15
made
I
each
ttmc
_
you file
3
a.nd the rule
4
_ptcssed
wrc_
th_
5
fo* dm
for the thv_lon,
but there
ofthL% thaeshow
a_e the
understood
he',vrmett.
7
That*ihow
DESA
Just I_e
before
18
sp¢clfic_t]on,
19
clam_
apphed
to reply
we go
In the drst
of trying
has d_:usscd
been
to a co_le
on wzth
place,
to _
they
TI_ slanac
says
21
text and dra,.vmgs
22
claims
23
clmms
into
of thffercnt
of points
tmmboned
ulemem
not apply
the
in the Sage
before
we get
The
9
Sage,
I0
meat_
In I994
10/25/05
Page
that, into means
plm
#us
plus ftmcttc_,
14
first
16
mgge_
to the
17
Both
I$
funcUon
that
t_ tha ride
Hearing
dram
I 12/6 -- du$
It says thai
dmstep
ts m Lmcar
rr=ny other cas=s
¢lemenl
applies
you hay©
that tnggcr_
to revoke
thai 112/6
and m
- wben
m a claim,
that you intended
10/25/05
Page63
m there
a
I 12/6 and thai I 12/6
if me_,_
hand,
of those
tf you don't have
but you use funcuonal
tbe opposttc
pt¢_tmaptton
presumpbu_
ts m thai
I 12/6
apph¢_
20
rays,
by showm
21
stn]ctttrc
22
ph_
23
m there,
24
pr_umptlon
By
8 that the ula_m
you've
apply
functional
presmr, cd that
nt by showing
includes
to per foem fi*tc imttre reented
-
means
nf there's
thai vail per form that fUnChOn,
as Sage
su fficlcm
function,
language
then
sm2ctm-c
the
t$ ov_come
the same
token,
vf the word
Markman
JA 0796
that
thai I 12/6 doesn't
"tmmns',
but you can tebul
the fmmUon,
the word
language,
m'c rebuttable.
I f you t._c the woed
19
25
Markman
dectst on, and
Thcre*sre_Ilya
ts that
On the o0_'r
sm
the
yes,
case,
ts
- the Sa$_ case
p=e*umplzon
"means"
fimctton
then.
ca_e
to Sage..
in your
I$
flmeuon
to tmpon
changed
the Phllhps
afle_ the Phtlhps
ctrcmt
and it*_ m many,
apph¢*,
before
13 ©lement
by reference
to _
you me suppo_d
not mc_-.s
12
that they
car_nal
$od'talndcdocsn'lapplytomemxsplus
I f it were
_es
dm rest of tt.
the elmm
that does
a numbex
and mterptetedbytftccom_
that Still cxtsta
therc'stwothmgs
8
the
ca_e,
rule thai existed
It was a federal
I 1 p_esm'nptlon
112/6has
17
The
6-well,
Thamanhackm
up, the guy who
Phdhps
2 anything
after apphcatzon
me
The
one*
iL
Now,
14
apphca_on
clmms
_
who
wh_e
I thot_ht
_re the ongu_
m ap_hcatltm
7
25
the
22 are nol tot the -- when you say "original",
or thvtsum
However,
13
whal
these
tha original
6
24
m the
2l
that's a mouth
Ilearing
th_s
Again,
So you see these
20
and quartz
OOO64
I
16
MR
]9
OOO63
12
elements,
I 8 always -- whenever
if you thd that.
control
IVlarkman
5
$pecnfically
20 hm':ch ofclmm
circuit7
detector
arc clrCUttS
THECOURT
clatmed
17
it was a
way to do tt so you do not hay©
would
It's much
weren't
they did in the '937
15
or ¢lse'_vhere
2. control
knew
They
So when they had a name,
] 3 something
that ertttr© long - what t f they had to repeat ul]
23
25
12
16
elemera
It's a convcmcnt
22 to repeal
Identt
of the word "meara",
detect
zero creasing
argued for any ttme there was any kind o f cnrcmtry
I I eot_paralor,
iddmtt fief
mea_
o_Zy one exception,
lamp
u.smg
Here's the o_gn_J
10 Two of these, the zero cross m_d detect ClrCmt and the
smdcontlolctrcmlmear_,m
means,
and rtol
passive mfrared
plaanly
plus fun£tton
9 It_
about
between
lamp
So they
8
at by the shoaband
14 Situisensormear_,numb_
16
6 halogen
7
Wberetheydogobackandrc(trtoall-
later m the -- to a clmm
compafator,
talking
the thfference
language
label m (toni
said rc_ccuvety
ha_ e Io go back
knov. s v. hat you're
they also k_ew
3 mea_s plus funct.on
that appearJ; - that clause appears once m
phrase
Now,
$, fc* example,
12 same claim Or otbet claJrra, they put a shmlhand
15 number
m
Theync_erhavetot'eferhacktod.
i0
13
I and evcrybedy
2
they thdffl I put any Sho*lh_d
There's
6
m some and not m
theamwcttothaltsprettyobvlous
m the on¢_ that were
4 the clmm_,
5
language
"means"
Hearing
tsn't in
10/25/05
Page64
62
OO365
I the cl_um so fl_ _
clarm Ispreened
2 by 112/6, you can sallha_e l_comtnled
3 you _onsu_¢
OOO66
I d_smcl
no[ [o be governed
und_
l 12/6 If
thalthe langoagc of the claLraispurely
4 t'unctlonal
court decision
a - the
And
thews the language thatMr
6 moughlofPhllhp_
? Ic_kmg
aL_¢
In the Phdhp_
3
me gel
the ac_u_J ]ang_g¢
here,
4
clrcln_
means
energy
6
TcasoP-s
7
to apply
--Ym
sor_', bam¢,
we're
9
9 s_s not rne_u_ plus function ]_.guag¢_ so w e'reoo[ going
u_c
II i[mLo -- d_,y _n'outed
cer_n
things to th¢ barnes,
12 _
would
hevc io be p_rely
15
fLmc0ona] to lake a clause hhe thal,baltic,_d
mlo a I12/6 thing, ¢I_r_
And
B_
smcc itIsn't,
then it_
18 means langu_e,
and _c_¢
cl2_rns,those - the c_s_
t9 apply to the othe_ s_dc of (he pres_np_ion
20
apphcabl¢ here
21
And
112/6
there
_as
s four
IS overcome
in th_s case
_0 say
And
We
thai ctrcm[
the
r¢o.son we're
iLsel fspcc_fics
clrcu_L
][ was
Thee
_hc_c
arc nol going
means
W¢'_e
Io apply
for rcco_d0ng
gomg
going
_L
cnccgy
ctrc_utry
t_
In a r¢laled
16
s_d
17
imma_mal
a Iocal_on
for _he
in a housing
in the paient
a_cncc
There's
co-pending
tha( this
to say Lh_t is hecaus¢
-- specified
was a complete
]4
18
tha!
of any
means
co_cspon&ng
no showing
apphcaiIon,
c_rcmt
of clrcu_[_,
the pa[cn[
for recording
sm_ply _e
no¢
had no co_equ_mcc
And
finally
19
h:s[o_'
20
i[ Io bc cov¢=¢d
he stud
con[amcd
21
e_ am_n¢_
energy
was
So this
_o it, v, asn [ imporlant
thal the
no cs'lde1_c¢
prosccullon
tha_ the
file
app[_canL_
intended
by _ 1256
case
is _ along
'_th
Magnc-Tck,
c_e,
hot those
who
CelINeL
The
then
that'sthe bulk of the decagons th_ Mt
H_gg_ns _srdymg
23 Apex
-- there
use
that'son the other slde of the p_esumptlon
I? Thai's on - we're on one slde of the s[r¢_ _hc=e th_e'$
22
Yo_ r Honor
s._ld, we]l
the presLonp_lon
going
13
turn 11
nora I12/6
16
_by
I I th© claim
12
14
the dlSO_Ct corn1
based
- let
is no; 112/6
10
I0 - Itwould ha_ ¢ to he purely funcilonalm ocdcr to
13
for recording
112/6
thai the _ord
case the_ _e
pht_e baffle means
_ ©n, _
thai thc_'¢ _,c_c -
H iggms re._dyou
8 and the corn1 looked al thaland s_d thaiisstruc_ml,
they _d,
to appl_,
upon
And
5
fact
thai decided
2
upon- He rehes upon the Apex
was n_¢ a m _r_s c_se. _p4fon
w_
c_e,
22
apphed
anoth_
23
Magne-Tck
24
from
thsO_ct
simply
courl
appll_l
d¢c_slo_s
C¢IINc;
--
case v,_s
opposile [ooo_
_
Nor_acrn
D_stnct
of C_h fom_a
24 case
25
Lme_,
the same thing CellNe_. CellNct w_s a
Marknmn
O0067
! stud
_.t
2_
he w_s not going
2
mstcadhea_phcdSage
3
feder_cm:_tro_¢
4
a foc.g_o_
fo_ a piece
5
L_'ft surf|c1
enL
6
cm:mt
Hearing
to apply
10/25/05
the CelIN_
Page
_
-
m a I_cr case,
0O068
I that we
2 and
II'sthe
-- _¢_¢
appear
11's a sampling
3
He&dn'lstmplysaysmccth_rcwas
m Mr
of cas_
?
So he re fo.sad
m the
cRum,
_o not apply
BUl on the [eR
Thc_z_s
By the gam¢
t ok ¢'a, Nedson
thlT_L)udg¢
took
9
(hat's m Magm-Tcch,
paint
expcrl
66
slat¢.'mcnt,
subjecl
hand s_d¢ here,
Th_¢
we've
are
shown
racaas
all v, hercth¢
! 12/6 to a
5
prcsm,npt_on
_s that
I 12/6 apphes
6
mclude_
word
mcaz_"
7
slaLcrncoL
the
heca_s¢
followed
the claim
by
cfomen_
a fonc_lonal
_ s. MoLorota.
a
a look
at the sa_mc claim
same
palent,
same
BUt on thL_ Sty,
the
COU_ fOUnd tha|
thcr_
Was
clement
plam1_ if, sarac
9
m.Sufllcl_'at
10
On--
_g'Iore
m c_ c_y CaSe
held¢*
| I
13
Page
10/2S/05
P/,p¢ clama
I0
12
Brcy_
[ha[
$
$
-- Judge
Hearing
on the
4--th¢_caxeallmca_sc_scs
of $o.dctm¢
the
Markman
65
r_onal_
Sage_sbcltc_law
A ed
And
¢arhcr
he thdn't
holding,
sense,
becaas¢
it can't
14
ra_onale
[_
for a c_:mt,
16
follow
Magne-Tck
he stud
go along
_
the
with
somehow
jo_[
holding,
it just dc_-_'t
thai
idea.
heca_s¢
the
the
make
a focat
to_
17
was
18
thc_e'samynadofctrcuJLs
a _chmcal
19
docsa't
he sa_d [ -
¢ngm¢_
MR
13
¢v¢_t
14
I 1736 apphed
L_
Lh_t 0rat'S safllc_enL
What he sa_L
THE COURT
12
I'm a techmcZJ
dining
guy, 1
the sca'vlc¢,
and
I know
cas_
But
16
_al_s
17
vc_
19
21
tonal
22
aclually
23
,sa'!
ctrcml
- whal
Now,
24
whcth_-
25
cnlzr¢
suf_ficlcnl
these
on 0_ts side,
s[roc0_¢
ca,sos
a_¢ on the
and the way
&ffcrcnt
flora
claoses
in_ufflclvat
in
arnoan[
o f s_n_clm¢
thai iI's I_d
oul _s very,
the sensor
In the c]am_
$_zuc[Lrre
means
|hal
and
con_ol
we're talking
So
clrcm_
about.
Lqn't sufficlcnl
kind
or no! there
Anti
wc ate
prmctpally
mc_s
claim
ha]king
about.
Your
Honor,
lCsa,ev/gencncte_m
- JUSt s_ymg
there's
function,
_'ba_ -
That's
youslmplyc_.n't--tl
say an,/,,hmg,
So _
And
in thee,
I g means
20
And
COOK
any
C¢11N¢1
you m_al[io¢_
I|
the
thai
Loc'r¢_¢,
or a ctrcoat
- the
you
declsto_
Ls sumcl¢.n[
:s illustralCd
thcrCs
by
Markman
fo show
sensor
21
_]¢mcnl
22
this
clement
and
the conool
cwcml
claim
how
Thosearcth¢_hatma_ethcdlffcrcncem
you
case
use
-- the S_gc
sox_¢tar¢
the
a
ac1_lly
a couple
20
23
n_e
to p_'fol"m
24
the
_5
o f ¢_np[e_
Hearing
10/25/05
Page
So those
focusing
arc
the ones
on for the mos(
Here,
Ig'rfora1_on
thal we're
means
Cxtenthng
Markman
67
JA 0797
going
to he
pa_
fr°m
Heanng
the leg
10/25/05
Page68
00369
OOO70
I 111.5 ts a claim
2
And
3
pants
4
film,
for teaming
It w_
Then
- the diaper
II had a plasltc
a s_el
5
pants
for a cbid.
had a cloth
coating
per forauon
7
waistband
9
mea._
theperfora0o_
II
know
Io the ouler
IX:flotations
14
ll_l
15
the plasllC
ch:ld
17
It do¢_*l
I$
c_cular
_y
it Lr..
They're
or _x_l,
and that Is su ffic_c_t!
23
r craov mg the Irammg
7
structm-e,
9 logcther,
band f,o
te_
diapeT
are
off
off
or
andyoueanseethalstn_tm'e
ex_tly
Now
the leg
Maf,._ngdl
He'$
V_ade_b:lL
AndDr
$
the ¢lmm clcm¢_
bncfm
[he ftn'lc Uon of
the case of an ace:deaL
wll} allow
iI to tear away,
tle=nng
open the door
that su-¢tched on
10125/05
Page
and thc_
14 that I]cx_
the door opens
when
it would
thai function,
pull
8 piece of metal
and pulls _1back together
You don'l know what kind of a _pnng
ts being used
Io keep the door shuL
tsn't t'nough
SO
dcsertpllon
you don'l know ._ hal str.Jct_¢
cal]ad OUl Io perform
thai sln_cture,
to
_s
they apply
112/6
21
YoucanenvlslOnlt,
fc¢ pet focrall'_
This
ts a class:c funcl:onal
Tnzs. the tr_anmg
claim that I 12/6 has
22
governed.
23
'_ here th_e's
24
word there m thc means was szmply
25
wefe_*[ trying
s_uclure,
pants, es a classic exarnp]e
they wall dec:de
to _rtgg_
happenstance,
Markman
of
thai the - the
a I 12J6 examination
69
1 claims -
the prof..,or
Uoyd
[,hat they
because the
Ilearlng
10/25/05
ofele_mcal
at t_m:
In his - m yore
7 i_ow
thai
m tl_
ilm3der -
at
3 tha[=nthls
wd] be ¢efe_'ed
you here and ¢kcca_
5
m'e things
IO = Iol - at ta_
them
4g, 49,
And
l*ll show
them
12
senso*
13
exlcraal
14
ca_,
g]vm
_
(o
each
claim
9 sony,
to the appmatu_,
v, e have
g3vcn
Wc I_,ve _lven
16
A ad th_n we've
17
t_ m - as = code,
18
thn
clement,
m IlnS c_e
a _med
one
:l a reference
name,
oul LI_ ='ntrr_
_s a key,
II
Page
70
m this
1o whal
"slm._l"
mea_"
cI,a_.L_ Ix:re, and
we're
laying
16
clan'a
und_lmed
20 bolded the mea_
all the
not m this
24
pei'form
sln_tural
lang..m_¢
We I_v¢
19
and then we b*w¢ I_1 m
20
laflguase
up the Sage
c,.'k_es_
the enure
the
for la_ua_e,
fimeuona_
So that se_
23
I'tm¢0or_
DESA's
M_
cxpe_
CaHson
opmad
Senso_ _cs
str_ctu_e
Sensor and sensor means both
on that basis, he s_d
performs
ftmcUort,
thai I 12/6 should not bc
tcst
TheteSltswhetheror
- =s suffic:c_[
nol whether
to p_form
the s[ru_
the
]angua_ _
cortnote_ s0xtcture
hnc o f ci_pulc
IYagomgtodisc_ssth_s
betwec_
the
mg_ealerdet_l
18 because lt*s v e_y nnpot'lanl
We've
lla]l_
C_rlson,
on th_s subject,
connoted
Thxs ts a sharp
17 p_ues
about
beCaLtSe there's
the stated func0on
we took Mr
He used the wror_
n:clled
I _ stmply
Ilu.s
_o-
claims m
concl_mn
$otucrm'¢
13 nOl the l;tructure
14 t'ntuc
Ma._engdl's
thai st'r tso)" and s on.sot me.arks are both _ I'm
And
12 applied.
lel1_r A
it a shor t_md
SpeIlcd
II*_
Dr
Io perform
who opmad
cormoles
10 connole
condition
of the key phrases
also _hcn
Carlson,
8 ftmctlon,
vt:ry I_efly
fo_ _
struclure
7 [hat the sen.sot _
50 and
Tab 45, thiststhe m,_l_ claJm ch,_[. Onthe
] I left. we've
And
6 Mr
finally
ca3e llTJ6apph_ssmce
4 msu fficlenl
case.
8 51 irethesm'ttm_esofh_op,mons
[0
en_nee_lng
and these
where th_s clause _tppcars in the claims,
2 9, l0 and I I, and then
M_._en_n]lh_apphedtheSagend©to
6
25
iI pulls :1 back
I grt-w up, we had a
II mlgh[ be a leafspnn
20
to the
EMLhas_tamedlhese_tc_ofDr
4
2Z
$o you woald
18 pexform
Tharsdiekmdofstmclm¢
3
2l
what kind
OOO72
2
19
m_ghl be h'k© a -- where
17 becatts_ you don*t, b_c au.se the©
I
I$
a_¢
_hat
have a spring thai rOlales on the axis so
16 Io keep the door -- to at[_mp[
I £1n_ tta'e t_ ', cry de fimte.
9
necessarily
13 tt back Iogalhc_
15
mangular
I_II you
t-,reran 8 from
-- per thmUons
You can'l envision
10 screen doo_. and we had the cod spnng
the per foratlorls
bul tt does
andsodia_tsstnmlure
to keep the door closed, they
warned to kccp a door closed.
spnng'_
'You might
12
you ¢_m s:mply
Markman
00O7
for
19 being
ways,
ffyou
$ thai when you open th_ door on the hinge,
to the leg
Ix:rtor_or_
per fomt, c,_
22
_
me'a_
and xt has
the _ aJs[hand
these
on thts s=de, you can see the word
I I the door out here
see the struclure,
21
-- ov_
6 of a spring they have m mind.
You
and talc© the cl_ld's
whether
m la_¢
19 wbal
25
you can See the
ofpl_l=c
from
p_l
yoo can
20
24
layo
1o the
case of L,I accident.
has an accident,
outer
Bul
me:ms
is b_IL
got a piece
atoning
if I_
5 klnd ofa
the le 8 band
and pea'aerie
bnefm
how th_
You've
13
There's
3 spnng means pr et ending
here r,aJd
from
Youcaneav_lonthcpeffofatJon
¢_aady
16
exlendmg
you can see -- here
10
12
a
4 the kind of-
th© i_aamng
$o
2
of plat:c.
means
8 remo_ng
I that's ncccssa_
pa:r of di_4_
on the ou_lde,
And so the l:tntciura/lang_e
6
diaper
t$ - h_
21 didn't
mqmry
enough
as Io whether
stnu_tm-e
ftmcu ot'l of the ttahctzed
Tlum m the aexl
coluran
Thc_
und_
we've
Markman
or
Ilearlng
where
ga_e
there ts no qu_on
changad
They didn'l
this o_
w_L
They
begin Io ovcrntlc
with Sas_
Sage
They simply
apphed
23 a rule m thai c.&sc But the case was dcvo[©d to other
24 issues,
the
10/25/05
overrule
h_n't
22 They wc_entl even concerned
m ii to
secuotl
f.hown
ShoLdd be no que_zon,
the law, Phdhps
25
Page
71
not to this issue.
"DIE COURT
WCTe all the_C Amtco.s m _
Markman
JA 0798
Hearing
10/25/05
Page
72
OOO74
00073
I because
2
they weTe
thai they oughl
scrod it to the _¢1
4
Is a_t
5
The
6 &dn't
d_$em
I'm glad
9
ctrcmt
l0
has
COOK
And
13
deference
court dectslon
pleased
cv_
thai?
_
they
qucsuon
m the (_
patent
in frmgcment
case
n's a questlon
of law,
40
percem,
apparently
COOK
Ig
the • mous
19
And
panels
20
think ii bad been
21
Texas
22
thai ended
probably
Law
up vnth
the mc_t
- the original
up wlth
some
&ffcaem
a;vroaches
permctous,
because
_,
that w_
unfortunate
said
tl IO the extent
of law
And
they
two things,
GnezsthatTexasD,gnalsmd.
wefi,
th_
Markman
hnc
of
6
are not -- unk:ss
7
he defined
the lerm
8
thctlonary
and ha didn't use thai
9
thcuonary
definmon
12
c_es,
13
definitions
nuschlef
16
we v,¢ten't
17
dcfinztlons
IS
think
2 shatdd
w ay Io do th and _
bc a speclf'm
3
Some
4 DtDta]
5 you
Hearing
10/25/05
Page
THE
20
te_ few should
21
something,
sazd..,,ell,
know,
de that, you start
the chmr_,
$
1_
9
you would
con fusing,
_t"the
th+s one
and
that we
:t led
hn¢
of
to a lot of
In the p_or
should
app)y
$alected
bt3¢fings
malupl¢
a deflnlt_on
that v*e
by the specification
CODRT
Wcte
not _
the
Amlcm
a helle
MR
23
t_ymg
24
were
25
Wanted
de novo _ Suxdy
a_gumg
mote
COOK
to get nd
than
that the
about
roguing
Butprmclpallythey_ere
was
the
for
that
- there
as to _ hat
to hear
v,_¢
Some
of the
expressed
they
sc_ oral
they wanted
issues
thai
to i_a_
use of thCllonanes,
Markman
_r not thc_c
-
out of Tex_
w_th a dlcuona_,
they
overoAed
and then,
_
at the spcclficat_o_
techmcal
phrase,
ycu
Icok
If there's
I_e
at
-- tf
ZeTO c_mag
I
dclm_ttlon
and
2
are pteny
mu_h
3
clazm
4
the vectted
_nd
they
the
Ilearmg
Page74
10/25/05
demct.
and Hill and look
Then
I f tt's a gcner_
that.
13
then you
term I_e
THE COURT
14
MR
Sage
hne
16
to pofotm
up
dra_ rags at the
8
and
a furthe*
on the board_
next tab.
be addxessmg
_thx
B
There's
and
a sen¢_
l'll put one
of th¢_e
tab 49, and we have
them
during
But tha*e are - we have
them
blown
up
the trial
km_
of things
definmon
of what¢
taken
m the patent
M r Cadson's
I ! particular
Chain element
12
And
you
13
PIRs hoe.
14
and whal
15
thol this
16
upples
!7
of words,
he sa_s
that thts
appears
tememhot
And
dravangs
Mr
so we've
Htggmssa_&v.ell,#sjust
drawn
what
Mr
Carlson
says
m blue
Okay
COOK
Thare'_: been
2005)
thai was
18
lescalledB¢ck._mMarme
Butthalhoeoflav.
a case
deeded
- there's
afi_
remarry-the
upptopna_e
ume-
But the
21
that Sage
tcmams
the law
So th_s m,_ter
s_u'm'nan2¢$
24
fo_cuon
25
has a_
at July 2g,
and zt applted
les2005US
20
23
case
Flulhps,
We'll get Yore- H_tor
22
o¢ somethm8
general
Stracture
Mr
Ma_cngdL
ts a place
Professor
now "._h_e
Masscngtlt.
we can
m red so
talk about
uppl_
and
We a_e not just
ttmng
a lot
rmt_
17
_5629
s¢_of
look al more
su ffielent
on that poml
say that thee
and see v, hat it
ts
hke
th¢*e's
7
l0
II
Carlson
Both of thcm
don*I co#2an
of these
weql
M_seng11D_IM)
m agreement
functton
6
9
go to Hc_wt_2
Mr
elements
5
stud you d_'l
v*hcr¢_ ¢_ tes uppropnam,
look
a htghly
v, heth_
that grew
you start
that regime
7
19
a
fou_ ot fi_ • dl ffercnt
We ha_ e each
19
disclaimed
D+gltal,
in this case
73
rufo
of the declstons
6
15
yew
atgtung
If
the
or a thscla_m_,
Tex_
apply
And nobody
that
Iexlcograpby,
or +fhc
lexicography
just
IS supported
used
f and n _ as dlffc_ cm than
trader
that w_
15
attome:_
DJgllal
de fimDom
00076
I upvmpc_te
12
from
But Texas
all dicuonary
fomsel
-- then
you could
And
apply
the patent
But aside
dictionaries
youcan_¢
00075
10
-- and change
said,
22
re_mha
it nght
- for
a hn¢
COOK
you can
with
I
declst ct3 m a case called
and _ubscquc_t
And thts Pfolhps
o, cr_ded
Sowhaltheydedurmg--
come
the - rll say
Dtgl_l
23
Right.
have
_lR
well,
can start
ycah
5
14
them
You
IS starting,
I 1 - you could
and the
Thayrcvlew)twtthout
And rc',e_e
COURT
the problem
10
m zl_
in cla_m inteTp_etanffA
MR
THE
3
4
has huppcned
t_w
THE COLrRT
17
25
2
Sothcye,;._-ntlaJlysecondgue_s_e_'ydtsmct
15
24
I dictionaries-
dcctd©
and then
that s an excellent
What
tssue
fedcralcucmltrc_ltdeno_o
16
w-_n't
fo_ that rc2son
12
14
c(mstructlon
for the m fnngement
No,
)t
Markman,
a Markma_
II
v. oald
that, but --
you asked
since
cffcult
_ ¢_¢ argmng?
certainly
up with
MR
8
eoml._
alI the Amlcus
come
7
the federal
to do all the cham
3
wSal
hoping
clann
the cform
eta_m al_,
that thcyc
a copy
m_ortant
App,
ofth_s
thing
Sage
18
L_ts
at the
Iorec_gmz_
mt_T,retatl
or ts o f the
and tl exphap.s
tsn*t s_ffictem
Markman
th_s
w_¢ans ph_
whale
structure
Hearing
Mr
Carlson
m h_
10/25/05
Page
we
and
oranges
can actually
see what
So we hay© prepared
19
way
20
argmng
21
cha_t thor's m tab 48,
not apples
ehaxmm
Thon
thts we think
by elemtmt
at A_x
22
yaur
bmder,
v.e'v¢
23
now
for each
24
the pater,
25
o_t*ht_matclmm
Io show
lot example,
10
gone
clatm
scr_ot
JA 0799
ts a _ oT
ts tha next tab
thrvugh
elements,
m_ans
handy
50,
the patcn_
6
m
And
_ c'_ e shown
Clmm
are
_ hare
L_'s
In
look
There
Markman
75
apph_
v, hal the two parht_
C, whtch
actually
of thc*e
ctrcmt
Ilearlng
10/25105
Page
76
OOO77
OOO78
I
So here's the dlawmg
2 means
for claim element A, sensor
llappca_,nCl_n_s9,10andll
I differentiation,
Andh_c'swhcTe
2
counlm8
and DESA
_s expressly
3 thal el¢_c'nlappears in the claJm itself So thlstab,you
3
corttrol ¢l_rcutt mearks
4 can '_cf_to 11to see 'Ahcze elemt-nl A aclua]]yf_Lsmlo
4
cn'cml
5 the chains
5
wsctled
claim
6 because
,I has
6
And
then finally,
we
ha_ e masked
7 pntcn! drawings in Appendix
8 Mr
D
up the tr_Xl
of the
And hcrc we've shown
means
8
9
I0
10
circuit
II thal tha textthalapphc_; to the scnsoz Citroen1'sensor
II
atlon_-y
12 mc_'ts,tssimply th_ small sccuon here. and Profes_r
12 read
manual
Carlson m blue, says
they
clatrn heheved
This
was the
view,
_e task of
I$
II'S a mistake
by sm'_ply w/rag Io
thls_ simple as p_slble
17 ere'ateone documenl
18
An_
16
M_scngHI
17
that tl ts a rmst2ke
explmn,
m_d CO.leo _e c.or_tceed th_l
18
For one
t_ung,
19
I tsn'l _sScrlnd,
20
language m the - to
20
Se]_ov
me2n$
- t_1
21
contro}
clrcml
inem_,
22
ore/ride
in ii
21 thasc chain clcmcms
In om
_ew,
i_ open and shul th_ 112/6 apphe_
23 Soweo_tlyhaveoncdcfinmon
24
We
Theyare
_Cn'l u.slngorchna._ meaning
25
Now,
112/6defimaoRs
23
d_.fmJt_ons
U'_re'shahn an ,ssucof clalm
Markman
llearlng
10/25/05
Page
this
w_6n'l
the paten1
appllca_on_
hear
chain
the
This
the
He
claim
you gel
25
mcludesapasstvemfr_cddeleClOf
3 znd 4. Claim
type of claim,
iI has
s_r_or
a lamp,
ml_ans,
$1ructure,
II has rn_nu2]
to Clam
3. and it says,
down
apparalus
why we arc con_ raced
look at Clam
f,arn¢
And
- Profe_so_
undersumd
and second
acctndmg
conl_ol
in Chicago,
the same
24
to Chain
I whcrcm
a
an
sa_d set.or
means
Tha_saPIR
Markman
That's
Ilearing
10/25/05
Page
OOO80
QI,Q2
2
3
bol I_
But then
you
77
0O079
I _
prepared
nol
S_mplyam_stske
tf you
Weha_cn'igone
22
does
was parl ofth©
m this
you wdl
19 112/6apphestothcsecla_melemems
through and apphed ordinary mcm_mg
asserted
hML
tt m_d made a mls[ake
cotmtmg
that once
the relao,,
e ts_m_ at,
e sol out.
wh_¢
o f course, EML
He pul pulse
wrote
mEsrcad
w_noloneoftheongm:Jcl_ms
who
counting
who ongm_d]y
IL In ou?
13
16 dccldmg
lsn I an
m i1, which
attorney
14
here and up to here.
Io nmkc
control
This
]2 is n_l hemg
-- the a11orney
th21 pulse
13 M _._scnglll
says. no, in rc_ the larg_ box, goes aJlthe
So th_s- ag_on, we'sc Uymg
claim
since pulse
12 under the
it says.
coUnllng
o_ erode
14 ",laydown
15
e]cmcnl_
pulse
Of course,
Bul there,
9 "_artottsclaim elements appeal In the [cxL
theTeyou r..un
see Mr
claim
includes
[hal, well,
ore. m Clatm
7 use
where
Carlson and I_'ofes_or Mas_cn8111 have said It_lthese
And
has a_gucd
called
I
NOW,
DF..SA say'_thaithe scztso_roc_ns tsOle PIR
II ts _c PIR
4
EML
says
ehal the scn._or
mr_ns
5 'D_ red box here thai Prof_or
6 th_ clrcmoy
7
mclud_
This Cl_m
9 aPIR
ltdocs_'trayasensorm_t_aPIR.
And it says d_
the d_ffe_e.ace7
II
_
m the sen_of
12
Thafs
v, ha_ the ongma._
13 _1
apphea_on
14
Now,
was
16
tsaPIR?
No
I7
o_'lgma]
cl2ffns.
It says
thai it con_ls_
_m _
et a _
20
_nclndesaqu,_'1_h_osenlarn
21
mclud_
4 says
use
23
allofr*ey
_
24
and not slmply
25
clfcml.
atlorney
ofa
wh_chv,
th_
12.rnp
p
statentenl
8
out m_o c_
9
for Pi'_.s
look _
And you
whal
14
hlt_e top hat
15
Each
advisedly
zaalsomthe
16
h plugs
I, whcrcm
18
What
It doefn'l
say the lamp
19
doesn'l
20
ra_o_
that the PIR was
of -
pal_l
part of the ser6-or _ngs
and _ol parl of the control
23
mfr_
Ilearmg
107"25/05
Page
79
has done,
ts gone
of product
have
tob58
a PIR.
you thts
_ochm_
Icnn_nals
_r© al t_
Youwlnseethal
the PIP. is this
He_gs
f_r _
beard.
- if you'll
a PIR, th_s
coming
mot_o_
elccmc_J
OUl the bottom
elrctut
II's snnply
c.banges
beard
a compcnent
In mfrated
radiation.
II
It dctcctschangesmmfrared
-- iI g_v_
off signal,
and back to zero whc_evcr
tt flops
there
ts a change
of
ra_o_
_
tha_ slgr_l
c_rCml?ythatwes¢¢h_c
Is procesaed
QI
by add_uonaJ
endQ2ar©PIRs.
Markman
JA 0800
EML
examp]_
Is a PIR
thai mgnal
fogh and low
25
Markman
Then
22
24
you
I'II _how
ts it dele_U;
detect
They
The concle_
anything.
whal
Yeah,
into a circmt
i! does
this means
dclector_
It'S a r.o_!
17
to Claun
The ongmal
done.
with II_¢e
of these
experl
well.
win find that m -- and thee
whc_¢
th_ _
pLR, or tha_ st
llsaysll_.3sa.','s
_n'! worth
wc have
and motion
uniformly
C],_mn 4
1hat.
and found
13
m_lnde_,
hc_nng
skill m the
fo_ saying
of th.al sort
So what
21
the lerrrt_
a b_s_
12
_
pun
6
can'l
to have
58and59-j_Itab58
de'pc_deml
according
halog_
have
II
this
from
m and say,
just puII tha_ out of thin a_-
Thay
5
10
this
courts
that come
4
Ihe_ jt_'l a FIR.
v*ho wre_e
cautlon_
of _na_
that there,s
how he mmrprcled
I_15 ss,/_'_ved
stud
They
palent
ehafi
cha'nenl
LookmCImm4,
19
22
It suggests
claim
Ihe taw
by Ik's3ons
3 lh_s to a pe_on
7
the sensor me'arts includes
he J_l uml_g th_ fontal
- &d he rcolb/mean
ha'rip
_
-
I$
18
aroend
this
cham_
Whaf_
the plY.
has drawn
3 was p_'purcd - tinsw_s m the
S _gmal
10
mclnd_
Masscngtll
Now,
2 tesumony
Ilearmg
Theyan:
10/25/05
Page80
78
OOO82
00081
1
2
th¢6¢ httle
a change
3
top hats
ofmfrarod
Then
sagnal
that mnphfit_
5
holds
it
6
clix_t
9
It won't
blocks,
Then
allow
there's
dns
and
the signal
there's
next block
4
dayhmc
wmdow
nght
here,
iI arbor
goes
Mgh
or low
l0
II
h wxll _ther
12
de ferghng
13
you
14
-. this ts whan
on whathet
havc
15
tfs a no, t f this
17
pn_dnced
Ig
tam op
19
21
tt and
mouon
"l_ts tS then
what's
m m frmed
io - then
vers_
a h_gh
Youcansecthethfft'reace
ofthemouondetecuon,
docsn*t mema mogon
mc41on
out here,
And
this
ctrcmL
out m a way
it's been
that ts easy
had
they
an mvtmtton
had
If
IS
andoff
here
16
threshold
18
for a small
19
off
procegs
fonge_
fo* an
Hearing
10/25/05
Page
you
if there's
fltckermg
_ ohagc
Is _ here
you
I, 2
turn
This
It'stv,
portion
is
ol_.cl
25
hght
vohag¢,
fhckers
on and
off.
can se_ _t fllck_
and
off
1_. el. then
of th_s on/off
ffthc
it will
cycle
on
Ix: on
only
II "._dl be off.
off, on/off
dmang
this
hghL
vohag¢
one
So If it's off.
bnght_
threshoM
lamp
and on
.s at one
But *f the thrt_bold
24
a low
This
can s¢¢ it or anyc_c
_ oltag¢
off,
22
out, it's been
dn
But m the
17
TbestgmJthat
cd that means
they
than
_ ohag¢,
on. on.
creates
is a th fferent
on/offcycie
that is produced
it v, fll stay
on, on,
a bnghler
on
off
light
in response
on a lot
that's a
That's
the bright
to detection
Markman
gl
of moUon
Heanng
m
10/25/o5
Page
82
00084
1 this !_tcat
2
If it's off. off,
3
the
4
moUtm
low
5
accent
7 control
the
moran
etrcmt_"
9 commt'_t
II
mdepondent
12
dnpendnat
could
Before
Your
on all
the time
when
ha sho_
m_
18
d_olc.e
hgbung
format,
pomts
just
gomg
to
Mr
Htggms
meauonnd
why
do you
these
could
ha_ ¢ ha'¢n
they
wt*m'L
to the palenl
beta
aRomey
Clam
I and
as m Claim
_bo
deew
the m:xt
I but add
one
The
v, lth _t
clazms.
- bot ©ach oftbes¢
20
clatmtsanegaavenght
21
practice
22
dOn'l tmderstar_
23
they foeget
24
don't
_hafs
dns,
pul om m
clalmnd.
Tkts
Ande,
cnal'ter
but a patcat
else
-
v, hat you
may
have
have
Markman
my product
4
negative
a patent,
pr_ent
somebody
7
myS¢l f wtth0ul
g
use to pr_
em
9
damages
SO that's
II
you
want
12
thffercnt
using
m fnngmg
also
d_dn'l
of
17
that's the
]8
Oh,
20
Htggms
2I
than
patent
and
owner
the
ts m fnngmg
get damages
on thxs, then
tL I may
somel_dy
somebody
on
Ifs a
else
to tL_e it
elSe'S but my clam
from
dnmg
I can
It, mj Ltt_ tlO_ or
right
the negatwe
you
I can
not be able
ha_ ¢ muMple
to -- a th ffenmt
c[atrns,
scopo
ts because
of clarms_
areclmmnd
fcamr_
You
-
22
a dam
to be able
wdlixmvahd
you
ha'.¢
flora
So that's why
16
a lo_ of p_pte
ill
6
so_mg
the
somebody
nght
It's to gay
19
tl g_
and say
and get an mjmaetton
will co_ cr the
featu*cs,
do_.
mto cotl_
15
have
a _t
have
3
patent
offlcc
theyhav¢unde*stoodll,
if you
the
to come
14
could
- most
ts somcthmg
nght
13
iL It
It's a matl_
ts -
But whal
2
I0
fore
hdn_n'tg_eyouthenghtto
to pracuc¢
Somebody
clam_
mentioned
have
thfferent
m dn this m a - m alhndependem
of th_'m
get
of more
Honor
an apparatus
17
I'm just
I
5
So igs lad
at the top and
I close,
¢lmrrgs, and
clam
have
16
19
keep
that's
al the bottom.
11 was up
been
then
m a nutshell
detection
On a couple
When
13
on off.
that you
the ca'cat
All nght.
!0
off.
hghtmg
$o that's
8
off.
tsn'l detect¢O_
6 out with
25
or mtereslmg
faSler
O0O83
15
What
21
Markman
This
this
14
on, _ Ice
to tmdevstmxl
is 1o81c
to ha_ e thr_bold
here,
It will turn on this lamp
Sotluststhaprocess
once
the
da)um¢
ts sort
thoughl
down
13
23
24
14
they
20
nghther_
23
why
This
the
th=s lamp
And
12
bark
It rams
lO
finally
for here
ii offdunng
thaL
the
th ca tlus _ o_tlth'r t
voltage,
then
on tha lamp
except
dunng
going
(tom
aria
lamp
tathauon
z¢:ro voltage,
And
9
_e
I_¢omes
out htT¢
m mfrared
or 3. tha r_ultanl
layer
you
rathatton
that
on the
is the ne,I
7
shut
do anythmg
v, hether
this is the mot.ca
spot
I I hghtmg
_oRage
-
I f a prodnr_
lad
or z_ro
useM to tan
vo}tagc,
22
25
and
L_ detected
change
a fow
vohage
the change
magsageO
16
20
be a hlghat
This
decides
up here
thai _ll
It won't
6
$
At
becausc
it's alI m one
ts the photocell
5
the
fmallyendsoppuls¢comtL
no,
clrcmh
Sis
mto
of filtenng,
engmeer
2 detecUon
3
thta_ this
to ¢scapo
} el¢cmcal
off a
gives
dov, n
an amphficatmn
¢omparato¢,andthcntt
this pomt,
when
detector
it somewhat
m_ttl tt kxrtd of calms
7
a signal
rathatlon
th¢_¢ ad,tmona]
4
$
And It's given
worry
know
aboul
about,
prior
prior
a_t that the patent
that roayb¢
or_
art that you didn't
of th¢_¢ ¢lamx$
know
Soyoustfllhavethr¢¢lcft
about
and
fl
So-but
idea.
and
one oth_
that
sad
what
really
that
DESA
we raly
TIXy said
23
reqturt_nent
24
to cover
thmg
needs
This
t$ probably
to Ix emphasized
reh_
on Sage
In
- Mr
for something
other
on R
that the
And
- that Sage
tt says
the stluetute
recites
that the claim
or the material
the
112/6
has to bo cons_
or acts
patent_
a patent
that coves
Hearmg
2:5
It
10/25/05
And
DESA
says
_e
want
to look
Markman
Page83
JA 0801
at acts
Hearing
we ate
10/25/05
Page
84
0_X_5
0_086
I Iookm8
a| azts,
no[ al suazcture,
2
ACts co_cspond
3 dmng
something
wc emphasize
on acts
Io pmcc_s cla,rns,a method
cor_isttngoftbe fullowmg
I well, thcre*ssufficlcm stuffm thee [o get out from
2 under ) 12/6,and the stuff l,_l Issuffictem in the c]_m
for
3 _s th)s ftmcl)ona]I_ng_c
s_'pone, step
4 PAo, 51t'p_c¢
Wedon'lhaveanyofthos©clanmhcze
4
5
thts lrgum_nI
5 going _o calJJlfuncuonal language,
And
wh_
suggests
is thai
whal DESA
And I'm going _o say -- I'm going Io -- I'm nol
6 *A_nLs Io do wlth ILS_ ery narrOW expression of ftmcl10n --
6 acts
7 and th,sISsomethJng thalhas only come
7
8 tlfor th© firsl
ume
th_ Ibelr
expel,on
up - today I heard
of_h_
the
YerarSago, thc_e was a - some
9 clmms
I0
! I we ate _ymg
I I clams,
dstectmg,
for example,
wlth
12 this one, Ifs rm4 dclcclmg ptcdclcn'nmed condmon
13
¢xteanal
14
to the apparatus,
And
they
it's just
were _ough
S0 they stud, well, ffyou apply I 12/6 to prcccss
_cn
It -
those acts are {he funclt
13
and showed
II
So thofs an _ssuc tb_ has - ovc_ the ycnrs has
14
been
r¢_olved,
no{ find any case
but this IS not a _oc¢_,s
15 w_sjustasmglevcrbmthroughomthts
Th_stswhn[
I5
16 they are sa>_g
th_sIsthe wrong
16 define the structure thai _ssupposedly
Is the function,
17 somconcoutofa
17
one 1o tmc,
- I shoulchYl be - maybe
but Ibey
_
saying,
okay,
this
18 and 01istsall-- these are the acts
19
18
Tberc ISdt any Case authomy
20
sort
of ana]ys_s
_o s_cmral
thalapphcs thal
clmn_
Io apparatus
clams
method
23
whal
24
ftmctJoctal
langtt_e _ supporl the £1zucRn-c
25
do_,
fl_
me,qns tha_ the -
That's wlml he'slaying to do
He's _v/tng to s_y,
10/25/05
lo
Su_clcnl
sl_ct_c.
hasn'Ip_ovulcd fl
a few mmm_s
over my
tm_e.and
Page
THECOURT
23
Well
it's noon.
24
break.
25
all
Okay
so I suppose
Thankyou
we ought
We'll take _n hour for lunch,
Allnght
to take ouz lunch
and we'll $¢¢ you back
00
85
Markman
llearmg
10:25/05
Page86
O0088
00O87
I
(Break)
2
3
Heanng
the s_q.lclm'¢,
So - I think Pm
22
you u_e the
Markman
"acts"
going totake
21 Fve reached an cr_
of doing something, thaiwould ix:an _g_mucn[, but
thai
And you wdl
112/6
II'S ahvays
20
clmm, a
case
that USe _C wo_d
authOnll_
19 If thwc isa c_c, DESA
21 "l'hat
would be an argurncnl lhatffthiswas a method
22
0rmJ s_tcrncni
12 m the proce_,s
dctecung
then clalms
all
m ICmts of funcuon
_'e Wnllen
9 ftmctwn *- whal Ibey say tbe fmlcuon is,,t'snol the long
at's Just
thoughl _
$ process claretswere covered by I 12/6 becau.seMl pmcc_s
I 0 - Ifs not thcs_ I_g words a_'r the "for', zlrncar_ for,
no
l*m going Io call xl
I patem
THECOUrRT
Okay
Areyourc_dyfo_th_firsl
2
w tU'_ss?
4
3 Mr
Y_YomHcmoz
MILHIGGINS
$
the fnsl v¢lu-a_,
6
queshOnS?
may
I ask a couple
THE
COURT
8
MR.
HIGGINS
9 Markrmm
12
12(C)6(C)
13
accordmg
Agreed
by the coral,
of_
tbe prepazed
12(C)6(C),
t6
m.'ty ruth adthmma]
My
28 of the local
_1ts stated _
Rule
15
stal_n_t,
wltne_¢s
_ct
proceduzal
pamc ul_'.
the cotrl
19
hothM_"
20
¢lazms
AndMr
21
address
thor question,
Cook
_
for.h
ii is
will be
m Rule
PaRerson.
23
contalned tahis wn_cn
24
off_
25
m gc_ holh_
You may
wlme:is
explain
Hcalor,
wbyareth_e
omncxt
Thai
m through
the dcclar_on
10
wtmt_ses
We have
atgtmacnts
12 Statcrae.nL
to mqmr¢
from a wm.a:ss
Marknmn
H1GGINS
COURT
the opmlo_
16
o* fo_xttm_;
17
19
to we bare
20
wltnc$$
I
10/25/05
Page
87
any
thsclmrner,
came
Rule
oppornmtty
12
to dtsct.L_
thc*rs ts thscmscd
m the
Yes
- at least
HIGGINS
as we[I,
neves
Yts,
Ym_
once
or twice
or tho_
had
andourststhscmsedm
Honor
And
the oppommtty
my qm:suon
n:latcs
to put thai into a
statcmenL
2!
And
22
ktstor/'ofthc
Mr
Panctson
23
complctt*
24
Io ask htm some
25
Ic*urnony,
file
ts famlhar
the rr.ath ng ofhts
sfl
w*th the prce, ecuuon
And_ttsmyrcqueslthatwhcnhc
qtumttons
slatontm|
about
that I be permitted
thai ptosccutlota
ehsclmrm_
may_
bÁarknmn
JA 0802
Mr
Ifsthscusscdalo[mthebnefmg.
MR
fommdcpend_t
Pa.q¢=son
had
Well.
THE
who pfacuces
Heanng
COURT
MR
Hevt_thel_s,
by
--
15
as
htstoty
of the ds for.dams*
n_vt_
and
THE
the h't c frog
of Mr
prosecutmn
14
zsprc[x_J_to
a statement,
file record
bncf-
18
in his dzrccl msm"nony
Rule
argtm_cm,
of
w_mess,
oa
clarms
McCavtL
has read
is m
v,hal's
ofthe
rccaII t.hal he was foettslng
office
dunng
concerning
mt_tanon
put m the patt:nt
tbe wtmcss
thn_ moramg
m -
pomo_
thsclammr
9
13
f,cts forth
pr_cnted
contmncd
8
I l those
i f Ibe court w_ll p¢_msL
tbe cc*.n'l tbe oppormn.ty
explanat_
t_
the qucsaon
me ahout
not contmncd
Yore
whxch
who culled
to furth_
qucitson.
asked
and
pal¢_,
the an¢_-y
quc_mts
18
hts
4 of the orficL
cnlcsed
_o tho !:_ccdur_
on page
14
22
opening
prosccutmn
12
And
17
O11 page
thal's been
day
the a_gum_t
7 JenstmandMr
thai the d=r¢cl I_Umony
prcscra_
5
Yes
Pmc¢_e.
II
Cook's
4 called
of procedural
cvcr_
6 an aflldavlt,
7
lO sI_¢d
Bcfofev.eculJ
law
Sc¢.ondJy,
Hearing
10/25/05
Page88
OOO9O
00089
I
THE
COURT
2 an oilily
3
Dtd
4
Imcfing'_
to pal
the
cxpol
do you
!hal m an expcll
witness
stalcracms
v,_ncss
come
MR
HIGGINS
THE
9
No,
COURT
because
MR
l0
that a legal
| t
StalcracnL
12
And
13
htslovj
14
slatcments
2
that, I _ould
all the
3
stand.
they
came
aRcr
5
the
W©ll, then
HIGGINS
Yes,
argumcat
the
would
stgm ficam
dctads
We!I,
tr_ y_,youm_yaakhtraafcwqu_honsab(mttt
probably
would
ask him =fyou
HIGGINS
20
Order
21
cra_omagc
22
free to mtcrmpl
23
any
24
mLcrcsl
ptoccc&ng,
the court:rod
wlmc85
the rcathng
al any time
Io the
25
DT Carnal,
COURT
I feel
Yes.
THECOURT
THE
W1TNrESS
11
MR
HIGGINS
that in formed
Okay
THE
Rinse
16
(WITNESS
and one
him
CLEKK
CLERK
THEWITNESS
THI_
COURT
THE
WITNESS
arc of
perfectly
f_¢
Thank
Hearing
Yo_
10/25/05
Page
h $
your
nght
hond,
ple_e
)
yow
name
for the record.
Goodafteraoon,
Honor
23
prefer.
24
right
Good
afternoon
If a _ould
sa_e
I can skip o_ er the bmgrapMcal
to the tcstrmony
25
you.
Iv,_
thc le_/cm
MarkPattmson
22
thai
) ou
SWORN
State
21
fccl
of
Youarcgomg
to do II from
WAS
aswcll,
toplcasc
the
please
19
12 sUacmcnt
_ imted
Pattersons
and -- l jr!st v, anHo
quc_uor_
Thank
15
THE
you
Myapolog]_,YoufHonof
THE COURT
Honor,
to
going
Patterson
IO
18
are
or is thai --
"touarcav.tmess
Mr
my mls_akc, not Mr
mtcxcslcd
to the
You
I undcrst0od
the podium
20
I'darkman
THE
ume
if you
m formation
and get
_
COURT
Thot
world
be fine
Markman
89
Ilearlng
10/25105
Page
90
Page
92
OOO92
(X_91
!
THEW1TNESS
nghts
of exclusr,¢
3 tssund tl_otch
from
Patna!
5
A patent grants
6 rcfcrred
7 from
8 into
ofllce,
using,
the Umted
Stat_
If anyone
offmng
patent m_ ent_on m the Umted
thepat=ntholder
13
US
Secuon
Assmmng
und_
which
Section
271 of the Patcm
SccUon
of a bargam
102,
betweeat the mv¢:ntor
17 and th_ gov_t.
18
In exchange
for t_
exclustmmy
19 patcta gram,
the inventor
20
spe_ficat_c_
poll!on
must
21
dcscr_ptzon of the mvcnuon
ofht$
provtd¢
m what's
c¢ her apphcanot_
and m_!
22
mains
mad us_r,g the mvenuon
23
concise
tcm_
called a
a written
d_'b¢
m such ful L cl_
and
wtthout
that m, on!Ion p_tam.s
_
to make aml use the
exp¢_mm_tatlo__
Markman
And
Hearing
10,'25/05
after
Page
JA 0803
I 12's
first paragraph
of the mventt
o f a patent
mu_t
out the
ts
on
also
invention
if thf
Thafs
14
as the preferred
which
allowance,
becomc_
the best
the pnnted
mode
ts often
referred
to
emhothment
A patent
ts dwtded
16
claims
.A hlch define
17
by patent,
I8
statute
19
oxabhng
20
the
patent,
again
The
cfalrns
22
and
hounds
23
by
and.
B
m[o two
the $cop¢
baste
the _ecificataon
are a part, which
thsclo*ure
forth
and best
mode
Sectton
of the patent
Iega/de_cnptaon
A,
the
rights
of whtch
sets
cttang
parts
of the property
gr mat ed
the ¢lalrr_
the _. ntlen
by
d¢_c_pl_on
m the te.a_h mg part of
I 12, first pax'agrapk
ate analogous
to the
of the real property
meets
conveyed
a deed.
I f a person
real property
com¢$
inside
the meets
w_thout the permission
Markman
91
a patent
to as a
first paragraph
patent
25
tl_
112.
13
24
Section
of carr_ng
In the apphcatton,
21
the rnam_m of
=s v. dl enable a person of ordmm3t skflhn
tho an to whtch
mv_on
rights o f the
referred
dasclosme"
description
mode
and L_C Lilt
the inventor
mventorhohot¢_thatsuehabestmodeextsts
15
und¢* Sect!on
and why
_cnabhng
is if the
how to make
ts oRen
the best
I l Secuon
Act.
world
ts why
a patent
Act
bargain
vail grant
The writ!era
12
and nonobvlousm_s
103, a pal!mr ts a Ixoduct
of
rncets the reqmrements
are no_ city tmd_
!01.
l0
of the Patent
the relevant
dooament
9 dlscl_
terr_suchpea'sc_an
that an mvcnuon
14 of paumtal_hty,
15 ulfltty
Stat¢_ v, )thou! penmsslon
pat=,mlaw
g
to a
112
thc Inv_rttor's
the gov_t
7 stud to reqm_
by the patJmtt¢]_JV¢
That
6 t=achmg
others
wor(_,
teaches
mventton,
5
to sell or =reporting
any of those _ls
I!
4
PTO
is m St'coon
In other
3 inventor
offi_
and sorn¢l=m_
ttcrPa dtat are cov_ed
ix*forms
u_dcr
_
the rtght to exclude
!0
12 mfn_cr
m_honty
alsolmo_n
tho patent ov,T.cr.
sdhng,
2
States Govcttxm_t,
adrmmstzatwe
to _ the patcnt_,
I reqmrement
Apalenttsagxam
the Um_d
_dTr_emark
ma_ng,
9
Allnght
the ddcgatcd
4 US
25
from
14
corot
THE
WITNESS
read
17
of the Rule
to m'tswcr
THE
statements
13
So --
Althoughtt'smthoAgrco:l
for the Markman
PatterSont
Thcsz.
1
you. Yore
Mark
m the wl_css
&dal"t
Thank
finalhottsckccpmgmaac_
COURT
Andwtth
Palterson
I trmt?
the o_¢
tfs an L._suc rm
17
24
THE
ma'am
ill call Mark
12
prosccutton
conlamed
Tnm_kyou,
plmm_ff,_
9 to take the stand.
m a witness
and J Michac_
IilGGINS
-
be testifying,
8
o f the
_ _e
Masscngdl
COURT
MR
an oppormnay,
bm wc &d not ant]clpalc
16
18
had
be contained
statement
of Dr
THE
you
7
it's m the bne frog?
disclaimer
15
16
MR
Slalcmen[?
6
8 chda_'t yoo.
2
bcfon:
I
thd not ha_ c
bn¢ frog
7
19
mean you
4
5
6
What
oftl_
a/_d botmd$
owner,
Iteanng
of
real
10/25/05
(XX)93
000S'4
I _t._c law labels such a pc,T,o
n a Ucspcsscr
I I03 compared
2
2
Slnul_ly, Tfa person makes, uses or sellsa
[o the pnor an
Tbe goal of _al_ng
a patent c]a_rn _ todc_nc
an
3 pcodoct wh,ch is msldc tbe cl_am tcnns without the
3 mvcnl_on as broadly as pc_sthle v,htle sull thslmgalshmg
4 ]x_m_slon
4 i[ov_
of the pascal owner, palen[ law labeL_such a
the pno_ _'I
5 person an infllr,gcr
5
6
6 tavenoan that ,sproperly described m the sp¢ctfica[lon
V/ben lafnngcxncnt ,$behc_ ed to exxst,pat_l
7 auccncy_ of'_n wdl say th_ a palcnt clalm reeds on an
by clmmmg
an operative
7 and by mcluthng ¢lcn,c-nlso_ hrattat,ons,n the chain thal
8 ;_,ccused
producL
9
This ,saccornphsbed
8 d_stlngu_sh [he invent,on from the p_o_ ar[
Wzthrcfc_cr,ccloU
S
P_U_,_tNO
5,59g,066, wh,ch
9
A palcnl dral_r will often w_¢nt
clalr_sm
10 _ oi_cn rcfcrred to _s [ha '066 patent, l wtlJpoint out
I 0 vat/rag $cop¢ to S_l forththe invcnlxon m ._.-vcrul
I ! a_d d_,cn'be the dllTcrcntsc-c_Joc_s
of the paCnt docuracn[_
I I th{rcrcnt ways to &s0ngu_sh
12
P_ts
are wrlncn to leach the mvcnuon
13
persons b_vmg
14
mvcn[_on _,
15
_rtha._7 skill,n the azl to which the
as sl_tcd in Seeuon
The parson o f ordma_
the mv_Ibon
from the pnor
to t.hos¢
13
Pa[enl clan'isare usually presented m ,:,hatare
14 sonlcom_
I 12
sk,!lm du: _rl,oP,cn
referred to as cl_-mcn_ of llmltatlo_
15 example, a claml may
For
r_clt¢a cc-t1_
n s[ntct_falclcm_t
and
16 shorlcned topersons sk_led m the an, Lsa hypo_etlcul
16 conscqucnt]y thlselcmcnl IEmllsthe cI_n_s to cove_ ouly
17 !x_'_on,s_nd_
17 those dcvt¢cs hawng
t8
lo a reasonable pex_on m [orllaw
Pa_'nts arc nc4 v.n[1_
to teach the gcnex_ pubhc
19 c¢ dmse wilh edvcnced or ¢xccp_on_
20
_s thosew_th_
deg_c_or
2[
a jedge or a juW
23
skdl m the arl _;uch
judg_o_jm_cs
19 br_ily
25 _
21
thr_'_,a lamp, _md thor,control clrcml means
22
10/'25/05
Howe,'or, Clalm
23 _xampl¢
m a way
Hearing
fo_ elcmen,.s
m the
ofa fm1_
two, s¢condscr_or
6 con_,ns
mean.s,
th_Icr hmllatlon
An
hmtL_ti0a rn Claim 6 _sthe further
24 language descn'bmg
_snovel tm,dc_ Stetson 102 and nonobvlous _mdc_ $ccuon
Markman
Thee
m-c On¢,_rslse'_ormeans,
skdl m the _J1
the fuacu on of a use ful mvc_uon
6 o f the 'O66 patent,
spaalcxng,has four elcmen_,
20
A ¢laml m ;m L_ued pascal dcfin_ the structgr¢
24 and somctlnu_
that swacturc
AS a furtherexample, Cl_m
although
may or_cn be charged w,th sumdmg
22 shoes ofa pcuson of ordmaty
Ig
the lamp "which can ernlla firs_lev©l
25 of ,]]ttmm;mon"
Page
93
Markman
0OO95
lleartng
10/25/05
Page
94
0C_96
I
Ifrequcsled, Iatn pr_
2 poml om
to the coral all_
dtmng
I msubs
the tutorialto
2
clcrmmts and Im_,t_o_.s of
h_nUul to one
of orthnmy
The thfferenc_
skdl
between
3
clement
In an accused
product
4
element
m the
prodoct
5 d_-'v:c_
must cont_,_n.-'v
cr/e]elr,ent and [ffn_l_on ¢iI_
5
same
6 htc_lly c_ an equ_vulenl ofone _.sc_led claim
6
substantxully
7
7
3 Clam_
4
6, 9, I0, I I and 12 of [be '066 pal_nl.
In ord_ fo_ a _
to be m fnnged, _
Tbe_c _'_ two [ypcs ofmf_.ge_r_nl
8 mfnnge_'nt
and m frmgcn_nl
und_
accused
L_ic'cal
the docm
n¢ o f
I0
L_Ul
m frmgcrmml
_ve_7 elcn_t
12 d_ freed as rec_d
In_t
occm_ when
17
h[erully
14
to a person
are avoided by m_cmg
15
dcefaed
16
a l_a'acubr so'u_n_
!9 de fmcd by the v.ords of_
20
Undm
g_
docmnc
2t
_cused
22
accused produc! mclud_
23
the cL_mcd
ehan_nt as l_Ic.'_
ly
clash.
of eR_avulcnc¢, howev_,
dcwc© wd_ new-nhcI¢_s mfnnge
24
An
¢Icmcnl m an _¢o._cd _oducl
25 clmm
lunli._t,on
i_0_ thfl'ca_nc_betw_
Markn_n
tscqu_vulc'nltoa
the two
Hearing
I0/25/05
mvca_on
19
would
Page
may
to the
To f'md mfrmgcmerd
ha mfnnged
Also
tmd_
U S PTO
i_ceth_re,
reqmrr_
{o sol forth all my _'n_On
24
Because
of the
25
patent
s_nsle
sentence
the terminology
JA 0804
the
plates
nv¢[
,s
screw
pa_ntlaw
patented
clam
m a paten[
ate not m fnnged
only one
chain
of
a patc-m clat m ts
In a single
rule
se_ltenc©
[o th¢_© unl'arm'llar
and syntax
Markman
95
"a
_ t_ol
a sepm'atc
clauns
23
claims,
c]a_med
of a p_ent,
need
_,
be so msubstanoul
that one
otbe_
Fo_
such
Urt0grUS
sets forth
while
language
the art th_
Thtts, tt Is po_ole
be m fringed
Cqmvalenee,
a nvel
law-¢xcttseme
of a patent
h mlt,xt,on
a pa_r of mctul
AlthoUgh
that patent
22
a s1_uci_reth_ _s eqmvalent Io
sW._mral elc_nCr_L
clagn
the
by a screw"
may have
skllhn
the
to obt_dn
mc_t prevulenL
togetha
thc th ITercnccs
of orthnary
way
co_dd xnclod¢
product
UnderUS
18
21
Ls the
jamed
and an
when
substanoully
as the clatm
to be an eqmvalen[
every
pe_rn_
to demonstrate
by a nvet.
a screw,
17
20
the
th_ ul_um tf the
plaits
togctber
13
change_
result
clmm
limitation
,nsubstantlal
the same
and rcsul!
An accused
Io pr_.,ml a s_ruaoon v,h_'e the
of cqmvulc'n¢c Isa
way
a patent
12 jomcd
In oth_ words, an accused d_'wce tna7 no_
18 w.co_o_a_
the same
pmr o f racial
I1
Itmlta_on as previously
d_ doco_m_
docome
15 hlcr_ wo_ds o f 'd_ p_mt
16 msuha_n_
I0
d_v,ce
m _e ass_Icd ch,_.nn
_
14 juthc_11y _
m
the _cus_
_'e
m _;ubstanttully
There me otbe_ ways
9 example,
I I hlc_lly o_nt_as
13
fu_cuo_
8 b_[ ftmcOon,
9 _a_,alcnce.
accused
m thc art
a claim
used
Ilearing
w_th
in a palent
10/25/05
Page
96
O0O98
1 other
OOO97
I cban
2
may
Meat
U $
patents lnalude both mdcpcndenl
3 dependent claims
An
mdqx'ndc_
2
and
claxm isone tnwhlch ts
4 complete - thatis,conta_ra allhmltattons on itsov*n --
Tim mdcpcmlent
clmrm of the '066 patent arc
7 ClaJms I.6, 7, 9, I0, II, 12 aod 13
8
A depc_dtmt
9 _t
II
12
clatrntso_¢ which refersto an
The dclx'odcm clmms of the '066 patent arc Clarms
2 throtv,b $. wluch are dependent from Cla_m I,aod Claim 8
_l'ach tsdClxndent from Cl_m
13
When
a dependcm
7
such tcfcrralitmcca'poratt_ the elements or hmttattov.sof
15
thcmdcpcndcmclatm
16
elcmtmts set forthm the body of the dependent claim
Thcnttadds
18 the str_tm_
elements of Clmm
19 tsreoted m Clmm
21
foe frmlta_onsor
I phts that strtmturcwMch
2 afterthe v,ord "mctudes"
mtctprttaUontsthcconeeptofanoIx'_cndedclmrrt
22
patent cl_m
23
such claim tssaJd to b¢ o[k'n-cndcd
25
tsmtrodttced wnh
Ifa
a word such as "comprising",
This means thatthe claim can bc co/x_trxted
to
_compa.ts
product
a nut and
set
All
forth
m the
ended
7
accttsed
product
8
Claim
can bc m fringed
clmm
TO mfnngc
must
contain
I plus the suucturc
Con_
cvs¢ly,
infringed
II
is missing
12
c..cry
clmm
13
claim
ts hkcwts¢
14
will bc missing
15
mdependenl
the
recited
claim,
claim
or hmTtatlon
focn as a mattc_
the nomnfrmged
not mfnnged
in
claim
ts not
alement
dc_lcc,
from
the
recited
in foc depcodem
sbxtcture
accused
dependent
a_¢ presented
all the stru¢lu_c
a recited
from
a w asher
a dcpendent
if an mdcpcrrdent
bocause
system
by an accused
a bolt and
in the '066 patent
form
10
for a fastening
a nut and
of the claims
in open
clam
a boll
thal combines
6
17
A ktv aspect of U S patent practice m claim
24
comprising
4
t6
Thus, Claun 2 o f the *066 patem contains all o f
20
to those
a patent
because
of law
independent
the accused
product
clalm refors to anothe_ claim, by
14
17
3
9
clan'_
I0
m addtuon
For example,
5
5 v.lthout referenceto any ofocz clalm
6
elements
first
appear tortured_
Markrnan
Hearing
Page
10/25/05
strucgurc
as was missing
from
the
clam1
THE
Mr
COURT
Can you
pa_c
one minute,
paltcrson?
18
THE
19
THECOURT
20
THEW1TNE_g
WITNESS
21
spectfica_onofthcU
22
wrltlcn
23
invention
24
known,
25
products thalinclude stractures,ftmc_ons or
foc s_e
Asnoledabo_¢,thc
that ts an enabling
which
The
Goahca6
Okay
S patemtsreqmzedtoset
d_Cllptton
for
Yes
Okay
m tmn,
car_mg
sets
cut
forth
forth
disclosure
foc best
a
of the
mode,
tf
the indention
specification
mttSl
describe
at lc_l
Markman
97
one
Heanng
10/25/05
Page
98
Page
I00
00100
OOO99
1 ernbothmlmt
2
3
|n _mnc
described-
5
pattmts
the best
cml:odm3tmt
6
than
one _nbodml_t
o¢ bc Inmted
3 fi_t
acbam
fomlh
all of the
features
claims
6 found
avoid
of a disclosed
8 d_'s
I0
This
ts because
wall contain
I I define
oflcnm'nt*
fealurts
which
the mmtmmn
a preferred
go beyond
alr_ture
cmbodummt
what
ts necessary
of an mvcnuon
wluch
to
m_ enbon
13
14
I_tentablc
Mm'_,
o_ ta" the Pnc*
makc_
tnm.-s,
be a din:el
if r, cl most
co:r_pondence
found
mode,
and d_l's
48, _,
4, hne 56 d_o_
clrcutl_
_hlch
fore.
cok_rrm 4, hn_ 5,
of the lamp
And that's
column
_11foc foat_
which
false dctcctlom,
full bnghmcss
5 Imc 58 through
is
m
col_mm 5 line 6
_otds
10 95 p_nt
Not
lamp
d_"C I c_cml_,
In coh_mn 3, line 62 d_rcugh
oflhc
avO_L_ the
fom_l
c_-cmi_
zero CT_Smg
to Im'_t the dlmnmal_n
I 1 colman
the
_mg
which
c_rr_nt _ hen I_
9 and fis c, clrcml_
12
12
m col_nn
7 pulse COLm_.g
8 cmbo_mt_
9
the d_.lce
cffcmb_
on rush
5, hncs 31 through
5 c_r_es
Rme., the patent
_lnl_n
of a mcdmn
acu_ reed to the Imght
4 colmnn
to may p,_tlcular
of the m_cr_otx
of the
two, slow
2 tmposttton
Is
thetetsnoreqmmmentthat
mode
In fact, most
7 setting
mo_
Howe_er,
4 $¢t forth
I sp_tfic_on,
of foe tnvenBon
_d
to
m
6, hnc 42
of Pre f_rred
cmbodsm_l
1 / ust
arL
all the
between
tram,
the_x
13 r_lted
rmay not
foe ainu:tree
m l_ph
14 thstl_msh
of the
22 may be neccss_
the inventlO_
Io pm_bly
m the '066 patent
ov_
_
prior
iSarL
15
weferred
16
patcm
17
embodmumt
ami
set forth
the stricture
Rtcall
that
18
broadapatent
19
ts aecomphsbed
20
rmmmally
21
r_lmag
m the sPectficatton
_ted
the patenl
forth
drafr¢c
go_
sol forth
subject
clam_
matter
In lack
17 p_ent
ml
allow
independent
patentable
16
ts to obtain
_otcctlon_.sthcpnorartwtll
by dralkng
of the
m the claim.
I 8 pn:f_rted
"this
19
which
20
w_thoul
it would
&allmg
_nbo&ment
COm_l_-ntly
pt_:tlcc,
patent
21 do not mclode
ex_
alemcnts
For example,
23
dcr_abcs
24
f_
m the '066 patent,
an cmbodamcm
mcludmg,
one,
oz Ix_t
under
clams
mode
standard
could
all of Lh_c
conl_y
cv¢_
_d
m good
fom_
m cv_y
U g p_nt
of the
clmm
cl_mmg
sboeJ d be pr_ented
_hlch
fcatm-_
of a hghtlng
a manual
4, hr_
FOr example,
m the '066 patent, c_n
cl_ns
do
the specification
dt-v tie having
ovcmdc
switch,
23 conlmn
many
the nmnual
24 embodlm_nt
and
25
25 foals fotmd m column
to include
or hmltattons
22
22
be gen_,lly
practice
13 - w_le
o_ _nde
- for _ample,
olhc_s
f_e
of the p_ forr_l
Claims
I foro_
do not, such as Clalm_
5, 7, 12 and
6, 9, 10 and ] I
26 through 37 o f foe
/_larkman
Ilearing
10/25/05
Page
Markman
99
JA 0805
Heanng
10/25/05
0010]
I
Ccrtmn
2
feat_
¢launs
do conlam
-- thai ,s Clatm
3 such
as Clauns
4
And
5
feature whde
6
and 13
7
do no_ get cla:med
9
if all of the fealur_
mventJon
ofa
II
clam_ _ called
featme
13
an s,.¢h
14
claim
15
_c
a p)ctm¢
feazes
a_
sc_k
clann
of_e
p_tcnt
such
,i co.lares
or best
what
ts mJmm_lly
I'm entitled
a palcal
19
to make
reg]st_.d
zt patentable
f_ (hca
the m&v_ual
21
have a t¢chmca]
backgro_d
22
pass a I_em
Pratt)co
ofpncUce
25
fur_eT
bcth_c
ram!
qu_Jfy
13
n_nobvlou_,
17
car_mg
of palenl
W_nkmB
mvenu_n
pe_ams,
and
21
d_cnpuon
would
22
skdl
is a person
)03.
aboul
of the
hxs or her
t_ tmderstood
SecUon
¢ompa:ed
101.
and
to the p_or
I work
arL
w_th
wn.en
dc'.cnptlon
mode
[fc_e
of the
ts knowr_
for
of _thaary
I stove
who
cormr_nly
skill in the
to make sine
be undc_toed
but a_
an to which
the
thai the wnttcn
by a person
of or&na_"
m the ao_
23
24
palatably
25
ark making
Page
a search
under
w_th the inventor,
20
10/25/05
useful
the b_l
and v, hat
novel
,I o_
by the nthngs
Hearing
in
the
ic_ms
If the invention
a detailed
ts,
Im_dure
how
has c_nducted
IS pat_tablc,
m¢lndmg
I I._ndls
examining
conducted
102.
mv¢_uon
always
by the PTO
or have
under See|ton
to cr¢_c
MPEP
I p_¢pare
it set of clam_,
thstmgtash
e._:h claim
the claim
sure thai cl_am tcm_
101
drawn
in_ ent,_n
are defined
Markman
to
from
the prior
_" w_u_d
Heanng
10/25/05
Page
102
00104
I othe]_
tse be unde_stond
by a person
of ced]_a_'
skdl
m the
2a_
3
It ts m_t
r_rowly
not to clann
by mct_,n_
5 _
feat_ns
to palentably
6 pn_"
arl.
7
De;_
8
case.
9
dctmled
beyond
thstmgmsh
too
wha_ _
ramm_ly
the mvcnu_
over
Idealty
one
only
o f _c.h
or ffmre ch_rr_
dcscnp_on
knowledgeable
3
appllCallon
Fo;
before
I ptupare
e
al l¢_tst ¢_n¢ of the p_lem
clam_
thai
element
_" hm_tat_on
The add_lmn
14
theclmmnovelmpat_l_
15
f,_neutm_
called
in many
of _
elem_t
Tha_nc'*v
the p_nl
cas_
_n mven_o_
c_bmal_on
of ¢lemen_
18
evm
ea_:h of the separate
is novel
Into a single
p_or
art, the pmt_ul_
20
thee
elen_nts
taught
m the pak'm
21
p_or
ar_
Once
23
sp¢cx ficauon
24
PTO
the apphcatlon
d_wm_
upphcat_on.
technology
15
d_4 group
of _
_ not fotmd
_
12
of the
t_lmology
that technology
elam3
may
18
of
ts the
to the
_t _
_gned
to a p_te_l
Markman
examm_
tlearing
m a_
10/25/05
Page
103
having
by
and
would
[3¢
Icchmcal
Io a pa_lcular
8 group,
a high level
knowlcdse
the palen_
relating
exammm
the examiners
of thmd _.nty
patents
_
have
with
m
the
t.e,
sued
m
20
of pam,_dabthty,
21
relatln8
22
comphance
23
the PaIen! ACL
examines
the upphcahffa
m two
A, comphancewlththestatutoP_requtr_T,_'_Ls
thai would
utthty
to novehy,
with
all of the requh-cmen
As part of this
will search
PTO
13¢ Sccttor_
examination
materials
I 0l,
102 and
and nonobv_ou_ne_,
and,
LSofS¢cuoa
pr oces.% the
fo_ relev_t
Markraan
JA 0806
be examined
for example.,
exarmn¢s
upphcat_ons
PTO examiner
bas_are_
25
would
and
area.
19
24
There
a person
and w_th the many
The
by
educaho_
educa.on
mvcat_ons,
can acqmrc
17
are ¢xamlnnd
u'aJnmg,
mventlons
[o a parbcular
16
in the
ha.n ng skd] In ¢Icctromcs
By a_gnmg
_.
m the
tt _ submliled
l_cct_mc
That
mvenbons
relevant
field o f the mveni]on
14
c_nbma_on
Ls completed,
and elamlS,
m the
described
phannaceuucal
in other words,
II
featurets
because
rtlcvant
by those
13
mvenuo_
e]en'za-_ts
19 be fom_d in the
examined
renders
of novelty
17
though
m the ¢lawa
cxp¢_crw.¢,
9
lO
would
_ n_l m the
with
Phannaceul_ca)
8
olo_
chCatlCa]
exaramers
7 (hosc having
pa_ucular
Theex_nmcr_suplx_edtob¢
of the I_hr,
example,
5 chemical
_m_
22
exarnmmggroup
2
4
the
of the mvenuor_
one
13
16
I
6 expme_c.
w_nen
I I mcthde
the mvenU_
on the cln:_
I may draft
IO
25
row-at]on,
the
_ stna:tured
or m papal
the xnventov
_9
00103
12
inventor
}6
_d
to learn
is new
to determine
If the
15
the
to the PTO -
Secuon
I conduct
under Secuon
14
inventors
the invcn*Jon
behev¢$
Then
a patent
ru_
way
how
ImP- an o_ I_
to
o_
for - thai
the PTO ts gove_ed
Markman
4
the mvenuon
novel
xnvcntor_
edrmmsteTed
by the manual
8
18
r,atts factory
Ifsudesof37CFR,
graded
the inventor
12
be fc_¢ the PTO to
to Tel_CScnt
b._ exammauon
7
for short
and pr_ccute
t w_th the patcnl
general
wofk_,
if
m_ enuor_
be fore the PTO,
24
before
mvemors
fm an m_vldua]
20
23
to i_lctlc¢
to rcpfesrnt
gram
In order
invention
I I OWn Search
n_essm7
] prepare
FirSt, I meet with
6
I0
even
_o as the MPEP
cor_ls_t'n
thIIowxng
9
a
every
mnde.
the
5
hand,
embothmenl
berate
in a mann_
AS an atzorncy
18
4
10, It
On the other
embothmenl,
beyond
the mvcatlon
coum
1,6,9,
clann,
referred
In my pracuce,
3 apphcabon
the pr¢ fen'ed ¢rabo&mcnl
in a single
o f the prefem:d
2
prior arL
16
PrO,
aboul
d_cl_ed
are included
do hoe,
the pulse
_s Clams
al all m a patent.
10
clalras
feature
feat wcs
8
12
s_h
such
00102
I r_faet_mes
de,eel
12 and }3
m includes
OtheT clalms,
do nol recite
other
_. 6, 7.8.9,
12 reclt_
Soracllrnes
17
10 - whde
I through
C]atra
the zero ero_mg
pno_
Hearing
103,
B,
112
Of
examln_
art
Any
10/25/05
Page
104
00105
OO1O6
I defielencles
found
by the
2
of the spaoficauon
3
are
noted
4
_
5ca'l! to the appheatlt
5
It ts common
o111¢© action
that
the PTO
patent
7
examiner
m a first office
8
percm_
9
mvent=oa,
=;omct= rues the PTO
I0
analymtlg
the mventt
v,'lll object
procedtmm
13
include
14
apphcatlort
plx_cett_
17
between
the apphcant
18
mquxted
m the grpheatton
19
mvcnuoi_
20
and
the
ongmall7
22
r_quaremam_s
23
allowance
24
or
oF the
a negooat=on
to agree
and
cleam
that
the
fo* _" as amended
o f Ih¢ tssu¢
A pazenl namber
as
f¢¢, the
patent
ts assigned,
grant
is
01¢ pateat
Hearing
10/25/05
Page
of I 12, parag_h
2 spac_fic
or part_ular
tl c_
5
expressed
6
¢l¢_'nts
9
mfrmgemmt
|0
rhea ts tdenttfied
pofformmg
13
thedasclcseds_cla_
14
dann
15
mqun3t
function
governed
duxmg
law
the
field
and
and rules
to which
15
the
16
Slrl_Ctmc
| 12, sixth
ftmctlon
and
the
which
rath_
skill
24
S_cuon
112,
of the tmn
rights
U S Palenl
ACl
by reciting
tts parncular
of _Cltlng
a screw
could
"meanS"
recite
wh_¢h
means
for
connoles
in the art, the
paragraph
_r, the
ra=ses a rebuttable
6 o f Se_ctmn
_f _, Ierm
bdoreo_
the
_s a fLmetlon
However,
ordma_
of the
than
the clalm
that paragr'aph
23
to ert_urc
and
ii1 the invent=on
ts msl¢.ad
be a stnlclui¢,
tt_
paragraph
clmeat
An example
The
_-s patenL_
grant¢_t
1o clatm
of_q
presumption
to be rigorous
not carelessly
an applicant
the clann
ate
I 12 apph_;
stracz_
to one
presumpllon
6 does
of
ts rebutted
and
not apply
¢¢rm rrt order
dev_
must
m the Claim,
or more
5
mfnngement,
6
cquwalen¢¢
clemeats
the
sffuca_¢
¢o _a/I outsede
the
Hearing
to
6, adtht_onal
or eqtu_
112,
wdl
paragraph
th© id_nucal
I1_ same
10/25/05
alenc¢
to that slna:ture
6 does
bc consmaed
as
apply,
to cov_
the statute
the stngttne
and
cqu_
that
the patent
ale_ce
thereo
f
Page
;my or all stw.h eqtuvalcnc¢
ts all eqmval_!
_s an mquny
to th_ Sffttclltr©
that
ts answered
Markman
disclosed
by thos=
Hearing
m
of
10/25/05
Page
107
an mqmp/of
nOl mfnngmlK'nt
although
there
tmd_r
under
the docent
9
eqmvalenc¢
under
112,
paragraph
I0
;esult
may
be t_;¢d
¢omlx_SOn
¢lo=_onlc
13
pracllc¢
t4
somewhat
15
technology
and
of using
thff_¢nt
Generany
17
only one
18
stnaett_es
19
b_t there
20
¢lecffonl¢
way
may
spe.aklng,
be many
ConSequently,
"means
23
has been
24
electronics
25
This
attorney,
ntn-nl_r
ways
dtrvlee
moire common
plus
over
way,
working
such
with
m patenls,
cla_rns
has
us ually
many
=s a wheel
to tmplement
the
been
to mechanical
there's
to deac_q_¢
mechanical
¢_ hinge,
a function
using
an
or circuit
In my exTenene¢,
_ gad or means
and
function,
gs compared
ftmetmn
the
the tL_ of the word
_lau.se
years
In a patm_t
m clarets
claim
directed
to
m_¢ntlorLg
is Ix=cause
a patenl
attorney
Markman
JA 0807
the
m paten!
a task,
of
t_etv, ¢_m
th_s ts because
o_ a hm]ted
doctrine
inventions
term
Sectton
m both sLtuat]op.s
in ¢lectromcs
component,
22
6
_s a pale'at
to acc_mpltsh
the
ofeqtuvalenc¢
mochanleal
"means"
thereof",
under
hteral
LS a thfference
In my expentmce
both
partams
tnfrmgement
And
21
aeixtally
6 ts mlt;a]ly
palent
"¢quwalenc¢
paragraph,
eqtuvalen¢¢
16
strugtlll-¢
sooh
8
]2
the
ose of the woed
7
I I
as eqmvalenee
paragraph
I 12,
form
mordm'tomfrmgea
perform
the
Despite
wth
for
as well
u_mg
m the art to which
2
I 12, paragraph
to determine
speclficalaon
112,
I oeth na_" skall
4
plus funcuon
Lerm ¢ovc_
functmn
m the spacitlcaaon
What
the patrol
apply
ftmebon
"fherc ts no reqtumncat
ths¢los¢
that
In comblnahon
to one
roles
by Seetl0n
a_us_
rl_ted
If Section
descn'bed
form
Thercfo_e,
set fo_lh m the point
21
In
3 m Section
m me'arts
m the pa_.m
18
I;ays
a
_s _
The
20
sm, gtux¢
clcmmats
6 apphcs
th© clatm_
ftmcllon
19
m the
Markman
cLann.
17
25
pltts
spa_al
of thai
12
24
include
paragraph
clama,
II
23
can
TI_ n_e..al_ plus
16
and d_av, tags
is conducted
in palent
are granted
105
o f slru_lta'cs
are not expressed
I f 112,
m a patenl
merely
a _ arlety
m me._
that
not ha_ e to ccamole
str_t_a¢,
connote
8
22
6 does
A palcaat claim
7
is
OO108
1 amblt
4
parmltS
25
ts
are
Sm:tion
14
22
the text
process
ts intended
of _xcluslon
21
_ nolle© of
proces_
12
20
document
as amended
trained
knowledge
thai trtt¢ m_ enttova
faslenlng,
eontalrts
examlnataon
I1
19
patent
pert_pa
The
would
OO1O7
fa_
;hventlon
[$
apphcat_on
will tssue
Marl_naan
3
9
17
formal
apphcallon
by pt_or_
techntcal
aat
m¢¢Ls aJI the
the PTO
ha_mg
upo¢l v. hat Is
can be granted.
is sat=stied
8
13
k_ an e_
hccom_
the exarnmer
a patent
payment
compleX.
apphc_tlon
to deseno6
for a patti,
AI_"
25
and
PTO
applied
to file one
the
document
patent
The PTO
admmlstcr_l
10
and
of the paten!
7
correctly
nOL
patent
p_ecutton
6
or to other pans
sense
The
5
fo_
tt dccs
pubhshed,
apphcant
of the ongmal
an
Su£harespons©nmy
In a pc-agtteal
wlueh
Whoa
21
action
the apphc_t
o¢= Of a palenl
part¢ pr0¢¢_
3
of the clam
office
to the claims
16
_
Sometimes
and
Io the
4
of more
of the appheatmn
description
permit
rnorerc$po1Lscstotheofllccact]on
The
sent
arlom©y
OIL_ and sometlm_
12
15
t_sued,
2
L_sucd by the exarnmer
action
m the
lunch&nears
I
of any clzara
v.dI reJeCt one
to porUorts
¢d deficlmac_es
PTO
m the suffimency
ol the appheanfs
6
I I
other
o_ m the patentabthty
m a v, ntte_
¢latms
exa, mmer
LSalways
lteaiang
10/25/05
Pag¢lO$
106
OO1O9
l
00]10
conccr'r_-d
_,lth obmmn_
2 corse
II_
for an in; _s
3
FOe example
broz_t
!
mVCZ_IZOrL
a pamnl
attorney
4 e]ec_onsc cotnpon_It
that swltche$
5 off would
_
l_ely
p_sstb]e claim
haw
elannmg
e]e¢_c
an
3 elcct_cal
cmTcnt on and
5 tcrm_ ptc_cnted
t_', SCR or mac,
6
as mca_
Dcpenthng.
8 control circuit,
a patent
I0
d_si_med zround
II
field to a_comphsh
ula_m uss_
a single term
be lx_ naxtow and too c_t ly
by _ing
other devlccs
rusk _ p_for_cd
I I
In thzs _text.
the _
s',viLch m_p.s
14 used m the clazm _._ a con_ c:ment shortha_l
15 bto_l
cla_
of different
16 slTuctx_._,
elcct_zlc
that _vzlch
cm't_t
17 the clazm oz even nec_a_dy
18
wttho_
In mo_¢ fecal
20
awzt_
21
mtcrptctau_
ACC_Iy.
24 clZml$
25 w_
i'_ve become
l_glgy
rcst_cZzve
practice,
a gl_Utow ml_t
el_lO_
we h_ •
THE
you, Mr
24
Pattc_on_
Do you
Maylupproachth¢
YeS
having
PATTERSON,
r_t
_
was cxamtned
duly sworn,
and tcStll_cd _
follows
Markman
Ilearing
Pagel09
001ll
clrc'_ t Lq
qucstzons?
Ycs, ma'_
COURT
MARK
25
10/25/05
Thank
HIGGINS
23
of the et_zms th_
Hearing
m an elcct/ontc
lectern?
22
in patcm
tmmtcndod
Markman
COURT
MR
2]
with thc;e structu_l
of_Ingiurc.
THE
20
or
the use of
the petcc!_Jon m thezr rmnd thai a
] 9 Wahl to ask him a few fo]]ow-up
claim ulcm_ts
do not 17p_ca]ly use
about word components
c]_um in conncctzon
has nol changed
]7 suggestive
to suggest
p._t teula,-ly
designs, m my experience,
16 phrase such as sensor means
the mcaz_ plus
or devices,
engineers
when t_Ikmg
means in a paten!
15 tcrt_
redor.cd the use of the wo_d "mf.z_"
to _ozd
]4
18
upplymg
m ou_ c_t
23 sul_z._al]y
to a
112.
to means plus funcuou
¢lcctncul
"mc_s"
13 devices used m their
_
years, patent at m_g'/s
thal some courts w_c
22
be
mtcx_dmg [o n_xtow
to mvoge
funclzoo prmtszot_ofSeclJon
19
would
reference
d_vtc._,
ts used. terms such as czrcuit,
Lq assoctatcd wtth a st._tcd functton
Although
12 th© word
tcm',s
context m
switch and I_ct_or axe tmderstood
10 whet, the Ictm
by
12 tlg mansz._or
13
axe struct_al
9 One or more e[cctxo_t c components
m the elcc_oczzc
tl_ same ¢Iccttonlc
tcrn_
of course, on the ovcr_l
7 whtch the Ictm 61" phr_¢
_ because
with
I have I carocd that persons of skdl
8
9 SLeh aS lZ'_SzSt¢_ would
10/25/05
Page
I10
COl 12
l
DIRECT
2
BYMR
3
Q
EXAMINATION
I mcnUoncd
H[GGINS
Mr
Pattcrsou,at
pa_¢5ofyou_stazcmc_t,
t f requested,
5
and [trmta_zons
elcxn_'zts
6
And
you c,zn point
thts ts tc_ly
7
_¢
Coza*t or Dr
8
thts ttrac poml
9
pamcul_"
of Clmm
6. 9,
a qu_suon
Carnal
would
_
p_cf_
o_t the eler_mts
you
4 bol other clams
;0 and
II
to wheth_
5 anything
of nm
that Mr
Pallc_0_
and Ilmllatzox_
of the
6 A
THE
7 st_cmcnts,
al
8 brought
COURT
An_'t
you gorng
_o have
I0
experts
II
MR.
13
LIg claun
14
not ag
15
theyarc.
16
yes,
17
Rre nt tssu_
H]GGINS
20
we just w'_ntcd
pomzmg
THE
whae$
BYMR
25
Q
about
for mt_wclahon,
wall be d_'usscd
later oa
]3
the clam
to offer
COURT
And whal
I mcan
ICnlLs o f iLq gctgrul
But.
1 _ pulse counting
that
16
or Dg
terms
C.'s'n_
a_l
wants
] don't
H]GG[NS
V_
the cha_
think
wel;.
we need
it pretty
Pattcqrson.azp_ge9
cucmt
Hearing
I0/25/05
Pagelll
wlu_e Clam
use ofth_
21
aspect. Clams
And
aI
t dcnucul m
ot ulemcr,ts
to Claim
rcc_t_on
I_nguagem
I _
and tfyou
I does not
make the assurnptton
0x_J would
12 gcdund,znt because m that
12 would be tthmt.cal tn scope
bc dlogzcal
a_c not _kullmg
24 ptcscnung
rcdtm0ant
25 tha'eforc,
you would
I
cu_cmt, that would render the
Claun
Claims
I_
of the
a claim under the docmn¢
And again, gencr_ly
claims
for pu_x_cs
cl_ums or to be dlogtc_l
m '2_at c_e
Markman
JA 0808
that m
c_-cmt means or any pa_l o f Clatm
23 ¢_a_ms - attorneys
ofyot_statcment.ycm
Markman
20
22
thaL
Yore- Honor
suggcs_
If you look
tt _ alm(_l
12 mclud_
19 includes the pulse cotmung
Innztaucms,
make
by thai _s th_s
So if you _¢ _a]y'_ng
18 that the cc_troI
that
I think
tha_ doctnne
was
you don't do any0:nng thai wo..Id
llmtt,_ons
that Clam
17 of claim th ffcrcnua_on
furth_
8
thffcrenuallon
be t]]og_ca]
14 and - cxcclX
HIGGINS
M_
And, generally,
ofwh_t
terms
mthcalc
practitioner?
the docwme of ulmm
up
12
pulse count
pulse count
Ithmkth¢_moneoftheupcnm
12 Clasm 12. and In its cr_rcW,
boz
m tcnn
W
do dtscuss
ou! o f h'g_.e clazm
m thspute
MR
24
wt]l be talkmg
m (huputr..
Rm.h_
clc_-
terms
i f the Comlwants
19
23
v.e
Thafsmoreofanmfnngcmo_tmqm
Bta
21
Well,
toxins that are _t tssu_
of the clann
our wxtncss_
18
a p_lcnt
9 the prcscntataon o f clams,
do thai7
12
to you _
m CLlrm
and ptosccuung
12 includes
do not include
Ycs, ltdoes
_ a_ng
in (kaltmg
3 patents, does the fact t/_z Ct_m
ou_ the pamculax
clam',s?
l0
the tcTm "pulse count"
2 AS a pm_on wzth experience
4 smm th_
22
engineers.
7 each of v. hJc.h tz a type of cleclxomc £wztch
This
_ an dcct_cul
working
4 in the ©tcccromc arts u_0cts_ancL_ that the use of re;my
the phrase switch t nc.z_ rather
6 than mote spect tic terms, Such _ _I$
It
In adthttou, from my exlx_cnce
2 crtglnccr and then eq a p_tt:nl attorney
of
And,
tend to not include the
Hearing
10/25/05
Page
112
I
i
00114
00113
I pulse counting hrmtatlon, forexm'nple, m Clarro I
2 Q
Mr
Patt_scq3,alpage
13 ofyom'stalelrmnL
m
3 paragraph 26, you us_ t_g term _co_.notessuitetu_e=,wccdd
4 you, please,explain what does the term "connote structus¢"
5 mean
6
to you as a patenl pr'acUtJoneThavlng kno'.vledg¢ o f
117J6'_
7 A
Wcll, again, I think thatcom_
from hoth knowledge
l lOand
I1
2
a[ issue
with
3
Dr
4
A
5
hcrc
6
ln_ cnuon,
7
draHing
8 of I _2/6 and how thatterm has been used m the czs4_ v,l_ch
8
9 have apphed 112/6
9
And
connotes m thaicontcvclmeans
I0 Itftt_ge_tsthatts elthe_the sm_tu:e
-
_phcttly recgcd
Andv.ouldyoucareloexpla_n'_,halyouthlnkts
r¢_pcc[
Well,
th_¢arc
One
and
let me lalk about
ofm_cn_on
I0
for applying
means
thts,
theme
12
clalrr_
13 stru_ts_'¢.
13
14
14
you extracl
15 power means for thlvmg the wheels of an autc_oln'lc,the
15
and
pu[ them
16 pOV,eT meaLS mcluthng a spark plug. Now,
16
17
the
claims
]8
the
clal rrcs ts thai
19
two i_e[s
17 sugg¢_l _ly
thatwould
to a person of orchn,_T skillin the art
|g [batthalpow_
means includes an internalcombustion
19 engine20
of some
And
rcqlmcmcnt
_nlty
k,nd
clmms
m a gepatate
example,
palcnt
l think
oflllmnmallon
22
suggests thatthere be other stJ1t_t_src
wRh
22
Thcorclt
you could
23
Q
24
Couat 1_e]f _ked
25
md_t
que_ttor_ as to wby
ther_ v,eTe four
cl,_ms atissue m the case, throe b_ng
Markn_n
Hearing
rea_t_
2
using
3
both
Page
10/25/05
4
unde_tand
Two,
5
6
thffertm
km_
of language
al leaut oca
combma_oea
want
of e|eme_t$
a jt_ge
to tn_lu_
m those
v. ould
mvRc
4
from
to cat_e
6
the
$
8
for all of those
Three.
and
combmattor_
I think
Mr
of ¢Icra_ts
Cook
alll.m_d
to the.
scope,
you
12
otammatton
13
tom,tiered
woeJd
process
And. also.
1 $ broad
clash
17
ClRImS _
the odds
at le_t
to be patemable
14
16
rmrtase
some
mvahdated,
10
clam_
would
be
still
rc_oo
a
have
narro_
er
a vahth[y chaJle_ge.
an m mdependcat
clatm,
you mtght
have
an
18
independent
d_om
that mclud_
featm_
A. B and D.
19
t_pemk'nl
claim
that
feax3m_
A. B and C. and a
20
thnd mdepetxlcn[
21
the conmxm
claim
thetr_
mclud_
ti_t
hamg
nxlude_
featm_
featm_
dual level _lunnna_o'n, bin you would ba_e other
23
cot_m_atmra
25
a sl/ategl
to mcte_¢
c use of the cla_ra_
the p_x¢_uon
Marknmn
yo_
have
Hearing
crc_s
examination
points
Ijttstv,
ahoul
In_ itmg
MR
theme,
in _ach
of
causes
I think you can
all Ihe patvat
w_1¢
one
mo_¢ th_n
to the
10/25/05
MP.
MR
At
clmms.
c[atm
m the
would
meet
onc_
Several
tleanng
10/'25/05
Page
respect
JA
0809
You_
Hono¢,
o¢ further
I
qu_sl_
[o that topic
First wc_l
have
No,
I ha_ c a couple
of more
anlcdt0makesm¢COURT
We'll
mterrup_
us lo ask questions
HIGGINS
13
Q
14
pomtmg
15
YO_
Honor,
16
now
II states
17
tab 75, hot _tualiy
18
if 1 may p_ss
Don't
wony
We vail no[ ha shy
Thankyou
Vc[ywell
HIGGINS
Donng
the
opening
statcrncnl
oul of a pazhcu]ar
THE
documc'nt,
we nccd
to pass
in the
exhthlt
MR
B_
23
Q
24
the -
cersmn
23
mean
aaythrag
up to you
book
was some
m an affichvlL
the joint
thai joint
lab 75 ts nol xncluded,
appendix
appcnthx
and
*s
_t's here,
that up to youS'
COURT
so you can
22
there
underhnmg
HIGGINS
Wcii,
I'm
f_unthar with
the
go ahead
All nghL
HIGG1NS
A_ a pracucmg
terms
may
patent
attorney,
be cmderhncd
to you as a patent
Markman
Pagell5
bmc,
the Coral
Areyoudonev_lthdlrcct_
BY
MR
thts
from
HIGGINS
THE
21
sysg'm
avadable
with
COURT
12
20
bc tho
HIGGINS
qucsbop.s
Ca_
19
v.*tth that.
So tfs really
by the attorney
ar_other
B. C and D.
B. m thin car_ would
22
24
theme
ClrCUll that
law
THE
]1
the
art
if for some
you wo,ald
wOUld w_[,_l
SO even
of thee
o_ er tho lloot
four. m hUgatmn
wexe
that dunng
Dr
9
*
I0 th_ you would "-w_t W - by including cl_'ns of thffcrcnl
l|
thfth_
5
thffere_t
chor_
NIR
3
7
to look
of the
Why would
2
that
otju_
7 c,_rmncr _o undertake a _ cry broad scorch of the prior art
9
look at all of
Markman
o f thenx
you wc_d
requtremcnt
theme
0O116
I CilCnL
so thai m hopes
ma[ e_ entvally
24
make
and that ,_ ouJd be IL That
113
Onetsthatyouw_ttooRcriexprc_theclatm
the examiner
apphcatton
25
6,9,
00115
I
patent
cal]y
wig
a comraon
of the lamp
a{ the common
throughout
23
all _h¢ patent
a common
the-re is a conLro]
So looking
nlIes
application
thai ffyou
In the '066 patcnl
first
bc a common
thai do no[ ha_e
see that that extcads
the
m_st
_s no_, the pa_en¢ office
those
21
the opening staterooms of hoth cou_el,
of
are complex
throughout
factlh_ strucrm-em the form of a spark plug _ reclted
Dmlng
of m_ emlon
there
thai runs
21
IL
of umty
of pa[¢nt claim
hhal -- there
but llenetally
if there
For
20
Even tho,_,h the engine _tselfisnot reclted,the
and [o
lv, opnnc]plesatwork
office
the other is a mat[_
II
For example, you might have a clalm thatsays
_o the Corn1
s_'ateg_
And
Umty
I thmk,
Is the patent
12 included m the claam ILmltat_on,tbal th_ suggt_ts
11 or by looking at ftmc_ons or pans o f st_'_tcturc
thalare
Io _hal question
Carnal_
does
the
fact
that
in that dcclaral_on
attorney')
Heanng
10/25/05
Pagell6
114
OOH7
O01[s
I wh_c,
2 mzr u_3m'_em
¢¢_nm_g
3 W]_._ _
U_ su_cd
4 I _
fins Is Scc_c_
$ _g_
p¢oc¢¢_,
wMr.h = Gu: Bthl_ by
m c_c_c,
_cs
_uUon
h_
3
m stmc why _e'/t_:
(t d_
_ cbm fy Lh_ by mu_
a _c_m_
stztc_md
4
_ to why
Othc_v_
o_cc
c.d]c_
7
_
_v_
that ducct_,,
_hat _e
r:_porm_,
withom
at0/
such •
_
fllow_
rchcd
on the ht:to_/or
Okay
As•de
ftom_c_derhnmg.
tkat when they did the c_mt_uat_on
_amma¢
9 ptedecr_or,
- thai
_II
tm_*nc_¢-_ts md so foak
T_COURT
ths f'_l remz_
8 tpl2teatxoa,
9
are _[0we_
_: ¢xm_mer
e. they ty_cally
_uom,
6
7 su_
If ag cl_m_
oflendree_
1302. that tf _cT¢ :s _)_u_
m the r_n
for _tar_9_
2 _ccdcn.
coaa¢:ted
,v*_
DF.._ or Heath, the
submdxed that decbra tmn _f those e*vo
l0 md_vlduals
II
u_m_4_
_
12 m_c_,m_
dc_Lr_v_v d_ums w _'_ _J_ed,
o f _e*_
m a _r_lr._trm
_he m_r e
II
mhm _cl _y the
And
1Z set'on
how do yc_ mte_t'et
_vll¢_'e tl_ _dedining
what tilw
a_pc_%
stud m the
gad what w_
the
I_ pmpou: m'_t?
14
A_
1_ c_m
dUL_11_LV=bcm _md_u
| r._'t c_cm _h_X ofa_ I_C¢
when: arty
t¢
w_h h_s cvc_ bcm
It w_a _bmt
IS I_a_g m_nt_m
red appar t-r,dy.
_
th© d_t_dan_
*t
sxt_mltted _Jon 8 wuh the
w_
16 contmmn$ appht_JOn _nd this prier m ofNtppon
17 und_I_mnB m,_
by _omc uJ_c_vn
pc_c_ m a Fa_c_ t
L7 been ermned
AJad_0 _= d=f_t_
IS
19
TKE COURT
W_f_
_
doc_c_t
called?
t;'m had
m _e first ap_tczdm'_
19 the &ffe'rmc_
n_hn_m
bcr=*_:ms the DESA
d'a_wa_ to point o_tt
pmcluct o_ the Hc_
20 product and the Nippon p_oduct
21
AIk_e
21
22
_CO_T
Sm_'nmt
o f R_so_
F_r
22
FirSt. [ have fll_t_lt[y
23 _a__mr_
or Cdm:c.d
24 d_¢nr._
2_
Markman
00119
1
And
2 l_
q_e
4 art. and
abo.R d_ff_¢
embodm_at
_ between,
tn an _nvcn_na
¢mtxxbmt_t
_
Pege
_
Claim
OO12O
I dodt
fro" _1#
e,
a I'a_
_-.q fk:J h_t'_a
,_J
¢s opp_cd
L'.'¢ Fg;¢
about
frg_
between a d_
or product th_
src
Hearing
10/25,_5
Pagellg
have : 297 m "/$
2
MR
H1GGLNS
4
THE CO Lr_'_
Maylll_dmyc_ytzptoLhe
of prier
! w_dd
hk_ to f_d :t m bae.
5 Can _m_on= cJs_ hdp me? Ls_t m _heb_nde_?
to •
LhCprior _I.
tKa¢."_¢
oomm_ts
_lMII3Of_
w,th s_d t ptcce ot pace
Markman
Ard i f !,oa Ioo_ _ t'_P::_ In _":e _
9 rcc.d'. _
they are f_na_
sUbmlttfd
pc-o#: m md_ to _ptmn
that m_y exit
117
m use thai
m a way to d_stmgmsh
6 commtretal
10/2_/05
m thos_ _cla,'a_c_
it's ap then Io fi_ attorney
m fom_llc_
7
oP.c_ they uw.hde
o f mforala_m
'_ a o_,'aercacJ
Hcm_]g
[ have seve_l
THB _
_
ceg_dn3
6
_
COOK
7
_
_]GG[HS
S
THB COL_T
9
M_I_
I I 279, 2E6 _
13 oumb_,
14
hn_-jb¢74mst=_uJof75
Oh. I _polo_.
IA 287, did _
Y=_
_)q
We'[IzLr, oberefcn_'_
2S7 _ he rm'_ e'r ex_ms
his o0rnmmL_
Yom" Honor
TH_
COL,_.T
_
COOY_
Yr, a_ I se= -- Fm Iockm8 m _=
I$ J,'_
16
I _tt_
17
b__
I ¢.Jal [hld d1¢ refuen_
H]GG_$
18 I1_1 flo._ to Ot:joml
19
TH_
20 •pp_s_x
your
_3p¢_hx
V41TI_SS.
TI'I_COLrgT
22
MR. KIGGIN$
_
R_k
T$ at appendix
18 290, _
IA 2S7
not _he_.Lu_on,
G_es (ho z_raR_J
by _he
19 I_w'j_'?
b¢_mnm 8 on ,_n_t I,
Ira•aramaic
prd warn,w/_¢_im_t
_A2g'7
tubm_tt_d
21 I_vy_" where he pn_'_J
/A •
22
[Itt_geltafh_
to the patem o_,m
TItBCOUP,
TTI_COLr_T
_-m'n_a
Okay
23 Icm_:= m=,_s for gcn_a_
oa
24 Aprd 2._, 1c;96
25
Yr.z_
2S6
21
23
16
to U'_ In h_'_
Hon_r, if ] may d_regt yo_
24 in.Crz,"cd,'adhld on is dc_:tcd
T
"i'm_:smT_
ycum:sayta_
Markman
Hearil_g
25 no( _t _aLL_B [he ]a,_p _LI
[
IOt25tO_
Page
Inzddl_on.C[o_m
and oo_n_og
JA08q0
h'_ puL_s
al IC_Sl _vo Of more p_]s4:_
Maria•an
I19
t_
pulsc_ ¢_:h _me _$1ve
He•flag
10/25/05
Page
120
OO123
00121
I have
been
counted
2 tbo ir_ttuctlon
3 Claims
2
6
m_.nual
manual
THE_,qTNESS
8
THE
COURT
THE
WITNESS
9
that you
I I clatrr_
12
13
one
of the
14
15
16
feature,
I I and
m the
I $ be re lets
to ', anous
claims
which
20
ins(rucllon
manual
21
ir_tnlctlon
manttal
22
23
ate
thal's
S the
Claim
clearly
are
recited
chain
WITNESS
25
THE
COURT
or
ttt 286
in the
t6oftheongmal
Clatms
HI ha_e
to look hack
ThLs ts -- Dr
Carnal
_,larkman
tlearmg
6, 9, 10 and
ha_e
you
P ige
10/25/05
I I of the issued
patent
THE
when
5
onpoge7
6
number
I look
Do you
THE
THE
THE
Imedtawn
14
COURT
I'm refemn
S to
and thts
-
'* ould
be
Idonthaveth_JA
Okay
And
da
you
sec the Claim
16
COURT
THE
WITNESS
MR
HIGGINS
there
s a C _tth
a
or¢lalms
for the
And
If you
Yeah
_,hat
does
Geaerally
that
that
atldl0throughl2
17
please
20
ha_e
21
through
22
_',bo
halp
I beha'.e
COURT
No,
softy
to Claims
I'm looking
Your
on JA 278,
amendclalms
15 through
H[GGINS
TllL
COURT
t7
I through
3
5
correeL
Whal
does
anything
MR
17
Thats
does
_hal
in suLt we do
so _ hat
knows
that mean
about
HIGGINS
The
25
Claims
2
t2
Claim
2
Claim
Those
Excuse
s discussion
claims
me,
[ knob
aboul
for cerlam
Ilearmg
olher
x_ay
10/25/05
around
Claim
Page
122
2 became
10becameCkam9
3
THE
COURT
4
MR
t, IIGGINS
5
THEWITNESS
to conclude
Okay
All nght_
Okay
whal
nfthe
only
in here
first thin S thai I '*ould
out is thai there
and
13
chime
this
to be pointed
II
Claims
i Anybody
suggest
10,
mean `/ We don't
not ha'.e
24
Claim
corr¢cl
PleaSeddet¢Clalms4and6through8
MR
Clam16
us _ _th that _ Claim
that's
[tsays
- In the palent
guess
74,
canceled
amendment
add
I v.as
attorney
LO Claim
12 which
clears
Your
relying
on the
whtch
became
16
includes
That
saying,
speoficallv
lL up
Sol
Honor
ts that the
declaration
_. er,.
12, v,h_ch
the
became
pulse
counting
to other
cl liras
hnlltalLOn
The arguments
12
and
those
13
hmltatlon
14
meanl
means
the
15
clam_
I'm going
JAIgg
contmuatlotl
- this
to refer
the court
and
Thtststhelnde't
_ ere
not directed
Cldlnl_
do nol contain
Claim
2
And
al all
ts a htslo_
of whal
claim
THECOURT
HIGGINS
So 16 became
Thatls
24
THE
WITNESS
Okay
25
MR
HIGGINS
And
12on
Lhat page
_
correct
you
_,larkman
v, lll also ste
Ilearlng
Claim
6
10/25/05
Page
which
IL was allowed
THE
17
273
_ hleh
18
paragraph
the pulse
20
_. ith the
21
feaLure
22
disclosed
COURT
toward
counting
[ guess
the
instruction
and claimed
Don't
24
lri of some
25
mSLant
those
sort
apphaallon
words
end
JA 0811
at _A
sn
further
testtag
a pulse
counting
o f the s'._ Ilch as generally
instant
ha_ e som¢.
thscfosed
_ The declaration
Markman
123
back
says
$'Aitch in accordance
did not ha_e
as generally
l_ as not rejected
which
In addmon
control
operation
In the
6
I m In.king
deciaraL_On
manual
false
Claim
example
th,l[ the energy
to reduce
23
became
as one
_s the actual
5
L9 demonstrated
appheatlnn
_ hat
MR
m
_
HIGGINS
THE
I i
my copy
are right
Anybody
apphcatlon
It did become
16
e_et)'oneto_additlonalpage
hacam¢
MR
Honor
16
10
Yeah
74
lthlnkClata116mayha,.ebeen
COURT
ongmal
prehmmary
9
"_
On
Honor
it
19
20
16 m the
7 arguments
lhavegot
it'_ under
JA
[s _hal
TIqE
15
6
-
WITNESS
18
23
Honor
amendment,
ts canceled
17
22
that
WITHESS
through
THE
15
21
Your
Let'ssee
al the _ cry" bottom
12
16
74, you
$ threcled
Ii
13
have
THECOURT
there,
COURT
THEWITNESS
O0124
I became
So
about
lab 75
Markman
that
9
I0
WITNESS
at the prchmmary
theprchmlnar/_-raendmenl
7
8
THE
$
2
3
Under
Ill
2 on--
4
7
23
what_
bilking
ours
19
in the
0_123
I hccame
Your
I$
by the
described
AndClalm
became
page
or suggested
stitch
CARNAL
14
not thscl_ed
on the prevlotts
or the
COURT
DR
12
2, 10,
are _e
THE
13
Claims
I think
5
II
regarding
CARNAL
Ihavegotit
10
16
othai" fealures
THE
argument
Yes
9 canceled
is
all of the
the pulse
in adthllon
not thscfosed
24
to make
manttal
look
THECOURT
apphcatlon
regarding
IO features
if you
bets
compa_ng
257 _
4
6
manual
I'm tr:ng
than
makm
On Io say
19
poml
rather
Lnstructioa
So -- and
not
ahead.
manual
12 ate dtrected
suggested
17
YourHonor,
Tha
and
he go_
clearly
to the
ycs,
it _
DR
3
manual
inst/_ctlon
be's only
chants,
Then
LO features
round
2
In addttton,
Yes
thai
to the instruction
I
in either
the Nippon
Go
will see here
cotmtmg
itself
be refcmns
is that
7
10
device
In the irk_ttUCllOn
tsn't he - v, hea
Instruction
is not d*scfosed
12 are thrected
or suggesled
Well
featm'¢
nor the
I0, 11 and
4 dlsclo$ed
5
Such
dpphcatlon
arerl't
and
the_, _ or_
clam_ed
itself does
Hearing
of
m the
ant
limit
10125105
Page
124
00125
I b_c
pulse
cotmlmg
to
one
2
THE
3 co¢_
WITNF_S
v.hlch
goes
5
clam_,
_
6
hctc'wtth
7
on to say
amended
9 or by other
I think
dtstmgucshad
fbat uxcs
fca[utc_
THE
COURT
THE
V,qTNESS
12
took that gcncr'Z
13
the claims,
14
the - _hlch
15
spcctt'_callythept_ecotm0ng
a_
Then
is -- became
whal
wtth
Claim
thsclam-,_
24
=rgtcncm
25
poise
COURT
filed
5
MR
HIGGINS
to Clmm
to tbe otbeT clatm$
on that $cquem_
to all of{he
comat#.g
claims
fc_tzrc
whtch
3
THE
speak
right
COURT
mlO th=t
MS
m:ke
MS
6 Q
7 never
been
Mr
ottploycd
8
A
Thaf$
by the PTO
9
Q
I f you don't
v,h_ch
ts a copy
H
^
Okay
mind
would
that one
19A
13 thesel_oceedmgs_sC]aLm6
14 A
23
[he
24
BY
25
Q
Page
23
funcuon
24
Q
25
"m_"
m
that clann
Is 0_I
agree
appea_
first scoot
means,
yes
m mcass
d_cs
wdh that
ttc, tiprarc
plus functmn
SCCltOn
I t 2, paragraph
Is_tstatedmamcaraplu_
format, yes, It ts stated that way
DO you agree with
me thai thc claim
_¢s
the wo_d
m it?
Markman
the bench
be refemn$
to first binder,
the cla=m
Hearing
u_es the word
]|236appbes
Yes
Turning
to the _ccond
elemem,
6 _cads
Second
semor
f_
means
10/25105
"mean_"
Page
m d,
|s that eor_ccl7
the
second
delecnng
el_m_t
a second
conchuon
8
A
Yes.
9
Q
It go_
on, con'¢cO
I0 A
Ye_
II
Q
Agmn,
12
th_e's
a presumlmon
became
that clazm
that Sechon
uses tbe word
*mcar_"
I 12, paragraph
6 apphcs
[3 Is that coercer?
correcO
If you mean
don't
th.at way,
only
Q
SLxrt$ 0ffco_OoI
It_
up on
Okay
4 A
17
And
6,1
m tab ),
Tbefi_t
6 rcad_,
can s_l thcm
$
And
scc _at?
A
because
the fom_
Yeah.
22
And
I6
18 A
21
Ye_
2 Q
Letrr_seelflcan
17 do _
format
OO128
] A
Y¢_
fo¢_onthat
You
WITNESS
I will probably
7 prcdctc_amed
tsthatcca'eCt?
in Clmm
COURT
3 0-,_e'saprcsumpu_thai
exammctO
wo_d
all out7
Markman
thalyOuha_c
if yoo
now
MITRAKO$
Q
elc'm¢:_t that =ppca_
Q
THE
MS
be be]pfu]
want to
15
Q
19
iI*you
14 A
_6
sure
mind7
125
thai you
al tssue
area
the
10/25/05
open
THE
22
a SOl
a set of
Patterson
me IO gea them
If you dodt
Yes, I do
I_
20
You want
Q
21
it's clc_
o f the clmrm
Smc,
Mr
the boxc*
of the '066 patem7
You tmderstand
Goodaflcmoon.
tl may
to p_ck you up
#case,
COURT
Q
from
I _k
as a patem
you.
THE
15
mind,
of
have
bnng
up to the wlmc_'_
don't
sort
the w_me_
the deputy
the bmdc_
coacct.
10
12 Q
concct
th_
I bavc
removc
thai included
can
wc mtcnded
May
18
when
so we can be sm¢
P_n.mnl
bmdcP3
Honor,
binders
but thd nc_
M[TRAKOS
Okay
13
Yore
a flcrnoon
4 Okay?
5 BY
of cxhtblt
] fyou
Hearing
Mlwakm,
Q
12
Good
has tab I IL
2
II
EXAMINATION
MITRAKOS
Q
00127
I
BYMS
A
m my
Pa_stbe
Tttankyou
17
cxphcttfy
Markman
YourHonor
16
scrnt
only m the one claim
Okay
CROgS
10
20
to apply
Ve_welI,
Cr_s.cxammat_on?
14
t©clmtca]
o f c_ cnts,
not be proper
made
v. hmh
dzdyouha'0¢
(Moveshcadfromsldetosldc)
with
that fcamr¢
=ncy of thai par_cul_r
arg,JmCnt
to
thing
fcatmc
tbe telo
v._
16,
did the nghl
_¢ f_c'nce
it "_ould
did is
Caxnai,
A|I right
THECOURT
g
fcatt_c
counting
CARNAL
9
It spcctficany
D)
v, ;tnt_
7
feat_e
12, the c [_.rn thai included
n m the pulse
And t_ed
22 judgment,
23
THE.
the altccncy
and upphed
to a chain tbal mchz]cd
that -
21
DR
4
Okay
m this case spc'clfically
I 8 rcfcvcr¢.c
feglm¢
3
_ $[aung
counung
Okay
qut_tlon_
m the
arncndmcm
the dccl_raqon
So ] thnak that the auorney
argue
recited
THECOUP.T
2 any
ere m the claims
Stalcmcnt
and dssungutshcd
20
_
by the pulse
_ hlch
II
19
ha_ e to
Io the r¢_l of the sentence
m the prehmlr,
l0
17
you
g
thai #s clthcr
16
I think
Or _hcr
In Other words
$
I
Well,
thai v. dh rcfcrcnce
4
00126
cl_zm
Hearing
10/25/05
mmmg
to the
element.
elrcml
lg A
Y_., ttdoes
]9
Q
And because,
20
the woxl
thnd
I _pologiz¢
elcmem
once
ngam.
JA 0812
tbat cham
clcmcnl
"means', tho'c'sa legal prtstm_aon
21
l 12, p,_rngtaph 6 upph¢&
22
A
ConccL
23
Q
Turning
24
see, con_'ol
25
Bccat._e
the word
,._c_
that .S¢cuon
arn I correci?
_o the I_1 elemer=t of Claim
_lrCUl[ m_v_
6 -- or
That eler_-m
m¢3_s?
inclod¢s.
"means _ ts mcludl_
Markman
Page127
of Clmm
foe thai
_
6, again
It g0_
we
On
in thal clemcm,
Hearing
10/25/05
Page)2B
126
00129
[
00130
thcrc'salegalpr_tm_lonthaESectwn
2
applle_
3
A
Y_
4
Q
Now,
5
lawsmt,
8
Q
9
also
12
9, t0 and I I a_c also
COURT
I apologh_e
at _ee
I'm having
f_
] beheve
cxa_dy
so
sure nght
beheve
LhaJ.
a bard time
m dos
hc_ng
To bc hon_l
Q
I _mk
A
[ doP.k [ have
15
tha_ says 6, 9, I0,
aboul
18
22
BYMS
23
Q
] m nol
of my memory
on one
report
copy
of my !_tten|
Notl2,9,1Oamll]
Tb_e'sno
Okay
loan*_find_epa_-agraphm
you &d mentmn
that
thwmg
yore
MITKAKOS
agrecwtth
24
v. heTe the word
25
_
A
2
gcncral]y
]ftt s followed
3
Q
4
ha_e
5
A
"_cs, l do
6
Q
You sLalc the use of the term "mear_"
7
rebuttable
8
term connot
9
the presumphon
10
apply
it ts, y¢_,
Now
me _t
m Cla_ms
"m==tr_* appears,
35 U S C SecOon
there's
I t2, paragraph
9, 10andll
a legal
prcsurapUon
6 apphes_
Markm=n
He_r_ng
10/25/05
Page
by a fm_cOonal
language
v, htch
thai*s tn_e
atpa_agraph26
ofyourstatcmento*doyou
that handy?
w_umpuon
_
Now,
12
wheth_
13
A
14
t_[
15
th fferent
16
slatement
thai
s_ct_rc
to one
l donk
legal
statement
that
legal
is tha[ [he claim
19
peyform
20
A
the function
21
the term
22
think thal they
23
is suggest
24
Q
25
claim
*denolc
rect[¢
su fficlent
the c_-ses
Structure
h has to conno_
s_'ucture
2 skall m the art ne_e_aty
3 Q
And
4 re_ng
the way
m the clmm
v
use the
_ some
generally
term "r eclte",
c_
tir_e the
all mean
some
tc_n
the _amc
They
g _
the stated
would
agree
has [o do more
than
_
thmj_, and
w_th me that under
simply
connote
Markman
1
And
1
that
thecase
law
stnsctm¢,
Hearing
the
concct_
10/25/05
Page
130
connote
s_ctwc
_c_ent
s_citn'e
to perform
dos?
2 A
fm:c Uon.
the clatms
can r¢c_¢
cxphcl|
lthmklha_ereadc_s,
ye_
Toax_appar_tts
3 such as th_s_ i can'[ necessarily say an apparatus such as
ts by
4 flus I'm awa_e of cases thal refer to dungs other than
[he
acts
They
I,_gua_e
l0
of str_tul'¢_
II
Q
12
of [he language
proce_
15 acl,
Or o0_
s_ctme
sttffic_t_
7 suggesl smu:[ure
aze used
refers
m prcca_s
pattmt the spe¢lficahon
a_d thai does
ftmcuon
Io when
nc4 epp_y
patents.
wouJd
m apparatus
me_
and pl_
_md tn a
ha_e
to set
claims
forth the
as we have
ldon't--lcan'lag_'_wlththaL
lthmktf
18
there's
language
m the clann,
19
¢laxm.
sn't_tu_
red,aLton
20
takta3 t 08ecJl¢_
m the context
21
m total wotdd
sugge_[
22
=_, sff_ctvx¢sufficienttoper forra the St_cd ftmcuon,
23
then ff_al*s -
24
Q
whether
any of thee c.ascscome
m mind
as you s_thcrc
I0 A
Tnc names
of the casc_? No
II Q
Yc_
12 A
No. I don't donk that they do
13 Q
Mr
H1ggmsaskcdyouacouplcofqucs_onsabout
14
claim d_ffercntlaho_ Arc you aware of the ]me of fcdcTa]
15
c_rcultcases thathold that thejuductallycrc_cd doc_nne
] 6 of cla_rad_ffcr_attauon cannot o'_Clyde the mand,_¢
16 h_7
A
Do
9 tod_y_
the exist ence
p_.thaltheactsp_ruofl
you just used
ctaxms
s_gxl
g Q
f_nc_lonal
v*hlch compote
to perform
can be
6 mtcrprcted by a pcrson o f ordtratv/skal]In the art to
_ hlch
can rCCllf other
subsm_ttn_
Ign'tllw_e.Mr
ftmcnon
o_ otha
Theydon*thaxetor_-ate,dlof
S_
9
25
I_se
s_ct_rr=
you
129
to one o f orthnary
to per fon_
7 com_teth_so,zctt_
17
cases
"connc_
5 specifics_xucmral language in the cla_rn,which
6 A
14
use
to
O0132
00131
I A
13
use
the
t_L
mes[
Sorrt= cases
not
cases
thal'_
_sn't a u'ue thai the language
18
does
of the regal
thfferen[
but I think generally
of the
Well,
112/6
if a
In the
am I co_ecto
that - you know,
language,
sktll
a
er
t¢_t to delermme
I 12/6 apphes,
tt's a _ e_" general
[ thmk
Howe_
of orchnary
and Section
thai Is not the
raises
I 12,'6 apph¢_
is rcbortcd
Sccuon
17 Q
but I behe',¢
Doyou
1
11
but I
I 1 and 12
MFIRAKOS
report,
you.
are a._ed,
co_ eTed this m your
WITNESS
MS
your
II arc
that
THE
19
best
a note here
THECOURT
d_tc
_l_
c_ms
to _c
you have
10;rod
corre_f_
now which
th;t_$ correct,
16
C1_-.%9,
m Urns lawsm_
14
20
tssue
Fm sorry
13
17
_
t_ffec['7
IOA
11
Clmrt,_
THE
you.
p_ragr_ph6
Am ] cortecf_
6
7
ll2
Are
that
pz._es
you aware
the Claim
rect_
fm_cuonal
m the claim,
of the _p4_lfiCat)on,
to a pe_on
the t_t
of a_y
language
of o_thna_
_dor
ca_¢z
acu; to _
Markalan
m the
all of whtch
If
skdhn
the
apparat_
Heanng
U S C
Section 112, paragraph 6'_
Ig
A
Y_
19
Q
I have no fu_
20
THE
COURT
21
MR
HIGGINS
22
THECOURT
23
the law
0_at apply
17
24
the test of
c]aJm such
10/25/05
25
as
Page
Mr
Patterson
MR
Thank_ou
HIGGINS
qucsuons
Okay
JA 0813
Any rcthrcclO
Nothing
Allnghl
fmlhcr, Yore Hono_
Youmaystepdown,
Ncxt w_mcss?
YourHonor.
mayMr
Paltcv3onbc
excused ,)
Markman
131
of 35
Hearing
10/25/05
Page
132
0013)
l
TH_COURT
Yes.
dOy0a0t
[V_ C00kw_E
2 /¢£¢_0S
3 ha¢?
Th.tnky_m.
OO134
I
Mr Cook -
_okcc!0Mr
I$ I1¢ cxc_co _
COOK
,_
$
THE WI'O4ESS
WI_
(WrrN_SS
4
"['1[_ CLE_*_
would l¢ Ith= m¢m do wxth
MS
MITRAKOS
8
TI_
COURT
those.
_
MIL
II
'_I'L.'n_suewll
HIGGINS
Your H_-,or,
II
C0t¢Ic. only dur[og the demotion.
bc dora2 v_z_o - wdll
rFl_
"(HE_
8
I"HE W_TNESS
9
I_4_ COUR'P
_d-'o
I _ vldeogr_ohcr is now g_wni
"i'H_ COUR'r
14
15
16
_._,
Wdlmm
Irll ] Inmk Oal the
AI thu _
THI:
COURT
MR
FL!CK3[iq$
Wdhlm
Rap_IieL_Sl_
may Ija$1 require ix_.e_u_-4117 when
19
hh'
20
h= II r¢2_y tO pC_Occn _o_¢_0mor_ [r3flO_.$, C_1 h¢ jtst
22 [,shin or wh_'cvct Ine tout[ wff,hcs so thzl Ins can do th¢
THE COUP, T
25
MR HIGG_3
Tee
_
_o_, your Honu
Markmna
_O12L5
I t ¢¢imo'o_y
:_
Faamm_'s
Olril_
md _'_
with "aar_
AI3Ct _lmg
flo_l
lO_S/OS
Hearing
Page
my j _lOr
I ¢O_lUlllt
) Pai¢[o_ For aa _.dd_oonzI Iwo y_'s
ofs¢,.ca_
'_th emphas_
en_
m earning
ng
sen t ol year_ _| T'F,d [ worked
lee2miclan
In GI_ mdmmM
ink
wl_teh was
Jolmaoa Wax
tedmolo_'
wa_ a h:afan$
4¢vdep_
for mdasmal
uze
m mk jct
I hell:_
Markman
_
In the _rea_
and F.a _men
field tot Po_r.lo_, [ocorpotau:d,
Stau_ l_tcloa
_0136
I
of
01"31_, LLC.
o f A_cht_¢lu.ral
aid
133
d_Em
T'fU
Board
dine _1 as cl¢¢Irollcs
Z_ [:nn_n_
laa
]Produ¢ll
and mlcro!lloc_o_
I an _ re_pst_e.d
19
24
an afl_ha[o
Uaw c'mr_ m 1991
23 d_v_zon of $ C
14
Sp_:llh_
_rom T¢'aa_te
22 J¢l _anlmg
23 c_nor_zr_llc_n?
DESA
e._l eaSmeeaag
In ad_uon.
_
_
ta e_
w_th the Teaeeea_z
21
Good aRcmoon, Ymw Hoam
bachelor
12
20
thai m the cot _'I .m_d the_ cmr.c dow_ here _0 cw, zme]
P_per
My_elsWlllmmRa_r
ofdJgqQl cll¢_o_rl
17
YourFl_,beinm
C_vm
Go<x[ afternoon
my u_d_trad_
I$ "r¢¢hnoin_peal
RRx:O
Ald,
= Wdh_ra
I r¢¢¢tv_
14 dcl_.¢
plamDffcalLs
My _,m¢
Olr.¢n, Kearny,
13
t5
I$
)
your rmmc for the record.
l"amk yo¢
TKE_
I Z _owh_
I'm¢
_s
product _g_lccs"
I I scllor
Raper
|7
21 _'ul
tO
mcas
bc dom$ R. o(
r_z_y [o vld¢o
Thafs
HJGG[H$
this u the _
_c
7
9 not oa, ¢on¢¢_
l0
SWORN
WAS
6
Youc_nt_.vedcm_crr.
.lust le_vl
_nd r_s¢ you_ ,igb¢
$ pl_s_
6 the* binders?
?
Pk_© s_d
3
No, wedon%You_Hoaor
4
TH_
2 h_L
PlRCl_on
ploece:
FD.ari_g
m_Jude producl3 m both hgh_n8
the
10t25/0s
Pnge
134
and
On 11
_ _Jl eh¢[n c_l
4 eagt m_r
D_lng
th_ _.n¢ [ vr_ - [ Sta_l_d wnun8
6 sofiw_¢¢ ¢0 IC_l my m,d0_,
7 d_gn_
on a sctf _
d_l
_d
$
microprocessor
programrmn 8 IX_LS usm s C and. C+--
7 _o_wsc
! pt_p_'n_m n8 hn_,_
9
Aho
10 brains
13
S _e
prior to my po_on
Tcch.n01_c_,
12 Jet p_n_
_ DF..SA, I also worked et
Incorpormd
9
thr _x y=ar_ a_ _a
Tethnologlcs
14 d_v¢l_cd
both m.qwam aod h_r_e
I$ In_CCS
md _L_
_pptlcadcm
m_d Potion, I
for _
_
IS Pnxt_
re./-mzed _Jtahon
_ad O'_,
19 Tob_co,
G¢_d
_
o'.k
I1
p=do_lm _mt m thss_e
]2
wbllltlle_i
I_
Sm_ com_
to DESA
S[x_d_
d_" myseU"
Io the U S
the 066 !:_.
of the
P;mmlNo
US
$.S92 066 so
- m the Inlinw_Ilg]sbls_lo_
2_a_'_J
_ O_1Cskilled in [h_ ¢inc[l_tc_
arl off.on
]¢znl_l J_rOalrc,idm_ I_¢ 'C.6_ pai_mL
"[_
fl 'czk,'Zcn_h
O_-_=s
of D_A
Fodu_
a r_:x_
_h
{mpa_
I6 _
S C Johasoa
19 _
20 W_
21
$,592,066,
ca_
ume
Ph_'u9 Momx,
Ft_lbps L_g_un&
m _s
c_ I co_
I &d aol F,_'uc_p,,_te m the ob_g
13 _r{_c_
_Hn 8 oon_p_c_
with conip_uc_
C_zmp_on
E]cemc.
imd _Xl_en¢
sbUed m the _rt re,bye
Pateat hum_
16
17
_ f my e_ucauon
of[ooor_
10
B t ¢chnok_/
Winle g _
Pnot _oh_stebrcm_l, Ircpo rledto D¢_qu
6 Caracl_ who lus prov_dr.d _ decl_rl_on
Produc_ ov_
five
ca_:l
DESAL
D,z_l-Bnle
Lm_
(0r _0se [l_d_cLI oFDESA
is a
Du._J-_n¢
which 0xnlon
20
fo ;*low _*vel ol" _¢r.¢_1 hghl hut Iulomalic_Jly
Zl
bnIhl_"
_[dusk
swdch to a
level whea [oe de,nee del¢¢l_ moi10n or a p¢_G9 or
22 obJ¢C_ SuCh_ a c.lt
23
24 for _oduc
G w_uch _n: c_mUy
on the m,l_ el Or _'¢ _out
24
AS pa_ of my duu_
DESA
I am
fcmt3t_r _,th
_
,_ el_:_¢_l
for
_g_n_
the dc_J_n and m_ufacr_Je
¢i"
_5 Ou.d _rn_ mo_ou scxsm_ h_
Page
135
Markman
JA081_
Hearlag
IOF_S/OS
Page
136
00138
0O137
I
The purpose
of tcsUmony
2 Court wdl conducl
3 Is to amv¢
a M_rkman
at a propor
I motion
I underst_J_d that the
being
the purpose
inlcrpreLatlorl
of tbe clatm$
of the
4 '066 palenL
5
In prcpanng
for the Markman
hc_ng
6 ] noted [hal the case rnanagemenl
7 lutona]
porhon
m this c_c,
plan and order calls for a
to cxplmn tbe '066
patent m'ld its rclcwmt
art
] behcv¢
11 Icchnologyistobufdslmplcdc_lCCStodemonstrat¢,A
12 nature
ofalcc_eal
stgnal
sensor
components
signal
may be coupled
Io a lamp
6
by the
use ofa
orcull
7
oulput
13 gcncraled
by a motion
14 actlValed
_,ben $ep_mg mollon,
I $ generated
by a photocell
16 sensing v,u3qng
17 daylight,
ho_
18 the motion
at rcsl m dayhght
levels of hght
including
to tbetr outputs
and be_
20
pholc¢¢ll
21
;lacontroletremtloglctoproduceaDual
22
23
and the signal from
In prcponng
23 sc-'r_ors menlloned
Signal
14
demonstrahOn
I_
invlle
[6
setting
of
a signal
from
the
sensor ¢_n be m_cd
potlton
]amp, 0ashhght
bulb
in the '066 palent,
need
to depend
upon
llearmg
10/25/I)5
the -- ts the _ tdco
Page
MR
HIGGINS
Video
4
THE
COURT
So maybe
5
video
6
this part oftbe
bcmg
7
And
8
then ifsbe's
9 can
taken
for beth
tfyou
all will
called
MR
furnish
12
and
Carnal,
13
ftxmlsh
upon
an audio
as
we could
and
a copy
the video
depend
autho
upon
portLon
to Ms
thts
Does
Vcrywell
a co W oftbe
of the demonst_
gom_
to be explaining
Dr
we,_e
now
at the
begm
Inlend
C,u_al
down
Okay
_s also
Th,tnk
Okay
COURT
Yes
And
words
and
are _mshed
the time when
you
the
take
Ihc
"_our Honor
lpresumelhewlmcss_s
,_ he docs
THE
v,e
thai the _tdcographcr
_tlon
H[GG[NS
[able
_.h_,n
Goabead
This
-_ [ rcqueSl
MR
1o sel the
of counsal
lake but a second
THECOURT
v, ork
wtth
Yeah
confers
golngtotrylotakedo_n_halsbecanbear
the courl
16
the mtcrophone
19
hold the
20
h's v, orth a try
thln_S _
_ourHonor
I'm a hltl¢
For purposes
concerned
abeut
of [11¢ record
It could
Ilearmg
I0/25/05
Page
138
The court
other
mtght
of
Maybe
you
MR
7 wtmcss
per sc
be
l0
counsel
from
Court
going
22
MR
HIGGIN5
23
THE
COURT
24
MR
H]GGINS
the
to be
No,
It hal
hts hands
16
htt]eblttycomponenlsthalhchasher¢
do
goofC
Honor
22
vldeo
23
Markman
Hearing
Dr
C_'nal
24
and
2_
as
10/25t05
Page
camera
THE
You_
and
HIGG[NS
]9
presented
table
as he's sho_
I$
do_n
and Dr
may
COURT
t_ Ice
HIGG[NS
THE
COURT
JA 0815
it
Carnal
Page
140
that a_ he Is
them
[s th,lt
thc video
mg ii to the
f_rst to [he
acceptable
Court
i
just
get
_ Why
does
i
There
may
nol bc able
be time when
the field
to p_ck up all of the
Thal'swhy
Let s try to not have
That's
the _ hole
We
thts thing
Ihmg on
our intent
Ihc
is to do _1
I_lce
My
intent
Markmal_
139
the
to suggestions
_ hy can't
I cl's Ir_ to get
MR
begin
_c
the
that he show
Wcll
could
Okay
during
nol on
ofcotws¢
lo the _ IdeO operator
thing
MR
- before
component
of the _deo
21
end ofcotmsel
then
It
th: bench
each
Is correct
subject
¢ to be IX_o processes
at alp
ask you Io come
and
17
thai
of course,
Andlhc_ldcolsgomgto
That
starled
"I H E COURT
used
W_ v, fl
H[GG[NS
m_ suggestion
and
the _ hole
could
Okay
we get
9 x_ould
15
that
Ask questions,
on the experiment
6
20
Is the screen
only
13
ts
may
THECOURT
14
else
you
I I demonstrating
things
up to him
and
process
but tbetzseof
reporter
because
be somebody
Ibe]texcyouwfllbeablctoseecxerythmgthatls
Bethrc
Io the Cout% to Dr
IO be th ffieult
_tth
there
microphone
from
entire
she
Lclmejustask(TbeCourt
reporter)
ts going
to be busy
3
12
15
I suppose
needed
of
for you _
Wewdlalso
video
_ell
2
be trained
Cole,
proceedmg,
that
I
4
the
to counsel
14
s_t aortaes
ha_ e an audio
to transcribe
from
THECOURT
are going
does
the video
HIGGINS
I I coursc,
25
Honor
Marknlan
record
get the autho
10
21
_.ldco
Couri
hearing
should
We
137
well _
3
17
"*ldeographer
20
up his
resuh
e lo the sensors
M_tkm_m
- th_s end
HIGGINS
19
picking
oulput
00140
I be we'll
Ig
MR
2_
or PR
0O139
2
IS
24
,Lnd the bare
a sensor
e a de_tred
Oka_
h _on't
THECOURT
23
slmpfe
PR detector
Markman
thJI up
photocell
my de_. _ce IO the
Your
al the
[7
22
of the
I ha_ e bulll
up
Ibe Co_trt and
21
Bnlcrcsuh
m this c_e
24 d¢_ tccs using a bcstc
HIGGINS
a lamp that _s
a mollon
for the tutorial
Mart, man proceedings
COURT
MR
of
such
Io achle_
rcsponsl_
of tbe
HIGGINS
THE
and the oulput
how
the demonstration
]3
the absence
can bc coupled with
MR
ph,_,e
12
and then
finally,
is
and
to the [amp
lulorial
where
signal
Ihc motion
to demonstrate
and
tbe ¢l_clnC_l
the output of the photocell
scr_or
19 responsive
C
the
I I place
stgnal
$er,_or at rest, no mollon
and
and coupled
during
of_th
¢onlrol
I intend
I0
tbe
B, the eh.'ctrlcal
as an output
Sensor
an c}cclncal
5
9
patent and the talc; ant
d_yhght
ho_
4
9
In the aleclromcs
photocell
sho_
gcncrated
g
A_ one sk10ed
and
My de'_lccs
3
g technology
10 Ibe bes! v, ay lo teach aboul the '065
_ensors
2
of _ htch
is that you
Ilearmg
no_ do it
10125105
00141
] trace
00142
I
2
MR
H1GGINS
3 Honor
rlIjust
4
THECOURT
That's
what I meant to say, Yore
hand the mmrophone
Okay
to F,|g Raper
3 oscdlc_cup¢
YouallnughtwantlOCOnm
MR
COOK
7
MR
HIGGINS
Sure
l would
add, Your Honor,
8 dcmonstrauon
has been the subject of a depc_uon,
9 the defendants
ha_ c scan flus d_moo.swauotx
t0
THE COURT
II
Okay
17 c_
thefirst
which
dower
120VAC
20
ts whahi'S
Okay
stgnats
13
ts cormcct
normally
showyouabatteWpowc_lstgnal
22
cormccted
23
actually
24
now,
so thaws flyer
25
bat_
So chats
K, the hnc
n:ferrcd
the z_-ro re fcreace,
up
2
so rm
volts
s¢l ax a 2 roll
I hate
a Wplc_
two o_:
and Mr
THE
COURT
Raper will
Well
5
THE WITNESS
6
THE
"7
(Laust, m
8
MR
COURT
of comic,
THE
COURT
MR
HIGGINS
24
THE
CLERK
25
MR
HIGGINS
thc-m
10/25105
Page
Murpby's
make sure thLs th=ng Is
we'llwec,_do_at
Well
Are we ready?
Yt_,
Your
Be seated,
Yo_
Honor
plez_c
we had a wrong
Honor,
Markman
I
he's m court
and
3
things
qucsuon
_
ts do you
COURT
No, jml
MR.
HIGGIN$
Th,mk
13
"_IE
WITNESS
some
Hearing
10/25/05
Page142
you,
Yore
THE
COURT
17
THE
W]TN]_$
Andv,
sa-nall
that w fr tm'l f_l On the dL'v=c¢
Okay
W]'¢I
I w_ml to dr,_o_stntc
harsoathtsboaxdts
firs1
mmplyth¢
Cook's
a_d the devlccs that are needed to bias
to as =ts normal
w=ve
24 w=thou[ ;my mouon
my h_d
mode of uperatton
over,
of my b_d
you ,_ _1 see _t
And
around I L It win
tfyou
it
let tl sit
Setl_¢ down
state..
Markman
Heanng
13
hghtttse¢_
14
It slowly
what
10/25/05
Page
143
up _d
a photocell
and
o f operation
you wtl| set: ts the photocells
And
what
dm_G-_s,
so
dcteeung
l wam to do
ts
and tt wOl U'ansltson to
m_ OUtlml based
on the amo_l
AndlcanvmythaLaswell,
with
item ] have
thai level
t$ simply
16
bulb that we conn¢clnd
to two battenes
17
th_
¢ztheg one
18
oper=tethebuJb
bright
Now,
by $clectmg
YouseebrlghL
AndlcansLmuJat_
ha[tc_
21
=rid what I want to do Is use thLs to implean_t
22
components
24
It's also
dayhghl,
25
pumng
the cap on
ctrcmt,
what I've destgr_cd
Is rust a vet7
to make
a dud
bnghl
very
light
few
go [ want to again
parts
on it,
all of these
system
stL% the light LSoff
The hghl
to
Okay
20
NOW, as tt pr_enLly
Okay7
a fl_hllght
0¢ both
m Lh¢ nex t dcrlmns_'atmn,
$=mpl¢ control
of
byapproachmg
my hand and change
the third
s=mulate
but
dar_e_s
by
will come on tO bright
Markman
JA 0816
of
slat=
NOW,
23
to a
an object,
a variety
neXl ts hook
v,h_ch ts -- again,
to pul li m a noem_d mode
So that provides
19
tlm
have
use
with.
what I warn to do
a photo¢¢n
We also
And we could
thing
it up to simulate
15
19 PIR d_vt ce_ which you saw a pmtm-c o f r.arhe* m Mt
up the morton
Now,
12
was v¢ly
-- okay
dayhghLsotfsatorgstate
I I a thffcrem
Hcmor
thing
can see whai iI does
8
so v, © got aII thai ftxext
16
Wh_11
the -- a devzcc
9
pink up
Since the signal
._"tttrt _
15 thai re'ads the raged,
21 what we rcf=
6
I 0 cover
THE
F¢_entatto_t,
demonstrme
wamt to
_ just pink up from
v,e ]et't off?
Lsthe PIRbo=d.
Now,
5
law
ts the
to do thai same
4
law
the begummg
where
you see the same
7 we
HIGGINS
[ had to c.harlge
And
2
)
12
25 normal
You_HoncLmaylsuggeSlthat
141
there has to b¢ sore©thing
II
picks
Oh
Yeah,
23
expL_n.
Murpby's
9 have the demo start fr0m
23
The
Your Honor
recess
{Break)
4 wrong.
22
from the dc'posll_on
Thevtd¢o-excuseme
'ITIECOURT
22
and a half voh
Ilearmg
If the
at the
;rod we can*t get t_=s working,
r ecer,s, and we'll
21
ts
scale
hane_s" signal nghl
3 ready to do his ck'me_tritton,
20
HIGGINS
-- (Court
00144
I button pmhad,
t8
COURT
MR
20 take a 15-tumult
00143
14
THE
19
ce,er and
The market" here
what was wes_nicd
was nol vtdeoed,
16
Isthzscxactly
(inauebble)
18 ready whoa you come hack7
lfyoullnotJc¢,whcnl
jumped
okay
he,z_ng ) ! was _kmg
HIGGINS
15
to
ts switch
Markman
tO whm_
MR
14 deposmon
om of the wall,
Ma_seng]llup?
Cen_n]y.
thfllculty
I -
Just a momcrd.
presented at the dcposmm
17 we tak© a shoil
What I want to do now
21
THECOURT
here
12 maybe he could play the video
looks hke here m the
wave conung
SO
! have
MaylbnngMr
I I deposit=op., and if it were,
ts
o_ the outlet
SO thn_ ts an AC
7
8 what w_
to the actual po_ _ line to show you a
16 slgzzal of what the etccmcal
19
YomH_or,
sign3],
small signal so that when
wrong
I 0 dcrnor, smauon _s exactly
I have do_¢ to start off with
15 the _clIklscup¢
18
a vo'y
COOK
9 reporlcr tnthcalcs
used m ouz field to look al cl_;mcal
And what
MR
and so
I ha_ e set up here for you ts an _cilloscupc
13 commonly
6
flus
Okay
THEW1TNESS
14
to show
5 connected something
6
small
4 let's see, I have got tt too faSL 11 s¢¢rr_
5 ovo"
12 thing
NO,V, the $¢TLSOroutput _ a very
2 what I have done ag;un ts adjust the sc;dc of the
Hearing
10/25/05
Page
144
00145
I mlually,
thcnltstabthzt;s,
2 doa_kr_og,
thehghigccslothm
rfyouc_._sccltt'romthctc,
3 d:m
Oka_
4
When
back _o &m
6
THE
COURT
THE
WITKESS
g angle.
