G.O. Bond Survey Results Presentation for Hartnell Community College District by Isom Advisors, a Division of Urban Futures, Inc. February 16, 2016 1470 Maria Lane, Ste. 315 – Walnut Creek, CA 94596 – (925) 478-7450 Methodology There are 96,397 registered voters in the District Hartnell CCD The Hartnell Community College District is currently assessing the feasibility of placing a general obligation bond measure on an upcoming ballot. A survey was conducted from 1/22/16 through 2/12/16 to assess support for the proposed bond measure. The survey tested voter attitudes regarding the District, projects to be funded by the proposed measure, and tax tolerances. 500 individual voters were contacted, which resulted in an overall margin of error of +/- 4.36%. The 500 voters were comprised of 59% likely June 2016 (high propensity) voters and 41% likely November 2016 (low/mid propensity) voters to help further assess a June 2016 versus a November 2016 election. This is reflective of the expected turnout by each voting universe. 2 Voter Attitudes and Benchmark General Questions Hartnell CCD Most voters are satisfied with education in the District Would you say that education in California is headed in the right direction or the wrong direction? How would you rate the quality of education provided by the College? Poor 3% Wrong Direction 37% Don't Know 15% Excellent 23% Right Direction 41% Fair 15% Don't Know 22% Good 44% 4 General Questions Hartnell CCD Majority of of voters have a connection to the District How would you rate the condition of the facilities provided by the College? Are you or someone in your family currently enrolled full-time or taking a course offered by the College? Or Have you or someone in your family EVER been enrolled full-time or taken a course offered by the College? Poor 2% Excellent 24% Don't Know 18% No - Never 24% Yes-Current, Full-Time 21% Fair 11% Yes-Current, Course 6% Good 45% Yes-in the Past 49% 5 General Questions Hartnell CCD Voters are satisfied with most aspects of the District Now I would like to ask you several questions regarding different aspects of the Hartnell Community College District. For each please tell me whether you would rate it is as Excellent, Good, Fair, or Poor? College Board of Trustees College President College Faculty Colleg's job at managing finances 0% 20% Excellent 40% Good 60% Fair 80% Don't Know 100% Poor 6 General Questions Hartnell CCD Majority of voters recognize the value of a quality College Now I would like to read you some statements about the College as well as other community related issues. For each of the following statements please tell me if you Agree or Disagree. A quality College is important because it provides training and education for better paying jobs. *(SS_B1) A quality College is good for the local economy, because it provides training and education for a skilled workforce and job readiness. *(SS_B2) Increasing access to higher education locally must be improved as only 60% of adults over the age of 25 have a high school diploma. *(SS_A1) 0% Stongly Agree Somewhat Agree 20% Don't Know 40% 60% Somewhat Disagree 80% 100% Strongly Disagree *Split sample (SS) question – 50% of voters surveyed were asked version 1 and 50% were asked version 2 7 General Questions Hartnell CCD Majority of voters recognize the value of a quality College Now I would like to read you some statements about the College as well as other community related issues. For each of the following statements please tell me if you Agree or Disagree. Because the state continues to reduce funding for community college facilities, local voters need to do more to protect the quality of facilities at their local colleges. Improving literacy rates and access to higher education should be a priority as only 5%-7% of the District’s Latino population has attained a 4-year degree or higher. Increasing access to higher education must be improved as local adults over the age of 18 have very low participation rates for college. *(SS_A2) 0% Stongly Agree Somewhat Agree 20% Don't Know 40% 60% Somewhat Disagree 80% 100% Strongly Disagree *Split sample (SS) question – 50% of voters surveyed were asked version 1 and 50% were asked version 2 8 General Questions Hartnell CCD Majority of voters were not aware of the refinancing The District recently refinanced some outstanding Hartnell College bonds that property taxpayers have been repaying over the years. The total savings to taxpayers from the refinancing is nearly $175 million. How aware are you of this recent financing? Very