Number_ _
ate_... ;...>;.;_acr-_
rode.
.~-----_
.. _....
~:..-
_ _.._--­
...
Lubbock, Texa.
June 23, 1983
Professor J. Hadley Edgar, Jr.
School of Law
Texas Tech University
Dear Hadley:
In my 35 years of teaching
law, at twelve different
law schools (including
summer visits), I have had
to evaluate and grade an
estimated 10,000 final
examination papers. This
paper of yours in the
Administrative Law course
at the University of Texas
~
in 1956 is one of the eight
or ten best papers, in any
course, that I have ever had
the pleasure of reading and
LLB-16
evaluating. (The grade should
have been a 93. My standards
in those days were unreasonably
rigorous.) That, of
Write the pledge in full OD the inaide perforated .heeL
course, is the reason I .
.
have kept this paper,
SlgD the pledge WIth your name
along with a very few
Do Dot
°te anything eln OD the perforated .heet.
others, for the past 27
years.
BIB
ue
00 k
I am pleased to turn it back
to you now, however, and I
hope you will regard it as
an unusual and desirable
memento of your exceptional
professional competence from
the beginning of your career
as a lawyer and a teacher.
Wirrl:gardS.
Wy lie 'T'7;::is
SCHOOL OF LAW
THE UN
Y OF TEXAS
--+-
_
..I.
F~/:J~
'&.t.~~.
0. .
c.Q.LL
•
&!,.W& ~~
i.u. ~
~
. lu::.tO., /'tA.'
rv'o14 tu~tia
? Lk
J
~ ~J
cuit...~~ ~ I ~dl(~Ic.M <t-OtCM~
~~ ~.
cui
tW.Q. /'C.Q..t.kuv - M'
r;
~~
~IVWV\. !'l'lU
~.
14
.r
,+tu.u.+luu u li4 C2
Lu.J...tD~@iciJ fttL~J
~C!J~~~/QI'ol1 ~
J..JL C1J
u..td.~u
l~,,~
l..lJ.4.f<t. .bJ , ~
.'
~ ~~~~~
~ Q.Au.~ll.
~CM.L - ~
~ ~Ma. fLQ
2..'
~c&
Q.J-
iLL~'
.,'
11',«
UI'-,
' cJ).
f
M
ttt.u-U.ur M u...J
~ CLI\.Q.. ~t..U A<:I..O..
~r'
Of
'F~~~
~
'!ALAU
~ ~~
U~ ,~~
~.
~"1~&u-
.w..a.
f'lc4
~~~\'
~.- MJ.C& ~
I
~...t.... t...Q.\ • e.L.
4
I" C'"'
$.U..
-K.u- ~ ~ ~ 6(
~dQ
.............,...". ~ """'' ' ' ' ' ' '-'11
k~.,,&
""""-U...... . . -
J
~"4 c~
~.
L..'
'&
~ ~ ~4"L8.-...
~
~~~"-W. ~w., ~ tfo k
~
~.
-#..u......
~.
~
~J
tLA~.
lv.~
VJ.4 Ll....u.- Jt.uJ..L
~
UAI-~ ~~
~ 'f.tu
A,.t
( §I
/I..J.J.J.A ~~
4lw<t.
Cl.A<.
<iL~
u.cl i...A
~
.UA.~
-r- . o..~,---",
~ MU.CUA.3 - ~
tu..u.-.
~ ~ t t.Jb
<l.U
~~
~~~~~~~~
•
:
II
IJ
t-
4lu.~"
QAJ...LM
-ts\.u
~
Lu.tl.A ~ ~.o....~
~~
Ii. eu.­
o..~
, A• ~
~
e 4.4
-l.4.J
~
•0
':u.~~~.u.. w~s." twv..t·~· ~.~
I
~~ ktl
F~' "r~
4L..o.. ~ o.,u.
l~~
CLJ ~ 6.tQq. :., )
.t..~ l& ~"~~ ~ 'l- .~~~
~s·' l..u.AIu-'
~
LU... ")
~J
d ~~4. ~~ ~
&:~.~It ~ L&M-~j
A;u.le&
~
e.o.. A...~~~
-btu.
~,dJ.'dJ
~C14 +<......A. LM±VuL #
k
~~,"
""'IV'A.IVI'
)­
l,.)..Jwo..M­
~
~ L.
~
...
Au.eJt.L.
I
l L
c!utuiu.<& u..u..cl
J
~ ~
bCJ.(~ C-v.l ~
~
~~
-
~
tM:~ cL. M+Y"9 .
tL
~ . ~
.. -H..u..u. ~
Y
U{ ~)
~
~
ClA
.
's /I.A-J::u~1 ~~
) 4tu. ~
~ lU.'
Q.LL& I ~~~
~
~~t.4J-Q."""""
