Charlotte Historic District Commission Staff Review HDC 2015-141 Application for a Certificate of Appropriateness Date: December 9, 2015 PID# 07804602 LOCAL HISTORIC DISTRICT: Fourth Ward PROPERTY ADDRESS: 220 W. 10 Street SUMMARY OF REQUEST: New Construction APPLICANT: Chris Scorsone (Hall Johnston, owner) th Details of Proposed Request Existing Conditions The existing site is a narrow vacant lot adjacent to a two story Victorian building multi-family buildings of various heights. The setback of the Victorian structure is approximately 35’ from back of sidewalk. The adjacent multi-family building is approximately 14-18 feet from back of curb. Proposal The proposal is a 3 story multi-family building with parking underneath. Materials include brick, wood ship lap siding, metal and stucco. Total height is approximately 40’. The front setback is approximately 23’ from the back of curb to the main entrance. New landscaping will be installed around the building. Policy & Design Guidelines for New Construction New construction in Local Historic Districts has an obligation to blend in with the historic character and scale of the Local Historic District in which it is located. Designs for infill projects and other new construction within designated Local Historic Districts must be designed with the surroundings in mind. The Historic District Commission will not specify a particular architectural style or design for new construction projects. The scale, mass and size of a building are often far more important than the decorative details applied. However, well designed stylistic and decorative elements, as well as building materials and landscaping, can give new construction projects the attributes necessary to blend in with the district, while creating a distinctive character for the building. New construction projects in Local Historic Districts must be appropriate to their surroundings. The Historic District Commission will review the building details for all new construction as part of their evaluation of new construction project proposals. Staff Analysis The Commission will determine if the proposal meets the guidelines for new construction. 1 Charlotte Historic District Commission - Case 2015-141 Historic District; Fourth Ward re hi ks oo Br m W ha a Gr St wa ee Fr 10 th St St y W th ine St P N Se r ttl e W h sL 9t n St e St t N pl o P S ar 10 th h St St h N St u Ch h rc St 9t p W 8t N Po W t rS la St W h 8t St ! I 0 N hu C 100 h rc N St 200 y Tr on St 220 West 10th Street Fourth Ward Historic District Property Lines 400 Feet Map Printdate; June .;2015 Building Footprints 220WESTTENTH SITE PHOTO - FRONT ENTRY (10TH ST.) SITE PANORAMA - RIGHT SIDE SITE PHOTO - LEFT SIDE SITE PANORAMA - REAR OF SITE TOWARDS 10TH ST. SITE PANORAMA - REAR OF SITE TOWARDS I-277 © 2015 CLUCK DESIGN COLLABORATIVE. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. EXISTING SITE CONDITIONS cluck DESIGN COLLABORATIVE 220WESTTENTH 2 STORY 3 STORY 4 STORY 10TH STREET - FACING SITE NOT TO SCALE 10TH STREET - OPPOSITE OF SITE 13 STORY NOT TO SCALE © 2015 CLUCK DESIGN COLLABORATIVE. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. EXISTING STREETSCAPES cluck DESIGN COLLABORATIVE 220WESTTENTH COMMERCIAL BUILDING MULTI-FAMILY CONDOS MULTI-FAMILY CONDOS EDWIN TOWERS MULTI-FAMILY CONDOS MULTI-FAMILY CONDOS SKYHOUSE HIGH-RISE CONDOS © 2015 CLUCK DESIGN COLLABORATIVE. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. EXISTING SITE SURROUNDINGS cluck DESIGN COLLABORATIVE 1 2 3 4 5 60' D parapet = 801.3' 60' 1523 Elizabeth Ave, Suite 120 Charlotte, NC 28204 D 50' www.cluckdesign.com 40' 50' ridge = 787.1' ridge = 784.7' ridge = 784.7' patio = 784.0' 40' 30' ridge = 772.9' 20' 20' #220 WEST TENTH STREET (VACANT) 10' G ra de G Sidewalk=741.7' Grade=743.1' =7 40 ' . 48 7 = e ad Gr 49 =7 .9' 1st level = 749.3' 1st level = 747.6' NORTH CHURCH STREET 51695 PRELIMINARY. NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION Sidewalk=749.5' Sidewalk=748.2' Sidewalk=746.5' Sidewalk=744.9' Sidewalk=743.1' .9 de ra 1st level = 745.4' 1st level = 743.1' 10' 1' SUBJECT PROPERTY NORTH POPLAR STREET 30' Grade=749.0' Grade=744.3' Grade=740.6' General Notes: 1. The purpose of this Building Heights Sketch is to show existing building facade heights relative to the elevation points at the public sidewalk, front yard grade ("Grade"), 1st level, and ridgeline of the houses depicted hereon. No rearyard or sideyard measurements were made. The heights shown hereon were derived from indirect measurements and are not intended for structural design. 2. The vertical datum for these elevation measurements is the North American Vertical Datum of 1988 (i.e., sea level). All other information and graphics are conceptual in nature and are not intended to represent accurate architectural or landscape features. WEST TENTH STREET EXISTING C C A.G. ZOUTEWELLE SURVEYORS 220 W. 10th Street Charlotte, NC. prepared for: HDC Review 1418 East Fifth St. Charlotte, NC 28204 Phone: 704-372-9444 Fax: 704-372-9555 Firm Licensure Number C-1054 Mark 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 Copyright 2015 Building Heights Sketch of 200 BLOCK of WEST TENTH STREET EVEN SIDE - FACING NORTHEAST CHARLOTTE, MECKLENBURG COUNTY, N.C. for Charlotte-Mecklenburg Planning Department June 30, 2015 Date 06/27/14 07/07/14 08/28/14 06/16/15 10/09/15 10/27/15 11/03/15 11/24/15 11/30/15 Description Design Layout Design Rev 01 Design Rev 02 Design Rev 03 Design Rev 04 Design Rev 05 Design Development Design Development HDC Package 60' B parapet = 801.3' 60' 40' 50' ridge = 787.1' ridge = 784.7' ridge = 784.7' patio = 784.0' 40' 30' B 50' ridge = 772.9' 20' 10' 1' 20' de ra G 10' G ra Sidewalk=741.7' de Grade=743.1' =7 40 ' e ad Gr 49 =7 .9' 1st level = 749.3' This Drawing is the property of cluck and is not to be reproduced in whole or in part. It is to be used for the project and site specifically identified herein and are not to be used on any other project. This Drawing is to be returned upon the written request of cluck. NORTH CHURCH STREET Sidewalk=744.9' Sidewalk=743.1' .9 . 