STRATEGIC PLAN PROGRESS REPORT Strategic Priority 1 - Student Access Goal 1A: Hartnell College will provide higher education workforce development, and lifelong learning opportunities - with seamless pathways - to all of the college's present and prospective constituent individuals and groups. Plan 1. Create opportunities for orientation, assessment, and counseling/educational plan development for incoming high school students. 2. Create opportunities for orientation, assessment, counseling/educational plan development for returning underemployed/unemployed student populations in conjunction with the local Monterey County Workforce Investment Board. 3. Work in conjunction with feeder high school English and Math faculty and administrators to embed the Hartnell College online orientation and Accuplacer assessment test content into the College Readiness component of the common core curriculum. 4. Collaborate with Community Based Organizations e.g. Turning Point, Peacock Acres, Girls Inc., etc. to embed the Hartnell College Orientation and Student Educational Planner on desktop computers to provide post-secondary information to students interested in enrolling at Hartnell College. 5. Implement a web based advising model for transfer preparation utilizing SKYPE or other online virtual tool for students who want to meet with a university transfer advisor. 6. Program and implement ESARS for students to be able to access Counseling Appointments online. 7. Develop and implement Student Success Planning/Career Exploration workshops for students. These workshops will assist students in identifying an educational goal and major. 8. Develop and implement a live chat software system for students to engage in online counseling with an academic counselor. 9. Develop a transfer orientation activity to ensure students Progress 1. The first activity to address this goal was completed during Panther Prep Days 2014. Panther Prep Day on the Main Campus was held on Saturday, May 10th. A total of 686 students participated in matriculation activities and registered for Fall 2014 courses. 2. Multiple meetings are in progress to develop service delivery between Hartnell College and the Monterey County One Stop Career Center. 3. In September 2014 we convened a meeting that included English, ESL, and Math faculty from our feeder high schools and Hartnell College to discuss common core curriculum, Accuplacer assessment test preparation, and college readiness. 4. Preliminary work has begun to install Hartnell College information on desktops at community based organization facilities. Estimated completion date is Spring 2015. 5. Preliminary exploration on this technology has begun. A new computer with webcam was purchased in Fall 2014. A tentative timeline for implementation is Summer 2015. 6. Final programming of SARS reason codes has been completed in Fall 2014. Implementation of student online appointments for counseling is expected in Spring 2015. 7. Curriculum for workshops has been developed and workshops were offered beginning in August and throughout Fall 2014. 8. A Faculty Inquiry Group (FIG) was developed in March 2014. FIG is targeted with identifying software that is effective, and will begin working with the Hartnell College Information Technology Department to test the software in Spring 2015. A group of counselors and the Dean of Student Success visited Fresno City College in Fall 2014 to demonstrate live chat software to use in online counseling services. 9. The first Transfer Orientation occurred in May 2014. This will become a biannual event to assist in the development of a university transfer culture at Hartnell College. Hartnell College also hosted the 29th annual Transfer Day/College Night on November 13, 2014. Day 3. Work in conjunction with feeder high school English and from our feeder high schools and Hartnell College to discuss common core curriculum, Math faculty and administrators to embed the Hartnell College Accuplacer assessment test preparation, and college readiness. online orientation and Accuplacer assessment test content into the College Readiness component of the common core 4. Preliminary work has begun to install Hartnell College information on desktops at curriculum. community based organization facilities. Estimated completion date is Spring 2015. 4. Collaborate with Community Based Organizations e.g. Strategic Priority 1 - Student Access Turning Point, Peacock Acres, Girls Inc., etc. to embed the 5. Preliminary exploration on this technology has begun. A new computer with webcam was Goal 1A: Hartnell College will provide higher education workforce development, and lifelong learning opportunities - with seamless pathways - to all of the Hartnell College Orientation and Student Educational Planner purchased in Fall 2014. A tentative timeline for implementation is Summer 2015. college's present and prospective constituent individuals and groups. on desktop computers to provide post-secondary information to students interested in enrolling 6. Final programming of SARS reason codesProgress has been completed in Fall 2014. Implementation Plan at Hartnell College. 