)
WL.
.
u.W.t.
w.lU.~ &..ut~
~\~
+<.u­
I
~cJ~
..Lu.. . .v.d.iu ~ ~ Q,,~
~
J
~oV- ~ ~
!,).JQ,;vJ1,. ~
~
~
CL.1
~
rGA
~~
CJ..A
~ MU.~
.
.
et", ~IQ.UO,,,._
~tU..tJ.
.u.A'
(~~QUM'{
~ ~ ~,,~ luwf'-JV\;.
-ttu. ~
VW
~
I
0:
~.
~
&
-ttu.
~~~
(M-~
Q..J~ -+L..uu. ~
-Hu ~
~ ~
.
~1 s .
<O.tA (,u.a ~
u- ba.UL
~ ~
.
0J
~
~~~) ~
~
r-
i-tu. ~
A.A ~
~~.:..
J
r
~
11
n
~a..u.:.w...... MU."""'"'­
A
u.&..u.A e& U,l.J'orU.A~'\oLAU1
I~Uu...u.AAJ
T
k,~.....,.. r~
.
-H-u. ~
CvJ
. o..~otJ....
.~ ~ a.. ~
J
~ ~(Q~ ~ -UA
r
t4fu
•__ ',L
~
. ~I' .~~~~.
+~&..
.
1~'
'I
•
.,
u.M.u.~
~MdJ
~
tLu- r~ 16 1VUU"1I~
a
~u.O
r
~
I~ ~~
7
cctu
~-
iL'
/ U ~ l~,",,~'~
&+..:..u,..:..-,
,-I-ku..
-
.a s.~
~
~
"1-.
. . . ."AI.J',..o,IM.t~~
~
~'c §
{{w ~ CU-L
)..~~
"M.L
CL
.
teu..
~.
~ 4tu...
~
~
~, y
L ~ciu.U-
~A A ~~
tL.:l:.~~
Q..
__
~
k~1
Q.4
.
~~tIJ~-\ ~
~J ~UL-\"Cu..
~,\h.L'\.~
.....-- •.
tLu
~~
LJ!~ I~)'
I
Q.L
ICA. '
tk­
~1 ~u.uct.
'ik
al P~ G.d ~ u..luM4
, tCL .
)..J...O ... ~
--..............
..
LuLw:.u. -'
U-AL
~fU.
F .
~ tf-~
~ -+lUA LVM C4.. ~
u.o f\l.~
o
AMM.~
A.~~
~~ c.d-o..kCI..AM.A . I~,
(
~~~~
~ ,
'Uu.~
~ ~~
0...
t
\, . . . . .
~ .4.M-~
, ,'-a.I\.'O;'
tui
~~~~ '1th~~'-'U1 ('"""fn ......~·1 (M,~,~u....
t
trr-
:v,
~ Jt,I\A1A~'~'
~ J ..r
~~'t1J.j.)~~Y
(CI.A &l~U~) ~~
...:...u.u...v,wv..l.I'V\MJ-"
CUL
~~
...,~~. ~
tr
. . .yW1l'~ ~ ~ +0
~~S
+tuA.o-
t\..k.Q....
~
b k
~
C4.~
cJ
Q
UtCLAGt-f..
-,
'1
Cw CL ~
~~ M &..u.u.CLu.
dJ..u.
. . . . . .---.,.
AI
PAJ~'7.
i€u..
~, &i:d ~
J
(j
~
CJ.
(cJ
~
f\
It ~ ~~
*of lu.tu.W.1? ~
liuU.- ~
~ leu.
P~ ~ ~ 1lII..M.'V1II.'~
~rl u.rlLub.u.- ~
f?.c, ev&... ~cl ~
V~~.""Uo/~
Cl.!tt.u. &I..u.
1>IoA.AAA("~v..S
T-.v'U-
lMLU.
-J.Jl~
~~ (Cu.ui
~+tu.
«u.
VV'~.AL
to-
k.A.AJ...
~ §b
0J.u..
MU..
a-)
~
~1-6 IVY.A.~
~~
A. +tu.
~~~,u~
~Ij.VVooVJ I -~ ~~
I,
jfu
I . I'
1-.1\
~'I ~Uu.AI
tUJ-Cl4d­
'k.t. .
~
'-"-'U'''--''--''''''J
cd-
~dA A-.
~ A' lA '~J
1­
u1.
«tu.L ~~t.J.ALJi
-
cF h..t4A
-tetM ~
~1 ULJ(..Jl.AI'
...
Wo1.~J~
Cv\
~
~
~
~~
~ ~~CL"tu~ ~ CJ/J +tw
~~.
Wtu"I10 k.lu.
~
l
.I.l.UlA.(
.~.~~
~ /Ul-~ C/... ~~~,
~
~.