So by _slng
There
II
stages
an outpal
of hghi,
12
Might
be haixl to tell from
¢l_¢ml,
_n omp_
and control
the thnd
Grcal
Now,
THE
WITNF_S
17
THE
COURT
I8
MILH1GGIN$
19 rcody topickback
20
na_ce
ofcongol
THECOURT
22
MR
&ffercni
23 of the screen cap_z_
24
I beheve
thin -
Raper_snow
stalcmc_
okay
Thedcmothatyoujustsaw,
thai are m hLs repel
ull
v, cvc d¢ items
Atthccmdofhlsstalemcnl
25 w¢ have the ¢ommc_aal
¢mbodunent
o f the device
Markman
Heanng
thai he _ dl
10/25/05
i_ doric
componcnes
by designing
in such
a way
]3
arranging
e]ceU'omc
14
capacllors
and
15
othcl_se
manlpul_t
16
a nc_
conffol
17
acu_lty
and
18
achieve
the desired
22
the available
23
'._ hl]c al the
24
the lamp
25
motion
Io
through
output
such
and
v, hlch
_
the hke
flora the
1",]3¢
circuitry,
resl$1ors,
in scrts¢,
the desired
is produced
final
lcsulL
m_, ol_ _
outpul
In the
scale
or
acllvdy
is
inlo
a result
controlled
of such
componcal
IO
r_ult
dc_ ice thscusscd
A
have
day,
above,
the lamp
is reduced
reduced
hghl
level,
r elurn
d¢61red
bulb
the lamp
change
the
in a sccunt)
the lamp
v, hen
]c_ el, C,
illummallon
of
_ cnl such
In dim,
Markman
be turned
dimly
1o a p, odetermmed
dim Io bright
is dclecled,
the
I]ashhghl
to, B, IIl_hmmal©
hghl
from
e a desired
such
e or lr_nslalc
signal,
are,
way
¢lrCUll Io
clrcmt
components,
coupled
the
as
other elcclTomc
of electrical
amphficrs
In the slmplc
off dunn8
and
as to achtc_
nature
and cont_olhng
components
a conlrol
o f a conffol
of sensor
21
aerially
arra_ging
in a certain
of sensors
_c_ ¢lopmcnt
the
clrcmts
rcsug
the outpul
20
of my v*orkday
creating
as
illumination
Hearing
10/25/05
Page
146
Page
148
00148
I when
l;'¢
2 ¢
mob;on
v,_
;'_s parsed,
hlhl
g_
and,
rclll_
E, rci_
the
lamp
to off
I
Io he
2
conslstctd
3
¢olunm
4
accl_rnphshed
In i level liedeleimmtlt
5 dayhght
4
A*'_Do_ddcszl"c_r¢sDll_F,
hgh_
bc act_'alcd
6
Results
7 comioclcd
8 sca_
photocell
I0
b_ _x_k,
II
13
thai
14
Inc_z_d
the lamp
dlmng
_
by haslng
or coupled
LScleric-ted,
the powez
lamp
b_
Igow_
D is aC¢OmplLghed
by m_
17
pe_od
18
detecung
19
dlsconnectcd
flora the lain!3, f,o thal now
20
d_
_o O_l it _lows
21
_hshed
22
the lalltp
23
moaon,
_ayh_l
F, or add_uonal
_Lton
not bc a¢'h_'gled
dmaly,
result
Markman
senso_
it Is being
is deified
set forthabo_e
nbj¢Cli;_
of the
8 through
22,
by m_ simple
The follo_
_e
066
palctlt
and thal those
de,.:ce,
_ tef_m_
9
THE COURT
I0
-- isWl the timer
11
coanecimg
12
¢¢rlaln
13
v, ithout
14
ser6or
15
counter '7
slaled
in
obp_l:tlV_
although,
admlll
ed,ly, I,.ol
clctectlng
THE
1o the
further
sens o_"m fed men the conlxol
if I may,
22
triangular
COURT
THE
WITNESS
MR
dayh_L
25
CamaI?
gale
_
output
isn't
Ifs not.
and
switch
The only
right
v, hlch
HIGGINS
Youi
that particular
JA 0817
or-the
mouon
cl_cml
output
via
does
of the
the photocell
the _
trmet
here,
m this
connected
cl_uJt,
to this
ts a comparator
Honor,
portion
Markman
147
Ihal if a
that the pulse
This
The raw
W¢11, whafs
,s the
by
of 01¢ motion
lamp,
an it
is this ¢omponcm,
looking
the
No,
counte_
such
d_t_ctlon
mohon,
from
aceomphshed
selene
ager
WITNESS
THF
S_msor
motion
eiap_ges
18
21
me on hoot: the - what
(o the moaon
pel]od
explains
10
Show
is disconnected
scr_or and the lamp
Page
IO pa_c
a ura_
time
that he sho_
10/25/05
diagram
A_th_clrcull
no_ has ¢ the pulse
23
by
¢lrcml
1?
20
again
mg clcct_cat
8 thagram
24
Heanng
the
thesirilplcd_iceasdeslgncd4bovc
19
or disconnect
F is accomphshod
s_
is
fl_d by
E c_l be
Lmcoupled
that ther_fl_
_lth
2, lines
16
without
md mull
Ix'tw c_n the moaon
whoa the phOt_Cl]
t:_
_me
o f th© moaon
the photocell
Io U._ it off'6hen
I_
of the motion
the o_tp..a
by having
ReSult
24 having
s¢lg¢or b'ueh thai i f a certain
eflcr dclect_o_
_.ch
-- by conx_¢ctlng
a tml¢l" to the mouo¢_
phot_cll
the oueput
to a lamp
to the lamp
16
fmlhe_
to
on, bul ortly Io thrcL
and the
elapses
7
is predelermml_l
which
motion
R_ull
6
the }amp
I_iolo_ll
L_Off, buI, two, wh¢_'_ tl_
of hghl
C m aem.omphsl_
see, sot
by having
Nolg
$ _s ©fllciemly
the day
th_.l, _m_, wh_112_
L'Imp "_ll _e
mouc_
whc_
15
_
della.is a I_¢1
A.S a refuel,
o f a PI_
moiaon
A and B ase accompILsho_
t/_
12
to_otb,2xc_
by _
to a pho_ll
daylight,
9
25
cl¢cffonlc
a cl¢_ired
Page145
00147
5
Much
invokes
12
19
at page 8 the
PageS,
Ihalwercdcmonstrat_toyou
c_glneer
I I _derst_thng
Are you donc?
Okay
WITNESg
coupling
The
Ibchcx¢thaIMr
HIGGI]qS
a¢comph_th
componenls
Honor,
Okay
and
6
9
m tinct
cucuth'y
21
5
10
a photocell
Is thai right?
_pw_thhls
_1 electrical
This
sc_ oral more pages of your
your
4
inlercoimO:l
15 stalcmc'a_
16
TtlI-
8
Thanhyoo_
this go¢_ through
3
7
VezygoocL
14
THECOURT
yore
the hgh!
as _, ¢l]
2
we ha_e implemented
being da_ hght
THECOURT
13 Okay
we go, okay
the ¢onbol
9 a mouon sea_so_ providing
I 0 V_o'q d_
btafl'sng_ow
I wa_ ¢ my hand ov¢_ it, iI v, lll go Io bnghl
5 and thin
7
00146
t de111o_lral¢
]
may
l also suggest
of the clrcml
Ileanng
to Dr
10/25/05
OO15O
00149
I l_obxbly
some l'olh_'.u_
,_7
Am
tO the _.S= CO_
Don'tthe-/do _
DR. CAY,.NAL.
THBCOtjp.T"
_I_
I v,tcng canoeing
NOl (o_s
Okay
_'t_c_ sol f'or p,_t t'_vo or three sco_n_
"i_
sm'rc l'tmc_on?
V/t T'I_fP.SS
$ to sc_ d_c h_¢
Doy_w_rllo_k_y
go b_ck d_n a_
Notp_l_uL_rly
7
THe. COURT
I
DP.. CA_AL
T_:C_U
I Sur._
would _o du_ aS,_n.
12
Y0u mI_t
not _
_=4cS
22
the dlm_nanon
or _rr.e_'u
r_ll_kcth_
23
sc_udP/cvcn_,
_r{E _VI_
Wc l_ve vn_tr_ clme=_
24
In h_ d_u_._ Irauvn,h= s
25
DR
C.AR_.&L.
v_n_on
Pot
I thinkI¢s_
Mar_.m_o
He.flag
_
10_d0S
Page
co_l
thu_, _rvo _conds,
The_
back _
aS_un
l_I rne go back _ _p
to C, o_
V*qulcz_ the rcduccdhghil_d
of thc bmp
ch,ln$c
fl_rn dan _o br_i_ht when a
I r- modon,
u_i5 _c_on
cJrc_uy
(s d:icctcd.
ts dc_cr_b,n_
_'or G_ p.l_t,
the m(wc
oi" dxc
nE_t, or LSthxs JUSt m
_arkman
l
"I_
3 _h
_h ,s n v_'
'J_I'N_SS
_
T'_s tu de_'n _S
_cme_,_/1_n
_s
clrcu_
of CLam 6 or _J'e
TH_WIT_
H_Hng
O_y
2 o/'the _mp_e
d_,ce
] have
._ thcM_kYrO_
hr.4rmF.
4 acoDmpt_hcs
thc rnam _'Ictlon_
$ _md thc obJc¢_vc3
I0/2_,0S
Page
150
7
|
"ITF_EV,_'I'F_S
9 s_.a_
I0 m h_.
II _.e_t
c_tn s_il _ck
Thz_sue.
up those things.
BmthemoI._n
If thcr_s
_t_ really _ookmg _o; z du_gc
Th_
_m_t
| c_rcml _¢
a chnn_c
m h=:u, so iI _
I0
_ _
cx_mplc
A person dulled
t_mg v. c]14mown
14
" S_C_._E_I
m dm clcc_ronlcs
_u_ompul
Pale
152
that Is
Dining
m
t_c _nal
I v,l_l $cI up and dcmons_te
16
_al
modal accompbsl_
For _:¢np[_,
Go_.
Pa_¢
151
_cr_uJ
21
¢_* lock o_I d"¢ dual bn_ht _,_e.
model
The comn_rcml
fli'nmll th_
_4
modcL
rmxlcl ahso has morc
the dJOdC mid rcs_or
FmTJ1y, [_c co_ml
of A
t_'_
ha3 much mo.e
L_Jul_ and include= a n_..u_/ovemde
_5
i_ul_
o_ bmlL
the commc_c,al
switch
wblch
_oph_snc_cd
oJ_:U_l m Lv_cSLmpth
model
Marl_nau
JA 08q8
basic
m_d a rnorc sop}u.._catcd
20
2_
This
d_c _'nc
thc _impl© d=v_cc I h=v¢ _t
22
['or
,r*a thS,_d c¢_ E'ol c_OJ_l
thg_ _.I componcn_
Lhcopc_anonof'modcl$_ISdu2Jbnghtdcvlcc
19
_t o0u]d
,n a mulb_l,Lc o£ way'J
i_
18
Goo_.
pn_ducc
con_n_| _rcu:t
1"7 _tuou,_h F _ set _or th abovc
O_y
_my pu1._:
c_rcu_.
o_"ana/oS ¢omrol
thc components
12 mcludm S the ,rnp]Cl_t
TH_COU_T
o_'dual "0n_hl _*chno[o87
m dw conuo!
I I *rnp_¢'m_nt the _
13
_a_r,8
w*]] d_11/_l_D'_Je =LI
N0_thalth¢c_z_ol_tr_.ut
9 ¢o_tmuo,,L1 and m1.1Jo_o,A_¢0 tho mpuL
thc_o thm_s.
16 r".._c_.._.._---._d._-_d.I_'_
Th_,sacoa_olc,n:nd
l_nll _
ot thc '0_6 pmcm wlthoux
6 counun 8 component
25
_o that we c*_.n
,I Eocs
_ot52
2
24
- wh_'n bc p3._ c_ k_
*twiH ca,._= the h._hl Io rcm_n
149
00_51
the I,_hl
clzp_¢d.
at boe,_'_
Now,
the _or,
That _uss_
_
THE COU'RT
21
22 c_.m plc,m the car_t_=_
2-3 m_ul_
thc umc _
20
$o .sl_vcs the I_t ac _ara
hc
C_Ch It g0 _Xlt.hL $0 l_c h,_ a
it mod_ *t So b_hl.
19 al_
_h_
hzvc z Umcr
tsn I thax flghi?
DI_ CAP_A/.
18 see _
t_vu }_ppcncd
&dr;t
m It, the msum_ l_Is h:md _oI beyond
17 _'_Shl _or m_othcr three
pc_odo_'l,_mea._@.emc_on_l:_S_:d
i/,t
11
16 h._._d o**-crthc _or,
_n'_ WT'I'NF.SS Ifl-
I nccd _o Sa blck :x _:cp
"what would
I0
IS
DP..C.AP_NAL.
y_
one= thc motion
h_s h_J',d ov'_ the scr_or,
I._ t_rncr m thcrc,
21 _
Vc_y mm_nal_
6 SCrl_Cd.
P pa._cd
19
0r
c._.,Your Ho_"
0fl_m olanythm_
DR- CAY.NAL.
¢o/_,zt
2SO
thel_r_
C"
has _ p_
H_r,
ng
_oun_
10/25/05
00153
00154
I component
2 num_t
In a co#to]
The control
_rcuz_
4 produc[
Is b_st_lly
g 2A _d
I
the potential
2B
7 sphlm_-o[o
facdl_tepnntmg
MR
I 0 _hcr¢
diagram
Mr
Honor,
Rapor may demonsLrate
3
hghl
Is Mgh enough,
at figures
4
don't
think Ifs --
been
patent
the commercial
device
THE
COURT
13
THEWI_ESS
14 a more sophlsl]c_t_
15 con_olctrcmt
16 Inttl_ily
Okay
Okay
vcrslon,
ifyou
I $ mltlally
_dl,
he_eha_e
of this b_ic
Thlststhecommerclalmadcl
Iw-n It off I ha', ¢ a pl¢cc
17 sensor so it wdl think
19
Yo_Honor
When'._.¢
of _PO o_ er the l_ht
tt_sdark in the morn
comes on, it comes on Io a full brlght
Ancr
the ctrcut_
20 s¢[tle
the light
21
go if you'll
22
up
23
you _ ould
(Paine)
24
mo_on
25
1¢_¢I
wdl go back
indulge
Okay
and the motion
me a mmule
up wdl
tc_le
The presence
fact
thai Claim
or absence
enough
lO
THECOURT
I I
I Ill
12
mlerpret
the
13
m formed
14
of the '066
15
function
that there
terms
The
electronics
20
to me
Sensor
meaPs
As
le_elhghtmgthal
or detecting
2.1
DESA
and pre_tously
24
Jncorporaled
28
mterchangeahly
Page
go
[ don't
But
device
up no*_
patent
al ho_¢ I
I have
o,.er v, hether
to he interpr
eled
_
been
certain
means
terms
ph_
ten'ns
t interpret
a person
art, the lerm
sensing
10/25105
at the lime
m the '066
or slntcl_tral
21
and any
or --
It wouldjttst
Thankyou
is a dispute
are
J
the terms
to me
19
to a bnghl
normally
Picking
follox_ m g is how
identified
off
tt go olT m tx_o stages
Okay
_sed
patent
azrth]ent
and go
m thts room to do tt though
WITNESS
terms
m the room
ff the
dayhghz
the commercial
22
6, v.hen
read
o f cel_am
is for detecting
structure
g
and
connotes
eXIKI the adthllOl_al
6
detract
7
when
g
colleagu_
9
mezaxs"
I0
from
I am aware
"sensor
that there
skdled
I used
are many
connote5
sensors
eleclncal
at Imaging
these
m the
means
in my job _
153
structure
directed
to
engineer
at
Technologies
ierms
"sense"
/glarkman
I read
or hear
Control
12 structure
13
ck'_ln_l
14
desired
t5
circuit
the
they
meara
to me,
that
and
_
at Potion
deleCZ"
]learmg
10/25!05
5 control
6 of desired
To me and
my
7 presence
"sensor"
clremt
and
8 circuit
"sensor
Page
154
skilled
the couphng
of components
[0
m the
16
_x:zmple
17
mtertormecllon
Resistors,
THE
capaclto_
IS accomplished
COUP.T
el celcra.
by some
Is that
hard
form
"¢.rang,
of hand
._
WITNESS
Hard
wiring
_act that Claim
17
x_rang
from
stales
THE
TH E WITNF.SS
24
the components
25
memo_
COURT
flsp flops,
In a digital
et cetera
Page
156
e
con_ eys an adth_cmal
componcnL_
the desired
so they
means"
of the word
' means"
connOtalton
_e terrzt "con[roi
are the same
are _S_nsI_
e
rcsull
does not
that occurs
to me
lomemd
circuit"
and they
arid
con_rnl
both connote
22 sLructure
Okay
.u'e physical
the
to the h_mp and responsl_
of my job ,_ an elecmcal
the st_ctucal
20 my colleagues
Your
21 circuit
23
the
or prohthlt certain
6 in IL_ entirety
in_ ob es couphng
A nd the addition
18 detract
Honor
22
number
to me
16 to sensors to achle'.e
An
not hlmd
I apologize,
in a chip
and arranging
19 _henlrcadorhearthetcm_"contrOlClrCmt'
THE
code
of
infinlle
condluons
to accomphsh
A slgnl ficam porhon
I S engineer
wlnng?
20
to accomphsh
c_rCml means is coupled
13 structure
a
are physical
amplifiers,
posslb]c
or absence of certain
l_e
14
the components
ofien embedded
12 Io _he firs_ and _econd Sez}$o_ me_s
or
result
circuit
bln_,'_
Ill a
results by u_tng sensors Io sense or detect
components
l I control
' connotes
to accomphsh
_lth
or progr_
9 actions
structure
means
or other controller
circuits
to me
As a porson
being
not
in conjunction
sequence
I am aware that there are an m finite number
that occurs
both connote
Struclure
tnterconrteclton
term
does
by hard wl_ng
m a preareanged
3 microprocessor
further
v, ord "means"
art, the tez'm "control
In an analog
18
and
I accomphshed
2 ¢_ecuted
that
4
connotation
in olaf exponence
electronics
motion
the term "sensor"
ate the same
slates
The
to me
of the
the structural
conthtlons
m Its entirety
4 conveys
21
it s hght
18
fleering
g the I_rst selx_or means
19
mOhon
think
Wdl
off
00156
I
II
be sensing
sensors
00155
2
No
we II let iI set
_e hght
?,larkman
WITNESS
s[alu5
see ouLszde _ hen II geL_ dusk
_ plc_s
COURT
[7
Io a dlm le'_ el
Andthlslsthelo_
typlcally
_I
SelIl_
it
sen3e
THE
It cannot
enough
of labe
TFtE
16
So _hen
it wdl
g that ts the basically
If the
if iI s hght
that piece
6
g
_e arc al the point
hut ff I pull
5
"/ off
Cou_ wIsh_?
12
know
gnghl
thafs
of the '066
Your
I don't
or not
Fig_2Aand2Bsel
em_xhment
HIGGINS
Nov.
2
dual
m the '066 patent
one elec_ca[
g forth the prc_rred
9
of the commercial
set forth
"This Is really
II
to r_luce
of false tuggers
J
6
ctrcut_
also
And
Markman
control
Example
the
Latches
mterconnectmn
I[earmg
23
ctrcmt
S_ itching
gale>
24 electronics
_s
25
10125105
Page
art
means
the lerm
As a person
'Sv.ltChlng
JA 0819
m the
connOleS
stnlctttre to me
Markman
155
skdled
mear_"
Hearing
10/25/05
I_L57
I
I'm _
dma¢ _c a_u_
ddIT_cI_ lun_
_Yt_Z
I
O1"
2 _,g_h_tode,_bv_to_mpon_D_mi_mlc_zcumL
M¢._s
z_por_v©
The a_dlL_l
$ ffo_ t_
0 f LI_ word "I'_,ID
s_u_
conr_Ul2cm that o_n
M_
_0r cat_m_ i_d
_lchmg
$ tl_old
Io amcwhq_ I
mc_
Aga+n, U_
The i_cmre
coukl I_ i _
17
a r_lp
M_
fgx-_x_uctng
20 umt_,on_on
of "lc_c_
Thls
I0 $ v3dely
0f
+i ctm_ul hem& an u_ICtCooi_: tlo_ o(
c_mpomcvAs
1t pro_tc_
two & ffc+cm l_vd= ofvoll_=
the sen_r
w_w.k rc+po_
d_ects
to _x_ labor
Ixml
_+_<'_&n 8 on
tl'a Frecm¢+ or ab_mc= of a
13 e_ndmon
of civic
to b_ aclmv'_
w_e _or_.
r.ompo_c_tl
a rl_tJt
t_ z scr_o¢
su'_tc_ur_ cm _l_r
L_kl _mg
me_s
15 the I_d mol_l wor_
a s_lch
o£ e]ect_c_l
ts ¢_sin_l
t0 ¢.Icc_.._
14
16 compemu:_tswhn_h _
_
c0mp_i
In the _C
9 dPAI_ c,+J_.ut_,
to _
to me _ome
o_ el_oolc
volt_e
12 wh+th_
13
in_c_te
4 com_<m_i
do_ not d_'_'l
7
9
Pot _=tn$
ttcz3o_ _
Far
3 _md "c_ir_"
4
IO $_
"l_u_ _n
b_ a
Whlc._ pg_duc_ a
"[qt_
Sxrt_r_r (o be tmumr except
_'n_mg"
pmtqde In for_=Uio_
16 U',al aEows on<_ skdlcd m t_
art Io latow thtt t_ a
17 p_locd]
dczcc_ IlghL
0t oth_" d_-n_ _
I8
C_CC_.Ul
a_U_S _n_
19 In_
s_sm& _
mc_s
_pOmlV©
for e.a_nns sa_d d_c+hold
20
hay+ a ch_cl value= I[c_e, IL_
;_
_om_on_t
the _ord
_0 s_ud
vdUle
to
md
"rcapomr¢©"
21 ramp wiv_tom_
22
Hole, t_
23 desired
ch_d
l_l_lu.l_
n_d_
__
wavcl_
Io m_- Pm Iw_r_
connc_cs
o f num_ro_
t_ munro&
24
"llus CoYotes
Z_ thcab_ve
M_rle_an
dcc.mcJJ
2 m_ox_c_b_
or dcczn_d
3 tho b_+t I_+o_r
9
mc_dm
_-_
m k_ defim_m'_
<:Ot.m'P
tmv.,+
_u_
was calmn_f
13
D I_ECT
14 1+¥ _
I$ Q
Pi|e
TI_s i; Imp=Lit to
MarCo
157
bang
_
_c
nmpands
Heal_g
1_125_)5
Pile
|_
Q
Dzd _¢ ctzCult or you_ _lmpIc _-vlc¢
_lLt_c
P_e
160
I
Io
A
h 6zd m¢_
+bore wt,_m _h= mmsor
Q
O-.d I_
_cd
A
NO, tZ_bd rim+
Q
O,_. t2m g=uve
A
yc_lt_
a thud 10vd o£vo_e
leveL+ d_cd
v/It._^
IZ
t cucmt
co_pcnm0_
8 d_ _+al_cd
I0
tt
10r_ro5
;emcmre to me
ItmfmtaameP/ofdcr.,_c.tlcom_3er_.
_ "_n_x
m,:=t
o1"y'm- - I_ m'=ml
P+n=t m"
dayfiSh_
I principled
8 bdeB,
c4vcu_y,
.rid Im:duc_
flora dmsl
t_ d_mctm_
6
VOIQ&©m r_o_o
0Otto
00159
I "£h¢ m_m _
4 daq_ml
Hem'bng
a PCS_I t_r_hold
d_ce_
m DE_A's
m._i+'_'td _=r,-t=,
PIP-+ or x,o="
m ¢_'_+ pl._ (umcu0n team
Okay
M P,.AP EP_
h_a
duly _'_
md l_u_cd
12 Q
as _low+.
13 =_ctm_
F_G_+_IATION
Do_
d_ PI_
orl_-r
dwcc
rJmmz+u7or _r_cm
Im c _'+y m+l o_
cumin7
m _m_r
HIGGt_I$
Mr
P.zp_+lh_com_kcd_ouac_Joaabout
16 _=co_tavd_
Is thcread+ffcrc_.cebm_¢t,_
17 I_lSi
c_+mt aJ_ Itm_
20
A
A u_
21
_o _y
2_
of_h_ _mor
m thu cxa.'_pk
25
pulses beau+
=t w_Jd
d_
IS A
Na, _,'+ +:mt=;m_ P+'+_ce-t-V_-
16 Q
/u= a pe_on
17 _l_t. _everJl
pm'uon_ IOyou?
19 you m t_¢ co_tr_l
wo_.ld z,/p_
LECdr_ea: 8o_1
dolled m _e decm_.I
_d
ome_ you r eCem=ciI_ ti'e phr_e
hSh=_l
In your
oC1_1 he=nflg_
y _c sorac+3ung th_ m mcd
offm the example sho*_
21
hc,_
M=tkxnan
A t ll_J:
I I lu:d 12, _£ #w.il" t<'-_.'nl:r_, y"du I,_l ll_
21 turd/
_v_c© v+m_d look Cotm,+luple
aJIo_ _h+ h_l
Q
to tram o.-
tte3nng
I0/25105
Pa|e
Markmaa
159
JA 0820
HeaHOg
IO_S_
{30161
!
0_15.*
_s_'_ly [ n:adCh_
2 _:4 _,,_otud _
2, Q
4 p_
6 a_d _t O_t To_tplnh
m CI=m
I =ecur_
0_:It_b
6
TI-_fs allI,]I¢
qucanerd I have.,Yotu"Honor
I
"rH_COD'P.T
6
Okay
Cm_-¢xamm_on7
CROS$.E3_TION
"7gYM_
Yes tt _s
3 Q
Ard
COO_
Good a_es-_con,Mr
9 A
Creed atlcrno_
I0 Q
Now
yuu rnenuone.41nyour sL_i_mt
I! l_th_ty_u]_J_bclbm_,s_jo_.dDESA
_ nuJnb_ of
lanlt_t_,hr
Tha s corrrcL
_Voulda t yo_ tSrcc with m_ thzt a pc_on who LSan
c=l:_e_r
_s fully abl= lo _d_r_t,u'_d
8 _cc_o[0g'j
OfLP¢ pe,tCnl'_
9 A
Y=.
=r, I th_k so
10 Q
_,ow, m yo_
d_omtr*tzor_,
That's c_r_t.
12 c_ the e_d ot'l]_e cO_l
13 _
And m =tr.hof tho.se
jQbs,_,ouworked ;__
13 p_tc_t
w_lt'7
14 A
L_o, tCs UCL
_J C*
F_gcu_ 2 _t'_¢
t_"A
Ta_ _ cm'rec_
16Q
And tI_ w_s your ,r_n_ns;y_
17 e_ect_
Ig ,*,
_nee_
t7 demor_'at
Isn'_
th_nght o
Tm:_e tsalrtmmg
_o_.
|w=salab
19 ter_nlcnn wluI= l'm_hlng coII¢_c,bUl thema.q_ _
20 bo_uobs
21 C4
! w_
at
Y_, I _f.
24 Q
"D,_nwh_
That L_Correct.
1') Q
._nd so [ _d_e_ y_u wouJd =lpee w,t_ Pr_ fe_so_
24 A
y_u joined DI_A, ye_ _t-rep,_ _ndu_e
25 et'over_-cus_
_© de_t_n ofmoron _,_m
Markn_n
st_lcmgnt LEa you," dL'rno=_mzuo n dc7]¢¢ &dn'L
He_r/n_
I_/_/05
Yes
Page
16|
Mark.mau
thcL_ngsth_wO_ddcl_rnma_e
Cf f'_sc p_mv(_
I Q
in m_Jon dc/_;t_onV
Wc d_d e_._pu_ z_y _l_uun
ct[o.utfy
I=dud.m_
m _t
_d_e
7 Q
Now, you mea_oned
_n_
'_ _l
yoe_ wor_
w_c,
c_cmt_loe_ln_frx
]1
ple_e explain _.hal I -
They
13 0
O_
t4
_
6 Q
7 want to deice1 in a_vancc, and _cn
In th= sc_¢
Ife_.
into L_c _=rc_ul. You _
o_ nmmn_
whcth=r t_
Q
$othcspc_f_cimonnpr_'_nmcd-
le._.v_ of
thee
to me by
13 A
T_e spec_fi_u _ _ det ¢_'rn_ed. yes
14 Q
_ow
I_ 531_
lst(yo_Ltnde'_t.t_bng_Ithal_lCel_:u¢c_
I_ Q
Wou.M you aull [o Lab 60 m y_r
t_
2]
zrc c'me_a _
thmj[p aad not od_
In a con'u_¢:aJ
le_
T_
2O gV MR
the _.'=_old.
2.2 d_vt c=. _¢ pa_en_ _¢
Page
164
|t'_
o_ b_k:bn_ Lbe d_.qce7
t,_k about your
cc_mm_x'd
_ev__. the
_m_s7
|n0_.c_¢ofthl_"_tc_l_c_n_ats
2f} s_mp_y rr=e_n_
rn advice
t:m'naa be.ml_ or ce.-s, a_l (h_n ?eu
en_¢'e_
Gen_:_-.ny. a _p¢_tl_catmn wouid be _pv_
_9 f_zzk¢lm_.
you desl_:a 0_c ._c_dt
G_m/__ _nnS_
l0 (hc_r sp¢_f[c.aa_
tl
on wha_ yOU w'a_t to dctc_,
6_t[ somebody ha_ d_c_dcd whe_ _
to d©tec_ _a[ part_cu_
In_u_-e_won_d_-cnu:_za_gtt_
17 dtsqp_ abec_t
to c=JI tho_¢
th_
D_dlhe_'youco_l_'
arc dcst_t_
16 _rae.'_ b¢_
A
162
c._nbe m the s_'_e o f n_a_eting
_h= m respor_e to _¢ _
12 dctc_mm_
_4 c_r_m
Page
cn=m_e,that =¢ d=_q;ned _nto tt or t]_Ju
to meet, _vQuld it be f_r
m Ih_ d_'mo _leetoe
if _'_ h:af met _l'e c_tcna _
I0
e_
I0,25_05
_pccll_ca_n
q,.u:s_on tha_ th_s couJd pck up a I¢zCi f - aa_ I Ihtnk
I_
Hearing
3 peede_-m'_n_d _oa_.oa_'7
pul_ co_n$_
6 A
In th_c
2 t¢$ de=g_ed
4 A
15 d_on
the
cmbodunc=t.
OO164
Ae4sp_:lgc_,ly
Z G'¢ po_f.e
_tc_a
- thzt would
Jt d._s n01c_n_Jncvcz_hln_n
.25 cotrtrn_al
s I_8h_,
_ =rid
_o[63
Q
wh._t yo_
ed?
22 reduce the _e=(_emcy '_ produce _al_e poslUves In rno_on
23 A
J A
pax¢_c _ad _ n_nbCT o¢'.t_,_t,ona/
2L ¢out.un all the _e=eme_that would pm4_ce
And y_._worked _ Im ¢I_Lnf._ e_smc=t t_ _¢
ove_ h_re
t,_blc, that w_sn*t t3gttrc 2 o_"file
13 A
20 Car_J*_
=n electr_c=d
_¢_
22 Jo_7
[ Q
the first
16 _'_J_ cSz._d _J;¢Ults u= _ over _rd ibovc
_ve_ • gntdu_ae
11¢
the *00:u_ L,_t yot_ bruit 2nd _towed
i2 A
14 cle=_¢_ e_int'_'?
c=
lsnt that nghl_
6 Q
I $ d=_non=b'_o=,
_
_o th3t _zme, you had no ex_lcn¢c
u_ lJghung,
5 A
7 el_caJ
8 Q
]sn'¢ _h_ n_t7
pr_
4 backsround
thew_me:_
$
hsh_._.
2 A
are dcsl_c_J
14earm_
10f25/0S
Page
COOK
Wl_ch b_nde_'
23 Q
Itstab60
25 BY _
dcv_.,c, yc_
Th_.©_r¢_,oor
"I_'_CO[_RT
JA 0821
_:eebmdes_
It'_ Voturne 2
COOK
Markman
16-3
_md=_, pl_u_?
IDid you sa_ 60"_
Tab 60.
22 A
24
thsn/p. Lsu'_ that _rr_:t?
Markraa_
Q
COURT
He_rJng
10_5/05
00165
OO166
1 Q
Valume
2
Okay
A
3
27
I Q
"t'}{E COURT
4 Q
Doyouhovethat,
5 A
Y¢_,
6
Q
Do you
7
tdemt fled there,
8
SlmSOr light
9
A
II
recogmze
it?
3
the documcnl
Mr
Raper?
4
prior art.
5
A
II appuars
6
Q
Now,
7
motion
8
that thffers
this -- the
the Reflex
SL
product
5315A,
that's
Iadse
count
Ithlnkllmaybebeforcmytmm
and I notice
12
sugg_t
13
A
10 you that
14
all the mformaoon
tt _
II'spc_thfe
On
see where
17
foreign
18
you See that?
Do_;thal
ptedece_*
of foe patenl,
pnof
docm'ncmts
19 A
Yes
Q
And you
2l
Pubbeat_or_
22
}l_aflvZeniflu
And,
23
SL-5315
coLmI morton
24
1989
25
A
s_
the
art?
*066 patent'
other
!tmbllCaUom?
the second ttern there
the second
serao_
hghl
control,
need
Io study
Igatheryouhavcn't
patent
andllh_q
Do you
ha_ • any idea
how
this
stud_edllprev]ously
12 A
I ha_ e no1 seen this document
13 Q
In this docurnenl,
asEML002087
16
A
Okay
17
Q
Would
18
the three
Is
it's pa_c
sheet,
you
15 o f
II appears
Raper o
read thai to yourscl_
thai paragraph.
paragn_hs?
Okay
Is that an accmale
21
c_mlmfl
de_cr_puon
of how pulse
works?
MR
23
comment?
Doyouseethat._
24
doctmmm
Ye*, I do
25
Page
page.
Ca.nyoutumtothat'Mr
Q
22
10/25/05
on the back
of the trtstmc0on
A
then
HIGGINS
You_
The wlmer_
before,
THE
Honor,
may
I rise
has stud that he hasn'l
and
I flunk
COURT
it's a htt]e
Well,
165
thars
for a
seen
th6
-
a ptolgr
Markman
00167
quesVon.
Itearmg
10/25/05
Page
166
00168
I does
fo_
describe
2
MR
3
gets
4
forthct
5
counting
6
flus vamess
how
-
counting
to come
became
I Q
m tim iment,
,s prqk_ed
--
COURT
_a he
talk abom
3 wtfom
pu_
4
pulse
m-.d I'm nol sure
5
moving
6
W¢11, weql
take it a qtm_t_tm
at
8 aurae
9
hfi_.HIGGIN$
Thankyou,
YomHonor
Very
well
II
THE
COURT
Your
THE
WITNESS
pres4ml
objcctlon
ts
ovemfled
13
Yes
I flunk
n'; a flur
And
18
v, atchmg
19
m front
a PIR,
the f,*g
hne
pa_tve
m frzred
of tbe t_mtcr_e
s4wam',
the heat g_ en off" by an object
ofthesensor
leos
Isthat
m the teat,
dete*t$
motion
A
I0
Q
I!
flung
12
object
that w_
13
A
Fal*e positive
A
Y_
22
Q
And
23
maythmg
24
seen 2s mobm_.
25
A
down
_h]ch
m the second
chong_
Isn't
tbe _
- second
paragragh
m the flutecOon
someone
A
i'm
19
Q
AIIngM
else desires,
.And that's
clrcmt'
aot sure
it says.
22
THECOURT
zor_ can be
23
167
Thank
M.R
correct?
hord
to
a I'aise posture
may
be
con&tion
that's hotll
coffee1?
your
Anyredm_ct7
No,
Yore
AlJrtghL
Next
HIGGINS
Honor
Thanlcyott
Youmay
w_tness'_
Plmnt]lT
we_]
questtor_
furthorquesttons
Okay
Yore" Honor,
the
of the
$o _
lhaveno
you.
where
not tho motion
con_dcr
need
Markman
JA 0822
a
of pulse
that's really
I undo_tand
Well.
IvLR HIGGINS
Page
with
nmtt on of the
Io detect,
the ptedetem_med
THECOURT
10/25/05
sctx_
u; aclually
be a situation
was
designed
Whol I would
the part_cttlas
step dowi_
would
ts somcflung
21
Paalus
motion
ii se_
the signal?
the s_gnal
-- tl was
20
25
Hearing
because
18
24
ts detected
0 f this doctmmnt
Aad a I'al*c pc_uve
into
0rot cofroct?
a rel]¢x
tt says
motion
of the purpose
that'; giving
thai was cattsmg
Q
moves
at the bOltom
that tbe_e _s actually
m the context
17
Y es, _._ w e flumon$1r_led
Marknmn
obJecl
Ye*.
16
20 does?
21
a flur statement
to verify
by
aP1R
down
ob)ect
n
= the object
demnlYaOnwhot
of lime.
moving
;5 what
then
_ m fy that what
9
BYMR
Q
can
g
15
rays
p_lod
Is that
14 define
COOK
a short
cotmtmg
and
number oftzm_
the
cotmtmg,
lt_-_.m._n en L
17
then the -
7
14
16
And
2 that by cotmtmg
v, hot I expect
out are now
tl ts reetted
THE
works
i'm fine v*3th that as long
fult ogpotnmlty
quest*ons
_
pulse
HIGGINS
the rally
7
12
of the
m the palenl _
19
t_
and
Hearmg
01¢ face
document.
control
20
(ca the Reflex
says tnso_ctions
to on
to be the same
from what's
15
DO
trader Other
Ltghtmg,
[he I'W_l _ Regent
flu you
Do you see the
Markman
I0
referred
you ts
that flus ts
to _
mthe53151thaspul*ecOUnlmg
I would
Q
that I showed
It appears
I I that nght?
to the 53187
and then
20
pulse
that's
14 the - or 14, actually,
tt lists certain
patent
I0
Ic;m'tsaywtthoulgomgforough
the face
16
emhodtmeat
then
Is that correcl?
sens_n 8 hghtmg
9 A
the cc¢'Amt_'etal
thalyOt_tc_te.dhere_tratedwas5318
15 Q
mouon
control?
It's a 5315,
docurnenl
for the 53 ] 5A
Got
] do
Honestly.no
IflQ
And flus
2 msm_ctions
ca]l* Dr
a momertt
tlearlng
Thomas
J
Io sea up the
10/25/05
Page
168
O0169
I computer and the sc_e¢_ again became
00170
I that
p_r[of hls tmonal
2 wdl mvo]_ e recreah_1 of the figmes m hls Rule 12
2
3 statement
3
J Paulus
4
been
5
as an cxperi
4
THECOURT
5 LeIMs
Bngg_-/one_
6
M_
7
(Break)
g
THECOURT
9
Okay
l_ow
HIGGINS
Wellt_keashorl[_
_ sc¢_ asyou _e
Yes. Yo_
ready
Honm
Readytol_oceed
Htggms?
MR
II
HIGGINS
Yes
Ptamttffca]k
Dr
Thom_
J Paulus.
12
THECOURT
Okay,
13
THE
Will
14
CLERK
Dr
Pault_'_
you
tmse
hamL
15
(WITNESS
16
THE
WAS
CLERK
SWORN
State
THEWI_
19
TH£_
20
THE
WITNESS
21
THE
COURT
22
THE
WITNESS
the _
be glad
to skip
24
pornon
of my -
25
tame
ThonmSJ
for the [ecotd,
Paulus
_
Good
Good
"l our H ot',o¢
aflermxm
and
ple_ae
you,
pro fcy61onal
I woeld
background
COURT
No,
I think I world
hke
Hearmg
Page
WITNESS
the Um_erslty
of $oence
laY.star
of science
the UmversJly
dog_ee
the University
of
in
of Tennessee
in
m Vot_ are
going
elecmcal
20
1968
I r¢cel_
degree
of Tennis,
I rtct'Jved
19
to have
I recewed
ed my
m el¢cI_cal
to slow
of_cJ_ce
from
doSree
the Umversfly
my Ph D in electrical
of Tennessee
I ha_ c over
and development
42
from
years
engmeenng
of experience
m
from
m the
doslgrt
trtstrttmcn[allon
ser_ ice as techmcul
169
m
of Tennessee
in 1974
of electronic
m_magement,
tmdorgladuate
engmeenng
see m 1962
my maslef
engmeemtg
tha Um_e_ty
2S group
10/25/05
my phi)
THE
17
23
to hear
ed
COURT
bachelor
24
bachelor
from
of science
from
THE
16
22
I have
mentioned
down
21
I f it world
[he aha_¢
engmeenng
my masters
I rece_
18
afr emcon,
Markman
project
resource
Marl_nan
and
and
Hearing
experl
10/25/05
Page
170
Page
172
00172
00171
I wlmess
2
m patent
I have
3
c_es
4
m one
and tmrJerstty
retained
as ma _
fete]
m four
leaching
I
patent
2
be_accepted_expertt¢smnor
cases
wes© settled
7 _
before
8
As aa m_mctot
9
Defartm_t
I0
1965
before
I had
retained
the up_onunlty
m;
to
tha ¢_mart
oftbe
through
I I _
for v. h]ch I was
m the Eloctrtfal
1972.
I taught
le.. el eloe_'ont
a vanmy
t_ courses,
ofb_c
mcladmg
from
as wall
As a part Ume
14
Engmetxt_
15
19g0
16
m the
I have
ta_ht
I am the
_
of ov_
and preflmtalloix_
Addm
19
Apph_l
20
E
21
Th_
22
KIIoX_ql
otmlly,
Elr_.u'omcs
and Mcml]
text
1 have
by
as
clrcmtry
utdtznd
relalmg
THE
COURT
professor
10
Deparlment
11
teaching
I have
Ertgmee_lEEE.
taught
Engmeenng
15
manufagtunng
CIx_lts
Ohio,
19
1972
_dwlthDr
Marknma
Glea
Headag
Yoar
Honor
Just
jus¢
and
on
an adpanct
PEC
see.
Knoxville.
clecU_mc
cottrse_
don[ of Paulus
PEC
the dos_n,
of small
E_g3neerlng
ofTennef,
umiergriduate
the pr_t
a mmute
a second
Computel
UrtlVLqslty
a_d
Adthuortaliy,
ts a small,
development
volume,
high
high-It,
oh
and
perfomaame
eleciron]c
21
and
Dole.
10/25/05
Page
171
conducts
senunars,
to elec_ca/and
[ thd s3Ol paruclpate
prosecution
affihattotl
24
other
No
and
cucu;ts and
I'm not ttlated
with
rather
I understand
tO nor ha_e
the plamttff
thai1 my parUc]pauon
on O_
5,598,066,
the '066 patent
any
or the defendants
m fills ease
that the court
/_larkmao
JA 0823
coth_
clecm3nm
In th¢ pr ep_tl
of O S Patent
Furthat,
23
25
a noted
PEC
rela_ed
systems
20
short
0 f Eleetncul
I
Somenrmtold
I _m c_tly
Company,
focusod
I g _ orkshops
of Tennef_ee.
numaerous
at the
bosmess
22
of the lusulute
WITNESS
gradtmte
13
a mmute'_
thank you
_t
m [he Electrtcul
I'm also cmreruly
17
text hoo_
Columbus,
It's79.
79,
if you _ oMd
14
-youJUtl
it
6
Pauht%
I _n
I _top
16 lmt_xLmerlLatlOrt
1¢
oonally,
Electmmc
cotwsts
paper,
and T J Paulm,
at the Unwer_ty
att._t _
25
tha
Company,
tl_
trade,
from
to et_ctronle_
coauatored
Addt
24
of Tennessee
le_ el electr_tcs
50 teelmtt:al
I F Pierre
Publr2amg
ts shlf
upper
find
CARNAL
9
Elecmcal
at the Untverszty
to 1985,
sermna_
18
ltx_tor
Departmenl
Can
Whalnumhar_zt?
DR
12
13
I can't
THE
Knoxville,
cot_
23
68
Enganeemlg
of Tennessot,
¢xperL
COURT
$
7 Dr
Um_lty
iP._t/_melfiallon
THE
4 mc
o4her tba_
expe_
nuclear
3 can'lfindhzsstatemtnt
b
c2de
The
_
been
matters,
Myte_ttmotayhat
5
17
1968
ts Thomas
Pauh_
ofelecuonlcs
engineering
15
)
your
B ¢ st:ate.d,
23
12
II
name
T J
in ]962
]3
ple.ue
18
6
electrical
with
My
_
ed my undergraduate
1 received
]0
14
6etd
m elecmcal
12
yam" nght
please?
[7
I reeel_
dogrres
9
lO
ma'am
known
in connection
in the
Tet messee
Mr
Y_
I'm professionally
retained
6
7
Okay
THEWITNESS
will
conduct
Heanog
a Matkman
10/25/05
0o174
0O173
I hC_rlng,the pttr_¢
of which L_ tO amv¢
as a force
at a pro_
2 mg'rprctatlonof the clash terms ofth© '066 palmL
3
vollagc
I ha_ e r_ lowed the "066 palcnt,and I tmdcrstand
4 the clc¢_ca_ ci_cutuy &sclo_cd in the '066 palcm_
5
the M adcman
pagc
7
trartsfcrnng
energy
8
foz cua_'Cnl L_ _|"
The pascal alLgSOa dcscnbcs _anous ¢Iccmcal
9 clrculls,
slgnals and components
]0 tutocm] tsto dcsmb¢
My
9
objccuvc m th_s
Vollagc
10
and iodefine the rclcvanl terms and
most
II
22 the '066 palcnL
12
m ot_ dally
13
baltcncs
14
convcrlS
13
Thls wdl b¢ done m stages as we paxcud
snnplc dcmmtslrauon
15
m thsputc
16
through a
of the Icchnology and the patcnl clalrr_
Wc
17 clccmcal s=gnals m c_, dally hves such as radio.
17
I g felt-,
tslon and radar However,
18
th© n_t
conm',on elcc_cal
19 slgnalsan: voltage and cttrrcnL
20
Using the ¢ady dcfimuona
frmn the tcxl
10
of the DC
AC
A wide
variety
including
AA,
ts a hulc
a DC _ oltage
*s shown
HIGGINS
19
dcmoPatTahng
figurc_
20
w_th
Poml
hzs Power
Your
from
Honor,
pr¢_cn[aRons,
HaytandKemmcrly,
pag¢
14
Marknmn
OO175
]
Okay
THEWS
4 ava/hble
f_
wall
Another
avadabl¢
?
going
ix_gl_
9 turn8
neg_e,
n_e_av
c valu_
II
again. "rhcn_lrepca_
12
ORcn
A graph of an AC
a sign
follow
a maxlmmn
zero,
po6mve,
wave
value.,
then
rear.brag a maxm_wn
passing
d_ough
wishes
Okay
HIGGINS
Thankyo_
Thconcsonthcscrccna_c
a httle bit more clea_" because th_-y a_c in col_l"
17
mBodueud
IS
various
es they
for AC volhlg©
IS a small
(vl),
m
voltage
is shown
In figure
'I'hc "066 pascal
These
oth¢_
2
_caches
waveforms
ar_ cacotmk-rud
curnmt
otr=.crvud than
22
hd you-
part of your body
'this
w_
24
DC, AC
or sc_¢
FJccmcal
ts a _ly
voRag¢.
a ba_¢ AC wtrc
23
a van ely
wall bc
m dm study
- _s a However,
m youi" hand,
the cffCCl of cu_mt
lust I_e
o f d_
3
fromabout
4
hc_
5
mc]udc
less
ffyou have
you
know
cvcr
that something
flov. mg through
a voltage, a currt_t
can
bc
In addmon
Markman
io b_ng
Ilearing
a voltage
10/25/05
Page
175
cfoctnca]
s_gnals
frcquc_cyCOnlCnl
Iiearmg
10/25/05
Page
174
a160
F.Jcctrlcal
8 vanou_
clccutc_
generally
o_ DC.
or clcc_onlc
II
r_cwmg
cl_mc:d
12
cxax_p]cs
cncou_|crcd
13
compaclto_,
ActP_c
15
=lec_ca]
16
Kcrm_crly.
sw_tchc_
and
Gtmcr_11y
to sorac
page
19
compaxalo_s,
devices
p_'tsslve
Other
21
and acL, vc d_ccs
22
patcnl
dc_c_
include
d_
o f dehv_ng
zc¢
Hay1 and
SOmcl_m_
pholoc¢]ls,
these
24
the relationship
beP.v eta
25
cu_cnt
them
and
the hn¢
&odes
devices
and
the voltage
amph
flora.
transtslces
between
Exampl_
can
include
oper ai_onai
scnso_
ts a bit bharcd
However.
"066 patent
including
Markman
JA 0824
capable
external
m frarud
23
through
19,
z_tslo_,
larnl_
cn¢OUnlCr cd In the
cl_tzom¢
20
page
include
19
Exampl_
vanotts
dcwccs
o f only
Kcmng'rb',
m the '066 paint
m_c also
can
or actwe
capable
Hayl and
There
These
c_ther pass=v¢
powc¢,
systcrr_
thcl"c ts a voltage
clrcmL
C.cacrally
htananscan
sound
hum
devices
dcvlcc_
power
Ig
_
devices
Tbos.
Often
Mc_st often
in an clcct_cal
be clas_lflCd
P_.s_v©
hcrlz.
the 60 hcrlz
ctremls
AC
by
nanea_¢anheari_¢qmmctcs
10,0(X)he_z.
power
a filter to reduce
7 sot_cc,
can Ix: cboractc_cd
Tl_hm,
20hmlzloov_r
the cl_mcal
17
other waveform.
s_gnats
their
14
clam_
Efoct_ca_
o¢ a curt'era,
2
10
the cycle
OtheT wavcforms
of other wavef¢¢ms
I
9
z.c_o
ThtswoRIdbcvoltag¢asafum:tmnofl_m¢
16
25
going
the symbol
pa_mthes4=
caughl
probably
6
gcaerally
possmg duough
14
¢_lly
Hz,
voltage is 220 volts.60 hertz,
c. zv.achmg
thc_
13
15
ThcACvoltagcmost
ts the 120 _o14 60 cycle _r hcrl_
_ oltagcs
10
21
MR
Markman
outlets
fltrnth_AC
AC
8 poIl¢_n,
20
THECOURT
24
173
for ourstovcs
These
19
Page
"l'hangyc_
ACsoltagc
3 conu'non m the USA
6
10t25/05
w_th h_s
the com'l
0O176
THECOURT
2
5
Hearing
coincide
coincide
to v_t'w
23
25
Voltagecanbcvlcv.cd
which
which
22
polats.
A g_aph
hc will bc
spelled
25
value
h_s Po_ c? Point
Publ,slungC_,
two
_hal
voltage
MR
Kc_m_ly,
pOle_qnal _lw_
common
and
1
23
the elcc_cal
are
facto._"
h_.s a fixed
in figm¢
22
Vol[age..
TI.,C
9 volt_
chcmJcal
21 Slal_nenl_ and the court can scl¢cl which
24
h fc
mlo ¢_cc_cl_y
arcmt anab:zs by H Wt, spelled H -a-y-l,and
McGraw-Hall
for
of battme_
D cells,
_gmealng
JgS6
Hay1 and
AC
21
K-c-m-m-e-r-l-y, 4th Edmon,
a
The symbol
m dady
and
¢lcrncnLs
voltage
charge,
clrcml
quanttly
are DC
Each of these
chemical
to vlcw
lulona}
of clcc_cal
m an elect_cal
hves,
way
will tLse an C_CIIIc_sCOp¢
Ctm-cnlcanb¢_lc'wedasth¢_chlclc
forms
Generally,
16
¢ncotmtcT a wldc varietyof
this
mouon
DC voRagc
15
Elcc_cal signals
We
gs a common
common
I ] condlucats m o_der Io bctlctuudce_tand the tcachlngs of
14
dunng
The
Kcramcdy,
hcatlng r_latcdto the '066 palcnl and
7 the rclcVanl technology'
8
tlm_
Currc_l
A common
of_ ollage _s V
Ls an on oscilloscope
al vanottS
I have be.caasked to glvc tutorialmformauon
6 dunng
In an e]¢cb lc,?J cffcull
The symbol
passwe
m the '066
mats
I_ easdy
acrc_
understood
them
Ilearing
and
by
the
10/25/05
Page
176
¢0177
00178
Z
2
Nex[
devjc¢_
3
_ e'I] take a Ixlef
encoanl_ccl
ResL_r
4
d_ectly
5
ma/c_al
6
re_stanc¢
m the
The
7
This
g_ven-myg)ology
9
cbvldcd
compaclto_
13
anothe¢
14
pvoputlzonaJzt),
Is known
The _'mbol
can
energy
b• used
to tsolale
AC
cmzenl
can
'066 palest,
!7
dascus_d
18
figure
capa_tm's
latcr
m figure
22
simply
'me symbol
m our
O_e
home
_r¢
page
DC voltage
thi'ough
] 28
A
from
a compacito_
as filters,
a concep_
for capacllor
ts shown
opens
dashwashers
or cl_es
PU_Uon
the hghl
25
:s sbow_
m figt_e
_
Ihe hght
ts off
Tra/LqL¢O_
2
sccracondu_ormatenals
3
:m amphfier
in
The
symbol
Tranl_tors
i,s the
mcchamcal
signal
amphfie_
Tra_Ls_
sw_tch
m o_¢
state
O!_a'a_onal
Page
and
ttans_tors
ts called
Wans_0¢s
aae o_nfig_¢d
The amphficaiaon,
16
only on the p_s_ve
17
outpmsoftbeop•rauonalamphfic_
IS
op•ranonal
sagnals
21
c* curte_
22
of the final
amphficr
c_
sys[ems
_s _hown
dlg:Jtal c_'ncras
19
avadab]e
earher.
oRen
ha_ • base
Modern
toprov_desuppresst_moftmwantedso_mds
reduces
25
frequency
m'.d the
treble
One
2
figure
3
rcspunse
4
r_spo_se
6
to pcrfonn
$
form
At the heart
host
a who]•
of
curr•nL
of a
cntcrtairanent
ofotber
Ioday
arc
systems,
devices
are
use
de_ :cos ate
PUlh ttsmg
a _ as_e_y of
passl_
c de', ice_
that determines
the
fonctlon
de_=c•
Io transistors,
arrangcmen[
Figure
_d
_nd
g
th• '066
parch1 teaches
elcchacal
dc_lces
of a filter
R 1 and
th• p_odu_
cltcmts
CI
Ilearmg
amph
the
R2 C'2 ¢on_ol
logic
10/25/05
fic_ LSshown
control
Translslors
• anous
In thts
h_gh
o_ low
12
low
Page
178
Page
180
In
frequency
the high
frequency
can e3_o I:¢ arranged
functions
chlp
I_ outpul
15
17
input
the
They
re often
input
9
20
o_ly
m•
opcrallonal
consols
22
Rather
Thcbas¢contro[
23
zero
rcf_cd
input,
24
signals
25
l0
than
JA 0825
are
:o gs on_ or zero
the OUlpu( is one
inputs
o_ g,_tc, th•
is
end gal•,
the
arc on•
outpu[
is on•
If
The
tho outpul
_s -- v, hen
the
outpul
ts zero
and the output
Is zero iftho
symbol
for lm m_ •riot
Is shown
A ¢omparlitor
amphfy
that acts much
the
depending
A compaxatOT
input
on the
and
signal
is a SpcctaJ
m figure
form
of an
hkc
s foglc
gate
the
output
_s either
relahonsh_p
_IS way•forms
Markman
Page179
as
_s ore
amphficr
or on•
and outputs
_nputs
In a two mpul
_f bohh
Comparators
21
op¢_cs
the
end gale
excuse
if the input
Is one
Irans_slo¢
,rod ar_ oPtc'/_ rcfcrrcd
In an m m_ertor,
_s one
I$
10/25/05
-
_n a two
cllh_
19
h_gh
o_ low
_s on•
16
fora_
applrcal_on
In a fog_c clr•mt
In a [wo input
?
Hearing
as m om
p_oduc L_ a_ aJlabl•
and
of other elec[romc
lI
sagnais
_.larkman
and
of
reduces
c;rcmts
h0me
In addt _o_
¢lccmcal
cc_trol
is special
hot hy el•ctncal
electronic
active
a_tlve
the use
14
_ehle
powered,
ltlsth•an'angeraentandconne•bonof
h_gh
as ",.eli as vollag¢
and
or DC
Computc_,
for our
cRher
fu the mpuLs an d
by frequency
24
frequemacs,
IS
lfr
ase depender
m figuye
As holed
a _amp
qmtc
of useful
Ices
Sta_e.
other
c,c_'_O.ed
23
low
and
Thesymbo]
be chal'a_enzed
Sound
a•t=_¢ de,
swltch¢_
Many
sermconductc_
confipuraUon
d•vzc_
amphfi_
17
9
pachage
m'nphficr
or gain.
chaz_"tsucs
m the o_h•r
convenlcnt
m a small
rang•
8
s'w_lch
$_ _t•h Is shown
7 Io _.s JoSJc gat_
act as _m open
an oper_onal
15
]/kf: a
and
It•an
homes,
Acta_ c d¢_lCCS and
Logic
s_ slcn_
5
_cy
fi¢_" One
at
much
as m o_
ts heated
v.lde
A eyplcal
_5 _1swjIch
s c/os•d
amph
s_gnal
be:
_lrcs
Markman
of functmnagas
and sound
m fgure
thai
16
_150
t
capable
'_ _re can
for I muh}-posaho_
I77
from
al their out!_L
_s a swdch.
[3
Ftlt_
resistor
24
$¢1cc_
control
of othe_ •l¢clnca]
s_ mbol
or zc4aO'
light
of the
10/25/05
r•'mot•
1n the '066 patcnL
trdnslstors
Heanng
m om radio
shown
]2
20
provide
23
m a sm_ll
gax) aL¢o _,¢
I f cr,mfigured
19
12
22
sw_tch
"IV channel
Inelthcrcas•._hepmposeofslamplsto
_'ans_$1ors
for a slmplc
are
they con_
example
14
flashlights
2[
c_ as a switch
then" input Eo a la_er
I!
]1
20
other
to the
Alampzsafamtha,rOo_cctlotts
powered,
A switch
axe made
Tbey
6
IO s'w_tch
Lamp
be AC
hghts.
cLrcmt
FosJl#c_
or.c elccir#caJ
Th•
Wpc of $_,ttch
mulll
6
I0
25
AS a_ amplify,
9
i_ fi$_r•
other ltcots
5
5
8
g
1_
00179
7
c_mpon•nL_
14
¢]cc_qcal
ts on. m the
blarkman
4
7
is slmdar
to a _ _cty
thai conti'ols
and
an efoct_cal
posmon
24
of the m_t
_ a wail switch
openers,
In _ae
I
connected
switch
Anolhcr
gs the
In th• da_._ b• fore
9
[nthe
m'e _ed
s_ltch
doo¢
23
6
3
4
Simple
garage
s_ltch
Sv, rich
'066 pale_
fu thLs s_ _ch
de.. _ce
Kemmedy
flow
ifanAC_oltagc_slg_phedacr_ll'_¢ompucttor
elements
4
law and is
e; shc_n
Hayt and
16
21
This
_s R, the
zs an elccmcal
15
20
s_ltch
t3
How•v•%
19
3
_s
m the
tseqttaHoV,
for resistor
M R[tl-pOSIIlon
t_ughl
0wough
as Holmes
Corapacltor
ofslonng
12
Ilowmg
/t'sg_cnbyV_R
by I
1
2
malen_
Compacltor
1 ! capable
dec_om¢
rr_ar_y materials
to the current
rclatlonshzp
8
10
aclcss
1be con_tam
of the
at ,, anous
'066 _t_t
vohage
inoporllonal
and
look
of 03• _wo input
arc shown
tlearmg
m figure
10/25/05
001gl
00182
I
In this c:_m'aple, the plus input
2 and th© mln_s
input
zs ;m AC wa_ e form.
L¢a DC way© form. V2_
Whc.n VI
3 _ alue less than V2. thr output of th_ comffatato_.
4 zero
WhcnVOt.sg:eag_anV2.
5
7
signal below
8 signal
allows
to a _efercnee
9 compara_
s_gnaJ
The output from
ts a pulse waveform
d_mdon
12
howlongthe
Pa._
VI
e m fran_
tsg_eatrr
_r.
PIR
14 humaasandoth_objects
15
]7
matcw_dcottplcdtoaspc_mh_.lstst_
t 8 electric
19
9
of each pulse wdJ
matgaaal _ budl I_e
20 eh_g_
V2
22
_
extcx,al
24
elc¢_c
13
to produce
15
illuznanatlng
16
Timer
Thepnof
with
A photocell
the dtmnmauon
The PIP, sensor d_lected
2 P.ap_s
3
tm_
fo_ i_nung
aze f_nllllaz
oYc_s
on an a_phance
fcal_cs
on
They are a convenient
for a fixed p_nod of"
Next I wdl dsscuss the demonsWatson
The demo_swauon
22
¢lccb_ontc eomponenl_
23
rcsu]z
by Mr
o_ Icscl of hgh_. A _rapl_
10/25/05
gape_
can be azTangcd to pToducc a use ful
P.algg can be dcsenbcd
_how_
in figLwe 12
25 to the dcmor_t_'at_ on ce_cm! was m L_
Page
by Mr
P.ap_z shows thai su'nplc electrical
The ctrcmts used by Mr
24 using the block &a_p_n
181
Markman
hand and the morton
The photoceU
detected
bo0_ the mot_ocn o( Mr
I znpul
of an ot_c_t
2
the change m 0so level
of
$
The _e
cz.-C_Ulmctud_s
6 compazatorandlog_cctrcmts
a ruler
amph fi_,
Thela.mpchangcdstale
? one I_v¢l of _]lurn]n_t]on
to a sec4_d level
of i]hwnznatJon.
and
The _
powez
fon_ of batlm_
Hearing
10/25/05
Page
182
I0
T'ms change m tqlummazlon
12 w'_'_tors
13
was figs! accomphshcd
returned
le_ el to a lower
The block
17 coupled
t_
hghl
fl'ccn the second m-
level of dlm'n_on
of -- _
- m thss dgure 12, the _'nsor_
m a dashed block tabcled School,
I 8 csrc_ut zs COUpled together
a
_e
and the conWol
m a dash block mazked
dsag_am of d_'monstratton
shown
external
14
condition
15
of a person
16
-apparatus"
20
12c_nbernadc_gcncza_asshownmfigmel3
22 three pOSll_On _
mdgatmg
Hcrethe
itch IS replaced by a g_
that the s_,wtch functton
block switch.
can be a_h]cvcci m a
of ways
Also,
0_e barnes
Markman
Hearing
10/25/05
183
_hown
prcd_tm'rnt_d
external
25
Page
labeled
23
said
to those
refer
we
used
to figure
to said
o f Claim
ru_t
sensor
m figure
14
a r_-cond
c_
to
14 In
a fz_
firsl sc_o_
6 can
mear_
be rep_e_'nted
Iocalcd
"Second
sepsor
being
condition
firsl saJd apphcat_on
motion,
predcterrnmed
con&tlon
comprising
from
by
m the
means
condlhon,
said
a prcd_terrnlned
foe
sccond
level
of hght
(o sa_d apparat_"
labeled
element
second
of claJm 6 can be _ented
sens_
hght,
Markman
JA 0826
1
Raper,
first predetrcmmed
t¢latJv¢
from the patenl,
The second
a block
Mr
a _trst pTedctermmed
separate
The first clement
22
on matena_
smulat
"An apparatus
motion
or objecl
dctc-ctmg
Based
Please
for dct¢cung
being
21
24
e_c r_'placcd by a mo_e gcnc-r_
clt agrams
Io saJd apparatus,
Again
indicate
of the circuits
6 of the '066 pa_enL
6 states,
13
m _m¢
can
d,scusslorL
Claim
the block
can
¢o all parts
demonstrallonby
Claim
the following
ser, so_ meap.s
Ig
mpu_ voltage
the demonswat]on.
12
control
that the input voltage
6 of the '066 pa:cnL
] wall use block
d_mbe
19 _ettsof,
The b_ck
24 vanr_"
to study
17
19 cwcmL
20
7
II
15 few seconds
16
dlscu_sedandth¢
I0
using
_ switches
"Vbe t_
14 h_,Ig_
Clatm
9
I I ustng a thn:e pos_uon swztch and then automalcd
thts genc'_
wlII bc provided
6 have
begin
mdrcaUng
or AC
Ftmher,
the powc-r
8
9 photocell
st_nal,
DC
5
from
8 a bnghtez level, d_pc:odmg on the stale of the PIR
voltage
be etther
3
4
2.5
E]ccLronlc
00184
I
23
to a compazato_
on 0_c level of h_hl
the photocell
21
value
OO]83
21
If the
19
to the
Ilearmg
depending
18 method
20
Markman
en as
of R sub PC
R. then the va]u_ of "_rPC will
can be coupled
a logic s]_.al
stovc_ and microwave
e_c_gy
_s a rc_tstoT v.hosc
_
] ? modern
a compacltc_
this voltag_ _lgnal
R sub PC is _
ts m_ch lazge_ than R, thc_ dlc
The simple ctzcull
14
of a pnoT electric
cffcut L
PhotocelL
25 chaag_
co_lc_
of RPC
A
12 approach ZCTO
a voltage signal
A tran_stor
23
va]_
I [ value of RPC .s mLu:h I_s
Thrc_]cun'c'nlflowslntoa_large
21 _asto_
lft_e
R
value
10 valueofVPCtsne_lycqualtothemputvohageV
c_ c-t$3, gz_ en off by
A _raaJI c_rtcml flow_ _c_ the m fraed
_or Lh¢ volLase
$ dzv_ded by R plus P.PC.
P_c_l_ e mfrarrd
they co_.st
expression
the
detectors
In straplest form.
R sub
the two _tstoz_,
to thelT _es_tance
7 the pzoduct of [he voltage., V, tnne_ th_ z_lo
Theyar©mcommonuscmmo_on
16
The voltage ts dJvldcd between
_ ardlng
m amphtudethan
13 SC'_O_ can defect the heat o_ infrared
is .Thow9 in _gLLgC _I a]ld
a rcststor R, and a photocell
5 and R S,,zb PC ifappor_oned
In thts case. each puls_
I0 has the same height, one_ bul Ihe width
II
4
V2. we ha_c
6 mat_cmatlcar
a compasc_on ofa
8 a photocell
of a ba_lcw,
3 PC
VO. is
W'nc"nlt'$a_'.¢V2.v.eha..eaonc$1atc:
A comparato_
circuit _ln
2 consists
the output ls one
So _c ha_ c a signal - AC
6 ZCTO
I elcclnc
ha_ a
located
Ilearmg
by
m the sensor
10/25/05
Page
184
O0186
OO185
I shownmfigurc
2
Back
¢_11
1
14
Io _
_L
A lamp
3
c_
4
cmlt
a second
5
than
sa_d Iivst Ic_ cl o f dh_ranation,
6
capable
7
lllummatton
8
9
of switching
rapidly
The
for causing
13
dlurnmahon
14
condluoft
15
condJuo_"
16
_rst
¢_lt
can
3
delcctlon
greater
4
le_ cl of
shown
_
m 5g_e
coupled
firsl and second
to crml
m the absence
portton
17
be rep_cn_'d
18
to and acccT_
19
mo0on
20
si_
21
connected
of the fou_
by a block
and
mpm
labdled
s_pl_ds
thai Is coupled
to _nd
7
mpul
the 5rsl
mohon
g
scnso_
9
to the s_ _tch, "._hlch
the sece_d
LScoupled
f,c_
light
I I the control
of
t2
• The
22
blocks
23
In thL_ msCmc¢,
are pa_ of the control
24
I_ cl of 15mm_atton
lflxo
25
predcterrmned
of hght
tbe lamp
le-.dl
czrcmt
w_l
motion
lamp
Um¢ mtcr_ a] and
19
sa_d ttme
20
at the
21
predetermined
14
22
salci 5rst
5rm or lay.
23
Is
and switch
is detected
and a
_s no¢ detected
Hearing
Page
10/25/05
conthtton
The fiRh
labolcd
2_
signals
f_om the
of a
¢ to expiration
lo thereaftcr
m response
emit
of
hghl
Io second
of a recurrence
of
be rupr_ented
by
conthuon"
elemenls
a block
me_u_cmcnt
r_sportsl_
lamp
means
of fi_t
m the absence
predetermined
24
sa_d control
for _mtiallng
first ]_ eL of 15ummallon
is deteCled
_s nol del¢c|ed
c Io detection
ml¢_. al for causing
e al the
,fmotton
"Whereto
_csponsl_
Tamp"
are part of
14
le_ ¢1 of hghl
to the patent
means
to the
,._,11 ope_t
Ic'¢¢1 of dlurnmallon
a p_cdeicrmmed
and second
thai is congled
timer
of Claim
6 can
that Is coupled
respo_L_ c clrc_ll
to and accepts
and
provld_
Markman
185
mpul
an output
Ileanng
10/25/05
Page
|86
Page
188
O01g8
}
2
The Urncr, _
3 pan of _
conb_
cm:_t
¢_'u_I
and s_ltch
shown
m fi_c
5 scold
m" _gb
6 l_cl,
of _l_r,_P_
7 _
i f_b_a_
8
An examm_
of _
m 5g_'c
14 and _c block
9 shown
level
14
12
c_et
bl_'k
&a_mm
they arc
One
12
the clrcmLs from
{tree of a sign
The
wa_ ¢fonn
The
Pnct- to cxan_mng
mterpolate
cLlm_
19 _h_ce fo_'a_ofelecmc_slg_Ls
20
g_cra]ly
21
.._foch as _c - wh_h
m the form
_
o_h_
I w_ll m_oduc_
_
a
17
of a s_go _.ave.
w_
_
and a pulse w_
e_o_m,
OL_p_t of a ¢ornp_a_or
arc taught
_y_te_'n. a _p
in the '066
v, ave f0xTn, aJ',d a
wave
fmT_s _e shown
Markman
e
lfo'o_g_
to go m a
re'0eats
the
m _q_c
I_earing
15
10/25/05
Page
time
me_l_c
tln_
Slgoal
shown
20
crossing
21
hnear
22
r_¢lbackloT_cro
23
s_v.tooth
time
_nd
untt]
thet_
1_C
JA 0827
must
be a way
to
at the
in_reasmg
nex_ 7_to
a ramp wave form
ts a ramp
posluve
wavcform
in _ ottag¢
c_osstng
brae,
Also
zero
m a
wbon
It is
Thenllrcpeatsthcp¢ocessproducmga
hke wavcfolm
Ramp
wa_ eform
can
of tbe DC _ohag¢
be eo.slly
re_,stor
Markman
187
that
z_ro
m c&_ure oftlme
thas is using
going
continues
the
through
Ifamot'¢
m 5gore
the r al'np sta_
manner
um_¢n_ iJme
the ZeTO C_OSS signals
of doing
shown
m an
shov, s a pulse
passes
ts a coms¢
Is needed,
between
method
wa_ efonn
se[¢cuon
15B
It'$hkecounting_lrtUt_
_
25
The
signal
acuor_
Such con_
m 5gt_c
t_m¢ the AC
the
The
wa_ c i_ one
shown
zc_o cto_s
19
24
The©
each
One
18 The
Eal'_,_" 1 discussed
DCvoltage.ACvol_e
wav_onps
a Zero c_ng
as we cxamln_
wl]l be _ncmm t czed.
slgnala
posm_
ttw_
and
'._3_. to synchrontT_
cost
_s generated
13
c_1cmLs can also '_ _;ed.
complcxl_y
conven3ent
zero
16
_lccmc_
zero,
w a_ e
a
p._.ses
• afoe,
through
lfi
accural¢
th_.¢
follows
a maximum
negahvc
passes
¢l¢cu_cal¢lrcu_ltstoha_cacontmonllmmgslgnal
Ig
Add_non_
palc_[,
13 shows
_su_
tupl _ a_nd e._'x_l_4S _
garnc slgo
c thrccl.o_,
9
"066 pal_k
17 fe'.v moR
22
8
fi
inaclrcult
m _¢
_ the
rcacl_ng
a maxlmurn
c threct_on,
I]
More complex
post tivc
[o go in • negal_
reaches
14
15 _
18
of Claim
dm/p_m_ of the
Slacken m fi_a_
w¢ wall obse'rve increased
15A
[hal the szgn wave
7 cycfo
m_:m_al
13 the 6_ns_.t_on.
16
zero
Ita_ts
m figure
Recall
of going
_ a}uc,
6 posltl_
set by _be
_ no( _t_clcd
Cla._n 6 can be m_pl_n.,cnted
14 _
_me
e_her
3 patlcrn
m the first+ or low
_ the e_d of_c
moron
10 dez'_o_on
11 _s_Uagy
of tSm_a,_m
wa_ e form _s sho_
2 stothed
bloc ks _¢
4
25
m 5gur¢
the
conthlton
00187
23
shown
predetermined
an outpul
slgoal
accepts
s_ itch blocks
predc[_rmmed
shce_cn m figure
Markman
c,rct_l
and
18
m turn,
,_t fig
clrctut
In this instance
Rcttan
_y a block
in turn LSconnected
resgonsc
of high
an output
17
that ts coupled
c_cmt
upera_¢
pro_ ,d_
sensor
tnclu_s
f'wst scr.sor
v._ch,
rcspot_e
both
bo rcprcscnlcd
16
and Wovlde_
tO the swl:ch,
to the lamp
and
The
and
the
from
hght
mean_
6 can
of the fosmh
circuit
signals
to
fo
conthUon"
tfos gorhon
response
14
both
manner
labeled
predcteTxnmed
re_yo_sc¢
Born
first prcdelcrmmcd
6
second
of ClaJm
stud lamp
KI rc_rtse
,dso
13
elcr,3cnt
for caoxmg
6 can
15
Th_
"And
I¢_ dl of iIItarllrtatton
of Claim
first predetermined
to stud second
of said
in a slml[as
!0
to said
scrJsor
hg.hl at sa_d first tcvcl
of said
14
to the patenL
a{ Said se_-o_d
element
bcmg
of the: c]a_m car.
tamp,
c,rcmt
to said
saJd lamp
lamp
said
labeled
"Conl_l
m r_
t_l
said
Back
2
left of illurmr_tlon"
by a block
patent.
- "A I,tmp
and can which
of the th_xd dlement
and re_gorts,vc
12
can
substzntlaily
from
to saJd second
be r t-prc_emed
lamp
o f Ig_dm_on
I_ eI of 15ummatlon
Thl_ po_on
10
II
a fir_t level
wfoch
generated
and
by careful
compac_tor
Ilearmg
Such
10/25/05
a
OOloo
OOl89
I clrCU_l ts taU_ll
2
In addition
3
voltage
4
c_c_ssmgslg_ls
exct_e
Well
$
a compa_or
9
ccenpa_or
!0
to mt_polale
the ume
form
m figure
16C as -
apply
bel-.w-en
3
¢_o_mg
of the AC
4
is shown
m figure
5
much
zero
15C
as refeTence
--
12
_lcss
volt._¢
13
output wtn
than
the "066 palcnt
thal occurs
reference
19
is za-o
20
reference
forth
taught
of an AC signal,
that por,aon
in
'I_
Is gteatcT
wave fo_
than
_alucofthegnted
bel the ra.mp
V
waveform
wave form
ts less than
V
o_ ttmc thai
the gate assigned
22
avaJlabl©
can b¢ ccm_'olled
23
voltage
Consld_isecondvalu_ofref_'encevoltagcV
24
te fe_'cnce 2. wbach
2.5
shown
m fignre
by the value
zs grca_
wave
ts
than V :c fez•nee
I aod _s
15D
Page
rcfc_'r, ce thode
thode
That-
4
(bode
5
&reckon
6
hot oldy
voltage
across
The
)3
A complet•
fignrc
Adthtlonal
shown
the
largest
and there win
16
slmplesl
17
voltag•
_s apphed
18
clo_ed
ot on switch
devices
ts a SeTnlCOnduct0T
a diode
can
the _ olu_g¢
20
diethod•ls
21
and tL__.vt tch eqmvalenl
purposethod•
24
vottag_,
The
3,
ramp
exceeds
and circuits
sign
wave
Diodes
two [cads
operate
hke
a switch.
m the
is I_e
&ode
Whcnpropcrlyused.
a
othe_ &rcctzor,,
are shown
R•f_ence
fo
When
The &ode
¢lrcu]l
A
or wtres
the thode
Is apphed
thode
much
oftbe
never
hkeanopenoroffsw_lch
23
I$C
V referc'n¢•
be no galcd
With only
In on• threct_on,
R•fc_ence
wave
to set
tn figme
value
the ramp vOl_,_•
aetlve
&od_
Whon
sign
t 5 is shown
15
terms,
ii may bc d_irabI¢
than
voltage,
gated
2 r_sul L_In a
¢_Ul be g¢! Io a value
In diL_ ]n._Um¢c,
V
zmo
wave
_mhol
m fignrc
16
_s a spectal
ltactsasafixcd
like: a bsttcry
value
of a fixed
vo]tagn
dsper_
Markman
189
symbol
for rel-cl_¢e
I
apparatu_"
The
In figure
2
by a block
lab•led
3
2O
II
_ass
_ goe_
12
through
r•s_ts_3_
17
ch_ce
_r
goes
on the
Ilearlng
"D_e tes_'to_
fow.
a_dVhzgh
18
window
19
szgnal_;[praler
20
dmsnan
A window
establ_h
7
dhm_matlon,
sa_d lamp
8 szJd first lc_•l
9
the gate
whc_
stgnal
is a
and
_ol_._ges,
produces
_n ompul
10/25/05
Pagel90
wben_,a-
fo_ the "_andow
CIam_
9 of the '066
22
9 will be d_c:_bed
23
fig_xe
c._mpa_
patenL
m tem_
tbe mpu_
_
show'o
m fq_me
The elements
of the block
&aBram
shown
foe detecting
a prcdete_mmed
condst_
Markman
com!:e_m8
external
Hearing
nfsa_d
Thts
by
to and acct'pts
o[ low
to sa_d
25
condition
JA 0828
lamp.
flora
of
of Claim
shown
9 can
m fig_c
to said ]amp
20
and
f.atd lamp to
of d]mnmahon
in th©
¢ond]t_on
•lc'ment
labeled
of Clmm
Response
mp_e signals
signal
9 can
Ctrcmt
from the
that ts cottpled
cl_ult
circuit
Icv•l
and th•
shown
the I_p
of dlummatlon
has nOl been
sw_tch
m fig_e
wdt
since
be
that is
scn_or
block
to the switch
blocks
are part
20
operate
al a first
a p_edetermmed
sens_
tlearing
10/25/05
dc_ecte&
Marksnan
Pagel91
of
the lamp
response
In th_s instance,
24
10/25/05
an output
of the con_l
a scr_o_
level
mt:_tns for cabin8
of ditrd
a block
elemet_t
coupled
pred•tennlncd
portion
&al controls
23
9 s*._te_. "An apparatus
m•ar_
absence
22
20
_
¢ffcu_t
15
The
of
rapidly
to sa_d second
labeled
al sa_d first level
21
in
a block
e to satd f,cr_or
20
a first level
level
of sw_tchxng
of die second
ernll light
19 and p_vld_
19
m fists•
than the first level
incapable
14
cottplcd
can erml
trait a second
g_eatcr
13 responsiv
18
of Clam3
by
A _(3ntyol
17 Teprcsen_ed
A¢_mt
9 can be represc'nled
f.er_sors shown
_
be tcprcsenled
16
s V
the
thanVh_gh_le_thanVIow
21
_our
the
whlsh
can
o f dhnn_nat_on
Th_s pc_t]on
12
18
WlumVl_w_slowetthanVtugh.
co_pa_
I1
passe_
two thodes
tgummatlon.
IO
th© _ ols_ge
co_
two rc for•nee
"A lamp
to zero
a gnled
ofClazm
within
and which
substanttally
the AC
a cornparator,
patent.
dlurnmat_on
fora_ac_sshownmfigme
by
On th•
f tllurnmal_on
elcm•nt
scnso_
6
unl_s
conducting
50
fi_t
the
gem:rain8
as whon
eo_np_xatc_
ct¢cmt fom_l
17
str_
4
conducuon.
once
two tc_rmznals
Thesymbol
Wthdow
16
_
and win s_p
to z_o,
z_-r_
I$
starts the
Tbe e_cw_nnoecondu_
_s Ix•sere
spectal
LSshown
amaccancoeductm
wlU teas•
its other
s_gnal
14
diode,
if a g,'tte signal
m._c _ a good
9 sq_nw.ave.
13
The
cqmvalem
Unh'kearegniar
l0
25
way•form
cxcxcds
near each
re_ult_ng
h_gh_
larger
10/25/05
A trtac ts a t33¢cJal type o f semiconductor
A_'O. a tnac
8
selectedi
and w_th the bs_:_y
3
24
l0
re f_rcnce
of time
OO192
I _fi•
7
which
Hearing
00191
2
sign
voile•
has value
ramp voltage
Tbe
conditions
9
2_
Markman
gated
sore•
111• re f_'cnc¢
22
of the reference
way•form
8
th•
the
p_aod
15 E. Ustn 8 V rc fetch••
Lh•referenc•vo[[agee'.¢rt
12
15D,
a shorl
7
19
!
The amomu
shor_r
14
a signal
of the AC
whJl© the r'.u_p voltage
1 ,._avadable_
at aJl _n_.
21
wave
2 for only
Und_
II
the ramp
ltlssuchagatedstgnwavefo_n_
In th_s v* a_ •form,
18
of
I
and referel_e
L_the gaming
input
the ramp
I and zero whenevcT
V reference
shownmfxgntelSD
17
• input of
be one whoncv_
V rcfcnmce
Use of tbe ramp
16
I to the negatl_
and the ramp ..rave form to the posttav©
exceeds
in figure
re fcrencc
6
V reference
Comparator
As shown
2
Sucharefc_c_ccvohag©lsshownaspan
I I voltage:
15
I
a re fczcnce
v, a_,Cform,
me - as VREFI
7
14
IO Lbe ramp
is needed
2, of the wave
6
m the '066 palcnL
Page
192
0O194
O0193
I
From
_
patenk
2
h£ht
3
stud ptcdclcrmmed
aJ saad second
4
elcmcnl
5
above
6
scco_
8
the pre - smc¢
9
conthuo_
foe lamp
the pr_mc¢
pogaon
I
to emit
to
wall opo_
blocks
as
the presence
of the second
of
pccdClCnnmed
_ powered
rraya_
"Whereto
by an AC
mcIud_
prcvcn_n8
_oltag¢
_*v]tchmg
and means
15
voltage,
16
second
17
tIIm'alnatlorL"
18
_
poOJon
level
fma]
also
wh_m
porhoa
ofoch
po_on
bc rcpr_cntcd
lamp
However,
sagn w_e
we can
being
23
The _ow wave
24
15E, and the
gTcat¢_
for s_d
for s,'ud
first Iv. ¢] of
of the third
dcmcm
by the s_a¢
blc_
recog_r_¢
of Claim
shov,_a
d_bcd
two _ ¢v_lov_
In rclaUc_h]p
form corresponds
high wa_ eform
9
In figm¢
_
first potion
2
can bc tepresenled
3
_ coupled
block
to the waveform
s_ ieh
10
control
levd
¢ond_on
in figure
sho_
n
sa_d Fredet_ramed
level
From
means
blocks
apparatus
The
a b]ock
cm;t_ hg'Bt al the
"And
for ca_m_
¢ondmon
_d
rnst
s er_sor
lamp to _B_II
and fo_ ca_mg
Ievel
o f satd Feedeterrmned
of
sa_d lamp
of ilhmunalion
Th_s pomon
of ©lemenl
m response
10 c_.n also
17
ilhtmmat_on
18
first sa_d level
19
lllummat]on
trp_esen|cd
]8
cot_led
19
20
p-ovaries
22
25
Response
input signals
lagr.al
re,pottle
part of the o_ntrol
orcult
_-cmt,
In th,$ instance,
s_oTnd
se_o_
_tbeI_d
Ctrcmt
from
thai _ co_rpled
compnsmg
"A lzJnp
lamp
From
can also
24
saJd lamp
2_
m h'_ absence
21
a first
a sc¢or_d
of switching
second
bY
m figure
satd level
to said
¢I¢'menT of C}_m
Lamp.
level
of
of fi_st
rapidly
level
10 can
n in figure
c_rcnll
from
of
at sa_d fl_l
"Whereto
I thdn'!
THE
Ilearmg
sa_d control
Wa,
WIT_ESS
THECOLIRT
7 &dn'l
see %ofrage"
8 palent
there
9
TH_
WITNESS
10
THE
COURT
ts p_wcred
I'm sorry.
Your
you
194
voltage
hn¢
there
Honce_
read tha_ agam "_ I
first hne
of the quote
Whereas
from
the
-
"Whelm
by an AC."
Page
Youwanttorcad
m the firsl
Would
in the
10/25/05
--
ammut¢
scc voltage
to
for cat_mg
conthllon"
by an AC voltage
THECOURT
again
means
}e_ el of d[uminahon
p_cdele_nmcd
the patent,
ts ppw¢_¢d
13¢ repr e_cntcd
21
rneart_ coupled
c to satd sensor
to cmtt Lamp
ofs_d
sho_.
Con_ol
and _ponsl_
F_3m
right
emit
emit
than
incapable
the patent,
]amp
12
shov*n
_ Ith can
greater
of dblm_nahon
labeled
said
means
to
"
_3
11
external
I 0 can be rcprescmcd
the scnso[
'_ hlch
s.ed
by a block
mear_
scr_
cond_uon
sa_d comrol
¢_rcmt
,sn'l that where
you at© _'_thng
now_
13
THE
14
TH E COURT
WITNESS
_
THE
W]THESS
THE
COURT
yes
Your
H_v¢
Honor
you got "vohag¢"
I ha_c
-- on the
_o]tage
m there --
m i|
rivet line ') I have
iI
be
on the second
hnc
thal u;
a se_.5or
Io the
m
block
swarth
and
that
Z8
THE
WITNESS
19
THE
COURT
20
"D_E WIT/qESS
21
TH E COUP.T
22
THE
I'm on th_ second
Arc
you on page
We have
--
2 I. nght
thfferent
thc_¢'_
--
the lamp
The
23
24
an outptq
con_ls
21
by a block
to and a_ce'_
of Claim
snbs_lla]ly
The second
17
17
apparatus
_ithm
the patent,
Illumination
that
of Claim
dlagraJ'_ shown
to
cor_t]o_"
3 of Clmm
sensor
lc_ e[ of iI]_mmauon
6
16
¢lemenl
16
6
of the
m the absence
clcm_al
_
15
4
to
the predcterra_ned
The
or the bIc.ck
a ptcdc{_mmed
labeled
3
21
_nce
"An
firsl
From
2
that
the seP.u_r
are pan
the patent.
_. iI_ dctcfmlnC
O0196
}
C,rcalt
thai ,s coupled
of illm_a_nat_on
al stud second
to detet:Bon
Rcsports¢
6.
shown
addmonat
Markman
|0
9
wav¢_z Io pro_ ide pow¢_
patent
m tcnr_
193
deu_t_
the patent,
! 3
of Chum
from
Page
10/25/05
9 has
sign
of Claim
of Claim
21
5
[he lamp
at r,md _st
hgh_
s_gnal
of IIlmnmat_on
hgh!
clement
stgnals
m figm¢
has no_ bee_
From
input
_.Bd fw_tch
In th_ _
12
15
shown
O_e hmp.
or_-mt
ct,-_mt, shown
or low
emlt
fig_rc
22
to the wavefocm
Hearing
labeled
an ou_
thal co_'ols
11
14
by a block
to and accepts
Response
8
9
of the third
and prowdes
6
7
8
21
g_d
m 15D
00195
I
$
ofth©
_._th figwr¢ 15
corresponds
Markman
4
I 0 _ ill be described
diagram
thagram
le_ els of dlummalton
10 or the 0_6
7
20
21
25
Claim
14
2O 2O
22
for the first and second
13
ha]f wa_ c of AC
being
than
lo s_d
that c[azm
ca{_on of u_mg _a_cd
12
and
shows
5
I 1 said
clrcmt
pcvml_ng
20
the b[_k
14, and the block
_ophlstt
I0
means
stud conuol
AC volLag¢
o f ha] f wave
of dha-am_on
clrcmt
Of ,_c_c_v¢ly
of stud
fo¢ a sclecicd
said
coau_l
and
mc;ws
the apphcatlon
! 4
said
befween
m figme
4
6
al the
since
sho_n
3 m figure
of the thl_d
bY the sarnc
A comparison
2
9
12
_
lamp
m r ¢_ponse
Tb_
of fllm_mauon
On the pa_nl,
II
19
said
9 ca,I b¢ rerrcscnu:d
or hlgb levd
l0
13
contht_on"
u_tanc¢,
7
for _mg
t_.-vel of lllummallon
o f Clazm
In th_
"And
m high
contht_on
and the _,vgch
sho_-a
the lamp
m figt_e
errors
lev©_ of _llurmnauon
has
bee.
hght
lance
cffcmt
are
Oh
Wc
ha_ e a shghtly
thffcrcnt
21
23
at the
the
Hearing
format,
so I can -
24
THE
25
Ti| E WITNESS
COURT
Well.
we
are m Cla3m
l0
predet crnuncd
d_ted.
Markman
WITNESS
10125/05
Page
Claim
Markman
195
JA 0829
I0
Hearmg
10/25/05
Page
196
00197
OO198
I
THECOURT
2 al the clash
3
means
its¢l£
"And
_ powered
4
by."
Lc_'sse¢
Lefsjust
whel"fm
grad control
in comma
6
_al'S
I
¢_rcml
3 The
W_tmn
COURT
v*hal mine
_.aJd comlol
Is pow_cd
_y_
-- th_
_
4
level
5
figm¢
by _
but you had
e_rh_.
9
THE
WITNESS
I may t_ve
THE COURT
II
13
THE
COURT
14
THE
W1TNP_S
15 mc_s
,s powered
16 clraut
means mcledes
17 permlUmg
Ig
to stJd lamp, a means
_tuated
20 AC
voltage and whereto
swl_hzng
and p_ev_[m
lot causm8
pomon
21
fee _
22
level oftIha_tmmotL*
means
the leY_er Of lower I_.el
to thc fifth wa_ ¢fonn
Tlus pocu_
m fignre
ofsa_d
This portton
I1
tepter, ented
12
contro]
t 5
said s',VllChmg meaz_
to be
zero
l0
sa_d conuol
AC _ oltagn
crossing
by a block
shown
output
of the form
the
From
16
generalor
17
rm_p puke
2 I
patent,
having
which
of _1cl half v, aves being gnat_
20
be represented
by Z block
21
control
shown
22
by the same blocks
d_cn'bcd
above
and
21
Markman
Ileanng
10/25/05
m nine
w hen sald
ramp voltage
point
cffcmt
shown
24
From
25
ramp pulse
In figure
of Claim
10 c_
ramp geneiator
and the
21
can be of
15C
"A comparalot
to a threshold
voltage
Page197
which
compar_
which
ac tuale_
and
Markman
_Z_
a
of
wave"
of the ramp generator
the patcnL
can be
to detection
element
labeled
m figure
m the
o f stud AC ,, ohagn
for the half
signal
detector
in respon._e
of the fourth
The output
the form
Detector
for producing a ramp
half wave
ts mmated
portion
voltage"
I 5B
"Means
thr each
cross
I5 E
I0 can be
Cross
of the zero
m figure
Thts
23
in
CirCuit
AC
of Chain
Zero
signal
shown
d_le¢[
of said
element
labeled
the zero creasing
I 0 can
form shown
m figure
crossing
m figure
19
than fo_ said fu,st
15
or high
of illumination
shown
points
of the fourth
ctrcmt,
The
"A zero
18
of the t)urd clement of CImm
24 also be r c'_esented
shown
foz detecting
the patent,
of each half cycle of said
second level o f dhiram._on
23
9
14
figure
for the second
to the wave
And
clrcmt
for selectwely
8 the apphca_on
fo_ a selected pc_lon
voltage, s_d
stud conwol
corresponds
of the
with
I5D
13
"Whereto
two _ erslora
of the half cycle
of dIummatlon
From
agmn,
Okay
by an AC
19
25
quote
pl_
pomon
8
rm_poke_
Iql sLari that
giraler
the
In r¢laliomhtp
d_icnlxd
7 cone*Ixmds
I
Okay
THE WITNF_S
12
Sme Wavl_i
6
AC vohagn
a _ ollagn
8 think
10
HOW¢_ er. we can recognize
2 Gated
9. Im¢ 28.29
THE
7
back
let's see
THE W1TNE$S
5
look
Hearing
stud
stud
10/25/05
Page
198
OO2OO
I _.vi_ng
mc:m$
2 tint _cecds
3
4
m a point
This po_on
b¢ rc_csmted
by a block
mpat _gmls
7 m_
that,,hold
prov_
The cc_nl_'a_,
IO pan
Of the omxWol
From
12 means
thai ts coupled
ctrCml _hown
fi_t
s_d
con&oor_*
pomon
Tht$ last
17 can be reptcscmed
dct¢chtm
22
and threshold
Funh_,
aceelm
repot
oltagn
24
the prcd_tm_med
23
The
use md
to detection
the
conthtton
effect
serts_
ramp generator
the
Markman
R_i_
scmo_
to the
15
dements
Ileanng
of Claim
Chim
The
fi_h
19
gtaning
with the
scnsang
me,_
21
presence
This
generation
el_nenLf
I I shows
use of
of claim
thayam
shown
in
24
bh_k
25
Is idenncid
thai the firlt
to the first four
below relating
llfth
to Clmm
of clmm
elernenk
_lve
portion
detected
Clatm
to stud
to
figure
22
below
I I sta_¢_."A light
_
for deleclmg
the
ofthtyhght"
of the fifth
element
by the addlllon
and the sensor
I I and
I I is (h$cussed
shown
to the second
of Claim
of a second
m figure
senso*
IHarkatan
JA 0830
The
the disc_ion
and abse_e
be represented
Page199
to
at vartot_
10
el_m_nl
20
23
10/25105
the
I I are Idemtield
I O and fignt e 21 llOplleS
to Itam ff
*s dlust_ated
of a zero
thrcy_hold
tbe light
of the block
lOand
of Claim
Coase_mmtly,
22
to drive
involv_
m tml_
of Clanm
four el_tm_
I7
mdUple
22.
14
16
This
the _e
and
11 o f the *066 patenL
13
I0
14
sophnst*catlon
wavcforn_
coral*on
ts cc,,4_1_ to and
of two th:_h_lds
Claml
include
wave form_
of dlmnmauon
complex
I$
has or has not been
AC
figtwe
block
clrcmt
vanot_
I 0 to figm-cs
funht_
10
detector,
c_
12
conthtzon
n_pom¢
m Claim
a
of Clazm
21 for Clanm
9 mthcates
tmprovcrncm$
I I will be dl_icnbed
ofsatd
element
taught
I I
to have
of the Ixcdetcrmmed
block
from
f.eax_or
6 and
S p_aflc
1o
to stud
value 'T2 com:sponds
the _hold
signals
and destgn
9 n_c
Tbeth_holdva]_T[
of tbe predetermined
23
4
of fignre
for Claims
7 ge_e_alc
2I
r_ponslve
of the fouzth
to the absc'm_
21
m figure
threshold,
andT2
19 _
and 20
6
Thr_hold
tch bloc ks are
by adding to the thr_hold
_dvatu*sTI
3
5
to the _wttch
m tbe absence of stud !_edetcrouned
16
condmon,
and _
the paLent, "A mea_
15 prc_tmnn_
20
and
15
Comparison
8 levels
14 taxi a seoo_d value m n_ponse
18
the block labeled
Ihreshold
R_ cammg
13 first _
that ts coupled
the lar_p
9
I|
10 ca_
the r_rnp generator
from
_sna]
of Claim
comI_uato_
from
vbltagc*
m_ output
that co_xa.s
labeled
In _gtirc
2
of the rough eh:tnenl
5 to and _cc¢las
6 accqm
I
saacl threshold voltage,"
22
I I can
senfol
hgbl
Thi-s e_ -
light thscussed
Hearing
block
with
10/25/05
Page
200
00202
1
00201
I rc_lloCImm6
2
anti l_g_c
The second scns_
hght
3 Ls coupled to the _spo_e
4
From
has an ompm
to stud I_t
me,_ns includes
value
This thsrd tl_:_hold
9 m th_ block &agram
d_ff_enl
zs dctccang
_
m _gmc
Also,
of the ramp
16 In tc-rro_ Claun
3 ts largcT thaa the blgc_t
sc_o_
18 ctrcmt s_s the t_rc_holcl
20
cm_Un_
21
tead_
22
Lamp during
23
I_*cl
25
figmc
dct_rs
of sophzsaca_on.
12 oftl_
light
pate/R
m terms
Clmm
The
elemeats
of the block
shown
Hearing
HIGGINS
fourth
and
element
Honor
9
"t oat
10
presentation
II
12 that do not b¢long
12
zero
13
th_eshoM
I can
th¢le
continue
_t with
the new
19
Ze¢o
the
th_s document
for
some
blocks
In figure
comparalor
and
t_gu_e 23 a_ is or I can
that deletes
those
erroneotts
four
] thmk_.ouprobablyought
i]lustratton,
cross
the ]amp
23
from
generator,
THECOURT
18
and
the
gpec_ficallynolcatledoutts
using
one
Thus,
12 dt fiefs
I included
ramp
6
below
m revtewmg
detector,
[tght,
m figure
of Claim
] I_nd thai
cross
sensor,
ts thscussed
slmdanty
12 are
of Claim
so reel u_ _hlch
detector
ramp
THE
WITNESS
22
THE
COURT
23
THEV_ITNESS
one;
rouse
are
deleted
gcnerato_
Ramp
generator
comparato_
and
threshold
Threshold
that has TI,
Co_lect
T2, T3 _
12tmeproceedon
IoTL_E COURT
Do _,ou
have
a copy
P, larkman
2
NO
ye_,
v,¢ sent
tt to you
of the
Hearing
revlst_d
Page202
10/25/05
4
$
i_fiL
COOK
6
THE
COURT
7
MILCOOK
extra
You have
it?
Idon'thavelL
Doyouha_e_
oa¢?
9
MR
HIGGINS
I0
THE
wedo
COURT
Could
yc_
provtd¢
some
HIGGINS
yottrH_nm,
that he's gwmg
herr today,
_xlthe
shdes
16
revtsed
that
THECOURT
Ig
MIL
Okay
HIGGINS
19
THECOURT
20
MR.
HIGGINS
21
MR.
COOK
23
THE
May
Could
means
9
]e_¢l o f _ltmmtanon
sensor
Amtyouha_eacogyofthls
16
shde
23
who
Pm gwmg
it to
Thankyatz
I jt._t hand
1 get a gtude.
You_
Honor,
to
Yeah.
bunch
detectm"
I'm looking
of figures
and
23's.
at figure
and
23,
they all have
all that stuff
Markman
Hearing
10/25/05
Page
JA 0831
Your
stud
lamp
with
the
circmt
to emit
m respor_e
figure
23,
fourth
means
hght
coupled
5taxgor
al sam
firsl
to satd second
m the absence
of said
first
"
of the four/h
by a response
inputs
are new
ahead
first _md second
element
clrcmt
from
the first
of Clmm
b_ock
ser, sor
the sw=tch
18
switch
19
figure
an outpu_
thai con_'ols
blocks
signal
the
12 can be
that IS cotmected
moaon
and
to
second
that Ls connected
lamp
The
ave pan of the control
respoase
to
¢lrcmt
orcmt
shown
Control
cut:me
mea_s
manual
overnde
and
in
23
From
the patent.
21
includes
selectively
22
se]ecu_
ely overndmg
23
manuaI
actuation
24
second
lex¢l
This
_Sald
aemable
said
to cause
oflltummahon
portton
t_rst and Second
saacl
lamp
mear_s
for
set.or
means
to emit hgh!
at sa_d
by
"
of the fourth
Markman
203
one,
hght_
17
25
to stud
condmon
It provtdes
20
it to hem?
Starting
ed condanon
This block
Go
*A contlo_
in response
predetermined
15
the original
Okay o
12 states.
foe e.aum ng
the corTeCaOn
-
COURT
a _.hole
cro_
That's
Okay
m th_ bundle
=nd there's
the z_m
8
an a¢c¢'pts
as well?
where
to sa*d lamp
14
mdudaag
show
Cla=m
represented
presentat_tm
Ve:_' last one_
WITNESS
7
12
whatrmhandmghtm
Paulus's
15
THE
element.
13
tsacopyofaIlofthesltde_mDr
14
COURT
GO to the _ cry last
of the packet
6
II
MR
THE
10 predetermlr,
to us as
v, elP
12
WITNESS
at the back
5
O11_
THE
HonOr
3
last
4 mgh_.
25
claims
I
COOK
24
second
12 to the
s some
of Clmm
eleanents
14 a_e repeated
The
of Clatm
I I shov,
three elemertts
Page201
10/25/05
23?
MR.
22
10 and
three
mot=on
m figure
8 oth_
24
m
the first
7
21
of Clatm
diagram
9
OO2O4
figtax
MR.
17
blocks
20
23
3
13
first sensor,
6
17
[I
6
to the first
5
blocks
clazms shov. s a
of the elements
of Clarets
25
2
II
identical
16
OO2O3
$
4
to Lh¢
T3, to lure off the
Markmaa
1
For example
replace
and the thr_hold
In particular,
_eshold,
'066
3
15
ts _pphcd
C3am_ I I to the e_hrr
12 will be described
elements
ga_r_ e_
Rayhght
CImm
24
zs nevc_
_ alue to T3
the _sc o f a third
A comparison
2
14
the AC Sine Wave
I I, th_ means no slgn_
Compa_ag
ts of a baghc_
I
'a.-aveform.
17 lamp and the second
19
of T3 to
to V reference 3, whteh
13
Consequently,
_
15C, _'_eshold
than V rc fc'rc_,ce 2 or V rc[crenc_
V re fc'rmc¢
dayhght
be rc'pt_¢nt©d
12 value
15
sam first and
22 by the addqlon
Re fc-mng
I I _ aluc T3 coIT_ponc_
from
mearis
conthuon
m fig_¢
10 the oh1c_hold block.
14 v_u¢
means
sc'm mg for c_us mg s_ud u_c_hold
to ha_ e a th_
7 sccond _atue v, hcn s_d switch
8
stgnal thai
clrcmL
the pateng "Stud c_l
5 rt_pomlve
6 voltage
14
element
of CImm
Ilearmg
12 ea_
10/25/05
Page204
C0205
OO2O6
I be represented
2 c,cmt
by a manual
shown
3 between
4
m figure
the sv. itch
One
mpul
5
wlach
6
(o emil hght
includes
to the manua)
9
sa_d setond
10
m ernde
II
Ix reprcscncd
13
shov._n m figmc
!4
From the
means
whereto
erm Ring at sad
This
poraon
21
be zt'presented
22
conlml
accepts
25
connected
and
fomth
cotm_ug
_m Input
sllp_al
to and
co_muug
m figm©
btock
froth
bfock
Q
14
you use the phr_¢
15
knowledgeable
16
"taught
17
A
18
some
said
sad
an maput
Markn_n
10/25/05
Page
in the
can
claim"
you
As a IgTson
explain
"_hat yOU mean
by
patent
gives
II gw_
in formallon
function,
and
suggc_ted
not ha_ c known
23
Q
24
wmu:ss
from ii either
of parts,
hot tcach¢_
a problem
that I mlghl
-
tha; I may
prior to rcadm 8 the pa1¢nL
Nofunherqucst_o:ts.
THE
to accomphsh
learn
arraugcmcul
me m formation
22
on how
I could
YomHonor
COURT
Okay
P_asthc
Crc_
Markman
205
Heanng
10/25/05
Page
206
OO208
!
MR
COOK
2
YI_.
Yore" Honor
CROSS-EXAMINATION
3
BY M]L
4
Q
5
than dos an-angemcnt
6
COOK
it back up
yore
7
Hone4". rm
[ need
COURT
Good--Dr
9A
Good
t0Q
plannmg
some
the ELMO
tccho_cal
help
rather
to hook
DO yOU have yore wnucn
2 A
Ido
3
Q
Wouldyou,
4
stalcm_t
down
5 Infrared
Sc_ors,
aRe_x_
As I undcrstaed
palmt,
12
mdus_y
13
A
"rhal ts corxceL
14
Q
Inch_ug
tt. you
you bad no mot
hove
expeacnce
-
]p_o_ to this
lsthalconecl7
no pnot
expmcn_
Cm_'r_
17 Q
Your backg/_Jnd
18 A
C_L
ts as lm ¢lecmcal
19
Q
And that was tho bas_
20
pak-nt,
ac_ as a I,ghaag
2]
A
CorrecL
22
Q
fo yore
23
lefssee,
24
the¢¢,
exlgmoc_'?
you
evalealed
th_s
9
p_wc
10
_¢rgy
12
e_crgy,
13
A
sta1¢namt,
m fmtll
THE COURT
which
to tha17
appca_
Well,
of yotL
Yow
wnRen sta_mcnt
Markman
Hearing
that you -
10/25/05
Page207
g_ven
rm
passive
ors
oiTby
their
gore8
humans
myour
P_Slvc
senses,
PIR
the heal or infrared
and other objects
function.
_sn'l Ih to deice|
m fr aregl
energy?
Yesh says
they
A
17
Q
18
Tbey
19
A
arc m _
_e
in mouon
detectors
Coerect
You haven't
ate srmply
That's
Would
THE
tdontflled
them as a _
m t_s¢ m rnotao_
detector
detecto,_,
correct7
the statemenc
you turn to tab 58 of your binder,
COURT
That's
Volume
please?
2 of the binders.
are the binders
23
MR.
24
it box behlnd you there
ROHRER
25
THE
COURT
I f I may.
Dr
Paulus.
What #ad you say,
Markman
JA 0832
blow,
a hca_n8
to pUl ,t on the ELb_O
infrared
can detect
changes m mfrarc4
16
where
ram'4
set,
Isn't that correct?
22
al tab -
youhavell
mfrared
15
21
wntl_
g?
you have
PIP., do you see that?
|1 says
Thafs
20 Q
_
t_b 79, can you ttr_
I gues.s,
on whtch
for a minute
14 Q
m the ouuloor
turn to puge
a_ the bottom,
I f you don't
8
II
m the hghtmg
ple'_e,
statement?
ldo.
7 Q
Okay
Paulus
II
A
on using
I Q
6A
THE
$ Q
25
mc a way
25
OO2O7
16
The
21
ts
as follows
EXAMINATION
"taught
task or some
m the
tlearing
to the other
m a clatm"_
to solve
the switch.
t¢chotqucs
compared
sworn.
lesuficd
of patents,
20
slgnaho
counting
Pauh_.aipages22and23ofyo_rstateraenl.
12 can
and
m the
12
HIGGINS
Dr
pans.
to and
clrcml
pulse
Jcahon
duly
and
DIRECT
19 suggested
23
ts connected
ofCisJm
J PAULUS.
was exammed
BY MR.
shown
12 and
Okay
firSl been
13
ftalher
o f Clam
a respca3sc
predL.Ces
having
12
of lllua_nauon
clecnCnl
and
THOMAS
switch
arc counted."
of the
ern Clmm
I I zs Ihc contained
cfc:ncnl
sophzst
THE COURT
9
and preve:ntmg
level
swllch
Il
time
be_
10 and
fourth
is further
8
Ch'Cml means
f_r each
LSdeterred,
by the pulse
The pulse
24
a pube
of the
12 can
to the manaal
sa_d contzol
second
pulses
ca-era1, shown
23
input
for cotmtm 8 sa_d pulses
two or more
20
7
of
manual
o f Clarm
6.9.
four cislms
ion
means
sad
dlffcrcncc
manual
h_re
10
clcmcnl
con<bh'on
means
from
The
m the absence
after
portion
taughl
the lamp
selected"
for generating
including
uuless
ovcmde
sa_d lamp
o f the fo_lh
patcat,
17
lamp
voltugc.
wall cause
23
first prcdotcrrmned
19
manual
by a no voltugc
16
18
The pnnmpal
¢lemenLS of Clatms
ts connected
I¢_ cl of dlurmnat
condauon
has been
Thz5 portion
L$ mclades
"Siad
predetermined
12
ts mpul
switch
ot hlgbe_
fo_ d_abhug
means
switch
fourth
swttch
by the manual
the patcnl.
means
m the conn'ul
The manual
at the second
From
8
23
hfock
m the lamp blocks
"..hen sclc¢ted
7
sw_tch
they a_¢ m
58?
Heanng
10/25/05
Page
208
00210
I from
_209
I
MR_ COOK
2
THE
3
screen
_
4
BY
5
Q
6
st_emcnt,
7
with
COURT
Maybe
Your
Honor
you c_m see :1 _p on the
COOK
_
_s a document
that I t_ed
and I rc feted
_
thr_
agr_
9 A
tab 58,
easily
MR
8 you
ll's
legs
Io those
coming
tha_ flaos¢
dunng
hnlc
down
my opening
top hat devices
_
them
_
PIRs
Would
are PIP._
Co_t
10
Q
II
mfran_d_ectors
12
chang_mmfrarcdenelT,
13
co_.r_
14
A
And up io the
They
15
Q
16
energy
17
A
do dct_t
And,
m f_t,
aswethsct_,s_lamomcatago,
_nfrared
they
energy
dct_.t
change_
m mfrared
lsn'tflaalc_c_
ThaWs co_ec_
I8
Q
19
m fr_ed
Now,
this zlso
20
recommead_
21
are hu]© cucmt
d_t_tor
22
dc_-_gne_
23
overall
_ys
sen_
flaat the LHI 778
_re _ccomracnd_d
py_oele¢_c
-
the design
forallv_a_antsofmo_onconlrol
comPOnent%
to b_ put m a ¢:r_ml
c_rcu_l
24
A
"l_rc
25
Q
Tha_
_
board
a c_mponcnL
"fbcy
hnle
kind o f an
y_
I©gs _:t_t come
Markman
A
4
g_ound.
5
Q
6
thai these
7
go into
are the source
for _
Accorthng
to the diagram
]nground,¢xcuscmc,
-
thee
the clrCU_l boasd,
They
9 wired,
boy, ever
Q
can
But
and the
_'a_nlng
Butthatsthepomt
t C_T_mals
axe designed
to
nghl _
b_: pul into the cffcult
you v, ant Io mounl
they're
the _aJn
nghl'_
tt is a source
yes
at_ d_lgncd
8 A
_d
Itttle componertt,
going
to go
tx3ard or bc haxd
IL
into a c_rcmt,
Is my
12
A
They
]3
Q
Now--
_dl
be tLsed :n a ctrcult
14
A
Letmecorrectthal
15
syslem
16
Q
Othe_
¢}ectncal
17
A
There
would
18
Q
Making
19
A
Yes
20
Q
And
21
reason
I brought
22
tdentlfied
23
detector
but
24
_stcm,
right 9
25
A
Theywlllb¢_¢dma
components
components
up an electrical
h¢_¢ s another
here
m a system?
13¢ al¢ctncal
this
In a eyslcm
c_rcult 9
-- and by the _ay,
up was )use
3s an infrared
to shov,
det¢ClOL
th_ use m a motion
the
only
thai the PIR
_s
not as a motion
delector
m a larger
right9
m a syst_a,
the 0u_e
are
or m some
Isn't _l
a componcm
wh_
Andfla_
aren't they _
3
those
lc't_nlna]s
I I point '7
Thca'fmlcuon_odt_ctlnfr;_ed-y
gale
10
top here, it says pyrocl_mc
the botlom
2
down
He_rmg
10/25/05
Page
If I could
comment,
the third
headc_
Markman
209
is designed
Ileanng
10/25/05
Page
210
OO212
(X)211
I for _
2
2
Q
Ycs_
3
A
I may use
4
some
ctrctul
5
dctcc|o_,
g
Q
7
I
conlxol
a conlponct_t
apphcat_ons,
1 would
say
It _'t
A
8 reading
9
detect o_
10
alcrmmt.
_
but jt_t
Q
how
13
doesn't
callthePI_monondetccton-
14
useful
In a mo41ort dxlcctof
15
A
16
maybetr_¢
18
Q
19
lnf_
talks
about
m moUon
da_a sh¢_
m d_tccung
GMBH,
_
25
you
md_i3_
right?
g_vcn
und_s_,nd
Thls_
And,
agree
I wo_dd need
THE
it and ar_v,_
s a _hole
series
Yes
you_
yo_
v, aat to g_e
hm_ time
to read
que_Uon9
6
MR
COOK
7
THE
COURT
8
THE
WITNESS
sheet,
Yes
flats ts typical
mtnlslon
I 1 Q
th_ the
you have
a Ge_nan
a_m_detector_andnola_motmndete_o_
Would
but there
Haw
many
I f I j_l
pa4ges'_
go to page
n',c, tha!
apphcatton,
alarms,
motion
Iyplcal
24 of the
appho_uons,
dcleCllOtt
R_ght
12
A
13
one
So tt's used
14
Q
15
mouon
16
A
rm
17
Q
Well,
18
m a mome_L
19
PerkmElrr_t
20
optoeleetromcs,
of the
m a motion
apphcaUons
Understood_
detector
they
d¢le¢i:on
Bul thts
it's tts_l
apphcahon
_
feature
do_n'l
desoa_oc
it a.s a
m thal apphcalltm9
not sttr¢ of your
qu_suon
ruth,s
111 move
on to a more
conctse
documenl
here
mouon.
Pyro¢lcctncdete_tors
24
&s a detfctor
c_¢_bol,
Bmtht.ya_cu:seful,_sl
Andhc_c'sano4h_PIR
A
COURT
9
lts_ysthey_ee
21
23
COOK
TttE
yes,
mfr_ed
cffcmts
th¢_¢ things,
20
22
context,
Andwhatwcarem_ngtoestabhshhe_e_
The parl_cul_
mdusby,
MR
4
S
d o_d_
Just--not
detector
12
17
detector,
a ge_-'ral
II
mdusuy
the same company
3
5
th_s ts a mouon
Used m motion
PJghL
_,qTNES
from
m
10
d¢
THE
so thL_ _ I_C ful _S a molton
fmmot_ondctecuon
th_ pa_
fashlo_
_s an engineer
say
lfsuse_ul
in a non-nofa_l
of pages
COURT
anoth_
co_y,
agam,
md_"J
appar_tly
thlsta[ksaboulPIP_
21
pease
that pyro
another
Co_orat_on
And again,
that's
piece
you
PetkmElmer
,.ktectors
calhng
these
23
it's not ca[hng
24
A
I*mnotst_c_hlchpage
25
Q
Thtslsagamm58
can s_
from
at the b_ttorn,
Corn
here :1 refers
22
Of hteral_¢
to pyroeleclnc
dewces
mfrared
infrared
delectors
-
to read flae ¢:attre data sheet.
Is th_
Here's
the ne_t page
o f th_s
exhibit?
Markman
Hearing
10/25/05
Page
them
mouon
-Whereatewe
lt's
at the end
Markman
211
JA 0833
9
ofthe
Heanng
10/25/05
Page212
O0213
I
00214
[nfratec
pttscntattoo_
I Q
2
THE
COURT
3
MR
HIGGINS
4
three
or four
5
pag_
THE
It's the Fuji
and Co ?
Thtsgoeson.
from
Thtstsmay_e
Is thLs page
A
4
apphcatlons
5
Q
247
I f I go
Q
YtS_ II t_
6 A
7
A
Okay
7 sccmlty,
8 to - m a motion
9
cull tt a mouort
10
Q
Pardon?
II
A
If I am
12
apphcatloa,
13
dclCClor
14
Q
IS
A
16
Q
And
17
they actually
18 A
19
detcctton
sensor?
door switch,
realtor
dctCCllOn
home
in
8 motion dct¢ctloix
well
9 Q
In other words,
using
oats dovice
well
ceil
m a mot]off
Oats dung
dotcctton
II
A
I f I read
12 Q
the moDon
Now,
Th© PIR?
14
- we showed
Yeah
15 patent
have
you srx'n anypDce
ca]l tt a mouon
m oats document
they couM be used
m such
a s.vstem
Ura_ood
delecbon
19
Andbcre'sanoth¢:rone.
from
oa¢ end, two pages
22
Company,
23
to ned the paragrap_
again
THE
pyroclccmc
the end, Fujt
detector,
PIPs
and
Take
m the - came
a moment
out of the
COURT
What is the qu_tlon?
not veery legoale
up wlth
21
A
IVas_
22
Q
In thts
Markman
Heanng
10/25/05
Page
24
conuol
25
A
that v,_
file fostoty
dtscfos_l
of the
to the
here oaey cull it PLR, passage
control
swuck
But h_e
And,
you
unfortunalcly,
have
other ¢trcmtzy
tfos ts
a PIP. in a module
Wo_dyoua_¢ewlthoaal?
Id]dx_'lUnde_tandtheq_llon
device
shown
m oats docmnent,
swtteh
I think -
you have
a
Andlt'scalledamodulec_-rgy
Would
you agree
oae copy
with
that7
I ha_ e ts not clear
213
Markman
00215
The
swflch
m 1996
heTe again,
23 PIRhookedupmclrcml_y
HIGGINS
tab, lab597
Ceramic
the one the attorney
energy
20 hooked
II'sacouple
from
And
18 infrared
eorrecdy
you tum to oae nexl
m oats lab ts the Nippon
Thtsts
17
Ifimlthattts
the morton
page
thts data sheet
would
16 patent office
where
detectc¢7
read OaedocumCnL
ts sagScstnd
BY MR
intrusion
d_teclOrS+
II says
thai seems to mc to inoacate apphcaIions
fast
24
the PIRs axe
of the page,
turn over,
Automatic
13
21 of pag_
to the bottom
_
agmn
and not motion
I 0 appropriately
I might
iq_phcatmn
25
, thai I mlght
dctettor
] h_emot
20 Q
aFphcatton
thai here
detectors
Y_
6
Itwouldsccmtomeffl'musmgthtsde_zce
you agree
IO as in fPMed
3
oa¢ end of el.
WITNESS
Would
2 it fcrted
Hearing
10.'25/05
Page
OO216
1 Q
2 n_xt
ABnght
page
MmcLtn't¢lther
m hctt: ts =gem
3
acUcmld_rgnthathasaPIRmtL
4
the
5
I'llmoveo_
_c
pyTo¢lc_U3c
The
_
I detector
Here's
2
PIR _ove_hereal
left
And
thts ts a home
pro leer where
6
tim y.tst fm a hobby
7
Ch_uahoa_.andhehadaPIRove_mthalefl
8
hc=_, he demgned
9
the mouon
I0
a cuctat
of hts pet do8
And.
I 1 has gone
again,
mlo
12
A
13
comTolcn'cmt,
oae dostgner
Wpe apphca_ou,
dM
it a
Andup
thal woeld
aM
me
chase
m a cacmt
a _
called
now.
ctrcmt,
3
They
4
a movcment
5
Would
6
a motion
9 engineer,
ffl
I0
se_or,
II
_s sensor
Thenoae_'sa
12
Q
I
13
module
concct?
andldon'lknowwhaltheoutpmts
And
have not rcM far cnoegh.
14
! 5 A
The
16
| agree
with
17
SystemasaPIR
18
i_
19
from
you done7
17
COURT
Whafs
'IME WI'I'NESS
IB
Q
Would
you agree
19
LkaI 1 showed
20
cwctut_
21
A
22
ts the s_'os_
23
pul m a control
24
from
25
Q
you
Agam.I
followed
tlus system
Now,
ciKmt,
qu_uon?
Pm nol sine.
oaal the -
w_s using
havenot
the o_
a pn_
rendzt.
el_c_aomcs,
I don't
docamem
m a mouon
It at_¢ars
by sornc
and
thts i_m
det¢ctton
called
Marlunan
followed
thaL
22
agree
with that?
23
A
The
24
product,
25
ts the scmo*
Page
215
you conecdy,
on a c_reul!
[ would
Io process
the output
ortha
Here
detector
is shown
wdh
a
board wlOa other c_rcmtry,
sa_d PIR movement
comzol
+t says thai this
detector
the whole
- I assume,
and
the r_t
to process
the
It'sachip,
again,
the
pIR
wouldn't
you
PIR sensor,
of the cl¢ctromcs
to be an LED
RE-2COB
I'm not famthar
RE-200B
a signal
that appears
kll uses
Thal'Sacomponent
wlOa Oats part,
ctrcmt_y
an o_tput
Markman
JA 0834
asan
oaere is a PIR
not characterize
Oae P IR to Faoduce
w hmh I wo_d
10/25/05
oats c]_mt
cnl delCctor?
lthmkthePIRL_asvparatesepso_,and
seRsor
a PIR movement
_1-
tt
detector
Howyounamca
by electromcs
by _ome
Q
Hearing
oaay _-c cldhng
title of Oats pap_
21
the ou_ul
dclCClOr
calhng
PIP, movement
or a movcm
oa¢ PIR movement
20
undershand
and
Tome,
tmdetstand
thai oaePIg
yeL
here ts something
now
mounted
Q
THE
agree that
m a ctrctut
detector,
tab 59
movcmCnl
Io do something.
15
16
PIR
followed
14
Are
dete¢lor,
Into your
moUon
ldonlknowthesottrc¢ofth_s
the plY.
lwouldvtewthePIRasoaeseaso_
a PIR
dctCCllOet clretul
you a_ce7
would
an: showing
you
Is further
infrared
8 la'nducthasalotofvartancesontL
oac room
oals ts where
detection
This ts on - th_
up al the top i! says
7 A
the PIR to deleCl
it around
And
w_th Oats
I would
say
ts a cm3trol
Hearing
10/25105
Page216
214
00218
00217
i clrctaUy
2 Q
Now.
hcTc's --cOnhnmng
on, here's a couple of
]
anoth_
scrtcs
2
Lhat _c
described
3
A
4 Thal_$ the ncxl Tn O_d_
4
pi'csc_tlon
5 A
5
things
3 pages, three pagc_, from Global Somccs.
do you see that?
GIobaJ som'ccs_
6
THE
7 Q
COURT
Do
6
you see thatpage?
8
0tat po_n_,
Ido
9
signal
Thcl_.np_vemslob¢
l0
Q
the
g left-handslde of the page allthese modules7
I0
II
Q
[don'Iknowlf
fbi's THECOURT
I_sjttst_cv/sma]]prml
It's
ha=d Ior¢_l even on thc page
14 By
MR_
15 Q
COOK
Okay
WcII, Dr
paalus, youhav©thcsamplcm
16 fronlof yov- You can see down
And
18 th_ tsa cal_og whole LtSays r/Iot1on
dclector and alarm
19 manufactm_supphe_
21
Thts_acalalogofmotlon
dc_cctors,would you agTec?
A
] thrnk thists a markcang
22
_p¢
23
it.rnotlon delccllonaJa._rct
LlXal
dcscn_cs
brochure page o f some
l_odm'ts thalarc me
24
Q
25
suppliers Andthenhc_c'smor©
2
3
MR
COOK
THE
COURT
MR.
COOK
Then
yeah,
andthc_twott'chnlcalwltn_sc_
5
sho_fldbcablctofmLshtomor¢ow
6
Mr
C_r[stm
7
is likely
$
We'll
9
rcg_ss
see you
Wc_rc
fc_
|0/2_05
witnesses,
Page
we have
om _lorney
b_
th/ec'_
wtmc_s
know
how
long
-Allnght
Verygood
back at rune m the morning
Wc
arc m
m rccc_
(TRANSCRIPT
Honor
MR
H]GGINS
15
MR
COOK
ready
to s_,r_ m a new
18
evening
CONTINUED
IN VOLUME
ll )
1|
12
]3
14
i5
16
]7
I$
19
2O
21
22
23
24
25
Markman
Heanng
10125/05
Exc_c
No.
)9
MR
COOK
THE
COURT
22
yo_
p_oof
Page219
JA 0835
olher
There's
bul the
purpose
of Lhc terms
of
Yotu
me
Is d_al a quc$11on
_
thai s a statcmcnt
Ob_ecllonsustmncd
arc_,
20
GI_¢
At
or some
apphcatlons
It's ten a/let
morning
m hcrc
the u:gagc
smcc
21
tt s hght
lwon'lconunucon.
THECOLrRT
17
ofscvcraJ
thai _t Fats a PIR
v, hcthcr
is to show
in cornmcr¢_aJ
consists
andsomckmdofsnoulpu!
Wcl]
14
all modules
mask¢_mg
_h_ch
perhaps
Ifyoua;¢
v*c'll s_op
for the
fi_ c
ye_lant
Wcql
A][nght
cornc
mc an estimate
back
You t_tr_
al nine
well
m the
finish
up
iomortow')
MR
COOK
THE
COURT
Wcslll]ha_¢Mr
C_lsonfoTthc
plamllff
R_ght
Markman
217
! t_nk
l d_a_
Okay
13
25
Iwo_fldthlnkthat_¢
to lake.
THECOURT
llearmg
wc have
Tkrc_
4
t,hls co]lcc_lon
24
Th¢ncxtpagchasgot
producl
of off, or things
12
23
Markman
10
fulfor,IfI read
Itsays. mot)on detector and alarm manufacntrer
00219
I
1 doz_'l know
Allnght
r_o PIRs
d¢lcclors
rnc as nol an untyplcsl
conlrolc_rcu_t_
16
uhc leftha_d sldc,thore's
)7 jizcta seriesof pcoducts hcTc m packages m housmgs_
20
strikes
l ! s1111 • bunch
12
13
fadm 8
n tbc sadc,
]n th_s c a.s¢, I'm prying
dclcctor
here these ¢k-vlccs- do yo,asc¢ down
do_
a_ motion
of a packaged
7
Now,
9A
This
looking
Ilearmg
10/25/05
Page
218
00220
I
00221
UNITED
FOR
THE
2
STATES
DISTRICT
MIDDLE
DISTRICT
NASHVILLE
COURT
l
APPEARANCES
OF TENNESSEE
2
DMSION
3 FOR
3
4 DF_A
IP. LLC,
)
THE
PLAINTIFF
ROBLRT
4
)
5
Pl_nldT+
)
IAMESR
HIGGINS,JR
TItEUERKAUF
J
Mzddlclon
Reullmgcr
2500 Bzown
& Wdhamson
5
Lomsvdlc,
KY
Tower
40202
)
6
) CASENO
vs
6
3 O4-0160
)
7
) VOLUME
EML
g
TECHNOLOGLES,
COSTCO
LLC
WHOLESALE
7 FOR
II
and
)
CORPORATION,
9
Eighth
Floor
San Franctsco,
)
Townse_
and
Two Embarca_o
)
9
)
Defendants
TIlE DEFENDANTS
IRIS SOCKEL
8
ROGER
MITRAKOS
L COOK
Tov, ns_d
Center
and Crew
CA
94111
10
10
11
12
TRANSCRIPT
13
OF PROCEEDINGS
14
15
16
17
17
I g BEFORE.
19
DATE.
20
TIME
THE
HONORABLE
26,
OCTOBER
ALETA
A
18
TRAUGER
19
2005
900AM
2J
22
23
REPORTED
BEVERLY
COURT
BY
24
OFFICIAL
A-g37U
25
OO222
I
COLE.
RPR
CCR
'IN 37203
NASHVILLE,
(6[5)
K "BECKY"
REPORTER
S COURTIIOUSE
726-4893tkma
n Hearing
10/26/05
Page
220
Markman
OO223
I
INDEX
2
3
THOMASJ
PAULUS
4
Conunm_d
Cr_s-Exammauon
$
Redtr_cl
Examznaqon
by Mr
by Mr
Cook
Higgms
226
237
COURT
COUNSEL
3
THE
4
MS
5
6
THE
2
maReT
Ileanng
10/26/05
STL:nJEN
8
Du'ec! Tesumony
CARI_ON
9
Dtnct
Ex_m._on
by Mr
I0
Crc_s-ExaTmnauon
by Mr
7
by Stcvcn
Carlson
COURT
morning,
YOUr Honor
Any pfehmmary
MITRAKOS
Yore
mailers?
Honor,
We noticed thai three oftho
_pl_cmc_ts
tha_ we would
243
8
THE
COURT
Higgms
289
9
MS
MITRAKOS
Cook
292
I0
11
(me housekeeping
whlch
cxhlblLs
12 J
13
Direct
Tesomc_y
Dh'ect
Exm_m_c_
15
O_s-Exmm_on
16
ReChreCl
_
[8
SCOTT
EVANS
19
Dwect
Te_omony
20
Dm_ct
Exammau_a
21
Crcss-Exanunauon
by J
M_chael
348
13
MS
Mitrdk_
381
]4
THECOURT
by
Higgms
402
15
MR
Mr
by Ms
Tho_
ivhwak_
403
16
by Scc_!
LLOYD
DnerJ
HIGGINS
are they?
75 _nd
right
now
76,
okay
or should
Arcthey
we do th_
at
17
THE
COURT
18
MR
H]GGINS
19
tcstmlony,
by Mr
Cook
420
20
Ie,x_o_
by Mr
Theu_kauf
21
p_ocedu_,U'_MPEP
22
the court
423
by Lloyd
M_engtll
428
25
Markman
Hearing
10/26/05
Page
222
he rcfen_d
fo_ allowar_e
23
THE
COURT
24
MR.
HIGGINS
25
tooppo_mg
We can do li al the break
Great
Okay
a
Okay
Y_terdayd_drLngMr
Io what
m called
Palterso_'s
a st._emen[
from the rrumual of patcm
of
examining
Wehavecopl_ofth_tolend_'to
All nghL
We have
Any objecUon7
al_
provided
a copy
counsel
Markman
JA 0836
I _ISO have
YOUr Honor,
mag_
pr©hmmmy
406
MASSENGILL
TesUro_
74,
MITRAKOS
Ewm_
22
23
al this point
nmnhors
74, 75 and 76
I0 need
by Ms
17
24
What
are the
Soweha',¢
12 the break?
M]CHAELTHESZ
14
going
hk© [o provide
Okay
THECOURT
I I Ones we're
221
Goc<I morning
Good
6 filedhlstorles,_omeofthepagcscopledhodly
7
Page
Hearing
10/26/05
Page
223
00224
OO225
Hoo_ccuon
}
_.IR
COOK
2
THE
COURT
3
the last Exh_h
867
What
Will
4
MS
S
THE
COLrRT
6
MR.
HIGGINS
7
THE
COURT
8
weql
9
of_
zI Exhtbtt
MR.
tha MPEP
That's
Very
You
Yo_
ltonor
g7_
to pass
that forward,
Is this just agener_
HIGGINS
abota
3_ts
THE
COURT
13
MR.
HIGGR,/S
14
'I_E
COURT
pmduc!
hk¢
THE
COURT
18
MIL
HIGGINS
20
wlme_es
yes,
you
23
y_terday
ma'am
related
to a parhcula_
Q
We will he prohably
of one
oftbe
Okay
h'kc to take the stand_
24
THE W1VNESS
25
THECOURT
You arc
Yes,
Dr
Paulus,
sUIi under
"_om
Okay
using this
defendants'
Okay
v.ould
oath from
Goahe.ad
Hearing
10/26/05
Page
cal m_ertal
2 The pyrcch:ctncul
4
Based
that the PIg
coupled
material
3 smafl otto-ant flows
S Dr
7 A
Good
8
Q
Vest.day
9
product
10
A
Y_,
II
Q
I see that I ha_e
12
_ as asking
13
report
Paulus_
morning
_hen
htt'ratm'c
we leg
_,th
you,
off
yo_
I ¢,_s
d_scussmg
some
recall_
sir
you,
a -- one
of the questmns
I see has been
add_sed
that
actually
I
m )_
IdMn'tapprccmtcthat
Would
you
15
at Lab 79 of the
16
of vou't
17
A
Y¢_,
18
Q
Okay
19
sa_d passr,
20
energy
turn
_o your
bmde#
Page
report
at page
S
you
Do
8, and that's
has c thai m front
slr
Tbefirstpartofthat
e m frgred
given
offby
22
phrasing
23
A
Yes
24
Q
And
25
are as follows
can
humans
Do you
then
we read
set, sots
t._c in motion
_tect
arid other
deteCtOl_
recall
yesterday,
b¢2tt or m stared
objefts
And
thai arc In
we discussed
that
that _
the next
two
In s_mplest
senterges
form.
-
they
three
consrst
Markman
to a spcclaJ Iran.slstor
zs b_lt
hke
a cap_ntor
_ the m Stared cnc_y
Upon thai Suttement,
offan
gives
would
elecmcal
I engineering
2 A
A
changes
3 science
you ague
slgaul
with
m re.spc4_e
me
to
semenc_
of a
}leafing
10/26/05
Page
225
5
Q
tbedevteephsstc$ofhowapyxoul_ctnc
Well
8 Q
Okay
g A
A
A
Q
I undcpslm_
12
A
I'm sure
13
could
14
SerillcorldL_lor
15
Q
16
and
17
have
15 &* reference
I rend
Hayt
real
fn: re feixaxc
17
Q
IS
b'tames
I9 A
Page
227
of
ts --
be a device
phymcs,
just
like sludymg
a U'finsl$1ol" _&ofk$
Okay
Are
you knowledgcable
as to how
a
tbe docur_mt
-- ] den't
recall
wbe:r¢
concerning
14 PIRsorphotcccIlsoranyoftheothc_toplcsm'enuonnd
16 _cct
II could
10
I _
12 Q
whtch
how
I0 ot coplcd from anoth¢_ lexl?
aspect
are dtscugsmg
That'sachfferentsub)ectffomelecmcal
engmcenng,
9
thai you summmzed
parhcular
you
7
cry, to tt or m thls somelhmg
or maleTla]
v, hat
that material
I would agrc¢,
you
exactly
4
7 A
l_d
It 9
I m not sure
6 d_ace',_orks
Andwbere&d--thdyouwmethtstcxt7
tsn't
I'm nOl SUre if lt*s ¢le'_tnca]
6 the changc of m franxl _crgy '7
13
as foffows
EXAMINATION
00227
I _lec_
}!
sworn
CROSS
224
00226
9
bee_
and t¢_ttfied
COOK
2& common
Honor
Markman
examined
Goodmomm
14
That ,s corcect_
THECOURT
22
"_ hat it ts'_
Okay
c_,-¢xammal)on
21
from
flats one7
lVh_L HIGGGqS
during
section
for --
tbe role saying
Not
17
19
o f rea_on.s
J_t
16
5
BY MR
6
and
p_¢, ious]}
CONTINUED
5
statement
ts the ar.a_
the slateraem
_s
4
well
PAULUS
having
3
corrcck
want
T]
2
Okay
12
15
What'S
thai b¢_
'_
10
II
wdl
thai be 877
MITRAKOS
mark
I
exhthlt
You don't
to sdcct
I referred
20
thff_em
books
21
wouldhaverefLari_tt
Kemmedy,
for the
but I don't
refearm8
th_ [_t_ut_dar
to probably
Spectfically.
m any text of
deftmt
a series
,f I bed
_on?
o f a dozen
co_ed
th_
I fedsmelsun'anan_d
rend seven_
23
Q
Yo_
24
A
NO
25
Q
And thaf$
any
pIP..
rlmacmbcl-
22 having
I
recall
1
from
t_urces
ao_ an exp_
in pyroe|c_mca_
delectors'_
Asls_there,
review
em subject
Markman
Hearing
10/26/05
Page
v, ould
previously
review, ed materials
remember
the
arlaWer
how
they
you no er understond
I have
not stuthed
Q
Would
you
20
pyro¢lecmc
21
¢op._tsted
ofa
22
r_ponse
to the ehangt_
23
that ma_cnul,
detectors,
matenat
the po)anty
which
I wouldnot
JA 0837
to other
to determine
to the question,
or
workeW
tbem
thsagrec
the
v,qth me tf I suggesled
dell:for
that's
p3_ton
polanze_
thai
of that
and
that m
radiation
falhng
on
13_p tidies m one dlr¢cl_o_
a_d
of infrared
produces and clecmcal
d_sagreewathyott
Markman
226
be common
for dcvic_
you
IS A
A
I feelcertamthatl
don't
19
25
than elccmcal
m, at_n_ds
Have
simply
24 then back
a thffer
lcannot
the rnalena/that
slgna]_
Idonthavea
Hearing
10/26105
00228
OO229
I bast_ for a_'eemenl
2 O
of thsagTeemcnL
3
THE
4
are
5
referred
2 PIP.s,
COURT
refmang
COOK
7
THE
COURT
th florence
the adthtlon
II
whal we're
correct,
And
pyroclfcmc
passive
make
any th ffetence
13
the pyroele_Inc
material,
ts coupled
to a field
t4
UanszstoL
co_les
the change
m the sxgnal
15
oulput
And
I understand
that comp_te
17
generates
an elecmcal
18
whalev_
way
19
BYMR
COOK
20Q
one
to proc¢_
po_on
matea_al,
polat_ly
7
electrical
ssgna],
a_l
8
morton
Does
9
r_;porLSC to any change
10
sensor
any
ofa
pc_on
mateml,
A
l'mnolst_elwouldp_sestthalway
you have
e mfrared
Is a pyroele_c
Now,
parilcu[ar,
14
Dr
would
llg_e
h¢¢¢7
Ihavea
change
m heal
and
signal
am uymg
to do :s r_
or stm_rnanze
Markman
Hearing
together
m the way
w hat
10/26/05
Page
objccl
Thal
Paul.,
Or_
18
_t has some
19
thal
copy
I'm going
_e're
could
be in
falhng
of the patenl
on the
to be looking
and
m
L_at tab I
to _sk you to [tan
going
enstead
at fig_s
to
2A and
Th_sh_tbemsldcbyslde
a deposlllon
ksndw_tmg
That's' not -- ] dor_'t mean
Bu[ tf you wo_d
21
of IS figm'_;
22
the ctrcueL
2A _qd
exhtht
on el m god
look
23
Isn't thai co.ecf_
24
A
Tab
25
joined
togetber
&b'_cg_'d
thai with
you.
at the -- W hal this consLgls
2B of the patent,
85 appea_
L AS a resuk,
Please
to d_tms
[fs one large thasr_m
to be
228
which
thvtdod
a copy
together
fo_
ento halvcs
of fig_es
Markman
00230
an
to the
you turn to the '066 patent
27
Th_s tab 85 was
20
to produce
In respof_¢
m m frarod energy
13
17
to a
Isn'lthaltra¢?
16 2Bsedebyslde
m
IL
sent, o_ 0k_l deLects
an elecmcaJ
AIH
said
or other
| think that _ correct
that
flxp-flops
that Lsn't n_essanly
Q
to the
coupled
whenthepyroelecmc
PIR,
12
effec!
the PIR
Now,
II A
the material,
be W_
o f the PIg
22
Q
_
thai can
21
25
thai
s wact m'e forms
signal
wanLs
So tbe sens_
_
6
15 tab 8_ because
16
passlv
Allnght
abouf?
WITNESS
23
with that stalernent
Okay
her© to
THE
24
] agree
Q
sensors
12
which
A
5
of it, ofa
forcrt,_they",meanmg
malenal
4
PaulmcanexplamthaL
of py[oclectnc
pyro¢lecmc
we ha_ •
if that's
mfrarcd
ofa
3 special t_anststor?
Honor
] don'1 know
SomaybeDr
tathtng
Your
Yousayxnsimplc_l
cor_st
You
set, sots
That's
between
9 sofnethmgelse.
ask a qut_t_on7
Th© PIR abtnc_aatlon
mfrated
MR
!0
Can 1j_Sl
to pyroelcctnc
to as passive
6
8
I you%esazdhcr¢
All nghL
2A and
Hearing
2B
10/26/05
Page
229
00231
I Q
And
they are)omed
tha_ the
2 patesRsxlgg_lstheyshouldbcjomcdtogether
3
down
al tbe bottom,
4
thagram,
5
2B joined
6
nghL
Is that
7
A
Yes.
8
Q
NOw.
right bere
9 yo_'ve
stde
a sz_
II
nghau_,
12
object,
fig_e
and
wo_ld
A nd then there's
block
3
eventually
4
voltage
5
to ttwn on the bright
6
A
2. then jt shows
2A on the Icfl and
you
- I think you
tlus m yo_
repo_
to &t_'Img
m thls c.a_
lsthal
2A
and
2B on the
uodrrstand,
thai
f.ome _e
a mot_
and
the PIR
sends
9
m mftatod
o f a p¢'r_on
|0
o_ oth_-
Tbel
_ corrcCL
Q
And
tben
I $ where
- t_
been
16
whc_
the cm:tut
18
A
Art
19
totbeclatmsofthepa_nt?
sel¢clcd
rm
down
will corms
we refeanng
pn3¢essed
to figm'es
to figures
21
A
In the preferred
embothment
22
Q
Yes
here
23
and
24
cha:acter_c
25
ngta7
And
the -
to the pomt
ov_
the piPs
clecmcal
QI
slgrtal
wlu:re
al as the morton
l*mnot
fe femng
to d_ point
on the
2A
And would
tdenttfy
making
2B7
of the palenO
lcfl, these
are the pIRs
THE
offthc
that wc have
Hearing
10/26105
f_
_s to _ bethe_
Page230
you
proc¢_
describe
just
the mpul
17
wed
th_
Are you
Yes,
of cl_cmt_
COURT
whether
h_m wha_ bl_cks
20
M_
21
THE COURT
COOK
are
Is thai the questton?
blocks
are the ones
that
l'm_tmply
which
stgnal
make
the decision
from the P1R w_ll be
light
The
the bright
m
to thu; docmnent?
asklng
wthch
partecula_
to turn on the b_ght
THE
from the
thai are revolved
by te fercnc.e
blocks
hght
Y_s,
of cerc_ut_y
thai
wd_ turn on?
that*s nghL
You
understand
thc question,
D_
Paulus7
THE WITNESg
24
this
embodiment,
25
m the palent,
wthch
the d¢ctslon
I think,
your
i$ a pre ftmred
to tm_
Markman
JA 0838
as to whethfr
th_ me the -- of jus[
bthcks
COOK
the blocks
to
coreect7
fo_aIlthecon_olc_rcult_y
ukmg
dcc_de
a dectston
done
o_ a low
the lamp
COURT
MR
23
discussed.
a high vo[tase
crrcmu 3, m h_ opmson7
16
22
of that slgna_
ctther
ch-cmuy
that selection,
15
19
hght,
for us the cncml
the control
18
xm'e
and Q2 glvc
Markman
d's -
and 2B c¢ n: femag
2A and
control
14-I'mnc4askmg
of a desttrd
proce_,slng
to c_cat¢
and does chive
13
tha_ slgnahs
decide
The
II
12
arc the ser_o_
that w_II be u_cd to make
8 Q
oul
co_x¢¢6'
13 A
th_
httlc
Q
7 ,_]sors
m n_'ponse
No,
&agram.
They
2
¢O_Te_t_'
14
20Q
a hule
that _ys
by side,
md_¢al_d
10
the_'s
I A
Youscc
bnghl
Hon_"
The -- in
embethment
desc_bcd
_r not ram
Hearing
10/26/05
Page
Z31
O0233
0O232
I Imght
ts made
at the output
of the on
umcr and
I shown
tram off
m figme
2
2
lnhthlt,
v*htch Onv_
3
a slglxal
THECOURT
4
at node
Waqnow
THE
WITNESS
6
THE
COURT
7
THE W1TNESS
8
THE COURT
9
THE WITNESS
me
So block
46'_
THE
COLrRT
11
THE
W1TNESS
52,
THE
13
14
deleltntnc
15
".ollagc
16
the
W1TNESS
_
I unde_
at node
paper
17
18
hff_
lase_
hand
on umer
[ ha_e
and _
I0
mbabH7
ts the block
us to the
thin _ dl
to genc_al¢
leg.
aboul
please
YotLrHonor.
THECOURT
a
mld_
ay down
_
maylhnngthe
lsee61
yoedon*tr_odtopomt
It out to me
21
THE
WITheS
22
reference
voltage
23
node6$
And
24
25
_ ol_ge
foz the sign
depen_ng
of 61 ts how
which
The
con_ls
voltage
at node 61
the
the dura_on
is the
- or the ramp v, hlch
on how lons
long
the
of the hght
Is at
ramp succeeds
tr_ac m sectzon
Markman
73
No_
th¢
_ on,
le_mma_sF
2
43
3
Q
Detector
4
A
Block43,
OUtlet
6
m_'bl_
7
Q
that is
Ilearmg
10/26/05
A
9
agmn
yes,
3 at the
3 is part
Do you
_ ant him
high
Dr
mhtb;t
No,
Paulus,
that's later
Io refer to figure
In getting
or low
and making
on m the
clrcun
up Io the on-timer
the decision
whether
you a_ree
w_th me that
12
_
in_ ol. ed in making
13
the
1¢fi7
14
A
15
sensors,
16
Q
So the answer
17
A
Would
18
Q
I would
19
are mvo]vod
20
vollage
21
decide
22
off 7
23
A
In thus pre fcr_ed
24
Q
Yes,
The d¢lector
block
the
the
or a low
The scmor
on
the
please_
_ htch
etrcmt
blocks
Io produce
up at the on
or no: the I_ght
m thts
from
43,
LS yes_
the decuslon
voltage
whether
blocks
block
szgna]
question
hke you to idenu[y
m making
circuit
to the set.ors
to my que.suon
repeat
be
hght,
'_ Detector
recet'.es
and so it's coupled
you
the following
that decision
and
it will
so as to go on and turn on the bnghl
hght
e_ther
ttmer
in order
_ttl
be turned
a h_gh
to
on or
ernbothmen(_
thagram
_ e axe _alkmg
produces
a signal
abou#
at F the
Markman
I A
Thafs
The
12
v,_odowcomp_z_
13
coup]e_
14
Q
And
15
A
II go¢$
the re'l
block43
prostrated
The
to the turn-on
46
right
he_© where
part of_
A
contmlblock.
where
c,atput
I'm pomtmg
rm pointing
goes
on to tbe pu_
IO the p_lls_ corral
3
the
4
count,
whzch
5
Q
And
6
this
parhcula_
7 pulse
counL
10
to block
48,
the
Andtha_outpulofthe,_ndowcomparzt_
tt goe_
produce
9 on
to 47
hexe7
ts connected
courd
I v.ould
2
block
"_
Clr_try
not use
a sxgrml
output
8 whether
TheoulpultS
circmffy,
0 f 47
"_
st-veTal plac_
Q
I_.O
Ilearmg
Page
10/26/05
233
of whtch
then
dectdod
by
thavc_
node
goes
the cl_cult_
you agree
wtth
that _ ould
etther
lamp
at thks point,
to, the output
be h_gh or low
has selected
ctrcuflxy
Io a pulse
to turn on the
me that
that I m pointing
the ctrcmtry
The sensors
the control
m thks embothmem
_ould
the Imght
A
the phrase
It ts processed
a signal
at
of the
de.rig
upon
thai wall ham
hght7
In this pr¢ fer_ed
stgnaJ
embodiment,
I l p_oce_ang
the
from
12
the contyol
clreml
13
Q
And
the outpul
14
A
Will
etther be high
15
Q
Iflfslow
16
A
In thts embodiment,
17
the concern
18
photocell
19
of the bright
20
Q
21
the--thatth_¢wdln_beabnghthshtturnon
22
iftt's
low
23
there
v, lll be a bright
24
A
yeah,
25
Q
Okay
ofSl
the ser_ors
a pulse,
wdl
the conWol
circuit
produces
internal
to
thal's correct
rather be
hlg h °r
low_
or Iov.
thebnghthghtttwnson7
I also
_ ouJd ha_ ¢ to mclude
517
A
In56_cxct_emeomSl
18
count
19
On-umer
Q
ks then
part of the conu'ol
Q
block
couplodmtothedetec_r,
of block
II
21
43 ts tbe firsl
of the d_t_:tm
10
20
Figure
Page232
"[']'_.-ya_ecouplodmlotheCtlnUo]cwcuttal
And that's
8
17
hax e figure
OO235
I
16
Now,
25A
CO234
5
COOK
I 1 would
the pointer,
HIGGI]4S
MR
w e d_n't
3_
9 tunvon
52
This
COURT
8 Q
al the -comer
pointer7
19
20
nght
t._nd IL a signal
61, whzch
May
YOU role starling
Okay
COOK
THE
7
Inhthtt
THECOURT
hfR
5
And
moment
6
52
Upper
I0
12
Excuse
WmL
4
3
Sole_referto
Block
COURT
61
blocks
5
3 of the patenl
TIlE
Tbeoutlmtoftbepulse
and d_s_nbothmenl
and _
And v, ould you
the pulse
comet,
or low,
corrects
to the block
nght
dr'pending
agree
where
upon
w_th me then
the
I'm pmntmg
high
thai you
24
identl fy thts a.,; stmx'.'_thlng thai w_"ll t_rn on the
25
hght_
have
Markman
thee
d¢c_ded
of
condmon
Bul at thts
the sv.atch
zs set
ts m 56 be fore
pomL
tftt's
high
62, and
I would
whal
have
that mem_.s
the
a turn on
that
And
her©, ts either
23
_dent_fied
,._be_¢r
thai the ou_pul
22
have j_t
52,
irth_d.
on where
czrcmt
wheth¢_
Hearing
that means
that subject
to further
hghl
on
processmg.
blocks
or not to
hngh_
10:26/05
Page
I think that's
Now
turned
correct
a_ an expe_
Markrmm
234
JA 0839
in ctrcmtry,
Hearing
Dr
paul_
10/26/05
Page
235
00236
OO237
I do -
arc any
of these
cltcml
blocks
2
things
that you ha_ c pcrsortally
3
A
I am
4
&agTam
5
Q
6
1_'1
7
A
8
$¢¢n all the elements
9
Q
famthar,
They're
seen
I beheve,
not anything
tmtqtm
I Q
m the past?
with
you
Or are they
all ©Icmen_
imven't
seen
That
I0
not seen
it m thts
3
b'a¢
4
A
I did
5
Q
In your
6
morton?
m this
before
arrangemem,
w_myquestton_
THE
II
COURT
BY MR.
