INSTITUTIONAL EFFECTIVENESS 2015-2016 PROGRAM REVIEW REPORT BY DISCIPLINE The Best Place to Start BUSINESS MANAGEMENT The Program Review Report assesses the viability and quality of credit and non-credit instructional programs to support program improvement through Area Improvement Plans, as established by College Procedure 2.03.01.18: Program Review. The Office of Institutional Research provides the data, which are by academic year as of August 31, 2015; the Office of Institutional Effectiveness produces the report, which presents the data by program. Standards are marked as “Met” or “Not Met” based on DISTRICT (“D”), not site, performance. Data by site are shown where available (if unavailable, boxes are blank). Standards after slashes denote critical thresholds, which identify especially unacceptable performance (and if not met, are marked "Not Met-Critical"). Results are color-coded, as follows: STANDARD MET STANDARD NOT MET STANDARD NOT MET - CRITICAL Overall Viability Indicator score 50% or lower or unmet Graduation and Student Success prompts formal review by the Program Review Committee. The Committee's authority concerning program continuation is limited to recommending that the senior instructional administrators review the program's capacity to improve its service to students and the community. The final decision on program continuation rests with the President. Program Type: Career & Technical Program Mandatory Accreditation: No Report’s Recommendation Last Year: No Formal Review Fully Accredited? (Y/N): Yes Program Review Committee Action required this year: No Formal Review - Viability above 50%, Chair informs VP of Unmet Student Success Reason Why Not Fully Accredited: THE PROGRAM’S RECENT PERFORMANCE SCORES (Citation of a year such as "1415" or "2015" refers to the 2014-2015 academic year.) 12-13 13-14 14-15 2015-2016 VIABILITY 12-13 13-14 14-15 2015-2016 58.82% 94.12% 94.12% 94.44% QUALITY 62.50% 75% 75% 62.50% RECENT RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE PROGRAM REVIEW COMMITTEE 2012-2013 None 2013-2014 None 2014-2015 None SOURCES 1. State Annual Data Profile, Mainframe, 2. Annual Data Profile and/or Automated Student and Adult Learner Follow-up System, 3. Mainframe/State Lonestar, EMSI proprietary database, 4. Program Review Status Form completed by Dean of District Discipline Coordinator/CE Dean/Director, 5. Master Class Schedule (Mainframe), 6. Banner, 7. Master Class Schedule (Mainframe), Fac. Employment Status (Mainframe), 8. SLO Assessment Task Force; TracDat database (All fields must have data for applicable cycle—no blank fields), 9. Credit Student Faculty Evaluation, 10. Graduate Survey, 11. Employer Survey, 12. Advisory Committee Survey & Minutes, 13. THECB Statewide Annual Licensure Report, 14. Faculty Development Records, 15. Non-Credit Faculty Evaluation, 16. Course Syllabus (Curriculum Office), 17. Advisory Committee Survey & Minutes, Program Review Status Form completed by Dean of District Discipline Coordinator/CE Dean/Director, 18. DACUM Audit (Curriculum Office), 19. Curriculum Office, 20. Advisory Committee Survey & Minutes, Employer Survey, 21. Student Banner Files, Budget Office, Public Community/Junior & Technical College Basis of Legislative Appropriations, 22. Credit Academic History. OFFICE OF THE VICE PRESIDENT OF RESEARCH AND ACCOUNTABILITY Z:RS/2015-2016 RPT/PROGREVRPT 1516-YR BUSINESSMANAGEMENT 4/15/2016 EPCC does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, national origin, religion, gender, age, disability, veteran status, sexual orientation, or gender identity. 