The Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC Service Satisfaction Survey Spring 2014 Table of Contents Overview of Key Findings .............................................................................................................................. 3 1. Please indicate which services you have previously used ........................................................................ 5 1a. Which Human Resources services have you previously used? ........................................................... 5 1b. Which Finance and Accounting services have you previously used? ................................................. 0 2. How often do you use Business Center services?..................................................................................... 2 3. When you contact the Business Center, how often do you typically use each of the following communication methods? ............................................................................................................................ 4 4. Satisfaction regarding BC services ............................................................................................................ 5 4a.Business Center representatives respond in a timely manner. ........................................................... 5 4b. Business Center representatives handle my issues to my satisfaction. ............................................. 6 4c. Business Center representatives are professional. ............................................................................. 7 4d. Business Center representatives are knowledgeable. ........................................................................ 8 4e. I know who to contact at the Business Center when I have an HR question/issue. ........................... 9 4f. I know who to contact at the BC when I have a Finance and Accounting question or issue. ........... 10 4g. The Business Center provides clear information on procedures and policies. ................................. 11 4h. I am comfortable approaching a BC representative when I have a question or issue. .................... 12 4i. Overall, my experiences with the Business Center have been positive. ........................................... 13 4j. The Business Center provides accurate budget preparation assistance. .......................................... 14 4k. The Business Center provides timely budget preparation assistance. ............................................. 15 5. Satisfaction regarding BC reports ........................................................................................................... 15 5a. The Business Center delivers reports in a timely manner. ............................................................... 16 5b. The Business Center reports provide useful information needed to monitor financial status. ....... 17 5c. The Business Center reports provide useful information needed to make decisions. ..................... 18 6. In which unit do you work? .................................................................................................................... 19 7. In what part of University Outreach and Engagement do you work? ................................................... 20 8. What is your position? ............................................................................................................................ 21 9. How long have you worked for your unit? ............................................................................................. 22 10. Do you have some positive comments that you would like to pass on? .............................................. 22 11. Please tell us what you think can be done to improve the Business Center services .......................... 23 Appendix A: Open-ended Responses to Question #10 ............................................................................... 24 Appendix B: Open-ended Responses to Question #11 ............................................................................... 39 Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 1 Research Objectives and Methods The University Administrative Business Center (UABC) was implemented in August 2010 to meet the human resource, finance, and accounting support needs of many units, clubs, and activities across the Oregon State University campus. With the implementation complete, during 2011-12, C2C conducted a satisfaction survey of Business Center customers to determine the satisfaction levels of faculty and staff with Business Center services and identify actionable areas for improvement. With a vision of including continuous improvement in transaction processing, financial reporting, and assisting the University in developing an effective and high quality workforce, OSU’s Administration in early 2014 sought to assess progress again by surveying Business Center customers. To assess progress, the Administration wanted to use the questions from the 2011-12 survey so that the responses