~
I
~
I;,.D o,,-"f"U.
.
..;,
r-
a., ~ cutQ tlvo ~ ~
~
.iu.
+tu
, "hu.vt~
'tiu.A ~.
lAhWQ
~
~
1
~iA..c£ ~
lUtz ~i
[CAM.
~
tuw.., o..u. CJ.&.L
~1
"""-''--''- WM
~~
i,;.;.
.
ruD4ut~ ~ ~LL.
rt
i-k
~
(,)
f\.
a.u. u.. . &.l..c iLL 'Q v."
u...u.. &.u..
Q..Cu..L
~'1
..
~~
-.u.L~ -ttu...
U-L~t
~
~e.)
.
w. ~
4i.,
,~~~
-te4 f\ A
~ R,
loA
QA& ~
1
CL4.L
f\.L/J
k.....v.J
~1I'\..U/I1UoV"-I...4IrV\,.., M.A-~
)
aJ
,4-4..I,.'t;. I t.L. l
hL ~
~~k
,~,~~
Mf.
~Lt
4~
'cutJ ~'~~
.,
&u itWL
l)(.~
~'u.
4
eu ~
~ ok WdA·
,,tt.,..­
~~~
1L~Cw.~~
- w..r.
~~I ~M..d-
~fLQD1l.tt- h..w ,
~ .u-M.~
.lJ.4
~ t..ti~'4.14.
lW.~~ AA
A11 &.t ·~OiL
I t
V. QJJ.lJI./. lU.) ~
~~~ w.'i~c~
,~ AI~ J u..u... ~
H" a u..A
4W. (MU4A..I
tu
lU.Ct LU. M
~c.J
r"
w.
Q.U.(,
--UL~,
.
u...
~ ~~ ~
d .
0-. /1M.
,~
M~
t .e.c:o.a
~~~t ~~I\L~
~
.
~ J..uCui.M.~
ib
~ ~
I·
~ ~c14tJ. ~
~o..u. &.t.. . Uw...
~
-Ku..
iM.
~
&
A.C
J..lM.
J
OA
ClAcO.. A.A.J-
.
.
-
~.\/J ')
~~
I
&J u1.Lc& u..e1A
~
+<.u-
M- A~
tLu.. ~
QA
1;
Otl
~
• . ")
~
'k
n.
~UJ Q.u~CUA..U- -tea
!\UJJJA <Jm~~ ~
~ - ~) Q ~v-W..'\ ~ ~ \u.lL~
;U..u..OAU .
~ fu ~~~
~ ~
~ Ufrai-u­
~QA..U. ~{-tA fu
. ~(. :± ~&.L. ~CUU-~
J
~
LL'
~.~M.L41'
~.
Wo..t.t
t.J..& -HA..t C:
&- (~ ~ Uf
~~~
&.cu1lL ~o.. ~l~) kfd~'Uoo1 CLU. t4
:;l &.1.'
.
Lu.. fH.U.u..l UO
rw..u \~t ~ ru
~ L-!tuM} +eu...
~.
F
,
-
m,CLAtl
~.
pCM:ll'
'
u.
GA
0..
J
'4-lu.
L.ill
&..LA ~
I
~~
~ ~~ '4~
iAA.*uuw.~ . l~1
~~e.&
~
CUA.
~ ~~
.u.....
~
.w
M
( ~~
-fU.t.~1
(}'~..L."""",,,~
1.t k.u.l'·~~i·'
~:hA l.LU~.
~~~I
1;0"4 ~ A.o
~
~. ~ ~
~
'I~ ~
~
~ ~
M.u ~.
M
~
1
r w:t,"
¥~~J"~ "f~
~,~ .1..u.. VJQ.JIQ & ~
p~
-H.Lt.
I
au~~ -1MCiLt k
'I
'i.A
"""'~L~""
l!...
. 1\. • •. '
~~ ~ 1 1cL)
o..u.J-.
.4tu.~i· ~,uH#.
~ ~;d ~l;,A£.
/ kUA
L~AJ~'UJ\I ~ <!Au..~
~o..-.A.
UM.
~~
:
A
(J
I
~ Cu1w.tu~.
~
~
I.M..o
II
f!4.
~&.'If~
~
& ~ UA't U-(.. ~ ~ ~&Lu~ M(yutu..
~ iJJ.. ~ cL. . ~
L.M .AA·~4o"A
~ cu&.
l.VQLJ q
\1
WOA
. &t.u.&...
~} LlA.l. 1A.
~ CuA ~'\..UoY\I~
i.M., ~~
,~UL-'\.A.~
C!..U/U..
~ ~~::_
~
~. . . . ),tu. ~~~~~~
N"o'VVV'~
CVJ CtM.
~. [~
~ ~&U~.
