INTRODUCTION The Pangborn Corporation, founded in 1904 and occupying its present site since 1916, offers a commendable architectural achievement on several accounts. At a very basic level, it is successfully integrated spatially into the surrounding community. This represents no small feat: to take a major international manufacturing facility and, through thoughtful site planning and design, render it not only largely innocuous, but arguably enhance the overall aesthetic of the surrounding neighborhood. Additionally, the physical body of the factory site itself is in some ways merely a locus out of which radiate a handful of related pieces in the built environment of the Pangborn legacy. The corporation has played a key role in helping to shape what was, at the time of its arrival in its adopted home town, a relatively undeveloped corner of the city – a role, arguably, that presents a case for joint ventures between the business and civic sectors. The Pangborn example is by no means an anomaly in the realm of thoughtfully-conceived industrial growth within small cities and adjacent to residential areas. Its status in the community, however – exemplified by widespread kudos at best, and casual indifference at worst – can be traced to very specific factors that set it apart from the hordes of industrial plants spotting American towns nationwide, most of them ranging in character from the ignoble to the unremarkable. The Pangborn factory’s self-conscious architectural presence and overarching sense of commitment to merging comfortably into the fabric of the city are an outgrowth of the entrepreneur’s desire to effect civic improvement through successful business ownership. This sentiment has its roots in early 20th-century social movements within the business community, and the period of legendary paternalism displayed historically by the Pangborn Corporation can be traced from the decade following its move to Hagerstown, Maryland in the nineteen-teens. This “golden era” of philanthropic community involvement held strong through the corporation’s fiftieth anniversary in 1954, with a postwar decline marked by Thomas Pangborn’s death in 1967, and a subsequent steady dissipation of appreciable positive effect on the city’s economy as well as company pride. The foregoing introduction to the Pangborn Corporation’s physical and social legacy in its community is mirrored in a two-part architectural manifestation of these interwoven factors. The first of these is the factory itself, today comprised of fifteen buildings, situated on roughly fifteen acres and utilized primarily for distribution and managerial functions since the complete “outsourcing” of production beginning in 1999. The second substantial component of Pangborn in the fabric of Hagerstown is the adjacent 7 ½-acre Pangborn Park, a city-owned and -managed recreational open space whose land was donated to the city by the company in 1935. While creating a greensward and de facto buffer zone, the park functions almost as an extension of the factory site itself, merging the residential, civic and industrial realms in a setting that is not only appealing to employees tired from a long day of indoor work, but that also provides a place of solace and leisure for local city residents. This report will focus on three primary aspects of the Pangborn Corporation’s role in Hagerstown, with a section devoted to each: 1) Its history, and the ways in which it both interfaced with and helped to mold the architectural fabric of the city; 2) The company’s legacy of paternalism and intense desire to promote a positive public image, 2 evidenced very clearly in the establishment of municipally-owned Pangborn Park, which sits opposite the manufacturing facility; and 3) A more specific look at the architectural makeup of the factory, examining both site-specific structural elements and the relationships between buildings as regards manufacturing processes and horizontal technoindustrial flow. Part I The Pangborn Model: Shaping Urban Space Early History In 1897, 17 year old Thomas Pangborn went to work for the Belleville Copper Rolling Mills in Newark, New Jersey, near his native New York. Promoted to the general offices in New York and moving into the sales department, he also enrolled part-time at the Pratt Institute in Brooklyn. It has been remarked that his seven-year tenure with Belleville Copper, and his ties to the leaders of a wealthy and hugely successful 5th generation business, set the stage for his entrepreneurial future. As a sales representative for foundry equipment, Thomas was exposed daily to the metalworking and manufacturing industries, and he identified what he saw as a lack of innovative schemes for the cleaning of cast metal products. His personal inquiry into this problem led almost overnight to the advent of sandblasting as the state-of-the-art method of efficient cast cleaning.1 While the process of sandblasting had already been around for 35 years, its uses had been limited to glass and steel; it was Pangborn that A more in-depth explanation of Pangborn’s products and manufacturing procedures will be explored in Part II: Production Processes and Flow. 1 3 heralded its acceptance and widespread adoption in the realm of foundry work. Earlier, inefficient, and not-always-effective means of cleaning castings such as coarse files, wire brushes, emery stones, and acid baths fell by the wayside with the advances made in sandblasting. In 1904, full of ideas and