Smith College IT Strategic Plan May 2011 Goldstein & Associates 2 Table of Contents Context Vision and Principles Strategic Opportunities IT Governance Organizational Implications Financial Implications Critical Success Factors 3 Context 4 Introduction Smith College recognizes that technology has become an essential enabler of its institutional goals and strategies. Faculty, students and staff depend on technology to facilitate communications and collaborations, organize and distribute information and support the basic services of the institution. The college anticipates the importance of technology will continue to grow. After a period of constraint, Smith is moving from a strategy of maintaining the technology it has to one that more aggressively expands its capabilities and extends its use. While the college’s educational technology has kept pace with that of other institutions, in other areas there is growing unmet need. Aspects of the wired network must be upgraded, the data center is nearing its capacity and the wireless network has only recently been expanded to cover the majority of campus. Significant unmet needs exist in administrative computing and the college lacks an organizational and technological infrastructure to support management reporting and analytical decision-making. Technological change is presenting new opportunities to engage critical constituents including alumnae and prospective students. All of these needs exist within a context of rapid technological change that is altering how organizations deploy and manage technology. 5 Project Goals and Methodology To help develop its information technology strategy, Smith retained higher education consultants Phil Goldstein, Mary Beth Baker and Harvey Blustain. The consultants’ charge was to Help develop a vision for the future of Smith technology; Evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of current technology; Understand Smith’s existing and emerging technology needs in the context of its institutional plan (Design for Learning); Analyze opportunities to extend IT collaborations within the Five Colleges; and Recommend strategies and initiatives to help Smith achieve its long-term technology goals. 6 Project Goals and Methodology Smith established a strong foundation for its IT plan through a series of internal and external assessments and the engagement of a working group of Trustees. The consultancy built on this work with the following additional activities: Extensive interviews with academic and administrative leaders; Meetings with ITS leaders; Focus groups with faculty and students; Interviews with Five College IT directors and the leadership of Five Colleges, Inc; Meeting with the Trustee Working Group; and Day-long planning retreat with members of the Senior Administrators, faculty and other administrative leaders. 7 Organization of the Document This document recommends a set of IT strategies and initiatives for Smith’s consideration. It begins with a summary vision and set of guiding principles for technology. The next section outlines ten strategic opportunities. It includes a set of initiatives that Smith needs to undertake to achieve the goals and benefits associated with each strategic opportunity. A timeline for phasing the implementation of initiatives is also included. The following section recommends an IT governance structure to oversee the implementation of the strategic plan and improve annual priority setting for technology. The document also summarizes the organizational implications of the IT strategy and presents a framework for dividing departmental and central responsibility for technology management. The final section summarizes the resources required to implement the plan. 8 Vision and Principles 9 Vision The effective use of technology and information is vital to Smith’s strategic directions and institutional goals. Technology will continue to enrich Smith’s educational offerings, provide students and faculty access to a global network of collaborators and augment place-based learning. It will provide new avenues for engaging diverse stakeholders including prospective students, alumnae, and the community at large. Technology at Smith will embrace best practices and never lag in the ability to meet reasonable expectations for technology. In most areas, it will stay near the leading edge* of technology adoption. Smith will be among the early majority of adopters of proven technology. The college will seek to be innovative in areas that support effective pedagogy and scholarship. It will sustain a technology infrastructure that is secure, reliable, and sufficiently robust. *Organizations at or near the leading edge of technology adoption are those that seek to be among the early majority of adopters of technology. They tend to follow behind the innovators and early adopters of a technology. Being near the leading edge suggests that Smith will adopt technology that is proven but not necessarily broadly used within its peer group. Guiding Principles Foster innovation and take risks in the application of technology in faculty research and effective pedagogy. In all other areas, be a close follower in technology adoption. Use technology to enhance place- based education and ensure that place does not become a competitive disadvantage. Create opportunities for students to develop a technology fluency and aptitude that will serve them throughout their lives. Invest in technology that facilitates individual and institutional collaborations both within the Five Colleges and beyond. Use technology to enable faculty, students and staff to work effectively anytime, from any place and with any device. Apply proven technologies in innovative ways to improve and sustain constituent engagement and effective administrative services and campus operations. Use technology to support efficient and effective administrative services and data driven decision-making. 10 11 Strategic Opportunities 12 Overview Smith’s IT plan includes ten strategic opportunities that contribute to one or more aspects of Smith’s vision. The strategic opportunities are interrelated and include actions that support multiple outcomes. For example, adoption of cloud computing solutions is called out as its own strategic opportunity. It is also a tactic that ultimately will enable the realization of other strategies including enhanced mobility, improved disaster recovery and potentially others. Likewise, Five College collaboration is both a strategic opportunity and an enabling tactic of multiple goals. The diagram on following page illustrates the interrelatedness of the strategic opportunities and their support to the vision. Each opportunity requires the implementation of multiple initiatives over a three to five year time horizon. Many of the initiatives listed within a given strategy are actually supportive of multiple goals. While cloud computing and five college collaboration are identified as strategic opportunities, they are also tactics that will enable multiple strategies. The detailed plan provides a complete description of each opportunity, its supporting initiatives, projected timeline and expected outcomes. Linking Vision and Strategic Opportunities • • • • Instructional Technologies Digital Asset Management Cloud Collaboration Sourcing Reliable IT Infrastructure Constituent Engagement 5 College Collaborations Enhance faculty, student and staff mobility • Teaching and Research Excellence • Smith without Boundaries • • Agile and Reliable IT Operational Excellence • • Business Intelligence Administrative Technologies Enhance web self-service Strategic Opportunity: Accelerate Adoption of Effective Learning Technologies, as appropriate 14 Description of the Opportunity Through targeted investments in infrastructure, support staff and faculty led projects, this initiative will accelerate the use of technology in Smith’s courses. It includes expansion of the number of technology enabled learning spaces (in and outside of traditional classrooms), creating mechanisms to support faculty adoption of effective uses of technology in courses, the development of processes to assess the impact of technology on learning outcomes and increased development of hybrid and online courses in collaboration with the Five College collaboration. Goals • Enhance learning experience inside and outside the physical classroom; • Better position Smith students to engage in Five College collaborations; • Provide Smith students the opportunity to use technology in ways already familiar to them and to experience the technologies that will be prominent in their future careers; • Become a leader and innovator in technology that improves effective pedagogy. Accelerate Adoption of Effective Learning Technologies - Key Initiatives Initiative Description Create a biannual instructional technology showcase. Some Smith faculty have already integrated technology into the learning experience, other faculty are experimenting and still others are unclear on how to leverage technology to enhance the learning experience. To educate faculty on how new and emerging technologies can improve their teaching and the student’s learning experience Smith should host a bi-annual conference. The objective of the conference is to allow faculty to demonstrate how they have deployed technology in the classroom, share lessons learned, and provide a forum for discussion. Add instructional It is expected that Smith faculty will more readily adopt and integrate designers. technology into their teaching program if provided access to one-onone, real time resources that can provide support tailored to their specific needs. Additional instructional designers (experienced faculty/ mentors or highly trained support) should be added in alignment with the faculty appetite for adoption and the availability of technologyenabled classrooms. This additional capacity will help support students in the classroom experience as well as their engagement with hybrid and online coursework. 15 Accelerate Adoption of Effective Learning Technologies - Key Initiatives Initiative Description Continue to assess utilization and pedagogical impact of deployed learning technologies. For each technology, a process should be implemented to evaluate the impact of technology on the learning experience. For example, as cited in Ad Hoc Committee report on Educational Technology, preliminary data from two courses suggests lecture capture software is useful to Smith students. A formal assessment should be completed of the utilization of the software to determine how extensive the lecture capture software should be implemented on campus. Similar assessments can be done of the impact of high-resolution video/web conferencing capabilities, mobile applications, etc. As technologies prove to strengthen the learning experience, the software and required infrastructure requirements (e.g., bandwidth) should be made available in more classrooms. Build more online or hybrid courses to support sharing courses across Five Colleges. One of the high priority opportunities for collaboration with the Five Colleges is course sharing. In collaboration with the Five Colleges, Smith should inventory and prioritize the courses that are good candidates for on-line and/or hybrid learning. Based on the priority and desired timeline for implementation additional resources (hardware, software and human resources) may be necessary to support the build out of the courses. 16 Accelerate Adoption of Effective Learning Technologies - Key Initiatives Initiative Description Create additional collaboration learning spaces and provide necessary resources to support increased multi-media collaborative projects. As the number of faculty members who integrate technology into the learning experience increases Smith may need to increase the number of non-traditional learning spaces for student to accommodate increased need for student collaborations. Such spaces will be designed especially for student project meetings and work sessions. Each room will be equipped with standard media equipment, office furnishings, and movable furniture to enable flexible arrangements to suit a variety of needs. Spaces refer not only to classroom space but public spaces, conference rooms, student lounges, etc. The Master Plan for the Libraries envisions the creation of expanded numbers of technology rich, flexible spaces within the library. This initiative should support efforts to realize this vision as well. As the opportunities increase for collaboration, students will also require more hands-on support for working with applying and integrating multimedia technologies into their coursework. 