Connection Solutions for Woodframe Structures Michelle Kam-Biron, PE, SE, SECB Director of Education American Wood Council Copyright Materials This presentation is protected by US and International Copyright laws. laws Reproduction Reproduction, distribution, display and use of the presentation without written permission of the speaker is prohibited. © American Wood Council 2014 2 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 1 Learning Objectives • On completion of this course, participants will: • Be familiar with current wood connection design philosophy, behavior, and serviceability issues. • Be able to identify basic wood material properties and learn how to avoid splits, notching, and net section issues in connection solutions • Be able to recommend fastening guidelines for wood to steel, wood to concrete, and wood to wood connections. • Be able to describe effects of moisture on wood connections and implement proper detailing to mitigate issues that may occur. 3 Outline • Wood connection design philosophy • Connection behavior • Serviceability challenges • Connection hardware and fastening systems • Connection techniques • Design software • Where to get more information 4 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 2 Outline • Wood connection design philosophy • Connection behavior • Serviceability issues • Connection hardware and fastening systems • Connection techniques • Design software • Where to get more information 5 Basic Concepts • Model wood cells as a bundle of straws • Bundle is very strong parallel to axis of the straws Parallel Stronger Perpendicular Less strong 6 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 3 Connecting Wood - Philosophy • Wood likes compression parallel to grain • makes connecting wood very easy 7 Connecting Wood - Philosophy • Wood likes compression parallel to grain • makes connecting wood very easy 8 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 4 Connecting Wood - Philosophy • Wood likes to take on load spread over its surface 9 Concentrated at a single fastener – wood is more prone to split and crush Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 5 Connecting Wood - Philosophy • Wood and tension perpendicular to grain • Not recommended Initiators: • notches • large diameter fasteners • hanging loads 11 Notching Problem Solution 12 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 6 Beam to Concrete • Notched Beam Bearing • may cause splitting • not recommended Split 13 Beam to Concrete • Notched Bearing Wall • alternate to beam notch 14 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 7 Hanger to Beam • Load suspended from lower half of beam • Tension perpendicular to grain • May cause splits Split Split C N A N A T 15 Hanger to Beam Lower half of beam • may cause splits • not recommended Exception: light load Split • <100 lbs • >24” o.c. 16 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 8 Hanger to Beam Full wrap sling option Load supported in upper half of beam • • Extended plates puts wood in compression when loaded C compression N A N A T 17 Connecting Wood- Philosophy • Splitting happens because wood is relatively weak perpendicular to grain • Nails too close (act like a wedge) 18 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 9 Connecting Wood - Philosophy Staggered Nailing Framing Wood Structural Panel Nail 1/8" Gap Between Panels Nailing not staggered Nailing not staggered Nailing staggered Nailing staggered 19 Connecting Wood- Philosophy Splitting occurs parallel to grain Staggering Splitting will not occur perpendicular to grain, no matter how close nails are Staggering gg g a line of nails parallel to wood grain minimizes splitting 20 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 10 Connecting Wood - Philosophy • Wood, like other hygroscopic materials, moves in varying environments 21 Connecting Wood - Philosophy • Fastener selection is key to connection ductility, strength, performance 22 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 11 Connecting Wood - Philosophy • Mechanical fasteners • keep them small • use lots of them • Issue is scale of fastener relative to wood member size 23 Next... • Wood connection design philosophy • Connection behavior • Serviceability challenges • Connection hardware and fastening systems • Connection techniques • Design software • Where to get more information 24 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 12 Connection Behavior • Balance • Strength – • Ductility- L d Load high strength strength, poor ductility good strength, good ductility low strength, good ductility Displacement 25 Connection