American Wood Council www.awc.org 2015 NDS® Changes John “Buddy” Showalter, PE Vice President, Technology Transfer American Wood Council Michelle Kam-Biron, PE, SE, SECB Director of Education American Wood Council Copyright Materials This presentation is protected by US and International Copyright laws. Reproduction, distribution, display and use of the presentation without written permission of AWC is prohibited. © American Wood Council 2015 2 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 1 American Wood Council www.awc.org Course Description AWC's National Design Specification (NDS) for Wood Construction 2015 is the dual format Allowable Stress Design (ASD) and Load and Resistance g (LRFD) ( ) document referenced in US building g codes and used Factor Design to design wood structures worldwide. Participants will learn about changes in the 2015 NDS and Supplement relative to previous editions and gain an overview of the standard. 4 Objectives Upon completion, participants will be: 1. Able to understand the load and material resistance design process and how it applies to wood structural design. 2. Familiar with the significant changes between the 2012 and 2015 NDS and supplement. 3. Able to identify the similarities and differences with respect to ASD, design values, and behavioral equations. 4. Able to analyze y format and content within the 2015 NDS. 5 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 2 American Wood Council www.awc.org Outline • Overview • Design Process Overview • NDS • Chapter-by-chapter discussion • Changes from previous editions • Summary • More Info 6 NDS History 1944 1977 2001 1962 1982 2005 1968 1986 2012 1971 1991 2015 1973 1997 7 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 3 American Wood Council www.awc.org Governing Codes for Wood Design 2015 NDS referenced in 2015 IBC 8 ANSI Accreditation • AWC –ANSI-accredited standards developer • Consensus Body y • Wood Design Standards Committee 9 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 4 American Wood Council www.awc.org 2015 NDS – Primary Change New Provisions to Address CLT • Charging Language • Design Values • Design Equations • Product Chapter g • Connection Design • Fire Design 10 2015 NDS Chapter Reorganization 2012 NDS 2015 NDS • 1-3 General • 1-3 General • 4-9 Products • 4-10 Products +CLT • 10-13 Connections • 11-14 Connections • 14 Shear Walls & Diaphragms • Shear Walls & Diaphragms • 15 Special Loading • 15 Special Loading • 16 Fire Fi • 16 Fire Fi 11 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 5 American Wood Council www.awc.org Outline • Overview • Design Process Overview • NDS • Chapter-by-chapter discussion • Changes from previous editions • Summary • M IInfo f More 12 Design Process Demand Capacity 13 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 6 American Wood Council www.awc.org Design Process Load Support Conditions Geometry Materials Performance Fire Economics Aesthetics …. Demand Capacity 14 Design Concepts Two Limit State concerns • Serviceability (performance in-service) • Safety against failure or collapse 15 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 7 American Wood Council www.awc.org Serviceability • ASD and LRFD • Unfactored loads • Mean (avg) material strength values 16 Safety • ASD • Unfactored U acto ed loads oads • Material strength values - modified • LRFD • Factored loads • Material strength values – modified less 17 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 8 American Wood Council www.awc.org Structural Property Variability Normal Distribution Curves x = mean x = standard deviation x x x R Relative Frequency SCL x COVx = I-Joist x Coefficient of variation Load Glulam MSR Lumber Vi ll Graded G d d Visually Lumber Material Property Values 18 Engineered Wood Design S>R Failure 19 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 9 American Wood Council www.awc.org LRFD vs ASD ASD •applied stress allowable stress Theoretical safety margin applied to material stresses Estimated Loads Design Load Adjusted Resistance Tested material strength Design values 26 LRFD vs ASD LRFD •factored load factored resistance Member performance factor Load factors to account for variations in loads Estimated loads Factored Design Load Factored Design Resistanc e Design values Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. Tested member resistance 27 10 American Wood Council www.awc.org 2015 NDS LRFD Basic Load Combinations ASCE 7-10 28 2015 NDS ASD