5. Implement a web based advising model for transfer of student online appointments for counseling is expected in Spring 2015. preparation utilizing SKYPE or other online virtual tool for students who want to meet with a university transfer advisor. 7. Curriculum for workshops has been developed and workshops were offered beginning in 6. Program and implement ESARS for students to be able to August and throughout Fall 2014. access Counseling Appointments online. 8. A Faculty Inquiry Group (FIG) was developed in March 2014. FIG is targeted with identifying 7. Develop and implement Student Success Planning/Career software that is effective, and will begin working with the Hartnell College Information Exploration workshops for students. These workshops will Technology Department to test the software in Spring 2015. A group of counselors and the assist students in identifying an educational goal and major. Dean of Student Success visited Fresno City College in Fall 2014 to demonstrate live chat 8. Develop and implement a live chat software system for software to use in online counseling services. students to engage in online counseling with an academic 9. The first Transfer Orientation occurred in May 2014. This will become a biannual event to counselor. assist in the development of a university transfer culture at Hartnell College. Hartnell College 9. Develop a transfer orientation activity to ensure students also hosted the 29th annual Transfer Day/College Night on November 13, 2014. Day who are preparing to transfer to a university meet with their attendees totaled 1,386. Night attendees totaled 740. peers to identify strategies for successful integration at their respective university. Strategic Priority 1 - Student Access Goal 1A: Hartnell College will provide higher education workforce development, and lifelong learning opportunities - with seamless pathways - to all of the college's present and prospective constituent individuals and groups. Plan Progress Outcome 1A.1 - Increase the first time student, recent high school graduate enrollment rate from service area high schools and maintain the rates at or above the California Community College statewide average. The participation rate of recent high school graduates for fall 2014 (38.5%) is above the statewide average (32.0%). The only high school with a participation rate below the statewide average is North Montery County (8.2%). Additional analysis and inquiry will be needed to fully understand this low participation rate and to implement strategies that will improve the participation rate. Early in 2013-2014, the College staff worked with each area high school to refine the steps to success process. Through various meetings, Panther Prep Days was created and implemented May 9 – 10, 2014. Hartnell admitted and assessed 1,617 students as part of this new initiative. During the two Panther Prep day events, 567 recent high school graduates enrolled for the fall 2014 semester. A total of 1,067 recent high school graduates enrolled for the fall 2014. At the August 5, 2014 board meeting, the HC Board approved two grant collaborations with GEAR UP initiatives. These involved South County with CSUMB, and North County with UCSC, increasing the outreach and recruitment to high school students concurrently enrolled at Hartnell. Financial Aid advising and parent workshops all the way to San Lucas and San Ardo are part of the activities. South County Education has entered into a partnership with Migrant Ed. to house the King City office for out-of-school youth, thus increasing the outreach to this vulnerable population. Through the Student Success and Support Program Plan , the position of College Pathways Coordinator has been created. This position will focus on strengthening K-12 and college relationships to ensure that the participation rates of graduating high school seniors continues to be at or above the statewide participation rate. This is particularly important over the next 5 years because the numbers of graduating seniors for high schools in the Hartnell CCD will not be increasing based on projections. Strategic Priority 1 - Student Access Goal 1A: Hartnell College will provide higher education workforce development, and lifelong learning opportunities - with seamless pathways - to all of the college's present and prospective constituent individuals and groups. Baseline (Fall 2014) KPI 1A.1a - Enrollment rates ofPlan high school graduates from 38.5% service area high schools. Greenfield 52.6% Everett Alvarez 48.1% North Salinas 41.3% Gonzales 41.1% Soledad 40.1% Alisal 39.2% OVERALL DISTRICT RATE 38.5% King City 33.0% STATEWIDE RATE 32.0% Salinas 31.5% N. Monterey Co. 8.2% Mt. Toro Cont. (17) N/A Actual (Fall 2014) Progress 38.5% 52.6% 48.1% 41.3% 41.1% 40.1% 39.2% 38.5% 33.0% 32.0% 31.5% 8.2% N/A Target (State Average) 32.0% Strategic Priority 1 - Student Access Goal 1A: Hartnell College will provide higher education workforce development, and lifelong learning opportunities - with seamless pathways - to all of the college's present and prospective constituent