NATIONAL QUALIFICATIONS CURRICULUM SUPPORT Practical Metalworking Fabrication and Thermal Joining Techniques: MIG Welding Advice for Practitioners [NATIONAL 4; NATIONAL 5] This advice and guidance has been produced to support the profession with the delivery of courses which are either new or which have aspects of significant change within the new national qualifications (NQ) framework. The advice and guidance provides suggestions on approaches to learning and teaching. Practitioners are encouraged to draw on the materials for their own part of their continuing professional development in introducing new national qualifications in ways that match the needs of learners. Practitioners should also refer to the course and unit specifications and support notes which have been issued by the Scottish Qualifications Authority. http://www.sqa.org.uk/sqa/34714.html Acknowledgement © Crown copyright 2012. You may re-use this information (excluding logos) free of charge in any format or medium, under the terms of the Open Government Licence. To view this licence, visit http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/ or e-mail: psi@nationalarchives.gsi.gov.uk. Where we have identified any third party copyright information you will need to obtain permission from the copyright holders concerned. Any enquiries regarding this document/publication should be sent to us at enquiries@educationscotland.gov.uk. This document is also available from our website at www.educationscotland.gov.uk. 2 MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 Contents Introduction 4 Safety in the workshop 11 Learner tasks Learner task Learner task Learner task Learner task Learner task Learner task Learner task 13 13 14 14 14 15 15 15 1: 2: 3: 4: 5: 6: 7: Welding run practice Lap joint T joint Butt weld Outside corner Action figure Wheel chock Appendix 1: Reflective questions 16 Appendix 2 17 MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 3 ADVICE FOR PRACTITIONERS Introduction These materials form part of Education Scotland’s commitment ‘to develop practical advice and guidance to support the profession with the delivery of courses where there are aspects of significant change within the new National Qualifications ‘. The materials build on and develop earlier advice and guidance on Curriculum for Excellence, both generic and specific to the technologies and Practical Metalworking with a particular focus on National 4 and 5. The materials complement other key support materials including, for example, the relevant Unit and Course Support Notes provided by SQA. They aim to reinforce key themes where appropriate, but without unnecessary repetition. It is clearly important that practitioners are familiar with those key materials which relate to Practical Metalworking. Crucially, this advice and guidance tries to meet the challenge of conveying the spirit of learning in the technologies and Practical Metalworking, with their focus on problemsolving, real-world relevance, and the world of work, within the framework of principles of Curriculum for Excellence. The materials aim to be accessible, practical and attractive, exemplifying effective and dynamic approaches to learning and teaching. They invite teachers, young people and others to explore them and reflect on the value they might add to learning, teaching and achievement in Practical Metalworking, to the extent that individuals’ need or wish. These materials are offered as a starting point and are interactive by design. They actively invite users to edit them (for example in the style of Wikis), and enhance the contents for their own purposes, but then to share them with other practitioners in a spirit of partnership. The summary pages 3-5 will be helpful for users since they exemplify generic positive influences on learning and teaching in the technologies contexts of craft, design, engineering and graphics. Other practitioners will wish to consider pages 6-7 which set out ideas directly relevant to Practical Metalworking. At the heart of this resource, ‘Fabrication and Thermal Joining Techniques ; MIG welding’ provides the insights and approaches adopted by one experienced practitioner, focusing on an area of the course which will, for some practitioners, represent an area of change. Practitioners will note, at this point, that the advice and guidance reflects the specific context of a school with particular facilities and equipment. Whilst these materials may not be available in all schools, 4 MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 ADVICE FOR PRACTITIONERS practitioners may be able to source them or access them in different ways, such as through partnership or consortium arrangements with colleges and other schools. Going still further, some practitioners may wish to use the reflective questions in appendix 1, or explore the links in appendix 2. These exemplify the much wider range of learning and teaching approaches, some of which may be well known and of proven effectiveness, which is available to support studies in the technologies and Practical Metalworking. It is important that practitioners bear in mind