13
Q
Dr
14
figure
2A o_ 2B ts mooc_
15
A
The motion
16
Q
And when
17
18
19
Dtd
9 A
Correct
quesUons
I0
Q
11
PIR scraot
12
A
refcmngtofigurc2Aand2B,
f'w_t straed
ts seined
mouon
al OI
whctcon
of a pcrson
him
pass his hand
Th© signal
shown
17
Q
18
arc you
Q
Wh¢.c
on
19
of figure 2 - QI?
20
fiBu_
ZA and 2B?
20
A
21
A
its shov,"n al the wmunal
scmot
21
cotdd
22
Q
Is figure
22
data
23
ctrcmt
of the pt© fcrred
23
Q
Whenyouwer¢obser.mgMr
24
A
It Is the ctrcm|
24
thd the
bare PIR sensor
25
the patcm.
25
A
2A
the cncmt
of the
cmboduntmt
S o f each
patcm
or the
of the paumt?
of the preferred
embedmlent
Markman
of
Hearing
10/26/05
detect
"7
that bare
over
the dct¢ctor
when
he p_ased
his
hand
when
you say the
re feme.B
to thc
[['s the source
shc¢l
stgnal
was
S shown
terminal
be the S terminal
which
was
value
from
the
on figure
of the PIP.,
There
was
S tetrmnal,
ZA as the
so y_,
outlml
its
the S terminal
on the
tco
Raper's
dcl¢ct
motion
demonstration.
of an ob]ccl7
h did.
Markman
Ilearmg
10/26/05
Page
237
0O239
I O
And what
2
A
A small
3
Q
And
4
detected
object
was
Lotu_tlle
I A
hat.
detctmzne
that
the bare pIR
_
3 Q
4
the bat be mo_ ed back and fourth
and watched
the mgaal
change
aow,$
Refemng
teat below
I 0 ctrcmt
you
figm¢
12, you make
mcludc_
II
ctrcmts"
12
_cm
13
A
May
14
Q
Please.
15
A
Ihavctt.
16
skatemcnL
to pag© l 0 of yore
the statcn',_t,
the filtc_ mph
That sentence
tier.
r_fcrs
comparmor
ts detected7
Would
8
Q
Is that clrcml_y
respcra¢
9
your
logic
I 0 on pagc
10 ofM_-
I!
of tbe Sctrmr be fore moUon
MR.
Do you
_ta_mc_
have
[ show
tl on
HIGGINS
_t, str7
page
Yottr
10ofmycowofh_
Helot.
do you
ha_ ¢ thaL
THECOURT
20
BY MP.
21
Q
lhavegotlL
H|GGINS
So ts tt coercer
22
rcfcrred
23
ctrcm[
24
_
25
scbema_c
Thankyou.
to you on
includes
thai the Sentence
p_¢
I 0 of you* stalemc_,
the fihct,
the Io81c crnatt _
o_ page
0_t
the amph
refers
I0 of Mr
Markman
the
flc_. the coraparator
to the figtu_
Raft's
1 jtt_t had
-
the
$_t7
Hearing
10/26/05
Page
238
you repeat
which
became
you
14
Rapct's
schcmat¢
Rape¢$
refcr
rcpocL
toonpag¢
_.sked hem what
on
represented
ts dctectco"_
You
the respottsc
MR
HIGGINS
ThaCscorrect.
THE
COURT
- I Lmderstood
p&'t ts the r_pon_
THE
WITNESS
19
THE
COURT
so reword
21
but I need
22
BY MR.
23
Q
24
thor© that you just
25
schcmat_
hav¢
lost
me
this representation
16
20
10of
schcmauc
Is that sclcctJon
I'mson_
}8
-- paf.c
o f the
m turn re fct_ to the c_rcmt
m D_
ctrcult
and -
you to say thc
c_cmL
Tt_s
Now
yore- questtc_
pomor_
yoo
I don't
arc going
somewherc
understand
else,
ii. He may.
to
HIGGINS
"rhatpomonofMr
noccssa_
Raper's
referred
rq, ort,
the_cbem_c
to. zs that poruon
for ;'us dcv_cc
Markman
JA 0840
ct_utoy
I_
bottom
trt your
that, ple_e?
that you
THECOURT
13
17
pomon7
19
_
clrcud_'
of
Rapcr's
to the semencc
be fore mouon
Ralx_s
porhtm
part ofM_
refers
A
12
I rcft_ to h_
also
t,cnsor
'1
17
whtch
7
the
m the
and
to what of Mr
R©ft_'nr, stothalpamcular
statement,
6
on
"T'he
bottom
ts that $c]ccuon
its value
statement,
to the
nol the top portion
I 0 o f you* statement,
7 osc_llo_og¢.
8 Q
It re fcr_ speclfical}y
2 that &agram,
of thai object'?
I watcbed
6 the bare PIP.
tha_7
sluggc_
holy did you
moron
5 A
18
PIR sensor
the _edloscope,
changed
Page236
00238
9
the S terminal,
on
Conect_
marked
a
the detector?
A
shown
mcludcd
thd you nottce
what &d you observe
_m outpul?
scmmg
bate
of a persotl
from
of motion
and Q2 ptoducc
morton
morton
Aed
15 A
Qt
dtd the
16
is the outline
does
dcrnonstratlon
detecting7
I watched
14 over
and Q2
ts seraed,
What
13 Q
m thai flgm©?
RalXt's
that the demoPatratton
obs¢tvatlon,
It dctecl
EXAMINATION
HIGGINS
Paulus,
It thd.
Any rethrect7
REDIRECT
12
further
Mr
notice
PIR semot?
8 Q
corre¢l.
I ha_¢no
dtd you
7 A
but I havc
of the components,
you obsc_'ed
y_tcrday,
that cortect_
I ha_¢
When
2
to have
of the
sensed
Ilearing
mouon
10/26/05
of
Page
239
0O241
00240
I a Ix'r_onm
I Q
_17
So ff the
court
2
thai the -- thai certmn
3
terms
4
c_rcmt
5
VdslCh ctrCUll
6 to using some other claim chart dsaf$ m the rccord'_
6
elemtm
I'_
7 A
on the pal_cular ¢lcrnmk_
7
A
I think
I1_ various
mventlor_
8
that I'm quahfie&
m block
10
2 A
No
3 Q
No_,
4 pr_emed
5
_
) ou h_l $cvcral
In Icrn_
of t_l_h ckum
9
d_cnbed
which
m the
block
corlsl_tu;_
13
l v, as able
wthch
;o combine
15
I'm no[ sure
16
d_,c'nl_d
make
17 Q
] kccp
THE
19
clmm
clear what
BY MR.
22
Q
m[o
pon,or_
m_ en0on
]lend
a smorg_bord
constltul_
dsal
the im entlc+l
Verybnefly,
COOK
Paulus,
YourHonor
- F-X-'_,flNATI
and 2B, shown
24
shownlnthepaiffl_t
25
A
tinning
back
at tab 85,
ON
to composite
thas ts the ordy
of figures
carcml
2A
thagram
I_II'1
thal_Ofr_cl9
Ye_
Markman
Heanng
10/26/05
Page
MR_ H|GGIN$
CarLson,
a_
3
package,
_fyou
4
COURT
w_
6
Do wc Imow
7
MR
8
THE
COURT
9
MR
HIGG[NS
Mr
65, bot ds¢_
Wont
And
_ ould
look
Io to dcctdc
v, ould
be used
IO define
a quesnon
of law,
and rm
Sodol
Dr
in
be the
a claim
nOl sttre
Paulus
Thalzsa
(Laughter)
12
BYMR
13
Q
There
COOK
14
A
This
ts the only
15
Q
Okay
Thankyou
is no other ctrcult
orctat
THECOURT
structure
m the palmll_
diagram
m the patent
Anythmgds¢7
Dr
may step do'.',
n Thank
You
Ig
THE
WITNE_qS
19
THE
COURT
20
MR
HIGGINS
21
THE
COURT
22
MR
COOK
23
THE
COURT
24
THE
WITNESS
25
THE
COURT
I m physiCS
Sttw e
2 years
Thank
Paulus
you
you.
you.
Is he exeused_
Your
May
Honor,
may
he bo excused
he bo excused
Yes,
_
_;'
he may
You
may
bc excused
_ cry well
Nexl
wttm_,_9
Ilearmg
10/26105
Page241
4
ts - I
Many
mcluthng
statement
_
fo_ sure7
6
used
on Broadway,
77, Your
Honor
7
thtater
8
con_x_l
tmd_
That
pomon
comes
9
lalcr m
10
AIInghL
fWH'NESS
15
THE CLERK
Raise
WAS
nght
SWORN
Stale
yore
ban&
)
name
17
18
THE
CLERK
SI_mB
19
THE
W]TNESS
THE
COURT
21
THEWI'I'NESS
Ka_e beam
re_am_
23
lawsmt
za _
24
systems
and
I reccwed
Good
Good
mormng,
Your
MyrtametsSte_enB
m the field
wlth
the
of hghtmg
Carlson
l have
o;er
30
of hghtmg
1
con_'ol
box
14
computer
nciworkang
among
Adthuonally,
Ethernet
17
¢ommltl_
ts charged
1$ metropohtan
area
of over
I also
3 and
24
standard
25
Enlertamment
control
S02 3
standards
and
of the
Our
for local
and
networks
fasthon
served
papers,
to hghtmg
the chmrman
arc
to move
the pro)ect
while
adhenng
IO all the
secrctaxy
of IEEE
ml_
Assoclanon
seP, e as the cxecuuve
I also
and
onnme
m 1EEE
setting
m_ duties
the shmr
-
penchng
40 tcchrucal
group
wtth
Standards
was
group
with s_eral
relating
study
in a ttmcly
802
field
compuler
As chatrraan
23
hgbong
nuerocomputct
others
1 ara cunemty
residential
IEEE
Syslcm
based
the fi_l
to p¢oJ¢ct
presentations
16
of the
control
rmhsled_anm_enlor
and
21
and
ex[ends
I am the author
forward
the first of their
Ilghlmg
system
thmrnet,
expcrtence
semma_
22
shove-named
¢on_,ol
13
20
were
the first rmeroprocessor
m the ¢lectr0ntes
19
Honor
_ng.
m connection
expert
their
Caflgon
Be f.raI_L
20
in 1974
and devclo_l
products
corgoratcmanagemcm,
15
foz the recocd,
please.
THEWITNESS
wa/I
My
I 1 patents
LerssweazDr
your
College
d_lgn
first computerized
hghlmg
12
14
of these
type
77,B
CLERK
In the
5
C.ar_oix
THE
Whitman
3 cotxt_01 systerpa
take but a second
has slaleng'nt
from
expert¢_;¢c
m the past
not bccn
HIGGINS
THECOURT
13
25
th_
of law
accurale
thafs
t_b h_
calls
C_dson'ssmemenL
I!
22
stnlcturc,
Markman
to set up the lechnology
Honor
Okay
5
what
plaintiff
to nccd
w_ll, Your
THE
told
Tl_
we're going
2
16
of law
be defined
00243
1
12
a matler
should
would
240
OO242
10
thars
_
elements
that the court
elements
17 are fimshcd
n_'_oss'_
clrcmt
THECOURT
question
16
COOK
Dr
strUclUre
I I
of
claim
Any
RECROSS
21
umquc
lha_e_fil_t_qu_uo_
COURT
MR
20
as opposed
cha_ appro._h
clemc'nLs
inchvldu_
V_'ywell
18
fy the
up that pal_cular
_[ of the sub
by _ch
md_wdually
to idenn
If [ go [oa masl_
14
th _-ams
to deode
claim
of a particular
9
at Ihc clmms
By looking
clmr_
you
pa_cnL
I I dmagrazllforra,
12 those
thal
Whythdyouch_)sclo
of these
I wanted to slay foc_ed
I0
_gr_ms
as pai'l ofyouxslalement
i's_c cl_w_
8
23
block
were
of 802
as the
3af, the Power_over-Ethemct
co-chart
of the
dss_
my
tmdcrgrathm_¢
Markman
bachelor
Hearing
of arts degr t_
10/26/05
Servtces
and
Technology
Markman
Page242
JA 0841
As*,octat_on
tteanng
control
10/26/05
Page
243
OO244
00245
I p_LJttCblS workmg
2
E-S-T-A.
3
gToup and was the cha_
advanced
I ctzrrcndy
4
Incorporated,
5
locking
contxot
_¢n the
HSD
network
I_eSldcm
HSD
on embedded
of the ESTA.
2
of }hgh Speed
Ls a hlgh-tcch
networking
Deign,
cons-lung
7
In edthbon.
$
Dusmess
9
hghtmg
10
lndusws'
II
_d
Pathway
13
others
provides
controX
rob|ode
No_¢l
Connecuvlty.
I chd nol parUclpate
of U S
16
Freebee.
17
c_dcr
18
parU clpatJ on m thzs ca._e
the p]amuff
Purpose
Swand
_de
m the _son
to or have
of my testimony
cmnl
21
z$ Io amy©
wd] cotxh¢!
22
of the '066 patent
23
| have
re'viewed
24
the electrical
c)n:mby
25
ha_e
| understand
a Markman
at a prup_
asked
otber than
hearing,
tatc'rpfetat2on
the *066 patcr¢
dzscfosed
to give
and I tmderstaod
m the '066
tutorial
2
clcctromc
4
clrcmt
de:_zgn program
bfock
Io
p m. if yes.
cl_gram
12
th_fo'lprml.
13
hbl¢
14
two
the
open coataCl
as well
by Wdl
_: a
P.apcr
to g_v¢ my uplnlon
claams
of '066
as
p_atcnt
skJn in the art relevant
result
of control
Ioglc
all contrbl
the desned
ts a solution
and ¢onlro)
logic
to
r_;ult
Mosl
many
of c_e¢1_cl_y
used
ball&ngs
a.,_ount
17
occup:ccL
18
peuple
_9
that sc_lsor
20
_n_
2_
arc tumed
off.. e_d
22
e]_Ul¢lty
and Its op¢_atln 8 COSl ts l¢_s
Bmlthn&s
to ]lg;lt rooms
us4: occupancy
through
a control
_o that when
a_
to detCCl when
couple
the
thm_)
the bolI&ng
the deszred
wlnng
ume, say
the
_cs
control
the
output
of
IO the
the room is no_ c<cup_ed,
be achlc_ ed by s)mp)y
of the
ate not
en'cm! reupor_slve
comequently
In its slmplc_t
thai alblr a certain
which
sensors
are In o_ are not m a room.
25
by fi._t
are conscious
|6
would
begin
ot_en thai desired
to a p_oblcm
AS an example,
24
clrccuts
problems
lights
lcss
result
lights
to a c]c<k so
6 OO p m, the hghts
Markman
9 2, the
basts
2
The control
are
Hearing
5
to mthcate
the
de'_ce
wo_d
ftmeuon,
hghl
whc_
I I
appa_endy
wehaveasWltchth_-c's
that would
go
botwcen
oudme
of the
lamp
a
points
one
|2
10/26/05
Page
245
&_'t
shoed
to
find )t nec_ary
Io woA
m _
16 tbo control
but
ofllce
at mghL
b_lthn8
So smzply
pc'opl¢
tumzng
22
of comacu;
23
wOUld send
The
_a_g
thzs. an occupency
to detect
whc_
a response
I_hL_ v.c4dd
upon
became
the
signal
door
_
_s Swua_
to lurn the
bo turned
which
Ileanng
of
10/26/05
ts
the desired n:se]t, hghts
could address th_s problem
the us_
Page
246
24
second
25
offhsh_
when the eccupant
the manual
deoi" swm_
beca_e
mlgfo
a person
be to add a
bc turaed
t',rsI door swing,
of pcrson catcrmg
mthcat_
the
leaves a'.d forgets
o'_c_]de
to the conta¢l so that thc hghts would
Markman
JA 0842
can block oat
ts belp ful bol does no( _
ncx! level o f r.uph_sl)catzon
23 lurn on the hghts
ts
_s m_ m&cauon
of sophtsucauon
22 off only sncr cvcry other door swing,
c_ or off
the dooc
conthUon,
the contact. IS the sarac
clrctnl and keep tbe hghts o_-
of what huppt_
Tt_
21 cou_tcr
be a set
upen
hghts
on wben
open doo_
Markman
could
because the detected
ovcn3de switch
19 to turn the hgh_ offor
the
20
ser.so_
this
and I ¢a','mg
Thts app_l_ch
18 problem
off. aP.m 6 CO p m Is not accclXable.
To addxe_
Is known
However,
has ju_¢ cr, t crcd th©
making or breaking
to coRs)stendy achieve
A manual
17
Um_
foglc
or on off
15 so that when tbe roo_n Is occuplcd,
be there
many
son of control
bang control,
Is
switch
13 om when thc roora ts nol occup_cd.
and
seem
is - and
funchon.
twn on tbe I_ht
Thus, an eY.xcascd leveling
nec4:ssa_
device
- control
Iogtc canno_ ten if someone
I 0 for both cntcnng
of the sw,tch
then
Ttus su'a_gfo forward
9 doo_" movcmcnl,
6
sw_tch
contacl
lfy_,
8 room or has left the room
be - m the
afl_
the door switch
6 m thc trade _ bang
conczpl
ts the mac
upcn?
of thts stmplc
logic
3 we s¢¢ a swttch,
to do
a w ell-known
ldo_'t_'_owlfthat'sUuconoth_copres,
hgfos
firsl
14
14
19
25
determining
7 conUol
control
NO_Tnally,
20
24
fonc*Jon',
tm'n off.the
However,
21
m Oread
that I use on a dally
Iogu: of such
AL_o, the I.d¢
18
are cbawn
term. Ls used
bblow,
In my copy.
thee
asked
m the
ol'or thnary
244
desm:d
The ccetm:4
9
|7
13
4 the d_r
¢_tgmcc_ng
7 of coctlJol rcs_
16 print
Page
work
The term "conwol
15
10/26105
been
found
of
I occup_cy
foUowm 8 thagrams
deign
6 elecuomc
I!
Hearing
the
the logic
clr¢_Ul block
OO247
3
8
Tbe natme
In my experience,
23
|
dunng
to a [k*lson
12
ou_
The
5
patenL
mforma_on
Markn_n
00246
I rimed
of wh)ch
m control
of the '066 pater
terms
II
that the
and the ncIt-rant
"066 palcot.
15
Claim term._
_.sked to teach
to be demonstrated
er, I have
the
my
the ptroos¢
of the
Moreo_
mean
to
been
of the clauns
9
among
to the '066 patenl
as exlncssed
constn_ctcd
l0
the '066 palenL
any affihauon
dc-,zc¢
to what ccrtmn
or
5.598,086,
tha_ams
6
8
IJghtm8,
Group,
I have
clxcults
5
7
hghtlng
Ccand
or the de fendanls
20
been
Networks.
Patent No
I am nc4 related
and
and cntctl_nncnt
and the
prc_ccutitm
design
m the arehltccltcal
managencnl
15
19
product
for comp_.nles
energy
Chc_ts
12
14
HSD
¢o_ung
Further.
4 conuol
6 upphcatlor_s
:elating
[c:chno]ogy
3
f'rrm
for mdusu_J
I_anag
I M_
task group
the xooln,
lel_l the room, so turn
tlearing
10/26/05
Page
247
0024S
00249
1
The cont_'ol object
for th_s control _ ould be
2 expccsscd as agmn, we haze
3 thnctlorL
Turn
hghts
the door g'v*qtch
on, on first door _k
l
Control
Rwa lights
3
5 comllc¢
_
5 nflhc
v4hJch is actuahng
hghl
swltch
Noic that the dcslr_d results, hghts
ss the same
occupancy
as m d¢
scns_
off, _ hen
second
m the form
of
9
ThLS new Icx el of sophlsbcatlon
1}
weJJ
For
cxaJ'_plc, lfa sccc_d
12 the firsl ]_
LSs[lll
has problcnLs as
Fc_Jon e_lcrs
I_ the _m,
_ fiJle
,._dl
R_n o/T
15
be a false dcccl
the desired conool
rcsull ts sllll
17 v, hen rOOm uncccuplccL
18
do¢_ nOl consls Icntly
19
the poss_thly
20
21 employ
o f an ¢x¢
the sco0nd
aclu_,
level o f sophssllcatton
c the conb'ol rcsull
22 ofllmcaRcr
would
because
LP¢ first door swlng
the urn_
would
13 scasor
mollon
detected
could
sophtsoca_ed
scrtsor
example
znd the
not be achieved
turn
the lights
go
off
cc_1_ol eJ_cu_l would
_r_sldc [he room
be
%vhcn the mol_on
iI could clo6¢ the clrcwI
15
As long
16 hghts
could stay on
to tun_
on for a period
24 many
ttrnc_ the door swtmg
ho_
Markman
Hearing
10/16/05
the room
of the
_ as su]l occupied
The control
logic
be v, c now have a too{ion
o f thts approach
dcteclor
Control
ftm¢tlon,
]fye_
22
]ogle is the same as for the
Note thai the control
first occupancy
lurnonthehghls'_llch
scrtsor dcvuee, el¢_:tnca]
c Io th_ swing
25 on and off
the hghls
contacts
of the door to send
The
a slgna}
only d_ffcrencc
Markman
Page248
OO25O
the
21 wasthcncarrlolloncvcnl
23
_ ould bc agmn
SCRScd mohon,
door s_ mg and a/so the Problem
Tnmc expired
24 respor_sl_
conbol logic 0f this approach
d_lcctor
Th_ssol_cstheproblcmoffalsc
the second
20 wo_d
urnc no rnan_
_ the moron
18 lights going out while
Ti_Jswouldiurnonthc
and kccp them on for the spocnficd
to turn
Is that the
Ilearlag
10/26/05
Page
249
Page
251
OO25 I
I sc/lso¢ ts rick'tung
2 s¢="/:gYg
would
3 _ I',c_
occupanl
Tba con_ol
5 of acLacvmg
too[ion
other than the door s'v, rag.
be placed so [hat its field of dclcctlon
the room
4
ts ILkcly
the contTol event
7 the&florence
Tba
I
Io be
3
IS cnbanccd
Again,
10 fo_ the mooon
6
ans_v¢:r
Was
scnso,_
I f yes, d_n turn on the light
0g_¢ a i_lon
evc_l
Thtls,
a pcrson and an
I 0 Thcr_
the mooon st"nso¢ may not be able to
t3
dmcnrmnale
14 the olx_ng
15
batwclm
mot'.c_
_
only being
ts a draw-back
swolcbad on and oPf
to th_s approach
because the moOon
o f a pea_on and the r_ot_on o f
! 6 su_czen_y
foug ame lY_
tbc _tr_
_nouonl¢_
w_ll exp_c,
17 thc_c ts a barner m the _xxxn _ hlch blocks
18 the !0¢_'Jo_ m motion
19 detect mouoek
roomts
21 LS ano_
form
Thteg, fo_" a t_m¢ Cerlod. the room
so tha_ t,"lc mo[lo_
15 detcclors
foe _.
16
of pcdm_
the cn_gy
of
thmks
the
Tl_hghtswouldb_ttancdoff,_h_ch
0 f fulsc docct
deice(
rdc41on t.t'r,sors to uncrcas¢
by placcnamt
of
the field of _ zcw of the
s_ors
[n Ch_ssltuaaon,
d_c cons'oHog_c
Markman
w_l
Heanng
10/26/05
Page
250
m the room.
l_cls
the occupancy
of soph_,caZton
sensc_
ca_
For example,
can ba a prc_sm_ ,...ave scnsc¢ 1o detect
op, e_
20
first turn on the lights
The opcamg
of drc doc¢ _-dl
dark
Thts wall tufa on the hghts
when the door
ercatc
bc fore
a woosh
Is
of _r ¢o
the person
has
cntcrcdtheroom
23
m¢lud_ a motlon detector alined to de,eel motion In an area
24
away
from
In th*s szmaaon,
be btu_
the raot_on sensor
2Z
the scr_or could
the door wh¢:r¢ a person _shkely
Thus, the ullzasomc
also
to bc
v. a_ e scr_sor of th_s dc_ _c¢
Markman
JA 0843
will remgm
and the moron
19
_5
bc -_ e now
IS fully
Ig
21
can b< addressed
after hc
have s¢_--n thera
Adtha_",al
17 into
ser_o¢ dces no[
gr,d m f2_¢ abs<mcc of detection
unoccupied
Ttas fdsc
multiple
13
14 u_bl a pason
a person will r_
occupier
12 or she has cntcrc'dthe rcom
dora
So_nct_ncs
on gny
know the ddTcrcacc
The hghts
l I sensor can only so'me moOon of the room
12
24 rco_on
funct}on
This contYol logic wdl materially reduce false
9
olqcct
22
Conlrul
8 d_n't
ofboth
Into ottr control
7 dclcc_s,but nolo once again thal the controlled componem
$or,sot con{Tol Ix not a complete
sea-Jsm d¢lccts rnotmn
fccthng
5 switch.
bCCatLSCtba
the hght5 don'_k_ow
Ls employed.
Tba moOon
mollOl_ dc[ecloP.i
4 of the mooon
"l_cy_ebemgixtmedoaandoffnonkallcr
8 _ hal scr_m
have thine
2 funclmn
3S
rcsuh ts the same, bul the cortststcncy
6 scr_c_gsmor©soph_socatcd
I1
proolcm
For
v. as In the room
A slfl} m_'c
17 d_tccts,
of
b¢ t o
the llghls
23 hghLs
9
t_uh
on for five minutes
unoccupied,
12 to use _ mo0on
19
[ex el o f sophtsacauoa
a t_racr "_ h_ch _ ould keep
The
Although
h",¢ sara¢, hghLs off
of a false dctccbon
A fur_cr
25
the false dctecl
14 onthehghls
This would
16
while someone
})
clt cult
and the hghts
lights on
after one rmnu_¢, tba control tcstth,
room
E_ cn worse
lO
the room
the con[rol
13 "Aill ouly rccc_d the second door swing,
14
offwhcn
Titre
expires
8 perccal of [he lime/g'nod
9 COnI3CL
I0
]eft the room
7 hghts
of clccmcal
address
[lmcr
[he desired control
Itmcr kcpl the hghts
6 person
level
ConLTol function
leave on ttntd
this would
4 II may nol achieve
8 sophLsacalloa
25
Whflc
Andwchavethedootsv_mg
7 room unoccupied,
23
[he door s'._ itch
door swing,
4 offonscconddcorcounl
6
20
we ba_e
2 on fi_t
Heanng
10/26/05
00252
oo253
I wOuld ¢um o_ tbe hgl_[s wben the v,oosh from
2 sc_scd as 01c door w_
opened
3 as the mort on da[cct_
_¢'1_¢d motion
d_c do_
and kccp Lbe h_ts
ofa
was
I d_eclJon
pc_on
3
in the
4 room.
"Ihe control
logic o f this d_/1¢¢
6 ha_etwomotlondatccto_
Control
funcuOrL
I0
ofthcmouonscnsors
lfycs,
Note again th= the c¢_tlol
! 20n_'J
the Icv©l of soph'_t_cat_o_
¢onUol
14 device
clrcmw]
m avoid
rn_© L_Cr fncndl-j,
7 Whc-n [h© um_
a molzon
8
¢vcmt on any
thc_mmontbehghL
II
13 with
as a_
doe¢ v, ocsh
Was d_e
¢vcnl LSthe same
f_s= dct_cs
Note
And we
=nd make the
on befor© ¢mmng
also b'_t the ac_on of hghts rcsponswc
as conm01]cd by tbe conb-ol ctrcmt,
anangement
II
fllumma[xop.
18 wh_l¢ m_n
occupied,
hghts
16
off wben nol occupied,
on
remains
Thc
Tbe forcSomg
diso.t_=on
Is rcl_vanl
to
22
w_th [he a_o_ ¢ dl$oJ_lo_
23
_.s a dast 8_1¢r of cl¢_:l_onlc con{To] cltcUll.% ] nol= {hal
23
des_cc
24
the c_=_ol
24
pby's_cs
25
[nkccpmg
with my cxpcncmce,
22
for Cl_Jm 6 Is as _onows
W© now ha_ c a block
d_zram
Lt_t shows a mo0on
Markman
Hearing
10/26/05
Atternal_vc]y,
Page
of being
I beheve
tcf_cnct
to the
da_c_
years mdusmal
hghlmg
a person
dagrcc,
who holds
or science,
m another
of praCltcal
such
products with
disc_phne
mdm_al
a bachelors
as myself
with a
along
w=th ab_zl
cxpcnenc¢
m
Markmau
Ilghtm 8 pt_lL_tS
1
which
as an cxamplc,
3 _
3 compm_
dcgr_
4 and aho_
5 ¢l_mc=l
=rid_vo years of pra_caJ
fivey¢=s
hghUn_
produc_
_
p¢_'_ons_e
u=chn_calcduc_c_
m Ix_Idmg
4
wh=ch con',am bas:c con_'ol
5
of mdusmal
6 ca'creeswo_dd also ix_scss _
_penmc¢
f,
dly c_
7
of _mdctsu_ndmg
Ilearmg
two
10/26/05
Page
253
10
sotmd,
I ! conwo[l¢_ daslgn
II
13 electrical
cogm¢_nng
and ooc to two yc=m_ mdus_naJ
14 experience.
Wbea
I tim r¢=d Cho _66 p,_nS, _
_
w"=s
hght,
Mat
13
ptant might
be
rnomtored
14
Is a device
U'_
produce_
15
p_poruon_
I$
vohose
19
telr, per_m_
I rc_d tbe spcofi_mon
_le/pmv_hng
21
and_tonp_t_nL_
22
23
co_ultmg
last In my
profcss=onal
scrv=ce_,! £r=lu_tly
r¢_d thc a_trac_, th,m d_ cl_rns _:I finally0_
22
au_nahc
spec=f_t _a
23
cond_uon.
The sp_:lficaaoa Is_anply an _,=nple
of the mven_on_
Markn_n
24
of one
U_mg
the '066 p._mt
Hearing
10/26/05
25
Page
Page
255
JA 0844
so fo_-th
G_
A tbermoco_le
_s row,,hly
voltage
cr_ctut
_hot offlf
Mtlhons
to a sc'am u v¢ volt
m urals
of tcmpemttec
by tbe thcrmocoeptc
c_
ThIs would
crtcmL
in
macber_cal
by a Lhcrmocee_e
a volt_¢
mlghl
d_e tempc_ture
be _n ex_np]c
of_tmll_r
Tbe
is analogous
also
_o provlda
_
to thc
be connected
alarm
reacbes
to
o_ an
a defined
of an analo 8 control
ctrcu=ts _rc tJ_ed every
Markman
254
and
and
phenomenon,
werc analog
may be connected
The thcrmocc_te
a vodagc
2.S posslbl= emlxx_m¢:m
vohag_
physical
velocity,
_-vlce_
thc &al cah_ated
produced
21
lhavefo_mdtl_tntsbes[Eo
and
to i_s [empefatmc.
That voltage
20
r¢=d
'_th
o f voltage_
For exampl_,tbetempera_m¢ofava_
18 nw_0c_
20
between
operate
of tbe_
to some
heat. acc©lera_on,
early c]ccUomc
natme.
n.,¢ter with
ndatcd.
c_rcmts
I mere-, valucs
analogous
12
17
wee
clrc_t_
_mcl freqwncy
Is gc_al_y
17 I then r,_l th= claims wluch s_ forth th¢ sp¢ofic
and how _¢y
a micro
the d_ffercncc
Analog
c_]cd
to the clam_
ul_l_zmg
control
to cxplam
CL_Cmtry
_omcume_
16
clam
asked
a dastgn
be done
than analog
been
and d_jtal
16 sufllc1¢ntfor mc to _mda_sh_nd u"_ n,_'_¢ o f the mv_',t,_
ro_ _ch
i[ would
Tbe magnlt_da
I0 m [he u_¢ of PI_ dat¢_tors,co_wo[ c_cmLs and m_c'_
m
wcr¢ to implement
c m3_"n_
cu_ents
These md_ndv.als had bachelors _
rather
analo8
8
Inmy
! have W'_med .l_mor d_'_ga _ngm_'s
Ifl
today,
I have
9
9 c_asol0ng busu_s,
pat_
6 continuous,
_kdl m the arts
8 =mdm_pl_tmgtbe_hnologyoftbe'oo6pamnL
24
capable
m the arl with
and building
252
2 ofth©
19
no[
operabonal
clccoom_
with two
m englnecnng
2 conta=n basso control c_cm LS,or a person with a hlgh
15
id_
of
OO255
etoctncal
I das_gnm 8 and hoddmg
12
6 do_
the mw'ntlon
a I_'_s o n who holds a bachelors
m d_l_mg
2.$ to fotw yt:_;
C_._4
7
to th©
21 b_s_c conb'ol C_'CmL_
m_prctahonofd_¢lam_.softhc'O66patcnL
logic
the claim.s,
is nol c*v_r ly lecknlcal
cr_lneenng
20 cxptncncc
from
logic of Claim
s_mplc
skdl
_
a_© sccn
c_m crmt a first level
a clev_
*066 patent
of or&na.,y
m cl¢cmca}
21
and consul!
_crtb_
I 8 *066 parers[ would
19
20
which
IO make
om by relaavcly
17 a p_son
motion events
eo the low [cvd
quoted
tn lamp
cotmtmg
The 'C_6 pa{fnt
turn
to the lamp and responsive
Nouce that th© control
14
to
h_ts
rct_n
Ihe wo_ds
sen_or
quic_y
lf)c_,
Ih¢ ]amp al th_ high loyal
If no morc
l0
15 c_n©d
17 the sc_ors
havc
_'nl'_
Keep
_xpncs,
clrcuzl coupled
13 rcqmre pulse
15 room, has ch,_gcd.
16
I f yes. lure o_ tbe _amp to a
level
9 control
12
of the scnsers used co*_pled
hshLs twncd
ouLs)de
Is thcT= a mollon
6 unu} 01¢ UmCr cXpul_
am(] the Second one =$ shown
8 ultz_socuc d_ccto¢ to detect _
revel
5 d1¢ lamp to a hl_
Tbel_rstoncisshownasaPIR
7 to deject a human body.
9
v, ou]d be "_ ¢ now
function
IS =1 _k
4 low
5
scaso_ and a hght sensor, a sensor arrangcmenl,
2 ate Con_o]
on = long
Hearing
day m
10/26/05
O0257
00256
I au_omobflc_,
omc¢
bmtthngs,
t'aetoncs,
I
and so forth, to
2 do slmpl© coat.Is
d
Digatal cli'cm t_y does nol use conbntzotzs wltag_
4 or curr_t_tolt-pr_rmtphy_zcalquan011_
5 _ oltage
and ¢unem
Rather,
lecels arc defined
lv.o
corr_pondang
The exact valu_
8 not Imlx_t
9 years
l0
I1
A popula_
12 hemg
_ oltag¢
logic
One
14
tolerance
15
zero
16
logic
of digital
m the sl_aal
operated
19
OldCrahonal If the garage hghts
23
wtshcs
b_! only
The logse._d and.
Open
button
with
off
con_dcr
fire
problem
and the garage
Tins could
G_-age
hght
Markman
_aystosolve_oblene_
2 superior
3 combination
4
$ v, hether
texan
6
mterp_t_l
7
terms
8
skdled
10
terms
Control
el_ctromc
art%
palents
_e
mea_
connot_
15
The
16
ulecmcal
17
results
18
md_tt_
parrot
varlo_
complex
15
nmmng
16
prects¢ly
term
ml_eormectl_n
the word
that,
22
connotation
"control
and
a
m_ny
does
thai occurs
tl_
_, ay that
control
ctremt
to _ehlr,
of
¢ the d_red
da ffenmt
sla_ci_r
es _
however,
redutr¢
the
com_e_nl$
The
from
to me wheal
of
the sm_ctural
plesented
have
thai
control
tha s_rl¢
Marlunan
clrcmt
and
10/26/05
JA 0845
calculatmns
to
ping/am
the
can
ad_enlm-e
the pesltlon
of bdhol_
dlU_lOn
of
of a
wodd
case
the
electromc
the thlTerent
functlorts
Analog
and
thg_tul
haedwaxe
Switching
mear_
ark
the
electromcs
arc
As
term
of the
thfferent
software
axe two
programs
d_fferent
Hearing
a person
"s_llchmg
Page
10/'26/05
skdlcd
m the
mealts"
most
257
certainly
to rl_
many
hfe,
types
of electrical
I am frequently
to control
sw_tch_
called
AC power
upon
usttally
lnmy
to dcstgn
for hghtmg
appll _hol_
Many
9
mod_ po_¢f
10
and
may
of tbese
12
M-o-s-f
13
other
de_ ices use
con_/_Org
he b_polar
transistors,
field
e t-s,
These
_
15
are all Switches
16
the
17
ebrmenl
elTecl
insulated
sennconductor
_hat
are tailed
The s_ ii_h_
transistors.
gate
dcctromc
oxide
Mosfets
blpola_
tra_asto_,
IGBT,
or
of d_tces
hut they
s_ flch types
', cxy th fferc_dt types
and dealgncl_
t_wn3 "Switch"
S-._ ztch
l-efff 1o _
po',_ or, rnetalhc
to W_lCall_
of power
elo:tron_._
s_tur_
will u_e
i e that a s'mtch
ks prc_e'nt
Again,
19
or change
20
opinion
21
meaning
the adthtlon
of means
the connotation
to mean
that switches
Seasor
23
electronics,
24
me
SeP.sor
meza_
means
the term
AS a pergon
"s erdor
ts a de:tee
that
do_
n_
I am
and switch
produces
subffa_t
the1"efor¢
have
skdled
me_"
Markman
Page258
calculate
program
reahsl/e
to create
performs
25
m_m,ng
Hearing
second
24
22
_ tth the term
can
a dlfferolt
folxn ofa
Rwnmg
18
p_'ible
addition
running
ts the same
14
of a nlmab_
lo
pr oc¢_,smg
can perform
calculating
each
I 1 sermconductor
¢lectrom_
the
t_ks
on a compote_
computer
8
m the
_ odd,
L_of logic
control
a word
23
There
the thgdal
modern
insu_lctlon_
and
in the
a computer
moxmg
comes
lex[ on the screen
computer
elements
6 p¢oduets
per$oo_
slolled
the term
not detra_l
op _'uon
m_an$
glth
5 professional
¢ffcml"
clrcml
same
ones
possible
up of _-asl arnotm
computer
the
_nlenalnment
In each
4
over
[he idt'nllfied
components
of¢l_lncal
I am of the
The
2 ei_lxonlcs
buteontrulcrrvantmeartsalso
czreulls,
"rneam"
same
forma5
t_o
of the
Markrr_n
to rn¢
and/o_
o_ly
on the
on on-of,
to program
v. hde
the door
based
hegmnmg
program
data
256
or as stru_alral
as Io how
r_ fer_ to mtereo_necUol_
to me that
21
with
wnuen,
stmclure
de_ce_
Not
sheet
financial
light
and
sausfied-
arc only
computal]onal
A spread
14
25
are to he
t_rms
AS a ptrson
! am farmh_"
All conuol
conrad
_ a dispute
art mt_'_et
mear_
g_rally
20
25
there
mg ts my opinion
ctrcmt
14
24
that
plus funcu_
m [he ©lectrom_
13
23
12
7
I!
19
arc
are made
garage
not been
the ,._orkhorse
thal can respond
and
on ss false
There
th_s humble
Computers
00259
I
devaces
From
false
] I clrctutry
h_lng
Page
and
3 coraloles stricture
of the '_
mear_
computcl
22
two
icn_
_
eloctr_u_s
m formed
The follow
9
12
of the
I ha_ © been
Many
dlgllal
21
[i'snotaqu_tmnofonehemg
to the other
9
logic
O0258
I
thai s become
be stated
10/26/05
decisions
de_ ice
a common
Heanng
makes
quammes
plcl_lre
on and garage
logic
8
game
equaue, n m _ts
and has
t_ues
per forra
tn_e,
doo[
logical
7
19
buttc_
garage
The
and
20
Is on.
garage
Digital
2¢f_s
on ,s one,
then
6
on
to b¢
button
false
clued
provide
would
b¢ v.-ntlen _a a loglc_d
door on equals
stays
18
are switched
illt_trat_
4
17
to have _at decmcally
..van_ the door control
The
on is zero
13
the one and
Tunlonthegarag¢only,fthagaragcdoor
is poshad
v, ay
levds
I f garage
3
10
logic L_the wtde
Th_ real v* mid example
24
25
A homeowner
garage do_
th_ly
logic
of dag_ta110glc,
problem
22
_ed g/I 0 of a _oh
Ic-. ¢ls thai rel_ent
18
ftmeuon
z_o
for over 30
z_ro and on bezng logic on_
advantage
17
21
m _
than i_ o volt_ _ oft
l_ ¢ls define
As an example
20
famdy
at hatween
and a vohag¢ grCaler
TI_se
13
of the _ ohages e¢ CUITc_atSare
defines a voltage
as of,
on
5
Io on
6 and off
7
hght
2
from
of the
the same
m the arts of
connc_es
slr_ture
to
an elec_cal
Hearing
10/26/05
Page259
OO26O
OO261
I slgnalmzcsponscto$omephystcalstlmubrs
2 rn_y
I provnkng
Thcreare
typ_ ofseasors, hght, beat. tcmpcrarac, pttsswc,
2
a vcty
3 rota[t
on.,po_ztton,voltage, cttrr
_'iLmagnetic field,too
3
4 m_ty
to enumerate
4
5
Each o f the sta'_orsconnote struclur¢ Aixl _ ts
5 not net cssa_
6 usually the case m clccuontcs, there ate many
7
8 conthtJoR
8 components
Agaxn, the _tton
]0 or cha_e
l] OpmlOn
12
of mcam
tbe connotat ion to me. l am
thatscnsc* _
,_or
not _ubu_t
thctcf_
from
p_cnt, th© scmors
12
_d
13
behavior,
art Suggested would be a motlon sensor and a hght level
14 s_
The sptofic tyix of each srmor ts dctcn'nmcd by
17 of opcr_on,
18
power
engineer
the cost.the area
16
function
and so fro*h,o f tbe _oth_Cl to be produced.
17
of the amount
M ear_
ofhght
re_otx_lvc
connote
20
20
pr¢_cnt
that responds,
21
cncmt's
oparat mg conch Uon
24 the scr_mg ¢[cmcms
25
umktstood
tlm
may be somewhat
they,axe
24
Imm¢ Of COI]ISlOn
25
C_MACD
Markman
llearlng
as
10/26/O5
Page
t_peads
ths_3vermg
3 career
4
to, data col]_lo_
the e_t_ncc
tbe ad_on
of _
meamn
An example
ctro_lry
t$ Im_em
II
properly
12
_m'nm_on
13
moUon
AS a person
18
ca_
19
conuol
o f the mouon
and tbe Inner cmcmtry
to
ehangesln
the
utthz_
computer
A¢ c¢_s Career
thts
says
Scr_c.
czrcmt_/
the Ethernet
Hearing
has
passed,
slolk:d
s_n_ctme
m the
10/26/05
Page
261
to me
21
cur_em
_ot_ly
no fttrth_
12
skdhx[
13
r_tv¢
to ]3¢
14
m an electrical
TO actuate
23
the swztch
24
into the base ofa
25
voltage
a switch
connote*
opexat e. e g the clrcmtry
to the gate
uanststo¢,
ofa
a smmtm'c
to supply
the encmt_y
Mos fee. or IGBT,
18
timid.
Markman
mpul
24
represents
Hearing
a hght
10/26/05
25
Page
262
wbun
wtthm
Tbe analog
vollage
As a person
"meara
structure
type
Th_
the mpul
the ompm
wbrch
may be some
the scasor
of the
sensor
to thgt tal _verlor
my
m
be
clrcmwy
chtp
to thSItal,
corn crier mc_un_
and translatc_
an
exceeds
a mtcroo3mputcf
ADC,
to me
that
wdl produce
flora
zl into a _usilal
value
the
that
that voltage
A srmplc
example
would
Markman
JA 0846
at vm_otm
leveL_ of
means
the _
ct_cmt,
to the analog
23
a
to satd seraor
_arator
Altcrn_ttve_y.
contained
vanom
of sofne
r_pond
_t
to produce
to provide
confute*
othput
22
9, ]0 and I I
on the swllcb
rneal_"
17
21
m Claxrra
ctrcmtry
_ erbs
ap_bed
from
to be acre.meed"
t$ elect_omc
of mtalog
20
meam
to _atd stmsor
_
for making
to supply
responsive
wdlrespondtotbeout_ofthes_or
cncmL
to tm_
m the arts of electromcs,
There
| 9
not subU_cl
froth tbe lamp
16
ty]x_
t_
the swtteh
cycle
15
the path of
"swlt chmg
_ _vld_d
to be
mea_.s
or break
in the lmc hail
Mtara
there _ffe _v2ny
to make
9
or the stmple
lamthereforeofthe
of tht$ is found
ctrcmuy
ithzrmnalJon
due to the acttve
stated,
that may be a_ed
An example
points
to me
link
by han_
of rneat_
to control
B Wbele
II
art.* o f elecu'celc$.
sttcth _w_tcbrng
that the teems
10
and tl ts still dark ou_ede.
mear_
tbe add.ton
u_eate
coupled
to the swztch
th¢ cormotatton
of
to the Io.,v level
$*.,_h swltchu_
fo* cau_n8
As has been
of _ttches
22
6 Where
and actttated.
20
Again,
6 _m_ply
have
an op_ca_Iy
of the contact
4 o* change
5 optmon
of the lamp
detected
cormotes
from
and "rcspomwe"
to the outline
ser<sor
for cm_mg
term "_
nol _boa_l
I _n thtrcforc of the
the tram interval
h._; bct'n
17 tmmatcd"
c]osm8
7
to re_d
once
Mear_
the
2
8.
reim"n the level
15 actuated
16
to me
e; fotmd m Clatm
IO SCrL_Or. the dayhght
14
of a
3
do_
that the tcrrns "dctcctzon"
thcuo*dmavd
8
I be.am to acttvath
of the pr_cncc
mgnal
Aga_
6 opmton
9
to
Th¢_e LS tome sln¢llffc
Markman
by serums.
c_ dete_ung,
5 or change the cotmomtton
7
skzlled
responsive
Ed',cm ct has the formal
Media
Enghsh,
as a
its suzthce
00263
I dcleClS,
2
Detects
In simple
to
AS a person
widely
m the world
260
0O262
box
changes
"mear_
to me
the .r._t
on
t on.
i c rcactsto
8 standard
nctworkm
md_y
must
blank
It IS Cl_gb
the t_
_t_:lttre
Fc_" example,
23
_otcnc.
by dtstgn cngm ¢._ m the hshtm$
22
of
and consmmtton
thctr
faJhng
to delect
detccltOta"
motion detectors Whdc
thcro simply
of the devtc¢
19
23 actual pb) sl_ oftbe scnsm 8 clcmcm
uses
photocell
19 patcm, the PIR type scmof and the photocell suggesl
22 _'_hcatton m _chlttctu_
engram
rand that the rc_t$_
of ¢lt_xoni_,
The PIR scttsm has a long i'nstoryof succcr_ ful
for
Orl are the ptm I_1C¢
a_ tt were
m the _
tbe'msclXc*
tn order 1o
of an IGBT,
characlmsucs,
Ig
21
phystcs
who
Tbe same ts U_e f_
und_
For products of the type dcscn'bcd m the '066
but 11 IS
phystcs
Orris COI_I_¢U
tbezt terminal
15
t6 the rcqturcmcnts, t t. the _*fommme,
of persons
types of clcct_omc
device
and the m¢ll_d
The
14
]5
the P]R devtce,
the devine
of the semlo_mductor p:oc_s
10
I ]
that
to understand
The actual
9 _x_pJ¢_
of the
the motion
that the P1R _s sensing the change
thai falls on
This IStntc of many
mcar_ have the same meamng
In the comext o fthc '0_
13
do_
to detect
use them
7 types of sensors thatmay be used to detect a parOcular
9
way
They understand
m thcrma.t energy
6
thffctcnt
useful
or objects
be an mpul voltase
Hearing
that may
10/26/05
Page
263
0O264
OO265
1 ra-qgef_omzc_otob.'_)_olLs
2 into
100 values,
IftheADC&vtd_sth_srange
co_csponthng
3 _J_ input volt_e
I of hght
to I CO p,_rc_'nl, Lbam
Ic_ cl of fi_e vohs v, ou}d bc c_n_ crttd
4 _aluc
orS0
5
Thts &g, tal nunub_
6 dlglt._
to zo'o
numb_
may be compared
stored on L_
2
to a
3
mcmo_,
5
opinion
6
light
7 Vt oF_aTn code v.qll I,_.ke some acbc,_
8
'r_e p_grgn
9 A_n,
code
Ihc ad_uon
l I
|'m _-rc
to Lhc scn_o_
of rncar, s does not _thtracl
8
f_om or
]0
fore of the oplmon
dial Lt_ £crm "means
hgh_
I I to fall upon
of Ihe ¢lccl_on,cs
rcqu_cd
_o produc_
the d_sITed
14 response
15
An
16 '_ hc_
example
con_zol c_¢ '._1_/d_lcrmm_
17 prov,dcd
IS
of such a rcsp0_sc
by the lamp
snd dayhghz
19
I 0
[he 1c¢¢1 Of LIl_rnlnatlo_
m r_pons¢
to van op.s s_p.qo_ mohoc
20
saad a_
21
dayhghL
22
the _
23
tosa_d appar _s
m_ns
_sponswe
for _
Io hghl
the fa_s_c¢
24 _yhght"
C,rcm_y
may
scnso_
16
presc_cc
or absence
Daylight
21
me.sine
the amount
22
space
_ _.n c_s
Hearing
Ibl go_/dayhght_ngt
2 _o_
g_n>up
3
d]umm_on,
4
arufic_ai
lq_hL o_ n_
5
¢or_c_v¢
enccgy
If fo_c
_
10/26/05
Page
2_
Bcrklcy
und_stlnd
wd]
hghL
dc_ }cesm
clrcmt
th¢llonaz,
its
T¢_ponse
y
by the stm
hgh_ng
ofextt_
BeTklcy
oflhc
Dayhgh(
the archltcc_uxal
In many
hghhng
con_'o_
syslc'n_
d]umsnauon
DcF_rtmenl
National
The control
including
the desired
tc'nn is so common
S_tc$
I C]alIRS IP3y _
2 not rcqm_cd
dayhght
reduce
it off all togefo_
fo_ amo_l
dayhght
thai It is _cd
of Energy
National
to
m a
by
al the La_ tt'_c c
Laboratory
I|ear_ng
]0/26/05
Page
265
a pc_on
the ¢.onccp_
sk_lcd
4
An
elcc_'omc
II
m_l_ove
!2
cn'_,_t.
_nd the
to th_ basic
r_q_arcmcn_
7 control
fo_
14
for ap_hcau
_ m_
o¢_ foal have
Th_
_
16
cho,c¢
17
m.ay be fo_M
! 8
foe way
]9
prepa_
c_'tmnly
21
mcxpc_ve
22
grc_
_p
costing
_
flcld.
o f foousands
speakers
_¢nt_
24
_k_-s
25
ou_d_pa_d_ck,
IoM spcakcm
may perform
15
of
spcak_
of dollars
m foc _l_
I7
for
fo¢
fox.ample
Markman
by the expenst_
loud _k_z
In_s_ncway,
H¢_rmg
sensors
o f a
c
used
_o r_luc¢
to nuno_ mot_oll
m
the output
c'vcnts
of a motion
of false d_ccUons
dctccto_ o_
reqmnng
be fore
motion
foe conb-ol
w_ll itc(uatc a change m its oulpUL
pulse counting
of the '066
Is s¢l forth In
pa_em _ recited
m Cl_am
I ftLrthor note
zccltcd
as pa_
_
pu_c
counting
of foe con t_ol c[rcmt
of Claim
12 Is
and _s not _
part
18 0 f a.ny SCl_sor
to
faction
Ls pulse
_Lscd technique
12
In my experience
20
pulse
21
of the
22
may no_ be n¢cessa_
motion
] have noted thai
i6
all
of h_-_t_z
p_owdr_
ts a wdcly
du,,'auon or magnitude
14 the specification
to p_cp_¢,
And
hghtmg
of a Iong_
13
or desired
Loud
of don_Ts
of such a_ cnha_cmCl_l
counlmg
clrcmt's r_ponse
12 ¢lrctal_
dcs_cd
rcqul¢cm'_nL
w_nely
t]_1 _rc
of the
Anod_crw_y_os_ythls_th_lpz_ccotmt_nl_m_y
19
they a_¢ both
majo_ly
The
elcctromc_
_
that the
not b¢ n_ded
m the wut¢
a f_
to _-v ¢_1
roay
a di ff_'-nt
s_.-n
m ff_¢ construct
Y_,
b_
Pu_e
I 0 Io reduce the Incident
to
li
arc done to _m-¢
n:s_h
b¢ made
for Clfoa_ccm_t$
the basac ftmctlonahly
9 be used to reduce the sensitively
[n _y
c_m alway_
tls per form,l.c¢
_
pc'tformar.c_
15
dc.nce_
¢nhan_cmcnls
and ¢nhxno_
i3
exarriplc
6 _¢hlt_Cttxral
m !ha an would
of dayhght
WTIII¢I1 to provide
to prowd¢
3 invention
of
m o_d_" Io
5 counting
Fm_w.cmcn_s
l0
23
fots
ofda_
m iIs or thrc_y
_r¢ a_cd
include
_odcs
Markman
$
20
the
dayhghL
the output
of day _ov[dcd
common
In fact,
the United
would
and photo
level
264
m foc_t ¢nc_gy
_ufficlcnt
the hghlm 8 _ztt_n
Thc_ef_¢,
9
ts used
az_
_c
24
of the sun,
._cnsor_
to _hleve
the hght
_t_t_y
23
of
Tcsponse
so Rs to allow
by me_unng
a dcs_cd
20
to i,gfo cx t_,ll
the structure
0O267
I (http//wmdo_s
7
dayhght
of
OO266
6
15
and able'nee
u_l)z_
Markman
can determine
sensors
responsive
that
c_rcultry
19
_I_UCTt._C Lo rn_
_ present
14
)_bl
t]_as_stors
Io
fo_ detectingthe presence and absence of
Co0_tr_
photo
external
AsapeF.onskdledm{hcar_of¢]ccttOnlC_.
"hght $¢nsn_g means
of such
photocells,
defimt_on,
c IO
the prc_cnc_
the dcsLrcd
to the apparatus
13
18
rcsporcsl_
indicates
bc arranged
I'_om
of the
iL
Examples
]7
ou_p_s
Lzsht s_smg
25
_s foe.rod m Claim
means
for dclcctmg
_o produce
would
ofdayhght
no{ st_b_acl
I am th_cforc
s_mply
required
cx_c_nal
does
sensing
app.tratus
of da) hght"
The scr.so_
hght,
)2
13 s_Jc_m'c
to sa)d
to contyo[Icd
or absence
to mc
that the trrm "hgfo
the clef!tonicS
is coupled
of means
the cormotat)on
exlcraa]
9
to me
outpul
the prc_¢nc¢
Lhc adthtTon
7 _'_d absence
will be r_pon.slvc
tO change the conno_o_
Again,
c_ change
and the
._ hose
LOdetect
4
Io anoLher
m)_oCompulC_'S
sensors
¢lreulh'y
on _'1
pat_nt
10/26/05
co!rating
dcvlc¢
The
wlfo
palc'nts
,S an cnhar_cracm
dcscn'bed
f_¢t that
pulsc
in the '066
patc'nt
counung
_s recited
23
12 _.nd not m any other clarm expresses
24
epJ_,'_J_,ccm
cn | 0 f pulse counbng
2_
chums
_hcrc
pulse
coLin!mS
JA 0847
in Cl_zm
Intent
to omll the
as a rcqulrcd c foment of the
ts not _ccetc_
Marlonan
Page266
m clcct_c_nlc.%
to _mpro_ ¢ the performance
Hearing
10/26/05
Page
267
00268
00269
I
Based on my reathn8 or the opcmn 8 and rcbutlal
2 M_rkman
bnel's in this case, ] understand
3 de£_ndants m thzs case contend
4 mt¢rpreted
5
according
I have had explained
6 intr_'¢tmg
claims
that the claims
to 35 U S C
2 function
should be
112, paragraph
to me the _qmtcmenCs
under 35 U $ C
t prescntatton
that the
reciting,
3 the structures
4 paten1 drawmg
o£
5 rcclled
6
Thts
AS a person of orthna_
skill
8 claims
8 whom
9
AS one of ordm_
10 '066
p_tcnl pcrt,_ns,
skill
I do not behove
I I claim
lerms _e governed
12 temrs
m part Lrs¢ the word
13 terms in conlexl
]4
in the an to which
the
thai the dzspuled
communicate
[he enurcty
stnJclmc
]0
those
of tho_e
Io me. nol mere
a means
I have been
16
mterprel
17
must Identl_
18
point to almct uz¢ In the epcclficalIon
)9
or drawings
20
W_dc
21
be apphed
22
'066 patenl.
23
engineers
24
w_c
informed
_at
plus ['traction ot 11 .?/6 clatm
the function
which
_at
perform
I continue
IS being
th_
m£rared
_c thspmcd
signal is interposed
analysis
when
18 sa£Cly device
clatm
21
terms
a.s i£ 112./6
we have created
a Pow_
Markman
Hearing
Point
Page
known
example
funclton
could be
break beam, where
a
is
era
br ¢,L_ be:u_ detector
prevent
The employment
one of mere choice
23
and they
garage
door which
the garage
is the
when broken
door from
or pet
era
P[R or break beam sensor
to person or ordinary
are mtcrchangcably
ts
skdl m the art
eqmvalcat
All nght
MR
H[GGINS
Your
Honor,
Markman
268
00270
I Is
known
Iwo sensors a_ld motion
on an aulomahc
22
25
10/26/05
well
of Claim
by the well
sensor, the same
between
20 closing on the chdd
la'._ ors and
alent
thai szgnal ts broken by a person or object
A common
24
In _al
PIR,
by the equally
Icxl
clazm tcrms o£ _¢
bul cqul;
recited In the claim
wh_lc the sensor means
19 by a child or a pet will
'._ tth DF_A'S
or the engineers
th fi'ctcnt
out the runcllons
example,
17
I 12/6 should not
C_alc
13 p_w¢
16 detected
to apply
25
For
and _en
of the palent,
cbe dls_ted
I have parhclp_tcd
in analyzing
term, one
performed
could
motton o£ a person or object
I$
said $1nJcture
to beheve
to lnlerprct
to
in the electi'onlcs
myself
12 sensing
14 pcKormcd
If 112/6 does apply
out Lhc
lctm$
I1
function
15
tral_cd,
9 structure to cane
by I 12/6 because even [hough
"means",
I have
of the '066
prcsenLallOn ts attachecL
7 at/5, I also state that a pe_on,
I 12/6 claims
the
or tcx_ which carats
7 whxch the lawyczs have called czther meos_s pl_s function
or
two
ten, n, and three
m the specification
references
runcuon
term
by the recited clatm
set forth
6
112, stxth para_aph,
one, the claim
performed
wc ate at the point
Hearing
10/26/05
Page
00271
I wbere
Mr
Carlson
2 have color copl_
3 the bench
We
'.viii now
of all of the slld_
have already
4 we'll glv© a COW to Dt
5
present the Power Points. und wc
thal wdll
provided
thorn
Carnal
as well
Okay
Wcll,
THECOURT
I
hand up to
to counsal,
and
7
THE
thcre'ssomeat_ched
There
_.rc, Your Honor.
8 think you wdl
find the color copies
9
THE
COURT
tO
THE
WITNESS
I I
MR
COOK
12 provided
Color
arc dlcglble
COURT
14
MR
COOK
I $ The tc_
m the color
The
whne
21
MR.
HIGGINS
22 through
15 because dunng tvtr
2,3 a_kcd some qucsttons
25
Mr
I I through
Cook's questions
by Mr
are except
C_r]son's
Cook
about
the s;_n¢
I"orshde_
deposition,
aS
a sepal',_te shde
is std] the same
bul
THE
HIOOINS
Youwanltopassthosc
Ycah
Andldon'lknow,
Rogcr,
copies appear to be clear
COURT
There
20
THE
II
21
scanned from
he was
22
And, of cou_c,
23
Image
Io
Wall,
my black
arc sections
and whatc tsn't ag
of the text thai
[ think [
25 counscl_
Page
270
WIT_qs
Un _orlunatcly
the actual '066 patent
th.tt dccs nol result
MR
COOK
I would
Your
Honor
hke to show
and put in
m the htgbest qu.dlty
m._y I consult with
him what my problem
Markman
JA 0848
this was all
_ bltmaps
un_ortunaLely
24
dunng his deposmon
10/26/05
Okay
19 c_m read ii. but tt has a shadow
that. shdcs. _tnd he
Hearing
hc was
6 also in Claim
ones oul now '_
MR
18 thai cle;_
thai
15 to ma.t.c tl alem" m response
Markman
9, I 0 _nd I I
icmls
II
there fore, the answer
16 why -- our color
except for color_
They
common
to be apphed to Clmm
THECOURT
15
hke to
cop,_
to give (o all o I"_LSexaci]y
those
not a separate sla(emcnl,
9. 10_nd
And,
17
Well. are the color
20 the black _d
m the dcposttlon
14 color-cixIcd
c,_1
COURT
19 you are proposing
added shdcs
6 and also Clatm
13
cop_cs can't Ix: read m a n umbe'r of
17 clear It up now ll'w¢
24
to C]alm
And
but
temls
12 intcrptclatlon
you can read
but I would
shdcs,
I _ the slides m_d_¢II clear th._l he es using the same
to black _.nd v.httc?
black and while,
are acldltional
5 thai l_'e common
9 tht Clmr_s
that we have been
They
whal -- there are certain
$ 9, but there w_
of r_SpCCLS
h may beJZL_t my cOp_,
THE
to read
15 subStllulc
explain,
10
AS opposed
HIGGINS
7 using th© dcfinlIlons
Yes
tn a number
THE
18
much e_ler
hul I
copies
The colol" copies
13
16 msLanccs
MR
Arc II through
shdcs '_
4 thay - as he wdI
6
WITNESS
or addtllonal
3
6 to this rcpOrL
COURT
THE
2 shdcs
Ilearmg
is
10/26/05
Page271
269
00272
!
_
RIGGI_$
2
(Co_®I
3
TI_
4 _
5 Icfs
[ _
wdH
_J_
o_
zTo_mg
II thls portal, znd ye_J _I c_n go through
these_
7
TH_
8
I"_E
3
TH_S
6 _If3_U$C
COURT
Ol_y
R_dy
7
to So?
y¢_, wc _= ready to go, Yore
}/2_ HI_[_S
_
COURT
8 pllolt,
And ha','c wl
decided
I0
tQ let th_:
M_.
C_OK
13 i_ _mce
I nee_ls_m_u_l
W'Eat w¢':o S,mm8 ¢odo, y©u¢ F{on_ ,
14 go_g_/_velt_ri,_c_ler
TH_
17
FCI" _1¢ p_ls
19
MP_ H]GGTN$
TH]_ COURT
21 wh_t¢ one= in_
col_ _
MR. HIGGI_&
_J
mm-ll_
CO,._.nr 0_.y
24
MI__ HIGGINS
25
aclx_ll
2/
2
TICE WIT'P_=3$
4
T_'I_ COU_T
_
7
TH'E oDLrRT
QI and Q2 wh,¢h Ire mounl_l w,thm
10,'26/05
He=ring
14
M_
_5
"n-_
t6
11"_COUET
18, is l_;t_ 11_ Irl It_¢
1111.11¢
i_tecboII
3
E.om d_e
SO, _eo0=d _er_r
Page
O1"
_om Clmim 6, on the n_z p._e
4 :thtmc4 f'_mct:on $_nd
5 _'co_l
Clllm,
6 :ond_n0_, being a predetermined
;uppon
wcdcwtm_cd
s¢_'_o_ m_,l_
I_dcscnpLt_
Okay
7 _lld lp01r_t'_
Ifs¢C_t_g_'_nd',¢
_
the d¢fi_lll_g a
cond_llOn szJd tccond
dlsclo_i
_'¢d¢¢mlined
L¢_¢1of It&hl CXl_=l
,o
s CP.zcluzehc_¢ ,s _¢
9 m/to n',,tk¢ tl Cz_t_r to _mth
L0
[Llooks Ithc K s m cotum_ 3,
¢omp_.=l_r=8=lgh.
11100_11k¢1_¢_
wsor¢
Amlnt,_tth¢_:?
ITIGGtNS
Y_=
¥ouu_nsl_
Ol_ty
Yo==renshL
I$
"fH_ WITNESS
L9
_
COI._T
ZO
"ff'_
_
M_
[ _J_J_¢sl that - ILm yO_
I;_
THE
COURT
I_
_R
I_IGGINS
Yea
V_well,
Yo_ultonor
Tnuth
Iwlrlt_ltom_c;u_e
THE
WI_I_ES_
16 111 pl_o(oc¢l] 56,d¢l¢cls
In _he d_scloscd I=Xttlal support
the predictor
=hs_l_= of
17 d_yh_ilL
y=_, ]1L_
Okay
y¢_,
a/J 0 fthJ= _cxl w_ll bc
21 Ilnt =_1 _¢o_11cm="
COUP.T
May
Or Iookzt_ll =1 th: co}or sl,d=s = the b¢_ch7
15
Soll_,s0_mthe
HIGGI_IS
I I _im_
14 you
L7 de I;11_o:1
th:sc_ ptlO_?
miami _
t 8, ,rod
txoc17
COL_T
13 t]_'= ¢om=x_£mm.
TI_
mxtcmal to the I_p,
_rk_a
Pa|e2?2
cr_lx_.,¢_=t
Z_
heusmg Z_
n_hl thctv.
No, no, d_sclclcd t_l_d
"JTcI.EWl'INF_S
"ff'_
support says t_ c-_cmt of fig.J_¢s 2A
23 I}@t plod,_c,:d by lo_c_s
$u¢=
W'II_S
8 wh_'¢ =1 that ¢o_u_
II
to
t:¢hum_lI¢I_ 25 and wthch Ire each r eJslx:_{v¢ 1o t_ir'_JCd
I II1_
L_ m¢ stop y_
_nv_Jy
_
tZ s_.o_d
10/26/05
Heanng
"l'_,lt I=¢1 com_
6
10 pre fcrrld
[ lh4r11<
- IPm I_ng
Q2, the pDI d=_:_s
OO275
3
9
24
the Ices, 26
TIlE CO UB.T
.¢ I_¢kg_lt._d.
_
_
bur., QJ _d
t¢<l,_l
m¢_m_
_md _J_ include= r_vo conve_Uo=tal p =.t_v¢ m fm_ed, pl_
23 _cnsoi_
whff_
tl.lV ¢ a _¢
[Tom s_d ippcf=lt_
Tho d,s¢10'J=d sm.t:',_¢ _ d_ow_
21 the &s:lot._l
_llrl_nan
0O2?4
1 _._st n_ I_h
ot o_ccl.fupatltc
20 poumlwll_ th_ J_
Th_/i_¢
more I¢IpI_I¢ lb_n the I_LI¢< Ird
we'ff lind the ht_ with
II1 Lhc dOCtlm¢:=L
Tttc claimed t'uncllo_ up/l¢_e., '_
19
Hc_or
IJ._ ¢olo_ d u_
fu=omon m the c_=am we_l
17 condJbOn t_01{ moUon r¢ItOv¢ Io _ald firll _
bare Ibc bJack ,in d
We bel,¢'_
;d¢'_lz fy _
15 scmor rnr.a.m,_o{"cfct¢clam{{,{fi_L pl_¢_cn_mutcd cotlthuon
in.
2/
so d may i_ s Ii1_¢
So wc have unde_ Cl{um 6, ih¢ finn sensor so whal
14
talk= u_c of
ol" Lh¢ record,
Vcm7 well,yo_
"I]I¢_ wgll
apph=_
to r,=d m some _lcs.
I _ o[ , p_o'z
20
l
t_lt this
r.o,_ u,.¢aun o( cthmm_co_s done
pa_l_r4ph6
_nd tl - btlx'n=p_,
13 wntl¢11 sup_ll
Wceegclng_the
Io _llow mc _ m/Io
COUR1"
ll2,
A.Slgldb,:fom,
b'malI }.?J6 dO¢3110{ IOply,
12 td_mltfy the _mJcn.trc zrd t;'_
w,Lh we'_
clearIo_¢-ex_,u_e
color, but dwy _¢e goml
Alln{hl.
! I _'=11 do ,s _dll
m _r noL, tl_ o01o¢c_ etch?
12
Okay
.lind _s I stld befo_:, th_ v,m.m._u=mcd from _hc
9 th_cuJt
to
COURT
$ pm_,¢'_taUm ,s _ _roposod
Honor
II come
2
4 ¢or*tmu= to _¢hcv¢
So
lzl¢= a 15 ImP.Jte t¢c¢l¢
(gr_.t)
I_
00273
I v..t_
I Ix.co,me e'_ din, L
wail
con£=r )
COU_T
6
9
V,_7
me=r= I1= ¢_l_ng
sad Emp to m'_l
Okly
52 cP.n_oL_ the _mlot=_ oft_
M=rE.,T_n
Heann_
II_t _he
10/76/1)S
;_ _11
Pale
174
l_hl
=I laid lcr._d
Icvd ot _l_lzna_on
Markm.ln
JA 0849
He=ring
m i_po==;
10_&0S
Page275
l*/3
C_21_
2 Be
well
00277
I
e.o-n n-_..*o on I_ the _t
3
_._¢[Q:cdr_,_x'Ual
4 th_ p_e
_tl_r.m
=_1:
c_ca_
_._r_
I:_-t o f the.
Tha
And r_ly.
l ulsle
conrail
zhe _sclo_A
t_'_
c:_ 8,_c drr:'_ cn_cuy
8 65 and br.t_
9 _hold
p_tt c_ 75, more spu:l fic.dly the
II
I h_ve
"D_
14 on-_net
15 r._t_l
m_l _-_l
I_
th_ the
Lr_ _41 In b]l_ck 52 _ n_l p_l
ctn_ul. _okmg
16
SO If| youz p_te_n
Of_e
THE. WTTNESS
I_
T_e tonal
THE COURT
19
u !_wt of the c_'_]
20
$o you dJ_ not _nl¢
t_l
TH_
volr.t&e at node 61 has a Ic_:J TI, th_ Lna_ _
L_ ramp voltase _ node 68 _car._
I:l_.:ze _ ._hOws the corr_pon_bn$
21
23
AC mpt_t sqp_aJLt zpphcd to the
FO" e.xample, with t'c_'_cnce m flgurc _, whe_ the
tht_hold
20 131acis _
No, nol of t_e; c_u'oI
"i'I_COURT
Okay
2_t
_ tl were.
_lt'_e
2_
Markman
He_rmg
[0/'Z6_5
Page
the haJf wave volt_e
to the lamp. 18, whc_
s r4_ex[
talus tht_b_ld
T2 u
,t ca_t m_relq_t
$
By compzd_8
aa_y.a
T2
the v_ml]e_
acr_
Markmao
the tamp, ! S, for
Hearing
10/26_U5
Page
_tng
at _ldTI
thtcah_d
$ whc_.
9
I sho_nd
Okay
So n_.u_
I I me_t_
r_vc
12 cotu_n
£ot (mt_tm_
s*Jd _mp
16 predetermined
17 sa_d Cra _m_de_m_
18
Mo_nn|
19 totem,
_.
¢_-ttmcr
[_nc_
$ tr_av'_.._
vbch
6 29 _r_c
_t
to show
7
_s
m _
m
Okay
10 on-I_mcr
On..umer
r ¢_Im,_
c_,x3d_'_zl
and _k
e_.l tt cza _e
thdud_
I. _
m _cc_nL, a dL_clos cd
tnw
¢_mz I_t
_ s_d
I_ _nf.le ;_tte
14
f_n_
u:c_A
_
era cecartmce
[Ithl_tt _tion
the pcrtw._
_
of
16 sigmlls
18
znd hack to
ts th_ _
Markm=o
_ _
He_rln
8
10_26_05
Page
the _¢
TH8
_
the pr_,_ou_
JA 0850
the ramp
COU_T
"['hn
shd_
I'm havmE a _VJ¢ _oublc
w_h
in tlun_
_
_1
"DI_ COL_T
_S
Okr/
T[u_ looks
[tke i_ com_
dlrectly
2 to me_
23
THE_
24
it on the _ee'_.
TH_
ftdcca
j_
rmse_y,
rmd_8
Io fxde _I_IT
COUR'P
Oh ot_y
Marltman
278
node
[_ad pka;e
fi-_m _r thephas¢;m_lecmYa'ullcr
2O
2_
the
hsiUz_8.
I[_ a Iltlte more _J_l_ _¢
con_v_
19 _et_r tadm$
bore.
irr_uS._
_
al the h.b_cd
AJ_d aS_'_. ] kave .n_l I'aded m th • zc-m crcr-_ ng
17 _ cxag_y
which
_hcr.
voltag_
aneeth_t_muhasexp_rcd,
thr theacce_t
I $ c_r_ulnV go _
_nea
swacmrc,
thsct_sed
[2 m the mac dt_ppm& back Io it_ . what we c_l
t_a-_
mu:_,_d
e to _d
*J_t _
the _cahold
II 61,w_uchwdlrcmltmtka
o f a _uk-umn_cd
of _nd
p_dac_
27. from _Swe
m f_t:c_Jtr,
h_ rrr,At*_
m tl_ pxcfc_red
9 phase znste cztcmlr_
mdt_dc_
finl ffedcte_mzr_d
th the r,c_t st_.e, on-um_
and u_l-on
rzm;_
tad I_u_ to acccm
ofsa:d
t_ th_t_r
we hzv_ tka d_d_r,d
on-ta'eer
t_._ _n:ch
_fl¢cloncofr_..eralp_dctcn_.r_ont_u:
fzded m j't:st fm
Ce_lrOl ¢arcm_ mez_
nw._ur_ent
m teepees
cev_h_
_
4 c_et
zero ¢:o_
page Fm
Io expc'zt_u
t$ le_ eI of*Utrntr_zon
3 s_
cnr.m_
to de,cc_
13 tat:a'val znd t_
f_ ra_n_
£c¢ _e
an the _he_
_us ts m the overall
10 Cl_mz 6_ the chttmnd
TI tkaa whra
tkan _ thr_holdT2
the textt_J s_ppc_
7 c_rct_u'/tkat
Ir_f¢ _cl_y
t _¢_ull of which the Im'np, t $, wQl
_O_v. en the set er.a I h_ve jtm
6 rr.fe_.e
".5
_rm_s
00279
"[I a_d "['2, It will b_ ¢vl_e:Ilt _
I thrcsEol_i
20
th_ [an_p
3 _I_o r,how_ the t_esult_n8vol_e
276
O0278
|4
_
oe.
The_ the m,_: _le_
24 L_ep I$ f0z:z_ffuen[_rcsbold.
2
level T1
volt._© arrc*_
22 die kanp dunn$ rem_mde.z of thzl haJf v_v_
I tha'zk that block $2 ts F_q o f
25 oCth_ s_b_rcu_l.
vot_e_,e
19 u zc_ dttrmg the tirol po_on of h_Jfw_v¢ er,_l the
21 _b-Cm_L
22
the 120 wh
IS lareF 18 fer t_.n_hold TI when: thc vott_c
block 52
ctrc_t_
THE_
th© d_ed_kl
t_.mp, t$
17
IS
at node 61
16 rerned _n wh_
czrcnd for nrnmg
_t riot:
b apphed _e
the comp_'_t0r produee_ _ ouzput whtch t_m_ oa tka u'uc
14
_ fl_*re 28_
the ctmp sqp_
input to wh_h
V,'hcn the nmp volUqt_ e_cu:dl
12 Q3 _o t_l
aow Caded thal b_ck euL
COU_.T
a furlb_
v_e
l0
Okay
Io
6 phase mg_c centre1 poruon 72 includes a comparalo% IC2D,
7 haY:n8 one input to which tt _4_h_
13
a phase
*$t _'ponllvc
4 t_'eSi'_d voltzSc a_ _O_e 61 for acmazi_ 8 a tin.c, Q3
t_t
--_d/_a.'qr_ a I _l_J: h2td to n:_= a tD-
12
suppor_
Wckavethem_Q3md
tn th© tn_
6 r _e
textu_
a "/2. of the _n:_z
Hearfng
10¢26/05
Page279
277
0O280
00281
THE
WITNESS
What
_ e'fe showing
here
herc'sthcclreulu_'th,tlwe_screaHywomedaboal
J_i
for ¢on_ emence.
ramp
waveform
actually
_ c're md_cahng,
tha_ helped
s_lect
[lille dkmcult
$
coding
And
10
whLch
12
_e
lamed
for lhls
3
Io
son
_upport
is d_n,
Lt up into
4
lh_ thsclosed
Inac
7
vohage
8
_ave
exactly
bcca_c
fo_ sarae
L_xtu,d support
as the -
thl$ Icxl comprises
the
So phase
14
re_ponslvc
15
portzon,
16
actualmg
17
angle
conffol
1o the output
66.
and
Q3
[ S 72 inclodcs
a comparatot.
19
apphed
ramp signal
20
inpul
t_c
to whlch
21
When
IC2D
across
12
wdl
13
18
14
ares_Rol'wh_chthelamp
for
15
thrcsholdT_
ponlon
] 7
ts apphed
voR=gc
the comparJLor
23
the tnac
Q3 so _t
24
apphcdLothelamp
the
one
mpul
the threshold
_ o]tage
exceeds
_s
at node
61
VAC
whlch
input
tufr_
on
s_gn J[ is
18
For example
_ith
reference
to figure
Markman
3
when
Hearing
the
_nergy
_hcn
threshold
T[
a_aL
_cd
I0/26105
Page
the screen
secLior_
Agala
the ¢ltcult_'
across
By compaang
TI
v.hen
the
and T2
to the
using
it
lamp
Ih_eshoLd
T2 a_
'_lllemlLmorehghLat
Now
[ ha_ _ jus_
faded
Lhls is Ju_
the _ext thaL Lalks
thai generalc_
by the tnac
control
slides
22
want
that was ,_ddcd
23
app[ytoClaans
24
Sensor,
Io make
th_ tanlp
that [ ha_e
earher
of foe
shdes
but I
that thee
sections
10aodll
Claims
means
_ olLa_e that'_
i_ o_c
h r_phcates
sure thJ_ ILeS_ndcrslo_L
9
m the 7ero
clrcull
the nex[ shde
21
Sensor
_ cthage
fo_atth_sholdT2
AOd on
19
a_ ¢
of that half
is $upphed
than
the l_np
un[ll the
the halt'_
for thresholds
18
TJ
9, l0 and I I
Cot dc_cclmg
280
Clatmcd
_uncuon
a predetermined
5|arkmaa
condition
Hearing
10/26/05
Page
281
00283
I external
2
to _ald apparatus
Okay
3 P[Rs
The alL,closed
And the disclosed
4 figu_
st_ctufe
[cxtua[
2A and 2B Lnclud_
5 P[R sensors,
7 infrared
8 p_slng
h_ht
17 dlsclos_J
_x_r_lon
foat the lamp
of mollon
by _c
to _c next $hdc
Scn_or
mea_s
condtLion external
16 ¢a5¢ foe d_clo_cd
sit,clare
_2
QI
Okay
Coa_'ol
and Q2
CLaims
Control
21
said _c'nsot means
ClrCUll mc_r_s coupled
22
said firsl ]_el
ofl[lc_nmatlon
23
predetermined
¢onthtlon
24
h_t
le_ ¢1 of Illumination
25
de[ecllon
ofsald
comparatot
the devLce
4
the thffercnt
ou(put
A_d
for ea_mg
to $_d
again,
that
And
9
identical
10
¢ontro]
to the thscfosed
several
the ths_losed
72 of foe ctrcul_
fo_dcleCtmga
[4
More
15
72 includes
a comp_ator
and _
16
apphed
ramp
dctccL_
17
mpt_[ LOwhtch
18
THE
19
lamp a_d r_pons¢_
sa:d _amp to enut hght
e ;0
at
the other
a[ node
the
spect_cal[y
signal
_s apphed
COURT
TIlE
21
THECOURT
WITNESS
m the absence of said
22
from
re_thng
23
THE
X_qTNE_S
24
rereadthalforth_folrdt_me
2_
on here
predetermined
Mafkman
Lo
condl[ion
Ilearlng
10/26/()5
Page
61
JA 0851
Again
heard
thai
thzs is
Phase
is responsl_c
deLect,
porllon
angle
to foe
66
for actlt_Llng
foe phase
and th_
a L_lac, Q3
in a
angle
control
portion
]C2D
having
one
at node
68 _ld
ha_ ing ,I fotahet
the threshold
Mr
C_tlson
Thank
mpul
vollag_
thats
you _ery
LeLsnotdothal
I am
pleased
A]lnght
Mark:nan
282
voilage
Io which
is
_t node 61
idet_tlcal
to
one
and for ca_L_lng said lamp to emil
m response
crossing
nimp
73
20
exceed
already
crossing
tna¢
9. L0 and [ I
support
portion
threshold
the
_rom
textha[
have
13
56
We
angle
m the zero
_,he_e
_c
_ ohag¢
again
pha_c
_s the
Q3, foe trtac, that sets
faded
to shov,
I_mmg come4
12
in this
that dn_es
Lo what
porhon
Tnls
levels
jost
Of the zero
structure
hines
[ h_ve just
as before
[ I o_tpaL
fols is r_enIla]ly
to said apparatus
20
at second
3
orcultry
move
this no_
a talks aboul sensors
z_ J pho(oc¢]l
circuit
we
7 generates
prc:sence Ot absence ofdayhght
19
ha_¢ seen
5
Ls acu_ a_ed in
sensors
_$ the photocell,
tcxtur,_t s_ppo_
And
2
6
e_ctemal _o th_ I.rmp and
9 10 and I I when
Sensormean_
15 predetermined
_h¢ housing
are eJch rcsponsl_ e to
on mhthlt
ofum¢
mo_mg
13 an or for Clazn_
[4
of
pa_sl_ e _nl-ra_ed
I
8
and _
to detection
Now
is foc circuit
the Icn_, 26
10 con Lrol_ the _mount
12
is Q I and Q2
are mour_ted wlfolr_
26 and _,hlch
T_r_l on-umcr
I I r_ponse
suppo_
produced by sources
through
again
_ o con_ em_ona[
Q L and Q2. _,hlch
6 tube b_hmd lens
lg
thai more
crossing
18
25
C_282
9
be e_ ident
using
apphes
T_
]e_e]
across
across
the t_m.undet
i_
20
the threshold
an output
120 voh
Io _ hlch
J funheT
the Inac
the lamp
16
6S and having
produccs
Rs
tnac ts
_ oltage
S the resulhng
vohag_
_3
having
at node
3 a]sc* sho_.
the
68 r_achrs
of the hall" wave
dunng
II
T[
dete_t
mlgl¢ control
and then
thradlfferentthreshold
levels
TI
at node
the _oh_e
portion
lampl8
a_ node 61
pothon
the phase
the r,trnp vollage
22
25
_oltag©
m _ _
specl ileal[y,
crossing
TI wh_e
the lamp
Figure
a le_d
_ oha_gc
[0
72 of foc cm:u]t
zero
the threshold
a _ac
More
portlon
of the
on,
across
61 has
the coffcspoodmg
the firsl
is Itwncd
9
11is the same
3 sho_s
dtuang
6
of a jumble
ha_¢
aL node
foc rzanp
18 for foreshold
wLChoL:t
andT2
l _
[_np
ll's a
plcces
voltase
on _ hen
FLg_¢
5 _s zero
foc schematic
finally
is baslcally
l I tcxlual
thceshold
2
her e'_ the
-- L_al ts used
to tTy to break
up v, lth jusl
9
I
And
the I¢_¢[
[['s -- _hc way
7
well
is
much,
YourHono¢
Youarc
to not h_
¢ to
Soletsmov¢
Ilearlng
10126105
Page
283
0_B5
I
A_I.'._
'_ac.=_o
Sw'ttk
Cl_9_10x_d
I ttru_e6l
f_f f.ct_gam_Q3.{nam..'._perdon.
2 73.
3
Mote sp_d I_c_dIy Lh¢pb_¢ a_[¢
4 77. _:_des
$ _ Sl_cd
6 a v_
¢o:r_'co_y
_I
_t_
_i- AC ix_w_ c_
a corn;_rat_.
_
the th_x_ld
w_ch to_i_ Qn m._¢ Q3 _oi_a
[0 s_i_
120"_
mp_
9 d_©_:.
m _Fphcd _ Lhe I¢,ap. 18
II
Cn the _¢¢_-_ I l_ve j_
12 ,.he p._e
f3 b¢_
(ompu_o¢
now, dn_g
14
I0
thdt_hn
d_ - _8_m,
c*_cm¢ d_t we h_e
t._
nm_
Phlsc _J_e,
IL"Jnp _.avcrorm.
9. I 0 _Id I I
Cl_Jd
an output, which _
¢lmmx I 0 and I I
Me_z_ for IXOducing a _
I ) each half valve 0f_d
CL_¢_
produ¢_
L_ poml
fol th©kalfwav¢
16
I_._.
IS
If _.e Io_
_
21 rc_tor
o_©r _J tl_ dv.de;ed .¢w_.t=re
f_.
we've h_¢h_i
dm'_ed
RA0 co _ to Q"c:_ I _?
Z4 p_i_t_'h,
Dus
rm's_pvol_¢
¢_J_ed
2 at_6_ts_lowllml]gxtr_J
3
p_e
4
u_d u; sy_.hn_ed
$
the_sveatnode67
6
drayed
7
a
vo_¢
cy_b:a._l
¢or:cs0o_n_
io the zcxo _S
of
m nod= 67
Marf_au
I 0f _e raeSe _" window
Itw|llbenotedl_t<nch
2
to _ re_po:_xve zero ¢_c_n8
9 _-.-_ fn-.t th_.-._e_
He_t_ng
10/26/05
CI_r_
._-%'e{o*--_e
_
',_
m_
slg_J
I S excced_g
l'P.¢ dclmcd
o_nF_t_or
_f a _lctv¢
port.n.
Pege
Ixc_L the _:&mn betw_:n
dte hml_
window
_ no_e
thin c_oad;
Wh_x a pollute
r_nse
24
w_adow
compm_or
25
respome
to Cu_
c¢ _ttve
or wx.qdo_ n de_c/ed,
po_0n
Mark]man
H
tk= F_-r_e
13
f_-_tc_
t_ _1=_ _
ph_t_dl,
=d
of day_
C|rcmlm_-.-lmcJizdegm_J_rL-_3o:_t_lO_
_0_k©
$o we'll now mo_
19 trml o_t the ¢_ ulr¢ol,_
2D _oto¢¢[I
o_ a
_i_e
22
_or_
w_
we have cr_l
to
pieces hcs_ so that you ¢_n see tee
conn¢c'ong m_o the d©t_t _d
21 thai If day_l_t
Cxr._dm s the
to th© nc_d shdr_ t_d w©'][ _e
dct_f_e_ u_'may,
and should be q_ore_
m _ct_ted,
_e_-q Cdo._t_y. so
the phozc<ell _az[ly
an oetpet which unll f_rce de _
(o E¢ - lamp I
23 wbaoff
_:d sa that the
24
putr, es m
inp=l Cp_e
m exceJs
H_nn
10/Z6/05
B
._a,._
L_t
tu #a,d ,tFf_ja _
tbc
r¢&xtt ve
only _f_ve
Cb_redP_r._To_
e to gSht ¢_r_1
_ d_
IS _¢ dayl*_t
_8 ou_u_
posla'.¢ or acl_vc
II
n=:_-:_
_cJ_l
17
_¢ts r_a
m
aS"¢ldy d_
u
ot _ relieve
b_n& a rt_¢
we have _:tttalty
,_'x_
limit
cx_.¢ot_u 8 a p_:d_tcrmm_l
21
2_
43. m_tlOr_
Ti_
at
For _lp_,l_ad_mbcd
_mc_.
h,t v L_ m imtplJl_Jde
_k¢
• p_d..'tt_m_r ed podnve
m amphtu4.e
9
eJ:d a r.cmcd
_ich
Ph_tecen.Cldm
"/ tcr_[nB m_
a I;A't w.2x_ Lq the
20
22
I 0 zr.d I I
of 6Sure 2A and 21], the voIL_e
ts _ threshold
i_er,
3 _ttunc_ous
e f d_ _."_', --tL._L_'_ _rd t'__'_'_'_'_'_'_'_'_'=r
3 pc:'t_
47.
19 I_vmS
4 _l_m dc_l
G
Ot _--A ¢:r_--',--'.'.'.'.'.'.'.'_¢¢-.¢tU_
_..V:t
point o f
Thc_lgnwavcatnode67ts
co._'p.._-.J_.
In (he ¢_
3 "male61 se_es
fh_rn the AC ;x_w_r h__
W "L'J_
16
on tP_e ¢_pact',n¢. Co 16,
or r'.mp of the w_v¢ form _ node 6g bes'm_ JUSt x.qer
10 C._¢¢¢
!7
v_¢
_
fm_h
OO287
I
14
th:t_
a_ a _w:
284
002S6
du_=
frmn _e five voh m_ly
73 d.'odc D 13alt_c¢_dofct._b_Jfwsve
Page
crm_ng
"11_3 durm_ e2¢h h_Jf ,rave cy_e. the _m_
20 C-16 u de_y
I0/_'0_
v._dch Ls
L_t _Jo Caifcd out by r_m_ m th= _.
19
Hclring
ha_|ng _o_
AC voll_ge I r'J._p p_c
I? I=:¢. we c_: - m _m.tl
M_rl<man
The ermined
wa_¢f_n
t 4 iiddtt_L [n _c_po_¢ to dch=:_o_ of the _
2_
_n
Q3, to that t 20 voh AC mpul t_S_._J_ applied
12 f_nc_o_
_he
a_ node 6 I
the th_h_ld
to th© hmp. I|
II
rr_y
voh_c
the ramp volu_e _
$ vdtaSe, dm corr p;r_or
9 o_
omyJol pomon.
hav_n_ one mpul xowh¢_
the nunp sz&_d at node 69 _J_dhavm_ a ftt_hcr
6 input m wl_ch _ _ohr.d
?
IC2D.
Aed the d_¢_d
7J dcects _
Puge
p_¢¢
[ctm,_J cup_n
e_ a_._
MarP, rl_n
286
JA 0852
ix, phemo:_l _
0f d_yU_hl md has _
H_arlug
10/26s0_
PegeZ$7
285
I _put
c_#_
m.
day_t
dc_x
mzl _
por_o
002S9
! cbITe_
F.' o¢
3
Dsyh_t
dcm.t
4 t]_ outFut oftl_
_xl rc_
_
ponma
ts rc=pc_[ve
$6 fix eITec_vdy
mid mm-cm mbiinE pac_
6 _/tl81_
Sq_uls fm_n d_l_umn
Imu_
7 do nm c_u_
sol_lt
t_
L_p,
1L to bc tth_
fo
ats_bbn_
5 outpm er tl= ¢_-um_
t_
3
A
4
exp_tst_s,
52 dram8
QI _
fal d_n8
Q2,
d=yh_t
6
Q
7
ftmcUoa,
dm _ the cud o f the p_._c_t_o__
I0
I_ECOURT
Okay
12
MR_ HIGGL'_
t3
T:_
14
lS
Rr_dy('c¢
Th_kyc_
MJr Hs_m
_
Ycs, mu'cm
(0 me. $cv¢_l
$0
Q
In _c l'coct_n
It
A
[ .m_oa_c=ses
12
the:c'_
_cmre.
CAP._ON,
14
_.cvld_
l_
Q
16
e[a_ora/e
du;y _m
_
fono_
In yc_
19 Q
Mar C_r[son,
t $ yo_
m p_34oFy_st_c_c=sk
20
s_.
Zl
go_ tn'w_, by 1L?J6 bcca_c
i"do rml t_ct_ccc _
th= thspu/cd
"mc_a_ o, thc cmttcl_
_ce add]tm_J
When a ctum
23 ¢_r_mm_,_
$_r._=e
At Oth_" _
2_
to _
20
A
Ye_,
21
Q
Cogld
22
A
If the chain S_
21
st_cturc.
24
c2_m that _
25
S_
ftmcLo_-
Can you explain
Markman
,rthee
H_rlng
tg a
I0/2_'0_
A
2 pm
y_.
I c_L
$ A
Y_.
6 Q
DM It detect _noa
9 Q
4 7_
dc_ccl _o_ea
tt d_L
g z_l _,_h _'cus
_d
e f a p_on_
the sensor
tt dc_cc[ t _on
- _c_c
me - w_.l_
you please
er#am
how °
On to elabor=le
o f an
to provide w.ote
really - ts rcal&y w13ttcn
I"_h_
than simply
mcx_
(am), _md hntcndcd
ofthc
3 Q
_c:.._m m _u
con_d
Now
Hearing
ref_ngyou
tothet_mon
5 A
Okay
6 Q
-* m the p_cnt
7 A
R_gh_
$ Q
[s It yct_
_ony
the.
thc turn on ta]_
block 46, _ Fan of the ma_'el
Is it or _ it act pen of the _cmcr_
12 A
IH_ not p_*rt o f th| _m_r
13 Q
I l_ve
yes.
Can a _
ma_n
wJ_out
s=_'c_.oa
YeS
19 Q
New. vrmlc _u
20 az_ _plzmm_yourshc_
21 _'ulzr
_tdc
22 qu_Uon
d_
_ to whct_r
_eczc dmug _o_
_ow.,ng
yo_
I]
THE
20
(Coucas:lconfer )
21
askr.d y_a a
o_ no_ L_ - I tht_
COL_.T
[ have thl_
22
CRO_
BY M'_
23 Q
G_cdm_"ams
24 A
C.0(xlmom_ing
O_L
Ma_cman
t_t
_
N_e
Hearing
Yoar
Hon_r
nm/l
tL
Okay
Q
10C_6_5
Page
290
RX2_MINATI
Yotl
_d
Mr Carl_on
[ met sorac re,_ths
MarRmau
JA 0853
ON
COOK
24 oft_ccoa_
I bcEc_'e that :s tho q_t_o_
_xc_cmc.
sItdc_
when wc a=:e zalkmg _ut
l have _p, L_ _dgc
_1C_[_$
I'm gomg to fix th_ so be cam _c
23 a_in - wh¢thc_ or _.ot the runl-_n uthtblt poc_cn v,'us pare
25 A
291
no Furd_-_ quc_txo ccr.
MR
16 approach?
17 c=_c_cry'_
18 A
xs
p_/sc count crrcma_
15
PI_ d_cz
t
_rc_O
Yc_,lt
I$ A
Page
_elP
I1 Q
16 Q
289
p¢_mcz_offi_re
IO A
w_ut
Page
to m_v* cr thai yc=, ,t _
11 A
14 c_u a b_¢c PIP, detect a_aon
IOtl6_S
c_c_
l0 cb_cc_'
t2 _m'_ _c_a_ the sc_o_
to convey
plus funtato__
thzt*v block 46.
9 p_ruon,
Yes Is_htmmovca_)wocxlmbatbackmd
the c[atm
Iben tt appcam _o me thtl We, m _a::L blr/e a
00291
I aa.swcxcd
DM L%t bz_c p_
_o yo_ :_ rcu_hm&
Markama
2 noC'
goes oa a3
me.. _om= mak:nal
it *,_
PageT.88
0_,_0
4 Q
zs hMu mq3o_u_l
_c
not mc_
or, ex¢_
_s to whcthe¢ or not I 12/_ appltc_ _
tcxTns m pa_
of yore" ride 12 st_=ra e_. y_u mc
the term "cc_aot e ¢a_cras c"
tcmn?
that
recites a fLmcuon bat thc_
sll/_¢a mt matcu_l
opralon
19
rrad the _tlrc
clabora_on
_gium
thc_c
oCdm=e tcrms m con ¢¢xt
clcm_c_t$
tttsduccdys_ed_othat
d_um _
cvc_ tho_
2.?. mc the word
24
you
f¢:t_ca
slixtct_al
_l._clP
17 o: z_.s cr _h_cRc.¢.
M]L HIC, GI_I$
lc_m8
In o_,¢r c._.c_A tf_ml
SlOVeN
te_oflod
a
Yc8
claim term you wdl
_d
t_o
WhcayoureadG'cclamatcn_sthat
13
first Ix_
_e
It suggests
St_lcmlcs.
_1o you f_d
Ok_
_zmmcd
_c_n
I me.xa _n all c._.
L"OURT
I_wn8
_
I$ By
or wha_ cOUld do
two ex_"es_m_
m the Claim tcrm_
9 A
aieyctLgomsto_kh_mathwmorcclue_Uom,
16
t_se
really is no _ ffer_cm
and
Okay
8 tccltcd
_
II
Them
5 suuctlm:
81_mt
9
bec_vcen
2 y_u mea_ by t_'9
2 ib_ dnnm.
_o
at your dcpcsiho_
Hearing
10f26/05
OO293
I Lh¢t_d
fC9._2
I md I _ed
],_0usmee que_ch_
Z lhcr_.¢lzzmterms.
3 q_uo_
_._ut
yo_" m_e_
af
t&_
A_drml_gtogoov_s_eof_h_
_th
y_t
l_c
d I c.tn ge_ the t_tmolo_
The l_m smser, C_m
6 b_ud.
_
6, f h.wc _
ts the Fast shde in _
3 Q
Any scn_, _
4 A
O_y
6A
NO
? Q
_
_
Y_,
9 Q
Behind _
i0 oae _e
collecuon of sh_es
II
t_le page- I'm going to pmcmd
follt_a'tgo_agto
_d
ae4 - we h_ve t_
fzdeu1_d
t'_?
zr_ many dJITC_cnt zype_ o f _.ms,
8 whch _ould.
[:_._tnd the utlc p'_c
to tether
fadeoul,
In your _cw,
I0 A
now,
llwl]lh:tvet_
It
o f t;_-m, wl_
Fttt_mp.
Q
^ nd j_I
fZ _
16 t_
fluxion
_zcd
y_u bJvc h_c_
And bene_
the _,
m Ibe me4_ plus fimcuon c_'_,
15 s_d _t
_ogt_
17
II
I _g or "f_I
Y_.
I_Q
$o the _
peme_ _ the rec_l
20 o£_he cl_m eJem_.
21 Se_'_r,
s t_
2_ _
btbztc0rrect?
23 A
Ye_
Z4 Q
Fdlr_
23 "s_-_',
_
z_me
the h,_hf_ed
_e sm4c_
fur_
p_am,
la_,_c
N_t,,_nyourvle_v,
betas moron rr.L_bv¢ Io
ot't pcno'n or object sep_
_m
So wouM _
agrc_ wlth me t_t
the ,.vord "get.r"
sector" does r_t rtgrlc mfl_ct_t
t_
_u_c_g
_on
swJLmre to
which _ th_
21 A
"t_ig won_ "so.of'.
_f ft _,.m_s campfct_ly
c'._ Qf _
24 B_ wL_
t.._
of tbc c_m,
m cr_,gexk _
y_,
x1_c
in g'_t _o'dd_
_I Ic]Lt _,_ wh_
_und_
bc ablc to p_'_rm
Hearlng
10/26/05
Page
_rlo_au
292
Healing
I0_26/0S
Poge
293
Page
295
OO295
I Q
"..k_
Lt. -_ you _7.
t:¢l a f c¢:'J.cxt, t_
I eJzborazou
".t._l d
2
_l_i,_
-.el convey
t.'_e _
e
:.Lzrn, I'_l by L'¢.£, it _o¢_n t _¢Z._ _J_tl" c.¢a_t
7
_w_u
8
_
9
:on z.I
te pn f,um _r_l_y
f_ iI, d do_
I0Q
]_r'_.
_e
_4
| _dc_'_
mc d_t wdre
6
Q
tbJ'.¢tmo _
7
rC¢ltCd f_nrJ_on?
_c_:
Ig A
ta r o
eel
the ¢_tcxt
y'_a fir d -- _
tt¢ roe,ted
t_ gt_d.n_
bezng modoa
d_.'t F.u m _n_
f_,
y¢'_" - whzt yo_
_h_o
4o
arc ¢_ym_ ta
9
c_
to
Q
aZI_z schmanc
of the dam7
of tha ctz_m, y_
i2 Q
Wt_lnthed_m
0
,_1 n_L
! _l pcd'oan
ccrtmn unc._s
per form _e
t9
THE COU_T
20
THE _S
21 tc[l_ yeu
BY bt_
23 Q
2*
yoa
25
A
mtzn:ly _c
A
17
_3r.tuaunft_'/
I_) t_
rc_lcd
sl_J_c
r¢¢iz_ oto
ftmct,_n7
"rt_cl_mx3vcx'/t_c_r
re¢lt::d ct.-¢t:on
c_ie:xl_ll
s¢l_ot
nWh_l_lZ_yl
'.bo_l_e
lt_rn_acn=_ccr
_u
Ir'L-_d
Frov,d._ z'_--por t t_f ycur
"_zt zs co_e_t The ¢_::tt
wb:n ty_¢ sc_c_g you w_udd n¢¢_
21
A
('_.*dy_=-l'-nnol
_eltmd_,2/.3"31your
23
Q
?,s I _d_1..-nd
24
11 _
ccr_CXl of the ru:hcd
COOK
l_owtbe
_
- bu_ not _1] sa_e_7
thai m conlcxL
word "t]_t s¢_'z_of" re_leZ sut_clcm
t6
F.Jzo,;
do you ftnd aW o_:x
for your opinion
D
;¢r_c_
otlg¢ thin m th©
to see
Ou_de
1_1 _e
3_cn
1"oat
type o f mQt_n
z_vhcre
Oumdc
V¢11'_ c_nect
COURT
fo_ son¢
II A
A
d_u-..d -
]c_kt_s
[[_lZd_hem_textm61pxes2Aa_d2B
l_k
14
TI_
c_JoOn
tim predcle_illzned
n:la,Jvc to s;dd _lrst .¢er_or means
Do yo_ F.nd the _nl_t
I_ supper
16
stud
,I ofsp¢lsOtlord_y._lscparatel_omsaJdappara_us
_f ;¢r_c_
¢lh
I f the _u_d
pre_terrnlned
£ot dctectm 8 ;z I_t
tn ¢_ud appu'aius,
_rd_llon
4 d_
22
a
to s;ud app_zzt_
20 rgated _c_on7
F1_t
m the
00294
17
Ig_e
Ford_ccung
co_dlUon t_
m_
19 pe_fon_ _n:_y
do_t_cwo_
n_ly
Markman
II
zc_or
2Z C_d b _(_
would sll _o_
n:c¢_L 0¢ _.Clt_d l_on
16 sud
htw
17 you e_?
A
of
hog. Is _h_t :orrcc_
R_l'Ows, andFmsolaglOr_IL
14 s_ud _rsl prod¢Icnmncd c0_d_on
_I
_I, you have ua_Irne_
_
_ perfon'_ _e
Y_t
I :* l'a_t p_cdaanuncd
14 a:pf_adve
b_ _l'fic_t
g tecllcd t'utgbOl_ aAd ;on_ which wo_d
_mm
on a PDF
12 Ul ea_J_ sb_e t_ m fmn_ of u_
1$ szys C1au_4
eJcment7
up _ t_
7 tl nno_
$ A
of _l_t '4din
All sc_or_7
4 w_k.
$
t_gdon
2 A
coatextth_Jyou'rel_'nr,8
for wkeredo
trot co_cxO
Wall
Hearing
I_ctt
25 ,Jz'._zu'i:,Ol.'¢xf_/lnl_llUCfi.z:_cn
m thu bJ_gthlge, [ tlnd [t In Lhe
MarI_aau
IL y_ Jx - ,._: _'oxd "11r_ gL"u_
10/26/05
Pag¢
294
Markman
JA 0854
_q_ pr_v_d_
_._mCl_l
]_lt
Lt¢cr_rc
Hearing
I0/26_05
0¢t_96
I rc_tcd
functx'm
h'_
you find I_
g A
11w z_,c ic"a_d'_g
3 Q
A_I of 117
4 A
- .n _c cflu_
$ Q
N_k'a8
6 A
All o f ,I/ak_
7 z!_c_gcally
2 thal d_tctzm_
tcxt -
3 Q
mnCllOlh _,ca
_
_.cnm
a who_¢ m ¢_nt_L,
.cd ra:c_mm
TI_cTe wl
[ I about
the 112.
some _c
dinah& the ¢pcnmB s _l_'r_a(
I'_ m 5up_
L1_¢¢Of. thai ggh ¢_1m
the cou_c
or s[cp f_" _mff_lng
[ r_nb_
t9 d_nbcs
20A
cha opc_m S s_a'_cn
21 doting
_uncuon
T_L_ma_[
22 Q
An acl_
2}
A
yc_
24
Q
And d_s
acts
Do
f/
t_ ph_,se_y_
a¢_ 1_at _uppo_
The x_cttcd
frrg
scr_ or nacam
for
_S
Markmaa
plus
7 A
Ycal_
8 Q
1 chute _dr pancrson
9
Yes, yes
A
g_l you
_q_.C_?
Heanng
suggc_l.s
chat
cagu" _
-
_gSe_'tedthat
dcm*t _rnd U_
posstb0tr
/
mtcma] combt_t_on
mgtae
Io think _bout ii. _n'1
I_ A
T?_
14 Q
Alln_c
10_26/05
LSCmTC_ y_
LcCs_oon'o_:cond_cr_x
l_ thcn_¢s_ade..
$cconds¢_or
I d I_a:de_m'mncd
ccnchtlonl
17
b_ng
a _rc_clcrmmcd
l!
apparatus
As [ ta_dcrstand
mcam
Page
yot_ chart hctc.
second
_c_¢tc'_lo
22
D_a:lc[crmmc_
*e_el 0 f IIghl cxlc:m_
23
_
24
rtot _
25
A
_'lcu
to s_d
you havc
a sc'cond
cot chUon, s_d
ed cor_
p_¢rmlned
t._q _m8
a
to)sgl_l a_a.raolg"
on of h'lls cLum CRT0_L
IS _1
That U _ncc__
296
Markman
C_Z
prc_clca_ra ned concht_on
e:clcmal
21
Lqthe tcclg'd
Thnts
_o_dc_cc;mga_cond
said second
Ic'_cl of hsht
20 isr, d_-Ilnrcl the _ h-ase _for dc_ct_ng
Dctcct]ng_s_nac(
nOlSl:ngRa'e
One poss_bdt_7
19
_he.
_y'_
.¢ bl_'_
12 COl'Tee_'
a ¢;x:¢1fic,d
mz_c_z/c_
Thalwo_Idbc_cpo_lbl_
6 Q
I I m the CL1tm You have
Si_L_ b¢ CO_S_110
,c_pondm 8 _m_ctgrc
16 you rcmcmt:¢.¢ that from
son o('[z_c
5 A
I0 Q
p=ra_raph 6 s'tacat8 and how the claim ifll'_
as a m_
17 A
bcu_ motu_a _ T_re_a_.4
12 _p'c_t_
t $ co'._
b_
¢L-J_rau_.
10 Q
$omc.vhcrc
4 Ihc_c hzs Io bc an ,nlcrna_ _rabccstton
m I_t_._'9
$ m_u_Ks[hcelxrallvcwO_lthc_e.
9 adduced
OO297
I the fact thac th_rc will nc:cd to bc zomc SZlUCtU._ to _o
f_' that ..
He_rmg
10/26/05
Page
297
Psrgc
299
002_9
lmer_r
4 A
tmg the r _..led
Y_
Q
L_chac _y
_m_t_:
m Chic _L
7 A
A_nn,
10 Q
Bul z_Isn'l m th_ ¢laJm ckmcm
12 Q
13 6
would
Eu-ea'am as :m act wha:h
Okay
z'or de_-¢nng I_
ri_ that _
(o _
l_y
_,_]17
clam element
lamp az_dr_po_tvc
"_IUCCXTCCL
T_
to stud f_l
17 scnsor rncar_ _ d_¢structural _ml_c
19 A
_s
T_next_]id_eo_n_olc_rcu_t_b_n
Th_s L_a _movhal
16 _lr.d
w'o_d _up_
- as [
and s_d
of _lua clam
"_v.'hy_htsl_hlcd_n
20 _due
21 Q
And _c _dcrlymg
22 _cotcd
f_nccmn?
A
24 Q
_on,on_
_olk:_n_
_rc tEc
Tllai is r._TC_L
r]_re._t_a(
_or Lhcrcco_
F_ca_csmg
_ud
lanlp _ Cq'rut hghl at sa_ _ir_ Icvc] c_fi[ltml_na_,_
Marksman
Pagc198
JA 0855
Hcan_g
m
10/Z6_)5
| file ;_smce
2 n_l_sil
0i'ilmt
lo szzl il=oed
J liu.l_t
.liid Ilill
4 fllgmiaiixin
A
_lxl
cendIIk_
hltl
il ilg d r,lr._
lo dclixaon
OO301
I r._talncoadidons
I1_1 za
lid
Ipcl
Youwlllnc_dctrcdgnol'thc_
2 _chlzons
Ibr
of
Q
AU nsh.
o C._mdCu:i
4 pe_on.
czm_cd_
6 lui_eal
Row. m yc'.a _v.
¢oa_ol
CU-C_l _
do_
couplcd
the h_hhK;'l¢d
_o _ud
I_np md
cm,chuooIh¢ rce.z_
fm:c_n
_
LOp_ £¢nn cnun:bj
_e rtug'd
Y_
8 Q
An n#a.
9 uzlicrlul_
I0
cm_
Io l=ll
Did l _pxras
7
p_d=lzn_m_l
m_
$ pna_c_l_[
6
Iirit
Now,_omeo£Chcwot_art
- m Ih= r¢c_l_[ £ul_tion duil I biw¢ liiil
rlid_
¢¢nzcdLhov_xLc_J=und==]mcd_lomeatcroL
II =xampl_,'lamp"
Pot
_n'tand_e_ard'_n_-_e"
8 A
If _k_ ph_._._ aJon¢ _ 1.zk_z aul or comoal,
9
aoL. it; ¢¢a_cl.
,t do_
And u3com=al
_.r_Zln _lcorrtCl
d do_
l0 Q
12
w_l
13
_¢c:_
I,I A
Th© w_
14
A
Yc_.
I$ _
ai.aelis _
L_them my ac;..O
a=y p=:t¢_r
I£ _lun'_n_on.
mczning
frora _¢ f;== thai sore© o£
w_=¢ _d_ch.cd
Eniii tll_l
LO_
at I_d
_bc _.zztx_
Ilrsl Iclcl
ol"
I7 rt:p:n_e tor,
aad scc_n_ p_edelermlned co_uon
IS ¢xasutS to e_at Izght al scgo_d - _ud _ad
It_ suu.¢_|
t_d_min
Q
(hr_acn
and (or
I?
opauoa'_
level of
18 A
{ ts to the _i_t
_
e of ¢_a,h,_m
L;ul is _mll
to L_ rcq_ed
24 ¢on_ol dzc_dt
YOU w111_
sor_ci_ng
Y_
2.
will I¢Id
tiilll&s _
m _ls
to Cau_ smcd_
will _
Markmaa
8
to
10/'26/05
tiearmg
o_1_
r.d by _h= f_chcd
t_- - _
cF ns_
.u'ucp_ro ta tha n_lrd
d_=n _t= wh ch w_a_d supp¢_
A _..ua. tl'c t.mg..._
u_ s..q_:_lr.d
i'l_r w_l
_¢rc
cxyl....g m do h_..
LE=rc _u I.U uctur_=
24
Q
2_
suru¢cU_?
chu_
dt_l_r_
by _C .zz_e.cz_:aL_
mo_c smgluse
Is bc=_
shnacuax_ha
clcraCnl iLlcl Cdoe.an't ¢0nt_a
Markan=n
Page3O0
a(
_p mot e c=.voa
b= anu..z0_ofpe=sPale
23
"l_s
ycut
"._x:'.¢a_rc;:dy t _c_ c=rh_" pe_oz_
r.o '2_ we =re ce_z_t;'/buil_hng
7.2 b_gt u_. Could
;x¢ all zhc z_anp thai point
tht_ _'¢ _,Lg_
s:ppozl
P_d b_ IM f=ct _at
20 claa_
23 you D s_:_rt
15 Io _
_
I_
20 prc_ek-rmme.d ¢a:_a _¢_x
_o I_
d_ thEgs
I$
19
22 A
_
m
¢hs¢_.¢ or"Cazz pmdcum_mod condaucn,
21 Q
tOassm'ncc_!
CZUOL Ateyou
I] II_ wi]¢_ IIx¢ Lmd=tlined 3rLd sor_¢ arc n04_
12 dm_r_
thr,
GlO=C
He=rinR
10/26/05
Page30l
O¢3O3
IA
2 ird_
3 Q
"l'ha_ _e only p(zil_l
ot lcllzll
llzzlcll'e
in ibis
4 ¢llizn7
A
6
4 A
Y_
Q
THE _)ij'R
7 0f Ihc Flrllhzt
Ii
zi ul_xlin_l
_t is d zlx, rilmg
9
"i" But yoa lue llTz_llliz©
_
u I_t clib_i"lll_
which smJ.!lc._ lofric
Ttt_WITN'ESS
"l_lliillc_l'rc_l.
fO_¢_dl_LO
8" "10iddyo*.l.-Ll_t
ilaberliz_
sm=_,
slilich_
Y_.
II is I_lxi oClhc t_d_
/_1 n&ht
6 A
But tt za not underlined.
7 Q
And zlz_the
p_z
-¢_epomoaof_c_z_'_"
I m d_ word "gor'.jtut
prior Io w5_'_
_c _._m8
9 boB=s, _
_krase, _¢s _o
Imc_ Ion_. _1
_icuJu
] 1 detecttoo ofs._d
13 Q
COOK
AI]n_tZL
lilculhi
wc bii
thisls
a v_llxi
0 f d_
I
IPiz h_l hilhltihdng
13 A
Y_S.
14 Q
b zll OI'LF_ sa_cl.ral
llf
17
"i'l_ COI_T
19
"rHE_
I doa_ thadi
;o, nol m dli
L_'I I>¢&m _th
17 mduc_',
l8
ITl'l'e
_ lioL
_lQ
Ia die bizet =zd while v=re.a
21 r_erl,
wlltO
ln_l:cd
N_. ICSnOL All ri_
ii_ uxl_ll=Em_l piton
Io yrw
C=n ).ou -- I
]l ll_ I_exl
Q
=_d b_n
_
rt_or_,o:
r,on_lU011"
to
L_1_2t
fl_-uol_
la_ga_
-- w_ll,
FIm_© _conttol
¢o_ut
to d¢_zmon of_ud
cotillon,
y_u _
Yes
21
D0¢= thzt stz1_'t_r¢ m yo_ vzcw r_fle
Q
m_:'_
C_t
_haz p I_lsc?
20 A
Z2 _,z,,_tm'c _o p_orm
li iI
t_
nSh: LEcre
r_=_ive
19 pi_l_l_'lziL_lr_
23 no"#
24 A
fix_t p_d_te'ntlln_l
I$ withdraw thaL
_n
16 li, Vlr Clr[s_i?
llill',=r
u_cludc_ rn_ns
12 s_¢l_al?
Movu_l_eioll_l_hd_
14 I._slldcclpuo_on-tl_ArldBZ_ToACccl_l.Cliim6
I$
.z[d_bJ_l?
flmcll_-,*_
1o read d, "_en _ol c_rccul r_e_s
! 2 BY 1_
U_I plxt O!'lh=
.1 _1_I¢_1 llm_izoi% clcn thoul_ tl'_ not ,_iuzlly
_t_Cl¢_d
cnu=c_y _e _edlCd fuactioa
ul_l
23 foUows _1_
Thii
Is _l_¢l_.
Al_l tile - som_ o f d_e liadl=luicd
Marlmila
plxuo_
Heart.It
ZS concr_ly
_ov, n -
10.,'Z6/0 $
Page
302
Markmu_
JA 0856
Beanng
10/26,0_
PriCe 303
O0305
1 CLuln ¢x[_cl_ty
u tt?
2 A
NOlCXprt_dy
3 Q
AJInB_t
• phrase.,
"mear_
_-lx_ns:ve
p'_de_rmme_
¢oet_u
6 t_ut term Ix:f_.
ap_Jn
9
o( L_
I I no_ _vl0e
_
m_tutal
fua_m
bec_e
e_
c_:t o f
ccmteXL b_ il 4ee_
to com_letdy
on _
_
_JI
paf_:
¢_t_Jy.
I _ tb= _'e t_ed,
_s
based upon th_ thm_
hke me_uze_tent,
_pm_r_.
_d
_lso
n_O
I_ Q
Pag*
o¢ thc c_m?
_t tt SLU_4.__0ne
t_ mdz_t
ft_t
u_ wc k_.vc _c_
rec_¢ _ut'_ _enl
p_l_ we _o Mve _omc
the _Ltb_zat_d
I t the rt._ted
of_
o f ¢oz_t _,
doer U'_ttL_J_l_
The please
l0 ¢_ulext
_7
to d_oe
_n', _tt
m the t_r_tl:_cl_
A
12
Itl,nthccbboratzo_
Solnyou_wewtl't._._--v.cud_t_:
3h¢_texLsl_del_semar,
Cl_rnsg,
20
ctmm ¢lfm_rt_ _d.s
21
prr.deten_u_cor_bnoncx_:m_Jtos_zda_
22
u_]t_hned
23
rcc_d
24
A
It u ttu: _ted
25
Q
_
pccuon
_st3:
10_dll
Th:
me_m_ for de_e_t_n$ a
T_c
LSp_cdctcrmtrcd
o3n_uc_z_
Is _
_c
fttnctt¢4a ol'thJ_ CLtsm clemcat7
n _]y
_¢uon
ladtx_e
304
_ f t_ chtu_ elm_L
- doe_ the r_ted
M_rknun
ft_ctlon
Hearln8
10/2_205
P_e3_
09307
2 A
"i've c_,tcxt I Ya l_ck_g
f_', Igat _ I_
__ U_tn_r._el't_¢_duc_tof_
4 the c_uJ,u ctaum by Lh¢ tun_ | m to C_rr_
.' uad.crst_'_d_tlt}wrca_¢wo_'r,
6 fcr d_m&
I
ta_l e'_e for de_.un?;
m other
n_ it] Ah_ claJm?
A
"13_'yarc zeclt ed, m other ¢Llum_, y_
12 Q
Okay
13 A
¥¢s, otlm; ¢]a_ln clcm_ts,
14 Q
Okay
15 ahcr_Kc
Oth_cl_um
element7
Ltm Sc0rr_L
A_yothcrcomcxtthat_uppo_.syout
op_uton?
I_ A
Wtdun the cl_med
17 Q
AllnEJu.
N_tt_u_sor_e¢CL_g,
I_
y_s _'e
G_.t t_
Wo_d
One
h_L
Iscze..
Az_d the_c ot}x_ sensors aze re.ted
_0 c_m_,
9. t 0 md I I. 1
so_mth_ly_tcm
U_.S_r_ thd _'e bew4 <f_',_u;_
9 Q
It
mc_.
*ookmg _
Af_[havctc.td
ftulcUon, no
stz_ctt.rd
10u_dtl
pOzl_Onof thu clam
1_ deraen¢ LI left,or me;_n_?
21 Q
And LI_ _hc r_¢d
22 s_.d_tu,nuned
co_d_do_
IUnCaon Is for dcteCl_r 8 a
extcra_ _0 sud app_Jaz_'t
23 A
Yc_
24 Q
.t_ wc h_vc sa_d berole, t_.m8 it out of the
Z5 oontcxt thai yot_ rcbJ upon, do¢l the trJ'_ _:
Page
3Q6
Markman
JA 0857
He<'_nag
m_
t0,'26/05
P_e3_
0gJ01
I p_s_t:_lch_
] A
11"IL_tl_q.laf¢Of_'x(_rO
$ Q
Aed _e contexl thtl yce'm Iool_nB for m _upp0n
6 o fyom" _l_e
7 A
9Q
for m fom_l_en
N¢ct _
10 _ol
3
Q
$ A
opmmn Is what'?
gl_ed
dc_'_,
I_n
_
c._l_'
¢llrn
©lc_c
s_mt¢_ Cta]rps 9. I 0 _t_l l I
m thu_ d_m ¢lcm_nt _ coo_
12 ©_u_t rncam-_xq,_cmc.
whet ec¢_ex_ do you rtly _
The underlined
text, "_elec_ve_y
r8 the _;_1 c_
7
Q
A_
9
EI2_2*_U_
Stmovct
10
Q
It
I_r_._'urc, the_h7
A_nl _tdo_Xl
12 A
Y:_.
t6 Q
And _.o_d yeJ _
w_'l
_,_ :t_; IJ_ rc_[ed
u _
.,_
AllnShL
16 A
_f'y pm'ml_tn_
_
6 mc._.,-_te_t_
_m,dy
_
_/_mll
___ =_ f_:u
fa_m_th¢_or
Q
_c_
How
M:lrlm_ln
00310
I besi_
_,_
He._nng
10/26/05
P_ge
4 ipoa
5 sm_ed fo_a=_
_
be pa_Ucuh,.-ly w¢11
ap_hcxUo_9
6 A
'T_al cs_rce_,
2_
_t=j_twe
24
Q
25
pernal and pr_.enl _e
ixed_
7 Q
X_yOu_;
8 A
A_n,
beyond chin?
al _ul Ix_nl tt depe_c_ on wh_
9 _p]_:uuonn'_dly
_
t_ _
th= yca_
_he
'i_eml_:beacbN'e_lp/peoC
4
==mp_mcs_
_'_w_ we're _i_
6
_lov_
Me.x_s
7
zcy._ _d fc_ _ scl_t_l
8
_Jd AC vult_c.
I:15xat cl_Jm ¢lc_x_t,
I_ A
Wc a_o bx'._ mcaru ,eo_cacu m_ stud nv:¢bx_8
I_; to be _u_ed
_or a seJ_
16 _ycle _d
17 Q
l!
W_
po_oa
or _h
mcam
bgf wave
th:u Llus puuc_u
The tilde rs dtrcclcd aHl_
Z0 sw_chml_ e_e,_zs Io bc aco_Ic_
=hde w=
me.ms Corcae_n8 s_ud
Aod ch_ r_t
7.3 p_ _as4 swt_mg
24 A
Q
309
wo_dd
u
=1 the ¢lmm e]em_t
LSthe sm_ctm-sl l_guage
say Ifs +m_u'xs _x" cat_utg"
AUnghL
Wodd_ou,x_thaxd_crc_t_l
in the _l_n
14 fo[k_ws
F_r c.a_sm 5 ==d _vt Lciun8 m_
Cot • =elected
a_
of c_ch half wzv_ ¢?d¢ of
t wou)d
f_ a selects1 pomon of
ot the Ipa_&uage before _z,_ ts j_t
17
A
Y_s
I$
Q
A_
19 ¢_1_l
21 e_c.!_hal f wave c-dale OCstud AC voltage.
22 Q
Page
_dc_c_
I_r_on
that 1 5arc j_t
of c_ch hab'_ve
fcs_ ts am
to be _nmtc_
_lg
o f _a_d AC
I _ vol_6e7
dm:_cd Io?
19 A
10/26/05
C,_be_.
I _ fonca¢_
15
AC vd_._e.
th.u the me:_
A
12 Q
13 o f _ms clam clrxa_--_| _ _w_tchmg m c_e'us?
Hearing
lamJ_'u_¢ m th_ ch_
Io Io_
_mon
II
I I
to a I_p
_o:c_m_nB_ds,,_t_ngme.untobo
N:_'t _de
9, 10 _
voltase
"q W_dxd_v
II
C1:_
of hght_n&
Out tcl_uvely
ofAC
the, Mr
th_ the sh'oclutxl
lO s m_p[y the wo_d "_+?
CSphase _
m_
zpphe_on
With _r_l d,mfi_un
G_u would be Irpm_ _pprop_ _Le for Cl_t xpplca['_
Q
of the art _d
numb_
Y_th-
10 _
12 The - _vOUJd you _pee with me th:u the smu:u_ral la,_,_e
that7
oft
_:u _
9
sugge_l
Out i_u_s= :_ rc_'y, vc_y
Ase that* e_her _L_ctan8
3
$
ye._
ue
_n tbe or0Jnary _E
Markmau
,_%15athcr+ ba_cd
_our v_¢w d'.at a mac wo_d
zs z pe_on
ce_l
003It
I A
_M_om
:t
0 f_tmctur_
An_ fi'_mmy
who h_ _4:_;gned qmte t I_g¢
388
m_u-7
A_d _c pow_fd
mconleXt
_2
2 Q
3 Q
I:_Vcr f_ly
lt_:d_sam
a pet_3
I'_ _ to
bm _,
Cr :tnambcr
for AC pow_" e_ol
t[u= p_z_
zI
cn of th_ ct=m ¢lm_.,._
*Jruc_ze.
Wha¢lxx,_'r_lysu_tedra_cmre
I!
_0 experience,
@_J _,_ I_
state t_t
In th_ c._e_ I'm m fe_nn_ m = mac, a
19 A
2,t lx-r'efn
_nd
Io ned Lunp =
to7
u-cll..knawn
Y_
_p_ly
n :_.cc_e
17
19 L."r_
20 A
;uSge_
15 y0u ref¢-ang
17 fir, I _ of _h.s cb, m clrn_ni
_tu,dly
h dac_ nel ".,_._: _e
14 Q
A
peru_mn_
AC vcl_¢
L_t:J_xt r¢cl_'_ _c_J C_eCl_
13 p¢_crl_]y
D
ofta_
t_
_
Cer_m m_m_ -- wdg. wmJJd you aE_cc w_fo me the.
I I the _ m,,cnf_J la.._g©
thc_'t._xGyc.%lxl_o_ldcSwSmss
Aad m eor*'_t,
6 _'_e'_u
t_the_m_ea3mmypf_noL_:msn,_
8 Io_lnng
a_.c.Jcr,/
|l'tl_ln
2
to
mtxp.s m coetcxt. I g,_c:_
d_X SUppC_
_
A
Even t_kc_ out o f C_XlrXL based un my c_
25
Q
Wh_
cxix_
fo'_
I_ fot_
cia_.
Agr_t
ts
m LF_
rCClU:d _XrCUO_7
c_ce_ _1
plussc
_LS
st_c_us_
or
(o me.
_ught _h_ be?
_L_rkm_a
JA 0858
OUl of
_
22
stt_co_'c_
310
_
21
I_f_slona_
Page
we have L_
I_uBuaB_ cxpr_ss_
24
lOr2_dOS
- Caking cv_G_mg
t_t
the_-c any _tur_J
23
Hearing
_y
20
That _ cor:c.cl.
Marl_n_u
_s thee
in t_ se-_¢
He_nng
10/26/05
Page
311
00313
I Q
00312
I A
h _&hl
be a nm_p anti compa_or
2 tos¢lc_vdyOmlrelaph,_c_gl¢.
3 c_z=ol[cr
5 Q
fcactzon
| unlc p_sc to
3 Q
L_tmc
$ Q
L_[ me r_,Lal_ IL
6 A
Y¢=h
Twoexmcq_]ea
How, t_ae's no word m here thai a_tu_ty _th_
6 m_."_t_ _ _
No
[Irmghtb_lm_o
wgh a t_mcr that gcm'n¢_
4 _xformthcsam¢
r/F_ o¢ cuclut
exprer_dy ot m a g_zcn¢ fashLo_ zs there?
? _.
No.
Q
8 Q
So Ozc_'s _o sl_ctcr_
word - exprc_
9 ,vord In b_¢ 1hat wou}d COnvey t_
T_lon_ _c underhr cd phrase I_'_
: Lm'i_,.
s_c_ua]
_z_
_ Lemaa_
stmc Lx_ethat yc_ say _S
Is "_
for a _cgzcd
IO af z.ml AC _o1_1[c ". t,d_n_ tl_
II
Thai t$ COZTCCJ_
[L l_g_zag¢ m tnOU_o f _tc._
And I f, ah_
Z_at the sZz_gtus¢ thaDs _uggcsteA
L2 ha_c u_¢d t_t
by th_ acta _at appear m thc z_catcd
13 _a_a_
12 Q
[3 to you zs _ted
14 fancbcn?
L4 _ar01y
IS A
Yea
L_ A
16 Q
$o wo_cl you a@-ee_th
I_
._
[1_ s_i._iz_r© ts m th_ dmcnptm.%
dO_ not rCC:t¢ Sufficaora sXzacrgre (O
Iv
Q
O fti_c claim?
$o you ;a'_ tz_nlg
22 I'gnctlcn - I'm j_L
_
takm$
thc cntuc cimmcd
a3qn_ m make sun: I'¢a Ck:zr
23 Q
All ngbc
24 A
From o_z_o[ cu_cu_ me._s to _ad AC volt_e
25 ofcomext
e.
thai
andl hav_ used that g'm_ up to aow
20 pcffcrm ¢aZircly the rcc_zed ftmcdon_
21 A
10/26/05
rcrocmrc7
2o s_
O f tim p_ase yoa gsr_t
21 Q
vchalsa_t_u©
2_ m _
_mdatmcd
25 Q
Hearlag
rz _
[o me.
_ Sp_afic_JiTwtalL_s_r_c_r¢
dz_n
clcmao
24 nm
o_t
or -
Markanaa
P_ge
lae.lud_a_ the aoz that _a m the phrase th_
Markman
312
Heanog
10/Z6/05
Page313
OO315
C_14
) pm_rng
Y_,
3 Q
A_jdc _r_zn c_c a_,
_._h,
_s _h_
"l_crc cs no spec__c la.n_._=
s_
p_m_ n _ [o
A[ln_'_.
Ne_
8 C[_ur_10andll
I 0 h_r.mg for _
]2 c_Y_r
I_
=l_mc_cm_
No,_¢c_mcdfu.n_ond_n_latc
ts me,ms for pro_uc_g
a _
h_,lf ",_v e of _"a_dAC vaI_e
I_ I_ci_
In r_ponse
M_ Cads_,
G_ c_mc
"I_¢r¢'s no cxpt_
rm_o_/,
$ A
T'n_
_ avc_rm
9
(2
okay
tO
A
II Is m'qgmt
a x_mp p_._
LI O
m d_ecnon of d_ zrr_
L3 A
cJazm d_a'ucnt _ol]owl_._ tbc
wh_h is 'mcaz_ °, s the _d
skq_em
or"wheg $_cp,_e
_s _hcre_
is no expI_cR s_._ cure.
And i_ impl_-_l
12 [hc_:cdatJc_o['_hc
g _o_nl _r th: _vc_
14 C_ _dof_,
Its
[tsunply
"; woaRi produce a ramp wave fomh
t_pwav_rm,
Hcrc_ch:cl,_med_ca_m
the ¢_um d_r_mt
_N_
¢say whal _ac a_cam s
IsnlLhatCO_L
If you - mcan_ foe pt oducanlga ramp wxve foera,
6 Q
6 s_u_.ctc
? Q
[( _n
JmL a m¢.a_
_ny
4 A
$ _.
a ramp waverorm
2 _'l_p¢oducc_ghaJrampwa_c_l_m
2 A
II
£ammon ofthzs clam dcmcn¢'
Whe_
ek_lz_ml oul o f conteXL m the way
19 t1_ ¢lJ_Lm¢ _'Z_
the re.tad
,l_s c_m
sufl'_.am_ stme.eum Z¢ Faxfon_
17 Q
17 iI'_xe hlk¢ h_as_
L| sci_r_ii_atyou
thai _ou a.ad [
[ ',vould d_sx_i'ee became to me. R doll re_ t_
L_ Ealz_r
mc thai if we take the -
r.Jaan cl_n_a_t ald.'J_
1_ Lh¢ _tc
t_'o, would you a_c© with mc _
doca not rca_
me.attl to
portion o f each hal f wzv¢ cTde
IO SOl_¢_{cl;[ to 7ou_
A
al the clam
lot c.lusm8 sazd [wlt_bl_l|
_m
the ac_s Lha_a,_: re_l[rd
_
ftmcban7
Butoolj_ltl_:_
A$[_aJdbCforc,
hah"
I _ wav_. ramp p,._sc, zero o'o_ Jang pomq, G'_cac _c mo_¢ Lhan
_ncUoa,
15 u 1:_or7
16 A
"r_
_s corrc_
17 Q
A_
_sth_
19 ha_¢ _d
16 Q
my s_rucr_e m th_ c1_
b'_ phr_e
17 Lbeu_
elemem
prow ou$1y which you on pomq Io Lb_l
'l_ey
_
_-o _o d_
_cy
d_at r_uR
nor_ The/_,_
_m
d_ mew_
not d_ n_=ms _df
i_ A
_ezcrocr_mm_polntoftheh_fw=vcd_snot
19 r_h
f_um_¢m_
_
"rn_Ic_mcsfrom_cACw_vcform
20 n_¢ll"
2L O
21 rcc_zt
f_c.u0_7
22 A
R.,_mp wavcf0_
23 vo_.
a r_p
_sc.
_ a _a'_lm'c,
_
uos_n_
_lf
wave of _a_dAC
haJf wa_c, zll of
2:4 _osc n'c s_z_
25 Q
Okay
Naw,_arnpwavcfom_lLsxmczns
M_r_m_n
H_rtng
10/26/05
d_n¢
G_e z_
23
s_m_l_
_hc zc_o c_c_smg
24
A
2_ again,
_
Pag©
Bul_eze_ocr_mRpoml
22
[_s _hc _
_Ln_
_phr_cd,.,_'_a_
dCL_L c_rctat
_mL
ca_smjg
JA 0859
_ 1Cs
p_nl
of _
wavc, an_
Lt t_ unphcal thaz you w_ll need c_rcm _'_ to dclea
Markmo_
314
_o_
oF the w_vc?
Hearing
10_9S
P_l_e 3LS
00316
00317
I the :z_fo cn3_$zng
polnl
2
Q
And detccuce
3
A
Y¢5
4
Q
- of the meam.
5
A
Yes
6
Q
I_
7
A
of the
_ the fmacuon
2 Q
And where
3 structure
cc_ect?
tn the mca_
that de_ects7
N:xlshdetswmdow
9
10andll
10
ask you ts th_
II
_
12
have
follows
"For ca_ng
a tim
value
13
conchtlon
14
r.aJd predetermined
said
claim
fw_t thr_hold
m the absence
and a second
of this
value
fmlct_on
vohagc
to
A
Y_
17
Q
And es the - m youx view.
18
laasuage
19
_mea_
20
$mor to the reczted
respor_
12
to dctechon
of
21
A
Yes
22
Q
I)o¢s
23
as you ha_ e j_l
24
to pefforra
25
clcma_
¢nt_ely
J_l
ftmcbc_
The: p¢_ifz'mlnnd
Bui the phrase
15
I'wstthresholdvoltage
are things
claim
the
Tneclatrnclam_forcausmgthe
voItage
I[isana_L
That _s an act, ts _! not?
Andagam.
thegmtcturelslmphc_t
21
Q
BuHfs
22
A
It*s not threctly
sum:tute
23
Q
AIInghL
claim
24
tht_ - again,
25
_xpress¢_
this aCL Is that nght?
not expected7
exp_¢d.
Andthesame
for thes¢¢ond'*alue,
It*s - the stnzctur¢
Page316
ts _ugge_Ind
Markman
00318
in
voltage
conthtlons
h I.s suggested by that aCL
10/26/05
per formed
ts - the claim dc'csn'l
h'ssuggcstndby
Hearing
Of
Ittsathmgaslsthe
A
clement,
to
10 the detcgtlO_
-- firs! thr_hold
20
ofth_
Markman
there
19 Q
of LhJs claim
it, reczte sumclcnt
the recited
value.
Q
18 m the elaboration
_pe.ars
I mca_
14
ftmcte_
w [uch
voltage
p_cdetcr_mned
that arc being
][t_a_h',actwc
first threshold
1_8u_ge
identified
no
A
foncuon?
the su_'tural
Well.
17
m¢'_$',
ofsa_d
V_U¢ In vt:spozl_
are the acts
16
the ph_e
first threshold
co.oct?
i_no_anact_
13 scco_l
to sa_d sw_or
cona,tlon.
And th_
the funcaon,
ts the st_ctm-al
the reclled
e to sasd _
Q
-
m the abeen¢c
the second
what
r_po_tseve
there?
threshold
a first value
II A
of thn_ claxm elcmenl?
16
that pes forr_
condlllor_
10
conthtlon"
Is that the tcc_tcd
7
9
clement
of sa_d p:ed_ermmed
m response
We thseu_
have
language,
"mear_
Is the structure
8 said _cdclctmencd
I'rngomglo
ftmcllon
ts the st_ci_al
th_ phrase
what
6
compara_,Chaws
Thlststbeundcrlmedpo_n
the reclled
does
4 means",
5 A
not Lbe swactwe
AllnghL
15
Yes
-
Yes
S Q
I A
.save
bul not
Ilearing
10/26105
Page
317
_)319
I A
It ts sugg_tnd
2 Q
All nghL
3 agree
bul not expected
So wtththal
w_th me that m - oul o f contCXl,
4
and I have
$
d_
6
m:ltcd
7
A
8
_ffi_¢_
reed
that ph_c
pv.-vlo_ly,
not recite su ffifacnt
function
Aga_
su'_tmc
of the clarm
si_cunr.
9
SUeCtmeS
Q
F¢_ the way
II
A
Th_
ts c_¢cx
12
Q
The
next clam
13
Th_
14
tcspcms_,
i5
the ffe_ce
function7
that you
3
A
Y_.
it does
dcmcm
4
Q
And
wou]dyou,
e_alrely
the
5 exphclt
_n yore
6 A
_1do¢_
II $ugge_t_
Yes
dram element
_.s you have
nuraerc_
B clear
elm.'hi
r_
as foilov,
e to hght external
what
_; the m-A_lmed
t 8
_
_m
IAght
spparatm;',
13
suffic;cnt
s_tmc
14
ftmcUon,
conect7
15
A
16
w_thm co_tcxt,
17
Q
18
dcteClCh'_ml_y,
19
follows
_
20
hghl
sensing
m th_s
21
have
a third
22
vaJues
._a_mg
mea_
fo_ dclccung
19
A
Thal ts corre_L
20
Q
And
21
lx_t
22
d_m
23
to IigS_ _t¢_
thai _
d_mcnt,
is the pbea_
to s_d
24
A
Thai ts CO.eeL
25
Q
Now,
tends.
of dayhght"
the structme
m this dram
fur, cumin of th_s dam_
which
m the ahao_
doer
12
II
¢l_mcnl
"for detecung
Am
- tha_ you beheve
exphctlly
present
hgh! _mg
avp_r_s,
that s e_ra_
Markman
the
I correct7
me_
r¢_port_l_ e
c_-re_t?
l_gua_e
seining
c_t,_a
Ilearing
10/26/05
Page
318
chain
25
voltage
t_cd
wbe'_
to hght
m yota" view,
out of contexl,
the phr_c
external
to sa_d
do¢_ nol r¢ote
cntzrcly
aga_
the recited
the answer
i$ no,
tha answ c:ris yc_
Ncxttswhatyouha_clabelcddayilght
ClaJrnll
mcans
means
vld_
f_
Tht_chamelementtsas
including
causing
dtfferent
stud hght seeing
that - ! gatheL
el_nent
to have
is the phrase
a third
value
means
s_d
responsevc
threshold
to sa_d
voha_e
to
from sa_d first and second
means
the recited
_ dclectmg
funcuon
dayhght
of this
"for cau.s mg sa_d th_hold
deffcrent
Markman
JA 0860
bc fo_c, :t _ vc_'
U'_at phrase" carhcr,
responsive
to perform
C_cu_l
Now,
read
of thts es
I gather,
Allnsht
24
ci_-m_
meam
Taken
23
Andthlses
Bt_take_OUlOfCOntexlmthes_se
and ] _vc
"hght
of dayhSh_
the tecttnd
I7
elemenl,
s
claim
AIInght,
IO that you
explam?
right7
the su'aci_c
II
Oaun
to f.a_d sppara_ts
and _
I gatbe_
t_ pholoCefi,
Jl_
the recited
Wbe_takenmthecontextofthxsftmctlon
7 and aIl the oth_
described
ent_dy
pTeasc,
view,
nc4 rex:ire
9 Q
that -
to per form
th_s clana
clCmml_
In contcxl,
structure
2
m the way
to perf_
tad_en oul of context'
10
t 6
I sufficient
unde_tandmg.wouldyou
from saJd flrsl and
Ileartng
10/26/05
Page
319
OO321
00320
I second values when
2 dayhf)at"
Am
s_d |igh[sen_ng
I sa_d £rrst _nd
rneartsisd¢leclmg
I c_r_eclo
3 A
Y_
4 Q
And I galher thatthe smm'ural p_llon
$ c[aun ¢lemem
tsthe phrase "m_ns
Cn_'u![_
irtclud]n
8 me.m_
r_po_slv e Io hgh[
yes
Andlhngc_ngloaSky0uadlffcrenlquesthon
]0 think I sc-Iop th_ _mry
II
Assume
A
Yes
Q
And
respoo_vc
including,and s_ns
Hc_e'sthcclalmclemcrtt
yr_
Iapologtz¢
12
r¢_ponswe
13
threshold
]4
first
15
detecllng
t6 stud firsland second vaioes when
]g
elemen_
}7
A
18
shd_
19
Q
20
"clrcmt
s_d hghl senslng mezas
A.ss_th_'stbe¢laJme]emrm,
18
pl_
19
A
20
the -
2l
Q
_L
2]
22
A
Okay
22
23
Q
And _at Lt_ --m th_ conlex[ or m thatclaTm
24
¢}¢racat,
25
sa_d
Okay
ttts
Sowe_remsurmngthatltlsdlfrerentthan
the subset
_
of the rex1 that L_ht-re'_
O_r rcc_ zrd funcUoa
tlaesho|d
_ oLUtge to have
_s _be cla_e
a thsrd vaSue
Markman
for cav_mg
dlff_cnl
Heanng
from
10,'26105
Page
to starl ov_
[hal the claim
¢[_Taent
lth
again
Mr
to sa_d [Lght sensing
voltage
'. alucs
dayhgh_
th_s _
Thal'sngh_
for causing
said
hghl
se_mg
sa_d
from sa_d
m c:_'_ ts
that thai is the c[,_m
_ s_bs_J
of whal
_
on the
[l'5¢-._r_'thmgafl_'thaphrase
mcar_
With
'7.hen
Let's assume
agaJn,
mcluchng"
tha_ _nderslandm
thai clam
mean_
to ha_ c a t_trd _ a]ue dJ ff_ent
and Second
$o
IS as fo]lo'._ S M_
citroen!
23
_c*hage
to have
24
s_cond
; alaes
25
dayhghl',
8
the rccm'd
_ the phrase
a third
_ aluc d_ffe_ent
,,_}3 cn _d
]_ht
funcllon
"for causing
from
5cn.sl_
of
sa_d threshold
stud fi_t
means
and
_; deleclmg
correc_
Marlonan
Yes
1 are structural
And the sm_:tural
the f_ll_
Me_x_
poruon
of _tat
t'cspon_ve
claim
to said hght
clement
_s
setting
4 _?
5
A
Yes
6
Q
Would
7
A
Y¢_
g Q
9
elcraenl
_
Ileanng
10/26/05
Page
321
Page
323
OO323
A
2 Q
3
I'm going
320
00322
I
of thai claim
col_cc[
metes
of that
Ihavego_edownthewrongw_ckv,
c]emenl
As_m'nc
means for causing
_7 isdei_t_gday}_!
