Proposal for Changes Master of Science in Survey Methodology Degree Requirements September 2003 For further information contact: Professor Katharine G. Abraham JPSM 1218 LeFrak Hall 301-405-1004 kabraham@survey.umd.edu Administrative Structure of the Joint Program in Survey Methodology (JPSM) The Joint Program in Survey Methodology (JPSM) is a consortium undertaking of the University of Maryland, the University of Michigan, and Westat. Primary funding for the JPSM is provided by the Interagency Council on Statistical Policy, a group made up of the principal federal statistical agencies. In September 1991, a National Academy of Sciences/National Research Council (NAS/NRC) workshop focused on the development of a “Center for Survey Methods” that would offer an advanced degree in survey methodology. Due to the interdisciplinary nature of the subject matter, no existing department was deemed to be a suitable home for such a center. The JPSM was created to educate the next generation of professional staff of the federal statistical system. The JPSM is housed physically at the University of Maryland and has all the curricular rights and responsibilities of a conventional department. The Director, the chief JPSM administrative officer, is appointed for a three-year term by the Dean of the University of Maryland College of Behavioral and Social Sciences, with the advice and consent of the Director of the University of Michigan Survey Research Center, and in consultation with the Chairman of the Board of Westat. JPSM faculty appointments are tailored to the consortium structure noted above. There is a core faculty (instructors with ongoing appointments for the teaching of required courses in the curriculum) and an affiliate faculty (instructors with duties of a more transient nature). The core faculty is drawn from the University of Maryland, the University of Michigan, and Westat. Teaching some courses from remote locations, using state-of-the-art videoconferencing facilities, allows students to learn from faculty with expertise in the whole range of subject matter relevant to the field of survey methodology. An Executive Committee has oversight of all JPSM administrative matters and policies. It consists of the Director (chair), the Associate Director, and two members who are elected by the faculty for two-year terms. At least one member of the committee has a primary appointment at the University of Maryland, one a joint appointment at the University of Michigan, and one a joint appointment with Westat. The program has a Curriculum Committee consisting of four faculty, who are appointed by the Executive Committee, and two students, who are elected by JPSM degree candidates. It is concerned with all matters relating to courses and instruction. Finally, an Admissions Committee consisting of at least four members appointed by the Executive Committee is concerned with all matters related to student selection and support. To date, there have been 90 graduates from the JPSM Masters program. Current enrollment is 66 Masters students and 5 PhD students. The majority of JPSM students are current federal government employees working on their Masters degree on a part-time basis. There are currently 17 full-time students in the program. Current Program Degree Requirements Students enrolled in the Master of Science in Survey Methodology degree program may choose between two areas of concentration. Below is the current curriculum for each area. Statistical Science Social Science SURV 410: Introduction to Probability Theory SURV 420: Introduction to Statistics SURV 440: Sampling Theory SURV 615: Statistical Methods I SURV 616: Statistical Methods II SURV 620: Survey Practicum I SURV 621: Survey Practicum II SURV 623: Data Collection Methods in Survey Research SURV 625: Applied Sampling SURV 670: Introduction to the Federal Statistical System I SURV 671: Introduction to the Federal Statistical System II SURV 722: Random and Nonrandomized Research Design SURV 723: Total Survey Error SURV 742: Inference from Complex Surveys SURV 744: Topics in Sampling SURV 770: Survey Design Seminar I SURV 771: Survey Design Seminar II Elective SURV 601: Social Statistics I SURV 602: Social Statistics II SURV 620: Survey Practicum I SURV 621: Survey Practicum II SURV 623: Data Collection Methods in Survey Research SURV 625: Applied Sampling SURV 630: Questionnaire Design SURV 632: Social and Cognitive Foundations of Survey Measurement SURV 670: Introduction to the Federal Statistical System I SURV 671: Introduction to the Federal Statistical System II SURV 701: Analysis of Complex Sample Data SURV 722: Random and Nonrandomized Research Design SURV 723: Total Survey Error SURV 760: Survey Management SURV 770: Survey Design Seminar I SURV 771: Survey Design Seminar II Elective Elective In addition to taking the courses listed above, students in both concentration areas must complete an