Number_ _ ate_... ;...>;.;_acr-_ rode. .~-----_ .. _.... ~:..- _ _.._--­ ... Lubbock, Texa. June 23, 1983 Professor J. Hadley Edgar, Jr. School of Law Texas Tech University Dear Hadley: In my 35 years of teaching law, at twelve different law schools (including summer visits), I have had to evaluate and grade an estimated 10,000 final examination papers. This paper of yours in the Administrative Law course at the University of Texas ~ in 1956 is one of the eight or ten best papers, in any course, that I have ever had the pleasure of reading and LLB-16 evaluating. (The grade should have been a 93. My standards in those days were unreasonably rigorous.) That, of Write the pledge in full OD the inaide perforated .heeL course, is the reason I . . have kept this paper, SlgD the pledge WIth your name along with a very few Do Dot °te anything eln OD the perforated .heet. others, for the past 27 years. BIB ue 00 k I am pleased to turn it back to you now, however, and I hope you will regard it as an unusual and desirable memento of your exceptional professional competence from the beginning of your career as a lawyer and a teacher. Wirrl:gardS. Wy lie 'T'7;::is SCHOOL OF LAW THE UN Y OF TEXAS --+- _ ..I. F~/:J~ '&.t.~~. 0. . c.Q.LL • &!,.W& ~~ i.u. ~ ~ . lu::.tO., /'tA.' rv'o14 tu~tia ? Lk J ~ ~J cuit...~~ ~ I ~dl(~Ic.M <t-OtCM~ ~~ ~. cui tW.Q. /'C.Q..t.kuv - M' r; ~~ ~IVWV\. !'l'lU ~. 14 .r ,+tu.u.+luu u li4 C2 Lu.J...tD~@iciJ fttL~J ~C!J~~~/QI'ol1 ~ J..JL C1J u..td.~u l~,,~ l..lJ.4.f<t. .bJ , ~ .' ~ ~~~~~ ~ Q.Au.~ll. ~CM.L - ~ ~ ~Ma. fLQ 2..' ~c& Q.J- iLL~' .,' 11',« UI'-, ' cJ). f M ttt.u-U.ur M u...J ~ CLI\.Q.. ~t..U A<:I..O.. ~r' Of 'F~~~ ~ '!ALAU ~ ~~ U~ ,~~ ~. ~"1~&u- .w..a. f'lc4 ~~~\' ~.- MJ.C& ~ I ~...t.... t...Q.\ • e.L. 4 I" C'"' $.U.. -K.u- ~ ~ ~ 6( ~dQ .............,...". ~ """'' ' ' ' ' ' '-'11 k~.,,& """"-U...... . . - J ~"4 c~ ~. L..' '& ~ ~ ~4"L8.-... ~ ~~~"-W. ~w., ~ tfo k ~ ~. -#..u...... ~. ~ ~J tLA~. lv.~ VJ.4 Ll....u.- Jt.uJ..L ~ UAI-~ ~~ ~ 'f.tu A,.t ( §I /I..J.J.J.A ~~ 4lw<t. Cl.A<. <iL~ u.cl i...A ~ .UA.~ -r- . o..~,---", ~ MU.CUA.3 - ~ tu..u.-. ~ ~ t t.Jb <l.U ~~ ~~~~~~~~ • : II IJ t- 4lu.~" QAJ...LM -ts\.u ~ Lu.tl.A ~ ~.o....~ ~~ Ii. eu.­ o..