"means",
scnstng
f_mct]on
Caxlson
15 stud threshold voltage to have a thrrd• alue dlffe_en_from
14 Me.ans responsr,e to sa3d hght se_smg
_ the -- the rcma_nd_
8
]]
_ _th
v, hen sa_d hgh_
ls that the rec=ted
th_ v.ord
7 A
10
clcrncal ts_; follov,s It
Allngh[
is s_mply
Q
_ alucs
dayhght
9 th_$ claim
I
m_operly
03aI the clam
!2 begins afterthe clrcml mem'_
13 the means
c}a_m _]cmenl'_
5
8 ser_smg mcm_
9 Q
3
responsl_ c lo sa_d hght
6 sensing means?
7 A
is dclcctmg
4
o f lh_s
second
2
you
Now,
element
10
does
sup_
Do¢_
11
'_¢][e
12
fintcUo_?
agree
valh
that_
tha_ structural
the recited
potion
thai stractm_l
porhon
of 01¢ claim
SUf{'tClelll SII_CtUr¢ to perform
Taken
of the claim
- w_ Ih4:h-aw
In the comexl
entirely
13
A
14
say
of Lhe _ hale
I_
Q
Out
16
A
l v_ould
17
Q
Okay
18
the _ are the ac_
that appem" I_ the recllcd
_9
th_'_
c,_r_ec_
20
A
yc_
21
Q
As v,¢n
22
acts or the recs_d
23
c_m
24
A
25
voltag_andhavmgthlrd_aluesthat
elemen[
patcnL
I would
_,¢s
of context,
as we've
u.sed that
term_
than say _
Andthecontexttha*you'rc;cly_ngupon_s
uaderJmed,
_.s th_ngs
that rmght
function
ha sW_gcsted
fun_t_ on b_t are not exphclt
by those
tr* tha
"_
Thallscorrect
Bu_wealsoUtlkabout
threshold
ared]ffc_t
Markman
Ileanng
3
Q
4
uhal make
5
A
O_r _mgs
6
Q
Whal's
7
and what
8
A
9
dctect=ng
m the[e,
actual
And they
_
are the thm_
the r¢cttcd
JA 0861
that are
that a_e caoscd
_ha_ c._usc
_
ar_
an exampleofthe
ts the thmg
Well
larter'_
that caused
fo_ example,
dayhght,
then
by the a_ts
functlon_
V.rhat tS the act,
the act_
the sa_d tight
that wtll
cause
scrmn_
mca_s
the threshold
Io 13¢dtffercnt
Q
AsIundc_ztandlt
13
n:spoo_lve
14
s¢_ang
I_
element,
16
A
No
17
Q
Sowlthlhat
18
v.lth
to hghl
means
_n'l
hghIs_lngmeans
sensing
means
th_ _o_ct_re
tsthe
II s not -- the hght
i_elfoftht$
claim
con-ect'7
thattscon'¢ct
me that
Yes
undersla_&ng
m -
) 9 slrt_rur_
]a_g_e
ol'I_s
20
sufficlenl
structure
tc* perform
21
fu.nc_l on'_
22
A
23
_ecl[e
24
Q
Y¢s,
oulofcontext,
suft3c_ert_
Bless_lly,
_ould
otR o f con_'_t,
as you
claim
yes
you
then agree
ose thai ienn
_len'_'nt
entirely
does
the
t_c_ recite
{he rcc:_¢d
In cont_xl,
*[ does
slJuclt_c
we are at the end
of this
(Laughter)
Markman
Page322
thmgs
m thai phrase
II
25
There
10/26/05
dcy_-nbed
I 0 voltage
the rcctted
¢lemcnt_
2
Hearing
10/26/05
00324
00325
I
MR
2
adaffelrat
3
COOK
tOplCWlthMr
THE
4
A]irlght
exa.mlnatlon
Carlson
COURT
wdl
rmaboutton_vemto
How
be, Mr
mtw.h tongrt
MR
COOK
Probably
another
6
THE
COURT
7
MR
COOK
8
THE
COURT
10
MR
COOK
II
THE
COURT
- anoth¢_
12
MR
HIGGINS
Excuse
Why don'l
why
Mr Cook,
14
15
but let me make
sine
afternoon,
Good
afternoon
9
I'm going
16
MR
HIGGINS
17
MR
COOK
I $ I behev©
19
ntmut_,
20
21
Mr
St_¢
No,
ofspeclficclrcu_ts
11
to tree
Honor
13
Yot_
Hoam
THE
COURT
it again.
15
jUSllctusknow
"._dl go Io_8¢t
You Wahl
to have
than
lunch,
(Laugbr_')
23
THE COURT
24
MR
I can scc nght tbrouf, h you
I dll_'l
COOK
thltL_
The
please
I wa_ thai
Ileal'lug
10/26/05
Cook?
ratho"
v. mdow
COURT
COOK
than
BYMR
Q
T_s
21
A
Is this
DF_A's
Icchnology,
in yota" bmd_
l_e
you
comparatot
so I'm
now ratber
to look at Is
chagram7
In hts rc'p_rl_
I'm goms
a different
20
a couple
on the screen
MR
19
aboul
wcd¢cldedthalwcwdlbeabl¢
to ask - I'll starl the
way
COOl(
ts zn tab 49 '_
figure
2A
22
THE COURT
23
MR
Massc'ngllrs
and 2B_
_s it 2A
COOl(
No,
and
2B or sore©thing
¢ls¢ "_
tbrs_stab49wh_ch_sDr
comparison
THE
COURT
So_¢syot_experfsskelcS_
Page324
Markman
00326
Hearing
10/26/05
Page325
00327
I
MR. COOK
2
THE COURT
3
THE
4 BY
MR.
That's
And
WITNESS
I
thafs
2
49
Forly-nmc
And what
6
window
compatator
7
_cur_e
b' charac term:d
I wznu:_cl you to do ts just
&agsam
JtL_l tO make
yc_r
check
sure
your
by thls pamcutax
the
charn
¢leraenf?
IO A
COURT
MR
COOl(
No,
Th_e
Okay
Youaresaymstha_youpulabluehne
arotmd
tbe hax
became
12
Q
13
A
- _nung
14
Q
I hay© taken
15
identdled
and tben w_lspo6ed
16
pul a bluc
hag on
17
overall
18
A
Okay
19
Q
I would
20
blue hne
21
A
22
0ae anode
and the _
23
togcth_
Ican'treaTlysee
24
including
it, hat Jl's a httlc
25
a,re
On yot_,
thuds
6
THE
COURT
7
MR
COOK
8
T}IE
COURT
II
yr_, str
12
dial catcuzt clcracnt
that you
it m figm'_
2A and 2B and
tt so v,¢ can see 11 m the conteXl
cErctuz dlagr_
here
As Ion8
jest
t_e
you to Salts fy yourself
on thts chart ts exactly
_s you are m¢ludmg
that tha
the unnanmi
&od_
node
o-
conn¢cl
llloo_hkeyoua_e
hard for me to _
Markman
ileanng
tfyou
10/26/05
Page326
Mr
-- no, rm
THI_. WITNESS
to
on -one,
G
for ca_mg
rmsorry
m
Ihresho_d
l'mona-says
one.
going.
Okay
Look
at Ihe nghl
hatlom
and you
Yousc_:tbeleltcTsmtheetrcl¢_
17
THE
WITNESS
18
TIlE
CQURT
Thank
THEWITNI_;S
20
BY
21
Q
22
selcctlon
23
Clam3 e]ernenl
24
_ntl_e CU'CUIL Thafs
25
drawing.
you,
Your
Honor
Okay
Okay
Thc_'e_cgo
MR_ COOK
I jU_l want
of the
io ask you sorae
w_ndow
And
] want
why
questions
compatalo_
block
aboul
used
your
fo_ thts parucu)at
to pul 1l m the context
I have
Markman
JA 0862
Iow_
Carlson_
Keep
THE COURT
wdlsceG
"Mcaas
on the _rong
THE COURT
19
-
of the rectlfi_
cornet7
14
16
you see tbe code
Are you on the _ght
13
15
of tha
ll'sG,
and you go down
Okay
THEW1TNESS
sertsog
It's not the
dusg_-sdown
ate codes,
Do
lO tohavc"l_altbelop,
no blue Ime beT¢ m my _
0tts is?
G
9 Ih© lOWer nghtohand
II
What page
of Exhlbt t 49
nghlhandcoraer
Number
that we
- put a blue hne arotmd
thai you say ts s_
THE
top page
3
4
Q
S ctrctul
co¢_eCl
COOK
5
9
things
THE
25
Markman
are m
Carlson
to dtagTams
17
24
Mr
firsI o11¢ that I would
go to your
8 questzon
don'l you,
hrr¢
16
15
Cook7
22
We
a_k you qtt_Uoz_
And
IO be tcfemng
than pulling
14
Mf
Io now
the EI,MO
12 going
lwdlbeusmgtlusfot--and
th_ my ex,_nmat3on
Q
l0
IthJnkldo.
] dOa'l ,.van I to t_c
Okay
Good
15 rmnutes7
LelraejUSlChaCk
Wdll
be back at I 00
COOK
8 A
Goabead,_d]n,ght
COOK
MR
? Q
doyouwaaltousthschlcthatporaonof-MR
THECOURT
6 B'r
ahaad-
13
(Break)
5
don*l you go
me, Your
youwetevctyl_al_patt_l
So we'll
4
15 minutes
you go ahr.ad7
I'm saying
for lunch
3 _c'c_
da you thlnk your
I'll wail
No,
THECOURT
2 break
Cook7
5
9
I
W¢canConllnUe?
of the
this par_lcula_
Itearmg
10/26/05
Page
327
00328
0_329
I
We've
oltllm_d
2 elcmr:m m blue,
_
3 A
Y_
4 Q
PTofessot
5 ted
_ hal you% c $¢Ict't_d
[hal's the window
Masscngdl's
I'm not going
tO _k
for thkc s:JaJm
J O
Yes
2
A
Yes
3
Q
Yes,
4
the threshold
compardt or
selecuon
you about
of cttcmlr/Is
in
that, just about the
THE COURT
8 BY _LR
COOK
9 Q
The c_tson
10 pm_on
So what's
t_: _u_stlon_
_s, the -- you scc the claim
of the clam_ element
a fn'st value
12 Rnd a se_:ond valt_
that talks about
m r es_rt._:
condmon
14 have thee
the - ha_,ng
fret
condltlOn
to det ecOc_ of sa_d
ca_slng
the 0ors_/d
_nd second valu_
_ olt_
t0
do you that, Mr
15 Cal Ls_n7
16 A
Yes
17 Q
Ar_l
does the _ indow
compar_x
ha_ e tl_ -÷ came
b'_e_hold • olUlg_ to have first and secmxh
19 A
No, the window
20Q
T_
thr_bold
compar_or
_olive
a]u_¢
does not
,s d_wa
al node
6L
_s iI
nol?
22 A
Yes, tits
23
m2p v,_
24
Q
It_
r_orted,
Now,
th_s,._thcv*rongblt
I bch_,c
,s what happened
All nghl
2_A
And
Yes,
lseethe61
8
And
so yot_
Q
_ a]ues
arc
my pen. corrcc¢
Thafs
lO and I I
10/26105
comparator
ts not the
l0
A
NO
thal'scorrect
I I
error
And
m tlus pa_i_cula_
clrcmt
12
Q
be-
14
and absence
]5
correCl_
16
A
That
ts cot_ecL
17
Q
And
v, hat are those
18
clalm_
19
A
The
prcdetermmcd
20
ourpu;
Of the pbotoceJL
2}
wiU_ln-
22
coming
23
node
claim
of predetermined
element
paste
_s supposed
conditions
Isn't
predetermined
conchttorts
wh)cb
to
that
condlllOt_
IB this
m thts claim
are the
Should bc included
aClt_ly
it'sd_fficuhlose¢,bulyoucanseeahne
down
from
between
the photocell
then the
other
through
ou_ 57 mto
coupled
and feeding
rain an unnamed
tv*o reslslors
ts the output
Page328
of the on
timer
IC3A
Markman
00330
this clalm'_
was a cut and
iI'scfcatlngfl'*ose_a/ucsmrcspor_etothcpresence
And
_
-- the _ mduw
that satasfied
That
13
25
Hearlng
yes
window
9 comparalOr
24
m CI2_s
Markman
I|eanng
10/26/05
Page
329
Page
331
00331
I Q
I Q I Q2 through
the detector
2 comparator
and
the pMsc
on up through the pulse co_ml of
3 A
dayhght
inthe cncmt of those blocks,
4
And flm_scm'e alldowr_slx_tm, if you will, from tbc
2 blocks of effc_m/he:re thaibcgm
3 QI and Q2
4 51
and commmng
They me dowmtrc_
with the --starlinglu
5 cortc_
6 right
I think v,e would ha_ e IO be fairlycareful about
7 dcfunng
what we mean
All right
9 A
Thcyarewhe_ethcyateo_thecucmt
Sine thai u:ps_cam
a_d dov, mstre.am
11
¢Ju_ drawing,
12
Q
13
drtecuon
14
and tmt_l to the - U_UI tl _uses
9
l'mnol
makes
a lot o f scm<e m
l*m simply
of prupaga_n
Upslream
rcfcmng
of the signal
f_n
the bmp
to the
the
PIRs
through
to go on
v. otdd b¢ Q I and Q2, ar, d dowmctream
proceeding
would
thal poml for_ ard
from
you agree
that
16
A
Block
17
Q
And
Wtth
]_lme7
I thoughl
20
c_3fmed
me.. Can v.ejustsay
21
BY
22
Q
THECOURT
23
and thenyou
Q
Would
25 nght,
appea_
you
wflh
on the drawmg'_
the
QI andQ2'_
There -_c go
agree
to the nghl,
that
th_
mlubLt block
control
And
to the
stgnahhat
to the stgnal
dtscttsslng
ctrcmtrY
ts
the
turn
tilts ts all to the
emerges
from
the output
that emerges
from
the
the da_ hght
detect
the
and
or'the on-{trner
the on-ttmet
t_ block
52 _
ts jttsl IO the
}e fto f pulse
52 ts the
block
l_t
on
it _c,cct_ es the output
count
oulput,
the top to the nghL
of the pulse
count,
receal.cs
the output
A
ofthewmdowcomparatot
21
s'Attch,
22
Q
Swttch
53 ts m the tc*tlmony
23
A
Pardon
me,
elernent
_s to the
24
Q
thai g_
from
25
then
10/26/05
the wmd0v*
-- for example
20
claim
Hearing
reset
from
[9
of the slgn_
Mark.man
and
18 correct_
COOK
tonght
RsghL
'_
19
ftomlcfl
And
A
Which
Can we use Ic_ right,up am/dov* n,bccattse you
Proceeding
Q
13
correct
A
leR or nght
12
Q
18
I knewv.haUtmeam
tt's from
15
thai ..
amplifier
tl not?
I f you're
14
_lldmg,
does
h r_sponds
on-hmcr
the
and Q2
cotmtcr
A
and
down
And iI rc_-ponds
"._otdd
17 und_s
ttwn-on
of Q!
Q
[ [ restt,
fra_tikIy
By "dowr_U'e_"
MR-
I0
and
and
and
countc¢
detect
to the right
8 ptdsc
l0
16 [_ _. etyllurlg
7
by "downsueam"
8 Q
15
The
located
5 on-Umer
6 A
24
threshold
_,lth
ts v,hcrc I pomled
7 A
- the
m the absence of S._ud predetermined
13 predet_
21
second
6 node-
7
18 t_
Thcnode61,_hlchts_hetc
- first and
5 ocommg,
6 blue
II
that'scor_cct
Page330
As thts
switch
ts drawn,
_3
It delz'ndsontheposmonofthe
I thrnk
ycah,
I f you pul thts
tt would
d_-nd
it actually
It is
Swllch
mto
on the
oulpul
Markman
JA
,863
--
ycah
the operating
of the
pulse
llearlng
mode
counter,
10/26/05
OO332
I correct7
00333
I
2 A
In opovatmg mode, [[would, yes
3 Q
Now.
4 A
You would hke me
5 Q
6 A
7 Q
Yeah, tfyou ha_ e the patem handy_
8 A
I dohavcthepatonL
wouldyoulook
zt C[alm l,pt_E
)
g_ c me a hne nttmbc_" on thaf I
AIInght
I sh_l
THE
COURT
4
THE
WITNESS
Thls would be m the patrol
5
THE
COURT
Yes
6 thai
7
MR
COOK
8
THE
WITNESS
I0
to look m the patent_
Maylputthtsbmdcx_ide?
THE
Ifs ;nobablyeas_er focme
9
BY MP.
10
Q
II
controlmearts,
_
COURT
Arc wc going to be refernng ba_k
II to tab 497
12
MR.
13
THEWITNESS
14 BY
Can you
3
9 than raanzpohang
MR.
15 Q
A
2 Q
COOK
We
Allnght
12 contzol
Okay
13
means
14
$c_Lgor means
COOK
We're going tobe n:fmmg
to &agtam
15 hghl
A and tab
the last paragraph
Well
It acWally
17 the absf;lce
ltappoarsa133
ovcrnde
Itbegtns,
including
sclcctr_cly
overriding
by manual
means
stud first
actuatmn
to cause
me'A_
_ccon_
Okay
Now,
20
the manual
21
58.
22
correct7
22 the _ how does the manual overnde
23
A
23
lower
_
m _
b[c_k
right*hand
down
cornet
here at the block
of the clrcug
And
m Clalm I th_¢ts
h'_ manual overnde.
actaose thai talksaboul
Hearing
10/26/05
The overnthng
of--
the first and second
24
25
Page
to ernn
sa_d lamp
_
m_._
m
pfe_t_mlned
h_
I_en
the $c]@CllVC OVL_th
scrtsor
In other woi'd$,
A[ wh_tt pOint does
how d_
figof
th21 occu_ m
o_erode
the stgnal
flora
m_7
where
do_
11o_-ral_
332
it cut into the Clrgtltl'/
Oil thC ClgCUl[?
Markman
00334
tlearmg
10/26/05
Page
333
00335
RIsht,
I A
nghl
Ctasmbyfc_cmgtbe-cxcttscm¢,
I
procc_s_
2 the - the fl_'_hold voltag© to be - al node 61 to be
2
A
3
3
[he nghl
th_ven
to a low
level
so that th© hght
4 lev_ of dlmnmaa_,
5
And
at the same
6 photocell
mpol
to e_c'nth_]y
7 II doesn't
matlcl" whcthe1"
8
mdark.
9
Q
I0
the .scns_rs?
11
A
12
wholcthmg
13
ovemde
14
b_u:k and f_rce
15
4
ume
thai achtm
be Ignored
the [tholo
caus_
the
5
at that poml
sa_f
IS set'rag
v.he*e
does
it intersect
signal
co."nmg
9
the swRch
Ildo_ttat
thcoutput
ctrcml blOCk
the
There's
outpul
from
17
not rcaJ]y
18
Q
19
block
WK_block7
20
A
Comes
21
block
22
Q
Block
23
A
Yes,
ye_
24
Q
And
d_tt _,
25
raVeL
of the -- that r_trre
describe
thl_
II
oftbemam._al
no named
b,3ck zrotmd
a coemeclr
s'me how to describe
Lees
b;tck through
node
that comes
[t v.lth
who-re
reference
and forces
tm coming
tt comes
down
from
52,
m tbe f_ nghl-h.and
af#m.
MR
COOK
Yore" Honor,
may
I object
to thts
ovemde,
ts a clmm
term that's not m
hearing
Can you
tell me _
YOU have
The
Ye_,Yota'Hottor
_'cpond
bn
15
that the m_ual
18
pm'p_c
of
n0t )_l
Ti_¢clatm
on the
clam11L_cl
f but on
a_e structum_.
heard
same
DESA
talk abom
- by the _amc
token,
opor_t_
ovcmde
MR
wtth_aw
CIRtm
upon
12 qmtc
I, and the
Clann
the signal
a
way
from
_c
couat
THECOURT
20
ahead
21
BYMR
22
Q
23
,fs opo-ratmg
a]? of the
_l_Cllon
t_
25
all the
Page
334
Okay
AIInghL
signal
way
m_mual
on a signal
proee_mg
up U'_ough
ovcmde
1864
Thankyou
OPO_
thai ha.s ah_..ady
blocks
43, 46,
47,
Markman
JA
I*[I
Go
COOK
So v_bea the
24
10/26/05
thai cxpl_latton.
With
I_GGINS
my ob_¢cbon
nghl,
Ilearmg
COURT
14
m thc lctl or to thc
Markman
'DIE
other clarr_
17
side?
creamy
to
WcaretalkmgabeulmanuaJ
mter_-etatlon$
19
the ptdsc
circta_,
-. rm
to a p_-Ucula_
out of the turn on-tu_no" and
control
tlus7
13
tbe
of all the
Q2, ye*
fm this Mafl_n
t2 how
to z_ro
it aL_o corm_
mlo z=o
Iogm
and
to my under_tandlng
7 d_putc
frown
coming out of --
MP_ HIGGINS
l0
rm following
chain
the
of QI
Im¢orqu_t_ons?
6 which
hght
the signal
It _s to the right
8
And
And then
resel
ts on at z_ second
o_ bright
then
16
overnde
21 the llrsl and second $_-'nsor m_¢ls,
Do you see the phrase thaibegins --
Markman
said rnanu_
lamp
|eleClC_.
20
thagram.
Yes
24 Q
25
ovcmde
m the
aJ_
sam
for thsabhng
Q
o_ crnde
sa_d manual
131_eterfi3 tnallon
A
I 8 con&tlon
Stud
manual
and second
of fllummaUon,
including
ofsatd
actuable
19
19
sa]d
llsays
is
the dmgramhci'e,
abo_ e
Y_.
al sa_d second level
16
ofall.m
I
Yca_
for selccl_v¢ly
17 thaz e0dffmt
I -ftrst
appoars
andrllrcadthtsbrtcfly
means
16 49, wlach Ffl put on _e screen, the tintoae m the - m
Claim
o f Cla_m
Yes
COOK
zre going to refer io tab 49
Galso7
37,
on someffang,
IraSsed
through
f_om -- sh'tr_ng
with
48.
poise
and 51,
Heanng
the
10/26/05
QI
Page
335
OO337
00336
I counte_,
2
A
correct?
It's o_ratm8
on a s,gn_
3 _11Lh©comrollo_cblocks
4 i_sc
that's
p_._ed
to thcn_t
of Ql
1
nmnberofd_ffetempomtsmthcclrc_uL
through
2
chosc_
up
3
s¢clzon,
4
T_ere
are
5
been
placed
6
Q
to the
r.ountblock
5
THE
6
Up to Or past the pulse coum_'
COURT
THEWITNF_S
cotmt
Notp,_t
7
pulse
- in one
case tl's
8
and m the other ca_e,
9
blOCk
10
Q
II
th_s red block
J2
A
[Cs co_
13
Q
Andlt'snotoperatmg&recdy
14
A
No
15
O
So wc_d
16
C']a_m I _
upto
lt'smthe
In the pulse cOtmt block,
o_
ctrcml
the slg_l
thai come_
&agr_r_
on thts chagTam,
wlthm
thai the se_or
memos1
19
contorted
20
s181_l
pc_cessmg
21
A
l otm_plelety
22
Q
The -
23
o_ ¢J_de
24
on QI,
Q2"_
25
A
The w_'_ttal
in th_
large
on QI
wlth
-- ,xlth
17 zs corP_slwlth the pc6]lJ_n
Ig
rod block,
v, htch
tzp to node
wRh
of Clalm
1
taking,_.hJch
for delecong
thsz_"e¢
ks oIx'ratn _
rne that m that scas¢,
the rnem_
and that's d_sp_te
ts a_
motion.
Is
all the
include_
A'_
thaL
the fact
on the output
that
ofthe
o_ c_mde coulcl
the manual
ted block
bc chosc_
Markman
and not
to operate
tleanng
al a
10/26/05
Page
a n_3er
of places
fi_at _"='_ua)
o_ en,?de
into
the ctrcutt
don'l
disagree
It Is opera_ng
113the pro fcrce_
Io pe_ form
v, ith that, but
on signals
10 Q
It's not gomgback
II
No
ha_ e
I'm
of the red b]ock_*
m the red block,
It is doing
and
co_Jd
the fimcUon
on the output
embodlmeflt,
does
yes,
thai, yes
operaung
on QI
and
Q_
tlLsno[
No_,
as [ understand
13
predetermined
condition,
14
motion
15
Q2,
16
A
LctmercadCImm6,
17
means
for dclecIing
18
to stud
apparatus,
19
motion
relalr_ ¢ to said
20
objcct
separate
21
Q
And
22
that motion
ts predetermined
23
A
Can
y_
24
Q
Predetermined
25
someone
of a person
pIRs
tt, the
dc flnllton
you undo_md
or objccl
of first
tilts to _fer
that's sensed
by
the
orpartoftt
Ftrs[scr,
D'ed¢lo'32Rne_
ct_tht,ort
Io the
- by Ql,
conec(_
a fi_t
sa_d first predetcrmmcd
from
fu'_t sclLsor
satd
(_ltng
means
wtthout
bcmg
of a person
regard
mOhon
m
Rap_
Io whefi_'r
or _t
corr¢ct'_
predc_c'_nmcd
v. ould
Mr
c_xttoy_
conthnon
apparatus
that's moUon
define
sor
motion
be the type
to deslg_
'7
of motion
a mollon
Markman
that
a --
6_le¢lton
Itearmg
10/26/05
Page
OO339
I sectary
hght
I_c
f_r them
to de_t:t
_ ould
2
w_'d
3
a pn:_¢lected
c_tena
4
A
_ no mention
5
_)g't:t_o_
Tt_r_
specify
c:_ _xhat_t.
for the
$_|t'ct w_
thai we
for example,
v*anl IO that
would
"_
c:2 te't_
_
And a_ a resuh,
_egatd$
fl_c mo_o_
to prede_'muned
the mte_pretamm
-- thai first
9 ts without
regard
10
par_culax
type of morton,
II
A
Noneofthosewordsarcmtheclazm
12
stands
alone
[3
Q
D_;p_te
14
m the clarm?
15
A
The
_
thai
of
m
correc
you ha_ e
pre_terrnmed
to _my pre_elecuon
MR
COURT
con&tlon
Ha_e
5 yot_'_')
f that the b)u_
yo_
prcdetemananon
of a
f_
Thecla_m
t_
fact
tha_ the word
pr_'rrmned
THE COLrRT
17
THE
18
THECOURT
WITNESS
conthtt_
"p_edetermmed"
_
ks
THE
WITNESS
Do yoa
have
Segsmg
Now,
t 7
A
The
18
wofkmg
19
ea_es
I_ofa
20
R_ght but an obJeCt ,s -
21
Prctlymuch
C4
please?
Markman
Heanng
10/26/05
Page
338
does
from
mcans
change
thro_
the C_yhght
t_
threshold
for -on
detect
to said
hght
_ aluc to ha_ ¢ a
first and second
ts detecting
_ a|ucs
when
dayhght
that you mctuded
m hcrc
a third _u_
m the hght
falhng
detect
on the photocell
_qd
reset cmrcmu3,
Io ha_ e a thtrd _ alue
HIGGINS
Excuseme
Whalexhtbltare_¢
on, please _
THE
COURT
23
MR
COOK
24
MR
ItlGGINS
C4
Sel49
ItsthagramC4
ldon'tha_cExhthtt49mo_
book
Markman
JA 0865
t_')eCled
rc_por_l_c
said
the dayhghl
the threshold
MR
means
the pholocell
to have
22
25
ofyou_
wm_t to sat,sly
h_vc
to the cla3m e]emenl
fled it _
for causing
sensing
o_ object
_fyou
accorthngtotheclatm,_tsaysthat
tnchtdcs
_ a/uc _ fl'erent
hght
Ofperum
It'snc4al]mottc_
Now,
means
a -thts
wouldyoutm'ntothcthagrara,
that m front
12
third
Okay
¢ausc
COOK
Now,
the ClrCml means
16
everything t_m_ ob3ect,really
24 Q
Q
stud
Now,
I ] '7
10
14
thaf_
coffect
I I
or object'_
21 people are objccts th_soxpmanobjcct
MR.
That's
Of a pc_on
19 pcsstm or object
20
at Clmm
13
thal'_
)lne _ _ hal you
You ha_ c identl
8 ctrcmt
15
mou on
found
thai corresponds
9
A
found
Ithd. Thaakyou
Yes
COOK
4 Q
7 thks page
tt ts
16
23 BY
TtlEWITNESS
6 as thc clrcUlUy
7 Q
$ gqv_
THE
2
BY
of any sort
Ha_ c )ou
I
circuit
or _ggc_Uon
6 Cimm6
25
it really
336
00338
22
in fact *t what
$ A
A
angle
_.htch
I certainly
12 Q
mQ2,
that unders_n&ng
thai F_,tL _
leading
correcf_
the red block, yes
you a_ee
cor_tem
out o f
m the phase
fo_ example
thai Ifs operating
9
hcouldbe
all the v, ay down
7 saying
it's
m the turn on Utter mh_blt
So n's ov_'mdmg
Io operale
Ilearmg
10/26/05
Page339
337
00340
0034 l
I
DR
2 under
CARNAL
Thete*s
It's
I offmspaccccrl_nly"
B
THECOURV
_bal
theycommuc
on into thcothcr
2 ctrcmtly and {he phase angle sect|onof the mail
3
4
_m A and B tab
There'slettets
they are dora8
S
ldon'lknow
3 Q
in theT¢ but -
MP_HIGGINS
Veryw¢ll
BYMR.
7
Q
Woulthl't
8
vafo_
to ex_17
9
A
When
)otl
say "th_
I0
Q
Tht$ clalm
clcmcm7
II
A
- ate you speaking
of ClaJm
12
Q
Thk* claim
thet's on C4
13
A
Yes.
14
Q
Okay
15
dayhght
16
It to the left-hand
17
A
Two
18
Q
h has two Ime_
Y_;
Okay
THE
COURT
5
MR
HIGGINS
lhevettnow
6
Allnghl
4
COOK
lha_enofurtherqu_uons
Any rednect7
Yes, YourHonor
Wewlllneed
6 to teestablssh our technology
you
agree
that th_
datm
claim',
rcqmrc*
you mean
three
7
THECOURT
8
MR
9
-
BY MR
e_exoent
yes
t I
from
12
asked
Mr
detect
and
rt_et only
s3de
coming
out of
Isn'[ thai coff_l?
values?
19
A
20
mtercormectaom
lfyouarcsaymgthat
2l
mtcrcotmectlon$
22
Q
23
the blue box m oedcr [o geHo
24
A
|doWIqt,
25
tht*e'_
no tmphcanon
moving
ithastwo
ottt of t t. YOS. fl h_
And so wmdd_*t
you need
I_ o
to continue
to the left of
the t_rd value7
lax
Markman
cuts
these
Ilearmg
wtres
10/26/05
Page
Your
quesuons
m contexl
dtmng
d0¢$ context
17
$hde
18
taiktn8
about
19
A
It's context
20
Q
So the context ts not jt_l
21
a parhcula_
sh_e; n's
22
A
that's correct
to you mean
Y_,
m terms
jt._t
the words
to explanmng
of the entire
In your
a.*Lswer
that are off thts
Claim
6 as ',_c'r¢
here7
m tern_
ofthe
you,
arc structure,
_
entire
Clatrn
6
m the pfoasc that's on
m thc contcxt of thc cntff c clalm7
m twmy
Are there other pomons
reform
Cook
or oul ofcont_Xl
OU[ of context means
16
Mr
his o'oss-¢xamlnatlon
to you _, tLh respect
versus
Or context
to the shde
the screen,
items he in context
having
my quest|on
a person
matertal
Case
of, for example, Clalm
skdled
6
m the art, that there
ot" a£1s which
elaborate
and reform
Hearing
10/26/05
Markman
340
_342
Honor
attenuon
ts up on
v.hal
25
you,
yore
which
15
24 that
lmc._.
that ttus blue
he w_
And
23 Q
letmde_tandyourquestaon
&rccong
presentahon
yo*J severed
14
has IWO values
Carlson,
your
13 where
Andtheboxthal_.OUldcntlfiedherelnth¢
Goah_.
Thank
HIGGINS
I 0 Q
I I?
Okay
HIGGINS
Page
341
OO343
I yo*a as a person
skdled
2
alrttctmal
3
A
yes
4
rather
not do at this pomL
5
suggest
6
elecmmt_
guy.
7
supposed
to read
8
any stru_ime
9
as opposed
m the
I I
fi_ctm¢
and
ctrcmt
further
elaborate
5
person
skilled
m the arl?
6
A
Y¢_
7
Q
Ar_ther¢otherporttonsofthcCImmgorlOot
8
I I, buca_c
9
commtmlCal¢
Then:tsmuehmthecla_mthatp*ovtdc$
I0
thai allow
the conleXl
II
term ts a funcummi
12
A
yes
13
Q
Does
14
the claim,
15
opmlo_
16
term?
to yotL
] mere3, frankly,
tes al_urd
Srmdarly.
asked
you to -
14
que*hon,
h _ould
as an
are
no tdca that th_'t
of what
_mply
you're
m th_ pamculat
)ou
to exclude
meara'asyouwaer_pondmgtoh_q_tton
17
the tetra that's on the shd¢ o f control
and hghtmg
21
Q
Does
22
words
"control
the axluslon
23
elaborate
24
you7
25
A
to you
c.scmt
_
Cook
"com_ol
cvrcml
Andrnyfirst
the ,t_luston
to you
Mr
of h_s
the words
queaoon
e stnm[ur¢
domg_
po_aon
16
to you ts. dot_
not nol
slnde where
m tbu oul of conteXl
IS
Yes
that
to me to think that wc
the*e and ._ay. I have
he _ked
A
thm_
a pc|son
at the beginning
of
rr_tead
thai tht_ clmm
this term appears
[o you
you
material
¢labora,ton
does
clmm,
not apply
m the remainder
A
Y_
18
Q
And
19
A
It doe|
20
Su_tant]al
21
clatm
22
bul we have
23
suggesting
the structure
of the
24
to perform
|ha functtons
m the clash.
exclusltm
you and
of the
ftmhet
struetu/c
to
Yes
25
Ileanng
10/26/05
Page342
do_
it do
amount
tl suggests
qtatc
ffyou
a
read the ent3tc
I'mjusluylnstolookalourhtllcsntppetbure
Again,
,
of mxt that Js explaining
as an ¢]ectromcs
control
guy,
Markman
JA )866
c]atm
that?
o f soxtctm'¢
a _ ea]th
of
part of yore
to thns part,cula_
17
that bucaus¢
or acts
or not the
t¢ffn'_
form
m tbu
how
that
whether
term or a su_ctura[
that further
control
to you as a
stnmtm-¢
al a conchl*lOn
the[ ts the entn¢
m lerms
controlled
meamng
m all o f them,
adthllonaJ
to mr|re
that 112/6
of the
means
term cormot_
Markman
ts part
or mform
otcmt
o f the
= mfmm
here
sktUed
_ts7
meara
on the screen
bumg
that th_ subclemenL
|hal's
Q
20
to contcxl
does the fact
4
13
clectrmucs
wnth re;poet
clmm,
3
12
19
Similarly,
2 of the enttrc
you will see many
-- ff$ crazy
way
I $ ¢olmot
I Q
to ftmcttonal?
htxe
II's Jt_t
buthat
teem ts
lfyoureadallofClatm6.whlchlv.ould
structure
I0
art thai the
circuits
as I read
Ilearmg
and
_a_'
dus, I
18/26/05
Page
343
00345
00344
! ha_ e cacmts kind of flashmg m my
2 paructdu phrase, and I _pocl
I thodes
head as [ lead a
and
the output
3
response
4
Q
5
tell you _here
6
A
7
stud p_edclennmed
8 _,ou recallthatlineof requestmg?
8
_alu¢
9 A
Ido
9
conthtlon
lO Q
3 people m th_ room
4 Q
Now,
would have the same reactlon
v,lth respect to the altde thatts now on the
5 screea,tthlch tstltewmdo_
6 comparat_
m Clmms
compar ator or titled_ mdo_
I0 and I I,Mt
Cook
7 to tmc of Ins experP_ alldes,that_
asked you to refer
tab 49 alG
aod do
Ido
the
this
h tills
Q
furthe_
12 window
comparator_
12
A
13
MR_COOK
I_
nc4-
14
Q
The text _
15
A
In the
THE
MR
16 Q
COURT
Would
you rephrase the qu_tloa9
HIGGINS
As flusclatm ftmctton ts on the screen m yore
17 allde II,v*hat are the rnfar_ thaiare rt_nst_
e IO th_
18 f,_'ttor
rtle_$ w1"ach cav:_¢1_r_tOlreshold _ ol_e
Io h,_vc a
_IR
In the
of
_alue
shde
occur_
one
case
of the
of
and
1he s•cond
stud pr•determined
c_¢
last ponton
of this
shde,
what
does
it
1ell you _
rmsony
When
textual
16 Q
Yes
17
A
Okay
18
B, the _c4tagc
you say the
suppo
last portton
Inthectrcmloffigmes2Am_d
al node
61 scmcs as a thre_held
frrstvalue m the absence of a predetermined condition and
19 purpose descnhod
20
a St:_
So _ here
m more
for a
detmq later
20
Q
21 predetermined cootht_on7
21
caused by these mt'z_s that you ha_ e on thls altds_
22
ths: _ anous
22
A
23
which ts the output of the comparator
24 thv_dors m the window
the upper and the
24
at node
through the
25
whether
25
Well, m thisshd¢, we ha_ e the -- excUSe me -- I
¢onaparator seumg
lower thresholds The mpul signalsapphed
Markman
Hearing
10/26105
Pa[te
2
Mr
Cookol£o_kcdyousomequesuotts
I ofthep_tent,
ahout
v.oo]dyougetthaLplease'_
3 p,a_ cularly,the rnmmal
4 A
Juslamomenkple_
5
O
Okay
6
m the c¢cmt
tint's
7
either
Or QI
8
A
NO, nothing
9
Q
When
I0
manual
Now.
Sert$or
o_¢mde
or Q2
stops
2A
after the mouon
t2
A
YtS,
13
Q
I have
ovem_
detector
h_
quesaons
Any recros_
15
MR
COOK
16
THECOURT
Mr
THE
MR
c_c
WITNESS
HIGGINS
22
MR-
HIGGINS
-
we hohevc
THE
v
we wdl
except
Okay
for those
COURT
HIGGINS
9
THE
COURT
I[ ;n fil_t
the
MS
behe_
• tt wdl
345
MITRAKOS
Page
347
it _
NoobJecuon
You
_z_l
LOpol
1
188
(WITNESS
16
TIlE
CLERK
18
THE
9.qTNESS
19
THE
CLERK
Be seated
20
THE
COURT
T-h_e-*-z9
21
THE
WITNESS
CLERK
WAS
g8
Okay,
your
right
SWORN
State
yes
hant_
)
your
name
for the
record
please
alton,
Your
J Michael
Yes
sir
Thesz
Yes,
ma'ara
Good
Honor
THECOURT
statement
COOK
Goodatlentoon
V_al
Letmesee
ts his statement
Let
numbc_
83, YourHonor
Markman
JA 0867
Caz_
Icanhandttuptoyounow
be number
15
MR
346
to subm,t
the exarmrtatlon'_
Okay,
25
PaRe
intend
tesumony
vetygo_d
Raise
me find your
10/26/05
Okay,
THECOURT
24
Hearing
you s_
THE
23
Marknlan
Page
M_chael
we
Thes2_s
lhaveset'n:t
14
w]mess_
to put On ItS
calls
Honor,
13
22
poroom
ready
10/26/05
this exammaaon
Yoa_
Ha_e
Ot do It du_ag
fol to our
Defeme
tleanog
as part of Mr
MR.
hel_
e_ tthmce
]e_el
_t up to you no_9
of [he d_ fendants'
prestmt
ta_-_xammaaon
COURT
yo_
that completes
the threshold
that axe used to select
Defendant
handle
MITRAKOS
exhibit
THE
II
9
Yore" Honor,
Okay
25
mouon
that am
and eventuolly ends up
o_ at its accent
Yes
_tll
8
l 0
that
-
COURT
case during
proces_ng
_oumaystepdown
Tbsx&
COOK
7
17
THE
v, here
the
Carlson
21
24
does
Norectx_s
Allngh_
for the pMmoff
23
rnooorL
12
COURT
19
detecting
ts on, off,
F,lltrakos
MS
6 I bs.qd
that stop
motion?
detected
M$
an addmoxal
tt does
no further
20
does
_s aaua*ed,
THE
18
4
doteeong
14
Thankyo_
1
simply interruptthe St#
I l occkt_
17
lhaveClalm
and 2B.
from
MR
3 ThesT.
Q I and Q2 from
the wanua_
override
2
1
wbsalthern._nualoverndetsas:tuated.
m flgm_
ts where
ate the thresholds
the lamp
o¢cm
00347
I first v*dn_s_
Claim
And
Okay
those
61
Markman
of CImm
portmn
61
at node
344
00346
I Q
thevoltag•
thresholds
23 need to get a hlllewaler _- w e ha_ ¢ the two resl_u_•
A
Wdl,
do
I'm
n_
AHrlgh[
19
value m response to a detectionof stud
m
condition
m this
m the absence
in the
to the detecuon
oth_
11
I$ BY
_alue
condlnon
In the
sv._tchos
support
) ou that tt v.]ll occtn
10
14
textual
du_shold
m response
m the absence
and
of the predetermined
&sclosed
Isthe me-.xnathalIs re_ponsi_,
¢ to the f.ensormean_
Itadme.
a first _alue
r.ondmon
[o the d•[ecuon
Does
I I thal causes the threshold voltage Io ha_ e a firs[value the
Objecuon,
has
2 the sa_d predetermined
m¢61 of the electlomc_
Hearing
10/26/05
O0348
I
THE COURT
2
'IVIEWITNESS
3
00349
I 1973
83, okay
MynametsJ
4 ad_
is 600
W_
Street
5 20024
I have
been
6 the law
rm
engag_
7 EM L Tcchnolog*e_
8 be fo:c
9
_c
Stm_
111 refcT to as PTO,
Io
Patent No
II
I b_e
12
expc_c_ce
13
_
forov_35years
PTO
17
and the Corrm_o_v,c_lth
pate_
electrical
al_llr._(r,_
21
pr_t]¢e
spacml_ed
ha_
has
elecU, lca]
25
1965
f_
as tn expert
a bad_le:
cr, gmcenn
and ajuns
OO35O
] as m fo_'ma|tc_l
3 the p_em
th_
8 from
wlmess
de_'cc
p_ten|
and l_tm_d
8
m de free tbe dmy
9
the PTO
_
Ilm
II
Maraud
12
_g
13
pr_tlce
14
profef_l_xals
of - tbe duly
17
Fro
w_
m
10/26/05
presented
m the Umted
Stat_
Page
patrm
to d_clo_e
P.mded
atso
=_d agen_
m how
17
apphcatlon.%
work
guidance
to Woceed
21
1996
22
p, ocess
the official
ts I_oked
_ement
to by federal
ofPTO
1 left the PTO in 1996
p_Ctlce.
From
1996
22
Morsar_
Lew_
and Ba_k_
At both
24
prtma_ly
25
appllca_ef,
of these
of W_ecutmg
m'gl CZll_d
fim_
Hogan
my W_:uce
and Super_tsm
the
prlvath
fxrmsof,
20021
have
cceststed
of
10/26/05
Page
350
been
Io
_
prepa_n
8
of other ma_crs, such
Hearing
sel f-e_nployed
Courts
I'm a member
Law Assooatt
9
chawman,
10
which
and am achndted
of Appeal
10/26/05
Page349
_s a patta_t
to prSCllce
Intellectual
] ha',e served
Secoon
13
l have
14
wo',t Id have
15
p_mon
Office
16
paragraph
asked
been
r¢.a._hl
sought
Secuon
20
fm:t_
of
undm"
to comm_l
on '7.heth_
c for a palcnt
examination
or nol it
applteant
und_
in Hcath's
S_t*on
t 12,
6
In my opinion,
19
Soctety,
112,paxagraph6
be_
to have
Prop_y
pre'x_enL
The first tOpiC 1'[I eddr ¢_s ts examination
35USC
*.he
as a cornmli_ee
and of the Patent and Tradem_k
I am a p_l
before
ci_Cml and
Office.
of the Ame_can
on, for which
of
for th_ federal
foe Heath
112,
THE
*t would
ha_ c haen
to chaff
clan'ps m accordance
paragraph6
COU_T
entirely
with
lhasemyop_mononse_¢ral
Have
you got a clean
cup ove_
_e?
23
TH E WITNESS
24
THE
COURT
25
TItE
WITNESS
Y¢_,
th,wk you.
Okay
Heath
Mariunan
JA 0868
1982
da_cs and
well
of the bars of the D_tnCl
and VIrganta
Stat_
8
22
of
from
cortsuhant
I'm a memb_
21
and HartsoT_
Ilearing
petlllOlk_ _
l S _ble
mu:l others
ofilce
issues
of inventorshtp
the U S Pat_m and Trad_xnark
s m the electrical
Markman
m the
ai PTO
and Wocedme
rc_tc',vulgd_clSlor_ on a va_¢_
7
12
as
in ventlork_
lpanlclpaledmthedec_owmakln8
6
11
patent
xn_ enuons
m_hanlca]
ofl_ctalon filing
Since
law
1,000
the deciding
eorreclIOn
I
until I w_s
clectncaJ
for pale'his
Umted
8 the prosecution
examiner
legal adv_of
Columbxa
with
for thelaw
a Semor
5
pohcy
to 2oo2,1worked
a_l
cotn'ts
or s_ctly
on }'TO policy
I was
and m 1977
the _lstanl
ovvr
mvotved
comml_lm3er
A._;sach,
17
Tha MPEP
_
and data proee_rng
In 1982
trine, I examined
all of which
I served
the a_ls_31
on PTO
to my
examiner
m 1974,
palent
4
fm palem
m deaJmg
Ih_
IO ehcmtcal
20
_
for pale_L_
Dtmng
G-_ MPEP
for
examiner
on the staff
3
L_w fog the paL_tl
pmv*des
comm_loner
to work
and
to
engmet_
was attached
_; a patent
examiner
a semor
lectures
the ethtot" of the
the MPEP,
a pnma_
2
m faxm_on
CV
Markman
and
a pro)eel
recognition
with
agency
m the
for electrtcai,
cha_cler
348
ride changes,
a tr_e_ f_
officer
_
of'my
PTO m 1968
for a poslUon
16
25 _
academy
*_ the reference
arid pal_l
21
23
Umvcrslty
commm_ca_ons
Procedure,
pas_,
15
oo351
t
appointed
Examining
selected
24
m the PTO
The MPEP
axz_mcys
m
m _lab_l_y
| 9911
p_c_dxl_
D_me
copy
Uon _
] co_txnued
14
23
ly of Nou'e
of the pubhc,
toplc_
tbe PTO
E ma_J
of Paxenl
m
as _
work
apphcatmns
_al,
recogm
18 opp_cd
PTO
including
at the
p_lent
I became
earned
19
Hearing
for PTO
law
o'*_r 1.400
i6
20
of
$ takanent$
w make
In Jlmuary
_
12
of Columbta
from Gco_e_wn
i altodralted and unplememed
18
II
m the
degree
at tbe PTO p_l
mcludm8
19
[_me
r=sponslble
7
15
and
m this
law
concemm8
the Umve_'_
bar and membc_
On a cm3_'x-/of
IO
m patent
mvemJ_
of science
doctm
I was also
6
inventions
on tbe pr_ccuuon
Markman
$ Japan
elecoomechanl
a_l procedmes
24
4
9
I0
of the D_trtcl
focused
p_rmLnly
I reccwed
2
U S
patem.
knowledge
i served
prog_Jns
I star_ed
I examined
o f the rcle_ am docuracnts
Army,
A U'ue and conect
8
in smt.
to I P68,
staIemenL
7
which
,
I also sc_,c
23
6
of Vtrg]ma_
pracace
_
testing
5
lamreg2s_edtolra_lxcebefore_e
My hw
Slat_
miss*It
a_d proced_e
Office,
the '066
on my pc_onal
I am adrm t_ed to the
20
I1) call
Umted
13
16
22
8 the palm
who has
15
19
pr,_uc¢
1965
4
of
below
['m an aRo_ley
18
on behalf
and Trademark
which
the following
hsted
by
mad Crew
From
3
D C
I_r,v consultant
conccrmng
regardm
and my rcvtcw
_
14
as a palcm
Paint
5,598,066,
eSk Washmg_cl
and T_
on Issues
United
Myoffiee
Southv,
of Townsend
2
MxehadThm
I'mself-cmploycdasapa_cnllawco_uhaml
would
ha_ e warned
Hearing
to
10/26/05
Page
351
00352
O0353
1 present clam_
to th¢ PTO v,h=ch would
2 art and _ hlch the patent
examiner
ha_ c avoided
v_culd ha'* c folmd
the prior
I
",',as tmprop¢¢
2
SecOon
3
in a claim
as hmlled
4
described
m the
to be
3 allowable
4
He.eda would
5 _'h_ch
would
also ha_ ¢ w_mtcd
stand
up m co_
6 m_ ahd_ty of the patent
7
m In Rc Donelson
9 mte_'prct Section
|0
[l_ltallor_,
Company,
112, paragraph
[4
[6
flora
of styuctu_,
I g sW.dlcat_m
_o_ctme,
19
The PTO
20
had been interpreting
a_ swdctu_
m the dana
wtthoul
ftmcuon
v. ithoul
14
dcscn'bcd
m a
17
_,larkman
2 pat_!
3
dunng
speczficd
21
Iwo
the differences
art
22
prior
axl ,trc so minor
23
b_en obvtous
24
time
expect_on
As Ih¢ pa_3!
6
of being
proscct_on
relev_nl lmor
flit
patent
enough
In thts
ha'* c a bc[ter
_s _ ahd o_ cr pnor
patcnls
are ol)en
_)" Ihc PTO
hl_gat]on
If
to hterally
c._
one
read
bctv, ten
surprised
p,_tcnt clalna_
th© prior
claimed
art
oL
ln_ enllon
in_ entlon
of ordm,try
chance
ar_
be c_,_lenged
the
upon
the cla_mcd
that the
to a person
that II w_
skill
and
Ih¢
_ ould
In the
ha_c
art at the
made
case,
I coropctitoi_
hxsIory shov. s there
art m exls[ence
at _c time of the
The p_or
;m mcluc_d
H_th's
own
7 sccun {y [_ghung syslcrn. Oh© msmc_on
8 _s hsCd o_ the face of Ihe '066 patent
9 cc_ld_dby_cp_J_:n_xamu_
rc fc_c:K¢ ts Defendants'
11
13 which
manual
_
Exhlbu
Hcalh
would
as Dct'endants'
16 Septemb_
17
Exh_bt158,
9. 2004
AL_o Profr_or
18 tndlv_d_J
! 9 paint,
Ceramic
io.stntctlon
Exhibit
and the Aronson
v.h_ch _; al Exhlba
PIR,
manual
of Jcnsen
dcc_at)tm,
dated
coavcnuo_
21
engineering
c_rcmt_ that co_d
c_ ¢tecumalc
Th© r©lev_t
a_ Dcfrndaa_s'
Fm'dl_,
type _
d_agram
of the
be t'ou_d m c}ccmc_
Paulus's de:oosluon
smcc _rctal] ¢lcctromc
prod_ts
arc
of the
here can e_tsfly bc purch_cd
Markmal_
Heann
valuable
since
5
an unfair
advantage
R
g_mmg
paragraph
As a resuh
not have
had
any
lleanng
ba_ c been
9
He_lh's
posr_on
10
with
10/26/05
Section
coverage,
10/26/05
expecled
vahd
the
at1_
prior
On
be held
P=ge353
the
factors,
f_
18
holdc'_
gammg
19
competitors
stat_
22
has been
23
mechamcal
"The
The
p_agraph,
_lenl
s_mply
It
for a p¢_on
c_r_
in
m _ccctd,_cc
6
p_sttlon
co_ crag©
ought
tn wc_
such
claims
and
wluch
30
range
of
nol to ha_ ©
of the c Ic_t'ness
a_c less
hkely
of
to
can pre_ Cnl a compe_lor
by duphcalmg
the patem
xs re.adl[y access_olc
o[ h_ st,_leracnt
practlct:ofusmg
somewhat
d_ffereol
technologtes
statutory
makes
meal.s
Mr
to
" I do
palent
_
claims
corapar
i'd to
not agree
pro_ tSTOn, S¢cuon
no exception
Patlcrsoa
tcrmsln
in ¢leclromcs
Markman
JA 0869
by
m the markciplac¢
In p,ra'agraph
21
can
fTom
marketplace
arc not gl_ cn a broad
c_rcmtt_,
v_hd
producls
m my op_mon,
an un fair ad_ an_g¢
electrical
for such
reasonable
In Hcath's
othe_ hand,
revealed
clrcu=try
paragraph
b_oaA
clrcultly
compchtors
m the
m_ ,did m htlgallon
17
25
Page354
a per,son
14
claims
prevent
holder
cl_arn_
thcar
re_ c'_¢ engineering,
1o ha_ c sougl_!
such
13
they
tmmmcnlly
112,
While
and
6 patent
of Ihcse
would
24
by
the palcm
g
20
Exh=b_t 60
corm6er_lon
4 be qmt¢
16
t cxtbooks_
pe_cs of Mr
112,
15
that's figurc_ 2A and B of _h¢ '066 patent, were
20
3 Section
12
59
of the ctfcult
or So-called
I I
PaoJos has te_t_ficd that aJl of th¢
c:rctnt clcn_mts
opt'n markel
trlspeCtlon
7
57 and the
14 dzscttssion of that prior all in II1¢ dccl._rat_on
15 a_d McCav:h
for wtuch
prior art
the Nsppon
in the
2 by cite
6 duphca0ng
56
c,nergy ¢ontarol switch
_s pro_lded
single level
H_spoorar/
The pno_ ml also Included
12 passp, ¢ m fl_red
25
ly
and
and ha_ c a bert_
Markman
5 apphcai_on
24
broad
PrO
with
_ssued
Page352
coverage.
4 was vcly
23
nar_o_
to the
OO355
I reason_lc
22
tmfamlha_
arc
_ a]ld broad
and
in court more
claims
in the
m ht_gatlon
m_ ahd
00354
|0
_t_taln_rd
20
able to obL_n
was
In thc Sl_Clficallon
plus function
allo'_ ed
19
10/26/05
PTO,
of such
¢lenlenls
and
descnl_d
on any
Hearing
pltc_ function
s_uctur¢
mcar_
Persons
25
m the
mterprcta0on
thai a_¢ nol hmltcd
apphcauon
that d_:s PTO pracuc¢
hmltatlons
tfthe
m the PTO
_ha! patrnls
to the corresponding
thereof
_ 12, sixth
tn cour_ actions
to I_rn
_c pnor
eqm_alencc
m c taln'_
of bcmg
115 of being
in the SpC¢lflCatlorL
clrcutl decldcd
been
I$
_ reading
to whc'_cr
chance
and
hmt_ttor_
st/_ctute
ther©of
Tht_,
15
to co_ ex IP¢
the function
was the same o_ ¢qtavalenl
The federal
equivalence
claims m a patcnl
24 sbxcturc
25
concspondlng
to mterprel
ftmchon
oCSectfon
_
a r csulL means
13
phts
plus ftmctlon
a_e construed
12
or acts described
23 stngtu_
As
claims
may
be eXl_CSsed ;_ a
specdlcat]on
had
ts required
mca_
Io the corresponding
to be Ih¢ same
I I than elements
years
be construed
p_fonned
regard
hm]latlon_
6
6hc mlerpretarlon
112 states, an
such hmttatlom
which
8
9
that the PTO
paragraph
means
rcqmred
10
thereof
m cxarmmng
Tht_
7
to
or aCLS m s_Oport
material
and eqwvaJ_:_c
t_ rcquzred
the way tho_¢
a sp¢¢1 lied
rn21ena]
and 6uch c[am..s sl_Jl
17 cotresix3ndmg
22
of Sccuon
o¢ sle'p for per forming
dmeo£
21 prim
the PTO
in a claJm for a con)bm._on
mear_
5
of [he fcdcraJ
for man)
The stxth paragraph
15 the recital
on
6. rf,cans plus ftmctmn
m a m.cqncr dl ffcrt:nt
13 eIcmc'nt
based
6 paragraph,
dccLqon
11 hmtta_tonshadbecnmter_¢tcd
12
a I:r_tcnt
o_er prior arL
AS a r csuh the ca _c
8 cncmt
m ob_n
to any cttzDcogc
and
112,
I 12, s_xth
for elcctrontc
Hearmg
inventions
IO/Z6/C_
Page
355
00356
00357
) Fm&_,
hasad ot_ my years of experience. I do nol behevc
2 I.:131palflllexaminer's or _t
attorneys _
I parch
thee
2
I have
3 hinttart
on._and claims thrected to elecb-onlcm'.enlsons
3
4 m a way thffere:nl
from other mventJons, nor should _ey
4 claim
$
5
Tbe chnns
6 mthspute
7 om
o f tbe 'f_6 patent
m defendants* Markman
$ Secuon
9
A chain Inmtabon
boo fs,tinges a p_esumptton
tmie_ mo_fiad
12
_tm:ly the seated functmn
"mcaa_"
combines
9
I 12, sixthparasraph,
16
17 "stung"
m the hml_mn
18 door closed.&d
spnng
14
_s m bo)d,
15
the funcnon
21
16
22 pa_
but ralh_ a term naming
&_'¢
18
staled
funcuon,
the out_
a structure,v.htch has a
22
training
b_efm
to one oforthnary skill
had the
24
112/6
25
25
Markman
Ileanng
10/26/05
Page
2
a Ioc_tton
leg band
means
3 ur_permeablc
layer
means
5
per fo_att or__
was
Th_'refofe,
7
th,s ©]emcm
8
of-
s'a_c tree cxtcn&ng
to the v. at_t band
layer
4
6
for th_
_,
tt_o_h
but tbeough
found
to re&care
t t v, a_ fotmd
suffic,e_t
for removing
me,ms
thz/there
to c_
the
the omc_
the cxtenl
Uamm 8 bnef
and permeable
of U"te
was Su3.q:tm-e
out cu',t,r e.3y the
m case
m
II
there
12
perform
13
_
14
to k et'p tbe door
15
v. as i_u
band,
ff_c_cnt
the st_ed
in the
first block
of an accident
19
encompass
22
23
_
24
25
mean.s
means
lot" tending
the door
so_c
cths_
structure but was fc_md
tha_ &e
show,1
st_ctt_e
of some&rag
&al
co_dd
stud goat
box means
4
projecUng
5
b,ax,a]
ebe
could
the cc_trl
beM the_
ftmcuon
Markman
Heanng
means
band mean_
for removing
by the u_eL
f_
the
the clmm
pr_u.mptlvely
w_.$ a
m the
term "pcrfora_On"
llearing
box means
th_ rotating
comprising
dov_wa_dly
10/26/05
another
sa_d blade means,
a pair of rotatable
from sa,d
Page
franc
mca3_
sha_
a_d _finmg
a
m that clement
The funcbon
blade me_s
The court fo,.md
language
shaO_
a_l defining
downwardly
for a mo_oraed
13
rm_hmg
a o_,c_tc
s_face,
14
el_ment
15
g_z
was
gexthle
box means
16
revolvmg
17
comprising
_ud
which
from sad
n_am
thai one
ndmg
frame
m_ans
on the
Dowel
the cl_m_ term was
shaft
means,
m&vidt_J
The ftmcuon
actualmg
_vc
m response
rotc_
in Ihc
a pa_r of
plane
m the next box below
L, kcwL_¢,
f,_ad
suuctme
"gear box" composing
projecting
a bmxmJ
v, as rotating
sul_c_m
means
to _d
stud
fca actuating
motor
fl¢_thle
shaft sections
foz
- clam
mear_,
drive
sam
thereby
shaft
ax m]ly linked
rr_ans
tOgC0_r
for facfl,tatmgbending
that was in the clatm
sa_d gear box
me_xs,
th_by
was
fm
_evo]v,ng
s_d
rotor
A.qdthcsmmturethalw_recttedmthalclement
was found
to be su_c,em
w_
flexible
drive
shaft
23 mcatts which opcratt* in r cspon,s e to sa_d motor means, stud
was
to cany out thai
and thee
means
IO the wrest
layer
in a claim
22
alao be par_ of &c
mcar_
&e
on the leN
planc
21 me.a_
be the spnng
that
waS, peffowt,on
me_'tq
12 left side,
20
fotmd
[o the left $)de of my chart
3
19
m that
"means"
and,
to per form
first block
found sWdcture
18 by _ctton &sk
sI:¢c_ ficat_on
m tbe -
o- let's
wc_d
the courls
case of an acct&mt
Relummg
II
to
s'_de of my
mc_
something
o_ could
So m Ihal cz_e
tr_u]t_clcnt
to keep
jt_ an example
the spnng
Tbere fore,
_-mg
the nf_lt
m the
impermeable
_s gear
Io
dermtte
found
w_
c_
be spnng
_oe_ mthcate
the court
20 specification
2t
would
thai a fpnng
Also,
m the Claim e]o_:nt
_ shown
_ lend_
not to be sumclc_tly
m&catc_
tl v.'a_ fotn_d thai
on the
Is undeflmad
in th£ clatm
leg band
icrm *'r_.ar_",
8 clement m _
closed.
Tbe f_ncUon
I 8
st_ctu_e
fm_ct_
]6 Tbe wold "spnng"
17
a c_,_e where
shown
c_mm ¢lcmcnL
9 rotatable
On the _
_e
the language
example
7
paragraph
term, &c
a ca_e where
strict
the
2
6
ftmctlon
9 by.urn"
I0
from
The court
00359
I
the omer
sixth
_
Markman
from the
two,
m my tcporl
m &e claim
356
00358
also
e}cmenls,
_.s shown
through
23
I a_
$,Jfl]clcnt
21
sumcsent to avosd the _'_bllof Scclzon i 12, sixth
or
Sulled
Is m iIzJics
c_tcndmg
rneanmg
112,
- the "n_a._*'
tbe swdcture
w_
24 m tbe _n _td wluch per forms the specified funcuon nan be
23 ren_onably well unde_tood
work
stde of my chart,
_ not tcqmrcd to avozd the acr,
blt of Sectzon I 12, slx&
to
the
paragraph,
Section
that a
with a
stntcmre
to pc'H'orm the
USC
found
pr_lu&ng
] 12, slx_h
sU'_cture
So, for ex _n'nple,
17
I 12. sixth p_raSraph.
thus
chain
ha_c
combined
Su fficlcnl
put up and ,l'S abo
19
d_ctateof Sectmn
recltauon of ps_ctse physlcal s_
r_lC_
funcuon,
of the clasm
20
19 the com_ton
20
However.
In each
see ,f thts wd)
no4 take tbe Immatlon oul o f tbe amblt of
"means"
so that 35
13
me'ms tending to keep the
the word
of Section
chart that we've
of the smut Lu'aI
language
t_lng
elth_
12
ll2.slxth poragraph
Fo_ example, me
the courts
doc_ apply
II
Stm_tm'e m the meaJ_ plus
comp,4rmg
m wh,ch
tn_ufl_clent
funct,_n,
10
func0oo cleancntdoes not preclud© the apphcabfltty of
15 Sectmn
one,
a table
c_ses
the stated
7 apphcabthty
by sulficlenldefiniteswacture to a_hleve
The recttatlonof some
function,
6 perform
that
se_ forth below
from
el_l
8 rec, t_
using the word
revokes Sccuon
II
14
_set
112, six& p_a'a_aph, apphes
lo wsth the ftmctmn
13
"DieclaJm ck'rmmts
here allmc]udctbe',_ord"mca_',',_hlch
langttage
10/26/05
Page
358
24
flexible
d_e
25
sections
axlaJly
shaft
means
comp_sm8
[Inked [ogctber
Markman
JA 0870
mthv,duaJ
by fncl_on
thsk
Ilearmg
shaft
means
for
10/26/0g
Page359
357
OO36O
I
facdltalmg
2
09361
bcndzng
Returning
3 the claJra
I o f commands
Io the nghl
element
thd nol [¢¢ttc
4
acht eve entirely
5
tbe laagttage
6
attenuator-
and p_moncd
7
filaments
so that rcpelhng
$
filaments
to more
9
ate dcpcsdcd
10
the stated
mmns
collccuon
cotzrl found
there
12
um formly
to mort
J3
_xc depos_
_ed on _tatd co/lectmn
14
thee
not sufffctcnt
_5
to carry out that function
17
vdth
19
tbe_,
to perform
the _
21
proccdui'e
o f a digital
of _mlng
22
for booting
23
mcluthng
24
commands
resident
on such
25
computer
for booting
s_d
sa_d &gllal
as Io g]_ • hldc
bc fore
they
compum_,
said
a first set of commands,
Nc.xt
5
i)t _a=cut_n
6
ov_
7
I v.lll
for booting
tbe prim
clrcmt
Producls
vs
Ag_rr_
"An mvemo¢
t_const$1t-nt
ix_mon
21
23
fomsa,
19
specific
of orthnary
sktll
thai structure
p]t_
and ts
ftmcuon
structure
On
was
p_eparmg
_1
prosecution
22
Mark
an the Markrnan
art could
b_ng
claimed
b_ng
l re_ icwed
Wdham
C
Raper
prc_css
Page
but that no
recllc_
application
10/26/05
clearly
o f the '066 pate_3t, the
J Patterson,
tnacfs
ofthe
360
thai IS, the
In the specification
my staeement,
h]sto_
mcansplus
structure
m the
was
of the palent
the
s_alcracnts
of
and Slephcn
B
Carlson
partl_
Patterson
s dcscnpt
t_ya
m paragraphs
5 to 25 of
Hearing
10/26/05
IMarkman
to expand
on his
I
apphcam
may
dt_3ng
whcn
HcaJ_care
thstmgulshmg
on clati_cons_tcl]on
6
within
Page
361
issuance
und_
stale_aengs
SccIKy_
16
o f the
made
c c_.'nlc
18
lls clam_
19
the apphcauon,
an
23
.,'¢_mre
the desired resultsof the
24
25
Markman
Heanng
10126/05
Page362
the right to rely
apphcaUon,
pulse
by
defimtwc
any interpretation
pulr_
prior art dunng
I| eath Company,
dt._clalmed
of
cotmtmg
tgs elatrr_
from
pr_cct_uon
of the '066
al the t_ne
any inte'/pretatlo_
the own_
thai _
of
not
counting
Ih a declaration
and slg_ed
on such
prior
sc'nse
from the Ntppon
d_sclarm_l
m thstmgm_hmg
Ceramic
to overcome
mak_
p_scculiOr_
Heath
filed
m the PTO on A0n129,
employees
leben
MarkmanHear_ng
JA 0871
m the
I 12
has sa_d that
mterp_'tahons
no( reqmr_
In my opinion
22
p_ot
desc_bed
pr_6ecutlon
its c[alm_
thai doe_
plus ftmcuon c]mm
by cctt_,
has
du_ng
ptaor art, Heath
pat_nl
used
to
thai the same
of Section
crtcmt
du_ag
claim
lh thsunguzshmg
17
21
View
made
the pubhc
Tcch,
v_
the federal
art can lead Io narrow
because
action
to the $_uc_e
13
15
is nol
ts nol permitted
_or proposes
arguments
14
and the pubhc
Strttc[_e
m frmgemenl
exphctt
the Nippon
Limited
the pal_ntee
12
of
of tbe
m cor_trmng
6
Simdarly,
bar an
rood
the examiner
that a part]cgl_
speclficanon
paragraph
& s_vo',_
claims
ad_ Is_
t_ eqo_a_ent
pato_t's
an exphoi
was properly
function
a patentee
20
USA
to be
_h_ch
his m_ _Uon,
I]
clam_
thai the stractatc
after p_ent
10
o__
act to
may
ll_ shorlcomings
plus
When
5
9
and v,hat it
th_ mx _oon
the 0alcott,, which had tlscd me_s
no:ed
the me_
strucet_e
and
WK_t his mv_tlon
takca before the PTO
24 wa_ "incapable" ofachlevmg
3
Co,'potal_on
hlstoP/c_toppcl may
m Signtech
p_lor arl slru_tuxe,
7 _.ger t m a subsequenl
the specification
dtstmgmshmg
That w as held
2
4
l_t_ art Im_ c often proved ttseful in co_sm_mg
plus flmeuc_
Fo_ example,
22 l_,
tccog_tzc
disclosed
25
set
dus to say m Vahd
may u_
St_t_'m:nts deladmg
roeans
One
18
Structure
connotes
and a second
17 I IZ, par'a_ra_h 6
20
tf
of the
Slxthpa_agraph,
compulct,
t_Im_ ale_e argtm_=nt under the doct_ae
15 eq_val_w.c, posmom
i 9 _Icwmt
co_cspond]ng
112
alw,tys
_ tth Mr
Wtumpeetatlon
had
Jusl _ _utlon
18
16
Section
hmltatlorts
m general
12 pnc_ m't_
16
la fact
ftmctton
I agree
pazttculafly
II tsnot. p_l_l_/whco
14 estop _
of the law
to a means
24
that a patent
clmm
tO proscctt_on ht_tO_ |o define
13
of _he apphcabfllly
23
art.
federal
(phoneuc),
stalemcnt
paragraph
not apply
stla_c|urc"
m tbe _alysls
set of
Ilearlng
Pauctson
does
"connotes
so broad
sramcturc
Is not a correct
l 16, sixth
l_
20
_ _s means
to do so
dtscuss
m the Pro,
The
scct=o_
icrm.
_ cte
.:.as
Mr
para_aph,
of s_ud thgltal
I am p_epared
upon
_t pafucttl_
_. Mrebcal
9
Hov.ever
ff callcd
thsdmm
] 2
stxth
function
'_ a_
OO363
I Kts statermmts
4
This
17
0O362
3
116,
stalcmcm,
device
storage
Markmau
2 dcsc_ptt_
of tbe paxhctdar
that Section
14
of the booth
sa_d firsl
indication
Io the
Commands
bul the language
8 states
no, beJpfu]
ftmct_ons
structwc,
26 ofh_s
J]
external
computer
th.tl the 5Waet m'e recited
out lhosc
In paragraph
plus
d_lce
satd digital
_3 elcmcnl
pTogrammcd
means
Io car_
Io represent
I0
a _ eb,"thal
langvagc
Tbe cottr_ found
9 a mear_
to mo_ c
on a slo_age
fo_ boolmg
7
they
language,
syslcm
claim
diwtal
6
tbe
cooperaung
conuol
computer,
found
not to be sufficlenl
computer
20
5
f_r clrctro_taucally
_ as fotmd
for a &g.rd
iI_suffic_cn_
m that clement
corona
and pasmoncd
4
a w cb
to form
recited
3
bcfo[¢
the filaments
surface
strtJctm¢
the fil_nc_ts
In a c_m
to form
sp_ad
pomon
sau$ atlcmmtce
! 8 charging
stnffm:e
m the fi]_._cnts
tml foemly
The tmdc_ymg
fil_mcms
r_tdcnt
computer
cloy, n.
In the
tbe
thgltal
to
chargmg
that the ftm¢l_oo
are reduced
2
_ tth saad
are induced
s_
"rcpcihng
16
one
fo¢ operating
forces
II
_
struclute
the second
for ¢lecU'oJtaP_caIly
um f_-mly
forces
examples _berc
suffictcnt
fum:tlork
v. as c_mna
on stud
T]_
side of charl
1996
and McCavth
McCavl_
I 0_26d05
Page
363
00364
I had
thls
OO365
to day
2 s,.vltch
Thzs
KcnMcCavxt.
and dLrco_ ¢ted
3 suT:_tantxa]ly
4
"1
5
about
Although
6
the opera,ion
7
mode.
g
and determined
wtth
the Nip_on
the msmacuon
of the cncr_
i te_[cd
wdh
9
o_" poss_ion
mariner
thai
II
rrtanuaJ for the l_t
F trth_
4
not d=scnbe
5
are normally
6
_
swflch
demonswated
dxsc[osedandcl=amedmthemstanlapphcatm_.
_d3tlon.
17
no_ have
dxd nOl have
furlh_
le_tmg
s'wltch
mst._mt ¢pplca_on
20
claJm._ _
21
heTcwlth
counting
tesung
accordance
25
counnng
dul
In
14
dcclm'atlon
15
pcn&ng
18
d_scovc-ry
19
c_amlnt_s
20
and made a number
2t
regarding
22
Claims
23
Clazms
as recRcd
m the
ame_'_mc-nl
bemg
ts further
CO_tTOI Swllch
manttal
filed
m
d3d nol have
olx-r_on
oflhe
a pulse
P._tch
He=ring
Page
Clmms
2
feaum_
cteady
3
mSb_l¢[]Otl manu_
2. 10,
not dr_clce;cd
only
II and 12m¢&Tecled
or suggested
rearm¢
that Heath
=ts nom'na_
ual ovemde
6
that Nippon
7 cotmung
featm¢
8
d_closed
9
pat c'm
about
Heath's
art, dxrectcd
anti McCavxt
o f charactcr,z_ons
ovcmd¢
the
declaration.
and rc_csc'ntallons
clazms,
Clmms
which
15, 16.
were amended
17, and hOt, amended
13 and 14
to the non-manual
amended
Claxm.s
ovemde
2, I 0, I I and
364
clmms,
which
! 2, the patent
Markman
Io n_uc¢
"puL_
II
file -
12
filehlstoey¢opyofMcCa_tfsd¢cla_._Jon
13
thzs tmd_lmm_
14
to all persons
15
competltt_r_ wL_hmg to know
16
avoid
I7
cor_ldcrcd
I8
plainly
was
done
Ous $11t_cr_[
21
ts _asonably
22
Imutcd
attorney
Ilearmg
23
were
24
_
25
cl_am appllc_'t.
radio=
cotm_ng
6
McCavd's
as
7
by hand
by
m the
10/26/05
Page365
ordy
be true K the
In accordafic¢
with
SeCl]On
112.
examiner
a_
to me_
_e; would
and cannot do to
notable,
as st
und_
McCav
thai all pef_mg
be
Sectmn
Clam_
to mean
only
Markman
Hearing
as "g_rmlly"
wo_ds joined
placed
13
Shlrt2cr
d_sclosecl
17
both dtsc]osed
and c[;umed.
JA 0872
McCaval
is gc'ncrally
in the _n.stant
I mwrpret
22
reclusive
man.qcr
23
forth
m only one
24
would
I_ tmm_
25
consmted
_'e
g_ven
I_ellel
to be saying
and gerrcraIly
apphcallon
gencraIly
Io mean
$1nc¢
in a _'©asonably
poise
cotmung
was _xprcssly
of the p_dmg
claims,
this statement
unless,
m accordance
6I
and
_s tmd¢_[ood
dJsclosed
of
as Ex;'ubll
&sclosed
Thu.;.gcncrallytstm_toqvahfy
So tmdcrstood,
45 xo 46
arc attach_
and cl_amed
ts
phrase.
by the conjuncUon
cor_tr_ctton;
cla_med
Page366
of Gramma_
a word
succeeding
the qualxfier
Pages
claimed,
21
10/26/05
the words joined
16
20
12, was
*and',
15
clams
wh¢_¢
of the conjuncove
m _he p]u-,ts © generally
It's st_emerd
thai a sxngl©
of Mr
of _'_nm_
cor_,_uctton
Elemrnts
"pulse counung"
v, ¢_e
m front
a para0el
Thus,
woxds
by the conjuncl_on
|n thai event,
are siren
the form_
inle_'tat]on
Is mitt, deal to quah fy two
_rnn_d_atcly
19
Uxtc if the clamTiS
[ 6, '066 p31c'n! Clam
9
18
In accorda/ice wlth S(_:tlo__ 12, sixth
than conswaed
convmoona]
[0
14
cx_
consm_-.d
or no[ Mr
m_Jcaung
Lr_Cludmg
wha_ they c_
Under
such
12
of 8_mu'nar.
reasonable
statements
8
II
M_tbk¢ly
porUctdar[y
whether
cot_ued
cores tllJed
as woxdd
and as a malter
pu/s¢
to reduce
thzt the parrot
In my view,
_s and an tmmmcnlly
mut_]med
the file htstmy.
be zf the clams
to purse
counung,
nol cOnSl_ed
$
apphcazmn:
feartm:
tmak_med
the patent,
] co.idled
were
4
of the swzlch
by Ihe palcnt
v. ho Lnsp¢ct
wouJd
Io pulse
2 clam_
McCaves
"l_e
m the _t_!
ts a£tu_ly
- L_tctually
mfrm_n_
opera.on
coxzntmg
of th© t_vztch"
were
.mlt lacked
fa/se
false
rm t,mry
I hmsled
om io
claxzr_
=rid clmmcd
The lan_ag¢
operauon
to
m the
pointed
Ceramic
10
20
Heath's
3 s=xth paragn_
5 &Slmgmsh
g_/y
were
and McCavtl
SmxdgtolTwcre
prior
[o _;¢ Jensen
the manual
9,
a prchmmary
examln_
Ccramxc
that the
w_th ca_e
[he Jcr_cn
amendment,
of the N]Rcxm
atlcrRion
] believe
I Io3.
the patent
Ilowevcr,
25
10/26/05
informed
I, 3, 5, and new
24
filed
[he law
Wocessmg
with other papc/s
was chos_
wtth
_s over
the word
Thus,
AlthalttmeC]a_m.s
in the
and clanned
declarauon
p_t_'n I attorney
In the prehmma_
and McCavll
and thai
here
zs ¢onslste_lt
concttrrc'ntly
a_tomcy
false
16
attorney,
In a
OO367
I stud. maddtuon,
s't_ements
Hea_h's
amendmenl
herew=th
by Jcnsc-n
attorney
o f the dcclaratmn
13
0O366
The
wo_dmg
17
Markman
4
II
function
fi]cd
and contaxr_
whzch
pr c'Far ©d by the palenl
op_auon
statemenL_
false
number
I0
to reduce
the rncrgy
to reduce
happened
and ad_css
_hcauon
filed
_qd McCavll
manuaJ
t'e3tmes
wdh the xnsi_.JCtlOn
firm's name
one
by the paten[
(o be what
9 dc<ument
(hd
drafted
_
m the instant
in the c Ialm._; as amended
being
such
TI_ Je_sc'n
12
clasrned
amcndmcn[
the msmJcoon
dtscloscd
the key
demoos_a_cd
featm¢
m _h¢ same
_d
_s recked
Decla_atlon
8
In the mswacoon
ovcmd¢
m the p_clmnmy
In the roregoms,
24
feature
or odu_
amended
23
SWllCh In
cd that [he energy
wdh
as 8c'r,e_ly
19
22
demonslrat
m _:cordance
a pulse
1B of the swxtch
a manual
prehmmary
7
tha_ th© energy"
14
control
mode
control
substantxally
conuol
16
in a nonfat
=s described
13
15
m a nont_l
switch
mcxJ¢
_tm8
switch
3
art.
p_or
type energy
mode
_caturcs
Ceramic
conuol
_1 fx._nctmncd
m the non|esl
dtsclc_ed
2 fo_ o_cr
rrxanuaJ _
rnanu;d does
a &miner
I generally
m the test mode
the tnsBucuon
contzol
the cnerBy
I0
[2
dial xt functlorcs
m accoldanc¢
Is talking
tcslccltheencrgyconv:ol
_
EML
contends,
the clam_s
w_th Se¢llcyn
I 12, stxth
Markman
Hearing
sc|
arc
paragraph
10/26/05
Page
367
O0368
I
Th_
m_npr_aP_
2 s_e';nenl
f_,ct_,
whlr.h
4
pen(hng
clams,
5
claimed
m the im_t
6
d_closed
w_
included
Is sm_ply
8
plus
9
c_cml
I0
counung
_e
m s_,
reF_'ed
rn_ua/o_
erode
bm nol all,
Io _
apphcatlon
I wou]d
fur_Do11
of _he
&_losed
r_her
than
2
g_erall_
tha,
all clam_
clemen_p
which
contain
sen._ot
could
me_ns
poten_l_
v_ o means
and
control
encomp_s
_he pulse
c_cmw/
_
12
v, bether
13
ofth©
con_-o!
pulse
14
wluch
_'ver p_ty
15
inch_hxt
_wsed,
Lhe pan,
co_ang
_s _
c_a:m!
as to
of the semor
means
_
es d_a_nx
tn wew
eonect,
means
oFtbe
ot part
dL_ctalmcr,
]_ulse ¢o_n_g
v, ould sit11 be
THE
COURT
_x_k
17
MS
MITRAKO$
yo_
Weha_eafew
fo]low+up
qu_bons
19
J
20
4
prehmmav/amendmem,
5
slate'meat,
2]
And
22
and
DIRECT
23
BY MS
24
Q
2.5
te_t_nony
"]4
8
A
I have
9
Q
Do y0u
I0
prchmlnaV/mendment
II
Jensen,
]2
A
Well,
I_
gamed
that art omey
14
declaraUon
prehmma_'y
The
and
21
know]edge
22
made
23
Section
24
¢el_Ta.
forMr
Palterson's
furth_+
Marlanan
Hearmg
I0_6/05
Page
Confl_cls
ofal],that
are
the
cxammersarc
]edge
such
_
a
that these
1001
The
tnie and
behef
are
sta_ernen_
thai v, iIIful
_Jglm_¢n_
by Jer_en
false
examm_
Io be role
are trmde
stalemenls
wlth
and
I$ of the United
would
_l
made
tha_ all s_al_menls
beheved
so
c¢ both
States
Code,
ha_ e ¢or_ldeted
Markman
th_
the [_c
by fine or _mI_nSOranem
of TLtle
by
and McCa_
that all smlernenL_
an:
and
con[amed
made
declared
368
OO370
ot _ontradlc_
I_ot e_ ]de-oee,
amendment
axe pumshabl¢
25
fu_t
arg_rnen_
thai - they
20
co_e¢l?
Patle_onthalthe
declatal_on
d_y
Thes_,youwerepr_cm
cm_ find m tab
v, hLch ts submitted
of our knov,
EXAMINATION
yes_lay,
I wouldsay
on m forma|_on
as follows
m yOU;
it dec]aratlon'_
made
Icsufled
you
somehow
The
mdacaled
about
ma'am
v, nlh Mt
a_tomcy
17
talked
am_nthnent
yes,
agree
hereto
._wom,
you
Io
and the
1
a copy,
McCa_
the
seemed
which
Doyo_ha_¢ltwlthyou
16
Pallerson
it declaration
prcilmma_
7
19
MITRAKO$
Mr
the
Mr
McCa_
m Conflict
18
first been
was exanuned
_,_rc
THESZ,
MICHAEL
h_g
right
hns lesilmony
that _h¢ Jensen,
]5
16
th,_'s
Dunng
3 mthcate
aad
_
Yes,
Q
6
note
claim
m¢_s,
Allhough
18
w1_
OO369
I A
by McCavlt's
a_d cla_med
Here
II
sup.vom'd
m the s-_rne paragraph
3
7
zs a_o
under
el
the de_[aratlon
tleanng
10/26/05
Page
369
Page
371
OO371
I of Je_se_
2 m the
3
and McCaVll
prcl munar_
as evidence
lunendmenl
| got _h¢ mlpr _lon
4
that somehow
$
wh,_
6
trut:
7
Q
Why
do you
8
A
Wall,
because
9
cxm'mne_
10
attoracy
11
by ff_e pa_enl
th_
the _rgtancnls
the decl,_al;on
would
was
Mr
saying,
and thai
thai
rely on
[1"1l v, cx¢ tru_
venus
thai
w_lh _hc declaration.
]3
_ould
h_e
Ira:pat
14
McCavll
15
office
16
Q
Is fl',crc anything
17
which
you
18
coml_g
19
_md II?
20
A
21
am_mdment,
22
Clam116
23
palate
24
pulsc_
a_l
25
pu_¢_
ha_ e been
e_ a new
to s_gn aad
_ o_ld
the
that
patenl
r_.nles
m fraxed
I I, the
racap.s
for generaang
rad_a_on
Is dctecled
not actuaang
_he lamp
pamat
a_orr,
pulses
each
aad counting
tmu]
a_ least
w.o
Ileanng
MITRAKOS
which
.*
on the apphcatlon,
patent,
you
arc
you a_e -
on the
9
TItE
COURT
MS
MITRAKOS
16
m fr_'ed
pulse
17
nol _at
10
8
the
Okay
line,
page
SA 287,
number
tad_allon
_
coumed
and
talul
3u_h
suchm_teducesfalsea_tlvaaons_psot
_s not thscloscd
device
t_me
22
II1¢
23
to fcai_ues
or more
24
ms_ctlonn_mual
25
_o me, an that besides
it_t
m _thet
sa_cL
each
lime passn_
cotmlmg
al lea_l lwo
mear_
19
20
s_hnga_the
anome)'
puIs_
d_t_ted
zng th_ lamp
_
ontha_-
the patcrlt
tt_¢an_ for gcneralmg
21
the
pulst_
or mote
reduces
Claim
e
and
p_lses
faJs_ a_t_vaUon
--
Suchafe_re
the instracllon
manual
2
12 _¢
aot
the
f
In addlboa,
Clams
cle_ly
I0
nol thsclosed
] 1 and
or susgest_d
dtre_tcd
in the
Themad&I_onparlofnlca,_betcad
or m _ut_on
Markman
)873
page
Wou_yougoox_thal
Yes,
second
ey sa_d
JA
Its
JA 28?
THEWETNES_
16 r_l[es
370
Honor,
th_n_
15
Page
Whal's
THECOUKT
again
have
p_cbmmar/arr_ndnm_t
You_
tO
top of JA 287,
10/26/05
No
_s pat1 of lab 74
14
cotmted?
Markman
WITNESS
MS
13
9
Not
not on the
TH_
and
lntendefl
Wh_e_teyou_
It's page
7
12
axacndmeat
6
you't_
Exct_emc
6
he
to the parcel
ot to be a pan o[ Cla_m
v, as page
COURT
8
O_fl_claslpa_eofthcp_hmlaary
which
TH_
| rae,_n,
I|
that
for Icnscn
Ihe agphcan_s
_rITNESS
4
somehow
subtmued
THE
_pphcaaon?
whnch
think
m tbe pr chmma_'7
bel_--, ¢ tr_catcs
_o be a feature
declaration
bare
THECOURT
3
precluded
by the
atloraey
I v, ould
1
2
not be
_rgumen_
Ih¢ paten[
agree
would
_s evidence
jt_t
_u_'t
saying
allomey
w v,ot b¢ tra_
the dcclaxaaoa
12
Yes
pa_cnt
made
attorney
P atl_"_ on w_
by the
bchewe
the a_guxn_n_
_ ¢ts'l_
to the
pulse
tleanng
countLng
10/26/05
00372
OO373
I feature,tha¢ ate Other eleanentstn the clmrns thatwere
I
THE
COURT
2 not disclosed or su_c_tr_
2
MS
MITRAKOS
3
3had
The language of the dcclarauon by Icnscn and
4
McCavlt.
the cnucaJ
5
t_ng
6
agcordancc
7
cotmDng
8
g_-,cral
9
or other
I0
prchmmaw
part, wasagmn
di:_o_sl_led
I 1
with
that the ta'g_gy
manual
fcalu_
to reduce
epc_lzon
ly disclosed
and
featmc*
false
clmmed
as recited
mncndincm
interpret
4
THE
COURT
m
5
MS
MITRAKOS
6
THE
COURT
7
TI-I E WITNF_S
did not have
m the
a pulse
of the switch
inseam
m di¢ ulam*a
being
further
swttch
cont¢oI
the instruction
I would
12 same
Inadchtttm.
apphcauon
as amended
8 argument
m the
l0
ha_.e
14
and M cC.av,
rul;cd on
15
atWmcy
16
BY
17
Q
18
they
19
argurmmt?
20
A
21
And thai Is set
22
Q
MS
the statcnxml
over
mdic
any &ffenng
declaration
stateroom
by
by
12
exammer
Jcrd, cn
13
rely on declarations
Y_,
¢xarmncrs
forth
examiners
or evidence
that
over
anc*ney
ale warned thai that ts the case
m the MPEP
Y_s
And
the
ftrst such
evld_cc
where
use the a£h3tlsslon
"i_e argumen_
credence
15
m ttma cII_
18
examinee3
19
of cwdeacc
t$ that oaths
as twtdenc¢
know
20
Q
21
the concepts
cannot
So -- and
take the plz¢¢
thts
soctmn
by die
that mere
Thankyou_
arguments
dOn'l
Doyourec2dlMr
ofclatm
nse
O
Based on your 25 plm years working
24
Title:
Cons,dmmon
24
A
35
25
And-
25
Q
- 35,
Hearing
10/26/05
Page
thseussmg
'_
thank
you for correcting
Mark,
at-
mc -- winking
man
Ilearing
at
10/26/05
Page
373
OO375
I PTO,
do you bcht',
3 A
e it ts appropriate
Well,
4 corm:dy
tint
to aFply
ofall,]
recallthat
Mr
satd thai clmm different,_on
5 th¢lm;guage
Pa[it_'son
c_,nOl
ofthestamteofSectton
But even t f clatm
diffctcmtatlon
7 apply
m thts case, hc saul that pulse cotmtmg
somehow
8 be m Clmm
I, L:_,I he used for an example,
9 specifically
called
out m Clatm
However.
11
Sccuon
12
_
if CImm
I 12, Puagraph
I 3 the specailcat
14
sc_ and
So the scope
15 _
o_e_ondmg
16
[o thai ckment
wtth
18
to the pt_c
19
it doesn't
c.otmtmg
mcled¢
So Clmm
23
The_'$
24
Q
25
re ferrmg
no problem
'Drank yo_
to Clarm
than Claim
cqmvalcnce
"r_efore,
therco
j_t
let diffelent
could
be pulse
you
Thept3nc]plcwouldapp]y
apply
7 cqmvalcno_
thereof
Clmm
I
Were
yOU
6"_
Thaz_you
appllt_,
Ilearmg
10/26/05
Page
374
S¢ctlonll2,
would
have
Clatm
12 would
pulse
cotmtmg
and
and
Just be hm]tM
to the
14
stztletute
Wcha;cnofurdi_questwns
COURT
L_
mc
i_k you. so if 112J6
h"ml you
read into
15
THE
W1TNESS
16
THE
COURT
counting
the beginning
to fred the
the claim
Y_,
-
thafs
nghL
- to perform
app¢2ds
the funOJon"
m the detailed
And
desmpnon
at
o f the patent?
19
THE
WITNESS
20
THE
COORT
21
THE
WI'INESS
22
THE
COURT
23
preferred onbodarnent
24
d_cu_ed
m the detmled
Y_¢.
And
that's
correeL
thai ts the sp¢ctficatson_
YeS, diat's
And
and
ev_
even
though
descnpUon,
di:SGIpqon
nghL
though
die diagram
the thagram
that doesn't
is the
Is
mean
tSJU_t a prcferr_
Markman
JA 0874
1o Claim
para_aph
swim|me
you re fer to the spet:tfiCalton
25 that the detz]led
Markman
they
to
12 than
-
to the corresponding
thereof
THE
13
18
refereed
countmg
I "2 the pulse
diffta'entlauoA
mennoned
Therefore,
t_uvak_x¢
Q
to
your commcn_
6 6 hmdat_ons
actually
Is closer tO Clmm
But
II
counting
Patterson
5 A
12
'_e
Mr
language
4 Q
-
rcfernng
scope
Now.
6, [ think
m
f
|pearled
wlth clmm
3
pulse
5¢op, e
12 _jusI
Claim
l. whmh
10
aler_¢
a_l
No, I think
Clatm
8
12 are
The clmms arc of &ffereat
tbeteof,
coLmtJr_
sm_:tm©
and specifically
I. fm cx=nple,
and eqmvulenc¢
22 be pulse
they refer
to me. t$ of th ff_rent
the cqms
tt was
cou_n
claims
then
otbet
and
1| s©_r_
no1
thereof
clam_s
st_ctare
regard
17
20
cqtuva/enc¢
12,
could
became
to tbe cofreslxmdmg
Claim
did
I A
2
9
I m the c4her
of the
6
12
6, Itrmtatttms,
Izmshxttons refer
ov_nde
112, paragraph
6
I0
tbe concept.*
here?
differenuallcm
2 ofclmm
21
level
Yes, I do
372
00374
- the
to ti_
Pauctson
y_tcrday
differenUatton
A
Markman
arc
and they know
23
argurnents
of
m theMPEP
and declarations
ex;'.mmer,
22
trot one place ts m Sectmn 2145,
an
Other sCCtlOrts of MPEP
But the point
taken
c_¢
a t'ejcctl or=
Wh*ch sccuan o f the MPEP7
rclmnul
says,
is not
m whach
in making
o f course]
in the record
17
argumt_ts
it is an ad_tSSlOn,
Several
ofepphcant's
sceuon
cvIdlL"I_@ I$
23 A
place,
wchave
Okay
to say attorney
may
14
16
IS there a law that IelL_ i:_Uml
that's what
Is thai 88 '_
not replace
on
ewtdence u_s
the paten!
MITRAKO$
should
It go=;
II
to be the
But even ufthatweren't trim,the examiner would
13
dots
that?
Your Honor,
9 nec_ary
filed hta'cwlth
the two state*heroes
DO we have
Ilearmg
10/26/05
Page
375
00376
OO377
I _/xghracnt,
2
tt is, m fagL
the spcoficauon_
WITNESS
Tbe
THE
3
ts tha
¢rillr¢
4
v, bea
I gefer to s'pe_ ficat_on,
5 imtlre
thsclosttt_
ths¢l_m¢
6
except
THE
jUst
THE
9 t, ocaethtng
10
THE
12
not ,nperang
13
r,al¢, not r_ng
14
into
16
rule
I 12, p_agraph
19
cor_espondw4g
21
Tbe
23
hmJtalloas,
4
another
5
patent
'.'-as d_afied
6
to]ust
this one
7
preferred
$
cambodlments
9
skdl
the preforred
fact
the
e,_dmal
embodiment
the so-called
apply
_ath
cardinal
regard
says
be mterpreted
that's
to Section
that
a mearLg
plus
as the
¢ontmned
m the
Solt
that
really
language
role deals
hmaat_otts
ft ts a cardlmd
preferred
specifically
mcotporale
rul_ aboul
9
_
should
stluclure
is msl
m the
the ¢as&nal
spe_tflcaaonandeqmvalen_ctha_eof
22
24
6, which
does
example
embothment
ifm
from
yeah,
- does
Imutatlon
actually
3
the
other
wfth
other types
than
Sect ion
of
I 12, paragraph
6
25
THE
COURT
And
so ft's sull
Markmau
not real
IleaHng
Page
10,'26/05
trying
2
to be a pr efc'ntd
cmbothmcnt
3
claims
4
THE
to r t*tnct
patcaLs
7
they
WITNESS
be used
embodiment
thal this
spc¢lfic
embndt
ldontknov,
thereby
that could
is just
had m mind,
nol to restrict
embo,_ment
cmbndtment,
mere
one
tfther¢_as
appheam
so _s In I_
so they
impl'.ang
called
there
aLso be known
bul the
themsel,.e$
by
It the
may ha other
one of ordinary
m the ar_
THE
COURT
plato
language
of'it,
12
that
-- If you
13
says
a pre fened
look
I mean,
it fooks
at brief
description
--
14
T}IE
WITNESS
15
THE
COURT
16
descnhad
17
accompanying
18
also
t f you jtzst
like they
embodunent
m detad
I_k
at the
are u3qng
oftha
to say
dra_
rags,
it
yes
-- of the present
beremafler
&awmgs
and
invention
with
reference
then
figtu-e
]s
to the
I, 2
A, B, 3
Then
--
19
THE
WITNESS
20
THE
COURT
21
hereinafter,
22
description
of course,
23
THE
24
THECOURT
about
Yes
-- detaded
v, ould
W1TNESS
this era]re
In detml
include
the
detaded
Yes
So lfyou
subject
you
don't
knov,
certainly
anything
could
Markman
376
I think
g
_
9
manufactta'e,
10
prefcrrnd
II
a ntmther
c_e
It works
called
13
_
ft the
n'r. ctlllon
!5
that you
only,
sho_
ha_ e to look
to find
functions
20
ffs
Onea
cmbothmcms,
ts the pre fcrrnd
e* reason
they
t_
thsclosed
I think
you know,
ed
and
cmbod]mem
to
corazdet
one,
with
can
In these
It the
at tho_
stntcttn¢
and they
_n mtenl
to the
encompass
to 03, to
fact
the
thal your
cXagl strdctt_e
tv.o figmes.
you ges to So:tton
r_tnd
The
only
bit to not be beld
But wh_m
19
they
pit fened.
tt a httlc
18
- I think
or it's the cbeapest
or fm _ kat_
2
to all the
description,
read that to
Iteanng
I 12, par agraph
hmRatloRs,
what
m the chaclosme
th©y are
6. you
- you
that performs
ha_ e
the
m the claim
only sl)a_ture
21
pate'hi
ts m figures
22
hrmtmtotLs
would
23
_es
of figm¢
24
thereof
disclosed
2A and
have
2A
2B
m this particular
SO, ob_lously,
to be read
and
tbe clasm
on the corrcsponchng
2B but tben
an eqmvalcnce
10/26/05
Page
377
THE
WITNESS
4
THE.
COURT
5
THEWITNESS
6
often
7
contains
8
make
9
d_cnbed
-- I mean,
COURT
But ft also
Markman
ts descn'ocd
Iteanng
m tl_s
10,,'26/05
Yes
narrative
description
That'snghL
And
the case,
too,
both
a v, Tatten d_.mptton
tt cleareT
so that you can
follow
COURT
ft's yore
THE
v_bethcr
the pulse
12
I guess,
,._hather
13
detection
14
thee
the
of
WITNESS
COURT
17
THEWITNESS
18
THE
COURT
21
pulse
cotmt
doesn't
is became
does
THE
"v_ITNLSS
23
THE
COURT
MS
MITRAKOS
that we've
JA 0875
It; part
cited
cffCUlt
of the
_ hlchaver
of
--
"/es
-- of this
patent?
Yes
Tharsnght,
And
the
reason
'_ork
ot prevent
12 when
n[ eqm'.
That
YomHon_
that
Claim
not mclnde
22
of law
circuit
cla*m
THE
interpretation
count
that
or clrcmL
mechanism,
THE
of thfferenttatlon
postl_on
Or box
to
bemg
or the control
16
19
also drawings
what's
tt ]s a pari of each
15
20
structtm:
pulse
mechanism
tt'_, a part
And
coont
that the patent
and
the docWam
that
tt talks about
the
alence9
s cotTect
Okay
yotaHonor,
m om
bnefwbet¢
Markman
Page378
count
Y_
I t's m the
It's often
11
25
of the pulse
porlton
24
THE
the inclusion
3
10
14
16
apply
of dt ffcrcm
of them
the best
In tlus case,
12
it was
I detmled
dcscnpuon
ts_hathewasdomg
v.lB dcsc_be
will say that
the detailed
t.hal v, ouldn't
rcallytheothcrv.ayaround,
6
25
that mlght
is "_
Pre fened
OO379
I be the apphcanl
17
embodiment
WITNESS
11
25
cleat
0037S
5
THE
l0
about
the -
as a whole
imply
fun¢laon
20
from
WITNF_S
I$
whafs
a preferred
So
c.a.se
elements
17
I mean,
'...hal
2
claims
thoa
Whal
things
doesn't
whal
to me
patem
clatrpa
m the speclfieauon
m tlus
COURT
THE
to the
The preferred
dJr_mbed
the structure
15
o f the
the thagram?
dcsc_paon
11
thal's
Wall,
WITNESS
that's
dc_qcd
maial you get
for the
COURT
7 cmbodn_enI,
S
up
I
speclficahon
d_re'salsoabody
the federal
Hearing
10/26/05
Page
379
O0380
00351
I cnctut has said the jud_clallycreated docmn_
of claun
I plebe
2 thfferentmhon jtxs[
cannot tn.u_p the apphcatton of I 1216
2
MR
3
THE
3
TIIE COURT
4
MS
5
THECOURT
6
MR.
HIGGIHS
7
MS
MITRAKOS
8
MR
HIGGINS
COURT
Any qtu_tiora9
MITRAKOS
9
No
Cz'o_s?
5
Leave thatup. plea.se
You want ttup_
for the fedcralclrCullon October
HAGGINg
TIIE COURT
Q
Good
allranocm.
Mr
Thesz.
I[
12
A
Good
aflemocft,
Mr
Hlggms
12
BYMR
13
Q
When
you say
that the cardm_
role thai
14
talking
does
apply
112/6cl=ms,
15
famdlar
16
lntm'aclAccesso,ocs,
17
federal
ctrctut
on October
18
A
I don't
recalhl
19
Q
Okay
10
lnc
ha_e
Q
court
vs
15
to I }736. "Second,
16
ofa
3, 2005?
the name
oftt
agmn7
Do
I
You don't
ha_e
tt yet Ix-cause
and we'll
pul thts m om clo_mg
COURT
I wc_ld
it
tm_on.ow,
Honor
25
hke
Markman
to have
a tomght,
Itearmg
Page
[t'sm_,L_'tlt,Mr
2 o'g sul_mtlcd
Thc_.,thatwbenyou
your
rtdc 12 slatcmenl
3 toDr
Ma_engdl,
4
A
Y¢_,
5
Q
So how
d_d you know
6
rule
12 statmaenl
what Dr
7
was?
g
A
Are
thai youhad
that sotmd
fromtlus
ft_ctlons
rather
than
independent
of any
hka an appheatlon
of the
bere '_
Mr
]tlgglra,
thcre'snothmgtobe
Heha.sn'treadth_scase.
Thas_sa
poml
MR
HAGGINS
Y_;,verywell
HAGGINS
I sultemenl
not spoken
2 him be fore he
3
Heanng
10/26/05
Page
381
Mazseng_l_
mforrned
by cotmsel
you aware
atat whenDr
that
you wine
al sevmal
Wepa_ng
tedmlcal
whal
5
opinion
hts pontoon
MassengJql
points
your
w_._
m thai
stateraenl.
A
Yes,
Now,
13
Q
14
Masser_ll
15
your oplmon
16
D_
=f yuu
before
MS
of thak yes
had ne_ cr commtmlcated
you
filed yore
on the stalt'me_l
rule
wtth
12 stale_ent,
Dr
how
thd
of the law get ¢orm'ntmlcated
[o
M1TR.,_OS
ObjectJon,
yc_rHonc_
Speculation
19
THE
COURT
20
MS
MITRAKOS
21
aqt,:st_onthafs
22
fofDr
THECOURT
Excuse
me?
Calls
foespoculaaOtL
That's
Massen_ll
Sust_ne_
Where
arc you gomg
thts?
24
MR.
that Dr
HAGGINg
M_._'ngtll
MR
7
mo.e
rches
The
point
on Dr
Markman
here,
- exettsc
Yore
Hone¢,
me, Mr
Hearing
Is
8
BY MR
9
Q
10/26/05
HAGGINS
and
page
wcr_ provided
Vcr/well,
4 of your
reasonable
YoutHonor
statement,
you
for Heath
to draft
35 U S C
laIked
13
todo
with re_p¢ct
14
A
NO
15
Q
You
16
tbereal3er
the holthng
17
thereallm
the PTO
18
_h
In a manner
19
I.nltatlon_
had
20
A
Y_
21
Q
SO after 1994,
22
thff_ently,
23
A
o_glnal
Tbey
appateatly
w_th anybody
I*ll
topara_aph
c_te tbe
been
ca_e,
_eqmred
what
_md state
case w_
to mt:rpret
thffercttt
for many
the patent
o/0ce
You
intended
that
thai
35 U S C 6
from the way
mteq3reled
6
tl'_.
aot,&dyou7
1994,
of the Donelson
have
claJms m
p_-agraph
about
112/6or
Donetson
was
say it would
Scctloa 112,
al Heath
yca_.
apphed
those
con¢cO
I 12/6
corrcCl?
Dt ffer¢_ltly
Okay
than It had
been
previously,
yes
Doyourccallthefihngdaleofthe
palCnl for
the "955 patent?
Markman
JA 0876
to
12 statement
HAGGINS
At
never
25
Page382
So?
theU pcopl©
12
24 Q
_s
bul be neA'er talked
h_s nile
on
I0 been entirely
M_tmglll7
17
COURT
by
I I _ecordance wxth
15"naware
12 SuMfmfffll
fired or subm]tled
THE
mformatlon
6
filcdh_
In his rule
vlee-ver$_
4
when
on you?
12
wsth
dt:.t_n'l
flied
coffecL
12 statmnenl
I I he reh¢_
23
rcsp_t
the
clatrns
meaning
rule m a ] 12 s,tuaUon
MR
BY
wtth
'by importing
Markman
cortCCl7
tha_
I v._
9 Q
18
legal
TheY_z, the
said
OO383
I Q
ndc
23
errs
for their
380
OO382
I0
gamed
that
Mr
c]rcmt
into the specific
THECOURT
22
to be doing
embodm_enl'"
Carthnal
25
10/26/05
a courl
device
Now,
24
THE
for the federal
the clama
working
20
I'm going
10oftheshpoplmon,
wofkrng
21
HAGGINg
c,lan¢ out,
Yore
Atpage
of appeals
17 rcathng
18
What's
HIGGINS
13
the
3, 2005
we'lljusl run a copy
HIGGINS
14
19
MR
24
MR
been
, Incozporated
Maybe
bccau.se--
areyou
tt?
22
23 jusl
v,e've
whtchw_ajusttxmzedby
THE COURT
21
Kmerlmses
Enterpmes.
It'sc_cnt_nber04-1410tssuedbythe
BY MR.
case oflVW
ItIsJVW
8 Court of Appeals
9
112-to
HAGGINS
7 thesl]poplmon
II
20
25
MR
I0
with the
tbe cltatlonand wc'll
6 Incorporated vs Interac[Accessories. Inc All wc have is
Yes
r_
I'IIglve zltoy(re.
Give me
4 pull it.
Okay
CROSS-EXAMINATION
aboul
HIGGINS
Ilearmg
10/26/05
Page
383
OO384
00385
I A
I think I ha_,c •
2 Q
lf[j_tteByoulfs
3
A
Th_
so_ds
4
Q
Why
don_ you confirm
5 A
It*s July
6
Q
Okay
7
the cl_n_
8
wmdd
9
say m yore
1 v, as av, a:¢ of Donelson
nght
29,
b_
[]l be glad
bee_
tn the apFhcahon
bas_
repoth
_
cerrect
A
I'rosony
DeCtSlonbywhom_
By Heath,
_o _¢
12
A
A_ you potnted
13
filed July 29,
t4
creat_q_ttca_plash,
]5
01at FTOhad
16
c_ae
1994
clatms
Donelson
should
h,_a'le
Donelson,
I behe_
e, m abuel
filed
_t|
23
7
A
3
_,_
9
Q
I0
goldclmcs
¢hdn'l
go into
fl
A
No,
/ sam
the palent
12
Q
I'm sorry
13
12 statement
you say
[4
could
rccogmze
15
that no spezlfic
16
of the legal tmphcahons
17
corwey
13
paragraph
19
A
apphcat_o_
20
behc_
the_ _
did no_
21
_
apphcanon
_ a_
which
actvzIly
bucausettch_gdth¢,._ay
or $o
guldehn_
me_s
c_c
lheheve
as to how
plus fonctton
April
..__
m July of _994,
J_ua_.y
or, c you
o f 1994
examme_
tssue
But when
deosmn,
v. c carr_ out wl_
]9
was
I buh_
Q
man_
rot 40._c_s
18
21
A
6
t.:'w_ t_
m a ccrtmn
lthmk
om m February
22
o_
out, tbu onglr_
The
hecnope_tmg
And
5
t_t
_
Q
20
please?
fo_ the '066 patent
a d_._l_
10
Tn© Fro,
Q
4
tsfftlt,
II
!7
3
to look at it
1994
pre_cnted
bare
ha_c
it7
Sod'senm¢lyr_onabl¢
and _e
claJms
the
affe_
o_ f.o of 1994
- the original
'066
_t_at
of 1997
So tl seer_
_o m(: thee
24
v, hfle tht_ patent
25
I h.v.enov*ayofkno_mgwhe_
w_
wa_
pc_dmg
at _e_t
thr_c _.c_.r_
that Donelso_
Hearing
3,
And
10/26/05
Page
the final
gu_dchnes
¢ they
Well,
clearly
changed
effect
of 1994
b_tcally,
pubhca_)on
_mtd
_ssued
1997 "_
8 _fyour
Of _chnaxy
that _cture
_Lq.'ct ur ¢ w_
dccJsJ_
m 1997
At page
that one
so it
of the
thai the examiner
I mtsunde_ztc_I
was
bcmg
of rule
m the at1
bang
cla_med
recited
11216
rote
skdl
but
i_ Lh_l panl
that you
AI the top, sir
mt or,tied Io
Tt'.¢ bndgmg
at the top
_ think
that's a comment
¢ one
of or thrk_V
I don'l
know
he could
m April
when
effect_
you say
M_scngdl
Well,
23
mto effect
the law
upon
I he_xd
to Dr
to Dr
go Into
immcthataly
I thought
_.ent
v, c_c pubhshed
dtd they
the court
m effect
22
25
but he should
bccn
skill
by me ¢_ what
In the arl co:rid
if thai was ncce_av/to
Massengdl
I would
imagine
I
do
be
conveyed
that hc wotdd
know
_ hal
do
24
_ as m cffcct
_cpr_cu_ngattome
Markman
m nol specifically
2
1994-
TIlE
m here
COURT
hc says
that
Is tt y_r
he conveyed
384
posttton
thai somc_
tnformatlon
to Dr
Marlonan
Hearing
hae
10/26/05
Page
385
Page
387
OO337
00386
I Massertgl[l?
2
Because
I mtssnd
MR_ HIGGINS
3
to "t_:r.om© more
4
e_c_r_j_tal]om_
clear
yore
wl_-n
THECOLIRT
6
BY
MR
7
Q
8
the declaraaon
9
well
l0
A
Ye_, s'_
11
Q
1s tt yore
12
tbuse
13
A
it
I
Honor,
v, eha_e
Okay
hhmk
Dr
it s going
Masscngdl's
Allnght
[_gc
welds
9 ot'yo_
hc_e,
m_e
12 statement,
and you have
opmton
that
m formanon
3
Q
4
thai need
you
got tt m _s
_h¢ ex re'rimer
set fonb
exhlbt
t as
under hned
m the --
think that hts intent
to anybody
else
I f the exammer
cerlam
6
MPEP
fo_ tbaL
7
A
Yes
8
Q
9
And,
lO
E_hthl_
believes
clmms,
isn't
Hor_t,
THECOORT
12
THEWITNESS
Q
unclear
17
the MPEP
section
says
18
way
on the
nght-bund
19
A
What
20
Q
130o-14
21
exeTctSe
22
the file h_stoq*
23
When
24
cxamm_
25
the reasons
17
Q
_d
I hehevr
th_
tt's most
Do you knov,
18
A
No
19
Q
Is tt yore
_0
mtcndedtomd_cal©
21
_
22
A
23
the exa_amer
24
making
25
allow
_ho
oplmon
&d that
thai
Lhe
tbut that tmd_hnmg
the
ts
reasor_
_h_
the
the ¢lgums'_
I Ilunk that underhmng
as he read
dectsmn
the paterit
underhmng_
to the publ_:
allowed
h_
I_ely
thai.
w_s
through
on ,,_heth¢_
most
hk¢ly
the doctm_ents
to alloy,
done
by
be fore
the clalros
hem m
and to
to i_oe
iarkman
Ilearmg
10/26/05
Page386
Section
1302
ldo
14_
14 ts cnuded
Ycs,
Reasor_
_
that'sconect
For
Aflowanc¢
HIGGIN$
So if the exmmr,¢*
as a whole
down
heheved
as to why
thai the recmd
he was
at the -
column
was
alfov* mg certain
about
three-fourths
cbams,
of the
-
page7
"lttsmctmth_mtuponthcexamtner
hts ot her resportm'blhty
xs as complete
an apphcaUon
is expected
is finally
as reasonably
acted upon
to deto_nme
why the apphcatlon
to
to the pubh¢
to see thai
Ix_ss_l¢
and alloy* nd, the
at the sara¢ 0me
ts being
lVlarkman
JA 0877
1302
to -- it's now
Do,_oubaveacopyofthat
Yes,
16
ex_trnme_
go:tton
I hehev¢,
yeah
13
Ye_,
16
tn the
37
II
BYMR
- declarauon_
wh> the examiner
procodute
MPEP
/_PEP
A
htrm_lf
the-re are reasons
a spetaal
I'm tefernng
14
Q
that
than
there_
[3
15
other
tO the pubhc
And isn't that _¢
Yo_
to convey
that
there's
Y_.
14
was
probably
to be commtm_cated
S allowed
HIGGINS
At
I don't
2
allowed
Ileanng
arc
whether
ex idem
10/26/05
00388
1 fromthcreconl"
Doyouseethat,
2
A
Yes
3
Q
Are you f.uggestm8
4
pomor_
5 place
No,
foat'$
when
prc_ecutmn
I1 tl_re's
no need
12
Q
And
13
&d you prepare
14
A
m th_
Q
16
_
17
"apphc_uon',
Q
Why thd you not consider
II
A
WeII, the
]2
threfted
13
fealm_
tha_ you
have,
19
Q
O_ manual
20
A
Well,
21
thlTcrent
22
wo_d
be included
23
Q
Well,
24
a dtscl_me_
for the interpretation
25
pulse
is m ew-ry
[f you can
HIGGINS
see?
rm sony
Can you see it7
I think
MR. HIGGEsIS
I can
- I can
see
May
I bnng
il clc_
to him,
HonOr?
Markman
Hearing
10/26/0'3
Page
Q
Okay
4
thepub¢_tmg.
because
Thafs
I'm sorry, ] thdn't
6
Q
WeB, yottr
7
_'s
a dLsclalm_
8
deciara_on,
and paruculady
9
und_mcd,
cor;_'_
Io
A
the e_'mner
m_t
follow
optmon
3 you know,
4
cotmtmg
that
--
are
THE
COURT
14
THE
',&fITNESS
THE
COURT
Slatrm_n!
17
made
of rr_sor_
the reaso_
That's
THE
WITNE.SS
THE
COURT
Ix_mc_
not needed
20
THE
W1TNF_S
21
THE
COURT
22
BY
23
Q
24
as part of tFas dcclaralion
25
argument
tha_ the
because
_
of the point
Exactly,
And -
tmderhmng'_
colTect
for the allowance
19
of the
Yore
rcgaxdless
E.x_ctly,
Yore
decliner
what claims
the
Well,
9
b_mg
wu
Honor
thscusscd
on'_
Markman
Heanng
10/26/05
they
for yo_.
pulse
Q
coun_nll
14
12 of the tssucd
15
A
If you
Page
390
20
clasm
21
manual
the thscu._lon
Page
391
me
to the
dunng
16 was
of Clmm
was the one
tl_
claim that
16, which,
l
thai had the specific
if I'm not n'_laken
feaim¢,
as well
thai Clatm
16 bccam©
Claim
p 'a_m7
I think
I rem_r_ber
my question
thai dis¢'usslon,
toyou.
Mr
cotmimg,
your opinion
_3d
yes
Th_tstJ_at
why _ot both
Is only
to be
of them,
mcorpoiat
whyno_
if
and
that pulse cotmung
cd into cve_'y
ptdsccounung
a_d
ovemde?
22
A
23
manual overndc
I don'l
think
24
that that's
25
Q
an ts_uc
WclL
I w_
asked
was inclMed
Io cord:d_
m thts par_cular
I'm llomg
v, hethe_
in these clmrra
I don't
knOW
matter
to return now to the Or Other
Markman
JA 0878
3ll9
SO the
_knd
to refer back
that Claim
Do you rcr.'_ember
Wen,
Page
are of lecord,
amendmem
are
I have
d_cussion
al that I_e
13
10/26/05
fih:d at the sa_ne time
prehmma-.y
what
thai
by the anomey'_
| 't_m_nb_
12
so that
Hearing
m_d the claims
in the
creates
lenns
DO I unde_md
do you remember
argued
in a
but iI
I suppose
of claun
w=
am_mknalt,
testimony
co_ errd
ts that th_s d_clarauon
declarauon
determine
or other
t'pociflc_lly,
claim?
19 tS the tCn_ that iS _t_quircd
of tmdcrlmmg7
or _s part of the altomey
_
portion
oplmon
to hsl them
Patte_on'=
18 poise
Honor
v. ere bong
coffec[_
I think, was
features
17 this declaraoon Isdiscussing both manua_ ovcmde
clear'_
MR. HIGGINS
that occurred
Q
16 Q
on
Okay
NOW, do you know
either,
that were
8 Mr
I I behev_
It'syo_
18
file histow
7
IOA
Thal*s
w_
6
Thcd_claxmer_sbecauscof
Not because
m emdc
in other feature,
your
_s I can
now
m the declaralton
corr_CL
13
answer
5 nghl
ts saJd m the
the poruort
that was used
underlined
that quesuon.
o f what
counong
thffercnl
thai the
w ith the mstrucuon
pulse
ovcmde,
- if I may
dcrnon._waled
etther
manual
thing,
as saying
testm_
in accordance
&d not have
I llunk
was
no4 Io other
Markman
toyo_corrccf_
_ thai pulse
_
Wcll,_sc_rccl
I I the language
16
swttch
2 as a prehmm_y
And th_'s
5 A
15
the furthe_
control
counl
00391
I A
3
it -
388
0O39O
1 colz¢_t7
Yes
read that sentence
feat_r_
of it
w_th the word
importam?
I think,
m the cl_
I would
m_nual
slo_
words
made,
feature,
18
and portlovs
and then I see -
A
being
p_d$¢ cOUnhng
recited
those
thai w_
17
THE WI_S
2
to the
point
© so
tmderlmnd,
On to Say _o_
it do_
cmrect7
"13tE COLrRT
12
Yes,
il go_
iI?
energy
21
Your
I0
_app]icatlon"
doesdt
16
MiL
25
_dlowcd,
the word
fcaixacs',
9 A
°
HIGGtNS
A fl_
14
but the hlf, hhf_ung
THE COURT
24
YourHonor
8 other
Is being
see i[ now
Yes
a]lowecL
the
MR
HIGGINS
paraphrase
19
a;_llca0on
THE COURT
7 Q
no
20
23
flora
on the cxMblt
of iI are
I belie_
MR
5
6 BY
fo_ _dlowance
po_on
4
15
Po_Jor_
22
it's clear
I can ce_a_nly
my
thts exhibit7
h_hhghw.d,
[g A
was being
the application
for rease_
the
Yes,
you.
in thCl
What
declarauoo
apphcaoon
why
NOt pc:_on,_iy,
15
tn that
the - when
record
takes
Sine
THE WITNESS
3 Thank
for allov, anced7
rm _gcstm&
why tl_
o f certain
declara_on
of re_ons
nol whal
it clear
And
I0
and Jonson
statengm
ts that the s_ls
$ thd make
9
that the tmderhmng
of the McCa_lt
7 opinion
THE COURT
2
of actual
6 A
00389
I
str?
Iteanng
10/26/05
00392
I Featut_p_lofthtsd_clatatlorL
2 y_
thaithe dec Larams beheved not only thaim;mual
3 override w_.s thffere_tm the appbed
for clanns and pulse
4 counting was &ffermt
for clmms
5 the Nippon
6 A
in the apphed
8 encompass
Q
tssued
after
3
the attoraey,
4
A
Yes
5
Q
Now.
6
the pending
7
A
I bcb_e
8
Q
Doyou
9
Claam
I 1 became
compared
_tcq_e7
II
the mp pa_graph
And you
mcntton
The lasl senteno_
13
a.s to the nonmanual
14
I I and
adduDon,
¢1¢_f_
17
language
II On page
o f that
I 0 of pa_
paragraph
o, ernde
the patent
clazms
cktrrns
aRorney
2, 10,
nol d_c]_ed
And
says
r_porl
20
A
Yes
21
Q
Now.
II
zgso¢ in thts
12
Q
13
quote--
cIalras
stud
- m
the
2
I O.
l I and 12 are directed
in _
I don't
up
appbeauor_
frc_
the
that
24
accepted.
25
a..mmdmcnt
pros_uUon
was accepted
16
repo/19
and
specific
by the
argtmleal
that
the -
afl_
THE
you
WITNESS
patent
Hearing
to the patent
exammex
Where
see what
you
_tth
are
you "_ I'm on page
quoting
Page
10
I 0 ofh_s
HIGGINS
sentence
Page
10ofhlsreport.
thcvcl3_
of the lop paragfaplt
THE
exal_llncr
COURT
"When
and public
MR
after
a patentee
edv_$es
the
HIGGINS
patent
igs_e
?
"That's
nol at the top of my page
10
YourHonor
Tllb
Anybody
COURT
Ifs at the top of my page
10
else got page I0_
25
_ssued
10/26/05
Page
TIlE
_ ITNESS
I'm sorry
Markman
392
THE
COURT
I have
Hearing
Page393
10/26/05
IL
10ofyour
I see .._here
pl_me'_
THE
COURT
Let's
MR.
HIGG1NS
Hcmor
patenl
be means,
I'll find
2
BY MR
HIGGINS
but can
3
Q
Do you
4
A
Yes
5
Q
Now.
6
aopenthx,
7
You
whal
I would
rather
do
-
apphcanl
may
ha_ e that.
str'_
iI
if wc
can go back
to page
277
of the Joint
go back
I think
THECOLrRT
lstlunderC
d_sclaun
that's
agxee
the beglrmmg
wzth
of the prehmma_
aracndment
tha1_
8 A
Y_
9
Q
And
I0
amendment,
II
A
12
Q
13
w_th
14
A
t5
Eegm
16
Q
Imsorry
lmlsspokc
17
called
Remarks
In youx
l$
patent
pracotlonex,
the Remarks
19
where
the atlomey
is pointing
20
why
21
A
22
the amendment
23
the claim
24
Q
25
second
whereltsaysa
a panic
page
287
ts the
I_l
pomon
of the prehmmary
ul.xr clazm
are
v. c ag_eed_
mtexptelaaon'_
THE
12
W1TNESS
No.
THECOURT
you
are looking
14
b_.
_ actually
16
pauml,
17
from
al the d¢cl_alzon
contained
and I would
m the
I_c
12. ycah
20
_u._
o_ erade
22
ftrst
paragraph
blR
Is page
and
THE
COURT
MR
II forint
I v.am
prosecuuon
okay
to go
"zour
hlsto_
to refer to the
Okay
Thai
Yes
And
at page
284
of the joint
appenthx,
that begins
And
Remarks'l
of the
pa_culat
yes.
thafs--v.all
the_c
LSa--
the
page
doesn't
Honor
_x]th Remarks
but there
_s a s¢ctzon
utled
Yes
there'sasectzon
experience
as a patent
Remarks
page
lthmkyouazeatthetop
s_mtrac¢,
clazms
hov.e_
Whexe
this _
H1GG1NS
er. _
ts al the top of page
on thclopofpagc
HIGGINS
JA 287.
D
exaxamer
and
of an grnendmenl
ts
to do that
THECOURT
of my pase
under
or the reporf_
Whcrt
aplxmthx
19
ofthc
nt
Thal'spagc
HIGGINS
the 3omt
18
25
I I
at
patent
the
Doyouha_epag©
language,
I1
24
Clmm
that ate
v. _s
ulumalgly
read thai
8
23
12 became
the ones
R'pOa7
7 Yom
21
is raying
COURT
know
00395
I
6
15
are
the prehmmar/
the dccl_ralzon,
THECOURT
5
13
claims
those
mattcx
MR
last
22
if that
I knov.
3
I0
10 beeameCla_mg,
Claim
hJsto17
9
know
Markman
9
Clmm
I O. and
com_'_
argument
wash'tit
I don'l
Claim
to features
ins_cllon
24
4
6 m
correct
altothat
I think
THE
15
23
2
that's
So the altomey
21
O0394
I
Claim
2 became
case _
m
20
exaxrantr
that Claim
_ssued
know
"I _.
19
A
>ou recall
"However
amended
mexely
of sugg_led
) ou pick that
of the patent
23
do
A
17
22
exRro -- by
_
-- m the
I 0
18
19
conect
by the
rn_nu_l"
IS
llandl2
tTymg to
14
12.
]6
10
and argttmenl by the
to
It'snol
let's look at some Specific
I0
15
andspeetficallyClauns2
that stal(-melR
_ e_/un_
wen,
12
Well.
2
r_ferenc_bul also other fcatu_es_
Thalsecmstobcwhati_sayzng
7 referringtospecificclaims so zfs,I suppose
9
OO393
1 Q
Doesn'tthalm&cat¢Io
al tab
section
things
oul to the exarnln¢_
to tha:
12
the
end
ceet_ln
c[mr0.s
y es. that's
are allowable
v. hcre
correct "t
the artoraey
or whoever
ts fihng
12
I arn m the joint
aplxmchx
or the paper
should
as makm
be alloy, cd and
thc
8 ht_ argots
apphcatlon
as to why
tssue
74
And
at page
287 of the joint
it says.
"In adthtlon
appenthx,
al the
Okay
Do you
Markman
have
page
llearmg
hne.
Chum
16 recztes
means
JA 297"_
10/'26/05
Markman
Page394
JA 0879
Heanng
10/26/05
Page
395
00396
| for
gcncvaUng
puZs_
e'_h
2
ts d_ected
and counun
OO397
time p._l_,
e m fr_ed
taxation
8 _he puJ_.es and not actualmg
3 lampun_lallca_;twootmorepuls_haveocour_-_
4
meam;reduces
¢lth_
6
dev_cett_clf"
7
A
Y¢_
Do
$
Q
And Claim
9
tanc _
10
Claxm
16 aJIowable._
II
A
Yes.
12
Q
Clmm
13
14
manual
nor
m tha
you see 0_17
t6 ts the claim
the attorney
ts argtartg
tha_ _ pending
that pels©
at the
cc_.mtmg
the patent
omc¢
allowed
by the attorney
makes
patent
office
accepted
.rust
5
sayno
6
Q
And you say that because7
7
A
Because
8
by .Iensen
9
have
consldl_ed
as evidence
whether
hexe.
12. C_TeCI?
13
A
poruon
A
Yes
14
Q
And the nonporUon,
15
Q
Th© _omey
15
goes
16
"In ad_'a_,
16
A
Yes,
Et do_
17
feat_cs
17
Q
And
tho_e othe_
18
i_lrtetlon
18
Claims
19
A
mak_
futth_"
2. 10,
I I and 12 arc &rcctcd
C_m_
clearly
not d_elosed
manual,
arsument
a..ld says ,
or suggested
to
m tha
_ correct?
Yes
20Q
Th© attc_ey
21
12 are patentable
22
A
Y¢_
23
Q
The
24
nol'P
25
A
ts argmng
over
patent
thai Clam_
tha Nippon
office
2, | 0, I I and
rcfcrcnce,
ar.cepted
coffccl7
thai argmnc_t.
I think v.e are - I a_
answered
Markman
&d it
that questl_
Hearing
10/26/05
Page
p_honS
2,
before
him
a decL_rauon
have
been
They
could
Q
And
th_e
21
Io.
I[ end
I I of the _ued
23
A
24
questton
25
the patent
(eatures
d_sn'l
would
po_Jort.
it?
be expressed
m
they?
be. y_
olher
features
as expressed
'066 palenL
conccdy,
Claims
2,
6.9.
10and
Isn't that COtTeC_
lflund¢_tandlha
all ycu'rc
eonlamed
in Claln_
and lssucd_
Igu_s|wotddhavetoagre©
_kmg
me _s tfthc
claims
the feat urea thai are conlamed
396
Markman
00398
h_ghhghled
the mmhl_ldJghted
features,"
12wereaIlowed
22
in
c_ nol.
sn"
10. II and 12. wouldn*t
19 A
*- he would
to con_ldsr
is ._ haJ we have
"or other
20
to
of it?
of d, y_.
on Io say.
have
he would
the claims
And thai d_ctarahon
correct,
-- it had
in the form of
I would
that he had
to allow
Q
as Clann
had
which
12
and _ucd
that argument.
the ex_mllncr
and McCavtt
II
allo_,ed
wl_th_
Solo_kmclfth¢
4
I 0 d¢cadmg
;6 was ulumate_y
the claims
and tt had evlderlce
3 adeclarat*onbyJer6enandMcCavtL
Suchafeaturets
m tha tr_truct_cm
II -
2 argum_t$
Such
falseacuvauonse_t
5 nol ch_]_r_cd
I
the
Hearing
of
m
10/26105
Page
397
0_399
I thoseclmrns,
andthea_verwouldbcyc_,ofcotr_
2
Q
3
w_re bern8 d_,cussed
4
Isn't thai co_u_t'_
3
A
6 $m¢
And tho_
w ould be _ong
m the Jcnsen
Idon'lknowyc_rbas_
of are ob_ zou_ly
8 Q
Well,
why _e
for saylns
recited
_ca_'_"
m the J_-a
and McCa_lt
A
Pm not tgnormg
m3y words
II
Q
You
chose
And y_u
14
you called
15
A
Yes_
16
Q
Now,
17
3 A
No. I don'l thatk I m_taled
5 to puts© counung."
l'mnc_
fcatm_
nc_ Io hlghhghl
cbo_
nol to make
dcch_at_on?
9 Q
Now.
them7
|1
THE
12
MILHIGGINS
part of the declaration,
_
c_e¢l?
_n two pax_
Say. "1 have
¢onsl_
whether
18
t_ rca._vably
co_
19
ttmltcd,"
20
hralted
by tha mca_
21
A
Y_,
22
Q
Isn't ii coff¢cl
23
apphed
24
claim?
25
A
further
wh_e
or not McCavlt*_
to me_m that all pcndu_
plus ftmet_on
_
znIcrpr etalt on. corr¢cl?
language?
©lemem
that's
by clemcnl
rather
pht_ functton
than
to an chute
Hearing
only
pendm8
10/26/05
Page398
WITNESS
Well.
sa_d m the declarauon,
oftha
Tha_'swhalthere_t
I beheve
ll's beCaL_e of
and I _¢d
to explain
my
words of the declatat_o_
HIGGINS
19 Q
You're
20 A
Ho. I'm nol an expel
no_ an expert m granm-._,
21 Q
Pno_ to your mvolvemenl
E_ements
ere you?
m th_s c_e.
have you of
of Gramma_O
23
A
I d_n'; recall
24
Q
And _sn'l l! correcE thai Io interpret the phrase
25
_ you wish the corn1 to interpret
Markman
JA 0880
as a matter
ts all about, yom g_tmmahcaJ
22 read _he book Shlrtzer
_
conect
Markman
THE
18 BYMR.
were
thay're
I see tha_ svatenc¢
that mem_
would
thaf_
clmrn even though
thai Ih_; ts becau_
Grammar
14
17 underslandm8
cl_'_
and v.hath_
c_ms
I think
A matter of _ hat?
o f that paragraph
16 what w_
you
COURT
13
15
ct Cetera, do you see that.
you beheve
IO of grarcanar7
contmtung
of pulse counlmg.
to the whole
cl_ns"
cla_m._ were lumled
8 one clcraenl of thai e_um may have pulse ¢oLmtm 8 _n IL
m Iha_ dcdarat_o_
_
"pen&rig
I mean thai all pending
7 fmr to say with regard
"c_ oth¢_
that par_ of yore
the word _pendsng
I say, "Al_ pending
6 include the hrmtabon
of the
co_'cl
_t, _mportam
Y_,
dcclaranon.
that
The
the wor_
10
Q
So Is this - you JUSZmisstated
2 claxras" here?
th_
m the clanr,_
you ignc*_ng
9
13
and McCav_t
you are making.
7 clm_
Tha_
featurc_
4 The clam_s -- when
whal ¢h_nca_n
12 A
I Q
the o_¢_
d. you have to act tutlly
Hearing
10/26/05
Page
399
OO4OO
I
tmport
OO401
tbe word
gmeEally
mto
the sentmce
where
1
tl doesn't
2 actudv: appc=',
3
A
No,
4
Q
Well.but
5
don*l mean
I don't
think you have
ts'n'lthat
v.hat
A
I think that's
phrase
that's tn that declaramm,
tt to explain
Q
I0
how
actually
14
A
you make
stud should
!6
Q
m'en'!
chd be'_
A
No.
]9
Q
So m order
20
that _t.
22
A
mttfWet
24
declaral_on
say.
into what
"So
4
thls_
you are
McCa_
the exact
McCavlt
it
actually
yt*
use the word
"generally"
it as you wL_h it to be
to import
that second
"gencTally"
into
ytm'_
I_asexplmnmghowl
v,_rds
that
ii wash
t necc_my
tbete to tmderstand
v.hat
are
m the McCa_t
for me
to tnsert
it
be was saying
Markman
Hearing
MR
Your
h_6 to dectdc
IIIGGINS
what
I have
no
pomt
the grammar
further
is fo_
questtom
Honor
7
TIIECOLrp.T
$
MS
Okay
MITRAKOS
Anyredlrect_
Short
REDIRECT
rethrect
Your
Honor
EXAMINATION
MITRAKOS
11
Q
Mr
12
v.as
Th_z.
attbettmctbeprehmmaryamendmcnt
13
overncle
14
A
Yes,
15
Q
Did
16
Jensen
or M f McCa_
17
other
18
ore-rode
19
A
No, thay
20
Q
Now.
21
Fhggms's
22
_. htch
lead to the '066 patent
23
A
Yes
24
Q
Do you
25
history
filecL Clmms
2,
c]aln_
10, 11 and !2 were
thenonmanual
Is [hat corre:ct_
thal's
my understanding
etthar
Heath.
than pulse
through
Its attorrmys,
it specifically
cormtmg
point
to thstmguish
or Mr
out any fcatmes
the nonmanual
cla_ms_
_d
not
l behevc
you tc*tt fled m re_pome
questions
that the original
recall
based
_ hat haplmned
was
patent
filed
on yo_
to Mr
apphcat_on
m 1994,
revtew
to that original
correct _
of the
palc'nt
Markman
Page400
10/26/05
file
apphcaUon
Ilearlng
'7
10/26/05
Page
401
OO403
OO402
I A
It went
2
and
3
commtzatton
th_
tl_
tt was
_on
m the patem
ulm'natcly
apphcauc,
4
Q
When
5
A
Fcthruaty
w_
abandoned
n. v. htch
I pa_,
omce,
2 andso
m fa_ or of a
then restdted
that continuation
3 LEer_
m a palem
apphcatton
4
filed?
and so forth,
forth,
6
Q
7
w_
So am
I conect
that the '066
patent
6
8
A
Yes.
9
Q
And when
was
m the
A
I behove
12
Q
So tben
!3
_ ears
14
A
15
_L
16
after
17
Q
after
- _.l'am
Donelson
apphcatlon
tt was
ted
Fehruary
cmcred
apphcatlon
the contmuauon
the federal
clrctnt
THE
meaning
o'. or. JA 77.
zs
m the patent
WITNESS
thai parucular
I think
version
THE
10
of the
COURT
ofl_c¢
for what
that probably
clmm
that
rn_m_
that
w as canceled.
Canceled_
acru_lv
12
filed two
THE
Not
actu2d]y
apphcatlon
resulted
_, as filed
m the
'066
two yems
by the patent
WITNESS
'a.tth apphcm_t_
No,
msli_cttorcq
THECOURT
appheauon,
t3
_
which
but canceled
It
of 1994
w_
_pphc_mt
9
issue
c._e
the '066 patmt
Donelson
The
going
wx_n
by
the
13. 19967
8
l!
been
13. 1996
on Februmy
I 0 tla deo_on
have
means7
7
filed
thai wc
th¢largeCwtththeslashthtoughtt
a stand2dd
5
THE
14
subsequent
15
else.
16
or tbe
17
hned
18
appheam
want
version
one
anymor_
Rtght,
He may
clerks
be m accordance
Sotakeltoutoftbe
It m there
WITNE.SS
but the PTO
it would
ust_dly
Okay
! don't
of I'tce_
and
t_y Io keep
that's still pending
he may
ha_ e replaced
_
ha_c
a
It w Ith f.omcthlng
the trto*t recent
the only orte that's
_ erslon
nc_
Dorur tson. yt_
lha_¢no
ftmherqtmstzons
18
THE
COURT
19
t_LR
HIGG[NS
20
21
I thmkyouha_emadeyour
I the one that
IO BYMS
pulse
and now
that -- v.hat
youdon'tha_cto
And
_ou
to be sawng,
and
to mleri_ct
don't
23
Aren't
9
not
you have
No,
of the
conclusion,
again
actually
of cotws¢
mtnVreted,
21
25
haw
be interpreted,
|8
3
to rephrase
your
But ha didn't
I'_ twice,
yottt
"generally"
I'm explaining
15
I reed
-
THECOURT
6
the phrase
disclosed"
the word
sa_L
and
ts tmder_tood
Is'generally
inserting
13
rmsorry,]
understan&ng
! was mter!mmng
McCav_t
! I counting'
12
you did7
the normal
And wber¢
tmderstoo_
Bmtoexplamll
5
7
9
to
to argue
6
8
Q
2
THECOURT
Your
Anything
Honor
els¢'_
Nothing
Okay
fmlber.
We'lltak¢
"_our
a 15-minute
(Or,=th)
23
THE COURT
24
MI
Th_z.
25
m _ _
one
more
question
iflaskj_t-youcanstaywhcrevouare
of th_s amel_l
THECOURT
20
ft.u'xher qucst]o_
21
d_d_'t
have
22
I ha.e
apphcatton
Markman
for
But
so the examiner
can
see ex_c0y
what
the
ts afle_
19
Honor
re_:e$_.
22
through
on
any
MP_
Thai
vel_. de£mtuvc
HIGGINS
23
on ts I'm nol £amthar
24
that estahhshe$
25
with
Mr
Okay
that?
with
that as the
Thef, z that
Anybodywamtoaskhtm
may
nol be thsputed,
statements
The
only
any
parllcular
pa_lacular
that ts often
what
about
thing
bul we
that
I w ould comment
MPEP
meaning
occurs
protoco_
I con¢_
but 1 don't
and the attomay
Hearing
10:26/05
Page
Markman
402
JA 0881
Heanng
10/26/05
Page
403
00404
OO405
I _nOW
_1
tl IS b'_ p311_lt Ol_r_
praCUc¢
2 way
Okay
3
THE
COURT
4
TH E WITNESS
ThaCs b_-'a_se d_ MPEP
5 manual ofpat_t
e_T_Inlng ixocedm_,
6 clericaln_n_l
The actual m._kmgs
7 ¢lamls are mado
tsthe
THE
COURT
9
THE
WITNESS
I0
THE
COURT
At tbe d_'_imn
-
13
THE
y_,
COURT
3
MR.
COOK
4
THE
COURT
THE
CLERK
CLERK
thars nghL
Okay, thankyou
COOK
Yo_
Honor, Mr
_omey
THE
W1TNESS
thazwc'U be mfr_ang
19 glv_th_n[oMr
20
II
THE
COURT
MR
COOK
12
HtggJm
'ITIECOURT
_._
tT
We
E_an._
25
Mr
THE
De fendant
it's next
wLmt_
Evara'wmlcntesnmonytsattab82
"_
COURT
,s *#
Heanng
10/26/05
Page
THE COURT
2 that.
Okay
THE
4
THECOURT
aren'tthay?
6
WITNF_S
S|
_
Sco.
I knew
Evans
S lind electrtm_
When
COURT
HIGGINS
MS
MITRAKOS
eaglet
1o read,
25
binder
and
ety
Mr
my copy,
Tbesz's
1
formal
old Underwood
all be the same,
Content
I
is stm the same
YourHonor,
and those
wc_lth_
that do _t_
cople_
the other
l0 on
was In a th fferen[
would
compute_
MR
24
an
discussing
1f we JUSt bed the
silly
OUt ]4-point
we were
to the --
it?
imnted
on= mmm¢
I make
that the COpy thai v,e were
dtsco_
the paglrtatlon
23
walt
may
to page
the break
presented
It'sthese
Evam
lcanclanfy
for witnesses
14-point
because
e_ple$
We
ended
It'S
up in yot_
brad.s
Markman
be something
Okay
I pe_on
fm_
2
Hearing
10/26/05
Page
405
Good
Mr
Evara
attcmo_
a 12_u:h¢lot_ of_lmc¢
tmgmeermg,
which
1 earned
My name
ts
I have
D_gltal
COOK
Perl C for Sp*c¢ Generation,
6
pt_mg
I!
MS
MITRAKOS
12
THE
COURT
8
mtemet
13
MR
COOK
14
THE
COURT
15
MS
16
THECOURT
ahead
been
All txght
Hc ha_ not been
MITRAKOS
$wo*n?
He has
Ilehaabeenswom.
ohay
Go
THEW1TNESS
19
scsence
20
f_om Cah fo_ta
m etecmca]
Okay
clecffomc
State
I am CmTenOy
22
Fort
Collins,
23
an mk-'_
24
Cmm
Colorado,
circuit
Ibeveahachelorof
engineering,
Polytechntc
employed
at A_lenl
formerly
ds_gn
which
[Jm_ erstty
I carried
Techao_ogl_
d_tgning
in
Packard
u
f_II custom
chips
In tMs _ty,
Markman
worked
with
Hearing
and high
station
including
such
tt*tmg
and
integrated
speed
as kshcl]
data
cirCmlS known
o f wamist
rmcrocompute_
and tecetvers
o_uatmg
a I OD
10/26/05
406
to my work
at AgdcnL
mdcpcmt_m
comuILam
I have
]nterlectron
14
d_te_tor
and
15
detector
dcs=gncd tot them.
Some
dov©lupmg
a low eo*l
a battery
powered
of the novel
17 pssslve
infrared
mooon
I8
detector
with
moUon
I have
ors Used m
boards,
at over
one
Infra_ed mooon
21
hghOngsys[¢m
22
mouon
det_tor
23
hghong
level
d_ector
mfrared
Signal
act
for
infrmed
moated
motion
motaon
I0 elex:Uon's
t_mlted
In palettt
thsctl_
w_th
EVIL
with
an adjustable
for
tnano_3
m De_clopm8
two
a p,x_tve
I_eI
Th]srestfltedmapatcntbemgmsuedfor
ctrcmO 7 w=th a_table
motmtm
backgrccmd
on the d_tgn
detectors
Markman
JA 0882
imsslv¢
tmpr ovt-menL_
dstecto[
I also wc_'ked with EML
passive
I pt_cntly
w0_ked
passlv¢
Improved
atao worked
20
25
Page
In addmon
13
24
[ comidor
_vers
clrcmt
of mllhom
as an
19
m 1978
part of Hewlctt
ta-,gmeer
c_-cmt_,
software
Specific
12
16
Sta_ovtff
18
other
Systems,
with htmdreds
reuters
II
be had
work
I0 GH_.
Y_
I thought
Control
al_hcatton
_om
YomHonm'.thd_eswearh_m?
Packard
many
$
9 dlffcrenU_fl
MR
aJ$o d_tg_ed
Ve¢flog
7 as a ASICa
California
Hewlctt
4
in el_tneal
State-
21
team dg_lgrling
mtcrowoc_o_
3
The_ear©mo_mgtatget_,
Goahaad.
WITNESS
I have
like
TabS1
81
I0
25
tt would
Now,'_betarcwelookmg
3
17
for the record.
OO4O7
1
9
name
I f you could
404
00406
7
h,_&
)
Yore" Honor,
typewriters,
2_
Tha_,_Idha
ca_Is
Markman
5
t_ bemg
22
MR-COOK
dmang
THE
t9
Okay
Scott
than
Scott
wl[h throng
IS
have
we bend them up to YoLLr
Y_.th_nkyoo_
right
yot_
and I was re femng
pre_ented
a
20
23
24
mcmloned
WeaLsoha_¢-
to In clowns
May
Tabgt
Be seated_
comment7
14 statement
Next
Honc_
2t
_
HIggms
your
SWORN
State
THE CLERK
foT
A[Inght.
17 c,_eth_tbe,_a.ntedto_f_rtomclosm&
18 two cas_
WAS
I0
thscovcn:d
MR
Rinse
THE
15 wlm_ss?
16
1t'$81
81
7
admm]stmal
THECOURT
82_
I'mwrong.
(WITNF_S
the Upphc_nts
14
Tab 82
6
9
By the _ammen;
At the th_'cuc_ of tbe attorney
WITNESS
COOK
THE
S pleasr_
II f_ tbe applmant?
12
MR
that'snot the
l_e thaton the
by the claks m the p_tcnl office
8
I
2
to do i1 th_
mclu_ng
of muhtpI¢
the dsslg_
Hearing
that
10/26/05
Page
407
00408
OO4O9
| DESA
_¢cuscs oflnfnnglng
2
3,V_n
3 dolccto¢,
or PIR
moUon
detects.
e$ a PIR
_lth
6 the s_gnals rccelved
from
7 of a pe_on
objecl
or oth_
9 have
_
_.ds
morton
I mcar_ a mouon
senso_, somettrnes
_ a PIP., [ogethcr
S dJ._sd
patent
I use the corm5 passzx ¢ mfrafed
4 v_hlch lnco/po_t
5 smlply
a DESA
c_ult_
dc_ecto¢
also referred to
v.htch
selects
the P1R that concspond
sought
r_._ved
the pro_u¢_ elcctncal
the PIR
T_
to motion
_]_lch
do n_
14 '_ thoul _y
the term
fmlh_
qual_6er.
cfec_cal
[empc/atm¢
and ploduces
18
to chang¢_ In tcmperaRI/¢
Curtal
20 vohag©
23
going electncal
25
then
p_tl_
The c_edk_cope's
captwc
¢¢'_enl
a rapd
v. d] I_'OdoCe a eharaclenstlc
going,
24
an ¢fec_cal
Thc_fOxe,
22 nega[ive
neSauve
cclnc e fement
from the elemcml ts convened
and amp]ified_
21 Icmpcratu_
| mean a pass[_ e infrared
wrc¢]
efemcnt IS sensllt_,¢ Io changes
17
19
al the bouom
e going
4
t_ characl¢'nstt¢
sensor
$
_o conver_
or- the signal
whiten
13
that a person
14
5,598,066
15
_¢qutres
I_
in the Ii_hllng
reqwred
Ileanng
10/26/05
PaRe
of
one
'066 pat enl, pemans
field
of orthnary
does
th_ patent
skdhn
the
no_ requ_r c ¢×p_nertce
_ngmeers,
points
the patents
_ do', oled
engineer,
wtth
such
at '. anous
THE
thsclosur_
to any efedncul
pa{ertt t_ nol conccr_d
AlSo,
Carlson
art Io _ hlch patent
to as the
perlatnS
113the
Mr
licld_
famthar
25
_nd
indedmg
skill In the
a person
the p,t[cnt
For on(: thing,
24
le_umony
_ecded
An e:_ampfe
on _{a_¢ln_{s
in the hshllng
fo my opinion,
art to which
23
cr, st PIR
resistor
wlmesses,
of or thnary
17
for hghttng
t_
of clrcmt_
voha_e
Io commenl
v, h_ch is referred
the
trace Shown in the Screen
_ _bJe
ofDESA
cxpc-aenee
22
_ og.'_e
_
a low
an_tmt
13"an.slstor of one
lesltmony
21
then
,:, hen a PIR
rathauon
a _mall
brim _ked
12
¢onc¢'p_
outed level
_ls¢or
_ have
20
e going
currenl
fo_ a few
to the backgr
that lyplcallv
v.lth
is one
effect
le_ el of _ olthge,
and posttlvc
produced
m Ifl_ared
be noted
the
change m
bne f pulse o r
and thc'n relurns
_s packaged
field
background
for a f¢_. mlthS_conds
]1 should
7
19
of page 6 or M r Rapr_s
at a parh¢_l_
lo change
into a
topics
typically
field
The
patent
r_¢r.,ed
how
much
light
_s
of lntercs[
one2, concerned
COURT
to
for example,
as specifying
in the
408
with
the
arnotml
-
chams_
l_|arkman
OO41O
ttearmg
10/26/05
Page
409
Page
41 |
0O411
I
THE
2
the 3_un!
