Journal Research in Peace, Gender and Development (JRPGD) Vol. 4(1) pp. 1-7, February, 2014 DOI: http:/dx.doi.org/10.14303/jrpgd.2014.001 Available online http://www.interesjournals.org/ JRPGD Copyright © 2014 International Research Journals Full Length Research Paper Perceptions of Internally Displaced Girls of Being Illiterate and Poor in an Urban Community: A Case from Khartoum, Sudan 1 Shadia Abdelrahim M. Daoud and *2Abdel Raouf Suleiman Bello 1 School of Rural Extension Education and Development, Ahfad University for Women, Sudan. *2College of Food and Agriculture Sciences, King Saud University, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. *Corresponding author email: raoufbello@yahoo.com ABSTRACT This study investigates the perceptions of illiterate girls of being illiterate in an urban poor community. A sample size of 30 illiterate girls was selected by the use of snowball non portability sampling procedure. A comprehensive interviewing schedule and focused group discussion were used to collect the necessary primary data. In addition five girls narrated their stories of being illiterate. The study findings show that all mothers of the respondents are illiterate and most of their fathers are also illiterate. About 53.3 of the respondents their mothers were the head of the households, and are working in very low income jobs. About 86.7 of respondents did not have sisters enrolled in education, 60% contribute to family income through work as domestic servants, tea and/or vegetable sellers. Poverty was the major barrier that hindered girls’ education. Inferiority and household chores discrimination between girls and their brothers are expressed by the narrated stories. The study concluded that barriers to girls’ education are primarily economic and social/cultural. Poverty remains the single major deterrent to education, and lack of education is a major cause of poverty. The study recommended the need for effective strategies to close the gender gap in education to focus on poor communities and address specific obstacles. Keywords: Perceptions, Illiterate Girls, Poverty and Gender Inequality Displaced People. INTRODUCTION Despite the global commitment to achieve gender equality of girl’s education, millions of girls are still out of school specifically among poor communities in developing countries. Although most developing countries have made considerable progress in reducing the gender gap in school enrollment, significant gender gaps remain (Randell, 2009). Gender inequality in education has generated considerable research. Numerous studies are being carried on especially in the developing countries where illiteracy and discrimination against women are major issues of contemporary relevance (Klasen et al., 2008). Gender inequalities in education exist in almost all poor countries and among the poor within these countries. There has been a considerable increase in gender inequality in education in low income countries over the last three decades (World Bank, 2001). Gender inequality is now considered as an essential concept for the analysis and alleviation of poverty because of its adverse impacts on a number of valuable development goals. Girl's access to education is influenced by poverty in various ways. Studies in many developing countries show that girls are at an educational disadvantage compared to boys. For example, Worku (2001) has examined gender role problems in education in Ethiopia and has found that while girls’ enrolment has increased, the gap is nevertheless widening due to various social, economic and cultural factors that hinder participation and performance of girls. In Sudan the spread of primary education reduces the gender gap in education but still some girls from poor communities are denied access to education. Conflicts 2 J. Res. Peace Gend. Dev. and displacement increases the number of out of school girls in urban displaced communities. According to the UNESCO (2008), Sudan has approximately 2,700,000 young persons out of school, the majority of whom are female. Various studies conducted on displacement and displaced people in Khartoum State indicate that the displaced people there are totally suffering, because they live in poor shelters, extreme poverty, and poor health and lacking the social services (Pantuliano et al., 2011; Nour, 2010; El Hassan, 2006; Daoud, 2005; Ali, 2002). The transition from a rural farming and/or herding background to cash based economy on the city has been highly stressful for job opportunities. The government and non-governmental organizations (NGOs) are providing little or no food security for the displaced people. This situation enforced the displaced women especially the widowed who headed their households to accept inferior and low paid jobs in the informal urban sectors like casual labors, street vending and selling to meet their basic family needs. education. Part four explores the perception of girls on their feeling resulted of lack of education. In part five, five respondents' narrated stories