1 VIABILITY (Overall viability score 50% or lower or unmet Graduation and Student Success prompts formal review by the Program Review Committee) 1516 Rpt (District Data as of Aug. 31, 2015) 1213 1314 1415 Rpt Rpt Rpt 1. No. of Graduates Within latest 5-year period (Fall, Spring, Summer) provided by the State (State counts graduates with more than 1 award more than once) (For info. only, after the score: Latest 5-yr award total known to EPCC, if not the State) Source: 1 Standard: 25/<15 561. For inf. Only, EPCC Data: 682 1055. For inf. Only, EPCC Data: 1,158* 1158. For inf. only, EPCC Data: 1,358* 1342. For inf. only, EPCC Data: 1,498* 2. Student Success Percent of students employed/transfer/enter military w/in 1 yr of grad., for last 3 years provided by the State. Source: 2 Standard: 90%/<50% 87.5% 87% 89.5% 89.6% 1. Workforce Demand Whether the no. of new and replacement jobs in the field forecast for El Paso, Hudspeth, Dona Ana, Luna, & Otero counties during the 5 years following this report’s publication meets/exceeds the no. of graduates during the 5 years preceding this report’s publication. (See end of report for data) Source: 3 Standard: Yes 2. Contact/Credit Hours per FT Faculty Sufficient contact/credit hours for all discipline courses, District-wide, disregarding lecturers, for FT faculty workload for last 3 years (F/Sp). (Excluding C.E. courses) (Unduplicated) (Cred. Tran. & Career & Tech. versions of programs share the same results) Source: 4 Standard: Yes/No 3. Class Fill Rate Percent of classes 75% full (Including C.E. students), based on optimum and no. of students in each section for last 3 years on census date, excluding MILS (UTEP ROTC), MUAP (independent Music study), MUSR (recitals), Independent Study, Virtual College of Texas, NCBO, classes whose instructors are not paid by EPCC; if room capacity is below optimum, score reflects room capacity. (For info. only, after score the measure is also calculated w/o concurrent students.) (For info. only, District average fill rate appears after foregoing data (No. of seats filled divided by no. of seats available)) Source: 5 Standard: 80%/<50% 4. Enrollment Trends Seat count (including C.E. students) is increasing, level or decreasing no more than 5% from the benchmark year (1st yr. of last 3 yrs.), based on program-specific courses. (For info. only, after the score measure calculated w/o C.E. students.) (For info. only, appears the unduplicated no. of students by year) Source: 6 Standard: Yes/>10% decrease Yes, for 1,112 graduates in last 5 years. Yes, for 1,098 graduates in last 5 years. Yes, for 1,258 graduates in last 5 years. Yes, for 1,360 graduates in last 5 years. Yes Yes Yes Yes D: 72% Dist. Seat Count: 82.7% D: 70% Dist. Seat Count: 81.1% ** D: 64.6% Dist. Seat Count: 79.4% ** D: 62.4% Dist. Seat Count: 80% Class Fill without concurrent, D: 61%, VV: 59.4% ** 100% 65.4% 63.9% 66.7% 61.3% D: No, -9%, Undupl. 2010: 1,583, 2012: 1,453 D: Yes, 12%, Undupl. 2011: 1,536, 2013: 1,689 ** D: Yes, 18.9%, Undupl. 2012: 1,453, 2014: 1,598 ** D: No, -10.8%, Undupl. 2013: 1,688, 2015: 1,489 Enrollment without concurrent, D: No, -12.4%, VV: No, -13.9%** Yes, 121.3% No, -41.5% Yes, -2.7% No, -14.2% No, -11.5% 5. Full-Time Faculty in Discipline There is at least 1 FT instructor with primary teaching load in the discipline. (Sept. 1-May 1 of latest year) (Cred. Tran. & Career & Tech. versions of programs share the same results) Source: 7 Standard: Yes/No 6. Student Learning Outcomes (SLOs) For each 2-year cycle, has the program documented & implemented the recommendations for its active SLOs and completed its assessment process for its active SLOs? Source: 8 Standard: Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes INDICATOR ASC FT. BLISS MdP NW RG TM VV STATE-MANDATED INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT *2013-2014 revisions to the Program Review procedure increased the period of years covered from 3 to 5 and changed the standard from 15/<10 to 25/<15. **2013-2014 revisions to the Program Review procedure required that C.E. students be included in the scored calculation. For information only, a second calculation was required to be made without including C.E. students; the change may affect Advanced Technology Industrial Manufacturing, Electrical Technology, HVAC, and Machining Technology. OFFICE OF THE VICE PRESIDENT OF RESEARCH AND ACCOUNTABILITY Z:RS/2015-2016 RPT/PROGREVRPT 1516-YR BUSINESSMANAGEMENT 4/15/2016 EPCC does not discriminate on the basis of race, color, national origin, religion, gender, age, disability, veteran status, sexual orientation, or gender identity. 