Effects of non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs on hormone production
and gene expression in hypothalamic-pituitary-gonad axis of zebrafish
Kyunghee Ji1,2*, Xiaoshan Liu1, Saeram Lee1, Sungeun Kang1, John P. Giesy2, Kyungho Choi1
School of Public Health, Seoul National University, Seoul, 151-742 Korea
2 Toxicology Centre and Department of Veterinary Biomedical Sciences, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, S7J 5B3 Canada
1
♀
♂
Without IBP
With IBP
E2/T ratio fold-change
relative to DMSO control
4
6
*
*
*
*
*
4
*
2
Hormone
2
T
Female
Male
0
0
more than 3 fold up-regulation
3
3
1.5-3 fold up-regulation
Hypothalamus
CYP19B
Pituitary
ERα
ERβ
E2
AR
GnRH2
GnRH3
GnRHR1
GnRHR2
GnRHR4
FSHΒ
LHΒ
FSH
LH
Blood
FSH
LH
less than 0.33 fold down-regulation
2
2
1
1
*
*
0.66-0.33 fold down-regulation
*
Gonad
No criteria met
Statistical significance (p<0.05)
* *
*
* *
0
mRNA expression standard
ASA
DCF
IBP
MFA
NPX
0
15
15
*
12
12
*
9
6
Gene
9
*
*
6
* *
3
3
* *
* *
*
10 100
10 100
10 100
10 100
10 100
ASA
DCF
IBP
MFA
NPX
FSH
LH
CYP17
FSHR
Progesterone
HDL
LDL
LHR
Female
Male
2-5 fold up-regulation
HMGRB
17-hydroxyprogesterone
CYP17
3βHSD
Prognenolone
HMGRA
more than 5 fold up-regulation
StAR
Cholesterol
Outer mitochondrial
membrane
Aldostenedione
17βHSD
CYP11A
Cholesterol
Testosterone (T)
Inner mitochondrial
membrane
T
CYP19A
less than 0.2 fold down-regulation
0
0
0
0
10 100
10 100
10 100
10 100
10 100
0.5-0.2 fold down-regulation
ASA
DCF
IBP
MFA
NPX
No criteria met
Concentration (µg/L)
6
14
Male
Female
2.0
12
10
8
*
6
4
2
0
2.0
1.5
1.0
*
0.5
0.0
Ctrl SC
0.1
1
10
Ctrl SC
IBP (µg/L)
0.1
1
0.1
Female
Male
1
10
Ctrl SC
IBP (µg/L)
IBP (µg/L)
0.1
1
Estradiol (E2)
E2
Statistical significance (p<0.05)
Concentration (µg/L)
3000
*
2000
*
1000
Ctrl SC
0.1
1
10
IBP (µg/L)
Ctrl SC
0.1
1
10
*
1500
1000
*
*
IBP (µg/L)
Ctrl SC
0.1
1
10
IBP (µg/L)
Ctrl SC
0.1
1
*
5
0.1
1
10
Ctrl SC
10
IBP (µg/L)
0.1
1
4
*
*
*
2
Female
6
4
**
2
0
**
*
LHβ
CYP19b
ERα
0.1
1
10
IBP (µg/L)
Ctrl SC
0.1
1
Control
IBP 0.1 µg/L
IBP 1 µg/L
IBP 10 µg/L
*
*
2
AR
*
*
*
*
FSHR
8
*
**
*
*
LHR
HMGRA HMGRB
StAR
CYP11a
3β HSD
CYP17
17β HSD CYP19a
Female gonad
*
7
**
6
5
4
3
2
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
1
10
IBP (µg/L)
*
1
9
Female brain
*
*
ER2β
1
Ctrl SC
*
0
GnRH3 GnRHR1 GnRHR2 GnRHR4 FSHβ
4
3
6
2
5
* *
*
• Average number of eggs spawned was significantly less at ≥1 μg/L of IBP.
• Continuous exposure to 10 μg/L of IBP significantly reduced the rate of hatching.
• Parental exposure to ≥1 μg/L of IBP resulted in significant delay in hatching, even
when they were transferred to clean water.
• Continuous exposure to IBP through F1 generation increased malformation rates.
• These data indicate that parental exposure to low concentrations of IBP could
influence the F1 generation, resulting in increased adverse effects in the offspring.
