UCL Institute of Archaeology ARCL 3043 Maya Civilisation Course Handbook Term II 2016 Option, 0.5 unit Small ceramic vessel (referred to as a “poison” bottle) found in burial 77S-B/2 at Minanha, Belize. (Drawing by K. Kelsey, SARP) Prerequisite: ARCL 2029 Archaeology of Mesoamerica Time: Wed 9-11 Room: 612 Turnitin codes: Password = IoA1516; Turnitin ID = 2970200 Course co-ordinator: Elizabeth Graham Bill Sillar and Claudia Zehrt b.sillar@ucl.ac.uk Room B16 2 UCL - Institute of Archaeology ARCL 3043 -- MAYA CIVILISATION -- Term II, 2016 1. OVERVIEW Short description This course builds on the archaeology of Mesoamerica and provides an examination in greater depth of Maya archaeology, ethnohistory, calendrics and hieroglyphic inscriptions. Week-by-week summary Lecturers (until Liz returns) Week Date Topic 1 2 3 4 13 January 20 January 27 January 03 February 10 February 15-19 February 24 February 02 March Introduction to the Maya Environment and resources of the Maya area Maya architecture, caches, burials, tombs 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 9 March 16 March 23 March Organisation of Maya society Maya ideology, religion, and the Spanish Conquest R E A D I N G Jago Cooper Claudia Zehrt David Pendergast Claudia Zehrt Claudia Zehrt W E E K Maya history, writing and the calendar Origins of Maya states in the Late Preclassic Maya states in the Early Classic & Teotihuacan The apogee of Maya states in the Late Classic The Maya collapse and the Postclassic period Eva Jobbova Claudia Zehrt David Pendergast Claudia Zehrt Claudia Zehrt Basic texts, web sites, journals The Ancient Maya, 6th edition, by Robert Sharer (with Loa Traxler), 2005. Earlier editions are fine, especially for the first half of the course; the 6th edition has more up-to-date information on the individual sites. MOST OF YOUR REQUIRED READING WILL BE FROM THIS BOOK. The Maya, 7th edition, by Michael D. Coe, 2005. This is a much less detailed and shorter version than Sharer’s, but Coe is a wonderful writer, so it serves well as a basic introduction for those who have never taken a course on the Maya or Mesoamerica. Ancient Mexico and Central America by Susan Toby Evans, 2004, 2008 or 2013 is the text we use in the 2nd-year course on Mesoamerica. It is an excellent reference text for Mesoamerica in general. The Classic Maya, by Stephen D. Houston and Takeshi Inomata, 2009. The chapters are organised according to themes, which makes this very useful to consult for essays, as is the case for Martin & Grube, below. Chronicle of the Maya Kings and Queens by Simon Martin and Nikolai Grube, 2000 and the revised edition in 2008. This is the definitive work on what we know from epigraphy about Maya rulers and Maya cities. It is published by Thames and Hudson and is well laid-out with lots of beautiful photos and drawings, and is well written. www.famsi.org is a wonderful on-line resource. It contains reports by archaeologists on a variety of topics including art history and epigraphy as well as archaeology. It also has 3 resources such as the Kerr Vase Book which displays rollouts of the paintings on Maya vases. www.mesoweb.com contains reports by Maya and Mesoamerican scholars in the fields of archaeology, epigraphy, art history and ethnography. It also has an encyclopedia as well as lists of publications. http://decipherment.wordpress.com is a site that focuses on Maya iconography and epigraphy. It is coordinated by David Stuart, a professor and Maya epigrapher at the University of Texas at Austin. It is a site that Maya epigraphers use to report on interim research. It has lots of up-to-date information on Maya writing and on developments in the field. Great pictures as well but make sure to acknowledge the artist and source. The website describes itself in the following way: ‘Maya Decipherment is a weblog devoted to ideas and developments in ancient Maya epigraphy and related fields. We welcome contributions and the participation of colleagues and students from around the world.’ http://www.mesoweb.com/resources/handbook/ Introduction to Maya Hieroglyphs by Harri Kettunen and Christophe Helmke. This is a Mesoweb resource available to anyone wishing to learn Maya hieroglyphs. Journals: Ancient Mesoamerica, Latin American Antiquity, Antiquity, Cambridge Archaeological Journal, Estudios de Cultural Maya, Arqueología Mexicana, Journal of Field Archaeology, Journal of Archaeological Science. Turnitin codes: Password = IoA1516; Turnitin ID = 2970200 Methods of assessment This course is assessed by means of two essays: First essay: 2,500 words, 50%, due: Wednesday, 2nd March Second essay: 2,500 words, 50%, due: Wednesday, 27th April Teaching methods: Illustrated lectures combined with discussion of core readings. Class will be registered on Moodle. Workload in terms: Lectures/discussion = 20 hrs. Private reading and research = 100 hrs. Required essays = 60 hrs. TOTAL = 180 hrs. Prerequisite Students planning to take the Maya course will normally be expected to have taken ARCL 2029, the Archaeology of Mesoamerica, which provides relevant background material. Lamanai, Early Postclassic Buk-phase, A.D. 10001200 2. AIMS, OBJECTIVES AND ASSESSMENT Aims 4 This course provides an introduction to the civilisation of the Precolumbian Maya. I expect that students will already have taken the course on the Archaeology of Mesoamerica, ARCL 2029, and will be familiar with Mesoamerica as a culture area. My aim is to provide an overview of Maya culture, society, environment, food production, settlement patterns, architecture, calendrics, and aspects of material culture to increase awareness of the importance of Maya contributions to civilisation. I also hope to increase awareness of the rich cultural heritage of living Maya groups. Objectives On successful completion of this course a student should have developed a basic knowledge of: 1) approaches to excavation and recovery in wet tropical environments, 2) humanenvironmental interaction in the humid tropics, 3) how data from archaeology, epigraphy, ethnohistory, and ethnography are integrated, 4) the nature of the colonial encounter, and 4) Maya culture history and the character of Precolumbian Maya urbanism. Learning outcomes On successful completion of the course, students should demonstrate: • Excellent citation and referencing practices • Expository writing skills • Research skills • Critical skills, particularly regarding source materials and their use Coursework Details on essays, their content, word length, suggested readings, and marking criteria are detailed in a separate handout. Chert small side-notched points from Tipu, Spanish Colonial period, probably late 17 century th 3. SCHEDULE AND SYLLABUS Teaching schedule Lectures will be held on Wednesdays from 9 to 11 a.m. in Room 612 at the Institute of Archaeology, 31-34 Gordon Square, WC1H 0PY. Bill Sillar and Claudia Zehrt will coordinate most of the lectures until Prof. Graham returns. On 13th January there will be a lecture by Jago Cooper, on 27th January and 9th March there will be lectures by David Pendergast, and on 2th February a lecture by Eva Jobbova. Tutorials 5 We have no tutorials other than our two-hour class time. However, students will be expected to discuss and respond to questions in the second hour. Syllabus 6 Week 1, 13 January, Introduction to the course Jago Cooper Dr. Jago Cooper is curator of the Americas section in the British Museum and has conducted research and filming in the Maya area. Who, what, where and when? History of the interest and awareness of the people we call ‘Maya’; a short history of Maya archaeology, and a review of approaches to the study of Maya writing and archaeology. We will also review the handbook as well as essay due dates. Required: this handbook Recommended: Coe, Michael D. The Maya, Introduction; Sharer, The Ancient Maya, Preface & Introduction. Evans, Susan Toby. Ancient Mexico and Central America, Ch 1, Ancient Mesoamerica, the civilization and its antecedents. _________________________________________________________________________ ______ Week 2, 20 January, Environment and resources of the Maya area Claudia Zehrt Cultural setting, the Maya area, language roots, environmental zones, subsistence, agricultural methods, plant and animal resources and economy. Required Sharer, Ch 1; Ch 3, pp. 120-133; Ch 11. Recommended • Restall, Matthew. 