2 QUALITY 1516 Rpt (District Data as of Aug. 31, 2015) 1213 1314 1415 Rpt Rpt Rpt D: 96% D: 97% D: 96.5% D: 95.8% D: 95% D: 94% D: 92% D: 91.3% 96% 96% 97.5% 98% Lacks 3 yrs of data 98.5% 98.5% 98.1% Lacks 3 yrs of data 99.4% 99.2% 98.7% N/A N/A N/A N/A 94% 94% 94% 94.1% INDICATOR ASC FT. BLISS MdP NW RG TM VV 99% 92.5% 95.3% 95.5% 96.5% 98.3% 80.3% 96.7% 91.3% 90.7% STAKEHOLDER SATISFACTION/PROGRESS 1. Student Satisfaction with Program Based on fall/spring percent of students satisfied with labs & technology averaged for the last 3 years. (Surveys scored 1 or 0 based on combined on averaged of responses: “Excellent”: 1, “Good”: 1, “Acceptable”: 1, “Weak”: 0, “Unacceptable” = 0. Average of 1=Satisfaction) Source: 9 Standard: 80% 2. Student Evaluation of Faculty Percent of satisfaction in fall/spring averaged for last 3 years, based on question: "Would you recommend instructor?" Source: 9 Standard 80% 3. Graduate Satisfaction with Program Based on percent of cumulative graduates satisfied with “usefulness of my major courses w/ respect to my job,” “availability of courses in my major,” & “level of technology in my major.” (Combined average of all 3 responses) for previous 3 years. Source: 10 Standard: 80% 4. Employer Satisfaction Percent of surveyed employers satisfied with graduates for last 3 years. Names of employers surveyed provided by the Dean/District-wide Coordinator. (Surveys scored 1 or 0 based on the combined average of the 8 responses: “Excellent” = 1, “Good” = 1, “Acceptable” = 1, “Weak” = 0, “Unacceptable" = 0. An average of 1 indicates satisfaction) Source: 11 Standard: 80% 5. Advisory Committee Satisfaction with Program Percent of surveyed members satisfied, based on averaged percent of satisfaction for the last 3 years. (Surveys scored 1 or 0 based on the combined average of the eleven responses: “Excellent” = 1, “Good” = 1, “Acceptable” = 1, “Weak” = 0, “Unacceptable" = 0. An average of 1 indicates satisfaction.) Source: 12 Standard: 80% 6. Student Licensure/Certification, As Applicable Percent of graduates/completers receiving licensure/certification, based on annual pass rate for the most recent year. Source: 13 Standard: 90% INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT 1. Full-Time Faculty Development For most recent year, percent of FT teaching Faculty at 2 prof. development activities during the fall semester (1st day of fall Faculty Development Week (FDW) through last day of final exams) and percent of FT teaching Faculty at 2 such activities during spring semester (1st day of spring FDW through last day of final exams). If FT faculty teach in 2 or more programs, their attendance is credited to all the programs. Source: 14 Standard: 100% BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 3 INDICATOR 2. Part-Time Faculty Development For most recent year, percent of PT teaching Faculty at 1 prof. development activity during fall semester (1st day of fall Faculty Development Week (FDW) through last day of final exams) and percent of PT teaching Faculty at 1 such activity during spring semester (1st day of spring FDW through last day of final exams). If PT faculty teach in 2 or more programs, their attendance is credited to all the programs. Source: 14 Standard: 75% 3. Sections taught by Full-Time Faculty Percent of sections taught by FT Faculty