that the materials relate only to a specific aspect of Practical Metalworking which may differ from their experience, to avoid disproportionate attention to the chosen aspect. Practitioners may also recognise that the focus on skills development in the new National Qualifications requires a different approach to planning and delivering programmes, to ensure that learners are given well -designed opportunities to develop key skills for learning, life and work. Effective and dynamic learning and teaching in Practical Metalworking Planning The importance of careful planning of programmes in Practical Metalworking is paramount and, in key respects, Curriculum for Excellence raises different challenges and expectations. Reflecting the principles of Curriculum for Excellence, and effective practice more generally, practitioners may wish to consider the following features of positive programme planning. Evaluation of previous relevant experience (stakeholder views, analysis of data on achievement and attainment, direct observation of quality of learners’ experiences). In the context of Curriculum for Excellence, practitioners may wish to give particular emphasis to involving partner agencies and learners, present and past, when planning the programme in Practical Metalworking. The act of involving partners and learners in itself provides a valuable learning experience consistent with the capacities and principles of Curriculum for Excellence. Delivery – learning and teaching influences for Practical Metalworking Practitioners may wish to consider the range of powerful influences, promoting positive learning in the technologies, which have become increasingly recognised in recent years. These influences include the responsibility within all programmes to seek ways of building learners’ skills MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 5 ADVICE FOR PRACTITIONERS in literacy, numeracy and Health and Wellbeing. Practitioners can emphasise to learners that a strong performance in literacy and numeracy, in the context of metalworking, will add to their standing and credibility in any contacts for example with higher education and employers. For literacy, Practical Metalworking offers positive opportunities to enhance literacy skills associated with its specifically ‘technical’ vocabulary. Practitioner professionals may wish to reflect on key principles of learning in literacy, including the need for young people to listen, speak, read and write using technological language, to build their skills systematically and progressively. Practitioners may wish to reflect on the value added to learners’ experiences where they have the opportunity, individually or in teams, to present oral reports on aspects of their studies in Practical Metalworking. Numeracy features strongly in Practical Metalworking, and effective programmes at National 4 and 5 can make a significant contribution to developing the relevant numeracy skills. These skills, in the context of Practical Metalworking and the technologies and STEM (science, technology, engineering and mathematics) subjects more generally, have high currency across learning, life and work. Examples of applications in Practical Metalworking include straightforward measurement skills required in practical and graphical work, and estimations and calculations for resource requirements for tasks. Health and wellbeing Practitioners might find value in using Health and Wellbeing as a reference point and source of ideas for programmes in Practical Metalworking. For example, consideration of issues of health and safety is particularly relevant , both in the classroom context but also as a related, motivating theme based in real-world practice. Examples in areas such as motor vehicle engineering, or structural steelwork in the construction or oil extraction industries, provide contexts which may add motivation and purpose to learning. The equipment in a modern gym similarly illustrates the relevance of metalworking skills and knowledge to health and fitness, and underlines the importance of learning about properties of metalworking materials, processes, structures and machines. The ‘big issues’ and Practical Metalworking A number of major social issues also provide helpful prompts for practitioners, suggesting new ‘angles’ and learning activities as they plan programmes. These issues include sustainability, citizenship and enterprise, all of which have clear relevance to learning across the technologies and 6 MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 ADVICE FOR PRACTITIONERS Practical Metalworking specifically. Each of these issues provides contexts in which the skills inherent in Practical Metalworking are clearly relevant, and which in turn may suggest strong features for practit ioners to integrate in their programmes. Issues of sustainability have particular relevance in Practical Metalworking in that programmes can offer well -structured learning about managing resources. This can be linked to real-world concerns and ambitions such as those associated with recycling and conservation of finite resources. Recognising its central