5 3LICING AS &
advertisement
6/,./ %4(./-53)#/,/'9 7).4%2 3LICINGTHE"EAT*AZZ%IGHTH.OTES AS%XPRESSIVE-ICRORHYTHM &%2.!.$/"%.!$/. !MERICAN5NIVERSITY 5 NTILRECENTLYJAZZTHEORISTSHAVEDIRECTEDMOSTOFTHEIRANALYTICALEFFORTSTO UNSCRAMBLINGASPECTSOFPITCHRATHERTHANTIMEMIMICKINGTHEANALYSIS OFhARTvMUSIC4HEPERCEPTUALLIMITATIONSINVOLVEDINEXTRACTINGANDCHAR ACTERIZINGESSENTIALRHYTHMICNUANCESASWELLASTHELIMITATIONSOFSTANDARD MUSICNOTATIONTOCONVEYTHESEHAVETENDEDTODETERRIGOROUSSTUDYOFTHE MICRORHYTHMICFEATURESOFJAZZPERFORMANCE)NPITCHORIENTEDSTUDIESTEMPO RALASPECTSHAVEGENERALLYBEENNEGLECTEDINFAVOROFSCALARANDHARMONICRE LATEDTOPICSEG#OGSWELL(ERMANN*OHNSON,AIRD+ENNY ,ARSON3TEEDMAN4OIVIAINEN4YMOCZKO! FEWOTHERSTUDIESHAVEADDRESSEDTHEINTERACTIONBETWEENTHEPITCHANDTIME DOMAINSALTHOUGHISSUESOFMICRORHYTHMARELEFTLARGELYUNEXPLOREDEG "ERLINER(AYWOOD*ÊRVINEN!NIMPORTANTANDPIONEERING EXCEPTIONISTHATOF0RESSINGWHORECORDEDHIMSELFPERFORMINGTWO FREEJAZZIMPROVISATIONSANDUSEDACOMPUTERTOEXTRACTTIMINGDYNAMICS ANDhLEGATONESSvINFORMATION(EFOUNDTHATSOMEOFTHEMICRORHYTHMIC MECHANISMSSOMETIMESINTERACTEDWITHMELODYANDPHRASESTRUCTURE -ICRORHYTHMSINJAZZHAVEBEGUNTORECEIVEINCREASINGATTENTIONFROM JAZZSCHOLARSOVERTHELASTDECADEPARTLYASARESULTOFTHEWIDESPREADAVAIL ABILITYOFINEXPENSIVEANDEASYTOUSESOUNDEDITINGSOFTWAREANDPARTLYASA RESULTOFACOLLECTIVENEEDTOCATCHUPWITHANALREADYADVANCEDPITCHBASED ANALYTICALTRADITION(OWEVERJUSTASMOSTRESEARCHONJAZZTHEORYHASSHOWN AUNILATERALPREFERENCEFORPITCHRELATEDTOPICSTHEGROWINGBODYOFWORK DEVOTEDTOMICRORHYTHMINJAZZRISKSNEGLECTINGTHEINTERACTIONBETWEENTHE PITCHANDTIMEDOMAINS3UCHISTHECASEWITHSTUDIESWHERETIMINGCONSIDER ATIONSDOMINATETHEDISCUSSIONANDPITCHINFORMATIONISEITHEREXCLUDEDFROM THEDISCUSSION"USSE#OLLIERAND#OLLIER&RIBERGAND3UNDSTRÚM 0RÚGLERDISPLAYEDBUTEXCLUDEDFROMTHEDISCUSSION%LLIS ©BYTHE3OCIETYFOR%THNOMUSICOLOGY "ENADONINDD !- %THNOMUSICOLOGY7INTER ORDISPLAYEDANDDISCUSSEDUSINGAhBYEARvAPPROACHTOMICRORHYTHMICFUNC TION(UANGAND(UANG)YER0RESSING )NTHISSTUDY)EXAMINETHENATUREOFTHEJAZZEIGHTHNOTEINORDERTO ASSESSITSEXPRESSIVEFUNCTIONITSRELATIONSHIPTOMELODYANDHARMONYAND ITSACCORDANCEWITHTHEhSWINGTRIPLETvCONCEPT4HERHYTHMICUNEVENNESS OFTHEEIGHTHNOTEISONEOFTHEHALLMARKSOFJAZZ3CHOLARSHAVEADDRESSED THISCOMPLEXSTYLISTICATTRIBUTEINDIFFERENTWAYSANDTOVARYINGDEGREES 7AADELANDUSEDFREQUENCYMODULATIONALGORITHMSTOCREATEHUMAN MOVEMENTCURVESTHATSIMULATEVARYINGPHYSICALAPPROACHESTORHYTHMIC PRODUCTIONINCLUDINGTHATOFUNEVENJAZZEIGHTHNOTES/THERSTUDIESHAVE TENDEDTOQUANTIFYTHEMAGNITUDEOFTHELONGSHORTRATIOANDITSDEPENDABILITY ONTEMPOBYZEROINGINONDIFFERENTELEMENTSOFTHEJAZZENSEMBLE#OLLIER AND#OLLIERFOCUSEDONTHERIDECYMBAL&RIBERGAND3UNDSTRÚM ONTHERIDECYMBALANDONSOLOISTS2OSEONTHERHYTHMSECTION%LLIS ONTHESAXOPHONE2EINHOLDSSONONDRUMMER2OY(AYNESAND #OLLIERAND#OLLIERON,OUIS!RMSTRONG3INCETHESESTUDIESEXAMINEA RELATIVELYNARROWPOOLOFSTYLESANDPERFORMERS)CHOSETOSAMPLEABROADER SELECTIONINORDERTOCOMPLEMENTTHEIRlNDINGS 4HEFOLLOWINGDISCUSSIONISINFORMEDBYTHE"EAT5PBEAT2ATIO"52 WHICHDESCRIBESTHETEMPORALPROPORTIONBETWEENTWOSUBSEQUENTEIGHTH NOTEShEIGHTHSvHEREINAFTERBYMEASURINGANDCOMPARINGTHEIRDURATION 4HEPAPERSUGGESTSTHREEWAYSINWHICHEXPRESSIVEMICRORHYTHMHELPSTO ARTICULATEPHRASESTRUCTURE&IRSTSHIFTSINHARMONYANDORMELODICCHARACTER SOMETIMESCOINCIDEWITHCORRESPONDINGCHANGESIN"52VALUEATCERTAIN PHRASEDEMARCATIONPOINTS3ECONDTRIPLETTYPEPHRASINGASREmECTEDIN HIGHER"52VALUESOFTENINCREASESATCADENTIALPHRASEENDINGSRESYNCHRONIZ INGTHESOLOISTWITHTHERHYTHMSECTIONSHIGHER"52VALUESANDGIVINGRISETO RHYTHMICFUSION4HIRDMOTIVICREPETITIONINVOLVESARESTATEMENTNOTONLYOF PITCHANDRHYTHMINFORMATIONBUTALSOOFMICRORHYTHMICFEATURES4HISLAST IDEAISPARTICULARLYPERTINENTTOJAZZIMPROVISATIONBECAUSEOFTHEIMPORTANT ROLEPLAYEDBYhLICKSvANDMOTIVICRESTATEMENTS)NADDITIONTOARTICULATING PHRASESTRUCTURE"52VARIATIONPLAYSAROLEINDElNINGAMUSICIANSSTYLISTIC PROlLE4HE"52DATATHAT)COLLECTEDSUPPORTTHELONGHELDASSERTIONTHAT DIFFERENTPERFORMERSTENDTOGRAVITATETOWARDSDIFFERENTMICRORHYTHMICFEELS %XTENSIVEANDCONTRASTING"52HISTOGRAMSFORlVEDIFFERENTPOSTBEBOPMUSI CIANSSUGGESTTHATDIFFERENTPERFORMERSARECHARACTERIZEDBYTHEIRINDIVIDUAL TREATMENTOFBEATSUBDIVISION)CLOSETHEPAPERWITHANEVALUATIONOFTHESE MEASUREMENTSASTHEYRELATETOTHEhSWINGTRIPLETvVIEWAND)PROPOSEREA SONSFORITSPERVASIVENESS)MAINTAINASDOOTHERSTHATTHETRIPLETPROVIDES ANINCOMPLETEREPRESENTATIONOFJAZZPERFORMANCEESPECIALLYINTHEBEBOP ANDPOSTBEBOPSTYLES "ENADONINDD !- "ENADON3LICINGTHE"EAT 4HE"EAT5PBEAT2ATIO !RATIOISAUSEFULWAYOFCHARACTERIZINGTHEDURATIONALRELATIONSHIPBE TWEENTWOSUCCESSIVEEIGHTHS4HE"EAT5PBEAT2ATIOCALCULATESTHEPROPOR TIONBETWEENTHEMBYDIVIDINGTHEDURATIONALVALUEOFTHElRSTBYTHATOFTHE SECOND4HUSTWOEQUALLYLONGORhSTRAIGHTvEIGHTHSYIELDA"52OF WHEREASA"52OFREPRESENTSATRIPLETCONlGURATIONIEAQUINTESSENTIAL hSWINGvPATTERNOFh/.%TWO4(2%%/.%TWO4(2%%/.%vETCWITH THElRSTNOTEASATIEDEIGHTHBEINGTWICEASLONGASTHENEXTTHEh4(2%%v BETWEENTHESETWOPOINTSINTHELONGSHORTCONTINUUMLIEANUMBEROFPOS SIBLEVALUESTHATPERFORMERSDRAWONTOVARIOUSEXPRESSIVEENDS)FAVOR THISNOMENCLATUREINSTEADOFTHECOMMONLYEMPLOYEDhSWINGRATIOvWHICH INTRODUCESASUBJECTIVEANDHIGHLYQUALITATIVETERMONECANEASILYIMAGINE HOWAPPLYINGAhSWINGRATIOvTOA-)$)lLEWILLPROBABLYFAILTOGUARANTEEA SWINGINGPLAYBACK%XAMPLESHOWSlVEPOSSIBLEWAYSINWHICHTHEBEAT CANBESUBDIVIDEDINTOABINARYPATTERN4HEPURPOSEOFTHISILLUSTRATIONIS NOTTOSUGGESTTHATJAZZ"52SAREDETERMINEDBYANYPARTICULARNTUPLETSUB DIVISIONBUTRATHERTOPROVIDETHEREADERWITHSTANDARDNOTATIONEQUIVALENTS THATCANSERVEASREFERENCEPOINTSINTHECONTINUUMOFPOSSIBLESUBDIVISION CONlGURATIONS)NTHISWAYA"52VALUECANBEASSIGNEDTOEVERYBEATOFA PHRASETHATISCOMPOSEDOFSUCCESSIVEEIGHTHSALLOWINGUSTOOBSERVEHOW MICRORHYTHMVARIESINTIMEACROSSTHEMUSICALPASSAGE"YMEASURINGTHE %XAMPLE&IVE"52SANDTHEIRMUSICNOTATIONEQUIVALENTS "ENADONINDD !