Aware 6% Somewhat Aware 7% Not Aware 87% 9 Ballot Measure (Pre-Benchmark) Hartnell CCD Support for measure is above the Prop. 39 55% threshold At this time, the Community College District is looking to make classroom and educational facility improvements and is considering placing a facilities improvement bond measure before voters in your community on an upcoming ballot. If the election were held today, would you vote YES in favor of the measure or would you vote NO to oppose the measure? “To improve the quality of education and job training; provide upgraded college facilities for students with funding that cannot be taken by the state; renovate, modernize, and construct classrooms, labs, and student support facilities; increase student access to modern technology; improve nursing, science, agriculture, and literacy programs; construct/expand libraries; and make handicap accessibility and security improvements, shall Hartnell Community College District issue $170,000,000 of bonds at legal interest rates, include an independent citizens’ oversight committee, and NO money for administrative salaries?” Lean No 2% No 14% Undecided 10% Lean Yes 4% Yes 70% 10 G.O. Bond Projects G.O. Bond Project Hartnell CCD All projects received over 55% voter support For each project, please tell me whether it would make you More Likely or Less Likely to vote in favor of the measure if you knew funds would be used to: 55% Improve student access to computers and modern technology. *(SS_A1) Improve nursing and skilled healthcare facilities and programs. Add or expand classrooms and labs for better job training and a skilled workforce. Provide new science, technology, engineering, and math (STEM) labs. Make health, safety and handicapped accessibility improvements. Construct additional educational facilities in South Monterey County to expand access to learning opportunities. Make technology upgrades at all campuses. *(SS_A2) Expand or upgrade facilities to serve military veterans. 0% Much More Likely Somewhat More Likely No Difference 20% Don't Know 40% 60% Somewhat Less Likely 80% 100% Much Less Likely *Split sample (SS) question – 50% of voters surveyed were asked version 1 and 50% were asked version 2 12 G.O. Bond Project Hartnell CCD All projects received over 55% voter support For each project, please tell me whether it would make you More Likely or Less Likely to vote in favor of the measure if you knew funds would be used to: 55% Renovate outdated and aging classrooms, labs, and student support facilities. Provide space for universities to offer four-year bachelor’s degrees. Improve student and teacher safety by upgrading the EM Systems including cameras, intercoms, and security systems. Provide facilities to increase services for financial aid, counseling, and tutoring. Construct and expand libraries/learning centers. Provide literacy and English language learning centers. *(SS_B1) Upgrade aging electrical systems. Add general education classes throughout the District to avoid or reduce commuting between campuses. 0% Much More Likely Somewhat More Likely No Difference 20% Don't Know 40% 60% Somewhat Less Likely 80% 100% Much Less Likely *Split sample (SS) question – 50% of voters surveyed were asked version 1 and 50% were asked version 2 13 G.O. Bond Project Hartnell CCD All projects received over 55% voter support For each project, please tell me whether it would make you More Likely or Less Likely to vote in favor of the measure if you knew funds would be used to: 55% Make energy-efficiency improvements such as using solar energy. Construct a Student Center at E. Campus in Alisal that would include a cafeteria, tutoring center, and student study areas. Construct an education center in Soledad to expand access to literacy programs and college level learning. *(SS_B2) Construct additional educational facilities in South Monterey County for student and community use. Improve campus parking and facilities. Upgrade athletic fields and facilities for student and community use. Provide indoor and outdoor student study spaces throughout the campuses. 