individuals and groups. Plan Progress Outcome 1A.2 - Increase the enrollment rate for adults 18 years Efforts to enroll students graduationg high school students has been successful as demonstrated in and older for all communities within the District and maintain Outcome 1A.1. However, overall participation rates for adults 18 and older in the Hartnell CCD remains a challenge. the rates at or above the California Community College A recent regulatory change has impacted participation rates for all adults in the Hartnell CCD. There were statewide rate. revisions made in the Title 5 Regulations on Repeats and Withdrawals that went into effect October 12, 2011 that placed repeat limits placed on physical education, visual arts, and performing courses. Many of these courses are taken by older adults. There are many efforts throughout the Hartnell District in which the College commits to working on enrolling adults outside of high school graduates. EOPS reports that 33% of their student population served is in the 25 years and older category. The Veterans program also reports an average age of their Veteran student population is in the 25-29 year old category. Our Western Stage's mission is to serve the Community at Large, so this includes many participants who are over the age of 25. Starting with the adult at age 55 and older they have their Legacy Players Program. Their annual Spring FEST has an average of 8-10 projects that include adults 25 and older. The College is currently involved in the planning phase of AB86 funding which is dedicated to improving and expanding adult education services throughout the District. Steering Committees were meeting during this spring 2014 semester to develop elements for the plan. Our South County Educational Services is preparing to increase their outreach efforts to re-entry ECE students from out South County cities by providing presentations through Mexican American Opportunity Foundation (MAOF) in Salinas and in South County Health Fairs. South County Education Services applied for a grant with the Community Foundation of Monterey County that would help non-college-ready adults increase their literacy skills. The Promoting Access to Literacy ("PAL") grant will make Reading Plus software and tutoring available at the King City and Greenfield libraries (Monterey County Free Library System), along with information on Hartnell College. Through the Student Equity Plan , we are planning to create an additional College Pathways Coordinator position that is parallel to the position for working with K-12. This additional position will focus on strengthening participation rates of adults who are not recent high school graduates. Strategic Priority 1 - Student Access Goal 1A: Hartnell College will provide higher education workforce development, and lifelong learning opportunities - with seamless pathways - to all of the college's present and prospective constituent individuals and groups. Plan Progress KPI 1A.2a Enrollment rates of adults (18-65) from communities served by the District (rate per 1,000 adults) Chualar STATEWIDE RATE Gonzales Salinas King City Greenfield San Lucas Spreckels DISTRICT OVERALL RATE Castroville San Ardo Soledad Prunedale Hollister Baseline (2012) 107.1 82.0 72.3 70.1 64.5 63.9 54.5 54.2 52.6 42.6 32.3 31.0 14.4 3.9 Actual (2012) 107.1 82.0 72.3 70.1 64.5 63.9 54.5 54.2 52.6 42.6 32.3 31.0 14.4 3.9 Target 82.0 Strategic Priority 1 - Student Access Goal 1A: Hartnell College will provide higher education workforce development, and lifelong learning opportunities - with seamless pathways - to all of the college's present and prospective constituent individuals and groups. Plan rates for historically Outcome 1A.3 - Increase enrollment underrepresented students. The student population of Hartnell should beProgress representative of the communities served by the District. Based on the most recent census information for the District (2010) and recent enrollment data (fall 2014), there are some small differences in terms of the representation of ethnic groups at Hartnell College compared to their representation within the Hartnell CCD. These difference are not of concern at this point of the strategic plan. However, this metric will be monitored annually during the term of the strategic plan for any increases in the current small differences. Baseline (2013) Actual (2013) Target (District 2010 Census) African-American 2.5% 2.5% 2.7% American Indian/Alaskan Native 0.5% 0.5% 0.3% Asian 2.3% 2.3% 4.4% Hispanic 72.8% 72.8% 74.7% Pacific Islander 3.8% 3.8% 3.5% Unknown/Multi-Ethnicity 5.4% 5.4% 2.3% White Non-Hispanic 12.8% 12.8% 16.3% Outcome 1A.4 - Provide an inviting, welcoming, and supportive The surveys of student engagement that are associated with Strategic Priority 2 provide campus atmosphere for all student groups. measures for assessing this outcome. Under consideration for the future is a student satisfaction survey and/or campus climate survey to assess this outcome. KPI 1A.3a Enrollment rates by race/ethnicity Strategic Priority 2 - Student Success Goal 2A: Hartnell College will provide a supportive, innovative, and collaborative learning environment to help students pursue and achieve educational success. Plan Progress 1. Develop Student Success and Support Program Plan, Student Equity Plan and BSI Action Plan to provide goals, activities, and outcomes to improve student success. 