~ , A• ~ ~ e 4.4 -l.4.J ~ •0 ':u.~~~.u.. w~s." twv..t·~· ~.~ I ~~ ktl F~' "r~ 4L..o.. ~ o.,u. l~~ CLJ ~ 6.tQq. :., ) .t..~ l& ~"~~ ~ 'l- .~~~ ~s·' l..u.AIu-' ~ LU... ") ~J d ~~4. ~~ ~ &:~.~It ~ L&M-~j A;u.le& ~ e.o.. A...~~~ -btu. ~,dJ.'dJ ~C14 +<......A. LM±VuL # k ~~," ""'IV'A.IVI' )­ l,.)..Jwo..M­ ~ ~ L. ~ ... Au.eJt.L. I l L c!utuiu.<& u..u..cl J ~ ~ bCJ.(~ C-v.l ~ ~ ~~ - ~ tM:~ cL. M+Y"9 . tL ~ . ~ .. -H..u..u. ~ Y U{ ~) ~ ~ ClA . 's /I.A-J::u~1 ~~ ) 4tu. ~ ~ lU.' Q.LL& I ~~~ ~ ~~t.4J-Q.""""" ) WL. . u.W.t. w.lU.~ &..ut~ ~\~ +<.u­ I ~cJ~ ..Lu.. . .v.d.iu ~ ~ Q,,~ ~ J ~oV- ~ ~ !,).JQ,;vJ1,. ~ ~ ~ CL.1 ~ rGA ~~ CJ..A ~ MU.~ . . et", ~IQ.UO,,,._ ~tU..tJ. .u.A' (~~QUM'{ ~ ~ ~,,~ luwf'-JV\;. -ttu. ~ VW ~ I 0: ~. ~ & -ttu. ~~~ (M-~ Q..J~ -+L..uu. ~ -Hu ~ ~ ~ . ~1 s . <O.tA (,u.a ~ u- ba.UL ~ ~ . 0J ~ ~~~) ~ ~ r- i-tu. ~ A.A ~ ~~.:.. J r ~ 11 n ~a..u.:.w...... MU."""'"'­ A u.&..u.A e& U,l.J'orU.A~'\oLAU1 I~Uu...u.AAJ T k,~.....,.. r~ . -H-u. ~ CvJ . o..~otJ.... .~ ~ a.. ~ J ~ ~(Q~ ~ -UA r t4fu •__ ',L ~ . ~I' .~~~~. +~&.. . 1~' 'I • ., u.M.u.~ ~MdJ ~ tLu- r~ 16 1VUU"1I~ a ~u.O r ~ I~ ~~ 7 cctu ~- iL' / U ~ l~,",,~'~ &+..:..u,..:..-, ,-I-ku.. - .a s.~ ~ ~ "1-. . . . ."AI.J',..o,IM.t~~ ~ ~'c § {{w ~ CU-L )..~~ "M.L CL . teu.. ~. ~ 4tu... ~ ~ ~, y L ~ciu.U- ~A A ~~ tL.:l:.~~ Q.. __ ~ k~1 Q.4 . ~~tIJ~-\ ~ ~J ~UL-\"Cu.. ~,\h.L'\.~ .....-- •. tLu ~~ LJ!~ I~)' I Q.L ICA. ' tk­ ~1 ~u.uct. 'ik al P~ G.d ~ u..luM4 , tCL . )..J...O ... ~ --.............. .. LuLw:.u. -' U-AL ~fU. F . ~ tf-~ ~ -+lUA LVM C4.. ~ u.o f\l.~ o AMM.~ A.~~ ~~ c.d-o..kCI..AM.A . I~, ( ~~~~ ~ , 'Uu.~ ~ ~~ 0... t \, . . . . . ~ .4.M-~ , ,'-a.I\.'O;' tui ~~~~ '1th~~'-'U1 ('"""fn ......~·1 (M,~,~u.... t trr- :v, ~ Jt,I\A1A~'~' ~ J ..r ~~'t1J.j.)~~Y (CI.A &l~U~) ~~ ...:...u.u...v,wv..l.I'V\MJ-" CUL ~~ ...,~~. ~ tr . . .yW1l'~ ~ ~ +0 ~~S +tuA.o- t\..k.Q.... ~ b k ~ C4.~ cJ Q UtCLAGt-f.. -, '1 Cw CL ~ ~~ M &..u.u.CLu. dJ..u. . . . . . .---.,. AI PAJ~'7. i€u.. ~, &i:d ~ J (j ~ CJ. (cJ ~ f\ It ~ ~~ *of lu.tu.W.1? ~ liuU.- ~ ~ leu. P~ ~ ~ 1lII..M.'V1II.'~ ~rl u.rlLub.u.- ~ f?.c, ev&... ~cl ~ V~~.""Uo/~ Cl.!tt.u. &I..u. 1>IoA.AAA("~v..S T-.v'U- lMLU. -J.Jl~ ~~ (Cu.ui ~+tu. «u. VV'~.AL to- k.A.AJ... ~ §b 0J.u.. MU.. a-) ~ ~1-6 IVY.A.