Journal of Research in Peace, Gender and Development (ISSN: 2251-0036) Vol. 1(5) pp. 166-172, June 2011 Available online http://www.interesjournals.org/JRPGD Copyright © 2011 International Research Journals Full Length Research Paper Empowering Teachers for Leadership in Conflict Transformation and Peace Building in Kenya Judah Mualuko Ndiku, Judith Achoka, Kennedy Onkware Masinde Muliro University of Science and Technology P.O. Box 190 – 50100, Kakamega, Kenya. Accepted 17 June 2011 Violent conflicts have been on the increase in Kenya. However, despite the occurrence of violent conflicts, the Government of Kenya is committed to ensure that human societies move from violent and destructive patterns of life toward the potential for creative, constructive and non-violent capacities. This means replacing patterns of violence and coercion with respect, creative problemsolving, increased dialogue, and non-violent mechanisms of social change. To accomplish these aspects, a complex web of change processes under-girded by a transformational understanding of life and relationship is needed. Hence, a conflict transformation process which can be achieved through several processes, among them: capacity building for peace educators, curriculum developers, and trainers is imperative. This study investigated the skills, capacities and strategies required by teachers to effectively participate in violent conflict transformation in Kenya. The study adopted a descriptive design. Teachers and Education officers in Mt. Elgon District were the respondents. It was found out that for teachers to effectively participate in conflict transformation there is need to train them in relevant skills such as peace education, counseling among others. It was concluded and recommended that there was need to train teachers and support them to effectively participate in conflict transformation through peace education and other processes. Key words: Conflict transformation, peace building, teacher empowerment, training INTRODUCTION Conflict is part of human societies. Though not all conflict is negative, when conflict breeds violence, it brings in negative aspects especially the suffering which goes with violent conflict like; deaths, destruction of property, displacements, trauma among others. That is why violent conflict should be avoided in society where possible. However, when violent conflict erupts, societies have to look for ways to overcome the situation. In view of the need to help societies come out of violent conflict, this study was carried out to generate information that would form the basis of strengthening the existing conflict transformation and peace building processes in Kenya. In Kenya, violent conflicts have been experienced since the pre-colonial days (Okoth, 2010; Republic of *Corresponding Author E-mail: ndikuyuda@yahoo.com Kenya, 2006). The conflicts in Kenya range from internal disputes between groups and cross border confrontations with groups of people from the neighbouring countries such as Uganda, Ethiopia and Sudan. The root causes of the conflicts are varied and complex and can be attributed to a number of factors which include: colonial legacy, poverty, competition for resources, inadequate governance structures and institutions, ethnicity, skewed development strategy and politics of exclusion (Mwaniki et al., 2007; Republic of Kenya, 2006). Where violent conflicts have been experienced in Kenya, inhabitants’ lives and livelihoods have been disrupted as well as their economic lives, while their basic services such as health and education are reduced (Lwaminda, 2009). Some of the effects of violent conflict include: loss of life, physical injury, and psychological trauma. Such effects negatively hinge on the psyche of the inhabitants, hindering their social and economic progress. Journal of Research in Peace, Gender and Development (ISSN: 2251-0036) Ndiku et al. 167 According to Kamungi (2001), most conflicts in Kenya take place in the Rift Valley and the North Eastern region. Whereas the violent conflicts which manifest themselves as ethnic clashes appear to be politically motivated, economic factors are mostly the prime moving factors (Mwaniki et al., 2007). In the northern part of Kenya, for example, inter communal violence over natural resources, mainly land and water, have been escalating. Sometimes such violence has involved societies living across the Kenyan borders especially, for example: Uganda, Ethiopia and Somalia. Importantly, it has been noted that, such violent conflicts, have been enhanced by the proliferation of small arms and light weapons; inadequate security to deter cross border armed incursions; high poverty levels; drug abuse; and, unemployment among other critical causes (Mwaniki et al., 2007; Republic of Kenya, 2006). In the recent past, a serious incursion of violent conflict occurred in the Mount Elgon District of Kenya and for a period of about two years, from 2006 to 2008, the district was under siege of local militia gangs until the government intervened and ceasefire achieved. Despite the occurrence of violent conflicts in society and in Mt. Elgon in particular, the Government of Kenya is committed to management of violent conflict and promotion of peace