Basic Load Combinations ASCE 7-10 29 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 11 American Wood Council www.awc.org 2005 NDS & ASCE 7-02 LRFD vs. ASD Load Combinations http://www.awc.org/publications/Papers/WDF 15-4-LRFDvASD.pdf 30 2015 NDS Format Conversion Factor KF ASD RN = CDRASD LRFD RN = KF RASD RASD reference strengths 31 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 12 American Wood Council www.awc.org 2015 NDS Reliability indices or data confidence factors 32 2015 NDS tied to ASCE 7 Factored Loads •Baseline 10 min (ASD uses 10 yrs) Permanent Long term Short term 33 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 13 American Wood Council www.awc.org 2015 NDS RN = KF RASD KF converts reference design values (ASD normal load duration) to LRFD reference resistance 34 Outline • Overview • Design Process Overview • NDS • • Chapter-by-chapter discussion • Changes from previous editions • Summary More Info 36 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 14 American Wood Council www.awc.org NDS 2015 Chapters 1. 2. 3. General Requirements for Building Design Design Values for Structural Members Design Provisions and Equations 4. 4 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. Sawn Lumber S L b Structural Glued Laminated Timber Round Timber Poles and Piles Prefabricated Wood I-Joists Structural Composite Lumber Wood Structural Panels Cross-Laminated Timber 11. 12. 13. 14. Mechanical Connections Dowel-Type Fasteners Split Ring and Shear Plate Connectors Timber Rivets 15. Special Loading Conditions 16. Fire Design of Wood Members 37 NDS 2015 Supplement 1. 2. 3. 4. Sawn Lumber Grading Agencies Species Combinations Section Properties Reference Design Values • Sawn Lumber and Timber • MSR and MEL • Decking • Non-North American Sawn Lumber • Structural Glued Laminated Timber • Timber Poles and Piles 38 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 15 American Wood Council www.awc.org NDS 2015 Appendices A. B. C. D. E E. F. G. H. I. J. K. L L. M. N. Construction and Design Practices Load Duration (ASD Only) Temperature Effects Lateral Stability of Beams L Local l Stresses St iin F Fastener t G Groups Design for Creep and Critical Deflection Applications Effective Column Length Lateral Stability of Columns Yield Limit Equations for Connections Solution of Hankinson Equation Typical Dimensions for Split Ring and Shear Plate Connectors Typical Dimensions for Standard Hex Bolts Bolts, Hex Lag Screws, Wood Screws, Common, Box, and Sinker Nails Manufacturing Tolerances for Rivets and Steel Side Plates for Timber Rivet Connections Appendix for Load and Resistance Factor Design (LRFD) – Mandatory 39 NDS – Chapter 1 40 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 16 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 1 - Terminology fb ≤ Fb' Reference design values (Fb, Ft, Fv, Fc, Fc, E, Emin) Adjusted design values (Fb', Ft', Fv', Fc', Fc', E', Emin') 41 Chapter 1 – Design Loads • Reference loads • Minimum load standards • ASCE 7 – 10 42 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 17 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 1 – CLT Charging Language 43 NDS – Chapter 2 44 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 18 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 2 – Adjustment Factors Reliability indices or data confidence factors 45 Chapter 2 – Adjustment Factors RN = KF RASD KF converts reference design values (ASD normal load duration) to LRFD reference resistance 46 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 19 American Wood Council www.awc.org Appendix N – Adjustment Factors tied to ASCE 7 Factored Loads: Baseline 10 minutes (ASD uses 10 years) Permanent Long term Sh t term Short t 47 Chapter 2 – Adjustment Factors Adjusts from reference to site conditions • CD ttime-dependent e depe de t Baseline 10 years 48 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 20 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 2 – Adjustment Factors Adjusts from reference to site conditions • Ct te temperature pe atu e Exposed for “sustained” period 49 Chapter 2 – Adjustment Factors Adjusts from reference to site conditions • CM wet service factor 50 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 21 American Wood Council www.awc.org Wet Service Conditions 30 Wood EMC % 25 20 Temp Temp 15 Temp 10 5 0 0 20 40 60 80 100 51 %Strength at 12% Moisture % e Content Wet Service Conditions 110 100 90 Impact Strength 80 Modulus of