~ ~~ A. +tu. ~~~,u~ ~Ij.VVooVJ I -~ ~~ I, jfu I . I' 1-.1\ ~'I ~Uu.AI tUJ-Cl4d­ 'k.t. . ~ '-"-'U'''--''--''''''J cd- ~dA A-. ~ A' lA '~J 1­ u1. «tu.L ~~t.J.ALJi - cF h..t4A -tetM ~ ~1 ULJ(..Jl.AI' ... Wo1.~J~ Cv\ ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~~CL"tu~ ~ CJ/J +tw ~~. Wtu"I10 k.lu. ~ l .I.l.UlA.( .~.~~ ~ /Ul-~ C/... ~~~, ~ ~. ~ I ~ I;,.D o,,-"f"U. . ..;, r- a., ~ cutQ tlvo ~ ~ ~ .iu. +tu , "hu.vt~ 'tiu.A ~. lAhWQ ~ ~ 1 ~iA..c£ ~ lUtz ~i [CAM. ~ tuw.., o..u. CJ.&.L ~1 """-''--''- WM ~~ i,;.;. . ruD4ut~ ~ ~LL. rt i-k ~ (,) f\. a.u. u.. . &.l..c iLL 'Q v." u...u.. &.u.. Q..Cu..L ~'1 .. ~~ -.u.L~ -ttu... U-L~t ~ ~e.) . w. ~ 4i., ,~~~ -te4 f\ A ~ R, loA QA& ~ 1 CL4.L f\.L/J k.....v.J ~1I'\..U/I1UoV"-I...4IrV\,.., M.A-~ ) aJ ,4-4..I,.'t;. I t.L. l hL ~ ~~k ,~,~~ Mf. ~Lt 4~ 'cutJ ~'~~ ., &u itWL l)(.~ ~'u. 4 eu ~ ~ ok WdA· ,,tt.,..­ ~~~ 1L~Cw.~~ - w..r. ~~I ~M..d- ~fLQD1l.tt- h..w , ~ .u-M.~ .lJ.4 ~ t..ti~'4.14. lW.~~ AA A11 &.t ·~OiL I t V. QJJ.lJI./. lU.) ~ ~~~ w.'i~c~ ,~ AI~ J u..u... ~ H" a u..A 4W. (MU4A..I tu lU.Ct LU. M ~c.J r" w. Q.U.(, --UL~, . u... ~ ~~ ~ d . 0-. /1M. ,~ M~ t .e.c:o.a ~~~t ~~I\L~ ~ . ~ J..uCui.M.~ ib ~ ~ I· ~ ~c14tJ. ~ ~o..u. &.t.. . Uw... ~ -Ku.. iM. ~ & A.C J..lM. J OA ClAcO.. A.A.J- . . - ~.\/J ') ~~ I &J u1.Lc& u..e1A ~ +<.u- M- A~ tLu.. ~ QA 1; Otl ~ • . ") ~ 'k n. ~UJ Q.u~CUA..U- -tea !\UJJJA <Jm~~ ~ ~ - ~) Q ~v-W..'\ ~ ~ \u.lL~ ;U..u..OAU . ~ fu ~~~ ~ ~ ~ Ufrai-u­ ~QA..U. ~{-tA fu . ~(. :± ~&.L. ~CUU-~ J ~ LL' ~.~M.L41' ~. Wo..t.t t.J..& -HA..t C: &- (~ ~ Uf ~~~ &.cu1lL ~o.. ~l~) kfd~'Uoo1 CLU. t4 :;l &.1.' . Lu.. fH.U.u..l UO rw..u \~t ~ ru ~ L-!tuM} +eu... ~. F , - m,CLAtl ~. pCM:ll' ' u. GA 0.. J '4-lu. L.ill &..LA ~ I ~~ ~ ~~ '4~ iAA.*uuw.~ . l~1 ~~e.& ~ CUA. ~ ~~ .u..... ~ .w M ( ~~ -fU.t.~1 (}'~..L."""",,,~ 1.t k.u.l'·~~i·' ~:hA l.LU~. ~~~I 1;0"4 ~ A.o ~ ~. ~ ~ ~ 'I~ ~ ~ ~ ~ M.u ~. M ~ 1 r w:t," ¥~~J"~ "f~ ~,~ .1..u.. VJQ.JIQ & ~ p~ -H.Lt. I au~~ -1MCiLt k 'I 'i.A """'~L~"" l!... . 1\. • •. ' ~~ ~ 1 1cL) o..u.J-. .4tu.~i· ~,uH#. ~ ~;d ~l;,A£. / kUA L~AJ~'UJ\I ~ <!Au..~ ~o..-.A. UM. ~~ : A (J I ~ Cu1w.tu~. ~ ~ I.M..o II f!4. ~&.'If~ ~ & ~ UA't U-(.. ~ ~ ~&Lu~ M(yutu.. ~ iJJ.. ~ cL. . ~ L.M .AA·~4o"A ~ cu&. l.VQLJ q \1 WOA . &t.u.