Annls Soc. r. zool. Belg. — T. 113 (1983) — fase. 2 — pp. 155-164 — Bruxelles 1983 (Manuscript received on 18 August 1982) IN T E R N A T IO N A L ST U D Y O N A R T E M I A (1). X V II. E N ER G Y C O N S U M P T IO N IN C Y ST S AN D EARLY LAR V AL ST A G E S OF V A R IO U S G E O G R A PH IC AL S T R A IN S OF A R T E M I A by P aul V A N H A E C K E , P a t r i c k LA YE N S and P a t r i c k SORGELOOS (2) Artemia Reference Center, State University of Ghent J. Plateaustraat 22, B-9000 Ghent (Belgium) SU M M ARY Variations in dry weight, caloric content and ash content during cyst hatching and early larval development have been studied for various geographical strains of Artemia. In general, decapsulated cysts contain 30 to 40 % more energy than freshly hatched nauplii; for Chaplin Lake and Buenos Aires Artemia this difference amounts to 57 % . Ash contents increase as decapsulated cysts hatch into instar I and molt into instar II-I II nauplii. Over a 24 h larval developmental period individual dry weights and energy contents of the nauplii decrease with 16-34 % and 22-37 % respectively. A small but significant correlation exists between the survival rate of starved nauplii and either the energy content of instar I and instar II-I II nauplii or the proportional energy consumption during metabolism from decapsulated cysts to instar I I-I II nauplii. The potential impact of these results on the use of Artemia in aquaculture hatcheries is discussed. IN T R O D U C T IO N Artemia only can ingest food from the second instar stage onwards ( B e n e s c h , 1969). As a result their organic contents decrease from the restart of the cyst’s metabolism through the hatching of the nauplius and into the instar II larval stage ( V o n H e n t i g , 1971) ; e.g. in individual nauplii of San Francisco Bay (California) origin dry weight and energy contents decrease by 2 0 % respectively 27 % as they molt from the instar I into the instar II-III stage ( B e n i j t s et al., 1976). As a result Artemia nauplii as food source in aquaculture hatcheries are most efficiently used as freshly-hatched nauplii. In practice, however, not much attention is paid to this potential economy in Artemia cyst uses ; e.g. techniques for cyst incubation and nauplii harvesting are usually not standardized, Artemia nauplii are sometimes stored for one or more days prior to be fed to the predator larvae, as Artemia nauplii are distributed only once a day, their retention time prior to being captured by the predator larvae often exceeds 24 h. In addition more and more new Artemia cyst sources are used ( S o r g e l o o s , 1980a) and nothing is known about the potential differences in terms of critical drops in energy contents during larval developments, or survival rates in culture tanks in unfed conditions. (1) International interdisciplinary study on Artemia strains coordinated by the Artemia Reference Center, State University of Ghent, Belgium. (2) Research Associate at the Belgian National Science Foundation. In this regard, we have studied nauplius survival at two different temperatures as well as energy contents and dry weights of instar I and instar II-III larvae for the most commonly used Artemia cyst sources. Since it has recently been shown that decapsulated cysts can be used as a direct food source for many aquaculture organisms ( B r u g g e m a n et, al., 1980) which could lead to a further economy in the use of Artemia cysts, we have also analyzed the dry weight and energy contents of decapsulated cysts for the same geographical Artemia sources. M A T E R IA L S AND M ETHODS Details on the geographical origin of the Artemia strains studied are provided in Table I. TABLE I List of « Artemia » sources studied Geographical source of cysts San Francisco Bay (Ca-USA) San Pablo Bay (Ca-USA) Macau (Brazil) Barotac Nuevo (Philippines) Chapfin Lake (Canada) Buenos Aires (Argentina) Bahia Salinas (Puerto Rico) Great Salt Lake (Ut-USA) Shark Bay (Australia) Margherita di Savoia (Italy) Tientsin (People’s Republic of China) Lavalduc (France) batch num­ ber or year of harvest mode of reproduction abbreviation (B : bisexual; used P : parthenogenetic) n° 288-2596 n° 1628 May 1978 n» 871172 1978 1978 1977 — 1977 n» 114 1977 B B B B P P SFB SPB MAC 1 MAC 2 PHIL CHA ARG PR GSL SB MS 1978 1979 P P T IE N LAV B B B B B Cysts were incubated in natural seawater (35 % 0 salinity) at a temperature of 25° i 0 .5 ° C and an illumination of 1,000 lux. A homogenous population of instar I nauplii was obtained by harvesting the nauplii when 90 % hatching was attained or, for the slow hatching strains, 8 to 1 0 h after the appearance of the first nauplii. The nauplii were separated from their hatching debris with a separator box ( P e r s o o n e and S o r g e l o o s , 1972). Half of the nauplii was analyzed immediately, the other half was incubated in an Erlenmeyer flask, containing 1 1 natural seawater at 25° i 0 .5 °C that was aerated by gentle air-bubbling and illuminated at 1,000 lux. After 24 h incubation, the nauplii had molted into the instar II and some even in the instar ITT stage. They were separated from their exuviae and a few dead nauplii with the separator box and were analyzed. Cysts that had been cleaned following the procedure of S o r g e l o o s et al. (1978) were decapsulated according to the technique of B r u g g e m a n et al. (1980). Dry-weight analyses of nauplii and cysts were carried out following the method described by V a n h a e c k e and S o r g e l o o s (1980). Ash weights were determined on dried samples that had been incinerated for 4 h at 550° C. Energy contents were analyzed on six replicate samples of approximately 25 mg dry material per strain following the wet oxidation technique of M a c i o i .e c (1962). The data obtained were analyzed for statistical significance with a one way analysis of variance (Model I ; S o k a l and R o h l f , 1969). For comparisons among means, Duncan’s Multiple Range test was used ( S n e d e c o r and C o c h r a n , 1967). The survival experiments were carried out in glass petri dishes. Per strain, three dishes each containing 1 0 freshly hatched nauplii in 1 0 ml filtered natural seawater were incubated in darkness at temperatures of 20° C and 30° C respectively. Two replicate survival tests were conducted for each Artemia strain. Once a day for the 20° C run and twice a day for the 30° C run, mortality was checked and dead larvae removed. LT 50 values were calculated according to the method of Litchfield (1949) and compared for statistical differences following the technique of Litchfield and Wilcoxon (1949). r e s u l t s From Table II it appears that the individual dry weights of decapsulated cysts vary considerably from one strain to another ; i.e. overall variation exceeding 100 % . No significant differences could be noted among batches from the same strain nor between cysts originating from the same parental material but produced at different localities, e.g. Macau, Barotac Nuevo and San Francisco Bay. The variation in ash content between Artemia strains is rather small (3.785.36 %). Differences in energy content between the strains studied are low, the maximal range being 9.3 % . Statistical analyses revealed, however, that the energy content of decapsulated cysts from the parthenogenetic strains of Margherita di Savoia, Tientsin and Lavalduc is significantly lower than for most other sources. Shark Bay Artemia make, however, an exception, being a parthenogenetic strain with a cyst energy-content similar to the values obtained for most bisexual strains. As a result of the differences in