DISCUSSION ON TUE THE USE USE DISCUSSION ON OF PORTS IN IN OF ESCAPE ESCAPE PORTS CRAB TRAPS TRAPS CRAB " by by Nelson E. Stewart Nelson E. Stewart INTRODUCTION INTRODUCTION One of objectives of of the State/Federal Dungeness Crab One of the the initial initial objectives the State/Federal Dungeness Crab Management by certain Management Program Program is is to to evaluate evaluate crab crab mortality mortality caused caused by certain fishery fishery practices and recommend changes in existing regulations practices and to to develop develop methods methods or or recommend changes in existing regulations to reduce or eliminate eliminate that that mortality. mortality. to reduce or One area of of major concern is is reducing reducing One area major concern caused by by sorting sorting and and discarding discarding female, female, sublegal sub1ega1 male, male, and and softshell softshell mortality caused mortality crabs from the the catch. catch. crabs from Escape ports ports in in crab traps provide provide aa means by which Escape crab traps means by which smaller smaller crabs crabs can can escape. Reasons for for requiring requiring escape escape ports ports include: include: escape. Reasons (1) to (1) handling handling mortality mortality to sub1ega1 (2) injury injury to sublegal male male and and female female crabs crabs is is reduced; reduced; (2) to small small crabs crabs resulting resulting from (3) loss is reduced; reduced; (4) (4) if if traps traps from fighting fighting is is reduced; reduced; (3) loss from from cannibalism cannibalism is are to escape; (5) they they benefit benefit are lost lost the the sublegal sublegal crabs crabs have have an an opportunity opportunity to escape; and and (5) fisher~men legal-sized crabs reducing the the amount fishermen by by retaining retaining the the legal-sized crabs and and reducing amount of of sorting sorting needed to remove remove the the sublegal sublegal crabs crabs from from their their catch. catch. needed to At the the present present time time virtually virtually all all crab crab traps traps are are provided provided with with at at least least At one escape port. port. one escape However, is that that there there is is no no uniformity uniformity as However, a a major major problem problem is as to of the the escape escape opening. opening. to size size of The purpose of report is is to to summarize sUITIllarize and and evaluate the available available The purpose of this this report evaluate the information regarding ports in in use use in in the the coastal information regarding the the size size of of escape escape ports coastal crab crab ~ inch inch minimum minimum size size limit. limit. fishery in in relation relation to to the the present present 6¼ fishery -2-2­ REGULATIONS ON ESCAPE PORTS PORTS REGULATIONS ON THE THE USE USE OF OF ESCAPE Washington and and Oregon Oregon have have no no regulations regulations requiring requiring escape escape ports. ports. Washington California law law requires requires that that north north of of Point Point Conception Conception each each crab crab trap trap shall shall California have have at at least least two two rigid rigid circular circular openings openings of of not not less less than than four four inches inches inside inside on the the top top or or side side of of the the trap. trap. diameter located on diameter located If side openings are are used, used, If side openings at least least one least one-half at one of of them them shall shall be be located located so so that that at at least one-half of of the the opening opening is (Edgerton, 1971). 1971). is in in the the upper upper half half of of the the trap trap (Edgerton, SIZE OF ESCAPE PORTS PORTS IN IN USE USE IN IN THE THE COASTAL COASTAL FISHERY FISHERY SIZE OF ESCAPE Washington Washington In December December 1973, 1973, the In the Washington Washington Department Department of of Fisheries Fisheries collected collected data data on the size escape ports ports in in crab crab traps traps employed employed in in the the Washington Washington coastal coastal on the size of of escape crab (Anonymous, 1974). 