nationwide (Republic of Kenya, 2007). To achieve this, several strategies have been proposed; among them is the idea of inculcating a culture of respect of sanctity of human life and restraining from use of violence as an instrument of resolving personal and community disputes. This means replacing patterns of violence and coercion with respect, creative problemsolving, increased dialogue, and non-violent mechanisms of social change (Republic of Kenya, 2007; Republic of Kenya, 2006). Thus a conflict transformation process which can be achieved through several processes, among them: capacity building for peace educators, curriculum developers, trainers and learners (Otieno and Mwakio, 2009) is imperative. This situation comes at a time when it has been noted that less emphasis has been placed on the role attached to education towards conflict transformation and peace building (Seitz, 2004). It is important to note that, the school which houses the formal structures of schooling forms an important institution where instruction is carried out. The school is also the centre of imparting attitudes, values and behaviour among the learners. The training is achieved through curriculum implementation which is carried out in a three tier framework: formal, informal and non–formal within the school. The importance of the teacher in this process is thus indispensable. For instance, the teacher has the onus to play a crucial role in the curriculum implementation processes that lead to change in attitudes and behaviour of the learners who in turn affect the communities and societies at large. Statement of the Problem Following the violent conflict experienced in Mt. Elgon District in Kenya, peoples’ lives were affected (Wakhungu, Nyikuri and Huggins, 2008). Thereafter, the circumstances that emerged called for creativity, adaptability and placing a high value on the needs and capacities of the people to manage violent conflicts and transform societies into peaceful co-existence. One of the pillars of enhancing conflict transformation is education. For this reason, teachers and trainers are central in successful implementation of conflict transformation programs in society and in schools. Not surprisingly, it is noted that, more than during peaceful times, education in times of violent conflict and thereafter is too critical to be ignored among the people and countries affected (World Bank, 2002). While the appropriate school curricula, materials, equipment, supplies and buildings may not be readily available, if teachers are present and able to positively respond by educating the learners in the right direction and alleviating the pangs of pain and sorrow borne out of violent conflict, such strategies can enhance the healing processes and safeguard affected communities from further and future conflicts, violence and war. This is because, teachers have education, time and space, as well as the learners with whom they frequently interact and also, they are influential persons in their respective communities. However, in Kenya, teaching and training for peace have been found wanting (Achoka, 2009; Marete, 2008; Marete and Ngare, 2008; Simotwo, 2008). Further, Okanga (2009) observes that teachers, who by virtue of their education and experiences are agents of change in ensuring a culture of peace among the communities especially those that are prone to conflict and violence in Kenya, do not seem to be proactive. In so far as Kenya appears to be susceptible to violent conflicts, there was therefore, need to study some of the various aspects that surround teachers in such circumstances with a view to suggest useful paradigms to alleviate negative forces and boost teachers’ attention to advocacy for peace at the expense of violent conflict. Specifically the new knowledge, skills and attitudes that teachers require to manage conflict transformation and peace building were researched. Conceptual Framework To institute a strategy to transform violent conflict through the teachers, this study adopted a Conflict Transformation Framework proposed by Lederach and Maiese (2003). This framework has three components. Each component represents a point of inquiry in the Journal of Research in Peace, Gender and Development (ISSN: 2251-0036) 168 J. Res. Peace Gend. Dev. Figure 1 Conflict Transformation Framework Source: Lederach and Maiese (2003) development of a response to conflict. The components are: the presenting situation, the horizon of preferred future, and the development of change process linking the two. In the opinion of this argument the presenting case/situation of the violent conflict in Mt. Elgon, the movement from violent conflict and the effects of the same towards the desired future is not a straight line, but rather a set of dynamic initiatives by several actors. Teachers may be part of the many actors where through teaching, training and participating in professional activities they can set in motion, change processes and create a sustained platform to pursue long-term change. Such a framework emphasizes the challenge of how to end something not desired and how to build something that is desired. The Horizon of the Future The second point of inquiry (Figure 1) is the horizon of the future. This is