&... ~} LlA.l. 1A. ~ CuA ~'\..UoY\I~ i.M., ~~ ,~UL-'\.A.~ C!..U/U.. ~ ~~::_ ~ ~. . . . ),tu. ~~~~~~ N"o'VVV'~ CVJ CtM. ~. [~ ~ ~&U~. ~ftuC(.J-Fk ~./~~ "F M.A.CJ..A.1 'o.t.. ~ M.~ ~~WQA~ k llLI..AUVVI~IA..l& i..u. ~cO.o..u.u... u.M...~ a l~ w-tu..UL ~ WQ4 ~&- ~ ~ ~ tt4­ J ~ L..eu.u.. ~ ~v..;u... ~~'IoVl ifuAJJ­ o..u.. ~ t. ~~~ wll~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ , CA~~ u..uA- ~~.~~ ~ ~ ~lk ~ ~e1A. ~ , 1~"AM~kQ.{ e, lit ~ -{tu ,l Cv\j­ ,~ ~ kwJ ) 0.. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~-U.J- tYUi.t+ (~ .VJM..c iliM' ~ U "\tv- UJ.. ~d- ~~~ l:t A.UA.~ ~ MClM.d..o..h, 1J +tu.~, ~. uK~~~~',~·t~J-tewu... ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~'fi 4IA.t.. ~CJ.Jf- ~ ~t ~. kkCl1 . ~ ",,,,V~. W!U'l ~ , ~ C4.~~utub: ~u- ~' ') beuu,.~~ ~ rd .t1.u.c:J- l;.Je.A ~ ~ v..&,:,() • r~ . 5": llAt~~ ~l (J..f.b~. 'ct ~ ~D4~IJJA i,~ ~ a.u..~, ~~ ~ """IJIUl.I~"'-» ~ \JU.Q.;<t ~ ~ ~uuJ..J). LL ~ ~.JV\~ ~ ~~ -1U) ~ tt.a.4 ~ ~ ~~~ ~. ~J,uJ ~ +fu-eAull:UdAU'S> AWJ -U.t.~ ~ ~ M- . ~ (J.. 1 CVlL ~ -ttu. ~~ &. iA &li..&, ~~ -f6L L.w:J-Ul ~ llJ..Ul M. l~&u ~ ~ iJ ~4A'1 -ftA.UAA. e.ub ~~u. ~, t~, ~ ~ ~ CUt ~ f-~a. rud"­ Vo.r~ ~g,..('"""o$~~~ ~/U~L. ~~ Q.. ~ ~ :dA CJ...M. v.M. ~ -ttu- cM.A r ~ rudl" ~ ~ ~ ~.~. l.cJ.rv.. (h(A.tttt..L. ~d4 UU-v\A I M..$..uJ cuo ~ C(. ~ ~ ~ -t-k ~ ) ~ )...UJ .~ MA4~4 F~' Jtu B Met. ~w.tA1 tu.&,~ eru 'bcLd.t., 10 ~~ wOA .u.d-~~ ~ ~ ~cJ.A ~ tJ.J..- u.. 0Mu Po:> 1)"ftu- ~ ~ ~~ ~~ ttU,1AM~ '. ~ ~ ~Cl..l:tU,., I Wt.L Q.U..'-l ~ ~ AM. ~ J ~ OA~dtJ Jv.M:J-~ ~~~ ~~~. ~iiAA.1 Ai. tA.c ~ ftu.., ~ iA ~ ~ ~d- ~ M<.t- • e ~.u..of o...L~ t4uL /U-Q.O..U.. .:4. 1 ~J -{..t.u. ~ ~ ~ 't<u ~o..tr 1 ~ r ..... ~ A:t 4 W ~ 4CLf1~'ec,Q&a, ~ -~~ i4C ) ( ~ ~ ~ rw1L i./'. ~ i4~; u.u.~ f~~ ~vv ~ -+tuM- ~ kCJ..J.ALt. d . 4: Ca.. CJ.M. .~.' I flJA~ ~ ~ u.ttlA ~ ~ ~ -tk­ lufw- ~~~ ~ 1J~ -\{u. d.A~ LU.. ~ a.-dt&. I ~~ ~, J~~~~ :ct- ~\A/. ~ J tW ~ -ltu-t tJ. ~ . ~~~. ~ &A ~ ~.u.u '. ~ Cl~..-., +tu.. /UA~~ CU\~v...t. 4tu:d' ~ &.MW1ut~L ~ ~ M..o Q.$lu.. I etA '~~ ~ &M~~J 0A.t. .u.o~ ~ &.LdMCi 'i~ ~ <- CUt ~ · ~~ ~eu... -tlu -~, tu~,.l4i ~ cd-~ y.u.we. ~ -U.L. tu,., 4tu tLw.L tr F . ~~ WM &L~ t j ~(L~ td ~ \Miu.1) ~ ~QA~ ~ ~~ I v1 ~J.JJ.. ~ l~~