2. Discuss and analyze results from the SENSE and CCSSE surveys to assess student engagement and to determine factors that affect why some entering students persist and succeed and others do not. 3. Hartnell College will fully implement its new "Steps to Success" student enrollment process in fall 2014. As a result of modifying the process and implementing services focused on increasing student readiness, including Accuplacer Test preparation workshops, students will demonstrate increased success in math and English. 4. Faculty, staff and management will engage in continuous, broad-based dialog to assess outcomes at the course, program, institutional, and service area levels. 1. Final drafts of the Student Success and Support Program Plan, Student Equity Plan, and BSI Action Plan have been presented to College committees and councils beginning August 18. 2. SENSE survey results were administered in fall 2013 and results were received in spring 2014. The CCSSE was administered in the spring of 2014 and received in the summer of 2014. Success and equity planning work groups used survey data in developing the 2014-15 Student Success and Support Program Plan, Student Equity Plan, and BSI Action Plan. 3. Hartnell College has developed a more structured process to provide incoming students with the tools to achieve educational success, such as: - Implemented degree audit and student planning modules - Held First Annual Panther Prep day (686 students registered at Main Campus and King City Center) - Increased pilot group participation (faculty) in ESP (Early Support Program) - Launched online orientation (Fall, 2014) - Provided ESL instructions for assessment in Spanish - Rolled out ed plan software for counselor use (Fall 2014) - Hosted high school/Hartnell counselor breakfast - Improved assessment offering to area high schools. 4. Service area staff and faculty have continued to meet and discuss outcomes, assessment, and interventions to improve student learning. Strategic Priority 2 - Student Success Goal 2A: Hartnell College will provide a supportive, innovative, and collaborative learning environment to help students pursue and achieve educational success. Plan Outcome 2A.1 Hartnell College will improve its level of student engagement. Progress See Outcome 2B.2. Outcome 2A.1 turns out to be redundant with 2B.2 and will be removed from subsequent versions of the strategic plan. Plan Outcome 2A.2 Systematically assess and, when necessary, revise Student Learning Outcomes (SLOs) and Service Area Outcomes (SAOs). KPI 2A.2a Completion of SLO assessments and revisions KPI 2A.2b Completion of SAO assessments and revisions Progress 100% of SLOs and/or SAOs have been developed. The number of assessments has increased, but the college needs to improve assessment rates, enact modifications, and reassess. Planning and implementation of eLumen software is ongoing. Baseline 71% of offered courses assessed 75% of academic programs assessed; 100% of core competencies assessed; Calendars developed for course-level outcome assessment Actual 71% of offered courses assessed 75% of academic programs assessed; 100% of core competen-cies assessed 44% of outcomes assessed 44% Target 100% of offered courses assessed 100% of academic programs assessed; 100% of core competencies assessed 100% of SAOs assessed Strategic Priority 2 - Student Success Goal 2A: Hartnell College will provide a supportive, innovative, and collaborative learning environment to help students pursue and achieve educational success. Plan Progress Outcome 2A.3 By 2017-18, Hartnell College will be at or above the statewide The Scorecard outcomes are provided for the following cohorts for average for all student success measures on the California Community College many of the measures: college prepared, college unprepared, and Chancellor's Office "Student Success Scorecard" overall (combining both). For the “college prepared” cohort the numbers of students are so small for most demographic categories (many with less than 10 students) that it makes little sense to focus our efforts on this cohort. Additionally, we know that majority of entering students at Hartnell are unprepared for college level academic courses. When comparing Hartnell outcomes to Statewide outcomes the question arises “when is a difference large enough to be of concern and to require additional analysis and possible strategies for improvement?” Hartnell has opted to use the following guidelines in assessing these differences for the scorecard measures. If a difference is less than 10%, it will be of moderate concern and we will continue to monitor the difference over time for any increase in the difference. If a difference is 10% or more, it will be of significant concern and will require immediate, additional analysis and inquiry for possible