INTERNATIONAL TELECOMMUNICATION UNION
COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC– E
TELECOMMUNICATION
STANDARDIZATION SECTOR
March 2006
English only
STUDY PERIOD 2005-2008
Original: English
Question(s):
ALL
STUDY GROUP 19 – REPORT 4
Source:
Study Group 19 (Mobile Telecommunication Networks)
Title:
Report of the Geneva meeting (23-27 January 2006)
Structure of the report R 4 of the fourth meeting of the SG 19
(Geneva, 23-27 January 2006)
COM 19-R
4
Annexes to the
report R 4
REPORT OF
OBSERVATIONS
Study Group 19 (Mobile
Telecommunication Networks)
Contains list of liaisons
SG19 Questions 1, 3, 4 and joint 2, 5/19
6/13 and 29/16 meetings
Annex 3 contains SG19 Work
Programme
Attention: This is a document submitted to the work of ITU-T and as such is intended for use by the Member States of ITU, by ITUT Sector Members and Associates, and their respective staff and collaborators in their ITU-related work. It is made publicly available
for information purposes but shall not be redistributed without the prior written consent of ITU. Copyright on this document is owned
by the author, unless otherwise mentioned. This document is not an ITU-T Recommendation, an ITU publication, or part thereof.
-2COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
Table of contents
Table of contents ......................................................................................................................
2
1.
General ..........................................................................................................................
3
2.
Documentation for the meeting ....................................................................................
4
3.
Approval of Draft Recommendations ...........................................................................
4
4
Next Generation Networks and SG 19’s Role ..............................................................
4
5.
Reports of Interim and Related Activities ....................................................................
5
6
Meeting Timetable and Appointment of Coordinators .................................................
5
7.
Approval of reports of individual Questions ................................................................
6
8.
Allocation of NGN deliverable responsibilities ...........................................................
9
9.
Future meetings ............................................................................................................
9
10.
Approval of outgoing liaison statements ......................................................................
10
11.
Work Programme for SG 19 .........................................................................................
11
12.
Planning for Workshops and Seminars.........................................................................
11
13.
Reducing Documentation Costs ...................................................................................
11
14.
Closing of the Meeting .................................................................................................
11
Annex 1 - Agenda ....................................................................................................................
13
Annex 2 - Notes on Additional Documents Identified in the Opening Plenary ......................
14
Annex 3 - SG 19 Work Programme .........................................................................................
17
Annex 4 - Q.1/19 Report: Service and network capability requirements and network
architecture ...................................................................................................................
19
Annex 5 - Q.3/19 Report: Identification of existing and evolving IMT-2000 systems ..........
23
Annex 6 - Q.4/19 Report: Preparation of a handbook on IMT-2000 .......................................
25
Annex 7 - Report of Joint Meetings of Q.2/19, Q.5/19, Q.6/13 and Q.29/16 ..........................
27
Annex 8 - Extract of Proposal on Trial for Further Reducing Paper Consumption at ITU-T
Meetings .......................................................................................................................
34
Annex 9 - Draft Work Plan for July 2006 Meeting of SG 19 ..................................................
36
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
-3COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
1.
General
1.1
The fourth meeting of ITU-T Study Group 19 “Mobile Telecommunication Networks” in
the 2005-2008 study period, took place in Geneva, Switzerland, in the ITU Facilities from 23-27
January 2006. The meeting was convened by TSB Collective Letter 4/19 dated 1 November 2005
and was chaired by Mr John Visser (Nortel, Canada), assisted by the following SG 19 ViceChairmen:

Mr Maurice Ghazal (MPT, Lebanon)

Mr Kiritkumar Lathia (Siemens Mobile Communications, Italy)

Mr Bruno Ramos (ANATEL, Brazil)

Mr Motoshi Tamura (NTT DoCoMo, Japan)

Mr Konstantin Trofimov (NIIR, Russia)
1.2
One Vice-Chairman was not able to participate in this meeting, extended apologies for his
absence, and designated a representative to take his place:

Mr Young Kyun Kim (Samsung Electronics, Korea) represented by Mr Kees den Hollander
1.3
One Vice-Chairman was not able to participate in this meeting and extended apologies for
his absence:

Mr Patrick Masambu (Communications Commission, Uganda)
1.4
The Chairman opened the meeting at 09:30 on 23 January 2005 and welcomed the
participants. The Chairman invited Dr Houlin Zhao, ITU TSB Director, to provide some opening
remarks. Dr Zhao gave a warm welcome to the delegates, and then noted a number of points:

SG 19 is the only study group in ITU-T that addresses mobility. From discussions in 2005
on proposals on restructuring the study groups, it was clear that the membership does not
support merging study groups for at least another year, and it was considered very
important that Study Group 19 continue.

Noting the strong relationships of the work across study groups involved in the NGN-GSI,
he was pleased to note that all involved were working closely together to ensure the work
progresses as quickly as possible.

He also noted that there are a number of new initiatives and topics being worked, including
networked RFIDs, Home Networking and IPTV. He encouraged participants to become
involved in these areas, noting that ITU-T is holding a number of workshops on these and
other topics.
1.5
The SG 19 Chairman provided his opening remarks and stated his overall objectives for the
meeting. These are summarized here:

Continue to play an essential role in and actively contribute to the progress of the NGNGlobal Standards Initiative by progressing our work on Mobility, and on Fixed Mobile
Convergence, as essential aspects of the NGN-GSI initiative; in particular:
o
progress our work on Mobility Management in Q.2/19 towards completing the
deliverable Q.MMR (Mobility Management Requirements for Systems Beyond
IMT-2000) at this meeting;
o
progress the work on Fixed Mobile Convergence, adding significant momentum to
this activity; and
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
-4COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
o
advance the work on requirements and architecture for IMT-2000 and systems
beyond while also providing a better description of its positioning with respect to
NGN;

Progress the work on the next iterations of Recommendations Q.1741 and Q.1742;

Advance the state of the next version of the Handbook for IMT-2000 and systems beyond,
and consider where else we could usefully develop guidance documents for the benefit of
developing countries and countries with economies in transition, and how we should go
about doing so successfully;

Continue to assert and promote SG 19’s mandate and role in the NGN-GSI context, namely
continue with our position that SG 19 should handle the approval of NGN-GSI deliverables
that fall within its mandate, while ensuring that progress on defining the NGN is maintained
in order to meet the needs of end users and operators; and

Consider future directions for effectively handling the topics and work areas allocated to
SG 19 with the aim of seeing these progress rapidly and effectively in meeting the needs of
the telecommunications industry.
2.
Documentation for the meeting
2.1
The agenda, as provided in TSB Collective Letter 4/19, is available as TD 245 and has been
attached to this report as Annex 1. It was accepted as proposed.
2.2
The meeting considered thirteen contributions (D 29 through D 41). The meeting
considered eighteen liaison statements, listed in TD 277. One series of Temporary Documents was
assigned. A proposed document allocation was made available as TD 293R1. TDs generated during
the meeting are not included in this allocation.
2.3
The list of participants was distributed as TD 317.
2.4
All documents for the meeting may be downloaded from the SG 19 web page:
http://www.itu.int/ITU-T/studygroups/com19/index.asp.
3.
Approval of Draft Recommendations
3.1
AAP Consent of Draft New Recommendations
3.1.1
No draft new Recommendations were presented for consideration for AAP Consent.
4
Next Generation Networks and SG 19’s Role
4.1
The report and the draft output document “NGN Release 1 – Scope” of the final meeting of
the Next Generation Networks Focus Group (Gatwick, UK, 14-17 November 2005) are found in
TD 263.
4.2
SG 19 continues to assert its position on its role in NGN studies, especially with respect to
mobility and fixed-mobile convergence, based on the mandate assigned to it at WTSA-2004, as
further discussed in §8 below. At the same time, SG 19 is working closely with relevant Questions
in SG 13 and other study groups to ensure that the technical work progresses expeditiously. One
example is the coordinated and effective discussions involving Q.2 and 5.19 with Q.6/13 and
Q.29/16 at this meeting.
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
-5COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
5.
Reports of Interim and Related Activities
5.1
While an interim e-meeting of Q.1/19 was scheduled 8 - 22 November 2005, this meeting
was cancelled due to lack of sufficient input documents to warrant proceeding.
5.2
Notes on the discussions on the remaining general documents identified in the opening
plenary may be found in Annex 2.
5.3
Open Access to SG 19 Documentation
5.3.1 The SG 19 Chairman noted the substantial increase in the proportion of contributions that
have been designated as available for public access. The SG 19 Chairman is also required to report
to TSAG on SG 19’s experience to date with respect to the conduct of a trial of making SG 19
documents publicly accessible. It is noted that ten of thirteen contributions (77%) and a number of
TDs to this meeting are designated for public access. All the publicly accessible documents,
including a public version of the previous meeting’s report, are available at www.itu.int/ITUT/studygroups/com19/docs.
5.3.2 No issues or concerns of any sort have arisen as a result of the open and public access to
these documents to date. The SG 19 Chairman will so indicate to TSAG at the upcoming meeting,
3 - 7 July 2006.
5.3.3 The SG 19 Chairman encouraged participants to continue to strive for greater openness and
public accessibility for their documents within the agreed guidelines in order to obtain the fullest
possible experience in this area.
6
Meeting Timetable and Appointment of Coordinators
6.1
The SG 19 Management Team proposed a meeting timetable in the Collective Letter and
this was provided in TD 246. This timetable includes joint sessions of various questions as
referenced above.
6.2
There has been no change to the list of Rapporteurs included in the previous meeting’s
report.
6.3
The following table provides the updated list of SG 19 Coordinators.
Function
Coordinator
EDH
open (SG 19 Chairman by default)
IETF, IEEE 802
Mr Young Kyun Kim (Samsung Electronics, Korea)
ITU-D Q.18/2 Liaison
Mr Maurice Ghazal (MPT, Lebanon)
ITU-R WP 8F Liaison
Mr Konstantin Trofimov (Russian Federation) assisted by
Mr Kiritkumar Lathia (Siemens Mobile Communications,
Italy)
Liaison
Mr Konstantin Trofimov (Russian Federation)
Meeting Scheduling
Mr Motoshi Tamura (NTT DoCoMo, Japan)
NGN
Mr Leslie Graf (Australia)
OPs of 3GPP and 3GPP2
Mr Ilkka Hyvärinen (Nokia, Finland; Q.3/19 Rapporteur)
Project Plan
Mr Bruno Ramos (ANATEL, Brazil)
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
-6COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
Function
Coordinator
Publicity
Mr John Visser (Nortel, Canada)
Security
open (SG 19 Chairman by default)
Seminars and Workshops
Mr Kiritkumar Lathia (Siemens Mobile Communications,
Italy)
7.
Approval of reports of individual Questions
7.1
Q.1/19 “Service and network capability requirements and network architecture”
7.1.1 The meeting reviewed and approved the report of Q1/19 in TD 310R1, attached as
Annex 4.
7.1.2
The key results extracted from the report of Q1/19 are:

discussed how to progress the work on draft new Recommendation “Functional
Network Architecture for Systems Beyond IMT-2000” (Q.FNAB); and

reviewed, and agreed to an updated work plan for Q.1/19, changing the timing for
Q.FNAB from 3Q2006 to 2Q2007.
7.1.3
Q.1/19 proposed one outgoing liaison statement as listed in §10 below.
7.1.4
Proposed interim activities were approved and details are included in §9 below.
7.1.5 A discussion on reinvigorating the work of Q.1/19 supported that the work should be more
closely coupled with Q.3/13 (“Principles and functional architecture for NGN”) as indicated in the
report and in the proposed liaison statement, and that this should be extended to include Q.2/13
(“Requirements and implementation scenarios for emerging services in NGN.”)
7.2
Q.3/19 “Identification of existing and evolving IMT-2000 systems”
7.2.1 The meeting reviewed and approved the report of Q.3/19 in TD 299R1, attached as
Annex 5. A public version of this TD has also been posted.
7.2.2
The key results extracted from the report of Q.3/19 are:

reviewed and approved inputs from ARIB and TTC for draft new Recommendation
Q.1742.5 “ANSI-41 evolved core network with cdma2000 access network” in
preparation for anticipated submission for AAP Consent at the July 2006 meeting of
SG 19.
7.2.3
Q.3/19 proposed one outgoing liaison statements as listed in §10 below.
7.2.4
No interim activities were proposed.
7.3
Q.4/19 “Preparation of a handbook on IMT-2000”
7.3.1 The meeting reviewed and approved the report of Q.4/19 in TD 311R1, attached as
Annex 6.
7.3.2
The key results extracted from the report of Q.4/19 are:

a new chapter on safety and security issues for IMT-2000 was reviewed and adopted
subject to revision as might be suggested by ITU-T Study Group 17 in response to a
liaison being sent to this study group; and

material for a new chapter on FMC was proposed to the editor.
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
-7COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
7.3.3 Q.4/19 proposed four outgoing liaison statements as listed in §10 below. One of these was
not approved as indicated in §7.3.6 below.
7.3.4
No interim activities were proposed.
7.3.5 The review of the report identified that recent ITU-BDT workshops in Damascus and
Nairobi might also be used as a source of material for the Handbook, similar to the material
identified in TD 311R1 for recent events in Kyiv and Tunis:

ITU/BDT Regional Workshop for the Arab Region on Guidelines on the Smooth
Transition of Existing Mobile Networks to IMT-2000 for Developing Countries,
Damascus, Syria, 13-15 June 2005

ITU/BDT Regional Seminar for Africa on Fixed Mobile Convergence and
Guidelines on the smooth transition of existing mobile networks to IMT-2000 for
Developing Countries, Nairobi, Kenya, 9-12 May 2005
Information in these events may be found at
http://www.itu.int/ITU-D/imt-2000/BDTActivities.html.
7.3.6 The proposed liaison statement in TD 305R1 was discussed. It was clarified that what is
being requested is only a brief description of the ITU-D Q.18/2 MTG document. Considering that
the WTDC-06 will occur in March 2006, that no meetings of ITU-D Q.18/2 are scheduled before
then, and that the outcome of WTDC-06 may alter the structure and content of the ITU-D
Questions, it was considered not appropriate to send this proposed liaison statement. Mr Kiritkumar
Lathia kindly volunteered to draft text to meet the need expressed by Q.4/19. It was therefore
agreed that this liaison statement was not needed and hence it was not approved.
7.4
Joint Q.2/19, Q.5/19, Q.6/13 and Q.29/16
7.4.1
are:
Questions Q.2/19, Q.5/19, Q.6/13 and Q.29/16 met jointly. The titles of these Questions

Q.2/19 Mobility management

Q.5/19 Convergence of evolving IMT-2000 networks with evolving fixed networks

Q.6/13 NGN mobility and fixed-mobile convergence

Q.19/16 Mobility for Multimedia Systems and Services
7.4.2 The meeting reviewed and approved with editorial corrections the report of the joint
meetings in TD 302 as reflected in TD 302R1, attached as Annex 7. Note that this review and
approval does not include that part of the report dealing with Q.6/13 specific aspects, that is §2 of
TD 302R1, which was handled by SG 13.
7.4.3
Joint:
Key results extracted from the report are:

agreed to propose that circuit switched services (i.e., voice services) of 2G and 3G
mobile networks are emulated/simulated in NGN in the earliest Release possible in
order to be able to use 2G/3G access networks in conjunction with NGN.
Mobility Management (MM):

1
agreed to combine SG 19’s draft Q.MMR1 and draft Q.MMF2, and SG 13’s draft
Y.NGN-MOB in order to create a common Stage 1 (MMR) and common three-
Q.MMR = Mobility Management Requirements (Stage 1)
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
-8COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
volume Stage 2 (MMF, LMF3, and HMF4) Mobility Management Recommendations
across the Study Groups.

Q.MMR was updated (D 30) resulting in TD 119 (WP2/13) / TD 312 (GEN/19)

Additional description of ‘Local’ and ‘Home’ Location Manager and MM Scenarios
were added to Q.MMF resulting in TD 120 (WP2/13) / TD 313 (GEN/19).
Fixed-Mobile Convergence (FMC):

agreed to narrow the scope of Q.FMC stage 2 to a stage 2 recommendation on IMS
based FMC and to clarify this in the working title by changing it to Rec.FMC-IMS5.
Material in the output draft from this meeting that is outside the new scope will be
transferred at the next meeting to another FMC recommendation or a living list. A
draft containing a substantial amount of new stage 2 material can be found in
TD 303R1(GEN/19) / TD 118 (WP2/13)

agreed to start a new recommendation on an FMC scenario using PSTN as the fixed
access network for a UMTS network with working title Rec.FMC-PAU6. A first
working draft was produced and can be found in TD 304 (GEN/19) /
TD 117(WP2/13)