of being illiterate girls. Socio economic status of illiterate girl The age of respondents lies between 15-19 years old. About 86.7% were single, their mothers are illiterate, while majority of their fathers are also illiterate. The families of the respondents were displaced form Darfur (33.3%), South Kordofan9476.7%) and Blue Nile States (20%), (the conflicts areas). Most of the interviewee their mothers are the head of the households and work in very low income jobs, such as domestic servants, tea and food sellers. Majority of respondents are belonging to big family size (90% having more than 5 family members). About 86.7% having no sisters enrolled in education. Most of respondents (60%) contribute to family income through the work as domestic servants, tea and/or vegetable sellers. It is observed that they are vulnerable and live in poor shelters. Barriers to girls’ education: METHODOLOGY This study was conducted in May- June, 2013 in Alsalam Administrative Unit of Umbada Locality, Khartoum State, Sudan. Umbada Locality was chosen because it accommodates the bulk of the displaced persons in Khartoum. A sample of thirty illiterate girls who had never enrolled in a school was selected by the use of snow ball non portability sampling method. Both secondary and primary data were collected and used in this study. The former were obtained from the relevant sources, while the latter were collected by using interview schedule and three focus group discussions. Narrative method was also adopted to collect five stories from five girls who have special stories analyzed their challenges of being illiterate. Descriptive statistics such as frequency count and percentages were used to analyze the data gathered on the socioeconomic characteristics of the respondents. Content analysis was used to analyze the qualitative data collected from group discussions as: All the group discussion transcript was coded, comment of respondents that simplify points to be discussed was highlighted, and finally the outline of the report based on themes was arranged. RESULTS This section is divided into five parts. Part one describes the socio economic status of illiterate girls and their families. Part two presents the opinion of girls on barriers hindered them to join the schools. Part three focused on respondents' opinions and perceptions on the benefit of Barriers to girls’ education take differential forms across nations and /or societies depending upon the socioeconomic, religious and cultural contexts. Girls interviewed (table 1 and 2 below), mentioned different reasons of being illiterate and out of school. Poverty was the major barrier that led to other barrier, contribution of girls to family income (both constitutes 53.3%). Economic reasons were repeatedly cited by respondents as the main barrier that hinders them from being sent to school. Two barriers related to gender in equality also mentioned by the respondents; namely the household chores and discrimination between girls and their brothers. This indicates the awareness of girls of the relationship between gender in equality and their access to education. As some of them said: -Priority is given to boys over girls -Girls do not get education most often because families give priority to the boys and therefore send only boys to schools. -Girls are expected to do housework. -Mothers encourage girls to remain home and attend to the domestic chores. -The mother cannot do the house work alone -Our parent did not send us to school because of lack of financial capability. -One girl wished to be a boy to have more freedom as she mentioned. “If I was a boy that could have settled everything for me. I would have done everything." Barriers to girls’ education can take differential forms Daoud and Bello 3 Table 1. Frequency distribution of the respondents according to their socio economic status Characteristics Age 10-14 15-19 Total Education of the Mother Illiterate Literate Total Place of origin -Darfur - South Kordfan - Blue Nile Total Household occupation(mother) Domestic servant Tea sellers Food sellers Total Family size Less than 5 5-9 10 and above Total Respondents contribution to family income Yes No Total F % 17 13 30 56.7 43.3 100 30 0 30 100 0 100 10 14 6 30 33.3 46.7 20 100 7 6 3 16 43.8 37.5 18.7 100 3 17 10 30 10 56.7 33.3 100 18 12 30 60 40 100 Characteristics Marital Status Single Married Total Education of the father Illiterate Literate Total F % 26 4 30 86.7 13.3 100 20 Head of the household Father Mother Total 14 16 30 46.7 53.3 100 Household occupation (father) Construction labor Shoes maker Tailor Total 8 3 3 14 57.2 21.4 21.4 100 Sisters enrolled in education Yes No Total 4 26 30 13.3 86.7 100 Respondents work type Domestic servant Selling tea and/or vegetable Total 12 6 16 66.7 33.7 100 Table 2. Frequency distribution of respondents according barriers of education Barriers Poverty Contribute to family income Household chores Because I am girl Total F 10 6 9 5 30 % 33.3 20 30 16.7 100 across nations/societies depending upon