REVISED JUNE 9, 2011 GuidelinesandProceduresfor HurricaneDeckATCProcess Description This project will allow contractors the opportunity to include in their bid proposal, pricing for a pre approved Alternate Technical Concept (ATC) that differs from the Commissionfurnished bid proposal. ATCsallowforinnovation,projectschedulereductionandcostsavingstoobtainthebestvalueforthe project that meets or exceeds the project goals, and which provides a product, which is equal to or betterthantheconceptitreplaces.ATCsmayaddress,butarenotlimitedto,specifications,materials, products,designstandards,designsolutions,stagingortrafficcontrol. For this requestforbid, the contractor may submit a bid for the Commissionfurnished proposal, includingtheCommissionfurnisheddesignsolutionorabidthatincludespricingforthepreapproved ATC. GeneralConditions TheCommissionfurnishedproposaldocumentscontainalloftheproposedworkfortheprojecttobe bid.ThecontractormayproposeanATCtodothework.Theminimumrequirementsforthefinished projectarelistedbelow.IfanATCispreapprovedbytheCommission,thecontractorhastheoptionof submitting a bid for the preapproved ATC proposal or the Commission furnished proposal. The contractorwillonlybeallowedtosubmitonebidforthisproject. TheCommissionwillberesponsibleforcompletingallroadwayandstructuraldesignplansforapproved ATCs. ProcessforSubmittalofAlternateTechnicalConcepts SubmittalandevaluationofATCswillincludethefollowingthreestepprocess: Step1:ThiswillconsistofoneononeconfidentialmeetingsbetweenthecontractorandtheHurricane DeckATCteamtodiscusswhatportionoftheprojecttheirATCimpacts.IftheCommissionconfirmsthis portionofthedesignhasbeenfinalized,thentheATCprocessproceedstoStep2. TheCommissionwarnsthatanyideasubmittedbythecontractor,inwhichtheCommissiondesignhas notyet beencompleted, maypossiblybethedesigndirectionthatwasintendedforthe Commission furnishedplans.Toavoiddiscussingconceptsonportionsofthedesignthathavenotbeencompleted; thecontractorwillbeaskedtodescribewhichportionofthedesigntheirATCwillimpact.IftheATC proposal impacts an incomplete portion of the base design, the contractor will have the option of delaying their ATC submittal until after the final design solution has been selected. If a contractor choosestoproceedwithsubmittinganATConanincompleteportionofthebasedesignthatendsup being the same solution as the base design, the contractor shall have no ownership or right to that specificATC.Thecontractorwillbeinformedofthissituationifitoccurs. Missouri Department of Transportation – Replacement of Hurricane Deck Bridge Page 1 REVISED JUNE 9, 2011 Step2: TheATCteamwillbeavailabletoreviewcontractor’sConceptualAlternateTechnicalConcepts (CATC).CATCswillrequireminimalengineeringandareintendedtoallowcontractorstopresenttheir ideastotheATCteaminaconfidentialenvironmentpriortoinvestingtimeandresourcesintodetailed engineeringoftheirconcept. TheCommissionwillreviewsubmittedCATCsandrespondbacktothecontractorassoonaspossible, but not to exceed 2 weeks. Yet, the Commission reserves the right to take longer depending on resourcesandevaluationneedsofthespecificCATC.Thecontractorwillbenotifiedpriortocompletion ofthe2weektimeperiodifmoretimewillberequired. Although there is not a limit to the number of CATC submittals, the Commission reserves the right to limitthenumberofCATCsubmittalsifinitsowndeterminationitfeelsthatacontractorisabusingthe process by not limiting their submittals to reasonable concepts. The contractor will receive a written warningfromtheCommissionbeforebeinglimitedonthenumberofCATCsubmittals. Step 3: Once a CATC is approved, the contractor may choose to pursue the ATC in more detail and submititforfinalapprovalandinclusioninthebiddingdocuments. AllinquiriesregardingATCsforthisprojectshouldbedirectedtothecontactaslistedbelow: NicoleKolbHood,PE TransportationProjectManager MissouriDepartmentofTransportation 1511MissouriBlvd. JeffersonCity,MO65102 Email:Nicole.hood@modot.mo.gov HurricaneDeckATCProcessSchedule February10,2011 An informational meeting will be held at the MoDOT District 5 Office to explaintheATCprocess. March1,2011 Commissionconfirmsdirectionforbasedesign. March18,2011 