Rec.FMC-REQ7 sections on high level requirements and capabilities were
considerably enhanced including a new definition of FMC that makes it clear that
FMC is an aspect of NGN, but not limited to NGN. It can be found in
TD308(GEN/19) / TD116R1 (WP2/13)
7.4.4
Mr Li Mo of ZTE kindly volunteered to replace Mr David McFarlane as editor for
Rec.FMC-IMS. Mr Minrui Shi of China Telecom kindly volunteered to take on the editorship for
the new draft recommendation Rec.FMC-PAU. The appointment of these editors was approved.
7.4.5
The joint meeting proposed one outgoing liaison statement as listed in §10 below.
7.4.6
Proposed interim activities were approved and details are included in §9 below.
7.4.7 In TD 302 R1 §5.5.3, a definition of FMC was noted. The Rapporteurs are encouraged to
ensure this definition is coordinated with the work on definitions in the NGN-GSI.
7.4.8 It was observed that the joint meetings benefited from the involvement of a number of
participants who were not registered for SG 19. (It is estimated that twenty-one participants in the
joint Questions discussions were not registered for SG 19.) All participants are kindly requested to
consider registering for SG 19 in addition to other study groups in the NGN-GSI. Noting that
associate members might be financially impacted if they are required to register for multiple study
groups, it was made clear that this request to also register for SG 19 is desirable but optional, and
that registering for any one of the involved study groups is sufficient to participate in a joint
meeting.
2
3
4
5
6
7
Q.MMF = Mobility Management Framework (Stage 2)
LMF = Location Mobility Management Framework (Stage 2)
HMF = Handover Management Framework (Stage 2)
FMC-IMS = Fixed Mobile Convergence with a common IMS session control domain
FMC-PAU = FMC service scenario by using PSTN as the fixed Access network for UMTS
network
FMC-REQ = FMC General Requirements
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
-9COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
7.4.9 It was noted by the SG 19 Chairman that the Rapporteurs for the four Questions making up
this joint activity had worked together very well in the best spirit of resolving differences in points
of view and in moving the work forward. An indication of appreciation was suggested and the
meeting responded promptly with a substantial round of applause.
8.
Allocation of NGN deliverable responsibilities
8.1
SG 13 TD 137 (PLEN) provides a listing of draft Recommendations and deliverables and
their evolution as the work of the FGNGN has transitioned into the regular study groups structure.
For SG 19, the deliverables FRMOB “Mobility management capability requirements for NGN” and
FGNGN-IFN “IMS for Next Generation Networks” remain marked as target study group “13/19*”
with the asterisk referring to a note at the end of the table that indicates: “The allocation of
responsibilities is under review.”
8.2
SG 19 continues to be of the view that these two deliverables fall within its purview per
WTSA-2004 discussions and decisions as captured in WTSA document 118 and Resolution 2, and
as “endorsed by a meeting between the TSB Director and Heads of Delegation on 7 September
[2005] and form the basis of the ongoing coordination, planning and management of the NGN
work.” (TD 240, previous SG 19 meeting.) At the same time, SG 19 has every intention of
progressing the approval process for these deliverables expeditiously in order that SG 19’s
involvement in the NGN-GSI be positive and constructive in delivering timely results to meet the
needs of all parties involved.
9.
Future meetings
9.1
The next meeting of SG 19 is scheduled to take place 24-28 July 2006 in Geneva per TSB
Circular 40 dated 25 July 2005, during the same period as SGs 13 and 11. Further details will be
provided by Collective Letter and will be posted on the SG 19 web site in the usual manner.
9.2
There was discussion of how to better schedule the activities of the three study groups
making up the core of the NGN-GSI. To this end, SG 19 considered whether the current schedule
was appropriate or whether a better allocation of time slots over the two week period 17 - 28 July
2006 might be defined. As a result of these discussions, it was agreed that the meeting plan
provided at Annex 9 would meet the needs of the technical discussions.
9.3
The SG 19 Meeting Schedule Coordinator, Mr Motoshi Tamura, presented TD 284 which
provides information on the schedule for selected meetings of other groups relevant to SG19. This
provides an excellent overview of meetings of interest to SG 19 and will also be used by the SG
leadership and Rapporteurs in planning meeting schedules as noted above. An update reflecting SG
electronic meetings and Rapporteurs’ meetings, etc., will be provided after the meeting as
TD 284R1. Mr Tamura’s efforts are much appreciated.
9.4
Interim meetings were proposed and approved as listed below. Electronic meetings will
take place using the electronic discussion board facilities at
http://forum.itu.int/jive/index.jspa?categoryID=2 supplemented by meeting document access on
TIES. Guidelines for the conduct of electronic meetings may be found at www.itu.int/ITUT/studygroups/templates.
•
Q1/19:
•
Electronic: 23 May - 6 June 2006
•
Terms of Reference: To progress the work on Q.FNAB
•
Joint Q2/19, Q.5/19, Q.6/13:
•
Rapporteurs: (22 - 27 April 2006; Kobe, Japan)
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 10 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
•
Terms of Reference:
Mobility Management:

to combine SG19’s Q.MMR, Q.MMF, and SG13’s Y.NGN-MOB in order to
create a Stage 1 (MMF) and three Stage 2 (MMF, LMF, and HMF) Mobility
Management Recommendations.
FMC:

progress the work on draft Rec.FMC-REQ

progress the work on draft Rec.FMC-IMS

progress the work on draft Rec.FMC-PAU
9.5
Mr Hideo Imanaka (NTT) kindly provided a brief presentation on the arrangements for the
Workshop and Rapporteurs meetings in Kobe, Japan, 20-27 April 2006. Further information on the
arrangements is available in TD 318. Information on the arrangements for the above meeting is
available on the NGN GSI web page:
http://www.itu.int/ITU-T/ngn/index.phtml.
9.6
Rapporteurs are encouraged to send out reminders as they approach the dates for their
meetings. The TSB will only post information about the above meetings as provided by the
Rapporteurs.
10.
Approval of outgoing liaison statements
10.1
The following table provides a list of the liaison statements that were proposed. All the
listed Liaison Statements were reviewed and approved during the presentation of the individual
Question reports except as noted in §10.2. The work of Mr Konstantin Trofimov in coordinating
these liaison statements is much appreciated.
10.2
In TD 112, received at the previous SG 19 meeting, TSAG requested that study groups
provide information on tracking outgoing LSs to non-ITU-T organizations. A report to TSAG on
this is provided in TD 298. All the Liaison Statements listed in this table were reviewed and
approved in the closing plenary.
LS
No.
TD No.
24
298
25
300R1
26
Title
For
To
Source
Tracking of Liaison Statements with
non-ITU-T organizations
Alert to SDOs of Q.1742.5
publication status
Information
TSAG
SG 19
Action
Q.3/19
301R1
Development of a PDNR in response
to Q.223
27
306
Information/
Action/Com
ment
Action
ARIB,
CCSA,
TIA, TTA,
TTC
ITU-R WP
8F
307R1
29
309R2
30
314
ITU-T
SG 17
ITU-R
WP 8F
ITU-T
Q.3/13
ITU-T
SG 3
Q.4/19
28
Revision of the draft new chapter for
the Handbook on IMT-2000
Preparation of the Handbook on IMT- Action
2000
Request for analysis and comments
Action
on Q.FNAB
Request for material for the
Action
Handbook on IMT-2000
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
SGs 13 and
19
Q.4/19
Q.1/19
Q.4/19
- 11 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
LS
No.
31
TD No.
319
Title
Correction to TD 43 (WP 1/13),
Q.1/13 Living List of approved/draft
Recommendations that could fall into
the scope of NGN
For
Action
To
ITU-T
SG 13
Source
SG 19
All Liaison Statements are available at
http://ties.itu.int/u/tsg19/sg19/documents/060123/ls/Outgoing/ .
11.
Work Programme for SG 19
11.1
Mr Bruno Ramos produced an updated SG 19 Work Programme which is provided at
Annex 3 and is also available as TD 247R1. Mr Ramos’s work is much appreciated.
12.
Planning for Workshops and Seminars
12.1
TD 273 provides information on the upcoming ITU-T/ATIS Workshop on Next Generation
Network Technology and Standardization, 19 - 20 March 2006, Las Vegas, USA. Further
information may be found at www.itu.int/ITU-T/worksem/ngn/200603. SG 19 participants,
especially those based in North America, are encouraged to participate. (A similar event took place
in Gatwick, UK, on 18 November 2005. A future event is also planned for 20-21 April 2006 in
Kobe, Japan. Further information may be found at www.itu.int/ITU-T/worksem/ngn/200604. See
also SG 13 TD 141 (PLEN) for practical information.)
13.
Reducing Documentation Costs