- %THNOMUSICOLOGY7INTER DURATIONOFEIGHTHSINAGIVENEXCERPTANDCALCULATINGTHERATIOFOREACHSUB SEQUENTPAIRWECANBEGINTOSHEDLIGHTONCERTAINMICRORHYTHMICPROPERTIES OFJAZZPHRASING 4OMAKE"52MEASUREMENTS)USEDTHEDIGITALSOUNDEDITOR3OUND &ORGEONAHOME0#)MANUALLYPARSEDTHEWAVEFORMOFTHERECORDED EXCERPTINTOITSEIGHTHNOTECOMPONENTSBYUSINGTHESOFTWARES-ARKERTOOL )THENCOPIEDTHESEVALUESONTOTHECOMPUTERSCLIPBOARDANDTRANSFERRED THEMTO-ICROSOFT%XCELWHERE)CALCULATED"52SBYDIVIDINGTHEVALUEOF THE"EATEIGHTHBYTHEVALUEOFTHE5PBEATEIGHTH4HEEXCERPTSAREDRAWN FROMAVARIEDPOOLOFRECORDINGSREPRESENTINGDIFFERENTPERFORMERSPLAYING ARANGEOFINSTRUMENTS)APPLIEDTHEFOLLOWINGSETOFCRITERIAWHENSELECTING THESOURCES4HEPHRASESHOULDCONTAINATLEASTEIGHTCONSECUTIVEEIGHTHSIN ORDERTOENSURETHATTHEPLAYERISENGAGEDINhEIGHTHNOTEMODEvTHEQUALITY OFTHERECORDINGSHOULDBEGOODENOUGHTOPERMITACCURATEONSETDISCRIMINA TIONTHETEMPOSHOULDBESLOWERTHANBEATSPERMINUTETOPREVENTLARGE MARGINSOFERRORSDOUBLETIMEPHRASESANDNONhSTRAIGHTAHEADvSTYLESSUCH AS,ATINAREAVOIDEDEXCERPTSNEEDNOTMAKEUPACOMPLETEPHRASEAND ARESOMETIMESASUBSECTIONOFALONGERMUSICALSTATEMENTANDALLEXAMPLES AREINTIME)ALSOAVOIDEDPHRASESTHATEMPLOYhGHOSTNOTESvhSCOOPSv ANDOTHERORNAMENTATIONORIMPRECISEMODESOFATTACK!SARESULTTHISAR TICLEOMITSESSENTIALEXPRESSIVEELEMENTSTHATGIVEJAZZITSRHYTHMICVITALITY (OWEVERIF)WERETOINCLUDETHESEATTACKhIMPERFECTIONSvTHEDATAWOULD BECOMEHOPELESSLYUNRELIABLE)NTHISPAPER)HOPETOPROVIDELIMITEDBUT ACCURATEINFORMATIONSOTHATGRADUALLYTHEBIGPICTUREWILLBECOMPLETEDAS OTHERWRITERSCONTINUETOTACKLETHEMYSTERIESOFJAZZPERFORMANCE 0HRASE3TRUCTURE 4HEFOLLOWINGANALYSESSUPPORTTHENOTIONTHAT"52VARIATIONCANBE CLOSELYLINKEDTOTHESTRUCTURALORGANIZATIONOFJAZZPHRASING4HESEEXAMPLES AREMODESTATTEMPTSTOBEGINBRIDGINGTHEWIDEANALYTICALGAPTHATSEPARATES OURINCREASINGUNDERSTANDINGOFMICRORHYTHMICELEMENTSFROMOURDEEP ROOTEDKNOWLEDGEOFJAZZMELODYANDHARMONY)NEACHGRAPHTHEYAXIS PLOTSTHE)NTER/NSET)NTERVAL)/)ORTOTALDURATIONOFEACHEIGHTHNOTE4HE STEEPNESSOFTHESTRAIGHTLINEJOININGTHENODESPROVIDESAVISUALINDICATION OFTHEDURATIONALRELATIONSHIPBETWEENADJACENTEIGHTHS4HUSAHORIZONTAL LINEREPRESENTSASERIESOF"52SATORVERYNEARSINCETHEDURATIONOF BOTHEIGHTHSINTHEBEATISPERCEPTUALLYEQUALMUSICIANSREFERTOTHESEAS hEVENvORhSTRAIGHTvEIGHTHS/NTHEOTHERHANDANALTERNATIONOFLONG ANDSHORTEIGHTHSTRACESAJAGGEDCONTOUROFPEAKSANDVALLEYSRESPECTIVELY 4HESE"52SCANBECATEGORIZEDASEITHERLOWROUGHLYBETWEENAND "ENADONINDD !- "ENADON3LICINGTHE"EAT ORHIGHANDABOVE4HUSALOW"52MEANSTHATTHElRSTEIGHTHIS SLIGHTLYLONGERTHANTHESECONDWHEREASTHELONGSHORTRELATIONSHIPISMORE EXAGGERATEDINTHECASEOFAHIGH"524HEBOUNDARIESBETWEENTHESETHREE CATEGORIESEVENLOWHIGHSHOULDNOTBEINTERPRETEDASRIGIDCUTOFFSBUTAS APPROXIMATEMARKERSINTHEmUIDGAMUTOFPOSSIBLEBEATSUBDIVISIONS!TTHE VERYLEASTTHISSIMPLETRIPARTITETAXONOMYCANPROVEUSEFULINTHECONTEXT OFMUSICALANALYSIS &ROMAMELODICSTANDPOINTTHEPHRASEIN%XAMPLEBY*OHN#OLTRANE MAYBEDIVIDEDINTOTHREESUBSECTIONSAFOURNOTESTEPWISEANACRUSISAN EXTENDEDASCENDINGDESCENDINGSCALARPATTERNTHATFORMSTHEBULKOFTHE PHRASEANDAlNALTHREEBEATTWIRL#OLTRANEEMPHASIZESTHISINNERSTRUCTURE BYDIFFERENTIATINGBETWEEN"52MODES7HILETHEMIDDLEPARTOFTHEPHRASE ISCHARACTERIZEDBYREMARKABLYEVENEIGHTHSTHEIRSTEEPNESSIETRIPLET FEELISCONSIDERABLYGREATERDURINGBOTHTHEOPENINGANDlNALBEATSOF THEPHRASE$URINGTHETWOPICKUPBEATSTHEHIGH"52STHATISTHEMORE TRIPLETYLONGSHORTPAIRSHELPTOINCREASETHEMOMENTUMOFDOMINANTHAR MONYJUSTPRIORTOTHEDOWNBEATRESOLUTION4HESAMEISTRUEOFTHElNAL TAGALTHOUGHNOTICEHOWINSTEADOFRESOLVINGONTHEDOWNBEATOFTHELAST MEASURE#OLTRANEDELAYSTHEARRIVALOFTHE% @TONICBYEXTENDINGTHE" @HAR MONYFORANADDITIONALTWOBEATS4HEINCREASEIN"52VALUESATTHEENDOF THEPHRASEMAYALSOHELP#OLTRANERESYNCHRONIZEWITHTHERHYTHMSECTIONS HIGHER"52S)WILLDISCUSSTHISDUALITYINMOREDETAILBELOW#OLTRANEIS PLAYINGCONSISTENTLYBEHINDTHEBEATBYROUGHLYTOMSABOUTAlFTH OFTHEBEATSOINREALITYTHESYNCHRONIZATIONOFSOLOISTANDRHYTHMSECTION "52SWILLBEINTERMSOFTHEIRVALUESNOTINTERMSOFASTRICTVERTICALALIGN MENT %XAMPLE*OHN#OLTRANETENORSAXh)(EARA2HAPSODYvBPMFROM ,USH,IFE0RESTIGE/*##$ "ENADONINDD !- %THNOMUSICOLOGY7INTER %XAMPLEBY,EE+ONITZPRESENTSASIMILARDELINEATIONOFMELODICSEG MENTSTHROUGHCHANGESIN"52VALUE!SWITHTHEABOVEEXAMPLETHEPHRASE BREAKSDOWNINTOATHREEPARTSTRUCTURE(EREAMIDDLESECTIONCONSISTINGOF AQUINTUPLECHROMATICAPPROACHTOTHEPITCH'ISmANKEDBYSTEPWISEAND LEAPINGMELODIClGURES+ONITZHIGHLIGHTSTHEINNERGROUPBYREDUCINGITS "52VALUESPROVIDINGACLEARCONTRASTWITHTHELOWANDHIGH"52SOFTHE OUTERSEGMENTS.OTICEONCEAGAINHOWTHE"52SURGEOFTHElNALBEATSHELPS TOSIGNALTHEENDOFTHEPHRASEANDTODRIVETOWARDSTHElNALTONICPITCH% @ THEARRIVALOFWHICHISDELAYEDBYAFULLMEASURE 7ESEEIN%XAMPLEAHOW"ILL%VANSARTICULATESASEQUENCEOFFOUR ASCENDINGARPEGGIOSBYMAINTAININGANINVARIANTDURATIONALSTRUCTURE%ACH THREENOTEGROUPFOLLOWSADACTYLICLONGSHORTSHORTPATTERNTHATPLAYSAGAINST THEUSUALLONGSHORTRELATIONSHIP*USTPRIORTOTHElNALDOWNBEAT%VANSTRANS FORMSTHEDURATIONALUNITINTOTHESTANDARDBINARYGROUPINGWHILESIMULTANE OUSLYREVERSINGTHEDIRECTIONOFTHEARPEGGIO2ECALCULATINGTHERATIOSOFTHE lRSTFOURBEATSACCORDINGTOATRIPLEMETERGRIDALLOWSUSTOSEETHATTHEFOUR EVEN"52SOFANDWHICHASWEWILLSEECONSTITUTE UNUSUALLYEVENVALUESLIKESTRAIGHTEIGHTHSFOR%VANSSMORETRIPLETORIENTED RHYTHMICSTYLEGIVEWAYTOTWOHIDDENLOW"52SORh5"2SvOFAND 4HEAPPARENTDISAPPEARANCEOFLONGSHORTPATTERNSDURINGTHREENOTE MELODICGROUPINGSWASALSOOBSERVEDBY#OLLIERAND#OLLIERINTHEIR ANALYSIS OF ,OUIS!RMSTRONGS ENDING TAG OFh#ORNET #HOP 3UEYv )N THE CURRENTEXAMPLETHEPHRASESEGMENTATIONISFURTHEREMPHASIZEDTHROUGH VARIATIONINAMPLITUDELEVELS%VANSDIFFERENTIATESTHEDYNAMICSWITHINTHE THREENOTEGROUPSBYACCENTUATINGTHEMELODICPEAKS%XAMPLEB4AKEN TOGETHERTHESEEXAMPLESREVEALANEXPRESSIVEMECHANISMTHATLINKSREGISTER LOUDNESSANDDURATIONASAWAYOFTRACINGTHELINEARTRAJECTORYOFTHEPHRASE %XAMPLEC %XAMPLE,EE+ONITZALTOSAXh/N'REEN$OLPHIN3TREETvBPMFROM 3ATORI-ILESTONE/*##$ "ENADONINDD !