2004. Maya Ethnogenesis. Journal of Latin American Anthropology 9(1): 64-89. • Graham, Elizabeth. 2011. Maya Christians and Their Churches in Sixteenth-Century Belize, Chapter Three, pp. 59-62. _________________________________________________________________________ ________ Week 3, 27 January, Excavating Maya architecture, caches, burials, tombs David Pendergast David M. Pendergast, Curator Emeritus of the Royal Ontario Museum in Toronto. Dr. Pendergast has worked in the Maya area for over 50 years and is one of the leading experts on the excavation of monumental architecture. Required No required readings from Sharer but I encourage you to peruse or read one of the recommended publications. Strongly recommended 7 Go to the library and look through any of the following publications by Coe, Pendergast, Loten. My review article might provide some insight into the nature of monumental excavation. • Coe, William R. 1990. Excavations in the Great Plaza, North Terrace and North Acropolis of Tikal, University of Pennsylvania Museum, Philadelphia. INST ARCH DFB 10 COE, 6 vols. • Pendergast, David M. Excavations at Altun Ha, Belize, 1964 to 1970. Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto. INST ARCH DFB Qto PEN, 3 vols. • Loten, H.S. and D.M. Pendergast, 1984. A Lexicon for Maya Archaeology. Archaeology Monograph 8, Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto. ISSUE DESK LOT, 3 hrs. • Graham, Elizabeth. 1993. Rats and Bats and Fluffy Stuff. A review of William R. Coe's Excavations in the Great Plaza, North Terrace and North Acropolis of Tikal. Tikal Report No. 14, Volumes I-VI, The University Museum, University of Pennsylvania, 1990. Antiquity: 67(256):660-665. _________________________________________________________________________ ________ Week 4, 3 February, Organisation of Maya society Claudia Zehrt Political and social economy, what elites ‘control’, markets, social organisation, settlement patterns, population, families, social stratification, rulers and rulership. Required Sharer, Ch. 12; Ch 2, pp 73-80. Recommended • Gillespie, Susan D. 2000. Rethinking Ancient Maya Social Organization: Replacing “Lineage” with “House.” American Antiquity 102: 467-84. And/or take a look at any of the following to get a feel for how we look at settlement, communities, and social organisation: • Ashmore, Wendy. 1981, ed. Lowland Maya Settlement Patterns. University of New Mexico Press, Albuquerque. INST ARCH DFB 100 ASH, 3 copies. • Canuto, Marcello & Jason Yaeger. 2000. The Archaeology of Communities: A New World Perspective. INST ARCH DE CAN, 1 copy. • Golden, Charles and Greg Borstede, eds. 2004. Continuities and Changes in Maya Archaeology: Perspectives at the Millennium. Routledge, London. INST ARCH DFB 100 GOL, 1 copy. • Lohse, Jon C. & Fred Valdez, Jr. 2004. Ancient Maya Commoners. INST ARCH DFB 100 LOH, 1 copy. • Wilk, Richard & Wendy Ashmore, eds. 1988. Household and Community in the Mesoamerican Past. INST ARCH DFB 100 WIL, 2 copies. _________________________________________________________________________ _________ Week 5, 10 February, Maya ideology, religion, and the Spanish Conquest Claudia Zehrt 8 What is religion? Classic Maya spirits and symbols, rulers as ‘lords’, shamans, daykeepers, archaeology and religion, cosmology, gods, creation, sanctioning rulers, the universe, the World Tree, religion and the Conquest. Required Sharer, Ch. 13; Epilogue. Recommended • Graham, Elizabeth, Scott E. Simmons and Christine D. White. 