1974). A total of 442 rings rings in in traps traps belonging belonging to to 41 41 crab fishery fishery (Anonymous, A total of 442 fishermen were measured. measured. The ring arrangements arrangements encountered encountered were were aa single single ring, ring, fishermen were The ring two rings rings on on opposite sides of of the the pot, pot, two two rings rings adjacent adjacent to to one one frame frame upright, upright, two opposite sides and half-rings in in frame frame corners. corners. and half-rings Escape ring ring inside diameters ranged ranged from from 3.4 3.4 Escape inside diameters to inches. to 4.6 4.6 inches Inches with with an an average average of of 4.23 423 inches. close to close to The majority of the the rings rings were The majority of were ~ inches inches (82 (82 percent percent of of the the rings rings were were from from 4.2 4.2 to to 4.3 4.3 inches). inches). 4¼ Oregon Oregon There the size ports in in There is is no no 'recent recent information information available available on on the size of of escape escape ports use in in Oregon. Oregon. use However, the the results results of of various various interviews interviews conducted conducted by by Fish Fish However, Commission Coninissionbiologists biologists indicate indicate that that the the majority majority of of Oregon Oregon fishermen fishermen use use at at least least ~ inch escape escape ports. ports. 4¼ inch California California The size of in use in California vary from from about about 3.9 3.9 to to 4.6 4.6 The size of escape escape rings rings in use in California vary inches. However, in in the the San Francisco area area the the majority of escape escape rings rings are are San Francisco majority of inches. However, inches. from about about 4.1 4.1 to to 4.3 4.3 inches. they range range from 4 and In in the the Bodega Bodega Bay Bay area area they 4 inches inches and , 1 I I I I I ~ -3-3­ STUDIES STUDI ES Length-Hidth Measurements /'~easurements Length-Width The legal measurement measurement of of Dungeness Dungeness crab crab is is the the carapace carapace width. width. This is The legal This is the the straight-line straight-line distance distance measured measured across across the the carapace carapace directly directly in in front front of of the tenth anterolateral anterolateral spines. spines. the tenth Although crab crab lengths lengths are are not not normally normally measured, measured, Although they they are are the the best best measurement measurement to to use use for for determining determining the the proper proper size size of of escape escape ports. ports. Crabs they are Crabs normally normally move move about about laterally, laterally, although although they are capable capable of of moving moving forward and backward backward (Jow, (Jow, 1961). 1961). The smallest opening through ''''hich forward and The smallest opening through which a a crab crab can crawl crawl is is about about equal equal to to his his length, length, which which is is the the smallest smallest dimension. dimension. can Therefore, to determine the size size of ports the the relationship relationship between between Therefore, to determine the of the the escape escape ports carapace width and length length is is needed. needed. carapace width and California biologists biologists collected collected length-width length-width data from 1,556 1,556 male and 373 California data from male and 373 female crabs crabs taken taken in in the the San San Francisco Francisco area area in in 1954-55 1954-55 (Figure (Figure 1)1". 1)11. female Jow (1961) Jow (1961) gives data data from from measurements measurements on on 268 258 male male and and 63 63 female female crabs crabs (Figure (Figure 2). 2). gives Oregon Oregon biologists length-width data data from from 1,000 1,000 male male crabs crabs in in 1967 1967 (Figure (Figure 3). 3). biologists collected collected length-width In In each each case case the the length-width length-width relationship relationship shows shows that that aa legal legal male male crab crab of of ~ 6¼ inches in in width width has inches has aa length length very very close close to to 44~ inches. inches. Escape Opening Opening Experiments Experiments Escape Jow (1961) (1961) presents presents data data from from several several escape escape opening opening experiments experiments done done in in Jow between 1955 1955 and and 1959. 1959. California between California Following is is aa suninary summary of of the the Following of results results of more pertinent experiments. experiments. more pertinent Comparison of Traps with NoOpeninQs, Escape Openings, Two 4-Inch Escape Ports,oror Two Two ?5?