From TSAG Report R 7;
11.3.2
TSAG endorsed a trial to distribute paper copies of pre-meeting documents for SG
15 and SG 19 only to those delegates requesting them on the meeting registration form. TSB
will include this option in the Collective Letters for these study groups. The Chairman of
Study Group 15 said that this choice would save more than 60% of the paper in Study Group
15. Taking into account the needs of developing countries, paper copies will continue to be
distributed to those who want them. Iran pointed out that this method already works very well
in ITU-R. The trial will be evaluated with the consideration to apply this option in all study
groups.
This refers to the discussion in TSAG Report R 10, section 4.3.
The Collective Letter for the current SG 19 meeting was issued before this decision was taken.
Therefore, the SG Chairman provided a proposal on how to conduct such a trial by email to the SG
19 reflector. The edited text of this email is included at Annex 8.
The proposal by the SG 19 Chairman in this regard was found to be suitable. No issues were
identified. All appreciated the ongoing efforts to reduce paper consumption and the associated cost
savings. Based on initial experience, a positive Recommendation can be made to TSAG to extend
this process to all study groups.
14.
Closing of the Meeting
14.1
The Chairman thanked the TSB Secretariat (Ms. Tatiana Kurakova and Ms. Maite Comas
Barnés) for their excellent support to the meeting, and all the participants for their hard work,
proactive input and cooperation.
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 12 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
14.2
The delegates expressed their appreciation for the SG 19 Chairman’s efforts in guiding the
meeting.
14.3
The meeting was closed.
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 13 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
Annex 1 - Agenda
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
Opening of the meeting
Welcome by TSB Director
Chairman’s comments and key objectives for this meeting
Approval of agenda
Brief reports of interim meetings
5.1 Q.1/19 E-Meeting (8 – 22 November 2005)
Related activities
6.1 Next Generation Networks Focus Group meeting (Gatwick, London, UK, 14 - 17
November 2005)
6.2 ITU-T SG 13 (Geneva, 29 August – 9 September 2005)
6.3 Others as identified
Information on other events of interest
7.1 ITU-T SG 19 Workshop “Mobile Telecommunications and Fixed/Mobile
Convergence - the realities going forward” (Kyiv, Ukraine, 12-14 September 2005)
7.2 ITU-D SG 2 meeting (Geneva, 12 – 15 September 2005)
7.3 ITU-R WP 8F meeting (Helsinki, Finland, 12-19 October 2005)
7.4 Workshop on Opportunities and Challenges in Home Networking (Geneva,
13 – 14 October 2005)
7.5 SG Chairmen’s meeting (Geneva, 3-4 November 2005)
7.6 TSAG meeting (Geneva, 7-11 November 2005)
7.7 WSIS II - Second Phase of the World Summit on the Information Society (Tunis,
Tunisia, 16-18 November 2005)
7.8 NGN Industry Event (Gatwick, London, England, 18 November 2005)
7.9 ITU-BDT Regional Seminar on Fixed Mobile Convergence and New Network
Architecture for the Arab Region (Tunis, Tunisia, 21-24 November 2005)
Organization of the work
8.1 Working methods
8.2 Appointment of Rapporteurs, Editors and Coordinators as required
8.3 Others as identified
Approval of Meeting Work Plan
Document allocation
Meetings of Individual Questions
Examination and approval of the reports of the Questions
12.1 Consent of Recommendations in accordance with the rules of Recommendation A.8
Future activities
Miscellaneous
Closure of the Meeting
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 14 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
Annex 2 - Notes on Additional Documents Identified in the Opening Plenary
D 29 from France Telecom is lists ETSI TISPAN NGN Release 1 Specifications and how they are
related to ITU-T NGN related Questions in NGN-GSI activities. The presentation at the opening
plenary noted that there are several documents relevant to SG 19 on the subjects of requirements,
service capabilities, architecture, mobility management, IMS and roaming interface protocols. In
the opening plenary, it was noted that there is agreement that the TISPAN specifications will not be
simply imported en bloc by referencing, but rather that they will be individually assessed against
requirements and referenced accordingly. Further discussion of the details of this document was
remanded to the Questions 1, 2 and 5/19 as indicated in TD 293R1.
D 41 (Korea) provided an overview of recent activity in groups within the IETF that are addressing
aspects of mobility. Remanded to Q.2/19 for further consideration.
TD 250 from SG 4 provides the Terms of Reference for the continuing Focus Group on NGN
Management which is supporting the NGN-GSI in this dimension. It was noted.
TD 251 is SG 9’s reply to TSAG on TDR/EW. SG 9 is working on a draft new Recommendation
J.pref (“Specifications for preferential telecommunications over IPCablecom networks”) which will
address the requirements in J.260. This document is for SG 19’s information. Noted.
TD 252 provides the list of contacts in SG 9, including details of how they may be contacted.
Noted.
TD 253 provides SG 17’s action plan to support the involvement of developing countries and
countries with economies in transition (DC-CET) in the standardization work on security, languages
and telecommunication software. Noted.
TD 254 indicates that, according to a request from TSAG, SG 17 started to review its work
programme for work that Telecommunications for Disaster Relief and Early Warning (TDR/EW)
system development can use and adapt the Action Plan. This liaison provides TSAG and SG 2 with
a first feedback on the actions taken. It is for information to other study groups. Noted.
TD 255 provides SG 17 guidance to TSAG and Study Groups on how ITU-T could strengthen its
role in conformance and interoperability testing. The Chairman noted that this document provides a
succinct and informative overview of the subject area and he encouraged SG 19 participants to take
part in an informal workshop on this area that SG 11 is conducting on the morning of 25 January.
Noted.
TD 258 is an action item from TSAG on behalf of the TSB asking that Rapporteurs ensure that the
TSB is provided with all documents from their meetings so that they may be archived. It was noted
that all SSG and SG 19 Rapporteurs meeting documents have made use of the ITU facilities and
therefore all our documents are already covered. No further action is needed.
TD 259 is a request from TSAG which is a request for registration and dissemination of the ITU-T
Technology Watch function. SG 19 participants are encouraged to sign up to this reflector.
TD 260 provides TSB Circular 47 which describes the NGN-GSI initiative. Noted.
TD 261 provides CCSA’s letter in response to Circular 47 in which the CCSA Secretary General
indicates clear support for the NGN-GSI activities in the ITU-T. Noted with thanks to CCSA for
their expression of support.
TD 263 is the report of the final meeting of the FGNGN. The attachments include the report of that
final meeting of the FGNGN. The SG 19 Chairman walked through this to note the deliverables that
were transitioning from the FGNGN to the NGN-GSI. The document indicates that any feedback on
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 15 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
the report or the outputs being transitioned to the NGN-GSI should be addressed to SG 13. The
document includes the FGNGN “NGN Release 1 Scope” document. Noted.
TD 264 provides the FGNGN’s response to the SG 19 liaison regarding comments on FGNGN
output documents. It is noted that essentially all the comments and suggestions provided by SG 19
were agreed and are reflected in associated amendments to the FGNGN draft deliverables
transitioned to the NGN-GSI. The exception is the comment on whether FRMOB is needed for
Release 1 considering the assertion in FGNGN-OD-00229 NGN Release 1 Scope (attached to TD
263 as noted above) that: “No major new interfaces for mobility are proposed for Release 1.
Existing interfaces between networks, users and terminals, users and networks, terminals and
networks will be used. Release 1 continues to use existing signalling capabilities for all types of
mobility as currently defined.” Noted.
TD 265 provides a summary report of the SG 19 workshop held in Kyiv, Ukraine, 12-14 September
2005. There were several indications that this workshop had been well received and was considered
very successful. Further information is available at www.itu.int/ITU-T/worksem/imt2000/200509.
Noted.
TD 266 indicates that SG 2 is the lead SG on TDR/EW. Noted.
TD 267 indicates that SG 2 is the lead SG on Service Definition, Numbering and Routing. SG 2 has
approved a new Recommendation (E.910), Procedures for the Registration within the Domain
“.int”, and also determined one new and three revised Recommendations:

E.156: Procedures to determine ITU action on reported misuse of E.164 number resources.

E.118: The international telecommunication charge card

E.152, The international freephone service

E.164.1, Criteria and procedures for the reservation, assignment and reclamation of E.164
CCs and associated ICs
Noted.
TD 270 is a summary of relevant discussions in the SG Chairmen’s meeting which took place just
prior to the last meeting of TSAG. The SG 19 Chairman noted the discussion on further clustering
of SG meetings and the consideration in doing this. He noted that ITU-T Recommendation A.9
(“Working procedures for the Special Study Group on IMT-2000 and Beyond”) was proposed for
deletion as these had been made available to all the study groups. One point was identified as a
change to Resolution 1. The deletion and change to Resolution 1 were agreed by the SG Chairmen
and were proposed to the TSAG meeting which also agreed. This is reported in TSAG Report R 7,
§11.1.1 and further elaborated in TSAG Report R 8, §4. The SG 19 Chairman also indicated that an
ITU-T/ATIS NGN Workshop is being prepared. Further information may be found at
www.itu.int/ITU-T/worksem/ngn/200603. Noted.
TD 271 indicated that the Resolution 40 should be used as guidance in deciding which approval
procedures, TAP or AAP, is to be used for a draft new Recommendation. Noted.
TD 272 provides the report of a workshop on “SOS by SMS” which took place 28 November 2005
in Geneva. This addressed how charitable donations in support of victims of natural and other
disasters might be made using mobile telephone technology, and addressed a number of issues in
doing so. Noted.
TD 273 alerts participants to the upcoming “ITU-T/ATIS workshop on Next Generation Network
Technology and Standardization,” 19 - 20 March 2006, Las Vegas, USA. Further information on
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 16 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
this event may be found at www.itu.int/ITU-T/worksem/ngn/200603. Delegates, especially those
from North America, are encouraged to participate.
TD 274 provides information on a number of upcoming ITU-T workshops, including some
described in other TDs. Delegates are encouraged to review this list and give positive consideration
to participating and contributing to workshops. Noted.
TD 275 provides information on meeting facilities, etc. Noted.
TD 276 provides the list of Delayed contributions. Noted.
TD 277 provides the list of incoming liaison statements. Noted.
TD 286 provides extracts of the results and outcomes of WSIS II. Noted for information.
TD 287 provides the “Consolidated Study Group reply to the TSAG Action Plan for TDR/EW
Standardization.” Noted.
TD 288 provides extracts from the TSAG report R 7 on conformance and interoperability testing
and follow-up actions. The informal workshop being organized by SG 11 for the morning of 25
January was noted and participants were encouraged to join this event if they had time available to
do so. Noted.
TD 289 provides extracts from TSAG report R 7 on Home Networking and RFID. A Joint
Coordination Activity on Home Networking is continuing. The attention of participants was drawn
to an ITU-T Workshop on “Opportunities and Challenges in Home Networking” that was held in
Geneva, 13 - 14 October 2005. Further information is available at www.itu.int/ITUT/worksem/homenetworking. A correspondence group on RFID is continuing. An ITU-T Workshop
on "Networked RFID: Systems and Services" will be held in the CICG, Geneva, 14 - 15 February
2006. Further details are available at www.itu.int/ITU-T/worksem/rfid.
TD 290 provides extracts from TSAG report on Network security. This indicates endorsement by
TSAG of SG 17 recommended actions: SGs to identify relevant Recommendations for review of
adequate security considerations and that relevant SGs review Recommendations within their areas
of responsibility and provide results each year to the TSB, with a copy to SG 17, in time for the
TSB Director to report to Council. SG 19 had previously provided inputs to the “Manual - Security
in Telecommunications and Information Technology - December 2003” and updated for October
2004 . These manuals are available at www.itu.int/itudoc/itu-t/85097.pdf and
www.itu.int/itudoc/itu-t/86435.pdf. No updates to this information were identified at this meeting.
TD 291 provides extracts from TSAG report on NGN-related issues. This includes the results of a
discussion on a contribution from Lebanon concerning moving certain work from one study group
to another. Continuation of the NGN Management Focus Group was supported. Transition of the
work from the FGNGN to the NGN-GSI was reported and endorsed. Noted.
TD 294 provides information on a “Regional Seminar on Fixed Mobile Convergence and New
Network Architectures for the Arab Region” which took place in Tunis (Tunisia), 21-24 November
2005. The SG 19 Chairman was also the Chairman for this event. Noted.
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 17 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
Annex 3 - SG 19 Work Programme
Recommendation
ST
Ques
SG
Q.1701
R
1/19
Q.1711
R
Supplement 30 to
Q-Series
Recommendations
Q.FIFB
Pri
Pag
19
M
27
15,37
99
1/19
19
M
29
15,37
99
R
1/19
19
M
15,37
00
N
1/19
19
TBD
H
15,37
27
Long-term high-level network
functional information flows for
beyond IMT 2000 systems
Q.FNAB
N
1/19
19
2Q 2007
H
ITU-T SGs 2, 11, 12, 13, 16,
ITU-R WP 8D and 8F (WGVision), ITU-D SGs, SDOs
(TTA, TTC, ETSI, TIA, ATIS,
ARIB, CCSA)
ITU-T SGs 2, 11, 12, 13, 16,
ITU-R WP 8D and 8F (WGVision), ITU-D SGs, SDOs
(TTA, TTC, ETSI, TIA, ATIS,
ARIB, CCSA)
15,37
27
Rec.MMR
N
2/19
13/
19
3Q 2006
H
15
Rec.MMF
N
2/19
13/
19
2Q 2007
H
Rec.LMF
N
2/19
13/
19
2Q 2007
H
Rec.HMF
N
2/19
13/
19
2Q 2007
H
ITU-T SG 19 Q. 1, 3, 5,
relevant SDOs (IETF),
relevant ITU-T SGs, ITU-R
SGs and ITU-D SGs
ITU-T SG 19 Q. 1, 3, 5,
relevant SDOs (IETF),
relevant ITU-T SGs, ITU-R
SGs and ITU-D SGs
ITU-T SG 19 Q. 1, 3, 5,
relevant SDOs (IETF),
relevant ITU-T SGs, ITU-R
SGs and ITU-D SGs
ITU-T SG 19 Q. 1, 3, 5,
relevant SDOs (IETF),
relevant ITU-T SGs, ITU-R
SGs and ITU-D SGs
Long-term high-level network
architecture for systems beyond
IMT 2000, including definition of
functional entities (FEs), allocation
of functional capabilities to FEs,
and interfaces model among FEs
Mobility Management
Requirements (Stage 1)
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
Timing
Liaison
Area
Domain
References
COM 11-R 116
Subject
Framework for IMT-2000
networks
Network functional model for
IMT-2000
Specifications of International
Mobile Telecommunications-2000
15
Mobility Management Framework
(Stage 2)
15
Location Mobility Management
Framework (Stage 2)
15
Handover Management
Framework (Stage 2)
- 18 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
Recommendation
ST
Ques
SG
Timing
Pri
Pag
Q.1741.5
N
3/19
19
TBD
H
500
SDOs, ITU-R WP 8F
15
27
Q.1742.5
N
3/19
19
3Q 2006
H
160
SDOs, ITU-R WP 8F
15
27
Handbook on
IMT-2000 (2nd
Edition) (Core
Network Aspects)
Rec.FMC Req
N
4/19
19
2Q 2007
H
299
All ITU-T SGs, SDOs
15,37
00
N
5/19
13/
19
2Q 2007
H
15,37
27
Rec.FMC PAU
N
5/19
13/
19
2Q 2007
H
15,37
27
Rec.FMC IMS
N
5/19
13/
19
2Q 2007
H
ITU-R WP 8A, 8B, 8D and
8F, related questions 77/8,
215/8, ITU-R JTG 1-6-8-9,
ITU-T SGs 4, 9, 11, 13, 16,
SDOs, IETF, ATM Forum
ITU-R WP 8A, 8B, 8D and
8F, related questions 77/8,
215/8, ITU-R JTG 1-6-8-9,
ITU-T SGs 4, 9, 11, 13, 16,
SDOs, IETF, ATM Forum
ITU-R WP 8A, 8B, 8D and
8F, related questions 77/8,
215/8, ITU-R JTG 1-6-8-9,
ITU-T SGs 4, 9, 11, 13, 16,
SDOs, IETF, ATM Forum
15,37
27
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
Liaison
Area
Domain
References
Subject
Develop contents for Q.1741.5
draft Recommendation:
architecture and specifications of
release 7 of “GSM evolved UMTS
core network”
Architecture and specifications of
each release of IMT-2000 family
members, making reference to
specifications produced by SDOs.
Q.1742: “ANSI-41 evolved core
network with cdma2000 access
network”.
The Handbook of evolving IMT2000 Systems (Core Network
Aspects)
FMC general requirements from
NGN point of view, identifying the
fundamental characteristics,
requirements and capabilities that a
FMC should be able to support.
FMC service scenario by using
PSTN as the fixed Access network
for UMTS network
Stage 2 of fixed mobile
convergence with a common IMS
session control domain
- 19 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
Annex 4 - Q.1/19 Report: Service and network capability requirements and
network architecture
1.
Organization of Meeting
1.1
Meeting Identification, Chairmanship and Participation
This is the report of a meeting of Q.1/19: Service and network capability requirements and network
architecture.
Q.1/19 met in Geneva on 24-26 January 2006. The meeting was chaired by Mr Bruno Ramos,
Q.1/19 Rapporteur. The meeting was attended by about 11 delegates from 6 countries.
1.2
Meeting Agenda
The Meeting Agenda was published in Temporary Document TD 296R1. It was reviewed and
approved.
2
Key Results
2.1
Work Items Progressed
Discussion on how to improve the work on ITU-T PDNR: Functional Network Architecture for
Systems Beyond IMT-2000, Q.FNAB;
Reviewed, and agreed to the work plan for Q.1/19, that has changed the timing for Q.FNAB from
3Q2006 to 2Q2007.
3
Meeting Documentation
All documents considered at this meeting are available at:
http://www.itu.int/md/meeting.asp?lang=&type=meetingdesc&parent=T05-SG19-060123
4
Liaison Statements
The meeting resulted in the preparation of one Liaison Statement to ITU-T SG 13, Q.3/13, asking
for their analysis and contributions on Q.FNAB v.4.0.
5
Recommendation Status and Work Plan
Status and Work Plan for Recommendations and other deliverables under the responsibility of this
Question are summarized in the overall Study Group work plan.
5.1
Future Work
The next activity of Question 1/19 will be in the form of an e-meeting, as described below:
Duration: From May, 23 to June, 6, 2006
At:
http://forum.itu.int/jive/index.jspa?categoryID=2
Terms of Reference: To progress the work on Q.FNAB.
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 20 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
6
Detailed Report of Discussions
Q.1/19 met during 24-26 January 2006. A total of 11 people participated in this discussion. The
agreed agenda for the Q.1/19 meeting is in Temporary Document TD 296R1.
6.1
Opening Plenary
The Q.1/19 session was called to order at 9:00hrs on 24 January. The proposed agenda for the
Q.1/19 plenary was approved. The terms of reference for this meeting are to continue the work as
assigned to this question (former Q.1/SSG).
6.2
312)
General Items (D 29; D 34; TD 249; TD 256; TD 257; TD 262; SG 13: D 310; D 311; D
The following provides a brief summary of the discussions on and dispositions of input documents
that were assigned to the work item “General Items.”

D 29 - (Disposition of ETSI TISPAN NGN Release 1 Specifications in ITU-T NGN
related Questions (and in ITU-T NGN-GSI activities))
Summary: This contribution presents the ETSI NGN Release 1 set of deliverables
published or soon to be published (as they are approved or in the approval process),
identifies the ITU-T Questions concerned by each document and proposes that the relevant
ITU-T Questions consider the relevant ones as a basis for their ongoing activities and make
normative reference to them wherever applicable and appropriate.
Q.1/19 Discussions: The group agreed to consider, during the work on Q.FNAB, the
deliverables selected to SG19.

D 34 - (2G Mobile Access Network Support in NGN – A Requirement for 2G Network
Evolution Towards NGN for Developing Nations)
Summary: The NGN architecture (release 1), recently released by the FGNGN under
SG13, talks about the interoperability with the existing telecom network technologies
including the PSTN/ISDN networks and 2G PLMNs. It also talks about the network
attachment with various kinds of access technologies. Moreover special emphasis has been
given for the PSTN/ISDN emulation/ simulation/ evolution due to its existing ubiquitous
large subscriber base.
However the fact of presence of even larger and ubiquitous subscriber base of 2G PLMN
has been completely ignored for the emulation/ simulation/ evolution aspect towards NGN.
This means that the existing 2G access network will not be able to attach to the NGN.
Moreover neither the existing 2G subscriber will be able to roam in the NGN nor will the
NGN subscriber be able to roam in the existing 2G networks.
A contribution, viz., FGNGN-ID-1073 – “NGN In-Roaming for the terminals belonging to
Legacy Mobile networks (Non-IMS PLMN) - Support of MAP”, was submitted in the last
FGNGN meeting.
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>.
This contribution is a follow up discussion on the same issue.
Q.1/19 Discussions: The group decided to consider this document in the directives to
Systems Beyond IMT-2000. Nevertheless, it was discussed that the correct forum to discuss
this document is ITU-T SG 13.
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 21 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E

TD 249 - (LS from ITU-T SG 4)
Summary: SG 4 is responsible for maintaining the Telecommunications Management
Documentation Plan. On this matter, Q12/4 asks for suggestions and comments concerning
keeping this document in the current condition.
Q.1/19 Discussions: For information.

TD 256 - (LS from ITU-T SG 17)
Summary: Liaison concerning work to extend OIDs to provide Object Hierarchical
Names.
Q.1/19 Discussions: For information.

TD 257 - (LS from ITU-T SG 17)
Summary: Status of Action Plan to address WTSA-04 Resolution 50 – Cybersecurity
obligations.
Q.1/19 Discussions: For information.

TD 262 - (LS from ITU-R WP8F (Helsinki, 12-19 October 2005))
Summary: Liaison Statement to ITU-T Study Groups 13 and 19 on the development of a
PDNR in response to Q.223.
Q.1/19 Discussions: The group understood that this document should be discussed within
the Joint Sessions of Q.2/19, Q.5/19; Q.6/13; and, Q.29/16.