the socioeconomic, religious and cultural contexts. Girls interviewed mentioned different reasons of being illiterate and out of the schools. Poverty was the major barrier that led to other barrier contribution of girls to family income. This means poverty and girls contributions to family income are interrelated barriers that hinder girls’ education) One girl said: “The educated woman is more useful than the uneducated woman. She knows more about the importance of good sanitation and how to prevent diseases that harm the health of the children. She also looks after the general sanitation of the house.” Perceptions on the benefit of education "Educated girls are very easy to get a job. They will have good future for their children. Literacy helps to understand things of life and to solve problems of daily life" Role of girls as future mothers was of large consideration of benefits of their education. Respondents believed that an educated girl would help her family with health matters. Other girls mentioned: 4 J. Res. Peace Gend. Dev. One of girls commented: who presented different opinion "Reading doesn't make a woman socially acceptable or useful, we women grow up to marry and have children. That is our role in life. Anything else is a luxury." Feeling of being Illiterate Most of respondents expressed regret about not having been able to learn to read and write. Typical reactions to questioning about how their lack of education made them feel included self-criticism, insignificance and a sense of missing out on a valuable social and life skill. One girl said: “I feel I am ignorant, and don’t have a contribution to make to my people. I blame myself. I have now seen the importance of education.” Many girls were pessimistic and felt that their lack of education was a lost opportunity, and an unalterable condition: “I feel that I am behind people, today since, I did not learn [earlier], and do not know what I can learn and how I can adopt to it.” Illiteracy creates many problems for girls. Girls interviewed believed that being illiterate increased their work load especially household chores. Narrated Stories: This part of present’s five stories narrated by five illiterate girls expresses their situation feelings, perceptions of being illiterate. Story 1: I am eighteen years old, was born in remote village in South Kordofan. My family moved to Omdurman city (in Khartoum) when I was four years old, and settled in Dar Elsalam displaced area. My parents hardly find source for living, because they are illiterate and used to work as farmers. Our livelihood was difficult and became worse after my father left us .Hence our household is headed by my mother (a poor illiterate woman), we are hardly meet the basic needs. Therefore my two older sisters and two younger brothers included me could not joined schools. We are all illiterate living in very poor family. My mother has to work for long hours outside the house so I have to look after the house and my younger brothers. I do all the household chores for this could not join the literacy classes. I keen to, become literate that can read and write. I feel sad some times jealous when see one of the girls read and write. I would not be good mother, because would not be able to revise the lessons of my sons and daughters. Girls who educated will have good future for their children. I feel that if a girl is well educated she can express her feelings fearlessly. An educated girl can support herself she need not depend on her parents or husband. Education can help a girl get employment being educated will help the mother of the family in carrying the day-to-day activities. Educated girls can decide what is right and what is wrong for they being illiterate face many problems of could not find good job and too much household chores. When I have children would work hard to educate them no discrimination between girls and boys. Story 2: I am 13 years old my family displaced from Northern Kordfan twenty years ago. Icould not join school ,because of the circumstances of my father and the low family income. The opinion of my father was that education for me was not necessary because I am a girl. So I cried every day when I saw my colleagues go to school every mornin,. but to no avail. All my friends succeeded and moved on to primary school, while I remained status quo. I very much want to go to school, but my family cannot afford to pay for the school fees, and clothing. Then I heard that an eradication of illiteracy class of uneducated girls and school drop-outs will be opened in my area .My parent allowed me to attend the literacy classes. Only then, did I feel that I was joining school one more time like all my colleagues and I realized my dreams. . When I first joined the class I knew nothing at all because I had never gone to school but now I know how to read and write. I cannot describe my emotions … at first it was like. I was blind and incapable of seeing anything … Now, Thank God, I can see, read and understand everything. Literacy helps