- "ENADON3LICINGTHE"EAT %XAMPLE"ILL%VANSPIANOh,OVEFOR3ALEvBPMFROM-ILES$AVIS 3ESSIONS#OLUMBIA#+ A"INARYLONGSHORTGROUPINGSYIELDEVEN"52STHATCANBEREINTERPRETED ASTERNARYLONGSHORTSHORTDURATIONSB,OUDSOFTSOFTAMPLITUDELEVELS CONFORMTOTHECONlGURATIONOFTHETHREENOTEARPEGGIOSC2ESULTANTLIN EARPROGRESSION %XAMPLEILLUSTRATESTHEREMARKABLEDEGREEOFMICRORHYTHMICMALLE ABILITYOFWHICHJAZZMUSICIANSARECAPABLE,IKEAGRADUALLYSHIFTINGPATTERN OFLIGHTSSHININGONAlXEDOBJECT'EORGE3HEARINGSYSTEMATICALLYVARIESTHE PHRASES"52SAGAINSTTHESTATICBACKDROPOFACYCLEDSIXNOTElGURE4HIS MOTIVEISlRSTCASTASASERIESOFRUSHEDEIGHTHNOTESORLAIDBACKQUINTUPLETS FOLLOWINGASHORTLONGPATTERNTHATISTHEEXACTREVERSEOFTHEUSUALLONGSHORT INmECTION3HEARINGSLOWLYRECALIBRATESTHESEhINVERTEDv"52SBYTURNINGTHE SHORTSINTOLONGSANDVICEVERSATRANSITIONINGTHROUGHEVENLOWANDHIGH VALUESUNTILHEREACHESTHETRIPLETFEELOFTHERHYTHMSECTION4HISPROCESS ISCLEARLYVISIBLEINTHEGRAPHABOVETHETRANSCRIPTIONWHERETHELOWDOTS REPRESENTSHORTEIGHTHSANDTHEHIGHDOTSREPRESENTLONGEIGHTHS.OTICETHAT THEONLYEXCEPTIONINTHISASCENDING"52TRENDISTHEVALUEATTHEEND OFTHESECONDMEASUREWHICHHELPSTOSIGNALTHEBARLINETHUSPROVIDINGA WELCOMEREFERENCEPOINTWITHINTHEMICRORHYTHMICALLYEVOLVINGlGURE "ENADONINDD !- %THNOMUSICOLOGY7INTER %XAMPLE'EORGE3HEARINGPIANOh7ALKINvBPMFROM7ALKIN 4ELARC#$ 4HE"523URGE 4HEINCREASEIN"52VALUEREPRESENTINGAMORETRIPLETORIENTEDFEELAT THEENDOFEACHOFTHEABOVEEXCERPTSISNOTUNCOMMONADDITIONALEXAMPLES CANBEFOUNDTHROUGHOUTTHETRANSCRIPTIONSINTHE!PPENDIXPOSTEDONTHE 3%-WEBSITE4HISPHRASEENDING"52SURGEMIGHTBEEXPLAINEDINTHECON TEXTOFTENSIONRESOLUTION3INCERHYTHMSECTION"52VALUESAREGENERALLY HIGHERMOREhTRIPLETYvTHANTHOSEOFSOLOISTS&RIBERGAND3UNDSTRÚM ASOLOISTTRANSITIONINGFROMLOWTOHIGH"52SISINEFFECThRESOLVINGvFROMA MICRORHYTHMICALLYDISSONANTSTATETOACONSONANTONE&RIBERGAND3UNDSTRÚM FOUNDTHATINRELATIONTOTHEDRUMMERSRIDECYMBALPATTERNSOLOISTS TENDTODELAYDOWNBEATSANDSYNCHRONIZEOFFBEATS4HE"52SURGETHEORY COMPLEMENTSTHISOBSERVATIONBYSUGGESTINGTHATSOLOISTSTENDTOINCREASE THEIR"52SATPHRASEENDINGSINORDERTOSYNCHRONIZEBOTHDOWNBEATSAND OFFBEATSWITHTHERHYTHMSECTIONTHEREBYINCORPORATINGAPHRASEENDING EXPRESSIVEDEVICE7ESHOULDNOTEHOWEVERTHATSOLOISTANDRHYTHMSECTION "52SMIGHTNOTBEPERFECTLYALIGNEDIFTHESOLOISTISPLAYINGBEHINDTHEBEAT ASWASTHECASEINTHE#OLTRANEEXCERPTABOVE&URTHERMOREINTHEABOVE +ONITZEXCERPTTHEONLYACCOMPANIMENTIS$AVE(OLLANDSBASSSO+ONITZS "52SURGECANNOTBEEXPLAINEDASASYNCHRONIZATIONWITHTHERHYTHMSECTION BECAUSETHEREISNORHYTHMSECTIONTOSPEAKOF!NOTHERWAYOFTHINKING ABOUTTHE"52SURGEEFFECTISINTERMSOFAlGUREANDGROUNDSCHEMA)YER MAINTAINSTHATLOWER"52SMAKETHEMAINPULSEMOREDIFlCULTTOPER CEIVEBECAUSEOFINCREASEDHOMOGENEITYANDTHATCONVERSELYHIGHER"52S ENHANCETHEPERCEPTIONOFTHEMAINPULSEBYFACILITATINGTHEPERCEPTIONOF AHIGHERRHYTHMICSTRUCTURE4HISHEARGUESISAPOSSIBLEREASONWHYJAZZ MUSICIANShSWINGvTHEIREIGHTHS!DOPTINGTHISPLAUSIBLELINEOFREASONING "ENADONINDD !- "ENADON3LICINGTHE"EAT ALLOWSUSTOVIEWTHE"52SURGEASAWAYFORPERFORMERSTOGOINANDOUT OFFOCUSINRELATIONTOTHEUNDERLYINGTACTUSCONCEALINGITWITHLOWER"52S ANDMAKINGITEXPLICITWITHHIGHERONESATSTRUCTURALLYSIGNIlCANTPOINTS "526ARIATION !SWEHAVESEENTHEJUXTAPOSITIONOFHIGHANDLOW"52SCANBEAN EFFECTIVEWAYTOHIGHLIGHTTHESTRUCTUREOFAPHRASE%VENWHENPHRASESUB STRUCTUREISNOTBEINGSPELLEDOUTVIAMICRORHYTHMACONSIDERABLEDEGREE OF"52VARIABILITYAPPEARSTOBECOMMON4HISISFURTHEREVIDENCEDBYTHE TRANSCRIPTIONSINTHE!PPENDIXANDIN%XAMPLEWHERESUBDIVISIONRATIOS WITHINPHRASESOFTENCOVERAWIDERANGEOFVALUES %XAMPLE4EN"52SAMPLES "UD0OWELLPIANOh3OMETIMES)M(APPYvBPMFROM*AZZ'IANT 6ERVE02ED'ARLANDPIANOh)T#OULD(APPENTO9OUvFROM 2ELAXIN7ITHTHE-ILES$AVIS1UINTET0RESTIGE/*##$#HARLIE 0ARKERALTOSAXh.OWSTHE4IMEvFROM#HARLIE0ARKERAT3TORYVILLE "LUE.OTE#$00HIL7OODSALTOSAXh0ENNIESFROM(EAVENv FROM"IRD#ALLS6OL3AVOY*AZZ:$3*OE(ENDERSONTENOR SAXh)SOTOPEvFROM)NNER5RGE"LUE.OTE#$0*IMMY (AMILTONCLARINETh4RUMPET.O%NDvFROM$UKE%LLINGTONAND(IS /RCHESTRA4HE'OLDEN$UKE0RESTIGE7AYNE3HORTERTENORSAX h3PEAK.O%VILvFROM3PEAK.O%VIL"LUE.OTE#$0,ES TER9OUNGTENORSAXh9OURE$RIVING-E#RAZYvFROM4HE#OMPLETE n3MALL'ROUP3ESSIONS6OLn"LUE-OON"-#$ 2OY%LRIDGETRUMPETh"IG3HOEvFROM$UKE%LLINGTONAND*OHNNY (ODGES3IDEBY3IDE6ERVE&REDDIE(UBBARDTRUMPETh3PEAK .O%VILvSEE "ENADONINDD !- %THNOMUSICOLOGY7INTER 7HETHERWORKINGTOARTICULATETHEPHRASESINNERFORMORNOTSUCH"52 CONTRASTSOCCURWITHINABEATBYBEATTEMPORALFRAMEWORKANDTHUSOPER ATEONTHELEVELOFECHOICMEMORYROUGHLYUPTOFOURSECONDS4HISSORT OFCONTRASTCANAFFECTOURhONTHEmYvPERCEPTIONOFPHRASING/FTENTHE CONTRASTBETWEENHIGHANDLOW"52SOCCURSNOTWITHINBUTACROSSPHRASES THATCANLIEAFEWMEASURESORPERHAPSEVENAFEWMINUTESAPARTFROMEACH OTHER4HESENUANCESCANCONTRIBUTETOTHESOLOSEXPRESSIVEDEPTHBYES TABLISHINGCOGNITIVECONNECTIONSBETWEENTHEBEATBYBEATMICRORHYTHMIC VARIATIONANDTHELONGERSPANNINGREALMSOFSHORTTERMMEMORYROUGHLY UPTOAMINUTEANDLONGTERMMEMORYROUGHLYAMINUTEORMORE7ALTER "ISHOP*RSPIANOSOLOINh-ELODYFOR-ELONAEvSERVESASANEXAMPLE%X AMPLE$URINGMOSTOFHISSOLO"ISHOPARTICULATESEIGHTHNOTERUNSWITH PREDOMINANTLYHIGH"52S(ECONTRASTSTHISARTICULATIONTOWARDSTHEENDOF THESOLOBYPLAYINGANEXCLUSIVELYEVENLY"52EDPASSAGE.OTICEHOWHE CAPSOFFTHEPHRASEBYRETURNINGONCEAGAINTOTHEHIGHER"52STHATPERME ATEHISSOLO,ATERWEWILLSEEHOWDIFFERENTMEMBERSOFTHEGROUPINFUSE THEMUSICWITHTHEIRINDIVIDUALMICRORHYTHMICFEELSCOLLECTIVELYSATURATING THEPOSSIBILITIESOFBEATSUBDIVISIONTOEXPANDTHEEXPRESSIVEDIMENSIONSOF APERFORMANCE 4EMPOPLAYSAROLEINTHEPERCEPTIONOF"52VARIATION!FEWSTUDIES HAVESHOWNTHATTEMPOAND"52SAREINVERSELYPROPORTIONALTHATISTHAT EIGHTHSBECOMEMOREEVENATFASTERTEMPOS&RIBERGAND3UNDSTRÚM MEASUREDTHEhSWINGRATIOSvOFRIDECYMBALPATTERNSASPLAYEDBYFOUREX PERTJAZZDRUMMERS/NAVERAGERATIOSDECREASEDASTEMPOINCREASED#OL LIERAND#OLLIEROBTAINEDSIMILARRESULTSWHENJAZZDRUMMERSWERE ASKEDTOPERFORMONA-)$)DRUMPADATENDENCYFURTHERSUPPORTEDBY %XAMPLE7ALTER"ISHOP*RPIANOh-ELODYFOR-ELONAEvBPMFROM *ACKIE-C,EAN,ET&REEDOM2ING"LUE.OTE "ENADONINDD !