17 Accelerate Adoption of Effective Learning Technologies – Phasing and Benefits Phasing Strategy The adoption of learning technologies is well underway at Smith. The phasing strategy illustrated on the next page positions the college to more fully leverage current models of integrated teaching with the goal of accelerating the integration of technology into more courses, as appropriate. In year 1 the goals is to create opportunities for faculty to share their models with other faculty and also to provide dedicated resources who can provide more personal attention to individual faculty members as they explore new delivery models. In years 2012 and beyond, as the pedagogy is proven to benefit from the integration of technology and as faculty adoption increases, the focus of this strategic opportunity is to expand the infrastructure and support resources. Benefits This strategic opportunity offers Smith the following benefits: • Improved learning experience both inside and outside the classroom; • Increased number of faculty integrating technology into the learning experience; • Increased use of multi-media and other technologies by students in their coursework; • Increased opportunities for Five College Collaborations. 18 19 Accelerate Adoption of Effective Learning Technologies - Phases 1 2 3 4 5 Add instructional designers. Continue to assess utilization and pedagogical impact of deployed learning technologies. Build more on-line or hybrid courses to support sharing courses across Five Colleges (begin with pilots, e.g., physics and math). Create additional collaboration learning spaces and provide necessary resources to support increased multi-media collaborative projects. Pilots Pilots December Sept June March 2013 December Sept March December Sept June Create a bi-annual instructional technology showcase June 2012 2011 March Initiatives Strategic Opportunity: Implement a Digital Repository/Digital Asset Management Solution 20 Description of the Opportunity Digital asset management (DAM) consists of management tasks and decisions surrounding the ingestion, annotation, cataloguing, storage, retrieval and distribution of assets. Digital photographs, animations, videos and music are samples of media assets. Digital asset management systems include software and hardware systems that aid in the process of digital asset management. Smith’s unique academic assets are increasingly digital. However, data, images and other artifacts are stored in stand-alone databases that are difficult to access. This initiative builds on work begun under the leadership of the library. It provides digital preservation services for scholarly resources, helping to ensure their integrity, authenticity, and usability over time. The initiative also includes establishing the protocols for organizing content, tools to facilitate integrating content into course materials and policies to govern access to content. The initiatives associated with this strategy will require the close collaboration of the libraries, ITS, the faculty and the museum. Goals • Provide holistic and consistent approach to digital asset preservation across the college (Museum, Library, Sciences, etc; • Make digital resources more accessible to faculty and students for integration into coursework; • Create alignment with student expectation for quick access to information; • Provide the opportunity for Smith students to experience the technologies that will be prominent in their chosen careers. Implement a Digital Repository/ Digital Asset Management Solution Key Initiatives 21 Initiative Description Develop strategy for the use of a digital asset management system (including researching current practices at peer and other institutions). The uses and solutions for digital asset management (DAM) systems are continuing to evolve. DAM, at its most basic level uses technology to organize resources, enables users to discover them and owners to track them. At its most advanced level, a DAM system can transform the way an institution manages digitization and handles access to the digital assets. It is important to develop a strategy that covers the complete continuum from creation to delivery: storing the digital objects and their related data; supporting on-line searches; enabling users to retrieve the appropriate version of a particular digital resource depending upon their interest and/or access level; keeping track of rights restrictions; and limiting access to verified users. Deeper analysis and research of how peer institutions are using digital asset management systems will help Smith shape its own approach and strategy. It is necessary to understand current uses, policy implications, implementation challenges and future applications in institutions including peer colleges, libraries and museums. Research into the commercial marketplace about existing and future solutions will assist the effort to identify the appropriate timing for implementation. Using information about available solutions in the external marketplace and current uses in peer institutions will help frame a discussion to determine the best strategy for Smith, to test interest for a Five College collaboration and to develop a timeline for implementation. Implement a Digital Repository/ Digital Asset Management Solution Key Initiatives 22 Initiative Description Continue policy work. A number of policy and process decisions are required to protect intellectual property rights before implementation of a DAM. Decisions must be made in areas including rights and licensing, privacy, fair use, metadata standards, frameworks and formats, access rights, storage and dissemination of data. Organize the project team. Identify the project sponsor, project manager and technical lead that will be dedicated to the project. A detailed project plan for completing the evaluation and selection of a solution and implementation partner should be developed by the project manager. Evaluate alternatives and select best technology solution. Develop a detailed set of functional requirements for a DAM system and conduct a rigorous evaluation of the commercial marketplace. Through an RFI/RFP process, invite vendors to demonstrate the products, discuss migration, integration and implementation approaches and to answer end-user questions. Based on these sessions select the solution that best aligns with the College’s strategy. Select Implementation partner. Once Smith has identified a solution the campus will be ready to identify implementation partner requirements, prepare and issue an RFP for an implementation partner, and ultimately select a partner. Implement a Digital Repository/ Digital Asset Management Solution – Phasing and Benefits Phasing Strategy As illustrated on the next page, the recommended phasing strategy for this strategic opportunity is to use the next year to more fully understand how peer institutions (including museums and libraries) are using DAM systems and to develop an overall strategy (or white paper) for how Smith should approach the implementation of a DAM. The white paper can be used to facilitate dialogue on campus and with the Five Colleges to determine what the approach will be for Smith. In year 2 Smith will organize its project team, select a solution and implementation partner, if necessary. The expectation is that implementation of a DAM solution would begin in 2013. Benefits This strategic opportunity offers Smith the following benefits: • Promotes greater utilization of Smith’s unique digital assets; • Increased student and faculty satisfaction with ease and access to digital assets. 23 Implement a Digital Repository/ Digital Asset Management Solution Phases 1 2 3 4 5 6 Develop strategy for the use of a digital asset management system Continue policy work Organize the project team Evaluate alternatives and select best technology solution Evaluate alternatives and select Implementation partner Begin implementation December Sept June March 2013 December Sept March December Sept June June 2012 2011 March Initiatives 24 Strategic Opportunity: Implement a Business Intelligence Solution Description of the Opportunity Smith lacks the technology, organizational capacity and management processes to adequately support data driven decision-making. This strategic opportunity will replace the college’s shadow databases and ad-hoc reports with an integrated data warehouse and tool set for analysis. The projects completed will improve data governance, train staff to be better data analysts and through a phased deployment, introduce the technology Smith requires to support operational reporting, longitudinal analysis, predictive modeling and other forms of advanced analytics. Goals • Create dashboard indicators across multiple units to inform decision-making; • Standardize data definitions across applications; • Create standard reporting templates; • Create standards and policies for access and use of data; • Reduce risk of data loss from shadow reporting systems (BAR) that are difficult to support; • Improve strategic outcomes through the advanced use of data to design enrollment management, fundraising and constituent engagement strategies. 25 Implement a Business Intelligence Solution - Key Initiatives 26 Initiative Description Prepare the college for the implementation of a BI Strategy. An overall project sponsor and project manager must be identified to oversee and ensure the success of the implementation. The project sponsor will be accountable for the success of the project, ensure availability of necessary resources, serve as the voice of the project to the college community, and support the project manager. The day-to-day project manager will report directly to the Project Sponsor and will be responsible for the development of detailed project, staffing and communications plans. Additional project resources will be required including technical staff to support the technical architecture/design, infrastructure and performance of the solution, business analysts to assist with data definitions, BI design, etc. Confirm BI phasing strategy for development of data warehouse and migration of BAR reports to Cognos/ODS. IA recommends that Smith pursue the following phasing strategy for implementation of a business intelligence solution: • Phase one: Enrollment Services – (Admissions and Financial Aid); • Phase Two: Registration Outcomes; • Phase Three: Advancement. Before implementing this phasing strategy Smith should confirm the data needs of each area, including an identification of the data elements that require definition. For those units not included in Phase 1 a prioritization should be completed of which BAR reports should be migrated to Cognos/ODS. Implement a Business Intelligence Solution -Key Initiatives 27 Initiative Description Develop common data definitions across the college. To ensure consistency and reliability of data and analyses the college must develop a common set of data definitions. Representatives from key administrative areas should be convened to identify critical data elements and agree on definition of the data, sources for storing and capturing the data and for confidential data ensure agreement on access and use rights. In conjunction with confirming the appropriate phasing strategy, Smith must evaluate whether to implement a custom-developed solution, or implement an off-the-shelf-solution. Armed with a proposed phasing strategy and desired solution, Smith will also be ready to identify implementation partner requirements, prepare and issue an RFP for an