Behavior 26 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 13 Connection Behavior 27 Connection Behavior 28 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 14 Connection Behavior • Balance • Strength – • Size Si and d number b off fasteners • Ductility• Fastener slenderness • Spacing • End distance Load high strength, poor ductility good strength, good ductility low strength, good ductility Displacement 29 Next... • Wood connection design philosophy • Connection behavior • Serviceability challenges • Connection hardware and fastening systems • Connection techniques • Design software • Where to get more information 30 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 15 Connection Serviceability Bristlecone Pine Giant Sequoia Western Juniper 31 Connection Serviceability • Issue: direct water ingress • Water is absorbed most quickly through wood end grain No end caps or flashing 32 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 16 Connection Serviceability • Issue: direct water ingress • Re-direct the water flow around the connection end caps and flashing 33 Connection Serviceability • Issue: direct water ingress • Or, let water out if it gets in... Moisture trap No weep holes 34 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 17 Moisture Changes In Wood Causes dimensional changes perpendicular to grain Tangentially Growing tree is filled with water As wood dries, it shrinks perp. to grain Radially 35 Wood Shrinks Woodmagazine.com 36 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 18 Connection Serviceability • Moisture Effects 1% change in dimension for every 4% change MC 37 Wet Service Factor, CM • Dowel-type connectors • bolts • drift pins • drift bolts • lag screws • wood screws • nails Saturated 19% MC fabrication MC in-service MC Dry CM 1.0 1.0 1.0 0.7 0.7 0.25 0.4* Lateral load (*CM=0.7 for D<1/4″) 1.0 Withdrawal load - lag & wood screws only 0.25 Withdrawal load - nails & spikes 38 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 19 Wet Service Factor, CM CM = 1.0 if: Saturated 19% MC 1 fastener 2+ fasteners Dryy CM 0.4 Lateral load (D>1/4″) split splice plates fabrication MC in-service MC Table 10.3.3 footnote 2 39 Beam to Column • Full-depth side plates • may cause splitting • wood shrinkage 40 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 20 Beam to Column • Smaller side plates • transmit force • allow wood movement 41 Beam to Column • Problem • shrinkage • tension perp 42 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 21 Beam to Wall • Solution • b l near bottom bolts b • minimizes effect of shrinkage Slotted hardware 43 Connection Serviceability • Avoid contact with cementitious materials • Beam on Shelf • prevent contact with concrete • provide lateral resistance and uplift 44 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 22 Beam to Concrete • Beam on Wall • prevent contact with concrete • provide lateral resistance and uplift • slotted to allow longitudinal movement • typical for sloped beam 45 Beam to Masonry • Application • Application Need 1/2” air gap between wood and masonry 46 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 23 Column to Base • Problem • no weep holes in closed shoe • moisture entrapped • decay can result 47 Column to Base • Angle brackets • anchor bolts in brackets 48 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 24 Column to Base Where’s the plate? 49 Hidden Column Base • Floor slab poured over connection • will cause decay • not recommended 50 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 25 Column to Base • Floor slab poured below connection 51 Next... • Wood connection design philosophy • Connection behavior • Serviceability challenges • Connection hardware and fastening systems • Connection techniques • Design software • Where to get more information 52 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 26 Mechanical Connectors 53 Traditional Connectors • All-wood solution • time tested • practical • extreme efficiencies available with computer numeric control (CNC) machining www.tfguild.org www.timberframe.org 54 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 27 Traditional Connectors • Long History > 100 years • Uses automated Computer numerical Control (CNC) milling technology • machine joints • pre-drill holes • Timber Framer’s Guild www.tfguild.org http://www.tfguild.org/downloads/T FEC-1-2010-with-Commentary.pdf 55 Traditional Connectors • Wood dowel connection design technology now available Schmidt, R.J. (2006): Timber Pegs – Considerations for Mortise and Tenon Joint Design, Structure Magazine, March 2006, NCSEA, 13(3):44-47. http://www.structuremag.