- "ENADON3LICINGTHE"EAT DATAGATHEREDFROM-)$)WINDCONTROLLERSIN%LLIS4HESElNDINGSARE NOTSUPPORTEDBYTHEDATAGATHEREDINTHEPRESENTSTUDYWHEREASTATISTICAL ANALYSISFAILEDTODETECTANEGATIVECORRELATIONBETWEENTEMPOAND"52S 7ITHTHEPOLAROPPOSITEEXCEPTIONSTHATASOLOISTSIRONOUTTHEIREIGHTHS ATVERYFASTTEMPOSANDBnFEELISMORECOMMONLYASSOCIATEDWITH SLOWERTEMPOSTHERESEEMSTOBENOSYSTEMATICINTERDEPENDENCEBETWEEN TEMPOANDSUBDIVISIONRATIOS)TISESPECIALLYIMPORTANTTOSTRESSTHATSLOWER TEMPOSDONOTNECESSARILYYIELDHIGHER"52SASMANYEXCERPTSTHROUGHOUT THISPAPERCANATTEST2ATHERTHANTRYINGTOPINACORRESPONDENCEBETWEEN "52ANDTEMPOPERHAPSAMOREREWARDINGENDEAVORISTOTHINKABOUTHOW DIFFERENTRATIOSAREPERCEIVEDATDIFFERENTTEMPOS)TSEEMSSAFETOASSUMETHAT NOMATTERWHATTHETEMPOMIGHTBETHEDIFFERENCEBETWEEN"52SAND WILLBEEASILYREGISTEREDBYANEXPERIENCEDLISTENERBUTTHATBETWEEN ANDWILLNOT%VENTHOUGHANEXACTASSESSMENTOF"52DISCRIMINA TIONTHRESHOLDSISBEYONDTHESCOPEOFTHISSTUDYWECANCONTEXTUALIZETHE NUMBERSBYDIGGINGALITTLEDEEPERINTOTHEMEANINGOFUNEVENSUBDIVISION !LONGSHORTRELATIONSHIPIMPLIESADEVIATIONFROMTHEISOCHRONYOFEVEN EIGHTHS"YDElNITIONA"52ISARELATIVEINDICATORBECAUSEITCOMPARES ITEMSRELATIVETOEACHOTHER4HUSTHELONGEIGHTHMIGHTBESAIDTOSTANDIN ATORATIOTOTHESHORTEIGHTHCOMPRISINGOFTHEBEATINSTEADOFAN ISOCHRONOUS4HEDEVIATIONFROMISOCHRONYCANALSOBECHARACTERIZEDIN ABSOLUTETERMSSUCHAShTHELONGEIGHTHEXTENDSBEYONDTHEMIDPOINTOFTHE BEATBYMILLISECONDSv4HEQUANTITYMSISANABSOLUTEREPRESENTATION UNLIKEARATIOORAPERCENTAGE3OWHATROLEDOESTEMPOPLAYINDETERMIN INGTHEMAGNITUDEOFPERCEIVABLE"52CHANGE!TBEATSPERMINUTEFOR INSTANCETHEREISADIFFERENCEOFMILLISECONDSBETWEEN"52SAND WHEREASATTWICETHETEMPOTHEDIFFERENCEBETWEENTHESAMERATIOSISONLY MILLISECONDS4HEREFOREATSLOWERTEMPOSTHEDISTINCTIONBETWEENDIFFERENT "52VALUESMAYBEMOREREADILYPERCEIVEDTHANATFASTERTEMPOSTHOUGHIT ISDIFlCULTTODETERMINEHOWLARGEOFAMILLISECONDDIFFERENCELISTENERSARE ABLETODISCERN&ORMONOTONIC)/)SUNDERMSLISTENERSCANDISCRIMINATE CHANGESASSMALLASMS&RIBERGAND3UNDBERGBUTTHISlGUREISFAR FROMBEINGECOLOGICALLYVALIDANDISLIKELYTOBESIGNIlCANTLYHIGHERINTHE BUSYCONTEXTOFAJAZZPERFORMANCE $UPLICATION 4HEPREVIOUSEXAMPLECOMPARESDIFFERENTPHRASESTOSHOWHOWTHEIR MICRORHYTHMICPROlLESDIFFER.OWLETUSBROACHTHEQUESTIONOFHOWSUB DIVISIONRATIOSAREAFFECTEDWHENTHESAMEPHRASEORMOTIVEISREPEATED )NOTHERWORDSDOESARESTATEMENTOFAGIVENSERIESOFPITCHESENTAILA CORRESPONDINGTRANSFERENCEOFMICRORHYTHMICINFORMATION3INCEMOTIVIC "ENADONINDD !- %THNOMUSICOLOGY7INTER REPETITIONISANESSENTIALBUILDINGBLOCKOFJAZZIMPROVISATIONITWOULDBE HELPFULTOUNDERSTANDHOWMICRORHYTHMPLAYSINTOTHISCONTEXT!S)WILL SHOWINSOMEINSTANCESMELODICREPETITIONINVOLVESARESTATEMENTNOTONLY OFAPITCHSEQUENCEBUTALSOOFTHEORIGINAL"52VALUESASCRIBEDTOTHOSE PITCHES)WILLREFERTOTHISPHENOMENONASDUPLICATION)NTHEFOLLOWING EXAMPLESANADDITIONALPARAMETERISINTRODUCED)CALCULATED1UARTER.OTE $URATION1.$BYSUMMINGTHEDURATIONSOFTHETWOBEATANDUPBEAT EIGHTHSOR)/)SCOMPRISINGTHEBEAT#OMBINEDTHEDATAAFFORDEDBYBOTH 1.$SAND"52SPROVIDEATWOPRONGEDVIEWOFDUPLICATION)FWECANSHOW THATTWOMICRORHYTHMICINDICATORSREMAINNEARLYUNCHANGEDWHENAPHRASE ISREPEATEDOBVIOUSLYTHISALLOWSUSTOFORMULATEASTRONGERCASEFORDUPLICA TIONTHANIFONLYONEINDICATORWEREUSED #ONSIDERTHEEXCERPTEXTRACTEDFROMTWOIDENTICALPHRASESOCCURRINGAT DIFFERENTPOINTSINA-ILES$AVISSOLO%XAMPLE4HETWOPHRASESOPENCHO RUSESANDOFTHEBLUESh3TRAIGHT.O#HASERv)NORDERTOASSESSWHETHER DUPLICATIONISTAKINGPLACETHEIR"52AND1.$LEVELSAREDISPLAYEDGRAPHI CALLYSIDEBYSIDE4HEMICRORHYTHMICSIMILARITIESBETWEENTHETWOEXCERPTS CANBESEENINBOTHPARAMETERSSINELIKESHAPEANDTHEYAREREmECTEDINTHE CORRELATIONVALUESR"52R1.$!SILLUSTRATEDBYTHESOLIDDOTS ANDSQUARESABOVETHETRANSCRIPTIONBOTHVERSIONSOFTHEPHRASEBEGINWITH ATRIPLETFEELTHENDIPTOWARDSSTRAIGHTEIGHTHSINTHESECONDHALFOFTHElRST BARBEFOREREPEATINGTHESAMERISEANDFALLPATTERNINTHESECONDBAR 4HENEXTEXAMPLELOOKSATDUPLICATIONINTHECONTEXTOFTHEJAZZhHEADv SONGMELODY%XAMPLEACONTAINSAFRAGMENTFROMTHEMELODYTOh'OOD "AITvASPERFORMEDBY*OHN#OLTRANE4HESAMElGUREOCCURSATOTALOFEIGHT %XAMPLE-ILES$AVISTRUMPETh3TRAIGHT.O#HASERvBPMFROM! 2ETROSPECTIVE$EJA6U$6#$ "ENADONINDD !- "ENADON3LICINGTHE"EAT %XAMPLE*OHN#OLTRANEh'OOD"AITvBPMFROM3OULTRANE0RESTIGE /*##$ A-ELODYFRAGMENTB"52ANDC1.$COMPARISONSACROSSALLEIGHTOC CURRENCESFORBEATSAND TIMESONMEASURESAPERFECTFOURTHHIGHERANDOFTHEOPEN INGANDCLOSING!!"!CHORUSES4HE"52COMPARISON%XAMPLEBOFTHE FRAGMENTACROSSALLEIGHTOCCURRENCESBRINGSTOLIGHTTHATINALLINSTANCES EXCEPTTHETHIRDANDSEVENTHWHICHPRESENTALMOSTNEGLIGIBLEDEVIATIONS "52VALUESFORBEATSTHROUGHAREARRANGEDINASCENDINGORDERBEAT "52SARERANDOMLYDISTRIBUTEDANDHAVEBEENOMITTEDFROMTHEGRAPH .OTABLYTHISORDERINGCONlRMSTHE"52SURGEEFFECTDISCUSSEDEARLIER4HE "ENADONINDD !- %THNOMUSICOLOGY7INTER 1.$COMPARISON%XAMPLECFURTHERSTRENGTHENSTHEMICRORHYTHMICLINK BETWEENALLEIGHTVERSIONSBYREVEALINGANINTERESTINGDURATIONALHIERARCHY BEATUSUALLYHASTHEGREATESTDURATIONITISFOLLOWEDBYBEATWHICHIN TURNISLONGERTHANBEATSEVENOUTOFEIGHTTIMES#OMPARINGTHISORDERING TOTHATOFTHE"52SWENOTICETHATTHEYARENEGATIVELYCORRELATEDOMITTING THEUNSTABLEBEATR3IMPLYPUT"52VALUESINCREASETHROUGHTHEBAR WHEREAS1.