internship that gives them hands-on experience doing survey work. Many of the students enrolled in the program have jobs that fulfill this requirement; internship placements are arranged for those who do not. Rationale for Proposed Changes to Degree Requirements Based on the experience with the program over its first ten years in existence, a review of the requirements for the Master of Science in Survey Methodology was initiated by the Director. A faculty committee was formed for that purpose. The committee members talked with other faculty, current and past students and potential employers of program graduates. The committee developed a recommended set of program changes that then were voted upon (and approved unanimously) by the JPSM faculty. Taken as a whole, these changes would achieve several objectives. • Ensure that all students take a statistical methods course that is sufficiently rigorous to prepare them well for later required coursework; • Increase the number of electives students may take in pursuit of their particular interests ( depending on their track, students currently have either one or two electives); • Better support students in writing the independent research paper required for the Total Survey Error capstone course; • Better align course credits with course workloads. Highlights of Proposed Changes to Degree Requirements The specific changes proposed for the Masters of Science in Survey Methodology curriculum are as follows: 1. Randomized and Nonrandomized Research Design (SURV 722) no longer a required course for students on the statistical science track. Will be offered as an elective. 2. Survey Management (SURV 760) no longer a required course for students on the social science track. Offered as an elective. 3. Introduction to the Federal Statistical System (SURV 670/671) reduced to a 1-semester, 1-credit class (SURV 670). Material in the second semester of the existing sequence deemed not to be critical. 4. Survey Design Seminar (SURV 770/771) changed from a 2-semester, 1-credit-per-term sequence to a 1-semester, 3-credit class (SURV 772). In its current form, the course carried too few credits for the workload involved. More concentrated exposure to a somewhat smaller number of design units will better meet program goals. 5. SURV 615 and SURV 616 (Stat Methods I and II) become the basic intro stat sequence for both concentrations, replacing SURV 601 and SURV 602 on the social science track. Experience shows that all students need the more rigorous treatment offered by SURV 615 and SURV 616. 6. Total Survey Error (currently taught as SURV 723) offered as a 2-semester, 2-credit per term class in which students cover relevant literature and choose a research paper topic in the first semester (SURV 720) and write an original research paper in the second semester (SURV 721). The two semester format will provide a more realistic time frame for preparing the required research paper and the increase in allotted total credits from three to four will align more closely with the actual workload. 7. Survey Practicum (SURV 620/621) offered as a 2-semester, 2-credit-per-term class (SURV 640/641). This change is intended to better align course credits with course workload. These changes result in statistical science track students having two electives, one more than at present, and social science track students having three electives rather than two. The total number of credits required for receipt of a M.S. degree is reduced from 46 to 45. Proposed Course Schedule for Full Time Students in the Revised Master of Science in Survey Methodology program Term Statistical Science Social Science Fall, Year 1 410: 615: 623: 670: 615: 623: 632: 670: Intro Probability (3) Stat Methods I (3) Data Collection (3) Fed Stat (1) 10 credits Spring, Year 1 420: 616: 640: 625: Stat Methods I (3) Data Collection (3) Social and Cognitive Founds. (3) Fed Stat (1) 11 credits Intro to Stat (3) Stat Methods II (3) Practicum I (2) Applied Sampling (3) 616: 640: 625: 630: Stat Methods II (3) Practicum I (2) Applied Sampling (3) Questionnaire Design (3) 11 credits 11 credits Summer, Year 1 Internship Internship Fall, Year 2 440: Sampling Theory (3) 621: Practicum II (2) 720: Total Survey Error I (2) 772: Design Seminar (3) Elective (3) 621: 701: 720: 772: 722: 13 credits 13 credits 721: Total Survey Error II (2) 742: Inference (3) 744: Topics in Sampling (3) Elective (3) 721: Total Survey Error II (2) Elective (3) Elective (3) Elective (3) 11 credits 11 credits Spring, Year 2 Practicum II (2) Analysis of Complex Data (3) Total Survey Error I (2) Design Seminar (3) Random/Nonrandom (3) Proposed Course Schedule for Half-Time Students the Master of Science in Survey Methodology program Term Statistical Science Social Science Fall, Year 1 410: 615: 670: 615: 632: 670: Intro Probability (3) Stat Methods I (3) Fed Stat (1) 7 credits Spring, Year 1 420: 616: 640: 7 