2013. The Spanish Conquest and the Maya collapse: how ‘religious’ is change? World Archaeology 45(1): 125. • Houston, Stephen D. and David Stuart. 1989. The Way Glyph: Evidence for “CoEssences” among the Classic Maya. Research Reports on Ancient Maya Writing, vol. 30. Center for Maya Research, Washington, D.C. INST ARCH DFB 600 RES. And/or have a look through: • Bassie-Sweet, Karen. 1991. From the Mouth of the Dark Cave. University of Oklahoma Press, Norman. INST ARCH DFB 100 BAS, 1 copy. • Graña Behrens, Daniel, Nikolai Grube, Christian M. Prager, Frauke Sachse, Stefanie Teufel and Elisabeth Wagner. 2004. Continuity and Change: Maya religious practices in temporal perspective. 5th European Maya Conference. INST ARCH DFB 200 Qto GRA, 1 copy. • Grube, Nikolai, Eva Eggebrecht & Matthias Seidel (eds.) 2006. Maya: Divine Kings of the Rain Forest. Könneman, Köln. INST ARCH DFB 100 Qto GRU, 1 copy. • Prufer, Keith M. & James E. Brady. 2005. Stone houses and earth lords : Maya religion in the cave context. INST ARCH DFB 100 PRU, 1 copy. • • Taube, Karl. 1992(32). The Major Gods of Ancient Yucatan. Studies in Precolumbian Art & Archaeology, No. 32. Dumbarton Oaks, Washington, D.C. Full text available on-line; also available at the Issue Desk IOA TAU, 3 hour loan. _________________________________________________________________________ _________ Week 6, 15-19 February, R E A D I N G W E E K _______________________________________________________________ _______ Week 7, 24 February, Maya history, writing, the calendar Eva Jobbova The history of decipherment, Maya glyphs, the writing system, the calendar and the world that didn’t end in 2012. Required Sharer, Ch 3, pp. 99-120, 134-152. See also Coe, Ch. 9. Recommended 9 • Bricker, Harvey & Victoria R. Bricker. 1983. Classic Maya Prediction of Solar Eclipses. Current Anthropology 24: 1-24. • Houston, Stephen D. & Alfonso Lacadena Garcia-Gallo. Maya Epigraphy at the Millennium: Personal Notes. In Charles Golden and Greg Borstede (eds.), 2004, Continuities and Changes in Maya Archaeology: Perspectives at the Millennium. INST ARCH DFB 100 GOL, 1 copy. • Matthews, Peter. 1991. Classic Maya Emblem Glyphs. In Culbert, T. Patrick, ed., Classic Maya Political History. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. INST ARCH DFB 200 CUL; ANTHROPOLOGY TK 28 CUL. • Proskouriakoff, Tatiana. 1060. Historical Implications of a Pattern of Dates at Piedras Negras. American Antiquity 25: 44-75. • Voss, A.W. 2001. Astronomy and Mathematics. In Nikolai Grube, et al. (eds.) Maya: Divine Kings of the Rain Forest. INST ARCH DFB 100 Qto GRU, 1 copy. _________________________________________________________________________ ________ Week 8, 2 March, Origins of Maya states in the Late Preclassic Claudia Zehrt Required Sharer, Ch 6, pp. 223-224, 251-286. See also Coe, Ch. 2, 3. Recommended I’ll summarise the emergence of Maya civilisation, but for further reading, Sharer, Ch. 4; Ch. 5, pp. 177-185, 201-222. _________________________________________________________________________ ________ Week 9, 9 March, Maya states in the Early Classic and Teotihuacan David Pendergast There are far fewer inscriptions from this period than exist from the Late Classic, but we will look at the sites occupied in the Early Classic, and especially at the rulers who seem to be connected to the great city of Teotihuacan in Mexico. Required Sharer, Ch 7, pp. 287-288, 292-317, 321-342, 358-376. See also Coe, Ch 4. Recommended • Wright, L.E. 2005. In Search of Yax Nuun Ayiin I: Revisiting the Tikal Project’s Burial 10. Ancient Mesoamerica 16(1), pp. 89-100. (Yax Nuun Ayiin was thought to have been from Teotihuacan.) • Braswell, G.E. (ed.) 2003. The Maya and Teotihuacan: Reinterpreting Early Classic Interaction. University of Texas Press, Austin. INST ARCH DFB 100 BRA, 2 copies 1-wk loan, 1 copy standard. (This is an edited book, but you might want to look through to see the various ways in which connections with Teotihuacan are explored; for example, Juan Pedro Laporte’s chapter, ‘Architectural aspects of interaction between Tikal and Teotihuacan during the Early Classic period’, pp. 199-216.) 