individual dry weights, the individual caloric contents vary widely from one strain to another. From the Tables III and IV it is clear that for the instar I respectively instar 11III nauplii variations in individual dry weight, ash content and energy content are similar to those of decapsulated cysts. As the embryos have developed from cyst to instar I and instar II or III, the ash contents have increased, whereas the individual dry weights and individual energy contents have dropped. Statistical analysis of the survival data shown in Fig. 1 reveals a great similarity in response among Artemia from different geographical origin exposed to 20° C and 30° C. The nauplii of Chaplin Lake and Buenos Aires always die off earliest, whereas Shark Bay Artemia have the longest mean lethal time. TA B LE II Individual dry weight, ash content, and energy content of decapsulated « Artemia » cysts from various geographical origin Source of cysts individual dry weight (in (Jtg) San Francisco Bay San Pablo Bay Macau (May 1978) Macau (Batch 871172) Barotac Nuevo Chaplin Lake Buenos Aires Bahia Salinas Great Salt Lake Shark Bay Margherita di Savoia Tientsin Lavalduc ash content (in % of dry weight) 2.15 2.48 2.25 2.30 2.21 3.05 2.66 2.87 3.23 3.42 4.51 4.17 3.98 4.37 4.28 4.31 4.21 4.09 5.36 5.26 4.82 4.51 3.78 4.49 5.09 4.25 energy individual content energy (in joules/g content dry (in joules) weight) 23 23 22 22 23 23 22 22 22 23 21 21 21 250 160 650 540 370 010 290 640 900 050 380 740 890 0.0500 0.0574 0.0510 0.0523 0.0516 0.0702 0,0593 0,0650 0,0740 0.0788 0.0964 0.0907 0.0871 TA B LE III Individual dry weight, ash content and energy content of instar I « Artemia » nauplii from various geographical origin Source of cysts individual dry weight (in |xg) San Francisco Bay San Pablo Bay Macau (May 1978) Macau (Batch 871172) Barotac Nuevo Chaplin Lake Buenos Aires Bahia Salinas Great Salt Lake Shark Bay Margherita di Savoia Tientsin Lavalduc 1.63 1.92 1.68 1.74 1.68 2.04 1.72 2.10 2.42 2.47 3.33 3.09 3.08 ash content (in % of dry weight) 6.33 6.17 5.83 5.88 6.07 6.59 6.32 5.51 5.69 5.28 6.17 6.63 6.03 individual energy energy content content (in joules/g (in dry joules) weight) 22 480 22 330 22 710 22 520 22 740 21 940 22 020 22 390 22 350 22 330 21 760 22 050 21 760 0.0366 0.0429 0.0381 0.0392 0,0382 0.0446 0.0379 0.0470 0.0539 0.0576 0.0725 0.0681 0.0670 TA B LE IV Individual dry weight, ash content and energy content of instar I I -I I I « Artemia » nauplii from various geographical origin Source of cysts individual dry weight (in (ig) San Francisco Bay San Pablo Bay Macau (May 1978) Macau (Batch 871172) Barotac Nuevo Chaplin Lake Buenos Aires Bahia Salinas Great Salt Lake Shark Bay Margherita di Savoia Tientsin Lavalduc ash content (in % of dry weight) 1.25 1.36 1.15 1.21 1.21 1.59 1.13 1.68 1.59 2.07 2.51 2.37 2.20 10.35 10.20 10.11 10.21 10.08 11.12 9.75 9.87 9.61 8.54 9.10 9.84 9.33 individual energy energy content content (in joules/g (in dry joules) weight) 21 21 20 21 21 19 20 21 21 21 20 19 20 520 110 880 120 470 450 370 810 310 680 840 940 150 0.0269 0.0287 0.0240 0.0256 0.0260 0.0311 0.0233 0.0366 0.0339 0.0449 0.0523 0.0473 0.0443 D IS C U S S IO N T h e d a ta rep orted in th is stu d y clea rly d em on stra te th a t in Artemia b o th the in d iv id u a l w eig h t a n d th e e n erg y c o n te n t co n s id e ra b ly d r o p as a resu lt o f th e h a tch in g m eta b o lis m (see F ig . 