_T.with No Escape Two 4-Inch Escape Ports, 41-Inch Escape Ports The fishing fishing qualities qualities of the three three types types of of traps traps were were tested tested at at Bodega Bodega Bay Bay The of the in fathoms of of water. water. in seven seven fathoms 11J Eight sets were were made made at at five five different different fishing Eight sets fishing A length-width length-width relationship relationship was also determined determined for for crabs crabs collected collected from from A was also the Eureka Eureka area in 1956 1956 which in close the area in which is is in close agreement agreement with with that that determined determined for for However, that data is not included here crabs from the San Francisco area. However, that data is not included here crabs from the San Francisco area because it it Is is not not known known how how many many crabs crabs were were measured. measured. because -4­ stations each type type of of gear. gear. 'The traps were pulled and and emptied emptied every stations with with each The traps were pulled every two days. days. two No significant significant difference difference was was found found in in the the legal legal male male catch. catch. No The average average The catch catch of of legal legal males males per per trap trap for for the the three three types types of of gear gear ranged ranged from from 1.1 1.1 to to 1.4. 14. However, the greater in in those those traps traps However, the mean mean size size of of malE:: niak ,crabs crabs was was significantly sinificantl,Ygreater having having 4¼-inch ~-inch escape escape ports. ports. The traps traps with with 4¼-inch ~-inch ports ports were were also also the the most The most efficient (sublegal males plus females) females) to to efficient in in allowing allowing non-marketable non-marketable crabs crabs (sublegal males plus escape. escape. Traps Traps with with ~-inch ports ports took took on on the the average average four four non-marketable non-marketable crabs crabs 4¼-inch every legal legal male male while traps with with 4-inch 4-inch ports ports and and those those without without escape escape for every for while traps openings took took 88 and and 17, 17~ respectively. respectively. openings Comparison of of Traps with One One 4-Inch, 4-Inch, One One 4¼-Inch, ~-Inch, or or One One 4½-Inch f)-Inch Escape Escape Port Port Comparison Traps with Equal numbers traps with the three three escape escape port port sizes sizes were set at at 10 10 Equal numbers of of traps with the were set stations in in productive productive fishing fishing areas areas off off Crescent Crescent City, City, Eureka, Eureka, Bodega Bodega Bay, Bay, and and stations San Francisco. Traps Traps were were pulled pulled and and emptied emptied every every two two days. days. San Francisco. No significant significant difference difference was was found found in in the the numbers numbers of of legal legal males males caught. caught. No The average catch of legal males males per per trap trap for for the the three three types types of of gear gear ranged ranged The average catch of legal from 2.2 with a a from 2.2 to to 2.5. 2.5. Traps Traps with 4- or or with a 4with a ~-inch port. port. 4¼-inch 4½-inch port port caught caught larger larger male male crabs crabs than'did'traps than didtraps ~-inch Significant differences existed existed in in the the numbers numbers of of Significant differences female and and sublegal sublegal males males the the different different traps traps caught. caught. female Traps with aa Traps with ~-inch 4½-inch port legal male traps port caught caught only only two two non-marketable non-marketable crabs crabs for for every every legal male while while the the traps with 4-inch and and with 4-inch ~-inch ports ports caught caught five five and and six six crabs, crabs, respectively. respectively. 4¼-inch Comparison of Traps with One 4-Inch. 4-Inch, T\,/o 4-Inch, Two Two 4k-Inch. tPi-Inch, ,or Two 4½-Inch 41a-Inch Two 4-Inch, or Two Escape Ports Eight with each each type type of of trap trap at at seven seven stations stations off off central central Eight sets sets were were made made with California. were pulled pulled and and emptied emptied every every two two days. days. Traps were California. Traps The legal legal male catch did did not not differ differ significantly significantly between between the the four four types types The male catch of traps traps fished. fished. of The average catch The average catch of of legal legal males males per per trap trap ranged ranged from from 1.3 1.3 -5­ to to 1.8. 