with limited funds available to him (according to a 1929 company newsletter, the sole capital consisted of a box of stationary and a rubber stamp – imprint at right) Thomas founded his own business in lower New York, representing manufacturers as a supplier to the steel and foundry industries. Like his older brother Thomas, John Pangborn began working in the New York area at 17 years of age, employed as a sales clerk for the Western Electric Manufacturing Company. Leaving his position to join his brother full-time in 1905, they moved through a series of buildings – from 42 Day Street, to 227 Fulton Street, to 90 West Street2, each move auspiciously representing the need for expansion as they gained the confidence of the Foundrymen of New York by reliably supplying their material needs. In 1908 the brothers moved across the river to the New Jersey side where, operating out of a loft space that expanded to three full floors within four years 3, they started what would prefigure revolutionary advances in the efficiency of industry as a 2 See Illustration 1. Jersey City. Here, from 1908 to 1911, the Pangborn brothers launched their careers in sandblast machine manufacturing. The plant expanded from part of a loft to all three floors of the building. 3 See Illustration 2. The early Pangborn staff. In just seven years, the company went from a one-man supply sales outfit to a fully operational producer of innovative sandblasting equipment for diverse industrial applications. 4 whole – the manufacturing of commercial sandblasting equipment. Their largest supplier was the New York Central Iron Works, located in Hagerstown, Maryland. In 1912, confronted once again with the need for increased space, the Thomas W. Pangborn Company moved to Hagerstown to occupy part of a new plant built there by their distributor, where they operated from 1912 to 1915. The Move to Hagerstown / Land Acquisition Once again prompted to expand production in response to industry’s growing demand for their machines, the brothers decided to build an entirely new facility of their own. Locating a tract of land in the largely-undeveloped northeastern section of Hagerstown, they began clearing ground in 19154, and the first building – still in use today – was completed in 19165. The original independent site of the Pangborn Corporation in Hagerstown was officially purchased on May 22nd, 1915. Consisting of two parcels of land bought from Walter V. and Lutie B.Spessard, this combined property was situated in the original “Morris Addition to East Hagerstown” plat. Totaling roughly five acres, it was bounded by Crestline Avenue (later changed to Pangborn Boulevard) to the east and the Western Maryland Railroad right-of-way to the north. On New Year’s Eve day, 1915, Pangborn mortgaged these original two parcels to M.P. Moller (of Hagerstown’s famous Moller Pipe Organ Factory) and John M. Lane in the face of outstanding debt, with the provision that the mortgage be voided if Pangborn paid the initial sum of $25,000, plus 4 See Illustration 3. 1915 - Cleared lot prior to construction at the new Hagerstown site. See Illustration 4. 1917 - The Pangborn staff in Hagerstown, one year into the new location. 5 5 interest, by the end of 1916. This they did, although such examples of real estate swapping and cooperative financing amongst Hagerstown business owners and developers manifests itself repeatedly in the land deed records involving the Pangborn Corporation. In 1918, Pangborn purchased an additional, adjacent 1.3-acre parcel from the Spessards, and in 1919 acquired yet another tract for $2,500 with the intent of a proposed street running West from Crestline Avenue. This would become the continuation of present-day Pangborn Boulevard, which approaches the site from the south and makes a 90-degree turn to the west at what, originally and to the present-day, is situated the official entrance to the factory. Interestingly, the deed to this parcel contained a number of conditions: 1. That no buildings shall be erected thereon nearer than thirty feet from the north Marginal line of the aforementioned proposed street. 2. That no intoxicating liquor shall ever be sold on said tract. 3 That no dwelling along the said proposed street shall be erected to cost less than $1800 for a single house and $2500 for a double house… 6 Such stipulations, while owing more to the concerns of the seller than to Pangborn as the buyer, mark the beginning of a long phase of development and civic involvement through which the Pangborn Corporation influenced the architectural and social character of its quadrant of the city. The growth of the site involved not only factory expansion, but the allocation of open space and the coexistence of residential, civic, and industrial entities. 