credits Intro to Stat (3) Stat Methods II (3) Practicum I (2) 8 credits Summer, Year 1 Fall, Year 2 Spring, Year 2 Summer, Year 2 625: Stat Methods I (3) Social and Cognitive Founds. (3) Fed Stat (1) 616: 630: 640: Stat Methods II (3) Questionnaire Design (3) Practicum I (2) 8 credits Applied Sampling (3) 625: Applied Sampling (3) 3 credits 3 credits 440: 623: 641: 623: 722: 641: Sampling Theory (3) Data Collection (3) Practicum II (2) Data Collection (3) Random/Nonrandom (3) Practicum II (2) 8 credits 8 credits 744: Topics in Sampling (3) Elective (3) Elective (3) Elective (3) 6 credits 6 credits Internship Internship Term Statistical Science Social Science Fall, Year 3 772: 720: 701: 772: 720: Spring, Year 3 Design Seminar (3) Total Survey Error I (2) Analysis of Complex Data (3) Design Seminar (3) Total Survey Error I (2) 5 credits 8 credits 721: Total Survey Error II (2) 742: Inference (3) Elective (3) 721: Total Survey Error II (2) Elective (3) 8 credits 5 credits Transition Plan for New M.S. Curriculum The new M.S. curriculum requirements are to be introduced for students who enter the program in the fall of 2004. During the 2004-2005 academic year, only the courses typically taken by full-time students in their first year will be modified; remaining course changes will be introduced during the 2005-2006 academic year. This phasing means that full-time students entering the program in the fall of 2003 will be able to complete the current program; full-time students entering the program in the fall of 2004 or later will operate under the new requirements. The only transition issues involve part-time students. This document addresses explicitly the transition issues for half-time students. There are relatively few students enrolled in the program on less than a half-time basis and schedules for those affected by the transition wil be worked out on an individual basis. Half-time Students – Fall 2002 Entering Cohort Half-time students who entered the program in the fall of 2002 are scheduled to complete their coursework in the spring of 2005. They will be able to complete their program under the old curriculum. These students will be allowed to substitute an elective for the previously required courses that have been made optional under the new curriculum (Survey Management for social science students Random/Nonrandom for statistical science students). Half-time Students – Fall 2003 Entering Cohort Changes in the M.S. curriculum include changes in the number of credits associated with the Survey Practicum (from 3 credits per semester to 2 credits per semester); Total Survey Error (from 3 credits in one semester to 4 credits over two semesters); and the Survey Design Seminar (from 2 credits spread over two semesters to 3 credits in one semester). Schedules for half-time students on the statistical science track who enroll in the fall of 2003 can be arranged so that they take only the new versions of these courses. Half-time students on the social science track who enroll in the fall of 2003 will need to take the old version of Total Survey Error, offered in the spring of their second year, in order to complete their degree in the spring of their third year without carrying an overload in any semester. Proposed transition schedules for students on both tracks are shown on the attached pages. In addition, half-time social science students who enter the program in fall 2003 may be encouraged to take SURV 615/616 rather than SURV 601/602, if their backgrounds adequately prepare them to do so. Half-time Students – Fall 2004 Entering Cohort Half-time students who enter the program in the fall of 2004 will fall strictly under the new program requirements. TRANSITION COURSE SCHEDULE FOR HALF TIME STUDENTS ENTERING FALL 2003 Term Fall 2003 Statistical Science Social Science 410: 615: 670: 615: 632: 670: Intro Probability (3) Stat Methods I (3) Fed Stat I (1) 7 credits Spring 2004 420: 616: 671: 7 credits Intro to Stat (3) Stat Methods II (3) Fed Stat II (1) 7 credits Summer 2004 Fall 2004 Spring 2005 Summer 2005 625: Stat Methods I (3) Social and Cognitive Founds. (3) Fed Stat I (1) 616: 630: 671: Stat Methods II (3) Questionnaire Design (3) Fed Stat II (1) 7 credits Applied Sampling (3) 625: Applied Sampling (3) 3 credits 3 credits 440: 623: 623: 722: Sampling Theory (3) Data Collection (3) Data Collection (3) Random/Nonrandom (3) 6 credits 6 credits 640: Practicum I (2) 744: Topics in Sampling (3) Elective (3) 640: Practicum I (2) 723: Total Survey Error (3) Elective (3) 8 credits 8 credits Internship Internship Term Fall 2005 Spring 2006 Statistical Science Social Science 641: 720: 772: 641: 701: 772: Practicum II (2) Total Survey Error I (2) Design Seminar (3) Practicum II (2) Analysis of Complex Data (3) Design Seminar (3) 7 credits 8 credits 721: Total Survey Error II (2) 742: Inference (3) Elective (3) Elective (3) Elective (3) 8 credits 6 credits