48 7 = 1st level = 747.6' 1st level = 745.4' 1st level = 743.1' NORTH POPLAR STREET 30' Sidewalk=749.5' Sidewalk=748.2' Sidewalk=746.5' Grade=749.0' Copyright 2015 cluck design collaborative All Rights Reserved. Grade=744.3' Project name/#: Grade=740.6' 220 West Tenth / 13_127 SUBJECT PROPERTY #220 WEST TENTH STREET (VACANT) A A WEST TENTH STREET West Tenth Street Elevation Survey WITH PROPOSED BUILDING 1 2 3 4 5 A002 1 2 3 4 5 D 1523 Elizabeth Ave, Suite 120 Charlotte, NC 28204 D www.cluckdesign.com NEW BRICK PATIO BRICK WALKWAY 45'-11" C 220 W. 10th Street Charlotte, NC. prepared for: HDC Review EXISTING 8" BLOCK WALL 4'-11" 27'-6 1/2" HVAC HVAC T HVAC T HVAC HVAC HVAC HVAC T T T 1 1 HVAC Mark 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 HVAC 15 14 12 13 T UP 8 8 7 6 7 6 5 5 4 4 3 3 1 2 4 3 1 2 2 3 4 2 FRONT PORCH 1 4 3 1 1 2 2 5 4 3 6 Date 06/27/14 07/07/14 08/28/14 06/16/15 10/09/15 10/27/15 11/03/15 11/24/15 11/30/15 8 1 7 2 6 5 4 3 7 PUBLIC RIGHT-OF-WAY CONCRETE DRIVE B 7" EXISTING CONCRETE ENTRY ROLL-OUT RECYCLING LOCATION 10'-9" 11'-11 3/4" 21'-0" WEST 10TH STREET B LANDSCAPING AT REAR OF SITE Description Design Layout Design Rev 01 Design Rev 02 S Design Rev 03 TE W L Design Rev 04 CH ATE Design Rev 05 W AI O N Design Development OD L Design Development FE HDC Package M NC AP G RE RI F D ER NA E D NC 83 E: 14'-0" SETBACK T HVAC 23'-3 1/2" 10 11 8 9 6 7 5 10'-4" 4 2 3 6" CURB 6" CURB NEW LANDSCAPING ALONG LEFT FACE OF BUILDING NEW STREET TREE ROLL OUT DUMPSTERS THREE STORY CONDOMINIUM TWO STORY OFFICE/COMMERCIAL EXISTING 6'-0" SIDEWALK C 51695 PRELIMINARY. NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION RAISED PATIO EXISTING 8" BRICK WALL ASPHALT DRIVE ASPHALT DRIVE PARKING FIELD TRASH THREE STORY CONDOMINIUM 18'-3" LE GUEST PARKING ASPHALT DRIVE PARKING FIELD A GE C CP &G ND CP - C - C U P : A D R DI B. - - CO LCU B & E P - DE RR LA G This Drawing is the property of cluck and is not to be reproduced EI IP - DU ED UG TED UTT EN R - EX CT BO AT P ER in whole or in part. It is to be used for the project and site E - EX IST IL OK ED OIN specifically identified herein and are not to be used on any other PL T project. This Drawing is to be returned upon the written request of FH U - EXI IST ING E IR AS GM - EN STI ING IR ON TI cluck. GP - FIR D U NG IR ON PI C PI GV - GA E H NK NA ON PI PE G PE S P N I Y Copyright 2015 cluck design collaborative GW - AT M D O L RO E All Rights Reserved. D HV - GAS E P ET RA WN LP AC GU V O ER NT M - L - H Y W ALV ST Project name/#: 220 West Tenth / 13_127 N B. - IG E IR E NI .G.S MA HT ATI E N R - . - P PO NG NP N - NE NAT BOO LE , VE NT P H NE W IO K IL PI B - P - NE W N IRO NA AT PM N - OW W AIL N R L G IO A E P OD O PP N, AR ER PUN P DE AI PG - P O C B C R TI R . - O WE EL OX H H CO C TB /W - PA WE R M IDE S O ND U L R G RV W M RI E P ET NT E . B G OL E IF EY W - - TE H R I M E W T C M W AT V - W ATE PO -OF IO - W A R R -W N AT TER BO AR AY NU ER M X Y B M EN BE VA ET CH R LV ER M E AR0 4 8 12 16 FT K Site Plan BRICK PATIO BRICK PATIO PARKING FIELD 14'-9" 1 A5 2 3 4 SITE PLAN Scale: 3/32" = 1'-0" U PERCENTAGE OF LOT COVERAGE: APPROX: 45% PO TI 5 W LI E TI 180 D R ES 0- U 77 K TE : 7- E P LE 98 O P 198 W 88 B HO ER N 8 A100 1 2 3 4 5 WHITE STUCCO D D STOREFRONT WINDOW SYSTEM USED AS GURADRAIL FLAT ROOF SYSTEM Max Height 40'-0" 1523 Elizabeth Ave, Suite 120 Charlotte, NC 28204 www.cluckdesign.com Finish Ceiling 