for last 3 years, excluding MILS (UTEP ROTC), MUAP (independent Music study), MUSR (recitals), Independent Study, Virtual College of Texas, NCBO, classes whose instructors are not paid by EPCC. Source: 7 Standard: 50% 4. Course Syllabus Reviewed/revised within the last 3 years, based on no. of course syllabi in the program and the revision date of each syllabus. Source: 16 Standard: Yes 5. Advisory Committee Meetings Held at least once annually, based on the meeting date(s) of each program advisory committee for the last 3 years. Source: 17 Standard: Yes 6. DACUM Completion within last 5 years, based on completion date of each program DACUM. Source: 18 Standard: Yes 7. DACUM Findings Incorporated, as appropriate, into curriculum, based on most recent DACUM Audit for each program. Source: 18 Standard: Yes 8. Secondary Articulation Agreements, as appropriate Percent of ISD requests for articulation addressed through analysis of EPCC course objectives for last 3 years. Source: 19 Standard: 100% 9. Post-Secondary Articulation Agreements, as appropriate Written evidence of attempted/revised articulation within the last 3 years. Source: 4 Standard: Yes 10. Program Accreditation, As Applicable Maintains/actively seeking voluntary accreditation, based on documentation of accreditation or application for accreditation for last 3 years. Source: 4 Standard: Yes 11. Community Benefit/Service Percent of surveyed advisory committee members acknowledging program meets community needs for each of the last 3 years. Source: 12 Standard: 85% 12. Program Need Percent of surveyed employers acknowledging program is needed for each of the last 3 years. Names of surveyed employers identical to those used by Employer Satisfaction indicator. Source: 11 Standard: 85% 13. Competitive Advantage: Quality Percent of surveyed respondents acknowledging EPCC meets/exceeds quality of proprietary schools for each of the last 3 years. (Combined average of responses on both the Advisory Committee Survey and the Employer Survey) Source: 20 Standard: 85% 1213 1314 1415 Rpt Rpt Rpt 1516 Rpt (District Data as of Aug. 31, 2015) 77% 79% 81% 90% D: 54% D: 53%*** D: 59.3%*** D: 58.8%*** Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes 100% 100% 100% 100% Yes Yes Yes Yes N/A N/A N/A Yes Lacks 3 yrs of data 96.7% 96.7% 100% Lacks 3 yrs of data 100% 100% 94.9% Lacks 3 yrs of data 92% 94% 98% ASC FT. BLISS MdP 0% NW 27% RG TM VV 63.9% 37.1% 63.6% ***2013-2014 revisions to the Program Review procedure reduced the standard from 60% to 50%. BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 4 VIABILITY INSTRUCTIONAL SUPPORT INDICATOR 1 - WORKFORCE DEMAND Measure: Whether the sum of new and replacement jobs in the field forecast for El Paso and Hudspeth Counties and the New Mexico counties of Dona Ana, Luna and Otero during the 5 years following the publication of the Program Review Report meets or exceeds the number of graduates during the 5 years preceding the publication of the report. To ensure that the data include career paths addressed by the program, each program shall provide the IE Office with a list of jobs for which it prepares graduates. The listings are from the EMSI database, which was created in 2001, in consultation with the Association of Community College Trustees (ACCT), to track occupational demand and wages nationally, by state and by region, drawing on some 91 databases, which include those of the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. The number preceding each occupational title is the unique Bureau of Labor Statistics SOC (Standard Occupational Classification) number assigned to each job title. Job titles were specified by the disciplines. Numerical anomalies may be due to rounding. TOTAL NUMBER OF JOBS PER YEAR SOC Code 11-1011 11-1021 11-2011 11-2021 11-2022 11-2031 11-3011 11-3021 11-3031 