intervention strategies. As a result only one outcome emerged requiring additional inquiry and analysis due to a significant difference between the Hartnell outcome and the Statewide outcome, Remedial: ESL (11.7% compared to 27.1%). Faculty and administrators involved in ESL programs and services will be examining ESL outcomes during 2014-15 with a goal of improving student success in ESL courses. Strategic Priority 2 - Student Success Goal 2A: Hartnell College will provide a supportive, innovative, and collaborative learning environment to help students pursue and achieve educational success. KPI 2A.3a California Community College Chancellor's Office Student Success Scorecard Remedial: Math Remedial: English Remedial: ESL Persistence: Unprepared for College 30 Units: Unprepared for College Degree/Transfer: Unprepared for College Career Technical Education Baseline 31.8% 43.6% Actual 31.8% 43.6% Target 30.6% 43.6% 11.7% 63.7% 67.2% 39.4% 46.2% 11.7% 63.7% 67.2% 39.4% 46.2% 27.1% 70.1% 65.3% 40.5% 53.9% Strategic Priority 2 - Student Success Goal 2B: Hartnell College will provide a supportive, innovative, and collaborative learning environment that addresses and meets the diverse learning needs of students. Plan 1. Develop Online Orientation 2. Create Panther Prep events 3. Institutionalize Multiple measures for placement 4. Increase Office of student life activities 5. Strengthen student services and academic learning support services 6. Priority registration for all Categorical programs and special student groups. Progress 1. Mandatory online orientation implementation starting November 17, 2014. 2. 1st annual Panther Prep implemented May 10, 2014. Second Panther Prep scheduled for May 2015. 3. Multiple measures for placement is a component of the Student Success and Support Program Plan now in effect. 4. Office of Student Life increased programs and services by 60% from previous years, including Alisal Campus and South County Education Center. 5. Increased tutorial support services at Alisal Campus and King City Education Center. Through the implementation of the Student Success and Support Program Plan, student services and academic learning support services are being expanded and strengthened. 6. Revised priority registration system was implemented fall 2014. Strategic Priority 2 - Student Success Goal 2B: Hartnell College will provide a supportive, innovative, and collaborative learning environment that addresses and meets the diverse learning needs of students. Plan Outcome 2B.1 By academic year 2017-2018, Hartnell College will achieve approximately equal success rates among racial/ethnic groups and for gender. Progress When comparing course success and retention rates for groups the question arises “when is a difference large enough to be of concern and require additional analysis and possible strategies for improvement?” Hartnell has chosen to use the “80% rule” that is often used in disproportionate impact analyses. The 80% rule means that if a particular group is less than 80% of the highest performing group, then the difference requires additional analysis and inquiry. Courses Success Rates No differences were found for gender or race/ethnicity. Course Retention Rates No differences were found for gender or race/ethnicity. Degrees Awarded For degrees awarded, the goal is to have degrees awarded to gender and race/ethnicity groups in proportion to their representation in the student population. For gender in 201314, women were significantly over-represented in degrees awarded compared to their representation in the student population (49.2% enrollment vs. 66.9% of degrees awarded). Men were significantly under-represented (50.8% enrollment vs. 33.0% of degrees awarded). For race/ethnicity in 2013-14, the distribution of degrees awarded by ethnicity is comparable to the ethnic representation of the student population with only minimal differences. Addditional inquiry and analysis are necessary to determine why men are not completing degrees in proportion to their representation in the student population. Strategic Priority 2 - Student Success Goal 2B: Hartnell College will provide a supportive, innovative, and collaborative learning environment that addresses and meets the diverse learning needs of students. KPI 2B.1a Course success and Plan retention rates by ethnicity and gender. Progress Baseline Actual Target Course Success Female Male 72.4% 70.5% 72.4% 70.5% 58% African-American American Indian/Alaskan Native Asian Hispanic Pacific Islander Unknown/Multi-ethnicity White Non-Hispanic 67.4% 67.2% 81.0% 68.5% 80.5% 75.1% 80.6% 67.4% 67.2% 81.0% 68.5% 80.5% 75.1% 80.6% 66% Course Retention Female Male 84.9% 83.9% 84.9% 83.9% African-American American Indian/Alaskan Native Asian Hispanic Pacific Islander Unknown/Multi-ethnicity White Non-Hispanic 82.5% 82.0% 90.4% 83.0% 94.8% 85.6% 87.7% 82.5% 82.0% 90.4% 83.0% 94.8% 85.6% 87.7% 68% 76% Strategic Priority 2 - Student Success Goal 2B: Hartnell College will provide a supportive, innovative, and collaborative learning environment that addresses and meets the diverse learning needs of students. KPI 