11-‘11, I AUDITION/LC EVALUATION Of VARIABLES AND MATERIALS IN THE RECOVERY OF WET FIBER MATS FROM COMPRESSIVE DEFORMATION April 1942 RESTRICTED CLASSIFIED DOCUMENT This document contains classified information affect in the National Defense of the United States wit meaning of the Espionage Act, USC 50:3 transmission or the revelation of ' manner to an unauthorized )ers i to I y law. Information so classifie b only to perI sons in the mil' t% ices of the United States, app officers and employees of the F nt who have a legitimate interest United States Citizens of known loyalty cm who of necessity must be informed 4 ET ; CH LA I:3 0 RA 1 - 0 Y aR, A RY No. 1295 UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE FOREST SERVICE FOREST PRODUCTS LABORATORY Madison, Wisconsin In Cooperation with the University of Wisconsin tm e-6 ADDITIONAL EVALUATION 0: VARIABLES AND MATERIALS IN THE RECOVERY OP WET _FIBER MATS PROM COMPRESSIVE DEFORMATION 3y C. O. SEBORG, Assistant Chemist And F, A. SIMMOADS, Associate Chemist ABSTRACT At constant temperature, the recovery values for wet fiber mats from compressive deformation were little affected until the surface tension of the suspensions was reduced to. about 60 dynes per centimeter, but further reduction resulted in marked, though variable, effects. Irrespective of the effect on the recovery value, a decreased surface tension always resulted in a decreased shrinkage of the test mat upon drying in air. The surface tension of ordinary pulp suspensions is the range where recovery values are not affected. At the same surface tension and temperature, different wetting agents, although not at the same concentration, resulted in different recovery values. This is taken to indicate adsorption of the wetting agent and its influence on the recovery values by a change in the condition of the external fiber surface. At constant surface tension and variable temperature, no consistent trends were found, recovery values for some pulps increasing with increasing temperature, others decreasing, and some remaining unchanged. As duration of compression was increased, the recovery of unbeaten and slightly beaten pulps was reduced considerably and in about the same degree, but the effect became progressively less with increased beating. These increases in degree of plastic deformation were indicated by the results of recovery determinations made on screen classified size fractions from a beaten pulp and also from groundwood pulps to be due to increasing development of "fines." The fact that groundwood pulps have lower recovery values than sulfate and sulfite pulps is also due to the larger percentage of fines in the sulfite pulps. It was confirmed that sulfate pulps, as a class, are higher in recovery than sulfite pulps. R1295 -1- INTRODUCTION In a previous reportl the recovery from compressive deformation of a bleached southern pine sulfate pulp was shown to have decreased 25 percent, apparently linearly, as the temperature of the wet mat was increased over the range of 13 to 42° C. The surface tension of the water was not controlled in this instance and, although the change in the value was relatively small, it was necessary to recognize that two variables were undergoing change simultaneously. A study was made at the Forest Products Laboratory to determine if the effect of these two variables could be isolated. Data were obtained on both the influence