2007 Accommodations Guidelines for • • • 2007 • Students with IEPs Students with 504 Plans English Language Learners All Students 2007 Accommodations Guidelines TABLE OF CONTENTS Introduction .......................................................................................................................................2 What are accommodations? ................................................................................................2 What is the purpose of this document?..............................................................................2 Who should use this document?.........................................................................................2 How is this document organized? .......................................................................................2 What about next year?..........................................................................................................3 Part One: Types of Allowable Accommodations ..........................................................................3 Category 1: CHANGES IN TEST ENVIRONMENT ...............................................................4 Category 2: ASSISTIVE DEVICES/SPECIAL ARRANGEMENTS........................................6 Category 3: ADAPTED TEST FORMS ................................................................................10 Category 4: OTHER ACCOMMODATIONS ........................................................................12 Accommodations Not Allowed ..........................................................................................14 Part Two: Selecting Appropriate Accommodations ...................................................................15 Chart for Selecting Accommodations by Disability.........................................................17 Guiding Questions ..............................................................................................................22 Part Three: Planning for Test Day ................................................................................................23 Part Four: Pennsylvania Alternate System of Assessment (PASA)..........................................25 What is the PASA? ..............................................................................................................25 Who can participate in the PASA? ....................................................................................25 How is the PASA administered?........................................................................................25 Part Five: APPENDICES ................................................................................................................27 APPENDIX I..........................................................................................................................27 Frequently Asked Questions..................................................................................27 APPENDIX II.........................................................................................................................30 Student Definitions .................................................................................................30 APPENDIX III........................................................................................................................32 Sample PSSA Page for Coding Student Data -- Grades 3 - 8 and 11..................32 APPENDIX IV .......................................................................................................................35 Confidentiality Agreement......................................................................................35 APPENDIX V ........................................................................................................................36 2007 PSSA Fact Sheet: Accommodations for All Students ................................36 APPENDIX VI .......................................................................................................................47 2007 PSSA Fact Sheet: Accommodations for English Language Learners ......47 APPENDIX VII ........................................................................................................................ 53 Contact Information ................................................................................................53 APPENDIX VIII .....................................................................................................................54 Bibliography for Assessment Accommodations Research ................................54 Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 1 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Introduction What are accommodations? Accommodations are practices and procedures in the areas of presentation, response, setting, and timing/scheduling that provide equitable access during instruction and assessments for students with disabilities. Accommodations are intended to reduce or even eliminate the effects of a student’s disability; they do not reduce learning expectations. The accommodations provided to a student must be the same for classroom instruction and classroom assessments. However, allowable accommodations on district and state assessments will usually be a subset of the large amount of accommodations available in the classroom, due to the purposes of these higher stakes assessments. It is critical to note that although some accommodations may be appropriate for instructional use, they may not be appropriate for use on a standardized assessment (CCSSO, 2005). What is the purpose of this document? The purpose of the 2007 PSSA Accommodations Guidelines is to assist teachers, supervisors, parents, and administrators in selecting appropriate PSSA test accommodations according to individual student need. The focus of this document is supporting school and district personnel as they make decisions on accommodations for students who are identified as English Language Learners (ELLs), students with a 504-service agreement, and students with an Individualized Educational Plan (IEP). In addition, this document includes a list of accommodations available for all other students in Appendix V. This list is also posted separately on the PDE website. Who should use this document? Those involved in making accommodation decisions and staff who may administer the PSSA to identified students should be familiar with the full contents of this document in order to plan for and provide appropriate, allowable test accommodations. All staff should be familiar with the accommodations available for all students. How is this document organized? This document is organized into the following sections: • Types of Allowable Accommodations: Lists the allowable accommodations and identifies which accommodations can meet specific student needs • Selecting Appropriate Accommodations: Describes how to select appropriate accommodations and provides a set of guiding questions for teachers, supervisors, parents, and administrators to consider as they identify accommodations for students • Planning for Test Day: Provides a checklist to help teachers and administrators prepare for test day • Pennsylvania Alternate System of Assessment (PASA): Provides an overview of the Pennsylvania Alternative System of Assessment (PASA) • Appendices: Includes a set of frequently asked questions, a set of definitions, sample coding pages, a Confidentiality Agreement, a list of accommodations for all students, a fact sheet including ELL accommodations, contact information, useful resources, and a list of people who provided insight into this document Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 2 2007 Accommodations Guidelines What about next year? This book will be updated annually as PDE evaluates the success of the accommodations described and as new accommodation practices emerge. The new accommodations or changes from the previous year will be printed in red. Part One: Types of Allowable Accommodations (IEP, 504, and ELL) In this section, detailed information on PSSA accommodations for English Language Learners, students who receive special education services, and students with 504-service agreements is listed. Included is specific information on accommodations that are allowed, as well as restrictions. The allowable accommodations are divided into four categories: 1. Changes in Test Environment 2. Assistive Devices/Special Arrangements 3. Adapted Test Forms 4. Other Accommodations Within each of the four categories, there is a chart that lists subcategories, with specific examples to assist decision makers. As you use this section, please keep in mind: • Accommodations listed on these charts include allowable accommodations for identified students. For a separate list of the accommodations allowable for all students, see Appendix V. • The 2007 PSSA Accommodations Guidelines includes a range of appropriate accommodations for students. The Department cannot list all possible accommodations because they are designed to meet individual student needs. If you have questions about a particular accommodation, please contact the Bureau of Assessment and Accountability at (717)787-4234 or (717)705-2343. • While accommodations are an attempt to “level the playing field,” they should not compromise the integrity of the assessment. This document describes some of the accommodations that are not allowed under any circumstances. The basic guide to use in making choices is that accommodations should allow students universal access to the assessment while yielding a valid measurement of their ability to meet standards. • While there may be the tendency to assume that all identified students require test adaptation, not every ELL, 504-service agreement, or special education student requires an accommodation. Decisions about whether any accommodation is needed, and which accommodations to use, should be made for each student individually. • Additional information is available about these accommodations and any new ELL accommodations in a stand-alone document called 2007 PSSA Fact Sheet: Accommodations for English Language Learners. This document is available in Appendix VI and separately on the PDE web site. • A Spanish/English Mathematics test for grades 3-8 and 11 is available for students who would benefit from this accommodation. This test must be ordered in advance. Additional information is available in the stand-alone document called 2007 PSSA Fact Sheet: Accommodations for English Language Learners. This document is available in Appendix VI and separately on the PDE web site. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 3 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Category 1: CHANGES IN TEST ENVIRONMENT Time Scheduled extended time The test administrator should extend the amount of time allotted for each section of the test, if needed, to allow students to finish the test without having to rush. The PSSA is not a timed test. Students must have sufficient time to complete a section prior to the end of the school day. The sections of the assessment must be administered in the sequence required in the administrator’s manual. On subsequent days, students are not permitted to revisit a section. Student-requested extended time Students can request extended time at any time during the assessment process as long as they are working productively. Multiple testing sessions If a school schedules more than one test section per day, multiple test sessions (days) may be scheduled for a student(s) that requires extended time. Students may not break and discuss the test items during the extended time. Scheduled breaks The test administrator may schedule opportunities for students to move around the room and/or take breaks. Students should be monitored during any break to ensure test security. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 4 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Category 1: CHANGES IN TEST ENVIRONMENT Place Classroom adaptations Preferential seating arrangements may help students concentrate or feel more comfortable. Adaptive/special furniture (e.g., study carrel, table space for large print assessment materials) may be helpful for students. Testing in a separate room To reduce distraction, a student may need to be tested in a room separate from the larger group. Hospital/home testing Arrangements should be made to allow for the testing of a student who is a patient in a hospital setting during the testing period. Arrangements should also be made to allow for the testing of a student who is confined to the home during the testing period. Grouping Small group testing Some students may require a testing environment with fewer students. Other students may require testing in a setting separate from all other students. Other Other accommodations, not listed here, may be available and appropriate for students, as long as the accommodations do not compromise the integrity of the assessment. Contact the Pennsylvania Department of Education’s Bureau of Assessment & Accountability at (717) 787-4234 or (717)705-2343, if you have any questions. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 5 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Category 2: ASSISTIVE DEVICES/SPECIAL ARRANGEMENTS Brailler/Notetaker Students who use a Brailler/Notetaker as part of their regular program can use it for the PSSA. Calculator Students may use an adaptive calculator for the Mathematics assessment where calculator use is permitted. Adaptive calculators with large keys and/or voice output are allowed. No calculators are permitted in the non-calculator section of the Mathematics test. Cranmer abacus Only students with blindness, low vision, or partial sight may use the Cranmer abacus on the non-calculator section of the Mathematics test. Magnification devices A magnification device may be used for students with visual impairments. Large print editions of the assessment booklet and answer sheet may also be used. Word Processor, or typewriters Word Processors or typewriters are an allowable accommodation for students with identified needs. School personnel must determine which students will need this accommodation and plan accordingly so that the equipment is available during the testing period. A test administrator must transcribe each student’s responses into his/her PSSA Answer Booklet. A test administrator must not alter student answers under any circumstances. Spell checker, grammar checker, word prediction functions, and other supports must be turned off. Students may use the typing function only. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 6 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Category 2: ASSISTIVE DEVICES/SPECIAL ARRANGEMENTS Word-to-word (translation) dictionary without definitions Word-to-word (translation) dictionaries are allowed for grades 3-8, and 11. (Native language to English or English to native language) Dictionaries that include word definitions or pictures are not allowed. Word-to-word dictionaries may be used on any section of the Mathematics test and the openended section of the Reading test for grades 3-8, and 11. Word-to-word dictionaries cannot be used on any section of the Writing test or for multiplechoice/passages on the Reading test. If using this accommodation, please code PSSA Answer Booklet “Translation dictionary for LEP student.” Qualified bilingual interpreter (English to native language) For more information see Appendix VI Interpreters may translate directions and clarify instructions for the Reading, Writing, and Mathematics assessments. Interpreters may translate, but not define, specific words and/or questions (multiple-choice and open-ended) on the Mathematics assessment. Interpreters may have access to the mathematics test one day prior to administration to aid them in preparation for translating the assessment. Interpreters may only access the assessment in a secure setting; the assessment may not leave the building (note-taking is strictly prohibited); interpreters must sign a Confidentiality Agreement (sample form in Appendix IV). They may not translate or define words or phrases in the multiple-choice items or stimulus passages on the Writing test. They may translate but not explain or define any part of the writing prompt. Interpreters may only translate the directions on the Reading test. They may not translate or define words or phrases in passages or questions (multiple-choice or open-ended). If using this accommodation, please code answer booklet “Qualified interpreter for LEP student.” Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 7 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Category 2: ASSISTIVE DEVICES/SPECIAL ARRANGEMENTS Qualified interpreter signs directions (Deaf/Hearing Impaired) Directions for all tests should be presented in the preferred language or spoken communication mode of the student with appropriate amplification or other visual or auditory support as needed. The assistance of a qualified interpreter may be used to interpret and clarify directions for the Reading, Writing, and Mathematics assessments. Directions for all assessments are provided to districts prior to the testing window. 1. Interpreters may not translate or define words or phrases in the multiple-choice items or stimulus passages on the Writing test. They may interpret but not explain or define any part of the writing prompt. 2. Interpreters may only translate the directions on the Reading test. They may not translate or define words or phrases in passages or questions (multiple-choice or open-ended). 3. Interpreters may translate, but not define, specific words and/or questions (multiple-choice and open-ended) on the Mathematics assessment. Interpreters may have access to the mathematics test one day prior to administration to aid them in preparation for translating the assessment. Interpreters may only access the assessment in a secure setting; the assessment may not leave the building (note-taking is strictly prohibited); interpreters must sign a Confidentiality Agreement (sample form in Appendix IV). Augmentative communication systems Letter boards, picture communication systems, voice output systems, and other augmentative communication systems may be used for all assessments. A test administrator must transcribe the student’s responses into his/her PSSA Answer Booklet. A test administrator must not alter student answers under any circumstances. Spelling/grammar checkers and word prediction functions must be turned off for the Writing PSSA. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 8 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Category 2: ASSISTIVE DEVICES/SPECIAL ARRANGEMENTS Audiotape or Compact Disk Students may respond on audiotape or CDs for Mathematics and Reading assessments and only the multiple-choice portion of the Writing test. School personnel must determine which students will need this accommodation and plan accordingly so that the audio equipment is available during the testing period. A test administrator must transcribe the student’s responses into his/her PSSA Answer Booklet. A test administrator must not alter student answers under any circumstances. All tapes and/or CDs must be returned with PSSA materials. Listening devices FM systems or other assistive listening devices may be used throughout the assessment for presentation in spoken English. Reference materials The only reference material allowed is a copy of the original formula sheet and scoring guidelines provided in the Mathematics, Reading, and Writing Handbooks posted on the PDE website at www.pde.state.pa.us and in the Handbook for Assessment Coordinators and Administrators. The only exception is for students who have a documented need for number lines specified in an IEP, 504 service plan, or ELL program. Paper, reading windows and highlighters Special paper such as graph paper, large lined paper, or widely spaced paper may be used. Highlighters, place markers, and reading windows are also allowable. Reading windows or frames are often used to help students read one sentence at a time. Typically, reading windows are a piece of paper with a “window” cut out to control what the student reads. In addition, students may use scratch paper, but any markings on the scratch paper will not be scored. Answers must be transcribed onto the PSSA Answer Booklet. The test administrator should collect all scratch paper at the end of a testing session. Refer to FAQ Page 29 for additional information regarding highlighters. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 9 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Category 3: ADAPTED TEST FORMS Braille edition A Braille edition of the assessment booklet may be used. Braille edition assessment forms for Grades 3-8 and 11 must be ordered from the Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network (PaTTAN), Harrisburg. Students who use the Braille form must have all answers transcribed by school personnel into scannable answer booklets exactly as the student has responded. Refer to Appendix VII for further details. Large print edition A large print edition of the assessment booklet may be used for students with visual impairment. Large print edition assessment forms for Grades 3-8 and 11 must be ordered from the Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network (PaTTAN), Harrisburg. Students who use the large print form must have all of their answers transcribed by school personnel into scannable answer booklets exactly as the student has responded. Refer to Appendix VII for further details. English/Spanish Mathematics test (Grades 3-8 and 11) All LEP students are required to participate in the Mathematics PSSA, with accommodations as appropriate. Students whose first language is Spanish and who have been enrolled in schools in the United States for fewer than three years may take the English/Spanish Mathematics test. The local educational agency should determine which students should use this accommodation. For additional information, see Appendix VI. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 10 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Category 3: ADAPTED TEST FORMS Signed version Directions for all tests should be presented in a way that meets students’ individual communication needs. The preferred language or spoken communication mode of the student with appropriate amplification or other visual or auditory support should be provided. Qualified interpreters may sign the directions for all assessments. They may sign questions on the Mathematics assessment. Interpreters may sign the writing prompt on the Writing test. They may not sign the multiplechoice questions or the stimulus passages on the Writing test. Interpreters may only sign the directions on the Reading test. They may not translate or define words or phrases in passages or questions (multiple-choice or open-ended). Directions for all assessments are provided to districts prior to the testing window. Interpreters may have access to the mathematics test one day prior to administration to aid them in preparation for translating the assessment. Interpreters may only access the assessment in a secure setting; the assessment may not leave the building (note-taking is strictly prohibited); interpreters must sign a Confidentiality Agreement (sample form in Appendix IV). Audiotape or Compact Disk General directions may be provided via an audiotape or CD. Verbatim sections of the mathematics assessment may also be provided. NO PART of the Reading assessment or the Writing multiple choice and passages section may be provided. School personnel must determine which students will need this accommodation and plan accordingly so that appropriate audio equipment is available during the testing period. A testing administrator must transcribe the student’s recorded responses into his/her PSSA Answer Booklet. A test administrator must not alter student answers under any circumstances. All tapes/CDs must be returned with the PSSA materials. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 11 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Category 4: OTHER ACCOMMODATIONS Student marks in answer booklet In grades 4-8 and 11 students may mark answers in the test booklet, including drawings and graphics. Highlighters may also be used. Responses must be transferred onto the PSSA Answer Booklet. In Grade 3 students respond directly in the PSSA Test Booklet. When using highlighters, students must be very careful to avoid making stray marks, marking the bubbles, marking in the open-ended response areas, and marking the black marks along the edges of the paper. If a highlighter mark strays over the answer bubble, the item cannot be scored correctly. Only pencil may be used to fill in bubbles. If a student marks the incorrect answer, there must be a complete removal of that marking or it will be scored as incorrect with two answers. Refer to FAQ Page 29 for additional information regarding highlighters. Dictation to a test administrator (Scribe) Students may answer questions orally if they are unable to use a pencil or have handwriting that is illegible. Students who require this accommodation may dictate to a scribe on Mathematics and Reading tests and on the multiple-choice portion of the Writing test. On the Writing prompts, dictation of student’s response is not allowed, but the administrator may transcribe handwriting that is extremely difficult to read. The test administrator must record the student’s responses in his/her PSSA Answer Booklet during the testing period. A test administrator must not alter student answers under any circumstances. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 12 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Category 4: OTHER ACCOMMODATIONS Reading aloud Directions for all assessments may be read aloud. The writing prompt is read aloud as part of the directions. The test administrator may not explain or define any part of the writing prompt. Writing multiple choice items and stimulus passages may not be read aloud. Test administrators are not allowed to read to the student any portion, multiple-choice or openended, of the Reading assessment except for the directions. Mathematics assessment questions may also be read aloud. A test administrator may not define a word. Marking an answer booklet at student direction A test administrator may mark an answer booklet at the direction of the student. For example, with multiple-choice questions only, the student may point to his/her response and the test administrator must record the student’s responses in his/her PSSA Answer Booklet. Providing visual cues A test administrator may use visual cues in the assessment directions, such as highlighters and colored stickers. Students may use visual cues throughout the assessments. Simplifying directions The test administrator may simplify the language of the directions, repeat directions as necessary, read directions in English or the native language, and have students explain directions aloud to confirm understanding. The test administrator may not explain or define any part of the writing prompts. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 13 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Accommodations NOT Allowed The following are examples of accommodations that are NOT allowable and are NOT appropriate for the PSSA: 1. Helping students answer items, such as: • Helping the student eliminate some multiple-choice items • Pointing to key phrases in test questions for students • Pointing to correct answers on the assessment • Giving correct answers after the student becomes frustrated • Having formulas or number lines on the wall or board (Only exception – if number lines are specifically documented in the IEP, ELL, or 504 Program) • Using a highlighter to prompt students on the assessment portion of the PSSA – in the questions, text or answers • Having a word wall, vocabulary words and definitions in the testing area 2. Providing time adaptations that compromise the testing setting, such as: • Giving students a lunch break in the middle of a test section • Giving students an unsupervised break in the middle of a section • Letting a student finish a section the next day 3. Allowing accommodations that are specifically prohibited, such as: • Using the IEP to violate the integrity of the PSSA by allowing a statement that permits calculators for entire assessments including the PSSA • Using the IEP to violate the integrity of the PSSA by allowing a statement that permits a student to have the Reading PSSA read, signed, and/or interpreted to them • Using the IEP to violate the integrity of the PSSA by allowing a statement that permits a student to have the multiple choice and stimulus passage portion of the Writing PSSA read, signed, and/or interpreted • Reading, signing, and/or interpreting any portion of the Reading PSSA, except the directions • Reading, signing, and/or interpreting the entire PSSA to an ELL in their native language • Allowing a service agreement or IEP to compromise the integrity of the PSSA • Giving a student a calculator for the entire Mathematics assessment • Using the IEP to violate the integrity of the PSSA by allowing a statement that permits dictionaries or spelling/grammar checkers to be used for the Mathematics, Reading, and/or Writing PSSA • Using a scribe or audio recorder for the prompt portion of Writing PSSA 4. Failing to maintain required test security, such as: • Sending the PSSA home with a parent for a hospitalized or homebound student • Sending the PSSA home with a parent for a student who receives instruction in the home • Discussing a particular question or prompt during or after the assessment Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 14 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Part Two: Selecting Appropriate Accommodations Accommodations must be tailored to the needs of individual students and should mirror strategies used in daily instruction to the extent those accommodations are allowable. It is not recommended to introduce new accommodations to students for the first time when they are taking the PSSA. Selecting Accommodations for Students with Disabilities For students with disabilities, IEP teams must determine the accommodations that the student will use for participation in the PSSA. That determination is based on the student’s IEP, supported by the Evaluation Report and/or progress-monitoring data, and should be recorded in the current IEP. Required accommodations written on the IEP within the “State Assessment” section must be implemented, as long as they are allowable. Once implemented, schools must mark those accommodations on the student’s PSSA Answer Booklet. For students with an IEP who are also ELL, an ELL teacher or a person with expertise in language acquisition should participate in the IEP team process to assist in the selection of appropriate accommodations. Selecting Accommodations for English Language Learners Appropriate school personnel – such as the ESL/bilingual teacher, bilingual coordinator, classroom teacher, the test administrator or coordinator, parent, principal, and/or counselor – should select accommodations for ELLs on an individual basis. This determination must be done at least annually so that information and adaptations are current, and should be done based on individual need rather than choosing categorically for groups of ELLs. All accommodations should be documented in each student’s file and recorded on the demographics pages of the PSSA (see Appendix III: Sample PSSA Page for Coding Student Data). English/Spanish Mathematics test for grades 3-8 and 11. For the 2007 assessment for grades 3-8 and 11, a student whose first language is Spanish who has been in the United States for fewer than three years may be given this accommodation. The local educational agency should determine which students should use this accommodation. More information on this accommodation is available in Appendix VI. Word-to-word (bilingual) dictionaries. Bilingual dictionaries must be word-to-word translations; dictionaries with definitions of words or pictures are not allowable. Electronic dictionaries that provide word-to-word translations may be used; but again, no devices that provide definitions or pictures can be used. Word-to-word dictionaries may be used on any portion of the Mathematics test and the open-ended section of the Reading test. Word-to-word dictionaries cannot be used on any portion of the Writing test or for multiple-choice/passages on the Reading test. Qualified interpreters. Districts may identify qualified interpreters and must document the process and/or criteria used to select interpreters. Interpreters may have access to the mathematics test one day prior to administration to aid them in preparation for translating the assessment. Interpreters may only access the Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 15 2007 Accommodations Guidelines assessment in a secure setting; the assessment may not leave the building (note-taking is strictly prohibited); interpreters must sign a Confidentiality Agreement (sample form in Appendix IV). Interpreters may work with one student or small groups of students depending on the test setting. Interpreters can translate the directions on the Writing, Mathematics, and Reading assessments. They may not define test questions or terms in Writing, Mathematics, and Reading assessments. Test content can be translated only for the Mathematics assessment. On the Reading assessment, only the directions can be translated. Interpreters may not interpret any of the Reading and Writing multiple-choice questions and/or the Reading and Writing passages. Interpreters should not answer clarifying questions that may be asked about test questions or the writing prompt. They may only clarify directions in the native language. In addition, a fact sheet has been prepared to describe the accommodations available for ELLs. This document is posted on the PDE website and in Appendix VI. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 16 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Chart for Selecting Accommodations by Disability or Needs Another way to help teachers, supervisors, parents, and administrators choose which accommodations to use is to organize the allowable accommodations by the needs or disabilities of the students. This chart provides examples of accommodations that might be most appropriate to a particular condition, learning need, or disability. This list was developed based on the accommodations described in the previous section but organized differently. See previous section for details on guidelines for using each listed accommodation. Student Characteristics Blindness Low vision Partial sight Allowable Accommodations for the PSSA • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Extended time Multiple testing sessions Scheduled breaks Classroom adaptations Testing in a separate room Small group testing Cranmer abacus (all sections) Magnification devices Word Processor, Brailler/Notetaker, or Typewriter Audiotape Braille edition of assessment Large print edition Dictation within guidelines Reading aloud: directions may be read aloud for all assessments The writing prompt may be read aloud (may not explain or define any part of the writing prompt) Questions may be read aloud for Mathematics only Marking an answer booklet at student direction Providing visual cues (i.e. highlighters) Using special paper or scratch paper Simplifying directions Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 17 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Student Characteristics Weak manual dexterity Difficulty or inability to write with a pencil or type on a standard keyboard Allowable Accommodations for the PSSA • • • • • • • • • • Reading disability Difficulty decoding printed text • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Extended time Multiple test sessions Classroom adaptations Word processor or typewriter (modified keyboard) Augmentative communication systems including a voice output system Audiotape or CD Dictation within guidelines Marking an answer booklet at student direction Using special paper Other (e.g., pencil grip) Scheduled extended time Student-requested extended time Multiple testing sessions Scheduled breaks Testing in a separate room Small group testing Word processor or typewriter Audiotape or CD Student marking in test booklet Dictation within guidelines Reading aloud: directions may be read aloud for all assessments The writing prompt may be read aloud (may not explain or define any part of the writing prompt) Questions may be read aloud for Mathematics only Marking an answer booklet at student direction Providing visual cues (i.e. highlighters, underlining) Using special paper or scratch paper Simplifying directions Other (e.g., use of reading window to limit amount of text presented at one time) Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 18 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Student Characteristics Deaf/Hard of Hearing Allowable Accommodations for the PSSA • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Writing disability • • • • • • • • • • • • Extended time Multiple testing sessions Scheduled breaks Classroom adaptations Testing in a separate room Small group testing Word processor or typewriter Listening devices Qualified interpreter signs directions Signed version Student marking in test booklet Dictation within guidelines Reading aloud: directions may be read aloud for all assessments The writing prompt may be read aloud (may not explain or define any part of the writing prompt) Questions may be read aloud for Mathematics only Marking an answer booklet at student direction Providing visual cues Using special paper Simplifying directions Extended time Multiple testing sessions Scheduled breaks Classroom adaptations Testing in a separate room Small group testing Word processor, Brailler/Notetaker or typewriter Audiotape or CD Student marking in test booklet Dictation within guidelines Marking an answer booklet at student direction Using special or scratch paper (e.g., student may draft response prior to writing final answer in answer booklet) Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 19 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Student Characteristics Allowable Accommodations for the PSSA Math disability • • • • • • • • • • Extended time Multiple testing sessions Scheduled breaks Classroom adaptations Testing in a separate room Small group testing Student marking in test booklet Providing visual cues Using special paper Simplifying directions Physical disability • • • • • • Extended time Multiple testing sessions Scheduled breaks Classroom adaptations Hospital/home testing Word processor, Brailler/Notetaker or typewriter Audiotape or CD Dictation within guidelines Marking an answer booklet at student direction Providing visual cues Using special or scratch paper • • • • • Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 20 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Student Characteristics Easily distracted Short attention span Allowable Accommodations for the PSSA • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Communication disorder • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Extended time Multiple testing sessions Scheduled breaks Classroom adaptations Testing in a separate room Small group testing Audiotape or CD Student marking in test booklet Dictation within guidelines Reading aloud: directions may be read aloud for all assessments The writing prompt may be read aloud (may not explain or define any part of the writing prompt) Questions may be read aloud for Mathematics only Marking an answer booklet at student direction Providing visual cues Using special or scratch paper Simplifying directions Extended time Multiple testing sessions Testing in a separate room Small group testing Word processor, Brailler/Notetaker or typewriter Qualified interpreter Augmentative communication systems Audiotape or CD Listening devices Signed version of assessment Reading aloud: directions may be read aloud for all assessments The writing prompt may be read aloud (may not explain or define any part of the writing prompt) Questions may be read aloud for Mathematics only Simplifying directions Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 21 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Guiding Questions Have we, as school personnel, reviewed the accommodations document so that we have accurate information on what is allowed and what is not allowed? Have we requested and obtained further information if we have questions that are not answered by state documents and information sessions? Which students in my school or classrooms receive accommodations in daily classroom instruction? What assessment accommodations are routinely used in the classroom setting that may be utilized for the administration of the PSSA? What accommodations are necessary in order to obtain a valid measure of proficiency for each individual student? Have we reviewed individual student files and academic performance to determine the accommodations that should be delivered? Who are the other school personnel that may be able to identify the appropriate accommodations that the student(s) should receive? Have we made accommodations decisions as a group with appropriate members in attendance? Have we recorded selected accommodations in the proper way, such as in the IEP or the 504 plan? Are there any accommodations that students normally receive that are not allowed on the PSSA? If so, how can we best prepare students to participate in the assessment without those supports? If students require changes in the test environment, such as small groups or individualized testing, have we made arrangements for additional personnel and made facility arrangements? Have we made arrangements for obtaining equipment required for accommodations, such as computers, adaptive calculators, and word-to-word dictionaries without definitions? Is the equipment in good working order? Is the equipment familiar to the students? Have all test administrators, such as qualified interpreters, received proper training in test administration so they can administer a valid test and provide specified accommodations within required limits? Have arrangements been made to minimize negative impact on the general testing environment, such as using headphones for audiotape? Do students and their parents understand what individual accommodation decisions have been made, what adaptations will be allowed, and what accommodations may not be allowed because of test restrictions? In addition to designing accommodations for special education students, English Language Learners, and students with 504 plans, have we fully utilized allowable accommodations that are available for all students in order to optimize test conditions for every individual? Have we done everything possible to create conditions for obtaining a valid measure of academic proficiency for every student? Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 22 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Part Three: Planning for Test Day Provided below is a sample checklist that gives examples of suggested activities for school personnel to complete to assist in providing accommodations for the PSSA. Planning Checklist Throughout the school year Appropriate group determines accommodations for identified students with choices based on individual student needs. Document accommodations on the student’s IEP, 504 plan, ELL paperwork, or student folder. Students use documented accommodations regularly. In preparation for test day Order special test editions for individual students based on information contained in their education plan (large print, Braille, etc.). Distribute to test administrators the list of accommodations for students that he/she supervises during the administration of the PSSA. Arrange adult supervision (with substitutes available). Train test administrators for each student receiving accommodations in small group or individual settings (if test administrator is not the student’s regular teacher). Arrange for trained readers, scribes, and qualified interpreters for individual students (with substitutes available). Arrange for special equipment and check for correct operation (tape recorder, CD player, calculator, computer, word processor, Brailler/Notetaker with spell/grammar checker turned off). Examine schedule to secure appropriate testing location. Secure test settings similar to the regular educational environment for the student. Inform staff, students, and parents of testing schedule. Replace defective equipment. Provide “Testing: Do Not Disturb” signs. On test day All designated students receive appropriate accommodations. Record provided accommodations carefully and accurately. Secure substitutes as needed. After test day Complete student accommodation information on answer sheets (e.g. use of audiotape, dictation to a proctor, use of computer, etc.). Return ALL student booklets (including Braille and Large-Print versions). Return ALL tapes and/or CD recordings. Collect and destroy all scratch paper. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 23 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Collect and destroy all original transcribed student work. Permanently delete and remove files of all electronically produced student work, e.g. student used computer for open-ended response. Return all equipment to appropriate locations. Schedule make-up tests promptly. Students who take “make-up” tests receive appropriate accommodations. Evaluate effectiveness of utilized accommodations. Record accommodations provided on required PSSA documents. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 24 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Part Four: Pennsylvania Alternate System of Assessment (PASA) What is the PASA? The Pennsylvania Alternate System of Assessment (PASA) measures the attainment of knowledge and skills of students with significant cognitive disabilities through a series of approximately 40 discrete items. Like the PSSA, the purpose of the PASA is to provide information to schools that will aid them in improving instruction. The PASA was developed in response to the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA ‘97). States are required by IDEA ‘97 to develop alternate assessment systems for students who cannot participate in the regular state assessments. Who can participate in the PASA? To participate in the PASA, students must meet specific criteria established by the Department of Education, Bureau of Special Education. The PASA is appropriate for a small number of students with severe cognitive disabilities. All other students must participate in the PSSA, with or without accommodations. Participation decisions may not be based upon the student’s disability or class placement. Rather, using the six criteria listed below, each IEP team will determine if the PASA is an appropriate choice for the student. In order to take the alternate assessment, the student must meet all six criteria. If the answer to any of the criteria is “no”, the PASA may not be administered to the student, and the student will participate in the PSSA with or without accommodations. To participate in PASA, students must… Be in grade 3 through 8 or 11 by September 1 of the school year in which assessment is to be accomplished; and Have significant cognitive disabilities; and Require intensive instruction to learn; and Require extensive adaptation and support to perform and meaningfully participate in the activities; and Require substantial modifications of general education curriculum; and Participate in general education curriculum in a substantially different way than most other students. How is the PASA administered? The PASA uses reinterpreted statewide standards as a basis for tasks that students are given to perform. In order for all students with significant disabilities to participate, these tasks are designed with varying levels of difficulty to assess skills that are useful in their daily lives. Teachers either scribe or videotape the student’s participation in the assessment. What is an alternate writing assessment? A student who is enrolled to be administered the PASA does not take the PSSA Writing Test. Rather, to assess such a student in written or expressive communication, the teacher should administer an “assessment”, probe, or ongoing monitoring instrument that is relevant to goals and objectives that are contained in the Individualized Education Program (IEP). The Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 25 2007 Accommodations Guidelines assessment used for one student may not necessarily be the same assessment used for another student. Such written or expressive communication assessments are not collected at the state level, but should be maintained as part of the child’s educational record. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 26 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Part Five: APPENDICES APPENDIX I Frequently Asked Questions Who is required to participate in the PSSA? All students are required to participate in the state assessment, with most taking the PSSA and a small percentage taking PASA as described previously on Page 25. Students in grades 3-8 and 11 take the Mathematics and Reading sections of the PSSA. Students in grades 5, 8, and 11 participate in the Writing assessment. Nonpublic, private, and parochial schools may participate on a voluntary basis, as well as students who are home-schooled. A student may be excused from the assessment if a parent believes the test conflicts with religious beliefs. Foreign exchange students are required to participate in the state assessment. When is the test given and how long does it take? The testing window in 2007 is from February 12–23 for Writing and from March 12–23 for Mathematics and Reading. Districts/schools control their own schedules within that window. The Writing assessment takes approximately 3 hours. The Mathematics and Reading portions of the assessment take a total of 5 to 6 hours and are administered over 6 sessions. Can a parent or guardian review the assessment? Pennsylvania regulations (Chapter 4) allow parents and guardians to review the PSSA two weeks prior to the test dates. For details and requirements regarding the review of the assessment, contact your local school. What does the test include? The test is based on the Pennsylvania Assessment Anchors for Mathematics and Reading and the Pennsylvania Academic Standards for Writing. The Mathematics, Reading, and Writing assessments consist of open-ended and multiple-choice questions. Is the PSSA a graduation requirement? Pennsylvania regulations (Chapter 4) state that students must meet three (3) requirements to be able to graduate. Those requirements are: 1. completion of courses and grades, 2. completion of a culminating project, and 3. proficiency in Reading, Writing, and Mathematics. Each individual school district chooses how they will determine a student’s “proficiency in Reading, Writing and Mathematics”. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 27 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Frequently Asked Questions Must all English Language Learners (ELLs) participate in the PSSA? In 2004, the USDE released guidance on participation of LEP students in state assessments. This flexibility allows LEP students in their first year of enrollment in U.S. schools an option of taking the Reading PSSA. A student’s enrollment in a school in Puerto Rico is not to be considered as enrollment in a U.S. school. If students choose to participate in the Reading assessment, their performance level results will not be included in the AYP calculations for the school/district. All LEP students are still required to take the Stanford English language proficiency (SELP) assessment. All LEP students are still required to participate in the Mathematics PSSA, with accommodations as appropriate. The mathematics scores of LEP students in their first year of enrollment in U.S. schools, not including Puerto Rico, will not be used to determine the percent proficient or higher for AYP status. LEP students in their first year of enrollment in U.S. schools are not required to take the Writing PSSA. The new guidance also provides flexibility in determining who can be included in the LEP subgroup. Since LEP students exit the LEP subgroup once they attain English language proficiency, schools/districts may have difficulty demonstrating improvements on state assessments for these students. The USDE is now allowing schools/districts/states to include in the LEP subgroup those students who have exited an ESL/bilingual education program within the past two years. When completing the demographic pages, school personnel should code the “Yes” oval for “Student exited an ESL/bilingual education program within the past two years” if the student has exited an ESL/bilingual education program within the past two years as determined by the local district’s ESL Program Plan. The two-year monitoring period begins from the date the student exits the ESL program as defined by the district's multiple exit criteria in its ESL Program Plan. Districts have the option to include or not include the exited students. The PSSA data will be analyzed with and without exited students and the higher percentage will be used for AYP purposes. Do students receiving hospital or homebound instruction need to participate in statewide assessments? Yes. All eligible students must participate in the state assessment according to No Child Left Behind. Schools must make the necessary arrangements so that the student can meaningfully participate in the assessment. Why can’t the PSSA Reading assessment be read to students? Allowing anyone to read any portion of the Reading test for ELLs and/or other students with IEPs or 504s is controversial among technical testing experts. The purpose of the Reading assessment is to determine if the student can comprehend what has been read. Reading any portion of the assessment to the student would alter what is being assessed and could Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 28 2007 Accommodations Guidelines potentially compromise the integrity of the test. Based on the recommendations of the Technical Advisory Committee, PDE has developed this policy that is consistent for all students in all accommodations situations. As with all accommodations, PDE plans to review them annually and make adjustments based on current or new research. Why can’t the PSSA Writing multiple choice and stimulus passages be read to students? As with the Reading test, allowing anyone to read any portion of the multiple choice items for editing and revising or the stimulus passage, might alter what is being assessed and could potentially compromise the integrity of the Writing test. Based on review and consultation with experts in the field, PDE has developed this policy that is consistent for all students in all accommodations situations. As with all accommodations, PDE plan to review this policy annually and make adjustments as needed. Why can’t dictionaries be used for the Writing, Mathematics, and Reading assessments? For the Mathematics assessment, the student may find answers and additional formulas in the dictionary that may not be provided on the assessment. For Reading and Writing assessments, the dictionary may provide the student with an unfair advantage in spelling, grammar, and understanding and defining words. Are there special concerns with students using highlighters? Students may use highlighter pens during the test sessions to highlight text in the Reading and Writing multiple choice passages or text in the Mathematics items. However, students must mark their responses to questions using a No. 2 pencil. Only highlighter pens may be used; other types of felt-tip marking pens may not be used. Please use the following recommendations if highlighters are used during test administration. Students should be instructed never to use a highlighter in the same place that they used a pencil. Accordingly, do not allow students to highlight pencil marks of any kind, including filled-in bubbles or students’ handwriting. The highlighters may cause pencil marks to blur or bleed. Do not allow students to highlight barcodes, preslugged bubbles, or any other marks or printing around the edges of the scannable document. The highlighters may cause the ink used for these purposes to blur and bleed. Use a highlighter from the following list. These highlighters were found to cause a minimum of problems in scanning: o Avery Hi-Liter o Avery Hi-Liter, thin-tipped o Bic Brite-Liner o Sanford Major Accent o Sanford Pocket Accent, thin tipped Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 29 2007 Accommodations Guidelines APPENDIX II Student Definitions School personnel are required to complete the all students section of the PSSA Answer Booklet. Following are student definitions to help districts/charter schools accurately report the students participating in the statewide assessment: Student with a disability served under IDEA A student with mental retardation, a hearing impairment including deafness, a speech or language impairment, a visual impairment including blindness, serious emotional disturbance, an orthopedic impairment, autism, traumatic brain injury, other health impairment, a specific learning disability, deaf-blindness, or multiple disabilities, and who, by reason thereof, needs special education and/or related services. Student is Gifted A student who is exceptional because the student meets the state definition of 'mentally gifted' and needs specially designed instruction beyond that required in Chapter 4. Student has a 504 Plan under Chapter 15 A student with a 504 plan who has a physical or mental disability, which substantially limits or prohibits participation in or access to an aspect of the student’s school program, and is not eligible for special education services. Student participates in Title I Program A student who meets the federal definition for participation in a Title I program. Student is a Migratory Child Migratory children are the children of migratory workers who have moved in the preceding 36 months across a school district line either to join a migrant parent or on their own, in order to obtain temporary or seasonal employment in agriculture (including dairy workers). Student is Limited English Proficient or English Language Learner A limited English proficient student (LEP) or English Language Learner (ELL) is one who: 1. was not born in the United States or whose native language is other than English and comes from an environment where a language other than English is dominant, or 2. is a Native American or Alaska Native who is a native resident of the outlying areas and comes from an environment where a language other than English has had a significant impact on (the student’s) level of English language proficiency, or 3. is migratory and whose native language is other than English and comes from an environment where a language other than English is dominant, and 1. has sufficient difficulty speaking, reading, writing or understanding the English language, and 2. has difficulties that may deny (the student) the opportunity to learn successfully in classrooms where the language of instruction is English or to participate fully in our society. Student is a Foreign Exchange Student Foreign exchange students are not required to be identified for English as a Second Language instruction based on Pennsylvania’s home language survey. Foreign exchange students are required to participate in the PSSA tests. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 30 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Student is Economically Disadvantaged Students who are economically disadvantaged are eligible for the Free and Reduced Lunch Program. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 31 2007 Accommodations Guidelines APPENDIX III Sample PSSA Page for Coding Student Data – Grades 3-8 and 11 Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 32 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 33 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 34 2007 Accommodations Guidelines APPENDIX IV Confidentiality Agreement Test security and student confidentiality are of the utmost importance to the Pennsylvania Department of Education, and it is the Department’s obligation to protect information about tests and students in the assessment process. Such information includes performance tasks, multiple-choice items, scoring rubrics, and student responses used in the Pennsylvania System of School Assessment. The nature and quality of an individual student’s performance must not be released. These assessments rely on the measurement of individual achievement. Any deviation from the assessment procedures outlined in this manual (group work, teacher coaching, pre-teaching or pre-release of the performance tasks or assessment items, use of old Pennsylvania assessments as preparation tools, etc.) is strictly prohibited and will be considered a violation of test security. Any action by a professional employee or commissioned officer that is willfully designed to divulge test questions, falsify student scores or compromise the integrity of the state assessment system will be subject to disciplinary action under sections 1259-1267 of the School Code (24 P.S. Sections 12-1259-12-1267). We are certain that you share our concern that all items and students’ responses be handled in a professional and confidential manner. By signing this agreement, you acknowledge that you have read and understand this Confidentiality Agreement and agree to abide by these requirements. Legal First Name (print) MI Legal Last Name (print) Title/Address/Telephone Signature Date Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 35 2007 Accommodations Guidelines APPENDIX V 2007 PSSA Fact Sheet: Accommodations for All Students The purpose of the PSSA is to obtain an accurate portrait of student, school, district, and state proficiency on the Pennsylvania Academic State Standards. In this fact sheet, detailed information on available PSSA accommodations for all students is given. The 2007 Accommodations Guidelines for Students with IEPs, Students with 504-service agreements, English Language Learners, gives more details on accommodations for identified students. Why use accommodations? Students vary widely as individuals in general and as learners in particular, and optimal test conditions vary accordingly. The basic guide to use in making choices is that accommodations should allow students access to the assessment while yielding valid measurement of their ability to meet standards. Accommodations should not compromise the integrity of the assessment, but should ensure the best possible measure of every student’s proficiency on standards. Accommodations used on the PSSA should mirror the ongoing adjustments used to optimize learning conditions for students according to their individual needs. In addition, it is helpful to give students experience with these accommodations in context of PSSA-like conditions prior to administering the actual assessment. This fact sheet describes allowable accommodations that can be used for all students. The allowable accommodations are divided into four categories: 1) Changes in Test Environment; 2) Assistive Devices/Special Arrangements; 3) Adapted Test Forms; and 4) Other Accommodations. Within each of the four categories, there is a chart that lists subcategories, with specific examples that assist decision-makers. Finally, there are examples of accommodations that are not allowed under any circumstances. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 36 2007 Accommodations Guidelines ACCOMMODATIONS FOR ALLSTUDENTS Category 1: CHANGES IN TEST ENVIRONMENT Time Scheduled extended time The test administrator should extend the amount of time allotted for each section of the test, if needed, to allow students to finish the test without having to rush. The PSSA is not a timed test. Students must have sufficient time to complete a section prior to the end of the school day. The sections of the assessment must be administered in the sequence required in the administrator’s manual. On subsequent days, students are not permitted to revisit a section. Student-requested extended time Students can request extended time at any time during the assessment process as long as they are working productively. Multiple testing sessions If a school schedules more than one test section per day, multiple test sessions (days) may be scheduled for a student(s) that requires extended time. Students may not break and discuss the test items during the extended time. Scheduled breaks The test administrator may schedule opportunities for students to move around the room and/or take breaks. Students should be monitored during any break to ensure test security. Place Classroom adaptations Preferential seating arrangements may help students concentrate or feel more comfortable. Adaptive/special furniture (e.g., study carrel, table space for large print assessment materials) may be helpful for students. Testing in a separate room To reduce distraction, a student may need to be tested in a room separate from the larger group. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 37 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Hospital/home testing Arrangements should be made to allow for the testing of a student who is a patient in a hospital setting during the testing period. Arrangements should also be made to allow for the testing of a student who is confined to the home during the testing period. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 38 2007 Accommodations Guidelines ACCOMMODATIONS FOR ALLSTUDENTS Category 1: CHANGES IN TEST ENVIRONMENT Grouping Small group testing Some students may require a testing environment with fewer students. Other students may require testing in a setting separate from all other students. Other Other accommodations, not listed here, may be available and appropriate for the student, as long as the accommodations do not compromise the integrity of the assessment. Contact the Pennsylvania Department of Education’s Bureau of Assessment & Accountability if you have any questions at (717) 787-4234 or (717)705-2343. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 39 2007 Accommodations Guidelines ACCOMMODATIONS FOR ALLSTUDENTS Category 2: ASSISTIVE DEVICES/SPECIAL ARRANGEMENTS Word processor or typewriter You might have a few students who normally use a word processor or typewriter as part of their regular classroom accommodations. For example, you may have students whose handwriting is so illegible that it cannot be scored. For those students, use of a word processor or typewriter is an appropriate and acceptable accommodation for the PSSA. Schools must determine which students will need this accommodation and plan accordingly so that the equipment is available during the testing period. Spell checker, grammar checker, word prediction, and other supports must be turned off. Students may use the typing function only. A test administrator must transcribe the student’s responses into his/her PSSA Answer Booklet. A test administrator must not alter student answers under any circumstances. Refer to Page 24 for handling of original student work. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 40 2007 Accommodations Guidelines ACCOMMODATIONS FOR ALLSTUDENTS Category 2: ASSISTIVE DEVICES/SPECIAL ARRANGEMENTS Reference materials The only reference material allowed is a copy of the original formula sheet and scoring guidelines provided in the Mathematics, Reading, and Writing Handbooks posted on the PDE website at www.pde.state.pa.us and in the Handbook for Assessment Coordinators and Administrators. The only exception is for students who have a documented need for number lines specified in an IEP, 504 Service plan, or ELL program. Paper, reading windows and highlighters Special paper such as graph paper, large lined, or widely spaced paper may be used. Highlighters, place markers, graph paper, and reading windows are also allowable. Reading windows, also called “window frames” (paper guide with a hole cut out), are used to help students focus. In addition, students may use scratch paper, but any markings on the scratch paper will not be scored. Answers must be transcribed onto the PSSA Answer Booklet. Refer to Page 24 for information regarding handling of original student work. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 41 2007 Accommodations Guidelines ACCOMMODATIONS FOR ALLSTUDENTS Category 3: ADAPTED TEST FORMS Audiotape or Compact Disk In some special cases, directions may be provided via an audiotape or CD. For example, students might need to have directions read to them and the school might be limited in the number of people to provide this accommodation, or reading directions aloud might be disruptive to some students. Verbatim sections of the mathematics assessment may also be provided. NO PART of the Reading assessment or the Writing multiple-choice and passages section may be provided. School personnel must determine which students will need this accommodation and plan accordingly so that appropriate audio equipment is available during the testing period. All tapes/CDs must be returned with the PSSA materials. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 42 2007 Accommodations Guidelines ACCOMMODATIONS FOR ALLSTUDENTS Category 4: OTHER ACCOMMODATIONS Student marks in test booklet In grades 4-8 and 11 students may mark answers in the test booklet, including drawings and graphics. Highlighters may also be used. Responses must be transferred onto the PSSA Answer Booklet. In grade 3 students respond directly in the PSSA Test Booklet. They may use highlighters, but must be very careful to avoid stray marks. Students should avoid marking the bubbles, avoid marking in the open-ended response areas, and avoid marking the black marks along the edges of the paper. If a highlighter mark strays over the answer bubble, the item cannot be scored correctly. Only pencil may be used to fill in bubbles. If a student marks the incorrect answer, there must be a complete removal of that marking or it will be scored as incorrect with two answers. Refer to FAQ Page 29 of the Guidelines for additional information regarding highlighters. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 43 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Dictation to a test administrator (Scribe) You may have a few students who normally dictate their answers to a scribe as part of their regular classroom accommodations. For example, you may have students whose handwriting is so illegible it cannot be scored or who have a broken arm. For those students, use of a scribe is an appropriate and acceptable accommodation for the Mathematics and Reading PSSA. School personnel must determine which students need this accommodation and plan accordingly so that the equipment is available during the testing period. On the Writing prompt, dictation is not allowed, but the administrator may transcribe illegible handwriting or a student-typed response. A test administrator must transcribe the student's responses into his/her PSSA Answer Booklet. They must not alter student answers under any circumstances. Refer to Page 24 for information regarding handling of original student work. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 44 2007 Accommodations Guidelines ACCOMMODATIONS FOR ALLSTUDENTS Category 4: OTHER ACCOMMODATIONS Reading aloud Directions for all assessments may be read aloud. Multiple-choice and stimulus passages on the Writing test may not be read to students. The writing prompt is read aloud as part of the directions. The test administrator may not explain or define any part of the writing prompt. Test administrators are not allowed to read any portion, multiple-choice and open-ended, of the Reading assessment except for the directions. Questions may be read aloud for Mathematics only for the small number of individual students who might need this accommodation. A test administrator may not define a word. Marking an answer booklet at student direction Test administrator may mark a PSSA Answer booklet at the direction of the student for multiple-choice questions only. For example, with multiple-choice questions only, the student may point to his/her response and the test administrator must record the student's responses in his/her PSSA Answer Booklet. Providing visual cues A test administrator may use visual cues in the assessment directions, such as highlighters and colored stickers. Students may use visual cues throughout the assessment. Simplifying directions The test administrator may simplify the language of the directions, repeat directions as necessary, read directions in English or the native language, and have students explain directions aloud to confirm understanding. The test administrator may not explain or define any part of the writing prompts. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 45 2007 Accommodations Guidelines ACCOMMODATIONS FOR ALLSTUDENTS Accommodations NOT Allowed The following are examples of accommodations that are NOT allowable and are NOT appropriate for the PSSA: 1. Helping students answer items, such as: • Helping the student eliminate some multiple-choice items • Pointing to key phrases in test questions for students • Pointing to correct answers on the assessment • Giving correct answers after the student becomes frustrated • Having formulas or number lines on the wall or board • Using a highlighter to prompt students on the assessment portion of the PSSA–in the questions, text or answers • Having a word wall, vocabulary words and definitions in the testing area • Using or displaying teacher-developed rubrics 2. Providing time adaptations that compromise the testing setting, such as: • Giving students a lunch break in the middle of a test section • Giving students an unsupervised break in the middle of a section • Letting a student finish a section the next day 3. Allowing accommodations that are specifically prohibited, such as: • Reading any portion of the Reading PSSA, except the directions • Reading the entire PSSA to ELLs in their native language • Giving a student a calculator for the entire Mathematics assessment • Using a scribe or audio recorder for the prompt portions of the Writing PSSA • Reading the multiple-choice and passage portion of the Writing PSSA • Explaining or defining any part of the writing prompt • Giving students reference materials for the Mathematics, Reading or Writing PSSA. This includes, but is not limited to dictionaries (print, electronic, Palm Pilot), thesauri, and spelling or grammar checkers. 4. Failing to maintain required test security, such as: • Sending the PSSA home with a parent for a hospitalized or homebound student • Sending the PSSA home with a parent for a student who receives instruction in the home • Discussing a particular question or prompt during or after the assessment Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 46 2007 Accommodations Guidelines APPENDIX VI 2007 PSSA Fact Sheet: Accommodations for English Language Learners This fact sheet answers some of the commonly asked questions about accommodations for English Language Learners (ELLs) or Limited English Proficient (LEP) students. This fact sheet should be used in conjunction with the 2007 Accommodations Guidelines posted on the PDE website. Who are English Language Learners (ELLs)? A limited English proficient student (LEP) or English Language Learner (ELL) is one who: 1. was not born in the United States or whose native language is other than English and comes from an environment where a language other than English is dominant, or 2. is a Native American or Alaska Native who is a native resident of the outlying areas and comes from an environment where a language other than English has had a significant impact on (the student’s) level of English language proficiency, or 3. is migratory and whose native language is other than English and comes from an environment where a language other than English is dominant, and 1. has sufficient difficulty speaking, reading, writing or understanding the English language, and 2. has difficulties that may deny (the student) the opportunity to learn successfully in classrooms where the language of instruction is English or to participate fully in our society. Who should administer the PSSA to ELLs? District and school personnel should decide the best way to administer the PSSA to ELLs. The most important things are to try to reduce as much anxiety as possible for students and to help them feel comfortable on the day of the test. Having a teacher familiar to the students administer the test often reduces test anxiety and is an allowable accommodation for ELLs. Who determines which accommodations to use? Each school must involve the appropriate school personnel in the determination of appropriate accommodations for ELLs. The ESL/bilingual teacher, the ESL/bilingual education coordinator, other classroom teachers, the test administrator or coordinator, a parent, the principal or counselor and the student (when appropriate) may be involved in this determination. Identifying the appropriate accommodations should be a collaborative process and should include content area teachers consulting with ESL/bilingual teachers. This determination must be done at least annually on an individual basis and must not be done for groups of ELLs. Are ELLs required to take the PSSA? In 2004, the USDE released guidance on participation of LEP students in state assessments. This flexibility allows LEP students in their first year of enrollment in U.S. schools an option of taking the Reading PSSA. A student’s enrollment in a school in Puerto Rico is not to be considered as enrollment in a U.S. school. If students choose to participate in the Reading assessment, their performance level results will not be included in the AYP calculations for the school/district. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 47 2007 Accommodations Guidelines All LEP students are still required to take the Stanford English language proficiency (SELP) assessment. All LEP students are still required to participate in the Mathematics PSSA, with accommodations as appropriate. The Mathematics scores of LEP students in their first year of enrollment in U.S. schools, not including Puerto Rico, will not be used to determine the percent proficient or higher for AYP status. LEP students in their first year of enrollment in U.S. schools are not required to take the Writing PSSA. The new guidance also provides flexibility in determining who can be included in the LEP subgroup. Since LEP students exit the LEP subgroup once they attain English language proficiency, schools/districts may have difficulty demonstrating improvements on state assessments for these students. The USDE is now allowing schools/districts/states to include in the LEP subgroup those students who have exited an ESL/bilingual education program within the past two years. When completing the demographic pages, school personnel should code the “Yes” oval for “Student exited an ESL/bilingual education program within the past two years” if the student has exited an ESL/bilingual education program within the past two years as determined by the local district’s ESL Program Plan. The two-year monitoring period begins from the date the student exits the ESL program as defined by the district's multiple exit criteria in its ESL Program Plan. Districts have the option to include or not include the exited students. The PSSA data will be analyzed with and without exited students and the higher percentage will be used for AYP purposes. School personnel should consider the following in determining the appropriate accommodations: The student’s familiarity with the accommodations to be used. Current accommodations used in day-to-day instruction and assessment are appropriate. New accommodations unfamiliar to students should not be introduced to students for the first time when they are taking the PSSA. An annual review of the student’s progress in English language proficiency and academic achievement. Knowing this information will help teachers, supervisors, parents, and administrators determine which accommodations are still appropriate given the student’s current knowledge. All accommodations should be documented in the student’s file and recorded on the demographics pages of the PSSA (for sample see Appendix III of the 2007 PSSA Accommodations Guidelines). If a student has already exited an ESL or Bilingual Program, can they still receive these accommodations? Once a student has exited an ESL or Bilingual Program, that student receives the same accommodations available to non-ELL students. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 48 2007 Accommodations Guidelines What accommodations are allowable for ELLs? The accommodations most appropriate for ELLs are described in the 2007 PSSA Accommodations Guidelines. Three separate accommodations are allowed: 1. Word-to word (without definitions) translation dictionaries (not for the multiplechoice/passages on the Reading test or on any part of the Writing test) 2. Qualified interpreters 3. Spanish/English Mathematics test All of these accommodations are voluntary and not mandatory. Test administrators/teachers should only use these accommodations if they are typically used with students during the school year. Accommodations that have not previously been used with a student should not be introduced for the first time during the assessment, as the change could be distracting or confusing to the student. When selecting accommodations for ELL, consider the needs of the student in daily instructional situations and in a secure testing situation. Keep in mind that students may require multiple accommodations such as interpreted directions and a small group setting. How does the Pennsylvania Department of Education ensure that items on the PSSA are accessible to ELLs? The Pennsylvania Department of Education (PDE) is committed to providing the broadest array of accommodations possible without jeopardizing the validity and integrity of the test. Using accommodations is only one way PDE tries to make the PSSA more accessible. Even before an item appears on the PSSA, that item has already been screened for linguistic, cultural, socioeconomic, and other forms of bias. After items have been field tested, PDE and teacher committee representatives also look for irregularities in how different types of students performed. What kinds of dictionaries can be used and who provides them? Districts may provide students with word-to-word translation dictionaries if students use them as part of their regular curriculum. Students should not be using word-to-word dictionaries for the first time on the PSSA. They should be comfortable with them and have used them in the past at school and/or at home. Students may use a dictionary as long as it is a word-to-word dictionary with no definitions and no pictures. Can electronic word-to-word dictionaries be used? Electronic dictionaries that provide word-to-word translations may be used, but again no devices that provide definitions or pictures can be used. When can students use dictionaries? Word-to-word dictionaries may be used on any portion of the Mathematics test and the openended section of the Reading test. Word-to-word dictionaries cannot be used on any portion of the Writing test or for multiplechoice/passages on the Reading test. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 49 2007 Accommodations Guidelines What is the role of the interpreter? Interpreters may have access to the mathematics test one day prior to administration to aid them in preparation for translating the assessment. Interpreters may only access the assessment in a secure setting; the assessment may not leave the building (note-taking is strictly prohibited); interpreters must sign a Confidentiality Agreement (sample form in Appendix IV of the 2007 PSSA Accommodations Guidelines). Interpreters must be of legal age to sign the Confidentiality Agreement. Directions for all assessments are provided to districts prior to the testing window. Interpreters may work with one student or small groups of students depending on the test setting. Interpreters can: o Translate the directions on the Writing, Mathematics, and Reading assessments. o Translate words or phrases (including test questions) for the Mathematics assessment at the students’ request. Only directions can be translated on the Reading assessment. Interpreters may not interpret any of the reading questions and/or the reading passage. Interpreters may not interpret any of the Writing multiple-choice items and/or stimulus passage. Interpreters may not answer clarifying questions that may be asked about test questions. They may only clarify directions in the native language. How do districts find qualified interpreters and what makes them “qualified”? Districts should determine the criteria for qualified interpreters. Districts must document the process and/or criteria used to select interpreters. Keep in mind that the use of qualified interpreters and word-to-word dictionaries is voluntary, not mandatory. Districts should try to provide these accommodations to the extent practicable and to the extent that they are typically used with students during the school year. For a description of these accommodations, see the 2007 PSSA Accommodations Guidelines. Can districts use a community member as a “qualified interpreter”? Yes, however, the district must certify that the community member is a qualified interpreter through a local process/criteria and the community member must follow interpreter guidelines as outlined in the above question describing the role of the interpreter. Community members might need additional training about what is allowable and not allowable on the PSSA. It is the district’s responsibility to ensure that community members who are deemed qualified interpreters have this training. Why can’t interpreters translate any portion of the Reading test? Allowing anyone to read any portion of the Reading test for ELLs and/or other students with IEPs or 504s is controversial among technical testing experts. The purpose of the Reading assessment is to determine if the student can comprehend what has been read. Reading any portion of the assessment to the student would alter what is being assessed and could potentially compromise the integrity of the test. Based on the recommendations of our Technical Advisory Committee, PDE has tried to consistently apply this policy for all students in all accommodation situations. As with all accommodations, PDE plans to review them annually and make adjustments based on current or new research. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 50 2007 Accommodations Guidelines Why can’t the interpreters translate the PSSA Writing multiple- choice and stimulus passages for students? As with the Reading test, allowing anyone to read any portion of the multiple choice items for editing and revising or the stimulus passage might alter what is being assessed and could potentially compromise the integrity of the Writing test. Based on review and consultation with experts in the field, PDE has developed this policy that is consistent for all students in all accommodations situations. As with all accommodations, PDE plan to review this policy annually and make adjustments as needed. Is there a difference between an interpreter and a translator? There may be semantic differences in the ESL/ELL community between an interpreter and a translator. This document has tried to consistently use the word interpreter, which would mean a person who could translate (word-for-word), orally or signed, the allowable parts of the PSSA and/or clarify directions, orally or signed, to students. Will these accommodations be allowable every year? There is a growing body of research on accommodations for ELLs. PDE will update this policy as new research about accommodations arises and will evaluate the success of the accommodations allowed this year. PDE will inform administrators of any changes prior to next year’s PSSA. Is a Spanish Version of the PSSA available for Mathematics for Grades 3-8 and 11? Yes. A Spanish version of the Mathematics PSSA is available for students who have been enrolled in schools in the United States for fewer than three years. The local educational agency may make a determination to assess students with this accommodation when the student has not yet reached a level of English language proficiency sufficient to yield valid and reliable information. Spanish language students should be literate in their native language for this accommodation to benefit them. How do we order the Spanish Version? This booklet must be requested from Data Recognition Corporation when booklet orders are submitted to DRC from schools. Only students who have a need for this assistance are to receive this accommodation. What will the Spanish Version look like? The special test form is provided for Grades 4-8, & 11 includes the PSSA Reading test in English, along with the English/Spanish mathematics test. The English/Spanish Mathematics form is issued in side-by-side English/Spanish format with identical test questions presented on opposing pages in the two languages: left-facing pages present questions in Spanish and rightfacing pages present the same questions in English. A corresponding Student Answer Booklet, in which students mark their answers in English or Spanish will also be provided for use with this special form for the Mathematics section only. For the English/Spanish Mathematics test ONLY, answers can be in English OR Spanish. Grade 3 students will be issued an English/Spanish Mathematics form that will allow answers to be marked in the test booklet. For the regular English Mathematics test, answers can ONLY be in English. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 51 2007 Accommodations Guidelines The PSSA Reading section is only provided in English and the answers must be in English to be scored. Test administrators should remind students of this. Who is eligible to take the Spanish Version? Only students who have been enrolled in schools in the United States for fewer than three years may take the English/Spanish PSSA Mathematics test. The local educational agency may make a determination to assess students with this accommodation when the student has not yet reached a level of English language proficiency sufficient to yield valid and reliable information. Spanish language students should be literate in their native language for this accommodation to benefit them. ELLs who have exited the program and/or are being monitored for up to two years should not receive this accommodation. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 52 2007 Accommodations Guidelines APPENDIX VII Contact Information Data Recognition Corp. (DRC) Customer Service 1-800-451-7849 Pennsylvania Department of Education Bureau of Assessment and Accountability 333 Market Street Harrisburg, PA 17126 717-787-4234 or 717-705-2343 Pennsylvania Department of Education Bureau of Special Education 333 Market Street 7th Floor Harrisburg, PA 17126 717-783-2311 Pennsylvania Training and Technical Assistance Network PaTTAN-Harrisburg 6340 Flank Drive Suite 600 Harrisburg, PA 17112 1-800-360-7282 Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 53 2007 Accommodations Guidelines APPENDIX VIII Bibliography for Assessment Accommodations Research American Educational Research Association, American Psychological Association, & National Council on Measurement in Education, Standards for Educational and Psychological Testing. Washington, D. C., American Educational Research Association, 91-100, 1999. Bentz, J., & Pavri, S., Curriculum-based measurement in assessing bilingual students: A promising new direction. Diagnostique, 25(3), 229-248, 2000. Buksar, A., Wilson, J., Huck, R., & Myers, R. S., ADAPT: A developmental activity program for teachers. Pittsburgh: Allegheny Intermediate Unit, 1984. Council of Chief State School Officers, Accommodations Manual: How to Select, Administer, and Evaluate Use of Accommodations for Instruction and Assessment of Students with Disabilities, Washington, DC: Council of Chief State School Officers, 2005. Gajria, M., Salend, S. J., & Hamrick, M. A., Teacher acceptability of testing modifications for mainstreamed students. Learning Disabilities Research & Practice. 9(4), 236-243, 1994. Gersten, R. & Baker, S., What we know about effective instructional practices for Englishlanguage learners, Exceptional Children, 66(4), 454-470, 2000. Marquette, J., Assistive Technology: A Focus on Accommodations for Learning. Penn Tech: Instructional Support System of Pennsylvania. Sireci, Stephen G., Li, Shuhong, & Scarpati, Stanley, The Effects of Test Accommodation on Test Performance: A Review of the Literature, University of Massachusetts Amherst, 2003. Siskind, T. G., Modifications in statewide criterion-referenced testing programs to accommodate pupils with disabilities. Diagnostique, 18(3), 233-353, 1993. Siskind, T. G., Teachers’ knowledge about test modifications for students with disabilities. Diagnostique, 18(2), 145-157, 1993. Thurlow, M., Elliott, J., & Ysseldyke, J., Testing Students with Disabilities: Practical Strategies for Complying with District and State Requirements. Corwin Press, 1998. Zirkel, P. A., Section 504 and the Schools. Horsham, Pennsylvania: LRP Publications, 1990. Pennsylvania Department of Education, Accommodations Guidelines, May 2006 54