6 6 In 1920, the Pangborn Corporation bought yet another tract from the Spessards, this time a substantial piece containing approximately 6.4 acres. In December 1921, repeating the circumstanes of 1916, Pangborn was again forced to mortgage the original two Spessard parcels. Owing $125,000 (representing a five-fold increase in value in just five years) to the Maryland Survey and Trust Company, they were given until the end of the following year to pay off this debt. Again, they were successful in persevering. In 1929, an additional eight-tenths of an acre was purchased from D. Walter Groh (another early Hagerstown industrialist), furthering Pangborn’s consolidation of land fronting the strategic Western Maryland railway, the primary means of transporting both raw materials to the site and finshed products away toward their eventual destinations. Evolving In A Civic and Residential Fabric : The Factory-Town Interface Though scant written accounts containing evidence of the early factory’s political relationship to the town-at-large remain, numerous factors indicate the presence of an almost paternalistic stance towards the city on the part of the Pangborns. Financial contributions to area schools, civic groups, and charity organizations were commonplace enough as to make Pangborn a household name in Hagerstown. An enormous gesture of generosity befell the town in 1935, when the Pangborn Corporation donated four of the original Spessard parcels of land, totaling 7.6 acres, for use as a public park.7 Situated immediately opposite the expansive southern façade of 7 See Illustration 5. Proposed plan for Pangborn Park, 7 the factory, the conveyance was based on a set of conditions intended to regulate the town’s use of that substantial piece of land in perpetuity. These included: 1. The plot of ground so conveyed, as aforesaid, to be used as a municipal park and recreation center. 2. That a reasonable amount of planting will be done each year for the purpose of beautifying the said plot of ground. 4. That the initial work on said plot of ground will be undertaken promptly as a welfare relief project. 6. That no vending booths or commercial structures of any character shall be erected on the said plot of ground. 7. That the said plot of ground will not be sold, alienated, conveyed away, or leased by the City of Hagerstown and that it will be used solely for the purposes of a public park and recreation center. 8. That the proposed park will be adequately policed and lighted by the City of Hagerstown. 9. That the proposed park shall be known and designated as “PANGBORN PARK”.8 The nature of these restrictions, while clearly in the interests of safeguarding both the well-being of factory employees and the public image of the factory (the park being in such close proximity, today separated only by a two-lane street, sidewalks, and the original thirty feet of setback on the factory side), also suggests an interest on the part of the company in having some measure of control over the character and destiny of the greater neighborhood. In an 87-year history of buying and selling parcels of land in the city – some contiguous with the factory, and indicative of the need for expansion (whether perceived, real, or speculative), some independent investments or trades on 1935 land deed records. 8 8 money owed or due – the decision to donate such a substantial piece of land entrenched Pangborn’s vision in the legacy of the city fabric. Following the conveyance of these seven and a half acres of land to the city in 1935, which precipitated a host of Works Progress Administration-sponsored projects in accordance with the stipulated plans for a municipal park, the Pangborn Corporation experienced substantial growth and, from all outward historical appearances, followed a consistent upward trajectory in production and sales. The architectural footprint of the factory nearly doubled between 1916 and 1950 9, adding three warehouses, a new mechanical shop, steel shop, an expanded sheet metal shop, a new cooling and powerhouse, and a doubling of available office space10. At that point, however, it appears that most of the land on which today’s total factory would be sited had already been acquired. Hemmed in by the railroad to the north and east, and fronted by its own road, the factory expanded largely through infilling of vacant spaces between buildings, forming a contiguous façade stretching westward from the unmistakeable 90-degree turn in Pangborn Boulevard. Only later would further expansion result in the officespace accretion to the south of the machine assembly building, and the addition of a detached, larger, rubber- and metal- fabrication building on the east side of a second railroad spur, thus bringing the factory’s eastern edge immediately adjacent to the northsouth railway line. As will be made more clear through a later exploration of the spatial evolution of the site, the first 35 years of the Pangborn Corporation’s factory in Hagerstown saw substantial growth, strategically absorbed by way of an original site 9 See Illustration 6. Diagram depicting the 1916, 1928, and 1950 factory building accretions of the Pangborn Corporation Hagerstown plant. Courtesy of David Tipson. 10 See Illustration 7. Sandborn Fire Insurance Company maps. 9 plan in which spaces between buildings permitted additions and expansions that kept the burgeoning company within the limits it had set out for itself. PART II THE “GOOD NEIGHBOR”: BUILDING INDUSTRY FOR THE CIVIC GOOD The early management of the Pangborn Corporation was guided by principles borne of personal philosophy, religious conviction, and the influecnes of a contemporaneous culture of “paternal capitalism” that sought to better society through responsible business ownership. A t the 50th anniversary of the Pangborn Corporation’s establishment in Hagerstown, employees presented Thomas Pangborn with a plaque that concluded with: “High ideals and unselfish motives are exemplified by your constant interest in our welfare. Inspiring leadership, and courage, and fair dealings have won our esteem and loyalty.” On May 23, 1967, following the death of Mr. Pangborn, the Hagerstown Daily