of duration of compression and screen fractions on recovery values. The results of these studies are here presented APPARATUS AND PROCEDURE The apparatus and procedure used ars essentially the same:as-previously doecribed.1 Improvements have been made, however, by providing means for controlling the temperature and eliminating possible side components of force during compression. The latter is achieved by transmitting pressure from a lever through a piston to a ball bearing automatically centered in a plunger in direct contact with the pulp mat. This apparatus is shown in figure 1. The temperature control apparatus, diagrammed in figure 2, maintains the selected temperature of 25° O. within 4. 0.5° C. This degree of accuracy holds over a range of 11° to 75° C., provided the water entering the heater is at constant temperature. In operation, artesian water at a temperature of 11° to 12° C., available throughout the year, was passed from an adjustable constant level device through the heater and then to the compression apparatus. An Occasional slight adjustment of the constant level apparatus offset the small variation in the temperature of the entering water. Temperature control in the 11° to 75° C. range was accomplished by using various sized orifices to regulate the rate of flow of water to the heater. The stream of constant temperature water passed through a copper coil in a hollow plunger of the compression apparatus and overflowed to a diked base, thus keeping both sides of the mat at the desired temperature. Prior to compression, the pulp mats were brought to the desired temperature by conditioning in ,a constant temperature bath. The weight of the wet mats prior to pressing was standardized at 50 grams, since this was found to improve repetitive accuracy. In the earlier trials, the weight of the pulp samples on the moisture-free basis was 6 grams. It was later found with the improved apparatus that a sample weight of 4 grams could be used. 1Paper Trade J. 109(8):35-42. Aug. 24, 1939. R1295 -2- The surface tension of the effluent obtained when the mats were formed was measured with a DuNoi3y interfacial tensiometer at a temperature of 25° ± 2° C. The wetting agents "Aerosol OT" and "Nacconal NR" were used to adjust the surface tension. EFFECT OF DURATION OF COMPRESSION As the duration of compression was increased, the recovery of the unbeaten and slightly beaten pulp was reduced considerably and in approximately the same degree, but the effect became progressively less with increased beating, as shown in figure 3. This trend is the same as that reported previously1 on 12-gram samples (moisture-free basis) of unbeaten and beaten bleached loblolly pine sulfate pulp. In the present instance it was observed that recovery values, except for the stuff lowest in freeness, continued to be reduced after the thickness of the mat had reached a constant value. Recovery determinations made on screen-classified sized fractions from both beaten pulp and mechanical pulps indicated the increases in degree of plastic deformation to be an immediate result of the development of fines. Possibly the more slender fibrils and fibrilated fibers in the pulp were distorted to a greater curvature without exceeding the elastic limit than were the whole undamaged fibers in the unbeaten pulp. Therefore, probably fewer f i ber s exceeded their elastic limit in the neaten pulp than in the unbeaten