2). S in ce th e en erg y c o n te n ts ex p ressed p er g ra m o rg a n ic w eig h t d o n o t ch a n ge sig n ifica n tly as e m b ry o s d e v e lo p in to free-sw im m in g n a u p lii, it is h ig h ly lik e ly th a t th e fa t-p r o te in -c a r b o h y d r a te ra tios rem a in a p p r o x im a te ly co n s ta n t d u rin g th is d ev e lo p m e n ta l p eriod . F o r m o s t Artemia strains stu d ied , th e rela tiv e d ifferen ce in w e ig h t a n d en erg y co n te n t b etw een e m b r y o s a n d in sta r I n a u p lii is fa ir ly co n s ta n t w ith in th e ran ge o f 30 -40 % ; C h ap lin L a k e a n d B u en os A ires Artemia, h ow ev er, con su m e su b sta n tia lly m ore en erg y fo r h a tch in g , rela tiv e differen ces in in d iv id u a i en erg y c o n te n t a m ou n tin g u p to 57 % . I t is n o t clear i f th is is rela ted to th e p h y s ic o -ch e m is tr y o f th e b io to p e s , e.g. C h ap lin L a k e Artemia is th e o n ly su lp h ate stra in stu d ied h ere ( H a m m e r , 1978), or th e g e n o ty p ica l orig in o f th e brin e sh rim p strain , e.g. B u en os A ires Artemia is th e o n ly rep resen ta tive o f th e Artemia persimilis sib lin g sp ecies w h ereas th e oth er strains stu d ie d b elon g to eith er Artemia franciscana (7 sou rces) o r Artemia parthenogenetica (4 sou rces) ( B o w e n et al., 1978 ; A b r e u - G r o b o i s a n d B e a r d m o r e , 1980). T h e h ig h est in creases in h a tch in g o u tp u t a t lo w sa lin ity (5 0/ 00 in stea d o f 35 ° / 00) bein g o b s e rv e d fo r p recisely th e sam e tw o strain s ( V a n h a e c k e a n d S o r g e l o o s , 1983) p ro v id e s fu rth e r su p p o rt fo r th e h y p o th e s is o f S o r g e l o o s (19 80 b) th a t th e in crease in h a tc h a b ility a t lo w salin ities is rela ted to en ergy. I n v ie w o f th e d a ta p resen ted, it is clear th a t in stea d o f fr e sh ly -h a tch e d n a u p lii, the use o f d eca p su la ted cy s ts o f Artemia as a d ir e c t fo o d sou rce ca n lea d to a su bsta n - CHA BA GSL It GSL1 SPB MAC 1 TIEN MAC 2 MS LAV SFB PR PHIL SB —r - —1— —I— —r- 20 40 60 80 — 100 I----------- 1------------1— 120 140 LT50 (in hours) 160 B CHA BA SFB LAV PHIL SPB MS PR MAC 2 TIEN MAC 1 GSL GSL1 SB 10 LT50 (in hours) —r— — r20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 result of a replicate test in time Fig. 1. — LT 50 values for unfed Artemia nauplii from different geographical origin incubated at 20° C (A) and 30° C (B). Strains connected by the same vertical line are not significantly different at the P < 0.05 level. II Fig. 2. — Comparison of the individual energy contents and individual dry weights of decapsulated cysts, instar I and instar II-I II nauplii from different geographical strains of Artemia. tial e c o n o m y in a q u a cu ltu re h atch eries. D eca p su la ted cy s ts n o t o n ly co n ta in 30 % to 40 % m ore en erg y as co m p a re d t o fre sh ly -h a tch e d n a u p lii b u t th eir m ean v o lu m e is o n th e a v era g e 30 % sm aller (ca lcu la te d fr o m v o lu m e tr ic d a ta b y V a n h a e c k e an d S o r g e l o o s , 1980 a n d V a n h a e c k e et al., 1980). T h is m eans th a t d ca p su la ted cy s ts ca n be offe re d t o th e fish a n d cru sta cea n la rvae a t an earlier life stage. T h e p rom isin g p ossib ilities in th is reg a rd h a v e a lrea d y b een d em o n s tra te d fo r several p red a tors (see B ru ggem an et al., 1980). Individual biomass and energy content further decrease as the free-swimming Artemia nauplii develop into instar 11 larvae (see Fig. 2). The data presented in this study for the S an Francisco B ay strain are in accordance with the results o f B e n ijt s et al. (1976) : e.g. 23 respectively 20 % decrease in individual dry weight ; 26 respec­ tively 27 % drop in individual energy content. Large variation, however, is found among the Artemia strains studied, i.e. from 16 to 34 % for dry weights and from 22 to 37 % for individual caloric contents. N o correlation could be found with biotope differences nor with genotypical characteristics. Artemia nauplii from the same parental stock (San Francisco Bay, Macau and Barotac