0% Much More Likely Somewhat More Likely No Difference 20% Don't Know 40% 60% Somewhat Less Likely 80% 100% Much Less Likely *Split sample (SS) question – 50% of voters surveyed were asked version 1 and 50% were asked version 2 14 Tax Tolerances Tax Tolerances Hartnell CCD There is support for $25 tax rate on a per month basis If the proposed measure would cost property owners $25.00 per $100,000 of assessed valuation per year/$2.00 per $100,000 of assessed valuation per month, would you vote “yes” in Favor of or “no” to Oppose the measure? *SSA: $25.00/year No 23% *SSB: $2.00/month Yes 45% No 20% Lean No 2% Lean No 6% Yes 62% Undecided 12% Undecided 20% Lean Yes 6% Lean Yes 4% *Split sample (SS) question – 50% of voters surveyed were asked version 1 and 50% were asked version 2 16 Tax Tolerances Hartnell CCD There is support for $19 tax rate on a per month basis If the proposed measure would cost property owners $19.00 per $100,000 of assessed valuation per year/$1.60 per $100,000 of assessed valuation per month, would you vote “yes” in Favor of or “no” to Oppose the measure? *SSA: $19.00/year *SSB: $1.60/month No 18% No 21% Yes 52% Lean No 4% Lean No 2% Yes 62% Undecided 14% Undecided 19% Lean Yes 4% Lean Yes 4% *Split sample (SS) question – 50% of voters surveyed were asked version 1 and 50% were asked version 2 17 Tax Tolerances Hartnell CCD There is support for $12 tax rate on a per month basis If the proposed measure would cost property owners $12.00 per $100,000 of assessed valuation per year/$1.00 per $100,000 of assessed valuation per month, would you vote “yes” in Favor of or “no” to Oppose the measure? *SSA: $12.00/year *SSB: $1.00/month No 18% Lean No 3% Undecided 15% Lean Yes 5% No 18% Yes 59% Lean No 3% Yes 64% Undecided 12% Lean Yes 3% *Split sample (SS) question – 50% of voters surveyed were asked version 1 and 50% were asked version 2 18 Post Benchmark Ballot Measure (Post-education) Hartnell CCD After education voter support remained above 55% Now that you have heard some more information regarding the proposed measure, projects, and cost, if the election were held today, would you vote YES in favor of the measure or would you vote NO to oppose the measure? Post-education Lean No 3% No 13% Pre-education Lean No 2% Undecided 11% Undecided 10% Yes 69% Lean Yes 4% No 14% Lean Yes 4% Yes 70% 20 Ballot Measure (Post-education) Hartnell CCD Over 55% support for either a June or November election Now that you have heard some more information regarding the proposed measure, projects, and cost, if the election were held today, would you vote YES in favor of the measure or would you vote NO to oppose the measure? June 2016 Likely Voters November 2016 Likely Voters Lean No 2% No 17% Undecided 10% Lean No 4% Undecided 11% Lean Yes 4% No 8% Yes 64% Lean Yes 4% Yes 76% 21 Conclusions and Recommendations Conclusions and Recommendations Over 55% voter support for the proposed measure Hartnell CCD 86% of voters strongly agree that a quality College is important for providing training and education for better paying jobs. 69% strongly agree that local voters need to do more to protect the quality of facilities at their local colleges. All of the bond projects tested, received over 55% voter support. Support for a bond measure before voter education was 74% (70% Yes/4% Lean Yes), and after education was 73% (69% Yes/4% Lean Yes). All of the tax rates tested, when presented on a per month basis, received over 55% voter support. After voter education there is over 60% voter support for a bond measure from both June 2016 likely voters and November 2016 likely voters. We recommend the District to continue to reach out to and educate the community to increase support after education, and plan on placing a bond measure on a 2016 ballot. 23 Next Steps Timeline – 2016 Election Hartnell CCD Following these steps are key to District’s success Task Responsible Party Board Meeting - approve “exploring” feasibility of a bond Conduct Survey Initiate public information program, speaking with elected officials, large taxpayers, community service groups to discuss proposed bond Board Meeting - Survey Results Presentation Finalize Capital and Financing Plan based on Community Outreach District Consultant Complete January Complete January District Nov. - March Nov. - April Consultant February 2nd February 2nd Consultant February April Consultant/Bond Counsel February May District Feb. - March June District March 12th August 11th Consultant/District Campaign Committee Campaign Committee March August March August Prepare Resolution for Calling Election, including Ballot Language, Project List, Tax rate Statement Board Meeting - Board action to adopt Resolution Calling Election Deadline to Submit Resolution Calling Election and Tax Rate Statement Submit Argument in Favor of Measure Form campaign committee and conduct campaign kickoff meeting Run Campaign Election Day June 2016 Election Nov. 2016 Election March - June June 2016 August November November 2016 25