pulps. Furthermore, such plastic flow as did occur in the beaten pulp might not show its effect, because the recovery of the beaten pulp was in the lotv, insensitive range of the determination. RECOVERY OF SCREEN-CLASSIFIED SIZED FRACTIONS Chemical Pulp: In figure 4, the recovery value of the coarse fraction from a beaten bleached softwood alpha pulp is compared with other samples comprising the coarse fraction plus increasing percentages of a fine fraction passing 115-mesh and retained on 150-mesh, as well as with this fine fraction alone. Increasing the percentage of fines decreased the recovery, the unit effect being greatest with the first 25 percent added. The effect • of fines is further emphasized by comparing the recovery values of the 115-to 150-mesh and 24-meSh fractions and the whole pulp, which were 45, 79, and 55 percent, respectively, Groundwood Pulpsf Recovery values of fractions and also the whole pulps of several groundwoods are given in figure 5, with the same influence of fines in R-1295 -3- evidence. In this instance, however, the finest fractions collected (between 115-and 150-mesh) were, for each pulp, still higher than (roughly twice) that of the whole pulp. The fraction passing 150-mesh was not collected, but it seems obvious that this is the fraction which is responsible for the final reduction of the recovery of the whole pulp. Of the five groundwoods, southern pine had the highest percentage of fines Massing 150-mesh. The higher recovery value of this pulp, in spite Of the larger amount of fines, is attributed to the fact that this groundwood had a greater amount of gummerwood fibers than the other pulps. It has been showna that summerwood fibers are markedly stiffer than springwood fibers, and that fiber stiffness is a major factor influencing recovery. When the opportunity occurs, the recovery of similar coarse fractions, before and after purification to various degrees, will be compared with that of corresponding ones from chemical pulps. RECOVERY OF UNBLEACHED SULFATE AND SULFITE PULPS USING IMPROVED APPARATUS The order of magnitude of recovery values of groundwood pulps as determined with the improved apparatus is shown in figure 5. Similar data for sulfate and sulfite pulps from the same species are Given in table 1. These results confirm previous indications that sulfate pulps are higher in recovery than sulfite pulps. It was of interest to note that the recovery value of the southern pine groundwood was practically as high as the highest value for the sulfite pulps listed. EFFECT OF TEMPERATURE, SURFACE TENSION NOT CONTROLLED The recovery of a bleached southern pine sulfate pulp had been found previously to decrease 25 percent, apparently linearly, as the temperature was increased from 13° to 42° C. with no control of surface tension. Additional data dealing with this relation for two unbleached pulps over the temperature range of 0° to 42.5° C. are in figure 6. In this instance neither the recovery nor the surface tension was markedly affected by changes in temperature. Since the recovery of some pulps varies with temperature, this variable must be controlled at all times. In those instances in which the variation due to change in temperature was greater than the variation due to repetitive determinations, it was found that temperature control within 2° C. was adequate. It was observed that surface tension tended to decrease somewhat