10 _________________________________________________________________________ ________ Week 10, 16 March, the apogee of Maya states in the Late Classic Claudia Zehrt This is the best known period in Maya research. We will look at the major cities, their architecture, their intensive warfare, and the seeds of the collapse. Required Sharer, Ch 8, pp. 377-403, 413-421, 431-451, 492-494, 495-497. See also Coe, Ch 5. _________________________________________________________________________ _________ Week 11, 23 March, the Collapse and beyond Claudia Zehrt This week’s topic covers a great deal of territory, but we’ll attempt to look at the aftermath of collapse, the key traits of the Postclassic period, and the Spanish Conquest, particularly in Belize. Required Sharer, Chs 9, 10. See also Coe, Chs 7,8. Recommended • Aimers, J.J. 2007. What Maya Collapse? Terminal Classic Variation in the Maya Lowlands. Journal of Archaeological Research 15, pp. 329-377. • Graham, E., S.E. Simmons & C.D. White. 2013. The Spanish Conquest and the Maya Collapse: How ‘religious’ is change? World Archaeology 45(1): 1-25. _________________________________________________________________________ ________ 4. ONLINE RESOURCES Online reading list Given that the required readings are from the Sharer text, there is no online reading list for this course. The full text of this handbook as well as copies or links to recommended readings will be available on Moodle. Moodle The enrolment or access code for Moodle is: ajaw All of you should also be registered automatically for access to ARCL 3043 on Moodle. If you have any problems, contact c.frearson@ucl.ac.uk 5. ADDITIONAL INFORMATION 11 Libraries and other resources In addition to the Library of the Institute of Archaeology, other libraries with holdings of interest are the DMS Watson Science Library and the Anthropology. There is also the Centre for Anthropology library at the British Museum, accessible through the North Entrance. Attendance A register will be taken at each class. If you are unable to attend a class, please notify the lecturer by e-mail. Departments are required to report each student’s attendance to UCL Registry at frequent intervals throughout each term. Students are expected to attend at least 70% of classes. Information for intercollegiate and interdepartmental students Students enrolled in Departments outside the Institute should collect hard copy of the Institute’s coursework guidelines from Judy Medrington’s office, Room 411A. Dyslexia If you have dyslexia or any other disability, please make your lecturers aware of this. Please discuss with your lecturers whether there is any way in which they can help you. Students with dyslexia are reminded to indicate this on each piece of coursework. Feedback: In trying to make this course as effective as possible, we welcome feedback from students during the course of the year. All students are asked to give their views on the course in an anonymous questionnaire, which will be circulated at one of the last sessions of the course. These questionnaires are taken seriously and help the Course Coordinator to develop the course. The summarized responses are considered by the Institute's Staff-Student Consultative Committee, Teaching Committee, and by the Faculty Teaching Committee. If you are concerned about any aspect of this course, I would appreciate it if you would approach me first about it. If you feel this is not appropriate, or certainly if you feel consultation with me has not proved satisfactory, you should consult your Personal Tutor, Year Tutor, t he Academic Administrator (Judy Medrington), or the Chair of the Teaching Committee, Karen Wright. Maya church at Lamanai, built ca. 1560s 12