could be compared to the previous results. The Close to the Customer Project (C2C) was commissioned to conduct an online survey for faculty, staff, and student workers and volunteers served by the UABC. C2C used the “Business Center Questionnaire” from the previous Business Center study as the basis for the survey. The questionnaire includes multiple-choice questions and two open-ended questions. On April 18th, an email invitation containing a brief description and link to the survey was distributed to 1,599 individuals served by the UABC. On April 22nd a reminder email was sent to those who had not yet responded. The survey remained open for two weeks. Of the 1,599 employees that received the survey invitation, a total of 480 surveys were completed for a response rate of 30.02 percent. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 2 Overview of Key Findings Overall, respondents who work with UABC report high levels of satisfaction with the BC and its services; although, there are a few areas in which respondents are seeking improvement. Below is a summary of the most compelling findings from the survey data. Respondents from UABC “agree” that their overall experience with the BC has been positive. 1. A majority of respondents agree*(responses of 4 or 5) that the BC representatives respond in a timely manner (Figure 11), handle issues to their satisfaction (Figure 12), are professional (Figure 13), are knowledgeable (Figure 14) and nearly half agree that they know who to contact if they have an HR question (Figure 15). 2. Half of respondents agree (responses of 4 or 5) that they know who to contact if they have a Finance and Accounting issue (Figure 16), feel the BC provides clear information on procedures and policies (Figure 17). Majority of respondents are comfortable (responses 4 or 5) approaching BC representatives with questions (Figure 18). 3. A majority of respondents agree (responses of 4 or 5) that the BC provides accurate budget preparation assistance (Figure 20) and provides timely budget preparation assistance (Figure 21). 4. A majority of respondents agree (responses of 4 or 5) that the BC delivers reports in a timely manner (Figure 22), the reports provide useful information needed to monitor financial status (Figure 23) and the reports provide useful information needed to make decisions (Figure 24). 5. Open-ended comments (Appendix A) indicate that many respondents are very satisfied with the helpfulness and reliability of the UABC staff. 6. For some statements, the units’ level of agreement is significantly different. OSU Cascades Campus, Students Affairs, and Extension have high levels of satisfaction with UABC as compared with other units, while the Research Office and Enrollment Management have lower level of satisfaction. There are 16 units served by UABC. Respondents to the survey were asked to identify which of the 16 units served by UABC that they work in. The choices were: x Academic Affairs x Audit Services x Enrollment Management x Finance and Administration (E&G Funded) x Graduate School x Information Services x International Programs x Office of the President Note: Responses to these questions were recorded on a five point scale, with 1=Strongly Disagree and 5=Strongly Agree. Answers of 4 and 5 indicate agreement with the statement and answers of 1 and 2 indicate disagreement. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 3 x x x x x x x x x Office of the Provost OSU Cascades Campus OSU Library Research Office, Centers, Institutes, and Programs Student Affairs (E&G Funded) University Outreach and Engagement University Relations and Marketing University Shared Services Other Instead of choosing a unit, a fairly large number of respondents chose the “Other” category and listed programs under one of the units (e.g., Extension and Ecampus instead of University Outreach and Engagement, INTO instead of International Programs). These programs have been added to the 16 units in the charts that break out responses by unit. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 4 1. Please indicate which services you have previously used Respondents were provided a list of 12 commonly used human resource services and 10 commonly used finance and accounting services. An open-ended text field was also provided for respondents to specify other, less commonly used services. Respondents were asked to select which services they had previously used at the BC and they could check as many as they wished. 1a. Which Human Resources services have you previously used? Figure 1 Which Human Resource services have you previously used? *New hire & payroll paperwork/new hire orientation 43.3% *Rehires/renewal process 15.5% Recruitment process 23.5% Performance evaluations 24.0% Pay/timesheet/leave balance 51.4% Reclassification 16.7% *Job changes 15.0% Law/policy/procedure/collective bargaining… 9.5% Position description updates Termination/final paychecks 22.1% 10.5% *Student hiring processes 21.4% Policy interpretation/consultation 15.1% Not applicable 15.3% Other 7.1% 0.0% 10.0% 20.0% 30.0% 40.0% 50.0% 60.0% Percent Of Respondents Figure 1 illustrates that respondents use UABC human resource services primarily for pay/timesheet/leave balance and new hire and payroll paper work/new hire orientation. The services marked with an asterisk* indicate there was a statistical difference in the usage of at least two of the units that use UABC services. Those differences will be explored in the following pages. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 5 Figure 2 Use of New hire & payroll paperwork/new hire orientation Information Services 31.4% International Programs 71.4% Average 49.0% 0.0% 10.0% 20.0% 30.0% 40.0% 50.0% 60.0% 70.0% 80.0% Figure 2 depicts the use of new hire & payroll paperwork/orientation by unit. The usage among Information Services employees (31 percent) was significantly lower than the usage in International Programs (71.4 percent). The average use of this BC service by all respondents is included in these figures as a reference. Figure 3 Use of Rehires/renewal process Academic Affairs Information Services University Outreach and Engagement 35.3% 7.8% 10.0% Average 18.2% 0.0% 5.0% 10.0% 15.0% 20.0% 25.0% 30.0% 35.0% 40.0% Figure 3 depicts the use of the rehires/renewal process by unit. The usage among Information Services employees (8 percent) and University Outreach and Engagement employees (10 percent) was significantly lower than the usage of Academic Affairs (35 percent). Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 6 Figure 4 Use of Job change services Academic Affairs OSU Library 29.4% 3.3% Research Office, Centers, Institutes, and Programs 26.7% Extension 5.6% Average 17.0% 0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% Figure 4 depicts the use of Job changes by unit. The usage among both OSU Library employees (3 percent) and Extension employees (6 percent) were significantly lower than the usage among Research Office, Centers, Institutes, and Programs (27 percent) and Academic Affairs (29 percent). Figure 5 Use of Student Hiring processes Student Affairs (E&G Funded) 56% University Outreach and Engagement Extension 13.80% 5.60% Average 0.00% 27.80% 10.00% 20.00% 30.00% 40.00% 50.00% 60.00% Figure 5 depicts the use of student hiring process by unit. The usage among Extension employees (6 percent) and University Outreach and Engagement employees (14 percent) was significantly lower than the usage of Students Affairs (56 percent). Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 7 Table 1 Other Human Resources Text Responses by Unit Academic Affairs Enrollment Management Finance and Administration (E&G Funded) Information Service International Program OSU Library Research Office Faculty fee form Health coverage Staff tuition waiver Background Check staff tuition reduction support for PeopleAmin reporting, BIquery connections, FTR spreadsheets FMLA Staff Fee Processing Reporting Staff fee privs Travel reimbursement Military Leave Staff tuition forms staff tuition benefit Exchange rate compensation checks Staff Privileges Staff fee tuition Name Change, Staff Transfer Fee assistance Have no idea who our Business Center is Student Affairs University Outreach and Engagement Extension Other Staff Fee Tuition Discount faculty/staff tuition EMPCENTER (LOTS) Cash out Staff Fee Priviledge staff fee form transfer of faculty tuition reduction reimbursements for work travel Communication Allowance Address information / help with staff tuition discounts Tuition forms for transfer of benefit to another university Staff Fee Privilege Form Needed copy for financing matter Staff Fee Reduction additional issues regarding coordination with employee benefits, FMLA, workers' compensation, disability claims, staff fee privileges benefits BC workgroup meeting on 4/16/14 not sure Tuition Family Member Transfer I'm at OSU-Cascades Staff Benefits (tuition reduction) Public Records process and litigation discovery. Also tuition waivers. Table 1 lists the open-ended text responses from the units that use UABC. Units with small numbers of responses to the survey were grouped together in the “Other” category to provide anonymity to the respondents. 1b. Which Finance and Accounting services have you previously used? Figure 6 Which Finance and Accounting Services have you previously used? Invoice processing/vendor payment 39.7% *Travel/expense reimbursement 51.5% Procurement/placing orders 21.7% Timesheets or other payroll issues 43.3% Budget/grant budget development 18.2% Periodic budget/grant reporting 19.0% Budget/grant analysis 13.1% Budget/grant management 15.0% Labor redistribution 10.6% Policy interpretation/consultation 18.5% Not Applicable Other 17.5% 3.2% 0.0% 10.0% 20.0% 30.0% 40.0% 50.0% 60.0% Percent of Respondents Figure 6 illustrates that respondents use BC Finance and Accounting services primarily for Travel/expense reimbursement, Timesheets or other payroll issues, and Invoice processing/vendor payment. The