during beating, as is indicated by the data in table 2. Paper Trade J., 113(17):49-50 Oct. 23, 1941. R-1295 -4- EFFECT OF TEMPERATURE UPON ZECOVERY AT REDUCED SURFACE TENSION Occluded Foam: When a pulp suspension at greatly reduced surface tension was agitated prior to mat formation, a great deal of foam was formed and subsequently occluded in the mat. This resulted in extremely bulky mats probably due to both the reduced contracting force of the water and the mechanical resistance -of the foam. It was necessary, therefore, to determine if the increased recovery values observed at reduced surface tension were the result of the entrapped air bubbles under pressure, since, as shown by the data in table 3, solid fraction determinations on the wet mats revealed greater void volumes in-the mats under pressure at reduced surface tension than in those at normal surface tension. Deaerating the pulp suspensions in a vacuum prior to the forming of the mat helped little because considerable foam was formed again when the suspension was poured into the deckle box for mat formation. It was found, however, that deaeration of the mats after formation under repeated vacuum treatment removed the foam. The average recovery values in table 4 of mats with and without the presence of foam are in good agreement, showing the presence of foam to be without effect upon the recovery values at reduced surface tension. Temperature Effect at Reduced Surface Tension: The effect of temperature on recovery at reduced surface tension is illustrated in figure 7. The recovery values of the unbeaten and beaten sulfate pulp decreased with increase in temperature. This trend at reduced surface tension is opposite to that of the same pulp at normal surface tension. The influence of temperature on the sulfite pulp decreased to some extent as the degree of beating was increased. In the case of the sulfate pulp, the effect of temperature was not altered by beating. Of interest is the fact that both the unbeaten and beaten sulfate pulps showed higher recovery at reduced surface tension as compared to the values at normal surface tension, whereas, in the case of the sulfite pulp, the recovery of the unbeaten pulp was lower and that of the beaten pulp was higher at reduced surface tension. EFFECT OF SURFACE TENSION AT CONSTANT TEMRATURE To determine the effect of surface tension, the pulp suspensions, either with or without the wetting agent, were allowed to stand 16 hours R-1295 -5- before determining recovery. This procedure was adopted after erratic results were obtained with suspensions that had stood only a short time after the addition of the wetting agent. The influence of surface tension on recovery of unbleached unbeaten, and beaten Douglas-fir sulfate and sulfite pulps is shown in figures 8 and 9. It is apparent upon inspection of the recovery values at reduced surface tension, as adjusted with the two different wetting agents, that they had an appreciable direct effect, probably by virtue of adsorption, on the recovery characteristics of the unbeaten pulp. The direct effect, although greatly minimized, seems to persist in the beaten pulps. It is, therefore, not possible to draw from these data a simple relation, if one exists, between recovery and surface tension as varied by the wetting agents used. If, however, the recovery values at the lowest surface tension used are compared with those at the normal