37'-6" Attic 29'-6" Finish Ceiling 28'-6" Third Floor 19'-6" Finish Ceiling 18'-6" 51695 PRELIMINARY. NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION Second Floor 9'-6" Finish Ceiling U 8'-6" First Floor 0'-0" C C C2 0 FRONT ELEVATION 4 8 12 220 W. 10th Street Charlotte, NC. prepared for: HDC Review 16 FT Scale: 1/8" = 1'-0" Mark 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 WHITE STUCCO - SMOOTH FINISH B Max Height Description Design Layout Design Rev 01 Design Rev 02 Design Rev 03 Design Rev 04 Design Rev 05 Design Development Design Development HDC Package DARK GRAY STUCCO SMOOTH FINISH STANDING SEAM METAL ROOF PERFORATED STEEL PANEL - POWDER COAT GLOSS WHITE Date 06/27/14 07/07/14 08/28/14 06/16/15 10/09/15 10/27/15 11/03/15 11/24/15 11/30/15 WOOD SHIP-LAP SIDING WITH 6" EXPOSURE NATURAL STAINED FINISH 40'-0" PERFORATED STEEL PANEL - POWDER COAT GLOSS WHITE STOREFRONT WINDOW SYSTEM USED AS GUARDRAIL Max Height B 40'-0" Finish Ceiling 37'-6" Unit 1 Terrace 30'-0" 29'-6" Finish Ceiling Finish Ceiling 29'-0" Attic 28'-6" Third Floor -Unit 1 Upper Bedroom 21'-0" Dining Area Finish Ceiling Third Floor 20'-0" Finish Ceiling 19'-6" 18'-6" Second Floor 9'-6" This Drawing is the property of cluck and is not to be reproduced in whole or in part. It is to be used for the project and site specifically identified herein and are not to be used on any other project. This Drawing is to be returned upon the written request of cluck. Second Floor Finish Ceiling Finish Ceiling 8'-6" 9'-6" 8'-6" Copyright 2015 cluck design collaborative All Rights Reserved. Project name/#: First Floor 220 West Tenth / 13_127 First Floor 0'-0" 0'-0" A A STEEL PLANTER A2 1 RIGHT SIDE ELEVATION METAL GARAGE DOOR WITH VINYL OR STENCIL GRAPHIC - IMAGES TO BE BOTANICALS FOUND IN FOURTH WARD PARK 0 4 8 12 Elevations Front & Right BRICK - BROWN IRON-SPOT, TUMBLED FINISH 16 FT Scale: 1/8" = 1'-0" 2 3 4 5 A201 1 2 3 4 5 WHITE STUCCO - SMOOTH FINISH D 1523 Elizabeth Ave, Suite 120 Charlotte, NC 28204 D Max Height 40'-0" Finish Ceiling www.cluckdesign.com 37'-6" BRICK - BROWN IRON-SPOT, TUMBLED FINISH Attic 29'-6" Finish Ceiling 28'-6" Third Floor 19'-6" Finish Ceiling 18'-6" PERFORATED STEEL PANEL - POWDER COAT GLOSS WHITE Second Floor 9'-6" 51695 PRELIMINARY. NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION DARK GRAY STUCCO SMOOTH FINISH Finish Ceiling 8'-6" First Floor 0'-0" C C C1 0 REAR ELEVATION 4 8 12 220 W. 10th Street Charlotte, NC. prepared for: HDC Review 16 FT Scale: 1/8" = 1'-0" Mark 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 Date 06/27/14 07/07/14 08/28/14 06/16/15 10/09/15 10/27/15 11/03/15 11/24/15 11/30/15 Description Design Layout Design Rev 01 Design Rev 02 Design Rev 03 Design Rev 04 Design Rev 05 Design Development Design Development HDC Package WHITE STUCCO - SMOOTH FINISH PERFORATED STEEL PANEL - POWDER COAT GLOSS WHITE Max Height STUCCO AT LOWER PANEL, GLASS ABOVE STANDING SEAM METAL ROOF STUCCO WITH VERTICAL & HORIZONTAL REVEALS - SMOOTH FINISH. CONTINUE PARAPET TO GUARDRAIL HEIGHT 40'-0" Finish Ceiling 37'-6" B B Attic 29'-6" Finish Ceiling 28'-6" Third Floor 19'-6" Finish Ceiling 18'-6" Second Floor 9'-6" Finish Ceiling 8'-6" This Drawing is the property of cluck and is not to be reproduced in whole or in part. It is to be used for the project and site specifically identified herein and are not to be used on any other project. This Drawing is to be returned upon the written request of cluck. First Floor Copyright 2015 cluck design collaborative All Rights Reserved. 