Department of Materials Science and Engineering
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
3.044 Materials Processing - Spring 2013
Exam II
Wednesday, May 1, 2013
The Rules:
I) No books allowed; no computers allowed; etc.
2) A simple calculator is allowed
3) Two hand written 3x5 index cards may be prepared as a crutch.
4) Complete 5 out of the 6 problems. If you do more than 5 problems, I will grade the first
5 that are not crossed out.
5) Make sure that you READ THE QUESTIONS CAREFULLY
6) Supplementary materials are attached to the end of the test (eqns., etc.)
7) WRITE YOUR NAME HERE:
Problem #1: Multiple
Driving Forces Conspire to
Print out a Film of Fluid
Consider a fluid printing
process comprising both
pressure and applied velocity.
H
Examine the diagram at the
left, which shows how the
-\ •
process works. Fluid is
1'\
placed into a vessel with a
narrow channel releasing it
onto a substrate. The whole process is at constant temperature, and the vessel slides across the
surface towards the left to emit fluid out the lower right as shown.
V
~
We are going to set up a fluid flow model for the channel region (which is the region of
thickness ho in the picture, and which you may assume is thick into the page.) The fluid flow
will be assumed to be a laminar, Newtonian 1-D problem in which flow is along the x-axis and
momentum transfer is along y.
Part A) In the channel region, both pressure and applied velocity drive flow. Explain, using one
sentence each, where these driving forces come from.
t'e.~::ssuP-E- ''"'~ \1E.A.D P~Z£-s ">U~E. Vf...c:sl"" -rwc.. ~E_IL:ii-!T oF
11-l£: FLV'D
REs.E..YGIJa. ;liP =J'j~; Q\{fJ2._\lJE.. D'"-TANC..-E o~L.
A f P tJ \0.5.::> '-if-L«-rr'i • lt-\S 1 Df' s.u e..\-Ac.E CR TI-lE CJ\ AN NE. L
1'1\ o'-JE S
rl'-1'= ~ 0
'\1-lf. LC'N-8<.. <:,.r)lt.. FAC.f:., 1\.lt:: Moll~ f\1
.
~ ~C.-11 ._f ) f"-R..O \) '!::, c S A. S~ "-.C..c Of f\1\<:J !Y\f.Nf-JV\ I c: D~ I\}'\':
-
\
,
)1'1 "TlJ~
Part B) Draw the channel region, apply a coordinate system to it, and then specify boundary
conditions needed to solve the problem.
.
~
~?.h__
-~:~ ~,0--~-~ ~~~~:--
L
~~
'i=-
6) ~(
'I
At
01
'i ~ ~0
0
\f==
/
\j :::::S'sJ_
.
--
-\\
L
d \/y. =- f 3 'f + n (,__
(o-_pj\ J /A '>J 'dy
)A-L
,_
(L-o)
j<!~
__ pal-l-/"
A+~
'd~ _
J(pvx) _
-fa'f
2
_fo d1 Vx + n~
-
"''·~<~,-,_
.o
c·"
.,..,. It'
'i·l\
D
J
'\
"'
'I
7..
''l.v><
d
. ~'j.,_
L
-
p · 3 t-1
.T_p-L
~
{.. .
IYx:
f
t~>"\i Vy.. -
"
MP t..'i
f1\
lV
· -·
Iv~ = £;2 (~~~~~'L)~+~~I ~oN
Part C) Solve for the flow profile, assuming that the process has reached stea state and that
flow is laminar. (You may try to call on an analogy to provide a solution, but that ay prove
more challenging than simp~ ~~ing it).
·~. ~
(\
A __:~-
1'-l r:> 11 ~11.. -S'Tot:..t:S ·_
;j{.
~6\.)N!)~Q..'j C.<JN!)\IIoN:,_ ·
2
®
\
fLo VV,
_____::;,
~~-~
, ..)
+
/-'- L 1.
B ::.. 0 .
'f
''-tl
~
...
+ .:P 3
H1 -"·
Zf L
Dj
j"
I
/
.
1-1 1.'---+
""
Alh.. .../
·~
= -~L.
v'o
()
Y\:
0_9.0
Problem #2: A Single Question That Addresses Virtually Every Possible Heat Transfer
Situation of Relevance to Casting
We are casting a liquid into a mold with a very large cavity of dimension L, which has a finite
wall thickness(< L), is not cooled internally, and which is sitting in ambient air.
Part A) Draw a picture of this casting situation along with a temperature profile at a general,
arbitrary time after casting, with no additional assumptions.