asterisk* indicates that there was a statistical difference between at least two units in the usage of that service. That difference will be examined next. Figure 7 Use of Travel/expense reimbursement services Information Services 70.6% OSU Library 23.3% Average 51.5% 0.0% 10.0% Average 20.0% 30.0% OSU Library 40.0% 50.0% 60.0% 70.0% 80.0% Information Services Figure 7 depicts the use Travel/expense reimbursement services by unit. The usage among the OSU Library employees (23 percent) was significantly lower than Information Services (71 percent). Table 2 Finance and Administration (E&G Funded) Information Services International Programs Research Office, Centers, Institutes, and Programs University Outreach and Engagement Extension Other Other Finance and Accounting Text Responses Request for Access processing JV Corrections Special Projects/Committee participation PCards Reporting forward contracts, foreign currencies Student billing for study abroad Lab testing fee calculations Vendor contracts; fee book pricing I don't know any of these people Event Manager refunds Tuition adjustments Communication Allowance Address Tuition forms for transfer of benefits federal employee benefits Revenue Distributions/Budget Transfers paid a 5cent charge When the need may arise I'm at OSU-Cascades Public records estimate information, litigation discovery. Table 2 lists the open-ended text responses from the units that use UABC. Units with small numbers of responses to the survey were grouped together in the “Other” category to provide anonymity to the respondents. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 1 2. How often do you use Business Center services? Figure 8 How often do you use Business Center services? Never 44 Once or twice a year 122 Once or twice a term/quarter 107 Monthly 122 Weekly 114 Daily 42 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 Figure 8 depicts the distribution of the usage of BC services among respondents. Of the 551 valid responses, 44 (8 percent) never use BC services, while 229 (just under 42 percent) use it once or twice a year or once or twice a quarter. One hundred twenty two respondents (22 percent) use BC services monthly and 114 (21 percent) respondents use BC service weekly. Forty-two respondents (nearly 8 percent) use BC services daily. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 2 Figure 9 How often do you use Business Center services? Never Acdemic Affairs Enrollment Management Once or twice a year Finance and Administration (E&G Funded) Information Services Once or twice a term/quarter International Program OSU Library Monthly Research Office, Centers, Institutes, and Programs Student Affairs (E&G Funded) Weekly University Outreach and Engagement Extension Daily 0.0 10.0 Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 20.0 30.0 40.0 3 Figure 9 depicts the distribution of the usage of BC services. The smallest groups of respondents were those who said they never use BC services and those who use BC services daily. x Among the respondents who never use BC services, 16 percent were from Enrollment Management and 14 percent were from Extension. None were from International Programs. x Among the respondents who use BC services once or twice a year, Information Services (33 percent) and the OSU Library (30 percent) had the highest percentages, while International Programs was the lowest with 11 percent. x Among the respondents using BC services once or twice a term, Academic Affairs was the high at 27 percent and Student Affairs the low at 12 percent. x Among the respondents using BC services monthly, Student Affairs (36 percent) and International Programs (32 percent) had the highest percentages, while Enrollment Management was the lowest with 11 percent. x Among the respondents using BC services weekly, 37 percent were from Enrollment Management, while only 14 percent were from Information Services and 13 percent were from the OSU Library. x Among the respondents using BC services daily, Finance and Administration (16 percent) was significantly higher than Academic Affairs (3 percent), the OSU Library (3 percent), and Extension (3 percent). 3. When you contact the Business Center, how often do you typically use each of the following communication methods? Figure 10 Average Percent of Use for BC Contact Website 4.9% On-campus 2.9% In person 7.3% E-mail 61.2% Telephone 23.8% 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Figure 10 indicates that most respondents contact the BC by e-mail (61 percent). Twenty-four percent contacted the BC by telephone, while 7 percent contacted BC in person, 5 percent contacted BC by website and 3 percent contact BC in person (on campus). Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 4 4. Satisfaction regarding BC services Respondents were asked to indicate their level of agreement with various statements about the BC. A five-point scale was used to determine levels of agreement, with ‘1’ representing ‘Strongly Disagree’ and ‘5’ representing ‘Strongly Agree.’ Responses of ‘4’ or ‘5’ indicate the respondent agrees with the presented statement, a ‘3’ indicates the respondent was neutral about the statement, and responses of‘1’ or ‘2’ indicate the respondent disagrees with the statement. Where no significant difference in the level of agreement was found among the units or departments, the total number of agree to disagree responses are presented in bar charts such as Figure 11. Where there were significant differences between units in their level of agreement with a survey question, bar charts that show the means for each unit are presented (e.g., Figure 12). 4a.Business Center representatives respond in a timely manner. Figure 11 Business Center representatives respond in a timely manner. Strongly Agree =5 191 4 178 3 77 2 27 Strongly Disagree =1 5 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 Figure 11 illustrates that, from 478 responses to this question, 77 percent agree (answers of 4 or 5) that Business Center representatives respond in a timely manner. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 5 4b. Business Center representatives handl e my issues to my satisfaction. Figure 12 Business Center representatives handle my issues to my satisfaction. OSU Cascades Campus E Campus INTO University Relations and Marketing Extension Student Affairs (E&G Funded) Graduate School University Outreach and Engagement Information Services Academic Affairs Office of the President Audit Services International Programs Finance and Administration (E&G Funded) Research Office, Centers, Institutes, and… OSU Library Enrollment Management Office of the Provost 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 Figure 12 presents the average level of agreement in each unit with the statement "Business Center representatives handle my issues to my satisfaction." In the units whose results are statistically different, OSU Cascades Campus has a higher mean than Finance and Administration, the Research Office, the OSU Library, Enrollment Management, and the Office of the Provost. Means of Ecampus, Student Affairs, and University Outreach and Engagement are all higher than those of the Research Office, the OSU Library, and Enrollment Management. INTO has a higher mean than the OSU Library and Enrollment Management. University Relations and Marketing has a higher mean than Finance and Administration, the Research Office, the OSU Library, and Enrollment Management. Extension is higher than International Programs, Finance and Administration, the Research Office, the OSU Library, Enrollment Management, and the Office of the Provost. Information Service has a higher mean than Enrollment Management. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 6 In the results above it was noted that the mean for Student Affairs is significantly higher than the mean of the Research Office. However, the mean for INTO, which is higher than the mean for Student Affairs, is not significantly different than the Research Office. This can result from the sample size of INTO being too low and/or the variance of INTO being too high to achieve a significant difference. 4c. Business Center representatives are professional. Figure 13 Business Center representatives are professional. Strongly Agree =5 252 4 174 3 41 2 12 Strongly Disagree =1 3 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 Figure 13 illustrates that, out of 482 responses to this question, 88 percent agree (answers of 4 or 5) that Business Center representatives are professional. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 7 4d. Business Center representatives are knowledgeable. Figure 14 Business Center representatives are knowledgeable. INTO OSU Cascades Campus University Relations and Marketing Graduate School Extension E Campus Academic Affairs Information Services University Outreach and Engagement Student Affairs (E&G Funded) International Programs OSU Library Office of the President Research Office, Centers, Institutes, and Programs Finance and Administration (E&G Funded) Office of the Provost Enrollment Management 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 Figure 14 presents the average level of agreement in each unit with the statement "Business Center representatives are knowledgeable." In the units whose results are statistically different, INTO, the OSU Cascades Campus, University Relations and Marketing, the Graduate School, Extension, Academic Affairs, Information Services, and University Outreach and Engagement all have higher means than the Research office, Finance and Administration, and Enrollment Management. In addition, Ecampus, Student Affairs, International Programs, and the OSU Library all have higher means than Enrollment Management. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 8 4e. I know who to contact at the Business Center wh en I have an HR question/issue. Figure 15 I know who to contact at the Business Center when I have an HR question/issue. Strongly Agree =5 97 4 109 3 108 2 99 Strongly Disagree =1 55 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 Figure 15 illustrates that, out of 468 responses to this question, more respondents agreed with the statement (44 percent) than disagreed (33 percent) with the statement. Twenty-three percent of respondents replied with a neutral answer (3). As the pattern of responses to this question differs from what is typical (e.g., Figure 13), the UABC should monitor the number of neutral responses (108), which outnumber the strongly agree (97) responses. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 9 4f. I know who to contact at the BC when I have a Finance and Accounting question or issue. Figure 16 I know who to contact at the Business Center when I have a Finance/Accounting/Payroll question/issue. OSU Cascades Campus Student Affairs (E&G Funded) International Programs Office of the Provost Office of the President E Campus University Outreach and Engagement Academic Affairs Finance and Administration (E&G Funded) Information Services Enrollment Management OSU Library University Relations and Marketing Extension Research Office, Centers, Institutes, and Programs Graduate School INTO 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 Figure 16 depicts the average level of agreement in each unit with the statement that "I know who to contact at the Business Center when I have a Finance/Accounting/Payroll question/issue." In the units whose results are statistically different, OSU Cascades Campus has a higher mean than the OSU Library, University Relations and Marketing, Extension, the Research Office, the Graduate School, and INTO. The mean of Student Affairs is higher than that of Ecampus, University Outreach and Engagement, Academic Affairs, Finance and Administration, Information Services, Enrollment Management, the OSU Library, University Relations and Marketing, Extension, the Research office, the Graduate School, and INTO. In Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 10 addition, the mean of International Programs has a higher mean than Extension, the Research Office, the Graduate School, and INTO. University Outreach and Engagement has a higher mean than the Research Office and the Graduate School. The means of Academic Affairs, Finance and Administration, and Information Service are all higher than that of the Graduate School. 4g. The Business Center provides clear informat ion on procedures and policies. Figure 17 The Business Center provides clear information on procedures and policies. Strongly Agree =5 84 4 160 3 124 2 61 Strongly Disagree =1 24 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 Figure 17 depicts respondents’ level of agreement with the statement that "The Business Center provides clear information on procedures and policies." From 453 responses to this question, more than half of the respondents (54 percent) agree (answers of 4 or 5) that the Business Center provides clear information on procedures and policies. Unfortunately, the number of neutral (3) responses as well as the combined disagree responses (strongly disagree and 2) each exceed the number of strongly agree responses. With a lower level of agreement, the Business Center should look into this topic to determine what is causing problems for customers. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 11 4h. I am comfortable approaching a BC representative when I have a question or issue. Figure 18 I am comfortable approaching the Business Center when I have a question or issue. Strongly Agree =5 225 4 138 3 62 2 34 Strongly Disagree =1 11 0 50 100 150 200 250 Figure 18 illustrates that, out of 470 responses to this question, 363 (77 percent) agree (answers of 4 or 5) with that they are comfortable approaching the Business Center when they have a question or issue. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 12 4i. Overall, my experiences with the Business Center have been positive. Figure 19 Overall, my experiences with the Business Center have been positive. OSU Cascades Campus E Campus Graduate School Extension INTO Information Services International Programs University Relations and Marketing Academic Affairs Student Affairs (E&G Funded) Office of the President Finance and Administration (E&G Funded) University Outreach and Engagement OSU Library Research Office, Centers, Institutes, and Programs Enrollment Management Office of the Provost 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 Figure 19 depicts the average level of agreement in each unit with the statement that "Overall, my experiences with the Business Center have been positive." For those units with statistically different results, the means of the OSU Cascades Campus, Ecampus, the Graduate School, Information Service, International Programs, University Relations and Marketing, and Academic Affairs are all higher than those of the Research Office and Enrollment Management. Extension has a higher mean than University Outreach and Engagement, the OSU Library, the Research Office, and Enrollment Management. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 13 4j. The Business Center provides accurate budget preparation assistance. Figure 20 The Business Center provides accurate budget preparation assistance. Extension University Relations and Marketing Student Affairs (E&G Funded) INTO Office of the President International Programs Graduate School E Campus Finance and Administration (E&G Funded) OSU Cascades Campus University Outreach and Engagement Information Services OSU Library Academic Affairs Research Office, Centers, Institutes, and Programs Enrollment Management 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 Figure 20 depicts the respondents' agreement to the statement that "The Business Center provides accurate budget preparation assistance." For those units with statistically different results, the means of Extension, University Relations and Marketing, Student Affairs, International Programs, and University Outreach and Engagement are higher than those of Academic Affairs, the Research Office, and Enrollment Management. Ecampus has a higher mean than the Research Office. The means of Finance and Administration, OSU Cascades Campus, and Information Services are higher than those of the Research Office, and Enrollment Management. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 14 4k. The Business Center provides timely budget preparation assistance. Figure 21 The Business Center provides timely budget preparation assistance. Extension INTO Office of the President Student Affairs (E&G Funded) University Relations and Marketing International Programs Information Services E Campus Graduate School Finance and Administration (E&G Funded) OSU Cascades Campus University Outreach and Engagement OSU Library Academic Affairs Enrollment Management Research Office, Centers, Institutes, and… 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 Figure 21 depicts respondents' agreement with the statement that "The Business Center provide timely budget preparation assistance." For the units with statistically different results, the means of Extension, and Student Affairs are bigger than that of the Research Office. 5. Satisfaction regarding BC reports Respondents were asked to indicate their level of agreement with various statements about BC reports. A five point scale was used to determine levels of agreement, with ‘1’ representing ‘Strongly Disagree’ and ‘5’ representing ‘Strongly Agree.’ Responses of ‘4’ or ‘5’ indicate the respondent agrees with the presented statement, a ‘3’ indicates the respondent was neutral about the statement, and responses of‘1’ or ‘2’ indicate the respondent disagrees with the statement. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 15 5a. The Business Center delivers reports in a timely manner . Figure 22 The Business Center delivers reports in a timely manner. Strongly Agree = 5 62 4 59 3 23 2 6 Strongly Disagree = 1 2 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Figure 22 depicts respondents' level of agreement with the statement that "The Business Center delivers reports in a timely manner." From 152 responses to this question, 121 (80 percent) agree (answers of 4 or 5) that the Business Center delivers reports in a timely manner. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 16 5b. The Business Center reports provide useful information needed to monitor financial status. Figure 23 Business Center reports provide useful information needed to monitor financial status. University Relations and Marketing Student Affairs (E&G Funded) Extension OSU Cascades Campus OSU Library International Programs Finance and Administration (E&G Funded) E Campus University Outreach and Engagement Office of the President Academic Affairs Enrollment Management Information Services Research Office, Centers, Institutes, and Programs 1.00 2.00 3.00 4.00 5.00 Figure 23 depicts the average level of agreement in each unit with the statement that "Business Center reports provide useful information needed to monitor financial status." For those units with statistically different results, both University Relations and Marketing, and Student Affairs have higher means than the Research Office. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 17 5c. The Business Center reports provide useful information needed to make decisions. Figure 24 Business Center reports provide useful information needed to make decisions. Strongly Agree = 5 62 4 48 3 22 2 21 Strongly Disagree = 1 6 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 Figure 24 illustrates that, out of 159 responses to this question, 110 (69 percent) agree (answers of 4 or 5) that Business Center reports provide useful information needed to make decisions. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 18 6. In which unit do you work? Figure 25 In which unit do you work? Audit Services University Relations and Marketing Other (please specify) Academic Affairs E Campus Enrollment Management Extension University Outreach and Engagement Finance and Administration (E&G Funded) Graduate School Student Affairs (E&G Funded) Research Office, Centers, Institutes, and Programs OSU Library OSU Cascades Campus Office of the Provost Information Services International Programs INTO Office of the President Figure 25 illustrates that 10 units responded to the survey in relatively large numbers (more than 20), probably due to the unit’s size. The largest three are University Outreach and Engagement (13 percent), Research Office, Centers, Institutes, and Programs (10 percent) and Information Services (8 percent). The remaining seven with high response rates include Academic Affairs, Enrollment Management, Finance and Administration (E&G Funded), the Graduate School, International Programs, the OSU Library, and Student Affairs (E&G Funded). Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 19 7. In what part of University Outreach and Engagement do you work? Figure 26 In what part of University Outreach and Engagement do you work? 3 6 5 Extension-on campus Extension-off campus 9 E-campus 57 Extension and Experiment Station Communications Other Figure 26 indicates that the largest number of respondents from University Outreach and Engagement is Extension-off campus. Of the 80 total respondents from University Outreach and Engagement unit, 57 respondents (71 percent) said they were from Extension-off campus. Only 3 respondents (almost 4 percent) came from Extension and Experiment Station Communication. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 20 8. What is your position? Figure 27 Figure 27 indicates that “Classified Staff” responded in the largest numbers, with 210 responses accounting for 40 percent of the total. The next largest group was 178 “Professional Faculty” at 34 percent. The 53 responses from “Director, Department Head/Senior Administrator” account for 10 percent. Twenty-three respondents (5 percent) identified themselves as “Instructor/Senior Instructor,” and 20 responded “Professor” (4 percent). The smallest representation came from the “Research Associate/Assistant” at 2 percent and “Graduate Assistants” at less than 1 percent. The 27 “Other” responses represent 5 percent of the total. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 21 9. How long have you worked for your unit? Figure 28 How long have you worked with or been involved with your unit? 85 144 Less than a year 1-3 years 145 4-9 years 10 or more years 143 Figure 28 indicates that only 16 percent of total respondents have worked in their unit for less than one year. The remaining respondents are evenly distributed in the categories of 1-3 years, 4-9 years and 10 or more years, each accounting for about 28 percent of the total. 10. Do you have some positive comments that you would like to pass on? In the open-ended comments, many respondents complimented BC staff members for their helpfulness and friendliness. Overall, respondents indicate that they are satisfied with the people they work with and the contacts they are assigned to in the BC. Some specific words that were used to describe BC staff and services are as follows: Knowledgeable Responsive Professional Friendly Timely Efficient Helpful Supportive Considerate Patient Prompt Positive Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 22 For a complete list of positive open-ended responses please refer to Appendix A, Tables 3-13. The responses are broken down by location. 11. Please tell us what you think can be done to improve the Business Center services The constructive open-ended feedback regarding the UABC indicates that there is a desire for better communication, faster access to cash, and more consistency in protocols and procedures within the BC and between the BC and each location. In addition, various respondents commented on their lack of knowledge of BC staff jobs and the array of services offered by the BC. Suggested improvements included: x x x x x x x x x x Respond to emails more quickly so they know the email was received (even if the BC can't help them right away) Streamline the process for hiring paper work Reduce staff turnover, hire more staff, and fill vacant positions quickly Increase transparency of processes, provide relevant information, and alert people when there is a change. Update the website and provide more detailed information. Make the BC website more friendly so people can find what they need easily Improve communication between departments and make the ownership of responsibility clear Improve instruction on who to contact and where to go Make policies and procedures among different Business Centers consistent Move the BC to a more accessible location Provide clear and timely budget report For a complete list of constructive open-ended responses, please refer to Appendix B, Tables 14-24. Close to the Customer Project C2C@bus.oregonstate.edu (541) 713-8041 Oregon State University UABC: Service Satisfaction Survey 23