30%baseplanswillbepostedtotheProjectwebsite. March21,2011 Start date of confidential oneonone contractor meetings. CATCs will be acceptedforreview. May27,2011 60% base plans will be posted to the Project website. Guidelines for HurricaneDeckATCProcessandProceduresfinalizedandpostedtowebsite. August15,2011* LastdaytosubmitATCs. November10,2011* ATCbiddablesetofplansavailabletocontractor. December16,2011 Bidsdue. *DatessubjecttochangedependingonthenumberandcomplexityofATCdesign. RequirementsforStep2ConceptualAlternateTechnicalConceptSubmittal RequirementsfortheCATCsubmittalshallincludeataminimum: a) DetailednarrativeoftheCATCbeingproposed(detailedtoatleastenoughinformation fortheCommissiontoestimatecostandtimesavings). b) Estimateofcostsavings. Missouri Department of Transportation – Replacement of Hurricane Deck Bridge Page 2 REVISED JUNE 9, 2011 c) Estimateoftimesavings. d) Impact to the environment, utilities and right of way and any previous permits or approvals. e) A description of any previous use or submission of similar technical concepts or value engineering proposals, including dates, job numbers, results, and/or outcome of the ATC/VE if previously submitted, as known by the contractor. This would include ATCs/VEsfromanystateDOT. CATCs may propose specifications and design standards that differ from MoDOT standard practice. MoDOT understands that, at times, MoDOT manuals, specifications and standards do not allow for maximum flexibility. Contractors are encouraged to propose Additional Applicable Standards (AAS) as partoftheCATC/ATCprocess.Theproposedmanuals,specificationsandstandards,shallbelimitedto those already reviewed by FHWA, for example, standards from other state departments of transportation. The Contractor shall provide the Additional Applicable Standards including but not limited to construction specifications, special provisions, design requirements (by discipline), standard drawings,materialsandtestingrequirements,andmanualsforreviewandapprovalwithCATCandATC submittals.MoDOTwillhavesoleauthoritytoapproveordisapproveanyAAS.IfanAASisdisallowed, thecontractorwillbenotifiedastowhy. EvaluationofStep2ConceptualAlternateTechnicalConcepts The minimum basis of acceptance for a CATC shall adhere to the project specific minimum requirements, general requirements and submittal requirements. Any CATC failing to include the required submittal information or one that fails to meet the project minimum requirements will be rejectedandreturnedtothecontractor. IfaCATCisaccepted,theCommissionwillprovidewrittenapprovaloftheCATC.TheCommissionwill estimate a cost to develop the CATC into a biddable set of plans. A CATC proposal must produce an estimated net savings after design costs are deducted greater than $100,000 to be considered for design.ApprovaloftheCATCtothecontractorwillincludetheCommission’smaximumredesigncost andredesigntimefortheATC. IfaCATCisdisallowed,thecontractorwillbenotifiedastowhy. RequirementsforStep3AlternateTechnicalConceptSubmittals ATCsubmittalswillonlybeconsideredifaccompaniedwithapreapprovedCATC.Thecontractorshall requestandsubmitfourcopiesoftheATCformwiththefollowinginformation: a) AlloriginalCATCsubmittaldocumentswithacopyoftheapprovalletteracknowledging theCommission’sacceptance. b) Deviation:ReferenceallrequirementsoftheCommissionfurnishedproposalthatare inconsistentwiththeproposedATC,anexplanationofthenatureoftheATCdeviations fromsaidrequirements,andimpactstootherdesignelements. c) Description:ProvideadetaileddescriptionoftheATCincludingspecificationsand conceptualdrawings,andadescriptionofwhereandhowtheATCwouldbeusedonthe Project. d) Justification:AnanalysisjustifyingtheATCanddemonstratingwhymodificationsor revisionstorequirementsoftheCommissionfurnishedproposalshouldbeallowed. IncludeinformationonhowtheATCmeetstheprojectgoals. Missouri Department of Transportation – Replacement of Hurricane Deck Bridge Page 3 REVISED JUNE 9, 2011 e) CostSavings:Adetailedstatementofthecostsavingsassociatedwiththe implementationoftheATC.Includeanitemizedlistofimpactedbiditemsandquantities