Part B) There are five possible rate-limiting heat transfer processes in this scenario. Identify
them all. For each of these, consider what would happen if it were the controlling process, and
indicate how the solidification time should scale with the size of the mold, L.
o
1
1D
'({V:SLS":J
\
A1~<....
u o. v,
s(Jt__
lM --------- - I
@ <;,uPEili'£~7E')
L\41./l;::,
-~ \~~~~~£
rJ\
' Al <:, _
1® (.6NfYJGT101'1
1N till' $6\.t 6
)
c
)
\fil cl(.fA'-f
® (.() N e,\)c..TIOI"l)
D
IN
!i-l£ ""
!Y<<TLwo
)
£.
;V\iSL.O
Problem #3: A Casting Microstructure is Analyzed by the Student
Here is a schematic cross-section of a solidified casting of a binary aluminum-rich alloy, along
with the phase diagram that goes with it.
tQmie h-rcent Coppe-r
,... •
f..l AT
"E
,
Q
»
--
40
~
-"',.-.X...:
L
-
l
'f!. ""
~-
~1
..
-~~-~~~~~~~~~-M~~~~~~~-·
...
..
El.ll t 011 (_
I'\ \(}2.£SIV?~ 12.{.
•AI
Part A:
e icht
Pe-~nt
Copper
Cu
By inspecting these exhibits, we can conclude that in this casting, the diffusion must have been
rapid in the liquid. Explain why.
\\\t:P-.t r\I'Lf
\-\ ~I)
(',
t\Jo !)cNDtc.Jif;"))
\_) N I t' 6fUY\.._
SC
1\-l£
U~v'D
--i\l (2_J:NOIJ~ ~~
C.o fv\ P<.l S I T\ ()'('<.!
MIJSI ~4Vt:".
SOL. I~ 1r: I U f'o.TiaN,
PartB:
What is the composition of the alloy just to the right of position 'X', and just to the left of 'X'?
I 'yI,
\o "T~c U::.f'i:
~'
'of\'\Po<:,\\1
o-N
-rut -elJ(E:.c.."nc... IE:Mf.
\o '\\.IE ~l()/J7: (.oMPoSl71,J/\.I IS
I w'6
E VI t:-v"1\ C... 'Is I"' P.
I
\S.
1
li.l ~~
Cs-=-
/~A-r
61='" 1(1-t::
0 w-r%
1$ -n-it-
u~i.!10t..iS
C.~_::: ))w,o/o Cu
Problem #4: The Student Recalls that Casting also Involves Fluid Flow
Consider two investment casting processes, which
we shall label 1 and 2:
In process I, we are using gravity-based pouring of
a molten metal to create an investment casting.
The mold is a tree of small components, each of
which is connected to the central sprue by a small
runner tube.
In process 2, the pouring is accompanied by rapid
centrifugation.
1
2
For each of the following parts, write NO MORE THAN TWO SENTENCES.
Part A:
The production staff working with process I have noticed that part quality (especially porosity)
seems to depend on a part's position in the tree. Specifically, the parts on the bottom are usually
less porous than those on the top. Why?
~~~Dtrtc.A-ri<Sf'J PILcrCED!CS f'f?.ASM
BOTTofV\ Vf'/ 8a\TOM \S
-n1E:.
\Mfi)~\T'i -foo iL 1
1')'1
IMPOP.--flltS.
~\)Sf) t-t.
Part B:
S6
s
loP 1 S
£,6\\cnM
f<..\'S:.~
1/'f\e'liR.If) ··-Aiel-\.
E'XY"ff'..AF-NC..t=:':l
PoQ.o"S;I7"/ IS cAU.SfD
\~IGj\\1::.12. \..lt.~\''J Pltf<;,s~e.~1
<::JV\,
In process I, what is the kinetically limiting part of the process (i.e., where is fluid flow the
. ~ \J 0<.
L.
slowest) and why?
A..Pj
\t-lE.
--roP
F6R. FLCV'/ IS C-dl.Av\7'1 6NL"f So f\)
LtSS f'!2.fS'S>V~f ~8'\D l)t?.JVES MEL/ ti\J,
DJ?-11/INC;j \=.s£Lc
o'l- 1\~E
~~~vS,
li<-H.. 1
(iU.. It\i~
~E -reP of -(WE !~E.. \ S
\(.tiVE"Tl
cAU '1
(We
L I Mill IV~.
Part C:
In light of your answers to Parts A and B, explain how process 2 might lead to better uniformity
of parts located differently in the tree.
C..EJ•.rf(U F'u(')f~"r'.oN
\
\~£
k\NETJC..
D\2-1 -J ES ·fLt..h D 1Nt'o
L\fv'\11\'TklNS
cA'J li1ES 1 o'J E~ca(Y\lf\J5]
ALL
IDENl"\.fiE:!)
1N
(\3) 1
AND
SCLID\i'tcftilcN
NoW
Pr2.oCf'D£ (LI\Dir\lL'I iNW/.\l'LD
SIIJTINC.)