importance socially and economically, the partner resource for these materials for Design and Make includes a ‘flagship’, major suite of support items focusing on sustainability. A link is provided in appendix 2. The application of relevant technological skills and knowledge can contribute significantly to active citizenship through, for example, wellinformed actions to enhance a local amenity or facility , or to discourage litter and vandalism. Enterprising ways of thinking and acting are inherent features of high quality programmes in Practical Metalworking, deriving from the fundamentally creative nature of this area of learning. Importantly, consideration of enterprise and entrepreneurial approaches can give a helpful, new direction to learning which takes the problem -solving nature of Practical Metalworking and relates it to social, business or financial themes. The rise in popularity of Skills for Work programmes offers another important reference point for practitioners designing learning in Practical Metalworking. Whilst its general relevance to the world of work is obvious, there is ample scope which practitioners may wish to exploit, within specific learning activities, to reinforce the links with careers, work, employment and life after school. Practical Metalworking– aspects of significant change The following section focuses on specific features of Practical Metalworking, which may differ from practitioners’ prior experience. Firstly, this section identifies the course structure and differences, and provides some initial links to materials which promote effective approaches to learning and teaching. This initial advice and guidance is then developed through exemplification, developed by an experienced practitioner, of a selected aspect of the National 4 and 5 courses in Practical Metalworking. Taken with the previous section, these suggestions are offered to practitioners to access to the extent that they need and wish. MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 7 ADVICE FOR PRACTITIONERS Outline of the Courses The Courses are essentially workshop-based, practical, exploratory and experiential in nature. They combine elements of practical metalworking techniques and standard practice with elements of creativ ity. The focus on creativity represents an important change in emphasis from previous practical courses. The courses provide opportunities for learners to gain skills in reading drawings and diagrams. They allow learners to plan activities through to the completion of a finished artefact, which may be of their own choosing, using a variety of tools, equipment and materials. Taken together, these features help to define appropriate learning and teaching approaches. The aims of the Courses are to enable learners to develop: skills in metalworking techniques skills in measuring and marking out metal sections and sheet materials safe working practices in workshop environments practical creativity and problem solving skills knowledge and understanding of sustainability issues in a practical metalworking context. Units Each of the four mandatory units, listed below, covers a set of metalworking skills. All include skills in measuring, marking-out, cutting and joining techniques. Learners will develop an appreciation of safe working practices in a workshop environment and an understanding of sustainability issues in a practical metalworking context. Bench Skills This Unit helps learners to read and interpret drawings and diagrams, and to develop a range of metalworking hand skills including bench -fitting work, basic sheet-metal work and simple measuring and marking-out work. Machine Processes This Unit builds learners’ measuring and marking -out skills and to develop skills in setting up and using common metalwork machines, equipment and related processes, working with an appropriate range of metals. Fabrication and Thermal Joining Techniques This Unit develops learners’ skills in fabrication, forming and joining of metalwork components and thermal joining techniques, whilst also building skills in measuring and marking-out. 8 MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 ADVICE FOR PRACTITIONERS Added Value Unit: Practical Metalworking Project This Unit requires learners to apply their practical metalworking skills, in broader and more challenging contexts, to create an appropriate project . Approaches to learning and teaching in Practical Metalwork Courses Learning and teaching activities should be designed to stimulate learners’ interest, and to develop skills and knowledge to the necessary standards. High quality practical demonstrations and direct teaching will continue to play important roles, in balance with approaches which suit the experiential, exploratory and creative nature of the courses. Against that background, the increased emphasis on creativity, personalisation and choice, reflecting the principles of Curriculum for Excellence, should result in projects which differ significantly from learner to learner. Wherever possible, partnerships with, and visits to relevant local industrial/workshop and specialist college