$SDECREASE4HECOMBINATIONOFRISING"52SANDSHORTENING BEATSHELPSTOPROPELTHEMELODYTOWARDSTHElNALDOWNBEAT -USICAL0ERSONALITY !PERFORMERSMUSICALPERSONALITYISDElNEDBYAVARIETYOFFACTORSINCLUD INGTIMBREPHRASEREPERTOIREANDRHYTHMICFEELOFWHICHBEATSUBDIVISION ISASIGNIlCANTCOMPONENT*AZZCRITICANDWRITER-ARTIN7ILLIAMSISQUOTED BY"ERENDTASSAYINGTHAThEACHOFTHEGREATPLAYERSHASFOUNDHIS ;SIC=OWNWAYOFPRONOUNCINGTHE;SWING=TRIPLETEXPRESSEDORIMPLIEDAND 2OY%LDRIDGESTRIPLETDOESNTSOUNDLIKE,OUIS!RMSTRONGS-ILES$AVIS DIDNTSOUNDLIKE$IZZY'ILLESPIES,ESTER9OUNGSTRIPLETWASUNLIKE#OLE MAN(AWKINSAND3TAN'ETZSISUNLIKE,ESTER9OUNGSv4OWHICH"ERENDT CORRECTLYADDSTHAThTHEREDOESNTEXISTANYFORMOFNOTATIONGRAPHIC REPRESENTATIONANDCOMPUTERANALYSISCAPABLEOFSATISFACTORILYREGISTERING THESUBTLETYOFTHESERHYTHMICPROCESSESWHICHDIFFERNOTJUSTSTYLISTICALLY BUTALSOINTERMSOFSPECIlCDISTINCTIONSBETWEENGROUPSANDINDIVIDUALSv &IGURETAKESABABYSTEPTOWARDSQUANTIFYINGSUCHRHYTHMICPROCESSES )TBRINGSTOGETHER"52HISTOGRAMSFORlVEPERFORMERSWHOASAGROUPPRO VIDEAREPRESENTATIVESAMPLEOFTHEPOSTBEBOPSTYLE-ILES$AVISTRUMPET *OHN#OLTRANEAND$EXTER'ORDONTENORSAXOPHONE*ULIANh#ANNONBALLv !DDERLEYALTOSAXOPHONEAND"ILL%VANSPIANO4HEDATAINTHISGRAPH AREDRAWNFROMTHETRANSCRIPTIONSINTHE!PPENDIXONTHE3%-WEBSITE %ACHCOLUMNINTHEGRAPHREPRESENTSTHENUMBEROF"52STHATOCCURWITHIN AGIVENSLICEOFTHE"52CONTINUUMACROSSALLEXCERPTS)NTERESTINGLYBUT NOTSURPRISINGLYEACHPLAYERSDISTINCTIVERHYTHMICSTYLEISREmECTEDIN THEPROlLEOFHISDISTRIBUTIONCURVE&OREXAMPLEWHILETHEPREDOMINANT "52VALUEFOR!DDERLEY$AVISAND%VANSISCLOSERTOEVENEIGHTHS THATlGUREDENOTESALOWERLIMITIN%VANSWHOSEMOREhTRIPLETYvVALUESARE HEAVILYDISTRIBUTEDTOWARDSTHERIGHTSIDEOFTHEGRAPHANDACENTRALPEAKIN !DDERLEYAND$AVIS3IMILARLYTHECLUSTERAROUNDISSTRICTLYEXCLUSIVEIN 'ORDONSCASEBUTSMOOTHLYFOREGROUNDEDIN#OLTRANES4HESEOBSERVATIONS ARESUMMARIZEDIN&IGUREBWHICHILLUSTRATESTHEAPPORTIONMENTOFVALUES INTHETOZONEBYSPLITTINGITINTOITSLOWERMIDDLEANDUPPERTHIRDS 4HATSUCHDIFFERENCESEXISTACROSSPERFORMERSUNDERSCORESTHENOTIONTHAT EXPRESSIVEFEATURESOFhTIMEFEELvSERVETODElNETHESTYLISTICPROlLESOFJAZZ "ENADONINDD !- &IGURE0ERFORMERPROlLES A)NDIVIDUAL"52HISTOGRAMSANDB"52DISTRIBUTIONNFORALLEXCEPT $AVISN "ENADONINDD !- %THNOMUSICOLOGY7INTER MUSICIANS"AUER"ENADON"USSE(UANGAND(UANG (ENCEITSEEMSAPPROPRIATETOAMEND&RIBERGAND3UNDSTRÚMS SUGGESTIONTHATONESHOULDhDISTINGUISHBETWEENINSTRUMENTSANDFUNCTION SOLOACCOMPANIMENTWHENDISCUSSINGSWINGRATIOSvBYADDINGhINDIVIDUAL PERFORMERSvTOTHEMIX4HUSINTHESAMEWAYTHATDIFFERENTJAZZPERFORMERS BRINGTHEIROWNMELODICHARMONICTIMBRALANDRHYTHMICCONCEPTIONSTOA GIVENPERFORMANCETHEBLENDINGOFTHEIRUNIQUEMICRORHYTHMICAPPROACHES CONTRIBUTESTOTHEMUSICALRICHNESSOFANENSEMBLEPERFORMANCE)NTHEBLUES h3ONNYS#RIBvFORINSTANCE#URTIS&ULLERSHIGH"52SSTANDINSHARPCONTRAST TOTHEOTHERTHREESOLOISTSMOREEVENSUBDIVISIONS)Nh*INRIKISHAvTHEDIF FERENTTYPESOFLONGSHORTGROUPINGSARTICULATEDBY*OE(ENDERSON+ENNY $ORHAMAND-C#OY4YNERGIVERISETOTHREE"52LAYERSEACHEXPLORINGA DIFFERENTREGIONOFTHELONGSHORTCONTINUUM%XAMPLE 4HE1UESTIONOFTHE3WINGING4RIPLET 4HEOVERALLABUNDANCEOF"52VALUESBETWEENANDINTHEFORE GOINGEXAMPLESSUGGESTSTHATEVENEIGHTHSAREMOREFREQUENTINJAZZTHANIS GENERALLYACKNOWLEDGED4HEREISALSOANOTICEABLEPREPONDERANCEOF"52S INTHETORANGE)FTHISRANGEREPRESENTSROUGHLYTHETHRESHOLDWHERE THEUNEVENNESSOFEIGHTHDURATIONBECOMESPERCEPTIBLETOTHELISTENERABIG hIFvTHATWILLREQUIREEMPIRICALCORROBORATIONWECOULDTHENSURMISETHATJAZZ SOLOISTSAIMTOARTICULATEAFEELINGOFLONGSHORTNESSATITShMILDESTvPOSSIBLE STATE!TTHESAMETIMETHEREISAWIDESPREADBELIEFTHATINJAZZMUSICASE QUENTIALPAIROFTEMPORALLYUNEVENEIGHTHNOTESCONFORMSTOATRIPLETSUBDIVI SIONWITHTHEDURATIONOFTHElRSTNOTEACCOUNTINGFORTWOTHIRDSOFTHEBEAT 7HILETHISNOTIONISLIKELYTOBEQUALIlEDBYMANYLISTENERSANDPERFORMERS ITISPREVALENTAMONGJAZZSTUDENTSANDEDUCATORSANDASSUMMARIZEDINTHE TABLEBELOWITABOUNDSINTHELITERATUREBEGINNINGWITH-ARTIN7ILLIAMSS ABOVEQUOTE&ORFURTHERPROOFOFTHISALMOSTUNIVERSALCONVICTIONWECAN TURNTOTHENUMEROUSJAZZLEADSHEETSTHATBEARTHECONVENTIONALINSCRIPTION ATTHETOPSHOWINGTWOEIGHTHSFOLLOWEDBYTHREEEIGHTHSTHElRSTTWOOF WHICHARETIEDWITHATRIPLETBAROVERTHETHREETHATISINDICATINGTHATTWO NOTATEDEIGHTHSARETOBEPLAYEDINASTANDARDhSWINGvFEEL4HISINSCRIPTION MOSTCOMMONLYAPPEARSONBIGBANDSWINGCHARTSASTYLETHATPOSSIBLYOW INGTOTHEGREATERNUMBEROFMUSICIANSPLAYINGSIMULTANEOUSLYTENDSTOBE MOREREGIMENTEDTOWARDTRIPLETSUBDIVISION(OWEVERTHETRIPLETDECREEIS HARDLYLIMITEDTOSWINGSTYLEBIGBANDCHARTS)N+ERNFELDSTRAN SCRIPTIONOFA*IMMY(AMILTONCLARINETBREAKTHEHEADINGhSWINGEIGHTHSv ISUSEDTOAVOIDhCUMBERSOMETRIPLETNOTATIONvEVENTHOUGHTHEACTUAL"52 VALUESLIENOWHERENEARTHETRIPLETSEEIN%XAMPLEABOVE "ENADONINDD !- %XAMPLE#ONTRASTING"52APPROACHES Ah3ONNYS#RIBvALTERNATETAKEBPMFROM3ONNY#LARK3ONNYS #RIB"LUE.OTEBh*INRIKISHAvFROM*OE(ENDERSON0AGE /NE"LUE.OTE "ENADONINDD !- %THNOMUSICOLOGY7INTER 4ABLE4HEh*AZZ4RIPLETvINTHE,ITERATURE THERHYTHMICINTERPRETATIONOFTHEJAZZIMPROVISERSMOSTCONSISTENTLYUSED RHYTHMTHEEIGHTHNOTEPATTERNBECOMESALONGSHORTTRIPLETPATTERN#OKER 4HERHYTHMOFLEGITIMATEJAZZINCLUDEDTRIPLETSWING2OBINSON *AZZMUSICIANSDONOTUSUALLYNOTATESWINGRHYTHMTHEWAYTHATITSOUNDS BECAUSEINDICATIONSOFATRIPLETSUBDIVISIONOFTHEBEATCLUTTERTHEPAGE +ERNFELD EACHMEASURE;DIVIDES=INTOFOURBEATSANDEACHBEATINTOTHREEPULSES "ILMES ;#HARLIE0ARKER=SUPPLIEDLINEARSUBSTANCEANDANEIGHTHNOTETRIPLETAPPROACH TOPHRASINGTHATWASPERFECTLYRIGHT#ROUCH;= 7HENAJAZZMUSICIANISGIVENAPASSAGEOFQUAVERSTHERESULTINGRHYTHMIS NEARERTOATRIPLET$ANKWORTH #ONVENTIONALJAZZRHYTHMSAREBASEDONATRIPLETSTRUCTURETHATISONA TERNARYRHYTHMFEELING"ERENDT !VALUEOF;PERCENT=PRODUCESPERFECTTRIPLETFEELSWING&INALEn 4HERATIOOFWASUSEDINTHISEXPERIMENTASTHISISTHEDEFAULTRATIOMOST COMMONLYEMPLOYEDBYJAZZEDUCATORS!BEL 4HISSTUDYS"52SSELDOMEXCEEDANDMOSTOFTENLIEBETWEEN ANDAREMARKABLEDEVIATIONFROMTHENEIGHBORHOODOFTHELEGEND ARYSWINGINGTRIPLET7HILETHEEXAMPLESPRESENTEDINTHISSTUDYREPRESENT ANINlNITESIMALFRACTIONOFTHEJAZZDISCOGRAPHYTHEFACTTHATTHEYWERE SELECTEDATRANDOMTHATISWITHOUTABIASFORNONTRIPLETPHRASINGINDICATES THATTHESEOBSERVATIONSARELIKELYTOHOLDTRUEACROSSMANYOTHERBEBOPAND POSTBEBOPPERFORMANCES4HISWINDOWOFVALUESISALSOLOWERTHANTHOSE PROPOSEDBYOTHERWRITERS%LLISSANALYSISOFBEATSUBDIVISIONRATIOS ASEXHIBITEDBYTHREESAXOPHONISTSYIELDEDAVERAGEVALUESOFTO #OLLIERAND#OLLIERWRITETHAThTHEREISGOODREASONTOBELIEVETHAT THESWINGEIGHTHSRATIORANGESBETWEENTOANDTOvWHEREAS 0RESSINGSUGGESTSINSTEADASLIGHTLYLOWERRANGEOFTO)N ANYCASETHECOMBINEDEVIDENCEDISPROVESTHEIDEATHATJAZZEIGHTHSARE ASARULECARVEDFROMATRIPLETMOLD7HILENOSINGLEMODELCANACCOUNTFOR THEINlNITERANGEOFVARIATIONINEIGHTHPAIRSTRIPLETTYPESUBDIVISIONSSEEM NOTONLYINFREQUENTBUTALSOREMOTELYDISTANCEDFROMTHEMAJORITYOFRATIOS FOUNDINTHISSTUDY!S)REMARKEDEARLIER"52VALUESARENONUNIFORMWITHIN PHRASESOFTENOSCILLATINGCONSIDERABLYFROMBEATTOBEAT7HEREWRITERSHAVE SUCCEEDEDINAVOIDINGTHETRIPLETASADEFAULTVALUETHEYHAVEFAILEDINSTEAD INPROPOSINGAPREDETERMINED"52BEIT'RIDLEYETAL "ENADONINDD !