Nuevo) metabolize in fact at different rates. A possible source o f strain differences might be attributed to the different swimming speeds o f the nauplii as reported for at least some o f the strains studied here by M i l l e r et al. (1979). The data reported for the different Artemia cyst sources provide further evidence for the critical need to standardize the hatching procedures as to always assure feeding with the most energetic form o f brine shrimp when using Artemia nauplii in fish and crustacean hatcheries (B e n ijt s et al., 1976). W h erea s a 24 h a g in g o f th e n a u p lii has a sig n ifica n t im p a c t o n th eir en erg y c o n te n t, n a u p lia r v ia b ilit y d oes n o t seem to ch a n ge m u ch a fter 1 o r 2 d a y s o f stora ge. A g a in sig n ifica n t v a r ia tio n ex ists a m on g strains. S in ce C o l l i n s (1978) o b s e rv e d a correla tion b etw een n a u p lia r su rv iv a l a n d n a u p lia r size w e h a v e p e rform ed a d eta iled correla tion an alysis b etw een th e su rv iv a l o f th e n a u p lii an d th eir v a riou s stra in ch a ra cteristics re p o rte d in th is stu d y . S u rv iv a l a t 20 ° C a n d 3 0 ° C d oes n ot sig n ifica n tly correla te w ith n eith er th e d r y w eig h t n o r in d iv id u a l en erg y c o n te n t o f c y s ts a n d inst ar I n a u p lii n or w ith th e a m o u n t o f en erg y con su m ed d u rin g h a tch in g an d e a rly d e v e lo p m e n t. S u r v iv a l a t b o th tem p era tu res, seem s, h ow ev er, t o be sig n i­ fic a n tly corre la te d (P < 0.0 5) w ith th e en erg y c o n te n t (ex p ressed in jo u le /g d r y w e ig h t) o f in star I (r = 0.5 5 - 0.7 2) an d in star 1L -H I n a u p lii (r = 0.61 - 0.6 4 ). A sig n ifica n t co rre la tio n (P < 0.0 5) also o c cu rs b etw een th e m o r ta lity rate o f th e n a u p lii a n d th e g lo b a l p ercen tu a l en erg y c o n s u m p tio n fr o m cy s t to in star 11-111 n a u p liu s (r = 0.8 2 a t 20 ° C ; r = 0.62 a t 30° C). A lth o u g h som e rela tion sh ip m a y e x ist b etw een th e e n e rg y c o n te n t a n d en erg y c o n s u m p tio n o f th e n a u p lii an d th eir su rviv a l, th e r e la tiv e ly low v a lu e fo r th e correla tion coefficien t suggests th a t still oth er p a ra m eters m a y in terfere. a c k n o w l e d g e m e n t T h is stu d y w as su p p o r te d b y th e B elgia n (N .F .W .O .) th r o u g h G ra n t F .K .F .O . 2.0010.78. W e are v e r y in d e b te d t o D r. ir. E . .J a sp e rs N a tio n a l S cien ce F o u n d a tio n fo r p ro o fre a d in g th e m a n u scrip t. REFEREN CES A b r e u -G r o b o i s , F . A . a n d J . A . B e a r d m o r e (1980) — In te rn a tio n a l S tu d y o n Artemia. II. Genetic characterization of Artemia populations — an electrophoretic approach. In : The brine shrimp Artemia (Eds G. Persoone, P. Sorgeloos, O. Roels, E. Jaspers). Vol. 1. Morphology, Genetics, Radiobiology, Toxicology, Universa Press, Wetteren (Belgium), 133-146. B e n e s c h , R . (1969) — Zur Ontogenie und Morphologie von Artemia salina L. Zool. Jb. Anat., 86, 307-458. , F., E . V a n v o o r d e n and P. S o r g e l o o s (1976) — Changes in the biochemical composition of the early larval stages of the brine shrimp, Artemia satina L . In : Proc. 10th European Symposium on Marine Biology (Eds G. Persoone, E. Jaspers). Vol. 1, Universa Press, Wetteren (Belgium), 1-9. B e n ij t s B o w e n B r u g g e m a n C o l l in s . S . T .. J. P . D u r k i n , G. S t e b l i n g and L. S . C l a r k (1978) — Artemia hemo­ globins : genetic variation in parthenogenetic and zygogenetic populations. Biol. Bull., 155, 273-287. , E ., P. S o r g e l o o s and P. V a n h a e c k e (1980) — Improvements in the decapsulation technique of Artemia cysts. In : The brine shrimp Artemia (Eds G. Per­ soone, P. Sorgeloos, O. Roels, E. Jaspers). V o l . 