1.8. The mean size of of male male crabs crabs increased increased with with escape escape port port size. size. The mean size The The numbers of by the the different types of numbers of female female and and sublega1 sublegal males males caught caught by different types of traps traps differed considerably. Traps two differed considerably. Traps with with two crab every legal 1egal male. male. crab for for every ~-inch ports ports caught caught one one non-marketable non-marketable 4½-inch Traps with ports caught caught two two non-marketable non-marketable Traps with two two ~-inch 4-inch ports crabs for legal male, traps with 4-inch ports ports caught crabs for every every legal male, while while traps with 4-inch caught four four to to six six non-marketable crabs. crabs. non-marketable DISCUSSION AND AND CONCLUSIONS CONCLUSIONS DISCUSSION At the present present time time most used in in the the Dungeness At the most traps traps used Dungeness crab crab fishery fishery have have at at least port for the purpose purpose of of allowing allowing small small crabs crabs to to escape. escape. The The least one one escape escape port for the problem is is that that there there is in the the size problem is considerable considerable variation variation in size of of escape escape ports ports used it is is permissible permissible to to fish ports in used and and it fish traps traps without without escape escape ports in Washington Washington and and Oregon. California requires requires that that crab crab traps traps have have at at least least two two escape ports of Oregon. California escape ports of than four four inches inches inside inside diameter. diameter. not less than not less However, this size size of of port port does does However, this not appear large enough not appear to to be be large enough to to allow allow adequate adequate escapement escapement of of sub1egal sublegal males males and female crabs. crabs. and female Length-width than 2,800 2,800 male that aa crab Length-width measurements measurements from from more more than male crabs crabs show show that crab in width length close the smallest smallest opening opening of of ~ 6¼ inches inches in width has has a a length close to to 4~ 4 inches. inches. Since Since the 8 through to his his length, length, it it appears through which which a a crab crab can can crawl crawl is is about about equal equal to appears that that the the optimum ports with to the the present present optimum size size of of escape escape ports with respect respect to minimum size 6~-inch 6¼-inch minimum size be 44: inches. inches. limit should limit should be Escape reported by by Jaw (1961) indicate indicate that that traps traps with Escape opening opening studies studies reported Jow (1961) with escape ports of escape ports of 4, 4, ~, in diameter 4¼, and and ~ 4½ inches inches in diameter will will catch catch approximately approximately the the same number of of legal legal crabs. crabs. same number However, the the larger larger the the escape escape openings openings the the more However, more efficient the traps In actual actual efficient the traps are are for for releasing releasing sublegal sublegal male male and and female female crabs. crabs. In 3 inches, legal crabs through an port of fishing fishing operations operations some some legal crabs may may escape escape through an escape escape port of 48 4 inches, but loss would potential savings but it it appears appears the the loss would be be minimal minimal and and the the potential savings of of sublegal sublegal male and female female crabs crabs could could be be much much greater. greater. male and -6­ Crabs reportedly reportedly often often get get caught caught in in escape escape ports ports while while trying trying to to get get Crabs out of the the trap. trap. out of each trap trap should should have have at at least least two two escape escape ports. ports. Therefore, Therefore, each The ports should should be located in in the the upper upper half half of of the the trap trap so so that that they they The escape escape ports be located can still function function if if the the trap trap becomes becomes partially partially sanded sanded in. in. can still RE COI4r~ENDAT OATII ON RECOMMEN ON Because of the desirability of providing providing protection protection to to sublegal sublegal male and Because of the desirability of male and female crabs, it it is is reconinended recommended that female crabs, that all all Dungeness Dungeness crab crab traps traps be be required required to to have aa minimum two circular ports of of at at least least 44~ inches inches inside inside diameter diameter have minimum of of two circular escape escape ports .