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/09/SF-Timber-Pegs-March061.pdf 56 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 28 Mechanical Connectors •Common Fasteners • Nails • Staples p • Wood Screws • Metal plate connectors • Lag screws • Bolts 57 Fastener Values • Included in U.S. design literature Fastener Type Bolts B l Lag Screws Wood Screws Nails & Spikes Split Ring Connectors Shear Plate Connectors Drift Bolts & Drift Pins Metal Plate Connectors Reference NDS or ER NDS or ER NDS or ER NDS or ER NDS NDS NDS ER Hangers & Framing Anchors ER Staples ER Evaluation Reports (ER) are developed for proprietary products 58 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 29 NDS Chapter 11 – Dowel-type Fasteners • ASD and LRFD accommodated through Table 10.3.1 • Bolts • L Lag screws • Wood screws • Nails & spikes 59 Fastener Bending Yield Test Center-Point Bending Test Load 60 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 30 Dowel Bearing Strength 61 Yield Limit Equations • 4 Modes of failure • 6 Yield equations • Single & double shear 62 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 31 Yield Modes MODE I •bearing-dominated b i d i d yield of wood fibers MODE II •pivoting of fastener with localized crushing of wood fibers 63 Yield Modes MODE III •fastener yield in b di att one bending plastic hinge and bearing – dominated yield of wood fibers MODE IV •fastener yield in bending g at two plastic hinges and bearing – dominated yield of wood fibers 64 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 32 Yield Limit Equations • 4 Modes of failure • 6 Yield equations • Single Si l & double d bl shear h • Wood-to-wood • Wood-to-Steel • Wood-to-Concrete 65 Yield Limit Equations 66 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 33 Yield Limit Equations 67 Chapter 11- Dowels 68 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 34 Updated TR 12 http://www.awc.org/publications/TR/index.php 69 TR 12 • Background and derivation of the mechanics-ba sed approach for calculating lateral connection capacity used in the NDS • Provides additional flexibility and broader applic ability to the NDS provisions. • Simplified Equations 70 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 35 TR 12 71 TR 12 Allows for evaluation of connections ti with ith gaps between connected members 72 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 36 TR 12 • 2014 Edition - New information on design of • wood members attached to hollow members • design of driven-fasteners with tapered tips • optimizing connections based on location of thre ads relative to the connection shear plane. 73 Chapter 11- Dowels 74 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 37 Chapter 11-Dowels 75 Chapter 11-Dowels Threaded length < lm/4 lm Dia. Fastener = D Threaded length < lm/4 lm Dia. Fastener = D 76 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 38 Chapter 11-Dowels lm Dia. Fastener = Dr 77 Spacing, End, & Edge Distance 2012 NDS 78 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 39 Spacing, End, & Edge Distance 2012 NDS • Unless special detailing is provided to accommodate cross-grain shrinkage of the wood member. 79 Spacing, End, & Edge Distance 2012 NDS • Adds the following notes to 11.5.1 The perpendicular to grain distance between the outermost fasteners shall not e ceed 5" (see Fig exceed Figure e 11H) unless nless special detailing is provided to accommodate cross-grain shrinkage of the wood member. For structural glued laminated timber members, the perpendicular to grain distance between the outermost fasteners shall not exceed the limits in Table 11.5.1F, unless special detailing is provided to accommodate cross-grain shrinkage of the member. For structural glued laminated timber members, the perpendicular to grain distance between the outermost fasteners shall not exceed the limits in Table 11.5.1F, unless special detailing is provided to accommodate cross-grain shrinkage of the member. 80 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 40 Spacing, End, & Edge Distance 2012 NDS • Unless special detailing is provided to accommodate cross-grain shrinkage of the wood member. 81 Local Stresses in Fastener Groups • 10.1.2 Stresses in Members at Connections • “Local Local stresses in connections using multiple fasteners shall be checked in accordance with principles of engineering mechanics. One method for determining these stresses is provided in Appendix E.” 82 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 41 Local Stresses in Fastener Groups • Closely spaced fasteners • brittle failure • lower capacity • wood failure mechanisms need to be considered in design 83 Local Stresses in Fastener Groups • Properly spaced fasteners • increased ductility • higher capacity • spread out the fasteners! 