the image of what conflict transformation wishes to create. It requires consideration be made about what ideally should be in place. Vayrynen (1991) considers transformation of the following: actors; where changes in parties, or the appearance of new parties is considered; altering the agenda of conflict; rules where changes in the norms or rules governing a conflict takes place and structural transformations where the entire structure of relationships and power distribution in the conflict is transformed. In the same argument Lederach (1997) sees peace building as a long-term transformation of a war system into a peace system, inspired by a quest for the values of peace and justice, truth and mercy. The key dimensions of this process are changes in the personal, structural, relational and cultural aspects of conflict, brought about over different time-periods (short- mid- and long-term) and affecting different system levels at different times. This study considered transforming the personal, structural, relational and cultural aspects in Mt. Elgon region to bring about lasting peace. Where the role of various actors is crucial, the role of the teachers was the point of reference in this study. However, creating the change is not linear, in which there is movement from the present situation (violent conflict and its effects) to the desired future (Lederach and Maiese, 2003). While the presenting issues act as an impetus toward change, the horizon of the future points toward possibilities of what could be constructed and built. It represents a social energy that informs and creates orientation. The arrows (figure 1) suggest that conflict transformation is a process structure and it is cyclic in nature (Miall, 2004; Lederach and Maiese, 2003). The Development of Change Processes This is the final major inquiry is the design and support of change processes. This component requires that actors think about response to conflict as the development of change processes that attend to the web of interconnected needs, relationships, and patterns. Because the change processes should address both the immediate problems and the broader relational and structural patterns, the need to reflect on multiple levels and types of change rather than focusing on a single operational solution is paramount. Change processes must not only promote short-term solutions, but also build platforms capable of promoting long-term social change (Lederach and Maiese, 2003). Among other methods, Journal of Research in Peace, Gender and Development (ISSN: 2251-0036) Ndiku et al. 169 Table .1 Frequencies and Percentages of Strategies required enabling teachers to Effectively Participate in Conflict Transformation Item/responses To enhance peace; 1. School curriculum should introduce peace education lessons 2. Schools in Mt. Elgon should design school based activities to promote peace 3. There is need for support and guidance through quality assurance services 4. There is need for training in new methods of teaching affected children 5. There is need for training in handling affected parents 6. There is need for enhanced skills in counseling 7. There is need for skills to implement peace education curriculum 8. There is need for new skills in conflict resolution and peace mediation SD D U A SA 4(2.2) 3(1.6) 12(6.6) 66(36.3) 97(53.3) 8(4.4) 67(36.8) 103(56.6) 7(3.8) 54(29.7) 111(61.0) 6(3.3) 52(28.6) 122(67.0) 2(1.1) 2(1.1) 3(1.6) 7(3.8) 1(.5) 1(.5) 12(6.6) 8(4.4) 8(4.4) 49(26.9) 105(57.7) 11(6.0) 4(2.2) 10(5.5) 64(35.2) 93(51.1) 2(1.1) 2(1.1) 7(3.8) 67(36.8) 104(57.1) 0(0) 4(2.2) 49(26.9) 1(.5) 128(70.3) Figures in brackets ( ) are percentages training and facilitating the future generations to avoid violence and conflict is key hence the role of teachers in this process. Figure 1 illustrates the relationship between the three components of the conflict transformation framework. Taken as a whole, this framework provides a lens that enables people to envision the possibilities of immediate response and long-term constructive change. It requires a capacity to see through and beyond the present issues to the deeper patterns, while at the same time seeking creative responses that address real-life issues in real time. The defining characteristic of the conflict transformation platform is the capacity to generate and re-generate change processes responsive to both immediate episodes and the relational context. It is in this way that an adaptive process-structure, one that can produce creative solutions to a variety of problems is created (Lederach and Maiese, 2003). Objective The main objective of the study was to determine the strategies required to empower teachers participate effectively in conflict transformation and peace building. began in December 2006 between the Soy and Mosop sub-ethnicities of the Sabaot ethnic group over allegations of unfair land allocation. A Sabaot Land Defense Force was formed, which led to a number of killings in the region. As of late 2007, over 300 people had died in the conflict, while over 60,000 people were displaced from their homes (Wakhungu et.al, 2008). One hundred and eighty (182) primary and secondary school teachers and 8 education officers participated in the study. A Questionnaire