supportingthecostsavingsfortheATC. f) ScheduleImpact:AdiscussionoftheeffecttheATCwillhaveonthecontractcompletion timeincludingdesign,construction,rightofway,utilityrelocationandpermittingissues. g) CertificationthattheATCmeetsallapplicablefederalandstatedesignstandards,or conformstoapreapprovedAAS. h) Utilities:Adiscussionofutility(publicandprivate)impacts. i) Permits:Adiscussionofpermitchanges,additionalpermitsand/oragencyapprovals thatmayberequiredfortheATC. j) RightofWay:Adiscussionoftherightofwayrequirements(bothtemporaryand permanent)fortheATC. k) TrafficandSafetyImpacts:AdiscussionoftheimpactstheATCwillhaveonmaintenance oftrafficduringconstruction. l) EnvironmentalImpacts:AdiscussionoftheATCenvironmentalimpactsascomparedto theapprovedprojectEnvironmentalDocumentincludingimpactstoenvironmental commitmentsandcommunityimpacts. m) Maintenance:Adiscussionofthemaintenanceimpactsoverthe75yearlifeofthe project. n) History:AdetaileddescriptionofotherprojectsonwhichtheproposedATChasbeen usedincludingcontactinformation(name,title,phonenumber,addressandemail)for projectownersthatcanconfirmATCimplementation. o) Inspection:Anyadditionaltestingandconstructioninspectionrequirements. p) Risks:AdiscussionofaddedriskstoMoDOTandotherpartiesassociatedwith implementingtheATC. q) Adescriptionofboththeexistingcontractrequirementsforperformingtheworkand theproposedATC(ifmoreinformationhasbecomeavailablesinceCATCnarrative). ATCsubmittalsshallincludeenoughroadwayandstructuraldesigndetailstodetermineacceptanceof theATCwhichshallincludeifapplicable,butnotlimitedto:geometrics,hydrauliccalculations,profiles, typical sections, and traffic control concepts; and structures to include type, size and location superstructure information, substructure information, and any other significant information. Where different from the Commissionfurnished bid proposal, the ATC submittal shall also identify the contractor’sspecificapproachtothefollowing,asapplicable: a) Mechanically stabilized earth (MSE), the contractor shall define the MSE system to be usedanditsassociatedapplicationcriteria. b) Describethecorrosionprotectionmeasuresforstructuralsteelandconcretereinforcing steel subject to chloride exposure, such as decks, elements under joints and locations withinsplashzones.Thedefinitionofsplashzoneshallbeincludedifutilized. c) The application limits and material requirements for structures for protective coatings suchasgraffitiprotectiontobeused. d) The specifications for the application of proposed coatings for bridge superstructure, signs,messageboards,steelpilingandmiscellaneoussteel. e) Thetypesofbridgeexpansionjointsandbearingstobeused. f) Specifywhatmaterialswillbeusedfordrainagepipesinvariousapplications. g) Fortrafficrelateditemstheproposershalldefinehowtheywillinterpretthe‘guidance’ recommendationsinMUTCD. Missouri Department of Transportation – Replacement of Hurricane Deck Bridge Page 4 REVISED JUNE 9, 2011 EvaluationofStep3AlternateTechnicalConcepts ATCswillbeevaluatedbasedoncompliancetotherequirementsoftheseguidelines.ATCsthatdonot meettheserequirementswillfailandnotbeconsideredforbid.TheCommissionandFHWAshallbethe sole judges in determining compliance with these requirements. If a CATC is proposed and approved basedontherequirements,butdoesnotfulfilltheserequirementswhenitissubmittedasanATC,itwill notbeconsideredforbid. ATCswillbeevaluatedusingthefollowingcriteria.Ifanyofthefollowingcriteriaarenotmet,theATC requestfails. a) TheATCmeetsorexceedstheminimumrequirementsandengineeringstandardslistedinthese guidelines.TheATCwasfirstevaluatedandacceptedasaConceptualATC(CATC). b) TheATCdoesnotadverselyaffectthelongtermmaintenanceoftheproject. c) TheATCisconsistentwiththeoverallprojectgoals,whichincludebutarenotlimitedtothe following: a. Delivertheprojectonbudget b. Minimizepublicimpactbykeepingregionalandlocaltrafficflowingefficientlyandsafely throughtheimpactedarea c. Incorporateinnovativedesignincludingfaster/betterconstructiontechniques,quality control&inspection d. Coordinatewithallpartnersandthelocalcommunityresultinginaprojectthatis viewedassuccessful e. Demonstratequalityconstruction,encouragegreentechniquesandprovidealong