environments should be undertaken. Video, simulation and online materials will provide valuable enhancements to other resources , at times supporting delivery of aspects which are not otherwise available in a particular school . Throughout learning and teaching, it will be important to involve learners in judging their progress and making decisions about next steps. Key features of ongoing dialogue with learners will include: sharing learning intentions/success criteria using assessment information to set learning targets and next steps adapting teaching and learning activities based on assessment information boosting learners’ confidence by providing supportive feedback Practical Metalworking Exemplar This exemplar has been developed by an experienced practitioner reflecting the resources, skills and needs in a particular school. The example focuses on Fabrication and Thermal Joining Techniques; MIG welding . The thinking and planning processes, implicit in the design and preparation of this exemplar, demonstrate some helpful principles for materials development. These include most obviously the resources, skills and context in which the courses are being delivered. Key references: practitioners may also wish to refer to the following resources. Reflective questions for Practical Metalworking (appendix 1) Technologies resources weblinks (appendix 2) MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 9 ADVICE FOR PRACTITIONERS Fabrication and Thermal Joining Techniques; MIG welding Practitioners may wish to view the associated PowerPoint presentation prior to possible use with learners. This guidance supports learners’ use of Magnesium Inert Gas (MIG) welders (as shown in the illustration) for a range of purposes. The guidance, which comprises this text and the accompanying PowerPoint presentation, includes coverage of how to prepare material for welding correctly, using a variety of techniques available in educational and industrial settings. The resource emphasises the key feature of safety in the workshop and exemplifies some possible project tasks for learners. Welding is a very important part of manufacturing in th e modern world that we live in and includes contexts in industries such as oil and gas exploration and extraction, and energy engineering businesses more generally . Recognising the importance of high quality, precise standards, oil companies and others involved in fabrication industries require welders to be highly qualified. In oil and gas industries, and in energy engineering more generally there are two main types of welding jobs. In the first, welders have a permanent contract and regular work on company sites such as oil rigs. Their job involves repairing existing structures and fabricating new ones , working both above the surface and undersea. The second form of contract is for freelance welders who are called in for specific commissions and emergency work, a form of employment which typically attracts high levels of financial reward. 10 MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 ADVICE FOR PRACTITIONERS Safety in the workshop There are significant risks involved in welding, including those using MIG techniques. The subject is covered in considerable detail in the advice offered by relevant trade bodies, unions and government. The following notes highlight some of the key issues and effects. Radiation from the arc Ultraviolet and heat rays from the arc, i f not properly screened, may produce the following effects. Skin effects These are similar to those from over-exposure to the sun, which may be painful and result in severe blisters. Precautions Ensure that no part of the skin is exposed to the direct r ays of the arc. Eye effects An extremely painful condition of the eye known as ‘arc eye’ or ‘eye flash’ may be caused by looking at an unscreened arc, even from a distance of some metres and for only a few seconds. Symptoms include watering of the eyes, sensitivity or intolerance to light, stinging effects which feel like sand in the eyes, intense pain, headache and, occasionally, temporary loss of vision. The symptoms occur 4 to 8 hours after exposure and, provided the exposure is not repeated, recovery is generally complete within 24 to 48 hours, usually with no permanent damage. Precautions Protect the face and eyes with an appropriate welding helmet. This is made of a lightweight, non-ignitable material that insulates against heat and electricity, and is impervious to the rays of the arc, complying with the recommendations of BS 1542. Together with appropriate screening, such as that provided by a welding booth, a suitable helmet is essential. MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 11 ADVICE FOR PRACTITIONERS Personal Protective Equipment – PPE Safety clothing Special precautions must be adhered to at all times when completing any welding exercise. Appropriate clothing and footwear are essential - trainers are not acceptable. It is important to use the correct PPE, for example including welding jackets which provide protection against metal splashes, flames, sparks and ultraviolet radiation. These are usually manufactured from flameproof natural fibres and heat-resistant materials. 