- "ENADON3LICINGTHE"EAT "ILESOR)YER$OUBTINGTHETRIPLETSSUPREMACYSEEMS WISEBOTHBECAUSEITAPPEARSTOBEANINADEQUATEVALUEANDBECAUSEADHER INGTOANYlXEDRATIOCONSTITUTESAMISREPRESENTATIONOFTHERICHVARIETYOF EXPRESSIVEMICROSTRUCTURESFOUNDINJAZZ2ATHERTHANREPLACINGTHETRIPLET PARADIGMOURAIMASJAZZSCHOLARSSHOULDBETOEMPHASIZETHEABSURDITYOF ASCRIBINGTOANYRIGIDFORMULAWHATSOEVER 4HEFACTTHATTHETRIPLETCONCEPTISDEEPLYENGRAINEDINTHEJAZZDISCOURSE ANDUPHELDBYWRITERSOFVARIEDSCHOLARLYPERSPECTIVESONLYSERVESTOPERPETU ATEITSPOPULARITY9ETITISNOTAMONGTHISPAPERSGOALSTODENYTHEEXISTENCE OFTRIPLETTYPEEIGHTHSBUTMERELYTODOWNPLAYTHEIRUBIQUITY4OBESURE EXCLUSIVELYTRIPLETEDPHRASESDOOCCURSEEFOREXAMPLE"ILL%VANSIN THE!PPENDIXTHOUGHSEEMINGLYNOTOFTENENOUGHTOBOLSTERTHECLAIMTHAT JAZZEIGHTHSAREFUNDAMENTALLYTRIPLETS3OWHYISTRIPLETSUBDIVISIONOFTEN TOUTEDASANINDISPENSABLECOMPONENTOFJAZZPERFORMANCE&ORONEBECAUSE JAZZSOLOISTSOFTENlLLINTHEBEATWITHTRIPLETSGIVINGTHETRIPLETAPROMINENT ROLE!LSOBECAUSETHETRIPLETREPRESENTATIONISTHESIMPLESTPOSSIBLEWAY TODENOTEADIVISIONINTOTWOUNEQUALPARTSLONGANDSHORTOWINGTOTHE FACTTHATTHENUMBERISTHELOWESTORDERPRIMETOCONTAINANASYMMETRICAL BINARYGROUPING7HILEOTHERREPRESENTATIONSMAYPROVIDEMOREAC CURATEDESCRIPTIONSOFTHEACTUALDURATIONALRATIOSTAKINGPLACEINJAZZEIGHTHS THEYCANSEEMUNNECESSARILYCONVOLUTED)TWOULDBEMOREORLESSTRUEBUT HIGHLYIMPRACTICALFOREXAMPLETOSAYTHAT-ILES$AVISPHRASESHISEIGHTH NOTESWITHANELEVENTUPLETFEELOFATYPICAL"52OF4HEREFORETHE TRIPLETVIEWMAYOWEITSPERVASIVENESSTOTHEPSYCHOLOGICALCONVENIENCEOF CONVERTINGCOMPLEXRATIOSINTOSIMPLEONES0OVELASKEDBOTHMUSI CALLYTRAINEDANDUNTRAINEDSUBJECTSTOLISTENTODIFFERENTSHORTLONGSEQUENCES CONSISTINGOFTWODURATIONSWHOSERATIOSRANGEDFROMTO7HEN SUBJECTSWEREASKEDTOREPRODUCETHESEPATTERNSTHEYTENDEDTOLENGTHEN ORSHORTENTHESHORTERDURATIONTOWARDSTHUSAIMINGFORASHORTLONGRATIO WHERETHESHORTVALUEWASONEHALFOFTHELONGVALUE4HUSWHILEPATTERNSIN ARATIOWERECORRECTLYIMITATEDIMITATIONOFALLOTHERPATTERNSFOLLOWEDA SYSTEMATICDEVIATIONFROMTHERATIOINTHESTIMULITOWARDANINTERVALRELATION OF4HISTENDENCYISVIEWEDBY0OVELASANATTEMPTTOlTTHESTIMULUS INTOANINTERNALMENTALSTRUCTURETHATFAVORSASIMPLERATIO/NTHEmIPSIDE #OLLIERAND7RIGHTSHOWTHATMUSICIANSTENDTOPERFORMTRIPLETSAT RATIOSLOWERTHANTHEEXPECTED(ENCETHECONVICTIONTHATTRIPLETSARE BASICTOJAZZMAYARISEFROMTHEBELIEFTHATA"52OFSAYISHOWTRIPLET EIGHTHSACTUALLYSOUNDCOUPLEDWITHTHELACKOFIMPORTANCECONFERREDTO SMALLDEVIATIONSFROMTHATVALUE)NOTHERWORDSIFALISTENERASSOCIATESTHE TRIPLETCONSTRUCTWITHA"52OFTHENA"52OFPERCEPTUALLYSLIGHTLY DIFFERENTFORANEXPERIENCEDLISTENERMIGHTSEEMTOOINSIGNIlCANTAVARIATION TOWARRANTSCRAPPINGTHETRIPLETTERMINOLOGY "ENADONINDD !- %THNOMUSICOLOGY7INTER !NOTHERREASONFORTHETRIPLETSPROMINENCEISTHATJAZZDRUMMERSTYPI CALLYEMPHASIZETHELATENESSOFTHEUPBEATEIGHTHWHICHPRECEDESBEATS AND/NEOFTHEQUINTESSENTIALSOUNDSOFJAZZISTHERIDECYMBALORHIHAT hLAYINGDOWNTHETIMEvWITHALONGSHORTPATTERNMOREAKINTOATRIPLETTHAN TOOTHERHIGHERORDERTUPLETS2OSEREPORTEDAMEAN"52OFIN PLAYALONGRHYTHMSECTIONSAND0RÚGLEROBSERVEDCONSISTENThRIDETAP PICKUPv"52SOFATBPMINTHEPLAYINGOF#HARLIE+EIL2EPLAC INGTHESOMEWHATARTIlCIALLABORATORYSETTINGWITHREALLIFEPERFORMANCE SITUATIONS&RIBERGAND3UNDSTRÚMANALYZEDTHEPLAYINGOFFOURWELL KNOWNDRUMMERSTODISCOVERTEMPODEPENDENT"52SRANGINGFROMTO WITHTHETRIPLETOCCURRINGATAROUNDBPM3INCETHERIDECYMBALOFTEN SERVESASANANCHORFORGROUPCOORDINATIONITSRHYTHMICTEMPLATEPROJECTS ONTOTHERESTOFTHEDRUMSETOTHERRHYTHMSECTIONINSTRUMENTSANDTHE GLOBALSOUNDOFTHEENSEMBLE2ECALLTHATTHISSTUDYONLYINCLUDESPHRASES WITHSTRINGSOFEIGHTHSINSOLOISTICPASSAGES)TISLIKELYTHATACTUALTRIPLETS MAYBEOCCURRINGWITHGREATERFREQUENCYWITHINMORERHYTHMICALLYVARIED PHRASESSEE0RESSINGASWELLASINRHYTHMSECTIONACCOMPANI MENTS!LSOMANYJAZZCOMPOSITIONSARECONCEIVEDINAFEELTHINKh4HE 0INK0ANTHERvSOWESHOULDNOTBESURPRISEDTOENCOUNTERHIGH"52SIN SUCHCONTEXTS)NTHOSECASESTHETRIPLETEIGHTHISANATTRIBUTEOFASPECIlC COMPOSITIONORPERFORMANCENOTTHENORMFORJAZZINGENERALh'OOD"AITv ANDh7ALKINvABOVEWERETWOSUCHEXAMPLES%XAMPLEPROVIDESTWO ADDITIONALONES)Nh"IG"UTTERAND%GG-ANvTHETRIPLETYFEELISMADEEXPLICIT DURING7YNTON-ARSALISPRESENTATIONOFTHEMELODYAND2EGINALD6EALSBASS ACCOMPANIMENTSOTHATWHENSOLOSCOMEAROUNDITMAKESPERFECTSENSE FOR"52STOCONTINUEALONGTHISRHYTHMICVEIN%VENHEREHOWEVERLOWER "52EDPHRASESSTILLMANAGETOMAKEANAPPEARANCEEARLYINTHESOLO"OBBY 4IMMONSSh-OANINvISANOTHERTRIPLETFEELCOMPOSITIONAFEATUREREmECTED INTHESOLOSRHYTHMICSLANTTHOUGHAGAINLOWER"52SARECLEARLYPRESENT MOSTNOTICEABLYINTHEBASSSOLO -OSTOFTHERECORDINGSEXAMINEDTHUSFARWEREMADEDURINGTHEBEBOP ANDPOSTBEBOPERASROUGHLYnANDITISCONCEIVABLETHATAPARALLEL ANALYSISOFTHEPRECEDINGTWENTYYEARWINDOWMIGHTYIELDRESULTSMORESUP PORTIVEOFTHETRIPLETEIGHTHSTHEORY$IDPREBEBOPMUSICIANSPHRASETHEIR EIGHTHSWITHAMORETRIPLETORIENTEDFEELTHANOBSERVEDTHUSFAR'UNTHER 3CHULLERWRITESTHAThTHEEIGHTHNOTES;IN&LETCHER(ENDERSONS BAND=AREPLAYEDVERYMUCHASADOTTEDEIGHTHSIXTEENTHPATTERNvWHEREAS hATTHESAMETIMETHE;+ING=/LIVERAND;!*=0IRONORCHESTRASWERE PLAYINGAMORELOPINGTRIPLETRHYTHMv4HESEREMARKSAREPROBABLYACCURATE ASFARASTHESEBANDSOVERALLRHYTHMICINmECTIONISCONCERNEDALTHOUGHTHE POORQUALITYOFTHEACOUSTICALRECORDINGSMAKES3CHULLERSASSERTIONDIFlCULT TOSUBSTANTIATETHROUGHSPECTROGRAMANALYSIS4HEASSORTMENTOFRHYTHMIC "ENADONINDD !