~ftuC(.J-Fk
~./~~ "F
M.A.CJ..A.1 'o.t.. ~ M.~
~~WQA~
k
llLI..AUVVI~IA..l& i..u. ~cO.o..u.u... u.M...~
a l~
w-tu..UL
~
WQ4
~&- ~ ~ ~ tt4­
J
~ L..eu.u..
~
~v..;u... ~~'IoVl
ifuAJJ­ o..u.. ~
t. ~~~
wll~
~
~~
~
~
,
CA~~ u..uA- ~~.~~
~ ~ ~lk ~
~e1A. ~ ,
1~"AM~kQ.{
e,
lit
~
-{tu
,l Cv\j­ ,~
~
kwJ
) 0.. ~ ~ ~
~
~~-U.J-
tYUi.t+
(~
.VJM..c iliM'
~
U
"\tv-
UJ..
~d-
~~~
l:t A.UA.~ ~ MClM.d..o..h,
1J
+tu.~,
~.
uK~~~~',~·t~J-tewu...
~ ~
~~ ~
~ ~'fi 4IA.t.. ~CJ.Jf-
~
~t ~.
kkCl1
.
~
",,,,V~. W!U'l ~ ,
~
C4.~~utub: ~u-
~'
')
beuu,.~~
~
rd
.t1.u.c:J-
l;.Je.A
~
~
v..&,:,()
•
r~
.
5":
llAt~~
~l
(J..f.b~. 'ct ~ ~D4~IJJA i,~
~ a.u..~,
~~
~
"""IJIUl.I~"'-» ~ \JU.Q.;<t ~ ~ ~uuJ..J). LL ~
~.JV\~
~ ~~
-1U)
~
tt.a.4 ~ ~
~~~ ~. ~J,uJ ~ +fu-eAull:UdAU'S>
AWJ -U.t.~
~ ~
M- .
~ (J..
1
CVlL
~
-ttu. ~~
&. iA &li..&, ~~ -f6L L.w:J-Ul
~
llJ..Ul
M.
l~&u ~ ~
iJ
~4A'1
-ftA.UAA.
e.ub
~~u. ~,
t~, ~ ~
~
CUt
~ f-~a.
rud"­
Vo.r~ ~g,..('"""o$~~~ ~/U~L.
~~
Q..
~ ~ :dA
CJ...M.
v.M.
~
-ttu-
cM.A
r
~ rudl" ~ ~ ~
~.~.
l.cJ.rv.. (h(A.tttt..L.
~d4
UU-v\A
I
M..$..uJ
cuo ~
C(.
~
~ ~ -t-k ~
) ~ )...UJ
.~ MA4~4 F~'
Jtu B Met. ~w.tA1
tu.&,~
eru 'bcLd.t., 10 ~~
wOA .u.d-~~ ~ ~ ~cJ.A ~ tJ.J..-
u.. 0Mu
Po:>
1)"ftu-
~ ~
~~
~~
ttU,1AM~
'.
~ ~ ~Cl..l:tU,.,
I
Wt.L
Q.U..'-l ~ ~
AM. ~
J
~
OA~dtJ Jv.M:J-~ ~~~ ~~~. ~iiAA.1
Ai. tA.c ~
ftu.., ~ iA ~ ~ ~d- ~ M<.t- •
e ~.u..of
o...L~
t4uL
/U-Q.O..U..
.:4. 1 ~J
-{..t.u.
~ ~ ~ 't<u ~o..tr 1 ~
r .....
~
A:t
4
W
~
4CLf1~'ec,Q&a, ~ -~~ i4C ) ( ~ ~ ~ rw1L
i./'. ~ i4~; u.u.~
f~~
~vv ~ -+tuM-
~
kCJ..J.ALt. d .
4: Ca..
CJ.M.
.~.'
I
flJA~ ~
~
u.ttlA
~ ~
~ -tk­
lufw- ~~~
~
1J~
-\{u.
d.A~ LU.. ~
a.-dt&.
I
~~ ~,
J~~~~
:ct- ~\A/.
~
J
tW ~
-ltu-t
tJ. ~
.
~~~. ~
&A ~ ~.u.u
'.
~
Cl~..-.,
+tu.. /UA~~
CU\~v...t. 4tu:d' ~ &.MW1ut~L ~ ~ M..o
Q.$lu..
I
etA
'~~
~ &M~~J 0A.t.
.u.o~
~ &.LdMCi 'i~
~
<-
CUt
~
· ~~ ~eu...
-tlu
-~,
tu~,.l4i
~ cd-~
y.u.we. ~ -U.L. tu,.,
4tu tLw.L tr
F
. ~~
WM &L~ t
j
~(L~ td ~ \Miu.1) ~ ~QA~ ~ ~~
I
v1
~J.JJ.. ~
l~~