3
_d
4
than s_d
5
upon
6
a _¢nsor
9
Moreover,
I0
s_g_Jl'_c_
m my cxpcncr_ce.
conc_buuc_
For example,
12
_ssued
[3
p_en_;
patents
14
o_¢dbyDESA
15
_phca_
[ _m r_rned
_l_d one pe_&ng
arc on sec_ly
lights
ons _
17
on.ricer
! 8
[¢sofied
19
ertgmeer,
20
be fore jonah
21
not rda_cd
22
2_ _J_d 29. which
Mr
3
4 DESApa_enls
_s dotect_l
by
anached
5
oF _cu_ln_
o f illu_n_t_on
marc
By the
th_
same
be L_an ¢lcci_
and that
See
m figure
app[ical_on
12
T_ o of those
es
ca] engineer,
are _tt_ched
Raper
also
ICStsfied
who
specify
ho_
24
c_stor_'s
25
del_ cr to _ _'mtts
F_xhthlts 63
points
and 64
not a hghung
o f mdosl,_,
Rapeds
ck_osmon
hshl
M_rkmin
DF_;A's
Ileanng
p_ss sel of values
18
find
all c()mta
pasts
21
65
tamps
should
Once
10/2_05
Page
mvenlor
Whal
22
values
23
'066 patent
24
thsclo_ed
25
powe_
JA 0883
in_enlor
apphcatlons
on sc,_al
on which
are aIta_hed
thsclc_ed
as Defendants'
of dect_omc.s
of experience
and more
m designing
deteclols
Io come
to find values
tn the patent
low
tap with
cos{
a fn_t
_ al_
of a circull
of componenl
bmld
_ alues
a lyptcal
and imp]emcnl
For the
elSht
in [he palcnt.
that would
lmpl_'nt
]1 wits not my mtenl
worthy
analy3t,s
I thd was
thai work
doptc¢cd
Io be tt_¢d in the d_gn
_tutes
c_se
To do
2B
mol_on
intcrd w_
cases
and
pal¢'nt
and the CI_CUll dza_Tams
my knov, ledge
my years
I buth
in the '066
That
they
v, ould
clrcwI
with
the design
I decided
Io _e
to
i_, I dad not
and ensma_
operauonal
thai for
always
features
amphfim
work
typical
m the
thai _:e
an LM 324
low
q,,kad amphfic_
Markman
410
_
_n for my leshmony,
a se[ of preducl_on
do a worst
DE_A'S
t_eld of _ntcrcst
15
20
Exhthlt
tl Is always
used
passl_ • sn fr_-ed
the d_lgn
and palen{
and figure
14
19
as Dcfcedan_'
2A
I then
17
ts n.tmed
through74
the pzlenl
specifically
m a fi_ld
experience
enginec_
that
much
m the
Raper
I s_dwd
My
36
facl tha{ he _s nc_ a
a_d 67
13
[ 6
Mr
o1" palcnt
the circuit
11
Raper
Is a n._-ned
66
as an sn_ entor on stx
of _ hleh
Mr
In pt_'p.a_tt
thts
lnhLsdeposmon,
Mr
Ea_b_t_
l0
_.as as an decretal
to hghung
7
through
Seepage73
Raper
9 olx'raled
not a hghtm 8
h_s ion years
8 DE._A
Mr
tidal.
as Dc fendanls'
token,
engineer,
Copies
6
8
engineers
a{ Ieas{ one
en_neer,
hght_ng
35
like me, de, pile the
dc_
Coplcsofthe.seF_lentsandp_n_
I_n an elcclncal
ll's on pa_ngs
Also
grealcr
povulcd
¢lecl_C_]
m _$
I ag_n
2
a_
k_ ca_c
two Icy©is
with
of tJluxnmation
con&tion
mgmc_
between
concern
sub_ant_Jly
or nol a _med
dc_c,_J
the thffe_ence
only
_ bethel" a first ]c_d
I_, d of dhamnab_
whed_a
Ar_
Patclnt c]31ms
I¢_ el of dlummatlon
_
8
II
_ITHESS
of hght
a second
7
23
mdhseconds,
16
m
m respomc
or posll_
Markm_n
16
more
I f
l ha_ c hefped des,gn
"PIP. sensor" or {ctm _PIR"
15 sen_o¢ wl_ch C0RSLS_ ofa
begins
St the ¢lrcug_
and EM L
] _
This
3
10
When
]6
negatl;e
6
F_'equcncy or amphmdo
ls thc lypc of clrcut_
12 tot IntedecU'on
13
goes
exposed
10 eh_a_msl_cs
IZ
which
2
among
to b¢ detecled and
from
I
Ilearmg
10/26/05
00412
Th_
OO413
allo',_ cd me to use only two
eight
opora_or_d
volt
pow cl supply
refining
amph tiers
to a low voltage
70P
$
input
since
that includes
vult._cs
All of {ho_
10
Sm_c
tl
Id'ety the
12
I_ckagc.
13
c_,hl
C_l
must
I
a five
gets
have
ho
a c.on_cm
mvcnto_
v, anted
and _mg
t_ o quad
15
dcslgr, s fo_ tho p._t
has hocn
Is Q2, the
6
mode
7 was
range
g
_
p[P_,
it scorned
use all of the OP amps
packages
allows
one
m one
to _c
ull
ttsed m many
that the '066 p_cm
Sixzs
m an mcxponsl_
I p_c_cd
CMOS
21
mare
23
braid IY_ c_rcult
AC vohage
24
supply
_ct]on
7.5
ctrcml
elcmcn_,
shows
based
low
voltage
along
_v¢
with
cr_culU-/.
any
I dcc_dcd
to
I_gh
the
vohagc.
five _oh
| 10 volt
_ttpply
ltearmg
10/26/05
Page
$c_tSltlVe
copper
PC board
oul hol¢_
_
the co_poncnts
to the PCB
a_l
12
from
soldered
Supply
tho power
them
etching
1
the sold_fic_s
sl_cad
board
fro_
the powc_
= fo_
on a elca_
PIR mat
ac_yha
sheet
and t O0-watl
all the compommts
togetho_
alo_ 8
halogen
Wtth the componc_
all _e
15
obs_cd
interracial
_
Tho
17
the tc_ cxrcmt
clrc_t
19
light cnvtronmem
cx_tut
21
a _ctahvely
"_outd
I pr¢l_ed
d_m level
I wouJd
I o_erved
and
PIRs
to cr_me
16
poln(
of Ihe Frcsn¢_
mountlrtg
uses
I would
I
at a local
plasllc
response
25
and capa_tors
I of
model,
I sa_
thsclosed
m the
lens,
alignment
its
block
P_PS motmtcd
for the
at the f_al
lens
board
pnnted
_rcmt
to motto!
on a PCB
copper
PCB
bmfi
by photo
boo_,
the m_n
board so I could
! expected
t]_
which
! bruit the
etching
d_llmg
a sl_e
out the
the ¢leculeal
board
_;ided
holes
for
co_ls
on a cullul_r
_ az7 clrc:_
and
board,
the tv, o PIPs
and then _;oldm_lg
I m_t_ally
24
a clrculuy
ha_ e two
to as a PCB
spread
m figure
able to mc the Fresnel
and the
bud! a small
23
values
so I could
to gee tho
use values
of reslsto_
I had on ha_d
Ex_3_t
68
and 69
or mgh_me
wluab
world
hgbl
the
a lamp
rclauve
c]c_e
24
produce
an oetp*.,t wl_ab
p_ox_mlty
25
rcL_]vcly
inzo
v, ould
rehalvely
3
window
4
did =',ol produce
comparato_
Th_s
Hearmg
mthca=d
10/26/05
7
rad_a_o_
falhng
8
&d i_s job by reducing
9
doc
12
tfl which
13
a _¢(Jetermmed
14
light to alm_t
15
lamp
of vzew
The
cucml
ch._tng¢ tho lamp
In
Page
413
would
18
_ttsfy
Ilearl_g
10/26/05
fi_!
24
I¢_1
show
25
_ well
Page
414
At this
tl',2t th_
such
c=rcmW/and
valu¢:s allows
h_t
up the
slgt_l
to
lamp
o_ Lmdcst_cd
Thcclscrv*ouldl_ethelantp
having
to wa_t for a second
p u_,c
long
like to demonstyat¢
I b_ll
a.?ul invite
Markm=n
JA 0884
of the
the
it vc_3' large
ts not unexpected
I would
the trait thai
_
IrtU_n/_J
gTca{_r tha_
tho _rcult_
my ctrcml
wlthOUl
ts very
corpora!or
lime
the czrcm1J 7 to hghl
pulse,
co!mitt
time,
u_F_¢nn 8
had a wtdth
will cause
that t=tn8
quickly
of fatsc
m infrared
clrcmUy
from the v_ndow
pulses
cause
very wul¢
pulse
count
a _'fe_[Cl3111tted
fromtheuscr'spomlofv_ew
If!ha
the PIPS had
the poise
pulses
mlmmt_m
I behove
but [he circuit
the lamp
of a change
hkchhood
within
- will
the pulse
23
to a
output
] al.¢o noted
hght
of
The
pulse
tho first of those
for a stable
the PIR
an output,
would
mthcaove
the
_unous
o f the file!tit
17
22
signal
tzpon t]_e PIR,
Succcs_fl_
porllorl
prodt_¢
which
into the field
from
to mc thai although
an output
II
mo_e
distant
would
p_odu_cd
Io a single
I could
an outpol
6
20
Ic'vcl of dl_tlon.
Markman
token,
at a Iocauon
2 t to respond
the field
to the PIP.
By tho same
2 view
19
at
of dlm_ma_lon.
rr_vc
I
16
to b_uld
!ha! to a low
8 to _t
an output
23
b_ghl
able to probe
m order
aS De fcndants
co_e_pondm
prodwcc
I was
m the ctrctut
as mterulc_t
cha_aw.s
the circuit,
20
Then
of mic_c_
arc marked
In tcsUng
22
tOgethcT,
nodes
they worked
16
18
! w_
15
I0
lamp
w_th
componcrt_
14
However,
5
m place
box
board
supply,
I wired
13
and Q2
model
the He_dvZenlth
Markman
ho_d_
| moun_."d mare
_lth
no longer
pla.suc
I then
hk¢ the drawing
412
a ft_le
ussn 8 photo
the components
I btnll a clear ac_/hc
I I huldc_
Q!
SL5630
oo415
u'ar_ fcncd
l0
_olated
of a Frcsncl
two P]E°,s labeled
1 oponed
14
22
P_rst, I bruit the pov, cr
photo
the powc_
'066 patent
tho components
v.ould
6
9
12
21
_e
5
8
thai the modcJ
the 110 voh
and bud1 ;I t_m8
I _bfllcd
7
II
sc_smve
Although
al a _ocaJ point
shows
looks
Whon
photo
m (v.o sccuo_
thai
model
20
3 PCB
tcch_quc_
4
Iha patcnl
ts _x_nate_
designed
3
I0
supply
| [hen
sided
Thts
power
]C.
test
componcnt_
Depo
9
19
I_:x mvcrt_
00414
2
Home
including
foramuchsafer
able to plch up the Hca0vZenlth
t_ referred
m_ crto_
work
The '066 potent
18
of CMOS
to be able m _olat©
from
the use
frmctlor_
Iouch.
e package
Markman
I
ls_
mare
all the h=gh vulta_e
typzcully
17
thai c_m nm five volts
I waJ_tcd
22
PIR
wdh
Thlsallowcd
thcf,_ncnurohorofmverlO_sthal
the CD 4069
h¢_ m_ crttn
Since
consumer
tw o dccad*_
I also nouced
17 ofs_mver_fs
19
from human
13
LM 324
18 _
4
In tho LM 324
m conym_er
a board
with
PIPs
OP _1_
16
cnvlromncnl
near _ound.
_ always
bmh
3
its
a corrax_on
arc avadabl¢
I_
20P_psandmvc_lors
OP amp
of the PIR. which
m_t
fc_r_r_
14
20
capable
amp for tho first stage
9
the patent
the first gain stage
from the so!tree
to gel all
the pat ent shows
to the OP amid.
In a_hoon,
posmvc
Since
i_ckages
of at
you to come
Hearing
down
10/26/05
Page
415
00416
0O417
I
MR
2
court
3
dtrnottstrauo¢l
HIGGINS
thai w¢
tnR_d
to video
THE
5
_,OLHJGG_$
sectmax
may
drLS portion
[ rt'mmd
the
1 Ftesnal
COURT
Okay
And_.e'vecle_sedoffflxalsam¢
of the plalntt ITs Co--el
table
for the
7 demomtra_im.
g
THE
COURT
9
MR
COOK
I0
WrlRen S_Tca_nl
II
bucome
Okay
For tburveord,
referred
tab 72 and
YourHonot
to Exhlb:ts
65
and
the
69.
those
ha_ e
73
THE
COURT
13
MS
MITRAKOS
14
MR
COOK
What
pnge
js thai c_'_
LaslpageYtmlLatdretopofpnge6,
thlrd
16
TH_COORT
A ad
17
MR-COOK
Tab 72
18
THE
COURT
J9
THE
WITNESS
open
fotyot_
and
become
_ ha_9
73
There
4
thai kind
5
MT
I would
like
thai I btulL
Fffxt
23
the ctrctatry
that we v, ould
24
ts the pov.et
Supply
we ha_e
COURT
THE
WITNESS
g
in frared
rathatt
9
encourage
the
10
a person
the PIR
same
thai make
17
top
aol
halogen
I_e
bulb
people
tmjde
serLsors
the actuahmtt
We ba*t
to touch,
v, hzch
this c_e
and Frc_nel
blarkman
lens
The
Heanng
Page
wlr¢_
can now
look
are
turn
Io poml
sitting
of high
$othlststhepbutosetlsor
23
s_ttch
you
s also
a switch
of _lcw
board
hvtt
do_
to
rathatton
as
ts rest of
that za¢ the exact
_s in figure
2A and
underneath,
there's
the p_nted
it
cffemt
2B
a --
boards
componcms
find
on the
that httl¢
mmule_
there
Is a cad
It's the thing
_ttmg
kind
Andtht-retsa
to go
into the
accent
mode,
that alfov, s you
and 20
416
mlnut¢_
Markman
OO418
meas
¢o a/I tho_e
under
al[o_
to five
ler_
fo:vscs
in m frai-¢d
out that
22
that
lem
on the unit and
cell
minute
of
just dropped
l also need
There
Fresnel
components,
connectrons
l had
the
field
- for v, hat
sulphide
2_
10/26/05
clrcml
21
24
a pan
In specific
the
lexul
if you
copper
I have
20
you
of.the
low
all the
We
cap
m this plastic
Frwnel
the PIPS
for the one
gttl¢
does
through
_ ou can see
those
that has
that _ ere
to _ee a change
the test
one
16
focated
The
on onto
pIRs
components,
15
sertsors
What
ts _alkmg
Then
13
ofpl_0c
ex#x_a_on
THE
the
sheet
like the top ha_
7
12
thm
m tt
6
19
Okay
to show
a quartz
crrcmt_y
like a seal I They
brown,
axe tv, o PIP.
of look
Cook's
18
you
lsthtson?
22
have
wdl
Would
Right
We
tho_
Okay
21
25
hcrc
3
14
15 pa.'_g_upb.
lefl one
Ions elements
II
12
20
left5 ts this
2 small
o f the
as v, elf t
4
6
Yore" Honor,
thin
to se|cct
of timing
mode
otto
idong
Ileanog
afl_
10/26/05
Page
417
Page
4_9
CO4_9
|
a m_on
2
on
detection
of a pe_sov,
how
long you
keep
the hght
I Iong_
for
3
2
Ther_salsoatestmcx_hcve
asvdtch
4
going
to keep
5
upctd
up this test, I ha_ e shorted
6
resttt m- to the rrtorc hke
7
m abota
$
tt m the one
minute
We're
cormcclion.
to
mmme
so II v, tl] time out
We could
bored,
watt
9
a htti¢
10
sulpMd_,_.ndthectrcta[ts
the full one
so I have just
rmnut¢,
now put
and
we might
And
4
the
5
s_mulat¢
ha
a cap o_ er the Cad
-nowhasgonetoathm
Tths
ts the at.cem
13
e',enmg
14
tm'aoffthcacctmtmod¢
15
mcely
And
16
radratlo¢l
17
change
18
lo show
19
now
wo_ld
21
can
22
tfytm
23
off,
24
enough.
daybght
And
you
7
Iogghng
_s_ch
8
to sbuv¢
you
9
this
This
25
hlfl¢
you
mode
You
halthtssv,
chaage
can
also
for one
hack
mtattte,
a - the rmmua]
Mr
fi_ e or ten seconds
17
over
18
A
That
19
Q
Allnght
20
Lens, F-r-e-s-nq:
21
A
22
correct,
on
poe, t.r switch
Apparently
on here
and
I didn't
or 20
portion,
toggle
So _
toggle
Markman
mmules
v, htch
th toggle
toggle
it
asa
bit
Hearing
or
tram off
_hal
by
| wanled
an'_ questtot_
a_tual
regarding
clrcmt
EVANS,
and
duly sworn,
tes0fied
as follows
EXAMINATION
Just
a couple
E_ gns. dunng
the Cad
Y_,
ofquesno_
for Mr
the demopstlahon
sulphide.
was the
Was
pho¢o
that the
you
E_ans
put a plastic
photo
seraor
cap
_
sensor
AndthenyournemlonedtheFr_snel
l
Isn'l that rtght_
_md I'm not posm_
but that's how
I have
e I'm pronotug'n_
betm pronom_mg
that
it for
:23 years
|v,
it _ little
I
occurs
tt long
Ithdthesamep¢oblemmmydepost0on
bit too a_xtous,
it
ten s_onds
COOK
Q
fi_ e nlmutes
ovemde
MR
16
_t t$ m that timer mode
show
BY
15
on for upptoxtmately
nd of tfos cotmectt
examined
had
vail
so If. I w_s to
bas;ca21y
of the
which
dayhght
out of this ovemde
Thal's
for one
DIRECT
14
And
tt should
toggle
again.
SCOTT
that
detected
now
mode
fl gels
out in the
and see i f anybody
13
m mfraled
c_._ see that ii has
right
ts a one
was
day,
for dayhght
ha_ mg firs[ been
12
ltchdoes
into a o; erode
the next
of timing
can also
10
be on m the
the accent
tf I ha_ e enough
take the mmn
and
that would
That'sv,
wgff¢ to get
stay on
also
w_.rtted
has gone
_
|l'we
20
ffyou
out he*e,
and
mode
tt goes
untd
$o tr_tead
11
12
and
dusk
t_me ouL tt waits
6
am seton_
There,
on untd
3
In order
out the one
a tim Second,
stay
10/26/05
24
Q
25
plastic _
It was
curved
like thls
Itwasshoraofcu_wed
_|_rkman
Page418
JA 0885
He._rmg
J0/26/0S
00420
1 A
2
lfs
a sheet
that allow
3 Q
piastre7
5
A
6
_,fymg
you descrthe
I gu¢_
9
Q
pique
race
are the
Tb_'s
13
Q
And
14
magmfyabuok
15
A
Tkat*s
16
Q
No
17
_t has
_a tho_
excepl
area so ,t can
fymg
glasses,
buy m the _kugstore
Im_
COURT
THE
W1TNES$
3
THE
COURT
4
THE
WITNESS
,t's a
6
THE
COURT
7
TIlE
WITNESS
a_tually
the p_e,:.e o f
for a cottple
of
m tt. and _,ou can
me
tt to read,
ls thalnght7
qu_teom
COURT
You t_ay there
was built
based
NO,
thts w_
butlt
on the
THE
COURT
22
TIlE
W1TIqESS
THE
COURT
24
THE
WITNESS
..
ilh_raaon,
Where
w_
The
component
9
there
Yeah,
that's sitting
on
THECOURT
II
BY
MR-
bigger
btgger board7
b_ard,
that's
12
Q
13
you took
14
It thcln't
15
capaolon_
16
You
Okay
Just briefly,
18
nght_
the
have
actmd
values
22
not on the actual schcmattc
23
Q
ts m thctc
24
thai you
25
tab 72 and 73_'
That'sconCCl
hnlc
over
Crc_s?
you
wMch
was
2, and
and the
to build thc ctrctut
Is thai
lalsohadtoreadahtlleb]t
there was thlr_
fi_cmmuleand20mmulcttmcr
Tbun
did then
&dn*! -- figm'e
for rt:slstors
Io know
those
mcnboned,
appear
] thfftk
hka a one
Otherwls¢,tt's
saying
_alues
420
one.
five of 20
m the schemaltc
_hthl168
&ageams
69 that arc now
and
Markman
G0422
ftmny
OUt what [hose should be, selected thcm,
figure
counts/?
Page
what
d,ageam
so --
10126/05
single
AIInghL
to summarize,
schcmauc
mmutc,
Hearing
every
that ta there ts actu.aIly
COOK
21
]can-
Markman
there?
yes
Okay
into the d_cnptlon
yes,
It do_n
on that
On the
A
the pulse
pull cotmtmg
SO It was
19
lllt_tr_ton
23
Was
h's m there,
20
-
21
Where?
17 and then used tho_c values
on
des,g_?
W1TNESS
8
I0
O0tTeCL
fm'th_
THE
pat¢_
THE
2
5coff_t
flat
pointing
of.u_methmg,
Rapcr's
19
25
the really
canter
THE
20
t_0421
I
m it
correct?
A
Mr
etchings
m the c_ed
the _tmc
t'ial magm
thai you can
12
18
has seen
up m a proper
thtcct]on
These
I I dollar_,
with
the etchings
it woxks
o f thof*c Imcd
8 gel some
I0
,f any'oody
gla_es,
7 bunch
pl_tlc
to tt act hkc a lens
Would
4
of curced
Ileanng
10/26/05
Page
421
OO423
I
A
I'm glad
2
Q
Yes,
3
you are ketpmg
okay
Thank
I a device
y_
you.
THE COURT
4
that strmghL
Okay
Cross7
CROSS-EXAMINATION
5 BY
MR
Go_af_-moon.
7 A
Good
8 Q
lust
Mr
acotzpl¢ofquesttom
Io bdabox
the point
I0
and,
I tlunlc Mr
II
dewcc
12
just
13
that cttCml
14
A
That
ts corre_
15
Q
And
tt Is m_c
16
m accordancew,th
17
t_c "r
18
A
19
clam_
20
Q
Not
21
A
Yes
22
O
Okay
23
A
I a._Stml¢ that
24
claims,
25
Q
also,
Evans
afternoon
9
thai you jufl
a rephcatma
I mad
bcc_ur.e
Cook
for you_
I think
just
figmes
ldon't
the judg©
clarified
dcmonswatad
of the prc fatted
thageam
A
No,
I thd nOL
3
Q
And
the same
4
not read Clatm
ctanfiui
it
tt, but the
embodzmenL
that is,
any de,
patch'J_
the schematics,
We
could
7
Q
You
agt_
8
those
9
clatm._
10
A
lees
Isn't tbul
not the
the clmms7
the $chcmaac
does
implcmenl
the
though.
for cx_raplc,
Markman
reed C}alm
Hearing
6 and braid
10/26/05
clot ms
67
b¢ ffxte for Clmm
a device
go through
wtth
12
Q
13
you w_me_
me,
Youthd
9
In accordance
with
thai
Now,
thd you
Mt
- I bchcve
Y_,I
15 Q
He made you ner,,om?
16 A
Only
Q
Mu_hy's
18
A
422
you
d_tratott
14 A
17
m at.oaf thrace
w_¢
here.
but &d
yesterday?
b¢cau.sc of dgraomtrauot_,
too
nerve
wTccklng
nghL
Yes
(Laughter)
20
Q
21
hartd
22
go
to a brtght_
23
A
Y_,
24
Q
And vely
Solgut_
in frlml
Raper wave
youalsow_m_edMr
o f the PIR
Igv¢l
sensor"
o f Ms dcvtcc
hts
artd the hght
15 that e.orr_ct 9
similarly,
you war,,ed
device,
Markmaa
JA 0886
those
tkat ts the
Andhemadcmcnet_ous,
law,
thd tr:ad
wtth
plctuY¢
Rapes
thd.
lbtuhtht:-
to grid ] I, yo_
1 bruit thedcw'tcc
_r_Ib_wn_nt
25 of the PIR sensor ofyo_
Page
all the clarwa
6, 9,
and butld a device
Tlus t$ a_e.
I I preferred
ts
23, aad 2B m the paleot ?
th¢clalrraofth¢
to rmplemem
waat
to us thts afteraoo_
thai you chd not build
you didn't,
Claim
would
9 and braid
6 A
t9
Bul
with
5 clmm?
THEUERKAUF
6 Q
m accordance
2
your
hand
and the hghl
Hearing
m from
went
to a
10/26/05
Page
423
00424
OO423
2A
Yes,
3
Q
4
d_monstratcd
5
front
6
A
7
hzs hand
8
Q
9
Actually,
10
the covet
Okay
AndsothedeveethatMr
yestceday
of _
sen.sots
D ¢trx.tcd
I wa_
my
deterred
the motion
oF thai dcxace
the change
of his hand
Isn t that
of m fr'_eci
pages
13
Q
And
14
refctr_cetoaP[_
15
woTds
16
co_ec¢_
17
A
Aed
IS
Q
Ymsony
you
Okay
AndjuSl
4 maybe
a hril¢
bit ioo qmek
corr_t_
rathaoon
5
bceatLg¢
"molaon
b_¢fly
to your
aren't numbr_ed,
thscms
page
20
thstmctlon
21
_d
22
A
yt_
23
Q
Okay
24
you,
25
A
do_
dctcclm"
v.tach
back
to yot_
6
star cmc'_t
You
8
exact
I I
among
the s]gnals
12
stalcment
13
A
I th_nk you're
14
Q
Okay
15
of the patent
16
In_ -
tt's abuul
17
A
Ycah
IS
Q
And
19
for me
LSt_SCd
IS that
P[Rs
bctv, een v, hen ustng
the
And
words
you
make
"mellon
a
detector
_
_ser.so¢'7
Doyouha_eacopyofthepat_tth_©w_th
str?
I do nol
Markman
ilearing
10/26/05
tt -
mouon
as wc just
to the
discussed,
when
using
patent
gomg
detector
ts used,
together
with
rec¢_
ed from
you are
the v. ords
and is it tnJc here
sensor
concctly
you
but if _ ou w oulcha t mind
between
"sensor"
a PI_
--
arc thsc_lng
and
whorl
UndcrlloFyomstalcmrnt,
you
detector"
thuds
m
-- and I brought
are making
9 _aytng
of wrms
m h¢_
J_Lgt for a s¢coed
a thst mcuon
I0
t_s _mder the
one
statement
And
hc_¢ a conp}e
or "sci'.soT"
WS lab l_
but It's the -- tl'S not
Andyoumakeathstmcuonwhenthe
19 Tcrrmnologyg,
thts mearcs
csrcml_
the
"motion
Lh_t yOU're
to you
v, hleh
pIR
that
selects
am I reading
yo_
th¢'re_
paraphrgsmg
Ves3, good
please,
mc fauly
and to Claim
hne
con'ectly
Andlf_ouwouldgotocolumn7
69
If you
v, dl go
to
55
can you
tell mc _ hat
-- can
you read
thai hne
plcas¢_
20
A
21
peedeteTmmed
A first sensor
22
Q
So the v, ord used
thcTe ts "sensor",
23
A
Thee
sn there
24
Q
25
abu_
And
h_
55 again,
for dcteclzng
external
Ls "sercsor"
Okay
lane
means
conthtlon
same
the
a first
to stud apparatus
cortcct_
yes
ts true
m Clatm
used
zs "sensor"
term
Page424
Markman
9
ts it not
Hearing
10/26/05
Page
0O42"/
OO426
[ A
"Sc-r_or
2
Q
AndffyouwouldgotoClalm
3
about
line
4A
mtans"
is m thff¢,
rnc_ns
As_downallmc-al:*_lSI
Q
Okay
A
Number
7
Q
So the
8
scRsor
9
A
I I, _ ou ,ae
please
¢lzm'_
talking
of the patenl
abouL
sensor
means9
m those
a_e USLng the term
claams
that you have
MR
4
THE COURT
5
MR
THECOURT
Okay
Anyn_dlr_t?
13
MR
COOK
Notl_trcct
[4
THECOLFRT
AIlnght
Thankvou
"loumay
slop dowrL
16
THE
WITNF.SS
17
THE
COLIRT
18
MR.
COOK
Thank
Ncxl
blay
THECOURT
yot_
Mr
Ev_.r_
be excused,
AnypToblcm_tththat
Yore
COURT
COOK
22
MR
HIGGINS
23
THECOURT
24
MR
NO objoctlon,
Okay
HIGGINS
Thttmrkaufh¢
Your
excused
from
Markman
Yore
Honor
"Coomaybucxcused
HonOr
may
tlearmg
may
be excused
next
THECOURT
_s-- l thmld
12
MS
MITRAKOS
13
THECOURT
14
THE
15
(WITNF_qS
82,
82
CLERK
WAS
CLERK
18
TIlE
WITNESS
19
THE
CLERK
your
ll _s
State
hand
)
yo_
name
for the
record,
#e_se
MS
Lloyd
W
Massengdl
Be seated
MITRAKOS
your
Honor,
21
tnatt er. be fore Mr
Mi_smagill
starLs,
22
using
during
testimony,
some
boards
his
far a_ ay I{ m_gh¢ be d+fficuR,
so w¢
have
for the balance
25
an oghl
TttECOURT
and
we're
as a housekeeping
gomg
but
IO be
for those
so _ ¢ ha_ e
. Io see
a half by 11
Can I pass
Okay,
dlbugood
Shallwe
Hearing
10/26/05
thatv,
Markman
JA 0887
right
SWORN
t;t_ttrtg
426
H+s_tatement
nm'nbez
Yore-Honor
24
Page
_s Lloyd
Okay
Rinse
THE
wh,ll
23
10/26/05
_s well
w3mess
LfoydM;L_Sengdl
tt, but l Oon'l know
ask that
I also
the courtroom
you
Defendants'
M_sengtl]
2O
Mr
H+ggu_?
me
Andaslong_swear¢cxcmmg
MR
17
That's
All nghL
Tbusz _
THE
16
wtmess?
Who?
KAUF
COOK
Mr
8
I1
q_l+ons
Mr
THEUEP,
7
I0
f_
12
20
THECOURT
3
9
to
No
of the day'_
2
6 wlmcsses,
Is that cortecl?
] see SealSOr mea_s
Q
I
10 for me
S¢_¢
6
IO pointed
yes
I 1 or 12"_
5
Mr
Q
m
T_mology
Y_;
25
3
7 making
pag© but the second
A
21
I b¢l there's
Raperbmhand
to rcfc_ _ on/usl
12
15
J believe
A
_ as mo_ms.
I I section
II
] Q
2
I dKL
al around_
Page427
425
OO428
00429
I mark these
2
Exh_a
$omewhcre?
3
They're
MS
4
report
82A
perhaps,
already
already
m bert
I Hlgglra7
in htTe_ okay
MITRAKOS
TheyarepartofMassengdl's
Thescarej_[eolorone$
5
we have
?
version
Whlchtswhattab?
the black and white,
I don't
8
MS
Okay
Again
and tht_.e are a colored
$¢e them .-
10
WhJchmalchthebo._dsthat
THE COURT
I don't see thera
_s part of tab
MR
schemata:
COOK
clrcutl
14
The_ea*etab49,
thagrarns
TttE
COURT
MR.
COOK
ts a blac.k and
wtal¢
vet.ston
yot_
copy,
THECOURT
19
MS
match
Forty-nine
Okay
m color
m
v, ell
21
THE
COURT
22
MR
COOK
23
hcadmgontbetup
purpc_¢*
Thee
be putting
are clearer
copies
wl_ch
up
Okay
Tab49doc*n'lha_etheblue
COURT
of a clean
Why don't
record7
we make
49A
for
IO that, Mr
tlearmg
10/26/05
Page
elecmcal
] have
3 ctrcml
including
5
Threat
6
and deszgn
Reduction
7
w_th compam¢*
8
Acrofpa_e.
9
Ma_n
Aget_y.
_uch
$omf
Your
Horior
Ready
for
we are
Go ahead_
Good
into the suhatance
persona]
afternoon.
of e_ectncal
engmeenng
You_
of my opinions,
and proft_tona]
I'm a professor
Hon_t
I would
hke
background
englnemng
at Vanderhih
mid
University
m Nashville,
Terme_ee
l'm also
the
[he Vlmdetbl]t
15
or ISDE.
16
dl_tgn
I?
engineering
fotmthrlg
Imtlmt_
where
threclor
of lmgmeenng
for Spa_
[ d.ect
for vanoc_
and Defense
all electronic
government
for
Electromcs,
modchng
analysts
and corporate
and
flmded
aetivmes
I'm aIso
a fellow
19
and
Electronics
20
lind B $
degreea
21
Carohna
Stale
22
Un]v_dy
o f the
Engmet_
Imtdute
with
in electrical
Omver$1ty
the
of Elecmcal
IEEE
I hold
engmemng
a_ad have
from
workc_
Pk D,
M S
North
m Vanderbdt
$1n¢_ 1987
[ have
taught
24
In nllgroelfcnonlc
2_
digital
mldergradoat
c and graduates
Ctl'_mt analysis,
]Ogle, dlgtt.3J
circuit
des]glt,
col_
es
¢tzCUlt d_S]gn,
anldog
compute
Markman
Aca_;pace
secret
2 Is d'tc mca_
and space
the DARPA
_
BAE
aided
design.
Hearing
10/26/05
Page
429
Hams
and Texas
anaty_ls
Compaq
5
design
Boemg
and design.
9
l0
hold
a DOD
Section
Is ptov]d_l
as Defendants*
14 retried
16
US
17
patent,
I have
been
Patent
No
_ked
Io study
5_598
066
m order
to conmbule
I 8 me
as Marknmn
proceedings
19
me
- allow
20
foe my opinions
FIrsl.
me to oudme
22
drv_dedmtoth_csecttoea
23
techatca]
language
Wlesermarm
to whal
has
or datm
the topics
patent,
15
to as the'066
been
explzaned
co_W.mtt
_
on
to
So now
tmon2as
_
My
let
Thzrd,
p_enl
provided
2i
ts
d_cnp_lon,
Accoxthngly,
conclud_l
m_l
23 Whiten
Markman
Hearing
wluch
conlmn
10/26/05
Page
430
COmLSl with
who
_Pm_
by eoum¢l,
DESA's
Fotmd only one claim
claim
wtth S¢ctron
including
elements
112, paragraph
6tructu_c
the d_awmgs of the
as to the claml ¢Icrnems
be mL--q3reted
and identified
descnpl_on
6 are
set forth m
thereof
concspond
24 those
claim elcnu:nts
25
In thts respect, _ edvtsed,
which [ have
m accordance
which
porllo_s
with
H 2/6, I
that the
to and there fore defined
markman
JA 0888
recite
to per form the
the concspoadmg
and eqmvalcnce
by oth_
m each of the 12 clmmed elcmcm$
sufficzem
35
the recited funclZOn
here _s largnly
as advised
22 have determined
wlmtsses
where
none of the 12 c]arm e]_L_
tn accordance
FirsLlmzppleramttbe
[ addxess "_bethex or nol the sm_ctmol
m accordance
6
Stcvcn Carlson,
cd to m_n
18 the wn_ten
19
or nol U'_ose, **mear_ plus function
to perform
that r¢¢lled
17 mt¢_n-t
and the bases
presentation
Staled m the ¢[mm
ftmchon
16 construed
20
the topics
Secoed,
thees
_hJchl'ilrcfer
that
recite sul_ct Cnl
be mtclpreted
112, paragraph
My opzmon
13 ¢lcmenl
E.xhthll
43
15
whether
s b_clure
12 exlx'r t wdness,
of my CV
the funcl_on
In my opinion,
sufl'iclent
I I
cleman¢c
A copy
of ffmc0on,
by a sLatement
format,
As I have been edvL_cd by counsel, th_s _s the test
8 U SC
Lockheed
m
I also
to IX_form
7 claim c_cments" must
Insmmamts
pubhcanons
followed
plus thnctmn
6 fo_ dctclTnxmn8
Ccfapmer.
Semw.ondu¢lor,
=meanS"
4 clement.
the Dcfnx_e
elecnomcs
Systcw_,
the word
3 su_cturc
systems,
Force,
and NASA
on commercial
I O0 techmcat
theory
secunly
I
the U S Air
Aerospace,
I ha_ c over
13
25
9 to give
m mlcroelectronlc
the nuhta_
Navy,
woAcd
Hughes
I I electromc
24
W1TNESS
I go
theory
:eseafch
foe the U g
[ ha_ e also
IO
engmemng
per forrocd
an._ys_
4
21
fine.
Okay
OO431
and ha_c
2
14
THE
8 Bcthzc
Yes,
428
OO43O
12
COURT
23
this
Any objecnon
Markman
!
THE
Ig
Thalshouldbetheooly&ff_rence
THE
25
Sothtslsjust49
MITRAKOS
the board
24
ts actually
Yotu- Honor
Ig
20
MR. COOK
6
14
that's
right.
Pror_sor _gdi7
13
So 49
No,
All
5
12
cornpamonwtth
offlu_
16
17
COURT
I I computer
12
15
HIGGINS
THE
I0
82
13
MR
3
7
M[TRAKOS
weql be puttrng up
11
2
4
THECOURT
6
9
or are they
_md as cvldcat
Heanng
from
my
10/26/05
Page
431
0O432
I rcedmg
of the _ng
2 wttne_ea.Mt
written
Cat_*,.
Mr
3
sharp
dtsput_
betv. ten the
4
sensor
mcam
for detecung
5 extenmI
to said
Raper.
Dr
parae*
first I_cd_tmmned
7 ap'paraIu_
as re/ares
_e
9 mg-aa
I0
jt_l
mean
the PIP.s,
the PIPs
wh;ch
aurnl_.
46.
}4
_torblock,48
mc_dcm
19
20
later,
21
fwsl
upon
re_sm_
$_
t$ part
signals
mgar_
thal
m greater
tntopretat$on$
clrctulay
ffDESA
ts m:_ part of sensor
of a COrltrOl ct_emt
means,
incorrect
15
constitutes
16
_lemems
17
detail
and
the
Number
would
Heanng
10/26/05
Page
one
19
dra_
pa_tculady
20
d)ag_:o_ of figure
rags,
Number
and
'.tlmess¢_
25
Nfr
for each
of'the
claim
including
2A
of tbe
descriptions,
_J
'066
clmms
the schomatt¢
patent
a._
orcufl
2B
po_ort$
of the
depositloI_
I_tlmorly
t_ this case
three
Number
24
recite
the follo_,mg
v, ntteil
t_o
exhthlls
s'ffuctme
Myopm_om
My undev_tanthng
its textual
23
be
on
Including
22
but instead
the supporting
,tre based
]8
21
and
for my opmmra
the _nllen
m tht_ ease,
Patterson,
Mr
Mr
sta_e*noltS
Raper
Ev_ns
Mr
a_d Mr
Dr
Pault_,
Thtaz.
Markman
432
of the
Carlson,
Ilealang
10/26/05
Page
433
Page
435
OO435
I
Ntmabet
four,
th_
ca_
4
Mr
E_ans'stest
5
thsclt_t_re
3
and
_
Nttmhor
6
$
'066 pale_
9
And
_
my exan_n,_on
and opera,on
as an electrical
maceordanot
nutnb_
with
seven,
mcluthng
oullme
the
my 23 yeats
chart_ and
claim
For
;6
c/ann
_s marked
17
,_ hsch -.
18
MRfollowing
20
thai
COOI_
along
That's
and
21
dement
22
L_ A, B. C. mid a _feax'nce
Th_
plus
_bel_t
-
ftmctton
s_ctm_
tab
48,
-- whteh
txtal,_
the
Yot_
such
strutture
_
of my written
8
Ex_u_ml 45
as to each
e ts governed
Stalement,
THE
MR
II
THE
COURT
12
MR
COOK
13
THE
thai I
14
&agrams,
ts a mast et
15
these
Exhthlt
16
etrcmt
17
¢omend
each
44,
ff you
_g
claim
marked
_
COOK
COURT
WITNESS
ftmct_ortM
23
patent
means
24
d_sputed
m_
25
approptaate
Hearing
m each
and states
!0/26/05
Page
434
Cla,ms
6
reference
as De fendanl$'
cncmt
pateat
B
2B of the '066
which
for DESA,
claim
por0ons
and
el_rnent
Apbenthx
of the
'066
!, fo_ EML.
and
subelcrnent
C of my wmten
Exhthlt
46
--
50
Okay
-- ,s a photocopy
each
9
and
claim
c_crncnt
and
IO and I I marked
lcucr
from
Markrnan
JA 0889
Appendtx
2A
to show
Tab
THE
with
vl marked
De feadants's
THE
clmms
sube]cmcnl
112/6,
right
to each
key
21
language
that
correspond
MR
and
35 U S C
-- ts a set of schematm
_.fr Car[sor_
22
and
letter,
marked
C ts tbe claim
statemenL
element
apphcs
hrghhght
49
of figmes
20
t 12/6
To
49
That's
arc
diagram
claim
by
WITNESS
& agram
U S C
re_tes
m order
Is that 45 or _
COOK
copies
language
funcuon
dlag_rm_
whtch
COURT
retard
_or
and sub¢lemem
Marknmn
of thsput¢
stated
that 35
be my comp_son
I behex
7
19
assigns
the area
the
the prcsumpuon
B would
10
Honor
a re f_rence
and ftmcttortal
el;ran element
to o_ etcome
of experience
thts
m dtsput¢
chart ,dtm_fie_
3
or not the smmtura_
to perform
9
e_a_c of
staItmaent
structure
and
as Dc rendant_'s
marking
THE WITNESS
and
gTaphtcs
chart
A Of my wntlen
and
so ffioent
6 which
of the
as to v_hcthct
2
4
my opmtora
_ tbe m_tt*
cha*L
the thsclo*ur¢
my skill, trammg
;t'ftmmc e Apl_adLx
25
of
_tthth¢
of the '066 pakmt
15
language
] optmon
engineer
to sttpport
Fwst
24
m
5
my stmula_on
pa_culaHy
So lea me
wtll tt_
six,
finally
I!
23
briefs
exh_lts
m accordance
expe_¢nce
are
Markman
of the supportxag
clrewtbtult
10
14
of the
o f tbe '066 palent,
ctrcmL
12
my review
fre,
And mmalx*
7
19
_'e
elements
00434
13
of DESA
and a_ to what
Z5 the same
2
on behalf
to avoid
the net lcsu]t
Markman
elemenL_
or not the clatm
mc_'_
means
the ctrcml
stnmture
. e
and to
I beheve
w bethcr
are correct
correct
the _ anous
sufficient
by
In
and subelements
Incluthng
set.or
v,e*c
_. htch support
112/6
11
I ha_ ¢ correcOy
14
output
9,
I 0 and
13
radtatton
d*f_aats'
9,
"._ltne_ses
I behove
elements
Carlson
thehasts
6
the _.mdow
con&uon
m infrared
that I wdl explain
Hov, cvcx, c-,cn
sclectton
47
by Mr
6
o f thsagtc_'ncnt
thai ofDESA
why
v, e th ffe_ _, hy
S¢coad
on points
clatm
clmrra,
cla_ ms - clam
of the cl,_m_,
elerneslts
func_on
means
12
bhrckSI
w[uch
change
of the opm_m
24
block
and
aze
asserted
mhth_t
the PIRS
I_
23
and fillet,
plt_
I 1 selected
2 of the '066
the turn-on
of a I:¢edttermmed
For
22
43,
aedthepulsccount,
17 or that ts Ibe 5elccled
the circuit
to
carcwt
I will comment
my analysts
the extent
13
I8
I _ tll explain
be interpreted
m figure
de;exmmt*
particular,
elemen_
oftbe
m each
bel_een
I0
which
present
7
to as the,
t m_nbez
control
6
set.ors,
¢lrcmt
m each
to stud
with v. hal I re let
cncuttr/,
are the r_uhs
are
Finally,
means
detector,
"l_is ctrcmt_t
elements
_dentdied
mdudcs
the PIRs
4
9
sdtctma
16
1 l, state
8
patcat
15
10 and
of to
12
fi_
3
term
included
mtetptetauon,
! ! quote,
ts, the selectton
5
mfraed
should
That
2 necessarily
for
cxlemal
ts Dl_qA's
m combmatton
the amph
means
ofpzss;v¢
$ or PIP.x. m the ck't =cleon o f raot]ot)
the
ts a
cor_htzon
semor
conthtLon
_o the
tbere
as to whetber
of first
OO433
l
of D ESA
Paulus,
a ptedelermmed
apparatus
6 &tcctmg
statements
the
of the
'066
subelcment
and labeled
master
Hearing
clmm
of
with
the
chart
10/26/05
00436
O0437
I
And D Isthe mxt key
2 statcmc'm
Appcnthx
which ism_kcd
3
MR
COOK
4
THE
COURT
5
THE
WrrNESS
as De fc_n_'
2 photo
sensor
3
4
scrtsor
5
part_cula_
- Isa photocopy
of foe *066
and l_Icd
v,lth the
corts_ts
charactcrtstlc
l0
posluve
Carlsc_ has sclcctc'dforeach claim clement aad
II
elecmcol
12 sobcl_nd
tsrn_kcd
|2
!3
backgrotmd
i I the textMr
Now,
Carlson and I thffcr,
inbfoc
The firstparlof my
14 SIalCTaCnlisa short _c_uc_
N_'nb_
[8 coosistsof a match _Isuch _
_
23 Th_
begins
at a p_cul_
for a few
16
few
17
ts charactcnsl]c
18
exposed
ca&mum
sulphide, or CES,
exposed
to
moc_n_
25
resistancewhen
Tr_istanccm complete darknc_s
Icvcls of :thmmt._
m'tdhave a iclallvelylow
He.ring
10/26/05
Page
21
as a &g_t_z_
3, the
24
bccattse
25
it's connccled,
going
m rcsp<mse
capt m'¢
ICSUmony,
level
of voltage,
then posluve
rcum',s
for a
to the background
produced
level
_ hc'n a PIR is
rathatmn_
operational
amphllcr
o_ Op amp
And
_thn"
as an amphl]cr
_"
can
be used
one can
to a small
its output
wntlen
m m fr_red
As an amph flcr,
signal
then
ncgaOve
m the screen
bacl_o_md
then
amphfic_
23
and
and then
n_lliscconds,
s_gnat
an Op
prodoce
a largo
lnpu_ s,gool
cannol
amp
436
exceed
can bo also
ou_pul
NevcrtheIc._,
the voltago
_cd
Markman
O0435
to which
as a thgmzcr
Heanng
10/26/05
Page
oo439
I
In ot_
2 certain
3 volts,
words,
II will pco_c
"._hercas
i f Its In_
v_lll prod_e
5
it's connected
6
Whcze
7
op amp
8
_mc_
an ouq_z
ts below
Rn output
szgnal
volt_e
_ above
cquol
a
of zero
that level,
to the _ oltago
ii
to wl_ch
9
op amp wall be e_thcr
l0
Iru_.'uJm_
II
to represenl
a. quote.
of tho ctrcu_ts
to a c.of_s[anl
o f the p_ent,
vo_c
The
zero _ ors
s_na]
ye_ or no in a logic
clrCUlL
lCl mc move
the ou_pul
or five _ oils,
out_
'066 pa_enl dcsc.nbes
a security
systc'_n
the4 ts scnsmv¢
to preach'bed
16
person,
bul mse_Sl_.e
[o n_tof_c_bod
17
b_kgmtmd
18
actt_ arcs a secunly
mtcrfcrence
The patenl
20
st_r.h as a thin
21
bright
22
a_tlvated
can bo _cd
dcso3bcs
dlunnnatllm
active
hg_tmg
thai
motion,
_s a
sur.h
amrnals,
The
25
tt_cr sele_d
of lime
3
an aulornal]c
pbo4osensor
based
4
ilhm_nal_on
dunng
var',otts
opm'alzona}
or accenl
baseline
_ and a bright
a u_cr selccuble
manual
scrtso_
drm vcrstts
overnde
fcaRe'e
Markman
Ileartng
the
to mmnt2m
bnghl
followtng
ovcrnd_
a_0_ at*on, and
function
Io disable
day
on Clmra_
6, 9, 10 and I I of the
9
written
10
_0_nbmahons
sta_m_k
II
Claim
large_lnumb_ofcornmoncla_mclcmcms
13
m_k© upClaxrns
II
15
fo_ analys_s
Accofdmgly,
9, 10and
19
bnghl
10/26/05
Page438
CI,ttm
6 c_r_s_ts
othe_
to clatm
hand,
wbach
ofthcclementsofCl_m
clcmcn_,
clalmelcracolKI
tsqtuteslmtlar
Claims
It
9,
This
101a_l
e_crncnt
r_n©
ts because
s ev-sor
means
6. element
A m Clanns
o f whzch
of ClaJros
elements
1, is nc_-Iy
9, 10 and I [. and
toclmmelcmentCI
A and I mcl_dc
f_" deleting
i* predet_lncd
of
the common
conth[Ion
to sa_d apparatus
Markman
JA 0890
K2.
the
The¢lements
Claxm
22
cxtcmol
A duough
contam.s
to any of the elements
21
25
elonents,
11
On the
phrase
I0
of various
etoracnts.
subsets
of foul
o_ tdcnllcal
6. 9.
mmy
II _saeonv_'_en[stRr_lngpoml
idcnuca_
24
c_.slsl
10_rc
20
23
a
9 and
appears
claim
I I, w_th nine claim
18
and a
these cbJms
12
_4
are C)a_n
m thctablcwhtch
of 15 d_ ffcrent
Clann
mode.
muter cortslde_au_
forth
are Idcnufied
for mot_n
to force
The cl_
17
dlu_ma_on
off ba_kgrotmd
feature
_ background
16
fe_ttr_
mode.
Next
_s
m response
use of passl_ e m fmrcd
sensing,
a pe_od
and ii
mode
24
f_
8 and II,assc_
ea the '066
moUon,
o f t_ecs oc sraoll
hghl
tilurnre_t_on
23
i liming
lllmmnatton
7
of the
th_eby
w_ch
on W backgrotmd
15
19
ill_l_tion,
2
6 "066 patent.
of frye volts,
to as the r_'l voltago,
&g_mJ
an
patent
14
I
5
is connected
Now,
stgnol
s_ga_
as m some
re feared
12
zf ,ts mfra
level.
4
13
operational
by
radiation
a
going
Rtpor's
of the slgoal
to a change
20
going
6 of Mr
rmlIIscconds,
Number
22
response to
exposed to bright dhn'nm_orL
Marknmn
n_re
19
a
a_d forth
m infrared
produces
trace shown
Boos ncgahve
r_tsmr.c.cwdl dechne co_un_u.sb/in
24
The OSClHO_COpe
which
A photo sensor
or PIR,
h_s
or cuncnt
15
is hght
22 wln h,2_e a rchlweb/high
vol_e
ba_k
of ncgaOve
or lx_ltwc
14
Within ItS range of sc_stlvi_, a photo Sexlsoz
21
gomB.
tulonRl This supplc-_cnts
19 v.Fnch cb.angos _s elccmcal r_istance when
20 photom,
m pol_nly
of page
one, the photo scnso_
whtch
to changes
bnc f poise
at the bottom
Paulus and Mr
fo_" the
m frarnd,
ma[enal
sw,tchcs
cx!_sed
13
16 Carts(_
17
raptdly
when
background
15 the tcchn)calmtorLd provldcd by Dr
the symhol
A pa_lve
of an msu]alor
Its rap_d chango
9
I0 --lo foghhghl the points where Mr
patcoi,
m my Wn [len sultemenl
polamy
180 dego_c_
8
The
shown
Thts poiamy
7
clRlm c_rt
the ext I have selectedin red
ts _
"I_*vo, the PIR sensor
6
I bchcwc corresponds to each
8 appropnalc rcf¢_ncc _cttcrf_om the _cr
I have marked
In 1_8m¢ 2 of the '066
I
Exhthlt 47
51
¢la'acntand subclcmcnl rna_cd
9
wn_'n
TabSl
6 pa_cnt tcx!wlth t_ ICXl_
7 cl_m
D of my
Heanng
10/26/05
Page439
437
OO440
I
And
2
control
3
light
4
coo_tao_x
elemen_
ctrcmt
CI
me_x_
m re, point
5
I have
6 tdeaucal
and KI
for _mg
clmm
advised
hav¢gmeratedtbegrtm_t
$ briefing
and testimony
9
lI
p_nl of the dJ:bate
paws
of¢lmm
35USC
12
Section
[ wdl
two
in accordance
by ¢le_nent
AndlqIBotcthat
14
elements
m the ¢lmm
15
wrt_en
arc tmd_lmnd
uptnlot_
on
tths
thc_eFatrsof
element
16
Tbe other
17
ftm_on
18
! 12/6, what
19
v.foch
part o f the debate
datm
eltmems
thosec_m
I will expre_
subject
mUSt be comtrued
is the ¢orr_pondmg
d*fine_
20
22
plus
23
type m the table
ftmc0on
element
claim
clmm
m accordance
stnmtmc
by
And
clemtmts
All of my olnmona
the m,ast_"
p]u*
with
m the patenl
elernems_
m this statement
24
is i f tbe mcam
¢lemem
upmlom
rll note
that the means
arc tdranfied
on this tup_
chart
and
on tens
are summarized
m the compar_on
Markman
from
5
orctut
tn
Page
10/26/05
I ha_ c also
orcml
THE
Isthat--48
WVrNESS
yo_.
tssornethmgclse_
Honor,
v* e ha_ e a board
8
standard
9
from
12
operation
13
rood* licatlco_
with
Ios¢
With gove_tment
17
o _,et_lghl
18
Defense
SPICE
20
the oparatlon
read
g
THE
WTFNESS
9
MR
COOK
I0
MS
MITRAKOS
I1
(I.a,_#ter)
12
THE
13
resulta
oftbe
14
device*
15
PIR
IS
LHI
778
19
20
2!
22
plc_
_
me
Wc
*066
Tins
fig_e
board
2 ctrcmt
the _oltage
from
thr_d
_ e*¢ parfonned
of QI
3
been
as the
Mr
ttlghman
signal
plc_ shows
reF_t*entatt_
the PIP.
e of the d_tect_on
IR rathat_on,
such
a* a person
signals
of some
model
_ alkmg
at Q I
change
m ftonl
m
of
Andfflm_ypomt'_
24
detam'bnd
25
A
are these
The seclmd
cro_
rll
8
the amph
9
clrcmh
Ttnsonc
tv.o sl_as
_gnal
What
Labeled
plot sho_
Markman
lha_e)um
PER Q I and
s ouput
PIR Q2
10/26/05
filter,
rule
shows
066
figure
JA 0891
plot
figure
2
10,'26/05
2 oremt
Note
a_ ts -- iI h_
lahel
Page
441
that
not yet
detector
&agrarn
larg_
labeled
signal
47
43
If
up on the ELMO,
ts the
output
of
of the '066
figttrc
2
amphfy
and
stgnM
has beth
clrcmt
fillet
mol_on
,unphfind
selection
Also
note
flurd
No[c
18
V, lndO_
19
m respome
20
arnphflet
signal
comparator,
that _
de*cnbed
comparatot
shows
48,
t
in this
and
and
output
filter
of block
o f the
'066
patenl
figmc
2 ctrcmt
descnpUon,
the
as negative
_martatt
slgnuls
_anablc
outlmt
rnanlfest_
signal
for
ofthes©
og flora
going
put_es
the
block
fy and
of the amplify
So that signal
the
fm_ber
process
that both
oftbe
m the '066
to the analog
So the amph
The
plot
block
and
filter
filler
is appearing
st gnul shown
here
Sorry
m the clrcmt
here
is the
here
block
al the
47
batteries
on my Lase_ pointer
Markman
Page442
12C(6)c
s s_gnal
of the '066
that is, they axe cont muoualy
17
output
local
a -- sho_
Hearing
small,
block
as part ofthe
The
24
ed by
thagram
window
47
cor_woct
E_ ar_ under
ts the signal
The
fy and
16
25
the o f tbe
Itear,ng
board
amphfie_
conunue
analog,
23
of
ref_encc
He*c the
output
and
rewesentatlOn
_tmulattons
L_ qmtc
and that's
second
22
for Space
ay:d [ have
ask for the '066 ctremt
21
the uppamm
23
IR_tltule
accurate
48
m tbe
The detector
15
Rape/s
43,
slsmficantty
_c
¢
acn_lt_¢s
cttCUll Sch_nanc_,
oremt
signal
14
PIR
extttnal
block
the detector
ptndetermmnd
by
tool on a frequent
the tt_t
his
of my SPICE
13
and Q2 as dc_mbed
examined
of Scott
the PIR
Iv, rag rePre_entatt_
by
as "_ell as in my engineering
E_hthit
figercd
61
ttsnd
Clr'Cotg
m my tt_earch
a highly
In¢luthng
12
input
8 O,
of the cltcmt
show s slmuLauon
at node
of design
Defendants'
2
lO
f_ll asleep
trace of v. hat he d_cnbed
The f_-t
rout Q2
I ha_ c the board,
c the impact
the statement
re*ults
7
Could
cxpectnd
¢lassc_
pro_3de_
E_an_
Il
_gm_
! 7 c*ctIIoscopa
tab52
okay
Excuse
s_tmulat_om
mImt
52,
WITNESS
through
Tbe
Tixafs52,
_n alysLStool
at the Vm_derbtlt
I ha_ e also
23
Version
Electromc_
19
Scott
and
industry
go "*_v
sponsors
dLttl_
the
PSPICE
the use of this
m my x_ amic_tlt
could
COOK
so fo_axe
wot]dwide
or threct
16
22
mg
Systerm
m_d to stmalat
basis
6
Okay
THE COURT
stmulauon
dt_tgncrs
15
5
MR
'066
2 using
Thls ._3 Fo,v are tsa preeminent
I could
7
oftbe
pomon_
figure
Design
ctrcmt
5
16
circuit
1]
4thaL
6
0f'066
Cadence
4
THE COURT
design
implemented
soxtcBwe
OO443
1 detector,
TH_COURT
d_a_
ctrcmt
Markman
1 crrcmL
3
the '066 patent,
dectncal
of baste
440
OO442
2
SPICE
operation
7
25
on
orcmt
studtcd
my knowtndge
24
d_agrar_
Heanng
carefully
I have
4
21
v, tth boldface
gt_ e background
3
14
table ofm_,
statement
let me
of the '066 patent
IO
w_th
paragr_h6
eIemem
And lasd_,
2 stmalattom
6
CA
mtheMarkman
of no4 th_c
L_tmmtlusstater_'nt
72
I _md the p_r
be c_tt_e.d
13
21
bngh[
pa_rs of nearly
debam
mo_
112
expre_
two
is v*hethe*
¢lem_ts
00441
I
phrase
ptndetertmned
that ts A and
7 andKI
I0
of said
thai these
elements,
the common
r_ad Lamp to emil
to detccoon
been
metnde
have
Heanng
j_t
g_en
10/26/05
Page
443
00444
I out
OO445
2
THE
COURT
3
THE
WITNESS
4
THECOURT
Anyhody
have
Tnpl¢
beuenes,
double
1
(LaughIer)
2
THE
A "I
A
Wemlghthavesomc
Dowchi_¢
4
$ some_
6
HR
HIGGINS
7
THE
COURT
8
whosejttst
Oh,
got battcne$
9
MR
lO
THECOURT
II
We may
in your
too?
DR
CARNAL
13 chambers,
Your
( Laughter
15
MR
took
beheve
Your
[here
i[
8
Honor
20
MS
21
THE COURT
[hem
m my calculator
in
You have no Ldea how
many
progyam
m my
COURT
MITRAKOS
He has
Now,
out then
YOU
2t
THE
t'.ISMITRAKOS
[ apOloglzc
WITNESS
Yott¢ Honor
I _as warned he may
23
partOUl and
p]ol also shows
51 o f'066
So node A
motion,
llearmg
10/26/05
Page
e
from
here
2 c:rcull.
this st_l
ts [he outpul
51. as shown here by my pomler
description,
the
pulses in such a
of _lsc
Lrlggenng
by
Is nol preset[hod
which Is high when
prcscnbed
In the stmulallon
25
n_all_
cmanalmg
the oulpul of Ibe
responds IO mu[hp[e
and low when
transl[ion
bere
manl_sts
figure
in the '066 palcm
circuitry
signal,
24
forgot
output
The output o£ the pulse count block,
thgltlzed
22 detected
24
complratnr
block
As described
20
any9
the outpul Of
as I mthca_e
block
signal
node A
19 moIion [hal
asupply
why don'l you have
the_¢ ¢wo pulses,
In the '066 patent
18 way _ In reduce [he prohab[hty
Let's not t;d.e [hem
23
filter
block,
17 pulse coital
node A
motion
:s
In low
Iransttlon
Markman
molion
is detected
that circuit has selected
so we see a high [o ]ow
=s a
no prcscnb_d
plots we see a h:gh
stemming
444
00446
prescribed
In [his ploh
Hearing
10/26/05
Page
00447
I right at [his pomt
2
I Section
AI abouI 3 8 second m response
3 window
compm_tor
[o [he Second
pulse. [he fourth
4 output of the Itmcr block,
block
signal plol shots
3
patenl
4
ii_ufl_ClCnl
[he
that In thL m¢_
52 m the '066 figure 2
This Is a [hgllal
7 when
[he lamp should
high
or low sign,,
be in the bnghl
8 prescribed
motion dclccuon
9
[hal the slgn;d remains
Note
IO motionh_ce._ed
lcng[h
[he signal
12 wdl be m hoghl
13 mu]lt
position
Z4
The fourth
vo0age
mode
16 showing
signal
[he
by tbe 'O66 patent,
m block
node
fgurc
6t bnght
L_ the node
thc
I0
and [hus the lamp
12
The slgno]
vohag¢
threshold,
21 gcnc_lor
22 cuwcm
Is dcscnbed
angle blocks
to [he lamp so [hal
a thin
wdh
the ramp
mode and a bright
mode
(he
_re
25 material
concludes
my introductory
and background
In[hcnext$CCtlOnofmy$1Jlcment
Markman
whlchi$
Ilearmg
plus
by comlsel,
those
"means"
introduced
are
Col[o_ ed
by the word
10/26/05
funct mn claim
Icltcr A, el,
been advised
Is presumed
elements
t 0 and I I. arc the claim
claim
C2, C3.
thai a patenl
In have mtoked
in the
elements
C4,
E, G
apphcatlon
or
H
chart
who subm_L_ a cla=m elemcn(
18
This
19
rec:[ed st_cmre
Page
446
prcsumpt=on
[hnctlon,
2I
m this case. DESA.
and the p,lrty
In my opinion
ftmcuon
can
ts su f_clent
20
22
23 estabhshcd.
This
means
IS
m means plu_ I'uncl=On
exammallOn
under thai -
17 of [hal cla=m element under I 12/6
os [he
gates
plus
6.9
by reference
I hive
16 formal
on the
appropriately
usual]y
K I .rod K2 m the masler
15 appheant
here and dim here. _d
which m combination
and the phase
of function,
Claims
=dent=fled
14
So thaPs
m the '066 patent
the
As advised
whLch me]ode the word
the meal_
Thus
13 I.J.
18 sehern=uc at [hL_ point
19
to address
asked
In the Oh6
structttre
been
claim elements
t I asserted
via [he
l*m indicating
elements
9 "for"
52
2 czrcmL
['[] [hSC_L_S my opinion
¢[alm
[h¢ SlalCd J'urtcllon
7 the cIa=m =IcmcnL_
p]ol =lso shows the signal
61 of'066
[hrcshold
Followm$
even afl_
will remain high
shown
17 [h=l_$ node 61. v. htch
high
is user sel_t_hle
switch,
al node
mode
6 function
_unctlon
[0 pcrl'ontt
8 by a statement
As dcsc_lbed
ofume
rcprcscmmg
statement
pl_
6, 9, I 0 and l 1 the reclled
C]atrns
I have
5
6
5 In my wntien
2
5 cffCUJL
24
the window
$1gna]$
oPthc
That's
al th_s node.
[hal _ dcscnbed
The third
16
I _ould lose my
That's
wc see here
15 of the pulse count, block
[o gel in this C;L_e
of these signals
pulses in response to the analog signal
14 labeled
Markman
20
going
12
22 are an engineer
]5
Note
l0
block 48
pulses,
eomp;L'ator
9 de$cnpoon
Youhavcsomc
[hem out
THE
I l
going
7 the window
)
19
25
comp_'ator,
6 negative
13 pulse coum
CARNAL
ffl
back
that bo[h
that is. {hey 0so a_a]og
[bird signal plol shows [he oulpul
I I the amphfled
[ have
16 hitt cries you ._e gore8
18 coJcuhtor
[ can't
Hc's an engmccL
HIGGINS
DR
somebody
The
No[e
v_nab]e,
5 window
ba.encs
Honor
14
17
we have
[hfferenl
He'sanengmeer
pocket
12
have
in hls p(x:ke[
HIGGINS
WITNESS
3 m'¢ continuously
claim
be o', ercome
only
to per [hnn
seeking
to overcome
has the burden
applying
these
23
p[_
24
of those claim
25
[o perform the entire Staled I*uncUon
JA 0892
tales
to the mea_LS
6.9.
fad to recite suf_clenl
Markman
the prcsumptton
of proof
elements in Claims
elements
If the
the entire slated
tlearmg
10 and I I _]1
structure
10/26/05
page447
445
_-14S
00449
1
Tkc rc_wn
2
for my opu_e.u
folloxvxu S du_u._mn
3
SO _
tint 0pumm
$ u_ffic_cll
6
oql2n_ed
Is _pl:t_ed
suuctx_
8
MR. COOK
9
TI_CO'J'_T
2
rclaI_l to c.hu_n clcmenQ, A
CU,Ad wc _2vc _x_ x'_
"I'i_
I n_l_c gx_'sczeftt ¢_t,ctx_e
by c_um clcrne_L
to a_otd tnlv_r
7
m the
COIX_T
c_r_
c_
ch_
3
AccorcL_iito
5
:_c macy types
_
6
prc_rc,
7
field, too many to cntm*_:_at c, not aJl al" thcsc
_c
EL-MO _
_ppencEx
9
I0 _b45
TI_
t 2 $_or
WI'C_ES$
m_
_3 _terr_
_
Cl=m
_s_l
de_ec_m_
app_tu_,
_ere_nt
= pte_t
and d_rn
I I 49, p_e_
12 palle 14
115
1_
tecnm_ny
42
I ai_e
_4 Ca_o_
I_ I_'cdc_c_ncd
t6 /L_
cond_u_
pte_-.cmu.._
t? first s_-x_c
cxlcmal
c_d_
n_u_
to sa_d _p_awq_
being echelon
e f a p_son
_
_o s_d
I_
C_m
17 cat_
And [ vm_Jd ao_n th_ m _
n_._¢_
cthun chas_ u_d
21
bcI_-_c b_._
22
h_B._hl
cu_ctexe,
b_ld _pe
t_ the I_ggcr
24
Thc_
e_c'he_, _d
the xt_Ji¢_ lugh_t_t
I_l_U_c
te _x_ d_p_l_c_,
23 ck'm_
that I_ u.,xd_lmt_ g
Mr
and the
_0_
or "_¢_r
Marian
that _
to
10/_6/0_
us sor_c way
Statc_cnts
_hthlt
la_gu.zSc
rc_tcd
_0
by Mr
tha£ rmShl mccl
by th_s cJzum clc_CnL
_Ct_'CS
wott/_ i_cr_'_
d_
lagn_w_tbMr
me:ms
pc_crrn
do_
_he s_=cd
fw_c_on
My o_mton
_2
the SLaU_
_,
slalerner_
C_lson_thctc'm_
not rccxtc su_clc'ng
of c_m
m th_ r_poct
of Mr Th_
1_ furth_
On page
Mr T_CSZ provl_d
__-ocAb'e to
e]e_n_J
!
st_pp_tcd
by
7 af hts W_llt_
_.L_btc of CxampJc_ of _c'_t
Z4 ¢]a:rn ¢lc'me_ _ which have bcc-_ hclcl to h_.vc StLrt'iC_
c_t
m e._u_" did _xot
He_nE
[11¢ forc_otng
_¢cot_fJy
21
me._i
I_zrl_n
I, Ih_ v,o_d "scmor"
funct,on
to mo_cn
_s¢cd f_mcu c_ of thtS cLttm tic'remit.
t9 fir_ sc_
20
C
would scr_e.
In r)e fendan_'
_OWCVCC, t*_ o £ thc_c
lS
[9
CtUT_mLutalF,_
c_n be fc_md at _3e fe.Mants' Exh_lt
,'3, _nd 47, _d
w_
I $ thc su'ttcxta_
celt _vc
di_rc
Tl_c_ axe _ly nt Lq_" o _'s_tc_ca'_
stud
_m objccL sc_c
w_3Ld([
o f so'risers, hght. heat. tC_T_pCr_t
_C,
th_ _.o_]d be ¢or_Lalcd
Th_
c_'_ltt c_
elc_r_xt
scoot
He _d
He wc_t on _ _ay y_u wc_dd need _ see_0_ thzt hzd
_. _ as _c_l ov_
exmmed
to p_ fon'n thc sla_cd thncu_e.
rol,zU ot_ IX_ILIOP,_olt_c_
m mJ_ul
l0
I1
Car_S¢l_ nGtjt_tany
uade_- I 1_6
$
l'mscr:y
vtr
bc s_ ft'_-nt
_b 48
T_b4B,
_c _U_,tcd fuftc UOn
4
That's thc =ppc_th x A, right?
_u_s
to per_or_
ul the _'_um el e_llemg m L_lt_
_5 SU_C_C
=rid _utTicl_t
_tnJct_c_
Page448
Markmau
10/26/05
Hcaring
Page
449
P_e
451
o0o_O
ln=u=u:L ( rind cLum element _. sen=or me4ms,
2 L_nSx_=
us the cl_un =le_w_
3 su_c_ex_l
s_.tcca_
dlo_'d
wluch
dtec"ctlyuu]oSous
were held _ have
mc _o c_v_on
to kc_p the _
_ specl_c
F_
6 tr_n_
it_umct ci_
lt_c_
4 s uuct'_e.
$
to the cl=m e)e'mcnt _prm 8 tn e._'s tendta 8
cfosc_ which _vz_ he*d to*I_ve
_uple,
m Mr Thesz'_ cxxmpl¢
pa_u. _= c_mm :l=ncnl.
7 ¢_',,ch_g
fi_om _
/_ 1 havc b_cn zdvtscd, m his 4cposmc_
o f a chum
Culs0_ scaxc_ that hLS _cflmdons
pc_fQramm
Ic_ b_qd mc_ts
to _h_ wa_stb_d
m Clmrn 6 _t
_r
bodi the
"_ ti_s_ an_l sccond sensor inc..t, cswould =_p_y m the s_'t_or
rnc_s
rn=._ra c)a_m dements o f Cta4ms 9, ] 0 _nd _I, th=cby
9 _'_mu_S pa.'_s m _c
I O hdd
It
to F._vc su fl_c_t
_pcc_=
12
p_'x'o¢_
_t
indJc.t_
wl_lch w:_
aJk_vs mc to _vxston
held _
h._.ve ins'._q_c=¢_
S that thc _
mcens, clcn_¢nt A, of Cl_r_
P, 10
a
11 e_e_¢nt [ of el:urn 6
_r the c_m_n_ pan_
_,e s_r_c_x_aJ _U._e
'.vhr ch w_
F_
o:mxpl_
a v_r,c_ng
17 tcndm|
_g
19
spec=fic
20
_.cht
m thc _l._m
_Uuct_u¢
&d
s_c_u_c
2_s_s
e:_._ple
Lhe clmr_ e._-'_
c_¢d.
_s
t _nrq_
w_ch
n_ _low
or"= chu m t'rom
me_r_
for
16 _athia_
wa_ hc_l Io h_'c
me m cn_c_'x
c[_t
¢le.m_t
f c_p:u_
th_sc
¢xc_pta_/c_m
A Qf the '0fi6 p_c_t.
m _c
Icfldi_d
cl_
clam
col_c,n
of _r
2_
i_ _'ta! It does cot pe_m_I m_ _ _q_on
.__
25
s_mc_r ¢.
thc g_
l_
_m_
21
ci_m elem_
_2
_del_
Hea,'_ng
c.o_._
If _ct_u_
tu dct_ung
thc _L_Ca_c.l
_Ufllm_t
S_
m p_" form tl_ s_ted
f_ct_o_
L
_c
pr_de_Im-m_d
_dlt_
c_j_lce_
T'n_ _s _al:dc
_c
25
_,L_rkman
_C of a PB_ og _, pho_.ll,
t erm_l
to
I f_d G'_x Xhc ph_e
_3
req_
17
a
su_ S 5_cc_:
x_hc_
c_m
tn Mr
_..
to kc_p t_' _r
[_
21
_crac_
by thc _
allo_, me to er, vlt ion _ sp¢_ t_c s_ctuse
15
16
_c._t
su_c_rc
B7 mmpxr_on,
13 e_eme_
14
oC _
10_6/05
P|_t
450
_cme_t
A Intbeldmticalrczsm'_
Markmaa
JA 0893
t_l
w_ll_venow
Hearlne
t_
10/Z6_$
]
O0452
I ¢l._Lmeb:me_t J ¢_onds_m.rmc._s
2
So _e_me nov mow
G04S3
I ©]¢z_tczl_wb_z
[_ my opJo]0n cm ¢_m
cfomtnl
2
hive _
3 ¢lztm sttb¢_¢ot
4 lvo_ m_rp:clauon
_
$
J _ _
C_m
claret
112t&
? _d
_nd
Wedetermmed
Second
_sz:
prr._tc_nm=d
m_ms
$
concbuon.
being a pre_med
con&Lea
In I_
_t_tma,
I0 cbeu dreamt
J. f_ foe s._¢
C_m
dental
g c_ld_on
L th©
in tim abs_cc
end for CZmm|
13
]
"l'ms
_'_trnear/¢._ be found at dcfcmc
II ngrab_ 4_, _
16
I a_¢
II
web M_
m _hzs e_m
r_d
HOwever. fow of those s_
scatecl fu_c_on
20
es_e
22
m _'f,_r_
I$
of_s
2.1
_In._
ek_eeL
I$
19 I_/Mr
In zddt ct m.,z,
cxam_e
ofcla_
_._ IO]_'WC_U[_C_¢_I
clcmc_t_
antlogo_
5_lzclur¢ L_
to
I0/26/0_
Hearing
level of dhamnalma
m _lm,
ue
Mr
C_lsm
WnxLeMr
_ysls.
_.htbtt
49, p_e
for t_c sane
rc_o_
_c_
C_lsonchdao_s¢_;ifi_ally
t_crc a_c oo r_t_]
c_ ffct_cr_
Page
C._nmal ¢.¢u_t
KI tsts follov_.
Ch,tmdo_nl
mcae= coupled
z_ _cond
to stud Lump zad _c_pemtv¢
s_.sor
Io sud
foe _e.c_n g stud hmp
m_
452
Markman
to *_d s_coad
m _¢ zbsc_ce of t'_d {'t_l
] pi'e_e_mn
and f_
reed _dltnon
4 Ilgl_ al sa_ d s¢¢_d
dg'l_.U Un _fS_d
6
f_t
7 thlg dram
clcmmu
8 pr c_rmmc_
I_.cLcrrnm_l
Ig'twccn
IJ_ fu_
_
l_'.ld
_tt
cl_-_mts
3
10
K I an4 el
mf_'s to _
ts n_<
of dlum_ualmn
t_ I_r_1_e
corghu_.
_m
CI whu:h expressly
mafoz=oa,
I Oplnm_ Lhat C,_
caz_amn 8 sa_d lamp to emil
Nt=_l of i]hallli_aia0n
Onc _f_cucc
f_t
md
LOem_t Insht at
Hearm
ts
amdmoa,
12
elca_t'm
wh_'w..u _u'a
t_ We_:mm_:d
14 _mJ
m_',ma_,
Thcrc are _
10/'L6/05
8
Page
4f_*
offby
AS a re=all,
$ Hc_v c'vcL few of d'_c
sm_r._n
by _
phomccg,
It c_zz.-_
16 dm_uu
KI andCI
no1 m fe_ to th_ s_o_d
12
13 e_Cmctlts whech _ave _l
ha_
ctmm
15
_rt cqur_=u.
th_lCI
19
vol .t_
Fk.m alan.
20
_gom¢
offoc
21 ooat'_
gou_z
23
e.alls for t_lcaa:_l¢ob_powo_lby
cz_ut
_
wk_h
C_L_n_RIc[axm
slngtm_
_AC
thtsdfffcam¢_docsru_
affctt
gllmcRlf¢ =_IFsz_
la_ks m f_cu_
G_e
_o l_form
fo: the sam_ rc_0ns
20
no_
dcm_iKl
_C sla/_t
foat I at_'t_
21
w_
dOeSnOlrC_ml_c_h-_t
Rmcd_'_
Marlunaa
the c_rc
e_z/lowmz
10/I6/U5
CI
t_
tk2n to hls _an'_l_
hel_ Io bavc _I(P_C_t
_
c.t,_ m stl_t
Page
454
v_t_e
23
lhe slatedfan.on
Noljt_t
C_rlson
of
of c_m
Io pc1_
clcmcnlCL
to MJ C._Lson,
_
cc_cccled drm cla_
S_C_'C
_IClCnl
thc_e _'c _ vkq
5wtlch world
_rlanaa
JA 0894
fo_
the _hc_lnon
to s_ud lamp_
C2 _hd not recite
Accmd_g
_s:u4
switching mt_uI
1_CV_lmg
In tns _cposztzon, Mr
iwllchc3.
C2, _wlcl'J]3_
to _vozd
C_ ss== foDow=
pzlx_J Ring _d
¢l_mml
25
of clam
S_CR.fC.
undc_ 112"6
Clmm el=n=.
said AC
ts _U more _m=c_ocs to
x_tz/_ct c_t[ _ru_Ru¢
_tt_
22
24
I tm of G_C
Heanng
fa_crar¢
NOW my O_n
m_,
19 _:foclzvely
sme_ ,t *¢ the
s_c_
would p_orm
_doc_
18 ¢on_cd curcuatmeans n'_]ud_
mm-..c.
Ac_atmgly,
to hzve ,_U_CIC_L
16 mt_prc_mon
17
IB
C] c_q_J.leSc_cr_
thcl#mloce[I
0 f _'aS an_
rn:t
clc:u4:nL
of t_ls cbam cl_c_t.
Lik_v L_C.CtZlm _lt_c_t
14
fo_ lma'l:_S_
_a_ mJ@t
the
mgh'tlme
l)
tmmbc'r of sCuc_es
_uffiO¢ltl
second
_v_
z_sara_that
:101t¢11c
recited by tim c_a_
6 stnJ_l functmn
ume_ CXlax'mly c_Jls
K I, w_ach do_
e.ond_coa,
dct'_e_'t[ CI _
= t/_ su*ucnavl r_tu_c
]0
! I Fr_clcram_
24 Mr
_th
C.,v_
sa*ac_
24
Io h_ cx_.ro_J_ of ¢D.lm
2 pmdc_ermmcci coa_uoa
2_
=t De fcrahn_
OO455
I s:ad _t
2_
c_o bc found
I a_cc
._
h_:ld
wfdch have _
OO454
_
to p_ f_rm the
2Z 13¢twcenclmrn clmmcr4 g_ltladda.n ¢kaw.nl CI
Markmaa
9
concr.dcd t/_tc ¢ Iz_m
20 conm'wRt _l ¢l_famzC I for purpos_ offoe suf/_k'at
]
Lskcwt.w, clmm _xn¢_l J ts _r rno_
24 M_ "_fs
by m AC vollg=
K I r_ctt_d _clcn/s_mc_
"J_
ZI
t _11_
SZM COZl_mlCm;U_l
17 4"/;Lad--throughp28¢ $0
woukl perf_xm the
¢[aun element
I_ dc_¢mon of
wtl_em
Rmctm_
|_ted
16
mcct the
wh:ch rm_t
co_._d r,¢_r.ov
of seed pre_.==n_uncd
_z lus d_o_,tlon_ Mx C_[son
14 clcm_l
OuLv.ca for d_ _u'ae teas ore.
ntm_bcr o_tn_ttm:s
sm_:_ra_ langu_
19
cxhfott
$0 to $2, and nunfo_ $0, pa&e I
17 There _uc _
Con=m[ :zrct_L
m fe_por_
ODn_ll0n
lZ mctr_ = _
14
Io _o;d
z_d lamp to cr_t b@t a_ sa.,d
l0 second I_.'c] o f g_um]n_o.q
I I sxld pt-.._t e_tl_
13 tn ',_i_.
=t_ctturc
7 mczm for r_usln 8 s_d ILmp t_ c'm_thg_t at szad f]r_
conceded thai _s to
re, on u _._m
nxt_cncn_
eIcmcr_ C l ts =s follows.
B level o(,Ik_nmmon
,'_ra Carlson
_Tx_;tu.r_
IIZ_6
6 m=oz= ¢ot_pt=d to s=d Izr_p _nd _pon_v¢
S l_vd ofh_IM ex=mal to _d, _t,_
9
C ] t¢_
4 mlcrprcUmoa m_=r
foll_
6 rot ¢_ccung a pro - a _ond
held to l_vc s_umt
And a_w my apumo_ on cl_znn - my opzmon that
mrray o f
bc Stlfficl_wt tO
Hc_ring
10_._05
Page
455
_0_57
I #av_s
2 f_
m _Tea_¢_ fo_ s_d
s=d tint I_1
Ln h_l depost_oa
4 _lemtnts
_ta:_ts
9
the_e are an mfmtte
Net dl of these coatro{
Carlson tt_tlned
aa _r_mte
Th_ t_araony
pag_
that oano'131 ¢lnztut mea_
ra_'abn
of_ln_au_
_,u,_e
bul by :ts¢]f
to p_" forca _
am
_ agree _th
There
Mr
I$ However
Ixtmpl_
Carl¢o_
ate a_y nt_n_x'_
Lhe_;w.mruraJ ]_gua_e
19 $ _
be fotmd aL De fe_ae
59 through 60; a_d number
16 _ve_
Page
_[atm
to perf_'m
sttled
far_aort
15
2t
C_bon,
¢ltcgt_l
not rcclt_ salt]el©hi
13
17
th_
sm_clxre
wOUld rg'rferm th= stated ftmcaoe_
Mr
! I do_
It
Ll_a
_ctto_
I 0 t"w_frqn_
t2
Mr Car _son ¢orlceded
A¢cccthn 8 to Mr
"7 'tthmber ofconUol
8
Icv¢l of dlumma_c_
C3 chd _ot rectth sulTuaeat
$ the _tLed
6
s=c._d
o f ,llarmrmaon.
which
m_et
thence
_¢mt_t.
e_'_e_t_
456
m_
;e_=tcd by th_ claim =lcmcc/_
or"Lh_ c_m
ot clam
49,
_o_ _te re-_on_ he has
o f strecpa_
f_'_oft.h_scs_'uc.Lur_wotdd_rfonn
fimcucn
_.xhlho
S0_ page 24
w_eh
Markmaa
have _
Heann8
h©Id _ h._e
10/26/0S
Page
457
Page
4S9
oo4s3
w_h
_ave bee_
hdd W h_ve i'_ffi_c:enI s_r2v_
TRECOURT
you ,_ br_k
_¢ _
_
Mr M_.scn_t
nut _
We _¢
r_y bc w_l
J f¢o¢¢_1
_if_Iv."
y_u d_ Lb_s£] t_n_gh_
=bout hd_,W
_
,t _
tl_u_h_
3
I think
It s 5 00
_'_'_nm 8 and _m¢
_
W_'ll d_
=s _ng
f_h
_p _omor_w.
to _
_
_d
T'-tECOURT
MR
blIGGINS.
Th'ECGL_T
(TR.t_SC_
his
much 1onS_,
0J.n_'_ed _y t_¢ ¢ourL $o ho Wev'_" _._o
to _
who g_
f[_t _ up to/ou.
W¢IL 1Lhmk thop_na_sho_d
I
_ Lh¢
6
_in_non
,n the older
2 want 01e closing
V=q, wel]
_3kay
yo_Hoacr
¢/e_mrc¢_r.s
CO IqTli',/Lr_.D nq vo
LL_dE III )
the _hre_L,
you _uth?
I0
_._,.
IZ
THE COU_,T
14
_.L_, C_GK.
19
_COURT
21
_.W. C_OK
m_q_i=S.
COOK
W_I, we _
AnOth_
oa g._
h_ f ho_,
! th_nk something
16, I bchew.,
m_yb_,
_o_i
Sow¢'ll2us_gon._
_d
_._n
h_c
into
Y_
_you.
Markn_a
He_Hng
I0_6/05
Page
458
Markmaa
JA 0895
Heanng
10/26_5
O045O
I
CO46]
I
U't_TT=D STA'_=3 DISTKSCT COURT
FOR TH_ _,[DDLB
D[$11UCT
OF TE_qSSSEE
/_PP_ARANCES
2
3 FOK TH_ PL,_
RCOE_T
4
)
O_A
4
E=, LLC.
)
S
)
M_naff,
IAMT_
J _'_U_
P_ H]GGIN$,
UF
JR.
MaddJc=oQgcudJ_cr
?.5COBrour_ _ Wdl_m,_cn Tow_
L(xt_I¢.
KY 40202
5
)
6
fi
)
v¢
) CASEN0
304-0160
7
) VOL_
m
EM L TE_OLOG[E.S,
LLC =rid
)
a CO$7CO
',VHOLE3ALB
COP,.POKA'ilON,
7 FOK TH_
DE_F.NDANTS
B/S SOCK.EL
S
)
)
ROGE_L
MITP.A_O_
COOK
Toward
_nd Town_cnd _d Cre_
Two FJnba;cad=o CcaLcr
E_tt_ Root
$¢n Frucu¢o,
CA 9411E
9
l0
10
II
12
13
'r_ANS
_
OF PROC_D,
fG$
14
t5
t6
17
I $ 8_=OKE.
THE. HONOE.A.BLE
t 9 DA'J_
OCTIOB_K
Z0 _
9 COA_
ALETA
A
TR/_ UG ER
27, 2_05
ZI
22
23
REPO_FED
BY
B _/ERLY
E "BECKY"
O FFICL_L COURT R_POP_TF.K
AJ37 US COURTHOUSE
?.4
25
NASh'_/[U_E.
TN
COLE.
q_PR CCR
]7203
(615) 726"_,_.9,.3,*km=t= He=du
E 10/27/05
Page
460
M_rlonaa
[_DEX
I
2
PaEe4_l
5 C_=
_u_m:bon
by Mr lhsJcxm
6 Cx_a_clC._'c_ma_on
7 Rc<fuca
_mm,_on
by Mr Cook
$ _.Ex_byMr
F_R_'C_
d_dt - t=ll m8 w_ch
50?
by Mr HI_4
"_s_l
$_6
Cook
I 0 r_Jked
IZ E,_.r_n_n
P,APB_
by Dr
tab _t v._
_
- which w'_ the onK:ml
_ ctmm cor_t_r._ons
which am dJff¢=_!
¢l_gn ¢0_1_=
up Lty=odl_J_J rib 5, =rid
uor_
in s_mc
_d SO we've
- I0 md_¢._¢ bow :t
I I dJfiefS, ?.wen DF._A co=z_scl ¢opt¢= of d_.
C_fl
cktcr<l,m_
= on= ofd_= tab, !
filed ,,_ch L_¢ openmB bnct, ;race that um¢
9 =(t_nl from _hc 0n_l_lI
577
10
WHJJAM
w=
whch
572
H_pr_
Ex_aa_byMr
one=_
547
Ilon0_
Y¢I, Your
proposed dram ¢_lr_cuo_,
465
Arcwcrcody_p_¢¢¢_?
mat¢i_
COOK.
4 E.xFcr t $ ¢ztcmc_t P,r._l by Lroyd _.s=cn_pl]
Okay
TH_COURT
AU_ H¢]uum,_y
3 LLOYD MASSENGILL
I[
10/Z7/05
004_3
00462
I
9
He_rhag
We weufd ILk_
12 to b,t_ tt u0 to d_ ¢0=rt Cs wdl
541
13
13
7HE
COURT
14
14
b_.
COOK.
Okay
Th¢_='= o_e du=b'o m h¢_
15
16
! 6 ch=nBm5 _1_de_n_
o_ fi_t pred_te_mnecl co_ht=oa u_d
I?
It
I!
:Lt teJ'_'_¢= _ on th_1rJual.
19
_o
20 _ .t:¢J_ In C]_'n
_, wlt_
d m ":Jy .h=t d_c_e terns, "._u=d
Zl
22
23
Z4
25
11_E_COURT
M=rkn_u
Hearing
I0t2.7/05
Pag®
462
Okay, ve_goo<L
_L_rkz_u
JA 0896
HI2n_
l_t'esce
Now,
10/27R15
PaBe4_3
OO464
I you l_ve
00465
I _
me _vo Copies of the s_m_ething o_ no_
2
_,_
3
TH_COURT
COOK.
4 _p_e_'_ Hc_'s
Yc_, I d,d.
Okay
"vl]_ COOK.
6
TH_
COL/P.T
?
_
COOK.
8
THECOU_T
9 _.s_ _pll
Dom_
_ ex_r_ You _
5
,_ trlsUmCl_l
&rye th_ (o -
6
you have oac mor¢_
10
_COOK
II
TH1BCOIFP.'T
M_._li
II
Good
C._xlrnomlng
my own bauen_
Ti-_ coLrP.T
t6
(t.m_t,0
17
ta
"I_E
yourHonor
14
_15 m.ornm_.
THECOUR'T
20
MS
V_
onpasel6
M_T]R),.KOS
YeS Yo_"
T_kmgaboutC4
2_
"i_ECOURT
/_crncaskyou-no,
O_y
Mark, man
00465
1 _e
__ucctra]
2 _owev._,
Izeguagc
_tt©d
few c_"chose sm_tta'_
3 _ _'lled fua4_en
ctf _ts
wo_ld
10,'2"7/05
Page
0C_67
I _p3d.
elemr_a-
10
perform
_he enar_
3
wE*oh have _n
_p
Ib_ ¢l,_m_ ¢lcrne_t E. mc._
to pml"orm
LheStaled
f0r _¢ re.asons I_: _._
c_ wtac_ _,_l
Hearing
pe_'c_Tn Ll.,ecnUr© staled f_c_oa
[
la _lcSnnn.
i_e _r, tc_nl
_ _ quzt©_
_t
10127/05
ofthn
Page
465
clum
bnpt,_e
o f c_ra
_ed doer i_t aJIow me to
a sp_cl ftc s_:_n_
"; _]_
hdd tohave
8
_'_ ofricl©at
9
_
of clam
c[em_
s_
_
]
whtch have _
held to bay©
to claim cle_
held io I_ve su_t
w_ch
have
s_
Dul$c which
of the _
Intmdeposmo_M_
e'_yn_'_ I E&d _ot n_t¢
20
the s:a.e_ f_uon
value,
_:Ltes
to
"Tins te_umony
_uld a s_nd
Car]soncoc_natcJa_m
13
_edct
suff_c_mt sm_.t ure to per f_'m
19
z_lpv_
for thc t_r
_avc
al DCfc'_danL_'_11
60 _'c_ f,h61
_h5
whtch
17
_omt
v_/u¢ m r_I_P-_
errmn_
Mr
mlS_
25 bythtsdzmeLemcr_
_d
r_m :¢'r 50 pagc
2_
Carlson there a:e any nL_rnlx_ _ f
meel the _',_tc p._t
_1 ],_qgu,_ e rc_t_
ffowevr
IHar_man
10t2._/05
_nd _ se_c_t
23
t_lelen_lne_
25 client
fc_, otG_c_:s_uc_res
Hearlag
first v_lue
2/
24
In h_
Itre_ts
m_
21
to de_on
oC s_ld
_l_uo_
A_hnCl_m11
2O said ser_ot
_ umbe': 49, p_ge$
_¢_
se_
_ m znlualcdm r_'_e
cro'_mg
19
t _e_
_d
ramp waveforrn having for c_.h haJfwaveof_JC_
I_
21
to kay© _
I t .7./6
_
16 AC _ 0flag© a _
17 to ct_=u_n
I I t_'_h_ld
for
wave form. re_tcs las_ ff'tc_e_ t s_:u_e
avoid _:uezTge_nc_
1) pcodua_g
24
$_c.t_
]
IJ_an'.o cJ_m _ c'mr¢_ which have
My o_mo_
12 _$
22
of
been hekl to _ave su fl'ictent s_'_ztm'e
11
13
_i_J¢
50,
2 .-]c'mc'_.
cL'um elerncnt C4 LSf_r mo_ .taa]oso_
8 to e_arnplcs of da_m elemc_
9 l_u_clcnt
numb_
is of the op_ruoa Ihat tbLSclaim
ir_._ _clc'_
Markn_n
claim element
a_pce_qcsu_ce, u_
L_
Camon
464
_vi_n
7
76, _d
th_c a.r_ a v_cty
Thc_c _c any numbs- of _z_ca_
4 fl_mmt
e _'_
C_lson,
I aS_e wLth VIr Carl_on
25 _vc_
go
Hearing
m _h_ dtcm
b_ Cotmd a/de lense -
23 f_¢tlon.
24 HOnOr, F
25
Mr
22 eJ_m_nt rc_tcs
16F
Tn_._S
23
_
Exh_l_t ";9, pa&cs 74 through
A cr.ol&ng to Mt
21
Tt'IE COURT
f_¢tloP.
2O fu_¢_on
Wh_lpagc_Jdyou
21 gay q
22
cbam
to pe_orm
19 Hce,uev er no¢ all of the.re smac_u_es p_ Corm LE_S_l.ucd
Okay
['m_orr'J
$11_c_e
13 chffm.ent slwctun:_ descn3x-d by [h© s_uc Usral la_'_ge.
F of my wn_cn s_crncaL
19
CaHson co_cededthaz
_ufltclent
pa_c 2B
17
Veur Honor, [ br.Jl_© we ]_
_
Tlus _mony
15 D_enctan_'
I_
W]"i'M_
when s_ad hsl_ sc,_sln$ me,_s I_
(.4 _ld not _te
13 the S_ed
I
Ve_, gcxxL
- at s_oa
off_l_
v_e_
Inhtsdepotmon
12 _dfinal
15
incJucbn_ rnea-_
10 dele_tmg dayhghL
Okay.Dr
[4 b',_t
m'_dc¢Se¢c3on
cohave a _ur_ v_Jue cbfief cat horn sa_d
9 t't_l and _c*ad
yes. _e _e
_WITNF_
tmmprc_lon
to s_d ]tE_t sc"_ lng m r.tn_ for c.se.sl
n g _ud
Lhre.sh_d vol_e
forDr
on the sL_md?
12 mar_lng
I_
_hat cJmm _uhcleme_
CL,_mC4Jsasfo]lows.
Saxi con _ot ¢lrc ml mc._s,
7 t'_p_J_tv¢
Arewere_dy
My opmto_
$_J_lCpZ-C
m :tvo_
5 112, paragraph6
ycah
Ok=y
regbt
THE W I']3q'E_S
3 C_ m ¢lf._ C,_J_m| LPa_hold _o h;lvt: third v a_ r._ rc_tt_
folkso_erherch_w¢
Tha,'xk you.
to come b_k
"Fn_s_l
2
for _t_mg
m d_ _o_
M_xt_re_'!_eto
sa_. _',ne_l"old to have _
of s_d I_e_ten_lne_
v_Iuc m teg_r_e
con_t_u
_ deleCtt_
cf _d
ce_tm_
_mon,
G d_
r_le
My C_[_on
su_e_t
conceded
_ruc_'e
c]_
to peri'o_
_e
P_e
Page466
JA 0897
467
004_1
I st_J
00469
] Ninths" 49. p3_
f_on
2
This _ttmooy
J
Ninth"
4
c_
4% plg_i _
be f_md
du_u_
_,
I zg_:c gd_ b@ Cz._on
5 s w.gt_z_
Exhlb_
2
tad munich" ._0, pazc 26
t._'c
arc zsrj numb¢_ o f
4
Fiowcv_r, fcwofihoscs_ctugcs
_¢ colu¢ s:a'cd l_.._tlon
suggc_Is
¢_mttc_,
6 Dcfc_d=n_
Of L_:SdaJm clcma_.
photon dctc_ou.
ty_ofphot_mdeA_to_
5 pk_
wo_]d
72 0UOU?J174, _nd nttmb_" _0. l_lgc27
I do _oI z_'== wlth klm h¢'.'_ Th_ pht_c
3 s_mR"
wl_ch mLght mcct thc sU'_ctu_J Lmgu,zSo tccttcd
6 byth_scllummL
7 pcKotm
;t O¢_dm_s'
9
three, photo "_c
coml_ctvr_
SI, which c_mm
_ce_pt_
ct a/, th fi'ffi_v.dDctecto_
B 0a_ugh
thr_: b_Jc
Ot_c, pholo¢ovduc_'_.two,
_
_tl_btt
7 Dcremak
+hght
Thcru z_
_d
._g
Prom
Sy_tegu,
_
_6
17
Photon det_tl_m
invo_
thc concept
of
th_phomnofhgMmtod¢c_al_eqw
And
w
l0 CnnV_tmg
J2 cctc_|
oi_ th=
l)
14
P_ pmp_¢a
_1 three o f th_
1S m thc p_c_tccl
16
T_s
L7 s=gg_tmg
LI
Clam
ele_i_t
H _ _
thlle_'_
L_I_I _m
8
Itelr[ug
lOrlWO$
Pog¢
2 ]an_e
the 0wct_l
of the p_¢_
3 t'a_rKm_
22
p_fcrm
t_
detec_ng
_ur to _smc
So I m_pr_.t
_hsht
9 b_t I med_'rnmcd
tt au'_yglvc_
the p_n
_:ecmt has no w_zns
13 p'_dctcrm
14
m_l _moa
_n a _at
mOmC_L
l_ tin.cage
_
H _ n01SUfllCl_L
thus, ought
'T:_
to chc photcgctl_
20
TdEW_S
2Z
C_t._.T
Io |glg_g
^ad
so w_
_
"rH_ COWRT
COOK
hzndwmtcn
A_d tt'g the or_ yo. bav_ gwm me
go _¢_fot_
I_
MR COOK
a_=g;mon
16
TE_ COURT
L_ mtsun_n$
m
19 _oto¢cll
L_ _L_L_
Okay
Yes
Nw'nbcr
I_
I/',at'sthc_J_t
L_ghtsc-_smgmcz_a,yt_
Aad you sccm to bc sly_
wktl t_
= _t
A_dthal_ac_ml_ePtom
2)
MR
22
"i_EWI_
say_
COOK
S thst thc
t'm
And ho'l s=ym 8 t
enough. I thau_c
20 ontll_¢n_;md_o&dM/
[_¥d Of b_L
d=m
brtc_
cb._ng:_ o..
a/rout, v, luch Is K
ges:st or_ Co.ning a v_tagp
TH_COURT
me aS=m to
Y¢.S.
14 t_tlficd
_o you =cd
469
_c sccros
at y_0ut _cd
Io onc of your
! 7 sU'ucturc acc_s,_ T = a photoccU u_¢_
19 _dmcn
21 ChVl_
9
THECOURT
17 of I I_J&
tl
Page
to the !_o¢oCC]l
Pm Ioolun8
MR. COOK
not avoid
10/27/0S
cqutvalcncc tlgrcof
ltt_he.d
13
wh_
m my _inlon, the _'h'u_A_r4l
of churn _C_C_
16 t_c c_dr_ _'¢uo_
Ihzt _
10
tl
t; mL'l or ace
F_O_h'_s rc_l
Io
Hearing
TI_ - wotdd :mu t_
12
for zs+-'_mg
re f_
to
the le_lStOl_ p_ge _, ifs ym_
any igm_st_c
THB COURT
! com_uc_on
By t L_glf w_thOut additional sc_cctma ctrctul_y,
It
12
of h_ht _d_
dc_c¢_f
_c_dly rc_tur:d
I.ffi_b,u:q_ o f tho p_t
MR. COOK
to r+x=n r_( jusl h_,
quzu_
aw._t o f the _ogon
_ _¢c_
to
¢ rig ptff_?
th tTuent _ rags s wee th_
7
tO
_ wh;t
t_ _wIi_ent
as I tmt_'_,_d
ymfvc got. b_ock +6 o.r tim 56 cv¢_ut lab¢]¢d
3 phc_cc¢ll _
and
Ih_ _c Icgm light _.ad
to m_
dct¢ctoi3
ftmcuon, which,
s_'ncm,
fiugu©n
t_ that by
pholon
_ted
of thL_
with Mr _bon';
4 to bc ;idd[ng now rc_l$1ags al lc_t
d_-]i_ght wen: n_g_eA
8
mu_
The sw_cunl
2 Izt _J:.m.
the
_e W_cnce
of the=
t_n w_
the l_cd
=s to _u fi"c]em suuccue
th¢:n'l_Av_+ _
00,171
I cb.m_ cc_._tmct ion bcfom
of d_zghL
[I _
6
reqt_
to pt_onn
that I dg._pcc
21
th_
language
Markman
"_e ;_.ucau-A
t ct'c_'a to I=ght. _ I_:_
language
4 _grcc
- Pm gwO'
Mz _uhcct
IS _lT/clcnt
468
0O470
I hshz _1_'¢_
I1= g_d tho stP_c_
Tho _¢_
2._ Mr T_¢_es
Marian
to bc wl_
19
,a_Jng
_¢ cqt._lly mcfld
C_rC_L
whm
¢lanent
?,5
[ wgl
"._d
sccn_
1g clam
2O concfmwn
of th_ ,mdy_s.
photon dct_w
you aJI b_mlly
_.n:c d
HtgsIml
Iwdlshowy_sd_ec._rt
YoutHo_a_
tlt_hu
ucverbcm
23 my p_o_.
24
N_
2:_
THE COrJ_T
COOK
NO. It t_'1.
Well,
yo_
]_trkmaa
2¢
I_g - _
He,
flog
Wopc_cd
1_Z7/05
2_ yottr
Page
470
THECOURT
Oily
I:_Sl_l_, "ma| dunk It w_
Wdl,
Markmaa
JA 0898
tlrnaynot_veb¢cn
p_h_ps thc'g p_tuon
Hearing
._l
10_2W95
P agc
471
0C473
00472
I ¢q ea_le r m"r_.
2
I
MI__COOK
3 defined
Hefe';bo_v),fr
Mas_ca_p]lhas
it m red.
4
_'i_L_ COURT
I'm trym_ to g_
oppo._cd to lUSt dlS_
to thagmge
6
_ it'_ om+nptr_g cvcr into _c
7
DR_ _AL
_U_. COOK
S
THE COURT
P.,Sht, _
TI4E COURT
7
Ira orym 8 _o fred
_11t w-a.¢ nec_ai
MI_ COOK
THE COURT
t0
tha_B _c an: Ioolc_g a_ Bu[ _c oth¢_ d_a B we are [ookm 5
10 your
II
at_dle
11
t2
¢ons_l.c_tort7
doy_h:tvothedc_c_gm_'pmbosedcl_m
_m ¢:(tra.
L_that Ihc or e they handed
Tabf.
t_l
t7
wearetatkinggbOulW_edh.l.sbocnmsdcH
coc. [ock at the gs_ ClaLrn, ratmber 15
1 | COrlS_+_C_On that w_
to mean &at the _J_:t m'c n_a.+7
20
ftm_on
ts the phoiocdl
21 VCnLtC__fr¢
from
16
d_LS the one
the l_$v.t_:
photoocl]
Iq
DR. CARNAL
_nd *:_mc othu
D_
Markman
10/27/05
Page
W'mu's m_k_
3 d_us'_eml is _ :l.=mS: 6_m
L_'s
mear_
6 Massensdl
|n h[os t:_e
T_4FCOURT
8
I_
O<ay
WiTNeSS
9 KI, r_3
CI_m
I J r_,e._
In_mm
_
_tlal
o[ th_ w_
Hearing
10/27/05
_
few of the:
8
t_
L_=wlse..
Con:to] _s'm_l
[_-mp =m_ rem?ormt vc to _d
12
fi_t
5_
1_m_'e
a fc_rn
r_t _Jk_vr_©w
c1_'m_
sW._c
GI_
wh_h _a_
[O
beta bo_ to have
to =xampk=
My opm:on
thai clarm ¢lcmmt
and
I 3 to dete_tt vn of first predetermined
=t
14 w_a ffime_t
IS
to 5_d _'¢ rind
ofgl_m
¢I_s
c_a..dm omamd _- =au_ing _Jd l,_ntp io e'mlt
m the a by,m',ca of =ud f_t
K2 me.ms _po_3
con&Iron
se,JcoJ_e to :tvc_d mte_Pe_tlon
C_a_n ¢]eeaent K2 t_ _s follo_,_
I _ cm_h'o] ccrc_tt mean5
_tmm
17 l_=_-rmm_d
meJudcs
17 of s_Jd firs113iedeter_lned
_der
Wh_em
m_z,_
_nthBo_
se
reclte_
1) _J_
_a_d
_espo_Bve
t_ detec_on
[or mJBa_ng
I _ h.T_t _ s_d se=ond lev©I o_ill_m_ma_on m r_sbor_scto
LK mcaL_mO'ncnt
O[ _ p'tedeXef_CLmed Um¢ m _'_J
19 _t¢c_oa
19 to exp_azloa
of szld th'V¢ mt eJv_d for C4t_ mg sa_d Itrap to
In _
firsl _r =_mn_'d
de_llc3n
r_l_d
Mr
C._h_
c_nch_¢n
_r_=_
LmSU
_tcteat _CmW=
cl_m
20
d_¢r ¢_qer calla hBht _t _d
tO i_ _fOn'n _'C
_t
21
_¢
22
absence
Z2 S_m.d i_Jm¢_m.
23
Th_ t=s=m_y
c._c._c._c._c._c:cmm
bo fotmd al D ©fe_'
23
_t
24 num_b_" 45, ptS=s 47 thmash 50
2_
I ae_e¢ w_
Mr
475
cl_m
c[,_u'ncl fm_mt I( I i_ Cu-rn0re amJogo_
of_l_m
I 0 l_ut'flclemt
I _; predetm'am..d
21 c[omm't KI
Page
_um_
I t wl_ch b_v_ been hcld to have sun_c:=mt s_-_¢cur=
I $ s_d C_I levd of dlmmu=tt_on m re_e
Z0
4,"3
Lh¢ sm+ct_l'aJ _n 8xt,_._'cfecrtcd
However,
ttqmu=g_._'tdck_
9 e_mpl=
ser..3_d
14 s.e_ a d _ev.=or _e_m_ [O_ c_t=m 8 s._d lamp to e'ralLIs_
ofs_
Page
7 cr_v=10n • ;Ix=ffic s_tll:_e
s=m_mtm:to a_d
K I _ a_ follows
to _
I_ck wbon
F_'_ nn the m_ure ma_ed furct_on afth_
6 ¢lcm_IKl
HTJ6
=Im_t
c_led
thal _ust the
4 elememL
c:.=
_Imm dcr_=_t
to emit hght at fi_
re=_es ll_lKfi¢1_t
Lt mLm'!_clavont_
tus md¢_n_'nt
Hz£ o* and th_ chart Hts
we P_t in w_th fits original pap_
3 ,void
Go,mesA
My 01_r lon _
for cA_sln g _
g_v= _
he dadn t ague
_ frick-at
2 by th_s :_m_ ¢'¢ment
Cded ]us report 2ed _sv¢ bt_ dep_auon_
7
i2
of what these
w_
W© chdn I _
with out pOSltlOp. We
Markmaa
th= opm_mg bn e_. b_l _fs _I
ta - _md
went out :rod _ch_t_cd
who would t!pee
472.
on thu
been vmctun -- you kmow, th_ h=_ be_
gzv¢ u.I perrm_Jon
who would
$ p_t _on mm_ s=nce _nor to 01¢ _=methat _ s_rt_e Mr
10 t=vcl|,
Hor_r
so both sides
oe47_
1 suructar_ which mlghl m_
$o y=t. tI's a _-
4 =_a_
based on c)lenl tnleap_t_tlo_
22 opmmn
2_
_s
00474
I fi)m_ mor_
2
a
experts
Z4 ph_t_ll
M_"_gdl
Hearing
8 i_ne f, _e _d
the che_t, as both 51des put in
2I reed to t_nd someone
ZJ
[ th*ak the red oudme _t
the re_Lczordlv:d_" nefwork
2_ lr, Clu_rlg
whal this _
Wc TeteJncd Pro fc_,so_ Meal
Z0 emd find :,omcc_¢
OC- thafs
te_tstors
to 1cayo_ ¢[omg¢
tiled oar tsx.mn
hy Mr Amn.,on
wanled a hea_qg,
I_ o_t,dc
F_+ that p_calu
aadsothafsj_twh_l'maSkln_hm_
24
PII expl_n
when _
T_C_ wtlen Your
17 yau
md L[o.sdaim
be£cre _e_ char_ed tL
FT©s now sa3nag
23 t_nv_
pm not gou_
12 cheat exim'Is
aRaghed to tF¢_ brl¢_ I mtcrpn_
t9
t_at _JI
al th_ bomL
MR. COOK
13 dodaraiamn
o_
yCatL Soifyoa[ookat
te
bec_us=
I now tmdc_tlmd.
14 their cLL_m intcrptetauo_
D'IffCOURT
22
posmo_
12 At h_e he,arming
t4 t;'as raomng7
15
thch" pos3ttoo
the pholoceil
9
Do you have these that hay©
DR_ CA_A--
rm a_kmg the dere_dm_l bo:at_c
V _
8
t3
-
_, m_txa_y [ th(3ugbt _'c pamca wcr_ m agrcerncat
9 Cczhon and Mag_,_ gill _ yea.% thc red and blue. Tba_'5 _c
Let me_'lfIha,._
rm]ust
[ see the confumen
_t Eooks to mc ts i f they cha_g=d
pttLte wumt block, t gu_s
yOLU Honoc
phot_ll
3
4
as
_e
"J'F[_ COUgT
And wh_t he $ Ot_Imed nt red ts
5
reterrJU_ to _
2
C_hm_
_e_e ue _y
Markn1:_a
n_b_
Hearln_
of
10/27/05
Page
474
to s_Jd second
Mr
of _ccur_¢'a¢c
lust
kv¢l of J[hunmatma
predetccmmed
o_ s_ud _u_l pec_
:n
¢.ondYoo_ m _c
,_m'mned =¢nchaer
C_r]son thd not ¢O_L, xg O_ o_raraer*t on claim
24
¢lc'ment IC?. Assurmng
_5
5_e
my op_mon
th_ th_ wa_ an ov_s_hL
that this c]_Jm ¢lem_t
P*l=rkmart
JA 0899
_qd rcsp_nstv¢
I _1
r_tlCS
HeJarin_
10/27/05
0_75
O9477
I m_C_:zcm
st_u:_¢
to perform t_ s_l
I'ur_uon and
2 L:_=e_docsnolevozd=lerFi'e_,_onu._c=
3 o_o:
11_6
:: b:..qd o_ _e f=r._ L:_ th_
4 _ffeTe:t
conmol a_:m=
d_cuon
c f _d
E _pond
So th_s co_zcl_d_ my opLmo.
My
zr_q_acm
:re = v:st =rmy of
p:z'_
whtch coukL quote, r c_Tcnd to
fi_._ ixed_rm_cd
Io dclecLIon ol'nm[mn
co.non
clzm
6
Th:u is,
The neXl _uon
the ;_c.zu_
o f z pa_on m O_he=object.
7
8 which wou_d z_.
$ hz,ve - I _21c4
9
S_h
4 Conu_ ¢zzctu[ o_:x[ pOl i_ u._r.d [o tL_Z OO
II
_¢:ad,
f_" a spcai]cd
II could bc used (o s_d
Bffcze
we g_ Sl.lZ_l
find Lhem_t_
c_aJm chart
it to rae. that wo_ld be hclp£ul to me
And d_ utcx
chin'1 LS10ar..b_ _o wh_* m s,_tt _
apphmc= _¢h
c_m
12 U_
M_. COOK
15 hnth_, _t
15 _.
_m
e_u
I_
m _"
m_'e _logous
wbt_
have
I_
Appcn&x
A to F_ro_o_
th_
be In your
mA
a cove" SI_eL
UR. CAR_._L.
13
TH_
i_ufllc_e_t
[t rn_ _t_]p
d'z concez,_l behnd the t_ by first = -
17
to _ple_
hdd to _
o0 th,lL J
[ dofft kzo_,
a_d cooed c_l[y _r_
14 M _;z m_pD*_ wnzt _n st_e_enz_
Claim cl_
funcuo_ cl_rn
II
II
m d_rm, oFc'n = sa_c,
13
19
the mcz_s pl_
[0
[4 eJ_t¢l.
la
my opmmn aa
9 whxt [ _lzv_ do_e with it. but z{'_nybody h_ za exb'z c_y
period of or_¢.
12 u,do<k or lock * door, _¢rn on _ay ekcmcaJ
wF_:h s
c_'ct_s
6, 9, 10znd
"["r_ COURT
to
S¢cI_o_ I 12,
of my ilatma_,
;[_t_r_
wb_c_qd_fln_
clcmcn_s of Ci=m
_chtcd
Io ow'_,_me
Scctzon 6 of roy 'unt_a
7 s_re of wb_r.h wo_d perform L_¢SL_L_I CUnc_n but rno_[ of
IO a limp Ccom dim co bn_t
_ctu_
19 yore" _ly
I_s tab 48, YO_ Honor
COU'RT
Fin's'/_SJ_t, I d_n cw_-_t to _k¢
cop.y
20
M.R. H[C_]_$
22
_Ot. COOK
3.3 znd cowr=h_=
Her_'s zr_exb'_ copy
Lock _hmd
The=
_
th_o
supm'flucm t_bs
o£zD Cc_xof these
24 erJzthx_
25
M_rkman
H_rl_
10_7/05
Page
THF.COURT
_r6
H_rlng
10/Z7/05
Page
477
0047_
I t_
Now,
do_
tt m:y md_dc
- the ma_tcr cT_m cba_
thngs
it Iook_ hkc
u'_l uc r_t m dtrpu_
ccnc*.t _ Fox m._._nce, I_,
l &_'¢
d_£m© m th_ cZaJm ck,_t wh_h
hmp
wu
la
4
[0
]v_
CCOK
12
_U,_I_COURT
14
"r_'_s
zre in d_p_¢
or
b_ _e;18_ed
6
f_is
=_J_
So if| not t.p to d._te on t_
AIIrt_L
mceiv_r_tes
l_ c_ra_eaemtc_
Le.qczd,
AII_RhL
T_yo_
the _
WcYe
Thin
dz_n
d_
the
_31 oplmon rr.i_dm| thes[n2_re ci_nmg
20 been d._scusscd_d
Cla_n r.L.-rtr_Aha_ _ezdy
"1_: w_ttcn
cs n:produc=_ _ _"_ top of bo_'d A,
24 ap_
level _'hgh_
de_._t_
c_thtto_
tdc_
¢XI¢_
on a pho_cdl
Markmag
shown
However
soon u ;ny h f,EI
_ht; 8 not how the
On the pllCtOceg r _,_h_
_ome
l_,v_ dcc_d:d concsponds 1o Lb=_mwl]
tba_ _s LhC_d
"_
0f
o_m_mmc
level cce..ddbc _lccted
to be a_y _"_d of
furl darkn_L_ _nd full dayh_t,
IS t_n
weal tho cm_m de;t_z©nt
16
may w_h
In the p_en_, the se.Je_uon em:mlr/w_r_
d_.athn_
so_compl_
17 sel_J5 the i_e_ele_ed
lever ofphoto_JI
I _ respert_e to WhICh1_e
czrcmt wl[J switch I.be larop _
20
dlvtd_
_rp_
c m"r_ t In
on
Of two r_zslon On
I_o_k 56 oft_e
m pholo_.l[
flgm© 2B
fic_
22
THECOURT
23 le_lc_
el thee, _d
2_
col_s_og
ct_¢_ sz_" of the pbozocetl
LDSt_d
O_eprede=nv.medc.on&uenl_thepru;el_-_cd
u_c_
the
the errcu_ _u_d
12 da_mc,
21 '066 ps_t,
o f the p_cnt
ofpred_L_zam_[
w]uch
t_ ,ctrcmt does rml z._ztr_ the r;mp off"
19 to Off"_ a vo[t_c
21 _ lur.'_
*_e am lookm8 ath_'re.
23 two _xa
th_
I1 d_z_'s
14 h_ht ber.;ve_
Lhec_,,u_kry m_l_etex_
[9 c[aua clemml^,ser_orm:a_.
znd bdcw
level, th_ is the lev¢_ ;I which the c_rc_t
tO pr_c_
_Tk_
My
Io rec_Snt2e
9 uad] _he [_J_t _[_g
Okzy
the Izmp will be
7 eJro_tt of me pme_t wet k._
0_ly
Okay
whtch
as dzytazc_
to t'_vlt_z the I=mp oiTz;
on L_e p_meelL
13
t $ thllce_
fig=r e 2B, _v¢
be d_bcd
l( is tmper_nt
J
8
TI'IB COURT
_
1_ that
_mv
e_t:_ne_u
*C66 pat_
2 o_T,whch
rmL
22
Sothts3slab48.
Markm_n
00473
13
Thznkyc_.
ASnghL
Stop
Hr_v,['m
rm I®km S u ,% and thai doesftt
zeem m c4_rre_p_dw_th wh_
he j_t
sz_& So what zm l
m block $6 of
14earing
I0/27/0 S
Psge475
Markman
JA 0900
He._qug
10_27/05
Page
479
0GI81
O0480
L
MR
COOK
2
THE
COURT
3
MR
COOK
4
THE
COURT
MR
COOK
5
6
"predetermined
7
In v, ords,
He's
dlscusslngthe
So we have
the
only
golten
2
pan o f A '
_eah
aS defining
Once
whole
claim
THE
COURT
10
MR
I[
THECOURT
12
[ql be pahcm
element
that
are defined
uses
that
6 particular
7 circuit
phrase
So we arc gemng
AIInght
10
there
rathaUon
16
modem
the '066
on
patent
The other predeLermmed
a pa;r of P[Rs
figure
2A
shnv,
n as QI
V,hLch ",_dl cause
the
and
lamp
Q2
nl
to
17 swltch from on dlm to on bnght
18
AS wtth
the photocell,
19
the circuit
20
thrn to on bright
21
infrared
22
could
It _s Important
be designed
a_ soon
Io swlleh
_
_slth
cffcml of the patent works
24
s_ltch
25
mfvared
the lamp
from
_muon
detected
One
to
patenl
15
the
me,ms
claim
16
one
the photocell
and
17
And
two
sensor
the
from
On
19
means,
m
20
circuitry
Instcad the clrculldoes not
23
sensing
24
must
by the PiPs
meet
m
Ilearmg
10/27/05
Page
and
¢lrCUl[48
and
x_hat
as meant
elemcnl
A of Claims
support
9,
selection
selection
in Ct,_lm
clement
1 [ clann
I0
and
I I
circuitry
and their associated
w_th
ofthe
potenually
its associated
one
thing
ffelemcnt
duphcate
elrcullry
A sensor
or v_thout
which
bc rcspons_
a selecllon
the
of claim
pro,. Mes
e to hght
Moreover
A mcloded
that portion
that the
external
in J[I the claims
hght
_hcre
photocell
element
IO said
H
hght
sensing
means
appatattts
It appears,
f_larknlan
480
OO482
by predetermined
description
which
be lbe photocell
means,
25
certain
the amphfy
for se_ cr'al reasons
Poe
the change
PIRs
cannot
this _ould
untd
of the detector
comparalOr
tv, o structures
Nevertheless
the
to on bright
46
carl see that the ;_-nttcn
describes
the
¢o which
5 I
It _s understood
_e
22
to on bngM
clrcmt
selects
on thin
orcutt
the x_lndo_
14
change
fi thas ts not how
Markn_an
[learmg
10127105
Page
481
Page
483
O0483
I Clmms
9
10 and
I1
ffclatm
2 construed to encompass
3
photocell,
4
ClrCUlL_¢ this
d
CI
6
ofdlumtnallon
7
condmons
g
iflummaoon
9
condlllon
that
with
m the
absence
light
tn response
]fth_
photocell,
12
off
13
the
14
¢lementCI
15
II
lamp
clause
of said
to detection
Is off.
_ouid
tl does
not emit
_hcn
infrared
element
4
reprcsentatt_
at sald It; cl
5
output
level
6
hght
it's my concluSmn
means
ctrcultry
bo_ not to the photocell
20
selection
c_rcuttry
21
defines
refers
c_lm
aS marked
htch,
IO the PIRs
the
eleracnt
As shown
claim
clement
and
their _-ssoclatcd
of which
A, sensor
rae_ms
m red on
A IS marked
m dlagra_n
ctrcml
10,rod
selection
A
_ ah
14
pholoCell
shown
I5
clrcullry
for either
[ behex
photocell
does
20
structure
21
se_ eral reasons
in blur
24
clmm
element
A
25
response
the
Markman
Massengdl
Ilearmg
defines
th_
structure
10127105
PIRs
or the
Carlson
element
Ci
to the presence
JA 0901
_s a
condmon,
rcqmrcs
the
Q2
Carlson
and
associated
the
selection
does
not
first as that the
A
contention
the
{hal the
photocell
mthcated
A would
for
mclt_on
be inconsistent
that the
absence
Markman
Page482
'I've
A Includes
and
A
photocell
as I box e already
_hleh
and
any
_ ith Mr C:ulson's
in element
QI
structure
not define
For example
photocell
contends
PiRs
element
mode
low
of the predetermined
)6 without
reasons
defining
ot Io¢,
clrculffy
labeled
predetermined
the
A for t_o
f thsagrcc
of the
Carlson
tn block
element
selection
sho_, n on board A
only
the
in
thai m IR arc
_ohage
of the
c th.lt the
x_hich
changes
by a high
,rod Q2
the absence
encompasses
22
the struclure
the detection
23
Mr
eh.mgcs
ofthe
QI
By comparison, also
[9
in my opinion
the output
structttre
2 clrcmt
A
the Pigs,
13
18
those
as manifested
at node
And hlgb representing
17 define
A, sensor
in accordance
diagram
representing
16
_sth
its associated
sffxlcturc
as understood
element
9
detects
that _s either a high or low
12
by claim
figure
rathatlon
selects
c of motion
w_th
I I condition
as reqmrcd
and
Specifically
since
v, hen
of the '066
infrared
condition
be lamp
the etmm
that
and
10
IO the
would
energy
g signal
predetermined
the portion
external
7 _soc_ated
of
construed in accordance
19
¢imrn
3
v.hlchapFeLrsmcachofthcCialms
Ig
24
momlol_
the claim
ro apply
not sausfy
11 _6
I I _6
2
a selection
of said
cor_lrued
17
ofv,
I encomp_ses
xsere
prcdetel_uncd
in sa_d second
_ere
this
AS a resuLt
23
_lth
the first lex=l of filummalton
Howe_er
22
or without
b¢ inconsistent
and emit5
means
the predetermined conthtLon of thc
is nLgh[llm¢
would
A selLsor
9
11
16
clement
prm _des thas the Imnp emits hght
which
] 0
2a
designers
I[ is they wish
consas_
mhthtt
conditions
21
on dim
circuit
in response
from
Cl_CUll_
47
count
the
the phott_e
23
the
circuitry
output
lamp
13
any
detect
the
the turn on
pulse
J_np
thai
as the P[Rs
selection
PIR
selection
circuit
18
to reeogmzc
radlauon
However,
filter
I I the
Weregcttmgthere
14 condition is the preseIected levelof oh,rage In infrared
15
This
ctrcm143
12
WITNESS
'Ahlch
to _ halever
the
preselected
',_ dl switch
8
9
Go ahead
THE
13
conditions
corresponds
In the patent
- those
Okay
COOK
decided
the words
thafs
8 aSdefined by the red block
9
have
4 detect
All nght
This
conthtlons
is the
Thai
3
coodmon
then
I preselected
v, ords
lamp
of the
Ilearmg
with
emu
hght
m
predetemuned
10127/05
00484
C04gS
co_[ion_
wha_
conthoon
r c'mazr_
in the _bsc_ce
assoczased w,_
p_
the phc_occIL
Q'T_ I_'d
mghRlmc,
I
the Ixrop
2
off
pho_cell,
if e]_l_nl
A v. c-re to tncl_
th_s would dophcatc
clement H.
thai pomon
th_
of clam
musl
be rcopor_lve
eR'm_l
H appea_
6 s_ond
to
though
10 not m Clam_
I I lengthy,
clot
zs tdc'nocal m all thn_
12 _
13 all thrr_
sccocld reason thaH
15 smictu_e
16 el cl_-nt
do_
A must include scleclton
18 et_t
19 w_
..haz Mr
not wedetermmed
moBon,
cannot
13
tutorial
_scusslon,
14
material
hawng
15
forth
of
clrcm w/
rathalton,
neganvc
A couJd mclodc cztheT the P[Rs o_ the phazocdl
I8
voltage
the_sd'.
the sdecuon
Ix_ausc
_ d_¢c[
Mr
Carlson's
Carlson
comcnuon
d_t
clrcmw s" _sooal_
n_th_
w_
of thc_.e coroponcr_
19
trace
may or may
oh)eel
a p_edc_rrmned
co_cb _o_
21
de fmc_ _
"pr_d_rmmed
22
tr'nn
23
conthooo"
to have the same n-.e_nmg m Claams 9. ! 0 and I I
24
_s first p_'dr._crrm ned conth hon and sccor_
24
c_-ctuiJy
25
have
wedetc_m_ned
m CLann 6
Markman
produced
H_rmg
10/27/05
Page
I h_e
2
3
Using my
SPICE
4 of _g_l
plots.
5
THECOURT
6 that?
THE
8 wngram,
9 braid
_,
I have gcncualr.da pmr
not
m my
switches
back and
m mfra:ed
brief pulse
of
clccmcaJ
Rapcr'$
t_c]llos¢ol_
statemenL
This
motion
pulse
of a person
or
ctrcmt not all pulSes
lamp
the
Inslead,
the setccuon
th_ th c¢.c PIP. Ssg_;_s
by the czrcmt
destgner
which
Io r¢ln_cml
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
485
SPlCEgzzrudatlo_s
Stop
SPICE.
stmulatlon
You_
Here.
f eprr.se_tat_ve
Wha_s
_
Honor.
5 exttmal
and look at p_mc_
12
THECOURT
13
DR. CARNAL
Okay
o f it c_led
16
THE
17
THE COURT
18 scr_scofhur_x,
Thee
ohay
9
shownmthelop_agramlab¢lulPIR-I
the s_gnals
II
app_ox_mal¢ly
12
The
atand_ for Srmulauc_
yo_
_mecrs,
t_-y
have
a good
W1TNESS
21
stgnaJplotboaxd_ggef?
22
have
23
oFerat]_
gene_aled
The first signal
plots
m the ctrcmt
plot marked
that'$
could
have
a board
- a
the b_rd
Markman
v. hlch
14
which
m the _
15
output
of the
16
retie
A of the
hen:
ase tbe output
ofth¢
as Defendants'
thal
Exhl"bl[
w¢'_e Iookm8
Hearing
at
10/27/05
Page
486
arnvc
apart
figtwe
dcxaces
Exhi'_ t 52
of the window
2 diagram
count,
Theyarc
amemg
m t_me.
m Defendants'
is bleclc
which
ts block
comparator,
48,
51,
and
at the
me_mcd
at
'066 c_rOUL
go_;
low
the nega_ve
Scans
puls_
of th© window
Cmnl_,raio¢,
at tlus pumt
ts the output
And
22
moUon
23
Note
24
output
25
slgnllles
II ts _ th_
has been
detecled
that the htgh
and
Node
pumt
and
we see
aod this
of the
low
A in _por,
thai predelmnmed
that the Wecktennlned
the lamp
transmon
wJl[ So to bnght
tn t_
se to the amval
motion
Markman
JA 0902
PIR
counter
21
'066 palenL
to
osclll_copc
andPIR2
PIR
al the output
pulse
and Q2 respunslvc
Raft's
PIR s_gnals
of the
seconds
So the purse,
puls_
Mr
LHI 778
the
bolt om plot
thai signals
20
sllusWate
two
PIR- I aod pig-2,
Andtha_e$1gnalsare
al the output
shows
17
UsmgmySPICEstmulaOon,|
a pair o f signal
of the PIPs
52 Trigger" - a_d
And ill
s.nulaoon,
13
18
P[Rs to turn on the
of Q]
by
model
I 0
and
19 stgnaHhat
THE
He,mann
node voha_s
Than_youvcwmuch.
20
described
here and szmu]ath
to
N ulmng.
Th_dc
ofthe
_
labeled
voRag_
wlthmtwoseco_dsofeaobother
one
Theyhav©a
W1TbrESS
sz_muh.
P1R
8
allows
_'_dcyo_
SPICE
the top signals,
In _
14 I_wlthlnte_Su_racclmng_s
va,-ta_
_s a comput_
use o f the
7
tl_
of a ctrcul[ such as _n
zl c_ the computcr
slmulated
4 show
6 trace
WIThm_SS
a c_rcmt
a modal
-- illuswaIes
lamp
3
I'm _.or_
7
25
preseleCled
rathat]on,
0o487
2 cztCml to dctecL
24
mgger
only tnggc"z's the lamp
been
m
hgbl.
¢o chang_
Markman
I wh,_cvcr it_ thaithe cffCtald_ignei" zntcnded for the
15
6 ofhts
by the
m the palented
by a PIP,
detecl
og the reverse
m Mr
of page
484
00486
10
solng
shown
not be caused
Moreover,
23
rapidly
a characteristic
al the boRom
changes
As mthcatc_
exposed
po_tlve
_
detecl
con._*sls of an In_sulated
wblch
when
and
level
a predetermined
m tn fr_cd
a PIR sc'_so_
or current,
20
by
pIRs
&sputed
a pul_nty
producing
means
and
ofhght
be seriously
going
sensc_
and photocells
changes
by I80dngr_
17
Mr
levels
detsct
12
frrst
sa_d apparatus
apparatus
not motion,
That PIR_
16
z_:ludu_
25 condmon
_4_muon
rachat_on,
pr_etermlncd
to mean
_s l wdl explain,
Howev_,
10
C_lson's
condition
8
I
ILx hthat 49. png_
to said
from
scpar_e
predctem3med
clam
with
compo_mts
22
beheve
fi_t
relallve
to satd
it
m
defin_
motion
or object
m fr_'ed
_ qmt¢
for ¢lcrne_1A
not dcfinc A zs thaz the I 12/6
I c_cc
20 _
LS mtend_l
6 exprrssly
IOmean
9
clazms
TI_
17
A. v.hlch
I I aad
clazms, wblch mak_
thai the sam© meaning
14
21
10 and 9. cbnn
only m C_m
In De fendanL_'
7 of hght external
g said apparatus
Evm
condition
5 of a person
to hghl cx_mal
be fomgl
33
Claim
4
hght sc'r_lng mr.a_s, v. hich prc_ tdcs thai the
sensing n_.s
9
This can
32 through
3
In edchoon,
7 hght
of _e
pulse
count_
of the second
pulse
has beam detected
tlearing
10/27/05
Page
487
OO489
004S$
I
Thzs
lOW signal
and
lamp
2
the ]ogsc
3
gppropna_e
4
is nt ghtllme
5
6
looked
at ts _
9
ts al tab 57
10
tab
use of _
t3
_
t4
labeled
15
voltages
16
descnbed
17
Model
_ our Hor_of.
56 m yot_
four
20
s/xac_
PIR
This
I axal PIR-2
of QI
and
by Mr
again
Rapc_s
23
bo_c_cL
24
aparl
arc
bei_ _n
4
PiPs
5
mohoo,
6
stmulatcd
11
shov,
mprescmanvc
e to ext craal
trace
signals
fulLher
14
ctrcult_
as
15
Io PII_
PlR
apart
amv¢
17
go mlo
they're
thee
sdectcd
21
47
simulation
22
Ls the
to the PIR
signals
Ilearmg
10/27/05
Page
p¢_crthed
is
to
that ig
within
the
mc4mn
ou_puk Node
A. does
and
contlol
the lamp
hne at the mp hcte
by a sobd
u slays
h_gh,
iv, o s_mulat_oa
signals
and
the
cxpcnmems
m rc:_por_e
lamp
wdl
s=gnal
2 ¢_rcmtr/m
plots
the_e _c
_,t
nol
of Exhth_t
other PIR
the no
thai
thai are
43, 46,
motion
that
52
s)gn.ds
m response
to I_
as teprcsen[atl,.¢
tugger
s_gnals
Markman
488
sbow
blocks
of I_csen_oed
are no_ selected
mouon,
clearly
to LR del¢¢tion
as rc'ptcs_ntalr,,e
tagger
25
signals
mode
pIR
And
fmlhet
designed
do not arrive
count_
by the '066 figure
delecl_tm
was
condl(Iotx
tt no[ _ggn_ed.
show_n
bnght
24
And
not respond
4g, and5]
23
v,e scc
s_gnals
pulse
not go low,
are
20
the
tht's
Thcse
19
m the
s=gnals
rcspoodS
that does
of PIR
clremt
the prcsct_bed
_fll
16
lg
within
m Um¢
PIPs
of the
clear delmcaaon
_foch
detect
I wotdd
as, q_ote,
- bears
9
sclccuon
motion
and
ftmctmn
m mfrared
c)rctat_y
2
rarhallon
which
to scc mdttsu7
detecl
magc
from
re fernng
web
slte_
bear
thLs
Exhthtt
whtob
cxanponeats
l'a_a_on
54 tS a ¢oll¢caon
tllusWal¢
but not moOon
the other hanlL
conccboa
15
deR'¢_
'_l_.h
a_e no[ ¢_mt
16
otcmls
o_Rmru_
m bot_mgs
17
asso¢_aled
Ig
sa_d to employ
19
ofpcodact
hte_tm_
electrical
bill
p_lsc
22
THE
of
plots
of _xhfoll
Ilearmg
10/2";'/05
Pa_e
489
Exlab_l
comFone_ls
a number
Honor,
WITNESS
¢lerr_/ll
24
shou/d
A w_¢
25
efore e'nt A must
Photocells
co_a'uod
not be (or rcasom
also
It Is also
to mettle
! bare
be de freed
Markman
9
regarding
10
c_rctat
lfl
the
CImm
el_m_nl
CI
e tO first sensor
15
thagram
PIPs
b_
_6
wcrc
also
17
of L_
18
selexuon
a photOcelL
thai
which
CI
T_
logical
21
thin
22
Lamp state
of the
Page
491
control
wtth
23
reqmred
hght
Io perform
to mcMde
the photocell
s
25
!'n'edctcrmmed
at slud
t]_t
the
c=rcmt
_s
me_s
tn red on
sc_eezed
_s the
_oa
Io the motlt3,n
the funchon
lamp
the cttcmt_y
gaung
function
and
of the
oatpta
that
caL_ing
thai _s
to the lamp
stud
the
as
lamp to Cm=l
o£saM
at sa_d second
/Harkman
stale,
tmplemenls
ctatem
level m {h_ a_er_e
conthtmn
and
In my
tamp
by approp_ately
24
control
thal ts connected
of des_r_
along
thscussed
thagram_
perforratng
determmaaon
tt
JA 0903
CI,
of which,
i$ m_ked
_ h_ch I have
andtoth¢
thea
490
Myoptmon
element
been
el,
comparative
cl_mtr_
ot bright,
ah_ady
rt'_ar_,
crtctutry
cxplmn¢._
Page
clmm
efomem
2 cttcult
prc_vlot_ly
10/'27/05
of hghL
pleasc_
The structure
figure
This
20
C1
chum
s_ture
066
19
tf
on board
has
de fme:s
5g and
selection
level
mcaas
respOnSl',
tube
by a photocell
whereaa
a partlcul_
defimng
optmon,
my opmton
Hearmg
l;aucture
of the
A zs apphed Io
a photoeen
couldha`,eboardCI
14
are
tight,
to detect
13
ot'whtch
of hght
not just
only detect
_ needed
Now.
the presence
m elcmem
level
c_rcmt_y
tool=on
no_3us_
th_e
parl_cular
55 ts a
coummg
Yout
ofa
adthtlortal
¢1rc_I_
descry/¢_L
condmon"
reproduced
but complcled
c,_n_mtung
¢l[_Ul_
12
Exh_m_54aml_SarcSSa_d591ath¢
23
detectmn
I I
only as m fr_ed
for PIR based
ctr_mlrJ,
COOK
Inoth_'v,x_ds,
as electrical
detectors
D¢ fondant'
14
ofproducl
the P[Rs
and rc fc_s to P[Rs
detecthv_
On
rcqtares
S
fo_ PIRs
! 1 clrctat
the
5
7
_,.s c_tt
ht_
4
6
various
selection
As I ha', ¢ _rv_dy
3 ttaTn"prcdelermlaed
and
d_cctors
collected
Def_
13
changes
be surpt_ed
Malenal
bm_t
PIg
[hat ts,
And
2
spaced
mter_ al,the CLrCOfldo_s nO[ regard them
a result,
PtR
pulses
sequence
the
of the
figt_e
or object
tbe
reprcscmmg
As
c going
first prede(t'_nsned
Became
_
negattx
of wha[
of a person
nol change.
of the Hc_maan
p]oI o f thts dtagIa.ra
comparmo¢
as the
at the oulpu[
48 of the '066
this parucuthr
bounds
13
sumuh
PIP. signals,
to the pre'. io_
slgngl
the
12
in _me
v, tth appropriate
7
21
However
I associated
3
59
5
c p_flses
_s bthek
00491
Because
20
in tlln_
8 mouon
rachanon
the lop s=gnaLs
SO, agmn,
mthv=dual
amvc
the v. mdow
2
12
4 apart
7 intea'pte[
OO49O
I 53
10
by these
w ¢ ju.st
Here
the pIR
idoltlcal
they
illas_ates
Markman
$
shown
next b_ard
PIR.
In foe bottom
d_t
3 that's
if=l
that
tbe
by the negatP,
which
board
m mfrared
oso'lfoscopc
of e_ch otha
fur0x_
glmulalJon
And
board
Q2 rcspottst_
NOt© tha! the
22
inthcat_d
2 comparator
I0 pr_sclectcd 0me
not tm_a on the lamp
seconds
21
ptol
th_s board
bmdet
a change
In tht¢ slmulahon,
19
mode
Okay
Io dctecl
LHt 778
Ig
the
6 outside
WITRF_S
PIRs
_¢s
the stgnal
I
into
9
THE
12
to cause
that ts, bright
have
THE COURT
I1
ptopagales
please
MR_ COOK
$
lamp,
If I mtghl
A then
cl_m_ey
of the
no _gg_,
7
25
control
action
Now,
showing
a[ Node
level
Hearing
of
10/27/05
OO492
OO493
I _hunmauon
m n_portse to de_llon
I eatabl*sh
ofsa_d prcdclammed
2 conthtlOn
3
AS prcwously noted. Mr
4 elmgnl
CI
However.
5 umntmllOna]
6 _sume
And
fo_ purp_
Diag,'am CI tsmarked
9 the _ucttm_
_ hlch I beh_
I0
define,elcmenl CI
II
MR
4 Second
s_pply
c M_
Carlson mlmded
to
May
v,¢ mtem_pl
forjo.st
a moment7
been correct_lby DE.SA and
14
MR.
IIIC_INS
15
THE
COURT
16
MR
COOK
That's correct,Yoca
Honor
SO thisThlsdoesre1_enlMr
TIIE COURT
THE
Okay
WITNE.SS
AS shov,'nby the blue diagram -
20
blue markings of thagr'.,mCI, the _ungd
21
o f elemml
22
bebev© tsnec_sm),
23
opcrdt_o__
24
Carlson _fimoon
CI failsto mcludo the Iog,ccm:moy
to d_tercmne o_
&m
o_ bright
Tha strocrm'eI ha_e selected mcludos
25 ctrcum_, th_ is.the cm:tOl cornponen_
Marl_nan
wluch I
thatIoglc
_
Hearing
I0/27/05
Page
del'm_
subelement
C2
swztchmg
2 ned o_ d_a_'_n C2 o f the com1_r_ve
3
The stngttwe
wi'ach
4 of the 'C66 fig_
swl_hmg
5 cum_!
6
c_
is marked
9
th_ itpro_
Mr
II _
device
d_ve
17
the _
device
p_p t;_s_rs
mgg_
C._lso_n
He thd thscu_
Q3 and the
to thc
In the new
presented
cot_rt wtth
12
fully
13
tl would
be b_l
14
Carlson
sa_d In his U_tm_ony
15
selected
as opposed
explained
MR
You_Hono¢
19
the©
to Mr
Carlson
THE
21
THEWITNESS
board
23
defining
Well.
C2. please?
Claim
vep_eSenled
My
8
as only
tha
_
on bo_d
that,
element
on
l'Ilshow
GO ahead
C2 h_
Iflcouldhav¢
r©sardmg
C2. swltchzng
the su-u_turc
means
already
board (72. the suuct_uc
been
chscus._d
of which
and 15
m my
Heanng
rcgar_hng sb_ctm¢, d_finc
oplmoc
10/27/0S
Claim
causing thresho}d to have third valoe.
h_
_dy
C3, the $_,gtu_
of the comparaovc
no th ffat_c
e between
so we
dlv*derc_rcm0y
and logic ctrcmi_y
no output _md Isnol capubl¢ of genaatm
8 three
The Sm, g [we ! have s¢ICClCd mclud_
the Carlson
15 por0on without the photocell and voltage d_vlderwhlch
the claml ft_ncuon.
16 captuxed clsewbexe m ¢lemenl H, plus the c;rCml_y
optmon
18 th¢cla_n¢]e_3cnl
b_(_1d_._u,_scdalxhs
o f whlch m my
optmon
thagrams
Maasmglll
tlearing
and
D14, Dl$,R34andR58_'¢usedmth©
494
JA 0904
to creal¢ three thsUnCl voh_c
61 _d
thus arc necessa W
ek'men[s to perform the functlon of the cI_m
22
caosmg
23
thffcrcnlfrom s_d
24
Page
awangement
21
25
10.'_7/05
_s
17 necessary to generate the threshold voltages descn_oed m
for
agree on the soxtctural
Marknmn
C4 o f the comparative d]asT_ns
CarLson has selecled melody; the
13 thre_,holdvoltage va}ue_
14
My
on
m my opinion defines chum
m the _memre
C3, rn_ns
493
The Ca_I_,o_ con.su'uedclrcu_t,
W gcncrales a thg,tal
12 y_
m tugger the ma_
C3?
Page
subelcm¢=nt
causing threshold to have dord value
The struc0.(reMr
II
the
subeh_n_nt C3, s_ttchmg me_.s, tsm,uk _d m
cor_tn;ct_on,
to double-check
Than_you
20 leveb, o_"d_:ubolds, at Node
2_
here
I0 responsive Io dayhght
volt._e because the outpul voltage
Claml ciceroniC3
Th_e's
m bl_e
I wall adv_¢
My opinion
subeTement
that
what M;
IO v. hal he
Okey
7 tsm._rkcd m red on d_agram
SO
ipc_m ling and p_'ventmg
_S mstd_clenl
23 red on d_agaam C3
r_pect
and then
COURT
20
24
C_rlson
is thet e a th ffamc¢7
[11 ha_¢
19 voltase dwld_
det'mc_ datm
rely o,
is represmlcd
19 causing gw_Ichmg n'g_u_ to bo actuatr_
22
wtth
Mr
I bcbe_e
l'mgom_--wtthyou_lgrmtsslon,
20
22
shales thai were
to samply
IO wh_
HIGGINS
9 photoc_ll vol_ge
thts element
tf I co_dd, please,have bo._
re_
cla_ ros
to cotu_©l.
ht_ lest=nony
for the court
TI-tE COURT
18
cople_
thal during
6 sulglcrnc_ C4, means
the tna_
consox_d
the sh'uctm¢ denning subelmgm
21
his
thces¢ parttculaz
them
II
2
m_l r_s_zc_ tl_dlevel
_I_cU_I Is necessary to perform
NOw.
has correcled
his dep_llJon
3 C4, means
The mat: alone _str_uBl'_cJent
t_ perform
of IC2D
18 Rga_dmg
by nOl ;ntcrp_¢0n_
donn8
Carlson
5 board C4, the structure of_hlch
The levelahlflc_rc_t_y mcludod
16 1 have
Statcng'nts
9
Mr
to the lamp.
13 apphc_tuon of sa_d AC
15
8
Iwanl
4 elemcnl C4 has ubcady been thscusscd and tsrLVrOthged
12 the ftmcoon of se1_cuwly
14
con¢cl.