was used to collect data. The questionnaire had closed and open ended items. The close ended section of the questionnaire used a Likert scale model (Bordens and Abbott, 2005) of a rating scale. The scale had items ranging from Strongly Disagree (SD), Disagree (D), Undecided (U), Agree (A) and Strongly Agree(SA) and scored as follows; Strongly Disagree (SD)-1 Disagree (D)-2, Undecided (U)-3, Agree (A) -4 and Strongly Agree(SA)-5. Open spaces were provided for the respondents to comment freely on any other issues related to the study which were not covered in the closed ended section. Such open ended responses, enabled the respondents to express their opinions freely in order to provide in-depth information (Mouton and Prozesky, 2010). Data were analyzed qualitatively and quantitatively to make deductions, interpretations, conclusions and possible recommendations. METHODOLOGY This study adopted a cross-sectional survey design. Cross sectional studies address themselves to some phenomenon by taking a cross section of it at one time, analyzing it carefully and making conclusions and observations at a time (Bordens and Abbott, 2005). The study was conducted in Mt. Elgon District. Mt. Elgon district was purposively selected because of the experiences of violent conflict where a violent conflict RESULTS Table 1 above presents frequencies and percentages of the teachers’ responses to the items provided in the close ended questionnaire. To enhance peace through education, 53.3% teachers strongly agreed that the school curriculum should introduce peace education lessons while 36.3% agreed. Journal of Research in Peace, Gender and Development (ISSN: 2251-0036) 170 J. Res. Peace Gend. Dev. The teachers who disagreed and or strongly disagreed were the minority. These were 1.6% and 2.2% respectively. On the need for schools in Mt. Elgon to design school based activities to promote peace, majority of the teachers strongly agreed and or agreed with the statement as presented in table 1 where 56.6% strongly agreed with 36.8% agreeing. The same was the trend in all the other items of the; need for support and guidance through quality assurance services by education officers; need for training in new methods of teaching affected children; need for training in handling affected parents; need for enhanced skills in counseling; need for skills to implement peace education curriculum; need for new skills in conflict resolution and peace mediation. In the open sections of the questionnaire, some teachers commented on how teachers could be empowered to participate in conflict transformation and peace building. Though not all teacher commented, the few who commented expressed passionately the need to be accorded recognition and respect by society to effectively serve in conflict transformation in Mt. Elgon District. One teacher said: Teachers need to be respected by all in society if they are to handle community affairs such as handling the concerns of the violence and conflict in Mt. Elgon District. Teachers were intimidated during the conflict and this made teachers to be scared, demoralized and de-motivated to perform their duties. Another teacher commented, Teachers cannot participate in changing the situation in Mt. Elgon District if they are looked down upon and harassed by the SLDF and other persons in society. Teachers were forced to participate in the conflict by paying taxes to support the SLDF… this has to change if teachers are to be given the confidence to address pubic issues. Teachers in some schools required to be supported with more teaching and learning materials as expressed in the following statement: To teach effectively in Mt. Elgon district, schools need more teaching and learning materials especially in schools whose population went up when they housed the victims of the violent conflict. Another teacher showed concern that there was need for improved working environment in classes when he stated that: Some classes are so crowded to maintain harmony while teaching. This denies teachers an opportunity to give quality education to the pupils. There is need to expand the instructional facilities in schools to enable teachers work with ease and comfort.” The above findings from the teachers on the support they required to actively participate in conflict transformation were complemented by the education officers in their responses to the interviews. they recommended introduction of peace education lessons and teaching of skills to handle children affected by the violent conflict. The officers also observed that there was need to create peaceful teaching environments. For instance, one of the officers stated as follows: I recommended rebuilding of the vandalized schools to ensure enough teaching and learning space in all school. This would enhance the creation of condusive working environments for teachers and learners. This can be done through concerted efforts of the communities the Ministry of Education, NGOs and the Constituency Development funds. Another education officer recommended training programmes for teachers, learners and the community to promote safety and security; “Teachers and other education personnel should be provided with skills in handling injured persons, prevention