12 MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 ADVICE FOR PRACTITIONERS Learner tasks Learner task 1: Welding run practice This task provides practice in holding the welder gun correctly to achieve parallel welding. Provide the learners with a piece of mild steel approximately 100 × 70 mm. Ask the learners, with staff support, to carry out equipment safety checks. Remind them of the importance of correct use of the mask and other PPE, and monitor that they are doing so. If the learner is right-handed he/she should start at the right-hand side and move the gun smoothly and steadily to the left . Learners should then wait for a short period until the metal is no longer red hot, and then apply another run. For those who are left handed, these positions and directions should be reversed. The learner should repeat this process until the metal is completely covered with practice runs. Learning Prompt Invite the learners to speculate on the effects of inappropriate speed of welding, or inaccurate selection of current. Learner task 2: Lap joint This task provides practice in joining two overlapping pieces of metal effectively. By the end of this task learners should be able to produce one continuous, even weld. This task requires learners to ‘tac-weld’ the metal together, using a process very similar to task 1 on welding runs, prior to creating the full joint. Provide two pieces of mild steel approximately 100 × 70 mm. Ensure that learners carry out the appropriate safety checks . MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 13 ADVICE FOR PRACTITIONERS Learner task 3: T joint This task is a progression from the first two tasks. Once again learners will be joining two pieces of metal together, but this time positioned at right angles to each other. Provide two pieces of metal approximately 100 × 70 mm. Learners should carry out the relevant safety under close staff supervision. Staff should demonstrate the process, offering key information on the correct techniques. Learning prompt At this stage, where learners now have some practical experience of welding, involve them in group discussions and comparisons of what they think are the key features of skilful welding. In discussion, produce a list of five ‘bullets’ with the agreed five most important features of skilful work in welding. Learner task 4: Butt weld In this task, learners will weld two pieces of metal together in one constant, smooth run. Provide two pieces of mild steel approximately 100 × 70 mm. Monitor learners as they carry out the preliminary safety checks, including their use of PPE. Learners should first file a 45 angle chamfer on the edges to be joined. The butt weld joint is most commonly used in joining together large sheets of metal, such as ship hulls. The importance of a very steady and constant weld is obvious. Learner task 5: Outside corner This final practice joint requires welding two pieces of metal together to form a right angled corner. Learners should use two pieces of mild steel approximately 100 × 30 mm. Provide them with a jig (such as the box section shown below) to ensure the metal is joined at right angles. Monitor learners closely as they carry out the safety checks and use PPE. As in previous tasks, learners should, tac weld the two pieces of metal together, forming the join on the outside of the jig. Encourage learners to 14 MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 ADVICE FOR PRACTITIONERS achieve a constant, steady weld. When the process is complete encourage learners to explore whether the weld has penetrated into both pieces of me tal. Tasks 6–7 These tasks are directed at learners. They offer practice in the context of some projects which provide for progression and which learners might find of interest Learner task 6: Action figure In this task you will design and create your own steel action figure. Your teacher will be able to offer design ideas, and you can suggest some of your own. You might also find some ideas on the website: www.steelman24.co.uk Once you have a suitable idea, make a full-size drawing (no taller than 150 mm) and prepare a cutting list. The next stage is to prepare all your metal for welding. Ensure all metal is clean and free from any rough sections. The model can be manufactured using a mixture of welding techniques which you have now experienced. On completion, make sure that it is well finished, for example taking care to avoid any dangerous edges. Learner task 7: Wheel chock A wheel chock is used to keep a vehicle stationary, for example for safety reasons when the vehicle is being repaired. The welds must be very strong and penetration of the metal is very important. Follow all the instructions on the working drawings provided. It is worth checking all dimensions thoroughly before cutting the component parts for welding. On completion, the chock must be finished to a good standard, for example with no sharp corners or edges that would damage a tyre or the user’s hand. MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 15 ADVICE FOR