YourHonm
OO495
l d_flmt]on
m
ts the po_ton
8 shallthe ou_ul _ oltage of tbe phase a_gle _o_
I0
Excu_eme.
Markman
th:ag_'_ns
selected
al said
2 cm:mt whzch conu'_b the o_ off
"Flits includes
7 _
I have
means
of
hghl
Whallme:mltoSaytsthaI_.henl
492
00494
I optm_
HIGGINS
$_ld It w_
25
the ftmct*_
first level
satd lamp IO em;I
7
24
to
to perform
al sasd
ofl[Imm_tlon
_.fR
17
17 pt_t 0oo.
For c_uslng
tomahcacor_ccl]on
16
C_Ison's
and
needed
to emat hght
6
I0
COOK
voltages
stud l_rnp
level
$
as K I
13 that they ha_ e. In that.conI_rmcd this
19
dlummahon
A.
with a blue hr_ mthcaung
12 I beheve thato_ e_ighl has now
Ig
3
of thisstatement, ] will
thathe intended todefine elemenl CI the same
7 excepl wlth the adthuon of the powa
8
of caL_mg
C_alson does not adch_
I beheve thlsv,_.s.
_ m Elemml
ttu'eshold
2
And Node
of my
clcmemt
sald thr_ho]d voltag© IO have a dord _a]ue
t'trs
I and second valu_
61 ts the node atthe thtleft-hand stdo
_ed d,agram as l'm pomhng
[o yo_ beR.
Markman
Hearing
I0/'L7/05
Page
495
OO49"/
O0496
I
My
op]mon
r©garthng the sm_cmre
2 ¢[¢_nenl E, rnezns forproducmg
I
defining clalm
raxnp wavefonn
3 E has already been thscctssedand isteprodueed
10'sphrasecorr_spoadlngtoCla_m
2 first threshold
Clalm elcmen[
4
In Claim
5
5 smct
sa_d threshold
6 dement
E, means
7 red on thagram
oplnton defines clalm
for preduc]ng ramp wavefocm
ts marked
6 prior clause
m
7
E of the comp_'-aU v e dlagTarr_
8
The sma:ture Mr
Cadson
9 ramp
generating elements and [he z_o
I I the omtUed
Stmllarly,
12
13
element
G
14 delect clrcmt for delecung zero er_ssmg
14
second
_a]uts,
15
comparatwe
ely pcecedmg
added
one
F
pumts of said AC
Chain element E.
The stru_tt_e
16
detect
of which
means
LSmarked
Mr
has selected
cIrCUtL
The
encompasst:_
the ClrCUlI_
19 elcm¢nl G. means for cat_ing threshold io have firs[
and
low
of the mouon
20
20
whtch
21
corr_pondmg
22
md]catmg
Cla_m element G LSfound In both Clalms 10 and Il
and LSmerged
23
And
24
c,o_bmcd
mto the clmm
elemeat on the top of board G
footnote 9 of my v.nRen staleraentexpl_os
25
sta_emenh and I won't te,
ad that
In CPUm
I0
the phrase correspoodmg
Markman
- zn Cla:m
Heanng
10/27/05
Page
My
3 dement
4
been
5
H, hgh!
drscussod
The
slnlct_e
element
H, hght
7
H of _
_vt
8
only
14
15
c_cult
vea_'u5
17
$o thafs
shown
her_,
18
CaHson
and tM
rtststor
oponon
appumsonlymClarm6
22
repraducad
23
24 element
25
of the _
m red on thagram
threshold
25
second
value,
which
sh3tc_tr
dretdet
The sffuet_e
6
of the '066 figure
9
mo0on
_
the
ncd_A
form
II
a
to
of
to
And
m red tdemlfied
Clmm
by me
defining
dement
been
ctazm
I, which
&se_ssed
and
labeled
13
counl
ts
mea_s,
Is maAad
by a high
node
A,
497
Page
499
Io m fr_red
the porUorel
external
m infrared
energy,
output
and
e of
conthtson
to "._h_ch I grn re femng,
as the ouipul
_ oPage
al
;s
of the pulse
Io perform
16 handoul
version
17
by hand
by Profee, sorMassengdlonthlsth'awmg
18
mtght
of 1. node A ;sn't
want to mark
you_ cop'/of
19
THE
COURT
20
MR
COOK
21
THE
COURT
THE
My
You
opinion
v.anl
Node
Inthe
marked.
Thai
was apphed
Soyoo
iI accoalmgly
_o --
A Is nght
al thts
point
Okay
W1TNF_S
funcuo_
--
Justammut_.Professor
This sm_lure
predetermined
rcgar thng
ts necessa_/to
con&tlon
the s_'ucture
Markman
JA 0905
includes
or low
Page
d_slmgmsh
mo_ttors
LSnecessaey
COOK
m red on thagyam
498
10/27/05
includes
ely
MR
o. object
Page
changes
2 cltcull
ctrgmt_"
a person
10/27/05
s¢lecled
and a
figure
respond
15
25
a
_'tmct;on
In IR thai are repres_mtatP,
This smactme
24
Hearing
wtfl
to selccu_
detecis
thagram
claim
I
'066
has selected
whtch
output
the
definas
the
Hearing
winch
2 carcm[
manifested
perform
thag_ams
Markman
I haze
23
m my opinion
and generates
61, as I'm
a first value
m the
Carlson
devices,
chang_
on thts
22
of v, luch
to have
occurs
no abday
ra_haoon,
So tha
12
14
1
sensor
moOon
5
10
zdtmtt fiad by Mr
already
4
Mr
sensor
bul have
those
representative
the smtcmre
_
rad*auon
sel¢cLg
e is necessa_
the photocell
has
stricture
voltage
3
infrared
ice
mcludts
the PIR
8
necc_ar,/to
here,
clrcmtry,
to perform
x oltage
only
The siructwe
only
Io
Io respond
selecUon
at node
LSnecessary
sasd
7
cz_q be tunad by the destgner
reg_dmg
on board
I, lust
d_
stnlcmre
causing
includes
selected
prtsenceandahaenceofdayhght
1, firsl s4mso¢
The
clmm
respuc0_ely
th_ade_
functton
21
that
mghtllrn¢
The vohage
¢leratnt
has
high o¢ low
poformth¢
20
Carlson
the reststo_
an appropoale
My
li has already
defin_
Is marked
I ha* e scltcted
_
16
19
m my opinion
light senslttve
as well
dilyhgh[
¢tcmem
board H
&agr_
th_ath.'t
output
on
rt_¢sSaly
Markman
of the claim
Claim
mc_s,
e Mr
The swacture
12 voltage
13
sensmg
the photocell
photocell
raeans
of v, htch
The sing'rut
10
11
sensing
the s_'uctufe
aod is reproducad
6
9
regar thng
thr t_hold
encomp_ses
h_e
24
2
and
stnglure I ha_e
A, as I'm m&caimg
_olhage
This
OO499
I
opinion
dec_smn
496
00498
I al rggle 61
2
compgtator
_s at node
23
thls
clmm
first
G of the
Carlson
the hxgh,
_.¢cond'.alu_
defines
to have
thagran_
The struclure
selected
22
clatm
t dcnt]cal
m red on chagram
19
21
first Is
I I, have
threshold
I8
op_nlon regarding the structured_fimng
m the
voltage
m my opinion
for causing
clalm
element E would b¢ redundant.
My
word
Accorthngly,
I 0, and G, clmm
the '._ndow
18
ts tmphc_t
_ ohagc
threshold
17
17 c_remw/m
identical
I 1 meaning
mclodes only the
Therefore. mclvston of the zrro c_cssmg
only
l 0 at clause
G, Claim
13 d_ect flmc[lon ISclaimed in the clalgsea zero crossing
16
the
to threshold
I 0, the
there's
m Clmm
element
12 r'_mp g enc_almg clrcull¢leme_L$ since [he z_o crossing
15 vohag¢ immedmt
mean
_ ord "x olmge"
re fe_s back
in Chain
smcc
9 mentioned
ctoss;ng delect
I0
The sma:(:me I has e srlecmd
sa]dthreshold_ssatd
phr'.gses
F
8 surphlsage
has selected includes the
I0 carcu]telements
lI
These
3 thmg
atthe top of
4 boa/dE
The sUag:turcof _h_ch m my
II
_oltage
being
defimng
Ilearmg
mohon
of
c_atm
10/27/05
OO5OO
OO301
I elcmcnlJ,
sccondscnsormeaJ_
2 appears only In Clalm
3 reproduced
4
Clalmelemcnt.l,
6, h_
already
$ ¢]¢mcnl J, second
Mr
8 only the photocell
Car[_on
nccc_a_
to foml
II
can be tuned by the designer
thvldcr
of dayhght
predetermined
MR
16 mmule
Lct me catch up to you
17
THE
18 dcfinlng
ctalm element
19 el_menl
K1 *-
20
MR
COOK
21
THE
WITNESS
22
only In Claim
23
r¢produced
clrcutl
COOK
professor
WITNESS
My opinion
KI
of causing
9
dlumlnalzon
l0
second
wantJ_l
control
clrcutt means
Clalm
Claim
6, has already
Okay
elemen[
KI
been discussed
which appears
and Is
ptedelcrmmcd
in my opmlon
m red on thaBram
defines c]alm
llearmg
]_mp
to emil
rcg_dmg
K2, me.u_s
been
thscussed
I?
of whlch
18
red on dtagram
the str_cgme
o£
at said
defining
c lo detecllon
Clatm
clement
clatm
o_first
claim
sel¢c[cd
claim
K2 has already
on board
defines
Carlson
cOncludes
claim
My
pulse
first Icvet
Okay
h_
Mr
This
to
the fonchon
go emit hghl
K2
s[ructurc
K2 is marked
m
dtagrams
the same
and I agree
elcmcnl
The
elemenl
K2 or the comparative
del_n_
relevant
al said
lamp
and It reproduce
M r Carlson
sffUclure
to perform
said
responsl',
m my opinion
21
thai
nccc_sa_
condlllon
16
Accordingly,
m¢]ud_
light
fads
it nccessaz_
o£dlummallon
WITNESS
20
needed
£or causing
THE
2_
Page
voltages
15
24
10/27105
components
COOK
22
K l of [he compar_n_ •
clrcutt
MR
23
of' whlch
K I _s marked
includes
14
a
r_gar thng struclure
operallon
se]ccled
My opinion
13
has selected
[ behove
I ha'.e
and
gube]crncn|
Carlson
which
dim or bnghl
said
12
to
Mr
which
threshold
level
II
on board KI
structure
with
regards
Io whteh
K2
my opimons
on coP_ff_cllon
oC the
element5
final opinion
counting
ts In relation
']'his oplmon
500
to I]1¢ tsgue
Is. if the
sensor
Markman
of
mcans
Hearing
claim
10f27/05
Page
501
OO503
seLectlon clrcuitry,
4 m_ax_
5
weald
bnc£ DESA
6 pulse count mg Ctrcutt_
7 control
defined
9
9.
by claim
elements
Moreover,
is expressly
14
precludes
13
circuit
means
two conthllO_
19
[hat the patent
20
Of the colllrol
21
dtagram
clatrn$ would
in figure
Ctrcuzt
m a Iogeal
24
topology
2._ prescnllng
oflhe
call
In Vl_'
2 of the
dcsngners
_.ay
6, 9,
to consldct
often
design
12
counting
the of the
I0 and
II
it seems odd to me
count
schcraallc
the high
level
¢_pcc_afty
when
mg _
part
Hearing
the schemalic
The
or
10/27/05
claims
Page
502
o_ the
Clrcuttdeslgnp¢_p¢ctlV¢
7
one or two
8
dayhghl,
9
lamp
I0
deterged
Lhat IS off.
[amp control
12
These
three
]3
puxposefully
captured
lhc lop row ofczrcuil
That's
17 bere.
40
thal _s mouon
based
setC¢llOn
THE
WITNESS
including
llmcr
block
0906
--
52
Thclo_c
blocks
52 above
ctrcuit_/is
this
my pointer
here
and ovcmdc
I'm ou[[imng
row of circu_l
conffol
row of ClrCtUl dlagr'aras,
_,larkman
JA
In the
is sel OUl m
42 through
- 43 through
pcrhal_
beilom
io be
Forty-three
21
25
wlth
diagram
block_
Is set oul In the muldlc
modulatlon
seem
CltCUil/y
number.
circuitry
24
of
that mode
dtVlSlOns
20
with
on combmaoon
m the schemalic
read the
COOK
So Ibe logic
for the
blocks
MR
I'm oullmmg
or
a mode
clrcuitry
lhls row of cffeUlt
.. 1 cannot
23
Io choosc
implementing
functmnal
the dcleCllort
16
conthtlons
]ogle
the
of
from a
funCllOnOfdclccung
dlm or bright
l I appropnatc
speaking
layoul
thcdestBn
some
e'. cnL_ and then
between
_md the gr_phlc
broadly
predclcrmmed
performlng
I see paral]ehsm
claims
descnbe,
6
22
diagrams
a dCSl[J1 to others
Markman
4
of this palent and then
diagram,
struclute
19
thncuonal
teaching
functlonal
I read the claims
(he sebematlc
IS
_s pz'c_enlcd
axvange
3
]3
upon
by DE_A
out pulse
sludled
14 schcmallc,
control
Of [he way th;ll the sch cffkailc
patent
that mlm_c_
6,
ou[
mcap$
and comment
tirol contention,
CIrcuit
pulse
circuit
2
5
dlffcrcnuauon
as pan
-* contentions
AS to D ESA'$
Cla_r_
control
of claim
of Claims
elements
called
thai because
included
Claims,
is exprc_ty
o£ the
docmne
being
thai the
CirCultx 7
m nonasscned
D F._A contends
tt from
23
¢ou_tmg
c,'fl led out as pa_
l ha_ e been _ked
these
cnrcull
patent ts part of the
Ot' the deiccizon
means
I 3 m Cla_m 12, the legal
contended
A and I Of the _sert_d
pulse
as a pa_ of the control
16
of the conlrol
h_
of the '066
CIrcUIt rathcT th_TI _
I 0 and I 1 because
11
be _
tt should be,
claim element C 1 and K I
In its Markman
8
as ] Echcve
When
I
constnJed to not include the pulse
3 then the pulse counting
22
8
19
"['hc stnlclure
2 counting
18
¢slabhsh
hlgh
Thal'sJ
Justamomcnt
] e]crncnt$ A and i w_¢
t7
7
versus mghltlme
M_sengdl
off
The circuit
Iognc circuit.,
[hal
whtch
the logic ¢lrcult_
6
[
OO$02
12
to determine
3
level of hghl
Markman
l 0
4
as the
to outpul an appropnage
15
elcm_l
Io include
mclud_
The structure
The structure
3
on diagram
vo]L%ge dlvldc_3 clrCUll Is nec_$_
14 perform the [lsnctton
25
I thagran_
2
Is
c]a(m
in _
as well
a voltage
voltage rcprescntatlve
The
device
the pholc_ell
r_LSlOr$
] 3 rcgpcc[ively
del_n_
has selected
hghl scnsmve
includes
I0
24
_d
thaBrams
The stnlctur¢
9 have sclcclcd
In my opmlon
s_usor meax_, is marked
6 J of the comparauvc
12 or low
beta discussed
on board J
The gLnlClUr_ of which
7
whlchalso
mlddle
block
,rod all ofthe
c_rcuttry
thal
lanip
ts tel out in thc
as l*m outhmng
l[earmg
here
I0/Z7/05
Page
503
OO_O$
1
L thm.k thul w_
_ _RF:_X
_ t_,p d_ctncd
1
3 _
_
_
_nth r_
_u
a f _¢ d_c_m
1 whe_a
3 m_
s_
_j_s
fozs vr_ c_y
0x fuam_
z_lmlc_l
th_
the first _0.so_
a beJam._s m _
10
_[_s_d
_:_ cou_d
s_sor
8 ir_lud=
mr..,_s
9
! have b_
11 file h_o_
12 e_.m_z
_owu
that ninths" Cl_
ex_ly
13 am_
that the '_6
the ¢_mal
p_'_t
12 nor my o_h_ c_m
hmtL_
m p_L_ c_,una_8 w_e
c]ai_
w?m_ the _'an
w_
14 filc_
As m D_A*s
20 cannot b_ _1
s_
co_on
cf _c c_rol
_
cl_'m_ mc_
22 ezra.sly
c_]l_d _u_ _s _ Im'_cn
23 mmms nn C_am
24 eI_t_
12. [ with
ofCI_tm
_ly
to po_
_ amo_
mc_'._ _s[_t
_th
_t
L I ¢Ls=l_
of the means
as _
Moreover
_fchaned
hng ar_tmer_
f_" excluding
14
c.o__1
¢_t6mt m_
eLem_ts
ofCIttm
17
Mr Carh©n
II
cloncnl_
s cuntc_uun
Urd_ke Chart
Fur_ef.
10,'27/05
Page
redeadant
_be o_inal
*_
3 _d
the
I
A_ a t¢_uh,
3
K2 m the cl_m.¢ nec¢_'=nty
¢t_tnt
mea_¢ m Clam
4 _hg the l_t
6 ¢h_,_m
12 tmde_cores
m _rl_
w_
to ac_on
of the suber&v.z4¢
d those subot&nate
wnth re_'d
_r$_m_L
EoDESA'S
d_m
I also no_ that the 1_4V:
trebroadJyllmtted,
9 t_ ca_t bfl_at
of
6
to ftmctlonofcgusmgthelamp
hgl_ whoa th= fast Imutttrtrmn:d
I0 ts_kt_ct_lmd
m erml&m
:om_ol _r _t
_'_tt_C2 tht_
e]rmm_
L'I fa=t. _
9 lt::t.st those
¢.J_m
C4 a_d K2, _
_1
lae da_ras filed
He_rl_
10/27/_5
Pnee
505
has a _po_hmM
spear tic tlttags
12
fo _y
_'_ atI
c¢cmt mc_tt_
ofth=
evem,
pa_at
office
Prior
Art
21 s_bon_hna_ cot _o[ c_tc_l¢lum ¢_cat_
22
t_ _,_em_n ftmgu_a
23
hght whc'a the f_t
24
to ea_!
_
abeent
of cta_ng
the lamp
would be =t forthcr
I & pulse
c_0_mung Is not included
_rc_tcrmm_
&m hght when the _
zonthttoa
u_ dclccted
_'ed_tom_cd
23
7.5
Markm=n
He,
ring
10_3/0_
THE COUgT
that the _tttls¢ co_t
_.4 dt _ecnon
¢o='_Juo_ ts
Page
ql_
of the
from the Nippcn
of the claim ele,ntmts
thsdauntth
to cooclttde
I. tt _ou/d
that tf
of the set.or
_¢_r_/ude_l_
=
cLrcmt m eav, s el=am
or gctect_n
L_ ra= _k
Is put oftha
yoe, it = yo_
opm_oa
conlr¢:l ¢=rct_t, r_t the
¢lr_ut?
31_EWLT_F_g_
No
Your?Rlnor
MarRnmn
JA 0907
is or'the
as a lnmltauon
of the prmlar/contrOl
cxch_:
¢lh-'a:ota C_ mdKl
22
aad
Aaad
re.on
o_Jv
_1
not that
decthranon
puke cottnl_t_g has _
_
21
_r¢ suborcb_
m ¢:n,t bnglg
Tht_z
any mtcyp_elahon
17
2O hmttauon
othcn,
ac t:t_tan3y
the M¢C_wt
_,tt Cttm_
of
ust_d_
¢:acompas_
aad pc_stbly
to d_ua_msh
t9 mcza_datm¢_¢mca_
I_y the_.,nt lok_ lh¢SAag_Jfoacttcnof"the
_u:gery
f no_ th= Mr
o_t teqtur_
the r_;it._loil
gtmt_al cat ¢1:¢ _
th= by follooang
16 that doel
clmm elcm_
nn the pramaV d =Ira ele'mt'nLs C I
_n _ f,x-ner a_ _tlegoty
sp¢¢= ft= tlun_,
11 these
I _ C _'armc
_ciKl
stDordmate
C4 =d
a_ly ore or mote or
=t matler o f gramnllr
mcJta_d
ment_or_
i3 optalon
s_borda_I© Io
[/,quaJi5cd by [hephr_¢, wbcZcta $_d co_ol
2.0
_
"l_c Io_cal
exehtde
Hemen_
10 o_
l't
Hoa_" my _ent
[fSCI
_
c_admon
CI and KI
Y_
16 e_rorthere
_d
the
e.la=m ¢ltm_'n t (22 throush
8 "v.ake_ it c]¢gr thai the g_ral
hght wben the 5rsl
All o_=_e su_ e_em
17
L
a_v_
5 lrgl K I
7 spcr _.q¢ things
A_d.
o f Cl_,n
then CTaim J
*t c4rmot be _,a_d that the _x p_.s
the h'k chbood
t_
me_
OO5O7
bctwcc'_tbe ¢_usi_:_ ofCl_m
3 ¢¢_ol
84 pn_..r]
_t soctalext
_n:may,
blarkraau
pmvtstoa
13 el_nca_
LL,
wotdd
m_m.s da_m
pa_enl a_tca_on
504
fr,'a_ the
lO and
c_t_y
ofCl_
as I have bee_
•
pained c]ai_
12, i f _',e fiv,_ sm_
2
12
6, 9
that the _rnsor
of the
8 ltltKl
_re
of C_
the s_uoa
2 _=tmq and *n_l_ton or"
p _.s¢cou_nng _ p_
5
the patent
fde ;_L_0ry slmwt that CI:Um 3 was among
L5 ¢._
He.lnug
wholly
23
I_ snn_ a pasalv c
wh_h
3 amorxg lhc _66
do not include
22 _oaktbe
_s _o_uoo
_ot
l_dse e_3_tmg
I thd not mcl_u_e the P_R sele_on
24
wo_d
daf_tlal_on
compd
20
clalm_ t_
I wh_h
for de_e_tmg m©uon
13
of Clam
conm_l _L_Ull
umg_ssth
_ the only _n.so_
19 wtth ut_e s_mors
_'_t tbe r_e
the 'O66 _l_t
Markmau
OO_O_
I mcc_trnc7
_£ _
ofa !:¢rson or an o_ec_
"Tats '_oukt be [o_t_dly
Zl
of Claim
morton roltn*.¢ LOstud
10 in frare_ deteccor
p_se o_g
6, 9.
clatm clcm_t
for detc¢._
m_s
1 _ exnst_¢_
19
8 to
a _swe
a P[_
L2
included
=l_]t_r_
m_.as
gs m_
7 t]e_[ s_k_ot
md _
ae¢ofdm
m e_tr_ t_lt_
_?DES._comenl_a_co_c_toChtml2,
6 _$ dclined
8 12 _ m _r_ly
An app_c"_a_
$e_ot
_d
d_eclor
4
_,_
3 u; as fOllows
C_mm
2 CL_n
He=tin
Ircmyclpinlotl
8
10fZ7/05
Page
507
00.*_
I d_
d_¢ pub¢ ¢ounl n pitt or wh_
2 Lh_ d:_ctlon
TH_COL'RI
_ 0_Y
q_o_s
before c_
4 _rJlow.up
_
6
COOK
Ls
I I_¢r_q
Th._kyo_
0_'/
Any
Z A
No_ ==, I I:.ave B;t ]
3 Q
A¢ a pc, xon _u_yml_
Okly
Croa?
CROSS-EXA.M;_ATi0N
BY,fit
HIGG/N$
I cm:_l
a_l _wmg
9 Q
Good _ormng,
Dr Mt._san_111?
9 Q
¥o,I _'_¢
I0 A
Good momu_,
Mr
10 coa_ancd m th= _cm
II
Pmf_
Q
12 Pro_¢¢
_
llowarayou?
Doyouprc_Dr
MC_m@IoT
Mmsc_/p0?
opm_om I_m
16 ¢o=onnu_
the p,_=l
|1 A
"i_n_
12 Q
,'_r_ _ou - w_
_[c hL_oty
C.OrrCCL
you mtormed _
¢v _lc_:= w_
_Fccl
to d¢ p_t=nt mc.¢_ L1¢
tU I11,:h_m,'y
a_d Lh¢prior
]
whoa 1 _k yeu qu_ _or_ _
25 _1_1c
[
IH=rkJ_ln
Hl_nllg
_Jvld_nc_, _
th_
Pnge 50S
10_05
m_r_,c
I_
a_l
91at you ¢_n u nd_"_._d
,'Hark.m_n
00_I0
2
_td_mc_
16 1¢_2Jtcm_ tar.an
24
Q
u par_ otyow
e_ldC_ce _md ¢_mmlc
19 patCnl docum¢_! i_¢h'ar_l
"1"1_1 cer_
cm_
cJa_m_,corrc¢_
_nd _hal _ _ho com_c_s
18 m_l¢
20A
thc pascal.
aJt.oa._cd (o L_cJ_lCl ¢¢r_n
14 ¢o_ethm 8 c,_l_d mm_rc
[$ you h-'v_ mo_ Rccndy d_cmsed.
25
al ;m ¢¢_¢_ m a _
No, YOL7 Honc_
TH_COUR'P
7
i
I hi_¢ idc_cd
S©I=¢_on ccrcwb-y
Hear_n_
10/Z7_05
Page
G0511
A
3
( bci._vc
[
sc_
I_:I_ CO_1
_
7 th= pncr =tO
9 A
I I BY _
My cl_'J_
b Lka _'o_
_t
d=_
ffJG_LN5
12 Q
As [ un_tand
I)
your _Ltmony
_,
Lhc _ua_cny
_ ba._d
_a_ y_u hay= j_1
on _._o pm_a_7
d_rocn_
12 Q
m
13
Now
-- so m _h¢ _.x_ o/'a Pro, _ LI)_m" 0_m_
that L_ P[_ ¢_Wl
d_:l
moho_ wldloul scle¢_on
14 _=tu_'y?
IS
Th_ _
_ _h_I tho s_n_
I _ un_l_l
m tbe_e m_
17
l_'_rm_
_
I$
zn _Um._nd_cha_
19
A
I bd_'v¢
_ur¢
_lled
wh:u ] s_d
s_=d
_n_nm,
y_
21
And _a:on_y,
_al
Q
2_
24
25
_rta/_
Dol
29 cnurc
22. b_ _¢i¢n/to
la_
dram _am
cna_c
_as
be c=p=ble
IS A
IdodlbehevIdt=f;wh_
17 Q
And tb_ :s will
wb_d_ wa_ ,_]z_z_d
sm_.a_i
y_a {o air.ion
r_on
m_
21 so d'Ju _h© c:¢_1 _il
a _p_'_ _
22 _)¢
23 Q
You u_cd 0_ c trmi "_nv _ion _pe.cl/_¢ s_uc_m'_
I_ st_cat
[r_d
y_u ¢sll Lh_ _ i_.m_ _el_ed
W
_ l_=t'_nn d_=
_n_.T_
lolm_m_Rtd¢
IlZ.ld.
ot
h_vc_conca7
was sul_au
_
_
m_t
a
24
_odolhavothalcorr_c_
M=rku_n
H_rm_
10/27/05
Pnl_
$I0
Now, _ dm_ _:l_uon
m any lar_
25 A
sclcct or d_._r tmm,_c _a_ -
ot moaon to emma L_ lamp IO _o o_
_dc_c_mlmc_
ot any ¢I_m_ m _
co,trained
p_w_t?
"1_ word "p_deJ_m_a_d."
M_rkman
JA 0908
'_
He_nn
8
10.,7.%05
PageSl[
509
005t2
I Q
Well.
2 *designer
what
[ j_[
scl¢cllon
asked
cn[cna
wa_ whether
the
ICrm
Oh
4 Q
That's
not in a_y
clalm
S A
I don'l
recall
v.ord
6 palcnt
no. sir
7
Q
Is there
8
cntcna
9
A
And
In _c
_lng
abottl
_ being
designer
m the
selection
you
N_w.
a[I of your
SP[CE
tra_
they were
all conducted
12
clrcutt
2A
I_ that
and
2B
demonstra_lo_
Tha{'s
I behev¢
that's
contained
13
pa[¢n_
14
A
That's
15
Q
D=d you do any
16
clrctltt
'
[7
A
Na
I$
Q
Dtd you build
any
19
patent
Io _
imdcrsta/td
20
A
D=d I bultd
22
A
Such
as what
23
device
24
Q
Now.
you_lUl_sedd_edC_lcclhatblr
25
._ it _as
m the '066
corr¢c[_
slmulatmns
on any
other
8 A
I don't
No_
to _:tlcr
a physical
Mt
demonstrated
de,
Evan_
in the
th_ Icachmgs
Q
Mr
you
recall
built
2A
thc
2B
device
ha_ ¢ teatlficd
13
A
Yes
sir
Q
And
that se]ec[lon
15
enabled
thai dcvlc¢
ht$ hand
con'ect
clrculO3_
In your
the mo_lon
clrCUltq/allowed
Q
Now
A
Yea
sir, [ did
23
Q
That
device,
24
conlaln
25
A
Page
diagram
clrcUllry
as
opinion
Ofa pcrgon
as hc
or h*s ale',iCe,
_
The selection
22
10/27/05
that
to the ¢lrcul[
selection
o_ cr Ih¢ motLort pOrhOn
2[
Hearing
according
to detect
form
Markman
e×actly
_t_ouldbeco_'e¢l_f
i_dld
20
corr¢c_
did you
aF,o u[ cortcct'_
ice _
courlr,_am
for one"
him saying
[hat 1I did conlam
dlszrlmlnat¢
E_ansbulll
"one
wl_.taw
19
[ did nol butld a
term
h¢_nng
i[_
did _ NO
the
d_dyou-
Evans
I g A
of the
hc used
14
17
d¢_ ice _mg
budl
patent
htm say that 1
[6 _alvcd
sir. I dtd not
was
in the '066
my tmdcrstandtllg
9
12
co,oct
SPICE
hear
[ I in figure
the actual
{hal Ihat device
diagram
corrcct'_
I0
:rod your
concerning
understand
Io _h¢ clrcul_
6 Q
pa[¢nt
signal
I did
5 A
7
(hos_ _or_
Q
figt_c
4
ts it '_
"selection
any dlsct_slon
at all
No(
the
I I
[hat type of morton
of infrared
dldyouwlmcssMr
any
hl_ circuit
o_er perhaps
[o
some
othcr
radlalton
Fromhls
Raper'_dcmoreatvatlon_
howe_
selection
cr cn_d¢ it m_ght
ctrcuflt_,
lestlmony
did
b¢, did nol
tt
i_s mytmdcrstandmg_t
Markman
512
did
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
OO515
OOSI4
I not
I arl _hen
Q
AnddldyoustudyMr
3 A
Y_
4 Q
So from
$
know
- you
6
ht[]¢ device,
7 A
Raper's
Rule
12 statement
h_s testimony
saw
and
the clrcull,
_¢
from
hts
conlro]
statement
¢lrcutt
you
ofhts
con'egt _
"_¢r¢
v_,_r
was no selection
cl_cul[ry
m that
wa_
A
Actually
II
Q
And
12
A
13
in _acl
14
arva_gcd
IS
Q
His
Mt
what
I_$ pholo_ell
Ilt_m
T_al's
¢orr=ct
i$
Q
Tint's
_c
19
industry
20
A
No,
6
a r_l$[an¢¢
7
off_c
Photocells
ttsual[y
network
that changes
sb¢ll'as
And
jtts/a
then
one
coal pul _hcm
$o you
of_hat
A
Absolutcly
[t'_,asapholoccll
13
Q
And
ork
14
oul,tphotoc¢l],doyourememberlhat
1_
scc you
[6
A
Yea
17
Q
"_es
that v, as an offqhc
Ihey
come
purchased
by peoplc
m
; oRag¢
de;ices
hght_
thal ha_c
and
they
come
In a voltage
v, Ill be
from
dl;idcr
_1low
to
to a high
or
o_" hght
have
In the
ha'.c
Ihe
pholocel]
Q
_© photocell
_¢
arc b,_lcally
[he threshold
Icvel
t mcludc
put m his
Wllh incident
12
he called
v, here
Raper
do _ol include
Photoc¢l[s
iI
thcr¢_
dJ_Jdcr _lv,
way
divider
lhat be_
co_ec[I
A
A
5
a parhcular
that'S a pholoc¢ll
17
dcmonstratton
4
iI doesn
a_ Mr
I0
demonstration
Now
to phot_¢ll
such
choose
wa_notabarcphotoc¢ll
m _ _ o]lag_
refer
9
Higglml
would
3
8
_
10
_cy
2 off-_-shelftl©ms
_
I did
Is_wh_,aczrcuztdlagram
Q
_cr¢
2 Q
3 according
10
9
Yes
"_
3 A
2
OO513
I A
your
rcad
066
o_n
the '066 patent,
patch11he
correct
abstract
_
simply
calls
_ Thal'sa[[abl
copy
[
Ihcre _
Thc,_b_tract_
18
THE
COURT
20
MR
H[GG[NS
Arc
you
t_[kmg
about
the
_
str
his circuit
21
Q
Andlhatwas
2_
A
Yes,
23
porhon
24
I11¢ selection
2_
Q
sir
Or thts
had
an cx_ema[
reststot
21
-you_yflla['ssclec[iortclrcmtryl
As I ha_ ¢ dcfincd
[ defined
the
voRag¢
11 for _¢
dl_tdcr
pholo¢¢ll
_
part
of
clrcm_ry
So is it your
lc$[imony
that
Markman
p_op[c
skilled
Hcar[nR
in this
10127/05
PaRe
514
patent
includ¢_
THECOURT
23
THE
B_
25
Q
MR
ma'am
WITNESS
RL_ht
Y_S
faccofth¢
Oh, okay
it says
a photocell
IllGGINS
No_
_s_lyouropmlonthalpeoplcskdlcdmthe
51arkman
JA 0909
The
a_ abstract
22
24
No
Ilearlng
10/27/05
PageSl5
513
00516
I mtow_x_h
d_
_
2
a pholo_dl
3
A
4
_
_1_
5 Q
At _honn
0_17
p_sms
would not _d=sumd
wh_
A pmson sk:d]_
Lq i,he _
= photocell
wo_[d
4 of d_e p_nt,
s pb0:cc=l156
_c_
psmc_ty
_¢
I&_
And _en he t_0k h_s h_d and he p_E it m _qd c_t.
5 dc_-r
m_d ra_T
s_ I_ne I S,
6 slg_J c_ge._
It
prcs_oc
o_ _ncc
$ Q
wot_
tmdcsstm_ _
I I would
_
12 A
A pcJson fJ_[l:d m _¢
ts a Itf.td ]_ssuv¢
_y,
a phot_cll
II
t_-_c_ttnd
COURT
16
"i_l_ W] _.SS
i 7 tbC ¢_Cf'S
A
TL"_0uld _d,
thai hxIIc _c_ll
_¢
on his
or a_cnce
N_
16 Q
Your H_nor, on
of
Now
o f hSht ss 5e
w_
= contmuoml_
w:s oh:mS'mSwt_h _c love1 of tJBh_
_h_t p_u_cu_
17 photc_U
(0 d_'t_c p&
by d_e u_unt
bsc.k _qd Cor_h, so _=*
I $ dsyllgh( In _t
r_y_=,_7
of what h_ w_
_
_o,
It v,_ bern8 mod_b_l
13 ou_ut voi_=se _
d_t ce. a.nd at cord d be *_.sed
Wtth_d
_d
cbcb_*tt(?
t)c_d, dc_cczm_ _c p_mcc
12 moved h_s ha_
th_ a
td
T'r_
li_m thc b_c phQ(_U.
10 _tlSh_
Ce_unly
15
IS
_t weald
So wasn't _
9 ?1_ _oto_cll
the pre_mc= or atu c_c,= of day]_[?
13 pS_¢_Z[
14 m _
j_t
xw_
th=e _.
of
_ it yo_" _3unl_t_ L_t pcoptc s_llcd m th= arl
L0 of the _56 I_c_t
tnd LSm you saw th© s=S_J _ge,
4 Q
s _yn_
9
m_lmC,
3 A
a_;ol_t ely
m:sns
6 Lzdtscx_.T,_thcopo_onm_lax.tpmof=[_lotocJ=ll
7 ssy_
t sun"lzlc
2 &_tn't you7
"_u xn dx_ ccmt_ct_
vol_.ge i_ _L_l_ve
dcmors_l_oa.
_hcF=_xt
c_
[ don'L k:_ow
stco_unm 4 &c_s on _s_y
detcc_ dlc p(_m
z
or _m cncc or"day]tsht _nd
dayiA,_c
19
"_
COROT
ZO
"F_
W'_'_ESS
ha'c rmght m_J_
Zl
22 tl, c dm_:rs
Ok_
FO_ c_sm_c,
_c p_o:U,
th_ to0m 1_t_t m
It m1_1[ no_, _S
BY MR. _GGD_$
24
Q
25
_m
t4_w,t_t
Mr
t.be photocet_
M=rkmsn
O_cc _c pho_cdl
22 A
COr_L
24 d_l_ht
Rs:g_:_s demon_tt,'_t_,helutdahtt]o
_tlt_ a IiuIe f._tp, tl_t _e put o_
Y_
_0 Q
hss dct¢c_:d, tt p_t_:c_
m
on
_=_
23
t9 A
HearlZlg
_nd n_.et pcruon _'_ o£ _
25 A
to
10/2"//05
Page
cmc_,t.
_rr__
M_rlunan
516
H_r_ng
L0/_7/05
PageS1/
00J19
I Q
Cea_ct_
SotTsal d_dayllgi_t
_dd_-/llghtdedect
2 _ZX[reset ]_t%ma. _7, L_I tS Shown _1 fi_u_
3 cu..'_dtnd_tofth_sc_or,
4 _htt w}_t LI_: _ot
A
the_l_to_:ll_:_sar
Irmu_,'r/
a day_l_
bdt
A_d you ,u_ s_ym_ Iba_ tho_¢ r=_stor_ tnd
3 ¢apa=tto_ _
4 l_t_Eed
[w'_sloekmgaLrayd_s_xe_
Phot_¢ll
2 Q
S=yS7
6 m_ten_you==dMr
7 Q
I //¢1c two [_lStOl_ a_d a e.ap_lt o¢
2A. ts of the
A
TI'cl_t
HIgh.s7
_6 _:t_Ls
somctbl_
= to _
o1_
th_q wh=t Mr
No you zre - I_:e I s:ud. I'm no_ _yms
6 z18_11 _L1JIvc
you _e _a_tly
o0rr_L
md t_n m _a
10 Q
- coupled to _ d_[If_t
9 Q
Andts_'t
t_=t d_w_7
10 t=VC (0 be bl_ed
dctc_ a_d r_r_[ pot Uon
Ll_t n'_t
II
12 Q
o-s=r_luve IO whltcv_"
13 A
_'=¢=ot_¢0fs¢=._or=m&_eml
The p_cll
I;
Okay
Q
thc_
n du: s_.
17 A
u_lt_a'sthew_yrt,
"nxs_-yet
[flcoeidret_nyouto_._
rc_'_t
2t
II s concct, t._[
22 s_mr,Jc _
23 sn _eu.d_dnt
_o f,c_sc7
[fSt_mo
Forex_tnp]e,
dlepho(oceIldo_nol
16 ne_..dt_ be bl_ed
e=_ufied
17 Q
So y_j w_uld
=_lr.e wxfft mc I1_, tl'_ b_r c PIP, C_t
Ar:t y_J _._
F.n __-=
P._p_s_:_on
to tl-e p[_?
It. _
Mr
Ral_s
the b=e PtX did d:t_t
Itrde
mo_n
21
ofa
_c_
Q
22 vl_
Fts F.=d m_r 5_
P_t, r_d
did J_J C_:_,¢7
t_
Not toa_&,_: v_th ye_
at_e_ _pe_
they a_l=_kcd
d_ags'_
20 w_
24 A
are_ _y
dcv=c_ m sene_'_l. _n¢l th= piP. tl =
15 _m¢onda=t_d_vt¢c
_am_cO
_
"llut s _ltcxL
14 of _¢wa¢onducmt
y_.
aot o f the mr.
I_ Q
_rr =t7
A._ddu:d_I_¢md_t_c_r_po_on$7
L6 ts of ti_ c_r_at _t
18 tl _n t_e
were
to be-
IZ A
tl_cs_r_r
A
m ord=
Li $7 of the ct_'_O
14 A
(o be
-
Cor_.L
SO ti_ pi_t_:lhs
_
rise ;_"_ence or a_smce o f
9 A
13 Q
R=_'
t;_e o¢¢Iu'._7 bx_ on --
o= _.
Mr
Htt,_ns.b_
quate, btm P_
M:zrlcm=
du:_c v,_'m
boe:d there
n Hea tin 8
24 d_r_zt3,
u_
rz'.ed=ht=_.
"_¢r0
I 0,q7/05
P=ge
Markm_a
51g
JA 0910
He=tin
8 10,'ZT,'flS
Prise
519
0052O
_521
I A
A_ly,
Mt
R_8_'m_thePlR
2 tl_hl:als_mblr
3 eteJl_ng
_nBr_p_to
_band.=_dlt
tha tt w_
4 mou_ofcmirlc.
I /m] JtU:_ ;aid* tbe eh:mgt$
2 tl_tt
_ll_is_u
respondn_ (o.,_hu:h
was cau_J
by the
BullCllr_mlhcb_|
_cl t_t
3
p_r_on or object rclauv¢
4
_*
T'he _xzmple
5 Q
6 Q
So :s ttimpott_t
7 between _S
ezlet_/a_d
to _,_a that there's
n_pons_vc
mnt]on_
9 I_ttfym
8 tn fins Cm_"
i'm ;_t
il
e daITe'rm'a to yc_ _ a person
to _: as Sm_se as poss_¢
weth
[ respl_d
I_l
19 BY MR
20 Q
W¢I|. bttt, Yo_"
HIGGINS
of a _u_e
2_
A
24
cen_nl¥
Th=nky_.
Ho_r,
t_ag_
T_E
h_dmto
t_'t
_ a r_ul(
2 p_X'e=L
"Fe=r_
of t_e mct_n
urda_tly
WITNE_
_mkm_
_
Hcanng
10/27/05
3 nr._e_rc [o t[_ _lpmmd.
6 BY _
7 Q
COURT
be - thc_: _votdd _bll be a _gn=t't_re
9 e,r¢_
¢m_l_
i 0 w_r_
II
13 Mr
Rzp_- u_.,ed
14 bzs_b'aJl_
I_
A
e_ac that _I
R =f_'mn 8
TrlE
25
"D'IE COURT
7 hg_
;o._
kc_ _
whm
'_z_ the ¢_'¢u_tde_ec_ a sJg_. f_.an_ ¢han gcm
Q
I_ Q
and l =_tee _th
Page
521
the sprat or"whJt you _e
str _owhe_b,tr
*- i_ w_
Rapcrwa_vcdli_ebat
P[R was d_t_ttng
- cxct_c _c,
- v.hat w_
a was _
hght so_rcc_ pm,_t.c_
= ¢h_1t¢
m
by a s_are_
corl¢ct_
It we_ rc_0ondm8 to t cheng_ m mfitrcd
It f.ht
An4_';wl'atthep.'_eml_ysat_oltu_n3
It's-y_,slr
hsays,
hne
eachrespo._velo
Okly
Now
mMJ" Kzl;_s
[6 agt_: that la'_cIxm: PEq. was _t:rc
Y_.dlcc_cu_t_smom(onn_
to _-,e t=m_p
dmt0_tt=an,
slnc=wc
and it dct_:lCd the mouon
17 of both = p¢_un tnd _m obj¢_l, it &d _o wtthout .m_.
f_r .u_os
I S s¢lc_aoa csmualry, d_dn t it _
19 A
20 - _11. I n:_llo
maJ_ s_
21 _ou md I qpt_
t_._ t_ ,_as .p_z a b._-e pIR7
22 A
I wall ae_
2]
f k'_ow 1hat hm'$ yotc
o_h_r _aa the bu=m&,
do
20 mfrared
2i
w_[b )_u.
NO S_ _zzs-
10/27/05
d_lp_c o f I"dicn/_ going on, bat i ]olow wh=l
-- m frued
I_t A
;luiLgc_
18 cbm&cs m thaz vol_a_¢.
24 A
Hearing
14 m fra. ed [tght produced by somce_ _lemal
17 G'c c_t_u_ o f Lh_ = s_u-_ors,,rod Lt rs Iook_
Q
Okay
12 2_, eo_¢¢t?
pIR_
16 d'cc_q_ofr_ch_c_or
morton ts m_=mg tl_
10 sot,tee, ye=, _n"
chm_;c m d_c ouq0ut of c_th_
aud LEe Loud.die
Wall
W]TNEX_
Tlhlnkyou.
9 A
43. or th= ¢_.._ut,
_ppe_ed
beeaus=
xs be n; _7
g =atere.al u) Lhe_rdo_,
T_s_.sorsQla.'_dQ2
w_t
over I.hal _
gul a _= n=dly n:a_
2_
II
I n_,
m ba_kgrotmd m _ated
3 _._ylng
s_or
1._
"II',IE COURT"
of tl_ mn_n.
or his hand. thc bile
po_on.
&'.cczs any sq_fic_mt
eh_e
eneqgy
6 _dtn:a_
_o a det_lor
wtOt that, _me
22
Okay
g _caI.Lma3.a_hncs34d_muSh]6
If thereo-
mfr_
2 p:*tt _-e _l_g
the m frayed
what the pa_enCsa_?
L)_ ha_d
Y_,Yo_rHonot
move3 tow_'_ the P[_-, there would be _om¢ chaise
It wo_d
00_23
I th_']
H[GG_,S
And e.n't d_
bnngmg
the
Bcca_c
_ofnfi_.acoon_
]8
4 Q
_
catr_
Markman
bodyt,"_c_,_
Pl_ k _
PI_
THEWITNESS
Page520
So a's kind _n"a iv._-,_cp
m_zCeOf=_rm
Woulda_'t tbe act o f bonging
COI/RT
c_rl,_t_Iy is minion
2L
IS 3 _¢$UJI Of mO UO_ Of a _'v_O9
Markman
VilB
stj_n =rta=.
17 m be_kffmtmd
20
m heat,
a?
PI_ _ d_a=an_,
l
to
m_ared e_e_gy
when Lbe_e n m_uc_ _
_
L_ambltOfLhc
15
V_wel[
hea_ -- ¢ha=8c_
-- that is r_ mymg
m ob_et,
_
enea'l_,, not tnc_de_t
Mot ton ¢,an e_._ e c."tanJ_es m mfrafed
19 revolved
T_c_ c,lt30_lf
_
d7
i_ only _cn=uv_
_,'_d the c_Se_
13
tr0m
I£1GG[NS
LEafs sayl_l
these'aso:
it, would
9 Q
f 6 tf the ha_
B'-q whoa a PIR seea_
Z$ Q
_retty thffcr_t
_
_
htshazd_er
t deteel
10
14 th_
MR. HICrG[thS
16 may
tt wouldn
m mfrared
12
Heal SOU_
t_ n_.
I$
thu yoa Just ga_ c u zrue
NO. tt woLdd not became a P_
A
of Lbe
t t_
I I c=rt_n]y
11'_ CO_q_T
14 rrr_uon
mouon,
8 eh_ges
f3k=y
13
,vlthout
to that set,sot. _
Rape'rbeld
A_d a'Mr
? A
_e _orc_ 't.e _e
12 (_
21
_=8
6
Io changc_ In medent m f[a.'r.d
'kre _
10 A
= dJffe_enc_
m me ld_'tl m fi'al_ed meTgy
ts produced hy the mouon
etm_g¢
_e_e w_ac_pac_'o_
HearJu_
to my other c"a_e
22 Q
And Jm't t_at a de_ct_on
2], A
Ifs d_te¢_ng
hal =s well
m m frat cd CnerSy
by that P12.7
a ehlmge m infi'_ed
_e-j_',
)_,
24 str
Lh¢
10/2"//05
energy due to the l'.an d and Lheb=ebttl
as it w_tdd _pmad
25 Q
Markmaz_
II *- I o_ecrved d respond Io the ch=mges m
Page
And t_
fnhared
en_3ty el _r_ly
MackJrta_a
522
JA 0911
coael=e_
Htarln8
to
10/27/0_
Page523
005"24
0052_
2 A
11wu
3 Q
$o srl _;m rr.t_ you 1o co[unto 6 of _e patcnJ7
4 AI m,umn
5 u some
0 f tu..n n'ovir_l It5 h,_
_
QI tad Q2 deu:_a m_Jon,
the way _
He specffic_,_om
_beanSd_ed.
de_c_bes
'l'e_'_ w_
AJ_d ffutt_ whtt you ase _femng
^ad
6 ;ec¢,m_
then theu:*'._d
h_lfkmdor
that ¢_-e,
czl _a
10 I_e
_u: bmprc_pc.d7
W_hlbebllf,
16
slm_e
hlmnd=?
.*rod so _h_t
17
n Wt_'_
I|
_andswmf.o_,-y
tl_t
Wealt bct(r.cnt
a_dc7
Wflhtb¢o177
He _uem
the vm_'_
_y_
w_e
t_m8
you ju_l qt;otcd.
Uh-I.,ub.
I¢ Q
Just hke the fu_
the same, v._re_1
The Items c_une _
20
I_¢ mmmg
21
Q
0f th= evil
iS He s¢_unly
Cve_t
Ih_ Mr
Yeelmtme.
The w'ty those
t_o devr.es
73
_e,
in Hc _0_
24 Q
24
wtth _
2_
the eVenL_ were He =am_, wt_e_t
Whdc tts ta =cer4
-
Markmaa
Hearing
1_27105
Page
2 A
2
DR
Q
C._n_t
1! A
|1_
|2
And Here w=t no seler.hon ¢_z_y
Q
13 doing [h_.
wu _'c7
la _r
_
1¢; A
I h,v_ no_ s_udJ_
17 b=_eve hz sa_
IB
Q
dewc=?
the_c w_
0f whir you _
20
A
Ao_Jly.
21
_
22 J'_
¢z_c f_y
no nd_:tton
5ov._Hm_u_or_u_.
19 _
23Q
lus cma_t
Mr
7 A
Y_,
|
Andyeuh.'tdMr
_d
Mr H_lelmeb_dcup
will
you'_
s_ng
PlX?
_t_e,
A
Well
25
_a_c a H_l_m,
l _dd
I betie_c
anqp_fym881ass
Markmaa
IlcarMg
10,'27/05
Pogc526
10/17_S
Page52_
o f tome |o_
g_7
My_mu_
wa_ Som_
to _c_"
m
"IT_ COURT
14
"_
15
TI'_ COU_T
16
THEWITNE_S
17 BY _
'_GGII_k_
Okay
"n_'re_somevt't7
In Mr
_:v_u_ ct_cu_
Ev_x_ or Ra_
"_V'_'_N_ S
AJ_d the _kctmn
Let's
Loek=I_czsetofccastm
[ m sorry, Yore H_m
Okay
Mr I_tpce_a_cust
c_-'t_3,
to ]usl He ¢onlrot
_ how
1,_u _
clrCml tlufs
ddMm8
coupling
and the outpul of the photocdl
to the Urn.p7
Wcll.lt
Ioo-ks to me I_te th= P_
mMr
R2_m_s_rcmL
seaso¢ m d-dvth8
A_dthccomFaa.of
_tlm_Jogvoltag¢ofHalPU_,lOSOmctlun_
_
And
I_".cl, _o the cutout
Markman
JA 0912
8
fist_e-
sdcc_on c_c_uy
25 _1Ic_k= I_(c LI'Sa _:fcrcn_:
b_a |
Henna
H_'e'_ama_'nl_SSl_.s
13
24
Thl I_mp _a-_c On to
Vo_ nccd a _ng
TH_'_i'TN]:_S.
22 A
- tf I o=uM
bmh
wu =muhtcd,
_dhet
I0 _thn
2t
c¢_
lucH ez it tad tall y_.
they?
d¢_nemuatlon
TH_COC_T
23 acomparttot
hts cnnt'e de_t_,
cu_utt_y
20 He ourpm of He PI_. _
ttol
C.a'r=_
24
that Mr Rep_r
[ d_d
19 tt _t opted
Yc_'rc
of He enlue
Hc device
thai
one
cancer7
9
18 Q
P.q_er took the
I ;_ve a_reed u a b_o
about the dcm or_-_u_
tl_ P[R, c_ tl_
but ]
¢_rcma V
_s
be.runs,
12 n_lment_y
m_ot'._hn
_x devr._
&gotL
6 _u
II
ISQ
w_ked.
_3_slsjmttc_mdl
You I_ew
Q
th_stme.
Io all of the ¢_cmw/,
boat'd_, wt_cn mshmme
CARNAL
rmson_
4 nQt _
A
ptt_t.
little _
O_s27
I belzeYe it h._ 5e]ecuon
l_='s
they
W_w_u
Marknun
3 A
7
bm]l acr-ordmB
S24
I &m7
bmh
on of the bghts?
2J lf$ the prod.,_:m'_ncd moron
E,_cusc _
on
Hm7
THECOURT-
_u
Wall. w ;'n: t._km& _3_u_ d_ zc_cn t Irvcl hew..
E'v_
the '068 patent,
22 Mr
25
dO_n
daunted
bulb came
_
They were He _me?
Q
20 Q
_le
devt¢o
17 A
19
22 A
the phc¢ccetl
8 to _JI of the ct_mu'/ta
19 vthat do '.re do LbOUhL
21 d_t_zed by the PJR& ¢_rrccl?
whe_
the hUIc fl_Mfsht
1_
a ImJe b_l of
And t]'tcdezec_.u_ o f He event s mouen betas
ctrcu_,
of _if_t.
I.I A
18 we_
we h_ve detected our c-_mt, aow
wl_'uhe
_J_d the PI bo:trd Iogethe_ w_J_ h_s
_hth_'t Jr_
| $ _¢orc_
wh_
I_,p_scr_de_tton,
be:vd
_n_'ol
II I_e absence
lus
(ram u Ck:_,n'bm&
And so th= part you _Je r_
IS
And-mMr
9 put He photocell
12 to _
14 wcII, howwdl
to u He
eve_u'
8 Q
_l
12 been dooc.
I _
it ssy_
uze
of what kind of mot_n
how the lawp retl.*<luts on_
QI and_2_
5 Q
¢ovenl
It
poult_¢o.l_z_
4 A
9
the thsmmm_uon
s_'ne
if
he_'z, the way t_'; Ixokcn down, m the fL.= half
tO to-
-Ifa_
3 moia_?
m=_
8 vm=m
m_,_dy
R[_C
QI md Q2 dmccl mo_n?
tha_ u:nmu
^¢maJly,
I A
2 Q
?o_. sb
6 of tho p_.l=nt al ha© 2 tad 3, It f,ayl dltl
_omt th: u_;on
6 th_ p_:m
7 A
I n_l
HcaH_g
_s-
10/27;05
Page
K_7
00529
I SO It'S thscnmmatmg
0_52S
I
Q
Would
thatreference leveljustbe thc biasing
of
2 B _, MR
2 thc P[R '_
3 A
No
4
3 Q
sir h'sthe -tts_ccomporator
THE
COURT
And v.hat is itcompanng
5 compatriot is compRnng
_hal '_Companng
4
) The
6
6 something, isthat_hat you sald
7
somewhere
9
MR
I0
THE
COURT
II
THE
WITNESS
12
THE
COURT
13
THE
WITNESS
I -welllook
10
Can you m.tke _Iout _
I'lltry,_ o_
Honor
Okay
Itlooks hke the output o f the
14 PIR sensor goes mlo an op amp that'sbeing _ed
15 amph
16
as an
Then
IIlooks hke 11goes intosome
Raper so thalttlooks hke
20 thing and IfItSocs below lhatrcfcrence itdoes ,_otber
22
So I would co_tdcr
23 The ctrcu;115dcctdmg
24 $1gn;llthat'sch_gmg
25
lhalrucbmemary
and it'$deciding well inone case
1 _ant todo one thing m other c_se I _t
Markman
todo _othcr
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
to do
that's
ho_
this
tts stgnal,
lamp
correct
clreutt
op,_rates
COUR
P
to try to come
up l_lth
MR
13
THECOURT
14
(Break)
copy
I think
And
_-e'll
I'm going
a better
HIGGINS
lake
copy
Very
COURT
_ell
Were
MR
HIGGINS
plamttffs
of this
perhaps
Your
We'lltakea
THE
our mormng
Io aak the
an
Honor
15 mmulerecess
we able
Io find a betler
i
Regrettably,
Your[{onor
web',ere
nol
19
rilE
COURT
20
MR
HIGGINS
area
of examination
thfferent
THE
23
thdn't
24
anything
25
thai
know
All right
Sol'mgomgtomo_etoa
COURT
if yota
th fferenl
Let mc
looked
or anylhlng
_ c app_ently
ask Mr
at it o_ef
don't
the
Massengdl,
break
else you
want
ha_ c a better
copy
Markman
Hearing
I
or saw
to say about
10/27/05
Page
529
Page
531
0O531
I
THEWITNESS
c_not
read
3
thts
THE
4
B',
5
Q
6
Mr
7
correct "_
8
A
9
so [ don't
10
Q
MR
12
do
13
Q
YourHonor
lapolog_ze
I
[just
COURT
Dr
3
Okay
M_sengdl
ii _s coffcct
report
That's
to sludy
correct
think
I could
But did you
That
thal
read
try thai
w_s not one
February
same
cnher
before
now
of the tasks
ha'* e had
5
represemcd
6
A
ldo
7 Q
The
9 on
Higgtns
)
to
no.$tr
Would
14
bonkupthcrc'_
15
A
you
re fer to tab 79 of the _.lmess
ThtslsDr
Paulus
binder
report
16
Q
Andspectfically
17
ofthal
rcporL
rm
A
All right
19
Q
Do
20
portion
II
amphfler
comparator
12
correct
13
A
Thats
14
Q
Okay
you
topagc
10
THE
with
21
A
Yes
22
Q
Directing
23
says
24
power
you
recall
Dr
PauluS tcstlfymg
about
Ido
your
respoct
altentlon
_o Mr
to the demonstraltOn
q'he PIR
sensor
to the tcxt
Rapor's
Dr
dcmonstral_on
ClrCUtt was in the
det_tcd
_,larkman
both
Paul_
the input
folm
the motion
Ileanng
of
of Mr
10/27105
Page
wLth the
includes
JA 0913
the filler
clreUllS
That's
contained
report
is _hal
Dr
ctrcult
mcluthng
the
fihc_ed
and logic cffcults
be says,
COURT
amphfier
v, hafs
Raper's
yes
Arc
Paulus
Isn t thai
sir
you
MR
question
HIGGINS
Your
asking
h_m if be agrees
TIlE
20
B'_
MR
21
Q
22
chzraclenzatlon
23
bdr
24
A
25
thagram
That
was
gom_
to be
my next
Honor
COURT
Okay
HIGGINS
Do
Raper's
The
you
agree
that wnk
oFthe
h_tle clrcu_l
diagram
Dr
resportse
thagram
or figure
] ha_ e not studted
Paulos*s
circull
as contalncd
on
_
12 is a functional
ho_
Markman
531)
abo_e
block
that or if thai s _ hat he says '_
19
th_s
°
logic
response
what
in the dlagrara
circuit)
Mr
the
18
of his reporl
batteries
IOrefer
from
has called
16
Now
response
circuit
and
I0
17
18
_tth
going
responsc
thai figure
15
All right
ctrcult
it says
response
the comparator
is m there
l v. _s asked
by
The photocell
m the le_ el of hght
respol_e
of th_s year
Mr
that
The
_t you see where
thJgram
it then
the change
4
thal you
since
And
Raper_shar_dandthemouonofanohjcct
2 detected
h*s t_o sn_[I
HIGGINS
Rapor's
I I A
25
changed
fled ,rod sent to thc
528
00530
2
THE
22
selecllOn
- its looking atdos _alog
It v.ants
the
if the PIR
believe
12
21
21 That's _hal ttappears to me here
don'l
some'.,,here
18
19 ffthc PIR slgnal goes above thaireference,ttdoes one
amph
,it this point
17
IIIO some
simply
I I on_lna[
16
sortof
17 comparator arrangement _beTe It'scompanng
18 reference thatwa_ chosen by Mr
w_
15
fy to amph fy the analog slgnal
what
H_ggins
9 recess
YourHonor
that signal
Rapcr'sstmpledewce
_
You
8
perha1._s'_
HIGGINS
A
7 Mr
Is LhCrea better copy of Ibis'_ Is tbere an
$ ongmal
AndmMr
thscnmmaiton
5 that signal
the output to
from
HIGGINS
iI might
relate
Hearing
block
threctly
to
1{}/27/05
OO532
I Mr
Rapcr's
2
things
3
Q
OO$33
¢ircmL
Very
4
photocell
6
hide
-- I mean,
If you could
8
nearby,
9 you
within
any kind
Il
some
t2
PIR_
aboul
means
soil
THE
yes,
Your
had
WITNESS
the
4
THE
WITNESS
17
THECOURT
That's
7 produced
of water
and
g Q
of water
an element
would
without
underneath
thai
v, ould
tnggcr
respond
9
iI of
Even
though
Vcs,
Okay
there's
the PIR
one ofthe
me
Do you
Essentl_ly
Okay
would
ask me that again
A
II could
23
itself
Itwouldbescnsmgaheatstgrmturethafs
24
changing
25
Q
in that situation
the change
through
in beat
of the water
changes m infrared
I9
A
Actually,
hght
And
21
-- changing
22
tS a result
23
Itwouldcbenge--Jlwouldscnseelthcronc
Markman
II
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
25
O
I'msoro/
3 mfrared energy
3
4 Q
4 includes
And in fact,atpage 5 of your Rule 12 statement,
hne
5
6 lhts isin Scctlon B -
6 26, aald which
7 A
Section, excuse me 9
7
8 Q
B
8 A
9A
B
patem7
paragraph
Yes, sir
li
BYMR
The phrase appaars,
12
Q
closed paten,
base hght
acUvatcd
]6
PIR,
17
A
Correct
18
Q
lmean
21
A
22
Q
23
3, _
24
A
Co[umn
25
Q
Yes
mode
scr_mg,
parch, or
that
scxtsors,
and you agree w0h
plRsarc
that a[ page 5
coffee{?
Rlght
And
that's
533
and 2B
PIR,
sensors Q]
housing
to infrared
not say
22 behind
IcIIs
light produced
motlon
see motion
m that
or Q2 detect
a change
-- what the PIR Isdoing
14
in mfrared
energy
change
emitted
m the
Is detecting
by a person
the
or object
tO that sensor, con'ccl _
16 A
It tSseining
17
Q
And
18
sensors
over
that change,
at column
Q I and Q2
Right
yes, sir
g, hne
_xe detecting
19
A
20
the fit_l
21
just read ts describing
3, l[ says
motion,
specifications
which
detection
of the motion,
are responding
Mr
from
the aclual
that the
corr¢ct'_
Anda$IexplalncdeJzllcr,
pail o['the
And
HlggUlS
you ha_e
of the motion,
and that's where
Io mfrared
hght
you read
produced
external
then
over
in column
6, ,:,here
51arkman
JA 0914
Page
correct '_
Il does
thesensors QI
by sources
534
_
infrared,
the output
25
Page
10/27/05
that w_
13 output,
24
10/27/05
the
HIGGtNS
3 of the patent" _
Hearing
hght
Hearing
wtthm
to the lanlp,
paragraph
that the sensors
Markman
mounted
or the next
the dtscnmmalton
m column
which
produces
of figures
passive
I don't
22
tt is described
Is what
hne
are each responsive
23
that
thscussmg
the mfrarcd
the circuit
arc each
_
the way
wc have been
infrared
that's detected
d, begmnmgat
COURT
When
15 external
mfrarcd,
correct '_
patcntsays
statcmcnL
vatous
and a bright
thafswhalthc
for mOltOn
of your
describes
mode, the use of p_st_©
SenSors for motion
20
the patem
such _s a dlm dlmnmaoon,
24.
external
THE
10
rearmed,
which
That'swhalltsays
9
15 dl_rnmanon
I 9 wed
Q2, which
by sources
of the
body
moving
column
tv, o conventional
5 or al leastatpage 5 on the copy that I w_s provided -
_mboy?
now
lfs
approximately
and
hghl
the in frar_d
szgnature
not creale
0self
I don'[ reca0
2 Q
[tISone dnng thaiwilt caRSe a cbenge m
the '066
that produces
heat
ofthe
does
mfraed
0self
But the body
OO535
1 A
Could
It?
IHarkman
I change In infraredenergy, correct?
an there
produce
of the mfrared
of the mutton
The motion
a word
wouldn't
it's the body
532
00534
We are dtscessmg
hght,
signature
[CS the body
infrared
IS by mollonl
would
it's the changing
24
hght
and
Motaonofapcrsonor
to the sensor
20
Is
the air,
infrared
light
ple_e
and
of water
infrared
I missed
Ig
22
also sense
I think
relative
be sensing
responding to in Fr_ed
to produce
to the lamp
Actually,
Letmeaskttthtsway
_
14 _ccnt.
by sources
the same
objccl
concct
I d oparallonal
tl
28,
Oneofthewaystoproducemfracdhghtby
13 a somce external
15 you
ways
are essemm[ly
12 Q
_
_
agree that
Q
21
12 Q
d, hne
produced
to the apparatus
lI A
to that,
It would
correct,
external
17
the heat
II A
hgh[
HIggms '_
16
Q
from the body
Mr
Yore" Honor
19
Q
at column
Somcllmesthehncsdon'tqutteaddup
Goahcad
20
I0
says
to infrared
And
excuse
I0 energy
the
no mohon
hne,
6 A
idea.
HIGGINS
nsmg
What
27or28
14 A
16
What
A
d Q
have
a pool
The PIR
about
Honor
COURT
2 A
be responswe
would
you could
up that pool
up the water,
THE
BYMR
be -- _s the patent
I'm stth a
the motion
as tt were,
you jt_t
15
Ig
again
a PIR set up and
of heating
that heated
a question
the PIPs
the heat and
have
of motion,
13
14
Let me ask
its view,
had some
10
I would
2
two
3 extcm_d to the sensor, conect ?
COURT
con eroded about
7
those
well
THE
5
not correlated
] have
you
Hearing
v, cre just
10127105
Page
535
00.=36
0,0537
I re_=AmS, *.h2t - t_ [ e_pt 3med. t_afs _te _eco_
2
this w'_'e
.fs _-,d oI u.ToJig a shorfo_Jld
3 then it_ desm_omg
4
w¢II _
do_
_c
6 tim the ¢=_f_=_
I Q
|
thafs
wrixJ_
9A
I foal whftl the pt'u34o,_ei[ dele_led
that, or_
2 thcbuL_
respond.
doe5 it e,r_ o ft.
j¢_ kind of a sho*'c_amd
Q
L__t
rcreto_
QI a.qd
f..orrcc_
4 Q
And whcnIv/x
7 Q
¢enwr/
_down_Im_34=nd35
15 I;_$iw
tt says. yes.
16 A
Th_'s
wh_
17
Q
Now,
mM_
18
to fort,
AS biased,
Q
- e_.k
2.2 detected
for dctccLmg mo13_,
K,tpc_'=_oto_mon,
tha_ Mr
y_,
13
A
|4
_
15
_'11
fos_ut_ovc_thc;PIK.ti'¢
fo¢ct_cmtofM_
h'_t you
P_pcr'_
W_¢h
he c.utnot _d
16
Q
v*'_ no p_ls¢
=8_ce with m_ _ouldn_
co_llng
you,
t_t
t=l that _rc_t3
Ihc_dycSlerd_yMr
Raper tcsni_m
t_t.bUEl
t _orYartcu_ o't thai c',flCtU_ "vlr Ht_
bec_
c I
_md=ed it, and [ c_rt _ rr.xl tL
Yo_ k_
fozt p_ds_ c=otmt was a p_¢ut
ady
lf.I ¢_n _
Rupees
der_ns_rauon
had
t8 A
Tt_
19 Q
An_ yo_
sir
was e=p]_e_
to me, y¢_,
devol¢_
a gu_.wtl_J
op_ruon to the p,.dl ¢ cou_
_
po_ou
o fyour
bcm 5 p=_ of. foc rc_mred
you - detected reot_on of h_s _
rnotmn _fthe
Itttfo [_utcvdle
u_f LI_ tvhen _
stugBer b_ed=ll
22
A
put I_gcthcr,
23
I spent m_t
the ¢onlrol Ct_u_
24
CW;UIEth_r'='_
25
cc,_ tz,.u;tms wb_
whcde httle _
2¢, t_c PE_ board, the photo_il
2._ "=oud w_
corr ccf_
it _ays
we've a_ecd
Z0A
2.] _
a f the pa_'nL il _ay_ that a
iI1E'_Jed _n_0¢
,_nd=r
ne_t ptuo_e - you w_tdci
2 thcrc
AI_,Ln the _t
Raper waved
TFIE COURT
I|
"rb2f_ w_
the I_p
tY_
12 comcP
21
Okay
9
i4 Q
Ctn'_l=led night
cor_W/
to bright, ¢_r_©ct_
I d_rr,o_l_aUo_
.t._dow_=t_olu_m
13 .4.
tod_m,
_A
5 btdb w_t
C4_e_
lo
c.tmctm
t_ds uxed
Aod Jr= - ituu d_=_
OZ d.c_cct =noee_
vv_
t_n|
_o¢_ '3to IlI_t go brtVtt, does It go _"n,
And so I _¢_e_c
h_df o["
put to_u.tter
w_
_3oa_d _d,
:rod co_ed
to chc tlashltght
_larkmaa
He=ring
b_lb,
t0/27/05
Pal=e
Iwou]c[nt
Charactcnz:elltl_t
wry,
o f my ume studying
a3 con_ncd
_ E¢l_
Mr Hif._lr_
tde dar_
tn ttx_c
ed mi_c==ltcd
536
Markman
a_d _t_dym_
_ar_
o_ =r d_:
the c_m
Hunng
tl_
a_l
_m',_ c__*
|0,'27/05
Page
537
00S29
[ m fo_"
ctmmL_
"l_atts what|riper
moat of my mice
1 thtt. Mt
2
3 Q
But yo= kne_v t]_t pulse
4 abe=ace
_f pu._
$ the c_ f,_ol
_t
c_cmi
6 pre_te_
zt p_
co_t.
w_
of the scr._r
_'1 irn.0o_tnt
'o J=d_c Tr=u_r,
fo_
7 A
NOi Sir, _ w._._ t p_c_ttcd
=tQ
SO-
9 A
I _u
|0
io_¢hereor
I!
_sue
12
Q
13
to '.ha _ur_
oo_ to_d tl_
them.
foe precen_
_
_
or
_, the _3t_I
L_U= U'_ WOUI(i be
3 h_2rm_
to me thtt v_y
the ptg_c ¢OtLr4¢:rW_
9 ¢oul,u_
impommt
_t;
iI hclpftd
Well
tha_ an ¢=g¢_1 _ Supl:_cd
w_to is of zs$_l.,t_¢
t8
r ¢c¢_,_i-/a.'=
_dvocatc
qtu_t=0n
_3 the cotul
for =_
EaF_
lure ,d=OUlfo=t
t_ you keep -
16 Q
_o yca Under.rid
13 to _:
14 _dj_l-
yo_
to t:*¢_t p¢_oo
$o forint-Mr
_ld not
p._'_'_
Mr
irhe
edvoc.t_
21
=_4 _e
22
Q
,'_d
23
_.d_
_ur_t _
24
_ hc]p the courl tmders_td
.t.
fc_c_t=_pa_/
op_toas
so _ your ncnulvo¢_c
_
Nc4 _o_Luly,
itl=e
fo¢fin_
16
THE
17
TH£COI._T
_O Can fm_
_tcre
po=uo_,
you d_n'¢ ¢o-t_dc_
J_
k_owm$
that
thai im_r_,_
t
WITNESS
MarlU_au
c=r_
Hearing
I0/27/0_
MR.
Page
_33
to ask
it'. _ ('_t. M_ _t =per
thml_ is the ¢_e,
t just reel
Y_=t¢£tdly_u¢lp.tuns,._hti
t$ we th2z c_JI Mr
P.apef oo
I_ul that th_ ts !3er fealty _p-o_qtle.
Mark/_n
JA 0915
Y_k¢cp_m_b=_.k
on fo=s. I need to kao.,v what L_ the
HIGGINS
I w_ g0m$ to _t
forw_d'0¢_lase
aad hl_ ]a.vyct may w_t
_._'_pl_
exp¢_
_2
2_ tebut_l.
how to z_'wcr
wh_t r_
be£¢lre we $o r,t,_er
24
turn your ¢_
Yore _Ionor Yo_ttr¢£me.
_|
23
_¢_xe?
I - I d_rCt Y..,_
wanted lo _ow
18 to tl_s wtfo him, and you _y
I'm=medcq_=_r
foat I hay© ex_rt_l
m._-t oath
T,.voldd hk= D_ C_,n_
Ragcr m_ybe¢ottldyou¢.ome
19 5trth_ ¢l=:Sa_ns ot'D_
20
of rca4m_
you_su_
_2 fi'om when you le_ £ted i_ fore, _d
cor=ten_or_ and [3 ES _.'s
I'm n_ ft#e I tmderstand
Lttustrat_on with two _
-- I bchcve what hc _l_d ¢_ [he _atne seI_:uon
rmt p_'t of'_t©
15 .t,
17
I have _ e=p¢_ who s
IO ¢3'1te_ a _ the _az_1[.
wt.ll_
II
to tau_'_ t.u_l Mr _xp_s
going Io - '0¢_t_e
7 r¢=d Va" Eap_$
puY._c_tm_
And b¢_ s _o aw'_re, you d.d._*t co_ttd=r
that purse _
_
In ilrl[et'Rlpt yoU for"jt_g
fn:e wheeltl_g _a forte of MarJca&-t
6 _.'*_st_nlt m e_ _.qd my cx]3¢rt tells mc d_t. m Pa=t' I:¢ c=n
mth== _¢.
14 c_t_uo_
FmgoinSIo-tnthetnl_'e¢l_f
ml_ersLtl_llnS, I'm going
4 a m_nule, uld lipvcrt _
]_ar_o_"
t you7
I w_aw_¢th_
HtS.._ns
T_COL_T
Hearing
10/27/0_
Page
539
00540
00541
I
THE
2 can _k
3 Mr
Dr
COURT
Lcl'sget IZnow. _d
M_cngdl
R_cr
everybody
MR
$
DR- CARNAL
6 hke Io mc
RAPER
THE
8
MR. HIGGINS
Your
9
THE
COURT
COURT
THE
COURT
_©
freewheeling hc_e
Honca?
I d_n'tre,fly think thal's
Goah_ad.Mr
box. _ad - I_ _dn't know
R_x'T
WCllputyouuph_cm
I w_
I'm no4 gou_
law without
_ tthota
MR
to get arf_l
No. youwdlnoL
bcmg
for
You
may me
THECOUKT
which
RAPER
THE
_
]I w_
_awn
c.c_'non]y
COU_T
used
thee
Ilearing
10/27/05
Page
¢ngmcer_
m here,
3
to blow
lt up
Bet_y,
W or T?
You'vegc4
IL
PAPER,
p_vlo_sly
duly
and leSt_ficd
sworn.
_
follows
CAR_NAL.
17
All right.
Now,
good_
Thal'Sexa_tlywhat
w_th tfmy
th_s point
21
A
Thafs
Q
Now
double
nghl
I want
eycg]_s_
here
iodo
are wo_kzn 8
ts recewmg
the output
from
Isn'tthalnght?
correCL
Thal's
I'm beg_rmlng
23
THE
24
(Laughter)
25
THE COURT
the molton
to sound
COURT
Don'l
mpuL
hkc a lawyer
worry
1'11c_t yoo
540
aboul
offlf
Markman
Wealsohavealo_of
5
BY DR
Okay
['lHefram
thai
WITNESS
tell a lot of la'.vy_
We
3
BY DR.
4
Q
f_nthaL
it
yc*a get -- wc
Ilearing
10/27/05
Page
541
Yes
Q
And l'm going
7
they wall be -- well,
8
tek_copmg
8 gt._
the Ihl_
thai
girtk_;
n_
abo_
tl t$. ,_ it I_
ts bastcal]y
a I_nd
parl
pa_
9
f]Re_7
Io
II
THE
COURT
12
DR
CARNAL.
13
THECOURT
14
Q
Y_
15
A
Whal
]6
_lve_3'htgh
17
th_PIRtsanope_s¢_3_3¢
from,
19 b_.k_end
a wk_l?
Bandpass
Bandpass
h¢'l_ _.aymg
frcqucn_t_
flirt:x7
13
a_c summing
IlCa_dcte_t
ou_cts
]o..v
a_ddoesdetecl
and jttSl gcner_
ne_
know,
as a mou0n
_t _ as _ne o f the ftmcuo_
Ser_;os,
;I*S typzc_
to make
tha_ that 15
out
THE COURT
do what he just
THE
SO you are fatymg,
yes.
that does
Yeah.
Markman
tlearing
10/27/05
Page
542
And
thlTercnl
baslca_b'
the two
14
A
Thal"_ correct.
Q
And
16
stmanmg
17
connected
18
re f¢_'nce
node,
19
me about
the c_cult
20
L_thai o_e
21
deszgned,
22
thzS netwOA
then
_
this
one
so
of the
whercyoueansce
25
from
both
and the_
I guess
-- the
one
strUClUrc,
called
nght
piP.s,
here,
nght'_
take oul the
th=
otht'r Ilnng
cc_aected,
of these
Umc
t,¢_on
the two
parl -. if I'll just
bnns_ng
the
would
thin8
*s
be the
thai stokes
Iwo clr cmL% you know
in yo_x
the s_gnal
ctrcm!
that you
in, and you have
got
Igrc I0 _ound.
THECOURT
24
from
-- b_slcally
of them
you're
m d_s
two capac_{c_,
signals
if you I_e,
sara¢
the s,_nc
f_rrn
these
of the other,
through
at the
I'm seeing
of the jtw/box,
Dr
Mess_gtll,
canyousee7
Ifyouwa_ttoslto',_hcrc,
why don't
btove
szlm
yo_
Markman
JA 0916
use thts htde
Io bccanse
in here
lts¢ll',
15
23
sa_d it thd7
_S
them both
the patent
Delectm
Andpartofth_tsdoncbccausc
say, clccmt_J
Bu[ from
12
out very
have
her_
I can'l get
filter7
Is that tl _]u_s
to - I should
I may
I 1 and it's m a shghtly
_x_*am.
So, y_
tt useful
Bzslcally
I$'_
Fther
CARNAL
5 A
"l'ht_p_a_ofthectrcmtcynghth¢_,l
Which
B_md pass filter?
6
9 of the c_cmw/nghHhere
22 film_l
COURT
THE
CARNAL`
Okay
20
THE
(Lau_h_)
7 Q
18 notre
I
2
too
DP.. CARNAL.
4 .mke_mcla_
25
_._e
OO543
I havegotenoughlawyc_zmh_e_
24
been
That's
22
On the cafn_ter_
00_42
23
Q
th©bw_PIR
tha_ar_
nced
MITRAKOS
examined
20
m a schc'mau¢
t_ draw
| don'l
EXAMINATION
19 prop_[y,
Dldyoud_wthls¢Ireml
_L_rkman
21
CARNAL
having
w_
lg
S_r_
thmg_
theEI_O
You
WILLIAM
BYDR
Maylappmachto_v©av_ual
th_r_m'_
MR.
Io
MS
16
the
Edd to the _v_In_7
24 pa_ka_¢,
6
DR
15
zrre_a:d_
HIGGIN$
23
2
9
10
13
a hcensc?
THECOURT
25
THECOURT
14
DR. CARNAL
zt, you made
hem
12
going do lhLs.
I hale these
Nolyo_dlagram,
Ii
14 by the'_ay
22
themlncl_s
8 help
Should I sl_-p
dovm. you_
13 the wla_a_
pta¢ u_ng
CARNAL.
7
12 ncce_ary
|5
RAPER
DR
6
We
II
21
Yes
MR
FIIstand _J_
WITNF_$
20
Bul you configm_d
5
Okay
THE
19
Y_
COURT
4
Honor. ffl may. I wou/d
too
I0
I 8 EI_O
RAPER
THE
3 tl?
Sh_llst_dh_e?
the EL.MO
7
17
MR
2
saysal II_spomL
4
]6
1
abou_ Ih¢$c rn_tcrs depcndJng on v.hat
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
$43
00544
OO545
I
DR
MASSENGILL
2
THE COURT
Thank
you.
I Q
from
3 to see v.hat hds doing
3
the other
4 BY
4
"k
DR.
"._tmg
7
the
]ncedzoomoulahtflebltbecausel*mnot
thal
small
circuit
8 A
to be able
CARNAL
Okay
6
fat you
-
2
5 Q
It's _mportanl
So flus ts bes_cally
thai you
have
in your
the topology
nt_nber
10
Q
_
Tl_ae
_t Is_
THECOURT
12
THE
_e
Q
So.hat
}4
$cn_
with a capac_zot
15
_ltot
to ground _
16
A
Yes_
17
Q
lit the feedback
18
nelv, cck m the
_es.
Jl IS
WITNE.SS
13
youhavegotareststot
Io groun&
feedback
path,
19
A
Paulus's _ports
lttsftltert'd
21
Q
22
the paleal,
23
thfferenl
24
lillel_,iswhattbe) ane
25
A
KlghL
forms,
That's
m a
msents
of
be_ e got that tow
path
nght _
Wesaythala}somDt
Tbenm
at least
tesastot
paflu you
thepatenhltgctsloudcr--m
part of It, baalcally
but they
bes]mlly
_
are
these
ate two
both band
p_s
Tbeoneonmvnght-
correct
Marknmn
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
nghh
is the
the
one
Su/ttmlng
from
ha_ • that the
nov*
9
A
Okay
10
Q
AIInght
Tab
full thagram
80
Wdl
CARNAL
"_ou see the
"Faat's
12
sensor
13
thai too
14
A
15
Q
16
_._
17
ctrctll_
I8
ft_ thc_e
one
-- I dse'_,
basically
what
the green
-- ha_ e to zoom
l ha_ e outhned
m green
there
Yes
And
0_1
the
only reul thff_ence,
$1D/T _l
$UDLg _
Itha.shttlelowpa_
lhavenl
_
Iht OthO"
from
flhettheremffOntof
Okay
So. I mean.
thal -- here
all I did m tryang
we
- you
ate -
know,
flungs
is thtt
depenthslg
19
'_ ord eqtu_
connotations,
alent
21
lechnlca[
polnl
22
theyar¢
bandpass
23
A
24
required
25
th_
ts the right
_. ord
they
two
of_
- I don t know
alld [ don t want
of_ew
the judge
these
on the $el¢'¢tton
are funcuonally
20
to advise
b_lcally
d may have
to get into
perform
some
that.
a/ues
tf the
legal
but t_om a
the same
fullctloll_
filwrs9
Theydoperforms_mda_
for the
ftmcuons.
motion
arc casg5 _hgre
you
Theym-enot
1o operate
sensor
wotdd
wafl110
Markman
In other words,
up the
pick
tleanng
enllre
10/27/05
Page
545
Page
547
00547
I
fluid of the scraor
2
somewhere
3
th© $¢a'tsol
and make
as to the
4
data
o_" anything
dcmma'_d,
8
rma'kamg
9
see from
dccmons
ma_,b¢
the
spoct/um
entlre
1
of
hal
for pmix_es
to thls
o f th_
Andalotofthalts
aaltc_Ufiedtheothe_'dayloMr
Cook
10
t:x ample
device
I[
culhnglhtsad_lcethat
12
¢_ample,
asa
So some
14
th_
filter,
15
s car_or to Itrmt
thal's
d_a=n tx-'d m the patent
embudlmem
as wc ha_ e been
tsmorem_k_kable
actual
In_ enu(m
of the cncmtE,
ts put m there
]t mote
ts the
17
THE
COURT
Ig
DR
CARNAL
19
THECOURT
in here
as a addit
to tbe
-- fat example,
)ca tt_ the
appl/catloll
motlo'a
v, ¢ are tr-fl ng to
Okay
May
Yes
I be excused,
Thankyou
your
Honor9
youmaystep
down
22
23
rebUtlul,
24
any
THE
kVITNESS
THE
COURT
but I wanted
Thank
You
to clear
yo_
may
shH cull him
up that
point
on
before
v.e v.ent
fur, her
MR
-- thank
HIGGINS
Very
well
Marknmn
You;
Honor
Hearing
{ think
10/27/05
PageS46
to do
5
welcome,
6
flo_.
Now
you
MR
HIGGINS
Your
Dr
fÜr leilmg
Thank
yott
You are
Honor
ff)ou
your
You
flow
are yew
kind to suggest thai I had a
LLO'_
9
ha', tag
I 0
was
D MASSF.NGILL.
pte_ Iously
been
examancd
CONTINUED
duly
and testdted
sworn.
as follows
CROSS-EXAMINATION
12
BYMR
13
Q
Dr
Ma._sengdl.
[4
ligttre
2A
and 21_ of the patent
15
where
the QI
16
_uphn¢offigm'e2A
OF
LLOYD
MASSENGILL
HIGGINS
and
1 v, ouldhketoretumyouto
Q2 are
Do
17 A
Y_
18
Q
Now,
19
scrt_rs,_havraglet{o'sD,
20
S and G stand
21
A
Yes,
sir
22
Q
And
v_ hat are those
23
A
Dts
drying
24
flus
25
Q
case.
fig_tre
to the
the poruon
left-hand
sade of the
you ha_ e thm_
2A depicts
QI
SandG
and
Q2.
whlch
are the
PIR
DoyouknowwhatD,
for_
_t also
Now,
and paructdarly
show5
the
9
S _s source,
and G Is gale
means
grotmd.
source
_s the output
Markman
JA 0917
M_gdl
r/_ lntert_
(Laughter)
I I
for
claims
16 _ue_
21
would
7
as the
flung
THECOLrRT
8
- the pie feted
Ixa the
an excellent
4
dt'vt ce9
RighL
It was
2
funcatm
SO the dev¢¢
13
you
Bul
samdar
THEW1TNESS
7
mtelhgent
3
THE COURT
_-¢¢¢
6
2.5
yam
ts not including
544
0O546
20
DR
; l put the adthll
Okay
I ba_edonc
20
5
Q
8
What
this
H1GGINS
7
-
the screen
l don'l
MR
B_I
R In the book_
II
Okay
6
of
on
and
sotsoO
5
Idca'tha',¢theothetthagramtorefcrto
9
I guess
the palent,
of the
And
PIR,
Hearing
m
eorwct
'l
10/27/05
OO549
l
A
2Q
In I_
_Sem_t,
_,
O]_zy
NOW. | w_l
fo t_
3 Ihe p_a=l( g c01m'nn ] g_Iz _re
4
AI c_m_n
$ ooupl_
6 _cc=
sg, th2f_ eonec_
I Q
you m L_I po_
_mg
of
_oou_
3 A
J, Ira© 34. sco._0mQI and Q2 =re
s_Epd_._s
m m_'a_d_=_y
rm-rmson7
$ Q
$_re.
W_eltsrjsh=rc
Conl_t
9 Q
a_d gle ou_
10 t_0m QI,
It
A
tl Iho_n
a_ $ 0e _gurc 2A OT._qUm]E
Q0n_
_o _heTe L_
14 _o_ _ r_po_vc
i_ _
II
Y_I_ |_, t_
e_mo_
QI z_
19 I_¢ curtal
- ii h_
b_hl pr0_
de_:l_d
m=ysv_
fica_ dv, n_
,a
_
_ght
10 Q
- d_o =,_l_lC.ml
I[
m fra_l
m _,
I]
by source
A
colTc_?
And t_
pomo_ 43 of
No_ of_a
22 A
It e_
2_ Q
An_ th_ dete_ts sl_f_l
o(the
?4 of_e_e_nr
,=dJ_
a
ZA, c_n¢ct?
17 A
"rn=l_ c=rn_:t
11 Q
And ts tl - _re you _n8
to - _1
you atp_e
m tbo cm_mt a_ S, wh,ch - is a
20 d=t=ctmn of_smt_c.m=
sc_or
L_¢outpull_
wmdd bc co=rim8 _mt of the $ pomon
19 v, ttb rr= Lb_ ch_
Cor_eel.
= oh==_
dcJ_te_:L
out 0fth= d_'_ c_t
16 tb='s show_ on fq_=
co_
21 Q
cb.mS¢ m _= o=tpul,s
th_ tha_ _rnsor hu
_ c=mm[ _g
I$ Q
zrc coupled m a _e_or
cne_
NO.SL_ [h¢il_ll_m{¢h,t_g_m
14 _=n|e
s wh,_ dN rcspoodmg Io.
20 A
2_ ^
whtch _,cc=
12 cor_?
outpu_ of I_e _en_or, ,I h_s
Io m_a_
i0 ib_ dcv _
I_ A
9 A
corn_ _
11 d ¢le_/ed -- b_clnn_ t_) I0 hne 2_, ii h_
I_ ¢x_uJ
a th_
8 t_= output of ctthcr =m'=or -
T_'s
12 Q
md_©l_l=mGr,
d_nS= m I_= ouwul ot _dl_r
7 4_, of tho _:_u(
8 A
co_
lwz_]ookm|_twhal?OUjUs|
4 n=4d. Co_ddyo=repltrL_e,p_r_15c?
I0 a dclccmr i)m_on. 43. of the c_cm_, w]_c_
_
And =o wl_m _e output ofLhe sewr_ ch=mges, t_=I
2 ts r.b_=
titans© mth= o=tpuL =_d _
,$
21 _e d_tecuoa o f mot:on?
_mL
ch=nse m Ihe nu_)_l
cxlrn_l?
_n_CL
Markman
H_rmg
10t27/05
Pnzc
22 A
Th=t_ no_ wh=l Iht_ =ay_
?.3 Q
Arc you uymg
L_
24 0_pul
Of e P.ht'z_
wouJ_l nol _c = change m m fra_cd
2_ _:r_
ty=_
by tbc _'_mo
dctc_
Sd8
z _l_c,_nt
Markmnn
ch_nl_e m the
Hcanng
10/27/05
Png¢
549
oo_o
J A
]-tbJtwa_a¢_poun_qec_ott
2 M]e.e.
• dc_bl,
nc_'_
[lh_,[
m it Co_d
I h¢=_ ,I a_
Q
3 plec=_9
4 Q
S
] gu_
we h,v.e -
4 you n_l
Th'_ COUR1 _ TP/_at_
6 Q
c_gly
It'_ b=d m _k
A
m Pb.Ds. )m,a _.
IJ
glo_e por_n_
Y_,
sb. I n_l
C_Hsonconc_
Do
of your £_[?
[hose.
wbcn - Nc',m_mm_.
IfS a ¢L't_u::_
C_¢'¢ cf J= .¢r_,
14 cJ'c'r _.:t3_z_
8 A
Fo#_em_tl:_t.
9 ofM_
C=lson's
I0 Q
BUl =l t_mcy_
_t a _%x3o _ _ ft,.cod c_
_ _ ..h _:a._
_: a r:-_l
_
lhavc
.lw_ptov_dcdar.opy
_'p_o_.
s_ern_,_oul_In_r
12 dc_,,_oa,
subm_your
Ru_ I;2
r_Id_¢'_mulyofMt
C_Oa'l
had you?
a_ =-_r_c_ o_
_:3
14 (_re_y
I$
I$ ,A
of yore" Le_umosy. yoa pm
Your Fonor,
II
12 A
How, al _'ver'.J pomo_
3 Ihep_cmyo_g_teme_ld_lMr
I_xJ=lolofm2_e_aJIogo_hrou_mdn_d.
[ daa I _Jl
whell_
l SOt thr_u_
that whole t,_nl_
C_'t :=.
2.1 c .-'rc_
21 Q
8ot_c_r_t_v_r_pm_ld_Io_uby_r
24 Q
{_
- lm l =L_O=;nz_,
_,
Coo_
I1_ It I_e I]tae
2_ _c'. -1, ccr_cf_
l_d[arkmaa
Hearing
[0/27/05
Pale
_Marka_o
550
JA 0918
Hear_ag
I0_7/05
Page
551
00_$2
I Dr I_r.l_'t_
l
A
Nc_ii_dn_dl_l
izis tluntill
0
Ol_dztx_lm_rmr.mr_'
_
4 dcp_lllon
O3553
I iiy
dqx_atmo?
I da-rl rlzill
2 Mr
1
if I icld
_
_
3 dcposmon
hti
4 A
mlilily
Do yau rrm=_bcr
_
t_mSs _ _e _
COnceded _
to Mr
Carlson'sr_pome
al_ul
1 dclill
_uon
Cock_
6 Q
d'nrlls oul o f conl_i7
teclll "conll_xt" lhat wofdb_nguseclil
And #ould
thaib:
b_cattsc you didn't r_d
T M_ Cl_lsmlsdcilositlcmlnl_cnurciY
Do you r_lmilxT
m= ilkmll
9 /our_clll_cn+_rcr#
ofDi
I 0 I!p_ ng the reipor_
I ;kJmm_l
I l read tl cxmfidly or study it
12 A
7ou die quc_lon,
P=ldus'; _o_:ilQn_._d
I did _l
IllltCeyourwmd
foriI.
Mr
1.1 Hlil_r_
I._ Q
Yo_Hl_0r
16
I'#
M_.
tll Q
Hc tik_
HIOGIi, lS
19 t_llmony
_d w_
I w'u
21 Q
Anti
lbt'_ wil
C_bixIgiv¢
Isn'l li c_irc_t
o_lntn_l
bY 1_
i Iol of _culslon
dlsmctioni
b_tw_a
Naw,
_
3 ¢+W_4 c e f/xcfocmmB
4 opmlcm
m _ni_xt
5 Fh¢ undalmed
6
d_._u_n
th_ _nwe
do
yc_
Okay
_"
t_¢ word
llt
A
rcclL"d Rmct_on,
Q
im,_u_e
is mc_piblc
the _l
L_a_I w_
TW_ COURT
o_ _L
t_
I pJ_S
17 M_c_g_l
ifs
_._ued
Wi_a
T_C document
My m4_O_
TI_
ye_
imporl_ll
wh_
Io _ow
wi_
be wzt locking
Eai I_ml_c
a{t ct"t_e word "for" you ne_'¢a" coil_ld_lst
22
o_'thc ¢]_m tt_If
A
2J Mr
CoOk _t
Tow_cod
to _ctcrmm_
_J or _c_
I _m'_ t_t_k thl
pointed
bl Tolm_l,
and Crew _ _ell,
Dr
at du_
and Cr_,
whc_=
Ihc_
m the Pcm,_c_
i h U:_dly _e
5 Q
And when y_u _re _a/mnmg
I_ A
Conecc
9 Q
- cr_d i_
l0
to _rmum
II
A
out. 13u_ nobced _t
no* muctr.r_
cnwton
_Irk_an
H_rin8
I(YZW05
,tTee=tic _tr_ure.
my =i;_mml
do_
JA 0919
==ys.
dm trod=dined term m _
=or pcr_ut _¢t= to ¢_w_
I
cam_7
Com_
17 Q
And where you arc looking
you _dn
at the _
I sct_h
ix the r_zu_d¢_
clatrn chxrt,
any oth=" port_n of
of the clam fol smcttw:,
to you wh.tt the
rmg_l b=. I.s tt_t ¢_._e:¢1_
rm r o[ s_e I undc_st_d
wh_ yo= mere by =ct=
h_ alegtlme_.ams.
co_ned
wdhm the clam
lo per fore1 the f_lctmn
Markman
554
555
term only, oo_c¢1 -
16 A
23 samc_ent
Page
Page
Ihcse Icrms in thlt
you _ay thai ti'c r¢otcd
y_m - cx'c_e m= - mxbl= pou
wh_
dl be:=me
alum d_q
24 s_lcture
ti_ere are
lira It_¢L
a _p¢¢tfic tlructt_?
23 rm p.uetb=t
_M:
553
And so wh_m you ny m y=ur opmma tb=t a mm ==
22 A
w_s
Page
8 aRex the "for"
ye_. _r. t,_'s
21 s_'ac_e
pomos
10/Z7/D$
weal I t£sed _ my lcs_
no_ _ve_hm
2O raat _'_d, OF_:U that wouJd d abort=
of the clam9
berlitz,
Hearing
Wl_"t_L,1Jldln8 dt_ Lh¢ I I;thr_2¢d
w=s _¢ £m_<tlon. u_d d_li
19 that ¢l_Jm _
_s _l concci _at
my oth_
Cook to_cip me wk_ me
4 II w_
I_
yo= w=c look_n_ at the mz_icr cl_Jm clur_ _
21
24
_
11 attcr Lb¢ wind "for'
prcpa_xd by Tow_c_
m_m
sir [rchcdO_Mr
So it W_
12 Q
W_L_a 11¢_¢d_f_r¢_K
20
2.1 $_coJ_
tltl'i_
]
7 su_cturc, th _t*s the und=imcd
of
11 BY M]L HIGGINS
19 Q
_
done by Townscz_d, To_n_end
14 _ti
16
"r_l
clxlm _lar t, II -o k"vcrd Rm_
t_n_
ObjccL_orkYou_Honor
A
3 r_i
you#
I]
15
and
A_d t_e urtde_limr_$ of the lerm "for/t_tctxtre',
2
thai )o_r opm_n _ays t/'c
tbc doc_zro_l.
12 m_
il_l
00_55
t chum _Jmra_ts which have tmdmlmmg all_
B stmcroJ© bc_ B
ng _
COOK.
wclc tmd_lmcd,
Markillan
yo_'t¢ r_fcttm 5
word is_¢ Sl_U: Rue, and u'_._y_
thtL w_
cllum _
"for" WM bolde<._ xnd 01hci [l:l_ns wcil:
PageS52
Whcnyouwe_¢-
_
Aod l_s t; the pomon where cc_lun claim lcr'nl
22
co_=ct?
9A
ll
10/I7/05
ch_l
7 s_uc RL¢ -- _C undedincd
l0 Q
CC+V_L
25
of the r_.__'_c_m
lhc ,void "CC¢" _ the £mcaon
p_ fo_m_,
Hearing
sur+h _
on lee fom_l
iI _
- Fou_f_
24 c._r_c,'?
I_
when you
t_waz
claim
14 Q
21 TowngmdmdCmw
li_
Ilxal all o f Ihe pliCr_ w hcic y_ u
ofthe
op_oRs,
Cook. co_C'
thaL
Markma_l
2 Q
yoar W=lllraiaon ol'yo_
23 ih= w_
2_ Q
b_ politic.
* _xc,as_ i'n_ Pro fc_so r M _ enlll_l, in
htl
Cook abo_t oul or conmxi _d
I _
dim rely
'vlr
17 liah cl_
yo_
23 you :_m_mb_
24 A
m_y
13 A
20
Yri,
I lcllll
Now,
I CS_cn
for it
wlamMr
r_s
20.1,
22 Ca_lso_ _nd Mt
y_ui word
Tlilnk
yo= w¢,_a_cnt
IOQ
15 wcm tcicnilfil:d and _
may Ixppmach7
THE COURT
[ prcsin_
12 Io - ficqu c_dy to the mlst_
_ 15
_d
b_Cccrcyou
yolir Rule 12 siil_'ncnt _
9 A
II
Was Ibit your l_sw c'r lh_n7
I _on'l ha_e ti m ftcs_l o f me+ bul I ls_me
13 sm_otijUSlr_dtt
8 itibmll_
htvc
you
It vcr# quickly,
l_ll
_aJI
whm wc II_I mc and we took yew
6 dc!a¢ll_m_
I! Q
upen
dann8
Iv+_lookJng
for
e_cmcm w_uch w_a
.vlthm the cbarn et¢_=mL
Helnng
10/27/05
0¢t55S
0O357
] Q
AJ_dozdy the clam etc"e_at th_ ycmtwere ey..c,_tm_
2 +mp._ofdememC[
orK]
ofZocA
3 A
Corro:t
A_d _
5 A
WcP. of caun_, yot_ c;m_ re_d mW of these .+
3
m the rcr_er
was d'e t_l
7
of the cJzm al alrl
P to be In the _<JcubJ
9
"DI_ WITN_S
I0
_
rtot -
the who[© taJ+St._e of
IUI_
13 c2azm clemmnL ar+d apldy+np _
I _ s_m_ml
I .w_ Iook_
test _
a e._ h
tt_ $1_c_u2e recited thc/e _-t't'on'n
- is tl
[w_ttorcrama&amtonurkesmel_lb+ve
In Iookmp
_l amy p._c_t
Z3 IPe slrt_e
clatm ¢lemc_l m d¢:.-_mm_
thai ts underbned tn that clam
3 5o I _ppme
the corot
5
MR. HIC._INS
T_t
TH_
COURT
16
Q
Okay
10 tbe su_ral
He_rfng
IW27/05
Page
wa_
ldon'thavcmydcpc_loost.Mr
f_41n_ m8
in jult
HIGG[_S
_ aer.ond,
that o_
37
HIM3m
rll be bel:py
to d.tow iim 3_u
s_r
Quesu_n
2_
*'_C¢"{a _l_mammg
Andm_partofyouropm_on,
the won_
wbe_
you
thai appear
a_er the word
of nol tbe _e
Margmatt
I Q
Okay
2 A
Yes, aar
P Q
Ve_weP
perlorms
[0P.7/05
Hear_g
Page
557
Vmywell
_t I_
followu_
_ o_ pag_
"for" a_ pm a f
Rule i i Z/5 ._s
expba_d
to
Als_po_onofyouropuuon.
_'1
¢ f_
It's the prefened
erabo_ntenl
and
2A+ 2B?
MR_ RIGGINS
/_
in _
I beh_,e
exlabt|
TH_
COURT
Yeah,
9
_.
RIGGII_
R_L
II
_or
a ponton
o f flgun_ A ;rod
_.
tber_
20
THE COURT
book.
Ye_, set
Node A t_ r_l c_JLed o_t m tbe p,_Jent :it_l.
33
BY M_.
Q
In the o_pnal,
Ye_.
g._g¢ m
25
A
Yes. str
descmor
Zl
A
1_
thesd_don
_rcuJW
to be w_d_ng
as pat of
[_thatco_eet7
[ u-sad _t _JI part of my dr.=c_ptloa
He_rmg
Q
A.'_I parl of th:u was b_ed
2 _.sur_a_om,
2_
Marl_l_n
Th_t'sanomc2-_latumthallu_
An_ you reed thalnode A _s a Rer_ons_attonof 0ow
[0
23
oB page
No, tttsnot
o£ thai m m_
22 OpU_Ofl
HICGI2_3
iI _s
t¢
17 to _derto
fythata0oe.
I h._ e tbe t]_ttr_
24
I;Swe io
[4 Q
19 you wew
That's on a th fi'_
m _
13 A
16 A
P_c23
TI{E W[TS2S$
Now, tho - yo_ ae :©fem_
Q
13 I1_
1 ffdt_ ifs on 25, Is thtt wbet
PJGGINS
It's a pomorL
12 nc_= A. c_m_[7
you
I ofM_._l]
P
I_$ Q
19
bet
And the cou_t t_ as well?
1O BY M]t_ HIGG_qS
bergtvlrtgthtt_m.s'x¢17
of tbe re, on U'lat _
ong_d,
$owean:bethlo0k{ng_the.s.3J_c(hmg?
THE COURT
5 lk_te_.
18 y_u s_ad.
t_
M_
no, s_r, [ don't _ememb_
don't evrr co_de_
object_op.
d, but lql tato your wc_d
I"H_ COURT-
22
^
6
beginning
bt_a_ae
[ don_t r_n_ber
ZI
_rds
DoyOun=neml_rmeaskmpyoutl_uquesl_O_
24
w_s Ibe obj¢c0co_
Do_rcm_r,
I-_ g=t m I figure, figure
_
th_ lt._lg_cd
20
4
the woNs
la_g_qF:
memthrJw_y
17
"for" ¢_
dapos_d0n7
5_6
13 ii.
16
s_w tbe word
_ _Jtl
AI pa_e 71,1me
23 Q
Ovew.deth
And yot_ arm_er
Q
yo.
fe#owl_
7ZB
9 71. I dld not consld_
I,t
t_'_a_
I d.d r_l constant
22
BY MP.. HIGG_
12 A
af_
tho wonb
.Acm_y,
demenl+
w:ll need to p.de on _
V_gu_'_
II
t_ woad "rod' _ tbe dagn
19 Q
r_-_uon?
THE COURT
P Q
ot tbe _
I appl_rd
OO55p
slued
4
7
a/l_
yo_ wcru c_awanm&
IS A
whetber o¢nel
Mr Cook _t t]ud point r_._e.d a_ ob_ e_t cr_ wS_¢.
6
d_
21
Do I have
Markraan
2
Arid ev_3_w_
^
|
23 carr¢O
oo558
I d_c enme
the
_
dram elcmex¢, you
24 0ex'f<_'m_ the er_uIcstated ftr.cbcw
the
L7 d_nn8
Pl rtever ¢o+urdered dm waxds L_o_atpecr _0e*+ tbe weed ',los"
22 m thtt ex_mm:d
wu
as a_JJet._ed. and that's th= tat
14
19 ¢P.u a_d the ¢¢.rt h¢5 tt cluty
Z0
to consider
uad_'gm ed ;hid to [or_:der
that's r_md
16 d'¢:_
Q
fun:_on
13 p_
17 BY MR+ IJJGG1H$
I!
9
that _
12 "for', you thd .at _td:r
tbe fimcllam
*o pcsform t_e ¢_are _don
i_m wh_l he d_d m h_s
I applied the tt_t LS the taw
tO me. _d
_u'_¢ltUc Ltlat',Jcited _
II _mg=t
THEWS
Sunc
Well. he_ I_km8 - re_ srdthss or"
WITNESS
8
10Q
! 1 the cfaLm fop abxml_trc +)
14 rl:CJte- tl_
_
7 weS eXPlained
VC+, Your Hono¢
- smxch_
Yo_Honor
the document
TH_ COURT
6
COURT
Obpeuon,
before,
reporL Ovemdcd
'I_e Iz_stmSc tar the smL.'ture had
dement of the cla_
_
4 what the Cf_*umenl - hds _kmg
I t_¢d
'I'H_ COIJRT
12
M_.CO¢3K
2 obtectson
4 Q
6 t_
I
conecf;*
10:27/05
Page
558
A
SP[CE
'f+¢l, ttr
Markmao
JA 0920
upon yo.r
con_?
Hearln_
]4_Z'IIO+N
Page
55Y
C056,.3
I Q
TEe SPICE slmtdauor_
that y_
00_6l
I A
_1 w='c only o f the
No._r.
I dad ooc
2 ezrgtut, C_xa'c 2A and 2D, of the 066 p_u:nz, ¢.o¢n::C*
2 Q
3 A
TEar'S corral
3 yqun:_m_u=t._blemM_
4 Q
Du:lyoudoanySPICE=tmuhm_
5 _[_om_'anon
of Mr
Now_ at s_m_l
¢ recdI
Rapers
[ do mc_I
6 Q
6 you7
7 A
Nosn'IdJdno'.
a Q'
D_d you do any SPICE gtmufotzons of zny other
al _dp
I0 A
R¢lzbvcm
actually s¢¢_ _¢
9 sho_dd
o- i1 w=_ a &alk
10 $_=ncnt,
ltbthema]l
a_i
your Rule
12 _cm=_L
(able m Mr T_¢s.z'$ |t_leraent_
bul I was s¢_t a ckafl o( his
l -cad LL
i
rny study ofth_,_¢nt?
doyou
thaL
A_ L_¢ _m¢ yo_ subrmctr_
T bad you
9 d_c_
RMe t 2 st=t _mmt
_stat_nc-ca
t_;t?
A
m t_ cttc'mt G'talhad . w_ provtdcd to
I_acc= m vo_
II
tlu:tm_¢,Mr
IZ Q
II Q
Htf_m
That _u
a badqu_non,
t 3 W_h re_pe_ to y_
14 any o_¢r _PlCE
wasn'zlt9
_gageme_t
stm_ops
for t_
[
I_corma&_b¢_¢)_uact_dlysubn_tmi
12 yo_Rc4¢
I'm _md
12z 'mz=m=_l. youno_er
=FOEe_q_h
M_
ca=e, &d you do
14 A
at zl]_
15 A
No szr
15 Q
So you never cUd a SPICE slmuJatlon
No.r_.lm=tMr
_0¢ct_flr;l_n_ontlu_
15 _ofmyde_x_lm
thai would,
]
for
17 e_m_l_C.n-npfomcntaczrcmltazmord.anccwtthctazm6
Is
13 thai _?
19 A
All of my SPICE _amuhUons
19 slal_mt
wezc o f figux¢ 2A and
AadYo_l'H_
th_weuld_-
2O 2B
ZI
Q
And _
22 A
of znY pzmculzr ctexn of d'¢ '066 Pttc_r_
You sunula/¢ a ¢lret_t
22 h'l
| w=s slmt_atmg th=t
p_1 of V
And
tt IS one. two.
thr_
- Li's m 5A,
23 ezxemt
21 Q
And you pev_ atzemixed to ntzk" a :re:rut wzth
2S resp,ecz Io clam t; 9 IO or t I of the _
M=rkJnan
25
pateal dzd y_
FI_zrinl[
IQ/2"//05
Page
"II-_COI/_T
_hkcllsan_al_ll
M_rl_r_n
S60
Heart_
10/27/05
paee
561
O3563
00562
I
MR. HIC.'CrllqS
2
"rile COURT
P_,g¢I I
h Ub2tthe paraf, r_h
3 my Qpu'go_. m th_s _ ;:,_'_tIs m mp_rt
4 Mzcbtel
I"_'7
_
6 BYMR
? Q
$ _
ofa
th_ su_s
s_¢_at
"rnaf= on p*ge I I of the t_bb_l
I_GGINS
by
pomoe. 82
I
(_ught_)
2
M__ H]GGI_S
3 to pat_t
l=w3e_,
4
TH_
6
EIGGINS
mY" (cpOfl _
COU'RT
• bJ_nk ofhtS _teme:nt.
Mr
a ta_¢ of t:xam_les, yez: sta_e_e_!
Q
7 IVB
AI p_¢
THE
"_z
9
I_kew_se has a
5 your original
COURT
|0Q
Yes. t_ do_
11 a ]=ghRng Sy._tem t_l
your
H_o_,
_
13 "p_ca _'_ b_"
13 blank _ wdl7
14
"l_c..ECO URT
¥¢._th. hut tt w_
15 w-_s -e:M_a8 tl by _c.v_bo_.
fil]¢d =n when he
[ h_ve wrm_n m o_ _g=
7
l_ Q
Th_
I_e _t:d
19 Atse._r_
20 ta_¢
23
24 rind
n_nwhcn
pctmsyou_(um
]a _
21 any of t_= _
22 A
W3 TNF=q._
of ferreting
that w_¢
your op[n_
AI p18_ _ o f yoth" O_lll:d
All nRJ_
y_u_
Did you ev_ t'e.M
20
Q
22 Q
24
25
No, n_t_'__
Marlu_a
1-1earm 8
r_otlc_rl but
the word
sLtl_
f_L. LIlts L¢_n
the SPICE
sunula_o_
that
10/27/0_
I ne_
(o m_e
Rtrtherflitted
Thelastsc_¢cnc¢of_¢_ph._¢
say_, hrre Lh= ;_g_i
JA
192t
b=s bern ampE firA a=d
as par= ofthe ¢zrcmtssdecuon proee._
Now, I beh _'e we've ¢_afirmed
Mark.man
Pmge 562
sure dlat -
Fag:
IIIGGINS
VOTwd]
23 tatrd _b
wine Io
H0n_,
THE COURT
21 BY '_R
m Ibc table_
c_es?
TI4E_
Do_
being the_e, no
132 Ih=_ is h_lkmg aboul
19
You _d_l _ You d_n_
to pr_bcd
in the '066 p=amt, s=r_
15 Q
18 A
m Mr
No. sir
THE COURT
app¢_
[ don't re_alht
The_
y_
tht_cc.as_
u s¢_4Uv¢
17 you I1;v¢ do_c7
Sere= _s correct
hcre_lh_s_t
6. l tRm_
14 A
16 !_mon
16c£17
?N:e
12 m4c'n=ev¢ to noaprescn_oed morion.
your st_t=nco¢ h_ _
iq m
- Ihe apc_ung line says, L_ 066 pal=_t d_cnb_
corral?
I bel,cv_
- and _
stai_cnl
pat_nl-
BY MR. HIGGI]NS
I1
12 Q
A_d jucls_
ta_ng_oa_t_='_66
l0 blink,
A
It _t-g1_t:lfo ey _'¢ ordy lm Po rtlt[tt
Your Hoaor
5 BY MR H1GGrNS
Ve_ well
_.l _e - on tl_ _e-m_d hne, tl s_y$ on Page --
9 _
25
f_m_
that the wc_d
Hearta
8
10/27/0S
Pages63
005_
I "scJcc_on" does nol _
m [hc p_C_l, cotT_?
I patti
c_rthe I_lc Imtocy,
2 _ld_m¢l:
3 Q
^ncl
_¢n tt _x:_ c_ (o s._ zc_:noo
4 _cdc:_c_ltne_
too(ran. Now,
doc_'t
L:_:_s
3
for
_: ps_nt dJJm ludf
I bchcv¢ c:_o_ _e L_ _ds
7 Q
A_d Jo wh_, wo_d
_u
_¢
used, yeS. _r
Wotdd you _¢¢
mouoa_
I¢_ c_r_sw..
tt _
10Q
rm _ukb_
a b_)k up h_¢
r.;rn_
brochtua_
lesal _unotauom
I 0 r--'n_ n v_dor_
i_
for passive
xs wcl_
t2
1_o.
b_t I_s ml
14
scr_or_
_
of
provided
was F.xh_lt
by
_4 to
IthlrLk_ts$Saow
Thmu prockct
t3 to d_c '0_6 _.tcm
m_'a'_d
! bchcv_
II youtorigtmdstatcmc:nL
13 A
to Lhc'066 F_cnt?
['m_tt_,k_ttt¢,m*tua_t:d_L
And m your _tat¢*JaC_t, you rcf<: Io a num_
9 _to4t.ct
D_ M._scn_,
w_
7 pax of the _tc_L
$ Q
9 v_
cvtdcnra
u, tth me that De fcnc[an t.¢ ExMbtt
6 the word "evte_mc¢"
prcdctcrn.n_i
and cxtrautc
m those Jmma
4 _ I, D¢l'¢mLk. ts Cxmntt¢ _rtdca¢¢
S P.
6 A
not e._'damcd
brochu_ra
a_ *cP.
MP_ COOK
are cxtnmlc
_th
tt'_pcct
c_-tcct?
O_eca_,
tails for k_d
I$ cor, clmzou.
16
"]HE COURT
Sm:_m¢c[
17 BY MR. H1GGfi_S
I|
20 14-
YoJZ Hon_.
th_s _ m c_d_scc_lon
ofc]_m
el_nt
Q
Th¢_:
20
In the p_¢t',ff
NO. sir
_
tm:¢h_c_
A
22
23 Q
Dc_m_(.
24 tnmm¢
Do_ou
_mcmlx*_
cvtd_m¢_ md cxm_l¢
d_us_
cv Jd_e_
_boul
nnd I t,_:_
2¢
Hesrlng
lwouldrtotl_ow,
! ltav¢ thai.
$
Q
- Lhx:t¢ ts a sc_k'nc¢
4
ktscd
L_pon the facl thai thct_ arc _ v_t
$
con¢ol
6
l_¢tcrmln_d
corder,an,
pm s_:
object,
_t.ued
¢q cmdd
tome
Lhat a paton
17 Q
Okay
;tO A
Yc_
21
C._ttldMr
tr?
25
A
!l
cordlnon,
that werccttcd
I bc corrccl thlt4 you
*tthcr _
;',Io. 1 &d not.
h.nd _t p_t,
tlmit
_7 tff yore" P.u_ t2 _ta-ntmt
mVI.
A2-ther,
the pholc_:ll,
"on dim" to "on Might"
Ym_"
camd]_r".Srz_ofthat
tt ts important
to rt:co_ntzc
_ s_tch
Ik_ lam_ flora
_ sooB as the p S!_.Sdotal
my
12 cMmg¢ ut In fmrcd ntaJat_tm
¢tt_zLs
tJ
cotdd bc
A
14 _d
t_ dctr¢'u on of that
t$
woudcm't you7
Q
Wh_¢_eyounm_ng,
second pmagt _ob.
$_.ond
Mt
Ht_7
Ith0u#lyou
l don*t s¢¢ th_L
parzlp*_ph, und_/wab_c
nummd _ on pM¢
I_; 17?
18:ud IcP.
17 A
,Mr Ralxr_
_]r
l_ut Mr
_eC,l.S_
that wctt a;cn tloncd. Wou_
8 FIon(x
Da
Thu_
¥o_
1!
"I'HECOURT
19
MR
20
THT_ COUP."t
H1GG[NS
t;that_22_orm?
Go_eud.
IwamloJ_veDr
Ma_4cu_tll
It _ the pazalpaph t._tatstare _J
21 "atth LI_ p_ot0ceJ1. It Is Impotlam?
Evara?
Hcd_
24
wnttcn st,tit:mint, he had :,oru_ ofl_,c_
Q
Cmddyoudestt_andlmddt_h_cu'_'m_
Could
Pa_e_d_S
opu_o_ to _c
_
6 A
ofmcUon
- striX¢ thaL
th._'_ whu
19 Q
rc0m'Ing m yc_
3 their, tn Mr
o f wh_r.h would
sloUtd m the
agree that some ¢onffol
I $ fi:st pred_tcnmrtc:l
[ bcJt_¢
10t27/05
opwmnand
10 tim the ctrc..ut could be d_¢d
zmt t_nk to bc rcspom_vc
16 A
Hearing
Th_s
$ d_da't read any _fth_©
t'_
(hat
You _o,dd
14 d:mgncd
22A
patt_
"A'henyou wa¢
9 says. as _
you wOtdd zglt¢
Q
ofxmd
tl_at, std/
It
t3
- thts Is m
2 t_bl_ MMr
4 c_
_:my of _ fl'c:cnt
to motto,
fmcntm_mmostofw_uchwouldnoc
[ do _
12 e kcutm¢_
[havcnotrratdLhe
M_rlcman
I_
t r. rcxpot_d to d:ttcuon
¢]oted
10 A
Q
fl_at say'., my oWuon
ctrcuJu whxch could rcs]xmd
9
_ d'a:
_
At p=8_ I _ of yOL= c_b'm_J _ta:¢'rv_t
I O
A
pcrfo_'.dut
u¢ _t
Mr H_,g_r_
psge$64
I_ fo_c V -
2
8
psodma
00_7
00566
I _lt lest par4grlph
"; of a pert, on _
10r_7/0S
m the
Re
25Q
Marl_me
arc no( mmuoncd
the_
t3© hLS:Or_ of the pa:_-nt, at= th¢,fl
23 A
t r,_
btochmc_
a_
ZI Q
22A
plod_a
19 _tr_t,
_,ans¢o_l_ct_
Mark.malt
M__ I..aGG_$
24
THE
V/ITN'2B5
Yea
14o, your Honor
25 BY MP.. H1GGIN$
ycs.s_r
Hcarttlg
22
10/27/05
Mnrkamou
Prig©566
JA 0922
.qeJarlug
10/27/05
Page
S67
O0_.6Z
_69
I Q
[ h_
2 ho'_ ev_,
2 A
as wzth tic plzoicccQ, th_ _ not bow the ¢1¢¢mt
3 ofzhepa_cotwor_
4 _.zcz_
I goes _t/l
it local O,'HO _ay zl_-'r w h.tt I h ave i t_[ r ca,
d.
A_d_hcnyo_szy_eclzcm[ofdz¢
you an: _cfemn_
to _8m_
2A _d
2B ot'd'= '066
T_zl was Ihe _mt
7 Q
[mt_d
8 °m ¢bm" Io "_
5 Q
Y¢_
6 A
'l_t
do<_ no[ swlCh the I_¢np _m
brl_"
th_'_
shove
_
_ou
tc_d,
reth_
_ that _hat
I - ¢._. t_
7 _Z_cn
8 _md_c_7
un:_} abe chaoS© m mfr_©d
¢ot_u_
wh_
hav_ dccM--d ¢c_c_d
the ¢.u'¢tul
to whs_cr
Tamw'_-_ut
u _s _
howl',w_dd¢l'me
9 radmucn dctccJcd by _¢ piP. re.octccrt_n prescLccted
9 pzedct crmm¢_
|0 COndLrLo_ ForexampIc._c_tzo_
10
Q
H
W_J¢_cz'4"_pz_co_&_o_&"_dthet,_o_fpr_crm_eJ
IZ
coadR]o_
t3
_
TO _ _uc_ clan_ &re you rc fcr_ng_
11 d_z_¢_
1_
haw _
wbxch the¢lrcmt
c_rrc_po,_
¢o whz1_v_r _ _ _ey
Hew, do¢_ tic word "prc_dcclcd cc_dmon"
appear
A_
d_n't
Claim
In the c.l_
14
Q
S_x?
I _¢hcve th© pateat usca d_cword "prcdctcrr_ncd"
15
A
Andthcqumbon
16Q
And a_o" P.omm_ - ¢xcv_¢ me. A;_bl¢ numeral 3, the
I _ peed_t_rm_n e.d :onchlmn
l? _nlmce
_
bqp_.
onc_ _t _ uodc_tood
6, *_clf, J_l
Yes, sir
t9
[ [ does s_y, pr_d_',_Tm_"d
_ wha¢ you have just dc_cn'bc.d up
A
20 relauve
_h_ch the cttcmt
have deeded cc_es'pO_d to whzt_e_
*t _sthey
2[
22 Q
23 ?,
T':zat'_ correcL
2} defined
24 Q
And Io that _ w_l
you mc_l
a_d _at z_ how _
by Ix¢_zv_m_med
_,und_
Mzr_u
24
ofyoux opmtoo
|leanng
]0/27/05
Page
]
T_¢ szzteme_
4 Q
- z_
6 _h.zt _l says - a_t_w[b
7 of _bemv_uca
8 _ll_s_-_c
to
z_-_r_zzc_
_ _r¢ fcrrcd cmbc_ncnl
ttwall be _
_f t_e &sd
that vznanons
o._1 zp_r_zm,
mc[_
o f pz_s, he w_hm _¢ scope oC_
tl_
present
l _ laven_o_.
12
|3
Did _'_t p_'_e
you b.lve gz_
[4 A
fo_
z_
F_
o f y_m opm ons d_zt
zs p_rt cf ym_ t_s_zmcny m th_ c._c7
I_h_e_recfly_d_L
My_P_l_swzs
[_ on _
:h'o.zk Rfz[_m
t6
And you di_n t £_c_s _J _1 on vane.s
Q
19 o_'vc_
o f figx_c 2
oFlmcm _Zl y_z have rcnd_r_l
to _c cour_
20 co_:p
2J A
_o#t_ncw_[lwo_ds_y_Jt
22 minor
rno_fic._
23 aL_
- [ _khc
2_ buttbc_t_c
M_[I
wh_vo_
_m_ng
Heanng
thc
10/2.7/05
Page
569
Page
571
l[somebody;m_k'numl_dthec'._toft_c'_
p_Aerd wlth dtgltal comp_nmL_
l_st_
of_alog
_qmpon_
ti'tal the czrcmt _ct_d
ts
S_111- LS
•.
T_¢ c_rg_l _f 6g_c
6
Q
Ym
8
Q
You
9
_3_t._lly a_ oppof_d
I0
d_ff_'e_ll to a pergon
27
h.q txxn <bscIo_cd. m da._l for
F_xpos_
9 or mocbf_lzo_
Ne_,v Df
The
w r_d a_d _sk you _o coblenz
i _c'.d
_ also
Y_
.v'od d It be your opmlort
z_cu_ pm ferted C_t:_:L_C_
[ m j_lr_
7c_.
Markmaa
2
bcm8 mc_n
its¢]_ ¢o_rc_t _
568
_'/
L_rncmz_¢s_z_{gzvey_u_effght(l_cs
5 pa(¢zz; _Ts
yo_
ofa p_'s on or obJeCt
app,ltao_
ql the clam,
A
G057[
I Q
A
frcr_ _
con_uon
_
Axld t_e _ec_nd predetermined _ethtzc_
25 Q
OO$7O
2 c_h_p.n 7 Imps 3 thigh
t_ s_d first s_c_
sc!mraze
22 w Lth t0 dczc¢[, ¢crtcct_
25 _n&_o_,
_t
17 q_tmn7
what u mca_t by
[_ Q
21 d_Ign_'_
_sthc
dc freed in thectmm, _
19 pr_dcl_ncd
20 t_cr¢ as d_ p_'z_cJec_cd¢cn_oz'_
the fir_
zs - _ I ur,dc'_u_dlt,
I g prcdctcrmzzcd conthtxra, and wh_l yoa _e s_yzu8 about
¢o_d_m
define
ILselU
I$ A
[4 m d_: '366 _c_d
to
you're
4 _skm8 _
I z_zI_,z_L, yes. stf
L_¢ _rc_t
_"am I ¢on_:l
I _ that [ tleLteve prede[t*'mm_
3 th_ _tamaeat
$ patcz_. ¢or_ct2
6 _.
respect to that i_:t_
"V_
on - _r
11 A
The _rcua
12 Q
Weuld
thai the czrc_al o f fif_'m'e 2 _f doae
w_th ar_og
sk_ied
comp_nea'gs
woaldb¢chffr_e_
the operauon
Y¢_,s_"
_ f the c_r_mt ,,.ath digital
13
compon_llts
14
vl O,W.R _le s_'_e bY _ _-:.on
instead o f gn_log components
15
A
[do_tl_oww_yc_meanby
t6
Q
Wall,
17
wh_c_ w_
1_
apphed
t9
A
III tek¢ your word fo¢lL
20
Q
Ti_a.r_ y,ot_ Aad
skz[led
"oe h"mstole
in _
-
aRT
vlewedthestrae"
a Ixrson
codd
take the carrel
- d's new
b_m
I i yea_
f_- ong_aally
wouJd be
m the art _
or"figu_:
a_o when
L
the palent _
in 1994, co_t?
farce th_ eatlyg0_,co_tmmng:o
Forex_-,'al_e,a
_ v-_n_ z clr_mt, f_z cxzmpl¢,
d_.c_bedxt
tr_ _tym8
_s_
L._
324 op_p,_d
_co_'r_onZSlbe
Markmazz
Hz_rmg
22 w c_dn'l
_s_l
my
23
same
10/_05
Page
A
you agree
l would
w_i_ that _
alW¢c w_h
_k_l_
thaL
24 Q
So a _r_on
2_ codd
Lake the em:tt_l of fig2m 2A and b_atd a c_rcu_t _,
ra _c _ec_mc
Markmaa
570
JA 0923
g"_ a:_y
Hearing
10/27/05
0O572
performed
the
same
analog
componcn_ts,
A
That
Q
0O573
way
using
MR
Your
Allnght
then
Honor
Yes
first wtLh regard
heal ver_L_
motlon
II
mfrared
12
m front o£_e
13
that cause
14
A
Yes,
tl would
15
Q
And
would
16
II was
In mo[lon
17
A
Thal
would
18
Q
Do¢_
_¢
19
changes
20
A
21
mfrared
en_rg'l,
versus
ff you
chang_
Io the
an heal
had a statlone_
PIR and then
the PIR
to gwe
that
healed
or changes
object
it up
wzthout
and
rapidly,
regard
bo wzthoul
In m fr4red
h responds
reg,_d
just
sat lt
would
to whether
or not
radiation
to mo_lon
to mot;on
whlch
or to other types
to mollon
that causes
causes
as well
cbongc
TM
of
mthatlon
Q
Wghoulregardtov,
23
Now.
24
stal_ent
donng
25
Do you
Mr
have
your
hetherornottCs--v,
Hzgglos's
-- coup]e
patent
lthdraw
examtaatlon,
of $_temenis
he refc_ed
in column
in &oat
you
to a
g of the p_tenL
of you '_
{'vlarkman
Hearing
I0/2W05
Page
which
2 and which
are mounted
w_thm
are each rc_porL_w¢
Does
5 proce_mg
housing
22 behind
tO m frared hghl produced
the patent
then go on to d_cnbe
of the -- the szgnal emanating
7 A
Itdo_
Itd_cnb4_¢propaBatlonofthe
8 signal
through
the _ano_
ctrcult blocks
I see that
8 Q
Now,
lamp
the
is only turned
version
yon mentioned
of somethlilg
that that w_s
thdl was
A
Ida
Q
What
p0rhort
Of the
13
A
It w_
back
in cohtmn
14
said
15
the
16
that the second
17
mainly
about
18
bright
or off
And
sensing
19
Q
20
Io _
21
A
22
operation
23
figures
24
place
25
include
and
first
how
what
this
hght wtll
24.
convenllonal
palenl
you
referring
to t
I beheve
whal
respond,
p_slVe
going
ii says,
I have
and
ts talkmg
to accenl
or
refemng
]l descnbes
where
the c_rcult
of mutton
thai you were
3 where
I
describe
part appears
first pan
PIR sensol,_,
-- hne
two
in the
spccificallons
- th_s Is lane 24 -o I believe
o- nghl
a shorthand
and thscnmlnallon
Il was back m column
of the
were
3 -- wen,
in whzch
was the
if the
'_
part of the
the
and
said
'_
s31d elsewhere
patent
detecung
half
$ertlen¢¢
on at nlghl
Doyoaremembersaylngtha[
was thai the
6, at
mode
Doyouseethal
12
I Q
from
fur_er
the PIP,
thllowmg
And
11 A
I'm not sure [ undc_tand
concluding
with
12 Q
The pnxessmg
the
what?
the qu_tlon
of the signal through the v_ou._
13 blocks
wtth
the end r_ug
14 A
Well,
_
bemg _hat
far as thscnmmahng
that IS the security
16 because at node A there's
'7
the predetermined
c'vent, _t tennlrtates
a htgh or low
17 repregenL_ _c -° It has b¢c-'n detected,
at nodo A
ouzput that
the event
h_
been
18 detect ed or not dotecled
Whtch
processing
puritans
of the signal
h:,_h or low at noda
of the patent
from
text describe
A_'
22 A
It begtns about line 24 and then contmae_
Line 24 ofcol_mn
24
A
25
26 of column 4
the
the PIR all the way up to the
23
--
3•
0 f cohm_n 3, and it continues
Markman
up about
llearmg
through
line
10/27/05
[ncludtng
the
the circuit
of
the right
of figttres
infrared,
the -- jtlst shah
3 A
Right
4 Q
- stctton?
5 A
Rtght
6 Q
Including
7 A
Correct
8 Q
Now,
9
l0 Q
Q
the
bright
2A
_d
2B
PIR sensors
llearmg
Q I
10127/05
Page
573
of the manual
2 ovcmde-.
by
9 PIPs
21
113thai parag_dph,
II
Ic'ns 26
6 s_T,sols _
20
around
26 of colunm
Markman
3 source_; e._ctetnal Io the I_rnp
19 Q
to full
0O575
I and Q2,
15 motion,
hne
seasmg
572
0O574
4 Q
around
andQ2detectmollon
l0 ¢ayller
m
'_
P[R r_;pond
beginning
the motion
7 A
9
ISSue of
a signal '_
be
down
scnsorsQI
EXAMINATION
M_sengdl,
I0
Where
turning
colLgequenlly
Anyreth_"ct_
COOK
Dr
Ida
Q
questions,
REDIRECT
22
A
of
says.
COOK
7
BY MR
instead
is ix_sslble
I ha_ e no further
9 Q
componen[s
correct '_
THECOURT
8
thglu_]
Page
in front
the photocell
In the
ofyou
master
seetton
claim
chart -- do you
10
A
Ida
II
Q
-- were
12
rials, the language
13
A
Ido
14
Q
Was that language
15
recewe
16
your repor_ I
17
A
It w_
-- well,
18
patent,
which
1 had to bogm
19
these
elements,
20
recall
the -- I don't
21
Q
Did
22
your
23
A
Oh,
certainly
24
Q
And
dtd you
25
reporll
the -- you
JA 0924
thai
that language
you
see m the
chum
text pOrhon
of
there?
provided
to bogm
ofcout_e
I recetved
recall
rccctv¢
to you
working
-- when
I1 at some
d_d you
wzth and prepann$
thelanguagetsm
w*th
hal the
point
the
breaking
out of
but I don'l
the date
It in advance
of yottr
prepanng
report?
rely on that language
Markman
574
have
--
m prepanng
|learlng
your
10/27/05
Page
575
00576
I A
0057.7
I&+L
2 Q
I Q
AI_I dJd _C_I T¢_ 0n _al
IP_JPL_Je m ro_-l_nZ the
3 conclraSl_n tP_a'SmOo:ted m tbc fifth colm-m_ or _¢
4
cc_un_
0( _e
m3_
cL_
r
L
A_dQsapers_n_'I1edmlbe:m,m'nl_
2 _-
Imc.za._hav©aPb.D
$
_wm_d_rmct_y
chin?
5 A
A _solule_y
6 Q
Aed _c
9 Q
! h_vc no f_LfJ_'T qU_UO_,
LIlac _ut
_:l_,ons
_ _p_ho
A
6 mdcsc-/
±c
Q
L0
T_
CO L'RT
II
,MR I_IGG_S
Y_r
Any _*c_s
°
Briefing,
BY M]_ F_GG_$
t4
Q
15
you woe
16
n_t_rcl_m_
Dr M_D,
Yore
Ln r_por_cto
_Jluz_
_oa
_
t_c b_cu_
No Pu:_r
COOK
qu_uoP_
I_
b_o one ft_h_
_o z_k the g_,at m'ae, Yo_
I oc_leaed
11
_loeo_
R_DI_F_CT
qu_ lon
Hono_
EXAMINATION
NflL COOK
14 [cok OV_ on pa_c 2 al clcmem C 1, do ?cu scc the.7
Cooksq_toB,
u f th_ ct_'_u_
Youco_
Ve 7 _
MP_
10 t_
[hzv_or_cdm
Idtmk.*syou_cs_r_.c;_c_t_t',_o
9
Ho_r
12 BY
13
blc_:mcal{_m_g
t_t
m t_c
you_clfapc_onslu_ed
15 A
[do
16 Q
IDo yau
_e
Lh_ - tha#. thee
is underlined
langt_c
t'7 fol_o_ng the word "for=? "_¢ wcrd "for"_Bp_rl B_¢C :n
IS A
Y_,
19 Q
D_d yo_,
2O c_m
d_eat
11 t_
s_"
yo_n¢l
f, eve_ z;t_npt
of _ny ¢_m
to br_k
_e fore you r_:e_ved
_y
_c
m_qer
21 ¢_wn _ln_
2._ A
Br_ko_
Z3 the pz[cr4.
No
[ ao(lccd
Ik_ww_n[w_sfir._sm_'_nn_
th_ the clzu_
w_
_'r_g_
clmm elera_L
m _nd
A
Y_
2[
Q
Ckdyouco_dcr_hatlzngcmgcmee_tngyo_r
22
concision
_3
sufflocat
00.771
t Q
2 A
]_c
9
O
I0
A
th¢_
you ar_ rcf_n_
Thtl_tmdedmed
Markman
yeu I_vc
m mm_ when _ou
_
4
V_
H_q_yd_osa_oa_ow_Jayc_c
Y_
I _
probaMy )Lu_ bc_g
aol vcr/c_r_ftd
atKt bc_aB ptcc_c m my _cr
[uld_l meal (c_l h_c
14 just n_ _hmkmg _x_l
which
TRE
WITNb._$
ThE
COURT
6
Tile
9,'ITNE_S
7
10/2.7/0_
the _td
_
texl. _d
"_H]E COLrR T
Psge
$77
t8
m _y
clara de.eat oth_ tb_nj_
19
A
T_c_,x
hs
BusJclmc_voulo)u_kaJ
_t
_d
w_kircad
an_rlmcd
t_l _
tha_ in formmB
"rH_WTrNT'_S
14 d_cnmm_oo
18 p_oa'bcd
CI_
aOL TbaCsthconlyopc.
22 M,_'a_flL
23 _e_:_t_on
COL'RT
[ have oee qu_uoa,
D+d/oucommder
myo_pgen_
Z¢ wo_d _ m t_
dlsct_cn
_M_lmnOfQm&
Yes
If yot_ w'ax_ to c_d] _ thaL of_l
Aad th_'s _
T_ ff_ COU_T
10
"I'H_ WTTNF_S
ofthzL
Okay
Did I :x,sw_
you_ ques_on
24
and s_lcc_on
1O/ZW05
THECOLrRT
YcudJd
You&d
Doyouh_v¢
23 aay qu_L_oe.f_
DR
CARNAL
THECOURT
Youl_spo_edlohts
Hearing
goes through a pr oc¢_._of
[ cor_ _.._r to b_ d'*cevent, the
19
:_2
- mcolumn3or_c
M_rkmao
itdoes
_'cscLcOlon¢ltc_]PJta_th¢
wilt
_c_c
your op_m¢_
yo_tHonor
2, ap fxopna_el_
Dr
_str ,q_l_xn_ a._ardyc<a_[_e
zbo_ pr c_tcraaln_l
Ihe
e'_tm_
And thatlsp"_1o['the
pr_c_.
17 d_rnJn_$,
G_ word"for"
Io)_trzclf
_el] m= _f It contains _he word *select _ _d
: f you c_nslde_d
13 cont_n_bewo_l'scEcc("
qucsLmn
no
RLghL
_eb
12
[
T'eamk ye+
TH_
m
Rxghl
9 sc_sors Ql end QZ, ifyQu
II
cle_aly
[ _v_ probably
when [ answered
_,_b=c
21
_s
An4. I 0unk you amwc_d
16 o_t_uts of QI and Q2 and _m
_y
"prespied"
8 o01t_.n 3 m the m_ddlr_ the parzgr.ph tha_ bcp.m
10 p_r_r_ph
m my
bc_ze
I ¢onsld_cd,
_T Q
c_lly
lleanng
"['hen I._[t.f o1_ I b_ I E'_e yOU lllO W_"e :e;kt'd
L_ b'_s¢l_O10nc,rCul_
_
by ++_
3 d_d _hc word _5¢1ec1"appe.at m the p_L
_
about wh_c_ "or not Y_U strnpty co r..sid,_'wd
qt_on
thal _'oa dzeb_'lthink
2 St FIt_IL
++pan aftbe
_( th_ mlem_L
D_
I + camlflered +ill of the _lmed
20 Q
_0n7
lo _ pOwe_
_
576
I qu_uon
Yes,[_L
I I a._x_ ex _o'_
12
Psgc
the tc_t(cd
10 _nB
la_ua_c
CO._79
5 HIggwt¢
? A
10_7/05
Y=
s_nxre
4 O
that
as Iowhethc_ o¢not th_ cta_'n el¢¢_Cnl
r_clk'_
stRcauc
_$ AC voltz_c
He_nn_
Ina_c
_:r 1
_0
14 A
blarkm_n
Do you +ce the _deflm_d
19 fOllOWSth30
o_
Psge
NO ma'zm.
Okay
Canlgetane_nmalcab_u_
Marlunan
578
JA 0925
Hearing
1_27/05
PageS79
O058O
00581
I rebuttal
proof
and how
2
MR
H]GGINS
long st will
take?
YomHonor,
I that contmm
atfiltstrmc,
arc_c
2
3 going to take a t_cak for lunch?
4
THE COURT
5
MP_HIGGINS
and
Yes, yes, )cs,
wc arc
THECOURT
6 think thc*c _ ill be r cbutt,fl i_co f, bm may I ba_ c the hmch
6
MR.
7 hour
7
THECOURT
8
MR.
COOK
9
MR
THEUERKAUF
l0
THECOORT
It
MS
12
THE
COURT
MR
HIGGINS
Good
COURT
9
MR
HIGGINS
THE
YcL
you may
Thank
COURT
Imvc cfosmgs,
14
Okay
Okay,
And
then zftt v, tl)
bncf
vcty good
Well
All
nghL
We
come back at I 30
We
and we'll go fiom thc_¢
Vc_good.
15
(Brczk)
16
THECOURT
17
yott
proof, tt wzll be mcrclfolly
12 v, dl take an hour for hmch
13 wdl
Ibchc_cfl_t--Idont
to cons_dcT that?
THE
13
Wc'rcmrcccss
Sorryfo_thadclay
of file thsk,
15
to roam
16
for courtscl
17
p_omptly
Arewercady
14
fe* closings7
18
MP..
HIGGINS
19 cafls no rd_ff_
TIIE COURT
21
MR
I address
24
25
ofttm
Yore
Hoaor,
the ptamuff
18
ws_e_
20
22
Yes,
Okay
YourHottor.
of hovaekce'pmg
THE
COURT
MR
HIGGINS
bcforelbcg.n,
may
matters?
Okay
First, wtfil
d_mlraa_
thai occurred,
respect
we
l_|arkmaa
to file vtdeo
(to ha_¢
file d_k
Hearing
10H7/05
Page
Okay
Thatwlnbethcncxt
HIGGINS
I think it's 89
Okay,
89
I don't
have
phys=cal
MS
It's89
89, gr¢.at.
And
only
wtth respect
one
copy,
and
Io file phys)cal
so I request
of the vtdco
for file Court,
to file court
TItE
I ;how
Bnggs-Joneswdlknow
p_sesszon
and
m mdct
89 t; what
MITRAKOS
we have
Do_thatsoundngh_
the I_t
pcrm_lon
copy,
to return
make
topees
the ongmals
for flhng
COURT
Is filat all nghl
wlfil
you,
Mr
20
MP_ COOK
21
TttECOURT
22
gomg
to substitute
23
copy
of the vtdeo,
Yes.
tt t;
Okay,
8 copy
-
which
24
MR
HI(GINS
25
THE
COURT
filat'sfine
you
Soyouarc
a_e going
v, xll bc marked
to give
t_ a
Exhtblt
90?
_
Y_.ma'am
Okay
Markman
Hearing
10/27/05
mantptllale
it to your
Page
581
OO583
MR
the bmdct
arc
I assume
COOK
going
all the come
to be cop.mdored
cx_blts m
mtzodu_ed
I any
the corn1 or Dr
ttme
3
THE
COURT
they v, ¢_re coming
7
Yes,
I presumed
into evidence,
MR
COOK
MK.
HIGGINS
by sttpulatmn
_ma I correct
THE
thatc_
Y_,
filaF$ correct
5
There
9
cfosmg.
MR
arc
on dunng
7
acc_-pt _I smo
8
po_esston
I I
mtnr_lc
MR
HIGGINS
10
Okay
Foe ¢xzz'nple.
the ¢xmm)c,
TltE
14
Ice's make
15
mctudmg
I have
SUTC MS
Bnggs-lor_$
the filings
that have
MR-
HIGGINS
c,_anlhal_.e
matt_
as a rnait et of cvtdonce,
18
of Mr
Raper's
19
d_le*ed
my set. so
has a complete
_
And
17
cleposluon,
THE
21
MR-HIGGINS
THE
added,
one
that,
oka_
final housekeeping
wc have
the phymcaJ
of course,
COURT
You
mean
example
ts fully
Excmc
22me
23
THE
COURT
24
MR
HICK]INS
Okay
We wdl be suhfalttmg
I mox e for its ada33t_lon
Markman
aBd re_lpl
Hearing
gugh
that as an
that al
10,'2"//05
that'sthe pnma_
582
Andtfyouwon]d
and allow
¢o_et
m; to retain
I m_an,
COURT
What
we
What
doyouall
physical
com't,
to Dr
we'll mare
had a patent
I5
b¢¢.atme he had an tmorroous
16
things
*t
17
used
to ths$ kind
MR
Pa¢.$tretie
20
vtdco,
21
record
_a]
thaL
do aboutthescthmgs_
m h_e
a couple
of
I loanedmycourtroomtooneoftheofiletjudges
that went
19
do you think about
_ually
of filing.
and tbe mote
THE
COURT
23
DR
CARNAL
24
THE
devices
It w_
._o, I mere% you
do you
e_ photo_ph,
easdy
22
What
And
usually
huge
_ll ate
do7
MOSt of the ttme you use a
[[]GGINS
t_Xhlhlt such
I mean,
device.
on big trucks
COURT
and I wanted
flied
or m fills rage a
fac$.smtlc
ts put into the
Okay
Yore
Honot_
We arc dtscummg
what
yOU to he_" it, MS
Markmau
JA 0926
to the
at any .me,
week*ago
25 these
Page
evidence
e tt.
Of co_r_e
14
18
h_ d_lc¢'_
lmeandomomtraaon
Cook?
13
set,
on file "adeo
20
to mampulat
of s',_cb a thing
avatlablc
12 Mr
COURT
intend
the atoragc
HI(GINS
to opposing
II
dtstmctzon.
13
I don't
about
of tt so that It's avmlable
9 Carnal,
COLrRT
can
6 re:asonwemnd¢filemotlontodothevtdco
cc,"tam pot'lJtm:s o f fil4ml to w ht ch we w't fl ctmm_mt
TItE
COURT
4 I'm )us1 wondenng
Yes
8
l0
Camat
mto
evldm_?
_hsblt
as
will be what'_
580
OO582
16
that thai be
19 Cook'_
HIGGINS
a couple
suggest
3 evidence
which
8
v,c wo_d
I mo_ ¢ for its m_ndttCtlOn
5 exhfillt,
II
25
the video,
as evld_'u:¢
4
IO be any rebuttal
12
introduced
He_ring
to do about
Bnggs-/ones
10/27/05
Page
583
00584
I
MR
2 phyrucals
COOK
Orate oNc'_
into _ l_nce,
3 _afdcccpmg,
then
tetm'n
some'body
be
theTn to ¢Om_d
they have
00585
] _ o de',lcea
put
them
Io _gue
m the
THE
COURT
7
MR
COOK
You
Okay
But us_l]y
8 the r_cor&
cotmsel
9 something
for pm'p_c_
can a_ce
3
THE COURT
a box
THE COURT
II
DR
We
ha_ c an e×hlblt
room
We
can put them
m exhthtt
pho_grapha
or
of that
Why
5
MR
HIGGINS
6
THE
COURT
MR
to counsel
9
dellberal)on
I think
_oom
m
we do that_
Verywell
Yeah
retrain them
NiP.
don't
Is that atl nght_
COOK
8
I0
10
CLFRK
or something
7
thcn_ once they arc m
on l_Odw:mg
THF
4
]11_e'snotlme
6
'_
2
for
can stand up and wave
4 foth:raJ ctrcult m the 15 mmmes
5 ca_'_dcmons_thcm
"zOli_ Honor,
Wbunthkstso_et,
for safcko:pmg,
thafs
a good
H1GGINS
then
but dtmng
tde_
And the
final howekcepmg
Okay
CAP_AL
"_om Honor,
11 rnattet
rna_ I make
] 2 Rule
ts the ctrcu)t
that was on
12 statcmem,
we
page
IO of Mr
_ ill pro_ ide an enlarged
P.aper's
copy
for the
12 stz_8_tton9
13
T_IE
COURT
14
DR
15 togethc'r
on boa_s
3
S_c
CAJ_NA
L
You know,
some
of those
16 and things could
get ]c_t and _L
17 a iccord ofv,_
those
18
19 c_rcutt thag_m
20 ctrcu]l
21
w_e
be Ic_e
really
to wh_
2_
a _ag_ le
was on the
23
at this point.