in understanding children's homework, speaking with the teacher, speaking with the doctor, writing one's name, reading and writing letters, reading the destination of the bus, and checking change in the market. Story 3: I am17 years old girll ,come from small village in the Blue Nile state . Unlike other children, I and my sister always wanted to go to school when we were younger, but we never had the chance. Every day, brothers go to the school, and every day I and my sister stay home to help our mother with the household chores. “My mother tried to send me to school, but my father didn’t listen to her at all instead, my father emphasized that we learn how to perform household chores so we could run home homes Daoud and Bello 5 when we get older. When I heard that a class for eradicating illiteracy will be opened by in my area and that it could be in any home of the girls who want to join. I asked my father if I could join and he said 'No., because my mother needs me to look after the children. I felt jealous when my father allow my two younger brothers to go to school and asked myself why not me because Aim a girl I wish to be a boy. Story 4: I am 12 years old girl born and live in Daressalam in Omdurman area for displaced people .My family moved to this area twenty years ago from the Southern Kordofan , looked for better quality of life . My father work as casual labor and my mother is selling tea in the near market .Their income do not meet the needs of family consist of ten members. We are three sisters and young brothers. The two sisters are older than me .All are out of school. My two older sisters work as domestic servants to the survival of the family. My father inspires my three brothers younger than me to join the school. Working members of my family work hard to keep my two brothers in the school. I was disparate to go to school as my peers go to school, but I have to look after the house as my mother and older sisters work outside the house for long hours. . When I see my friends going to school in uniform, I do also like to go to school and I know how important education is for my future. But if I go to school, my mother and sisters could not work. I do not have good future; of course I would join my sisters to work as domestic servant. My dream was to work as teacher. I would realize my dream on my children specially girls, I would do my best to educate them to become teachers to educate other girls and illiterate women. Story 5 I am ten years old girl my family headed by mother, displaced from Darfur six years ago and settled in this area (Jabrona ). We are five. I am the youngest. My older brothers and sisters drop out from the school and of course I could not able join the school. My mother worked outside home for 12 hours per day and two of my brothers and one sister also work but we still hardly meet the daily meals and other needs. My dream is to go to school. I feel jealous when see girls of my age in their uniform go to school. My dream would not be realized I have to look for other opportunity to learn skill that can help me to find job because I do not want to end up as domestic servant. I always believed that illiteracy is the cause of my poverty. When I heard about the literacy program I jumped on the opportunity, hoping that by getting literacy skills I would be able to get a job that would allow me to get some money. Luckily I managed to join literacy class. Poverty was one factor that pushed me to join the literacy program. I do believe that illiteracy is the cause of lack of financial resources and I think that by learning how to read and write, I could gain rich knowledge and skills, which could open doors for me. DISCUSSION Many authors identify the education as a fundamental human right and vital to achieving economic growth, increasing income, and sustaining a healthy society. Education is important in helping to improve lives, break the cycle of poverty and ensure that all people, particularly women have control over their destiny (Durdhawale, 2004; Nwaobi, 2007) ) Results indicate the lack of education among illiterate girls is an obstacle to block them in deprivation and poverty trap. The vulnerable and poverty situation that characterized the livelihood of illiterate girls who are mostly displaced from conflict and poor area is consistent with Daoud (2005), result who indicated that when a group of displaced people arrived in Khartoum, the found no alternative than to resettle in the shantytowns, where the majority of displaced people and urban poor live. They were confronted with many obstacles and they contacted with a mix of varied ethnic, religious, and linguistic communities. They suffer a lot because they live in poor shelters, extreme poverty, and poor health and lack the social services. Similar phenomena have been observed by Evans (2007) in his study on the internally displaced persons in the Cassamance conflict, Senegal. The study findings also indicate that poverty and girls contribution to family income are interrelated