11-3051 11-3061 11-3071 11-3111 11-3121 11-3131 11-9013 11-9021 11-9131 11-9141 11-9151 11-9199 13-1011 13-1021 13-1031 13-1032 13-1041 13-1071 Occupation Chief Executives General and Operations Managers Advertising and Promotions Managers Marketing Managers Sales Managers Public Relations and Fundraising Managers Administrative Services Managers Computer and Information Systems Managers Financial Managers Industrial Production Managers Purchasing Managers Transportation, Storage, and Distribution Managers Compensation and Benefits Managers Human Resources Managers Training and Development Managers Farmers, Ranchers, and Other Agricultural Managers Construction Managers Postmasters and Mail Superintendents Property, Real Estate, and Community Association Managers Social and Community Service Managers Managers, All Other Agents and Business Managers of Artists, Performers, and Athletes Buyers and Purchasing Agents, Farm Products Claims Adjusters, Examiners, and Investigators Insurance Appraisers, Auto Damage Compliance Officers Human Resources Specialists 265 5019 25 113 373 37 272 5107 25 117 383 39 279 5185 26 121 392 41 285 5259 26 125 401 42 289 5318 27 128 408 43 Total New/Replacement Jobs 48 690 <10 26 69 <10 664 256 678 267 691 278 702 287 712 294 578 291 88 213 592 291 90 217 607 291 92 220 620 292 94 224 12 151 27 261 12 156 28 258 13 159 29 255 686 33 301 698 33 309 263 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 Average Hourly Wage (2014) Education Required $82.58 $48.48 $46.16 $55.25 $54.47 $49.15 Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree 92 54 $35.30 $49.88 Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree 630 294 95 227 99 26 15 34 $45.54 $56.80 $50.06 $35.45 Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree High school diploma or equivalent 13 163 30 253 13 167 31 252 <10 32 <10 18 $49.19 $40.04 $46.16 $24.85 Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree High school diploma or equivalent 710 32 316 723 32 322 736 31 327 95 <10 55 $49.40 $28.34 $31.87 Bachelor's degree High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent 267 270 274 276 35 $28.15 Bachelor's degree 1077 <10 1094 <10 1109 <10 1123 <10 1133 <10 154 <10 $47.51 No Data High school diploma or equivalent Bachelor's degree 14 14 14 14 14 <10 $23.84 High school diploma or equivalent 439 444 448 453 457 60 $29.95 High school diploma or equivalent <10 2036 1049 <10 2061 1063 <10 2083 1075 <10 2103 1086 <10 2119 1094 <10 238 124 No Data $31.33 $24.84 Postsecondary non-degree award Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 5 13-1111 13-1141 13-1161 13-1199 13-2021 13-2031 13-2041 13-2051 13-2052 13-2053 13-2061 13-2071 13-2072 13-2081 13-2082 13-2099 15-2041 25-2023 25-2031 25-2032 25-3098 25-3099 41-1011 41-1012 41-2011 41-2012 41-2021 41-2022 41-2031 41-3011 41-3021 41-3031 41-3041 41-3099 41-4011 41-4012 41-9021 Management Analysts Compensation, Benefits, and Job Analysis Specialists Market Research Analysts and Marketing Specialists Business Operations Specialists, All Other Appraisers and Assessors of Real Estate Budget Analysts Credit Analysts Financial Analysts Personal Financial Advisors Insurance Underwriters Financial Examiners Credit Counselors Loan Officers Tax Examiners and Collectors, and Revenue Agents Tax Preparers Financial Specialists, All Other Statisticians Career/Technical Education Teachers, Middle School Secondary School Teachers, Except Special and Career/Technical Education Career/Technical Education Teachers, Secondary School Substitute Teachers Teachers and Instructors, All Other First-Line Supervisors of Retail Sales Workers First-Line Supervisors of Non-Retail Sales Workers Cashiers Gaming Change Persons and Booth Cashiers Counter and Rental Clerks Parts Salespersons Retail Salespersons Advertising Sales Agents Insurance Sales Agents