implementation partner, and ultimately select a partner. Review and select best technology solution and implementation partner. Hire additional technical staff and analysts. Based on the selected solution Smith must develop a staffing model to support implementation of the solution and long-term maintenance of the solution. Complete first build/ deployment in Enrollment Services. It is expected that the deployment of a BI solution will occur over the next three to five years with the first deployment targeted for completion in 2012. Implement a Business Intelligence Solution – Phasing and Benefits Phasing Strategy It is expected that the deployment of a BI solution will occur over the next three to five years with the first deployment targeted for completion in 2012. However there are a number of initiatives that must be undertaken to prepare the college for the implementation of a solution. These activities include establishing the project team, confirming the phasing strategy for both implementation of the BI solution and for migrating reports to ODS/Cognos and selecting a solution. As illustrated in the Gantt chart on the following page, it is recommended that Smith take the next year to complete these preparatory steps and begin a phased deployment in 2012. It is expected that to complete the deployment of a data warehouse solution will take a minimum of three years. Benefits This strategic opportunity offers Smith the following benefits: • Improved decision-making; • Increased focus on data analysis versus report production; • Ability to analyze strategic data both from a longitudinal perspective within a business unit and to analyze interrelationships between applications (e.g., Admissions and Enrollment); 28 29 Implement a Business Intelligence Solution - Phases 1 2 3 4 Prepare the college for the implementation of a BI Strategy Confirm BI phasing strategy proposed by Incisive Analytics (IA) Develop common data definitions across the college Review and select best technology solution and implementation partner Hire additional technical staff and 5 analysts Complete first build/deployment in 6 Enrollment Services Build out additional phases of the data 7 warehouse December Sept June March 2013 December Sept March December Sept June June 2012 2011 March Initiatives Strategic Opportunity: Enhance the Effectiveness of Administrative Technology Description of the Opportunity Administrative processes do not take full advantage of Banner and other already implemented technologies. Capabilities are under-utilized, available functionality is not completely deployed and processes have not been tailored to take full advantage of software features. Significant complementary software applications do not easily share data with Banner. This strategic opportunity takes a three part approach to enhance Smith’s administrative operations through technology. The first set of initiatives focuses on optimizing the use of Banner. The second better integrates complementary technologies with Banner to create a single institutional data set that will serve as the foundation for business intelligence. The third part extends administrative systems’ capabilities through deployment of additional technologies and a repositioning of the skills within administrative computing. Goals • Improve the efficiency of administrative processes by fully utilizing Banner; • Improve the accuracy of data by automating the migration of data from complementary systems to Banner; • Maximize the return on investment in Banner by fully deploying all modules; • Broaden the utilization of Banner to all administrative, academic and student support areas; and • Address short-comings in Banner capabilities through additional software solutions and Smith developed enhancements. 30 Enhance the Effectiveness of Administrative Technology – Key Initiatives 31 Initiative Description Assess the current utilization of Banner. Continue to engage SunGard Higher Education to review the college’s use of Banner in key administrative areas including Development, Alumnae Affairs, Enrollment services and finance and human resources. Leverage the findings from these reviews to define focused improvement projects to deploy new Banner capabilities, modify business processes or analyze options to fill gaps in Banner capabilities. Implement Banner integration and improvement Projects. Prioritize and implement focused improvement projects after completing baseline assessment of Banner utilization in core areas. In addition, develop interfaces to automate the movement of data from third-party systems to Banner particularly in development and alumnae relations. It may be possible to stagger some implementation work with the on-going baseline assessment. Depending on the number and scale of improvement projects being implemented, the college may require a dedicated project manager and additional SunGard assistance. Clean-up Banner data. Analyze the use of existing Banner data fields and establish college-wide standards for their definition and use. This initiative is critical to improve the use of Banner, to enhance the accuracy of management reports and to prepare for the implementation of a data warehouse. Implementation requires creating standard data definitions, the establishing of on-going data governance process and inspection and adjustment of legacy data to correct for inaccuracies and inconsistencies. Enhance the Effectiveness of Administrative Technology – Key Initiatives 32 Initiative Description Analyze the use of shadow systems across the college. Several areas of the college use shadow databases to store information outside of the Banner system. These databases exist to compensate for shortcomings in Banner capabilities or because the department was unaware that a desired capability exists in Banner. Examples include tracking databases in student affairs and shadow financial records kept by faculty to compensate for difficult to use Banner reports and queries. ITS should work systematically with each division of the college to identify areas where shadow systems are being used in lieu of Banner. Where capabilities exist in Banner to meet the division’s need, the shadow system should be retired and users trained in the Banner capability. If Banner can’t meet the division’s need, efforts should be made to develop or deploy a complementary system to meet the requirement. Strategically reposition the Administrative Computing team in ITS. In the next two to three years, the Banner software will undergo a major technology shift. This shift will require the applications development staff to become more facile with web development tools. At the same time, the college requires the administrative computing team to broaden its skill sets to support the integration and in some cases the maintenance of an increasing number of non-Banner web-based software applications. As part of this strategic opportunity, ITS should develop and implement an organizational development and restructuring strategy for the administrative technology team. Enhance the Effectiveness of Administrative Technology – Key Initiatives 33 Initiative Description Perform a structured assessment of staff members’ technology and analytical skills. Staff technology skills and analytical capabilities vary greatly. As the College upgrades technology in key administrative areas or pursues initiatives to improve the utilization of technology, it must also invest in training and professional development for staff. The business intelligence initiative in particular requires staff to learn new tools, deepen their knowledge of institutional data and develop analytical skills. Formal and information assessment of current and required staff skills should be performed as a routine part of technology deployments and resources invested in training to close significant gaps. Enhance the Effectiveness of Administrative Technology – Phasing and Benefits Phasing Strategy As the timeline on the following page illustrates, the initiatives tied to this strategy may be phased in over three or more years. Depending on the scope of the Banner integration and improvement projects, Smith may elect to stage their implementation over the first 12 to 24 months. The transformation of the administrative computing organization will be phased in over at least two years and require a combination of retraining of existing staff and strategic new hires. Finally, work on the data clean-up should be synchronized with the timeline for business intelligence. Like the Banner improvements, data clean-up work can be staged by data area (e.g., enrollment data). Benefits This strategic opportunity offers Smith the following benefits: • Improved effectiveness and efficiency of administrative processes in strategically important areas; • Improved accuracy of data to support reporting and analysis; • Reduced effort to manage shadow systems and move data between systems; • Delays investment in a replacement system for 5-10 years. 34 35 Enhance the Effectiveness of Administrative Technology – Phasing 1 2 3 Assess the Current Utilization of Banner Implement Banner Improvement Project Banner data clean up Re-position the Administrative Technology 4 Team 5 Analyze the use of shadow systems December Sept June March 2013 December Sept March December Sept June June 2012 2011 March Initiatives Strategic Opportunity: Enhance Web Self-Service 36 Description of the Opportunity Smith delivers many of its services to prospective students, students, faculty and staff via the web. This enables many of these services to be delivered as self-service, eliminating the need to visit an office during normal business hours. This degree of anytime, anywhere selfservice has become a minimum expectation of college constituents. This strategic opportunity extends and expands the college’s web self-services. Initial opportunities to extend self-service include both major support processes such as electronic billing, admission application submission and review, and financial aid award notifications as well as to support minor administrative processes such as conference enrollments for student clubs and organizations. The opportunity includes the exploration of the pros and cons of implementing a portal to help constituents organize web-based services and information. Goals • Enable a steadily increasing number of services to faculty, students and staff to be delivered via web-based self-service. • Selectively complement web-based services with customized mobile applications. • Facilitate greater mobility and extended hours of service through web based self-service. Enhance Web Self-service - Key Initiatives 37 Initiative Description Identify priorities for added web self service This initiative leverages the Banner process and technology assessments referred to in strategic opportunity number 2 to identify an initial set of priorities. Additional priorities should be identified annually by the Committee on Administrative Technology (CAT) through a call for project proposals to administrative areas. This annual effort should be informed by periodic market reviews conducted by ITS to ascertain what new mobile and self-service capabilities are being made available by the college’s software vendors. Extend the capacity to develop web and mobile applications As part of its long-term organizational strategy, ITS will re-align the skills in its administrative computing team to increase its capacity to develop web and mobile applications. This change is necessitated by a shift in Banner technology and the growing need at the college for small web or mobile applications. There is likely to be more demand for web and mobile applications than can be supported by the existing positions in ITS. To expand its capacity, the college will retain relationships with third party development firms that can absorb spikes in workload. Analyze the need for a college portal and develop a strategy for adoption, as appropriate. Many institutions have implemented college-specific portals to organize their on-line services and information for students, faculty