barriers that hinder girls education. This result confirms with UNICEF (2010) finding that more than half of the 72 million primary school-aged children out of school are girls. These children mostly come from the world’s poorest communities and, in many cases, from nations with long histories of conflict. This is also supported by the study conducted by the Federal Ministry of Education (2008) which shows that poverty is one of the major factors hinder children access to education in Sudan, especially among marginalized and displaced communities. Illiterate girls are aware of the benefit of education especially for family heath and children care. This result is consistent with the World Bank ( 2007) and Klasen et al., (2008), who concluded that there are many empirical evidences of increase in female education improves human development outcomes such as child survival, health and schooling explored that lower female education had a negative impact on economic growth as it lowered the average level of human capital. The result of four stories has revealed that, gender socialization ensures that families invest the financial expense of education in sons rather than daughters, 6 J. Res. Peace Gend. Dev. based on the idea that education for the girl child is a waste with eventual marriage inevitable. This result is supported by Kotwal and Gupta (2006) who stated that subordination of girls is responsible for the socialization process that emphasizes the pre-ordained role that she will assume as an adult. The implications of such unequal treatment result in limiting the opportunities and choices that girls may have, both in the present and in the future. These narrated stories expressed freely and critically why girls did not have an access to education. All girls are disparate and feel inferior of being illiterate .Household chores decided their future that prevented them to join school and also to eradicate their illiteracy to get better job to reduce their poverty. Most of them indicated clearly that they are forced to look after household to allow their mothers to spend long hour working outside the house. They expressed clearly their awareness of gender discrimination and in equality that resulted to being illiterate girl loaded with household’s chores. In particular, the child labor literature often overlooks the potential for housework and childcare responsibilities to interfere with educational attainment. In the same regards Kotwal, and Gupta ( 2006) argued that young girls around the world are faced with a very difficult sense of reality. Often when one or both parents are unable to care for the home or family, a daughter will have to step in and take care of the household chores. This also goes with Magnoli (2006) , who indicated that in many poor communities there is a lack of knowledge of the potential long-term benefits educating a girl can bring. The low status of women along with deep-rooted patriarchal attitudes often results in girls’ education being perceived as a low priority. Gender disparities in literacy can be traced back to whether or not families decide to educate girls. The decision to send a girl to school depends on how the family values education for the girl, as well as for the entire family. The findings also indicate that poverty is pervasive. When compounded by discrimination and strict gender roles, poverty keeps girls unschooled and dependent. They are unable to escape the demands placed upon them by a society that neither values nor respects them. This result is consistent with Daoud (2012) who argue that frequently girls are kept home to do household chores and care for younger siblings, or they are thrust into the labor market to contribute to household income. CONCLUSIONS Poverty and socio-cultural barriers are real in Sudan and need serious attention if the plans for ensuring girls’ education and gender equality are to be realized. Therefore, policy initiatives, programs and schemes that address the issue of opportunity cost of sending the children to school, especially girls, could prove effective in addressing the access issue and gender parity in basic education for boys and girls across urban/rural settings. The study concluded that poverty is main reason that put girls out of the schools. It can be said that poverty among displaced communities is acute, where the source of income is low paid work, specifically more difficult for illiterate females headed households to meet the needs of their families. However, the respondents are aware of the negative effects of being illiterate on present and future life. They are also aware of the relationship between their illiteracy and gender in equality. Moreover despite the fact that barriers to girls’ education are primarily economic and social/cultural poverty remains the single major deterrent to education, and lack of education is a major cause of poverty. Uneducated girls become illiterate parents unable to support their children, and the vicious cycle continues. When families face