Securities, Commodities, and Financial Services Sales Agents Travel Agents Sales Representatives, Services, All Other Sales Representatives, Wholesale and Manufacturing, Technical and Scientific Products Sales Representatives, Wholesale and Manufacturing, Except Technical and Scientific Products Real Estate Brokers 658 98 685 101 709 103 730 105 744 106 130 15 $31.18 $24.27 Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree 357 377 396 413 426 91 $24.51 Bachelor's degree 2329 2375 2417 2455 2483 288 $29.83 High school diploma or equivalent 96 99 101 103 104 12 $23.71 Bachelor's degree 160 53 122 161 64 58 62 517 88 164 55 127 166 64 59 63 525 91 167 56 133 171 64 60 65 535 94 171 58 138 176 64 61 66 543 96 173 59 141 179 64 62 67 552 98 40 12 32 29 <10 10 10 74 23 $30.38 $30.75 $42.62 $38.07 $30.36 $33.69 $18.41 $31.28 $25.00 Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree 113 334 24 60 114 340 25 61 116 346 26 62 117 351 28 64 118 355 29 65 15 36 <10 11 $13.85 $18.98 $31.80 $23.83 High school diploma or equivalent Bachelor's degree Master's degree Bachelor's degree 4293 4395 4491 4581 4657 856 $25.17 Bachelor's degree 417 426 434 442 449 80 $25.55 Bachelor's degree 3174 920 4186 3241 945 4268 3303 967 4342 3363 987 4410 3413 1002 4463 467 149 658 $9.57 $20.45 $20.25 Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree High school diploma or equivalent 626 634 642 650 656 63 $26.20 High school diploma or equivalent 10749 19 10895 20 11021 21 11133 22 11209 22 2374 <10 $8.97 $9.17 Less than high school High school diploma or equivalent 975 641 15009 200 556 384 993 651 15329 201 572 391 1009 659 15620 202 588 398 1024 667 15889 203 601 404 1036 672 16104 205 612 409 165 99 3248 30 114 63 $13.06 $15.60 $11.38 $20.80 $18.88 $33.57 Less than high school Less than high school Less than high school High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent Bachelor's degree 80 2425 77 2480 74 2530 72 2576 71 2616 <10 470 $17.25 $19.40 High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent 468 477 485 493 498 69 $37.00 Bachelor's degree 2620 2634 2650 2667 2686 273 $21.52 High school diploma or equivalent 34 35 36 37 38 <10 $33.62 High school diploma or equivalent BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 6 41-9022 41-9031 41-9041 41-9091 41-9099 43-1011 43-2011 43-2021 43-2099 43-3011 43-3021 43-3031 43-3041 43-3051 43-3061 43-3071 43-3099 43-4011 43-4021 43-4031 43-4041 43-4051 43-4071 43-4111 43-4121 43-4131 43-4141 43-4151 43-4161 43-4171 43-4181 43-4199 43-5011 43-5021 43-5031 43-5032 43-5041 43-5051 43-5052 43-5053 Real Estate Sales Agents Sales Engineers Telemarketers Door-to-Door Sales Workers, News and Street Vendors, and Related Workers Sales and Related Workers, All Other First-Line Supervisors of Office and Administrative Support Workers Switchboard Operators, Including Answering Service Telephone Operators Communications Equipment Operators, All Other Bill and Account Collectors Billing and Posting Clerks Bookkeeping, Accounting, and Auditing Clerks Gaming Cage Workers Payroll and Timekeeping Clerks Procurement Clerks Tellers Financial Clerks, All Other Brokerage Clerks Correspondence Clerks Court, Municipal, and License Clerks Credit Authorizers, Checkers, and Clerks Customer Service Representatives File Clerks Interviewers, Except Eligibility and Loan Library Assistants, Clerical Loan Interviewers and Clerks New Accounts Clerks Order Clerks Human Resources Assistants, Except Payroll and Timekeeping Receptionists and Information Clerks Reservation and Transportation Ticket Agents and Travel Clerks Information and Record Clerks, All Other Cargo and Freight Agents Couriers and Messengers Police, Fire, and Ambulance Dispatchers Dispatchers, Except Police, Fire, and Ambulance Meter Readers, Utilities Postal Service Clerks Postal Service Mail Carriers