24
c_dm_
l thlnk
TII_'S
Lha_ has its own problem5
a grca_ sugg_tton
matters,
I thmk
$o do you _mk
that _¢
B_ glVCn
w¢ probably
_ e can kec'p thee
Markman
can't do
dc_ )ces
zhc_e
llearmg
I0_27/05
Page
COOK
]6
wlthhtsbexwlththeexhthltmlt
THE
18
_ookmg
19
the propose
20
ne-.etdothal
MR
HIGGINS
cou_¢l,
thai has been
dfl:g_.c
6
May
_pr
may
g
be doing
9
.aby a_¢ we hereo
10
clanns
_ hen
,_ • pm up a shde
the Powe_
Pomt
de_lcez
COURT
23
_on't
Okay,
that's
my decision
ts -_ I know
your
fine
If you--
I am
at the end of Ioday
eycbrov,
s are going
so if
up
People
I'mdomglt,
purpo*e
ts for me to J_!
for proposes
need
of making
have
thts claim
these
consmictton,
I
them
24
MR
25
THECOURT
Dr
m _a
the
court SIalT
om
Pow_
HIGGINS
Verywcll
Okay
A]lnght
Plamtt_s
Itearmg
10/27/05
Page
585
wc'_¢
cffcmt
3
dusk
The
4
lamps
from
5
mght
of tbe
II
13
_
I wdl
ts the
a unaq_
ii many,
w hal t_ the Icchnology
_¢
16
mid con_'ul
secu_ly
to consl:me
many
we
T_:
mot;o_
;oImm_._lo_,mthlscasemoBon
21
lois
_
to produce
mm
I;unps on
m
thth¢c2_
m om p_c_ar
t uro.q _¢
lamps
exampl_
on
m respo_¢
Thecomlhasbea.rd
Io _hal
And m addmon,
the pre fer_ed
24
patent
25
um¢
mc]udc
ctrcml
turin
at
the
when
morton
clremt,
ts dclected
r¢_lar_
at
reoccurs
Io keep
the
the I_'aps
al
Tbemneronlymnesoutffnofurthe_mot)on_s
delected
Other
featur_
were menBoned
of the comm_cla[
12
fealur¢,thepulsecotmt
13
test'tmony
the
_rmbo_men{.
a t)mcr
a n_otton
product
as well
Io keep
ser_os-
m the
15
t_ggers
16
featm'e
device
the pulse
propose
contrul
Ibe manual
ov_mde
Tbe¢ourlh_he_rdmach
Zero
I8
wa_ ¢ form
19
knov,_
by people
20
control
the a_tl_tty
count
of pulse
m the pre feared
17
as the clatr_
_s
of the
'066
crossing
count
THE
ts to a_o)d
mnbothment
detect
Tins
to actuat c the lamp
22
a term you
23
prcfeffed
skdled
and
poeduces
because
a ramp
a ramp v,a_ cform
in the art as a _cful
of an clo:tron:c
COURT
false
in the commercial
way
is
to
clremt.
Let me make
s_e
I'm understanthng
- are
you using
24
word
was
u_lng
You
are usmg
mbod_ment
are
and
commerctaJ
o whatcvt_
Comme*ctat
embodtmem_
the second
-
on for a specified
25
Markrnan
embothm_t,
is
thai _s described
fl_e lamps
aboul
Tbe
21
23
to bright
so long as mouon
I4
product
mghmme
s_or
20
22
accent
And the txmer, the contlol
I ] cl_ctUl
t It
_cboofog_es
are knov, n, photocells
stmulat_
o f I_un'._
on only to acccnl
the contlol
[ar_s
m_onsetoapredctermtT'_dle_:lofhght
_
sensor
7 timer
9
the
of [he '066
o f the '066 patent
of L_o_
hghtmg
Pho_oceIls
19
motion
ts the c0nt_ul
turla the lamps
6
8 bright
lhss clewing
h_e
ts tbe co_ _ page
We ha_ ¢ a]] seen
And
of the '066 patent
'O66 _em
And tha_ of comse
! 2 patent.
featme
The photocell
opening
Point.
dunng
of coupe,
A key
2
]0
18
E_ansmayha_eesc_aped
We']lre_ell
all of the urnc
we began
pr_mlauon
And,
court.
and appreciate
and of I_
temcra_
s_l_-ncnL
the
tc_am
ot ed io thu; hc_amg
¢ of all the wlmess_
you
:t please
_ • _ cry much
_
7
17
Okay
lmtoldM_
Io announce
So ffth¢
22
1
3 Can_,
15
t_ o days
0O587
2
14
within
Markman
I citing?
5
COURT
MR
Cam;fl
584
(;0586
4
TItE
15
21
tl
THECOL_T
14
17
Ar_thenffanyofuswamstoth)anythmgwnka
recreafo
for Dr
l_.ave
In the _, cnt of thal
t o do _ ouM bo to l_r_lucc
whlch t5 accur_¢
la4_" wc wc_d
2.5
was pol
m)gh!
We _'t
componenL_
A s_mplt_ thing
the clrcmt
conncct]or_
COtWL for cotmsc]
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
MR
HIGGINS
Markman
586
JA
)927
Hearing
10/27/05
Page587
O0585
Bat _
2
Win. _]NS
) i"_'/i_t_c_
4 ducu_
3
Tb¢'J _¢ not mI_c_c_ole
:_d I _U
Iz d:|msmS
m
dill_ 1 8o
- Se_aaa
to pmvt_
as well _
a _mi_m
tl_ bcsl mode
_t_'_ptlon
Btu inI_p._ o f tim prc,qmv.d_bod_cnl
enabling
th:4_
porlmn of_c
ofth_
patroL
T_
o0mmc_ud
9 4a1_or_l_d
a:_u'no_
u L_ _¢¢ond pm
I 0 r_r© phys_ly
U wb_ Mr
0 f h_ dano_,-zoon,
l_r_e rnouea s_t
_o,
11 to'1_ on It z_'x_w_th d'¢ h_fogen bu,_
12 the cornmeal
rc_tl
d_e ¢ondil_m_ of p;_amblh1_,
.bhty
and noao6vlogsr,._s,
I l 19 of the f_T_
b_e
9
pn_'xd_
m_ormauon
I 0 _bl¢
w*fo the
w_ch
may mcl_
'_ond
lJ .s _
_e
14 e.aro_ig
)$
of cb_p_:'b';cdm_tmau;
i_,.
?
21 t_*_._nzd_
Y_
OfS_t]Oa
Honor, t*_ m_ olve_ ¢n
1 l_,p3ra_pJz
[ _nd p_x_z_h
ofa p_tem, mid dml'_ the _erm _
74 I;_e _r_le_
d_s_'_pt,e,_, Ihe d_wm_¢,
2
Hearing
"Fac ¢_am'_ o r _
pat _
z n_pmv©
t/t,_
20
ibota
21
TiUo3$
of h'_ p_¢ f_
_
4
_n'_ofpzlc_f_
5
of_e
_a_
cmbodamcaL% thin
h'IC_I]_$
f_
a laodacl
25
you are hmUm i _e d_l_d
u__ I_.lmie.aJ
"l'r_ COLTRT
tcrrn ofizl
s'p_
ficalmn?
II
wnJ_md_.,cnpt_aoftho
13
_
'_
x_
I d_sc_patm
d_t_ss_oa
$_n_n
t _4 of
_
Well. coald
>ca ;_t
gh_p_.ir_
aaswa
my
m the:palate*
dcsenptxon
If
to bern 8 a
Hearing
10/27/05
PaeeSS9
d'cb¢_t mode. P_cfcn-©d_bo<hm_t
6 _h_
m
r._cltt_
d_on
abom
w_fo I.Se pkr_¢
COURT"
"g'a¢sg, c_*Qcaao_
mvcn_c¢,
Okay,
mcJta_a
tl m¢Icd¢_
_Uca
II
d_¢
wdh O_e Or more chdm_.
o£th_ [nwndon.
tim _lmg
d_cl_'Rrl
MP._ 81C_li_
esw'¢_lyro-._r_glm
_=_p_on
How, i1'1 (he cbur_
1"a¢ _m:rgot_on
t 4 _nbod_mcm
L_elbd_CL
_
of z Fa/¢_t the4 defJm_t the
13 p_cf_,z_d m_bo<lm_-at u_ d_op_-nl,
of _1
tll_ mw_t
ma
is pal
|i ts _brely
oftho v._t¢o
IS t.v_
_
19
And tI_'s
thit prefom:d
dt_puon
p_JIthla for • !:_t
ofclmms
o f _c WefrJ'_d
bcc_,
R1CGnqS
22 I.q or _o _c
Oka_
_
ts d_aca_m_
The qx_a fic_.JOn
Hesrln_
IOF27/05
Page
_90
COURT
expI_n#d,
w_fo jt._ o_
n_©
_1frora fo© prior
of Sr._Jon 1 I2, d_
_dy c'_'_
dmlncdy
fo_ mvrntmn _
fi_omfo© prior
1 &_n_t me_
Marknmn
JA 0928
Io hzvea
paragon
th= F_:_t
24 & ITcre_l _P,_cmrd compon_J
_s - El h:_ aclu_ly
_
Matl_mao
foc llnsu._c
2_ points o_ and _cu}
what _as
p_._'_t,
emb_t_'_a.
_ Mr
21 clcm_mt m _hc d,_ma d_! d_tmgu_¢s
I"F_ COURT
eft_e
oon¢ of which L_- coRt_
Z0 pztc_ law_¢r_ er_ to _fme
Arglmthtsca_e_t
ZI ks a_ _¢IL
_s abel
of the
mventton, _d
1:_ nt_zzo e.x_lude. An_h_ fo=altmtfon':_lerot;_:_'c_a
-
Is fo_oncoltmm2._:_leddescnpi_on?
_.
2 of
the sp_:lfi_¢on
9 mven_On, dm b_t mode for _xrc_m _ OUL_
I&
t9
msomc
dc_._ pllon
Thea i f you look _J S_cuon 2 o f -- pu'_"_h
5 $¢¢_on I 12, II be_
A
disclo_t_c
thal ts rtqmnn 8 an ax_blmg
_l_t_
17 ¢12,_11- ,_I¢_
Z_ p_lml
or *.Se
t0 it also mdudcs d_ c._ms.
MR. HICGINS
Z_
ts
l¢_thon_hlto
Marlunan
4
I _v© rc_d _ lot of _
10
20
t12
_
o_"foc
_ou _gaxd somc
3 ¢._cs referred to as the d._'_l_l
as cxpr_cd
IwL.zlyouto_omt_om_mlhis_twba41sd'_
pII¢¢¢
OOUP.T
_8
what am the
Io th= mark c_lar._
_
I_
mode
rmb_t
*,_ _©3_vo.
qu_aon?
gpc_flca_mn_z_hraml
9
mvamo_
Th_'s
24
ItL_aota_yo_uldo_ul_nlythak
f'_almas
6 sp_'_ _ca_l
14
b_
d_c right _
b'ran_mapaI_nthold_
"I_
2. Sc¢ot_
12
n_t.
_md
Page
I ofS*¢u©n
_e
dcacnpuo_.
2-I
10/Z7/05
_et fop_
O0_PI
_590
I 6cscn_trn
8
an so Is
[xme.. fi_e b_sL rnod_ in a pal_l
mclades
_e ab._ncx
Marlunan
3
m _
In _e - et foot fo= p_af_¢d
_ad',_d_ t_tt'_
23 ;_ifica_oa
s_ll©d
- _t _*_= m_ the pre rc-m:d ca'nbo_m_m
19
_[_NS
dcscnpuoa
otu the mv_tt_ott
I$ _tailcd
20
novd_
wnttm
of paragraph
mu_l a_
bl a._ oftha
16 cxpr_.*xcd
if d_
¢onth_on
m_a_t
17 _ci_
19 ¢_c£z:z'xt_ar.b_
to t_¢
r.ame_
0¢
t_gm to make md t_¢ the in_ _'a_acn, lhcn th¢ w11tx_m
12
of or_ ¢_mm but not _c45s_mly
16 n _-1_ _J d_,-r_
_d
wc bad
If _c tavcn_¢n
z_l so forth* d_I _s
of foc _l_t
embodxmrat
I_
is called fo_
n*ay r_'_mbcr
bar $_un
9
? p,z4_P.L
p_em
Yoa
_tsct11_ 0n!l about t_¢ Inv¢_o_
8
*a
of foe mwa_*_on
for can ./m 6 th= rove.ha on cut.
Tac v*-attea _pdoa
_© ci_s_g
t reqm_:s
I IL pangaq_h
app_icam
to $_ you oft
Flear[ng
I0/2W05
Pale
$91
00593
00592
I track
I
2
3
MR
Honor
HIGGINS
Ha_e
No.
I sausficd
you
THE
5
MR. HIGGINS
And
clams
claims
different
7
fcalur_
$
9
Io
For
COURT
"/cs.
ddTcrcnt
example
o_ cmdc
_ hen
I'm talkmg
mcludc
patent
m Claims
13
only
prise
count
feature,
cmbudlmcnl
claimed
14
$
9
12 and
The
_
a property
zero
the pro fcrrcd
cross_ng
as a property
I $ those
claims
Nevertheless.
nghl
,Ahlch
manual
m Cla:m
bul ifs
12
is d_scnbcd
as pazl of
description,
m Clatms
9
arc claims
do not Include
dcscnptton
or dctaded
Andmthec_cofCthlms6
20
nghl
detect
embodiment
claimed
that's pRrl of the
m the detailed
17
l0 and I I
pulse
count
o_cmde
those
claims
and II's par1 of the proper ty nghl
22
patent
_c
pall
of the patent
that is granted
by the
omcc
23
The o_vner
24
¢_:cludc
25
oxe defined
of the 066
people
from
patcnl
makmg.
by .my one
h_
Rslng
the right
Or s¢llmg
to
dC_lCCS Ihal
claim
51arkman
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
it's a ve_
imporiant
poml
thev.mmllendcscnptlonoffo¢
3
which
patent
5
of the '066
b_
began
12
the cntffc
13
the claims
14
¢nhrc
Bul
the de_ ice
defined
by
_l_h
do
Raper
wc use when
_c
I mean
bufu
palcnt
do
6 is
and demonstrated
¢onstrucllon
wc _e
but _ e arc here
of the
in the
font Clann
Carnal
the clanns
patent
the pre fcr_cd
that _ as discussed
nc_,erlhclcss
thai Mr
to Dr
So _hat
II
description
patent
to the cou_1 and
here
to const_c
as _nformed
_ Wc
to mlerprcl
nol
or mfcrpret
by the contcxl
of Ihc
patcnl
And
16
palen_
17
dunng
lhc
o_cc
_ ahthtv
properly
of the
066
Issued
the paten_
patent
whether
the
_$ nol an _ss_e
this pail of the proceethng
"_our IIonor
19
shdcs
that
20
bc thscussmg
21
of the argumenL
22
happy
23
counsel
[ ha_ c color
I am gong
Io - thai
I v. as mttndmg
bul Ifll
to pass
them
and D_
eopLcs
of all o f the
1 ha_c
discussed
_o deh_cr
_ould
please
up to you
no_
and _dl
them
at the close
the coup.
I also
have
I'll be
copies
for
Carnal
24
THE COURT
25
MR
foff, h propony
rights
dttnng
And
9 ¢¢rlaln
namely
one,
I I zcmo crossmg
m dtffcrcnl
And
14
pro_eeubo{1
15
thfferenl
manttal
ha',c
delecl
and no manual
13
*S nol requLrcd
Well
HIGGINS
patent
Ihat mlghl
May
[ just
bc helpful
hand
it Io counsel
Ilearmg
_
10/27/05
Page
593
scope,
_
Mr
6
Patterson
to this shde,
thts
o_emdc
cerIaln
poise
and
count
and ccrtam
as v. hy
stralcgy
and allowance
that v, as _cd
of the
066
patent
Now.
_JI of the
17
arc enabled
18
12 _s the only
19
discussion
20
thai _ hen
21
about
22
description
by the
you
m thesc
v, nucn
claim
of pulse
because
fcat_
demcnptlon
tha_ includes
counl
in the ,.'.nticn
clreu]l
m the
13
Ic_ els in _esponse
set foflh
[4
dcscnplLon
so
you understand
explained
as pail of the wrltten
_ hat
it Is
o',emdc
othcrsdo
25
feaLW_
if yOu _dl
Nc_e_elcss
is fully
thscusscd
IMarkman
do not mcludc
manual
thcmanualo_emd¢
claims
had
20
motion
21
the lamps
description
The opcrallon
dcscraptlon
turns the lamps
is the
level
10/27/05
Page
And
24
and K only
dl ffcrcnl
pholoccll
of hght
thcPiR
Page
595
JA 0929
_cll
activity
iI detects
a
dusk Or nlghmmc
it'd.out,
abouL P[RS
In the
patent
fore
accent
then
the IlmCr potion
times
ofthc
_
to t_,o dl fferent
when
namely
as v,c
l_bcn
So long
Ihc control
_¢ha_c
dclect
C_TCUl[[lUgS
the control
,_ there
contmucs
ouI If Iherc s no furlher
_hileallofth_sc
Ill
the P[Rs
to bright
clrcutt
to bc mohon,
mollon
th_spa_t_cularcla_m
Markman
594
of
Thecon_rolclrCUltOpcr,lIes
sensor
e_ e._" time
No_
and
on to accent
as recited
rcstari_
go back
the opc_atton
an the x_ntten
thai
lots ofdLscusslon
23
th[ can
in thc wntlen
to sensing
the lamps
19
25
m thc _nttcn
Ilearmg
_nlIen
The mollon
22
of the specifieaUon
24
predetermmcd
18
and don't
The operalLon of the motLon sensor is fully
in the
The first scn_c
17 _o turn
Claim
is a
it's also
count
the photocell
16 $1mulatedhercLnlhecouri
claLms
there
explained
And
pulse
¢xplamcd
,:,$ die control
Cla, m 12
of the cla]rng
is fully
12
dLffercnl
count
photocell,
features
coun_
E_ en though
pulse
o f those
these
explained
]l's bccn
some
features
l I tamer _s fully
cxammc
SKmda_lv
The
ha_ c
15
therefore
o',cmdc
claims
clmn_
16
manual
[0
o_ emdc
the claiming
and
coum
t contam
9 dcscnpt:on
no pulse
speclilcatton
true o f poise
that don
cla]m_,
and certain
cla_lr,_ have
also
of cthln_
7 lalk about
g the
oFfoe
ts enabled
Thal's
tree
5 conlam
are seating
portion
claim
3
to
his te:gt]mony
ha',c
only
2 the
4
of the
so If l can reltum
claims
I dcscnptton
thai
¢latm
It S jUSl that the clatms
8
23
than
or detailed
Markman
066palcntorany
to any parllcul_r
7 discussed
1o appreciate
ts pall of the SPOCLfiCatlon
4 b¢ dLrcclcd
12
a lot different
II turns
that _as
00595
[ thank
2 thts
10
a de'_ice
592
00594
6
fl _as
m his demonstration
dcmonsffatcd
It's obvlo_tsly
embodiment
18
and
Raper
ol" course
tcchnofugy
Rapc_
6
15
but It s
10_ndllherc
do not include
21
I
Claim
l0
The
onl_
4
$ defined
5.7.
by Mr
oul that Mr
6
the manual
I through
the underlying
3
5
aboul
dlffcrcnl
13
prefcrTcd
19
yes
m the '066
ts contained
12
16
your
7 body
I I
15
at all
the coun_
4
6
dtdn't
No_,
2 demonstrated
Hearmg
10/'27/05
00596
Z ¢otttalm
OO597
less
than all o f the fcazmes
2 cmbo_mcnl,
3
v.orkmg
4
ofln_
it. nevertheless,
dcvlce;,
as Mr
is a complete
Patterson
w_
enlbothmenl
Icso lying,
the Imle
6
Lsacomplcte'_orklngd_.tc¢
7
anybody
8
,sn'l much
wahl
glzzno
thai Mr
Now,
to make something
of a m_zkel
for Mr
THECOURT
Raper
Ithc thai7
There
6 mistake
MR
13
I_f,
D,dl
I perhaps
object,
16
of a person
I'_
Now.
_ hy thai thin8
anybody
wahl Io do thal_
9
20
wahl
21
bo sold
dctecl
IO make
Io youngSlCXS
23
you teach people
24
mcd
25
dzlTcrcnl
to leach
of a mzrkcl
of Ra_o
how to make
people
_
And
clrcmt on Octob_
24
which,
so thai you gel two
th ffcxc'nt
_csul_s
25
case
Ilearmg
be
10127/05
Page
by the Supreme
nol
tl_
thud
5th m Oclobor 3rd,
I can'l
and apphcd the c_thna]
Markman
remembov
sin Io a I 12J6
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
597
OO599
I0, _ _dte
]
Paracutarly
at p_ge
2 shde.
a court ¢r_
by tmpOllZ_g
3
(L-'vzc¢ into the specific
4
cl_r_
5
cmbodmcr¢
6
meaning
for thclx
The co_
g_
tt on the
I paragraph,
ofa
2
be a wntu_
the
3
pt oc¢_._ o f making
of any wodcmg
4
and eXaCl t¢-_m_ as to enable
$
person
6
ii is mOSl nearly
_
9
a sp¢ctf]ca_o_
|0
mvc_non
II
which
12
the slx_ficauon
makes
13
the clm_s
cmbothn_ts
14
smct]y
fr(xn
only m a I_CnCS
desc_bes
or cvcn
than nathng
ts the czse,
wnncn
descnpuon,
specific
only
of couxse,
th© '_6
8 cafiTtr_
10
conclude
II
znd thslm¢lly
12
applicant
mtcr_
m the spcclficahon
for
to bc
13
chtnng Dg
[ _kcd
Mas_glll's
him if the language
17 jtlstbefofeth¢claa'r_w_rmpoflamtohlm
18 bid thai claim
o_ _
poruon
19
from the palclzt-holdcrs
20
mtcnd
21
desm'bed
22
claims
23
coex ICr_lve
to have
the claims
I b3_e
we've
already
talked
Markman
finally,
combination
ex_er_es
and
And
shall
13_rt icul_rly
mat_
pointing
which
I 12, p_agraph
mear_
so the p_nczpal
I ] 2. tbo first
6, about whmh
or per f_"nu
ng a specified
thal ha_ e b¢_
_
m incorporate
the ar_wo
23
IzJkcd about
25
We've
Page
598
JA 0930
p_u.mptlon
oul
the
Of SI3_tclur¢ rtl_f£n'_l O_ acts
112/5
2Z out oplnlorl,
24 paragraph
iI
by mveuat or fo_
applyto_llmc2azs
examples
terms,_[
from the lne feted
21 cmbothmcnllOmte_relthecl_softhc'066palen[
for the
to be strictly
10/27/O5
which
the same,
tboreof
zs it necc_ary
Ilearing
and _¢
talks abo_l a e]atm and a
thf recital
20
I 12.
clarets,
the _ubject
15
to whal w_
S¢clJon
- any
of with
says, the sp¢ofica_on
Sectt o_
pre_n3ladloyoulsdO_
about
key word
rcgaz'ds as his Inv_ll_
19
'(366 polar
now _
claiming
tborc ts much thscusszon,
And
the
con_pla_ed
paragraph
14
m supp_l
io make
w_th one or more
And
I8
thafs
and
ful}, clea% concise
invitation
The _cond
17
and the manner
it m such
-
conne¢[cd
thai they thd nol
and thd not imcnd
oft_
up on the screen
a slgnal
patCnl _cnds
Ix: resb3ctnd
m the sp¢ct flea.on
Now,
of _
and using
I _ fU_CIIOU Wll_[
7
He_t_lno,
m th_ _
and the cmbothm_t
of cohmm
mvcotloa
m the art to v,h_ch it per_n,s
OUl his
--
pazcn[ - uzdey.s
oftbo
forth tbo bc_t mode
9
crnbothr_'nt
thai tbo patentee
d_cnptlon
skilled
s_
IIw_II
ta[kmgaboultheWnltcndescrlplm_
of the
coe_te_swe
You may remember
whal
7 shall
e_ t_ when
crnbo_mcm
a tangle
with
clear
ofcmbothments
exampl_
a _t_y
desc_:s
cro_s -¢xan*ar tatzoll.
24
v.o_kmg
on to say m ,Vv'W, we do no_ import
8
15
ratbol
md_z
IzfllzL_llOll_ m[o U_ chains
m _e
caging
the ftmctlons
claims
7
25
l;m does not apply to
Io SlOp
596
0059S
We
The case that we talk about, 112/6, the federal
23
h could
',hal the _mal
shouJd ne_ cr know wh_
22
case
m the c]affn m ord¢_ Io Itmll such c]arm, wc
of two
clrcml
Markman
sin of patent const_coon
If once we boom IO mclnd¢ elements
outpm
the
the ongma]
The eardrum sm has bet'n descnbod
21
IO
Webehevethz_JldOeS
20 menllonc_
and could
betwee_
Thewnncnd_;cnpUon
And that _s quolm8
19 Co,,h'1 as saying
m cleclTomcs
a conbol
how to mamj
that
ha_e lalked aboul the carthnal
18
_ ho
ii could
v.orkm 8 mndxl
Markman
16
the thffcrence
Thal_stheftmctlon_dpurpo_ofthecla_ms
17 112/6c_cs
Io the co,Jit
for people
gl231_
_. ho axe interested
be a complete
is nol a_
does not dehmJI the nghl
t5
for th© cmd_
Shack
_]cctromc
thai a
bul
Thts_swhal
14
ts the motion
R_p¢_ broil and dcmonslxaznd
And II wo_ld
has to say abo_
13 exclude
condmon
think
go on the kzl porhOn
to l¢_zm how
Phl]hps
16 Tbor¢ vt as discussion
I can actually
m K a_arnazoo,
Masscn8111 thought
by the patcm office
we keep taIkln 8 abo_
12 part of the sp¢clficallon
a
or objccl
that Mr
11 couM
of the decision
And
II
paxaphrase,
would
dctcCl a leaf, but a leaf ts _J1
and the ftrSl prCdclcrmmcd
19
22
improperly
a qucsoon
And the -- it _ould
15
I B device
and Dr
8 issue here.
Idon'lthmklsaldthal
HIGGI_S
thd ask
why would
14
m Chicago,
10 thewnttcndcsc_ptzonandthecla_ms
I!
bul you
zs not at issue In
had been made, and th_s and that soil of thing,
7 the vahthty
probably
device
say thaC_
12
of the palcnl
We bozrd d_sc u.sslons about the Iawycr
5 and the lawyer
m_e
thccourlsaldv.bywould
Rapcr's
about we are here [o consume the
aa_t the vahdi[y
3 thls thing
the trolly
4
In addmon,
9
So we arc talking
2 elaine,
of a
emlo_
5
I0
]
of the pr e ferred
6 of Sectton
bcca_
II_
In
to both qU_llO_
what
I 12
the stazute
_ no
says
We do r ly._gmze
claim Icrr_
actually
Markman
Hearing
ThL_ ts
thal there L_a
use the word
10/27/05
Page
599
00600
I "means"
A ptt_ump_lon
ts rebutlab]e
Z the courl has bemd sufficient
3 skdlsd
4
And be behc.e
evulence
from
In the art that the pt_um_lon
Remember,
5 chums oul)
Phllhps
v.ho
2
arc
itself saul
fonctlon,
means p]us function
hmltanons
There
tssue m Phlfops
Now,
4
forexample
5
meaning
6
the b4DE,
7
7
No_,
we Imo_
8 prtsumptlon
ts r_t
thai the defendants
rebutted
contend
and, therefore,
I 0
ts thai the ptt_amllMion
I I rshUlled
because
the _latm
12 either
of t_ o rcosort$
]3
Ettbet
the term
14 mentioned
several
15 the Modem
17 Structure
terms
"co_es
of Elect/onlcs
Massengtll
Phdhps
No_.,
both parttes
22 taxi _ ¢ apply
23 Lxnguagc is '_ here a claim
Itself
¢lmms
thfforentl_.
2 here
is -- as m_hcated
_ hat's going
3 defoodants'
_d_m
on bath
c¢ as to what
The _ arJous
6
Dermack,
7
exmr_lc,
tho_
and
to a _cry
9
tmdcrslcod
Modern
maicnal
entffelv
Hearing
the
Page
10t27/05
saad
product
are
they
that's
You
brochmcL
external
is defined
the
10
true
all knob
is dclined
in
m the MDE.
a sensor
m
People
People
v. hat a control
ctremt
is
skilled
m
TIle sarnc thing
is
for switch
You
kno_,
m the
the
clmms
fact
12
icons
13
understanthng
of people
14
Now,
w e put other
15
out opening
16
to those
page_
Now,
the
t9
the
Linear
20
and
we also
ts added
not detracl
skilled
from
m the art
defimttons
brief,
to tht_c
the structu/al
In pages
and
we
7 and
_. ould refer
8 of
the cottrt
back
of ore hnef
what
structure,
that means
does
Markman
Ig
",_c say wtth
term itself
Technology
cite
Th_c
rcspCCl
to thts
wc Cite the Apex
ca_c,
wc
connote
case
cite CcllNet
we cite
Data
Systems,
MagneTck
cese_
22
"control
etrcult"
23
"reverter
means',
24
IXtsorts
25
structure,
sktlled
all say thai cerlam
or "clrctut"
terms
or _¢lrcult
hk¢
mcaiks" or
all of those
tcrots
are
m the arl to connote
even
with
the word
understood
by
struclurc
No
whether
matter
to be
"means"
l_larkman
2 cq not
of tic
llearmg
the court
Page
10/27/05
601
I 12/6 apphes
deczdes
mcara
ts defined
you sull ha'. c a lot of cor_st/xlctton
3 tmderstaod
that
4
ar e some levels
The_
because
5 fo_ ¢1 o f dlumtrtanon,
066
patent
They're
be if not thsrcga_dcd
to do
o f agreement
We
The first
the
7 that's
sclfd¢fined
8 okay,
the parties
9
Now,
rend
the ¢lmm
terms
Phtlhps
for the_
tetT_S m terms
secood I_. el of tllummat_on,
condmon
the
That ts one of the things
m the ¢latms
And
al_ of those
are
relegated
to the cotul
of what
tl_
6 second predetermined
case has
enur¢
of the enttre
agree
v. c suggest that when
that tl focus
the court does ds
on a clatm
at a trmc
And the
context
context
I 1 reason is becaose
of
of the words m Sage Prnducls,
12 says that where
the clarm rect I_
13 on to elaborat©
m the c_a_m
a funetton
where
tt
but then gces
the c_ttr© pat_tt
Now,
_e
also
behove
that the defendants'
proposed
lmprop_ly
words
14
cOn_tr_alon
m mmay
ways
imports
into
Nov,
v, e think
that
the master
claim
chart m_ ttes
the
15 mtscthe f because
15
what
600
the textbook
to the
should
read the clatm
13
14
Sensor
of F_ectromes
post.on
ts that most
a senso¢
low p,L.r$uas_ on point
And
I I You
12
in tbe art
Dict_or,ary
clrcutt
10 cortswact_on
I0
ts that sensor,
but then goes
the defendants'
m the shde,
that v, c say
at, is ex h'm.stc to the '066 patenL
5
8
9
OO603
I
No_,
well
m the ari know
21
OO6O2
I
first thing
ccrtamtermsmthepatentha_east/uctural
The k_
stnmture,
- to pet form
Pdarkman
4
skilled
17
to you Sage Products
qutt¢
function
- Phtlhps
sufficient
the claim
of
the fmlct_on
r¢c11¢_ a ftm¢llOn,
stractu/c
25 ot acts _ lthm
m
of tmderstaodmg
functional
_e cttmg
Sage Products
24 on to elaborate
and v. e
on to elaborate
only says
the
Contrul
8
I I
stn_¢ture _ for
as an exptesston
20 says only -- 112 ts on b pro-ely
21
Is
that _ as rccogmzed
or acts to pcxfotm
Remember,
to I 12"6
m the patent thai are defined
ancltor the claim _ts¢lfgocs
18 sufllclcaat strllctttrc
19
according
itself cormotcs structure,
Dleuona_
16 even by Dr
term
plus
all of the
be comtzued
out ¢ontcnuon
is not In means
thai the
9 terms thai u_¢ means must
Nov.
the claim
formal
3
is rshurted
agpl_, to purely frmeuor'2J
6 ,*as a 112'6
people
OO6O1
I recited
thai
It has everylhmg
all jumbled
and not m
clam',s
16 the context of a cl_Jm
16
UnUl
today,
the de fct',_bnts
wen:
s;t_ng
that
fi_t
17
17 prcdet ermmed
_oodmon
meant
morton
of a person
You remember
18 paultts
18 sought
were saying
Wall
20
21
we k_o_
THE
Mr
that they
COURT
you
wtthdarw
have
beat
that thts
Mr
Raper
Dr
dram down
on
that,
Htgglm
22
(Laaght_r)
23
MR
HIGGINS
"Dettmmrrcd
beforehand"
20
the claim sufflclcnl
21
the claim w_
23
is not
In D_
a fratl
Pulse cotmt
do_
_
appear
elaborated
shl¢
by the [¢mamder
to perform
m forming
Mass(mglll
andclatm
the entire
of
rCClled ftmctto_,
them
s approach,
l],aod
where
you pul kind of
©lcrnents from
¢ovsb-a¢
Claim
tbem that way,
9 and
tsolatod
tn any asserted
25
clatm
l_,|arkmao
being
salad of dl ffe_ent clzam
24 Clmml0
24 m the p;Ltent
stractme
morning
22
25
Carlson.
that they read tbe clzarix_ aod wine
to be detcctod
19 to determine
19
that Mr
or object
Hearing
10/2"//05
Page
from
the remmodcr
of the claim,
Marknmn
602
JA 0931
we think
that t_ not the
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
603
006O4
t right
way
to
OO6O5
apply
2
whatc
d
material,
4
the claim
7 and
goes
we'_ • heard
contentton
6 qttotc
itself
ProdocLs
became
on to elaborate
a case -- excuse
says
Dr
stffficle_t
talked
$ a proccs$
claim
Now,
what
been
12
t ea_Fang
aboul
only
t¢fers
¢lec_ontc_
funcuonally,
15
electrical
16
sense
here
whaTe
zt was
and thafs
engineers
becaase,
know
You
18
mohon
19
Now,
20
moron
can s_e¢
moron
wzth radar
the ¢lec_'onlc
are
IoCs of ways
can
21
with a pig
You can sense
an of these way_
of doing
be acc_nphshed
Tha same
thing
Yc.acanpowcltt
23
voltage
the funcuon
by a w_de
wtthhatterms
24
po_e'ttt_.lthstcpp_down_ohage
25
0riven
Youcanpov,
devtce
with
variety
a brake
driven
AOd.
co_tDJed
cases
_ut
7
sulk abom
8 CcllN_
w_
mv_tor
w_th the desired
functtons
m MS stateroom
result
And
In his
ways
to achlevc
by cleemcal
and
engmet_
componenu:
So nolwdhstanthng
control
the result
who
to accomphsh
develop
these
the OI c_sc that the defendants
c_e
Ig_e th_s on_
15
to elaborate
In the art what
16
sh'ucturai
an m formed per;on
and what
THE
skilled
COURT
Now,
19
casc_, don't
20
I don't
case
you think there
being
g_cn
YO_
for elect;onlcs
be some Case law on thaC_
would
YOu
I sure wlsh therewere
2d
we have
24
yes. those are ths_qclcourt cases, but m CelINct, the
25
termthalwascortsl_edwasctl'cmtmea_
yoa
Honor
know,
sor_
gzven
is
troy
HIC_INS
law,
al]owed
ffthat rcalb, were the case
thatthere was kind ofa spacml cxccpoon
MR
to
be
ts not
18
recall
I gubmtt
22
dewce
Page
talk about
C_Ison
funct:onally
c=:cmts
21
10/27/05
Mr
begins
should
of clrcmts
Youcan
But the case
CcllNct
604
and we
have
law
that we have,
glv _'n you Magm
Tech,
/nMa_l-Tech,
Markman
v,e
have
meal_
t f a term ts structmal.
of that posttlon
ocale
I f ,t's startle,
6
_
tbe testunony
Ileanng
C:rcmt
;cs sU'_:Ru
mea_
calls out that semots
t_t_zrnptmnzs
3
thrce
And
4
the way
And
the only
that.
skilled
II
SO wl'at
predetermmedconchuon
13
bere
14
sel f_ermed
15
object
hacause
17
relative
THE
the meamng
19
M_
ngam,
al to an elecmcal
12
5
that - you
m tha art. me
7
eng0neer
_s the f'nst
10/27/05
Page
605
m said sensor
COURT
where
ts motion
m the Claim Jtse[ f. mot]o_
s_
we
are
of a _
or
s_Jd apparatus
1 thndc you arc m agrecme_l on
the f.¢r_df
Apparently
L%y_U know.
has Io I_ve
22
wheth_
23
for IIto detccl moOoR
Ag._ n, I will
par¢cularly
l0
motion
we
are now
sugg_l
the art read the palem
the senso_
$ch_tton
to you
because
aod see that tl calls
Markman
mcarts
clrcmtly
thai people
and
m order
detect
out there.
a swtmmmg
read the
Claim
abom
thc PIR sense
language
6, Claim
exactS,
motlo_n.
a questllm
would
moOon
3 descnhas
But [
pool
it. yes.
or body
tt would
of the clam_
6jusl
says
that 11detects
Itdocs:n'lsaythaltthastocaclodeallother
So thc fact
13
beatcd
14
there.
I_e
15
gensc
the beat
16
also dewct
In the '066
sk;lled
m
10/27/05
devtce
20
pool
21
person
beatm8
Page
606
Cl_um
up to the hlghar
or an object,
MR
23
portion
24
word_comlm_ng"
25
d_cu_mg
that
6, you
level
tfyou
out
vail,
pool,
bot it wall
wmt
the
wouldn't
want
o f dlummatton
not the pomL
Thai
=s written
thts
upon
It's to detect
ts cone¢l
and open
the
a
But the
ended,
YoumayremcmberMr
And thai meaRs
MarPanan
JA 0932
read,
_md ttmt's nelthra
HIGGINS
of the clmm
It may
But you wo,21do't
even
'I'hafs
and yOU
act accordingly
COURT
up7
pool
$c_x_or hght detector
off the swtmmtng
and
of th_s -
to go
a swimming
a morton
patent,
commg
motion
THE
19
that If you had
at ttp tmd you had
22
ota that the
Heanng
m column
a heal slg_aturc
up,
But if you
9
18 descnpt_on
HIGGINS
']'be h_g _sue
of wate:r heated
17
of thai
20 that today w'asdaopped.
21
- you asked
12
- fl's
from
there's
tlm_,andot
QI and Q2 detccl
I I events
I'm not sure exactly
thai the t_m
the patent
thai a PIR does
yes,
6 wtll
not I 12/6, becau._e
w e ha_ e 1emamm8
we say
ttmex
8
reverter
nmethffer_nt
pan_ctdatly
0xal _ha
o f those
arescnsocs
2
again.st that _'voc_
tfs smtcture
fotmd
I QI andQ2
R is
and Magm-Te_h
9
2.5
a
thfferem
the corn1 that the w ord "acts" cert_nly
a ctrcmt
Ileanng
]ldo_n'lmattcru.he'Lher
4 for _n _
5
w_
you know,
3 s_ucmrdl
24
many
OO607
the term thai
2
18
of com_ol,
Sg'OSOf $1[UatlOr h he c_dlcd I[ baglg, bang
17
Youc._nhaveacurrem
of a voltage
agree
]4
beam
00606
10
II
-
Youcanpowerltw_thAC
Markman
I
control
to
er=t_lthsteplwdupvoltage
instead
functmn
he wd]
can _mplement
rely on. m an clecmcal
of sensing
poweang
h_s -- I donk
c._ eYtglneers
13
You can set_qe
motion
zs Wae about
22
are done
o f yea_.
rim[ion
17
9
10
who has
are &'a Red
thai there
sine.
And al] of the th fferenl
12
t mean,
heard
70CCUp_._cy
ts an
foi" a nmnber
c/a2ms
the
that he always
law school
that ¢tectromc
tesuJt,
You
claims,
Pattea_on
pater_ts
that at Vande_bdt
14
Products
8
about
rm
that the ele¢_
ways
to inocess
Andyouhaveheai'dMt
He says
tbe
the OI case.
we are talking
practicing
Carnal,
with me
al iss_
IO elcOJ_nl_¢_se
It
me,
that acts m the Sage
they pro_ tried us wTth a case
13
Products
desired
by the defendants
thai we
9
Sage
SWdCRUe 0_ acts
Now,
5
Sage
h has the
Patterson
that _1 can detect
Hearing
more
10/27/05
Page
607
(33609
0060g
I than the e_ em thalIscontamed
2
And
3 Mi
m the clarets
tornak¢ a v+orkmg model
!
3 marketable model
5 worklng
9 commg
10
embodiment
in Ma_kntan
6
on
first
predelermmed
13 conthtlon bemg
conthtlon,stud firstpredelermlned
mot)on of a person or object Telalt_e to the
And, you Imow, v,here I reall) feelI'm ha_mg
16 faJlme toconmaunlcate
tsthe chfference bet_ een a
17 com3rnerclalembothment
9
firsl
l0
figure
andaclalm
Tbeclalmltself
you
the
2A and
Now,
12
there's
13
in fra_ed
14
abstracl
PIP.
I?
caJled,
can
Those
piP.s,
Ig
19 emb<ulrmenL
19
thee
20
20
persc_and:_o_af<_l
accordrng io thatclalm, for exaruple,the hrtlegizmo m
21
a Ix'rson.
22
tbe box here, Ifyou put thalup by the s_.immlng
22
The scasmg
23 probably would flutterallthe tlme because ilv,ould he
23
_hen
24 di_te_tmg lotsofexems
24
Now,
25
25
tl's coupled
pool it
Bul one of the e-.ent_v+ould cetlamly be motlon
Markman
llearlng
10,'27/05
Page
PIRs are
mo'aoa
ts tcacthng
o_e,
4
a control
crtcmt
of ,_ bach all of these
5
toclu_ng
pulse
corral,
6
fullhe_
7
beforehand
sc-_soi_,
that
number
_ takmg
elements
that
c.on_uon,
to deice[
corOt,on
bemg
tt t ur_.$ cut
!2
em_
13
drtect_r
14
the way,
radar de[eclo_
15
detectors
detect
there
ts
3 your
are a pan,
4 by
and
5
mgn_
6
The c]_m
g
pred_crmmed
9
a fi_l
rnot_oa
thai m thss orcull
1hat the scasor
_s a PIR
m this
but ,t could
be a radar
Youknov*,rad_dete_c_sdet_lmouon
| d_3_
- yc_t know.
the
porllon
of
QI and
o f that
the gource,
as it's
of the device
of a sertsor
sr:_
II _s nol all of
st_e
thai i; only
has an outpul
it IS dor_
itself
says
a
artd not a legf
The outpUl
to a det¢ClOr poruon,
_R_¢s
_a:ulno_
a parson
by the PIR
the pate_l
in the
thai the outpUl
or thalllon_yscnsesa
ts done
passive
as stated
that's
of the PIR
-
sc_smg
that ICs connected
-
43
no[
of the clreuth
Hearing
of [bu World
Ig
these
19
imme_z2gly
Series,
20
Is. 97 n_'le_ _m _
21
an he_-,
days,
whim
_md thai
h,w¢ had
pllch¢lr
-- 1 ca_l
_
th_
£ the
mlagme
Itts
slx'_Lbult_no_r_tlyv.haHtsmeasm3ng
24
In_,SI_II_
25
the _
a _bulCa]
IT_h_f
m_gna_ pmgs
IOFL7/0S
Page
609
around
it gc_,
m0_¢ time thal
the
techmcully
od_ncl_
is _unng
not what
I0
thai the sensor
II
revolvmg
12
convertmg
IS happening
Is counlmg
m frared
rathaoon/rat,
m_
way
17 talk
abeut
18 you
g ant to detect
Tha(s
20
And
21
ov_-techmcal
Is m*c for a PIR
dete_ts
LW/leir tel d_Tll be t31/e['n
the de R-e,dants
are
m their
all of this gcop
24
gc[ the pred©lermmed
10/27/05
Well,
that's
Mr
motion,
what poopl¢
23
25
you
to be mcluded
JA 0933
m tncld_'rt [ -you heard
talk about
Mr
Raper
th thai if
m the art m,_etst:md
the co_n
defimt_on
a **_
skilled
use a PIP.
skd[cd
_skmg
People
if--
Carlson
to be so
of sensor
they
IeChnlcul Ierm
m the sensor
beforehand
not in the claim
Markman
Page610
ts
it Is
Y_s.
cha_g_;
you know,
th you heard
22 of this goop _ that's_
ffs
and
IS
v, heel
thai to sp_ed.
Tbe same
19
thal'$
Is happenmg
tLrneS the
mcldrnt,
16
fast the pitch
I_t
Whal
hme
IS sensed
thai to speed-
how m_.rty
irt a particular
And the
dewcc
.six.cal.
thai tt really
any
and atotmd
magnetic
a stat_oneq+obTect,and ,I converts
yore-
m
thatlsdone
wheels
and arotmd
It's tn_
iltsmeast_nng
tteartng
on ot_c o f your
And it goes
ts detectmg
the speedometer
yotlknOw,
I_
out and a tetras
Marl<man
sen.sot
actually,
mtheartunde_smndthalarcaPlRdetecugmot,on
b_[I to the plate,
What
IS _
or the odometer,
a magnetic
gun
Strmtarly,
14
Io watch
that -- c_ 78
that a radar
radix
fan o_ not, b_
ho_
car
fasler
undcrstand
13
done by a rada_ gtm
23
the radar
[hto_
It pops on the sc_ren
r_ul.'_tsamei_or
_
know
a c_ance
If you axe a b_scpa]l
_
up -
Wdl,
_¢
people
lt'smeasunngspet-d
Andby
spr.ed.
IChOr. i f yon
17
22
molion
IO make
or Ihal II only
But
speed_
7 by
the sevaof
s_t
NOW,
16
2
motion
Qt'lly tequm_
I1
n_nber
iv, o, that
WcIJ, th_ c J_ m d+L_'sn'l l'CqUlre _aL
9
de fenders
con_ cntlonal
Markman
tt Into _hat thay callthe predetermmed
refinmg
10
oulput
_bmcemen_
the PIR
I
the patent
3
g
by the
for deieclmg
OO611
And so m comcxt,
that
mierpretahon
so I'll mo;e
ber¢, there's
the
confirmed
608
OO610
I of the set.or
2
my laser
the PIR.
iI ts the outpui
21
Ilono_.
and
_s all of this
the S there,
or that IS the
other
me_'ts
for detecting
18 read the clall_ _ ou don I ha_ • to ha_ e a cotnmerclal
h raa_ be true thalthe --I dc_ +ce made I_eczsel)
poml
arc
M,issenglll
or beth
And
w_th the
the conlenlIon
conthuon
sensors,
Dr
16
mqm_'
first s_tsor
Your
ir,qm I_ and rnixmg
2B
Ill
Q2
I suggesl
proceedmgs
stall ga_e
predetermined
15
a
_c
thai the sensor
II
ItjUslsa)sthalltdctecLsa
14 device
15
Now,
8
thalde_ ice v_otk
Bul the clazm itselfdoes not requi_ethalthe
II d_ic¢onlydetcctmotlon
12
commercial
thatis
here.
the m frlngerm:nl
thai is al issue
7
the clmm
domg
the
pool heal as v+ell as motion
from the pool and v+ould make
we're
5
In thalSl0Jatlon,el¢cOacalenglnecls would
8 figure OUt a way [o block out the mfrared en_gv
IO satisfy
_hal
4
not _ ant a
devlc¢+you may no_ v,'Z_ltosellone thaiv+ould be
6 respor_iv¢ top¢.'llnm
mg
7
you may
Nov.,
3 is that we at_ mlxLng
Ralx+ thscus,tedthe thfferencc betv,een markelmg
4 objc_tl_¢$ and techmcal objectl__
And thal'S enough
2
want all
They
Want
so thai they
mo(toa
And
It's contra_
Hearmg
10/27/05
Page
611
00612
006[3
] tO _¢
03¢3teXl of_
patCnL
2 ki10w
Gl_lla PIP, _[¢cts
people
InOllOtl
skilled
m the art
YOU _¢
I v, hafs
a Pi[R lo _[_t
3 mot10_
4
It would
The
be a httle btl hkc going
5
play
6
Chicago
7
is a_ o_fn ffig ,fJ;ell e in Chicago
8
into a wedge
9
fi_st um¢
-- ] don't
And
l0
wt'_¢
12
£tan0_ang
full
And
me av.ay
15
hke after I saw
16
had
- who
17
w'_
the best
] saw
danctng
that's - t._l
21
being
25
infrared
all of the dancers
ts very
low
get
at the end
of'he
wedge
(mdlcales)
And
ttjt_t
and I say.
be
back
to me and r,atd,
that _.as choreog_phy
of a_um_tll
You
thai ] $ubtml
that the PIR dett_ts
motion
lteatL_themsemoetoverar_o..et
oh. no. tt*s only
deterring
but people
skilled
return
going
enm 8
MR
HIGGINS
THE
COURT
21
MR
HIGGINS
22
THE
COURT
MR
HIGGIN$
23
thaPs
10/27/05
video
that you saw,
25
Page
of
we said
bul we will reach
evenm&
stay
19
m the ml know
this
18
20
and
the
two hour
say thaL
ta stay
to stay this evening.
this _
you one
if you both make
ts prepared
24
that
in context
m the midge
back at my ruder,
so let me just
We're
the rolt*
up to two horns,
know.
I hope
everyone
The corn1 is _tpartxl
Very
well,
You*
Honor.
to
so not¢_
But not tmuI 9 00, I hope
As we as wall
Okay
I would
_fyou
THECOURT
vnll
s_gg_l
to you thai the
--
Id_dn'tseeavldeo
612
Markman
00614
Isawa
Heanng
10/27/05
Page
613
OO615
I h_ c dcmor6traUon.
2
MR.
ffyoell
I porttonoutofQI
HIGGINS
perma
me
Exct_e
me.
a bye
dcmoratraaon.
foe a seconcL
4
5
(V,_
6
{A second
7 co_asel
)
8
_n8
wdeo
THECOURT
9
really
10
Ume
don't
= played
by c_¢1
ru:on_g
ts #ayed
th_s again,
12
(Video
13
MR
HIGGINS
Now,
_
d_ f,_rl_¢d
the e_'mt
tt_ltt'_.
16
R_p_s
And
HIGGINS
hlfle
I have
I_'.o
20
statement and dmmg
1
yore
Honor
Dr
paulus
-- _Ct_SI: me,
gave
h_s
the d_'vlc¢
diagram
of Mx
Rapes
devtce
Patth_'s
has tesomony
thing
that
I wo_ld
point
the respouse
3
demonstrating
4
cmcutL
oul ts
the selectton
7
_ really
the ttraer,
23
feeding
and
_te switch,
- the omp_
so 0tat the s_
of the t.enson
Markman
ts _mla_
Ilearlng
are
to the S
10/27/05
Page
614
portion
of the control
that the semo_
that's
ctrcultt_
happoamg
yes,
tm_t
fm the court
that Dr
Mas_mgfll
And.
take thts otaput
tt's W._ thai there
I0
t_pon._s
II
you'renolgomgtodetectaswtrrm_mspoo!
12
done
13
t_e Lamp
of the semot
in the reslmme
SO v*hal we
thee
16
evt_
17
_tnmtmal
18
Contro_
crmull,
19
meara
re_]3om_ve
20
of the clmm
21
electrical
though
clrctut
they _ve
ser_ot,
m fotr_
swttch,
ptoduo_
the outpm
be _omg
lo
o f the tenm
q';_ex_"
arc
hght
the structure
_
to
aml we say m_l
m II_m.
art
Sensing
a_ Sage
mc2r_,
Products
tlmt ts d_mg
even
_ys.
the rt_t
that
fimctlon
So we lcok
and
al c,_es
23
Cei]Net
24
that may
be enough,
25
"c.ont_ol
ctrcmt',
hke
Magm-To:h
and we
espe¢_ly
Linear
Tedmolosy,
If the Itam connotes
say espeeudly
for terms
Markman
JA 0934
a leaf or
in the electrom_
to b¢cat_e,
to
&ff_ent
W detect
should
terms,
t.kd]ed
about
ctro._]L
Bmthat's_d]
the word
to a p(rson
ts that
are ]o1_ of ways
whtch
say Ihe courl
non-mear_
again
talking
and go through
so dkat you a;e nOl going
comtrue
_
h¢ce tr_=_M of the oont_ol
9
15
¢tt_mL
ar= not part of the control
8
22
24
Theouiputof_hest_sor_arefv--cdmg
etrcmt
And where
6
14
block @a_rs
Andth_t.s_halwasmD_
So that the kr_
of
)
when
with
the block
Iog]ctoC]atm6
v.cn,
t$ $10p_
recording
19
21
V_
2
5
by
m the mter_t
MR.
15 ofM_
)
W¢.ltmsawthtsyest_rday
n*r._ t_ _
II
14
looked
thai U;
m incident
Sowesay
II1¢ patent
Let me jm;[ mtcwupl
17
well
ovtx
Hearing
! .1_
arguments
clcamgs,
was
the sensor.
so tt's sensed.
Io change
of &mmlshm8
16
ff the
it certmrdy
circuitry
by rtadmg
COURT
| do_'[ want
15
that
Andthcy
change*
Markman
3
THE
poml
who
man.
lts output
of
Ma_englII
by Phflhps
mlnut_
14
l ha_.C of scen
turned
lays
energy,
determined
i 3 clc_mg
It wotdd
and
all of tirol is aRet
8 scn._or t$ b_t
II
Dr
three,
it's no_ selecuon
m ad_tton,
stated
the concept
asked
In column
had
9 _
are
w_
know.
And
l0
by the de fca3dan_
patent
"se_ec[*
to death
The court
7 QI.Q2.have
And as the
arid ht g_et" and
superstar,
I thtrik
LSIhe ktt_l
supphcO
aridovo
BuL you
6
that ewertt, a_d I Uurmd IO somebody
thai ._ asn't da..'_lng,
say,
5
tt for the lUSt txme
was a Broadway
19
24
play
sccn ii. bul thee
gel ht_her
forward
when
20
The
word
beat
ctret.ut_y
12 the same
And thai IX'rson
23
wheTe
the people
they dance
blew
22
4
heaghL
_4
18
$cl¢¢uon
the Broadway
happening
1 thtnk we*re
3
to a Broadway
¢Ourl has
flat: {_t:_2;
un[fl finally
13
saw
the fronl line dancer
II_'e_;,
I I high_
I ever
kJaow lethe
really
2
I_
Apex.
strtm[me,
fo_ tem_
hke
"semor%
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
615
00616
OO617
I _pcclal]y
2
for tcr/'Rs ]1k¢ "s'A iIch"
Rcmernbex
3 slruct_e
Magm-Tcch
Io a pcxson
4 clrcmt
means
5
Now.
6 _ holly
_
demons
conslslcnt
7 and that
_tsclf said
ski]led
IS stl'ucmr¢
m the
_zth
art
m_ c_cz
ski[led
[ will submtt
'Ahal the contcxl
¢*ax proposed
corc_lrucuon
means
2
3
4
the
to you.
5
cIazm
_s
terms
ts
10
And
_ c stlggcst
thai FAiL
I I zmporhng
terms
] 2 delcctcd_
13
gone.
to be detected.
15
ptcfc_cd
16
tlmtocLarmswhcxc_osc-
17
docsn'_
crabodtmcnt,
19
say iI do_n'l
s c_'_ot
2i
We
22
_
23
and 2B
as parl of e,,cry
mc *÷
9
thatll
on
10
count
or from
appcax
tbe_
m the
'066 patent
S} st_'ns
Nov.
] 2, and pm
15
manual
t6
That
QI
the palcnt
ts vow
o; cmd_
is fo_md
¢ltcu_l
m FIg_cs
the conlcxt
Rcmonber
21
12 ofth©
2A
22
¢_ntzo_
¢_reml
23
v, ht_em
said
24
generatmgapulse
25
anywhere
dcclslo_
Ilearmg
r_spo_lloCIzaml6
20
10/27/05
Page
appanthx
feature
stated
that
pulse
_qear_
has
that pulse
count
only
wtth
JA287
16 was
allowed
Clmm
12
and became
And
the a_kht ionaJ
means
and
rc f_rerg¢
JA 273
f argued
o_ er the Nippon
ctrctm
vs
"o0R'r
count
m the Ntppon
273,
Here's
coatro]
Weaxc
Corporauon
Thal'smthc_ecordat
pat_.-m
fact
uaamblguous
b_ldes
7 htmsal
that C[mm
'066
to be
the
at 833
clazms
attorn¢
a thsungmshmg
19
and
not present
aljomt
counting
Technology
fl d¢clarallon
w_re
patent
from
of tbe
m the Phdhps
The
1 $ was
and Q2 ate separate
tL_]f
impormn[
_nd_e
F 3d 823
the M cCa;
Is a
pulse
12
be cleat
of the ptmthng
the
nolx,.tthstanthng
o f Storage
329
is gl;mg
to lntow_
m Clmm
re_labO_
mcludes
$ott'smCla_ml2
Claxm
12,
lhal,
a mear_s
It should
for
nol b¢
e/se
Markraan
616
llearmg
10,'27/05
Page
617
Page
619
00619
O0_lg
I
The ¢.xanuner
2
reasons
3
130ZI4
4
because
theae's
5
McCavtt
_Leclara_
6
by the examine,
7 clerk,
und_hnmg
9
I_ocedme
l0
was no_ do_e
on and
1 Hthas_eryhmttcdmdust_yexpcn_ce
Sectton
13
aqd
suggeSle_
15
manual
no1, u may
ICrms m the
may
ha_e
ha_ c bctm done
been
bel _-_ ¢s that
for an al)owanc¢,
office
there's
employs
done
there
_s a
and
argued,
rega, dmg
m a_¢htmn,
to feaiur_
m the - I ha_e
The examiner
CImm
Claims
clearly
al the
and
20
reqmres
16
2, 10,
pulse
22
com_
fr_'n
23
s_tggest
24
thart
that
cotmt
nol dlsc]ogcd
wo_d "Nippon
Cbum_
that
DE.SA
4
cetera,
_t*s far less than
7
P_.ulus
8
ttself
12, and
m._t
of¢,halM.r
Dr
M_,seng_lJ's
Cook
Rale
he has msufi3ct_nt
tsgomg
12 statement
be &sregardeK
experience
Markman
to argue
And
Heanng
of the master
15
re'matador
depasluon
cxarmned
the
says.
chart,
spoke
a clatm
material,
ftmcuon,
he ne_¢_
22
the
23
shaictur
24
was ttahctzed
anoth_-
I_ dJd nol _
wtth
thing
rccztts
&d
tn the frmt
looked
al the
tmdedmcd
Thesz,
t t'rn_ as recRmg
capable
but he rehed
Ma_sengfll's
and should
not be revlewe(L
1 Ioo_ed
of recdmg
the C_LSCO f Pc_onahzed
Markman
stud w_.s
suffic_enl
at the term
term, he stud,
e was
Mr
that 1M Masscngdl
the _, ay he looked
Well,
r, ever
SowethmkthatDr
ts not parsuastve
Now.
I
JA 0935
whcr_
of the claim
_ufflcltmt
r_ed the suls:lernents
claim
youknow
becau.s¢
618
of Mr
the remainder
Products
on to recite
Hc also never
ouhtm
21
Page
chazL ct
of the clam
tl
10/27/05
Sage
All he &d w_s
salad
25
he never
or acts to I_'rform
that
w_th patents
rend th_ complete
but goes
20
Why Is
to h_m
all gtvcn
He thd not
cIatm
tha_
19
claim
were
Rcm_nb_.
a functton
! 8 statcmcnl
that
the m_tcr
And
16
clear
patent
Hen_.erreadthccompictcdepo_ttonofDr
14
17
Hchasne_¢rread
of the '(_6
of the exh_L%
He m-vet
Carlson
13
or
an mt erprctatzon
to be part of ¢'v_
any
htstory
those
6
12
_ tr_IroctLon
2, 10_ 11 and
proffered
to the cou_i thal tt should
Well,
prepare
I I alnmtur¢
II
II of the _366 patcnL
to the cot_
umm_btg_o_s
Now,
allov,¢d
6, 9, 10and
I s_mu
19
3
9
it
Andthalappea_alsoalpageJA2g7
they became
the ptmecutton
5
by a
a spataal
to do that,
2
l0
to the argumems
atlomey
12 are d_ected
14
it -
m th_s cl_e
In adchtzon
the: patent
21
MPEP
that underhmng
tf an examm_
a reason
that the patent
12
18
the cot_
of the McCa_
or iI may
who knows
I )
Wc ga_e
of
IthmkthaltltSabzgst_elchloarguethat
need to slaIe
16
m this case ,_ued no statcmcnl
for allowance
8
25
Cisco
featmcs"
as pan of the
Marlunan
17
12
14
Ctmm
say ts nccessagJ
ls f_d to thc con_ol
which
mt_t
the case
sen_or
palent
requlres
clmm
m CImm
the
from
that
only appaars
13
b¢ forehand
thaltc_nd_csn'lcxlsl,
ct rcm_'_,
R crn_mbe_
patc'nt,
pulse
of
h_c
A dmclzam¢_
Io you
of the
on hob
Io a
coupled
a]so sa t that there
Interpreted
citing
each
not ofzh¢
the cOnleXl
the dcfcndants'
I]
Q2 arc
mstrucuons
8
to b_
an clement
Now,
right
o[:,oalmg
premised
Wedclcrmmed
the
and
thsclatmo"
now It s _ mslead
Io take
So v,e say that
17
ouff_
24
_
say thai the sc'_ors
_
excuse
Q_
43 of the ctrcmL
7
that
Selccuon
20
_¢
c_th_r sought
_t's no_
altcmptmg
slaI¢
DF_A
into the clazr_s
Or there
18
_
mtcrprcta_ons
v. hlch Is no_
sought
14
25
Io you
and Co_tco's
paflton
courl
6
ts as
$ w¢tl
9
thai the sensors
detected
stud
of the patent
of tho_¢
ts
m the a_t
CedNet
to a pcrsc_
trallon,
I says
Lhat s cnouph
_
stmctu_
pr_e_lcd
to ham,
to s¢¢ If that
the entire
Metha
fLmcuon
thai
vs
Hearing
10/27/05
O0620
_0_21
I lntemanonaITta_cConm_ss]oa
2 slays
3
net dg_r the fact thai
tts funcaon,
4 ptcetsc
5 the
no/the
phys_cat
an dclraC_
6
Now,
7 the '066
8 mg
16}
a detector
faCl that
structure
from
thai detent
does
nOl call
but the same
structur_
Icrms,$uch_clamp,_contam_
II
tmportanl
ts not simply
12
ts defined
m zcrras of v, hal
13
name
14
meaning
15
Endo-St_gcry,
m the a_
F 3d
So om proffer
tt does
m page
dctlnmons,
cl_ums
as atkkc_scd
19
¢OnSIractheclazmsmconR'xt
20
_at¢
21
tbe c_ms
22
Thal'S whal Mr
don't
24
clazm
25
used
mcdmmsm
cagb
import
clmm
the same
]7
m the arL
skdled
18
We
and we
etcmem
stud
hmzmtmns
from
Wc use thctmaanes
a lot m ot_ brief,
a preferred
where
claim
itself "o01'ltrol Cl_CPJt" IllC_IL_
structure
Co_bol
d_n 8 as control c_rcuJtmeans
20
to emil light, but there's
especmIly
lcchntcal
m the
tbe MDE.
acls?
23
_¢
thetttman_
Hearing
10,"27/05
Page
csrct_t
to people
Does the claim itself
go on to daborat c sln_ctu_c
_
The
22 to scr_or
embothmcnt
apptolmalc,
those -
And
:Lself recite suf_ctcnl
ofonc
or connotes
19
and
ftmct_on,
we stud
yeS,
s_cit_c
means
that's causing
her© when:
And
the
there's
lamp
a
IVsrcsp(msrve
la tls t'csponsc IO dctccUorL
there'sacts m there
24
somethmg
to people
skdled
25
Something
thal's going
And these acls mca_
m the clect_x)nic
arL
to emit light, $omcthn_
620
Markman
00622
has to be
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
621
OO623
I thlvmg
2
that light
PcopIe
3
thaL
4
extracUng
clecb_omcally
_of_a_aCL
ICL
abom
a dcvzee
undeaxmad
"may
fully
And
Mum
) ou pta
shodd
II
_lustr, m_ c of ¢, hal
12
_md on the slaad
not apply
Wc urge
14
byDESA.
15
the court,
16
the pazcat,
thai
elecmcal
uade_mad
It's nol on, bul It wtll be mjust
THE COURT
5
thal 0ct¢oaon
phrase
ot_ wtmesscs
the corn1
Now,
have
to adopt
ff tt does,
tsan
7
i 12/6
I think
m bn¢ f
you
_or/rauch,
THECOURT
m coatcxt
-- cx cose
of the ml_nst¢
yot_
Hon_
Thankyou,
Mr
of
we have
to turn on the
HIGGINS
22
THECOURT
me --
Htggn_
I'mmPammgth_s,
"Fnankyou
Okay
You_Hono_
Ateyougomglouse
thts nmc.hu_?
24
MK
COOK
25
THECOURT
Y_S, a hRle
Iho_tt'son.
Markman
COURT
somebedy
MP,.
! think
could
that remo_
grab
ROHRER
that
maybe
Ar_$happen?
She holds
12
hgMflask
ldgb'tseethchghL
13
Isymgtotumonthccamcra.
14
eve_ythmgckesetup7
Goodbye
15
your
I hope
16
pe_onally
cl_mg
eomrol
Youknowhowtodothat_
I ha_ e a hUle Im of _xpenence
Sbegcesbkcthts
THECOURT
ll up
Usua_]ywescea
It'son
Okay
argumenL
Wewere
And
She
you've
dc¢_n't
you don'l
Sbedzdn'twm_ttohea_Mr
18
MR.
t9
(Laush_)
20
MR
THE
lthmkltncedstobemmcd
take
got
want
to bear
that
Htggt_cdh_
tecor_
Cook?
21
M]TRAKOS
w_thth_s
II
Andwcmge
cxtr_a¢ous
In conlCXl
I0
coosmguoas
tbe lerms
MS
- maybe
9
that's jmt
done both
the clarm
to apply
uo_ coasldcrmg
_,'ldencc
Tlumk
COOK
hc_e
6oo.
that m the
all of dm smfftogcthct,
to that claun
cvcn
19
a moment
3
Wcu_getheco_laolla_vplyll2/6
17 _t _nnslc
Mr
for
8
9
18
clmm
Ti_cym_derstand
10
13
a ptoc_s
_
2
4 carno__
We're talkrng
8
abom
ml undc_tand
coal
6 cagmccrs
7
I
slo lied m the dcculamc
We*to not talking
5
23
control sirocco
16 means
Wc
one
SO we s_y the tcrm
]5
in_enuc_
Is a g'pa_lc
blarkman
20
not3ml
m
cmbodrmcm
in
to people
Tlmt's what
Paulus
¢¢sc with does tbe claim
14
a pr¢ freed
v, hal Dr
] 3 stna:t_e,
Wcconsa_c
beP, vecn
Carlson sa_d
That's
12 Products
the
Ethtcoa
m the art.
means
II we toad the remainder of the claim as stt_r..stcd
by the Sage
tmdcrstood
ofthecnurepatraL
wltllcsscs
cffcmt
here has sm_cturaJ meaning
Raper sa_d
1583
stalled
6, c_e_/Icrm
end "_hat om
the control
21 cont_olctrctut_ Ifscouplcdtoalarnp
And
23
7 Claim
arc s_cstlng
for example,
l0 Mr
as ¢oatamed
to on_s
the dzffetcnce
6 thd on the stand,
8 skilledm the cltctromcs
tltal the term _
v$
Enterprises
9
well
Caec'nbczg
.few
So what we
¢,cllMcfincd
bneC%webegmwtththewmdsofthedalms
I g the
5
of
and that's the br_d
embothmcnL
shp opinion case thal wc deh_ crcd to court and counsel
commonplace
ot a dclenl
b_
of any working
4 y_stctday,
%qlalts
a delcnt
1550
3 new
m
the clmrrtsfog thclgmeanlng
And wc rod
2 mdepend_t
m say, tt ul
a single
has a re_onably
citing
o_
Ix stud of oth_
thal
skilled
IO the tcmts
go_s
to rmrgl
cottld
for the sixt_tme
of those
l
of
of the straetm'e
Medm
10
17
not connote
vc D' tmporhlnl
structu_
91
toTn does
m the minds
9
16
m Icrms
be the
Pcrsoaahzcd
aIpage705,
zs defined
the de finiteness
we say that's
patent
F3d696,
blL
]beltt'snot
Heanng
Page
622
Mr
COOK
YourHonor,
thank yo_
22
thL_ has been
a very
23
appt_tat¢
24
and
ltmg
the attCmllOn
the re_t of the court
Dunng
Th_z,
so much
ofyota_df
Evm_m--
Letmesc_
Allnghl
fory0_Sl_hence,
procccdta&
lknow
We certainly
and
Proft:ssor 2 Carnal,
employm
the course of th_
Markman
JA 0936
Mr
AllnghL
21
25
10/27/05
MR.
COOK
Wccco:hnss, the_'s
Hearing
one
10/27/05
Page
623
OO623
0O624
] thb_
thai h_n't
2 s_tulc
b¢_
but it hasn't
3 and I think
th3s, that
Or stnlclure
I that _ wall
in the
2
has no_cd _t before
the -
¢o_ e_ a
4
for applying
paL_nt, tt co_ el_Sthe
5
112/6 doesn t j_l
or acts zn _
p,_ent
plus
7 eqm_ alence
8
And
so these opinions
9 P'_Olessor M _scngg!
I 0 cove_
the _d
I1
Th_'s
d_
p0stbon
beca_
lh_
14 eClUlv_lcnc¢
15
tl co_ ers _
a_vays been
12 ofDF_A's
13
that ha_ c been
And d_
tha_ we haven't
comes
_
_
tf zt go_
20
the clrcmt
2i
o_ IK'$ the san_ _s az_ equt_ _ent
ifs
If It'S cor_,n_ed
_
2S
the _qmvalmL
phase of the
that far, _ ¢ w_]l
_ccordmg
Eo 112/6
Io the clrCUJl th_gm
there v, ould he an opponun_y
d_c ules should
to
fftha1's_halth¢
he consm_d
as the claim clement oz
and th_n thc_e would
be ¢xperl
test_mon_ on
Hearing
10/27/0S
Markman
sensor
o_ crndcs
elemenLs
dtsc:Io6ecL
co_ er those
4
then
mutupl¢
Page
I 12/6
language
7
tmdex
ll2/6mbecausetftheyha_¢
$
v.tl] be oul m the marketplace,
9
thai might
I0
to copy
somebody
II
c_rcmt,
for example,
12
_ al_ble
13
16
17
thet the tee.son
Ix: simply
And
toj_t
iI's a matler
And
12
_ anou_
13
no_ ju.st one
mulupl¢
me_u_
for the
language
thereby
be presumed
17
the law,
the York
18
pre_va'npt]on,
patem
co_ er m_ple
embothmca_ts
m applying
for fos patent
intended
be's rtol hmtled
apphcatzon,
to m_ ok¢
to actually
to simply
one
21
there
22
ha_ ¢ had a Claim elemenl
23
o_ c_thng
or instead
24
could
had
had
claJm
been
have
e]menLs
instead
of a sensor
szmply
But tho_c
multiple
claim
thxt
So ff
da_m,
he could
for mantmlly
means
a ser_or
menl
he shows
o_ ernde
thai sa_d mear_s
unde¢
that
ernboch
call out -- cover
o f a mant_d
and
112/6
Ingg¢_
He s Im31ted Io whatc_ er enl bothme_Ls
the respeci3_¢
those
and eqmvalmLg
and also
20
co_
embothments,
to use the tngg_
to have
c_e,
or muthpl¢
that the clatms
c._nt wtshes
16
of thai
pro ferf ed ernbothment
it would
So tf an apph
m the palent,
_s eqLuvalence
Io the extenl
embothments,
15
disclosed
as well
of choice
one
or
the pie ferred
to whal's
patenL
to thsc fose
another
_
eqm_alence
to absolutely
replacing
cl_Jm clement,
you
elemenl
-- and if ther© had been
ment*oned,
the purpc_e
Ilearmg
20
naz_ow
arl and want
21
can you
use I 12/6
22
_ ulzd clam_
_nd
23
using
language
2g
take your
to make
v*ithm
you
10/27/05
gel narro-_
but presumably
a_ otd mggenng
_ rthout
the word
_means"
112/6
by
m tt and
chancc_
can put m a clam
the a motion
Marlunan
detector
Ilearmg
chains
conunuaaon
Page
625
and
m
10/27/05
Page
JA 0937
112/6,
by doing
the second
application
could
also
m the same
get a thff_ent
and
co_ crage
or m the
submR
scolg
thing
to take
regular
apphc_on,
And
937
1 mentioned
patem
no_
ca"fik
of chains
a
It's done
It's
And
mcar_
17
sensing
plus
of the
recull
fm_cuon
language
how
a sep_sor -- a scr_or
21
perfectly
22
dcfcr, dant
23
112/6
24
"sensor"
25
_1 oser mlo
Iog_c'al
t_cd
to argue
to come
a motion
sensor
Htggms
_s sm:cture,
there
m and
gse
of a sensor
mea_s
foz
foz scr_mg
I 12/6
thai Mr
the _c_ cts¢ Wesumptzou
would
patent
dtsclosure
thdn't
Instead
mSg_
the arguments
20
the cla_rr_
xtjL_T said
That doesn'l
The
on the _dcnt_cal
'066 patrnL
m _t, you'll
motlorg
Then
ts based
-- On the tdent_c_,l patent
patent
a conlmuau_n
16
th_s to you m the opening
of W_escmann
argue
would
pro_ _dc suf'fic_c_t
h_s made
that would
to a_old
almut
be
ff somebody
-- the
v* hat thai co_ ers Ls
apply
structure
and
the word
to avoid
ktckmg
112/6
Markman
626
control
mggc_
ull the tmle
19
then
you
with
not
the o_u_zs_y
have
in a _A3_imuatlon
fonctton
12 motion
Th_z
are m a
sure you get vahd chains,
can
the
not precluded
apphcat_0n,
15
coverage.
type coveeage
then
I 12/6 clalnts
_d
btx_adc¢
of the firSL You
o_gmal
]4
op amp v, zth
ff you
you're
Artd
m combination
of that sort,
go_ much
13 specl flcatlon,
Thosekmdsofcolofful
of a I 12/6 ts also
kave
m vtew
11
it also
are embraced
you
7
12
And
v, lth a I_np
something
6
I0
the
aswchavementlonedandasMr
19
then
9
way
ts _ evy, yew
a pacuculm"
112/6
3
8 ph_s
that
the e_sle_t
r_oduce
oDl_
changes,
of the
that
cold
of conduct
coforfoJ
aho
genera]
thai
ex_Jnmed
co_ccmed
c_rcwt,
5
product
and zeproduced,
thfferenlkmck
_pecl
And,
and they're
then the coverage
from
get
2
4
thal
Io employ
aspectfic
cop_ed
that _nd
really
You
deod_
wo_d ar_
ts jt_t
op amp,
I comblnaUon
zI would
v, ¢ menuoned
mgg_
_t stops
sumps sonugme
18
25
structure
hmlled
mlo
for cor_trumg
Markman
manual
I 12/6
that people
that mea_
It sto_s
been
m the opening,
there
_
or mu]uple
tf R had
6
15
2
112/6
l('s Itmtlr.d
c of the
of course
undc_
624
embodLmeats
And. o f ¢omse,
zs -
dlscfosed
5
14
the swact_r
ay -- and thai plays
OO627
I multiple
3
7
25
0_626
2
embOdlm_nt
]9
¢lthe_ the san_¢ as
m'g_that_hatp_ucui_cucmtblock
24
h_.Emg about
-- accused m fnngmg
Io ezther -
point
been
snlo the m fnngmenl
the m_nnge
_s eq_v_Jc_t
So al tl_
It s not nano_]y
6
]4
re.on
d_
1$ be then _rgumg
23
about
-- any_
for clmms
I 1 embodiments
to reco_ltzc
t been la]kmg
that's
of the rationale,
I 0 apphc_nt
II's p;ltl
Bm I thznk st's Lmpo_ml
hasn't -- _e haven
some
9
A
plus _quJ_ _enc¢
parl of OUr posmon
17 c_s¢, and we _ m/nngement,
22
clcn'_nl
h_re
16 zt ts because
19 pt'_ucls
-- hk¢
_ hen be says thai the c]_m
block,
I know
3
to make sure dut you -- that we
the su_J:t_re oftbe
6 r_lcnal
[t s n,_t
been -- nolxx_
ll's tmportanl
4 all recognize
5 sm_tu_c,
nlentloned.
Heanng
10/27/05
Page
627
OO628
0O629
I
SO thts kind of a]tema[¢
2 something
{hat's [n the arsenal era
3 could use any kmd.
4 _s this is
5
s fJ'a[egy ts
I aflcrncon,
I_tC'n[ attorney
he
He can get (he kind of coverage
they
clearLy took
7 t}_.al way, and {hey _n.restuck
3
thai he wants
6
l[ hare I f {hat is io
9
I'll comment
lO Greenhatg
on -- Mr
I 1 them,
{hose were nol means Ingger
12 where
{he word
[3
c,'_es
like sensor were adequate
I 12/6+ even though
15
16
II _d
-
to be addressed up fron[
19 do
They read l[ for the proposfllon
22
claims
applied
And
were Bdcqt_te
coven
There
SLnlCttlre lllatcnal
arc appa_lUS
_e proce_.s claims
25
-- '_e handed up a case to Your Honor
+t says
the
or malct]al
-- structur,fl
qualifies
J.nd acts qu_h fies slcp
word
clearly
interpret the term
21
This
Page
"steps"
and the
co.elation
to the
steps
of such
bclween
{h_s pacagraph slructu_e
24
acts go with steps
25
It goes
on.
to refer
IS corLsISI¢I_t with
interprelallO_
23
last night - yesterday
Io Lha
rethrs
of elcmenLS era process and {he mnn
aCLS to refer 10 [he ImplemcntahOn
20
And
of such a concept IsobvloLLs[y by SltUCture
We
19 generic description
of
10/27/0S
means.
and malenal
{his Is on page
628
[he
_nd stnlcture
In
go with means
and
m_rl_
5 of {he copy
Markman
{hat we
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
629
00631
handed up to Your
2 no _uthonly
Honor,
and It's controlling
[o {he con{ra/y
3 In Fulu_e c._ses
There
4 acL_ to suppor[
any -- there's
t
h*s been cited and apphed
2
arc no cases {hat have ever apphcd
functional
language
In a m_ns
6
And therc_
7 Ifyou
a good
lake the nrcl_d
plus forte[ion
reason v. hy a wouldn'L
f_nc[lon
a funcll0n
[0
In _sence
II
Rmctlon.
[hat the acts m tha fmlctlon
you would
It would
ha_ e rcdaced
14 have any cffecL
15 languuge
nulh_,
You
supporl
{he sl_[ute
{he r_cl[ed
You would
io an
17
0 f course, Congress
that if you're going
19 h3ve gol Io hmlt
be any hmlL_
thdn'l
plus fune_on
Congress
plus func[ion
you
so_e t _,-c in the
patent
22 the example
Is because if you -- and
[ u_cd in {he opening
was if you invent
23 carl and call st a m _.'_s for Irar_ponauon.
24 _ ould co_r
automobd_
and mrplanes,
then
an ox
of Ihat
soft
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
630
have
For example,
plug
internal
and
types
D hSA.
have
combustion
both.
have
clement
mcd
can
Io
- that
in {he claim
structure
a spark
plug
of (he ctatm.
m {he * {he
{hen you
infer
an
cnglnc
Lncd, but can't
12 suppOrl
{hat notion
13
elcmenl
or eLscwharc
14
sh_c[ure
find any ease thai v.ould
II'S [he shazcturc
in the claim
m the cham
you could
find other
In the c[alm
We haven't
16
You haven'l
17
criticized
found
heard
-
for no[ seeking
18
the thCl of {he matter
19
and noled
20
Mr
and said
any
cvcn
other
[s Mr
wel].
other slruClure
though
Carlson
h_re
Mr
in the clatm
M assengdl
structure,
relying
-- nobody
ha_ been
on {hal,
has come
is thal other struclure
m
thai
M_cngl]Llgnored
Mr
22
claims
23
you lOok
24
claims,
M.L_englll
dldn'l ignore
any slPJctere
in the
Heanalyzedeve_smglcp.'.uqofthoscela]ms
through
you
And
his -
wdl see that everything
even
in those
If
{he chart {hal he prepared
chain
h_
efemenLs
Markman
JA 0938
t bc
o f Iransportallon
c.m infer other
if you
wanted
ox cart shou[dn
{hat {he claim
[s an ¢lcmenl
[ have
{hat Congress
of{he
Io rely just on the smlctutc
hut {hat you
9 spark
25
Markman
Carlson
sLr_ck -
8
21
{hat claim
and {hlngs
don't
15
on it
want {hat
Io use means
ii to the text _d
And the n_ason for that
clement
of claiming
the Inventor
over a o- other
Mr
{hat the
11
sEmply have a functional
Ix able Io use mr_ns
16 la, nguagc, and {h c_'e _ ouldn'l
you
7
tO
and the 112/6 statute wouldn't
would
6
-o by saying
12 ahaurth_y
13
argue
IS a - IS
a bunch of acts, then the -- by applying
Now.
5
Because
Is Ihe kind
because
coverage
4
In an app_-a[cLs claim and
8 [hc-n lake the acts OUl of {hat, which
9 rumply
That
[o avoid
3 given
$ apparatus claim
25
And
18
0O630
21
q_allfies
17 LmplemeniatlOn
or aCtS And
He2rlng
case, under {his case they
Mar
on to say {hat sm_cturc
"means"
as
{hat ha_e steps This has been discussed
Markmall
20
gone
15
than we
two kinds
under the Tcch
Now,
have
ofslnJclure malcB_
thereof
16 generic descnpt_on of an uppdrat_s clement
or slP,JClUre charns, and {he_c
24
18 s_d
or acts
22 esL_hshed
23
I
{hal and SO forthWithout the retrial
m support
You could
of the decision
that - In the means
Out of {he fact that {here _¢
a specified
this and doing
14 that's over oll [he next page
m IL
And
language
of step for do:ng
9
13 and material
needs
notes, they+re reading it differently
claim
{here
e0nslstlng
I0
11
to avoid
Is {he Sugc products case
HIgglns
{hat comes
The step Is a -- IS pro<ess
12
pOlnl that ] think
18 Mr
20 plus f_nctlon
were c_es
some funcllonaH&ng_zage
NOW, also, the -- another
21
Those
wa_ n't involved
And so the rcveTse prcsumptmn
14 words
[7
_means"
to the
referred
Media cases, and he quoled from
for a combination may be
as a means or step for psr forming
8 say a me{hod
HL_Ins
and PePsonahzed
c_¢
tLseiP,
function
7
8 {hc_rdisadvantage In thlscase
- thai we were going
(pbonctlc)
And this case sta+tsw_{h the statule
5 expressed
Thcygolex_Jnlned
with
h+s the el Tech M.u
4 [ 12/6, says an element m a clmm
{he i 12/6
Thcyused{hcLnggcrlanguagc
I should say, in order to
2 to refer [o
Hecouldha_econtmmngapphcatlons,
But m {hus case,
6 opllon
chaining
hacn
o f the
identified
that he -- where
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
631
00633
OO632
[ he m_'kc_ and _how_
2 30 .ro_,
which ¢lcrncnl
_a a9 ofthc ,e_c_J
3 int_'pre_eoe_
dmr_,
A I$ and wbxch zs B. _nd
5
2 roo_on
wml ouL:tdc a_d wcTc _l_tn_cd
4 consider, Lion o f othc_ p_.r_, othc: p_
la zny cv_l,
the bo_Ic_ lu_
6 lftbe_eweramy_uk
"7 inu_o_tapon,
3
b,ur_ on
robe fo_dw_th
the o cvcn
_
M_cn&qll*s
9 heroic _1
is _
Now, _ao_
_/R
_
6 raayb_ t_:sw_'l
cx_Uy
swpp_rt_l
by
w_d
hc._ u_ _d
p_nl th_ I Lhtn_ _sw_Ll
II
_fyou h_
_ ot
y_a/su_g_t_0n.
u@ m ft_ntof_P_
9 _ulda't h_v¢ zn_hmB
I0 d_m_e
_nporcu_t
by tmvmg, as you s_gg=str.d,
_ Izr_cmb c_
Bu_ you _u]d hav_ _ st.m¢_'
10 any f:l_3 _ _w L_v
II
YOu cotdd have a c_.nge o f h¢._ s_l_c_mt
| bch_ed
opmLoo, whdc i_ :_ - tl's
to _j ;u_d avotd I 12/6
S_youl_venld¢l_ed
f_:t
$ q_,nu[y of w_
none h_s been pomlcd out m sp_'_ fic_
And _h- C_r_n's
by th_
4 mgg_
of the ¢1,_ms
Is _ut
ezmayr_¢
I cvtdmceofm_eon,
n_ny ofhzs
objectthatwotdd
_d[nf_thcIR.
Iodo with m_Qr_
It
Th_'_ s_mply
m he:L
So the _eci_'._mmed c_ndm_n
m t_ c L_,mab_
IZ [acend_ffncd,znd w_ - _x_ri_s_y ¢t_ilned.
and wc :grccIb_
13 PIP. _sby tt_i f not • mooon
dct_-_to_
13 its modoa
0tmo_n
0r_d_'rn_ _d con_tlon is_hc mooc_
14 af a pcx_on _" o[h_ Obj_L
I $ how it wod_
I_ t_
po_
?_
w'_
_ s pzccc o f _'r_ o_nduct_r rn_tcnaJ
l_
i_s exposed _o chen_
l_ t_
In m_u_d
And _o _hc_ tst se[_boa
Thcr_'sno qu_un
th_c_s _ sclcalo_ lu_ a PRR only d_ts
|7 m infr_ed r_ha_on whc'a you
I_ unul you p_ m sc_ecuon c_¢o_
19 s _'_21 then ts a sqp_ztu_c o f a ch._c
20 r_oa
_ c._ge
21 doll
I_ _
m mr_ar_
21
BU_ If you k_v¢ _ chan_e m hca_ su_c]e_t
23 m_g_
Lh_ s:p_l,
• I_lp-_op of the p_lz_,
[o
So the moron
_:n
23 MI
you
thatwhlch
]wll]nolcil_ncRh_Mr
]4eanag
I(V_W05
P_of
Cl/tson z_llcd Tothal- employ _it _'Inclp4c b_ D_
sorac comments oo _.al,[ _ked
wh_t _¢ sun_t_c of thc!_C_[_OlC
Page 632
Markamn
Healing
10/17/05
Pa_c
633
Pace
_5
OO635
1 infrared
However
3 e._vob_
m LM pofuon c4"his repor_ where he
a PLY. _c _d d_cn'oe
5 tnd tc_tmony
Ltm_s_
6 q_te mph_cagy
_v¢_
_nd v_
8 _ exc_se mt_ wroa|
9 pc_t Lt_ the_ _
¢_e
4 Sl_
w_
¢_'_.r_l
8
Kts be_n _ hzs mad_ _
_
about G_e mo_c_
16 _ ff_r_t mod_
o_
21 dcle_¢
22 o f cr_
Ard
16 c.be_g¢ ofh_
_ mg
I _ _¢ IX _d
on col_
which
thenh_
a s_ml
_ _ wk_
Lt
IIcanng
[h_tse_t_nclrl_lWtswh_ls
tulerpr_
_e change of infrared, the
s_cd
by
i¢ _ motion ot - o f z person or
Mr
T_o,_kcd_boul_a_rnc_by_-_-_cm
23
he t_t_ _:_d oul _
An_
_ p_a
9 of _
bw. w_e_e - _nd
Yc_ COLdd i_ave a thsd_amer _*_ntl_ m b_c Pa_l
_y
L_S p_u_ dOesn _ ttTpl_ [0 such _
2_ d_dz_ne_,
of
lOr2710s
end m ht_ w_tten repo_
2 _ d_c:'e $ "._nous kands o f ths¢l._mers
3 _ou_n d line 34
m rt'_Rse Iocl_ng_
Markro_n
_
mtgrprr.l
21 wntlen rcp0_
_ p_
rczdllsc
2_ ud
d_cn_:_c_how _h_ _w
of_c
0_cchange of tern pr._a_r c th_
20 :n hr_ t_Atm_y
He wouJd Io_o_ A, R';net mol3on
2_ previous 5ec_on, b_n_it_
All they do
IS obj_
s_lh'_ t_c_z_t_g
tfbc uaders1._'_ how iIopera.s
ofmouon
15 uscd _0 n-_sla/e
_]_ng aboul
_f Opcr_a On. _cy w_¢ ._om_ b._.k_d
skill
m Ibcart_botO_ _I
ty_:s of razuo_.
Lbcp_tcnt L_Jksabo_ d t_en _ _
14 d¢_mnt_..3_on
]Re_
19
20 moron d_ector
don*t _ct into t¢lLm_ _x_u how to
12 r ©P,_CLS
_r._L_d. Nuw _-J wc_
o foz_
prpc
m ct_:_u_b¢
11 p_e_etermm_Uon _ to whzl the stgr_
l_ _ s}_._umd _.r_
_ut _ _u
Bu/they
r_)_on of a
mouon - whatever
10 ts Lhey 1¢11yc_ L_t _ere is how you rnake a
13
b_
It'_ decided wl_|I :[ looked at w_
9 d_s_n&'_t_hbcr.vcc_ d_ffcn_t
QZ
14 v_/_lc_tlul[h_jweet_kmgz_Jtthc
I_ mo'_on h_
e_the_ahtgh
L_g_vcn off by the arc_Jt m ord_
7 o f moUoa they we_c _mg
_ has
:e_:lm_ Io &c de_c_on
- b7 _he - QI _d
or 3 low s_g_l
5 to - af_
r_o pJa_e_ m the parent ova, I
fuji bngh_ mode _
1."reopen by _
a 8o_ngtlvoo_dltbepv_ce_gm8
6 porto3 oT o_e_t or no_ or wha_'vcr
I 0 beheve, m cokm'.n 6 when: L_ _
I I stating
_hc Opmton
by Pm£cs_or Masscv_ll
- DE_A
_he'o pmccec_ dow_ L_e c_l_'_n :rod _p
¢o]_'e_
3 ¢lfcurayu_tJtll-m3J[ydesc_b_how_
:[r.oJ ly
Now, also m _he patcn_ _crc
radlaoon _d
2 Lhcac_t cold.an
_ as de_ec_ng ch_nge_ m
4 mfi_Tcd m_ ztto¢. So _at wa_ c.m_]stent _th
I_
_d
Thc're's
be_n a Ioiof {_tm_ony on _h_L [ bhlnk
25 h_m ifhe ic_y ka_
be
O0634
7
todtsungmsh bc_w_
r_L_on
24 Pa_t_, _cn though he m_¢
_ n_c - [h_ che_gc ta _. my
Markman
2
of :afr_i
2Z I_$ f_rly¢]tm
24 8:t a sl_mJ, and only t_m
2_
_e
m he._L NOt s_mp_y he_[. heat do_a'r
[fyo_@pIyas_dyhe,_.
23.
_y
cb.aag_
_[docsn t d_tc_|rno¢_on
Mark_nan
P_e6_
JA 0939
t_ch. _t_
whe_ m 01e patens or]Ice, when you rnake zn
Hearin_
10t2"7105
0O637
100UnS I'_ ;i 112/6 Cx_mJrdwioo. [ put L;_ w01_ * m _"
at] _¢S¢ ¢_11
$ _'_.n
_
why tl_
I:'r_
r_.'l ¢_vr_d
by G'¢ d_.r_
Ja
¢I_nenf_
_LI trS not -- li'_ _mc_l_
_ul m my d=nu_, g_
ts
7 el_nQl_
e
And the _=znlne_ _ _L_'I_
9 e_=Jnhm'=e]f
b=;k and _k
Helmmvll-wh_t
lurn |a
heva'a_t_kmj_tbo=L
10 He knew wh_ the p._1_1 t_tcfne_ w_ _a_kln_ apuw.
II
The p.ttent t_orney nuy _lve be_
I Z him.seW z li P,1¢hi: or wi_le
t 3 _vc
_1
! I ?.76r.l_n _ ]u_©, L'Qm_ mo_e __
14 ml=nl was vcl7 cJ_
1_
_om
gw©
_=11, [
(_r., PUl the
_¢ bml[mSc m Lh¢ M¢C,[vd
Acul d_e mgm'_'_t pomon by the altorn=7, t_e facl
17 d_
II
_m_
room by not sty(n&
he _ feted ¢opu_e ¢o_tm_
be=n$expl_:Jb'? m Ct=m
16, wl.ch b¢_tme Cl=um 12, _1
t_J [h_e - m _&tmn.
_er_s
d_
s._d, In _dd_oon.
mh_r (r:mm_
m C3_ur_6. 9.
20 10=_111
21
11t_ p=n_ohr
a,'lpu_t.
2Z szy, 611t he _tetprcted
?,3 pu_
_ you h¢.ud Mr
Ft=_
Ltt_ to me.=n d1_ I_ addid_
Qom_d_. Ihcz© ate olh=- feat_¢s
eo
[. Ibcs¢ o_=r
24 ct,tm_ ¢Imen_
2.5 _¢¢nm_;m_a
li2/6.
H_kndto_(_
mu=nmu,
Markn_n
Hc._nag
rm
23
10/27105
P=ge
The -- I put a che.rl up dunns the op_=tm_ emd
636
Markmau
Hemnng
IQI27i05
P=ge
_37
0C_l
1 r][ men.an
It briefly zg_up. TtlZ_
2 Def_.d.xnls'
_xhlbtt40
I_]
d_at that L_
[_mkz['_Ql,zb43,
]
if[
]_,
he O3g]d Ot',lyt ¢['A"rO It L_S;Z_dI(=_or roatl_
2 at !*'4JdcolI_q=IclRu_ImGI_.
_4_you
_ns_howI(:nz_y
3 n:c_L
4
But alan,
i_
_u_t _ho_
$ _1c wozd "m cam._
_ j_l
6 fa._
I]_l he _ed
7 _pn_119
S ofdz_
r_.h_
(_,n u_le s
4 y_u wa_d
m"m _ dc ri_.Jcur
5 ¢]t_¢
_ uz_L I_
w_l
°mmn_
of wh_b w_
cirri,
I_1 _
pl_
14
And Lt_ feSI of I]_c_
I_ _
h,l_
r_
It
And G_ - e11o£ _
t9 excepl3_
20 mm_,c_
2]
c_'n_
IbzZ Lhe-- =l_m
m_
t7 fc_
by
12
_
m
_
purboa
_ml_=6_s _I
fi]_s
m get nd of
=o
Ih_ o_cr just szy m_._u
o_e_ - _e_:z
sw.em_
o_r _ a_ml
knJ£O(
| 7 ¢_¢_t
onJ-j _
I|
_o _zz ride, tz _zt _fl _f the on(s d_l use d_e
_
hae. _swhc_ _be Pg: _
ranlp_,,_, saz._
h_z( zcmm s mca_
Q_hexl_lf dor_,
£_m_
nxn_oa
e_m© ztru£z_nzl zntnx_lm7
¢_
c_:mr_t m _© 1_=r
dete_zon
t2 or m _.ze.I (_ cc_WansoP, hc dJdn_. He cglcd _
_
mr_zlS plu_ _'_mn
m
I0
16 rr,_ms, matml
m a p_1¢ul_
z_o _
He couJd h.we c_le_ IhoSe rne:uq Ibr _
I_ sm,'cp.rvJ _
_
_o put _= ,,_hole d_'n
in 14
:pcm_c c_c_zz? =nd stxp_gc I_t_zSe
9 Ih_ fe_nzmm_ five, _o
II
m_
?ou h_
m dt of the ongn_d ct_m._, _
c _z'a etch,
_nd _ed
d_
_ • tluow-awa?
o_ I_
[u_
c_In_ dow'_
_ve_
1_moyou put &st_
c_¢mi_']ILi_pounngw_m;Oaknwl
19 _mu_d ; 1_e
bat un_ tt _v_L_ly
m_o a
[ts]c_h_
sL_i1_
pFr_e, zrc
whtcb ate re[e_ted to Ixmf m the c._m _- I_1_- m
I]
lULFp_,_&
If)_J_h_ndvol_,it_utdbl_wauta
Z20LhQ" cl=ms_ so glzt I_ pzz_nt si_o(ney could use the
?.1 Q_r
me.z_, for exzmple,
24 ",_k[
;r/.r.zul
s_o_
u 8 shon,_r_
mc_s. rc(_nn_
p_._e
?,_ I'un_l__z-l,ds_t=n'z:nt oflhc mcam plus fun_on
Marlo'nalZ
when he
bzck to i_e _
floating
clzu_.
10/2"//05
Page
638
Markma=
JA 0940
Hear'rag
10_27/05
Page
639
OO641
0O64O
[
done
At
2
order
3
l_mgs
4
that would
thk$ polnt
to select
the patent
the frcquencle$
So there $ some
5
photocell
tt goes
threctly
the patent
making
that they
9
they
l0
first pulse
happen
l I
wuhm
And
that's
12
ts in a panlcular
[3
wlth motion)
[4 pulse
t _ aCrOSs
[f they
result
I$
ume
19
mthedte
20
have
21
that
22
ltme
they
snterva],
Ifyou
tuggers
c_cn_
'._
the puLses and
7
e_entually
g
mouon
and that
al
here,
12
thal
here
they
could
If'they
ate
and a
13
one
14
accorthng
15
p_ss]_e
16
sensor
be as a
too far aparl
thai
thai a human
be an insect
tf you
being
PIR
the first flip- flop,
24
pulse there, and the second one comes
25
close
have
and you
pulse
} 9 the
would
Like
the first
ha_ e got a
here, they are pretty
counting
Markman
then cattses
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
art would
3 ts mote
4
than
NO_,
d
back
6
the
apparatus
23
halogen
24
lamp,
Is ,_ sensor
means
h_
other
suffix
just
accorthng
the
includes
in it
It's one
of
But
_, ash I sJmply
by using
where
includes,
thai ,In
he says
I whereto
say includes
a
I the
final patent
alJo_cy
claim
to Cla)m
doesn'l
a PIR
claims
careless
next
means
thai Claim
ed into
bctng
sec in the very
it says
sensor
than
thai the patenl
whlehwas
an apparatus
3 says,
said
of the original
Io show
ts
aswe'xenoted
suggeslmg
things
object
tn the patent
Claim
detector,
lamp
or other
said
a quartz
lamp
ts a quartz
hallucinogen
is
So includes
and
is shoxx the mtenl
Markman
read
that
the same
that
set6or
mr_
- sf you
regarded
the attorney
ts actually"
of
here
ar_arLgemCnl
_hcre
1 have
for detecting
LI to the apparatus
says a seine
on ¢,hal
the
atcangemenl
i4 a single
httle
high hat
Into
a beard
a sensor
cOndltton
exlemal
fordeteclmg
Implies
17 thffcrentlatlon
a generic
19
dependenlclatmsays
20
a PIR
for example
21
sensor
meo.n$
22
m it than jt_st the
23
idenllcal
Is that
logic
three
than jtk_l
ifyou
haxe
- if somebody
claim
and
then
the
Iog_c og that
m the c_alm above
P[R
_s _ ell,
in claim
3
Ileartag
the
10/27/05
Page
641
the claim
would
and the logic
a Iog1¢
is
Thafs
+ _sumes
Markman
not
thai
I[earmg
or the
And
thfferenttatlon
13
mdependent
10/27/05
16
logic
17
is less
Page
you
that one
JA 0944
rule
funcuon
actually
Page
643
Is always
A
statute
controlling
m a CaSe hke
mdependent
force
dependent
That's
of
the
translation
have
might
the
present,
da;m
claim
where
you
where
ba_e
got an
claim
got claims
I and
duplicate
thai are
Claim
separated
from
12 are m this
In some
respect
case,
the
_other
claim
pcrsuasl;e
ease,
Claim
Nobody
ever
I and
Claim
12 slmpty
tried
to hne
up
ha_ e a
* a means
thai they were
dupllcale
In facl
that you
22
function
23
eharactenzatmn
24
mean
25
function
the fact
claim
that they
elemenl
element
m one
case
of that element
are
if_t appbes
and
to that
were
the element_
not
and
plus
a speclfe
m another
the s,u'ne became
Markman
642
claim
poss=ble
anypos;ilbthty
[the Claim
In this
2 [
plus
has its real
another,
$bow
aren't
means
that
of the claim
and
When
one
fact
]fs noI a stalulOry
why
kS the
paThcutarly
12
15
The
a redundant
is ak_ays
error
not In a dependent
20
more
written
thfferentlauon
duphcales
have
ha_e
mterprelatlon
19
lYs used
people
claimed
9
IS
scope
But that's simply
8
clatms
ltlmmps,myhml
18
the
is - lYS SOl In have
otherwise
thestalute
that's
rule
in a
ifwherelnthesensormeanslsa
then
7
14
terminals
of the claim
- an independent
might
But
statutory
I I ifs
redtmdant
that all the lime
do
Human
6
10
It
struclufe
with
The
argvraent
has claimed
more
component
th fferentlanon
18
as gtllde
a predetermined
hdoesn'tsayaP[R
15
Claim
tt says
arcangemcnL
Sensor
plugged
underlmed
somebody
5
slgnlfcant
focusing
People
4 possible
look
and the statement
as fairly
IO be v, ntlng
2
i$
And
Id
oi' the
of the mvenuon,
t_ usually
tm'¢
lnvenPon
16
I going
know
3
can be said
In the Stalemenl
9
and would
lust a PiR
invention
7 becat_/¢
25
22
is the
I whereto
to - w_n't
can
h,xs deculed
things
640
Thtstssomethmgthatapersonofordmaryskdl
2 m the
24
you
of
OO643
I =ntent
12
trying
21
block
It, ts v. hal
circuit
claims
thai actually
20
no bright
that enare
of a person
',_ as one
-- _d
rejects
there's
culled
the
several
infrared
then
Massengdl
inCla_m3
means,
25
00642
10
mouon
IO Claim
the few
and
whereas
counter
or other object
¢.lth
That
18
or something
shoc.ed
:rod the circuit
might
_hat
of the ongmal
17
m
as Dr
gorexample
h,Lg v, alkcd
that somebedy
high
light
pulse
the tdea thai JL_t the PIR
for detecting
I L incorkgtstent
asscctate
get a poise
23
8
And
the
components
clrcmtry,
detects
a hnght
then
lea_ es the voltage
o f a person
9
and that the
+ If the pulse
too bnef,
Massengdl
together
selection
sensors
too far aport,
as Mr
And
apart,
So all of those
6
would
indicates
just
acitvaled
light
the
inter,
tlme
It wotdd
So
coital
nfs counting
It v_,ts not something
done
4
$
there s tv, o pulses
that they
or If the first pulse
and
the
to create
to go Io_ and
3 them
beings
the v, ay then
of mde_ndent
that
of heal
voltage
if they are I'ar enough
I0
of the two
are
2
enough
that probably
tn front
16
17
says
for example
here
frequencies
into the pulse
ate -
I the
In
(o human
go through
a particular
Ls wld¢
correspond
to human
8
sure
that
11doesn't
7 pulse count,
that tfs filtered
eba/ac|enstie
correspond
Then over here
6
lays
case
doesn
m the means
t
plus
item in the
Hearing
10127/05
00644
OO645
1 _c¢lficauon,
If:l wuc
a PIR,
2 means
plus fu_uon
clam
3 cov_
the PIR and
ecpavalcncc,
4
cl_m_l
to be a PIP,,
$
for htcr_d
7
claim
Infrmgcmv_L
8
Now,
9
at_w_
10
wnltCnlCXt
12
1_
13 other
14
t_t
I a_m'a_t
be t.on$1_d
over
Io
i'_we, whc_e
I!_
tt's
Hovor
askc-'d wb_l
_
andth©&awmgs
-
spactfir_mn
_e
desC:_l_ton
of the druwlngs
5
then
the deladed
6
de_cnbes
7
aII the ex_mples
The
if$ nol one
p=t'cc of lexl
_xt
and L_ dcawi_,
I_re's
And
(k_e_d_ - people
10
other than
II
prior
sclenufic
14
them
Of course,
tht'y a_e -
17
thcrc'_
&s_lon
18
c_vc_ng
the pnw
19
p_lmns
of_]_
20
they d_cn'b¢
21
clrcm:andd_fam_:eth¢_rcmL
22.
you're
23
pnOT art
24
The
_mg
ofpn_
art
wnncn
v,_
m t_
art
wnRcn
de_cnp_on
[fs not going
Ifs 8ou_
to be
to bc covcnng
d_.cnlmon
the
and the drawings
thcnr myth:ran
_ where
;h_
wh_c
show
the
_'sd_pomon_l
out and u_mg fo_ I 1_'6, not Ihc _u._lo_
- Mr
dc_:n;mon
}|lg_s
also
of the mvcwavn,
was
thai
_r_mn 8 th_
phrase,
Marlun_n
r_f_
of
Hisgms'
17
_ent
m se_achtng
Io find
_ it's just
pubhcatloJL5
a re_earch
patenls
that m'e relevanl
cases
t5 _.lk]ng
20
refc'rred
to Is wh_i'e you*re
21
workm 8 devtce
upl_t
about
into
to the
25
_e
the eardm_
to the J"_
nlghl.
the quote
0mrs
b_m8
thc fuz_llons
of a
irnporlmg
for ts the pro_lt_on
You
sin
of
Enter_sea
But th_pm_Jeuhr
- in fact
cl_am Io dec_de
Js
of
the claz_LS
All th_ sla_
fm-tctJon
_bs_act5
on Mr
thai w_5
_nd referring
caseth_tw_brought
24
abss_acls,
pubhsh
of commenl_
He had a shde
dectslon
to the
always
m'(
what
_c
supPoSed
Ih_ teat Io dc_cn_
thin you
function
to go
-- recited
Into the te._l and
Ih_ f_ctlon
644
Markman
Ileanng
10/27/05
Page
O0647
I
In means plus funcl]on _,
I
you look _ ll_
And
2 wo_ds of the clalm a_l only thalto dccld¢ wha; the functlon
2
3 ofthecla_n_
3 d_cnptlon
4
You don'l $o cbewh_e
and look f0_iL
Thafs alI lluac;_¢ _tm..dafo_ It'Snol
5 a_pllcablehen: bccau_
6
EML
$ the clam_
9 embcdm_em,
wl_re Mr
5
to the pre fer_l cmbodnnenl,
again, i_s t_n'l
(_on$
_t
m no clam_
$
even a _ngle
to mtct_0ret a mear_
we thoroughly
_ascu_ed
sornc qu_or_
Mr
them
here
unl_
made a - an eloque'nt
_t
about
Hlggm_
II
lea f, and a parson,
12 aclually _lls you to go to the Icxllindu_e _hc textto
12
reason
13 ;ntetprc'111_clz_n
13
nolse)_lnspc're_ol_ofl_tv_;orpools
14
14
m the clmm
Th_s
the statute
a & ffcrentc_accpl from :h_ co_celx thal
15
15 Phllhpa was dealing with m th_squo_a_on.
16
By II_ same
tohc_ the quo_
froenMa_r_an
16
th_ th_
why
scr_c_
a parson
thai argmnen!
t5 the motion
Is became
o f a pe_on
19
and -- that argue
thaL Andtheonlycas_theycouldfind
20
that would
for an exceptton
21 d;umtng.
21
parucular
22
22
0tat we
19 p_3_.e
of the cl_ams. again, thaf_ lalkwg alx_t gene_l
claunmg.
Ifs nol lalk=n_aboulm_ns
plus funcuon
The _la[ute.as I t..a_l,
tellsyou I_ go l_ok al the
23
specification_md look a_the d_.cnpuon
24
how to interpretthose clam_
25
concept
inotcha to d¢clde
23
If; an cnmely thfferem
Markman
Hearing
10/27/05
Page646
Mr
24
least
25
& florence
idea that t_c_" _s a spacla]
argue
_
Mr
_luaBon
have
_e
Hlggms
the CellNet
excc_lon
admits,
there
for
are no ¢_,
in the -- m thts
and
M _m-Tcch
d_Ilngu_shed
C_Lso_,
Rapar and Paulus,
two ou_ of fl_ee
between
o f them
se_r_
I hellO,C, all -
sa_d that thor's
means
Markman
JA 1942
the
to do thaL
elecUomc
cas_,
we're
or object.
a PIR plus
18
Ii_ :sth© func_on
ned a
W]3al_e_u_$clt_tng
17
parlo f the spac_fw.a,on do_
and paoi,
of thai, the
nol
d_:np_aon
18 d_la'mt tl_ rightm exclt_.
The
ts ma_hcable
the - It tak_
ctrcmi_
h_
about
and no_ a pool,
not a leaf, and the point
And so thaf_
f,clect_on
thc corot
;rodd_
17 wnmm
and
i!
the PIR only
gm¢_'al
plus fum¢_ o_ language wh¢_
the CcllNet
l'mnot
any further
I0
I I lang.._a_c,
not mca_
patent
p]te; fimctlon
It)uSldoesn'trnakeanyse_;e
to ad4rcss
9
me.m_ plus
I0 fun_ion language al all.dus _ lalkmg abo_
that would
at the te_t ofthc
looking
m order
1 fl_nk
7 going
abou_ hrml_g
_oul
has
6 MagniTe_h_mdLmea_andApexc_sesmomb_ef_
of pat_mt
H1_ms'_hdctal_
DESA
you from
prohthlt
4 c[a3rt_
has dora: nothing of the tort
In lhc quotauon that- II_ cardm_l sm
7 co_mumon
20
It
at it fo_ any purpose
purposes
19
the
00646
tool
look
like techntcal
They
]8
22
Page
Tlul_
if you wall. at least
_s simply
don'_ normally
c 0_q_Bon
look
10/27/05
and
invent=on
8 out Ibc invention
I tlunk tt's -- a coupIe
16
23
Hearing
0_e _awmgs
of the
embodiments,
so Ihe abstract
for re_earch
15
16
m the5 --
_ a b_ef
that desenbc_
d_cnptlon
ofc_ln
It's a handy
13
s_
the_e
and
_rL
12
_J
The
IS m the body,
fo_ example,
the Weferred
9
_" the
Io m_ctpc_t
patent,
8
AndsollZI6.youlookmthcp_cnli'pcclficahon,
including
4
is _©
Th_'$allp,wlofthc
mv_[ion
in the '066
a
_ a spaclficatmn
Ihe pal_nt
of the
3
m $copa
15 - that dcfea_
Andl'_ouldtaken_uew,thL_
2 d4_cnptlon
be jttst a PrR.
_ ould be dlffcTimt
And
q_tlon
no_ the
wol.dd
-
_'gtu_c_fl.
Yot_
to th_
clmm
wha_
t[ would
dlffert'ntlallo_
_
cI_n¢_
And so the fwo clams
6
then
and sensor,
tlear]ng
al
no
con_ol
means
10/27/05
Page647
645
OO649
OO648
] and conlzol
To
2
They
3 legal
slgmficmw_
4 though,
that all meant
them,
arc nol lawyers
And
I don'z think
e_ ex really
6 t_ofart
Andltw_
THE
COURT
$
MR
COOK
thin t use it in normal
A comment
14
the change
15
ofthe
16
mou_,
17
chorused
_c
ofIR
v, I_ we
d_opp_
report,
wzth
;hmkmg
_
that pxcx_temllned
21
thmkmg
about
22
mot+on,
th_
We just
has to _
and
that,
thai
from
Phtg]ps
7
functional
8
there's
9
about
10
prevent
that
nOl outside
any
structural
I 12/6
flora
if you read
Mr
15
ts a vet-y skilled
16
this
being
they
Htggms
made
His job
and
v*asn't
to take the claim
thai requlrcmc11L
and
so we e]mzlnaxed
clcmenL
st_c_"
tt o_lv
has r_le_ _ce
Hearing
10/27/05
He "7._n
22
of IR
Page
And
that's
jilt
wlfi
whaz
;ill pOml
_e_y clearly
CO_L_
about
the
m thai
And
t - his job
the
re]table
He dttin'l
24
claim
-+ I*m sor_
25
build
somethmg
just
-
tf the patent
language
from
at
the
DESA
Hisjobwas
and
app]y
zt to the
that w_
at the cIazm
the clrcml
a look
_ _.
to evaluate
m a way
look
Massengdl
H e took
Rapedsclrcmt
he thd that by -
23
person
w a_n't
Mr
Professor
1 -- Professor
to determine
ctrcLut
the change
element
experienced
smctly
from
m the claim
Mzsscngdl.
21
but on
of
-- where
formal,
some
Professor
20
that,
I 12
I 12/6
direction
Imean
selection
ent
funcuon
_mpo_ed
them
clrcmt
sugg_ts
_here
then
prc_ em
in a non
plus
language
19
the
thai _fi
thai _ d] pr_
stnmtuxe
the means
of predctc'rmzp_tzo_,
es
format
-- it has to be purely
any
vahd
of morton
tcTm "cormo{e
sa_d purely
Ma_se.g_ll
we
of funcnon
Just about
14
why
function
applymg
hc sa_d
delvers
ph_
of sm_ctwc
I$
condmon
,I, _ e rcalzz_d
that safeties
very
¢lt_nent
thagrmn
and
or the
the text and
tt
Markman
648
Hearing
Page
10/27/05
649
00651
I
"[_e e]rc_ut tha_'_m
2 a c_p_t[or,
3 _
an op _nlp,
has no -
zt s _;_,_s a _zst
but tt doesn't
say w_
Andthosevah_scouldch_nscar_
thfference
m the oparatmn
So ratha
5
_tzon
b_u3_
I to treat mea_
_,
;alu_
they
thalcouldr_kea
- Mr
- be used h_
b.uh
Evans
exp_enc¢
not a
]L hc _zh
as a mohon
one
de_cczm
9
And
IO
then he co_ed
_he_
11
that d_phcatcd
tbe schamauc
t2
vulucs m _-
13
And
the11_
simu[alzon
k_ st mu]_zo_
down
to _sute
thai the
_Ncctad
patent
_all
office
6
application,
7
filed
AS thr ;tHhe
re_fl_
paltm[
expaRs
t9
Mr
20
address "_ ere z_suc_ _
m_ o_
21
_nenee
ol_ce
paitczso_
those
O_
m h_s
v_ues
he was
getting
m
thafs aCrL_Hy shown
else
think there
vv_
any cont_;t
are
between
co_cemcd,
Michael
I don't
Thasz
and
Tbetssuesthalthaywerehamgaskedto
L_ t]_
The_
23
Office
24
and he _ _ _
25
Donebon
He e_ted
pat_lt
has
parent
ralat]_
worked
the ma_uul
a_ the um_
- m other words,
m som_
-- It v.as a major
two years
before
m.stz,n¢_
Mr
writing
15
that bccaL_e
16
II1 both
17
c_t_
elazxo_
an examiner
o11 patent
d_t
exammmg
the q_tzon
how
ts the patent
Marknun
Heanng
office
going
10/27/0S
Page
a very
in claim
18
The
nottota that Mr
19
his w_ttcn
20
hghong
hghtlng
statement
that w&s three
Thasz
JA 0943
he
a
year_
w_
filed
with
argument
m
you shouldn't
do
says,
legal
seemed
tnthscnmmalely
COX_OL_IIC_
and
m fnngement
office
Carlson
said
m -- 1 think m
testimony,
you had
the patenL
wc
re;It fled as an expert
to be a
saw thai
here,
had
no
expener_e
Mr
Rapar,
when
he was hired by DESA.
24
or st;< yea_
as an alectncal
2_
sup,ef_slo_t
of t124_motion
cngmecr,
d_tecnon
Markman
650
his
"means"
or m his
who
beln_
which
-- there _as
application
specific
to tmdet_tand
Paulus,
_weryone
mterpretatlot3
m tbe patem
23
pr0_edu_e,
of
a_ Mr
and
22
m the patent
It has
expart
decision,
issued
the word
And
tha
of
apphcallons
by comparison,
14
- both
and
to tL and
Paller_on,
2 } Professor
_
event
the continuation
to be thai -- ha uses
bo_
of the
(phonetJc)
that eventually
13
exammanon
exactly
the sequence
the timing
and
and the continuation
given
the
told you
chazacter_ed
e to tha DoneIson
lot of pubficzty
dmmg
He
those
In the file hL_tory
evenlS
] I the claims
have
with
he aco_rmely
And
5
l0
thagram
here that now
used
the circuit
18
Mr
3
9
and
on the sobc'ma_c
thagntm
Masseng_ll
and nc¢ something
22
he _ as mvol_ed
12
15
17
iI to show thai i[ wodced,
vaJu_
Professor
14
_
op_Med
charm
he _ as there
S gazd was
8 '0m_der to select the values
p]u_ frmctzon
2
4
of the de_ ice
h_-an g',,'s_'esmgat thL_ SinCe ha W_
detector
7 fiz_ wo_
16
5
standard
13
O065O
6
a low er standszd
m other _ords
applies,
mcarts
to bc some
h_
MarIo'aan
4
-- or Io_er
12
the combination
Is whal
and that's
0_re
sorm: sort
pr_l_crrmnat_on
The
there's
4
pr_umptlon
u_lng
sought
the
v, h_e
isn't
3
17
always
20
25
tha re,erse
I I cas_s
PIR dcl_ts
- _ e agree
sort of -- the_
24
context
wLth the czrcudzy
19
szg_a]
oth_
It has
thaL
[ v, _
23
the patent
thai because
M_mgl}l's
zs v, hal
was
It's a
]anguage
Professor
]R -- change
that
And
out of_ny
on the reaso_
m IR
here
do this
by selecting
It
18
Lawye_
no rm_mmg
to be detected,
a ;_
_gmcers
anyv,
_here
2 somebody
to say that,
-- ¢l¢cmcal
use the term meam
ing_'zlo_
alr_olumly
13
fo_ them
lt*slav,_cts
10
12
I
thing
6
7
was
_zme
",_ord "me, ms" h_s
[ think _n
dam _ngm_rs
5 or anybody
9 s_e
The
t_
placed
secm'31y
Hearing
be'd
m charge
had
fwe
of
fighting
10/27105
Page
651
0O653
00652
I Froducts
2
there, _
he _
Th fre's nothing
_n_c_
I
or IF th_ palf_l
2
v_ lymr
h_n_
irl this claim
3 thaireallyreqmr_tbeexIx:x_eofahghtmgexpcn
4 t._ _
t_km.g
_b_t
I_mc'ns
_
fo_
5 thai sort, v. hlch Ls what hghtmg
6
Now,
7 lmXee6
the - whal
from
h_e_
exl_rtS
9 tdonttfied
t0
and t_n_
4
of
We, of co_,
beh_e
and _zed
01al Mr
_al
6
HOW would
12 intcrpzetatlon
and thal ef,.s_ ua_ly all of
the cotul charac_nT_
decision7
13 the ppmlon
I1 scans
thai the cot_
15 relevanl Io the ** a p_JlZCU]_ clam
16 th_
Its claim
to me thai in this case,
should rcf_" to the -- to t_',¢ portion
14 c_rcml thafs been ulen0fied
Ls the sw._ture
element
ts
and sta_
thai [he claim ¢tememl applies
tbe_
Io,
17 plus equlvalence.
18
And that _ otdd be _e
19 efficzen0y
to ch,u_tcn_
20 Thai would
21 would
I f there are odor
24 no_t
25
pomons
say almosl
of the pa_enl ts stncdy
cnorely
a d_p_on
Markman
be
w_thoul
of
Heanng
So t]_e text O f the patent
play m wntln8
9
thai though
a 112/6
10/27/05
Page
block and iJ_e
we could
_4"the ¢_c_t,
II
tdfnofy
the
12
thai _pphcs
use a formless
of the palest
to that potion
the master
15
all the claim
16
ga_ e h_s SU_
17
stJucture
In the
elements
charls
20
I'_
21
o f the clrctut
_s
thai jttSl w_nt
appcr_x,
24
apphed
25
palent
_pmlon.
Idenufied
whcth_
and idenllfied
to them and
n w_
sttpponed
here,
by
not
wa-s the sen_
i_owded
be one way
would
through
he stud it was
al_x_t_thx
_
of
and th_s ts whal
to ch,_Jct cr_
wh_l
ppmon
_s covered
And then the thud
23
the
and thai
a leuer
instance
second
thai have
sugg_llng
amend
to al_o
that b2_ been
and _$1_ed
Ofh_
And then
mt_
t_ identifying
of the c_rcu_
or not, in each
color
come
I should
and hls ch,a_s,the first c_al, _as
clam_ charl
19
c_tx't
Pm'haps
_ w _'d]d be _p_n_',e
pouon
14
_lflly
pp_moA
the -- m addition
pe_hap_
1_) po_on
22
of the spe_ficauon
be relying of_ theft those mlghl
Hov, e_ ez, the - I would
fa_l, the _1
it
specific
23 that the ¢.oust wc_ld
*nto saym_
You don't have tha_ kind ofd_scuss_on
8
t8
mosl
under I 12/6
pass musWr ai the Corn1 of AppeaJs became
be ve_
22
way thai I 0unk
the - a doctslon
comparator,
t 3 Profe_or M_scngdl
o f the
decul_
gel
text
7
11 _6 should
M_ser_ll
thera thai _ppc_r on the targe chasts
11
I_n'l -- It thdn'l
really
W.ste_l of a window
5 comp_alor
deal wth
should - how shouJd the court
8 be applied to the claim elements
2 ctrcm!
So tbere
3 In adthtlOZ_, We COUld chartge I_I ¢:ornp_lor
We
_es,
thai figme
be's
8one
-
the third part ofhts
d_ough
the loller A m this
spe_tfication
the patent
instance
that dm_cn'o_s
and
of the
this
Markn3an
652
speclficalJon
to the po_on
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
653
Page
655
OO655
_54
I
2
So that wotdd
I 12/6 opinion
3
4
Wtth
abom
m EML's
'.bat. You_
I am _
of thmgt
All
I think eve_hasbcc_sa.'_
MIL HIGGII,
I0
THE COURT
IS
No
funh_
rcbutt_,
4 have a cle_
setof the binders7
5
MITRAKOS
MR.
12
th:.cu_wh_
13
_curatcly
14 we
_flected
wo_d
p_ef_r
15
a_ma_yselected
16
_
_
17 -Mr
or Tuesday
7
dad kind of all--_nd I
Mr
0_1
as _l_led
enough7
20
be_k
Okay
by what
Okay
(Break)
22
THE
COURT
- the b_
o_
mMr
Dr
imd red.
the tler_
t3
and
14
_
W© do _
raid you we needed to have a clean
24
MS
w_]lll_Sk
Masscng:II
bebev_
Dr
Markn_
MS
M]TRAKOS
MR.
We
Andwchavemarkedonc.trstoo
HIGGINS
yore
Honor, we also need to pul
tothe box of goodies d_re tl_'_ m
fionlOf MS. Jones
THE
COURT
16
MR
17
Tile COURT
Box
HtGG]NS
I _ So g9 '_I be "_deo
Tenmmu_'_ak
of gcoth_,
yes, the actual
Thmglthntl_tha['s90
That wlll be, l_ohably. 90, yeah
Why
d_'_ we rmsk_ 90 the plam_t'f_
19 ap1_ratus and 91 the defer_e ap_?
andw_lbe
20
MR
HIGGINS
21
THE
C'LEKK
Which
- we do 11ol have - I
22
THE
COURT
Are they both In lhal box'_ Are
se_of the bmde_
23 thty both Inthe s,,_ac box7
as c:¢_btts
Sbe has gol. [ thrulc, tbe on_
Okay
1.5 demonisation
_'stest_n_ny
Okay
23
Bnggs-Jonc_
COURT
12 a_ exhth_tn_thct
M_II
WelltakeaWnmmuleb_eak,
2t
25
D_
f_,ts
II
_. • _. e_e
_x_d.
T}fECOURT
19
closing.
Cazison's
the corm
THE
I0 _les_ you have a clea_ set
_p_by
a_d p_csc_ted
C_tsm_
1_
Bcfor_
thec_
We're going to rcqt_;!
8 tl_nk we have allc_om'bahzed them
bul I thd
Go abead.
HIGGI_S
MS
6 permt_slon to n'._la sel m Monday
9
II
[he vld¢o thaiyou
3 But before you leave, please make sure she's gc< - do you
_3 _lk
zt well
l_beenalc_tgdwcedays
8
vo_. and then she wdl mark
2 a_e going IO ft_n_h _ 89, I gut,s you sald wa_ the ntunber7
H_,
THECOURT
doyc.J?
I supplemented
_m appropriate
wew
and om of energy
5
7
a.tso be part of a -
tha_ you
have
||¢_Inl_g
10/27105
Page
24
MR
HIGGINS
2_
THE
COURT
Very wen
c_e t__Inch7
No. thafsjust the plamuffs
That's just the plam_
Markmau
6S4
JA 0944
lleanug
ffs
10/27/05
OO656
OO657
I
THE
2
T_IE COURT
3
b_,
4
THECOURT
5 gotng
6
CLERK
Okay
I ba_ e bad
9
h_,¢
l0
Chaxlts
had
Carnal.
And
anti
14
paymg
ne_er
I thank
been
dun_
expert
_sststance
for making
to the Court
him a_ rulable
to me
and
for hfm.
]5
16
beltnng
17
head
! 8
m cot, strums
helpf_
to me. as _ as the Matkman
In terrra of all the expert
amf the =guments
19
_
DSSA,
t_;tlraony
for nee_M
that I ha_e
background
and
asstst_nce
cla_m.s
the plamttff
20
for mfnngtmaent
21
ufl¢d
22
number
5.598.()66,"
23
as ha_e
the Paints
24
m thsput¢
here,
of fore
"A t_ o I¢'¢el
25
seo2_ty
v,htch
at thts
arc Claims
Determmang
has sued
mdel_a'xtent
system
I'll ref_
to as tbe '066
The
I 0 and
,._berber
and
Costco
of tbelr
hghtmg
bemang
6.9,
EML
claims
patent
beanng
clmrm
Patent
patent,
that
temmn
I1
a Pattnt
clann
Markman
has been
tleanng
10/'2"1/05
Page
a jutT,
8
coa_oxwd
9
tn frmg_nenL
Tbe
furl days
]2
accomp[a.h
13
the clmr_,
puqx_c
major
16
and
17
word
18
means
The
_ bether
of thts heanng,
held
"_ theh
major
_sputc
t_ch
19
Code
20
clement
21
means
22
the r_ttal
23
thereo
24
coreespondmg
88
spec:fica0on
of law
h_e
Secuon
I 12/6
m a clmm
or step
for the
m caeh
that uses
c_atrrts
which
l:,ro_ _des -- and
a cornbmattoa
claim
--
the
Umted
m
States
I'm quoting
- *An
be expressed
ftmctton
as a
v, _thout
or acts m sttpport
shall be construed
structure
claim
arc written
38
may
a speetfied
material
of
Cotwl
ts a c[mm
of those
for per forming
_ as to
-- the f/rgt
so as to m_oke
of smtcture
_ :m
has been
tem_
format
for
f and such
again
ts whcther
each
there
the construction
the r¢]_,ant
-. wbethet
ptus function
or _bethr_
w_th MaW, man,
thai is m d_s_pat¢
_me2axs"
m thss
as ptop_ly
two steps
ts a matter"
thspur¢
fact-finder,
v, thch
m accord_¢¢
ts v, bether
claim
we
a jury'_
the claims
_e',_ct
the first of thee
The
I5
Okay
I'e_d on the acc_cd
I ) three
cta_ms
1 behcv¢
"tes
wd] determine
I0
bert,
material
_md eqm_a]ence
to cover
or acts
h_
described
in tbe
thereof
3,1arkman
Hearing
10,'27/05
Page
657
Page
659
OO659
1
So the first fomg
wbetheT
3
Sectton
It _
actually
5
wesumpbon
6
that's a quote
7
deCtSlOtm of the
8
me*
the Co*a1
| t2/6
weU st:tiled
4
9
COURT
656
OO658
2
COOK
case
- and
Ha_ e you all requested
MR
14
II was vcay
trial
THE
J
car;nccong
ha_ ¢ a jmy
7
of tbe thsputed
the facl-finder
5
Dr
at T_e¢
m elec_ea)
and sco_
6
beanng
the beanng,
appomled
FllsLthcCourtmust
the meaning
Second.
4
construcoon
Markman
and
o f in'anem¢
the ixam_
TbeComtls
haanng
_ ho ts a Wo fessm
construe
3
m m_ mind
of my cottr_
Um_erslry
be has
2
on the claim
be fr_her
io the _
the a_tstancc
/ t Tec2mo_og_ca_
13
tts dects_on
Itwdl
-- lmo_
a_ ay'_
Allnght
ha_ e had a three-day
8
12
went
OurswmattoDen_er
to oralb/g*_e
We
I mfrmgedm_olvestv.osteps
ycc_rs
COOK
m this c,xs¢
7
Okay
thai a el_:m
the "._ocd "me,ms"
118,
tha Apex
ft:_k'_d
the peesm,aptlon
I0
Ar_
I I v_otd
"ratans"
by ¢omz_st
t2
Sect_ontl2dc_nota_ly
)3
"t'_ea_"
14
He'n:,
15
"means"
16
rebuRed
17
18
nonethcleas
19
or rtmtemd
20
the
tbe
23
spectfv
24
clmm
25
bxlfflclent
Pam_
agret
"meara"
thai does
Is used.
_to_ use tbe
prestm_ption
thcuseoftbev,
drams
al_hes
use the w ord
a function
stngt_¢
tram
rat.bet th_
may be
but
Court
t uactmn
wber¢
ftmcuon
u_
the lerm
"mea_s
etth_r
the clatm
_
for
but tben go_
the means
The
th_
14
structure
and.
15
presumptton
not
the
tbe cLatrn
Heanng
10/27/05
So
Sectmn
I 12/6, _
t9
mcam
20
means
658
LSwell
thinks
rebutted
that dectston,
feder&t cnemt
w_thout
that must
23
sp_lfied
In the
24
thereof
ArMthat'saquotefromtheOlCorp
Actor
ts hmttatmon
thngly,
once
mt has hoen
Markman
JA 0945
m order
¢o apply
that S_'_tlon
to pertmt
use of
of air the possthl¢
apparatm
be paid
of the c|alm
_cnpbon
denotes
that the
was intended
recitation
that corn emer.ce
'_ ntten
to
tbe
souctwe
has stated
be t_sed in a clmmed
price
e that
finds
on from
the
the
the ¢_atm
_eoolt_
the Court
documented,
that might
Ho'_ ever
as a
And
funs tlon
not been
expressto_
that by a
In the c L_rrl_
not find Ix'rsto.sm_
therefore,
the
clatm$
thspute_
of 1¢t$ within
recited
does
h_s
at these
ts not elaboraled
matmal
moving
appbe.g
to demonstrate
dsal are
22
25
Page
looked
the p)amtlff
112./6
18
h_
the
Courl
Ja_guage
I 12/6
the
or _ct.s so
evidence
that there
_tlrely
containing
matcnal
that Secuon
the clemen_
s1Iuchlre
!_'r forth
21
=,
ot_ to elaborate
or a_:ts w ithm
Markman
or where
fmds
tc'm_
stricture
ts on D F_A
the Court
notJmt
ftmcntm
clatm
sumclcnt
of the
]8
17
st_ct_re
of the ela_med
a ¢la_m does
matmal
9
16
rtot LLSe the t_rm "means"
r_-ite
the burden
And
whole,
12
c¢d
The prt_umpuon
lawformancc
a com:spondmg
And
8
tl
the rectted
that the
as to rehot tbe presttraptmon
I 0 suI_fi_enl
that
ways
ms rebutted
"means"
enttrely
contends
6 pr_ondcrance
2003
_on
_. hea
3 v,o*d
5
collads_s
presmnpOon
rectt_
g 3d 1365.
both
term
foncuot'_
to _sc_dbe
Con_ er_l),
22
And
to per form
DF_A
4
6 apphes
a re_utlabl¢
a ¢la_m terrrt do_
presumpaon
2t
Io the
on
a rebuttable
"_,hcn the word
a clatm
trigger
fo_owmg
r_ht_
that
ttself
2
7
so tim ptesumpaon
Wh_
325
l think
all of the d_'puted
m _
revokes
Paragraph
Thin
L_c_lrdJ
I
clremt
apphcs
wdl
hmltatlon
case,
That ts not m thslmte
that
ts
a_hes
that Soctton
from
has to daod_
and
for me
of
to the meat ts
eqmvaltmc¢
case
datermmed
Heanng
that the
10/2"]/05
O0660
OO661
I sccuonapphc_.theCourlm_tdotwothings
2
:dentl fy the function
3 explicitly
recited
4 corre_pondiug
5
ftmcllOn
6
the function
g
function
tmrecited
and
that
pcffoms$
then
that
I
to the
fi_t
not permit
step,
identl
ficatlon
by adopting
a function
And
"l'ne functionmttst
that
comes
m factcome
However,
with
regard
to the second
to par form
13
ideate fication
of the structure
14
Court
to the
15
-- the written
16
palenL
tesorls
17
And
per foml
20
determining
21
descnption
so thal
19
d_Cnplton
the Coutl
I g carefully
the
must
rccllcd
what
al issue
file st_ctufe
I$
Spcclficahon
23
or pr_ecutlon
history
24
slruct_c
ftmctlOn
from
Micro
9
and
finthug
are
to be read
IS corr_pondtng
to the
So moviug
structure,
should
clearly
13
to the claimed
14
usually
paris
oFth¢
15
to
the spool
ficatton
or _._sociale
that
r t'CltCd m the claim
on to the actual
clanr_
that
arc at tssue
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
17
the spco
18
clear
court
m wew
because
analysis
wews
n
and
also
Is which
to m comsttumg
makes
of the
COl_haactlo
close
kinship
claims
n vcl'_ clear
is
these
clmms
thai claims
spaclficatlon
of v. htch
is always
n analysts
between
IS enforced
ficatton
concise
The
with
aS well
of this
reference
highly
and often
desert
and
claims
bed
exact
ate
they
relevant
thsposltlVe,
language
description
and
24
constntctlon
25
And
most
the
I/1.11
m full
are
a par(
mac to the claim
ahgns
mvenuon
Court
in; cation
to be cottsistcnt
they
that stays
naturally
of the
dcscnplion
requlrcmenl
tetras
of which
The conSlrUCtlOn
22
the claimed
to be construed
the sp¢cl ficatton
23
the wntlcn
by the statutory
with
the patent's
will be m the
lakes
mstructmn
end the
from
Markman
660
correct
the Phdhps
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
661
OO663
O0662
I case
on the
2
The
importmucc
plamllffs
m this
tried vtgoro_ly
has
4
appaa_
5
abstract,
6
the field of the invention,
7
maybe
] think
8
very clear
9
which
l0
get
begins
to the
] I speetfication
which
13
paten[,
summa_
m column
the
to which
the Court
the
2 of the
which
starl
co_rdel
17
mt_l
refer
3 ts m the
of the
19
specifications
20
the clam_
that
palenI
patent
are
and m tzymg
intended
to fulfill
22
and
not. mozco_er,
23
embodiment
24
The thagraxrts
which
have
played
m delall
makmgrefercncetoFtgurcs
6
make
go_
tt
we
I0
to
to find the structure
he w_
plamtttTs
re femng
to the
detaded
the
are
before
we
appropriate
to find
function
to consult
the smzclUre
of each
describe
spectfically
an Important
Markman
jttst
figures
clear
d_¢ actual
12
So I'm going
14
really
3,
15
think
And
to both
17
visual
the text and
The
first term
20
to said apparalus
clatm
21
The
22
Masscnglll,
23
The
24
condition
this
10/27/05
Page
For detecting
patties
25 too[Ion
heanng
reso_l w_
through
notch
JA 0946
pro_ Id¢%
tt became
2B very
parcel
closely
2A and
ts the
predetermined
-- de fcndanl_'
which
prowde
a
first sensor
condition
exlcrnal
6
witness,
Dr
to this as "r' in his malCrhtls
ate m agreement
_s defined
constn_ct_on
2B,
up the structme
to be construed
has
say that
bul [
fie,It:on
In my ¢Imm
thai make
has referred
and
of the sp¢cl
the thagram.
a first
below
embodiment,
Thls IS a ICnn In Claln'i
de fenda_t
relative
that process,
as what
that the
is self
first
defined
Io said firSl s elL_O_recaP3
51arkll|an
fi62
Andthe
this patent
A -- 2A and
be rel'emng
¢lemcnls
was
pan throughout
my innlal
of a pre['erted
H'S pail and
that
2EI.
the description
to put it one
more
means
and
below
lext
19
2A
notch
that Rgute
so I wdl
for the
Ig
as
drawings,
and3
to find out how
in going
I 1 track
16
is described
1.2AandB,
these claims,
to me
patent
preferred
[leaalng
However.
pretty
m construing
mthvlthtaI
the
to the accompanying
one
-- a
m', enllon
for the function
it -- it's a hide
at the
get to the clair_
reference
13
d_cnption
all of this material
structure
that the pro fervcd
of the present
text description
9
7, Is the
that
with
in co.truing
7 to the
g
tmtd
2 states
5 Cot_rt puts the drawings
dcscrtpaon.
and
in cohtmn
when
views
21
does
g
4
and maybe
here
in column
embodiment
the
ts not enough
detailed
patent
preferred
which
[none oFhl$ argrtrn¢:nts
locolumn
And the Court
18 beginning
here
-- in parl, the specit_cation
in his ai_um¢lll
mad column
2
to. oh, maybe
Ivsi_mony
And =t thd not c::w.apa my notice
15 itself
was reremnB
c_e
of the laventton,
bul thai
law and
the description,
claims,
tn thts
the speclficalion
of the
the
the case
that
- plamttlT
to limit
at the begirming
and
I Tile
o f the spcctfication
3
25
The
and the
21
the Court
disposlllve
16
19
in the
link
makes
Phdhps
patent
cited as
disclosed
some
hcanng
And
Ibe slracture
The
20
structure
Court
oFthe
needed
ate
the
10
the
on the law
Matkman
as a bit of a tutorial
12 are a parl, _md the sp¢cl ficatlon
function,
features
the
for the Court
us through
what
the
background
it pretty clear what the Sl_'¢lfiCallOn
8
prclty
Markman
16
kind of walks
that
inquiry
structural
tfth¢
the
relevant
that
function
To determine
25
limit
only the
step,
c_¢
from
fromwithmthc
:rod all parts
and all the
22
[4
6
II
12
Phllhps
7 makes
I I claim
12
the
plies
hLI more
case -- 1 know
Phillips
5
of
oFa means
ddl'ercnt
The
4 here has been a tutorial
particular
the hmttahon
a htdc
I dothat
g
ideals fy the
the
here - let me give
2 before
Is
claim
recTled m the claim
C_t¢mieals
means
claim,
in the
dccs
claim
P expheldy
10
in the
respect
7
the
structure
sol thzlh
With
_
Fffst
predetelrnlncd
In Claim
ofa
Hearing
p¢/_on
6 as
or
10/27105
Page
663
C_46t
I objc_ sqr_'L_ _ram _d
2
SO tI'Z_S
_lmIBS
I ptef_t¢l"ml.ned
no dsput ¢ ab(_/t wM.t C[r_ d_K"rm_r_4
2
whtch t_ d_ mo/xoa ofa pe'_on cr
_ntht=on
I'mC0,_t
ohJ_O-
thcre_aKm'_['/
Yo_allagreeon
3 _a_
4 scl_¢,%_i
_
v.h_Te the palm(
$ own Ic:_l:e_althcr_
6
And _1__'_ee
7 to su_
9 _'_m
I0
that the C=u_
tl'a f,.mctlon of _ _
g prnd_m'mm_
cmath_n
m ¢ol_'a_
c_M.*.
4
w'nter _ acm_g _ _r
finds m the lcxt
ex_=J
7
Io s_d =pp_r_
3 .qth line 24 aed g_
3 _aclm_*elopo_'c._
Tt_
ts -
to the on4 o/
4 _&n_lth]me
Ox_
finds _J
_t
THECOURT
5 zt
mtm'e s_uem _cn_
9
MS
;0
Ttt_CObrgT
II
MR. HIGGIN$
IZ
THECOI_RT
16 Iet_n
I zPagomE _ _r
s Cot Ib_ t:_.zus¢
17 co_slc_t
_ s_m'_ to bc _
19 to th*l_
20
I'mgomgtor_"
APd t_ pmm=_ _
s_cr
mcar_ f_
dct_%mg a l:rr_ele_mlr*_[
2_, _-lumnd to stuff_I:_aml_,
24
II
-Iin_uf_ll,
2_ _r&lmn
20
M_IlcSI_CI_m
whI_il _
In CI_
22
9 I0
_t_l
_ _
_ _qmv_lenl
m the (i_t
tleanng
10¢2.7/05
Page
2 flltlsll=l_
t_e I_e_._tl
$ M_il
th=t _e
has dubbed
6 mcaru _
7
o f IFe d_wm_
dc_ccung
"fh¢ _
a _ccond
_
And
And ;o _he _nc_oa
find5 _
13 dffe_t
coa_
_h_ _nd
tha_ w¢ m_
to s_d
_olarrm
aFp._a_us
LSthe
3, _na 21 tl_0ugh
¢o_omn 4, hne $
MS
Hon_r?
,v.r;_<os
Canvoun:peat_aI.
Yoar
IYa ¢_
THE COURT
24
O_m
25
add to thai "_d
I1's the szme mlmg
A and ClaLm I have
Cxacdy the sar_
as for "1"
mhng,
_d
[ v, iu
_qmvak'a_:"
H_lrm=
10/27/05
Page
665
2
_
3
THF ('_31 ]_T
_[GG]_g
I don'tth_.8't_'e
4
MS
MITK.a_OS
5
"v_
COOK.
6
"rJ_CC_RT
Page
667
YO_ Honer
Okay
_'s
_m_c£
Tn=,'sco_.
(_kay
Tl_scl=mr¢_L_
C._at_ot
8 fi_l
=rodsecond sensor _
9 hl_
at s=_d fi_l
_o¢c_uang _
to sa.d
lamp to crml
Icx e] of ttlm_u_z_on _n the zbs_ce
o£
_md the _v_'_
The
t¢ anly the photocell
thai 1_ mclm_
tu
7 ctr¢_u_ me=ru, ¢ou1_1_ Io :s,ud I.unp and _pon_vc
prcdc_mland
aL_tara_
th_ _m_re
ra_,lm
scr_0r
Tl_aol
I I _r _ for d=_t_g,l_caJly
12
_ second
pr=dc:='mm_
on w_l
8 ca_t_on_z._ltha_m_hram=
10
_
of
0O667
I CCn¢¢L l=th_t ¢_';
I_ dr_wm_
J
m _
m A fo_ dct_(m$
Markmau
mounded 1"_i_us Fin of
_e_t
landA.
that the str_:[m¢
e.on_ _oo _
664
C_666
Anchn lerm;
fln_
dl=cnbnd
th_ng [ jgst d=scn'b_L
23
th=F,_agn_u_al_=dmmmmcd
Marl_man
1
the (_Don
21
c_{hbon
Thalwm
And _al_o_aofth_c_Ja_rl_
I _ pr _;1_=mlnnd
to lae m z&,'_e_me_tLh_ dze
wluchDr
ye_
Wehavegotagce_-m_"__
And so {11¢Coral
19 sa_e
We do, Yo_u Honor
Mr Hig_lr_
the sl_lmlr_
17 s_pon
°I"
21 next_mt¢cor_m*_d,
2._ A
16
most
z_d c',c_bndy
Ig caIJmgthe_ethm_d*ffe_lthm_
"_e-youa_r_dodt
¢_m I:¢: e_nsln_¢lt m the sam_ wly
1_ mgkL_g
to Dr M_=*gtll'_
Wc had ,_ m,L_y dram _
MITRAKOS
I} mytraw_o_14 _¢,'*:1b_:
_nd
Okay
$ you_
13 the $[ru_lm'¢ for _r._mm p[=$hl_ the ttmcl:zoB of _m flml
15
(Counsel m_ves he=d up _d
6
d=&ectm& a re_t
I I the top ofcalBzrm 4
IZ
HIGGI_5
L_l_r
11 second Fredegwmned
_ff
12 sud Itmp
and the
_he _hoc_e[1
13 m response Io _t¢ctlon
and 9"_
conditma
to cmtt Itsht =_ ;_d
_d
_c_'_d
_o_¢.x_q ng s;ad h_l
-
I¢v¢1 of iIl_z'_tn_o_
ot's_ct I_rtl pr edele'_'m_n_
14 ¢Ondl_O__
t5
At_
17 ccn_ly
"_'_lc.dly _'u$ just m¢:_
&c[n't _mde_tznd
in plain lar_t=g¢.
it at the begx_umg of tht_
I g p_uc_ndmg, thai the _t,m_ o'_ _s the m _q._ _or ca.u_mg the
And [ w¢._X tO rind the texlt,_J rc f_'_c_
19
20
_l=t
t¢¢olt.u== 4, Lines 19 and 20.