Elasticity 70 Modulus of Rupture Crushing Strength 60 50 40 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 Moisture Content of Wood (%) 52 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 22 American Wood Council www.awc.org Wet Service Factor, CM • Sawn lumber MC < 19% considered dry • Otherwise, NDS Supplement for lumber 53 Chapter 2 – CLT Design Values 54 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 23 American Wood Council www.awc.org NDS – Chapter 3 55 Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations ASD vs LRFD – adjusted stresses from reference • ASD F′n = Fn CD x adjustment factors • LRFD F′n = Fn KF n x adjustment factors 56 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 24 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations Beams • CL beam stability Critical Buckling Design Value for bending members 57 Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations Columns • CP column stability Critical Buckling Design Value for compression members 58 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 25 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations E min 1.03 E (1 1.645 (COV E )) / 1.66 E 1.03 1.66 COVE = reference MOE = adjustment factor to convert E to a pure bending basis (shear-free) (use 1.05 for glulam) = factor of safety = coefficient of variation in MOE (NDS Appendix F) OR Emin values published in NDS Supplement 59 Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations Tension members (tension parallel to grain) • ASD F′t = Ft CD x adjustment factors • LRFD F′t = Ft KF t x adjustment factors 60 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 26 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations Tension perpendicular to grain • Not recommended per NDS 3 3.8.2 82 initiators: • notches • moment connections • hanging loads 61 Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations Combined bi-axial bending and axial compression 62 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 27 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations Combined bi-axial bending and axial compression 63 Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations Bearing perpendicular to grain • F′c = Fc CM Ct Ci Cb (ASD) • F′c = Fc CM Ct Ci Cb Kf c (LRFD) 64 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 28 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 3 – CLT Design Equations New 65 Chapter 3 – CLT Design Equations New NDS Commentary – guidance on CP Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 66 29 American Wood Council www.awc.org NDS – Chapter 4 67 Chapter 4 – Lumber Design values • Visually graded lumber • MSR / MEL • Timber • Decking 68 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 30 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 4 – Lumber Lumber adjustment factors 69 Chapter 4 – Lumber Lumber adjustment factors • CF - size factor 70 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 31 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 4 – Lumber Lumber adjustment factors 71 Chapter 4 – Lumber Lumber adjustment factors • Repetitive member • Cr = 1.15 • 2” – 4” lumber • < 24” o.c. • 3 or more members • Load distributing element 72 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 32 American Wood Council www.awc.org NDS – Chapter 5 73 Chapter 5 – Glulam Adjustment factors 74 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 33 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 5 – Glulam • Adjustment factors • CV Volume Factor • CL Beam Stability B St bilit Factor F t • Not cumulative with CL • Min (Cv, CL) 75 NDS – Chapter 6 76 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 34 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 6 – Poles & Piles • Poles - post-frame • Piles Pil - foundations f d ti 77 Chapter 6 – Timber Piles Design values • NDS Supplement 78 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 35 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 6 – Poles & Piles Adjustment factors 79 NDS – Chapter 7 80 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 36 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 7 – I-joists • Design values • M, V, EI, K – no changes • Evaluation l i Reports • Contain proprietary design 81 Chapter 7 – I-Joists Adjustment factors 82 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 37 American Wood Council www.awc.org NDS – Chapter 8 83 Chapter 8 – Structural Composite Lumber • Design Values • Evaluation Reports • Contain proprietary design Relative Frequency x = mean COVxx= x SCL I-Joist Glulam x MSR Lumber Load Visually Graded Lumber Material Property Values 84 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 38 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 8 – Structural Composite Lumber • New products • Laminated Strand Lumber (LSL) • Oriented Strand Lumber (OSL) • ASTM D5456 85 Chapter 8 – Structural Composite Lumber • Adjustment factors • CV – volume Cv < 1.0 1 0 Not cumulative with lateral stability factor, factor CL, then min min. (Cv, CL) Cv > 1.0 Cumulative with lateral stability factor, CL 86 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 39 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 8 – Structural Composite Lumber • Adjustment factors • Cr Repetitive Member Factor = 1.04 • Cr is different than lumber (Cr lumber = 1.15) • Applies to Fb only 87 NDS – Chapter 9 88 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 40 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 9 – Wood Structural Panels Design values – obtain from an approved source • FbS • FtA • Fvtv • Fs • FcA • EI • EA • Gvtv • Fc 89 Chapter 9 – Wood Structural Panels Adjustment factors 90 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 41 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 9 – Wood Structural Panels Adjustment factors • CM - wet service • Ct - temperature 91 NDS – Chapter 10 New 92 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 42 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 10 – Cross-Laminated Timber New 93 Chapter 10 – Cross-Laminated Timber New 94 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 43 American Wood Council www.awc.org NDS – Chapter 11 Ch 10 Ch 11 95 Chapter 11 – Mechanical Connections • Design issues • Reference design values • Ch t 12 – dowel-type Chapter d lt connectors t ((nails, il bolts, b lt lag/wood l / d screws)) • Chapter 13 – split rings and shear plates • Chapter 14 – timber rivets • Adjustment factors • No significant changes • Connections session 96 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 44 American Wood Council www.awc.org NDS – Chapter 12 Ch 11 Ch 12 97 Yield Limit Equations • 4 Yield Modes • 6 Yield Equations • Single & Double Shear • Wood-to-Wood • Wood-to-Steel • Wood-to-Concrete 98 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 45 American Wood Council www.awc.org Yield Modes MODE I •bearing-dominated b i d i d yield of wood fibers MODE II •pivoting of fastener with localized crushing of wood fibers 99 Yield Modes MODE III •fastener yield in b di att one bending plastic hinge and bearing – dominated yield of wood fibers MODE IV •fastener yield in bending at two plastic hinges and bearing – dominated yield of wood fibers 100 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 46 American Wood Council www.awc.org Dowel Bearing Strength 101 Fastener Bending Yield Strength Load 102 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 47 American Wood Council www.awc.org Fastener Bending Yield Strength 103 Chapter 12 – Dowel-type Fasteners New 104 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 48 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 12 – Dowel-type Fasteners New 105 Chapter 12 – Dowel-type Fasteners New 106 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 49 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 12 – Dowel-type Fasteners New Non-uniform for CLT 107 Chapter 12 – Dowel-type Fasteners • Adjust lm or ls to compensate for orthogonal grain orientations in adjacent layers • Parallel to grain: Fe/Feǁǁ Example: ½” bolt in southern pine 3-ply CLT with 1-½” laminations lm = t1ǁ + t2 + t3ǁ = 3(1.5) = 4.5” lm-adj = t1ǁ + t2(Fe/Feǁ) + t3ǁ =1.5 +1.5(3650/6150) +1.5 = 3.9” 108 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 50 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 12 – Dowel-type Fasteners New 109 Chapter 12 – Dowel-type Fasteners • Lateral – any end grain • D<1/4”Ceg=0.67 • Lateral – any CLT edge New • D>1/4” Ceg=0.67 110 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 51 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 12-Dowels 111 Chapter 12-Dowels 112 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 52 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 12-Dowels Threaded length < lm/4 lm Dia. Fastener = D lm Threaded length < lm/4 Dia. Fastener = D 113 Chapter 12-Dowels lm Dia. Fastener = Dr 114 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 