Department of Materials Science and Engineering
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
3.044 Materials Processing- Spring 2012
Exam I
Wednesday, March 14, 2012
The Rules:
1) No books allowed; no computers allowed; etc.
2) A simple calculator is allowed
3) One hand written 3x5 index card may be used as a crutch
4) Complete 5 out of the 6 problems. If you do more than 5 problems, I will grade the first
5 that are not crossed out.
5) Make sure that you READ THE QUESTIONS CAREFULLY
6) Reasonable assumptions are permitted, but please state them clearly.
7) Supplementary materials are attached to the end of the test (eqns., etc.)
8) WRlTE YOUR NAME HERE:
Problem #1: In Which A Curious Shape is Heated
A complex shape of steel is shown below; it is long into the page (this is a cross-section).
Af'f..o'/.. .
25 em
R.A'ttUMITINC:f
SPa-r
.
~I
In the heat treatment of this shape, we need the whole piece to achieve a temperature between
600° and 625° C for 2 hours.
Part A:
Our engineers claim that we have a unique process that can instantaneously fix the surface
temperature at a desired value. What value should we choose? Write I sentence explaining your
choice.
(p25e>C
-·\~E AR-E !oL-D THAI IHt WHoLE
I? \EC...E ~MVSI &IE"
f::ICT v--JE£N GOo' & 01Bc c.._ 1 SO
C.J-\ooSINCq ~2')"' vJout.-D ~S!.)L.:T \N 11-\E: FASTt:ST
PartB:
H~A'll r--16] PoSSI&LE:.. Wi--n-\OtYT g xc..E£ CINGl
!t-IE-
D£SI~
e:,cJND~.
Obviously, this shape is complicated, but we still need to know how long it takes to heat the
whole thing up once we apply our process from Part A. In 4 sentences or less, explain how you
would make a good estimate of the heating time for this specific part.
--} 1\-\ E ~PiTt:- LiMilil\lq
S,PoT
IS TH£
Pol NT
f'At<.:n-l~SI
Al'i'l SO~FAL£.
_...,., ON£ vJA'i "Tc fll\cOCL Hf.~Til\)~ ~ APPr<...o'XiMATE 11-JE..
1~14.£.5\ Loi:SE ot= -r\1£ Ptu. . ~ AS AN , l~f'H-.ItT£
f'"f<-.OyV\
c_,-n..JND£1<..... ~EN;
Part C·
oo
-ro
? & C:r :
FIN.D
IA6L.i:~
fell<.._
~ S c.f'l'-1 AND FiN.D "Ti-lE
Ir
:\
0.. liiZ.S-~
oLl/1
H£~1 1\.lE. C£I'IT'Et2.... 1..~= 0) \o l.!::\1 =&is -1.S -= (}, -I L
L)s,E ,e.A.D10S-= (<._
C'1UNDEI<.
· tl ME
iJSE
J
Well, it turns out that our engineers were wrong- although our process heats the surface fast, it is
5
2
not instantaneous. It actually has a convective surface coefficient that is high-about 10 W/m s.
Explain briefly how this changes your answers ~om Parts A an~.
-7
Bi
= l;.l.. ::: ( \05
\<..
--? ~ 1 Nc..£ ~~ > > 10
vJfM"-k) (D-,"2S
~31- W(Mi<..
1
5o out( p..NS'i'Jef<-,S
~
~/
CJ:;,Nvt:.c.TJCf'.i 1-s.
-ro A &;_B
2 ~ 1- G >> 10
(ui'Pt:P-. eavri.D oN
\
1..._)
c)(Tre..ErAEL-"f FA~-r..~
~Rf
UNc..A~ANL::jE.D.
Problem #2: Newtonian or Non-Newtonian
We always enjoy a problem when conduction is fast relative to the competing processes, don't
we? For each of the following situations, figure out whether or not the cooling will be
Newtonian.
B) A 2 mm thick plate of alumina ceramic is cooling in still air at a temperature of 1500° C.
'6\::
~= (1o w'/..tK...J(.o.oo2 "') ::::. o.ou'L
k
("-' \0
w/Mk..)
