DEPARTMENT OF HORTICULTURE, FORESTRY AND RECREATIONAL RESOURCES
POST TENURE REVIEW GUIDELINES
(Approved by Faculty Vote on 4/11/2014)
Candice Shoemaker, Department Head
Date signed: 2/16/2015
John D Floros, Dean
Date signed: 2/18/2015
April C. Mason, Provost
Date signed: 3/23/2015
*Each academic department is required by University Handbook policy to develop department
documents containing criteria, standards, and guidelines for promotion, tenure, reappointment,
annual evaluation, and merit salary allocation. These documents must be approved by a majority
vote of the faculty members in the department, by the department head or chair, by the dean
concerned, and by the provost. In accordance with University Handbook policy, provision must
be made to review these documents at least once every five years or more frequently if it is
determined to be necessary. Dates of revision (or the vote to continue without revision) must
appear on the first page of the document.
Department of Horticulture, Forestry and Recreation Resources
Post Tenure Review Policy
The purpose of post-tenure review (PTR) at Kansas State University is to enhance the continued
professional development of tenured faculty. The process is intended to encourage intellectual
vitality and professional proficiency for all members of the faculty throughout their careers, so
they may more effectively fulfill the mission of the university. It is also designed to enhance
public trust in the University by ensuring that the faculty community undertakes regular and
rigorous efforts to hold all of its members accountable for high professional standards.
Kansas State University recognizes that the granting of tenure for university faculty is a vital
protection of free inquiry and open intellectual debate. It is expressly recognized that nothing in
this policy alters or amends the University's policies regarding removal of tenured faculty
members for cause (which are stipulated in the University Handbook). This policy and any
actions taken under it are separate from and have no bearing on the chronic low achievement or
annual evaluation policies and processes.
The department policy on PTR follows the overarching purpose, principles, objectives, and
procedures in the university policy on PTR (see University Handbook, Appendix W), which was
approved by Faculty Senate on February 11, 2014.”
The following procedure will be utilized for the PTR every six years.
1. All tenured faculty members of the university are required to undergo a performance
evaluation annually. Faculty undergoing PTR will submit the six previous annual evaluations.
2. The department head will review the submitted material and give feed back to the faculty
member. The specific standards for the review are outlined in the Department of Horticulture,
Forestry and Recreation Resources (HFRR) Annual Evaluation Guidelines approved August
2012. The PTR will assess the faculty member’s strengths and areas for improvement to
determine whether he/she is making appropriate contributions to the university or whether
additional plans or activities need to be developed.
3. To determine if the faculty is making appropriate contributions to the university will be based
on the following:
a. If all six annual evaluations meet or exceed expectations then the faculty will be deemed
to be making significant contributions to the university
b. If any of the six annual evaluations do not meet expectations then in concert with the
faculty undergoing PTR and the P&T committee a plan for professional development will
be created. This plan will be utilized in future annual evaluations and PTRs to review
progress toward any goals set in the plan.
4. The PTR will be conducted for tenured faculty every six years and shall conform to the
timeline associated with the annual evaluation review. The six year PTR clock is defined to
mean that PTR will be conducted for all tenured faculty either every six years, or in the sixth
year following promotion. The following events will modify or reset the PTR clock:
● Application for promotion to full professor;
● Application for Professorial Performance Award;
● Receipt of a major college, university, national or international award requiring a multi-year
portfolio-like documentation, i.e., University Distinguished Professor, University Distinguished
Teaching Scholar, or other national/international awards.
The schedule for PTR could be delayed for one year to accommodate sabbatical leave, health
issues, or other compelling reasons, provided that both faculty and department head approve the
delay.
5. Exceptions for PTR: If the faculty member has already been identified as not meeting
minimum standards according to the policies and department procedures relating to chronic low
achievement, that process will be considered to serve in lieu of PTR. Those who have formally
announced their retirement through a written letter to the department/unit head, or have begun
phased retirement, are exempt from post-tenure review.