- "ENADON3LICINGTHE"EAT %XAMPLE(IGH"52SINTRIPLETBASEDCOMPOSITIONS Ah"IG"UTTERAND%GG-ANvBPMFROM7YNTON-ARSALIS3TANDARD 4IME6OL#OLUMBIA#+Bh-OANINvFROM!RT"LAKEYAND THE*AZZ-ESSENGERS-OANIN"LUE.OTE#$0 APPROACHESSEEMSTOOCCURSIMULTANEOUSLYASEACHPLAYERINTHEENSEMBLE SUBDIVIDESTHEBEATACCORDINGTOHISORHEROWNTASTECONTRIBUTINGTOTHEKA LEIDOSCOPICRICHNESSOFRHYTHMICANDMELODICACTIVITYTHAT3CHULLER CALLSAhHORIZONTALLYSPUNOUTBLOCKOFSOUNDv&OREXAMPLEMOSTOF*OHNNY $ODDSSCLARINETOBBLIGATOSACCOMPANIMENTLINESIN+ING/LIVERS#REOLE*AZZ "ANDAREPLAYEDINEVENEIGHTHSOFFSETTINGTHEMOREUNEVENCORNETRHYTHMS OF/LIVERAND!RMSTRONGWHICHINTURNPALEINCOMPARISONTOh"ABYv$ODDS WOODBLOCKS"UTEVENWITHINTHEMORETRIPLETORIENTEDLINESPLAYERSDIDNOT ADHERESTRICTLYTOTRIPLETSUBDIVISIONSPREFERRINGINSTEADSLIGHTLYLOWERVALUES #OLLIERAND#OLLIERREPORTANAVERAGE"52OFFOR,OUIS!RMSTRONGS SOLOSINh#ORNET#HOP3UEYvANDh0OTATO(EAD"LUESv4HIS VALUEISDECIDEDLYHIGHBUTCOMFORTABLYSHYOFTHETRIPLETTHRESHOLD#LARINET IST*IMMIE.OONESSOLOINh#AMP-EETING"LUESvYIELDSLOWERVALUES STILL!DDITIONALEVIDENCEFROMTHEPREBEBOPYEARSCANBEFOUNDIN$UKE %LLINGTONSBAND3AXOPHONISTS(ARRY#ARNEYBARITONEAND/TTO(ARDWICK "ENADONINDD !- %THNOMUSICOLOGY7INTER ALTOSUBDIVIDETHEIRBEATSATAVERAGERATIOSOFTRUMPETER#OOTIE7ILLIAMS AVERAGESAND$UKE%LLINGTONSLEFTHANDVAMPOFISSLIGHTLYMORE PRONOUNCEDBUTWELLBELOWTHETRIPLETSMARK%XAMPLE &INAL2EMARKS 4HISPAPEROFFERSSOMEEVIDENCEINFAVOROFEXPRESSIVECONNECTIONS BETWEENPITCHPHRASESTRUCTUREANDMICRORHYTHM3UCHINTERRELATIONSHIPS WHENEVERPRESENTARENOTALWAYSASCLEARCUTASTHEFOREGOINGEXAMPLES MIGHTIMPLY4HATCERTAINCONNECTIONSCANBEFOUNDBETWEENTHEPITCHAND TEMPORALDOMAINSBYNOMEANSGUARANTEESTHEIRPRESENCEINEVERYSITUATION SOANYGENERALITIESABOUTLINKSBETWEENPHRASINGANDMICRORHYTHMMUSTBE ADVANCEDWITHCAUTION,ESTTHEREADERBELEDTOBELIEVETHATJAZZCOMESIN ANEATLYORGANIZEDPACKAGEWHERERHYTHMANDMELODYALIGNWITHPERFECTAC CURACY)MUSTEMPHASIZETHATTHESEEXAMPLESHOWEVERTHOUGHTPROVOKING %XAMPLE0REBEBOP"52S .OONEh#AMP-EETING"LUESvBPMFROM+ING/LIVERS#REOLE *AZZ"AND4HE#OMPLETE3ET#HALLENGE2ECORDS#ARNEYh%AST3T ,OUIS4OODLEOOvFROM4HE#ENTENNIAL#OLLECTION"LUEBIRD (ARDWICKh"LACKAND4AN&ANTASYvIBID7ILLIAMSh#ONCERTOFOR #OOTIEvIBID%LLINGTONh%CHOESOF(ARLEMvFROM +EN"URNS*AZZ#OLUMBIA,EGACY#+ "ENADONINDD !- "ENADON3LICINGTHE"EAT ANDPOSSIBLYCOMPELLINGREPRESENTTHEEXCEPTIONRATHERTHANTHERULE4HEY ARENOTDESCRIPTORSOFAGENERALTREND.EITHERWOULD)INSINUATETHATTHESE LINKSAREARESULTOFCONSCIOUSTHOUGHTPROCESSESONTHEPARTOFTHEPERFORMER SUCHADISCUSSIONISBEYONDTHESCOPEOFTHISPAPERANDCONCLUDINGONE WAYORTHEOTHERWOULDNOTDETRACTFROMTHEANALYSES7HATISMORESOME "52VALUESMAYDERIVEFROMANUNINTENTIONALLYANTICIPATEDORDELAYEDATTACK RESULTINGFROMSAYATANGLEDlNGERINGORINTHECASEOFWINDINSTRUMENTS THEPLAYERTAKINGABREATHRATHERTHANFROMACONSCIOUSEFFORTTOARTICULATE EIGHTHSWITHASPECIlCFEEL)NDEEDTHEMICROTEMPORALNUANCESONWHICH MYARGUMENTSAREBASEDAREASTHENAMEIMPLIESMINUTEINSCOPE-USICAL FEATURESSUCHASCONTOURTEMPOTIMBREANDARTICULATIONMAYCAUSESOME "52STOBEPERCEIVEDDIFFERENTLYFROMWHATTHENUMBERSINDICATE!LISTENER MIGHTPERCEIVETWOATTACKSASBEINGCLOSERTOGETHERIFTHEUPBEATSLOUDNESS ISGREATERTHANTHATOFTHESUBSEQUENTDOWNBEATORFURTHERAPARTIFTHERE ISABREAKBETWEENTHEOFFSETOFTHElRSTNOTEANDTHEONSETOFTHESECOND 4HESIZEANDDIRECTIONOFTHEMELODICSKIPMAYALSOINmUENCEOURSENSITIV ITYTOTEMPORALPROXIMITYBETWEENTWOEVENTS1UESTIONSOFTHISKINDHAVE BEENEXPLOREDINTHEMUSICPERCEPTIONANDCOGNITIONLITERATURETHOUGHTO THEBESTOFMYKNOWLEDGETHEYHAVEYETTOBEADDRESSEDEMPIRICALLYINTHE CONTEXTOFJAZZMUSIC4HESEARENOTTRIVIALDISCLAIMERS.ONETHELESS)AM RELUCTANTTOATTRIBUTETHEABOVElNDINGSTOMERECOINCIDENCE)CHOSETO EXAMINETHESEEXCERPTSBECAUSEMYEARSDETECTEDSOMETHINGTHATSEEMED WORTHEXPLORINGANDITISENCOURAGINGTOCORROBORATESUCHINTUITIONSTHROUGH THEINTEGRATIONOFMUSICTHEORYANDRAWNUMERICALMEASUREMENTS4IMEWILL TELLINTHEFORMOFCONTINUINGDIALOGUEANDRESEARCHWHETHERTHESETHEORIES MERITVALIDATION)NTHEMEANTIMETHElNDINGSREPORTEDINTHISSTUDYSHOULD PROVEINSIGHTFULNOTONLYTOJAZZPERFORMERSSCHOLARSANDEDUCATORSBUT ALSOTOARTIlCIALINTELLIGENCERESEARCHERSSEEKINGTOEMULATEASPECTSOFJAZZ THROUGHALGORITHMICMODELING)NTHEREALMOFJAZZTHEORYTHEQUANTITATIVE DATACONTAINEDHEREINWILLHOPEFULLYENRICHOURALREADYVASTANDWIDELYDIS SEMINATEDKNOWLEDGEOFHARMONICPRACTICESANDMAYSERVETOFURTHERTHE DESIGNOFTHEORETICALFRAMEWORKSFORJAZZIMPROVISATION&INALLYITISHOPED THATTHEAUTOMATICADHERENCETOATRIPLETPHILOSOPHYWILLBECONTEXTUALIZED IFABETTERUNDERSTANDINGOFTHEINTRICATEMECHANICSOFJAZZPERFORMANCEIS TOBEGAINED .OTES 4HEREISOFTENASMALLBUTPOTENTIALLYSIGNIlCANTELEMENTOFUNCERTAINTYWHENMARK INGATTACKPOINTS7HILETWOCONDITIONSFORTHESELECTIONOFEXCERPTSWERETHElDELITYOFTHE RECORDINGANDTHETRANSPARENCYOFTHEATTACKSNOPHRASEWASENTIRELYFREEOFNOISEORONSET AMBIGUITY&OREXAMPLELEGATOPLAYINGINVOLVESAMOMENTOFINDISTINCTNESSWHERETHEPITCH ISTRANSITIONINGFROMONEEIGHTHTOTHENEXTPARTICULARLYINWINDINSTRUMENTS!LSOTHETIME "ENADONINDD !