of escalation of war and effects of conflict. Also, there is need for training on how to give psychological support and promote learners’ emotional well-being.” Another education officer observed that teacher empowerment through training was the only way to change the society in Mt. Elgon. He said, “… to make strides in peace building and development, teachers should be empowered to advocate for peace in and out of school… because teachers are opinion leaders and shapers in society in their own right and they form a critical mass of agents of change in society.” DISCUSSION The findings of this study that there was need for increased support and training to teachers in conflict transformation affirms the arguments by Nicolai (2003) and UNESCO (2006) that the need to support and train teachers to participate in conflict transformation and peace building are important. According to Nicolai (2003) and Ndiku (2007) teachers are the single most important shapers of student learning and provision of quality education, therefore, well trained teachers should be availed in crisis and emergencies. This is because emergencies like violent conflict not only have many negative effects in society; they place new and different demands on children, their communities and education systems as a whole. Thus, training and support can help teachers respond to these pressures; cope with increased duties and responsibilities. From the comments given by teachers, it was observed that teachers in Mt. Elgon District may have felt the impact of the violent conflict as they were intimidated by the militia, forced to support them financially and morally. The need to support them through the education offices and other educational stakeholders to adjust to their work and where possible perform additional duties in Journal of Research in Peace, Gender and Development (ISSN: 2251-0036) Ndiku et al. 171 dealing with different students, parents, colleagues and communities who were coming out of the conflict is crucial. Some teachers may have needed additional time and space to be with their families, repair their homes, or deal with changes in their lives. Such situations needed understanding support and encouragement. The support can be offered by the school administrators and educational supervisors such as the education officers and the Quality Assurance officers. The teachers and the education officers requested for increased staffing in schools. This was a sure confirmation that there was shortage of staff in schools in the area occasioned by the violent conflict. This situation may have been brought about by the effects of the violent conflict on teachers where some were transferred owing to the pressure from the violent conflict. Worst affected were the teachers from other ethnic groups in Kenya. Increased staffing may lead to improved provision of the education services as teachers may not be overwhelmed by crowded classes, heavy workloads and lack of provision of individualized attention to learners. The findings on the need for training as a strategy for enhanced teacher participation in conflict transformation and peace building affirms the fact that there is need for teachers to get new skills to help the students, parents and community members affected by the violent conflict to cope with the crisis, promote new effective ways of teaching and learning, increase awareness of the impact of the violence on children and the communities and promote peace and facilitate restoration by developing peace skills such as; negotiation, building confidence and morale among teachers, students and community members. The training for the practicing teachers can be done through short courses and the in-service mode of training. Thus, expanding teaching skills beyond traditional methods gives opportunities for new and old teachers alike to gain fresh knowledge, strengthen skills, and practice new teaching methods (Nicolai, 2003). The demand for training teachers in new skills calls for teacher trainers to adjust their teacher education curricula to accommodate emerging issues like conflicts, disasters and other emergencies. The implication of this argument is that the question of teacher education and training is a long life affair and thus there is need for training of trainers in emerging issues in society. The need for teacher support from the Quality Assurance officers and school administrators stated in the findings was crucial. This is because emergency situations call for new methods of instruction especially to students affected by the hard conditions. Teachers who are not familiar with new methods of handling affected children require training and follow-on support from education officers in order to implement the new methods successfully (UNESCO, 2006). New subjects or topics such as peace education may be added to the curriculum. Methods for measuring teachers’ impact and providing in-school support with regard to the new topics needed to be developed hence the need for support by education officers such as Quality Assurance officers in this respect. Other circumstances which call for support by education officers and school administrators included the fact that some children may have been out of school for