7
3
*
GnRH2
8
Male gonad
4
0
6
8
5
3
10
IBP (µg/L)
Male
Control
IBP 0.1 µg/L
IBP 1 µg/L
IBP 10 µg/L
1
0
IBP (µg/L)
Female
500
* *
10
0.5
Ctrl SC
0
0
*
1.0
9
Male brain
5
15
IBP (µg/L)
Male
* *
4000
1.5
10
2000
5000
20
0.0
Ctrl SC
10
Female
Fold change
Male
Female
Fold change
Male
E2/T ratio relative to control
• F0 fish endpoints:
Mortality, Egg production, Somatic index,
Sex hormone concentration, mRNA
expressions of genes along the HPG axis
• F1 fish endpoints:
Hatchability, Time to hatch, malformation
*
6
Brain
ASA
DCF
IBP
MFA
NPX
*
• Godanosomatic index in both male and female fish was significantly decreased • Exposure to IBP affected transcription of genes of the HPG axis.
- Significant up-regulation of CYP19b along with greater plasma concentrations of E2 does not correspond
at 10 μg/L and ≥0.1 μg/L of IBP, respectively.
well with anti-ovulatory properties of IBP.
• Concentrations of plasma E2 were significantly increased in both male and
- A possible explanation is that down-regulation of ERα, ER2β, and AR mRNA in males might be
female fish at ≥1 μg/L of IBP.
compensation to greater production of E2 as a negative feedback.
• Significant decrease of T was observed in both males and females at ≥1 μg/L and - Changes in gene transcriptions were observed at 0.1 μg/L of IBP, within the environmentally relevant range.
10 μg/L of IBP, respectively.
Gonadosomatic index
Experiment 2: fish exposure
• One most potent NSAID identified among the five NSAIDs was chosen
and its effects on reproduction and development of the next generation
were evaluated.
• Four male and six female fish were placed in a spawning aquarium, and
exposed to 0, 0.1, 1, or 10 μg/L of IBP for 21 d following OECD TG 229.
• On 18th day, thirty eggs collected from each tank were placed in 48-well
plate containing exposure water or clean water for 6 d.
Hormone production standard
Female zebrafish
8
Experiment 2: Effects of ibuprofen on F0 and F1 fish
Hepatosomatic index
Experiment 1: fish exposure
• Four male and four female adult fish per group were exposed to 0, 10,
100, and 1,000 μg/L of five NSAIDs for 14 d with static-renewal method.
• Concentration of sex hormone in plasma and transcriptions of several
genes along the HPG axis (brain and gonad tissue) were measured.
- Transcriptions of FSHβ, LHβ, FSHR, and LHR genes in females increased after the exposure to NSAIDs
which could subsequently accelerate gametogenesis and maturation of oocytes.
- Test NSAIDs induced down-regulation of FSHβ, LHβ, FSHR, and LHR genes in males, suggesting
possible delay in spermatogenesis as well as maturation.
- Possible explanation for the lesser concentrations of plasma T in male zebrafish:
1) lesser transcription of 3βHSD, 17βHSD, and CYP17, 2) greater transcription of CYP19a
Testosterone (pg/mL)
Test compounds
• Five NSAIDs, i.e., acetylsalicylic acid (ASA), diclofenac (DCF),
ibuprofen (IBP), mefenamic acid (MFA), and naproxen (NPX) were
selected based on the frequency of detection in Korea waterways and
their toxicity.
• Concentrations of 17β-estradiol (E2) in plasma were significantly increased in
both male and female fish after exposure to IBP and MFA.
• Concentrations of plasma testosterone (T) were significantly greater in female
fish, while T was decreased among the males.
• E2/T ratio was significantly greater in females exposed to ASA, IBP, MFA, and
NPX, while more pronounced increase was observed in male fish exposed to IBP
and MFA.
• Effects of NSAIDs exposure on gene transcription were sex-dependent.
Condition factor
We investigated the effects of NSAIDs on the hypothalamic-pituitarygonadal (HPG) axis and related mechanisms in freshwater fish.
Experiment 1: Effects of five NSAIDs on hormone and gene transcription
17β-estradiol (pg/mL)
Non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) have shown estrogenic
activity in vitro and in vivo, however, the mechanism of this activity is
not fully understood.
Testosterone fold-change 17β-estradiol fold-change
relative to DMSO control relative to DMSO control
Male zebrafish
8
0
0
GnRH2
GnRH3 GnRHR1 GnRHR2 GnRHR4 FSHβ
LHβ
CYP19b
ERα
ER2β
AR
FSHR
LHR
HMGRA HMGRB
StAR
CYP11a
3β HSD
CYP17
17β HSD CYP19a
- Left: Control embryo at 80 hour post fertilization
- Middle: Embryo continuously exposed to 10 μg/L
of IBP with cardiac edema
- Right: Embryo continuously exposed to 0.1 μg/L
of IBP with cardiac edema
IBP could modulate hormone production and related gene transcription of the HPG axis in a sex-dependent way, which could cause adverse effects on reproduction and the development of offspring.
Potential ecosystem consequences of endocrine disruption by NSAIDs deserve further investigation.
For questions or comments please email me at jkh526@gmail.com