- %THNOMUSICOLOGY7INTER SPANBETWEENANOTESATTACKANDTHEEMERGENCEOFPITCHINFORMATIONCANVARYNOTONLYFROM INSTRUMENTTOINSTRUMENTBUTALSOFROMNOTETONOTE)NALLCASES)MADEEVERYEFFORTTOBE ASCONSISTENTANDACCURATEASPOSSIBLEWHENTAGGINGTHEONSETOFANEIGHTH7HILETHESEAREAS OFAMBIGUITYSEEMMINUTEINSCOPEESTIMATEDTOLIEAROUNDMILLISECONDSTHEYCANADD UPTOASIGNIlCANTPERCENTAGEOFTHEOVERALLMEASUREMENTBECAUSETHEMAGNITUDEOFTHEERROR INCREASESPROPORTIONALLYWITHTHEMETRONOMEMARKING(ENCEATTEMPOSFASTERTHANBEATS PERMINUTEMEASUREMENTINACCURACIESASSMALLASMSYIELDANERROROFABOUT&ORTHIS REASONALLEXCERPTSWERESELECTEDFROMPERFORMANCESWHERETHEDURATIONOFTHEQUARTERNOTEIS NOLESSTHANMILLISECONDSEQUALTOORSLOWERTHANBEATSPERMINUTE4HISCUTOFFPOINT ISFURTHERSUPPORTEDBYTHEINFORMALOBSERVATIONTHATPERFORMERSEVENOUTTHEIREIGHTHSATVERY FASTTEMPOS4HELOWERLIMITONSLOWEREXCERPTSWASAUTOMATICALLYDETERMINEDBYTHEFACTTHAT MANYPERFORMERSUSUALLYSWITCHTODOUBLETIMEPLAYINGWHENTHEQUARTERNOTELIESAROUND BEATSPERMINUTEORLESS !MPLITUDELEVELSWEREESTIMATEDUSING3OUND&ORGES3TATISTICSTOOLWHICHMEASURES THEhMAXIMUMSAMPLEVALUEvONASCALEFROMTO 0RÚGLERPRESENTSTHEDATAINMILLISECONDSWHICH)CONVERTEDTO"52S 2EFERENCES !BEL2OBERTh!N)NVESTIGATION)NTOTHE/PERATIONOF3WINGIN*AZZv5NPUBLISHEDPAPER HTTPWWWMUSCAMACUK^IC0AND0!BEL!BELHTML "AUER7ILLIAMh"ILLIE(OLIDAYAND"ETTY#ARTER%MOTIONAND3TYLEINTHE*AZZ6OCAL,INEv !NNUAL2EVIEWOF*AZZ3TUDIESn "ENADON&ERNANDOh3PECTROGRAPHICAND#ALLIGRAPHIC#UESINTHE)DENTIlCATIONOF*AZZ 3AXOPHONISTSv%3#/-0ROCEEDINGSn(ANNOVER%3#/- "ERENDT*OACHIM%RNST4HE*AZZ"OOK&ROM2AGTIMETO&USION"EYONDREVISED BY 'àNTHER (UESMANN TRANSLATED BY ( AND " "REDIGKEIT .EW9ORK ,AWRENCE (ILL "OOKS "ERLINER0AUL4HINKINGIN*AZZ4HE)NlNITE!RTOF)MPROVISATION#HICAGO5NIVERSITY OF#HICAGO0RESS "ILES*OHNh'EN*AM!'ENETIC!LGORITHMFOR'ENERATING*AZZ3OLOSv)N0ROCEEDINGSOF THE)NTERNATIONAL#OMPUTER-USIC#ONFERENCEn3AN&RANCISCO)#-! "ILMES*EFFh!-ODELFOR-USICAL2HYTHMv)N0ROCEEDINGSOFTHE)NTERNATIONAL #OMPUTER-USIC#ONFERENCEn3AN*OSE)#-! "USSE7ALTER'ERARDh4OWARD/BJECTIVE-EASUREMENTAND%VALUATIONOF*AZZ0IANO0ERFOR MANCE6IA-)$)"ASED'ROOVE1UANTIZE4EMPLATESv-USIC0ERCEPTIONn #OGSWELL-ICHAELh-ELODIC/RGANIZATIONIN4WO3OLOSBY/RNETTE#OLEMANv!NNUAL 2EVIEWOF*AZZ3TUDIESn #OKER*ERRY)MPROVISING*AZZ.EW9ORK3IMON3CHUSTER #OLLIER'EOFFREY,AND*AMES,INCOLN#OLLIERh!N%XPLORATIONOFTHE5SEOF4EMPOIN *AZZv-USIC0ERCEPTIONn h4HE3WING2HYTHMIN*AZZv)N0ROCEEDINGSOFTHE)NTERNATIONAL#ONFERENCEOF -USIC0ERCEPTIONAND#OGNITIONEDITEDBY"RUCE0ENNYCOOKAND%UGENIA#OSTA'IOMI n-ONTREAL-C'ILL5NIVERSITY h!3TUDYOF4IMINGIN4WO,OUIS!RMSTRONG3OLOSv-USIC0ERCEPTIONn #OLLIER'EOFFREY,AND#HARLES%7RIGHTh4EMPORAL2ESCALINGOF3IMPLEAND#OMPLEX 2ATIOSIN2HYTHMIC4APPINGv*OURNALOF%XPERIMENTAL0SYCHOLOGY(UMAN0ERCEPTION AND0ERFORMANCEn #ROUCH3TANLEY;=h"IRD,ANDv)N2EADING*AZZEDITEDBY2OBERT'OTTLIEBn .EW9ORK6INTAGE"OOKS "ENADONINDD !- "ENADON3LICINGTHE"EAT $ANKWORTH!VRIL*AZZ!N)NTRODUCTIONTOITS-USICAL"ASIS,ONDON/XFORD5NIVERSITY 0RESS %LLIS-ARKh!N!NALYSISOF@3WING3UBDIVISIONAND!SYNCHRONIZATIONIN4HREE*AZZ3AXO PHONISTSv0ERCEPTUALAND-OTOR3KILLSn &INALE-USIC.OTATION3OFTWARE5SER-ANUAL%DEN0RAIRIE-AKE-USIC &RIBERG!NDERSAND*3UNDBERGh4IME$ISCRIMINATIONINA-ONOTONIC)SOCHRONOUS 3EQUENCEv*OURNALOFTHE!COUSTICAL3OCIETYOF!MERICAn &RIBERG!NDERSAND!NDREAS3UNDSTRÚMh3WING2ATIOSAND%NSEMBLE4IMINGIN*AZZ0ER FORMANCE%VIDENCEFORA#OMMON2HYTHMIC0ATTERNv-USIC0ERCEPTIONn 'RIDLEY-ARK2OBERT-AXHAMAND2OBERT(OFFh4HREE!PPROACHESTO$ElNING*AZZv -USICAL1UARTERLYn (AYWOOD-ARK3h2HYTHMIC2EADINGSIN4HELONIOUS-ONKv!NNUAL2EVIEWOF*AZZ 3TUDIESn (ERMANN2ICHARDh#HARLIE0ARKERS3OLOTO/RNITHOLOGY&ACETSOF#OUNTERPOINT!NALYSIS AND0EDAGOGYv0ERSPECTIVESOF.EW-USICn (UANG(AOAND2ACHEL6(UANGh"ILLIE(OLIDAYAND4EMPO2UBATO5NDERSTANDING 2HYTHMIC%XPRESSIVITYv!NNUAL2EVIEWOF*AZZ3TUDIESn )YER6IJAYh%MBODIED-IND3ITUATED#OGNITIONAND%XPRESSIVE-ICROTIMINGIN!FRICAN !MERICAN-USICv-USIC0ERCEPTIONn *ÊRVINEN4OPIh4ONAL(IERARCHIESIN*AZZ)MPROVISATIONv-USIC0ERCEPTIONn *OHNSON,AIRD0HILIP.h(OW*AZZ-USICIANS)MPROVISEv-USIC0ERCEPTIONn +ENNY"ARRYh3TRUCTUREIN*AZZ)MPROVISATION!&ORMULAIC!NALYSISOFTHE)MPROVISATIONS OF"ILL%VANSv!NNUAL2EVIEWOF*AZZ3TUDIESn +ERNFELD"ARRY7HATTO,ISTENFORIN*AZZ.EW(AVEN9ALE5NIVERSITY0RESS ,ARSON3TEVEh-USICAL&ORCES-ELODIC%XPECTATIONAND*AZZ-ELODYv-USIC0ERCEP TIONn 0OVEL$IRKh)NTERNAL2EPRESENTATIONOF3IMPLE4EMPORAL0ATTERNSv*OURNALOF%XPERI MENTAL0SYCHOLOGY(UMAN0ERCEPTIONAND0ERFORMANCEn 0RESSING*EFFh4HE-ICROAND-ACROSTRUCTURAL$ESIGNOF)MPROVISED-USICh -USIC 0ERCEPTIONn h"LACK!TLANTIC2HYTHM)TS#OMPUTATIONALAND4RANSCULTURAL&OUNDATIONSv-USIC 0ERCEPTIONn 0RÚGLER*OSEPH!h3EARCHINGFOR3WING0ARTICIPATORY$ISCREPANCIESINTHE*AZZ2HYTHM 3ECTIONv%THNOMUSICOLOGYn 2EINHOLDSSON0ETERh!PPROACHING*AZZ0ERFORMANCES%MPIRICALLY3OME2EmECTIONSON -ETHODSAND0ROBLEMSv)N!CTIONAND0ERCEPTIONIN2HYTHMAND-USICEDITEDBY! 'ABRIELSSONn3TOCKHOLM2OYAL3WEDISH!CADEMYOF-USIC 2OBINSON * "RADFORD h4HE *AZZ %SSAYS OF4HEODOR!DORNO 3OME4HOUGHTS ON *AZZ 2ECEPTIONIN7EIMAR'ERMANYv0OPULAR-USICn 2OSE2&h!N!NALYSISOF4IMINGIN*AZZ2HYTHM3ECTION0ERFORMANCEv0H$DISSERTA TION5NIVERSITYOF4EXAS!USTIN 3CHULLER'UNTHER%ARLY*AZZ)TS2OOTSAND-USICAL$EVELOPMENT.EW9ORK/XFORD 5NIVERSITY0RESS 3TEEDMAN-ARK*h!'ENERATIVE'RAMMARFOR*AZZ#HORD3EQUENCESv-USIC0ERCEPTION n 4OIVIAINEN0ETRIh-ODELINGTHE4ARGET.OTE4ECHNIQUEOF"EBOP3TYLE*AZZ)MPROVISATION !N!RTIlCIAL.EURAL.ETWORK!PPROACHv-USIC0ERCEPTIONn 4YMOCZKO$MITRIh4HE#ONSECUTIVE3EMITONE#ONSTRAINTON3CALAR3TRUCTURE!,INK "ETWEEN)MPRESSIONISMAND*AZZv)NTÏGRALn 7AADELAND#ARL(AAKONh)T$ONT-EANA4HING)F)T!INT'OT4HAT3WING3IMULATING %XPRESSIVE4IMING4HROUGH-ODULATED-OVEMENTSv*OURNALOF.EW-USIC2ESEARCH n "ENADONINDD !- %THNOMUSICOLOGY7INTER $ISCOGRAPHYSEE!PPENDIXONWEBSITE !DDERLEY*ULIAN3OMETHIN%LSE"LUE.OTE#$03% !DDERLEY*ULIAN4HE#ANNONBALL!DDERLEY1UINTETIN3AN&RANCISCO2IVERSIDE/*##$n 3& AND#OLTRANE*OHN!DDERLEY#OLTRANE%MARCY$## AND%VANS"ILL+NOW7HAT)-EAN2IVERSIDE/*##$n+7 #OLTRANE*OHN.EWPORT)MPULSE'2$ #OLTRANES3OUND!TLANTICn#3 #OLTRANE0RESTIGE/*##$n#/ 'IANT3TEPS!TLANTIC!'3 ,USH,IFE0RESTIGE/*##$n,, 3OULTRANE0RESTIGE/*##$n3/ $AVIS-ILES3ESSIONS#OLUMBIA#+ 4HE-ILES$AVIS#OLLECTION!2ETROSPECTIVE$EJA6U$6#$!2 +INDOF"LUE#OLUMBIA#++" -ILESTONES#OLUMBIA#+-) 2ELAXIN7ITHTHE-ILES$AVIS1UINTET0RESTIGE/*##$n2% 3TEAMIN7ITHTHE-ILES$AVIS1UINTET0RESTIGE/*##$n34 %VANS"ILL%XPLORATIONS2IVERSIDE/*#nn%8 -OON"EAMS2IVERSIDE/*##$n-" !TTHE-ONTREUX*AZZ&ESTIVAL6ERVEn-* 0ORTRAITIN*AZZ2IVERSIDE0* 'ORDON$EXTER'/"LUE.OTE#$0'/ /NE&LIGHT5P"LUE.OTE#$0/& /UR-ANIN0ARIS"LUE.OTE#$0-0 !3WINGIN!FFAIR"LUE.OTE#$03! *ACKSON-ILTAND#OLTRANE*OHN"AGS4RANE!TLANTICn"4 0ARKER#HARLIE-ASTERWORKSn'IANTSOF*AZZ#$#0 "ENADONINDD !-