ITU-T SG 13 D 310 - (NGN Release 1 scope document – WG1 output of Gatwick
London November 2005 FGNGN meeting (Ref.: FGNGN-OD-00253))
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

ITU-T SG 13 D 311 - (NGN Release 1 Requirements document – WG1 output of
London November 2005 FGNGN meeting (Ref.: FGNGN-OD-00252))
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

ITU-T SG 13 D 312 - (FGNGN-FRA Version 7.1 (Ref.: FGNGN-OD-0244R2))
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>
6.3
Functional Network Architecture for Systems Beyond IMT-2000 (Q.FNAB) (TD 297)
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>
6.4
Review of Work Plan for Planned Deliverables
It was agreed that one electronic meeting should be held to progress the work on Q.FNAB before
the next SG 19 Meeting. The planned Q.1/19 Rapporteur’s Electronic Meeting is scheduled for May
23 to June 6, 2006.
6.5
Closing Plenary of Q.1/19
Q.1/19 held its closing plenary at 9:00hrs on Thursday, 26 January 2006. The Q.1/19 report,
including all annexes, was reviewed and agreed to. The delegates were thanked for their
participation in the Q.1/19 activities at this meeting. Q.1/19 discussion meeting was closed at
10:30 hrs.
6.6
Review of Meeting Report.
The draft meeting report in TD 310 was reviewed and approved as TD 310R1.
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 22 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
7
Acknowledgements
Participants - for their participation at this meeting.
Mr Atsushi Minokuchi, from NTT DoCoMo, for his outstanding work as Co-Editor of Q.FNAB so
far. Mr Minokuchi has just moved to NTT DoCoMo Japan and will not work in this PDNR from
now on. All participants of Q.1/19 would like to thank Mr Minokuchi for this work with them and
would like to wish him every success in his new assignment.
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 23 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
Annex 5 - Q.3/19 Report: Identification of existing and evolving
IMT-2000 systems
1
Organization of Meeting
1.1
Meeting Identification, Chairmanship and Participation
This is the report of a meeting of Q.3/19, title: “Identification of existing and evolving
IMT-2000 systems”, met in 2 sessions on 23-27 January 2006. The meeting was chaired by Mr
Ilkka Hyvärinen, Nokia Corporation, Finland and was attended by eight participants from various
countries.
1.2
Meeting agenda
The Meeting Agenda was published in Temporary Document TD GEN 281R1. It was reviewed and
approved.
2
Key Results
2.1
Work Items Progressed
Meeting reviewed and approved inputs of ARIB and TTC for Recommendation Q.1742.5 and
developed a Liaison Statement to 3GPP2 SDOs requesting additional inputs for the consent of
Q.1742.5 in the July meeting of SG19.
2.2
Recommendations planned for Consent at the next meeting
The following Recommendations are planned to be submitted for Consent under the Alternative
Approval Procedure at the 24-28 July 2006 meeting of the Study Group 19.
Table 1 – Recommendations planned for submission for Consent at the next meeting
Rec. #
Q.1742.5
Rec. Title
Editor(s)
“ANSI-41 evolved core network with
cdma2000 access network”
Documents
Mr Charles C. Teising
Jr.
Lucent Technologies
(USA)
3
Meeting Documentation
All documents considered at this meeting are available at
http://www.itu.int/md/meetingdoc.asp?lang=&type=mfolders&parent=T05-SG19-060123-TD
4
Liaison Statements
The meeting resulted in the preparation of Liaison Statements as summarized in Table 2.
Table 2 – Outgoing Liaison Statements
Addressee
ARIB, CCSA,
TIA, TTA, TTC
Document
number
Question
For
GEN
300R1
3/19
Action
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
Title/ Subject
Alert to SDOs of Q.1742.5 publication
status
- 24 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
5
Recommendation status and Work Plan
Status and Work Plan for Recommendations and other deliverables under the responsibility of this
Question are summarized in the overall plan for the Study Group.
Meeting made the following change to the work plan of Q.3:
-
change the consent of Q.1742.5 from 1Q2006 to 3Q2006
5.1
Future work
No interim meetings proposed.
6
Detailed report of discussions
6.1
Work item 3a: General
The meeting reviewed and approved the agenda (document TD GEN 281R1) as recorded under
clause 1.2.
TD GEN 247 provides the draft work programme of SG 19. The Q.3 meeting reviewed the
document and made the updates recorded under clause 5 of this report.
6.2
Work item 3b: Q.1742.5
TD GEN 268 provides inputs of TTC for Q.1742.5. Document reviewed and as the presented input
information included all the requested data, it was approved to be included into the draft Q.1742.5.
TD GEN 269 provides inputs of ARIB for Q.1742.5. Document reviewed and as the presented input
information included all the requested data, it was approved to be included into the draft Q.1742.5.
6.3
AOB
No other business recognized.
6.4
Review of Meeting Report
The draft meeting report in TD 299 was reviewed, revised and approved as revision 1 of TD 299.
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 25 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
Annex 6 - Q.4/19 Report: Preparation of a handbook on IMT-2000
1
Organization of Meeting
1.1
Meeting Identification, Chairmanship and Participation
This is the report of a meeting of Q.4/19 Title: Preparation of a handbook on IMT-2000.
Q.4/19 met in Geneva on 24-26 January 2006. The meeting was chaired by Mr Maurice Ghazal,
Ministry of Telecommunications, Lebanon, and was attended by 10 delegates from 6 countries.
1.2
Meeting agenda
The Meeting Agenda was published in Temporary Document 285R1. It was reviewed and approved
by the meeting.
2
Key Results
2.1
Work Items Progressed
A new chapter on safety and security issues for IMT-2000 was reviewed, adopted by the meeting
participants and sent to the ITU-T Study Group 17 for further revision. The material for new
chapter on FMC was proposed to the editor.
3
Meeting Documentation
Documents considered at this meeting are available at
http://www.itu.int/md/T05-SG19-060123/sum/en .
4
Liaison Statements
The meeting resulted in the preparation of Liaison Statements as summarized in Table 1.
Table 1 – Outgoing Liaison Statements
Addressee
Document
number
Question
For
ITU-D Q.18/2
TD 305R1
Q.4/19
Action
Request of the material for the Handbook on IMT2000
ITU-T SG17
TD 306
Q.4/19
Action
Revision of the draft new chapter for the Handbook
on IMT-2000
ITU-R WP8F
TD 307R1
Q.4/19
Action
Preparation of the Handbook on IMT-2000
TD 314
Q.4/19
Action
Request for material for the Handbook on IMT2000
ITU-T SG3
5
Title/ Subject
Recommendation status and Work Plan
Status and Work Plan for Recommendations and other deliverables under the responsibility of this
Question are summarized in the overall Work Plan for the Study Group.
5.1
Future work
The next activity of Question 4/19 will be in the form of physical meeting on the next meeting of
SG19 in July 2006 in Geneva. It was decided that no Q.4/19 Rapporteurs meetings are needed. An
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 26 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
electronic Rapporteur meeting will probably be established after the next meeting of SG19 in July
2006.
6
Detailed report of discussions

The Delayed contribution D 35 “The proposal on editing of the Handbook on IMT-2000”
from Russian Federation was presented to the meeting, reviewed and adopted by the
meeting participants. This contribution contained the proposal to use the material from
Kyiv Workshop on FMC (TD 265) for the new chapter. It was proposed during the
discussion to use the material both from Kyiv Workshop and Tunis Seminar (TD 294).

TD 265 is the TSB Report of the SG19 Workshop on Mobile Telecommunications and
FMC, Kyiv, Ukraine, 12-14 September 2005. It was noted. The material from the
Workshop can be used as a material for new chapter.

TD 294 contains the information about ITU-BDT Seminar on FMC and New Network
Architectures, Tunis, 21-24 Nov 2005. It was noted. The material from the Seminar can be
used as a material for new chapter.

TD 248 is a Liaison Statement from ITU-D Q.18/2 on the Revision of WTDC Resolution
43 (Istanbul, 2002). The Liaison Statement to ITU-D Q.18/2 concerning the material for the
Handbook within the scope of the Resolution 43 was prepared.

TD 253 is a Liaison Statement from ITU-T SG17 informing the group about the SG17
Action Plan for developing countries and countries with economies in transition (DC-CET).
It was noted. The Liaison Statement to ITU-T SG17 concerning the revision of the draft
new chapter for the Handbook on safety and security issues was prepared.

TD 283 is the Executive Summary of the 17th ITU-R WP8F meeting. It was noted. The
Liaison Statement to ITU-R WP8F concerning the preparation of the Second Edition of the
Handbook was prepared.

TD 247 is a SG19 Work Programme. The Q.4/19 portion of it was reviewed. It was decided
to postpone the issue of the Handbook to the 2Q.2007 because of the large amount of
material to process.

TD 282 R1 is a chapter on safety and security issues (for the second edition of the
Handbook). It was revised, approved and sent to the ITU-T Study Group 17 for further
revision.