lastingfacilitythatcompliestoADArequirements. d) TheATCisequaltoorbetterthantheoriginaldesignproposal.TheATCshallnotcausea decreaseinengineeringstandardsforanysafetyrelateditems,includingbutnotlimitedto: reductioninshoulderwidths,reductioninlanewidths,decreaseindesignspeed,decreasein clearzone,reductionincleardistancetopiersand/orabutments,reductioninvertical clearance,orreducedtrafficcontrolperformance,etc.Tobeconsideredforapproval,allsafety relatedelementsoftheATCmustmeetorexceedtheMoDOTdesign.EvaluationofATC proposalsmay,atMoDOT’sdiscretion,takeintoaccounttheoverallprojectdesignincluding increasesanddecreasesinsafetyrelateditemsthroughouttheproject.Forexampleadecrease inengineeringstandardmaybeallowedinoneareaif,inMoDOT’sandFHWA’ssolediscretion, itisdeterminedthattheoverallsafetyoftheproject,ascomparedtotheoriginalMoDOT baselinedesign,isincreasedbyincreasingtheengineeringstandardofotherpartsofthe project. e) Directorsecondarycostand/ordelayrelatedtoutilityconflicts. The Commission will make every effort to evaluate the ATC within 10 working days of submittal, and givethecontractorapassorfaildecision.TheCommissionwill,inwriting,notifythecontractorofthe ATCspass/failstatus.IfanATCwithapromisingconceptissubmittedwithinsufficientinformation,it willberejected.ArejectedATCresponsewillincludealistofoneormoreofthecriterialistedaboveas towhytheATCfailed.ThecontractorwillbeallowedtoaddresstheCommission’scauseforrejection andresubmittheATCpriortotheATCsubmittaldeadline.AllspecificATCdiscussionsshallbewritten orinpersonwithminutesrecordedbythecontractor,andapprovedbytheCommission.Innowaywill the Commission discuss specific ATCs without documentation. The Commission and Federal Highway Missouri Department of Transportation – Replacement of Hurricane Deck Bridge Page 5 REVISED JUNE 9, 2011 AdministrationwillbethesolejudgesofacceptabilityoftheATC.TheCommissionandFederalHighway AdministrationreservetherighttorejectanyATCrequestforanyreason. A request from the Commission for additional information from the contractor will be considered a responseandallowsforextensionoftheevaluationperiod. IftheproposedATCisgivena“pass”recommendationtheconceptisconsideredpreapprovedandmay besubmittedbythecontractoralongwithbidsfortheotheritemsofworkcontainedintherequestfor proposal.IftheATCisgivenapassrecommendationtheCommissionwillprovideadateforcompletion ofthefinalredesign,i.e.constructionplanset,withtheATCapprovalletter.Thecontractorshallnotify theCommissioninwritingwithin5calendardaysofapprovaloftheATCtheirintenttopursuetheATC. An approved ATC which is comprised of multiple elements must be bid as a whole, selective implementationoflessthanalltheelementswillnotbeaccepted. The contractor will have no claim for additional costs or delays, including development costs, loss of anticipatedprofits,orincreasedmaterialorlaborcosts,iftheATCisrejected. An approved ATC that is not submitted with the bid will not be considered a preapproved value engineering change proposal (VECP). The awarded contractor may submit their approved ATC as a VECP,however,thefactthatitwasapprovedasanATCshallhavenobearingonpotentialapprovalasa VECP,anditwillbereviewedindependentlyinaccordancewithSec104.6. In the event that the awarded contractor utilized a sunshine request to obtain information about approvedATCssubmittedbyotherbidders,theseideasshallnotbeconsideredeligibleforsubmittalas a VECP, unless the awarded contractor has an agreement letter from other bidders stating it is permissible. Confidentiality TheCommissionexpresslyreservestherighttoadoptanyspecificCATCorATCasstandardpracticefor use on other contracts administered by the Commission, whether the CATC or ATC is accepted or rejected.TheCATCorATCshallnotbeusedbytheCommissionuntilaftertheawardoftheHurricane Deckbridgeproject. Other than as listed above, all CATC and ATC submittals are considered confidential and will not be sharedwithotherbidders.Allmembersofthereviewteam(exceptFHWA)willberequiredtosigna confidentiality agreement before reviewing any submittals. A copy of the form to be used for this purposemayberequested. DesignRequirements