0'-0" Project name/#: DARK GRAY STUCCO SMOOTH FINISH STUCCO - SMOOTH FINISH A STUCCO AT LOWER PANEL, GLASS ABOVE A1 1 0 LEFT SIDE ELEVATION 4 8 12 BRICK - BROWN IRON-SPOT, TUMBLED FINISH 220 West Tenth / 13_127 A Elevations Rear & Left 16 FT Scale: 1/8" = 1'-0" 2 3 4 5 A202 1 2 3 4 5 D 1523 Elizabeth Ave, Suite 120 Charlotte, NC 28204 D www.cluckdesign.com THREE STORY CONDOMINIUM 51695 PRELIMINARY. NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION TWO STORY OFFICE/COMMERCIAL C 14'-0" 10'-4" 15 14 13 12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 T T UP 10'-0" T 1 T 8 8 7 7 6 6 5 5 4 4 3 3 1 2 T 1 2 4 3 4 3 1 2 FRONT PORCH 4 1 1 2 2 3 8 1 7 2 6 5 4 prepared for: HDC Review 10 'REAR YARD SETBACK T T Mark 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 Date 06/27/14 07/07/14 08/28/14 06/16/15 10/09/15 10/27/15 11/03/15 11/24/15 11/30/15 Description Design Layout Design Rev 01 Design Rev 02 Design Rev 03 Design Rev 04 Design Rev 05 Design Development Design Development HDC Package 3 20'-6 3/8" 16'-5" B B 5' SIDE YARD SETBACK 7" WEST 10TH STREET 3 5' SIDE YARD SETBACK 2 6" CURB 6" CURB C 220 W. 10th Street Charlotte, NC. EXISTING BRICK WALL A1 0 ALL UNITS - FIRST FLOOR 4 8 12 This Drawing is the property of cluck and is not to be reproduced in whole or in part. It is to be used for the project and site specifically identified herein and are not to be used on any other project. This Drawing is to be returned upon the written request of cluck. 16 FT Copyright 2015 cluck design collaborative All Rights Reserved. Scale: 1/8" = 1'-0" Project name/#: A 220 West Tenth / 13_127 A All Units First Floor Plan 1 2 3 4 5 A101 1 2 3 4 5 D 1523 Elizabeth Ave, Suite 120 Charlotte, NC 28204 D www.cluckdesign.com 51695 PRELIMINARY. NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION C C 10" TYPICAL DIM. WALL UP 220 W. 10th Street Charlotte, NC. prepared for: HDC Review DN Mark 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 BALCONY BALCONY Date 06/27/14 07/07/14 08/28/14 06/16/15 10/09/15 10/27/15 11/03/15 11/24/15 11/30/15 Description Design Layout Design Rev 01 Design Rev 02 Design Rev 03 Design Rev 04 Design Rev 05 Design Development Design Development HDC Package BALCONY TERRACE B B B2 0 ALL UNITS - SECOND FLOOR 4 8 12 16 FT Scale: 1/8" = 1'-0" This Drawing is the property of cluck and is not to be reproduced in whole or in part. It is to be used for the project and site specifically identified herein and are not to be used on any other project. This Drawing is to be returned upon the written request of cluck. Copyright 2015 cluck design collaborative All Rights Reserved. Project name/#: A 220 West Tenth / 13_127 A All Units Second Floor Plan 1 2 3 4 5 A102 1 2 3 4 5 D 1523 Elizabeth Ave, Suite 120 Charlotte, NC 28204 D www.cluckdesign.com 51695 