and staff. Increasingly, this technology is being eclipsed by mobile applications and technology users’ preference to organize their on-line lives in applications such as Facebook or iGoogle. Currently a portal is considered one mechanism to increase use of Banner, especially by the faculty, and may be considered a bridge strategy to future technology. In this initiative, the college will analyze and determine the the need for a conventional portal solution. Enhance Web Self-service – Phasing and Benefits Phasing Strategy The addition of web and mobile applications to facilitate greater self-service will be a continuous process. Each year, the college’s IT governance groups will solicit and recommend project priorities for ITS and its vendor partners to implement. Likewise, the organizational transformation to deepen ITS capacity to develop web applications will be phased in over the first three years of the IT plan. The assessment of need for a college portal will be undertaken in the second half of the planning horizon. This timing enables resources to remain focused on other priorities and to allow time for further developments in portal technology. Benefits This strategic opportunity offers Smith the following benefits: • Increased student and faculty satisfaction with services; • Increased percentage of services that can be transacted from anywhere and at any time. 38 39 Enhance Web Self-service - Phasing 1 Identify and implement priority selfservice development projects. Extend capacity to develop web and 2 mobile applications Evaluate the need for a traditional 3 portal. December Sept June March 2013 December Sept March December Sept June June 2012 2011 March Initiatives Strategic Opportunity: Improve Constituent Engagement Description of the Opportunity Social networking and similar highly interactive web-based technologies are transforming the way organizations and individuals communicate and collaborate. These technologies present Smith with new methods to connect key constituencies including alumnae, parents, students, Five College students and faculty, and perspective students, to the college and one another. It creates new avenues to bring the digital content and events of the college to these varied constituents. This strategic opportunity creates the capacity to explore and deploy multi-media, social networking and other interactive web technologies to enable constituents to access existing campus resources (e.g., JStor), lectures, short courses, etc. Additionally it considers how CRM* solutions can be used to support more sophisticated communication and outreach to alumni and prospective students. Goals • Create additional expertise in digital media and their potential application. • Leverage the college’s technology infrastructure to make its assets more readily accessible to its constituents. • Implement the use of social media, mobile applications and other forms of interactive, web-based applications in strategic areas such as alumnae relations, development and admissions. 40 Improve Constituent Engagement Key Initiatives Initiative Description Develop a strategy for technology enabled constituent engagement. There are many potential experiments that Smith could undertake using technology to enhance constituent engagement. The college should begin by quickly researching best practices in higher education and other industries. In particular, work going on with social media and multi-media in development and admissions at other institutions can be a source of ideas for similar projects at Smith. Likewise, vendors are designing applications to be used in conjunction with social networking and mobile devices that represent a potential source of innovation for Smith. From this effort, develop a strategy for how to approach constituent engagement and reach agreement on who are the constituents, the criteria to use to prioritize projects and what mechanisms are required to manage electronic outreach. Smith should then identify and prioritize a series of pilot projects and/or full deployments of solutions to enhance engagement. Assess Collegewide staffing requirements to support research, deployment and use of digital media. Digital media (including social media, mobility and interactive web technology) is a growing area of specialization. Professionals with a combination of marketing, technology and project management skills are emerging in organizations to bring new expertise and skills to develop strategies to leverage these technologies. These individuals are skilled at partnering across the organization to identify new opportunities to use technology creatively. Smith has some of these skills resident in multiple organizations. In the future, the College is likely to need additional staff, deeper expertise and enhanced mechanisms to coordinate initiatives among units pursuing digital media initiatives. 41 Improve Constituent Engagement Key Initiatives Initiative Description Implement technologies to enhance engagement The implementation of new technologies to enhance constituent engagement will likely take many forms. Some may require the development of new applications. Others may be accomplished through partnership with third parties and still others may be accomplished through new uses of existing technologies (e.g., Facebook). As such, the college will have opportunities to pursue multiple smaller projects rather than a single, large implementation. Deploy a CRM* solution Constituent relationship management software working in tandem with Banner and the college’s future business intelligence solution enables more sophisticated outreach and communication. This initiative includes developing a conceptual design for how Smith would utilize CRM capabilities, developing a definition of functional requirements, selecting a technology and executing its implementation. CRM may be an area for future Five College collaboration to economize on the costs of acquiring and operating the technology. * CRM solutions include software tools for customer relationship management that enable an organization to manage interactions with current and prospective students, alumnae, donors, etc. 42 Improve Constituent Engagement – Phasing and Benefits Phasing Strategy Smith will likely pursue elements of this strategic opportunity every year for the life of this IT plan. In the plan’s first year, the focus should be on making a strategic hire with expertise in digital media, researching best practices and devising a tactical plan for particular constituent engagement projects. Starting in year 2, the college will begin to complete discrete projects to deploy or utilize, mobile, social networking and other technologies. In the final two to three years of the plan, the college can plan and deploy a CRM solution. Benefits This strategic opportunity offers Smith the following benefits: • Improved constituent satisfaction with the college; • Increased penetration of college communications to their desired audience; • Increased stakeholder participation in college events, activities and initiatives; and • Increased revenue from new channels for donor outreach and engagement. 43 44 Improve Constituent Engagement Phasing Develop tactical plan for constituent engagement 1 Assess College-wide staffing requirements 2 for digital media initiatives Deploy technologies to enhance engagement 3 4 Plan and deploy a CRM solution December Sept March December Sept June March June 2013 2012 December Sept June 2011 March Initiatives Strategic Opportunity: Support Five College Academic Collaborations Description of the Opportunity The college’s strategic plan anticipates expanded academic collaborations among the Five Colleges. In the next five years, Smith is likely to engage with other Five College institutions to share faculty appointments and courses. Greater academic collaboration will increase the number of students and faculty who require physical and virtual access to the resources of each of the Five Colleges. This strategic opportunity outlines several collaborative initiatives that Smith should champion to use technology to make the student and faculty experience seamless across the Five Colleges. Unlike the other strategies in this plan, Smith can’t execute these initiatives without the support and resources of the other four institutions and Five Colleges, Inc. These are areas in which it is in Smith’s interest to take a leadership role within the Five Colleges including providing staff, financial support and a willingness to compromise on technology and process design decisions in support of its larger strategic objectives. Additionally it is expected that the Five Colleges will contribute to scanning the environment for new technologies and identifying their potential applications. Goals • Make it easier for faculty and students to access resources throughout the Five Colleges. • Position Smith technology to support Five College initiatives to share faculty appointments and courses. • Reduce the time and effort required for a student to gain access to the electronic and place based resources of Smith. • Make it easier for students to discover opportunities to take courses across the Five Colleges and to register for the courses that they select. 45 Support Five College Academic Collaborations - Key Initiatives 46 Initiative Description Upgrade identity and access management capabilities. Identity management is the technology and associated processes that Smith uses to define, provide and rescind access to its technology and digital resources to members of the Smith community, visitors, guests and other stakeholders. It is also the means through which Smith students and faculty can gain access to the resources of other institutions without requiring separate log ins or passwords (federated identity management). This initiative expands existing identity management solutions to create a mature set of provisioning processes and the ability to offer single sign on to Smith technologies. It supports the completion of the pilot phase (already underway) and the full scale implementation of federated identity management within the Five Colleges. Support Five College efforts to facilitate course registration. While some improvements have been made to aid students’ ability to find and register for courses across the Five Colleges, greater integration of information and processes are possible. Smith will play a leading role in Five College efforts to harmonize registration processes and policies and use technology to make it easier for students to select courses offered on-line or at another college. Support Five College Academic Collaborations - Key Initiatives 47 Initiative Description Improve student technology support processes. As the movement of students among the Five Colleges increases, the need to coordinate technology support services will also increase. Smith should continue to work with the IT organizations at the four other institutions to provide reciprocal access to help desk and walk-in center services. Where possible the Five Colleges should standardize technologies in use by students, and implement practices that enable support to be delivered at a distance. Assess and deploy an Interoperable One Card Solution (Two phases: software now, hardware later). Greater interoperability of one card technology would make it easier for students and faculty to access buildings and services at each of the Five Colleges. However, one card technologies are not currently compatible across card reader solutions. Smith should continue to engage with the Five College’s to assess opportunities either to make their respective one-card solutions more interoperable or plan a migration to a common one-card solution as card reader hardware nears the end of life. In addition, Smith should work collaboratively with the Five Colleges to analyze the processes by which cards are provided to students taking courses away from their home campus to reduce the time required to obtain building access. Migrate to a Common Learning Management System (LMS). As the number of cross registrations and shared courses among the Five Colleges increases, the fact that institutions maintain multiple learning management systems will become increasingly inefficient and cumbersome. Smith should provide leadership within the Five Colleges to move to a single, shared LMS for all in-person, on-line and hybrid courses. Migration to a new LMS must be in alignment with ramp up of new online/hybrid courses. Support Five College Academic Collaborations – Phasing and Benefits Phasing Strategy The pace at which Smith pursues these initiatives will be dependent on the interests and priorities of the other Five Colleges. Momentum is already building for improved, federated identity management. Completing this initiative should be a top priority. Work to streamline processes, policies and technology to facilitate student registrations should also receive early attention. More costly and complex changes such as a common one card and learning management system should be phased in when readiness is higher and the need for such solutions is dictated by the academic strategies of the Five Colleges. Benefits This strategic opportunity offers Smith the following benefits: • Increased student and faculty satisfaction with services across the Five Colleges; • Increased numbers of students cross-registering for courses; and • Reduced elapsed time to receive access to campus services for students and faculty from other colleges. 