surface tension as given in table 5, it is seen that an appreciable increase in recovery did occur when the surface tension was reduced to approximately 30 dynes per centimeter. Surface Tension and Shrinkage: After determining the recovery of Douglas-fir sulfite pulp and stuffs, the mats were air dried at 65 percent relative humidity, the diameters measured, and the shrinkage calculated as a percentage of the diameter of the wet mat. The shrinkages at three different freeness values over a wide range of surface tension are plotted in figure 10.' Although the essentially linear decrease of shrinkage with decrease in surface tension may have been due partly to adsorbed wetting agent blocking fiber surface available for bonds, the reduction in surface tension is believed to be the major factor. For example, Campbell: a has shown by calculation that the surface and internal tensions of water evaporating from a fiber structure are great enough to account for a compacting force in causing the shrinkage of the structure. Effect of Weight of Pulp in Mats of Groundwood Pulps: The recovery of groundwood pulps of different species and of different weights of pulp in the mats is shown An figure 11. The influence of the amount of pulp in the mat is found to be the same with groundwoods as ,:rith the chemical pulps previously reported. The curves for the southern pine and birch are in a distinctly different category than those of the other groundwoods. The southern pine groundwood was markedly higher in strength than the other pulps although the birch possessed no outstandingly different strength properties as determined by the usual test methods. -Paper Trade J., 95(8):29-33, Aug. 25, 1932. R-1295 -6- Consequently, sample weight of 4 grams on the moisture-free basis has been selected as the standard weight for use with the improved apparatus. CONCLUSIONS Recovery of pulps and stuffs from compressive deformation was affected by the duration of compression. The longer the mat was pressed, the lower the recovery value, especially in the case of the unbeaten pulps, indicating the effect 'of plasticity of the fibers. Recovery values of chemical and mechanical pulps and stuffs which had been classified as to size of fractions showed the large influence of the fraction passing 150-mesh on the recovery of the whole pulp. It was confirmed that sulfate pulps as a class are higher in recovery than sulfite pulps, and both are higher than groundwood pulps. Tho effect of temperature on recovery values is a complex one, being influenced by such factors as surface tension, plasticity, and the physical condition of the fiber surfaces. At constant surface tension and variable temp erature there were no consistent trends, recovery values for some pules increasing with increasing temperature, others decreasing, and some remaining unchanged. When the surface tension was varied at constant tem perature with two different wetting agents, the latter were found to have a direct effect on the recovery characteristics of the pulp itself. This indicates that it will be extremely difficult to determine the exact effect of surface tension on recovery. It was, however, possible to show an increase in recovery at a sufficiently reduced surface tension. Fortunately, the normal surface tension of pulps and stuffs does not vary enough to necessitate control of surface tension in the recovery determination. Beating was