PRELIMINARY. NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION C C UP 220 W. 10th Street Charlotte, NC. prepared for: HDC Review DN UP BALCONY Mark 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 BALCONY B Date 06/27/14 07/07/14 08/28/14 06/16/15 10/09/15 10/27/15 11/03/15 11/24/15 11/30/15 Description Design Layout Design Rev 01 Design Rev 02 Design Rev 03 Design Rev 04 Design Rev 05 Design Development Design Development HDC Package B A1 0 ALL UNITS - THIRD FLOOR 4 8 12 16 FT Scale: 1/8" = 1'-0" This Drawing is the property of cluck and is not to be reproduced in whole or in part. It is to be used for the project and site specifically identified herein and are not to be used on any other project. This Drawing is to be returned upon the written request of cluck. Copyright 2015 cluck design collaborative All Rights Reserved. Project name/#: A 220 West Tenth / 13_127 A All Units Third Floor Plan 1 2 3 4 5 A103 1 2 3 4 5 D 1523 Elizabeth Ave, Suite 120 Charlotte, NC 28204 D www.cluckdesign.com 51695 PRELIMINARY. NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION C DN C 220 W. 10th Street Charlotte, NC. ELEV. OUTDOOR GAS FIREPLACE prepared for: HDC Review ROOF TERRACE ROOF TERRACE ROOF TERRACE ROOF TERRACE ROOF TERRACE Mark 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 FLAT ROOF ROOF TERRACE OPEN TO BELOW ATTIC B Date 06/27/14 07/07/14 08/28/14 06/16/15 10/09/15 10/27/15 11/03/15 11/24/15 11/30/15 Description Design Layout Design Rev 01 Design Rev 02 Design Rev 03 Design Rev 04 Design Rev 05 Design Development Design Development HDC Package B B2 0 All Units - Attic Floor 4 8 12 16 FT Scale: 1/8" = 1'-0" This Drawing is the property of cluck and is not to be reproduced in whole or in part. It is to be used for the project and site specifically identified herein and are not to be used on any other project. This Drawing is to be returned upon the written request of cluck. Copyright 2015 cluck design collaborative All Rights Reserved. Project name/#: A 220 West Tenth / 13_127 A All Units Attic Plan 1 2 3 4 5 A104 1 2 3 4 5 D 1523 Elizabeth Ave, Suite 120 Charlotte, NC 28204 D www.cluckdesign.com 51695 PRELIMINARY. NOT FOR CONSTRUCTION STANDING SEAM METAL ROOF C FLAT ROOF FLAT ROOF STANDING SEAM METAL ROOF C FLAT ROOF 220 W. 10th Street Charlotte, NC. prepared for: HDC Review ROOF TERRACE ROOF TERRACE ROOF TERRACE ROOF TERRACE ROOF TERRACE Mark 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 FLAT ROOF ROOF TERRACE B Date 06/27/14 07/07/14 08/28/14 06/16/15 10/09/15 10/27/15 11/03/15 11/24/15 11/30/15 Description Design Layout Design Rev 01 Design Rev 02 Design Rev 03 Design Rev 04 Design Rev 05 Design Development Design Development HDC Package B B2 0 ALL UNITS - ROOF PLAN 4 8 12 16 FT Scale: 1/8" = 1'-0" This Drawing is the property of cluck and is not to be reproduced in whole or in part. It is to be used for the project and site specifically identified herein and are not to be used on any other project. This Drawing is to be returned upon the written request of cluck. Copyright 2015 cluck design collaborative All Rights Reserved. Project name/#: A 220 West Tenth / 13_127 A Roof Plan 1 2 3 4 5 A161