48 49 Support Five College Academic Collaborations - Phasing Upgrade identity and resource access 1 management Support Five College efforts to improve course registration 2 Improve student technology support processes 3 Assess and deploy an interoperable one card solution (Software now, hardware 4 later) Migrate to a common learning management system 5 December Sept June March 2013 December Sept March December Sept June June 2012 2011 March Initiatives Strategic Opportunity: Enhance Faculty, Student and Staff Mobility Description of the Opportunity Smith faculty and students are increasingly mobile on and off-campus (including Five Colleges). Providing students, faculty and staff the ability to work effectively at anytime and from anywhere is becoming a baseline expectation of the campus community. This initiative deploys the technologies and support services required by a mobile population. The position of a digital media specialist will assist in supporting the increased demand for web and mobile applications. Goals • Enable staff, students and faculty to work anytime, anywhere with whomever they want in a secure environment; • Provide self-service and after hours technology support; • Provide capacity to develop and deploy mobile applications. 50 Enhance Faculty, Student and Staff Mobility - Key Initiatives 51 Initiative Description Plan and finance a regular renewal and replacement program for the campus wired and wireless networks. An upgrade to the wireless network was recently completed and will not need replacement for some time, However, aspects of the wired network need upgrading. The college should anticipate that both will require additional investment in capacity and redundancy as network utilization and importance grow. Smith should be proactive in development a financial plan for how and when it will fund future upgrades to its network. The plan should include financial support for investments not only in new hardware but possibly upgrades in client devices, network infrastructure, updated management tools, and training. Pilot and if successful implement virtual student labs and virtual desktops. Recently Smith agreed to jointly test and evaluate a proof-of-concept model for a shared virtual computing laboratory through the Collaborative Virtual Computing Laboratory (LabSTOR*)—led by Allegheny college, Harvey Mudd college, Middlebury college, and Occidental college. Participation in this pilot will enable IT staff to develop experience with virtual labs and determine whether the solution or an alternative should be deployed on campus. Smith should remain focused on experimenting with the virtual labs with the goal of exploring virtual desktops in the next 12-18 months. * LabSTOR is a collaborative project focused on building a shared virtual computing laboratory that allows member campuses to make software applications remotely available to their students and faculty. The project seeks to reduce the need to invest in departmental computing infrastructure, and also intends to help reduce costs in configuring and maintaining complex software images for installation in departmental computing labs. Enhance Faculty, Student and Staff Mobility - Key Initiatives 52 Initiative Description Implement tools (knowledge bases, remote desktop management) to improve selfservice and expand after hours support services. Currently the ITS website contains some information on how end-users can trouble shoot problems. The current support model is primarily a dispatch service requiring personal interaction. Tools are available to increase the extent to which end users can self-support and trouble shoot their questions. Such self-service tools are particularly valuable in off peak hours. Smith should evaluate the existing toolset and identify the best opportunities to implement more self-service/remote service. Implementation of new tools will require staff training and resetting enduser expectations for which issues they are capable of trouble-shooting and solving versus those which require Help Desk support. Enhance Faculty, Student and Staff Mobility - Key Initiatives 53 Initiative Description Develop a mobile applications strategy. The world of technology has shifted from a wired, desktop based environment to one that is increasingly mobile and wireless. As such institutions are defining new ways to interact with alumnae, prospective students, current students, donors, etc. Smith should be proactive and develop a mobile strategy that includes developing an understanding of end-user needs, creating potential use cases (or finding existing applications), and defining the platform that will best suit end-users and is in alignment with its technical architecture. Some questions to consider in the development of a mobile strategy include: • What are the needs of the mobile student, faculty and staff? • What mobile devices will you support? • How will you prioritize which mobile projects you undertake? • How will you track and manage changing technologies? The work of students and faculty is becoming more collaborative. As the need for collaboration increases, a concomitant investment is necessary in collaboration tools to support the endeavors of faculty and students. Collaboration tools (virtual desktop, file sharing, video sharing, etc) are required to help participants keep up with an array of people, tasks, documents, and deadlines. ETS, in conjunction with a handful of progressive faculty and students, should work together to identify, test and implement a suite of collaboration tools that will be supported by the college versus those that end-users will self-select and support. Implement expanded suite of collaboration tools for faculty, students and staff. Enhance Faculty, Student and Staff Mobility – Phasing and Benefits Phasing Strategy The implementation of mobile applications will be a continuous process. With the recent upgrades to the network infrastructure Smith should first focus on how best to leverage existing and emerging tools to take advantage of the wireless capabilities. Skills and experience developed through the use of new tools and through participation in the LabSTOR can later be applied to the development of a more comprehensive mobile strategy for the college. Benefits This strategic opportunity offers Smith the following benefits: • Confidence that Smith will keep pace with changes in networking technology; • Availability of technologies that enable students, faculty and staff to securely access their data and software applications via the internet; • Access to self-service and after hours technology support; • Increased productivity through improved ability to collaborate with classmates and colleagues. 54 55 Enhance Faculty, Student and Staff Mobility – Phases Plan and finance a regular renewal and replacement program for the campus 1 wired and wireless networks. Pilot and if successful implement virtual 2 student labs and virtual desktops. Implement tools to improve self-service and remote support and expand after 3 hours support services. Develop a mobile applications strategy. 4 Implement expanded suite of collaboration tools for faculty, students 5 and staff. December Sept June March 2013 December Sept March December Sept June June 2012 2011 March Initiatives Strategic Opportunity: Source Technology to Collaborations and the Cloud 56 Description of the Opportunity The alternatives to self-operating technologies and support services are growing more numerous and mature. Smith is already engaged in some IT collaborations within the Five Colleges. In addition, the college has turned to third parties to host some applications such as the content management system. This strategic opportunity positions Smith to source more technologies to commercial providers and other higher education collaborations. It enables Smith to systematically review and determine the optimal sourcing strategy for each major technology and support service. It lays the technical and policy groundwork to expand use of cloud computing. Technologically it relies on initiatives highlighted in other strategic opportunities including the continued upgrading of the wired and wireless network and identity management. It also includes initiatives to mature the organization’s capability to evaluate, select and manage more varied sourcing strategies. Goals • Establish repeatable, objective processes to weigh the pros and cons of cloud and collaborative services. • Reduce the cost of providing commodity technologies. • Improve the ability to prevent and recover from departmental disasters by sourcing technologies to third parties. • Gain access to new skill sets and speed the adoption of new technology. Source Technologies to Collaborations and the Cloud - Key Initiatives 57 Initiative Description Identify cloud and collaboration opportunities ITS will annually review with TSC a list of candidate technologies and services that have the potential to be sourced to the cloud or collaborations. The list will be developed using a number of criteria including the cost and performance of the existing service, the availability of alternative solutions and the risk of switching. From this list, the TSC will work with ITS to identify one or more opportunities that warrant deeper analysis and/or pilot implementations. Based on the experience of other institutions and corporations, the initial candidate services for cloud or collaborations should include email, calendar, personal productivity applications, file storage, desktop back-up and help desk services (especially after hours). ITS should continue to regularly scan the marketplace and monitor higher education’s experience with the cloud to augment this list. Prepare policies and procurement practices for cloud and collaborations The college will undertake a focused initiative to review its information security, procurement and contracting polices and processes to align them with the specialized issues and risks inherent in moving data and technology services to third parties. Policies should be developed to guide how and when individual departments, faculty or staff can elect to use a cloud service. ITS should begin to develop a more detailed understanding of the cost of providing its major services as a basis of comparison to cloud and collaborative solutions. Finally, standard evaluation check-lists should be developed to guide analysis of the pros and cons of cloud and collaborative solutions. ITS and purchasing should work jointly to develop skills in negotiating and managing cloud based vendors. Source Technologies to Collaborations and the Cloud - Key Initiatives 58 Initiative Description Sustain the technology infrastructure to facilitate cloud and collaborative solutions. Smith’s first priority should be to continue to invest in the reliability, availability and performance of its wired and wireless network. The robustness and reliability of the network is essential to many strategic opportunities including cloud services. Likewise, the college will require a strong set of identity management policies and technologies to manage access to cloud, collaborative and on-campus services. Source Technologies to the Cloud and Collaborations – Phasing and Benefits Phasing Strategy Work will begin with an initial set of activities to assess current cloud sourcing options and develop the policy and procurement infrastructure to support cloud and collaboration sourcing. Once this initial assessment is complete, the college will likely be evaluating cloud and collaborative opportunities as part of every technology sourcing and adoption decision. Benefits This strategic opportunity offers Smith the following benefits: • Reduce cost of deploying or sustaining technologies or services. • Increased capacity to deploy new technologies. • Greater ability to focus college resources on strategic services. 