a long time. Other children may have suffered from hunger and emotional needs caused by trauma. Other difficulties which teachers may face after a violent conflict like the Mt. Elgon violent conflict are large classes which may make it difficult for them to do their job and for students to learn. There may also be scarcity of teaching and learning materials. The situation in Mt. Elgon District presented such difficulties. Therefore, when teachers and education officers argue that there were added duties which may call for additional support to teachers to effectively participate in conflict transformation was very valid in this study. CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONS Violent conflict affects communities negatively, and though teachers may be familiar with their jobs, they may need additional support to cope with the changes thereof. Related to this therefore, it was concluded that even those teachers with previous teaching experience, need training on new topics to be taught in conflict situations and to handle affected children, parents and colleagues. Teachers also require professional support especially from the education officers to effectively participate in conflict transformation. Such support may include quality assurance services and management support. Violent conflict and emergency situation are posing new challenges in society and in Kenya in particular, in the recent past. Teacher education curriculum should be adjusted to accommodate the emerging issues of conflict, violence, disaster management, safety standards in schools among other emerging issues. The practicing teachers should be exposed and trained in the same issues through other modes of training like in-service training, conferences and workshops. The government and other agencies like teacher unions and associations should take this challenge to sensitize teachers on the best possible way to handle the emerging issues. REFERENCES Achoka JSK (2009). Peace Pre-Requisite for African Development: Study of Peace education curriculum in secondary Education, Kenya. Kenya Journal of Education Planning Economics and Management. 1: 75-81. Boudens KS, Abbott BB (2005). Research Design and methods (6th ed ). New Delhi: Tata McGraw-Hill Kamungi PM (2001). ‘The current situation of internally displaced persons in Kenya’. Jesuit refugee services Report. Kothari CR (2008). Research Methodology and Techniques 2nd edition reprint. New Delhi New AgeInternational Publishers. Journal of Research in Peace, Gender and Development (ISSN: 2251-0036) 172 J. Res. Peace Gend. Dev. Lwaminda P (2009). “How has the “Ecllesia in Africa” made a difference in AMECEA Region with Respect to Reconciliation, Justice and Peace.” Afri. Ecclesial Review. 51(3): p216-241 Marete G (2008). “Peace Studies to be taught in high school”. Daily Nation 25th June. Nairobi: Nation Media Group. Marete G, Ngare P (2008). “Karua roots for peace lessons to avert strife”. Daily Nation 25th June. Nairobi: Nation Media Group. Mouton EBJ, Prozesky PVB (2010). The Practice of Social Research.Cape Town: Oxford University Press. Mwaniki TW, Mbuchi PM, Leleruk M, Mwei F (2007). Peace building and Conflict Management. Joint Case Study of North Rift Region of Kenya. Nairobi. Paulines Publications Africa. Ndiku JM (2007). The issue of poverty in the provision o quality of education in Kenyan Secondary schools. Educational Research and Reviews 2(7):157-164 http://www.academijournals.org/ERR Nicolai S (2003). Education in emergencies. A toolkit for staring and managing education in emergencies. London: Save the children. Okanga D (2009). “Professionals asked to back culture change.” The Standard 29th September. Nairobi: Standard Group. Okoth PG (2010). Kenya and the Contemporary World order. Kakamega: MMUST Press. Otieno S, Mwakio P (2009). “Ministries resolve to make teachers agents of peace.” The Standard 17th September: Nairobi: Standard Group. Republic of Kenya (2006). National policy on peace building and conflict Management Draft I. Republic of Kenya (2007). Kenya Vision 2030. Nairobi: Ministry of planning and National Development. Seitz K (2004). Education and conflict. The role of Education in the creation, prevention and resolution of societal crises Consequences for development cooperation. German Technical Cooperation. Federal Ministry for Economic cooperation and Development, Germany. Simotwo M (2008). ‘Time Ripe for Major Changes in Primary Teachers’ Education’. Daily Nation 10th June. Nairobi: Nation Media Group. UNICEF (2007). UNICEF calls for end to violence against children in Mt. Elgon District. Nairobi. UNICEF. UNESCO (2006). Guidebook for planning education in emergencies and reconstruction. Paris: UNESCO. Wakhungu J, Nyikuri E, Huggins E (2008). ‘Land Tenure and Violent Conflict in Kenya in the context of Local, National and Regional legal and policy framework consultative Conference proceedings Report’. African Centre For Technology Studies. 6th October. Hilton Hotel Nairobi. World Bank (2002). Children, Education and war: Reaching Education For All objectives in countries affected by conflict. Conflict Prevention and Reconstruction Working papers, paper No. I Journal of Research in Peace, Gender and Development (ISSN: 2251-0036)