Investment Financial vs physical capital • In the consumption-saving model studied earlier, we studied the role of financial capital and investment. • Financial capital consists of IOUs like stocks, bonds, and money. • Financial capital may facilitate production of final goods and services, but does not directly produce output. • In contrast, physical/human capital serves as an input in the production process. • Think of physical capital as an intertemporal production technology. Investment • Investment refers to newly produced capital goods. — machinery, inventory, homes, office buildings, roads, sewers, maintenance and repair. • NIPA only records investment in non-human forms of capital. — in reality, human capital investment is hugely important. • But physical capital is obviously important too (just look around you). • Most of the business cycle is accounted for by swings in investment. Intertemporal production • How might Robinson Crusoe transport coconuts today into the future? • In the consumption-saving model, RC transported his private consumption into the future at the expense of his debtor’s consumption—no additional output was produced. • But suppose RC can physically transport his coconuts to the future? — e.g., by planting a coconut or holding it as inventory. — this can be done even independently of financial markets. The investment demand function • Suppose that units of investment today yields an expected output () • () is an increasing and strictly concave function, 0() 0 00() 0 • is an expected productivity parameter. • 0() is the expected marginal product of investment (future capital). — an increasing function of and a decreasing function of The investment demand function • Let denote the gross real rate of interest. • Expected net present value (NPV) of capital spending is given by ( () () = − + ) • The investment demand function ( ) maximizes () i.e., 0() = 0 or 0() = • is a decreasing function of and an increasing function of Stock market value • Define ∗( ) ≡ (( )) • Can interpret ∗ as the value of business sector capital (corporate stocks and bonds). • ∗ is a decreasing function of and an increasing function of • Re: increase in = “good news” and decrease in = “bad news.” • Good news leads to boom in desired capital spending and stock market values. Investment and saving • Earlier, we studied the consumption-saving choice of Robinson Crusoe assuming only financial capital. • Suppose now that RC can invest in domestic capital . • GDP flow is now given by {1 2} = { ()} • Consumption-saving decision is solution to 2 max (1 2) subject to 1 + ≤ + ∗( ) Investment and saving • Solution implies a desired domestic saving function ( ) • is increasing in increasing in and decreasing in — note: an increase in and elicits a weaker response in desired saving than changes in or individually (why?). • Recall ≡ + + + and ≡ − − implies ≡ + • In our model, = ( ) − ( ) Closed economy • In a closed economy, = 0 so that saving must equal investment ( ) = ( ) • One can think of equation above as defining an “IS curve”—combinations of ( ) that are consistent with = • Alternatively, one can think of IS curve as representing the aggregate demand for output as a function of and • This framework can accommodate many different views of the business cycle. Classical view • Level of is determined in labor market, largely independent of and • In this case, (∗ ) = (∗ ) determines the equilibrium interest rate ∗ • Fluctuations in reflect rational changes in expectations, inducing cyclical fluctuation in capital spending, stock market valuations, and interest rates. • No obvious role for government stabilization policies. Keynesian view • Level of is determined by aggregate demand, a function of and • In this case, ( ∗ ) = ( ) determines equilibrium level of ∗ • But ∗ may be either too high or too low because market expectations can be overly optimistic or pessimistic (animal spirits). • Stabilization policies are desirable, e.g., lower (add stimulus) if overly pessimistic decline in .