Postal Service Mail Sorters, Processors, and Processing Machine Operators 428 36 1454 <10 441 38 1468 <10 451 40 1478 <10 460 41 1490 <10 467 42 1498 <10 56 <10 175 <10 $21.29 $40.95 $10.12 No Data High school diploma or equivalent Bachelor's degree Less than high school High school diploma or equivalent 172 4077 176 4156 180 4228 184 4295 187 4349 29 676 $12.20 $22.39 High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent 379 377 375 373 370 29 $10.47 High school diploma or equivalent 12 <10 12 <10 12 <10 12 <10 13 <10 <10 <10 $14.96 No Data High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent 703 1455 3829 729 1490 3896 753 1522 3957 775 1551 4014 793 1574 4060 176 231 377 $15.76 $12.95 $15.27 High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent 16 655 261 1656 50 24 16 532 99 17 665 264 1683 51 24 17 542 100 17 674 267 1703 53 25 17 552 100 18 683 269 1722 54 25 17 561 101 19 691 271 1736 55 25 18 569 102 <10 96 49 401 11 <10 <10 71 <10 $10.15 $16.39 $17.42 $11.15 $17.50 $21.85 $14.93 $13.70 $15.26 High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent 8790 416 404 9002 419 411 9197 421 418 9379 422 423 9533 423 427 1754 47 55 $12.23 $10.86 $13.09 High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent 265 774 151 441 494 273 782 153 442 498 280 790 154 443 501 287 798 155 445 504 292 806 156 446 506 77 54 21 52 63 $11.12 $16.73 $12.62 $12.34 $15.21 High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent 2145 147 2186 146 2221 146 2253 146 2275 148 371 11 $10.16 $18.87 High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent 805 811 816 820 821 90 $17.35 High school diploma or equivalent 263 430 327 270 432 333 276 432 339 281 433 344 286 432 348 54 26 61 $16.85 $9.41 $15.78 High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent 477 485 493 500 506 87 $15.19 High school diploma or equivalent 131 139 641 185 130 136 635 183 129 134 628 181 128 131 620 179 126 128 611 176 13 <10 87 <10 $13.86 $24.17 $24.40 $22.96 High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 7 43-5061 43-5071 43-5081 43-6011 43-6012 43-6014 43-9011 43-9021 43-9022 43-9031 43-9041 43-9051 43-9061 43-9071 43-9081 43-9111 43-9199 Production, Planning, and Expediting Clerks Shipping, Receiving, and Traffic Clerks Stock Clerks and Order Fillers Executive Secretaries and Executive Administrative Assistants Legal Secretaries Secretaries and Administrative Assistants, Except Legal, Medical, and Executive Computer Operators Data Entry Keyers Word Processors and Typists Desktop Publishers Insurance Claims and Policy Processing Clerks Mail Clerks and Mail Machine Operators, Except Postal Service Office Clerks, General Office Machine Operators, Except Computer Proofreaders and Copy Markers Statistical Assistants Office and Administrative Support Workers, All Other 672 681 690 698 706 103 $19.79 High school diploma or equivalent 2112 2115 2120 2128 2138 252 $11.47 High school diploma or equivalent 5500 1002 5549 1016 5593 1029 5632 1039 5659 1046 837 94 $10.27 $22.60 Less than high school High school diploma or equivalent 307 7458 308 7573 309 7678 310 7775 311 7857 23 770 $17.42 $13.14 High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent 233 1269 94 33 438 233 1245 95 33 443 232 1221 95 33 448 232 1198 95 33 453 230 1174 94 33 458 <10 58 <10 <10 69 $13.47 $10.18 $16.52 $13.84 $17.26 High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent Associate's degree High school diploma or equivalent 305 308 310 312 312 37 $12.91 High school diploma or equivalent 10873 146 10973 149 11064 152 11152 155 11219 156 1279 26 $12.61 $11.73 High school diploma or equivalent High school diploma or equivalent 18 11 207 18 12 216 19 12 225 19 13 232 19 13 238 <10 <10 56 $12.65 $18.74 $16.54 Bachelor's degree Bachelor's degree High school diploma or equivalent BUSINESS MANAGEMENT 8