Mail printed an article that included these words: “Thomas Wesley Pangborn in his life span of 86 years excelled in many things – industry, philanthropy, church leadership and humanitarianism among them… As founder of the Pangbron Corporation, a key Hagerstown industry for over half a century, Mr. Pangborn made millions of dollars; as a humanitarian he gave vast sums of money to schools, churches, and institutions in the service of humanity… As an industrialist he was concerned with the institutions of men. He was honored with degrees in law, letters and science by five universities or colleges. He was recognized by museums, hospitals, business organizations, colleges… While these institutions were the immediate recipients of his many benefactions, it is the public served by the institutions that is the real beneficiary. His relationship with his employees was one of devotion that in turn inspired intense loyalty…The poor youth from 10 Brooklyn, New York, who adopted Hagerstown, had an idea and a belief. All those over whom his shadow fell benefitted from them. No man could give more.” 11 The foregoing comments are not unique – in almost all published accounts of Thomas Pangborn, testaments to his generosity and community involvement abound. While it may be readily concluded that he was a highly motivated individual, his enthusiasm stemming from much more than self-interest, it is important to take note of the era in which he started his corner of the industrial empire, so to speak. The early 20th century, a time during which the Industrial Revolution itself was being revolutionized, also yielded a breed of entrepreneur guided by values considerably more humanitarian and forward-thinking than the CEOs of today’s ephemeral fly-bynight companies – entrepreneurs of businesses more entrenched in the social fabric of their communities, and indeed members of those communities themselves. In his speech delivered in 1954 at the 50th anniversary of his corporation, Thomas Pangborn made these remarks: “The corporation emblem atop our plant water tower, boasts justifiably of quality, to the four winds. We are proud and deeply conscious that it siginifies not only quality of product, - but the quality also, of you men and women who are the Pangborn Corporation. I want to thank all of my fellow workers… and you our neighbors and fellow townspeople…we can and will strive – from year to year – to contribute our full strength and talent to the tasks before us, - so that… [we all] may experience the same noble pride and satisfaction… in the accomplishments and well being of all our people.” 12 11 12 11 As touched on briefly in the foregoing, The Pangborn Corporation’s, and, in particular, Thomas Pangborn’s, place in the larger realm of social and architectural movements – including welfare capitalism, industrial paternalism, the City Beautiful and Garden City movements – served as a template from which evolved the company town aesthetic 13 of the Pangborn Site. Continuing forward with this theme of the “Good Neighbor” , it is essential to explore some of the corporation’s philanthropic contributions to the residents of Hagerstown – most notably, the establishment of the 7 ½-acre Pangborn Park – in an effort to further underscore the factory’s role in shaping the architectural landscape of the city. Pangborn Park Pangborn Park, built on land donated to the City of Hagerstown by the Pangborn Corporation in 1935 , was officially dedicated on June 10, 1939, 27 years after the Pangborns’ arrival in Hagerstown. In conjunction with a well-conceived façade, sidewalk, and allez of trees that, viewed together 14, can be likened more to a smallscale city street scene or series of adjacent storefronts than the front of a bustling machinery plant – Pangborn successfully inserted itself into the fabric of a previously underdeveloped portion of the city. In so doing, it managed simultaneously to create an open-space buffer equivalent to half of the eventual total property acreage of the factory site itself, encouraged the coexistence of industrial, civic, and community life by While lacking the monarch-like status that marks a true company town, Hagerstown’s relationship to the Pangborn factory was one of significant economic dependence. For the purposes of this report, however, the architectural manifestations of the company’s influence on the cityscape will supercede issues of political influence. 13 12 fostering the establishment an adjacent park, and sculpted an outdoor aesthetic that would have made any employee proud to wander through after a day’s work indoors. PART III 15 SITE HISTORY AND SPATIAL EVOLUTION Introduction The Pangborn Corporation factory, while exemplifying a unique fit into the urban landscape of Hagerstown, follows a decidedly utilitarian model in its fundamental architectural character. Availing itself of the widely-used industrial building technologies of its era, it represents pragmatism, affordability, and durability. Extensive glass fenestration, steel frame and truss construction, and non-load-bearing brick walls are the hallmark structural characteristics of the majority of the site’s buildings. While the scale, number of buildings, dense site organization, and very intentional layout all serve to reinforce the factory’s undeniable impact on the immediate neighborhood, it must be stressed that economic contingencies govern the practical nature of most industrial architecture, and Pangborn is no exception. That said, this section will attempt to give a more accurate description of the architectural character of the factory’s buildings, with special attention given to their place in the industrial canon of the time. Construction 14 15 See Illustration 8. See Illustration 9. Pangborn Park photographs, 2002. Courtesy Mike Yengling. 