TheCommissionwillberesponsibleforcompletingallroadwayandstructuraldesignplansforapproved ATCs. The Commission will work with the contractor on any ATC that requires design and/or plan changes.Ifnecessary,weeklymeetingswillbeheld.Theplanswillbedevelopedtoadegreesuchthat the Commission and contractor are satisfied that biddable quantities are established. If the successful lowbidder’sproposalcontainsanATC,theirATCwillbedevelopedintoafinalizedsetofconstruction plans. Missouri Department of Transportation – Replacement of Hurricane Deck Bridge Page 6 REVISED JUNE 9, 2011 PlansshallbecompletebeforeanyconstructionrelatedtotheATCcanbegin.TheCommissionwillnot beresponsibleforanycostassociatedwithprojectdelaysduetotheredesignandproductionofplans, specificationsandquantitiesasneededforimplementationoftheATCsoranyadditionalconstruction costnotforeseenpriortotheATCdesigncompletion. BiddingRequirements Ifthesuccessfulbidder’spreapprovedATCisabandonedbythecontractororfailstobeconstructedfor any reason, the contractor is obligated to complete the project utilizing the original design at the awardedcost. BasisofPayment Theproposaldocumentscontainalloftheproposedworkfortheprojecttobebidasdesignedbythe Commission.ContractorschoosingnottoparticipateintheATCprocessmustbidthebasesetofplans furnishedbytheCommission. ContractorssubmittinganATCbidwillreceivemodifiedbiddingdocumentswithseparatepayitemsfor the preapproved ATC and other applicable bid items. If the contractor elects to bid the project with preapprovedATCs,thecontractorshallentertheunitpricesinthemodifiedbiddingdocument.Ifthe successfulcontractor’spreapprovedATCisabandonedbythecontractororfailstobeconstructedfor anyreason,anocostchangeorder willbeprocessedtoreadjustthe biditems tothe originaldesign quantities. The contractor is obligated to complete the project utilizing the original design at the awardedcost. NodirectpaymentwillbemadeforanychangeinquantityofpayitemsnotincludedintheATCthatare affectedbythecontractor’sdecisiontouseanATConthisproject. NodirectpaymentwillbemadefordelayofscheduleduetotheuseofanATC,includingbutnotlimited todelayresultingfromthedesign,review,implementationorconstructionofanATC.Additionally,if theATCcausesconflictswithutilitiesthatwerenotpreviouslyidentifiedintheoriginalATCsubmittal, thecontractor’ssoleremedyfortheeffectsofthepresenceofutilities,delayintheirrelocationorany other effects they have on delivery of the project shall be a noncompensable, excusable delay as providedinSection105.7.3oftheMissouriStandardSpecificationsforHighwayConstruction.Notime delaywillbegrantedforanyutilityconflictsidentifiedintheoriginalATCsubmittal. The following are requirements and limits that will be placed on the Alternate Technical Conceptsforthisproject. GeneralDesignSpecifications–MinimumRequirements 1. Roadway and Structural designs shall be in accordance with any state and all federal requirements,unlessotherwisespecifiedelsewhereinthesecontractdocuments. 2. Utilitiesshallnotbedisturbedexceptatthecontractor’sexpense. 3. There are many factors that limit the options in altering the horizontal alignment. Prior to investing an extensive amount of time in any Conceptual ATC proposal that would affect the horizontal geometry of the base design; the contractor is strongly encouraged to contact MoDOTtodiscusstheselimitationsasnotedinStep1ofsubmittalprocess. Missouri Department of Transportation – Replacement of Hurricane Deck Bridge Page 7 REVISED JUNE 9, 2011 4. ATCs proposing changes in maintenance of traffic should maintain traffic as good as or better thantheCommissionbasedesign.Closuresexceedingthatofthebaseplanwillbeconsidered dependinguponimpactstothetravelingpublicandlocalinput. 5. If a proposed ATC is beyond the limits of the Commission’s existing right of way, it is the contractor’sresponsibilitytocoordinatewithpropertyowner’stoobtainthenecessaryrightof way. The contractor shall comply with all applicable federal laws, rules and regulations, including42U.S.C.46014655,theUniformRelocationAssistanceandRealPropertyAcquisition Act,asamendedandanyregulationspromulgatedinconnectionwiththeAct,andwithChapter 523oftheRevisedStatutesofMissouri.MoDOTwillauditandreviewthecontractor’srightof wayacquisitionprocessandwillinitssolediscretiondetermineifarightofwayacquisitionhas been obtained in accordance with all applicable federal laws, rules and regulations. If MoDOT determinesthatrightofwaywasnotpurchasedinaccordancewithallapplicablefederallaws, rulesandregulations,thecontractorisobligatedtocompletetheprojectpertheoriginaldesign attheawardedcostorcompletetheapprovedATCwithintheexistingrightofway. 