59 60 Source Technologies to the Cloud and Collaborations – Phasing Identify cloud and collaboration 1 opportunities Prepare policies and procurement practices for collaborations and cloud sourcing 2 Sustain required network and identity management infrastructure (on-going) 3 December Sept June March 2013 December Sept March December Sept June June 2012 2011 March Initiatives Strategic Opportunity: Maintain a reliable IT infrastructure and Improve Capacity to Prevent or Recover from Disaster Description of the Opportunity This initiative commits the College to annually assess the condition of its infrastructure and make investments to enable its on-going renewal and replacement. A reliable infrastructure with sufficient capacity to meet current and future demands is foundational to all of Smith’s strategic technology opportunities. It is critical that Smith maintain a network with adequate capacity and redundancy to provide access to critical technologies on and off campus. Computing hardware and software must be kept up to date and continue to be replaced at regular intervals. Major Smith technologies are vulnerable to prolonged (hours or days) outages in the event of a disaster in the primary data center. In addition, the college faces increasingly complex information security threats. This initiative expands formal disaster recovery planning and implements strategies to reduce the time required to recover from disaster. It also expands current information security capabilities and practices which will become important as Smith adopts more web and mobile technologies. Goals • Create greater capability to continue operations in the event of a disaster that limits access to the physical campus; • Provide back-up of information and documents if the original is destroyed; • Reduce risk of prolonged system outages; • Provide dedicated expertise to assess and manage information security risk. 61 Improve Capacity to Prevent or Recover from Disaster - Key Initiatives 62 Initiative Description Regularly renew and replace the core infrastructure Update Business Continuity/ Disaster Recovery Plan. Develop multi-year plans to invest in the maintenance and modernization of the campus network, server, desktop and classroom hardware and the data center infrastructure. Annually assess the state of the infrastructure and adjust plans as necessary. The current business continuity plan is outdated. Smith must undergo a process to evaluate what level of risk is acceptable if a serious incident occurs which prevents the college from continuing normal operations any day at any time. Such an event may be the result of flood, explosion, computer malfunction, accident, grievous act, etc. To refresh the existing plan an inventory of major systems should be completed and a determination made of the required recovery times for each in the event of a disaster. Develop a plan for securing new data center space in collaboration with another institution or a public or private cloud. In the short-term Smith should focus on how it can extend the life of the existing data center rather than building a new data center on campus. To create improved capacity to recover from a loss of the primary data center and relieve some of the demand for power, cooling and space, Smith should evaluate options for moving critical systems such as Email and Moodle to the cloud. In the long term, and with an understanding of specific data center requirements, Smith should evaluate a broader set of options for transitioning of servers, applications, etc to: 1) An outsourced vendor; 2) Public or private cloud service; 3) Five College Collaboration; or 4) Another institution. Improve Capacity to Prevent or Recover from Disaster - Key Initiatives 63 Initiative Description Create a dedicated position for information security (could be a shared position within the Five Colleges) focused on security policy, risk assessment, communications and training and monitoring developments in technology and regulations. The information security officer typically resides in the IT organization and usually possesses technology expertise, emphasis tends to be placed on the technological interventions that can help improve computer and network security. However the scope of responsibilities is much larger and includes security strategy, policy development and enforcement. A sample of the scope of responsibilities of a security officer includes: • • • • • • • • Develop, implement, and maintain a comprehensive written “information security program”; Develop a culture of security-awareness for students, faculty, and staff including the delivery of training sessions; Perform risk assessments that identify and locate information assets vulnerabilities; Update information security policies and procedures; Implement security technologies designed to prevent, detect, and deter security incidents; Coordinate with other IT staff in the areas of user identification and authentication, user account management, user privileges, configuration management, event and activity logging and monitoring, and other technical best practices; Coordinate with process owners for business continuity planning and disaster recovery; Work with the college’s data stewards to establish appropriate safeguards, etc. Smith should evaluate the depth of its needs in information security and determine whether this individual could be a shared resource for the Five College Collaboration. Improve Capacity to Prevent or Recover from Disaster – Phasing and Benefits Phasing Strategy This strategic opportunity requires immediate attention and resources should be devoted to these three initiatives as soon as possible. As illustrated on the following page it is expected that in the next nine months these three activities can be completed with the right attention and resource. Benefits This strategic opportunity offers Smith the following benefits: • Reduced risk to business operations in the event of a prolonged system outage; • Guaranteed availability of stand-by systems; • Improved information security including awareness by the Smith community of their responsibility for information security in terms of technology applications, physical paper and digital assets. 64 65 Improve Capacity to Prevent or Recover from Disaster - Phases 1 2 Regularly renew and replace the core infrastructure Update Business Continuity/Disaster Recovery Plan Develop a plan for securing new data center space in collaboration with another institution or a public or private 3 cloud. Create a dedicated position for information security (could be a shared 4 position within the Five Colleges) On-going December Sept June March 2013 December Sept March December Sept June June 2012 2011 March Initiatives 66 IT Governance 67 Introduction Effective IT governance is critical to the implementation of the college’s IT plan. IT governance is needed to monitor and adjust strategies, establish annual priorities, lead efforts to change culture and practice in concert with technology change, and spur continuous exploration of new developments in technology. There are a relatively small number of options for structuring IT governance. Smith already has the structural elements (ITCC, CET, Banner Committee) common to most institutions’ IT governance. However, the roles of existing groups need to be clarified, groups’ memberships adjusted and committees’ activity intensified. In addition, Smith should complement its core IT governance committees with groups organized to lead particular initiatives or bring together communities of technology stakeholders. 68 Components of IT Governance We recommend Smith convene three core IT governance committees*. These committees will be complemented by ad-hoc project teams and informal communities of interest. Core IT Governance Committees – The focal point for IT governance will be the Technology Steering Committee; supported by two subcommittees: 1) Committee on Educational Technology; and 2) Committee on Administrative Technology. These committees will recommend or establish IT priorities, monitor the implementation of the strategic plan and provide sponsorship for major technology initiatives. Initiative Teams – Ad-hoc groups will be appointed to sponsor, coordinate or support discrete projects or initiatives. Their membership, charge and duration is determined on a case by case basis. Initiative teams are accountable to one or more core committees. Communities of Interest – Communities of Interest will be regular, informal gatherings of IT and non-IT professionals, faculty and students with an interest in a particular technology or technology topic. Communities are sounding boards for IT decisions, may identify new technology opportunities and share best practices. *Committees represent all aspects of Smith including the Alumnae Association. 69 Components of IT Governance Provide input and ideas Technology Steering Committee Committee on Educational Technology Initiative Team: Digital Repository Committee on Administrative Technology Initiative Team: Business Intelligence Align IT with Institutional Priorities Communities of Interest: Data Analysts Communities of Interest: Technology Innovations Coordinate IT & Process Change Communities of Interest: Technology Providers Provide input and ideas Governance Advisory 70 Core IT Governance Committees IT governance will be carried out by three standing committees. Responsibilities of each committee are introduced below and further described in the pages that follow. Technology Steering (TSC) • Focus on all areas of technology; • Oversee implementation of the IT plan; • Recommend annual investment priorities, policies and changes to IT services to Senior Administrators and the Committee on Mission and Priorities. Committee on Educational Technology (CET) • Focus on technology related to teaching, learning, and research; • Align educational technology strategy with effective pedagogy, faculty interest and student expectations; • Recommend priorities for investment; • Sponsor initiatives to expand the use of technology in education. Committee on Administrative Technology (CAT) • Focus on technology related to administrative services, campus operations and the effective use of data to support decisionmaking; • Recommend priorities for investment and identify opportunities for collaboration across administrative areas; • Sponsor initiatives to improve efficiency and effectiveness through the use of technology. • Solicit appropriate input from faculty regarding their administrative technology requirements. Technology Steering Committee (TSC) 71 The TSC guides and advises senior-level IT decision-making at the college. In collaboration with the Executive Director of ITS it recommends IT priorities, policies and strategies to the college’s executive leadership (Senior Administrators) and the Committee on Mission and Priorities. The TSC is co-chaired by the Provost and