13 The Pangborn plant was a project of the Frank D. Chase Company, a firm specializing in the custom design of industrial buildings for companies throughout the East and Midwest. Flat monitor-type buildings, brick endbay parapets, metal sash curtain walls, steel roof truss systems, and concrete slab floors are prevalent throughout the site. Single-story construction predominates, with high ceilings for overhead cranes, and only the front offices (located immediately behind the southern entrance façade) occupy more than one floor. Extensive use was made of natural lighting, and the interiors of the large production buildings are flooded with natural light from both the continuous sash curtain walls and central overhead monitor windows. 16 The importance and logic of illumination will be discussed in the next section on site orientation. Site Orientation By the time the ground was broken for the first new Pangborn building in 1915, electricity was widely available for use in commercial and industrial lighting applications. Nonetheless, many industrial buildings of the era still followed the practice of situating buildings on a north-south axis so as to permit maximum infiltration of natural light as the sun followed its daily course across the horizon. Originally this was enhanced by extremely narrow and longitudinal building design, following the imperative that sunlight – the primary source of workplace illumination prior to overhead electric lighting – be allowed to flood the interior of the structure from either side. In the early 20th century, greater roof truss spans led to the proliferation of central, overhead monitor windows 16 See Illustrations 10 - 11 14 which, in conjunction with glass curtain walls, supplemented the more consistent – but comparably expensive – output of electric lighting. The foregoing trend is indicative of early 20th-century dependence on natural lighting in industrial buildings, a factor that is, arguably, of inestimable benefit to factory employees’ well-being. The majority of the Pangborn factory’s larger production and storage buildings follow this pattern. They are all rectangular in form, and those that have not had later, adjacent buildings built directly on to them display the trademark steel-mullioned phalanxes of windows that all but comprise the long east and west sides. One notable exception to the predominant north-south longitudinal orientation of the site is the foundry, one of the original buildings appearing in the 1918 Sandborn Fire Insurance Company maps. 17 In the absence of historical documentation such as an architect’s notes on the project, there are two hypotheses regarding this discrepancy. One is the fortuitous siting of the then-new factory on the preexisting east-west Western Maryland Railroad line, and the desirability of having a primary building (in this case, the foundry, the most important building for a metal-products manufacturer) that permitted easy unloading and storage of bulk and heavy materials – such as fuel and metal stock - along its length. Another possibility is that the depth of the original site (prior to additional land acquisitions) necessitated locating the foundry behind the main administrative, manufacturing and assembly buildings. Hemmed in by the railway to the north and Pangborn Boulevard to the south, and filled almost to its depth by the long north-south buildings and their fronting facades, it is possible that the foundry was quite 17 See Illustration 12. 15 deliberately sited behind these other early buildings, as its noise and filth would have been anathema to the docile streetscape of the factory’s southern entrance side. Building Layout: Production Processes And Flow Questions often asked by visitors to or passersby of the Pangborn factory are “What goes on here?” , “What do they make?”, or “Why so many buildings?” One answer to the last question is the fact that the Pangborn Corporation represents a vertically-integrated industry; that is, it has historically attempted to retain control over its production – a desire part economic, and part oriented towards strict quality standards – through the on-site orchestration of as many steps in the manufacturing process as possible. Purchasing materials in a raw state – metals, rubber, wood – the factory was equipped to convert each of these, in distinct places within the factory, into the various parts that comprise their machines. Work generally began in the foundry 18, where metals – aluminum, iron, steel, manganese (used in the making of a hard, malleable and ductile steel, with a ratio of about 12 to 14% manganese), even a Pangborn-patented steel alloy named P-44 – were cast into parts used in the blast cleaning and dust collection machines for which the company remains famous. P-44 was invented specifically to meet the need for a steel extremely resistant to scratching, and while brittle, is used very successfully in the manufacture of the walls which house the rooms and chambers in which blast cleaning is conducted. That is, the machines that the company produces are used by large manufacturers – automotive, aeronautical, and military, to name some of the larger 16 categories – to surface-clean the parts they are manufacturing for their products. Consequently, the scale can be quite large, and Pangborn’s output includes not only sandblasting technology, but the accompanying structures to house the procedure. As a result, the space required is substantial. While single-story, the larger buildings at Pangborn are quite tall, as evidenced in interior photos of the assembly hall and metal shop buildings. 