6. ATCsmaynotresultinanetincreaseintheacreageofdisturbedwetlands. 7. ATCsrequiringnewDesignExceptionsmustreceivebothMoDOTandFHWAapproval.Anynew design exceptions must be offset by elimination or reduction of existing design exceptions elsewhereintheproject.Anycombinationofexistingandnewdesignexceptionsmustproduce a design that is judged to be equal to or better than the existing design as determined by MoDOTandFHWA.MoDOTinitssolediscretionmayrejectanydesignexceptionproposalthat itfeelsdoesnotprovideasuitableorsafedesignpriortoFHWA’sreview. 8. Any proposed ATCs requiring modifications to previously approved actions for this project (ie NEPA, Design Exceptions, Conceptual Reports, permits, etc.) must receive MoDOT and FHWA approval. This information is available upon specific request to the MoDOT contact person. MoDOTinitssolediscretionmayrejectanyproposalthatwillrequiremodificationstoprevious approvals. Any work required for modification of previously approved actions shall be the responsibilityoftheCommission. BridgeDesignSpecifications–MinimumRequirements 1. Alternatebridgedesignsshallbe inaccordancewiththe2010AASHTOLRFD 5thEditionand 2010 Interims, Load and Resistance Factor Design, for Seismic Performance Category A, as modifiedandinterpretedbytheMoDOTEngineeringPolicyGuide(EPG).Bridgedeckdrainage design shall be in accordance with the 1986 FHWA Report “Bridge Deck Drainage Guidelines”, andthe May1993FHWAReport“DesignofDeckDrainage,HydraulicEngineeringCircularNo. 21.” 2. AlternatedesignsshallmeetthefollowingLRFDloadingrequirements: x HL93 x 35lb/sffuturewearingsurface Missouri Department of Transportation – Replacement of Hurricane Deck Bridge Page 8 REVISED JUNE 9, 2011 3. Drainagespreadshallbelimitedtotheshoulderwidthplus3ft.Thedesignstormeventshallbe a25year(8.5”perhour)frequencyandfiveminutetimeperiod.Drainingwaterdirectlyover theedgeofthebridge(i.e.curboutlets)isnotallowed. 4. Minimum vertical clearance for finished structure shall be 45’0” clear over normal pool elevationof660.0ft.foraminimumdistanceof200’. 5. Designlifeforfinishedstructuresshallbe75yearsminimum. 6. The minimum number of lanes and shoulder widths for finished structures, as shown on the contractplans,shallnotbereducedfromtheoriginaldesign. 7. Areinforcedconcreteoverlayisrequiredforprestressedvoidedslaborprestressedboxgirder superstructures. 8. Ifdrilledshaftsareusedforintermediatebents,allrequirementsintheMoDOTEngineerPolicy GuideorequivalentdrilledshaftrequirementscontainedinapreapprovedAASshallbemet. StructuralWallDesignSpecifications–MinimumRequirements TheseminimumBridgeDesignSpecificationrequirementsapplytoalternatewalldesigns. 1. Alternatewalldesignsshallbeinaccordancewiththe2002–AASHTO17thEditionLoadFactor Design,asmodifiedbyMoDOTBridgeDesignManualSection3.6.2. 2. AnaggregateshearkeyshallbeusedbelowMSEWalls. RoadwayDesignSpecifications–MinimumRequirements 1. ThisprojecthasaTrafficManagementPlan(TMP)thathasbeenapprovedbyFHWA.ATCsthat impacttheTrafficControlPlanortheTMPwillrequirethepreparationandapproval,byMoDOT and FHWA, of a revised TMP. The revised TMP and Traffic Control Plan shall provide an equivalent impact to traffic during construction when compared to the one described for the baseplans.Thedeterminationofequivalentimpactsoracceptableimpactstotrafficshallbeat thesolediscretionoftheCommissionandFHWA. 2. AlternatepavementdesignsmustbeconsistentwiththeAASHTOMechanisticEmpiricalDesign guidelines. Any alternate pavement designs must be determined, by the Commission, to provideanequivalentdesignandperformancetothedesignincludedinthebaseCommission plans. Missouri Department of Transportation – Replacement of Hurricane Deck Bridge Page 9