Designing with AWC’s 2012 National Design Specification® (NDS®) for Wood Construction John “Buddy” Showalter, PE Vice President, Technology Transfer American Wood Council Michelle Kam-Biron, PE, SE, SECB Director of Education American Wood Council Copyright Material This presentation is protected by US and International Copyright laws laws. Reproduction, Reproduction distribution, display and use of the presentation without written permission is prohibited. © American Wood Council 2014 Copyright © American Wood Council 1 Description AWC's National Design Specification (NDS) for Wood Construction 2012 is the dual format Allowable Stress Design (ASD) and Load and Resistance Factor Design (LRFD) document referenced in US building codes and used to design wood structures worldwide. Participants will learn about changes in the 2012 NDS and Supplement relative to previous editions and gain an overview of the standard. standard Learning Objectives On completion of this course, participants will: • • • • Be able to understand Load and Resistance Factor Design (LRFD) and how it applies to wood structural design. Be familiar with the significant changes between the 2005 and 2012 NDS and supplement. Be able to identify the similarities and differences with respect to ASD, design values, and behavioral equations Be e able ab e to analyze a a y e format o at a and d co content te t within t tthe e 2012 0 NDS. Copyright © American Wood Council 2 Polling Question 1. What is your profession? a) Architect b) Engineer c) Code Official d) Building Designer e) Other Outline • Overview • LRFD Primer • NDS • • Chapter-by-chapter discussion • Changes from previous editions • Summary M More I f Info. Copyright © American Wood Council 3 Outline • Overview • LRFD Primer • NDS • • Chapter-by-chapter discussion • Changes from previous editions • Summary M More IInfo. f NDS History 1944 1973 1991 1962 1977 1997 1968 1982 2001 1971 1986 2005 Copyright © American Wood Council 4 NDS History International Building Code • SECTION 2306 ALLOWABLE STRESS DESIGN • 2306 1 Allowable stress design. 2306.1 design The structural analysis and construction of wood elements in structures using allowable stress design shall be in accordance with the following applicable standards: • American Forest & Paper Association. • NDS National Design Specification for Wood Construction • 2307.1 Load and resistance factor design. • The structural analysis and construction of wood elements and structures using load and resistance factor design shall be in accordance with AF&PA NDS. Copyright © American Wood Council 5 NDS and Supplement • 2005 • 16 Chapters • 14 Appendices NDS 2012 Approval • ANSI approval • August 15, 2011 • 2012 IBC Reference Copyright © American Wood Council 6 NDS and Supplement 2005 • 16 Chapters • 14 Appendices 2012 • 16 Chapters • 14 Appendices Wood Design Package 2005 Wood Design Package Copyright © American Wood Council 2012 Wood Design Package 7 Addenda/Errata • Publications Addenda/Errata • Comprehensive List • http://awc org/publications/update/index html http://awc.org/publications/update/index.html • Free download Outline • Overview • LRFD Primer • NDS • • Chapter-by-chapter discussion • Changes from previous editions • Summary M More IInfo. f Copyright © American Wood Council 8 Design Process Demand Capacity Design Process Load Support Conditions Geometry Materials Performance Fire Economics Aesthetics …. Copyright © American Wood Council Demand Capacity 9 Design Concepts Two Limit State concerns: • Serviceability (performance in-service) • Safety against failure or collapse Serviceability • Unfactored loads • Mean (avg) material strength values Copyright © American Wood Council 10 LRFD - Safety • Factored loads • Material strength values - modified Structural Property Variability Normal Distribution Curves x = mean x = standard deviation x x x Relative Frequency R SCL x COVx = I-Joist x Coefficient of variation Load Glulam MSR Lumber Vi Visually ll G Graded d d