IN ltJE
(ji]I'C.t2-lN'oS.I Pol"Ll"IJN o~ (t~£ PAILI':,/ dV E~c.&{V)u-Jq liJE LJ/\11 \ltYll<JNS"
\Nti...-L
\1)\::N\\\Jt.O \N (A.) 1 DRI'.Jii'-16.) \l-It frY\pl)fUTi(S 10
S f'j?_..U \:; . \N l~ I Gl I <, ...,._ y./ f>r 5 '"IE 11 -A. N'I W i\ '1,
\JJE
CfNTAAL
Problem #5: Blowing Hot and Cold
Below are five scenarios in shape forming. In each case, there is a question about how a change
in temperature can impact the process. For each, indicate whether an increase or a decrease is
the required change, and explain in ONE SENTENCE why this is the case.
A) A sheet being stretch-formed is developing a local thin region that leads to a rupture.
The engineer in charge would like to introduce a local air jet that would either heat or
cool the material near the thinning region.
\tM'ff:I2.-A\Vf2t
\Nc:.JZ..CASE
E> t: ~~A. \j I CIC._ ~
\)t:U'-\Of\'~G-
s.I
0~
"T\J£ <;\4£E.T -----?
~A IN 51
AD t_t::_
Nt'N\ eN I A.N- L \ ~
1' \-\1:f
1UJ -i'l\)12..£
~~~~f' )__.JfC~'>-U'i \N~i~.f ;Z..i)fTI.he.f u(\:J.Ii2..S
\)f: CJZ...~-~<;.f Sff_iM'".J
...
f.~f j
8<-.Cttt f'l2\u/?_ "\0
TEMI'St?..A-TJR£
'10
l'lJ\"\U~~-RATOAE.ltl
..·~~~~~
.
B) Aluminum is being shape formed at a stress of I
MN/m2 and 300° C; the ductility is insufficient to
form the desired part geometry. A deformation
mechanism map is provided for this material.
J::>Ecfl-t:I:!.St,_
'fY\CiR..£
-"!>
, ')\~~ IN t)\f~V)Ioi'/1'-liL ~
(Y)
\
<; -
j_ : -~-.
__c..__
C) A thermoplastic is being continuously film-blown into a large tube. The plastic is
coming out cloudy.
C\..-0 \.\ D"i =. 'P y2._f: <;.t r..J C.f
Of
ce.'-1 ':::>1' ~ L-LI t
~ Tt oN
--s
bt:(.fo.:C-~S£ I~MP€:1'-.AT\Jf-E: ~ 5TP."t l?:,t::LliN
'f LA STI C •
1N 'lW !:.
D) Glass is being poured continuously onto a bed of molten tin. The waves created on
pouring are not damping fast enough, and the sheet is coming out non-planar.
---:s:.Nc.R~
~'.JZ~'~'ilE-ll-A\U~E:
~
iDECR.~s-E.
~ --ltN\E \o '((£~(.}1 s\t:.A.D'j--STt;,.·Tf
b
~ f\i\. P'C D
fu"i' .f"\\1
<::,~ -.
v'1sco~n'1
I~EO'E~S.ES/
~~
-f..-y..f' ( -
or- c.1 LAs~
OScHUrf!of\f..S
,f~ -:A-*
'
)
E) A melt is being sprayed into an atomization chamber to create powfe& These are
coming out irregularly shaped instead of spherical.
\ N Cf'-fA S.t
-N;;=
p
6
1\.l-s
--r t: f\'\P£e.A'TiJ f2.E: -".!>
I 1\1 eft- EA 'S£
--nrY\.E KS
Si:ll.. t D\ r I c.Afl oJ"'.l
~
eAe.~iic.l-E.S, \-ll'lvE ltM£ To Si-lAP£-fQu,Lt6!<-41't D0E. IO
u. f'l L.LA rz_'i yQQ_C£ &G f 61<-:'E (- 12.. -c E ~ tt\JC.:j ~ -n..lt"J (.ofv\'t ()l.SI SPIJfttJCilL
Problem #6: What a Drag
The graph below indicates how tbe friction factor (proportional to the drag force) on a spherical
particle in a flow changes with the Reynolds number of the flow.
\
--·-.;:':}-
Now consider a particle of a different shape: a thin disk, which is oriented such that its face is
into the flow.
Briefly describe how the friction factor might be different, in both the laminar and turbulent
regimes. Draw a schematic curve on the graph above that is consistent with your written
comments.
liJt: E.D~E ':,
Is
NG\}IIN Gj
f
AS,
ESfCJSYV\cS
-:f
').<
Fat.M
0,
CJ2..<>~s-.....,
~p IJ ER:f:
j
~'
MIT OpenCourseWare
http://ocw.mit.edu
3.044 Materials Processing
Spring 2013
For information about citing these materials or our Terms of Use, visit: http://ocw.mit.edu/terms.