-8
eCJl "13 _ ("-'CJ,I-\r))C5,(,!,d0_
k
v-J;
1
::: o.o3
e,: '" o.1-
'"'\ (o co2M J (
"""-k)
~ \ 0 """I"" ~)
St.Ji1.F
\
.
I
...::;> No
!
\Of"'""
Cc_ot.-D)
hz\0 wjM."z.K
f\1
~-;:;:_ 235
) i (~crT)
vfMJ<.
'b·-
---
G~ltl'f\S ~J ~€vJ\cN' A.~~J
C) A thin film of aluminum just I 0 J.lm thick is sitting in still argon gas on a silicon
substrate; the whole stack is cooled from 600° C.
\
_
Ar
,"
1'800ky
5
\
-
'hL- (\ow/.,_"-kJ(\D M}- L) ;<.\0
23 S ""'/M..K...
I-
-c -
0 ·.
L~
~ No
o .'L
C:::!~\fNT s.
;~N~T~,~oJj
Problem #3: Serial or Parallel Casting
........... ·-··
We are going to do some sand casting, of metal objects that are all the same size. We will do it
two different ways, named process I and II. Here are schematics ofthe molds:
I
II
Part A:
Draw a schematic of how the solidification process occurs in process I, by charting the location
of the solidification front vs. time. Make sure you show the point where the solidification is
complete. Explain the shape of the curve in one sentence.
T
PartB:
Draw a· similar chart for the center of the three objects in process II. Explain how it is different
from your answer in part A, or if it is the same; why it is the same.
s!i\
L
Problem #4: See Spot Weld. Weld, Spot, Weld.
Spot welding involves a pair of electrodes, which are used to
apply a high current through two laid-up sheets, as shown
here. Take the sheets to be 0.5 mm thick each.
Heat is generated evenly within the two sheets as a
consequence of the current passing through them (resistive
heating). Melting eventually occurs, and solidification on
cooling yields a joint between the sheets.
metal
sheets
electrodes
In this problem, you will consider the heating portion of this process.
Part A:
Write down the full form of the heat conduction equation that we need to understand heat flow in
the sheets. Be sure to use the proper coordinate system-the system is radially symmetric .
•
dT = o<. \!'2. T +
d~
~AD\~1..-L'-i- S'-IMME-1~1'- C..~LINDR.IcAL... LoO(Z..DINATE
yd<.. A
Part B:
-fi-r
= (_I_r ~a (('
\dl
~
o(
Ql \
2J I )
+
rr
~
d ~t.)
-f- .3..,___
f
Cf
---------------~--~
If the sheets are steel, and we are welding
in air, indicate whether or not we need to consider
~
\
convection at the free surfaces.
v • _ ""J::-_ _
K
o_
""'J
Ll.
..::.. <::.
~
\2
U'l No
\<_ -
(1- o ""/.v-."-
o. o 5
::: 0 , OD1
(31 W/M.'f...)
C;:)~DIEHS
IN
\f \ 1\ coN \J -E. c.....116f\J
9
~
~ NEyL~bLE
rr:;;- No-r
1
H~p.-r LOSS ----
CCNSI O€(<.._
Write down all the boundary conditions and initial conditions that we need to solve this problem.
Please make sure that these are consistent with your answer to part B. Also-you may assume
th the sheets ave no interface resistance between them.
~-c. ~
AT
1:
t= 0/
~=~ -l > 0/ r<-IZ-;
y-
\
13 .c.
=\\-z·.
E.V£R...'IV\1\-J~£.
\-=-To
AT
B.C. -\\3'· P..,l
B.C. l\:-Lf: FaR..
I:::
('
C>D /
> (<._I
I= lo
= 0)
(JT
~/
~T~
ALL
tl'f
=-- 0
::::.
-1
..L.
C.CNII-f'-Tl~
Part C:
I.e:
,...,
u ·
Q .
Problem #5: A Heat Balance Problem-How Can You Even Think About Skipping This?