poverty, girls are the goat of the escape, the first to be taken out of school and put into very poor paying work in often dangerous conditions. RECOMMENDATIONS Efforts to improve female education in poor communities need to go beyond rhetoric and should involve policies and programs with and be gender-responsive. In addition, infrastructure and safety in schools, as well as on the roads leading to schools, must be secured. To realize the full benefits of girl’s education, it needs to overcome the barriers that keep girls from attending school. Effective strategies to close gender gaps in education focus on poor communities and address specific obstacles. A gender perspective on poverty and education highlights several possible strategies to tackle female disadvantage. These include: - Reducing opportunity costs to girls’ schooling, e.g. through childcare provision or investment in labor saving infrastructure, or flexible or non-formal educational provision; - Incentives and scholarships for girls’ enrolment to reduce the direct costs of girls’ schooling; - Educational initiatives outside of the schooling system, such as adult education and literacy programs, for those who ‘missed out’; - Improving the quality of education and tackling gender bias in the curriculum; - To build inclusive and just societies, the eradication of illiteracy should be considered a key; and - To make progress, government of Sudan will need to increase investment in literacy and build strong support for literacy through partnerships with non-governmental organizations (NGOs), international development Daoud and Bello 7 partners and society at large. REFERENCES Ali Y(2002). Effect of Poverty on Displaced Women: A Case Study of Dar-elsalam Camp, Khartoum State. M.Sc. Thesis, University of Khartoum, Sudan. Daoud K(2005). Coping Strategies of the Displaced Women for Achieving Food Security at Household Level in Mayo Camp, Khartoum State. M.Sc. Thesis. University of Khartoum. Daoud S(2012). A Critical Review of Gender Equality in Education: Reflecting on the Issues among Poor Communities in Sudan, in Halmarsdottir . H.B, et als Z(eds) : Gendered Voice Reflection on Gender and Education In South Africa and Sudan: Sense publ. Pp. 66-76. Durdhawale V(2004). Primary Schooling in a Tribal District of Rural Maharashtra, India: Some policy relevance, http://lst-iiep.iiepunesco.org/cgibin/wwwi32.exe/[in=epidoc1.in]/?t2000=028975/(100) El-Hassan A(2006). The Socio-economic Change of Displaced Women from Western Sudan to Khartoum State: A Case Study of Sheikh Abuzeid Marke. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Khartoum, Sudan. Evans M(2007). ‘The Suffering is Too Great’: Urban Internally Displaced Persons in the Casamance Conflict, Senegal. J. Refugee Studies. Publ. by Oxford University, Oxford, UK. Press. 20: Pp. 1. Federal Ministry of General Education (2008). Baseline survey on basic education in the Northern States. Khartoum: UNICEF and WFP. Klasen S(2002). Low Schooling for Girls, Slower Growth for All? CrossCountry Evidence on the Effect of Gender Inequality in Education on Economic Development”, The World Bank Econs. Rev. 16(3): 345373. Klasen S, Lamanna F(2008). The Impact of Gender Inequality in Education and Employment on Economic Growth in Developing Countries: Updates and Extensions. World Bank Group. Kotwal N, Gupta P, Kumar A(2006). Reasons for School Dropouts Among Rural Girls in Kurukshetra. J. Rural Devel. 55: Pp.1. Magnoli A(2006). Bridging the Gender Gap in Developing Regions. Index Working Paper, Harvard University School of Public Health, Depart. Popul. Int. Health. Nour M(2010). Assessment of the State of Women and gender gap in Sudan .Cairo: Arab Development Center. Nwaobi G(2007). Educational (work) Performance in African Countries: Problems, Policies and Prospects. MPRA Paper 1622, University Library of Munich, Germany. Pantuliano S, Assal M,Elnaiem B, McElhinney H, Schwab M(2011). City Limits: Urbanization and Vulnerability in Sudan-Khartoum Case Study. Human Policy Group., Overseas development Institute,111 Westminster Bridge Road,London.UK. Randell K(2009). Gender Equality and the Millennium Development Goals, Paper, Presented to the Rwanda Rotoract Associations Annual Conference. UNESCO (2009). Education for All Global Monitoring Report, Paris: UNESCO. UNICEF (2010). www.unicef.org. UNICEF (2011). Getting ready for school: A child-to-child approach. Program Eval. for Year Two, Grade One Outcomes. UNICEF HQ, August 2011. Worku Y(2001). “Ethiopia: from bottom to top in higher educationgender role problems”, Int. J. Sociol. and Social Policy. 21: 98-104. World Bank (2001). Engendering Development: Through Gender Equality in Rights, Resources, and Voice. New York: Oxford University Press. Pp. 52. World Bank (2007). Gender inequality, poverty. New York. How to cite this article: Daoud S.A.M. and Bello A.R.S. (2014). Perceptions of Internally Displaced Girls of Being Illiterate and Poor in an Urban Community: A Case from Khartoum, Sudan. J. Res. Peace Gend. Dev. 4(1):1-7