2B.1b Degrees awarded byPlan race/ethnicity and gender. Student Population Progress Degrees Awarded Target Female Male 49.2% 50.8% 66.9% 33.1% 49.2% 50.8% African-American American Indian/Alaskan Native Asian Hispanic Pacific Islander Unknown/Multi-ethnicity White Non-Hispanic 2.5% 0.5% 2.3% 72.8% 3.8% 5.4% 12.8% 1.8% 0.5% 5.0% 74.4% 0.5% 5.3% 11.5% 2.5% 0.5% 2.3% 72.8% 3.8% 5.4% 12.8% Strategic Priority 2 - Student Success Goal 2B: Hartnell College will provide a supportive, innovative, and collaborative learning environment that addresses and meets the diverse learning needs of students. Plan Outcome 2B.2 By academic year 2017-2018, Hartnell College will be at or above national benchmarks for measures of student engagement. Progress CCSSE (Community College Survey of Student Engagment) For the CCSSE, Hartnell is at or above the national benchmarks for all measures of student engagement. The CCSSE was completed by a stratified, random sample of students during 2013-14. Over 700 students completed the survey. SENSE (Survey of Entering Student Engagement) Over 300 entering students completed the SENSE. Results indicate that Hartnell has effective education practices for the following with benchmarks above or close to the national benchmarks: Effective Track to College Readiness Engaged Learning Areas of highest student engagement across these categories included the following: Prepared two or more drafts of a paper or assignment before turning Worked with other students on a project or assignment during class Worked with classmates outside of class on class projects or assignments Participated in a required study group outside of class Used an electronic tool to communicate with another student about coursework Results indicate that Hartnell is below the national benchmarks for the following: Academic and Social Support Network Early Connections High Expecations and Aspirations Clear Academic Plan and Pathway Strategic Priority 2 - Student Success Goal 2B: Hartnell College will provide a supportive, innovative, and collaborative learning environment that addresses and meets the diverse learning needs of students. Plan Outcome 2B.2 By academic year 2017-2018, Hartnell College will be at or above national benchmarks for measures of student engagement (continued). KPI 2B.2a Results of the CCSSE Active and Collaborative Learning Student Effort Academic Challenge Student-Faculty Interaction Support for Learners Progress Areas of lowest student engagement across these categories included the following: An advisor helped me to select a course of study, program, or major An advisor helped me to identify the courses I needed to take during my first semester/quarter Discussed an assignment or grade with an instructor Used writing, math, or other skill lab Used computer lab A number of initiatives are already under way to address these areas of lowest student engagement. Panther Prep Days has resulted in much more engagement of entering students in preparing an educational plan. Additional counselors are being hired through the Student Success and Support Program Plan (SSSP) to provide greater access to academic advising and counseling services. Additional staff members are being employed through the SSSP to provide academic follow-up services to students. The draft Facilities Master Plan includes proposals to establish a Student Success Center that can accommodate learning support services such as a writing lab, math lab, etc. Social support for students has been enhanced through a dramatic increase in activities, events, student organizations, and participation through the Office of Student Life. Baseline 50.1 49.6 50.4 47.6 52.5 Actual 50.1 49.6 50.4 47.6 52.5 Target 50 50 50 50 50 Strategic Priority 2 - Student Success Goal 2B: Hartnell College will provide a supportive, innovative, and collaborative learning environment that addresses and meets the diverse learning needs of students. KPI 2B.2b Results of the SENSEPlan Effective Track to College Readiness Engaged Learning Academic and Social Support Network Early Connections High Expectations and Aspirations Clear Academic Plan and Pathway ASPECTS OF LOWEST STUDENT ENGAGEMENT An advisor helped me to select a course of study, program, or major An advisor helped me to identify the courses I needed to take during my first semester/quarter Discussed an assignment or grade with an instructor Used writing, math, or other skill lab Used computer lab ASPECTS OF HIGHEST STUDENT ENGAGEMENT Prepared two or more drafts of a paper or assignment before turning Worked with other students on a project or assignment during class Worked with classmates outside of class on class projects or assignments Participated in a required study group outside of class Used an electronic tool to communicate with another student about coursework Progress Baseline Actual Target 55.9 47.1 44.7 42.3 42.2 39.1 55.9 47.1 44.7 42.3 42.2 39.1 50 50 50 50 50 50 46.3% 46.3% 62.2% 51.2% 51.2% 72.3% 52.7% 20.0% 34.9% 52.7% 20.0% 34.9% 67.1% 35.8% 53.4% 76.9% 76.9% 71.7% 82.0% 82.0% 78.6% 40.3% 40.3% 34.4% 21.0% 76.8% 21.0% 76.8% 17.3% 57.1%