Lumber Material Property Values Copyright © American Wood Council 11 Engineered Wood Design S>R Failure Statistical Model • Normal Distribution Curves for Safety Function, Z fZ = fR - fS mZ = mR - mS z R2 S2 Safety (or reliability ) Index m z z Probability of failure of structure Copyright © American Wood Council Performance Distribution (Z) 12 Probability of Failure Pf = one failure expected for x number of structures designed and built with a given • Safety (or reliability index) Ex. = 3.2 represents 1 failure for every 1 1,000 000 structures or members designed. • 5.2 4.7 4.2 3.7 3.2 2.7 2.2 Pf 1 : 10,000,000 1 : 1,000,000 1 : 100,000 1 : 10,000 1 : 1,000 1 : 100 1 : 10 LRFD - Range on • • Structural Design Range for Strength Various Materials Pf Copyright © American Wood Council Low 2.4 1 : 25 Typical 2.6 1 : 63 High 2.9 1 : 251 13 LRFD Design Equation Demand Capacity p y n Q Rn i=1 b = Safety or Reliability Index = Load Factor = Reliability Index = Time effect factor (replaces LDF) Allowable Stress Design • What stays the same? • Same basic equation format • Same adjustment factors • Same behavioral equations Copyright © American Wood Council 14 LRFD vs. ASD • Three new notations - , , and KF • Design g loads (factored) ( ) for safetyy are bigger • Design loads (unfactored) for serviceability are the same • Material resistance values are bigger • Load d Duration Factor changes h to Time Effect Factor LRFD vs. ASD •ASD •applied stress allowable stress Theoretical safety margin applied to material stresses Estimated Loads Design Load Adjusted Resistance Tested material strength Design values Copyright © American Wood Council 15 LRFD vs. ASD •LRFD •factored load factored resistance Member performance factor Load factors to account for variations in loads Estimated loads Factored Design Load Factored Design Resistanc e Tested member resistance Design values 2012 NDS • Factored Load Combinations ASCE 7-10 Copyright © American Wood Council 16 NDS 2012 LRFD Specification •Format Conversion Factor KF: ASD RN = CDRASD LRFD RN = KF RASD RASD reference strengths 2012 NDS Reliability indices or data confidence factors Copyright © American Wood Council 17 2012 NDS Baseline 10 minutes (ASD uses 10 years) • tied to ASCE 7 Factored Loads: Permanent Long term Short term 2012 NDS RN = KF RASD KF converts reference design values (ASD normal load duration) to LRFD reference resistance Copyright © American Wood Council 18 Why use LRFD? • Ease of designing with multiple materials • Does not penalize material strength for unknowns on loads • Realize efficiencies with • Multiple transient live loads • Extreme event loads • ASD load combinations have not been maintained in deference to LRFD load combinations Polling Question 2. Format Conversion Factor, KF a) is only used with ASD b) is not necessary when calculating shear strength using LRFD c) converts ASD material reference design values from the 2012 NDS Supplement for use with LRFD d) converts LRFD material reference design values from the 2012 NDS Supplement for use with ASD Copyright © American Wood Council 19 Outline • Overview • LRFD Primer • NDS • • Chapter-by-chapter discussion • Changes from previous editions • Summary M More IInfo. f NDS 2012 Chapters 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. Copyright © American Wood Council General Requirements for Building Design Design Values for Structural Members Design Provisions and Equations Sawn Lumber Sa u be Structural Glued Laminated Timber Round Timber Poles and Piles Prefabricated Wood I-Joists Structural Composite Lumber Wood Structural Panels Mechanical Connections Dowel-Type Fasteners Split Ring and Shear Plate Connectors Timber Rivets Shear Walls and Diaphragms Special Loading Conditions Fire Design of Wood Members Commentary!!! 20 NDS 2012 Supplement 1. 2. 3. 