~::-~'-~"--'-"-"- located top or side of of the the trap. trap. located on on the the top or side If escape ports are are placed placed on on the the side side If escape ports trap, they they should should be be located located in in the the upper upper half half of of the the trap. trap. of the trap, of the It is also also It is recommended that that aa period period of least 55 years be allowed recommended of at at least years be allowed for for altering altering crab crab conform with with this this regulation. regulation. traps to to conform traps LITERATURE CITED LITERATURE CITED Anonymous. 1974. Escape in use pots in in the the Washington Escape rings rings in use on on Dungeness Dungeness crab crab pots Washington 1974. Anonymous. coastal fishery. Wash. Dept. Fish, Fish. Prepared Prepared Rept. Rept. 33 p. p. Wash. Dept. coastal fishery. Edgerton, L.F. (Compiler). (Compiler). 1971. State California Department Department of of Fish Fish and 1971. State of of California and Edgerton, L.F. Game, Fish and and Game Game Code. Code. 47th Ed. Game, Fish 47th Ed. Jow, T. 1961. Crab trap trap escape-opening escape-opening studies. studies. Crab Jow, T. 1961. No.5, 110. 5, pp. pp. 49-72. 49-72. Pac. Fish. Comm. Comm. Bull. Bull. Pac. Mar. Mar. Fish. Prepared Program, Policy Policy Prepared for for the the State/Federal State/Federal Dungeness Dungeness Crab Crab Management Management Program, Committee Meeting, Meeting, April April 1974. 1974. Committee 130 130 . ,,(".,.ef' . 120 , 4-3/8 ,~ , . 110l!---------------­ ll0 t1 ~ inches' _____ I I.,.. 110 __ - § * " ~ ~ z -1 120 -' " , 100 1co I 100 ~ , " I II 90 90 \ I I 80 80 .. T. at Y = 6.51 + ).65X 65X II ~ 0.75X Y a -3.15 + 0.75X , -I 80 I I I 6-1s ~! " 4 6.-1t. I I 130 1 140 150 150 160 170 170 180 180 190 ~Dru~w~rn~ WIDTH NILLIMEThRS relationship of of male male and and female fe~ale Dungeness Dungeness crabs. crabs. Regression lines based based Lengthwidth relationship Figure 1. , Length-width Figure 1. on neasurementa of of 1~556 1556 male Francisco area on measurements male and and 373 373 female female crabs crabs taken taken in the San Francisco area in 1954·55. D!ta compilid compilod by by Walt Walt Dahistrorn, Dahlstrom, California Fish and and Game. Game. 1954-55. . flta California Oepurtment Department Fish 120 ·i~ .. .. '''' ~/ . 125 /" . ", ••••••• •••• ••••••••••• ••••••••••• ••••••••••• ••••••••••• • •••••••••• ••••••••••• ••••••••••• '.J'L••• 120 /' ). I ",t15 « ..... •• •••• ••••• • •••• •••••• •••••• •••••• ••••••••••• ••• •••• ••• . t; ~ ::; :i: ... ••••••• •Y' ...... ......~ ",.' ..J ~ I .,/./ 110 \,) ••••••••••••• • ••• •••••••• •••••••••••• .......•,;;,r. 2 ~ ",/ 105 /r /'" ~' -" ~. 7- ",,; . ~/ /' ", ...,.". ./' ",. V ./ \4Q /. /'" V 1 ••••••••••• •••••• ••••• •••••••••••• '2 ,M! . ~ ~ . ~--- "018.-49.0.60lC ~. 7.60 T. i.OQ '+d z~ ; 1 i - V ___-___-_ o• ., 145 145 150 150 155 y. •O.6SX ,...a...... • s.*.*a.a... •••••••••• s,.......... • ••••••••••• a..a....*.aes ••••••••••• , : -- 140 3 ••••••••••• i / ' • ••• • •••• •• •••••••••• •••••••••••• ........... ........... Jl 13~ 13 t/.. i;1' ~C .,, .... .... ·····r .a... • ••• •••••••• •••••••••••• •,. •••••••• ••••••••••• 100 ICC Y "'....... .. ./ y • 6 6t lC V ineT •••••••••••• j .. -- 160 150 165 170 110 uS 175 180 180 SHOULOER-WIOTH MILLIMETERS SHOULER-WIOTkMILUMTER$ " Figure Figure 2. 2. The lergth leqgth '$dth width relationship relationship of of male male and and female f~lale market market crabs. crabs. Regression Regression lines lines The derived from from measurements of 258 258 male male 'and 63 female fenlale crabs crabs taken taken from from central central California California derived measurements of and 63 waters during during 1958. 1958. (From (From Jow, Jow, 1961) 1961) waters " , I " Shell width in in inch inches Sh11 'iidth 3.9' 4.3 39 4.3 ,* 4.7 4.7 5.5 55 5.1. 5.1 150 15 6.7 6.7 5.9 6.3 5.9 6.3 7.S 7.5 7.1 7.], 7.9 7.9 8.3 8.3 5.9 5.9 -. . , \,~ , 140 ... . ,'7:". • .,,,, •t.t.t' I',•• I. •• • • •• , . .. •• - - - - • m Ii ~ - .. -- •• :!~tt .::••' • ,.& ,,,,t. • ~ "" If:· • • til . . . . ,- •• ', .. ~:·.f":'''· • I.:' .•• ~:.: •.' . ... -.....,:,. tt+f;- - ·05 !. ,1 • t " • •• , • . 5,5 • S.], 'It" 't .:~~ ,t .. :::r' .""... - • •••• I • 'Ii It I .\ .• -­ ----­ t •• 'I . 100·­ J• .I 80 f! 100' 100 110' 110' 120 120 I 130 130 ,. I ! ! 140 '150 150 Width in Width in '. .' ,S:: ' ..... s:: ..... "4 160 170 170 g"" ...:l siza. 2.8 2.8 2.4­ 2.4 1 180 160 190. 200 210 llm •. .' 1igure. 3. Lengthwidth Length-widthrelationship relationship of male ure3. male Dungene~s Dungenes crabs;­ crab." Data compiled· by by Dale Dale Snow, Snow, Oregon Oregon Fish Fish Comiiission1 Commission, 1967. Data compiled 1967. . ..c u 3.1 3.1 legal I ."'" '~ ~in~um ~ 10 60' . ~0 4.3 ;".5 90 , Il.I 00.., f .~ ~ .:::UCJ 3.9 J bQ ...... 1y.7 4.7 ~