Dean of the Faculty and the Vice President for Finance and Administration. The Executive Director for Information Technology supports the co-chairs in the development of meeting agendas and analyses to frame committee discussions and decisions. The co-chairs appoint the members of the committee in consultation with the Executive Director for Information Technology. TSC members should include all of the current members of ITCC. In addition, the Committee should include two additional faculty representatives and the Dean of Students or her designee. The chairs of the committees on Educational Technology and Administrative Technology are standing members of the TSC. 72 Technology Steering Committee (TSC) Charge Technology Steering Committee • Senior governance group for technology; • Co-chaired by the Provost and the VP for Finance and Administration; • Meets at least quarterly. • Recommend annual technology investment priorities. • Monitor and modify the IT strategic plan (annually). • Evaluate and recommend changes to IT policies. • With sub-committees, solicit and prioritize project proposals for new innovations or uses of educational or administrative technology (annually). • Review and recommend significant changes to IT service levels. • Monitor the balance of central and departmental responsibilities for technology. • Work in conjunction with ITS to sustain the required capacity, security and recoverability of the college’s technology infrastructure. • Review and recommend the retirement of technologies and services. • Review analyses and recommend Five College IT collaborations (as needed). • Review analyses and recommend decisions to source IT services to the cloud or collaborations. Committee on Educational Technology (CET) The Committee on Educational Technology advises the Technology Steering Committee and ITS on policies, strategies and services related to the effective use of technology in teaching, learning and research. The members of the CET should be appointed by the Provost in consultation with Faculty Council and the Director for Educational Technology. Its members should include faculty representatives from each of the three academic divisions, the directors of CATS, the Library and the Sherrerd Center. Membership will have routine consultation with the Centers for Global Studies, Environment, Ecological Design and Sustainability, and Community Collaborations. CET should be co-chaired by the Director of Educational Technology and a faculty member appointed by the Provost, in consultation with Faculty Council. 73 74 Committee on Educational Technology Committee on Educational Technology • Primary advisory body for educational technology. • Co-chaired by the Director of Educational Technology and an appointed faculty member; • Meets at least twice a semester. Charge • Recommend annual investment priorities to further the effective use of educational technologies. • Allocate annual innovation grants to faculty to explore new technologies or new applications of educational technologies. • Sponsor a bi-annual series of faculty demonstrations of uses of educational technologies. • Monitor and recommend strategies to sustain the technology in classroom and non-classroom based learning spaces. • Request and review the results of analyses of outcomes associated with particular learning technologies (as-needed). • Advise ITS on changes to technologies or services that impact teaching, learning and research. Committee on Administrative Technology (CAT) CAT is the college’s primary advisory committee for the application of technology to improve (and support) campus services, operations, management and data driven decision-making. CAT serves as the senior governance committee for cross-organizational administrative technologies (e.g., Banner and business intelligence). In this role, CAT will make appropriate recommendations to the Technology Steering Committee regarding changes in policy, annual project priorities, changes in service, and other issues that will have enterprise-wide impact. CAT’s members will be appointed by the Vice President for Finance and Administration in consultation with Senior Administrators, the Executive Director for ITS and the Director for Administrative Technology. CAT will be co-chaired by the Director for Administrative Technology and an administrative leader appointed by the Provost and VP for Finance and Administration. 75 Committee on Administrative Technology Committee on Administrative Technology • Primary advisory committee for information technology. • Co-chaired by the Director of Administrative Technology and the appointed administrative leader; • Meets at least 6 times per year. 76 Charge • Recommend annual investment priorities. • Prioritize and award annual innovation grants for the use of technology to improve administrative services. • Coordinate the management of enterprise administrative applications. • Prioritize Banner and non-Banner ITS development projects. • Resolve cross-module and crossorganizational issues that impact the use of enterprise applications including data definitions. • Provide executive sponsorship for initiatives to encourage the adoption of new and existing technologies, to revise business processes to leverage technology and to measure process improvements. • Recommend policy changes that impact the use of administrative technologies. • Identify emerging needs or potential applications of new technology that are shared across the college. 77 Initiative Teams Initiative teams are formed to provide coordination and sponsorship for complex technology implementations with broad college impact. They support implementation project teams or IT staff charged with implementing a particular technology. They provide project-based governance, formulate process and policy changes related to a complex technology deployment and provide a forum for significant operational decisions that affect multiple areas of the college. Initiative teams are appointed by the co-chairs of the Technology Steering Committee and the Executive Director of ITS. Initiative teams exist for a finite duration and are provided with a unique charge and scope of authority. 78 Initiative Teams To support the immediate project priorities in the strategic plan, Smith should continue the work of the BI steering committee as its first initiative team. In the future, Smith will form initiative teams for additional strategic opportunities such as digital repository design and implementation and constituent engagement related projects such as the deployment of a constituent relationship management solution. Charge for BI Initiative Team • Finalize technology strategy to support BI initiative (build vs. buy). Business Intelligence Initiative Team • Recommend a consulting firm to partner with Smith to implement BI. • Coordinate efforts to clean up legacy data and convert existing reports (with sponsorship from CAT). • Approve proposed revisions to data definitions (with support as needed from CAT). • Resolve issues as requested by day to day project leaders. • Monitor implementation progress. 79 Communities of Interest Communities of interest complement core governance committees and initiativespecific teams by bringing together stakeholders with common interests in particular areas or uses of technology. Communities of interests share best practices within the institution, build technology skills and competencies among staff with similar roles, help design improvements to technologies and services and look over the horizon to monitor emerging needs and technology innovations. Communities of interest will be created and hosted by ITS in consultation with the Technology Steering Committee. The composition of committees, meeting frequency and method of communication (on-line, in-person) will vary. 80 Communities of Interest To support the implementation of the strategic plan, three communities of interest should be established (table below). The Executive Director of ITS will conduct an annual review of the communities and report to the Technology Steering committee which communities will continue, which will be retired and which new ones formed. Community Focus Data Analysts • Share information about the BI implementation. • Receive training on analytical tools and techniques. • Discuss challenges and opportunities to implement data driven decision-making. Technology Innovations • Cross-organizational group of faculty, students and staff to discuss the implications of new technologies for the college. Technology Providers • ITS and non-ITS staff who support users of technology to discuss challenges, best practices and continuous improvements of IT support services. 81 Organizational Implications This section describes the the experiences and skill sets required in ITS and departmental IT groups to implement the strategic initiatives. 82 Organizational Implications To achieve its IT vision, Smith requires the efforts of its own faculty and staff in combination with outsourced service providers, Five College collaborations for staff and services, project-based consultants and contract employees. This mix of internal and external resources provides the greatest breadth of skills and the maximum organizational agility. To optimize the productivity of its own IT staff, Smith must manage its college-wide IT resources holistically. Achieving the IT strategy requires Smith: 1. To invest in new positions and competencies inside and out of ITS; and 2. To clarify the division of responsibilities between ITS and departmental IT staff and re-position ITS units to support new technologies and services, as appropriate. This section summarizes the new positions, opportunities for re-positioning the skills and focus of existing positions and a framework for balancing ITS and departmental IT staff responsibilities. Investments in New Positions and Competencies 83 The plan challenges ITS to significantly re-orient its skills and services. As services are sourced externally the College will require fewer positions focused on operating technology. At the same time, the plan calls for the addition of new consultative skill sets and positions to support the improved use of technology in instruction and operations. College-wide, Smith needs to clarify and pro-actively manage the division of responsibilities between ITS and departmental technology staff. Departments such as the Science Center continue to require dedicated staff to support unique technologies. Administrative departments require business analysts with technology skills to help configure Banner and other administrative technologies to work in concert with business processes. Departments also require access to staff with the skills to build ad-hoc reports and queries to leverage the new business intelligence infrastructure. As services and technologies evolve, college leaders need to continue to work collaboratively to manage the focus of departmental staff and avoid duplicating services that are or should be offered by ITS. The table on the following page summarizes the projected new positions and the strategic opportunities they support. Not all positions are required immediately. The priorities for investment in new staff and the timing of new hires follows the overall timeline for implementing the IT plan. Investments in New Positions and Competencies 84 Position Strategic Opportunity Comments Business Analytics* Lead (1 position) • Business Intelligence and Data Warehousing • Likely position within Institutional Research Data warehouse technical team (2 to 3 positions) • Business Intelligence and Data Warehousing • Includes data architect, cube/report development expert and technical position to extract and load data into warehouse. Digital Media Specialist (1 position) • Improve constituent engagement • Enhance student, faculty and staff mobility • Enhance effectiveness of administrative technologies • Additional expertise in web, social media and mobile applications. • Position will focus on identifying opportunities to apply these technologies at Smith, scan for new technologies