4. Sawn Lumber Grading Agencies Species Combinations Section Properties Reference Design Values • Lumber and Timber • Non-North American Sawn Lumber • Structural Glued Laminated Timber • MSR and MEL • Timber Poles and Piles NDS 2012 Appendices A. B. C. D. E E. F. G. H. I. J. K. L L. M. N. Copyright © American Wood Council Construction and Design Practices Load Duration (ASD Only) Temperature Effects Lateral Stability of Beams L Local l Stresses St iin F Fastener t G Groups Design for Creep and Critical Deflection Applications Effective Column Length Lateral Stability of Columns Yield Limit Equations for Connections Solution of Hankinson Equation Typical Dimensions for Split Ring and Shear Plate Connectors Typical Dimensions for Standard Hex Bolts Bolts, Hex Lag Screws, Wood Screws, Common, Box, and Sinker Nails Manufacturing Tolerances for Rivets and Steel Side Plates for Timber Rivet Connections Appendix for Load and Resistance Factor Design (LRFD) – Mandatory 21 NDS – Chapter 1 Chapter 1 - Terminology fb ≤ Fb' Reference design values (Fb, Ft, Fv, Fc, Fc, E, Emin) Adjusted design values (Fb', Ft', Fv', Fc', Fc', E', Emin') Allowable (changed in the 2005) Copyright © American Wood Council 22 Chapter 1 – Design Loads • Reference loads • Minimum load standards • ASCE 7 – 10 NDS – Chapter 2 Copyright © American Wood Council 23 Chapter 2 – Adjustment Factors Reliability indices or data confidence factors Appendix N – Adjustment Factors tied to ASCE 7 Factored Loads: Baseline 10 minutes (ASD uses 10 years) Permanent Long term Sh t term Short t Copyright © American Wood Council 24 Chapter 2 – Adjustment Factors Revised ASTM D5457-10 RN = KF RASD KF converts reference design values (ASD normal load duration) to LRFD reference resistance Chapter 2 – Adjustment Factors • Adjusts from reference to site conditions • CD ttime-dependent e depe de t Copyright © American Wood Council Baseline 10 years 25 Chapter 2 – Adjustment Factors • Adjusts from reference to site conditions • Ct te temperature pe atu e factor acto Exposed for “sustained” period Chapter 2 – Adjustment Factors • Wet Service Factor, CM Copyright © American Wood Council 26 Wet Service Conditions 30 Wood EMC % 25 20 Temp 30 deg F 15 Temp 70 deg F Temp 130 deg F 10 5 0 0 20 40 60 80 100 Relative Humidity % %Strength at 12% Moisture % e Content Wet Service Conditions 110 100 90 Impact Strength 80 Modulus of Elasticity 70 Modulus of Rupture Crushing Strength 60 50 40 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 Moisture Content of Wood (%) Copyright © American Wood Council 27 Wet Service Factor, CM • Sawn lumber MC < 19% considered dry • Otherwise, NDS Supplement for lumber Polling Question 3. Temperature Factor Ct applies to conditions where the wood temperatures exceed: a) b) c) d) 100 degrees F for sustained periods of time 100 degrees F for short period of time 100 degrees F at any time 100 degrees C at any time Copyright © American Wood Council 28 NDS – Chapter 3 Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations ASD vs LRFD – adjusted stresses from reference • ASD F′n = Fn CD x adjustment factors • LRFD F′n = Fn KF n x adjustment factors Copyright © American Wood Council 29 Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations • Beams • CL beam stabilityy • Critical Buckling Design Value for bending members Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations • Beams FbE Equivalence 1.20E'min K bEE' FbE R b2 R b2 2012/2005 NDS 2001 NDS • Emin adjusted for safety for both ASD and LRFD processes • RB = Slenderness Slende ness Ratio Copyright © American Wood Council 30 Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations • Columns • CP column stability Critical Buckling Design Value for compression members Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations • Columns • FcE equivalence FcE 0.822E'min le d 2 2012/2005 NDS Copyright © American Wood Council K cEE' le d 2 2001 NDS 31 Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations E min 1.03 E (1 1.645 (COV E )) / 1.66 E 1.03 1.66 COVE = reference MOE = adjustment factor to convert E to a pure bending basis (shear-free) (use 1.05 for glulam) = factor of