found to reduce surface tension up to ? dynes per centimeter. Tho shrinkage of mats of unbeaten and beaten pulps upon drying in air decreased with decrease in surface tension, the effect becoming ;1-eater as the degree of beating was increased. Adsorption of wetting agent blocking off available surface for fiber-fiber bonds is recognized as a possible second factor in reducing shrinkage. As a result of the effect of the weight of pulp in mats of groundwood pulps on the determination (chemical pulps having been previously covered), a sample weight of 4 grams on the moisture-free basis was selected as standard. R-1295 -7- Table 1.--Recovery from compressive deformation of sulfate and sulfite pulps Species Recovery :Designation: number : Unbleached : Unbleached sulfite sulfate : Percent : : Red gum Average : •. Douglas-fir A •. Average Douglas-fir : 3 . Average Jack pine Average Western white pine : Average 1 -Sample weight 6 grams moisture-free basis, normal surface tension. R1295 100.0 101.5 103.0 98.5 100.8, : : '. : : 64.4 64.8 64.6 64.8 64.6 58.1 62.0 64.9 65.0 62.5 93.0 95.0 96.4 100.0 96.1 76.0 73.0 74.5 77.3 77.5 74.6 Percent : : : : 49.8 51.8 55.2 54.3 : 52.8 92.5 90.4 92.5 92.0 91.9 50.0 50.8 49.8 51.3 50.5 69.6 70.0 68.6 68.2 69.1 56.6 56.3 55.7 55.7 56.1 Table 2. Surface tension values of unbeaten and beaten Douglas-fir kraft and sulfite pulps Pulp Freeness Surface Tension S.-R, cc. Dynes Der cm. Sulfate, unbeaten 860 71.3 Sulfate, beaten 710 69.2 Sulfite, unbeaten 885 71.2 Sulfite, beaten 816 68.4 Sulfite, beaten 500 67.0 Sulfite, beaten 300 64.0 R1295 LA N, 11. \ • .0 LA LA 1'1 • ‘0 NJ 0 t• 1-1 • 0 0.1 02 cO 0 C r.-N 1.-- 10 \Z. .- LA N.1 r LA r•-n LA r•-. '45 W /A •-n 5 • 0 1 n-n .-I I.-- SO • .-I r•-n N- sO '5 4, 10 NJ N.- 1X) 0, CO • U1 11N VO • NJ r-1 LA ..* 01 • P1-1 0-1 1•11 10 • 0.1 I-1 LA -1) 01 • 0 150 • rn 1.41 ‘.0 • 1.0 r-1 LA r- 0 • • ri NI 0 r-- • 1X) .-I • .--1 e-I Os I-I 0. cs.) to trN tr, 1.-- as sO N.- 0 r- 50 SO o ,o 4 ..,, LA 6 6 sE\ LA CO • .--1 LA s%.‘ Cs • sE‘ CO • IN LA • ,-.1 -1' LA e-I 4 1-1 o I..--• Cfs N- .0 •4• 0, a. • 1-4 Os 150 Pn CO N\ S 1.11 .5 .56 4 •75' j:13- .5 1513 g sc; ,2 N1 • ..1- 1-1 \S 1,1 • .../. .-I \S‘ 150 CU 0, • • • CO en /-I LA LA LA el In 150 • P.,) 4-1 .. LIN • CV .0:A b3 4 .y ‘Z 0 r- sel r.-, LC\ CN 01 r•-n r•-n 5 o r- • O 0 LA Os r-- .-I • § rel el .d•0 0 150 . c.1 • N .0: O IN r-- • LI \ •-1 • N1 Ss' r•-, & N .4 so • 8 N r-- • In N- . LA • US r•-, P...1 • • o CY: e-I • ors • a, .-I o CV r-- • K1 LA 0 10 150 1N1 N.1 1).1 ,-.1 •-n • • 2 ,-I • CO g ro • T10 Z w • K\ g N.- • el r-os • 0 0 • IP • 150 . .0- • CV . • • • 8 8 LA N- r•-, • N- r.,-, • r-- • 10 r- Q 0 • 0 el • 0 el 0 0, rA _U1 10 in as N1 1*--- N. W N5 n-I .3 N re. • LIS • r•-, LA St r-1 K \ N1 N- • N 1 11; CU I-1 CO ON cr. ...I LC\ .-1 N1 en r.., r- 01 tel LA .d.0, CO 1` CV LA ri 4. N's CU rn-n• r.,-, • W 10 111 .4- • 1.1 •-1 N- ”,-n .-1 ro-N • a. .4 el I-1 • OS /0 IN Cr, • • • • 0 r•-n .../. )-1 )-1 .. .. .. .. .. .. .. 4 I, sia Os r-Os • CO IA V) OS • .4 8 a, ro. 4 1-1 Ul CT CO r-- I,- sO • ,..I f n .0 r- , 0 CO 1),;) ,-1 LA e•-, • ri ti41S ‘EN\%' 0 LAO s%‘ Os • LC) r+-) CO • ,C1 0, .3 0.1 111 .:N .7 el In IA • r•-., ON CT ON 0, • • • • Lf \ \.0 LA 0 el I, 1•4 .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. g LA .-1 LA IN1 ON • LA r- r•1 P, \ r•-, 0, NJ • r--- el 0, • LA szT ,./3 gi‘ w W N1 Vs • 1-.