and coordinate projects to deploy digital media. • Position could report jointly to ITS and Communications and External Relations or Development. • Excludes any additional positions required to expand Institutional Research services or back-fill the time of the Director to support business intelligence implementation. Investments in New Positions and Competencies 85 Position Strategic Opportunity Comments Instructional Designers (1-3 positions) • Enhance and expand the use of educational technology • Additional positions create the ability to provide more one on one consultation with faculty, support increased use of video and other media in coursework and prepare hybrid and on-line courses for Five College collaborations. Information Security (1 position) • Enhance ability to prevent and recover from disaster and manage information security risks. • Complexities of information security increasingly require a dedicated resource. • Potential to share position with Five Colleges. Project Management (1-2 positions) • Adoption of standard project management methodology and tools; • Improved ability to manage project deadlines and risk • Efficient allocation of resources to projects • Will need project management to manage the implementation of the strategic plan as well as to lead implementation of several of the initiatives; • Depending on the resource requirements and phasing strategies for each initiative an experienced project manager can manage multiple projects at a time. Additional Implications of Strategy for ITS Services 86 The administrative computing group will need to further restructure and expand its skills and services. The group needs the capacity to extend its focus beyond Banner to include the integration, and at times, the operation and maintenance of other commercial software applications. Application developers will require more web and mobile application development skills to support the coming technology change in Banner and to meet expanded college demand for web applications. Administrative computing needs additional analyst capacity to work collaboratively with departments to analyze processes, define technology requirements, and select the best technology solution. ITS also requires an expanded project management capacity. The strategic plan calls for multiple, complex technology and process change projects. Often, there will be multiple significant projects taking place at the same time. Managing these projects requires more standard project management methods and dedicated project management staff. Additional Implications of Strategy for ITS Services ITS also requires an expanded project management capacity. (cont’d) ITS should establish a project management office (PMO). The PMO would select and train staff in a standard project management methodology and provide project management services to projects of moderate to large scale. The size of the PMO can begin with one staff member supplemented by consultants as needed. Building PMO capacity is also an area for potential Five College collaboration and inquiries should be made to ascertain if Smith could share this capability with one or more of the other colleges. Finally, incorporating remote diagnostic and repair tools, knowledge bases and selfhelp mechanisms into IT support would free-up some staff capacity. This capacity could be utilized to expand technology support for events, create additional project capacity and potentially support other new services. 87 Implications of Strategy on Departmental IT Staffing Smith will continue to require staff with technology skills outside of the ITS organization. CATS should continue to support specialized technologies used by Science Center faculty. ITS should continue to provide and support the common (college-wide) technologies used by Science faculty and staff. Administrative areas with extensive data analytical requirements such as Development and Alumnae Relations, Dean of the Faculty and the Dean of the college should have analyst staff to develop ad-hoc reports and analyses. Administrative areas with shared responsibility (with ITS) for enterprise systems (e.g., Moodle, Banner) will require business analysts with IT skills to help manage the configuration of these systems and to facilitate the alignment of business processes with system functionality. In some cases, these staff will also have report writing and analytical responsibilities. Offices requiring business analysts include Dean of the college, Finance and Administration, Development and Alumnae Relations, and College Relations. 88 89 Clarify IT Roles and Responsibilities Departmental IT staff should be additive, not duplicative of ITS services. Administrative areas and the Science Center need to work with ITS annually to review the division of responsibilities and confirm that central services continue to meet departmental needs. This process should be overseen by the Technology Steering Committee. As departmental IT groups pilot new services that demonstrate benefit for the entire college, support for the solution should be migrated to ITS. The tables on the following pages presents a model for assigning responsibility for major technology functions. 90 Clarify IT Roles and Responsibilities Technology/ Service General IT Support ITS Departmental Analysts or IT Support Staff Technology Users • Support all commonly used technologies (e.g., network, email, computers (hardware and common software like Office) and servers. • Support unique/highly specialized software applications used by a single area of the college. • Leverage self-help tools to troubleshoot problems. • Provide data storage, back-up services. • Support unique hardware used by a single area of the college. • Manage relationships with third party providers of infrastructure and software. • Maintain or source hardware • Develop ad-hoc and that stores data and provides standard queries and analytical tools. reports in the analyst’s area of data expertise. • Create and maintain programs Analysis & Reporting and interfaces to move data into reporting warehouses. • Define technical requirements for tools. • Provide help desk services. • Develop complex reports. • Define functional requirements for analytical tools. • Maintain data definitions. • Support functional leaders in • Define business logic – the development of the rules for what data is business logic that defines moved into the which fields are included in warehouse. a report or analysis. • Perform simple queries. • Perform analysis. 91 Clarify IT Roles and Responsibilities Technology/ Service ITS Departmental Analysts or IT Support Staff Technology Users • Implement patches and upgrades. • Manage application setup and configuration. • Define business processes and policies. • Triage support questions – • Research new help desk. functionality in existing applications. • Develop and maintain interfaces. • Develop and maintain modifications and complementary applications (including mobile applications). Application Development and • Support/participate in Support research of new technology. • Manage vendor relationships – report problems, coordinate troubleshooting of issues. • Track vendor technical direction and alert functional areas to new possibilities. • Research new technologies and emerging solutions. • Support troubleshooting – respond to application questions submitted to the ITS help desk. • Work with ITS and vendors to help troubleshoot software issues. • Test new functionality and changes to systems. • Develop functional requirements for new capabilities. • Participate in testing and troubleshooting. 92 Clarify IT Roles and Responsibilities Technology/ Service ITS Departmental Analysts or IT Support Staff Technology Users College Relations Web Site Management • Provide or arrange for the infrastructure to support the college websites. • Define technical requirements for web content management tools. • Sometimes make the content updates. • Provide material for content updates. • Sometimes make the content updates. • Define the look and feel of web site. • Maintain templates for web sites. • Establish processes for updating content. 93 Financial Implications 94 Overview These strategies require Smith to substantially increase its investment in technology. Smith currently allocates approximately 4.2% of its total operating budget to technology. In FY11, the core ITS base budget was $7,169, 848 or 3.8% of the college’s total operating budget. Including CATS and departmental purchases, the college allocated approximately 4.2% of its total operating budget to technology. High-level estimates suggest that Smith may need to increase its annual operating expenditures for technology by more than 50% over five years to support new technologies and approximately 8 to 10 additional staff. In addition, the college should expect one-time expenditures of a similar magnitude. While some redistribution of resources is possible, most of this requires new investment. 95 Financial Estimates – Incremental Investments Item 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Total Staffing $305,900 $756,344 $1,008,535 $1,059,637 $1,086,128 $4,216,543 Infrastructure $500,000 $910,000 $1,048,000 $488,000 $488,000 $3,434,000 $1,375,000 $925,000 $1,600,000 $1,200,000 $1,050,000 $6,150,000 $600,000 $550,000 $350,000 $250,000 $250,000 $2,000,000 Software solutions/ Cloud Services Implementation Support, Communication and Training' Sub-total $2,780,900 $3,141,344 $4,006,535 $2,997,637 $2,874,128 $15,800,543 Additional data center capacity TBD Contingency (15%) $417,135 Total Estimate TBD $471,202 TBD $600,980 TBD $449,645 TBD $431,119 TBD $2,370,081 $3,198,035 $3,612,545 $4,607,515 $3,447,282 $3,305,247 $18,170,624 96 Critical Success Factors 97 Critical Success Factors This plan represents a robust set of activities for Smith to implement over the next three years. To be successful there are a number of critical factors that must be in place to ensure the College’s success in implementing the strategies outlined in this plan. First, leadership must review the ten strategic opportunities and confirm the priorities and phasing for implementation. Not all of the initiatives can be nor should they be implemented at once. Campus leadership must review the initiatives and prioritize them in alignment with the overall goals of the College. For each initiative, Smith must identify dedicated resources to support the implementation. Such resources include project management expertise as well as functional and IT staff. In some cases functional staff time may require backfilling so they can truly dedicate their attention to project tasks. Project costs should also be refined to ensure a complete accounting of expected investment requirements. 98 Critical Success Factors Successful implementation of new technology requires a partnership between functional owners and IT and unified leadership to guide the campus through the cultural change that will naturally occur as a result of the adoption of new technologies and new ways of working at Smith. The IT Governance committees will play a crucial role in monitoring project progress and be willing to adjust priorities and timelines as needed and in light of the rate of absorption of change and adoption of technology by the campus community. Given the magnitude of change it is critically important that routine and transparent communication be made to the campus regarding the goals of the strategic plan and the progress made on the implementation of each initiative. 99 Critical Success Factors Training will be critical to ensure the adoption of new technologies as they are implemented into the work place. Training should be offered both in person and online to accommodate the various learning styles of staff and faculty alike. Training is also necessary in project management for the individuals identified to lead project teams. Such training, coupled with the adoption of standard project management tools will ensure that Smith project team leads develop the core competencies required to lead multiple projects over the next three years.