19 Where the foundry yielded cast parts, the separate metal fabrication and sheet metal shops produced a variety of machined and milled metal parts – such as springs, bushings, pulleys, and bolts, as well as rubber products – sheets, strips, and gaskets, to name a few. Simultaneously, a separate woodshop off of the foundry building custom-produced patterns for all of the cast machine parts. Using blank hardwood stock such as cherry or purpleheart, a reverse mold was meticulously crafted out of wood, from which the mold for casting each machine part was rendered in steel. 20 Remarkably, the factory still uses this technique to the present day in its off-site production facilities; an interview with a current employee of the company noted that while rubber molds were tried experimentally, the exacting and long-lasting woodshop-produced molds were found to be superior. In addition to the foundry, assembly hall, pattern shop and metal departments, the site contains office spaces, a powerhouse, storage buildings, large shipping and receiving areas with loading docks, and a large, recently-renovated showroom for demonstrating equipment to prospective corporate buyers. While the architectural configurations in evidence at the Pangborn factory are rather site-specific, basic 18 19 See Illustration 13 See Illustrations 14-15 17 patterns of horizontally-orchestrated flow of movement in the production process are evident in general schematic drawings of multipurpose industrial building designs. 21 Pangborn, while possessing an array of unique qualities, nonetheless falls in to a breed of architecture designed and constructed to cost-effectively meet the spatial needs of a variety of industries. Its basic character can be seen in a multitude of single-story factory sites that make use of ample fenestration and monitor windows (for both illumination and ventilation), and the large spans permitted by steel frame and truss construction to provide open floor plans and the subsequent ability to reorganize space as production and technological advances in machinery demand. The Illustration section at the end of this report contains section drawings as well as photographs of a variety of industrial spaces, from the unmistakeable sawtooth monitor buildings to the classic multistory mill buildings of the late nineteenth century. 22 The intent is to identify Pangborn within a contemporary architectural context, noting its characteristic features while providing a spectrum from which to assess the particular qualities that suited the needs of a specific industrial manufacturer. CONCLUSION The Pangborn factory, offering a rich history, an interesting architectonic canvas, and an almost congregation-like embracing by the townspeople in its first few decades in Maryland, went from a one-man sales outfit in Jersey City to become the largest manufacturer, seller, and distributor of equipment that revolutionized the entirety of 20 21 See Illustration 16. See Illustration 17. 18 industry worldwide. Furthering the intrigue is the fact that, beginning in the nineteenteens, Pangborn dramatically influenced the spatial evolution of its corner of Hagerstown. Now, however – while still retaining the distinction of being the largest manufacturer in its field – over half a dozen of the site’s most substantial buildings sit unused, with two-thirds of the plant’s approximately 300,000 square feet advertised for sale or lease.23 What does this represent, for a company that for at least fifty years prided itself on its selfless contributions and tireless involvement in the community? How do these buildings and their current state of disuse reflect a shift in corporate ethic, sense of civic duty, or financial solvency, and what do they bode for the future of their city, industrial or otherwise? What is the future of once-prospering industrial space, still structurally sound and infrastructurally relevant, now abandoned for locations offering cheaper labor, or geographically more desirable for the transnational shipping and receiving of goods and raw materials? The Pangborn Corporation’s plant in Hagerstown, Maryland, approximately 70% vacated for over three years, is now balanced somewhere between being a humanistic local pillar of success and wealth, and a bastion of faceless industrial progress which has inevitably moved on to more lucrative pastures. Its contributions to the community still stand proud – the park, local schools and churches built largely through donated company money – but the factory’s vacant buildings sit silently behind its townlike façade, an architectural testament to an intriguing past and an uncertain future. The Pangborn factory’s role in Hagerstown offers a compelling set of lenses for an exploration of the origins, development, and meanings within industrial space, and in so 22 23 See Illustrations. See Illustration. 19 doing raises questions that are not only site-specific, but germane to broader future visions of the interface between architecture and society. 20