PRACTITIONERS Appendix 1: reflective questions Does your course take account of the ‘purposes of learning in the technologies’ for example to ensure that learners: ‘become informed consumers and producers who have an appreciation of the merits and impacts of products and services’? How do you currently develop literacy/ numeracy/enterprise/ life skills? What new opportunities might you provide? How do you best use an appropriate range of texts (spoken, heard, written, visual, mixed media)? Where might these texts be used and how might they develop pupils’ skills in literacy? Which learning and assessment approaches and activities are you using that take advantage of a workshop setting and build confidence to enable the learners’ to progress through the Units and towards the Project? In what ways can you provide opportunities for young people to learn to work together collaboratively? Which examples have the biggest impact on learners’ skills development? When undertaking the more complex elements of the Units are there opportunities for the young people to explain their thinking to show their understanding of processes and concepts? (particularly relevant in preparing for the project task in the N4 Added Value Unit) What range of learning activities could you use more effectively to help to develop young people’s higher order thinking skills? How can you design activities to help young people evaluate the quality of their own work? Which experiences and outcomes could you link to, within the technologies, across other curriculum areas, and into the world of work, to provide a coherent experience for learners? Which partners do you work with effectively? Are there other partners in school and the local and wider community with whom you could establish working relationships to support young people’s skills development ( skills for learning, life and work)? What opportunities do learners have to investigate the world of work, including with employers and entrepreneurs, and to think about how this relates to their future learning and career options? How best might you link with local employers, colleges and Skills Development Scotland? How best can you capitalise on learners’ knowledge of the internet and search engines to help identify appropriate on -line resources? 16 MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 ADVICE FOR PRACTITIONERS Appendix 2 Technologies: hyperlinks to key documents for selected N4 and N5 Courses CfE Principles and Practice: Technologies Design Principles of new and revised National Qualifications National 4 Design and Manufacture Course Specification Course and Unit Support Notes Unit Specification Design and Manufacture: Design Design and Manufacture: Materials and Manufacturing Added Value Unit: Design and Manufacture Assignment National 4 Engineering Science Course Specification Course and Unit Support Notes Unit Specification Engineering: Contexts and Challenges Electrical and Electronic Systems Mechanical Systems Added Value Unit: Engineering Science Assignment National 4 Practical Metalworking Course Specification Course and Unit Support Notes Unit Specification: Practical Metalworking: Bench Skills Practical Metalworking: Machine Processes Practical Metalworking: Fabrication and Thermal Joining Techniques MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 17 ADVICE FOR PRACTITIONERS Added Value Unit: Making a Finished Product from Metal National 4 Practical Woodworking Course Specification Course and Unit Support Notes Unit Specification Practical Woodworking: Flat-frame Construction Practical Woodworking: Carcase Construction Practical Woodworking: Machining and Finishing Added Value Unit: Making a Finished Product from Wood National 5 Design and Manufacture Course Specification Course and Unit Support Notes Unit Specification Design and Manufacture: Design Design and Manufacture: Materials and Manufacturing Course Assessment Specification National 5 Engineering Science Course Specification Course and Unit Support Notes Unit Specification Engineering: Contexts and Challenges Electrical and Electronic Systems Mechanical Systems Course Assessment Specification National 5 Practical Metalworking Course Specification Course and Unit Support Notes Unit Specification Practical Metalworking: Bench Skills Practical Metalworking: Machine Processes Practical Metalworking: Fabrication and Thermal Joining Techniques Course Assessment Specification 18 MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 ADVICE FOR PRACTITIONERS National 5 Practical Woodworking Course Specification Course and Unit Support Notes Unit Specification Practical Woodworking: Flat-frame Construction Practical Woodworking: Carcase Construction Practical Woodworking: Machining and Finishin g Course Assessment Specification STEM Central provides a number of relevant and stimulating engineering topics that could be used or adapted to support the units. Skills Development Scotland has useful links for career opportunities at ‘My World of Work’ and which may help further contextualised learning. MIG WELDING (NAT 4, 5 PRACTICAL METALWORKING) © Crown copyright 2012 19