During the closing session discussion there was a proposal to prepare a liaison statement for
ITU-T SG3 to request the information for tariff and accounting principles. The liaison
statement was prepared and adopted as TD 314.
7
Review of Meeting Report
The draft meeting report in TD 311R1 was reviewed and approved.
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 27 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
Annex 7 - Report of Joint Meetings of Q.2/19, Q.5/19, Q.6/13 and Q.29/16
1.
Organization of Meeting
This is the combined meeting report of the joint questions of 6/13, 29/16, 2 and 5/19 that were held
during 16-27 January 2006. It covers the following sessions:

Q6 Independent Meeting – 16-20 January 2006
o
Reference to Q.3, 6, 9/13 Joint Meeting Report

Joint meeting across Q.6/13, Q.29/16, Q.2/19 and Q.5/19 – 23, 26 January 2006

Joint meeting of Q.2/19 and Q.6/13 on Mobility Management – 23-25 January 2006

Joint meeting of Q.5/19 and Q.6/13 on Fixed Mobile Convergence – 23-25 January 2006
The meeting agenda was published in TD82r3 (WP2/13) and TD 280r1 (GEN/19).
2
Q6/13 Independent Meeting Reports
<Notes are found in the TIES protected version of this document.>
3
Joint Meeting Reports across Q.6/13, Q.29/16, Q.2/19 and Q.5/19
The meeting was chaired by Felix Zhang, Q.6/13 Rapporteur, Leo Lehmann Q.29/16 Rapporteur,
Farrokh Khatibi, Q.2/19 Rapporteur and Kees den Hollander, Q.5/19 Rapporteur.
3.1
Key results
It was agreed to propose that circuit switched services (i.e., voice services) of 2G and 3G mobile
networks are emulated/simulated in NGN in the earliest Release possible in order to be able to use
2G/3G access networks in conjunction with NGN.
3.2
Future Work
The next joint MM and FMC meeting of Q.6/13, Q.2/19, and Q.5/19 is scheduled during the Kobe
meeting in the morning of 27 April. Please note that the joint meetings on FMC will be in the
morning and the joint meetings on MM will be in the afternoon of April 24th-26th April.
3.3
Liaison Statements

TD262(SG19) TD160GEN(SG13) LS - Development of a PDNR in response to Q.223

TD295(SG19) ITU-R Q.223-1 Text
Discussion: This LS from ITU-R WP8F informs SGs 13 and 19 that it has started work on
the development of a PDNR in response to Q.223 on IP applications over mobile systems.
Based on a brief overview of the document, the group agreed that it is important for SGs 13
and 19 to be involved in this activity.
Action: An LS in TD 301 (GEN/19) and TD 104 (WP 2/13).
3.4
Contributions

TD88r2(WP2/13) Report of Joint Meeting across Q3, 6 and 9/13
< Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

D546 (SG13) This contribution states the U.S.A. Position on the Use of IMS Terminology
[USA]
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 28 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E

TD84(WP2/13), TD278 (SG19) Technical Paper on Service Mobility for new Multimedia
Service Architecture (Rev. 0.3)
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

D29(SG19) Disposition of ETSI TISPAN NGN Release 1 Specifications in ITU-T NGN
related Questions (and in ITU-T NGN-GSI activities)
Discussion: This contribution lists ETSI TISPAN Specifications that are relevant to ITU-T
NGN-GSI activities. Upon review of this list, TD 278 (SG19) was generated and reviewed
in the MM section.
Action: Noted and review TD 278.

D34(SG19), D370(SG13) 2G Mobile Access Network Support in NGN – A Requirement
for 2G Network Evolution Towards NGN for Developing Nations
Discussion: The author of this contribution was unfortunately not available to present it or
clarify some of the questions that were raised by the contribution. Nonetheless, the
contribution was reviewed. The meeting agreed with the following statement to be
addressed at the Plenaries:
Propose that circuit switched services (i.e., voice services) of 2G and 3G mobile
networks are emulated/simulated in NGN in the earliest Release possible in order to
be able to use 2G/3G access networks in conjunction with NGN.
Action: Agreed to forward the above statement to the Plenaries.
4
Mobility Management
The meeting was chaired by Farrokh Khatibi, Q.2/19 and Felix Zhang, Q.6/13 Rapporteur.
4.1
Key results

It was agreed to combine SG19’s Q.MMR, Q.MMF, and SG13’s Y.NGN-MOB in order to
create a common Stage 1 (MMR) and common three-volume Stage 2 (MMF, LMF, and
HMF) Mobility Management Recommendations across the Study Groups.

Q.MMR was updated (please refer to the D30) resulting in: TD119 (WP2/13) and TD312
(GEN/19)

Additional description of ‘Local’ and ‘Home’ Location Manager and MM Scenarios were
added to Q.MMF resulting in: TD120 (WP2/13) and TD313 (GEN/19).
4.2
Recommendation status and work plan
The following Work Plan update was agreed by the group:
MMR (Stage 1) AAP Consent in July 2006 Plenary
MMF (Stage 2)
Stable document by 2Q2006 and AAP Consent 2Q2007
LMF Location Management (Stage 2)
2Q2007
HMF Handover Management (Stage 2)
2Q2007
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 29 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
4.3
Future Work
The next joint meeting of Q.2/19 and Q.6/13 is in the form of a joint Rapporteur level face-to-face
meeting 24-27 April, during the NGN-GSI meeting in Kobe, Japan. The Terms of Reference for this
meeting are:
To combine SG19’s Q.MMR, Q.MMF, and SG13’s Y.NGN-MOB in order to create a Stage
1 (MMR) and three Stage 2 (MMF, LMF, and HMF) Mobility Management
Recommendations.
4.4
Liaison Statements
No liaison statements were assigned to the joint session on MM.
4.5
Contributions

D40(SG19) Review of proposed new IETF work item: "Network-based Localized
Mobility"
Discussion: This contribution reviews a proposal for a new IETF working group to address
certain aspects of Mobility Management. The contribution includes the scope of the
Network-based Localized Mobility Management (netlmm) Work Plan.
Action: The participants were encouraged to follow up on the discussions in this group and
provide relevant discussion to the MM activities of ITU-T.

D41(SG19) Executive Summary of the mobility-related WGs in IETF
Discussion: This contribution summarized the activities of 64th IETF Meeting related to
MM.
Action: The participants were encouraged to follow up on the discussions in IETF and
provide relevant interaction between IETF and ITU-T.

D313(SG13) Mobility Management Capability Requirements for NGN (Ref. FGNGN-OD00246r1)
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

D469(SG13) Proposed added texts to Section 5.2 – IPv6 Capabilities in NGN
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

TD159(GEN/13) Final Draft TR on Corporate Telecommunication Networks – Mobility
for Enterprise Communications (ref. Ecma/TC32-TG17/2005/069)
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

TD279 (SG19) Roaming Interface Protocol Definitions for TISPAN NGN Network Access
- TISPAN NGN Release 1
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

D30(SG19) Draft New Recommendation Q.MMR
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

D33(SG19) Draft New Recommendation Q.MMF (version 0.9)
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

D32(SG19) Clarification of Local and Home Location Managers
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 30 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
Discussion: This document defines the terms ‘Local’ and ‘Home’ Location Manager. Note
that we could have multiple levels of Handover Management. There needs to be a clear
connection between LM and HM.
Action: The contribution was agreed and the Editors were instructed to update Q.MMF to
include these updates.

D31(SG19) MM Scenarios by Service Models.
Discussion: This contribution proposes the texts for Section 9 (MM scenarios by Services
Models) of Q.MMF. It points out that the application services models can be divided into
the client-server model and peer-to-peer model. The contribution includes a table that
compared different MM Scenarios by MMF. The comparison does not include all factors
such as resource allocation. Contributions are invited to add other factors to the comparison
Action: The contribution was approved and the Editors were instructed to include it in
Q.MMF.
5
Fixed Mobile Convergence
The meeting was chaired by Kees den Hollander, Q.5/19 Rapporteur and Felix Zhang, Q.6/13
Rapporteur.
In their opening remarks the Rapporteurs clarified that at future NGN-GSI and co-located SG 13
and SG 19 meetings, all FMC sessions will be joint meetings of Q.6/13 and Q.5/19.
It was further noted that the consequence of joining forces is that the scope of the recommendations
of both questions will have to be reviewed in order to ensure that the joint group produces a
consistent set of recommendations according to a consolidated work plan.
5.1
Key results
The meeting achieved the following results:

It was agreed to narrow the scope of Q.FMC stage 2 to a stage 2 recommendation on IMS
based FMC and to clarify this in the working title by changing it to Rec.FMC-IMS.
Material in the output draft from this meeting that does no longer fall within the new scope
will be taken out at the next meeting and transferred to another FMC recommendation or a
living list. An output draft was produced that contains a substantial amount of new stage 2
material. It can be found in TD303R1(GEN/19)/TD118R1(WP2/13)

It was agreed to start a new recommendation on an FMC scenario using PSTN as the fixed
access network for a UMTS network with working title Rec.FMC-PAU. A first working
draft was produced as output from the meeting. It can be found in TD304(GEN/19)/TD117
(WP2/13)

Rec.FMC-REQ was considerable enhanced in the sections on high level requirements and
capabilities. The new output draft contains a new definition of FMC that makes it clear that
FMC is an aspect of NGN, but not limited to NGN. It can be found in
TD308(GEN/19)/TD116R1 (WP2/13)
5.2
Recommendation status and work plan
The target date of Rec.FMC-IMS has been revised to 2Q 2007, because there is no SG meeting in
Q1 (the current target date).
For the new draft Rec.FMC-PAU the meeting agreed to a planned completion date of 2Q 2007.
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 31 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
It was suggested that these stage 2 documents can only be completed if the stage 1, Rec.FMC-REQ,
is available at least two meeting earlier. Since there is no SG meeting in November, it was agreed
that it would be sufficient if Rec.FMC-REQ reaches stable draft status at the NGN-GSI meeting in
November and the group hold an additional Rapporteur’s meeting between the November and April
meeting. The official target date for Rec.FMC-REQ is also 2Q 2007.
Lawful interception
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>.
5.2.1
Editors
Mr Li Mo of ZTE kindly volunteered to replace Mr David McFarlane as editor for Rec.FMC-IMS.
Mr Minrui Shi of China Telecom kindly volunteered to take on the editorship for the new draft
recommendation Rec.FMC-PAU.
Both nominations were gladly accepted by the meeting and both new editors were wished every
success in their endeavours.
5.3
Future Work
It was agreed to progress the work on the FMC deliverables during the NGN-GSI meeting in Kobe,
Japan. The FMC meetings will held in the mornings of April 24 – 26. The output results will be
reviewed in a joint session on FMC and MM in the morning of April 27.
The terms of reference for the April meeting are:

progress the work on Rec.FMC-REQ

progress the work on Rec.FMC-IMS

progress the work on Rec.FMC-PAU
The meeting discussed the planning for the July meeting of SGs 13 and 19. To allow enough time
for the discussions on FMC and facilitate co-ordination with Q3/13 it was decided to hold the
formal FMC sessions on July 20 and 21. Drafting may take place on July 24 and 25 and the results
of drafting will be reviewed in a joint session with MM on July 26.
5.4
Liaison Statements
No liaison statements were assigned to the joint session on FMC.
5.5
Contributions
5.5.1
General