84 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 42 Local Stresses in Fastener Groups • Appendix E NDS Expressions – Net tension: ' Z NT Ft ' Anet – Row tear-out: ' Z RT ni Fv'tsmin i nrow ' ' Z RT Z RT i i 1 85 Local Stresses in Fastener Groups • Appendix E NDS Expressions – Group tear-out ' Z GT ' Z RT top 2 ' Z RT bottom Ft' Agroup net 2 • Note: spacing between outer rows of fasteners paralleling the member on a single splice plate < 5″ 86 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 43 Chapter 12 – Split Rings and Shear Plates • Geometry factor, CD • Side Grain 87 Chapter 12 – Split Rings and Shear Plates • Geometry factor, CD • End Grain 88 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 44 NDS Chapter 13 – Timber Rivets • Many applications • Canada several decades • 2005 NDS • Glued Laminated Timber • DFL • SP 89 Chapter 13- Timber Rivets • Plates • Steel ASTM A36 • Hot-dipped H t di d galvanized l i d if in wet service • Perforated Steel Plates • Fixed-hole pattern geometry • Holes sizes lock and hold rivet to prevent rotation 90 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 45 Timber Rivets - Design • Four strength limit states: Rivet yielding • • Pr – parallel to grain • Qr – perpendicular to grain Wood failure • • Pw – parallel to grain • Qw – perpendicular to grain Plate yielding • • • Enhanced ductility Lowest value governs design 91 Timber Rivets – Design 2005 NDS 92 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 46 Timber Rivets – Design 2012 NDS 93 Timber Rivets - Design • 2005 NDS • Reiterative process • Parallel to grain timber rivet capacity • Pr = 280 p0.32 nR nC (13.2-1) 188 2012 NDS Perpendicular to grain timber rivet capacity • • Qr = 160 p0.32 nR nC 108 2012 NDS • Section 13.3.1: ”The maxiumum distance perpendicular to grain between outermost rows of rivets shall be 12” 94 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 47 Where to Find Design Examples •Timber Rivet Connections • Design Process for a Hanger Connection http://www.awc.org/pdf/ WDF17-4-rivet-pw.pdf 95 Timber Rivets - Design • Flow chart per the 2005 NDS • Reiterative process 96 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 48 Design Example – 2005 NDS 97 Next... • Wood connection design philosophy • Connection behavior • Serviceability challenges • Connection hardware and fastening systems • Connection techniques • Design software • Where to get more information 98 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 49 Connection Techniques • Must evaluate: • forces present • environmental effects • material effects • aesthetics 99 Connection Techniques • Wood bolts in all-wood structure 100 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 50 Pre-engineered Connectors • Post to Beam • Beam to Beam 101 Pre-engineered Connectors • Joist to Beam (Hanger) 102 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 51 Pre-engineered Connectors • Column Cap & Base hardware 103 Pre-engineered Connectors • Hanger hardware 104 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 52 Pre-engineered Connectors • Truss hardware 105 Custom Hardware • Difficult situations made easy 106 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 53 Connection Techniques • Bolts in heavy trusses 107 Connection Techniques • Connecting other frame materials : • Steel 108 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 54 Connection Techniques • Connecting other frame materials : • Concrete 109 Connection Techniques • Steel bolts in columns Hidden kerf plates 110 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 55 Connection Techniques 111 Connection Techniques 112 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 56 Connection Techniques • Larry McFarland Architect, V Vancouver, BC • CWMM Consulting Engineers, Inc., Vancouver, BC Operations Centre Gulf Islands National Park Reserve 113 Connection Techniques 114 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 57 Connection Techniques •Regional District of Nanaimo Administration Building Expansion •Architect: Neale Staniszkis Doll Adams Architects Vancouver, BC •Owner; Regional District of Nanaimo Nanaimo, BC •General Contractor: Windley C t ti Ltd Nanaimo, Contracting N i BC •Structural Engineer: Herold Engineering Ltd. Nanaimo, BC 115 Connection Techniques 116 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 58 Custom Hardware • A blend of art and technology 117 Concealed Connectors • Proprietary Systems 118 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 59 Concealed Connectors • Hollow steel connection tube • Expanding cross pins 119 Concealed Connectors • Self-tapping dowel s-w-s • Threaded screw w-w 120 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 60 Connection Techniques •Kwantlen Polytechnic University •Cloverdale Campus • Bunting Coady Architects, Vancouver, BC • Bush Bohlman & Partners, Inc., Vancouver, BC 121 Connection Techniques 122 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 61 Connection Techniques 123 Concealed Connectors • Shaped steel shaft • Steel pins or dowels • Non-shrink grout 124 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 62 Connection Techniques •Raleigh-Durham International Airport • Fentress Architects • Denver, D CO • Washington, DC • Stewart Engineering, Inc. •Raleigh, NC • Archer Western Contractors •Raleigh, NC 125 Connection Techniques 126 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 63 Connection Techniques 127 Concealed Connectors • Steel pipe • Stitch bolts • Tie-Bolt 128 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 64 Concealed Connectors 129 Concealed Connectors 130 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 65 Connection Techniques •Arena Stage at the Mead Center for American Theater • Bing Thom Architects • Fast + Epp Structural Engineers • Clark Construction 131 Connection Techniques •Arena Stage at the Mead Center for American Theater 132 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 66 Connection Techniques •Richmond Olympic Oval CANNON Design Gerald Epp, Fast + Epp Richmond (south of Vancouver) 133 Connection Techniques •Richmond Olympic Oval CANNON Design Gerald Epp, Fast + Epp Richmond (south of Vancouver) 134 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 67 Connection Techniques •Myrick Hixon EcoPark Building - WI Whole Trees Architecture, Stoddard, WI 135 Next... • Wood connection design philosophy • Connection behavior • Serviceability challenges • Connection hardware and fastening systems • Connection techniques • Design software • Where to get more information 136 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 68 Software Solutions Exist •WWPA Lumber Design Suite • Beams B and d JJoists i t • Post and Studs • Wood to Wood Shear Connections (nails, bolts, wood screws and lag screws) http://www2.wwpa.org/TECHGUIDEPAGES/DesignSoftware/tabi d/859/Default.aspx 137 Connection Calculator AWC.org 138 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 69 Next... • Wood connection design philosophy • Connection behavior • Serviceability challenges • Connection hardware and fastening systems • Connection techniques • Design software • Where to get more information 139 More info… 2012 NDS 140 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 70 More info… M4.4 M4 4 Special Design Considerati ons • Mechanical Connections • Dowel-Type Fasteners • Split Ring and Shear Plates Connectors • Timber Rivets http://www.awc.org/pdf/2012ASD-LRFD_Manual_WEB.pdf 141 More info??? 2015 142 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 71 More info??? • Technical papers on Timber rivets: http://www.awc.org/helpoutreach/faq/faqFiles/Timber_rivets.html • • • • • • • Timber rivets in structural composite lumber Simplified analysis of timber rivet connections Timber rivet connections in U.S. domestic species Timber Rivets-Structure Magazine Seismic Behavior of Timber Rivets in Wood Construction Seismic Se s c Performance e o a ce o of Riveted eted Co Connections ect o s in Heavy ea y Timber be Construction Timber rivet suppliers 143 More info??? • Load-carrying behavior of steel-to-timber dowel connections: http://timber.ce.wsu.edu/Resources/papers/2-4-1.pdf • New Concealed Connectors Bring More Options for Timber Structures http://www.structuremag.org/Archives/20071/p42-43D-Insights-ConcealedConnectorsJan07.pdf 144 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 72 Take Home Messages... • Transfer loads in compression / bearing whenever possible • Allow for dimensional changes in the wood due to potential in- service moisture cycling • Avoid the use of details which induce tension perp stresses in the wood • Avoid moisture entrapment in connections • Separate wood from direct contact with masonry or concrete • Avoid eccentricity in joint details • Minimize exposure of end grain 145 Connections …and and you thought connecting wood was complicated! 146 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 73 147 Questions? www.awc.org info@awc.org 148 Copyright © 2014 American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 74