Here is a small (differential) element from the cylindrical system, through which heat is
conducting. In general, there need not be any symmetry around 9, so there can be a heat
imbalance one as well as on r. For this problem let's stick to 2D, so you can neglect the z axis.
r~levant
.
9,..d
Part A: Draw all the
conductive heat fluxes (ins and outs)
on the diagram. Label the area (since we are only in 2D, length)
over which these fluxes act. (Hint: arclength is given by r·9)
A.i::. r .t. e
A2_=- (r+Ar)t>e
A e'" f::s_
r+Llr
'
~
r
t-ur
SL£fV\€ ('f7
'\f cs '- oJ Mf_ ~
\1==-r.c.rlle
e
't:N
Part B: Write out the heat balance equation for this system, including one term for each of the
('
e
r balance elements in the picture.
.
~;~
A
QIN - OovT ==-~--~~.:..=I;-~ ceN -:__: ~N
-·----~--.........---·---·e
' __b
~~UV\ =
8
I A
6
A q"~
2. ~VT
-~ LJT
A
-
e I
r
~~ -r ~ r ~-:·~--t ~~) ~-~_:c~-=~-~--t:-.J
Part C: Simplify your expression from part B, and derive the heat conduction equation in radial
,
...:. _
\.:_'\I
coordinates. (Hint: you can check your answer)
::
61
9 . FOt..l~IELS LAV'J' Q - q ACCUM. \) Lf a-f
0< ,
. -r L
_i_
T
~
.
0 Cp
J
.
OCp
J
·
.
-
r-t.r
(-~.rrf
Cl r
(
=
k
-..-t
~
o
CC -;: - k ~
J
crl- ...r.
~
~
t"
\
\
I
-t- - 1 " \
r)
r r:,oo
dTj
(-1-~\\,a) r
(r+ArJ <lr r-+6( ' - r-.
r-
o
oT) r
?:f
1
-t
AI:
\<- .
a a-r +
_-.:: _r_
-(~~\
_pcpl r- or
)
61
~{:
e_ k
j_
r'2..
(
LH"'
I
\
-k.~
01
'1-
br"
-t-
CC --
r
-
~
ae .
\-k-dT \ \ \
rd{) (l"ioi'r!
-I
rJ- rr:id
_
1
I
'dT \ - 0 \ \
K-2
i)d I e+~{) <)tl e )
r
,..,
'l..l]
L;)92
C.'O
;
Problem #6: Casting Plus Bells and Whistles
On the right is the phase diagram of ure
titanium, which you intend to melt, su erheat
and cast into a mold. You will conduct t 1s
operation at I atm of pressure ~in the
diagram at the right).
1
heXl3J
12
j'
(wJ
:
Draw a picture that captures the essential features
of the temperature profile in a titanium casting.
Your drawing should assume a@heat flow .
problem, but should include all of the following
elements: A cas · which is inside a mold
which i actively coole .
J
~
/\\
;(' \
s
hcp
/
)" (~J
r «l
11.cf'
no
.r--.+_,IT"bcc
500
.
~
1oao
e,c.<...
T~
1500
~
:cl:l
,o,:
,o'
1/
Liquid
1ooo
2500
'\ .
Draw your schematic of the temperature profile
.
"T;jp T"'
for an arbitrary time after solidification has begun, and WITHOUT any simpli:fy'ing assumptions.
Label every boundary condition that should be applied.
\~Cf oZ
tv
\9C~K
o=-
1:
t
BeL
f
uqv1D
1--
"'IZ<P IZ =: 1:J~
iN'TEIV' ActS
-
R.6t5l' t-.Nc..f
"---?
~,C-\\
i
~ f\T
&.c.~2:
~';:,.c..%-)"·
A \f"
\-\~ -">(3
S\£rf>N
#0 /
TJ.lt:N WE. WILL
c..,oNDil\(j1'J
A.i
A L.SO )-ll'Wf A
X:::::'/-."'(~ •
MIT OpenCourseWare
http://ocw.mit.edu
3.044 Materials Processing
Spring 2013
For information about citing these materials or our Terms of Use, visit: http://ocw.mit.edu/terms.