A Comparison of Gaze-Based and Gesture-Based Input for a Point-and-Click Task

GRASP 2015
A Comparison of Gaze-Based and Gesture-Based Input for a
Point-and-Click Task
Dominic Canare
Faculty: Barbara Chaparro, Jibo He
Department of Psychology, Fairmount College of Liberal Arts and Sciences
Alternative input devices to the computer mouse are becoming more affordable and accessible.
With greater availability, they have the potential to provide greater access to information for
more users in more environments. However, most user interfaces are built to be mouse-driven,
and the adoption of these new technologies may depend on their ability to work with these
existing interfaces. This study examined performance with gesture-control and gaze-tracking
devices and compared them to a traditional mouse for a standard Fitts’ Law point-and-click task.
Participants were capable of using both gesture-controlled and gaze-tracking devices to control
an on-screen keyboard quickly and accurately enough to complete the majority of trials.
However, both devices were significantly slower than the mouse, and were more prone to missclicks and failures. Our subjective measures indicate that participants found these alternative
input devices to be more taxing than the familiar mouse.
In order to make effective use of these devices, researchers, designers, and developers must find
control schemes which take advantage of the alternative devices' benefits while curtailing the
drawbacks. While this study does show that these alternative input devices can be used to control
a computer’s cursor in a point-and-click environment, it is inefficient, error-prone, and difficult
for the user.
Related flashcards

31 Cards

Legal history

23 Cards

Create flashcards