53 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 12 - Dowels Provide tools for the analysis of • gaps between members • various fastener bending moment configurations • fasteners through hollow members • fasteners with tapered tips http://www.awc.org/publications/TR/index.php 115 NDS – Chapter 13 Ch 12 Ch 13 116 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 54 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 13 – Split Rings and Shear Plates Design Values 117 NDS – Chapter 14 Ch 13 Ch 14 118 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 55 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 14 – Timber Rivets Many applications 119 Chapter 14 – Timber Rivets Design Values Capacities > 100 kips Ch 13 Ch 14 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 120 56 American Wood Council www.awc.org NDS – Chapter 15 121 Chapter 15 – Special Loading 122 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 57 American Wood Council www.awc.org NDS – Chapter 16 123 Chapter 16 – Fire (ASD) • Fire resistance up to two hours • Columns • Beams • Tension Members • ASD only • Products • • • • • Lumber Glulam SCL Decking g CLT - NEW … 124 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 58 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 16 – Calculated Resistance • Fire resistance of exposed wood members may be calculated using the provisions of NDS Chapter 16 125 Fire Resistance Glulam Steel 126 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 59 American Wood Council www.awc.org Performance of Wood vs. Steel 127 Chapter 16 – Fire Design - CLT New 128 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 60 American Wood Council www.awc.org Chapter 16 – Fire (ASD) Technical Report No. 10 • Background ac g ou d on o NDS S provisions p o so s • Design examples • Floor assembly lumber joist provisions 129 Chapter 16 – Fire (ASD) Code Updates Design of Fire FireResistive Exposed Wood Members http://www.awc.org/publications /download.php p p 130 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 61 American Wood Council www.awc.org NDS – Appendices 131 NDS 2015 Appendices A B C D E F Construction and Design Practices Load Duration Temperature Effects Lateral Stability of Beams Local oca St Stresses esses in Fastener aste e Groups G oups Design for Creep and Critical Deflection Applications G Effective Column Length H Lateral Stability of Columns I Yield Limit Equations for Connections J Solution of Hankinson Equation K Typical Dimensions for Split Ring and Shear Plate Connectors L Typical Dimensions for Standard Hex Bolts, l Hex Lag Screws, Wood d Screws, Common, Box, and Sinker Nails M Manufacturing Tolerances for Rivets and Steel Side Plates for Timber Rivet Connections N Appendix for Load and Resistance Factor Design (LRFD) 132 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 62 American Wood Council www.awc.org 2015 NDS – Summary New Provisions to Address CLT • Charging Language • Design Values • Design Equations • Product Chapter • Connection Design • Fire Design 133 What’s Missing for CLT? Seismic Design! • ASCE 7 Minimum Design Loads for g and Other Structures Buildings • Response Modification Coefficient, R • CLT not recognized system in ASCE 7 Table 12.2-1 • Options • Performance-based design procedure per ASCE 7 • Demonstrating equivalence to an existing ASCE 7 system • ASCE 7-10, FEMA P695, and FEMA P795 Quantification of Building Seismic Performance Factors; Component Equivalency Methodology Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 134 63 American Wood Council www.awc.org Outline • Overview • Design Process Overview • NDS • Chapter-by-chapter discussion • Changes from previous editions • Summary • More Info 135 2015 NDS Supplement • New Southern Pine Design Values • ALSC approves design values • • AWC compiles them • • June 1, 2013 NDS Supplement More information • www.spib.org • www southernpine com www.southernpine.com 136 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 64 American Wood Council www.awc.org Availability • www.awc.org PDF versions • • Free view-only • Buy a printable PDF Spring 2015 • • C Commentary t • Printed version 137 Technical Articles • Structure Magazine 2015 NDS • • January 2015 2015 SDPWS • • July 2015 • www.awc.org 138 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 65 American Wood Council www.awc.org Questions? info@awc.org www.awc.org 140 Copyright © American Wood Council. All rights reserved. 66