3, Ecology, Culturing, Use in Aqua­ culture, Universa Press, Wetteren (Belgium), 261-269. , N. C . (1978) — The ecological significance of egg size differences among brine shrimp (Artemia salina) populations. Bull. Ecol. Soc. Am ., 59 (2), 57. H , U . T. (1978) The saline lakes of Saskatchewan. III. Chemical characteriza­ tion. Int. Revue ges. Hydrobiol., 63 (3), 311-335. a m m e r , J. T. (1949) — A method for rapid graphic solution of time-percent effect curves. J. Pharm. E xp. Ther., 97, 388-408. L it c h f ie l d L it c h f ie l d M a c io l e c M il l e r , J. T. and F. W i l c o x o n (1949) — A simplified method of evaluating doseeffect experiments. J. Pharm. E xp. Ther., 96, 99-113. , J. A . (1962) — Limnological organic analyses by quantitative dichromatic oxidation. Fish. Res. Rep., 60, 1-61. , D. C . , W . H. L a n g , M . M a r c y , P . C l e m and J. P e c h e n i k (1979) — Inter­ national Study on Artemia. Naupliar locomotory rates, patterns and photoresponses : A comparative study of various strains of Artemia salina. In : Book of Abstracts. International Symposium on the brine shrimp, Artemia salina, Corpus Christi (T X U .S.A.), Aug. 20-23, 1979; Artemia Reference Center, Ghent (Belgium), 91. , G. and P . S o r g e l o o s (1972) • — An improved separator box for Artemia nauplii and other phototactic invertebrates. Helgoländer wiss. Meeresunters., 23 , 243-247. P e r so o n e S n e d e c o r , G. W . a n d W . U n iv e r s it y P re ss, A m e s, S o k a l , R . R . and F. J. R G. C o c h r a n (1967) — Statistical methods. 593 pp. ohlf The Io w a S ta te (1969) — Biometry. W . A . Freeman Co., San Francisco, California, 776 pp. , P. (1980a) -— Improvements in availability and use of Artemia as food source for Macrobrachium. In : Oiant Prawn 1980, Bangkok (Thailand), June 1980. IF S Provisional Report N o 9. International Foundation for Science, Stockholm (Sweden), 123-132. S o rg elo o s S o rg elo o s , P. (1980b) -— The use of the brine shrimp Artemia in aquaculture. In : The brine shrimp Artemia (Eds G. Persoone, P. Sorgeloos, O. Roels, E . Jaspers). Vol. 3, Ecology, Culturing, Use in Aquaculture. Universa Press, Wetteren (Belgium), 25-46. , P . , G. P e r s o o n e , M . B a e z a - M e s a , E . B o s s u y t and E. B b u g g e m a n (1978) — The use of Artemia cysts in aquaculture : the concept of « hatching efficiency » and description of a new method for cyst processing. In : Proc. 9th Ann. Meeting W M S. (Ed. Avault, J. W ., jr) Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge (LA -U .S.A .), 715721. S o r g elo o s V a n h a e c k e , P. and P. S o r g e l o o s (1980) — International Study on Artemia. IV . The biometrics of Artemia strains from different geographical origin. In : The brine shrimp Artemia (Eds G. Persoone, P. Sorgeloos, O. Roels, E. Jaspers). Vol. 3, Ecology Culturing, Use in Aquaculture. Universa Press, Wetteren (Belgium), 393-405. , P. and P. S o b g e l o o s (1983) — International Study on Artemia. X I X . Hatching data for ten commercial sources of brine shrimp cysts and re-evaluation o f the « hatching efficiency » concept. Aquaculture, 30, 43-52. V a n h a e c k e V a n h a e c k b , P., H . S t e y a e r t and P. SO RG ELO O S (1980) — International Study on Artemia. III. The use of Coulter Counter equipment for the biometrical analysis of Artemia cysts. Methodology and mathematics. In : The brine shrimp Artemia (Eds G. Persoone, P. Sorgeloos, O. Roels, E . Jaspers). Vol. 1, Morphology, Genetics, Radiobiology, Toxicology. Universa Press, Wetteren (Belgium), 107-115. H e n t i g , R. (1971) — Einfluss von Salzgehalt und Temperatur auf Entwicklung, Wachstum, Fortpflanzung und Energiebilanz von Artemia salina. M ar. Biol., 9, 145-182. V on