KI
i/ap_¢a._mCla_m6
"I_e a(_.t d_
21
is wh_
23 I1_1 wl_at Dr '_Lss _nglll
Z4 9, I0 _cl
t t, m _u_v_t_¢
Dr
19 I='._p to go on a( zcccr_ I¢v¢1 wh=l thc_= m no mot=on bm
for t_tL
Z0 i_s tha';= or dusk, snd th=t g,omg up to the h=S]x= ]_e} of
x,las_en_pl)
_ef_
21 _ummaaon,
(o as
laid:is C 1 which occ_l
m_d th= _;un¢
_,_uc'01 _elI_ve is 95 pm'c.=_ m _poa._
22 detect=on of the _o_ma
Andtheparaesse_'atoag_e¢
23
nl Clmn_
24 for
the same claim
go Ih_'s the plan la_gunSe of wh_l were Iookm_
And _e C_x.n finds thudthe slzuct'o_e that _efi¢_e_
25 thai fuecnou or c_rn _ 0u_ _
Marlunaa
tfe_rtag
10#17105
P=ge
666
fu_c_on
Margmau
JA 0947
to
of a p.mson or _bj¢cL
ts found
Headn¢
10/_7/0_
(XY_8
OO669
I bcF_'mmg
at d¢ boltom
2 63, bngmnmg
3 thffcrcnt
the words,
d_csho)d
4 ¢ndm B wlth
5
with
of colmml
vol_e
5 m the middle
"AI nlghl the photocell
to _¢ar
co]mnn 6, Im¢
ofhne
I the accent setting allot a s¢! ume intfrv_]
causes
2 has b¢_
_ node 61 ," _,ld
14, the end ofdut
3
peJo_ph
6 bc_nmng
of the pangraph
_d
th_s ts the
6
level
7 p_paph.
8
9 provide
the Sm_tmc
10 Mass_ll'sKI
for th_
andCI
I ! D_ M_c'n_]]
"_e
which
_d
f_ncuon
of_e
d_
Ag_,
AndtheCo_t
dl_vc
12 tl_s sl_cm_
13
thai langu_c
clcm_ts
mclu_lcd
to co.true
L¢what Dr
14 c_db K2
And,
15 thts clmm
because 1 _hcvc
16
_ the COnl_Ol ctrcmt m c'_-_ mclud_
17 Rsponswe
18 c_th_]on
19 michel
to d_cc_on
o f stud f_'t
me_st_cmcm
m_d r_ve
20
_o_ c,_sm8
21
I_¢1
22
p_edclctromcd
_d
24
25 s_ctm'e
f_rst
_o stud seco_
co_mon
m i_m
lang_c,
d_u wdl bnng
th_
ncam
a
_bout I_vmg
the romp go b,_k io
Markman
Ileating
10/27/05
Page
1
next clam
2 Ma_,c_IL
Th_
AC vol_¢
6 d_
_lows
8 dc fc_m
st,_
_
14 bcgmmng
fm_
th_
t/¢
m hnc
exceeds
And the d_pam
L_
21 -- pan ofth_
Now,
once _mn.
sho_
ngR_'nent
Does
scrambling
to
iI*s the -
and it shows
th_
red and blue
Yes, you
THECOURT
arc correcL
ye_
And,
Mr
HIBglrtS.dolhaveyom
on thal one7
MR
24
THE COURT
HIGGINS
You
do, Your
Honor
SO l don*t really
need
zo eonsWJe
thai one.
d_t
th_
Iteating
whal
which
_ r_re
Dr
M _¢_111
1 I_hcv¢
2.5 not rmed to coP_t_c
tl_ p_tc_
_
th_
_
4 sa_d AC
volla_e
"When
o_1 cn_
"_thm
to bnng
I0
m
II
d¢
"also
the
atxml d_t
h_ve m
_ po_ ofth_
mc]_d_
ruction
wl_
as clam
are m _¢¢mcn4
] ]3¢]1cvc th_
of Dr
10/27/05
I
C3,
and I do
10/2"//05
of each
_1
Page
669
the tcxt_mJ support
Page670
DO_
MR
HIGGINS
14
MS
MITRAKOS
15
THE
COURT
16
_ dcfcnb_
17
for each
hzJ f wave
18
mltlaI_J
in f_pol_e
]9
point
would
angle porho_
be colm'nn
5, hres
next
to det©cllon
6
_'mh$
d_?
YourHonc_
conect
Thars
_
I$ CL21_ E, wPdeh
a ramp wa'*e
of raid AC voltnge
a ramp
of the z_o
fore3 h,avmg
pulse
which
is
fxo_$1ng
wave
The func_on
21
ai2_thewo_:l"mcans"
22
_ung
23
wave
24
t]_a_ ts mmaled
25
crossing
a vol_e
_n_'ySL_ of
_nybodythsag_ccwlth
m Clmm
E ts the underlined
tanguage
Thc-dttslsthemeans
valymg
al a constant
for
ra_e for each
an elcClZlCa] link ofhaJfa
w avclengLh,
at a urr¢ co_¢spondm8
Io the zero
sI_
and
of the s_8_ wave.
Markman
JA 0948
tomy
Nothsagreemcnt,
"_
of
-- on the thagr'am
as m e_ L_thf p_uclng
for the half
cycle
to the
accmthng
with tJ'_ scnI_ce,"lnput
13
Io be
half wave
that C3 includes the p_sc
16,¢_'_thng
mt_r_
mc&'ls
of the plault_ ff wlUI¢_S¢_
and tho I¢_uroony
having
clrcml
al I¢_.Sl atA:oldmg
M,_SC_glII
_¢es
And
ti_ough
20
clmm.
Hearing
portton
12 _pphedtothcl_mp"
_ the
just the mac
Markman
for z selected
And
control
9 block on the -- on the dcscnpUon
to bnn_
vo1¢,_¢,"
d_cntxs
3 actualed
8 everyone
_ found
",Hhcr ¢ m _d
£or causing stud switching
means
7 ht_ testimony
_hom
the p_mcs
the _
|l i$ ..vgfd£d
include
5
The
fumuo_
slz_mtmc, and the de fc_¢
22 hay© dssc_b¢cL
of
needs mot ¢ than th._
1"2," that that _s the dsscnp_o_
_'_
24
C2,
m both
Yes,
23
2
a swteh
! 3 wtth the scm_ce,
the thn_hold
Ig
23
COOK
6 tc_tlmony
s_¢tmc
accomplLsh th_
¢pcc_fic_t_o¢_ of the suuctm¢
20 co_mc_
is b_,ca]ly
to bn_
flmct _,_
17 _'_t
19
appl_ca_on
of Im¢ 25, m the end of the scnt_c¢,
the.hold.
f_J_
MITRAKOS
MR.
I
Whcrczn
m e,_,s f_
Su_ t fi_c _c
th_
And d¢ Cowl
volt,_e
_
SO th_
the $_tm_
Io _compl_h
12 column 5, bc_n_mg
]6
Hc_e's
Markman
to ¢_th_r be on o_ off
ff d_:nb¢_
fun_o_,
sw,_t_
a_d p_c_tmg
pl_nu
I I about IJ_
t3 ramp
COURT
MS
by Dr
m th_ way"
toc]_cs
to stud b_np
the L_p
"I'_
Io
meam
ix_rm m_
5 _d
9 fu_clmn,
IS C2 of - as ds_bcd
one _s dcImc_tcd
comrol c_rcmt
4 sclcc_cly
7
turn-on
OO671
TI_
3 _d
If you are saying
668
O0570
_d
th_s funenon
We are quickly
of C2
And tt's outhned
agreement
of
hzsana]yststst]_
w,th that7
20
25
thai the thagram
that the on umcr
I 9
22
hcr¢
12
that suplxms
MITP-.AKOS
THE
funcoon,
21
rec_crc'nc¢ of
6 through
ngtced
look fc_ a p_clt_¢
18
Ume
of _,_d um¢ mtcwal
m the absence ofa
I:_detem_d
B_,cal_,
16
17
cmlt hght al s_d
,n rcspom_
co_,cm
MS
I$
mca_s
ofa p_cdcl_mmcd
to thc_._cr
have
,s the slraclu_¢
14 anybc<ly &sagr_c
predcm_mmcd
to cxp_tmn
hmp
of tllu_Jn_
23 s_Jd f_t
the parUcs
poJll¢_ are m _rcemcnt
_o_ L'ut_tu_
4, hnes
Mass_zglilwzllshowthatatlcast
13 mhthtl
actu_dly, I think I don'l need to comm¢
d_
cohmm
poszbor_
for thts and thai It's
And th_$ is K2, and I suspect
12
Ma_scngtll
to accem
of time
9 basically
Dr
ATId
the lamp back down
agree on _e str_ctmc
II
a rn_llon
I][U3_L_,R_IO_
my analy$,$ of the p_ucs'
Acd
I0
within
thai bnngs
8 tha_ you
that is Dr
findsthcdm_mlsby
are the s_nc
next clam
Th_
text to
mew
after a $¢1 period
7
The Cour_ conscu_
UP I0 the hl_tt_
IIg_
5
ends m Ihe end o f th0J
motion
go, tn olivet WOrds, _t'S in aCCL'_31
mode,
4 L_(_1_1_
Soltstvvvvvvv_romorfi_chncsdownfrom_e
a_ff
detected
Heating
10/27/05
Page
671
O0673
0O672
l
That isthe funclion thatwe
2 sian_-'mrc
roy _d
3 cohmm
the CCCLq finds the stracrwc for _
Dr
5
Iv,ohncs
Cam._amr_gbt
6
docsthat
DR
CARNAL
I w_n't
8
abouithal_
That
THECOURT
I I - dc
DR
sounds
n3ht
Youw_pcd_psz_cdout
m thlsroom
CARNAL
THE COURT
15
DR
CARNAL
16
THE
COURT
Yes,
And
Yes
I mean
_and
ma'am.
18
The next clam_ to be coraixucd
eqmvalence"
on all of these
ts what
Dr
m the absence
22 and a second valt_ In response
condtton
to detectlon ofsald
25
_olmgc
to have
for cattslag
the muu mm'n
in the
a first _aluc
Ic_ et of
absence of a
Markman
Ilearmg
10/27/05
Page
_
2 thzrd
_ aluc
3 sa_d
hght
4
for cattsmg
dlTc_c_t
scr_m
So th_
5 -
_
ca_cs
value
from
g
t_rd
So de
bcmg
hghl
and
external
absence
function
14
dayhghl
f_netlon
The plaml_ff
photocell
17
a_d de
elements
is whal
scasmg
apparan_
-
Dr
means
responsive
for detccung
tths
_s in Claim
the
presence
is fo_ detecting
16
the
to
the presetw.e
of dayhght.
So the
13
to be consmg'd
to as H hghl
to sasd
46 and
bc included
maintains
l I
"['he
;rod absence
that it Is simply
The defendant
maintains
of
the
that tt ts tl_
photocell
resistors
And
persu,_l_
the
c
Court
finds
that tt must
ftmcllon
the defendants'
include
the
argument
rcststors
20
for the
here
for the slructure
21
struciuretsseto=attncohmln4
hnes
22
equl,
mote
_s well
And
as -
that
19and20_.nd
alencc
And
the
24
M_.sengfl[
25
c_rctut means
lasl clatm
refers
to 13¢ construed
to as C4, wh=ch
mcludng
Is what
=s m Clazm
respons_
mear_
lMarkman
the
_aluc
_rm_d
that
second
th= hght
ts bas_cany
from
values
I
¢, hen
dayhght
bnngs
of • oltage
first and
sens_
s_cond
to ha_ e a
the demcc
to have
_aluc
And
ftmcuon
13
21
mth¢lraddle
14
r_ct
potion,
Court
_mds that
ts found
15
fromtheneaddleof21
Clam_
5
tt_
mcthdcd
yeah
DR
there
8
there's
the
9
swacture
4. Imc 21
Dr
I l, saad
c IO said
hghl
Hearing
10/27/05
to the
tl_
one
Page
do_to-
I think
12
tgo
through26
the
a,ff_er,
m that
ot
and the
m the pathos'
d_ram
poslt_,as
on C4
of what
,s
smu:ttm:
20
Now_
21
pm not st_
I'm going
22
_,hat
cl_ama flus
23
that's
_ eW clc_r
to go through
I sa_d m what
clam_
term at_c_s
ot_
-
, and
rr_c
for c_h
h_ghhghtcd
15
figunng
[ want
parag]aph
19
5, hne 6
20
m
21
to make stme
23
24
DR.
CARNAL
Your
25
THE
COURT
Ycs _
Honor "_ Yore
Markman
Honor7
Ilearmg
10/27/05
Page
W©ll, ffl'm
JA 0949
--
incthdc
-- I may
you
That
m tv, o colors,
stud
-- went tal
have
_t only
w as my questmn
so I'm has _ng a hard
CARNAL
Accotdng
4
to what
It s the bcgsrmmg
nghl afl¢_ line 55,
and
mclud_l
I have
_t
hmc
Good
I ha_e,
Okay
tt
of the
It IE'i'mlRa[¢_
DR
CARNAL
[ thought you s_d
THE
&ffetem
tt jttst
COURT
Then
Good,
1 mlstmderstood.
Included
In COh._'l_
that'sv,
hatl
Well,
I'msorry
two hnes
[ had fl marked
m two
colors,so I appzccmte your correcting thal
Markman
674
I I,
"means
halfway"
on and
but I thought
"P/IECOURT
24
25
of page
Yes'_
that state_,
reach
I go
11
had marked
22
that
one
form
Did
CARNAL
you,
DR
18
because
It $ de
_ave
start m cohann
would
t_me
CARNAL
here
tha_
out--
17
of these
of page
the bottom
my ov, n notattoetS
TH E COURT
14
16
cqmvaleac¢
read
bottom
on, e on
asked
hn_
13
That'sm
that 1 5ol con f_scd
The
a ramp
DR.
nusunderstood
that goes
You
I'm dmkmg
top of 5 u
11
_d
senlence
Forgtxemc
tha! wa_ at de
T1 [E COURT
to supp<m
It's
and
COURT
1 touldn't
for producing
"l'hcdayhghtdet¢ct
.t'sjust
That includes
shows
THE
7
wall bc no
ago,
the cla=m
6
I I
19
about
of d.ay
at all whc_
thc
In column
ltstarts
k and
16
18
3
CARNAL
a _hdc
10
t_
that
17
quesuon
a third
when
DR
2
4
abota
of d,W
II
12
ts dctaclmg
level
vohagc
and
Is the s'l_tlelm_
the mmmltml
means
threshold
s_ad that
8 mcm_
th ffcrmt
h_at
sald
_
ftmctltnl
7 I_,ht sensing
10
II
claim
refers
shows
value
of
ksfound
3g dtough
the dluslrauon
a second
OO675
I $¢nsmg
9
and
of a person
mo_o_
46
thai _ould
672
00674
6
hght
23
predctcr_ ir_d c_th llon
IS a mcan.s
I0
19
vollagc to ha+ c a
0f sa_d predetermined
requlrc'menl
of the
38 through
And
The next
MasscBglll
18
to _s G, means rcsponsp_c to sald sensor
4, hnes
m there
9
15
for causing sa3d fimt _cshold
Th_
descrthed
12
Your
I wltL add th dat "aad
athnce"
value
¢qtu_alence
7
8
Just the two hnes9
I 7 ¢qtu,
20 means
6
II'$C[;um
ItsthCbORom
]ustonemomeal
14
t9 Massenglll nffcr_
In column
_slm
arc
cB_ ironn_nlal
1o the sensing
"['beSIR_ClUt¢ thals upporLg thls fnnctmn
5
I'm sony,
Honor
24
object
4
I_sl clz_m on page I I
12
23
3
It'sjusHhc_e
E, andlbchcvclt'sjustthctwohncs
first
m rcacl_o_
foi]o_ mg corrc_0y
9 sul¢ halfthe people or more
21
2
soundnght'_
7 Yore" Honor
t3
m
4, hnc$ 55 and 56
4
I0
I predeterrnmcd
must find the
Ilearmg
10/27/0S
Page675
673
¢O676
I because
2
00677
m om thscttsston
the same
markmga
about
thaz, I know
that you
had
Wehadeoffcsponthngmai'klngs,
3 wantedtomak©smethall
had that
rlghL
I bccn
5
Now,
the parties
I'm going
7
many
thffere'al
$
ended
up taking
9
appear
10
constixtcUon,
II
plamuffs
because
ways
In the
plamtnlTs
v.htch
rchattal
announced
al the end of thas three-day
4
ha_ c hcard
many,
THECOURT
17
M_engdl's
18
appca_
Thal's
correct,
Okay
19
6
20
appcan
[ha[ Dr
"I" chum
9,
very
and
m Clam16,
2t
9,
The K - sorry,
10 ai_d
Lsml0andll
24
m I[
MR
COOK
I think
COURT
And
G,smlOandll
So those
m¢ the chum
Markman
THE COURT
afier thzs ndmg
MS
Is n a cert_n
MITRAKOS
yr.$.
telephone
oedcr say thai the
20
filed
60 days
_
then
=1'$ dgpoSnl_ve
22
THECOURT
Thof.¢
Page
we
SodaesRstale--I
Do_
d_posltwe
the
mot_or_
case
wd]
be
Fm_.
n's export
reports,
and
motions
Okay
certain
AIInghL
number
MITRAKOS
of days
That's
676
Buttheyar¢
allu
corrcct,
Markman
00678
thd have
whal
my mlmg?
MITRAKOS
ofra
MS
o f days
d_m_
or me, Itnd I don'[.
THECOURT
all keyed
25
10/27/05
set any
con felence
Okay
thal in rro_[
MS
23
I have
Hearing
thscus_¢d during the
21
at_dC4zs
that
nm'_ber
That's
n=s,.agem_t
E
we've
or somethmg'7
19
Htsmll,
beheve
W©haxeagreedtodeadhnes,
should have
10andl!
comtructtons
MITRAKOS
18
C3Lsmg,
he
Honor
17
is m - term ts m Claim
w_l
we't
appoars
I!
I
so
hts A chain
m ClaJm
al which
testify
case. I suppose,
] don't
16
24
2_5
MS
that
go to that phase_
¢_ for any of Lhal, have
Your
heanng
15 aprovlsnonyoutakmg60days|onde
AndtheCIclmm
K2 claim
of this
Will we
THE
14
but
phase
an ord_
and conclusions
wlinesses
gay thai Dr
I I, his J chrm
C2_mClalms9,10andll
23
|
experl
8
12
claims,
my froth nga
7
13
these
many
molnons
10
Ho_0_
w_th hut then
qmckly
appca_
I 0 and
Your
gave
HlsKIclaanoppeazsmClam16
m Oam_
the
by re ferenc¢
the next
thsposlove
9 daadhn
Soj_slfo_easeof
M_sscn_]l
to go through
m C'lam_
112/6
adopts
And
6
that they
I 0 of, I behev©,
thal was the chart I started
1 jusl warn
I
so
II
HIGGINS
the Iclt¢_
16
226
alternate
on page
claims,
_ anous
m the ordar
p_poscd
starts
MR.
reference,
are
5
and
be isstang
3
aid of
charts
I wdl
for
brief
13
15 added
to these
these
for the
claim
to make
snmply
Sothankyou
and
so many
to refer
- and
12
14
lo go through,
there were
upon
2
4 thai corr_.tlon
6
called
andl
th=s ruhng'_
Your
Honor
Hearing
10/27/05
Page
00679
I
THE COLrRT
So this ndmg
nmnmg
2
I would
sta.q yonr
3
vafi just
b¢ ¢mmng
4
re fexenc¢.
5
Anythang
clccka
a brief coder
was
today
And,
that adopls
¢1s¢ that we ¢_m do today7
6
f_" yore
¢xcellcn!
7
totally
$
Opprecuae
all yore
9
pta3x_e_
W© arem
presentanons
_ehens_le
made
and
l
I
2
yoo
all
something
- fulfilled
ILEPORTER'S
3
Thank
You mule
=I was
as I say,
so
by
to me co_epTehensible_
work.
today,
1, BEVERLY
and !
r¢c4_s
"BECKY
4
for the Umted
Sta1¢_ D_smct
5
o f Ttranet_See,
with olllr.cs
6
its
E
CERTIFICATE
That I reported
7
the p¢oceedu=gs
8
2005,
9
LLC and COSTCO
I0
Ti'tat the
a¢ctwal¢
v_th the
thrm
c=tlfy
25, 26 and
IP, LLC_ vs. EML
hexnng
2"/,
TECHNOLOGIES,
CORPORATION,
was
Repoxter
Dtsmcl
machine
couat c_ Oclober
W_OLESALE
m cora_cuon
typowntte_
Corn1
do hereby
shorthand
Thai a manscn pt o f p_ocee_,
! 1 Ill,
12
at Nashvdle,
of DESA
Officaal
for the Mnddle
on the stenotypo
held m open
m the malter
_ COLE,
Corn1
Case
Vo[my,¢s
I through
_-dm:ed
to
No
3 04-016_,
by me;
foregoing
transcnpt
n$ a trac and
record of the proceethngs
Io the b_t
of my alalls
and abtht=¢s,
This
the 23rd
BEVERLY
Markman
Heanng
10/27105
Pager78
day o f D¢cembe%
E. COLE_
Markman
JA 0950
RPR
2035
CCR
Hearing
10/27/05
Page679
677
°
Aprli
6, i965
I_
C.
I_ILTI-LE¥_L
Original
.,,, 77,_..9
MORTON
LIGHT
Filed
COII_OL
F_b_
IO.
!
•
1%0
1
_.,
|
I
A
C
I
•
9
_
nz
"_-_1,
•
t
FIG_
_----_._i
la
L_
_
I
_1
I
o(I
__
I
A
AC
SOURCE
f_lG.
Z
\
A
O_
z.
I /j,z¢
I /,;:b
-
¢z4
ROBERT
C.
MORTON
INVENTOR_
ATTORNEI(
Defls
14
DIE-00521
Page
JA 0951
132
United
States
Patent
I
3,|77,399
Ot ce
Pa|enleC]
Apr.
G,
IDG5
z
As
by
3.177_x9_
MULTI-LI_VEL
Rot_rrl
for_ia
LICHT.CO,'S.'TR
_iorlorc,
C-
Io¢lcwood.
Compufcr
i'fod_ts,
Inc.,
=_d_r
Dot,
1o
r_)'o
O
_ppllcal;_u
_o.
3,047,773,
Feb.
I_,
dared
1_60,
July
5rr.
3|,
Ca_l_
i_o.
|)61.
bul
u (or-
rocnls,
S
7.9Z_.
oow
I_v_ed
DppIIc_;oo
4 Claims.
fc
b.
16,
(CL
196Z,
Sir./_o31.5---201)
wbc;c
li2m
;n'.cE,
p
rclalc$
K
)_r_nl;clocn!
$_]lC]b;fl
d;spla)_
of
hal;on
a
I;oo
Ibc
axe
kind
used
divi_m
17S,72
L._mp_"
._r_tbcr
U._
f_n,-cmcnl
of
lo_
>1
bclwcco
The
diffelcnl
_o
aaJ
rc_l¢Cl
15
of
;am.p
d_ccOy
l;mc
_1c1_,
in
_o
25
x_c
xo
20
Ihc
I_mp
dudng
[ccdficr
c_t
1be
bclwcc_
Icalizcd
for
cur_cnt
_nlr--_val.
_,ou¢_-c
/or
of
LSc
com_lclcly
an4
_
Ibc
by
t_c
__ooeoe
._nCc
1he
a_an,o'_n_nl
of
_._
the
during
k_'_d$
level,
tamely
a chan£c
i_ i_ci
a
or
-]_l/-to_c"
I;r_c
flow
;_vcct;on
in
Ihc
IZ
00
lamp
and
prcC;ably
con_hicms,
b_l_ccn
mo_¢
1_
d_spl)ys
be-
change
)
in
;_
duri_lg
Ot_
the
all
full-loot,
Ibc
human
c_c
_Wilch_ng
_J_c
i_c21c[
s;n_lc
;_
40
con-
condil_On;,
_cJod
an
(onvcnlional
• ,hcrc
of
chan.rc
allcnl;Oa
_m
by
th.-
than
is
lamp
nccl
_t _lf-_xc
_cl
the
g_'.ncrat_on
-
-"
,A
ot
at_anGrmCnl
Ibc
thc;_
level
i_
the
stri_n_
Io
level
ia
_
IhJ$
04
-
a_d
Irm
t.
15
and
"* .....
tcslSlIvc
ad_nl)_<:_
Ib4;
Of
,_ttCtJ_c
two
clon_alcd
Ihc
at
Wo*;dcdmU_
In
Ihc
rcfclct_c-c
•
-
apl_n(_cd
senglc
tEar.clots
lamp
flaxh,ng
off.
[ulI-Io_.
and
FIGURES
i:_n_ccalcnl
a
2
_a_,;n£
and
and
aotoma|tc
Ic_
shoe|
:c(c0
In
o[
hkc
a/_angcmt_l
_ali-lonc
_
conl_oI
3
Inovidc
r I
0
drawmf.
of
a
pa_F
, a
I_Ulalll]r
I_11-
iUn_i.a-
illumi.lion
the
in
difference
ofl
from
haff-to_c
In
I]_o_ninallOn.
I_rovmclcs
26,
20
Ihlcc
d_ffclcuI
_s
disdng_i:,hcd
10
o_
FIGURE
clc.__nls
_0
and
22
is
l_om
I
in
aml
=1
fixed
ZZ
one
Each
I_iwely.
am:l
In
2g
22
is
movat_,
Co_oI
(I_
bcl_ecg
30,
211(I
L_,-_r_lallic
¢r_l
tb_,.c
of
as
maL_q_
o(
3Z
and
cl_nl
o_
34[;
I
$.
I(;
20
I_
a
funcl_on
c,r
al_
and
22
allc_l]ng
brc_kinl_
_cspcctivr-
34.
is
strially
_cnl
ckmcra
2 •
L
t]r
ca_n-
SOOICc
38
_
_
U_C
Ic
_t
.......
paten
..
I_kc
_,
.I
I_CL_
7._
,o
IO¢
I
t_
.........
I_-_all_-J_
==
a
_clcm
1el-
p_ov_mll.
anti
1
cXI',CClco
-- --
AI
of
_s_:_y
lamJ_
:O
al-
_q_OVl_C
70
ar_
;_
12_p
---
one
the
lamp
14,
led
thc
lamp
i,,
"--
E_3ch
COILS
of
" a_c_
1¢5.r_|
.
Ir4_allc_.
*
I1_
--tn3l
.
Io/
-*
._
bl
;hrOUl_
34
of
I_.::-
£
I_,_
_n
2Z._
20
and
In
FIGUP_f
clcClr_
f]r_l
IhlOU_lt
beating
Ibc
COd
dlodc
flow/
current
through
one
36.
18
I_
Ib£_/
and
DIL-00522
JA 0952
n_
dc_clcd
JO
_;T
ff
#
#
scspccl_cbt-r_cgall_
_13
clc-_.;_nls
limC
H
co.
I
_O$1_On
o|
co
" b;
h corn
15
g
a
|C
the
c_
mp
.
_
_
¢ 000
m=t31l;c
alrangc;nclll
Ihc
1hen
" _,**_
J
alt(_
I"
.'--*
:_nd
lla_
;_lanl
COnlrOI
IZ,
3Z
1_oh
0;_<:o.
g;vcn
•
and
30
3]
38
.rt_;_UrLg
Z2.
clc_lr'c_l
n
oF'C_t'_n.
I*t
no*'m._lly
illu_A_aliou
IZ.
'_]_c
c_ct=_cal_
.
.........
and
lamp
lamp
¢ffcx:l_v-..ly
_.
__ ..
"
_:" "
UIg[I
:. --_-_.'-I
;tnd
lee
;ec;mBc3c¢.l
coancclccl
10
.....
and
IS
_.
.
.
=cl_z_c
*
-
bbm=_..i:
G_.
Of
In
2g
and
COolac/s
of
Each
ly.
60
palls;
at z_'.hcm31;c
cha_:c
a
5all-lone
atrang_,_cnL
......
_c_dc_ccnl
the
c1_mo££e,
dcmcnL_
24
clcu)cnts
Two
rxmp
afr_n_crr:cn
fla_hm_
_
_.'mclxll;c
l_-nl_ratolc,
mclall;c
.
pc_od_cally,
lamp
pcg_o_c
corholllnl_
h£hl_pc:,crn,
c.
_c
palcnLs.E%.l~Saa.t3.00_.O_l
cent
31)
_uch
OI
two
_o6s
minals
14
or
hal(
wave
lccG_r
.
. ..
_.
l/co
io(_l_c_cnl
c_p0_41rc
;tn'J
a
in
[all-lOne
arranZcn_cnl
COuhol
of
o[
foz c__ampl¢
_" " I
3
I ¢c
',c
conlrO_
inlcln_*l_,
dls-
a_ra_:-
]4;_-1
ic_lcncc%
i_cUl_r
Iocl
fla_hmg
lamp
I_-mclall;c
50
en
__
nall-_arc
off
arran_cm_:n(
i.l_.ns_ly
on-off
eludes
.....
.....
.-__
dr_u_o_
tlmc
_2
12
mo;c
II_
o_
I_-al.
or
lamp
and
co.-
lamp
1be
cy_
Icrm;to
Th_rs
aud
i_-
d_
IlzC
diffc_ncc
human
16
and
_d
w_lh
condi6ok_,
clthcr
iUumlnz1_u
aml
12
_crir_
i_[-lonc
between
14
iolc.-ral.
"'I_c
I&
i_r_)dically
by
arfzo_cmc_Is
Illl_qll._l_llO_
tn
lamp
_rt
off
1be
Io
Io
_nd
complclcly
6_
tespc_i'_c
an
Ic_l.
10¢lwc£r_
as
_
inlcrvai.
l_vcl,
|0,
Icr/m_al$
Ih_
i_ con-
14
opcr_l_
diffe_cn!
d;ffc_c_L
10
s_l_l_nt_liy
IS
lamp
incaodc_cnl
IctmJnal5
tO
of
wxll_
_rzngcmc_t
10
_
ilh._mlnalioa
T'nc
I:_cl
_wccn
adv-ama_;c
u_c
_x
a
vlcw
oulli_cd
arrangement
I_lwccn
Bow
aoolbcr
2t
_
_oor¢c
tO
a_rmn_c
_c_cm_c
is
control
di/eclly
_cfcrcncc
peo_tdcs
c_sc
sw_cbcd
_cp:cc_mc
t'mds
x-
illu-
in
c0o_rol
x_
lO.
lamp
duxin_
_lumi_aliorm
dim
nc_Icd
i:om
cu_lillo_
i_vc_l_on.
In
c0nlrol
icc-1;fl_[
_lCminzllol_
i]lo.-r*_aatiOn.
sw_lc_
_
o_i
i_llom
o,ly.
Aoo_bca
mcnloflbcmvcnlionislhzllbctr_cofabalE-warcrcCti.....
_CI
fo_"
p4rOY_dl_
Ihc
_'COUCCd
h31f-tonc
....
on
pro-
:_l_racl(d
st_._ly
;nvcmion
is
L'all)c_in_
_oc_ccnl
.;a-
of
c_ngc
_ngcmco|
tbc
12
_
I.
i¢lcT_l,
Corl$c_ucnlly.
ap-
_um_t_-_
el
_cad_l).
than
ar_l_co=cnl
o_
;n-
lurthc_
and
ax_an_m:r.!
mo_c
Icxcl
a_--)oum
c_cn
Ibc
c_c_
;k¢
of
I;g_t
arf-_ngcmcnl
16
illumbaGo-_
_,
_l_r_l_n
_n
Io
{s
during
of
cmrcL_
cu_r,col
lad
thereof,
_
allrachvc
p_OV,d_
vadcly
porl]on
;an,p
14
Each
_ncc
in
col-
illumlO.al_on
ckmcn!
by
l_C
na_
Icvcl
_tumi_-
Off" _d
lh_cd
co.'_rol
coc.-,cc;
o[
d_s-
Is cflc_cd
chance
kvel
FIGURE
a|l_F_al_ng
lamp
tlom
Ih[cc
ful_[oe_
displa¥
!i:hl
wbcic
an
IO
the
_lcr
lampconlJol
coavcnliooal
flashing
I_m_
a-.Tangcmcnls
dispI)ys
cqpe_aticn
m
IhxouBh
I(._¢
a_
i nlcr_l.
bc_cca
hall-lor_c
and
-_uilciu:
Wov_d_
_o
Cbanlg;n£
¢vcn
co_lrollcd
Of
plm_
cl_-_cnl
of
chanL'C_
b_lWCcn
off
of
d_flc_cm
IL_L_g
Off
such
bi-mcL_ll'w
da_hccl
bc
dur;ng
d;ffcc-
_tcr_al
_ro_;clcs
of
30
o[
dcr;n_-
{u_l_cr
a
diffcrcnl
haH400c
an
I lhc
acr_p¢
oac
=l _J(-_*ac
_._ffcrcnl
doing
uoiqucly
_il_or_%
ad-
_milady.
a_-ocording
illur'..;_._doz,
the
ful]-lon_
_cn
only
not
_31_lcd
_cl
1be
dl_c_l;O'_
I'cduccd
Ih£
_d
_oc_
_ourcc
IbC
lamp
an_
example,
wl_)c
o|
a_l
Of
Ibc
Io
ncctcd
¢or_-
c_nn¢cl_g
lamp
a
du_;ng
_nlc_tup_n£
tween
=cladvcly
condd_oe_
to
m)_c
on
_ttr_cl_
c_l_ai_L'_g
FIGURE
c-Jrrznl
connc_g
cgccfin_
I_.mp
for
"_oll-lonc"
a
li_
the
_tlcrval.
_mc
il_urr_nal;OO
and
allc¢_adn_
I_;
¢_
ax_a_zcmcnl,
pfov_l_
m_c_
n_rnl
Ibc
Of
a;tcrna_n_;
mcan$
1"01- plov_n£
lot
d_splays,
_
lamps
tbc
to
In
_IICI[_-
lwtlchtrl_
wh)Ic
In
_.vilclunK
Jo
1he
by
var]dGg
is
af-
;l|um;nat;on
_u
ob_-cls
lamp
Wdo(lic
al_l
•
allr_ctloo.
0sod
use
the
SO
_h_
mille
an_
_
cx;c._;vdy
c_(c_ing
eye
bY
an
s_lchmg
coo_id_
;ocar.dcsccnl
Ior_n£
¢_hanccd
;0.
_ovlslon
lamp_
lcvc_
old
even
bc_n£
In,_,_nd,r_'c.",(
L_mp
cf_cCl_.g
by
_m_
folck'O;n£
n_lJn/_
the
;nCandcsctnl
Ulum;_atJon
cm
is
_ndcs,c:¢n(
manner
on
p, ovkh_
bcc
arc
_cntiOn.
;Jlum;-
February
for
mtt=aclcd
_c_ddy
by
3.047._7J.
;nvcm_on
Ihlt
in
a_pIIcat"o_
f_c4
m_c
tha_
"]_0_.
allcrnalc
Io
¢X1_c
for
I_)l
(:h_n_cs
Co01rol
lamps
more
co_Uol|_ng
lh_
7.926,
HO-
dlsp_aying
(albcr;ng
lamp
No.
L_¢h!
Fe-'_odic
and
lamp
o
Palcnl
o_cd
aulomal)C
pcr_od;c
i_
!
___ndc_.Ccnl
;a
aIICnIDOn,
-aulornalk
oow
L;oo
atUacl
app;kallc,
c nlilicd
tucil_
1be
C_tmas
d_IAay,
_ulom_;Ic
an
whc_cin
In
ol
1960.
In
cTc
loci
_hLU_i_m_.
upon
_cs_dcnlisl
l0
Tb;s
hom=m
illumin_lloo
slcad]'
icllcd
e_cd
th_
amd
t_c
;n
C_ll-
_,lc
Or;_o_l
P_|¢n!
know_
bs;£hl
OL
c_l'd_
i_
= cl_angc
Page 133
-)
3.1"_;
hcatl._£
¢c.il
_._
._ _rc_l_l)"
_
h_h
qucnllyo
r_k-d.
g_c'_.t_!
f.on_on
_lcct_c_I
_ltc_tin_
o_d
tcxmau._l
cOtlcn¢
¢_cO_cl_
lustful
_rcc
14g. through
it_tgumol I_o_ thsough
,cl_|
con3u_llon
_hc
14_
I;.ow_
I__¢o_gh
the: lamp
Ila:c_l.
-lllux,
it is scco
conlio_touffl
control
also
61
36.
b¢
Allot
to
Io
tbc
:1 clog:hi
there
is now
CuiTCnt
no_
n_nl
20.
though
then
_a.'l r _-_c_¢
flow's
L-JI_'¢_I
ilow.
conl_.c_
Z8
! I)
Thu_.
aM
set
ol
tl_
k
t_c-
clement
:10
la_p
drop
1 Z, at_
hali*t_asc
1_ is
olbcl
c_y
olbcr
1_
fir_
_t
to _o_
ckmfnl
clo_g
,_
lhc SeCOnd
lh_ _.f_nd
set ol conlzcL_
3_ _nd
2_4.
_rbcn
s¢l o_ COntaCts closc_,
clc_rlc
c_rlcnl
by_sc_
_c.ating
_nd
coz'ls
valuta_
/_
and
thc
shorl
bl-tT_|_tll_
_i[c
bier.
:10
ol Ihc
to ils
bl-ractalli:
add
o_
clca_c_tt
t_c
Io tk
Altcrr_tlvcly,
20
cooling
b_ca[s
firsl
tI__lm2_l
if L_t_ad
of
of
_
the
thr_gh
second
tl_
fiBI
L_'np
ol
IZ o_ly
in
contacts
ilur/ng
short
while
ia
which
illumination
b_-mclalhc
clcm_nl
t-l-rn_la_;c
clo_
In
cltm_nl
its
II_
circuit
13tl_:l
ab_plly
foregoing
off
and
tOOC
I1_
_Z
may
20
may
CALs.C.the
,t
_l_l
ol
lull
ball
hall
th:tt
_nd
,llumin3tlon
to_c-
_cmaiu
I_
he_lcd
ol
illumin_tig_g
tor_
the
level
cognitions.
ilh)mirtating
co_liq._
off
illumi-m_;in_
cor_hlions
66
kycl
of
lull
Io_c_
tk
ag._in
laJnp
Ih/c<
65
30_
IZ
I:rc_
cood_L,
The
l_c
ol
on
_0
dl_¢'l
66
a coofiguralion
cor.la_l
l_a
Ihr_*
12_,
arranT,
c_nl
_avc
gccltfirrs
l;*_ps
mal:c
I_t_ccn
f_lI
tic,ignited
lone
f_ncc
c__ch
i_,i
_{
ma<tc
.2,
with
and
clcctr_l
Ihrodgh
IIIc
throx_gh
to
18h.
%Vhen
corlta_
A
A
thai
|_tl_
II
|olo[
|1 of
lot
A
I_
bc
o_c
a
t,[
_ccl_htr
w_lh
_n_
ol
in
fIGURE
_
_lzd
Ihc
_IGURE
II and
The
tot"
c_ch
outer
3.
d_rccl
Io
00523
_hvs
/
tl_e.
tl
tcxm_n_
¢ot_!_cl
I
COItC_l_ll(tll_g
3
;
halfol
/
¥
f
control
ol
_,c-sll_o_]
the
/
clcc-
the l_mp_
number
_ot,c'a- Kg. i_
Ihc
n_ovc-
t;_to_ch
cnctgi?_cd.
ioclod_s
1
draw/hi
nl r.atc_
a select+on
f_ll.
JA 0953
IJh:_f
62
tO a ro_or
to
Icu_inals
_A
l_-n_,_,nal
_(Ic ol _ch
ilh, m_all:_
I
show,_)
rCSl_cct
/
Irom
ar_£cmcnl_
O_c
(not
lamp
pcrfoxmlng
cOl.l_'tl_d
pzovldin£
3)
the
Ooclcwtsc
tDc
such
various
for
FIGURE
Igo
thni
b_l_ccll
tI_
on.
(FIGURE
o|
17_
lcrrni_al
so
to
glow
12b
cuHcnt
62
w_lh
in_tant
illu0nal-
t_
64, as is ooz:
LIRE 3 ) to N
to a mol_r
tutor
68b,
fc_d
iS ci_uicahy
d,_:cllon
l-cl_ccl,
tx:l_ccn
6_
is co.heeled
6_,
ol
for
I;0 and
Io glOtlM
I:?_ ( FIG
b_-Iliancy
hal6ton_
Ekctsic
is
the
"l[_c.
given
suc_liog
control.
a clock_
I;ical
a
or
to
_q_l 12g wnll
o11c¢
lan_ps
or
instant
Ic.rrnlnals
directly
I :a thlxl
h_
a tow
any
12c
_4,_c
to
a
whos_
hght;
a c__tLglj_cuit
in
namely,
at_l
of
at
k_cr
source
i_Tf-_h_
wh,ch
_*_cnt
fit_l
_nd
a pair
ts cormccto.I
ol the. L_.mi-_
.T_.._ _._L_i-
its
to
28
Io p¢o'_dc
1o_¢
60
la_nl_
kvcl.
light
current
l_h,
such
Ileal a x/n_light
_avcl;ng
by
"thoLe,
n_ove_l
2 i]lesl_atcs
al_:rnalln_
cslcrgt_d
b_:lllancy
._ollowcd
succeeding
aforcn_ct_tio_.d
to
dl_sts_tcd
dxfl¢lC_t
a
I_
is
t_ru
_rL_ly
a markedly
to
thcrc
IcXl3_l
at
At
arc
thro_gh
t_u:
A
tl_c
_lTacicnfly
chance,
alice-
_[Z i___y
whdc
_lomi_tlon
changed
an
ox _hc _c_ond
_oata_t_
to
o[
!c'_cL
po_llon_
FIGUItE
tic
ch_ng-_
Io of[,
_
i_l_m_nalJo_
12 is _ulom:_l_lly
I_iods
suddenly
55
glow
fIG-
programmed
path.
fu_l-
ale closcdhght
di_]play
i_vclatlon_
IZa
a_c
display
ale
_t
b_-
_am_
tCr
clcmcnls
glo_
('.vll_
b__ da._¢, olhe_
_llu_,fin:_lioa
w*ll
_or_lit_
of
br, lhar_w
ol
to hall
t_g_
an.I
I_h _all
_t a Jull-lora_
121
t.'_
flow.
l]ow_
_t clo_kwi_
of
I1_
th_
ca_rcL_'
c_l rent
and
3.
] is to bc
ol
a high
around
nation
fi_1
cntrg/zatloa
cycle
mox-CtDCn|
of FIGUR_
is
_ivcn
aM
I:lJ_reP.1
the
laming
level
_il_ulat:c
I_ling
and
brol_/ng
¢__c_.zn;
tone
ilL_ sct
frown
;_ _._n
12
half
the
hall
I1_
lone
bi_mctall,c
lamp
Itom
b_lwt_ca
changc_
/3rap
cot
ca_
toad:t/on
I/_
o_hcr
to,tent
D.c.w.
Conscqu=ntly,
! _ :_blupli7
chn_
|runt
fllll
op,_n_
is Ib¢
a cast
f,0
36
3Z and 31 _rc broLcn
still p_:_-'_d_g
Ib¢ ckc-
allows
tl_4_ _Con_
tor_c
_-_df-
co_
ocnl
the
du¢-
a conllol
mrEr_£c1o bc col.:.-cllc_l
there-
FIGURE
zllumhaalion
to
display
ula.io_
li_t
clement
clement
natlng
lamp
later
hca_ing
.:_
to
I1_!
I_o_,
cyc:c
clcmcnls
_Jiolhcr
to
_cl_cty,
ol lamps
inc_uadcz,
so
o£,posc
bi-_clalllc
is op_:,
accotding
first
eight
I_vo
I1_
-bac_
Ig
to
bolh
bl-mcla|lic
3 _pi_l
yet
Rcfcr_Lqg
zlockazs_
brcalc
when
Z and
by_
col3trolk'd
4_
Ib_
ol
with
c_frc_
appl, c_=/able
clcmcnl
3 gcpr_cnl.
arrangcrocnt
dl_a_'i_.q)
curoI
ol
o_h_r
Z anti
_d
gn
of
rcclifier
of nllc_naGng
na
_'.hct
parallel
current
cydc
6._
_cc-
ix Co_lcd
Io opp_
is
2Z,_.,
l_opost_on
ha
ecclificr
at
h:lf-_.:c
is coor_(lcd
hall
lamp
aa:l
ac_x.:,_'_g
_
allc_r_atln£
I Z_
Ib¢
thnc,
a z_o.'_
fi_sl
30.
illuwinal/on
1b¢
incsc_
Ib,:
shown)
UE_
rr_n!
cha_gcs
t_q_
cach
olhct
_h_
the
_nd
is illumlnal¢_l
ol
"_
Ihc
lamp
average,
ti_c.
co0neclcd
to
an_r*gcm_nt
g__oup
as__tcd
Z0 mzy
bl-mcl_lhc
seth
every
-:O
k
aJ'tangcmcnl
Ion_
bn_llizncy
-F_G_JRF_
control
bt-
of
c.9olh_
_1 its
fi_t
_.-_llg
Ihor_
set
¢_l;on
-[h_
ckm:at
I1_
_5
;wo
full bP_li_0cy
o_ lull
_,J_._ go a_¢zxab:¢:
1Z through
3ccond
of Lhc
the
11_ c/scott
lan-,p
firs L I1_
circuit
othc_
upon
hi-mctalllc
and
ba_liaDCC
_k;tP_cul_tr
dcF_
wbcla
to
Ih_
on the
foe
ti_
tlmc_
I_G-
with
Z_
14 to
cnts
tbc
o[
;_nd
CoDl3cts
:_5%
is cou_'_clc_l
the
do_d
z
_x_y
(nol
_rl
fl_:.h_nl;
c levels
cnvi_o_m,
36
I
ix illu_r2P__led,
of
dining
sBch
Icucl
valet.
_o_d
COOLS (Lh_'
1o Cool.
the _c:ond
sctol
ccntacls
xvhilc
tb_ firs1 l_t ol coal__Gs
ale
tr/cal
_
la
half
ch_c
Iull-lon,
coil
of Ihc
d_:sirc,!
_r_r,-=cl
_cc_ific_
at
rcdifi;r
sis _ull
one
that.
"13_is s_coM
15
o_
to c_lccl
h_ll-_vc
12 to
clcmcol
a_d
Ihc time
ol
assoc_al¢_l
bc:_iag
coil).
"]fh_s.
11o_3
L_
o_c
OF 2Z
the lampabluptl¥
changes
i;o_
II_;u._Go_I
to 2.'1 c+q c._..'_-:l:o=
re._1
_'_/cnl
_amp
j_vo]xcil
ck_¢nl
coosl0-q_t
_cnt
now
contaL'__
3_
cl_clr_
c_m_nl$
mct_]hc
the
36
cuergiz_
fun
b_lian_c
31I he_l_
Ib_
30
with
zcc_l_c/
flow
_a_l-
_
1_,
back"
ins
b_-met_lllc
both
coil.
-:It-
o( I/_
_.mo_nt
_ho_xa)
first
tbc
I_lhancy
:s
(not
tO
anti
50%
latnp
hcal:'ng
this
oa
it
L!_
litxt
i
co'_hi_
in
FIGURE
_ gh
full
If
thai
tbc
got- :_bo_l
fil_
ac_o_
:_ppro_tltnalcly
I'_x_lly
_-_ by _a
_5
3fi
1_
brdllancy
at
Icy'el
and
fi*Xl _cvmlnal
ol
L_mp
likr
b;-lnr_:talllc
cactglz_l
half
oK its normal,
sa:mo_l
heating
cull
30-
20
th_
appaoxlm_tcly
tim:_
I_mc
_s
coil
tcl:1_cr
Lh¢ closing
lamp
Zg and
Ihc
slJut_iin:zt_on
d_lc_l
_s dc_icablc
with
dcrncnl
,'llumloa:d
Ibc
s_t'ficitnl
he.tang
fil3l
Ilals
k
¢lmla_!s
I_r_I
volt.go
t_;
dor_l_
30.
ol
--.0
di*l_nsing
conn_:ctlng
hall-toot
first
by-_,as_c$
of
ol
to have _0mc
hgh! o,I _11 ol
by u_ing
Ihc ;_gr_gcmt_t
_rr_n_mc_ls
is o/_ lot
38
I_¢
g
bl-mcl_Dtc
1t:c
I1_
cull
_
qclc
lo
the
illu_mir._tio_
I:.clwccqh:*ll-Sonc
hi_lall,c
the
LJfl_$
_c_pc_t
:_n aff_nFcmcnt
d_rcclly
In
lan_p
holhg
_a_rcnl
through
Ih_oogh
th_
|h_
provided
I. but
and
_.hl[clcnt
_lh
it is dc_.l_blc
may
bc p_ovidcd
URE
IS
thlcc
dcs_b¢._l
Such
wl_rc
This
31g _'ill
cod
3tg by an _notmt
by-_
flows
illu_nl-
¢lklat
tk
no apl_cciablc
coil-
visably
bcc_
ooly.
tirol
c_¢1_:nt
tt_r.,:_gh
second
fi/_l
coil
IO
the
Ihalc
hlln_:
dlo_c
IZ_ ,_il_
now
_o
flow
of
Ib_
ol
_
a Ic_c_
Ihc
_c-
-hr_gh
h_
_pl;_ci_t_d
c:3r* 1_
lhloog._
too.
tk
portion
firZ_ I_ali_g
cu_¢l_
$1nc_
b_l
whBc.
Ihc
cffc_:
ElcCllic
!_.
It ix aol
_
while
311 {Iharo_lgh
a sborl
by
ca_.
o.xrrcnl
10.
a sm_ll
co il
/_al_d
through
lamp
Ilxat
thai
hy
hczld,
s.lncc
second
Ibis
12.
holed
ari_ngcmtnl
_ill
in
:_foftn_¢n_:oncJ
l_o_
hc_t_n C coil 38 (cx_lIS in thl, =cvcrxc
of
_
In
thc
_l_Iy
andfith_llybatk;o-._gz;_.._-or,
.,_. I Icrm_l
k
•
_o_
tn.c_z_d
of iUomi_
tlmc:, cu_cnl
fro"_
ol
s.ccotld
diode
_gh
fi,_lhtalingco_36,
o_y
flows
the
_c
d,rc_llon),
th_-z ,L_-r_nt
_s_sx_ncc_
the I_p
I _ _ not
Dudng
:t suc_ivc
the
ol
500
latter
page
134
i
i1
t
",177,.300
G
5
cncf_lzc
_il_nl
Ilom
wl_n
tl_
rotor
tclmlnil
flow
IOf
thloolh
lcrmlnal
with
9uls_tlnK
IZ6
now
8.
xxlih
silJon
an
it
in
ma¢lc
lSa
lamp
lSh
to
12)1. _
iccGficl
a c_
t_
_olo_
_o
di_cl
cooucction
lee
Uc u_c_.
66)
:it bali
so
l
all
arc
by
arrangcmcnls
%aBra'lc I1_
I_l_qlcici
a
wish
tyl _:
_ppreC_ted
thai
llghl
:_y
Ib_
odgil_l
2 an_
of FIGURY_
diMday
tibet
tO
slnglc
s_id
for cx2mp_,
may
bc
5clecllvcly
to I_O_u_¢
contacts
Ke
by
by
il
20
var_,o_
bclng
po_6on_
poftlon_
_
25
halLIouc
L_
rccli6cr,
_
w_ih
to
directly
in tbc
be. co¢t;nuoud_
vldc a xcsult_qt
W_t
is chlm_d
d_play
i_:
of
of
|aml_
p_.txllc_lly
a mOvleg
An
a
the
levc!
pro_-_3_
to
pro-
_
one
d
It
i
curr_rA
di_liy
input
circuit
mcan_
desired
oaes
_x_
cuit
of
of
t_-_
kind
_daptcd
_ phu:dily
35
ooc
means,
Io sa_d
and
it
4.
circuS|
inpol
to
;ec :_:;
_!
ir_mps_
me_ny_
_
to
a
plu-
_
cir-
lln_
_d
cltc_tt
rcotifi_
_ua =
a
the
duling
¢ t
¢_mp.-_-
of OUllm!
IL_lld OpU2'olc
Of
a hail-w_tvc,
c_rcuiL_;
tO comx=d.
output
clzc_it_
to
tccllfi¢4_.
_3]d
_vT_lch_g
s_l-
COIXOcClI_O=I
a direct
said ouc of
to connect
to-
and
_?.nger_cnt,
plulaliiy
Io pro_c
a lower
b_twc_n
circ_iL_
fl_Kio_
of
wilh
interval,
conlloully
ouip'.zI
oulput
£1:cc_t
wP.b
llano
interval,
continuity
ollipul
Tbc
s_id
_
m_i
output
rcdificr
lower
c_c:t_tt
dar_n a._cdc_
da_d
_
c_._rgLr_tlo_
ar.d
during
iocludc_
level
to comp_l_ly
_1
_U-fl
in
claim
motor
c_rc_iI
_ut
_
blr_
_md
in-
d_rcrcdti'lhx_
driven
3.
w_crcln
rotor
salt
switch-
ci_mcnL
UlqiTED
2.177.4118
45
a
I_=tw=x:n
circuit
mr',a_gemeat
chef-
eoefg_zc
_l¢clJrely
|0
ch_
onlpul
"s_l
clicuiil
a dLll_c31I
sw_tcl-,ir.g
aP_aglng
lamp
ouIpuI
of il_and_n!
of sald
oulpui
Of sa_d no!tuber
corm_l_
_aicl _n_
terval
ing
_ciec_vcl_
O_timl
f¢_Cliftc_
diffct-cnt
said
mc_ns
¢_lC_lll_
clccUic_l
tic
-
a dcslr:d
pattern,
comprise=
r._'_t
mcacs;
incandc.mc_t
co_J_cclcd
output
and
i
circuil;
_w_tchiug
inuol
_
lamp
input
Rel¢/toce_
iaczndexcc_
c_-
a "dlt¢_.J[ confil_+:i_o-01
comical
eleclrlcal
incandescent
dmln_
pOt_._fis
Elf
of
and
_tll of
in_rv*l
slnglc
a dc_rr,
said
image
lamp_
r._-_Jl_d
caerglamlion
ir0agc_
com-
ouipt_
of*crabl¢
h=df-wavc
one:
Io
full-
50
fi_gers
tbc
tl_
ftdl-!O_C
aOd
_'._
I?y
kind
of
proYid_
and
dosing
_akl input
circuit
and
lug ode Lime interred,
!evcls
_fe-_-._.
conl_clcd
one
level
input
circuit
different
6mc
_.in_lc
Jbc
lamps
o_
a
It
circuit
o[
t_um_ocl
c;.Icuh;
at
"_rangcmcnlo
og thc
said
is
kxcls.
a plut_ty
mc:m_
_nicrv2|.
bt_k
r_C_od_
bc
p_ *JL_rn c_n
of the lap¢),
corrc.spond_
a half-w_vc
t,_mp_
full
tlm_c
a dlcrcnl
lug:
66.
_nt
• penchcd
lee lamp_
teat
a[c
current.
A chinEc
p_o_'ided'by
allcl_a6ul
tl_
(as
cl_Jgizcd
_t_cb_d
halfdone
cncrglzr_l
numb_r_o|
CL-e_gl/_d
=n image
to
IhfougE
h_vi_g
of
a I_gc
_d
alran£cmrn!
cl*¢t_z_l]or*
iladdng
_,lr_Cl_
input
one
Ir, r_ns
Thus,
wil_
It
W|_OY_= _lu_'ardlzaIioo
Ibarough
ol
inpul
_id
duzing
Sa_l
I_q*_
ci(cu]I_
ot_
mfan$
Of
lamp
inpu!
_ dc_ircd
completely
tc_ml-
it
d_pt;y
_d
7.z.lro illumln_lion
Swltcl_ng
e.lltig_.'zatlon
3 di_clo_
mTa_gctccot,
libel
display
and
connect
vld_
c_rg_r.A
rolo¢
a desire4
pcr_odic
3.
made
Oiscclly
Io
cxaml4e
th_!
p0w_
I7ml_
_lc_val
llm_
wh_rcT0y
incmuic_cal
Uctwccn
15
L'_ so*oh
(for
o._c
a paltcln
:t sin_l_
3w_?ChlUg
dag_.
ll._i
An
cuiL_;
I0
I_¢tlficl_
limps
mounlcd
to gololr
s_f.u'lar
p_]slnS:
b_ :*ppicc_icd'thil
be
coczglzcd
rcmai_L_
Ihc
instead
wouM
be
lol_
2.
no
p_*-
/*,
of
during
]r.lct_al.
half-lor*c,
O[.
¢onncc-
Ic*-miru_
3)
h will
the_
el:clsi_l
of
lone.
_ctso-
i
inc2xnJ_$c:nI
di_lday
it
I._c=_c_il_s
that
lclnilrl_d_
li_r'_
_l:_pd_d
lamp
level
a number
m_y
aze It
_
FIGURE
lamp.
thai
_
cullcnl
diflcrcnl
5
Ik
is tz_J_zcd
ii_rt
66o
as u_d
itcii_
_nglc
that
in
(no(_own)
il _p_'zt_
azls
p¢l
1_
Did
innct
CUn¢.'aI
lot" f.J=an'_plc
c_plm_lio_,
illullratcd
rccllflcl
sln_lc
on
ol
:_¢
o[
terminal
(12_,
convcn_n_c
For
ln]f
3 whole
cill_r
an
allctnatlng
R:xhi_lg
a po,.._6oo
L,amp.
FIGURE
w_th
co_c_ponding
L_mp
_
v,_ih
irv_*x_nl
sbow-n
llon
before
illumle,
is
is midc
_ii_b
CotL_qt_nllyo
hall-lone
_
IIo_icl.
_l_,erllalln_
18b
cullrcnl.
ioto¢
eoc.12fl
and
co.-t¢-M)ondlng
:_1 a
the
_mlrCc.
conL_cI
a Icclificr
Ih¢
81o'a_
clc¢likil
C.Xat_.'_.¢).
dirtct
wlw_
elective21
co,uurrcnt
66 m:ics
p:_l
otxlcr
C_alcd
lll:¢Nialil_!
(_86.
must
c_
D
the
Of
c:_ch
Ciled
I0139
Hunter.
2._,_.$03
!/$1
Seama_
2.896.12.$
7159
Morloct
3,062.956
DAVID
11/62
].
GALVIN.
by
Ihe
S3"ATE.5
Fdt_
PATE_'TS
..........
315---211
...........
cI
Primary
_i .........
Exar_nrJ'.
X
315--200-1
315--200.1
-
i_C_'_a_ly
i
/
!
/
/
r
/
D1L-00524
Page ] 35
JA 0954
o
I
315-154
AU
9/30/80
X_
_ -'--_
256
4,225,80&
United
Siates
Saraceni
-
1541
E_-
Patent
"--
SELFLqIll/E
1,9_
- =_
TI tl
-
._
I_q_ -
ILLUI_IIqA'I]ON
Rtlt,,*,_
++_-S|75|
lnve_nlor
Rcmo
Sarmni_
173|
Assignee_
Novlta_
Philadelphia.
pa_
""
.Santa
I¢lonicau
13 S.
Calif
-
Appl
|_2]
Filed
No+-
912,442
Pn,'_r
J=a.
151|
lal.
02
.........
1521
US
o
..............
197g
37/02;
F21P
315/194.
31
$/'360.
3100
_dd
of
Search
....
315/291,
gO2.
307.
315/154,
360.
:L_O/2ll.
SSI;
361.
362.
159.
DIG
4.
116.
307139.
194.
in
G i_dl_Lafl"
I kCbl_
JJtnt
199,
Or
lag
im_ions
Io
at
31511_
..........
I_
X
_15/191
..........
Jl_91
X
LaRoche
ic'l-"rn--W_.
ale.a_
cirt-afilry
of
an
ot_:_rver
_tabhshe$
¢:_ch
d
J 6:_.¢'gOZ X
_l_pler
_
_a_
.,u_s]naA,cr
r_pocme
mot
362/125.
340/527.
Ro_
4/1971
f_,'ssl
..........
_mtnrr--Eugcp+c
Di/lc*ent
].40/541;
362/I/3
ISBI
3/1970
4571
315/30_;250/221,
3151154,
F
.41g_'n_
|I05B
16;
]01/I
S,
s_ .............
Ulgl_
_J
1.1_9_]$3
30, 1980
Cited
I_vas
3.500.4S_
Sep.
DOCUMENTS
111%9
%1
l+ S'73
111|
PATE/ffi"
*+69_6-_/t_9
J.4_9
Inc_
4,225,808
145-]
the
The
arc
saele_tivcly
p_oximaCy_
Aa
non-h_ghhgh!
dhmmcJr
Io
area
prodtw.e
ix
i|luminal_
ovcl'nddcn
the
h_ghlighled
adjusl_blc
by
highhghl
dmakvcl
los
obs_lvel-_cns-
dlummatioo
level
52g,
541;
4 D_wi_
30_,.s,
32_/5
I-'ig.rcs
_£
II °
AF
II'LI--
Xl ]AR,9_II
AFf_AII.
"{
-
AREA
I
AREAl]
I
I
II
I
I
I
I
"
AIqI:A
I
8
I
L-
CONTROLLER
o
l RANSFORIVlE
12
POWER
SOURCE
D1L-00525
l)efis
t5
JA 0955
Page
136
[:J:S.-Patent
- s¢i,:30, w80
Sheet
I of 2-
-4,225,808
°
J
/
_r_-
/
/
FIG. I
I1'
I_REA
I. IAREA It AREA1[
AREA
AREA [
I
AREAl][
SENSOR
8
I0'
DIMMER
If"
o
--
i
8 =
AREA
-
It
comaou_ER
12
POWER
SOURCE
FIG. 2
DIL-00526
JA 0956
Page
137
U_S.
Patent _ s_¢. 30. 1980
ill0}
--
'is
Sheet
-4,225,808
2 of 2
E-
_l
I
.,_.29
I
V÷
I
I-_349
48
1
38
J
43
_42
47
o_--,
--
FIG. 4
DIL-00527
Page 138
JA 0957
i
_4,225,808
2-
It should
o -
also
Tha
invcnnon
rocogn;z_l
bccn
the
asIx:ct_)
Kindx
that
6ghling
o/Ibcsc
tc:chnlqdc:s
d_lay,
c_e_a
spotlighting.
"h_ck."
of ca/sling
which
known
faclof
for
problcu_
I0
I|ow_vor,
d_p_t¢
choice,
there
_'ll
Icchnlqucs
Icfl
mclrctmn_dzrang
the
add_cy,.s_l
groups
of |term
mrc Iooalcd
oreS-a||
_
I]
to
It is sdll
the
liculad/dTc_h_c
sltutmm
in which
grooping_
tardy,
to
o4r _uch
but w;thin
Ih_ space
found
thls
to bc
many
different
_
wa¢
a display
occupi_
ti_
ce_
{or those
il_m_
of
goods,
ot
tO 17¢ dixplay_d
area
by each
which
individual
hem
which
know|edge,
situ_tio_
th_,c
c_cn¢ially
has involv_cl
highI_ght
only
or group-
potions,
¢lr¢_tlvc_
ingl¥
OOL _
wa_ldul
of
liu_
|ugldighted
pos_'bl_
*ypex
be_n
be
(and
o_r
co_rc*
cmphaxix
from
Gmc
favo_
in pr_tlce_
of
to time.
llght
bet
to the
illum_mtlo_
m_d
throogh
as
_c_cdy
be
low
of
dexlrcd
I know.
il may
I_
havi_g
the
that
W_IL
Aga_B.
fred
ing
a_l
lc_ds
also
at lower
drann_
I_vc._
to _
45
this
CK_tC_
dd'_
d_
in
O_
with
frJtd
fro_
a rath_
ptod_l
api_ar_.
Pcrman++_
Otlu_
poss_Tbil_
prodlctablc
v_noo_
m:
0_
/_kc_Vis_
mrJ_i_lt_
_-
$5
shosl-
to a dlffcr_ut,
now
_s the
I_Oblcm
pla<r_lTnch_
wt_¢
cn_gy,
objccllv_.
oo
_1
I.; tl_
di_cn_dabovc,
k_wl_dgc
pie.
the
OVcr-aU
W_alcd
_4c_
-dommy
hpfl_llng
Icvct
co_ts,..
_
w_
iffccSlng
OIl_lr
l_htmg
Io_on_n_c
s_lisfaclo¢ily
bulb'."
I_xPI,Ili_+,,. trot
of illumir_GO_
matl¢i.
cn<:tgy
otr dls_y
also .or" bc_
s_ca|lc¢l
mutii+bofh
r_
mcad_r¢_
advcrsdy
f_cld
inlcflrdalodl
b_
of rw, J,ldly
¢_r_h_¢
mm_L FO_
I_vc
bc_n
Ihi_
_mply
which
60
_ c_lhdicdly
arc
p_ov/dl_
oftl_
ligbt
level
,c
afca
Ino_c_ve
own
that
_
fl_tur_
foe
low
_¢d_
high
low
ff Ibc hgJh_
for _ach
provided
un-
had
torn.
cont¢ols
fo+ controllably
dclaylng
in_,
allot
6_
All_cth_
by
poqcni]a|
kcting
Ihck
highlighting
might
portion
pa_of the
Attcnt_a
have
go_:
unool-
ti_inleml
hlf_ldi_htod
por6on
_nolml
tl_t,Jli_
Can k
_nhanccd
of the
of
I_a_ng
c_fc_clivcnc_
disld_
y
fle._xbilily
[tom
Io
Ihc
is
vaxl
mar-
_t_i
Moreover,
of clccld_d
thc
power,
Iochnlquc
t5 very
sincc Only
I_CollOlilIClll
a sol.rod
oIL -00528
JA 0958
i
-fhts
coq_l_oL
_cmalncd
lit
dts-
a_l)_'_Ls:. "rbc
tl_
improvements
of _ny
of the
vi_J_it¥.
indlvklual
which
i_vcntlvc
the
autom_ti.cally.._
hto
+ a llC_O_._
II_
po_ns
in _vcral
of |i&l_i_g
i_l_vldua_ly
m_l
smucc.
illi+n+
and
ia
to its low
m the
by
the
ilgKl_ng.
cfftct
w,c*chandi_:
of
Oa
when
of a hght
which,
com_
d_day
dramal_l
to
e_in
on
lh¢
level
I_vc|
b_twccn
mcan_
hi.dighted
• 6¢3habh_
a/.c
arc_
Ihc
sck_ctivdy
mrca
in tbc
in_me_tallty
lndivld0al
_uslomct
good_
IO my
[OWCt_
nu:a_
E_s1._vtmcsS
lyp¢
in_l_l
a_ual
play
drawn
dcs.ltzalblc
the
hght
its
instruo+.,m-
ol
instrumcntal;t¥
II_
chaur'_tcri_tlc_
_u_ca
-_
(;_t_e"
of
of
of
wlth
_
transition
dcvioc
dcdr_blc
tlcul_
Turning
ha_
rdum
p_odeO_
com_r_
there
by O_c scnslng
+rid
di_ptay
is b_ng
by
their
Icvdx
cu_torocr's
pt_.ow=e
ix DO |ongcl
beis_g
Th_
t_Ghnklt_
tng_*tOtt_ly
_CV'_;
a blend
hlgh|_.ht-
"black'.
of th_
_z¢ to
with
hlghilghfng
m
to a _ctatlvdy
a pho_oscn_vc
Tmalag
a +tO the
goods
tl+_ _ttmi_g
as
po_tioncd
hish
The
are
which
at a rclatlvcly
is _ch_evcd
b_ghtnc_
I1_
a_t
provided
I-_tlur¢
opc_te
c_utrol
iaZcz_¢y
Ifigh
to
aplmm
prcsc_ce_vithln
oflhc
by
tmcrgy
rcslx'c!
in¢cot_on
_rov_cd
th_
switch
the
v_ll
prc_Cnl
Ioc_lixc_l
no cttstomcr
they
whl_
a dkplay
o._tomer+
is _
I_dcr_bly.
the
_nlc_pla_vc
glmry.
hm_l,
also
relalivcly
v_Cin}ty
_
z* Iochrllquc
to
Ih¢
dc:_d
el
these
soch
which
LI_ li+hling
tha_
a tcchniqu_
gCSl_C_
b_
axc_. h fufthe_
in the
co_om_
with
cxalupk,
con-
of a pass4_by.
_4_t of fixtart_,
for sensing
at |c_q
other
ambi-
pfov_c
_xc each
opeJatlng
Each
hghl _ty
blgh general
lighting
level plux very dlvc_'_e
_ppleme_
t_l h_dif.htxug
cxcate_
too bright
an overall
cnvt_onmcnl.
wl_u
intently
Io
of
the
area
hOWeVer,
to Ix: sea'io_
For
to produc_
_rnc
40
local-
a t_chrdqoc
cnctgy
such
allex_iou
w_th
or
fixture+,
SO COol+
_,rs_ngtme_t.
I bcllcvc
hghting
of a p+o.spcctlvc
on
pt, r-
standpoint
prcmi_
poltions
la_ily
con_d_allo_
afca_ turning
the
a t_hnlq_
_tc:h
the
itself
highfightcd
:u-e_)
low
inch
p_ov/dc
obJ<x=ts
items
not
of
it+ e mannc_
w_th
of the
oth_
general
_coc_upany
art_ts
pO_l_)il_
_iVa_._._
did
ot
an improvc(I
ha r3e_Uical
only
in accord_noc
ins_lumc_tallty
co_idcre_l
of provldmg
display
they
been
fa_ as
s practical
wh_
cfr
have
posr_blhty
vit_
from
so
tl_
h_ghl_hfing
_x_lomt2f
may
bkcwlxc,
has bc_n glvco
cus¢omcn
I_hting.
highK_hting
disqplay
it_
por6ons
to prov_lc
Ill, bring
needs
ddl'c_cal
cff¢_t
)5
foe
to
obje._cl
t_t
_md
_*rra_gtd
highlighting
such
merchandising
obj_c!
the
sep_atcly
owa
inte_osclo
by
energy
The
210
light
be. cxcc_d-
Practical
lords
of
local
"pools"
suffc+cd
v_ry
would
and
_ot
(o_
w_th
through
woutd
otho-
potxioax.
Other
i_cd
has
general
tobc
tJ_eXgy.
This
Theu=
thi_
I1_
atlract_
lnolh_f
¢_3n_rmed
ach_wtd
followr_
toch_ique
c_onom_)
25
of alumina-
bdghl
for hrgc
to psovid¢
c_c4cut
t_ effluent
thix general
amblcm
attempt¢
tO f_
had
d_ti_fi'vc_cs_
dlumln_ion
on!
_
mo_¢
provided
_
tl_
have
of electrical
spoodlagly
g_
tmp+ovcd
indi,Aduxl
sol.clod
Objccl
_1_
I! _ stY|
for such
tre.alm_c
ltowcvcr0
lktattsc
Icvd, h_ghllghfing would
really stud
ia vogue
hghting
c_ti_c t an:x. Within
have
itulo0d
boca
cP_lain
hlgbly
been
one
a hlgh
prlm_fily
lion within
the
lightin b tlu_c
has
anotl_r
pmlic_Jiy
,_ffo_dvc|y
which
my
_
am
suilab_c
highhghfing
from
II k r_l|
r.cpa-
ing_
To
such
]o
Fs ImrKe t&livc
which
_
lighOng
erca.
ob_ct
bc
mvcnfoa
oQi_nlg
Io ptovld¢
another
which
I! is _till
I have
&jcc!
acoumpllshc_
in
p_ovidc
hlghlighls
dt_p|ay
for
of which
portions
which
.
p_exem
tl_
applications.
F_ pmllcu|m|y
I1 is _I_I _amhct
-
to
in diffc¢cut
technique
_IIualk_
xomcthmg
ob_c't
which
of
atu:t _
mc._,
numerous
bacldtght
w_rc
cff_l.x_m
is another
object
tc_:lmiquc
an _mprovcd
lechnklm:
wldd_
mtarchmadtsing
_
a i_ aa
to_plgyldc
I!
to • favmablc
hghtlng.
lighting
I_ particulal.
o
the
latex it*tl_ts_u:_stt_n
Aq_&ugly,
in
Dif-
to vary
Accordingly,
¢'volv_d
fully d"_
$
has loug
cn_omcJx.
fo_
comrade
Bood_
have
inclu_fing
vtddy
bccn
_
.
d
h/q_rtam
to prospoctlve
both
improved
of goods,
is an
hxv¢
wi6ch
vlsu_l impad
ing.
ly_
of lighting
in the cffectlv_css
lighting
fo¢ p_ducm_
v_
ol tim goods
_fday
fctcnt
to a l,:chalquc ['mcludiag
Id_Ics
and mdhod
visual _:sphy
cff_s.
In mcrchan_L_ing
- .
lhd
_bovc *rc ao( strlcfly limited tO d_lay
lighting siluat_Thcy
can also _
m otl_r
sitoa_ns
as mofc
a_um
,
I_: poled
porlkm
_rl osage
of tile
Page ] 39
l.
4__
=
!
4,225,gog
-
-3
[d,spLiy
_-_u
UOR-aI any
- _-_lo_v
_
stibj¢ocd_lo
givoa-_
_cl_avcly
Oah__
level. "l_is
_
ut oa_rgy.
TI_
ifitcns_
pottmns
arc
mamtmncd
_d,ly
_lf.
r_v<_ vc- O' substanliM
c_-_gy
_._v;ng_
_ [u_lhcr
z!
load
p¢_
!@
the fighting
wluch
greely
s_v_ng
quantl _greedy
and
lhl
both
_
Idoc.t_
as lo
_ho_n
Ihat
tl_
rcaddy
can
Fol"
amoo_
s_on wh_=h
! _
of
d_xplay
thagram
ot[ po[o_ming
FIG_
the
pul
FIG_
d
_iml'_u_
R_fca_ng
of
Ho_vcvclr,
_ that
flout
posifioncd
S arc op_(mg
hand.
when
bc
grouphags
clc_d
i_o_-'ctivc
mat.
the
J
•
ungts
havc
loC_lhaeL
Ibe
e_-clli_
which
_
Imp.
both
s_h
nh_:oc+"
external
d_oPo<d
be pla_cd
g
may
<.o_figurat_o_
cxampl_
f_
dimmer
co.tad
k ll£__
I_ p¢cfcl_l_y
Four
pl_+_cd
8 for
potion
from
tb_
current
to _
a signal
_om
area.
of
be
I wave
load
is prox4dcd
wh_m:h
would
go_r,
ahcrn_mg
alca
conu-ollc_r
the
with
g
bc
a
source-
is also
7. thus
lighting
wh_h
dchvtaroi
Io I1_
con
poamit-
system
cir_,try
a
urn!
dly
cut_tmt
vtcwmg
the
9_
ts c_pa-
load
! I al
c_mtmool
I1
cilcuitt_
capable
Th_
10.
w,lhm
of dcfivctmg
controller
wltffm
of xcnsm
the
The
m_a_
such
sc_a_ot
scnso,
ot
10
as a ptcssmc
mob,on ___o,.
a pholotk'_ltw=
to
v_g
_K/_/ucsr-_c¢____ab-
tl_-wm_rc_
d _aK
th_
a maximum
7 _ [c_po_s_c
located
switch. _..lt_o'--_
_a_.sor.
two
7. tbe
in
standat
th_
ttmc
as th__cp_'tcc
Itm_
upon
a x/gnal
is capah_
any
con-
of
a dimm_
each
_asor
• p_:_m
cac.h
umil" such
_,_ns<-dL At thai
8 Ix thc_a
wh/ch
_c
atca
the o.utcn!
Ihc
(olhc¢
wi_h
of
5 ax
as thai
to
m _.c_a=s
o(
controlk_
u_
g
+ch
statable)_
8 contains
lo_cl
4 _
dimm,_
urn!
may
fixtur_
Lm un_otmly
unit
o[ mainl_dn/.ng
hghtmg
dimI!
Frov/dcd
_dhaafion
dunmcr
load
fighting
vohagc
an,t
one
_ single
11+ The
v_wing
12+
household
Tl_
• mic,o-
an m_hblc
sound
( s_aso_
a COnVCn
a
such
9
m cot_CliOa
5 would
b_ag
ts idaccd
so_urc_
a prcs_h:cted
of a cu_on_r
th_
convc-
a positive
[_plo<_tJoaL
8
+t any
cacfi
wh/ch
sy_t_l
:_rta
d*mm_¢
8 +_.hown
units
Io illusmay bc
a vkwing
tk
S
II compo-
xr_-_,c
wh/ch
1. in which
s_vc+al
fixtmc_
Are_
ra_¢cl
load
and
fixtutc_
,ll+_IZ_tcd
I and
swrtchiDg
Area
O4r rnoxc"
dcscrib_L
fighting
is tllus,
in
I
the
a sing$_
to
Ib_
or
8. on_
compoc_nt_
as Area
a single
FIG
a power
bdow._g_ay
of
inclm=hng
prowdcs
m-a_LOUt
in
Ii.
bit
to
7.
Ihc
syslcra
d.e:scnb_
9 COmptLS_
units
6 above
as
the
eJampk,
3 by
of the sw,_chhag _-rs_c_ -_ sosisi,,+
switch,
oail
fully
unh
and
bo*h
such
arc_
om
_n
by
ling
5O
Z). and
couploJ
vicwmg
8 controls
_ tmcacd
55
mat
tcchniqt_:
either
The
when
courtlier
floor
with
lighting
As
3 b_-
above
K _yst_m
dlmm_-I"
fic'_nI_lc_d
z first
i* Cu_-
_
a switching
the
sv+rtlchin
I1
to conaocl3o_
standa,d
so
ha-
ol
Tbe:_
two gro_aps
ofo0mpoa_nts
two
vzrrath.,n_, in fighting
tcchn*qu¢
_nd
[_om
_ctwvr_l
arc
$_ _
may
thmm_t
_o4atab[_
m_ outlet
7 ('_o_ FIG
8. which
fixlurC_
cfimm_,
dunm._r
_t an
is then
prodoong
k=_d_
In go_=_aL
cxauraple_
5how
ncnt_
trait
tmzt
perlo_
IO I:_rmtl
of
2 have
load
capable
dday
FIG;
they
_cthcr
il_ For
diagram
of
as the
mo_c
dimmer
L_Thc_
on
such
ficsl
a,c-
is _cgulalcd
d,mmc_
uml 8 Io
level
Th_
dcL_y
tfic
low
al'ca
a blo_L
The
troll_
vilmally
whlcfi
advantageous
Or m_tc
of
gO I_tf
is wcfcxably
ptc_cIccled
vl_w|n_
70_
10
_his
Is lowered
I shows
show,case
mat_
Z. and
T_c
,as by
the
tz_:lf
the o_nfio,
g_acrad
uonal
upon
9,nit bc mote
ha FIG
figbling
dlustratccl
I. so
cons1_a=t_
a conuolle_
Io hgfiting
I 9 illuts_ated
Ihc
+p_isc
40
w_lh hUcrnal
ais passages,
customer
mighl
c_usc
aa
c4f the
_ co, redly ,cght_
; afi_m
4 x_qll
_tandmg
p(ovid_d
of wh_h
found
le_tvc
soh_cqucnlly
[Cl_l_
pctK_d
Ih_
I_hn*q_tc
m_t
hghl
5 a_c
m passageway
mcrca._:
motcdanmtr
6 and
oporatmn
customer
dq,<ndmg
mam_ftAl
_
ts also
uncut
mat
to
p_surc
oa_omtar
There
passageway
04[
6 r_ d_cd.
b_
7 Ca_
original
invcnllx_c
with
non-blghfighlmg
m the
oanv_at_aal
be pt0v_dcd
_
the
Th_
J5
as *o
kvcL
7_ After
boL_
dcstrt_CL
lighlmg
lighting
Ih¢ swstcfilng
dcvw_
5 lO
a dday
_s capable
_
45
mat whih"
ts o¢ is ant
i_c_u_c
the
•
Z
6 is p_ovid,td
o4[ any
Ih_ mat 6 my
hat_tconncOx_d
foc
so
zfle_
has
I1_
A
ofgtroup_ag.s
a_d
a s._g.acuon
a cu_omct
i
tbc
Ibis
6 may
of
_t an int_'_n_:
th<_c
fi_urcs
dtm.
mcvitalbly_lat_
I_rovalmg
30
pet;so:hi
po_
ci_cuilry
vlc_,ing
a,ca.
mat
however
which
passageway
h_gblighlmg
)owcr
that
Ihc
al¢:_.
i_ovldcd,
oompa_llvdy
real
the
_
p_rcv_ously
n_-_t loned+
It will bc holed
O_al
3
o[_x_rtumty
d_pby
a _ubS_nl_lly
fo_
L
I_of_"
sw_lching
_t_,c.
4 Io
scnso,x
bolh
possl_onmg
Ihc
ts the
in
IocM_zed
Rlumlnation
mat
thc_c
5 a_e
ai
as
of
FIG_
the
tbc
I_,
only
FIG_
I dc-
+howc.ascs
tnsofat
sld_
dtxitcd
o_ly
fo_c
sa_ch asill_ratcd
m phantom
al 4
to appro_=h
Ih_ goods
in • proxim-
whoa
the fixto¢c_
kvd_
On
th_ othes
prov_lc
m
the
h=fi the
fixtu¢c_
conttollo"
toln_l
IlgOtc:s
on
m glass
is Ih_ spoofs=
oppOs,lc
_I
; opo'_t_,g
20
o_cmt_y
2 d_l_d
shown
c_a._a]
I-_ttutcs
tim
d_mly
the
ttscd
in Ihc
cloIs as
4
has
has: passccL thc cOmrollcr
\_c_u_n
Ihc fights
In thor
2: and
a paxx_gcx_,ay
enclosed
as ¢ convdt_ul
l.Jghtlng
the
of
_
of goods
not
on
cuslomor
I. IO bc able
lUoVglc
_fc
1_ As
oot
is c:_mt+ml
ity such
/'_ pa_l
I. Ih_s shows
_ cono_
pto_cfivc
m FIG_
|by
ciscml
circa,,
4
M Sw_lch_
p,_rmi_ing
by
hgfi(mg
coml_ish_d
_s capa-
m I--1<3
of a customc_
unil
and
of
the
on<:
z_e
_
groupings
15
clcln_nts_
goods
th_
mvtJntlo_
conltollod
a contlolk_
passageway
_f
a display
Dc._£lzv_,
pt=rlOd
of a, timing
wh_h
• grouping
thc
g_6upings
vkwcd
c_usc:s
raven-
• dunw<r
_tas_tcd
nUmclals
1o FIG
I-u*cd bcrwcc_
Ihc
wh_h
o(
dtag_m
[¢Jczc.nc¢
I0 d_lmOtc
of
x
sc_hngqu_
clrcmu_
_
the co,nuollo
m FIG
Z
_
i
10 ahas
o4f a pot-
u¢=fizmg
diagram
4 _ a scl_+mm_c
as pair of
_lu_tratcd
A
ou_cs
_ccompanyhag
o( ci¢cuary
iavtat:vc
3 is a sch<mati_
_
atca
ptc_
dimmor
5 Io f_lL]_lr_('y
_dcvlcc
(_n ptrspo__ivc)
fo< operation
hclwcc_a
tl_
invent/on
II_vgcx_ngat_otshowc_3_Aflcrtl_c_s4omcar
IO ll_ di,,ct_-
of th_
Ihc
the
-fixtu¢¢:x
o¢ rt_o*c
t_ made
ma ov¢=t adl v_=w
a m_chandff.c
What
Ihc_c
tt_ easy adju_lmcnl
t,_ce_sar_
*C --'5"-
- ong+nal,
live= Icc:lmiq_:.
FIG.
2 is a block
sid¢_
all
_ nOl
l-un¢6m_n_ag z_
inlc_ aclm++
m a_x_o_dancc
with
Ih_ p¢_
¢contafiao:I-f_
has
IO l_rm,¢
placcracnt
Upon._c+n_ng
_t_
A_ly_
from
m hgh!
IbC
cxpcn*_=%
labo_
to ihz_'ty p_tccnl
lalkoa
+_Tlsc
mc_ls
wl_rcia
FIG-
ble
and
fcla'_
on
m_lntolam.cc
rtsulUng
dlctml%
follo'arx
-drawha_s
fixlate
parts
savings
[m11_¢
ah" coad/llonlng
hgblmg
rqplaommnl
h_)poscs
p<_s*l_on
such
5 -follows=
_ta_
c_
_c<_ablc
although
cnhanc_dbyl:htfac_lhalthisto_hn_qlt_alsotcduo_thc
heal
4
dlumhaa-
_
This
6S
ol[sct-
ll_
convc-
COntained
in •
maximum
UnCl] sm=h
rant:
dammcr
OUtput
cucrcm
unit
within
stale.
is
dchvcrnd
ag the com[ollc_
This
8 c_blc
Ihc
dlmm<:t
of
Join,rang
unzl
s_gnal rg ptodm+_wJ
DIL-005
to
tl_-
7 pov_dcs
load
I1
• _gnal
to
the
otcmtty
g IO tLs originaL
low
as [ollo'w_
_9
Page
JA 0959
140
:. ;
".-
"7'-,
-)
-
4,225,808
6fix|uT_
of indlvld_al
_-.. - detetminlug that atcustomer 4-ha_ k-fLLhe vioviog
_-_
-
will clxangc
type
siJ'le_
ofs,etao¢
ha stat_
u_d.
would
fcprcsc6t_,g
stale. Otbe_
asc
also
be_equivJd_t
_
to
Io¢oe_
4 to
the
viewing
|n
tO the
tbe
load
This
{cgu|alod
by
7
Ip_k_l
Upon
_ which
The
_nd
comrolles
switchi_.g
pr0vldcd
10.
wlth
and
i
o
- .
.2 •
-
_
drctfi!
th_t
i
te_hnlque
bighter
_]t
mum
|
the
[e:spocfvc
_.vohagc
the
to
v-,sty
both
to a given
display
f_llcer_.-nti_pro_ided
area
its 30
to
8 being
2 de_igthal¢.d
would
be
to
diffegc_!
¢.xample.
FIG.
A_e=l
useful
ha
unit
c.onUolfing
II com-
fo FIG.
8', 8" amd
_n tuna,
7. and
to
icgulalc
such
_
3 coeld
B, (_;h
of
Ihc
40
lighting
pa_r
th£
rcg_alztcd
Ihe low
current
_atdy
dlmm_r
the
_cgulattd.
_md
by
with
that
the
Io
Ik
othe_
levd
dimmer
produced
_
low
loads
|O_
the
<gh<:f
un_
8_- In
ha cacfi
showca_
with
the
o( fightlng
the.blgh
levels
may
of
as the
II;.
50
The
is _
55
t]_c inlcla_of
32 _
Ihe
va_ab/e
fighting
Other
thk
w_h
ha the
oe_'nbi_tlo_
a_c
I_hnique_
c-._*_t_olk4
fixtmcs
showc_¢
3. each
that
vlewmg
xhoxat_'_
3
For
for
rattle
hlghfight_ag
_d
in cotmct;tion
pJod_t:llo_
of olb_r
an
¢./1"o_
_
ha
pa_t
x diff_tcnt
n_y
may
ate
thr.n
and
_o
a
on
tIJ_
10
the
outpet
_att work
laia_
[_islol72
2|.
up.t_
acr_m_
3Z
tala_
21
Tile
_-
a_lr_
the
tt_c
31
to ope_tc
¢_luag
l_anC_
-
_
_ _
by the rc_tor
to tl_
In this
el/ect
co_nocted
the
19
o[
13, :/4 of tl_
capacilof
cam_:
cell
d_vicc.
ha a
RC
the
21
no_a-z_L_tinE.,
varied.
t_tl_
f¢om
a t_ggc=_
r_o_r
at wblc.b
hS nOrmal,
be
ha
state,
Rather.
variabk
Ihe
pOinl
16
to one
e_d
oK the
gate ial_at
2.4 is coo-
cxhx_bigr.d
varying
the
from
.s_paratcly
oulpm
of a shag_
_
scgme.nt
advaaLxg_ously
with
colorful
_.lb_
f;p_ctal
llgbling
cUects.
and
in pets
is p_oportlo*xal
By
24.
_
thereby
a _uclor
oflbe
31
22
18
I_1. "lrhis
ha_
vaflab_c
ic:_,lal_
r¢_'ist_r
re_r
tbe
On bl_ older
15
by
24
It _;istOr
"
from_the.
mack: [¢-
will
time
i_-
ga_c
change
to a c.ol_lu_thag
mam_l
the
cuJr-
slattsoidal
!_ _eht _al,_i_ to _ kn_ i I may be dmpl)_
_1 cor_e2 spoadingly warled- I. _ config_fio_/llu_r-_L
the
rJamplc.._vc_a|
S may be provldc_
SuCh
us_
23.
the
23.
_¢ca.
possible
;.pulx
-
f__.___.q_telnal
photoelectric
il
gate
25
Ol" lh_
corneal
may_"
the
ctrcull
the
_ photo-.,
bei_"
• signal
17 _
did)tie
21 UI.strated.
wiper
whlch
7 aEId _$Of
17 coln-
diode
.c_istar_c,
dlmmor
end
20 by
tot
b_ _ndiv/dua/ly
16 is tl_
L9 to change
m state
omatrolled
ti_
gate
a co_-
reslslor
optocoopl_-
gale
lnpe_ Z._is-connccled
eesisto_
22. and a sc, cond
to
output
3-ma 7 t_
15-
through
through
Ao_ordlngly.
Uta¢
r_n_mg
II"
the
a high
_cststancc.
high
b_t-woe_
laec'_tod
thl_
pre_.nc_
b]f th_ COnllro_J
levels
load
|_owcvcr.
d_rcd
!1",
_qh
11" _ leg_httod
ha
clrcud
emitting
emitting
change
of the
_tod
iO turn
_
4
current
is sealed
light
14) a low
this
is essesltladly
" A first
va.-iable
mx_-
11
provide
]14 and
TI_
c_ll
a re.latrvdy
20
input
pasalng
the
fight
m_gohl_
_slate,
of a (:n_omcr
the
20
to
a
light-
photoeloct_
to
20
when
load
would
_
Ea_rcn!
_¢:slslance.
OUtlmt
45
co_-
viewing
8". 8" whieh
It•mtd
oumpoocm_
10". Thus.
ur_lK
units
41 iS s_t_chroruzod
IoIr_f
showcase
unison
10' a_r,0clatcd
dehvc_d
rqubl_d.
of _
in
to
v'ah_.,
tra_asmission
of
of the OptOcoup_:r
in
thaough
the
Prior
a s_paratc
I1", !! _ for _.c:h
001:1hgm rat_loo or_
by the
light
load
is provldod
controllod
O[ dimmer
in th_
of tl_
2, th_c
cnclosme
here.used
h,gh
sig-
eJh]blt
wheat low
oa_.. _t_
II,
and
a rclaovcly
an iucar_
Ifie
_iatio_s
passe_
caus_
as the
o1" x _tstomc_
17.
manne_
OUtl_!
-_lllumln.'_ting
be
dimmer
this
the
to
The
voltage
late.r
oonUrof
emitting
din(re
18, at its haimt, and
19, _t ilx Ontl)_L
both
eompooesat_
in an
In
I_
_lso
Of _Jm:h a sy_ltma is egScnlia_3Ls_mil"_r
dl_c_l_d,
thc coatgoller
7 psovlding
_
HO_CVtJ.
by _
are
the _mor
ns_L_Ol/C_liO_
that prcv/oos_
slg_aals
a fight
cell
cxh_qbhs
now
unit.
_roner
ptisex
¢_
_c
wlth_
_tm
one
35
of the
14 o/the,dimmer
to
wilh
of am optoCouplc¢
fiE_L
input
5 ill_uatcd
3 _
ha s_rles
input
I_rov_di_g
IntUit(ms
showc_e
dimmer
of
_
in a vk=wlng
L mh
a separate
Capable
may be prodtm.<d
by Icf_'I_
to
input
ftse
to pfo_
shown
Io the
7
to
of
_
preferably
dehvc[cd
pt¢_.JaCe
the
14
!_.
Pla_od
tl_
to
be
DC
conttolle_r
glv_
_t=isto_
be
the
level
may
would
the
provided
inlml
prcsclcct_l
to
the
by
cur{cut
tk
ci, caa_
• variable
the
voltage
bc
_hln
a_t willbc
th_
o(some
are_/,
_?This
i_s
the
signals
a s_gnal
arc
solsi_g
the
now
produc_l
actor,
Itow¢;vcf
Such
voltage.,
_c_ting
f/ore
th_
Io t_gulatc
selected
cur_r_ts
Upon
g andxensor
cO_atroIler'/with
is po_ible
inte_L_ty
in
whh
dimm_
tto_
being
signal
leave
of the
provided
oftma_that
a_¢a. For
Referrhag
-
it
of FIG.
illu_t_atoa
fixtm_
!
and
_l(;h
onmta_hacd
voltage,,
t_tc:_t gt-O_and pot_llal,
In he _.-IJv¢_ted
to tk
load
_-/ff
w/It
signals
de_:rlb_g
means.
e_
This
a viewing
uni!
!
13.
of varied
provided
I
mdlvidtml
enler
scclion
comt)ommLs
fig_ing
-
an
unit
xirml_r
I I.
Dooents-
|
II,dxmmc-r
a
7. I have
}
_ow
1_me
a_ m_w ct,s_om-
A socood
lighting
toehnlqne
which
by the hgjhling
sy_cm
9 is _lusUatr_l
tho_:
i
load
_h
filling
diffedgatlal
wall astbcpefiod
load
ler
. nallng
p_e'_within
{lesc_l)_l
c.cu_r_
_ghL
discussion
.
9 ,F_apa 2 -
t(_h_kt_
cont,ahaed
varloos
15. Va0_ou_
cigcuil
ila the
tO the.
oetpet
The
th_l-_=l
gystcm
_ghtlug
ace imp_cs.s_l
!1
•
of
detail
tl_
I.
design.
_ plutalay
a s,_tchiag
ciscultry
7; ha order
load
du_
prcscl¢_._od
a_eats,
unit
hgfiling
of
of oombinatlor_
above
g_eatcar
Of the
handle
inv_tlv_
3 illustrat_
dunmer
.
provi_'ng
limhag
tl_
tbc
15
wlttda
.
of
i_
o_ntloll_r
ndvanta-
providing
.The
d_bot
FIG
fJ:_La
arras
By
o_
I
of
phazallty
rooelving
this
curlcnt
a_a_
7"as customers
display
•
usown
each
co_uoller
the
v_
)
is
ously
pwrl
p_ctlcallties
variety
lllustr'_tes
the
_
the
adapted.to
ha a wide
forclgo;_g
dimmer
convc_
level
tlme
fn_._
fi_x_l:l)_od0mhag
tO
the
by
7 hclng
d_
7 _ns
of
M,-rle
n _cpg_.d
to
is
only
indivldoal-'_ponents
7 pro.Aries a signal to the
7. is capable
funct_n
of
low
Ihc
longer
Ioca_d
r_tums
kavc
4 n_
and
e_rolle.r
The-
7
"10
_ls high
cxpJ_atloo
load
i ! to ,u, _K.in_d.
"l_c ahovc_d_cps
entea-
at
5
son_xr
conl_oll_
ti
_
_!1o_
9 is limiscd
such
_"
¢oQuoll6r
Safc-ly
a_c_tlt-13
time period, the cooUo/lar
umt
to
fo*
the
the
of
system
the
O[ a, switch.
orde_
a[_a.
wlthlo
cmecn!
comiollef
c_
thai
In state
al_
flu: dscultrj
" dlmmc_
• cfiamg¢
soefi
• customer
a wdl-llt
p redctcJrmincd.tunc.
the
in gcncsal
to
7 the!
bye
OUll_at
gco_ly
upon
chang_
controller
fourhd
m'.xia t c dcl_nds
zn "off" state-, closed
fcprcscntlng
_gaah
capable
of needling
the
the
mence,
cl_ng¢
! Iowcvmr.
possible.
signals
the
Thh
ate._.
5 provided
or
_
of
65
cannrcol
dlrc_c:lio_
"A _or
bc
fo_ the
numbc_
_ rcslSior
| may
] least
22
will
inc_catsc
as the
_
of th4: mrow
51 shown.
Z6 is iwovlded
m pa_alld
to IL.uR the
he _appficd
so.l_
light
Iowe-sl
_otmt
at the outpol
20.
IS provtdod
when
th_
tie
25
with
is moved
ha
the
va_mb_.
of tortoni
whwfi
a sxunng_that
at
cl=cutt
is In _e_:.
t
DIL-00530
]'age 14 l
JA 0960
4,225,808
-7
A xw_ci127
$.
to
whtch
:2Tsgvfichcxl
- -
A
the
off
swatch
has
tm_
the
8 _
_
dl_-Iyp¢
a switching
mumbo.r,
_sis¢or
27- As
8a
27
would
of the
at3c
rcsisto¢
8a
as
be Ol_ra_'d
dlmm_-typ_
may
be
77 would
ok:sired
The
the
strm:_u_c
An
20.
29
sy*Acm
v_wing
inductor
olmcitof
output
potentially
Wh£n
the
tc_eJot
a*e
approaln_alcly
tinily
plac_-s
on
ol
_dafively
short
1000
/a
Ih_ mput
|4 to
the o_ples
a h*gh rc:srstance
duccd
the gate:inputs
23. 24 returning
actx._
above
I cal_ble
again.
t
manner.
level,
tO •
I=]G
part
C_alrollc_
7 ice,
_uch
bit
ol
mg
afC_L
th_
input
tl_
Wl_n
the
I]_Jtcfo_c
r_istot
ao
34
current
quently
The
cx, rttmt
inpta
producmg
low
output
the
capacitor
to
Of Ihc
optocouplcr
35
lull
tbc
35
cutz_n!
a low
ic_r_taocc
36
is
an
to the
optoconpkr
in
at the
mput
_csistancc
p_miL_
b_tw_n
of
_o-_
a cu_r_at
thocby
area
_-oofe-
load
47-
previ-
outpuL
to
flow
l_b,s
IhC c_pacgrouf_d
rhc
• high
tbc
38
near
at
39
to
_he
a htgh
of
base
the
o_tput
the
currtmt
baxc
Thts
tt to exh,bit
to grom_i
a_
of flu" com-
the
to
the
that
ptevcnthag
r_istc_
rcgu-
rcntam
ground
"orriS. cau__-ng
Ic3i_Jat_g2_..
be
voltage
at
a
day,cling
OUtput
c_,c_ttlal
cs_cnt/_lly
at
37
may
wdl
Icvd
RC
non-
mc_ca_e
37 c_uals
thereby
the
through
voltage
_ot_par'ator
kvd
and
_csuhi_g
al the
a_ tbe
the
non-
unchanged
to
37
voltage
through
tra_tslstor
11. and
The
the
at
tLme delay
tcsisto_r
output
the
ma},
49
a high
41
thus
41
is
(:onsc-
providing
a
be
33
o_ the
vatted
00531
the
h_gh
,wyr,-invcrt-
level
w hca
as a feedback
in
tithing
a¢cordmg
the
voltage
path
for
3"/
timmg
is ddaycd
d_dc
t:ax_ttJng
to it_ high
compa_atot
of the
hghi
maint•in
at its
ts provldcd
whmh
input
the
37 dtange_
of the
DIL
JA 0961
to
37
compaCator
at a pOint
in .state
Off
48 is provided
op4_fatioo
Thu_
state
swltchiag
of IhC comparalor
of the
leveL
65
also
diode
input
p_op_r
Ih[ough
Ihc
to
swltcht_
_
"_'_" ing
optocouplcr
its
arid
quently
output
manner
r_
38
the
comparato¢
the
- _ "?:
impcdaa_.
ground
width
point
output
low
signal
to tl_: input
14 of the dimmer
circuit
IS
whic_h in-turin
causes
a low Cnt_r_t
tO be dclrvc_c_J
to the
the
c_tt_-"
cha_gmg
V t-
will
37
into
the
charge
to the
t_r_
from
tlowmg
di_:hargcd
4S _
sauzh
to Its upon
remains
comparalot
s3vltch
the
its
voltage
At (hat
miU_._>ll_t_
35
cltcmt
and
the
w-dl
the
state
the
level
flowing
35.
op_t_c_
37
voltage
the
to tl_
cxhib/tod
input
of k
input.
par_to_
"l_
the
until
inverting
flora
34.
of
tmtJ!
3"/ and
comparator
I_istor
iapul
ttttns
"'on"
re'tot
po(_t_
v_cw-
tl_ough
tbc
inverting
|
|
lime
Ihal
b_twcen
13
emitting
At
a high
,_ then
• reference
output
capa
tkc sw_tdh
op_n
tO flow
_th
transislo¢
state
o[
The
The
the
._J_dr:_
33
the
to ground,
pOlcnliM
"Off-
mpul
through
10
m II_" viewing
axea
_tc
g_ound
50
-on-
input
Imown
-.
t
diode_42
_em_un off
a _c:sull.
retains
36
light
circuit
circuit
capa_/tor
non-lnvc_thag
example.
4 in th_
•n
is pCtTaittod
S_.'_tching
dc:_c_c)cd,
ously
an
2, the
• switch
the vu:wlng
15 45
13
tlmmg
hl_
by the va_tab_:
t_.i_lot_
46. 47_
is int ro-
for
rup*_ling
input
the
36
of
diode
a rc_stoc
exhibit
compacator
capacitor
of the
pfov_k_
_om_-_L
_gnal
cuslomc_
is IWC_>_t
the
s_mc
4l
open
out-
Sl_lU_
cmimng
from
As
the rcSiSlO_r 44. which.
_:otding
time constanl,
cau_:_
the voltage
II
a soagof
c_cuit
s_m, ulatc_
4 k:avcs
to flow
the
hming
10 wh_h
CIO'_.
output
of the
the
IIowcvcf.
is 40
load
FIG.
of •
I_ p_t_hic_d,
, repre:s4r:ntmg
"()IV"
35
_:v¢l
flora
v'a t'ia bit
o(•
mput
an
at the
rclurn
current
35 would
cvcatmg
in
to ils
in cllc_l
area_
pte._oatmg
II
the
would
13 wt_uld
op_ocoupIcr
Initially.
21
13 which
m
may
a cu_o¢_r
wtml_
oi_u
In
of the
DC
c_tcutt
signal
This
pre_noc
the coslorae_
would
ito_
33
._gr_al
tn the
Of absence
area.
a sensor
scn_ang
s'.vttch
When
•
ine:_ncc
a v_ablc
by xdccting
its
level
to •
lUu_ur•tcd
a vartab_
v)c wag
at the
doo_d
volt_gc
supphcd
• timing
"/ As
yes
m ru_,pO_LSC-_rlhc
i
DC
ehang¢:2g
_ Showu
_ontfolk'_
in a purl fcular
to
Inac
the
ci_cml
optooouplcr'35
load
_hc
l_rra•io
of the
mvcrling
as
17 to return
is fe-lolgOthe
condalon,
inl_al
_y
nm_
t_ming
for
to lin_uhe_:ur_cu
p_ot_ct.
vacw/ng
t_ming
wh/ch
to glotmd,
the h_g
output_
it
W_
the
the
a hght
41
•
a high
as _ signal
exh:blted
end
This
exhibit
cllc_cnbc_L
IO a usc_
lh_cby
cOodi_OO
20 to the
th_
of
and
4 Icavc_
used
th_rex_qth
47- For high
ou_
illt_mlt_l_,
for low
39
to
of Ih_
41
to
the output
in sct_cs
of the
a cut,rent
u
signal
this
ba_
re:sat.lot
voltage
to
To
fto_a
invcrtlng
_mrr_t
IO t_
4 tl_r_
the
of
valuc:g
cau_vag
I1_
level
• switching
the
30
usccl
13
pbccd
Ibex*
circuit
time
13
flora
_rcoit
tO Ih_
- :
II_
rcgulalcd
the
output
Supt_cd
I_gh
bc
_l_rough.
diode
would
input
•
current
clrc_it
b_ng
at Ihe
is
"
Accordingly.
as I_cviOUSly
]_
also
customer
c_pable
of b_tg
scloCh=d
by varying
a
lewd
o_f full intensity,
and
th_n
back
In _$pong_
In
|
output
of dimming
[torn a low
rC:_tan,cc,
c
pf_'t,
thing
the
causing
="
follow
to
_tenttal,
_on-.
voltage
|he
"][_e ltbO_
of
returned
state,
ca_ng
Stale_ ]Fl_t_
In the
-
15 _
tl_
chrcuh
such
or_gln_L
low
Io _S orlgma|
to its o*_gmaL
_'-
c_rcUll
2_
by
to the
unGI
41 may
passing
c_n-
32.
thereby
to tl'u= load
output
potenLtal
bang
g_ound
oW
[rum
_z_n_ctcd
br_ngmg
rc_l_nc_.
value_
put
3"/is
By
the
3"/ to
potential
through
38
ClWCUll IS,
s*_t_,_.
43
max/variable
_
is cxlfib/ted
high
42 _ _ed
com_t_
propo_llonal
dimme_-
_
9
the
II_
trangtstor
level
13.
tran
conurollod
contmur--x
20
exhibit-
thclcv_llh
to
maxJmum
the
ohm_
near
Ihe dmatne_
placement
tho_=
capac_to¢
ddivcr_l
Ot_ent
th_
the
rs thercfo(e
constant
outpu!
high
that
scrc_s
21
state_
providing
26 and
pal_llcl
cuceit
tt'iac
of lh_ r_s_o4f
31 and
maximum
cu_ent
to bc
This
t5
output
Irrom
38 to a potuat
cmlttcf-cOi_ot
voltage
circuit
rcslstor
system
I000
of
is calxtbLc
of
I L Tim r_tslor
ohms
15
19 changes
such
time
the
of
across
llghlang
order
of a value
tbc
low
the
_:nc_,
in
the
the
then
load
a _hort
Opcrati,:m
knob
The
chrcuit
by
_
_e_istanc_
21
the
15
39. 40
Ihc
ground
bay.4_ cuncnt
rc_/_f
Is i_ovidcd
swkch_
physical
with
intcdcrcncc.
drmm_
cxhi_ted
dimmer
orcu,t
15
mum
current
to thc
10
near
co_parato_
of
ts switched
37.
to a value
311. Ihc
bluing
input
t)Owinv_t_Jng
O__tp_t of the-compaTato_
rc_ching
ground
of the
Iz-anf_lOf
wa_-
clrcmt
Value.
oust
the
the
as a compafator
of a (_or
bay_
_by
the
of
method
in $cJi¢:_
RF
the pho(o<:l_-Ii_
zt low
the
may
tl,.c
tam
azc pt-ovldcd,
30
:20. In p_otoct
s_cnts
o0mrol
se_rvc_
I_
The
thc_b
9 Io th<: e_sting
3.8 is provided,
of
which
at
Thhg caus_-_
- the input.
_tlally
area_
Ihc suppgc_u>n
and
mg
hghfing
as
and
rotating
¢J_
as
which
manncx
bc ph__c_ng
F_rmlt6ng
a convene-at
m the
for
by
of
_
used
as_d ouL
opcs_ted
tonalnd_
may
advantagc:o_ly
d/rumor
control
._ntmg
be
in
cx]hib4_ed
amp.
o*-dmmlJly
by rc_l_rOCafng
switch
bc
ilhislrated
control
which
voltage
_f.g full
b¢
switch
27. ganged
with
• retest/re
m_anbcr,
bc usod as the v'alLCbl.c r_o_
27- In thls
sv_tch
to
may
• dimm4_-lyl_
8
fixture
-- _
control
varlablc
2 at 57_ such
Itgjhtmg
con_c_cd,
d_ed_-
27 and the
in riG-
to cabbie
_
whc_
conventional
tl_
-
k-pruvid_l
changc_
a change
13
M
Jc_tatlce
th_
ol
Page 142
_
tim
_
vaxi_ble
of the
9
zesistot45.
r_(_r_l
and Capaeitmr
having
ddmy
•
Fm
_tamplc.
abo'_
of
4.7
oi va.-_uttiou
and
is
_dng
_tablc
to
c_rcttit
IJ _
to the
chcult
15.
regulate
_
rammer
ol_ration
Tim
of the
maximum
by tb_
age.
_
positlvc
c_L_it
"D_
tacl_
kvd.
IL
value
of the
for
t_.
flora
of slya_
tnd
to utili_
_ would
fixtm¢
cost.
It I_ralily
of
oncrgy
tfi_play,
xrart_e
_
Load
II
to
u_:
sttch
number
13 my
clccttitry.
could
slntilarly
;nlreder
CtLmCnt. th_
fmw6on_.As
"
pol(mtlal.
_
be
hlgh_F
iI_o
be
a_
v_ry
from
a _Ow
to a high
indication
ofth_
prt_mo:
s_rve*
the
fo_tgoing,
wall
Serve
at ;Ely
glvco
Imown.
have
foe
of the presct_-.c
b_ f_
of
that
objects
earlier
_ch
tcpe_..ted;and
i'film
tights
prc_.tmt
p_ezct_ce
oth_
For
_
L A
are_
_
d_pt_y
pobllc
pzt:_d
pc-dud
me_
of time.
in that
I_med
swat-
provide
iltu-
t_m_inteJval,
tl_
of _0_eOne_in
OVCt_O4m_
th_ ludlway
tl_
whereby
of
Icvd
oo
tl_
- __,
lear-
aftc_
(hfferenl
location
illumitmtcd
items
in
tO tt
_rcas_
separated
mlo
a _y
a_c_
_tt
_m-
backgrotmd
hght-
55
1_
a Ipe_xon
the-
to Said
lighting
f*Om
the
to
a k-rot
p_ovlded
upon
the
of
the
or, e dt_lay
dim
of
s_ing:
peJrfo_
from
the
xaid
one
gro_q,t_, and
the
level
ligbdng
dt_play
lighling
upon
the
pr_
The
2
ar(:_s
to
the.
ha a dimly
method
may
of cl:tlm
tm lighted
_g
of
m_*y
group
when
is pge_:nt
m,_i_h_ncd
per_n
Fust.
dim
_ng
initially
a dlz4play
mtcn_:
and c+_.
is'x_T'g_,
t 60
problem_
rely
to
._t_ing
its
odffhaal
Of II_
dc-
pa:Itue.
_0
he
• pctxoa
and
h_glthghted
dc_ot_
d_lay
the
gzoup
Id manlier
when
I whacLa
a vcrm_
._tla6m
or dimmed
movcrrm_t
of
_
v_th
off v_cwlng
may
be
no _
of d_pL_y
corte_p(mdlng
in
tlu= d_play
ati¢_t.
3 "l_Jthodofdaim
hghtlug
_vOttk_n
appgoach
ba_l_lotmd
dim
a_rc
to
tld_ can b_ awltwa_l
go out when
the e*er
area
telmn_ng-'_utolnat_lly
in
it
oflhe
tim
to
intrttdet'_
I_l_
Ihe dcvarlurc
d_pL_y
k is cus-
Unl_ts
invr_t_omtds
illuminate
Hlum;_tmg
three•iCy
_-J_mg
to-
with
m o_dcr
n<_d
th_
guard's
illumlnellon
the:
•tttomatlc2tlly
grcat_
45
_uml,le.
building,
cou_
tim
.*,clcctlvdy
[r_p
tim dt_lay
_,_ns_ng the
the
f_cign
at n_ght,
,tO
from
which
those
s_ch
_pplicallons.
pazttcu-"
sUmdpoinl,
is bcllevcd
to
down
for
o_
x_vilchmg
poillot_
pubUtc
to illumlaate
v.tch
a* the mdt:s IIoot of s depattz.crvc
to al¢.tl
i)e_on_l
leavlng,
an intru_eG
is .still ixey.enl,
and
one of the
ts d_mcd
_vc_
forth
be
to _lecttvely
narrow
particular
_Vha!
grOUp;
iuvctxtlon
set
.ql¢_t.
of
_vlng*
can
_n specific
spice,
would
possibly
badcgrotmd
_
invemion
d_d
exca* o[ • I_gc
me_
faofe,
it
thai someone,
dlum,.
ahr<:_dy
the
cleaning
an Other-
unillmnlnetedL
ts no
oil
-
qce_tr, appalenL
lighting
an
in it._f
th_tc
al_o"
prising.
of
the
aad
areas
-follow"
turn
dlumhaat_on
tt slmcc
omw
a bullld_ng
to
Yet,
_mlly
the
building,
used
each cons_tive
The
great
advlmtagc
I_rly from the energy
wldch
warn
did
a _lowef
in Which
_ugh
o4" stmb,
such
bc
mg
lime.-
to be
• given
illumln_tion.
I_t
ad-
oltcn
t_
applkattlons_
tmild_8,
all other
petrols
cam
to _a_._
many
ku_tanC,_
progt_vcly
of the
v_th
o4"a oaxatomer.
in some
the d_tatlon
has to he
dangero_"
a switch.
to
switchhag
il]ttm_•te
a=d
to prQvlde
che_ wh_h
t t_:lms
level
the
tO SelOCtiv_ly
As k wdl
mir_tion
of
35
by
al
a)'ound
impooant
pft:_nc¢
leaving
would-even
i_ d_c_tcd_
e_lmtage_
which
at_ obviot_et
It is to I_ und_Ot_'-_'_lb_s
stai_rwdl_
toma_
tither
may
to
04[- dcVl_
my
find _
zaw.h as a m_Ftistoo/_'-parmumt
hallwayx,
OCet*l_
ot_pt_
type
act
il can
to tchieve
gct h_r with_.___,
,the
above d_cm.
_nvmtlo_
;a bm'ldlng
o_ _o_
again
iu a
adal_ocl
sales per_xmnel
the
!1
interest
othcl
the
In addillon,
the
has"
limited
wh_h"
pfo_:_d
invett6on
oWmc
umsc
to
at
i?c_on
being
u._ed,
pe2eto_
in the
at night
If • guard
be
_ low
load
the
_t'gtttt
sense a prt_.ncc
In fact.
"I_
s_tably
adafut
25
still
tmoocupted
guard
load
I I 30
a 1_8ht -
tom
in dec ¢_dng
_
or to it*From
From
possible
while
the
mamtamod
thai
not
must
tirol
time period,
lhu._
orderly
fashion,
at
matron,
who
of the
lion
SO pfow_d_d.
provide
sav_g
20
as that malkcted
"MC
1458".
In
be approp_iat
el y
olp-amt_;
¢:an be
rueful
timc
of
in the
integrated
• variable
_vertl
11
which
may
[fa cu_omc_.
wise
_die*
to a fixed
a fade and
"follow"
Sl_flcdly.
crews
move
_fc
until
i_revk_y
to
ttaso_k
c_tttially
_oms
inthvld_t
up•rap
tt_d
to fo_m_ tim con, pat-asuitable
integrated
circuit
for thi_
toad
be • cotmlor,
given
the
hevc
,_ario_
pc_ou
thehsbts
dust
fO_ thO_e
capibihty
to
tim
to-the_
u'-n_:_l_rk)d
fo*
to a lower
with
li t_l_t_'t3Lfigh_to
_nda}
p_c._
to
vuIt - t_
50
idvantagoot_
C_e_h OflbC
S. the
_: mtemlty
T_c
1_
_pe_c
bt_g
lklng
pfovlded
with
may he adat)e_d toped(ram
;|natron
to
provklcd
tramformex
use in connection
I_tl_
would
he I dttal o_p,
by MOtorola
under
the send
t hi_ mana_r
twO 6adng
ci_cmits
may
flu:
toutc_
cle, e it is _
parl_t_lady
for th_
tot $7. A partict_lady
gfO_l_
_CCotml
TI_
able
th_ .-_cmlce
end
each
In _
hatelest
[]an
voltage
power
the eotttfo_ef
_
regelatio_
luted
nOt
_el_
GUlly,
*ho
10
_-'co_d.
ilhtmination
_
the
dlmmcr
7.
6mlag
: } ing
the
7 _
AC
rcc6ru_tloa
tEc
area.
throng
owa
thai
I'of
left th_avca,
tin4 m:_cording
• _
may proceed
in
mak_
using
the
of
coauollcr
L1 is dcr_
down
controUcr
14
loads
is eocempllth_
which
_
the
"3
need
I.o ptoccx_d.
their
accosting
the
a h_gh-lc_td'of
-
customer
4 in the vicwlng
7., the outlmt
41 o4[ the
In
pro-
cndt_tg
which
appro),-
pfey_moe
or ab-_m_: oft
As illustrated
ha FIG.
eontte_led
a
a_d
mcgohms
bct_:em
15 mlnutc:s.
function
semsed,
mlcrof_nds
rc_s/an_
capable
30 s4:coods
"l'bc
_.
tscs_tJally
cal_lcltancco{6_
44
• Ihnc
mately
10
Thisdclaypcdod
c_paialo{36ha_mga
a rcslstof
)
4,225,808
dm scn_ng
i whefeha
of il._ otaglnal
of
backgfotmd
thetcttunmgoftb_
Icvd
_ dclz*ycd
alter
dc_tmc.
ix automatically
)
t
DIL-00532
Page 143
JA 0962
- _,j ;>56
-
11111/80
x_
United
-_,233
States
webster
[54]
-
_
of
1,91
R.
Cia_r
Ih/h_ly
Fh_
.-
CONTROL
WebstcJq
167D
Bc_ch.
llq
- _
LIGIn_ING
- l.v¢olo_.
_5_G
Patent
el a_l:-
AIIrOMATIC
17q
Ex
J.
both-
Woedl_
S.a_lblc
AIA.
145J
Ae_e'g
AKene.
-rh_
invczilix:_l_f-_-datc._
syslcm
Appt
[22]
Udo,:l
|Sli
list.
1_21 IJJ
[5_l
_:_
No.
i_<u
CL I
_
is.
_78
.....................
1lglJ
............
of
._-e_rdt
ZSO/214
......
150/214
3151153,
-
of
I.
_
ZI4
N
pn_o_
A_ei;slonl
IO/1976
154,
156.
b_r_Igc
_s fed
of
J15/154
F_amiaer--Da_d
........
C
F_camJn_'--D_ewm
D
;in
a
11,
1980
Dtxon
_ulomall_
ligh_ln_
i>bolo_iivc
151
colllllol
dctc_lof
• _sle_r
7_O/214
R
iniclio_
a
_
in
a
tcqtn_ing
_,bsoquaml
to
of
add
modulc_
to
a
a
chaJagc
one
which
po_ex
supply
an
signal_
in
artificial
of
the
the
If
range.-
A
an
shift
cnor
signal
_
command
Io
level
iniermcdhtc
illumination
will
fo_
of
acccph*blc
ialo
pulse
iolenxlpl
ill_mgnation
oalilp_l_lol_
_n
ed
ctffeclive
OUlput
rcpic_ntallvc
dock
clock
or
ariifidil
dtffcf_tllal
oulsalc
load,
total
unbalanced
signal
is
tc_po_v¢
type
pair
crro_
the
a.d
_]he
falling
clxor
sciws|ng
naiur_
space.
Into
ilhiminal/on
tegist_
lot
the
mlor;o¢
a d/_lal
dal_lal
2|_
FJOCUh_ElffI_
Owelas
to
c_oilt
both
d_ritiag
40/14
AJL
btl_:lgc
an
ing
4 172.334
a
o(
thca
PATEIqT
Firai--R;chard
employs
w.hin
the
O_
wh/cl*
level
94Z._rT/
--qce-
or
Nov.
37937
leg
[21]
4,233,545
on£
or
itlumlnitio_
of
p_c_cni.
a
mo[e
shift
lighlto
slpac_
N_Im&
R_
}ltJgt#2itl'f
13
Claims.
4
Drawing
Figalles
-e-__
AIC
POWER
I,
I
|
I
XW,=
DII_00569
Doffs_
JA 0963
16
Page 144
°
O.S_ Patent
L _o_. l I, 198o
sh_l lot 2
4,233,545
__:_. --.-
-¢
POWER
FIG. 1
i
LOGIC lrABLE
FIG. 4
v,>v_
49
59
0
0
I
!
ONLY
2"_ .
__Iv, <_vz
L v,_>v_
v,<v_
°' I
I
!
_ _
_ONLY
I
DIL-00570
Page 145
JA 0964
u.S.
Pa(ent
-- No_. l l, 19so
Sheet
o
,
:"
V!
\
30
3_J"
3Z_
4,233,545
2 of 2
.
r4}- ;?
____-
I-
36I-
ss _c_
s_F__
FIG. 2
i
FIG. 3
I)1L-00571
JA 0965
Page
146
-)
_ 4,233,545
!
2
utd,zod
AI._OMA'i]C
LIGJITIN(;
CONTROL
-- _--
..
BACKGROUND
I
-j"
FIdd
_fh¢
of the
present
system
OF
naUon
lelatc_
the
in an ate•
of that ¢oml,_l
It.
ID_,oaptlou
Fhtorc_ccn!
tural
Ttm
con.XUmL
buildinl_
indud_
which
it,.du_lcs
the flt_o_at
an4
dttcthtg
the
for
service
tm_
ate
each
of |h_
of
ts ten _age_
o_s_ly
I_hts
_tt _
by
the
lighting
lized by architccts
aware
thai
the
quemly
adjust
tl_0C
me
_
30
uti-
o_ly
06ct_
The
not
th_
off
tim(:
h:vel
of
being
infrequently
clouds,
artlftcial
offt_c
e/l'oft
men
gene-,rally
will
to contlnuomly
dlomh_ai;on
_djust
*espon_ive
ob_u_od
foe short
the
to
polods
Momt
modern
in
1,000
to 1.600
IlO
v(dt
pow_.
offw_
whlch
watts
or
dcfmc
volt
dcsiga
and
sun
the
layout
amounts
of the
offwT_
imo
areas
Of n_tual
In
elc,_lr_P-/d
of
area
bc pos_b_
l_On and
the.
menl
gcn-
facing
iron.
masa_
Ofl-w_
inauoa
wc, aldofcour,_
a_c_
_tl aulOm•ll_
mamt_
The
pfesenl
d_n
ma_d_n
4.001.5-/I,
c.Icm!
tcquhe
_ued
bc dlscusscd
a_c
d_s_-d
Martin
OI modular
me
¢tw.l_t:_t_ll_f
6o
CO_RrO_ C_rGttl!
I|owcvet.
d_ig_
in
O_at
mil/2cd
CX_mI_
_rff_._
U!S.
wafio_
IOC:hnlqur_
in
the
of tlba:5_
Pat.
as Ihc
an ataificwbcn
actuator
the
illumina-
of Onto color,
illuminat_o_
colorccl
gya_u-
_.cr,_o_r
cnelgy
xvilb
typ_
to Ibm:
energy
a pfe_elemi_
light
_r_
_' • vest'
in 10S.
IqO.
othe¢
may,be
control
65
PaL
and
In
otbe¢
._o a_ to
_tlG-
po3odlcalty
lights.
_n_c_nt
the.
_-
ambkmt
vary-
The
inlct_y
tts_ Of the
Tim
dday
clccui-
fog
a dead
bat
the
i_teJtd
._0_[C,c
lath; below
of tlmc_
Th_
zo_c
or
a
_pi_l
¢lcct_:'al
supplic_
if the
a pt't_llelca'min_!
Itmll
wlfich
.soo_cc
NO.
3.180,978.
in_clud_
t>f
a_tificlal
of artifmial
does
a cloud
_ot
wall-mountr_d
dlumlnation
in
pt ovld_
intently.
energy
illummmmn
a sd_oclod
dlscloxc_
a
fl_cmali0_s
of
hght_ng
foe
of
changc_
somce
r,h:c_ic_l
amb_nt
of
tfansk_t
cllmlnatcs
vassage
of acccplable
sooloc
Io
llghring
system
doc-
cont¢OI
e avera_,g
oppos_
to the
automa6cally
Of illumha_l/o_
in U S. Pal.
s}rslon
_x
by lira
zot_
an
to
an arttfmL_l
Io_g-tlm,
tJ_ coll
to
be cxlfibilcd
_
to
the
c_eJgy
Icspom_ve
o4[ tl_
having
time
dlsclo_s
is d_sig_ed
light
of ckclfical
fmta4
Mg.
o_.e_rgy
_
flow
as woold
3,210.611.
wl_:h
to
clmagc_
such
ticm
No.
¢itctfit
te_pom_e
illum;natlon
dlurn-
_uming
¢t:::_U]llng
O[ docla-lcal
in the
illuml.
real
_
Ib_
of clc_tri-
such
rh:al
multi-"
hrom
illumL'hatt_m
_ co_trolled
by F4ac*ng
in _
w, ith the sourc_
o1 illum_m_t/o_
flow
llghi
of illumhtatlou.
tochnlqucs
O_l-to_
Io
f_om
53,
alumina-
to'nat
AS th_
reduc_cs
of
into
a photo-
p_ssage
electrical
a st/bject
ilht_uadou
the
otrl wa_dly
cooling
Sm.c_c the
lord
will
ly1:tOn
t_tt_l
Iccluuqttcs
biancb_
clT_ul_
a coffin!
llghDng
of the
_dy
•
all
to o_,tw_d
horn
no c_posme
thereby
_ drlv_
the hgb;
source
appar-
di_oction.
a clr_t
power
below
the
which
d'_closcs
gr;_dually
of different
K_amke..
at
tl_
elect
falls
ct:,t_ing
and
the|col.
whk:h
of artificial
arlll_l
_
ovc_r
relay,
p_ovide._
inlem/ta=
o/an
I]_L_ sy_cm
OUlpo!
is _ct_ted.
artificial
sOmC._
I¢oopl_:al
u_ntai_
additkmal
an
for
upon
2,078,6T/.
and then
illm_inmc
ctally
ilhmtlna-
area
ck_
llttlc
_o_ t_ftt
inv_aliOu
tO
grids
to control
fight
periOd:oily
out-
repot
50
tO supplc-
tl_c
s_pax•ted
having
Colltrol
would
moor
over
icx_mre
may
windows
nation_
only
cclatlvdy
• _e.as _b_has_t/_ly
f_g
modexn
atca_
may
of hal maJ
in
illuminal*on
w_ndtrws
while
Ics,_
from
o_ the
_L_c_
t._nl_l_-_t_h
iIhtmlnal_
_l_rmi_tgO_
co_tau!
In this
tlic
alt]ftc*a}
n.._tural
relatively
t,_
t o soLsc
use _
t/o_
ing
as through
wlndow_
tkyllghts,
etc.
If areaL_ roctivlng
similar
amotm_
o/natural
iUum/nal_o_a a*e defined,
thou
/t n_y
illumlnal_
vOIUIgf
non-budged
which
tl_
14o.
natur_
art/-
a pho4o-
In a single
disdo_e_
of light
app•ratu_
A.s the de'vlcc
ally
coloured
45
can
whk::h
of
limit.
I_
to
the
illuminal_
contacts
• control
d_y
_
t_
couplod
in US.
lighting
ol
interval
to th_
tluough
by
i_ acocp4able_
_c_llaic.
is utilized
¢:nergy
Is
I]he
=_ ut tied
to the
multivlbtator
_
power
¢'x*_J:f_
illummato_x
incide.nc_
exmpled
begln_
l_mg.
ial
40
s_,itch
wh*w..h umy Im utthz_l
In supply
head|ighls
of an _utomob;Ic,
the
lighting
so,_ce
deto_tor
the
lure OOItlfO_
the Supply
ofd_cdtrocfion
electrical
motor
Tim
a toleranc_
by the
whde
level
The
illumination
• tubc4ypc
of dlgmi.
m a stmp_
moire" can be ddvem
only
in U-q.
Pat. No. 2.920,247.
os_llal_OO
cad
_5
between
dlummal_
modules
_mlhur
modular
p_ovkk:
to
level
of ht_e_
is coupled
to asfifieial
artificial
multi_or
of trine by
conuo_-from
6Ocycle
Ihe_inumlnifion
eJ•lly_eoe_vc
have
twitch
Of art_fmial
Z77
Ca_dul
btfildlng_s
one
of
vt4btratof
¢tc_
systems
•
the
and
such
not
level
applied
d/scloxes
_claSive
_
_c_rgy
is
I_d
o/intczcsL
w_.h
to a single
scq,,_t:t_tlaUy
live
dcslgners
slncc they arc
_
Imilding
wdl
inf_--
illuminallon,
an area
to
artlf_|
the
clicuh
Is oU_/izcd
the
_
produced
No_ 3,961.183.
which
ts:r_ag
C_Tall
enexgy
intcg_tmg
with
_.as
of I_llumingt;on
an cxtc.r_lcd
PaL
photo<l_ector
utilizing.
Contln_t-
floqu_ttly
ovc_
_
ently
the
Fisher,
re-
Au
the_rcln,
point,
dcswcd
in illumination
the
does
pwee
o- _
in-
lyslem
adjestable
wl_n
level
k_cL
f0_
cl_l
area
_:
o_cupamts
of
meJ'cly
illuminatoff
tl_
L m U_S.
taotot
72,
switches
which
a single
vafia_ons
source
_talo_
tr/cal
fiawith
ot-_
0¢ twic_
I)cf day in tesponvr,
to tht: sun b_ng
scored
by eominuous
layers
of cloud_
smog. fog.
dcvole
level
b£1ow
wh_
hicldcm
2O Imt of
inclclxmdcntly
the
ficinl
FI_
am at_o-
_
cm_L'_gy to
of J]llumination
of
co.tro41ing
a phoIoc_ll
being
ck_lncal
storm
with
us_
paper.
hvlug
dlumlnatioo.
falls
sp*m,aod
dr_ch_cs
for
photocdl
of
v_aro:
d_vldct
as
forms,
the
s4::_c_tivc dclcctolr
for
lighting
poweJ
oco_pas_
controls
of
Debo
lira
c.dling
as wc/I
The
being
when
and tmilding
O¢.C_panL_
of
tin:
that
t_'-evexl
varlcty
the
th_tow
of
or false
These
on-off
from
va/iable
dftctatc
it_ modular
_vitch.
the
co0struC6oo
beating
modules
a pow_
arc
power
Ibc
fixture*.
asrangext
inte._ml_
equaha.c
15
system
ohrot_t
of
p_e.dct_mainc/J
hghtaftlfu3xal
Airchlt_-
_s g_y
and
• bridge
_omCc
|he
of photosc_Stiv¢
th_'_il_i
10. ar6faCtal
from
lslc_. 3.4Sg.770.
conuol
pqp0_mr¢
=atlo_
Ggbtlng
fixtxt(ts,
generally
of
space
belwe_a
the suspended
illummado,a
by
of
II1<
adjusled.
pto,_d{ng
bmkli_gt.
ceiling
hghting
ge_'ally
genctal|y
move
th_
kvel
and
hacand_ent
on
e,Cluad ccU/ng
for
conlrolk-d
and
• suslmmtod
ai*-conditloalng
trk:d
he
g,_crd_y
smpcnd_
lypc. Th_
total
d_paurtmg
system
, la_ U S. Pat_
;nl_ptotl
usod _
o/Tw._
llnfitafion$
corn•re*c/a/
- olfioe spaoc
may
dlumi.
.Art
Ptlof
fialmc*
ccO_omlc
_mloral
th_
chtd_
comft_
illum__n2_
malutzmc(I
a_¢ g¢o_lly
within
mod_u
and
ceifing
d_
hghtlag
mg fu_tutcs
iHl_mi=atloa
a _ght_g
of concern
dlum_6ou
of
w'Dthom
pr_t
Derelict
maticl_BI)ting
of attlftcJad
y $opplcmcnt
is geJu:r-_lly
kvd
In
intensity
Io autom)ricall
present
" ""
INVENTION
3
inv_ntlon
ill_t_
the
lure•lion
for conUo|lmg
h o(def
THE
SYSTEM
"
to
period
an illuminawindow
c_*_atmg
DIL-00572
Page
JA 0966
147
4,'233,545
frm
bchlr_
the
Ar_ out_._dc
--
dcscc_
Ihe
and coLg_pond_ngly
ingon
for
-
n(>rln_fcolmg-¢_ted
pho¢osc_o_r
_'_J_alnatloa
3
Cnta_._ty
ofc_0u_l
adlut_t_xh'e-l_U,ght-
zhemttC_cL_lw*ndowlopioduccdmilar
the
[ool_.
lh_J¢:by
in the intensities
_ol
c_¢cu_
may
fo_ _Jupply_ng
_xltm
tcrnal
f_lls
lh_
whm
be.low
nof_
th_
This-
fo_
dcec_rnint_g
Zotto
m
photodlodc
with
inl_ity
pholodtodc
Th_
artlf_iad
_t¢:m
for
._clcvw._--
_rOuM
whu:h
/.g
II_ ol)_atiOn
ch_mgc_
f_om
1_hu_x
lag
f_
PaL
Ho
of
utd_d
in t[_po_tat_on
3,_3,104.
el_ly
powc_c_l
lamps.
lun_._.
in U_S
_kc
tr/_al
h_hlmg
and b_¢_Ic
a modern
in
_
*o _nals
11_
lights
Irom
f_om
di_los_
cont_ollol
|)_ _
a Ioa_l.
budding
!h_
h
Nat_<_l
h_clud_
McCall.
_
flow
_
a
is rotatc'_l
lcvd
o_
_.
i_t_
pr_r
samila¢
dgsss_
x_ts
,Set_ No.
II_
arl
upon
I_1o_1 on
Dec
361/173,
149.
TI_
wh_
shorted
oL'_plablc
1"/4,
_e
175,
I_I.
IS2.
T.
155.
also
inch_ch_s
ubhzc
•
_5S
ll."m_
until
the
threshold
level
hmmt
A
45
signal
• ling
O_L_de
and
then
act_t_g
o_d_r
having
of _luafinaUon
a_-
"l_hc *npt,L_
asc thrn
thc
of
is
the
d,Etc-_t_r
is coupIdd
a distal.
s_nsed
dluminafion
hrrfit
and
clock
a
d_v_
_gC
dc-
a towc.
s*gnal
;c_cr.
Th_
one
of tb4: power
a cofr<_ondlng
the
gean_rating
mcceiving
a shift
for
within
for
din.in•finn
into
hghting
p_ovidecl
illu_a_tlom
Upon
F_ fed
mclud<_,
a
be_tw_cn
limit
_
_*n upw
d<_gns
i_ov/d_
shdt
the
rcg_st_t
con,,of
reduce
kvci',_
tim
will
dano_
x_lth
in
This
Ihc
sy_cm
illuminatlom_.
of IE_
" ivity
_;yst_nm
throug_h
the pro.scat
by
the
writ
which:
of am imc_iO_
_tcm
control
nalttf-al
p_c_ent
of the
ins.aUral
_oom
_n actor
for gcgulati_g
so as IO suplph:n_nl
the
Z lilacs
ci_c,sit_/_tilizc_
in
_vcnl_m
illum/natio_
of
a _tudy
illuslration
hghlhag
DRAWINGS
adx.antagc:s
tl_c drawings
autom_l_
prov_lod
of
_ntcz_
I_c.sc_/t_
appatoal
and
a_tlf_ial
bridge
oi[ iUumlnalao_a.
I _ a p,c_p,cctivc
an
.scnsitlvlty
rcL_llvd.y
fc_twrc:_ and
bc
of th_
thcrcb</wccn
D "-----------------F_CRII'i+'ION
OF
"rllE
obj_cL%
having
nodre;
cooplmg
ol-
d_r/pt,on
FIG.
-_-_c_oat_oi
tl_
illuml-
$1Jm_lgbl_
a schm-a_tlc
d/g-r_'n
of
_a tlhc ft_t
In_e_t
bridge
and
cmbodi-
menloftl_pg¢_u_tmVrmtiO_L
FiG+
65
3 illus_nt_
power
fcrrod
F'_G_
unac-
corobinahons
_nd
_ontrol
embodiment
l_m:_c'_l +
to
to
de_cc
an hnlTcdano_
Signal
increasing
lower
FIG.
error
mutual
generally
-EF
embodtrncht,
tl¢
tends
IS8,
couph'd
p_c_cfgL'd
coadillol_
and
an
Of an
or_
an
of *U_rni-
illumination
dluminallO_
a_O_
In
nat_o
_J_.
136.
Inpot_
crossc_
and
_f_iai
to
ruodulc_
within
_cl
detector
d_ocIof
dunng
55
+
the
An
couplmg
ten
many
AL.
enticing
and
hmiL
_gnal
.veniSon"
T_c
m Ih_ follow_-"
Off__c_c. 362/I.
_
g5.
+_arious
¢nctgy
COnenergy
Of |;ght,ng
a dc_ircd
phot<_cnsifivc
rc_pons*vc
crro_
BRI
a_c
This
153.
dluntmataon
Of clo:uIcal
dlumin•t_.._n
n•luraJ
_o
_s to
_olO_itive
Other
1o tl_
2J0/214
_o
to •n
flow
tO a p/ut_hty
th_
natural
error
d_tdng
_c-_po_s_vc
315/ISI,
the/col
sp+_cc_
II_:
while
of the
inhc¢cnt
INVENTION
the
el_-ctncal
th_
wh_Jh
;_:lu-
a id_otocdL
o_h_r_
arl
_
of
oL.shr.-_
ph_c.
ilhLqrat_vc
197.
311.
and
source
modules_
th_
_dcrc_c_
124.132
•
dcvlcc
1976.
is
I>_tiodg
_tiggc_mg
TT_
dlur_tio_
contgol
apparatus
of l_owcr con_ollcrs
cac_. interposed
Ja z first
75_.977
rcfctc'nyx__localc+d-gcnc_ally
olrU S Palca_t
307/116,117,
to
wl_-_h
23.
with
natio,a
plurality
is COoplb._
p_admg
This
_tchcs
OI • C_rcul_
inc_t
apphc_t_on
ct]_rgy
name
clock
of
st!hal
I_l_ so a_ tO adluSLthc
t_al
I_vcl of illumar*at_wwith_th_ intcxior
_lpaC_ tO fad w_thm
t_
acceptable
range
o_mld
a
c_r¢c_
zpaOc
(of s_l_-
m
II_c
the mo¢o¢ in StclYs
by
40
Pat_
wh_h
o/dlummatlon.
o4[ m<:rcory
_umhrat_oa
corded
typ_
dcv,cc
application
a_b.O_l IhC CiI'Cundc_c¢_cc
phtc
in U S
ol'_J_-_t_l
In
also
pl_o_'_l,vc
and _pa_c
Adm,n_trat_on
mochan/cal
moto_
which
a plushly
_-_t_]
and
an
designs
rctatc_
cont_olllng
a SOut_
illumination
_pOn-
,ccl,f-_
of th_
to _cld-m_L_l so_tccs
im_clud¢_
of
Inv_iloII
for
fim+ed b_wcem
tl_
c'_mt_ol of
compulcr
coauolled
A_o_aau_g
• b/diroct/o_d
cmu_gy
the
gmc:s
gh_ _cvcl_
intc_o[
In
to
an cloc-
_hool
invcnl/oo
_amphng
s._xmp/_,
fals_
aft
THE
OF
su_Ict_r_tin£
_nt_tior
of
L_ controllmg
o_
_tm_s_
S_padcat
U*_ilocl
osc
t_hliLattoo
tl_
_oups
fo[r
_,e_ng
tho_:
_c_po_iv_
d_s_lo_
• s_gral
fo_ controlling
Ihc
30
two
as
{ndcpc,_lcat
_uGc_CR)
Rd_ence
159.
off:co
through
a! the local
1.249.805
IqT;
for
by
_ot
3.767.924.
• com_¢c_
_t*onx
Z_
35
_ach
*s obtained
Iocml
dctcctc_x
c_
PaL _
of
b_
a Kght-
at lea_
_,_h
F_ch
laaa_p_ _ _'xd_e_d_ngt_
co_
oUcd.
a level Of amb_ni
dlomin_l_on_
C_a_l_
of
for _lar[-
d_.clo_c_
w_lh
I)f¢:_L'nl
from
to a _urc_
whoa
the pl_¢ot_nst_tor
c_d_tion
to
a non-
b<_ng utd_zed
foe
grOUpS
• I(_d
-['hc
troI Sy_lcrn
c_gy
Ct_cua! _ p_OV_l_d
of th_ ,clay
an din.mated
symptom
_o_r_l
the
p_o+
SUMMARY
_plplymg
to
will
dlun_una-
prc_:at
thctcto
to climi_lc
_o¢crn_nt_ov_d
thereby
20
off-
coopl_
clocked
network
lyp_c.ally
s,cl:_,_te
u_,c cdea Coati.onus
tc_ls
th_
R-C
device,
o1+ arl,l_cial
tlu:
and
rc.spoosivc
T_
555
level
lact-
R-C
ol the t_,ggcr
(:Jrcumst_,_._
winch
thi'g deign
clock
and
samlding
in
l_c son.co
wtth
pct_l_ally
g<:an_rate_l
of
the/ntcn_t¥
luras
•_c
pul_
in th_
a co_t_n_O_S
illumimtton
g_y
_.04trv_
co_ol
In cOntraLti
15 which
the
3.gTg.439.
d_lo_
a I>_oto¢o a Schm_lt
I_gg_r
a_t_ng
t_ming
A
m US_
control
not
on and
m turn
energy_
to attll'K:_ml
liming
false
Oflh_
th_
the
tl_
tl_
clock
ll.)iL_iion
38 l_[ccnt
Und_
Ibc:sc
t*_gg¢t
• fals4: change
_ilizc_
b,_dgc.
of a lalch_ng
•
O_[ I_
across
by _.Ko*t,ng
',all
dunng
inpuB
volt_gc
c_catcd
gc_/ly
co.rant
fccros._cx
Io groo, g_L Ol_:
iml_al_,_
llmc
any_m.c
of illuminal_
when
lhc
If _t
_n-tJ[_
tl_
_pl_oxtr_atc|y
p¢odoong
•
upon
Ibtci]bold.
anise
p4_t_od
the levd
mp_ra_
- -_
cxcc¢:_
prod_c_
d_clos_
i_nt
but n_c_cly
dctc_Ao(
cl¢_t_h:al
Of a rc_Ktancc
do_
_minal_on
In a relay
leg
powe_
tllura_t_x,
a_ a |h_hold
3.629.649.
op_r aDo_
in U_S PaL No
which
is co.plod
Ctoz,c'_.
I_mLs¢O_
_+
the
ek_-_g_:a]
aruf_¢_l
No_
illnf_fin_t_o_
oonL_olllng
ill_m_t_
of
one
of
Supt_ic_
oflbc
P_t
conq>d_ng
II_
wh_h
I/S
_
I_mlag
ace _';_'_FICd
llOn.
Dcl
tl_c
:h<: a_rop_ate
d_sign
14) In
_lumi-
having
lit_¢:_
the
Io exartif_L_l
_l_nr_l
cxlerna|
netw<_rk
.• wo_-k
-_oltagc
_alural
lira,t-
illum_na(_,_
_c_pon_vc
doc_ not
COntrOl
tl_c
so as to _mpldcmc_
S
conI_ghts
external
R*C
iIlumln_llOn
vaff_)_$
a t_cdetcrmir_rd
controls
_n/¢rnal
dlum_nL_tiOn,
but
:llumi_On
hghun_
dm_tlag
_n
:16(: t_mlng
o4 r,_lural
hghhng
Th_ clcctlh_al
_
_ c_c'd
'to.
the ovc_hc_l
pow¢:_r |h_cto
Blum_nat,on
4
illumtn_li<__
4 p, ovldcs
col*lzol
a schematic
c_rcorlry
of the
a truth
of dc_rcd
o_cn.lry
diagram
ul_l/+_cl
pcc_cnt
or
s:gm_i
Iogh_
lah4c
in
for
from
FIG
D11+-005+3
JA 0967
thc
tl_
logic
tirol
prc-
invention+
outpuls
a_ ilh:_t_ al_l
of
in
th_
the
vatlo_
bridg(:
2_
Page 148
)
_ 4.233.545
DETAILED
DESC.RiffflON
OF
dcnll
rgEFER.gEO EMt_ODIMEhrr
A
fit_t
matic
p,rcforcd
embodiment
control
fightin£
of
system
in
having
_nnhght
cxtctaaal
may
"n_
ck_uonk:
vwh_h
shis
of
automal_a]ly
fgom t_
_e
.s_l_l_mcs_
wath atlftc_l
I_c
'v-_zlablc
illumination,
hu:::axk:_nt
o_ flooJcsCcnt
llghl
AS
_lm_lc_
in RG
goats-ally
shown
the mt_
aaglc
sunlight
s,_llon
pa.w_g
ilhtm_tation
IS.
both
o4" she
OIt'otlgb
h_o
16. etc.
A
_
arld-lc_al
will
tot-
IS to hddgc
The
commands
o:cmuy
an
dcdvcd
which
portmn
actuatc_,
typically
moumc0
17
fo_
theretO.
tbe
manner
A l_:he_nati_
oDhc
ing
the
dla_t-am
systcmin
is shown
genexa/ly
scr/_
with
form
One
leg 31
rerdsto¢
and
y of an
the
_egzrd-
7_ The
cOup/d
by
light-
a rcy.iSto_r
_0_ A
circuit
a pot_ntt_n_ter
ano_h_
d_c45
33 so as to
rcslstot
35
is
_16 anO"ar_oshc.f
32
leg
of
detector.
fvr_
_m_
node
of the
secoad
th_
leg 3Z of
Isldgc
t:vc
dclcc_o¢
nod_
danc_
t_vc
luted
ally
bridgc
1O and tl_
[oe.lh
1]
30.
wh_cas
forms
the
no_
ciscult
30
A
by tbe oouldmg
rcslstot
node
37.
dcfmcd
DC
h_put
_cpfc:w.nt
port
10. arc
ChOSen ._uch
is Couplctt
and
43
into
comparator
port
ton
inc/dclat
to •
upon
within
In
th_
as V i I_,c the
•nd V_ foc_be
socond
-ode.
wi_h the dumgmg
hnic,_LmO_
will
vary.'u_-:
of she ¢boto_;-
IO. "]['yp_ca_ly
_
•
mod_
tl_tcfm_
ch•raClC_zed
sln_d_r
_
pho(o-_eny._;vc
CKSO_.
Mamdactming
_csp0nsc$
_
such
Co.
tO th_
of
human
photo_c_t_e
_u__ dcvt<c
as
3fd
eye
itl•y
/_
_ctt_toi
wl_ch
du4_L_y_
42
poet
I_r_J
wh_;h
the
first
SO
tlh_t_ttk: if any
by
Avc_.
sub_
is gc_¢_• tc_occ_d
of tbe
inpul
b_dg_
voltage
change
iml_dancc
.
_ot_g_
40
at
to
the
o_ttpu