D314(SG13) FGNGN-IFN (IMS for Next Generation Networks) (Ref.: FGNGN-OD00245r1)
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

D487(SG13) [Korea] Proposal for the categorization of the converged services in NGN.
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

D538(SG13) [ZTE] Fixed Mobile Convergence - Services Migration and Architecture
Migration Scenarios
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 32 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E

D36(SG19)/D464(SG13) [China Telecom] A proposal to initiate the study of FMC service
scenario by using PSTN as the fixed access network for UMTS network.
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>
5.5.2
Q.FMC Stage 2

TD234r1 (SG19) Output Draft of Q.FMC stage 2 from September 2006 meeting
Discussion: No further work has been done on Q.FMC stage 2 since the last meeting and
the output draft from the last meeting is therefore the basis for the work during this
meeting. It was noted that the scope of the current draft is limited to an FMC scenario with
a common IMS session control domain. In order to reflect this in the title it was agreed to
change the title to: “FMC with a common IMS session control domain” and refer to the
draft recommendation as Rec.FMC-IMS.

D38(SG19) [Samsung] Proposed revised text for Q.FMC section 7 on high level design
principles
Discussion: The proposed concept of FMC network domains and reference points was
accepted but the discussion raised the need to clarify the proposed text in a number of
areas: the stated goal of FMC is too limited and needs to be expanded; converged service
should be replaced by service transparency; the figure and in particular the reference point
between the session control and access transport domain should be checked against FRA.
Action: Address the issues mentioned above in drafting and incorporate the results in the
output draft from this meeting.

D39(SG19) [Samsung] Proposed approach for the development of an FMC specific
functional model
Discussion: It was clarified that it is proposed to complement the top down modelling
approach of FRA with a bottom-up analysis of the existing functional models of fixed and
mobile networks. The purpose is to identify the existing interfaces that are applicable at the
FMC domain boundaries and to investigate on the basis of FRA which merged or new
functions are required to support FMC. A number of questions were raised on the proposed
baseline figure that portrays an FMC scenario with UTRAN, I-WLAN and TISPAN DSL
access networks. It was agreed that the material is valuable, but needs further scrutiny, and
should therefore be captured in an informative annex at this stage.
Action: Review the proposed baseline figure and associated text in drafting and
incorporate the results in an informative annex in the output draft from this meeting.

D37(SG19) [Samsung] Proposed text for Q.FMC section 8 on mechanism on Unique User
Identity.
Discussion: During the discussions it appeared that many delegates interpret the
requirement in the current draft for support of ISIM equivalent functionality in the User
Equipment as a requirement to support IMS AKA. It was suggested that this is meant as a
requirement to provide an authentication mechanism that is supported by existing or
emerging IMS specifications and agreed that this should be clarified. It was further
suggested and agreed to strike the sentence in the proposed text that says that the proposed
mechanisms to support legacy terminals are not an alternative to ISIM functionality.
Action: Clarify the proposed text in drafting and incorporate the results in the output draft
from this meeting.
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 33 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
Results of drafting
The results of the drafting group on Rec.FMC-IMS were reviewed and agreed. The output
draft from this meeting is contained in TD303R1 (GEN/19)/TD118 (GEN/13).
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>
5.5.3
Y.FMC_Req

D418(SG13) [MII of CHINA] Proposal for FMC Definition in Y.FMC_Req
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

D419(SG13) [MII of CHINA] Proposal for Objectives of FMC Y.FMC_Req
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

D459(SG13) [ChinaTelecom] Proposal for adding FMC service requirements in "Y.FMC
Req"
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

D462(SG13) [ChinaTelecom] Some proposals to UPT Service Scenarios over NGN
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

D498(SG13) [Korea (Rep. of)] Additional Requirements on Draft Y.FMCReq
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

D509(SG13) [Alcatel Shanghai Bell, CATR/MII] Proposed text for Clause "Fundamental
characteristics of FMC" in draft Recommendation Y.FMCReq
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>

D510(SG13) [MII of CHINA] Proposed text for Clause "FMC networking capabilities" in
draft Recommendation Y.FMCReq
<Discussion notes are in the version of this document behind TIES.>
Results of drafting
The results of the drafting group on Rec.FMC-REQ were reviewed and agreed. The output draft
from this meeting is contained in TD308 (GEN/19)/TD116R1 (GEN/13).
6.
Acknowledgements
Rapporteurs of Q6/13, Q29/16, Q2 and 5/19 would like to thank all participants for their hard work
and dedication during the course of the meeting. Thanks to TSB supporting team, for help and
assistance before and during the meeting.
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 34 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
Annex 8 - Extract of Proposal on Trial for Further Reducing Paper
Consumption at ITU-T Meetings
As part of increasing the emphasis on all electronic working while ensuring that
the needs of the membership continue to be met, TSAG has authorized SGs 15 and
19 to conduct a trial of an enhancement to the indication of paper vs.
electronic documentation when registering for a meeting. Please read through the
remainder of this email for information about this change and the request for
those of you who have indicated on your registration form that you wish paper
copies to indicate whether you would be agreeable to an additional option.
This does not affect those who work only with electronic documents.
...
Currently, the registration form in the SG 19 Collective Letter asks you to
indicate whether you need paper copies of contributions or paper copies of TDs.
If these options are not selected, it is taken as an indication that you work
with electronic documents.
It has been proposed that this be modified to allow participants to download
documents electronically from the web site prior to the meeting and then to
receive paper copies only of new TDs generated during the meeting. This will
save reproduction costs by not printing copies of TDs that participants have
downloaded and printed for themselves before coming to the meeting (and would be
bringing to the meeting), but still enables those participants who need, or
prefer, to work from paper copies to be provided paper copies of new TDs
generated during the meeting. TDs that participants have printed at home would
not need to be printed again for the meeting, thereby potentially saving a
considerable amount of paper and the associated printing and distribution costs.
In order for this to work, there would need to be a clear demarcation point for
when TDs are considered "new" and would be printed, vs. when they would be
considered to have been downloaded and printed at home. The suggested
demarcation point is end-of-day one working day before the meeting when there is
an intervening weekend, or end-of-day two working days before the meeting when
there is not an intervening weekend. In other words, for a meeting beginning on
Monday, this would be end-of-day Thursday; for a meeting beginning on a Tuesday,
this would be end-of-day Friday; for a meeting beginning on a Wednesday, this
would be end of day Monday; and so on. End-of-day would be nominally 1700 hours
local time at the location where the meeting is to be held. For Geneva, this
would be 1700 CET or 1600 GMT/UTC for our upcoming SG 19 meeting. Any TD not
posted by this time (e.g., 1600 GMT/UTC Thursday for our meeting next week)
would be considered "new" and would be printed for those requesting paper copies
of "new" TDs.
The demarcation point for "new" TDs would be made clear in the Collective
Letter. A change to the registration form would be needed to add an additional
option which could be selected by those who still wish to work with paper copies
of TDs. The following is a possible approach to this:
I need paper copies for all Delayed Contributions: [_] <-- a current option with
"all" added
I need paper copies for all Temporary Documents: [_] <-- a current option with
"all" added
I need paper copies only for "new" Temporary Documents: [_] <-- a new option
In order to begin using this process expeditiously (i.e., immediately), I would
ask all of you who have registered for the SG 19 meeting ... and who have asked
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 35 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
for paper copies, to consider whether you would be willing to be provided only
paper copies of "new" TDs.
Kindly inform (the TSB) as soon as possible if you would be able to work with
only paper copies of "new" TDs.
I would further ask you to provide feedback to myself on whether this option is
considered useful for you, or whether there are problems that you foresee that
would need to be addressed.
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC
- 36 COM 19 – R 4 PUBLIC – E
Annex 9 - Draft Work Plan for July 2006 Meeting of SG 19
SG 19 Activity
Thu 20 Jul
Session
1
2
Fri 21 Jul
3
4
1
2
Sun 23 Jul
3
4
Mgmt Team
1
2
Mon 24 Jul
3
4
1
4
1
2
3
4
1
2
Thu 27 Jul
3
X
4
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
1
2
3
4
3
X4
X
Q.1/19
MM
3
Wed 26 Jul
X
SG 19 Plenary
FMC1
2
Tue 25 Jul
X
X
X
X
X
X
X
2
X
X
X
X
X
MM & FMC
X
Q.3/19
X
Q.4/19
X
X
X
X5
Notes:
1.
FMC is the joint activity on Fixed-Mobile Convergence involving Qs.5/19, 6/13 and 29/16.
2.
MM is the joint activity on Mobility Management involving Qs.2/19, 6/13 and 29/16.
3.
The SG 19 Management Team will also meet 1330h-1400h on Wednesday to review issues and progress, and prepare for the closing plenary.
4.
Recommendations for AAP Consent or TAP Determination, and Supplements to be considered for approval, must be provided to the TSB in sufficient time that they can be
posted and available to all delegates by 0830h Thursday. Question reports should be made available by this time as well, but as a second priority.
5
This session will follow that allocated to Q.1/19 and is to provide an opportunity for Q.4/19 to work with participants in Q.3/19 following their last session in support of the
work of Q.4/19.
_________________
ITU-T\COM-T\COM19\R\R004-PUBLIC-E.DOC