safety = coefficient of variation in MOE (NDS Appendix F) OR Emin values published in NDS Supplement Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations Tension members (tension parallel to grain) • ASD F′t = Ft CD • LRFD F′t = Ft KF t Copyright © American Wood Council x adjustment factors x adjustment factors 32 Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations • Wood and tension perpendicular to grain • Not recommended per NDS 3.8.2 initiators: • notches • moment connections • hanging loads Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations • Combined bi-axial bending and axial compression Copyright © American Wood Council 33 Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations • Combined bi-axial bending and axial compression New Added to account for possible negative value in denonimator of third term of equation 3.9-3 Chapter 3 – Behavioral Equations • Bearing perpendicular to grain • F′c = Fc CM Ct Ci Cb (ASD) • F′c = Fc CM Ct Ci Cb Kf c (LRFD) Copyright © American Wood Council 34 NDS – Chapter 4 Chapter 4 – Lumber •Design values • Visually graded lumber • MSR / MEL • Timber • Decking Copyright © American Wood Council 35 Chapter 4 – Lumber •Lumber adjustment factors • KF and Chapter 4 – Lumber •Lumber adjustment factors • KF and Copyright © American Wood Council 36 Chapter 4 – Lumber • Lumber adjustment factors • CF - size factor Chapter 4 – Lumber • Lumber adjustment factors Copyright © American Wood Council 37 Chapter 4 – Lumber • Lumber adjustment factors • repetitive member • Cr = 1.15 • 2” – 4” lumber • < 24” o.c. • 3 or more • Load distributing element NDS – Chapter 5 Copyright © American Wood Council 38 Chapter 5 – Glulam • Significant changes • New adjustment factors t ti • St Stress iinteraction • Shear reduction • Clarified or added • Curved members p • Double-tapered • Tapered straight Chapter 5 – Glulam • New adjustment factors Stress interaction • • Tapered d • Timber Construction manual Shear reduction • • • NDS footnote Non-prismatic Copyright © American Wood Council 39 Chapter 5 – Glulam • Clarified or added • Curved members • Double-tapered • Tapered straight Chapter 5 – Glulam • Adjustment factors • CV Volume Factor • CL Beam B St Stability bilit Factor F t • Not cumulative with CL • Min (Cv, CL) Copyright © American Wood Council 40 Polling Question 4. The two new adjustment factors were added to glued laminated timber design are stress interaction and shear reduction factors. T/F True NDS – Chapter 6 Copyright © American Wood Council 41 Chapter 6 – Poles & Piles • Poles - post-frame • Piles Pil - foundations f d ti Chapter 6 – Timber Piles • Design values • Significant changes from 2005 NDS • Design values moved to NDS Supplement 2005 NDS 2012 NDS Copyright © American Wood Council 42 Chapter 6 – Timber Poles 2005 NDS 2012 NDS Chapter 6 – Poles & Piles • Adjustment factors • Cct – condition treatment • Cls – load sharing • Ccs – critical section Copyright © American Wood Council 43 NDS – Chapter 7 Chapter 7 – I-joists • Design values • M, V, EI, K – no changes • Evaluation Reports • Contain proprietary design Copyright © American Wood Council 44 Chapter 7 – I-Joists • Beam stability factor • Braced compression flange • CL = 1.0 • Unbraced compression flange • Design as unbraced column NDS – Chapter 8 Copyright © American Wood Council 45 Chapter 8 – Structural Composite Lumber • No changes from 2005 NDS • Evaluation Reports • Contain proprietary design Rela ative Frequency x = mean x SCL I-Joist Glulam COVxx= x MSR Lumber Load Visually Graded Lumber Material Property Values Chapter 8 – Structural Composite Lumber • Adjustment factors • CV – volume Cv < 1.0 1 0 Not N cumulative l i with i h beam b stability bili factor, f CL - then h min. i (Cv, CL) Cv > 1.0 Cumulative with beam stability factor, CL Copyright © American Wood Council 46 Chapter 8 – Structural Composite Lumber • Adjustment factors • 1 04 Cr Repetitive Member Factor= Factor 1.04 • Cr is different than lumber (Cr lumber = 1.15) • Applies to Fb only NDS – Chapter 9 Copyright © American Wood Council 47 Chapter 9 – Wood Structural Panels • Design values – obtain from an approved source • FbS • FtA • Fvtv • Fs • FcA • EI • EA • Gvtv • Fc Chapter 9 – Wood Structural Panels • Adjustment factors apply Fb & Ft CG - grade & construction • • Removed (no longer used by wsp industry) Cs - panel size • • Clarified • Moved from commentary Copyright © American Wood Council 48 Chapter 9 – Wood Structural Panels • Adjustment factors • CM - wet service • Ct - temperature NDS – Chapter 10 Copyright © American Wood Council 49 Chapter 10 – Mechanical Connections • Design issues • Reference design values • Ch t 11 – dowel-type Chapter d lt connectors t ((nails, il bolts, b lt lag/wood l / d screws)) • Chapter 12 – split rings and shear plates • Chapter 13 – timber rivets • Adjustment factors • No significant changes • Connections session NDS – Chapter 11 Copyright © American Wood Council 50 Chapter 11 - Tabulated Values • Consistent titles and footnotes • Penetration assumptions in titles Chapter 11-Dowels Copyright © American Wood Council 51 Chapter 11-Dowels Chapter 11-Dowels Copyright © American Wood Council 52 Chapter 11-Dowels Threaded length < lm/4 lm Dia. Fastener = D lm Threaded length < lm/4 Dia. Fastener = D Chapter 11-Dowels lm Dia. Fastener = Dr Copyright © American Wood Council 53 Chapter 11 - Dowels Provide tools for the analysis • gaps between members • various fastener moment resistance configurations • fasteners through hollow members • fasteners with tapered tips http://www.awc.org/publications/TR/index.php Chapter 11 - Tabulated Values • New post frame ring shank tables • Based on ASTM F1667 Copyright © American Wood Council 54 Chapter 11 - Dowel Bearing Length Fastener Type Tip Length, E Lag Screws Appendix L Wood Screws 2D Nails & Spikes 2D E,, ℓs, ℓm < p – E / 2 Chapter 11 - Dowel Bearing Strength • Wood Structural Panels • D < ¼ Copyright © American Wood Council 55 Chapter 11 - Perp to Grain Distance • Glulam only Moisture content • • Glulam only • Moisture content Polling Question 5. TR 12 includes general dowel equations and provides tools for the analysis of: a) b) c) d) e) gaps between members fasteners through hollow members fasteners with tapered tips All of the above None of the above Copyright © American Wood Council 56 NDS – Chapter 12 Chapter 12 – Split Rings and Shear Plates • Geometry factor, CD • Side Grain Copyright © American Wood Council 57 Chapter 12 – Split Rings and Shear Plates • Geometry factor, CD • End Grain NDS – Chapter 13 Copyright © American Wood Council 58 Chapter 13 – Timber Rivets • Many applications Chapter 13 – Timber Rivets Copyright © American Wood Council 59 Chapter 13 – Timber Rivets • Parallel to grain • Timber rivet capacity • Proper application of CD Timber Rivets – Design 2005 NDS Copyright © American Wood Council 60 Timber Rivets – Design 2012 NDS Chapter 13 – Timber Rivets • Timber rivet capacity • Proper application of CD • Parallel to grain timber rivet capacity • Pr = 280 p0.32 nR nC (13.2-1) 188 2012 NDS Perpendicular to grain timber rivet capacity • • Qr = 160 p0.32 nR nC 108 2012 NDS Copyright © American Wood Council 61 Chapter 13 – Timber Rivets • Maximum distance perpendicular to grain between outermost rows of rivets shall be 12 • Consistent with glulam NDS – Chapter 14 Copyright © American Wood Council 62 NDS – Chapter 14 Chapter 14 – Shear Walls and Diaphragms • ANSI / AWC SDPWS 2008 standard • Recorded Webinar •Online course 2005/2008 SDPWS •Diaphragm Deflection •www.awc.org Copyright © American Wood Council 63 NDS – Chapter 15 Chapter 15 – Special Loading • Built-up columns • Flatwise bending check • Consistent with Chapter 3 New Copyright © American Wood Council 64 NDS – Chapter 16 Chapter 16 – Fire (ASD) • Fire resistance up to • Columns • Beams • Tension T i M Members b • ASD only • Products • Lumber • Glulam • SCL • Decking D ki Copyright © American Wood Council two hours … 65 Chapter 16 – Calculated Resistance • Fire resistance of exposed wood members may be calculated using the provisions of NDS Chapter 16 Fire Resistance Glulam Copyright © American Wood Council Steel 66 Performance of Wood vs. Steel Chapter 16 – Fire (ASD) T h i l Report Technical R t No. N 10 Copyright © American Wood Council 67 Chapter 16 – Fire (ASD) Code Updates Design of Fire FireResistive Exposed Wood Members http://www.awc.org/pu blications/download php blications/download.php Polling Question 6. The IBC includes provisions for calculating fire resistance of exposed wood members and wood decking for up to two hours. hours True/False True Copyright © American Wood Council 68 NDS – Appendices NDS 2012 Appendices 2012 A Construction and Design Practices B Load Duration C Temperature Effects D Lateral ate a Stability Stab ty of o Beams ea s E Local Stresses in Fastener Groups F Design for Creep and Critical Deflection Applications G Effective Column Length H Lateral Stability of Columns I Yield Limit Equations for Connections J Solution of Hankinson Equation K Typical Dimensions for Split Ring and Shear Plate Connectors L Typical i l Dimensions i i for f Standard d d Hex Bolts, Hex Lag Screws, Wood Screws, Common, Box, and Sinker Nails M Manufacturing Tolerances for Rivets and Steel Side Plates for Timber Rivet Connections N Appendix for Load and Resistance Factor Design (LRFD) Copyright © American Wood Council 69 Appendix E • Example E.8 • Acritical check Appendix L Copyright © American Wood Council 70 Appendix N NDS – Commentary Copyright © American Wood Council 71 Outline • Overview • LRFD Primer • NDS • Chapter-by-chapter discussion • Changes from previous editions • Summary • More Info. 2012 NDS – Notable Changes • Chapter 5 – Glulam • Chapter 6 – Poles and Piles • Chapter 12 – Split Rings & Shear Plates Copyright © American Wood Council 72 NDS 2012 Supplement • New nominal and minimum Timber sizes per PS 20-10 • Section properties distinguish lumber, P&T, B&S • New Coast Sitka Spruce & Yellow Cedar values • Revised Northern Species bending and tension values • Clarify Timber size factor adjustments • New and revised values for several foreign species • Revised glulam values - primary changes to shear • New Tables 6A & 6B for Timber Poles and Piles Southern Pine Design Values • ALSC approves design values • June 1, 2013 • AWC compiles them • NDS Supplement • More information • www.spib.org • www.southernpine.com Copyright © American Wood Council 73 Wood Design Package • Wood Design Package • NDS + Commentary • NDS Supplement • ASD/LRFD Manual • Example Problems • Almost complete Supplement: Design Values for Wood Construction MANUAL Future 2015 Copyright © American Wood Council 74 Coming in 2015 NDS/SDPWS NDS • • CLT Provisions Franklin Elementary School Franklin, West Virginia Architect: MSES Architects, Fairmont, WV Copyright © American Wood Council Source: LignaTerra 75 Franklin Elementary School Source: LignaTerra Franklin, West Virginia 46,200 sq. ft. 8 week assembly Franklin Elementary School Source: LignaTerra Copyright © American Wood Council 76 Franklin Elementary School Scheduled completion date: Winter 2015 Coming in 2015 NDS/SDPWS NDS • • CLT Provisions SDPWS • • Design Flexible and Open Front/Cantilever Diaphragms Copyright © American Wood Council 77 2015 Special Design Provisions for Wind and Seismic 2015 SDPWS Overview • Ch. 2 • Removes definition of flexible and rigid diaphragms • Defines “Open-Front Structure” & “Subdiaphragm” • Ch. 4 • Clarification of concrete and masonry wall anchorage • Revised Horizontal Distribution of Shear • Clarification of shear wall Aspect ratio adjustments Copyright © American Wood Council 78 2015 SDPWS 2015 SDPWS Copyright © American Wood Council 79 More Details • White paper - www.awc.org • Comprehensive table • Section-by-section changes • Structure Magazine • January 2012 Resources Copyright © American Wood Council 80 Resources Questions? www.awc.org info@awc.org Copyright © American Wood Council 81