-5 r-1 1,\ Lc, V CU LA 411 • 0 CV r- 1.0 111 LA CO • 0 LC \ • CC, el LA 1))1 113 u, N- • IIN • .0 Lf \ ot-, N- • N- \JD • el reN.0 • CO ot-, 0, • c., N-, In LA LA r-- Lt\ 0 CUCT .• LA 'a 4 LA CO \-0 4 • . N r•-n 1Le1 1.-, .6 2 6-, 1--- \4 VS 0 •10 LA LIS • r.-. LA1.--- en NO CU g: a OS LA ''R 415 w,• 1-1 r.,-, 6‘ .6 0 r- sO• ,-, 1.-- • N- r.4 143 r- r•-. K1 0 0 N-1 u, s. )-1 NI 1)11 • ,-.n 1.-- \ .0 • e.1 V; 0 a, U • Ur\ In • \ .0 1•1 NI; ..., LIS CO CN .* sO• In ln • . VD H K1 .. .. .. .. .. .. .. NJ a) r- S.0• 0.1 1-- • r•-n 8-1 LA OS OS • r- el CU .13 0 1.11 1,\ • V) 0 r- 1.0. 1-1 141 0 r-1 0 0 OS N . SO 0) 01) I -o I. 4s.. 0 0 I 4444 0 •,., 4-1 C ; 1. S 0 n-1 i 0 1 41 .4, I g 44 , 44 4. g t 0 : 0 0 a -4 0.) 1-1 4. 4-5 ,•,f a' 2. 2 A 8 8 ot ot 1 F . 0 4.1 o ID L. 47, 0 ,, i' 2 r-1 e4 1.4Q-1 4.0 44 6444 4-, C0 0 0 0 0 0 1 t 1 S ..1 ' --a, ,:a 0 .r) .-• -.I 0 -r• E,1.6,,2,:xpiz ii' 4-1 0 s -el 1. 0 t to r-1 1 I •-• )-1 ''..i?. g ...1 t -49 a A Table 4.--Comparison of recovery values of mats with and without the p resence of foam Recovery from compressive deformation, Percent 11 Sulfite= Sulfate2 surface 2 surface::Normal surface :ReducedNormal surface :Reducedtension tension tension tension Normal: Deaer- : Mat : Deaer- ::Normal: Deaer- : Mat : Deaermat :ated mat :full of:ated mat:: mat :ated mat :full af:ated mat : foam • • : foam : •n•••n•••n•n•• 69.6 : 74.5 : 151.2 : 139.2 :: 55.6 : 53.8 : 73.0 : 71.6 70.0 : 71.5 : 146.0 : 148.6 :: 56.3 : 52.6 : 70.8 : 68.0 68.6 : 71.8 : 141.0 : 150.0 :: 55.7 : 53.4 : 76.3 : 70.3 68.2 : 72.2 : 143.5 : 141.4 :: 55.7 : 54,0 : 69.8 : 72.0 : 144.0 : 149.5 :: 148.3 : 147.2 :: : 59.3 : : 71.7 : 150.5 : 138.4 :: : 159.0 : Am69.1 : 72.5 : 148.0 : 144.9 :: 56.1 : 53:4 : 71.8 : 70.5 Western white pine. a Surface tension reduced to 28.5 dynes per centimeter with "aerosol OT" wetting agent. R1295 Table 5.--Oomoarison of average recovery values at normal surface tension and at approximatel y 30 dynes Der cm. Percent change Recovery at Kind of : Pulp :Freeness: S.-R. : surface tension : in recovery, Douglas-: or basis normal fir pulp: stuff value : Normal :30 dynes: : per cm.: cc. Sulfite : Pulp 885 Sulfate : Pulp 860 Sulfite : Stuff : 53 40 : 75 79 816 : 27 Sulfate : Stuff : 710 : 28 Sulfite : Stuff : 500 Sulfite : Stuff : 300 81295 : : - 13 : +-5 31 + 15 30 + 9.6 : 22 7.6 : 18 : 7 +129 +137 L.1 O cZ ti ti .1 ,L,,I. b. n NOTE. SAMPLE WEIGHT 6 GRAMS ON MOISTURE-FREE BASIS 11111 _1111h......mirmilli ERR -S.-R. imunii 01....1. II im........... _-_„imilm.......r-.--.......BEATE BEATEN 0 ._ ._ S.-R. FiREENESS 450cc. I 40 50 nn FREENESS 787cr 60 70 I 80 I., 90 100 120 130 140 DURATION OF COMPRESS/ON (MINUTES) FIG. 3 EFFECT OF DURATION OF COMPRESSION UPON THE RECOVERY OF UNBLEACHED JACK PINE SULFITE PULP AND STUFFS. 80 Ct kJ 75 A- RETAINED ON 54 MESH 0.7mm ON SIDE OF OPENING B- PASSING 1/5 MESH BUT RETAINED ON 150 MESH NOTE ' SAMPLE WEIGHT 4 GRAMS 01V MOISTURE-FREE BASIS ti 70 CC O 65 ri;") CL. k 60 t•J 55 cc W Lu 50 45 A 0 6 100 25 50 75 50 PERCENTAGE OF PULPS A AND B IN MAT 75 25 FIG. 4 Z U 40932 F RECOVERY VALUES OF SCREEN-CLASSIFIED SIZED FRACTIONS OF A BEATEN BLEACHED ALPHA PULP. 100 A 0 B 150 160 220 180 z /60 cZi (3-1 /40 120 &' 100 eifil. Nom= wrilm __........ Iwzmil td,--, ... p..11111111 - NOTE. SAMPLE WEIGHT 4 GRAMS, MO/STURE-FREE BASIS --rilllit sii.w...11._ PULP LL.1 80 recco .. zoo -rail 1M 0175 PERCENT} 150-K151 1 SCREEN PERCENT .38 49 42 54 53 56 52 45 40 0.351 /50 /15 FuLp o -COTTONWOOD 6,-BLACK WILLOW • - SOUTHERN PINE A- WHITE SPRUCE n - CONWRCIAL SPRUCE 60 0.1 PEcovEw Of wHoLE AH001IT PASSING 0.700 SIZE OF MESH OPENING(mm) 80 42 24 MESH FIG. 5 RECOVERY VALUES OF GROUNDWOOD PULPS AND SCREEN-CLASSIFIED SIZED FRACTIONS FROM THEM. 60 4-, 50 Q • • • 566 7/0 n —.1 •. sae 56.5 1----750 635 152.8 •,c 40 NOTE : SAMPLE WEIGHT 6 GRAMS ON MOISTURE-FREE BASIS THE NUMERICAL VALUES AT EACH 6ROUP OF PO/NTS ON CURVES REFER TO SURFACE TENSION IN DYNES PER CM. k L,-. 30 e 20 o -.57,5 Ck /0 4.1 563 560 54.3 • 52.0 0 54.0 0 S6.0 n 53.0 530 0 20 30 TEMPERATUREX) 520 40 560 50 F16.6 RELATION OF TEMPERATURE AND RECOVERY OF UNBLEACHED DOUGLAS-FIR SULFITE AND WESTERN HEMLOCK SULFATE PULPS AND STUFFS. (SURFACE TENSION NOT CONTROLLED) Z M 40929 F 100 I I , LEGEND UNBLEACHED DOUGLAS-FIR SULFITE •- UNBEATEN, 5-R FREENESS &Mc - 628ec q -BEATEN, 3-H 381a. • - BEATEN, 5-R - UNBLEACHED WESTERN HEMLOCK SULFATE o - UNBEATEN, S -R FREENESS 860cc 5/0cc. ° n - BEATEN ,S-R 1 NOTE SURFACE TENSION REDUCED' WITH.NACCONAL Nle SAMPLE WEIGHT 6 GRAMS ON MOISTURE-FREE 84515 90 ,•.1 ! Lk+ 80 3I4 ---_____ eaa 70 —,,........,—..— ------------ 275 O 315 • 315 • es 40 8 e7 4 a ;30 Z k 20 4 Itl n IA 3A an an an 71 TEMPERATURE CC) F16.7 RELATION OF TEMPERATURE AND RECOVERY OF UNBLEACHED DOU6LAS-FIR SULFITE AND WESTERN HEMLOCK PULPS AND STUFFS AT REDUCED SURFACE TENSION. • 90 • • • *ID BO A a • o o •• • A 4.1 Q.. 70 UNBEATEN, S-R FREENESS 860fn • tz. ti 60 • LEGEND Lu A- NORMAL SURFACE TENSION • SURFACE TENSION REDUCED WITH' NACCONAL NR • TENSION REDUCED WITH 'AEROSOL OT' SO 0 - SURFACE NOTE : SAMPLE WEIGHT 6 GRAMS ON MOISTURE-FREE BASIS t:t 40 z 30 O VO • CC CC UNBEATEN, 5-R FREENESS 7 Occ. e0 Ct /0 0 80 70 Z M 40933 F 60 40 50 SURFACE TENSION (DYNES/CM) 30 F16. 8 RELATION OF SURFACE TENSION AND RECOVERY OF DOUGLAS-FIR SULFATE PULP AND STUFFS AT CONSTANT TEMPERATURE. HO 14:1 0 Ct 0 I-- Z) 7 -1-J c: , 1 ----IN C) kJ -..,...,, C J 14.-1 ( c-E7 L J i_`,_ LO 1--, •;K 1, ›.. co OC LQ 0 Q; ...> I--- (1) 1. ,'c Lk1 4J Qn Ct Lfh LE- 1: .1 I-- • C5 (0 --.. 1-4„ -.' LZ ''' 1 (0 4. 4.1 '=t . (7 0) 4J LL 0 4-... (f) C3 ki h. cr Q)(37 '~:), co LLI '''t n IQ l 1-... Pi o ko o Lc) o 0 CO o b- (Y) o ti o C'. (1N3D6e3c1) NOLLV14/d0J30 3/11.S.R7e/c/140.7 HOdd Ad3A0,238 . • c LA .?. 11 74 -4 0 4-1 -4 ....1 kJ 14 (..n ka J er Cc Q. 0. 1.9 10 l'• -,..t zCz11:C;ZI.K Z ci, C:a Ct , '-Z i.' 11.LJI.j'..) Lw c kJ k co ct 1.1 Et LAI ‘a '-' ki C:•:14T.K '4 L'"A) &3LW 'bZ <-..1, (3CrOlZ,CI '“) CO (r) Lb U V) kj Li 111111111 O• Cl• .1•0•1> 0 ke7 elfb 4 • 0 co (LN.3D(11.2d) NOLLtiNd0_1/30 3/1/ S.S3a1c1140.9 H082 A83/10.928 • i t2. L-i ,-).... ,., .1,Z2 r to V) 1.%13 La L.1 L. ce 1 1.0 2.‘ 4.1 I-4 kJ CO Lu Cc. .'4 .--L4a1,_ ZN 4i 14J ,,a 1-- It . L,-. tr, C. . k C1 4 "C0 V' ,,,n -''' ,„_ 4 v) 1,1 •--ii'4.1 "4 ,r) kt, 1 k 4J CM !•22 ks --I 4, k a._1--nc 1, i-L, tw ce ,.a. L, 4, -c .. k c Lo-,t 6 j 2 2 t.L._ v oc Zi ,k .c --VI VI C) ''', I 1 C3 • a 4:3 (LA1_792134 .39VVV12/HS" _LYN I, C3 C, ..) .Z1 1,.. 1-•- 03 CL_ ‘3- ...,._.. CO L. Cr 1.1 '4. CC - --. 4 Cc. -- 14.4 0 -..1 CC Liza. < CIL 4:Q a4.1 ,•1:3 LL1 -‹ 1--- t, Iru.t1 4‹ l z k. • i-c. I., 4 •T In '.b '`) 4 LZ: " CC Li. ki Z.: '0 • /G'Q 1.- kl kl L.1 CC "C Li 03 i„. ,..:. .., ,... .: CI 1 4 kJ 1 i. o 2 1.. . ::-L-I O L- ,,,,, ,•-• @0 14a 0 L, 6.1 i•-• 0 1,., ko ...., IT Ct • Ca 4c L.,.. 1--.. 0 ck ,-,.., .. 0 -c , v, 1,1 'C t.-3 L4.1 CC 1-....i. +._. CL) 1.'3'_ b• 1--1 rc% ON