University of North Carolina at Greensboro ACC 631 – Advanced Auditing Course Syllabus - Fall 2015 Tuesday & Thursday 12:30 – 1:45pm, Bryan 111 Instructor: Ambrose Jones III, PhD, CPA Office: Room 326 Email: ambrose.jones.iii@uncg.edu (Please use this as the first means to contact me). Mobile phone: 336.509.1223 (emergency only) Office hours: Monday, Tuesday & Wednesday (5:30 – 6:30pm) & by appointment, or whenever you see me around campus or in my office. I will tell you if I am already committed. REQUIRED MATERIALS: Auditing and Assurance Services: An integrated approach, 15th edition, by Arens, Elder and Beasley (ISBN No. 978-0-13-312563-4) or electronic through MyAccouningLab – Course ID jonesiii73524, or a similar text from your undergraduate auditing class. Valley Publishing Company: A Comprehensive Audit Case, 12th edition, by Jones and Morris (ISBN No. 978-0-912503-37-0) COURSE OBJECTIVES – to help you: 1. Think critically about auditing with a business perspective. 2. Recognize and evaluate audit issues in a business setting and communicate your assessment to colleagues. 3. Develop as a team player in an audit environment. 4. Enhance your understanding of the role that auditing plays in business organizations and in the economy as a whole. 5. Enhance and apply your understanding of basic auditing concepts: risk identification and containment, client acceptance & continuance, sampling, controls evaluation & testing, substantive testing and reporting. 6. Apply AICPA and PCAOB professional standards – the course will emphasize identification of audit issues, along with researching and documenting solutions. 7. Understand and apply the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct and its application to the auditing profession. 8. Recognize ethical dilemmas and apply an ethical decision-making framework. 9. Enhance your understanding of other assurance services, including the auditor’s role in sustainability initiatives (e.g. corporate social responsibility reporting). 10. Develop as a professional – this includes classroom conduct and participation. You might think of this as preparation for the real world of working with colleagues, clients and customers. Your reputation is always at stake and how you act as a professional will have dramatic impact on your ability to be successful in your chosen field. ADD/DROP DATE – August 21, 2015 LAST DAY TO WITHDRAW – October 9, 2015 Page 1 of 9 ACADEMIC INTEGRITY If you are not familiar with the UNCG Academic Integrity Policy, I suggest that you visit the website at http://sa.uncg.edu/handbook/academic-integrity-policy/. Each of us has our part to play in upholding academic integrity at UNCG. If UNCG is producing cheaters, this reflects poorly on the entire university community, even though you may not be the guilty party. A true friend will confront the person cheating. Individuals do not change behavior if they never have to account for what they are doing. If you observe something that is not correct and refuse to take any action, you are developing a habit that may be as detrimental to society as the habit you are allowing others to continue. Remember that your honesty and integrity are more important than a grade in a course or even a university diploma. GRADING 1. The weight assigned to each requirement is as follows: Quiz #1 Take-home exam Quiz #2 Final Exam Participation, including teammate evaluation & case presentation Narrative case studies (3 cases – 1 individual and 2 team) Audit practice case (7 team modules) Total Points 45 75 45 100 90 45 100 500 2. Your course grade is determined as follows: Points 460- 500 450-459 440-449 410-439 400-409 Grade A A– B+ B B– Points 390-399 360-389 < 360 Grade C+ C F KNOW WHAT’s GOING ON From time to time, we may discuss news and developments in the auditing profession. This will become more relevant as the semester progresses. As an easy way to stay current, I suggest that you register with CFO.com where you can subscribe to free newsletter and email alerts for accounting and auditing topics. Go to http://www.cfo.com/subscribe/. You will receive emails daily, many of which are relevant to the field of auditing. The articles are very concise and easily understandable. Another great source of information is the Wall Street Journal. Although not free, it is a valuable source of information and it only costs about $30 for a one semester student subscription. This Page 2 of 9 will entitle you to the print edition, as well as the online content. Similar to CFO.com, you can request alerts on various topics. Neither of the above material is required. However, if you are truly interested in a business career, this will be a helpful and fun way of joining the business community and engaging in current events may be helpful in your understanding of the course material and responding to exam questions. BONUS POINT OPPORTUNITIES As an incentive to improve your communication skills and to help your fellow classmates learn, you will have an opportunity to gather an extra ten (10) bonus points and it is very easy. Succeeding in the business world is based largely on developing and maintaining personal relationships and being able to identify and communicate current business or political events that might have an impact on your company or your client (see above, KNOW WHAT’S GOING ON). For the extra 10 course points, you can volunteer for a 5 minute class presentation. The rules are: (1) email your request to me, including the article and stated relevance to course material, within (not more than) 10 calendar days before your presentation; (2) “first-come, first-serve,” based on my receipt of your email; and (3) your topic should be about a business, accounting, auditing, economic or political event that could have accounting, reporting or auditing implications and you should state the relevance to course material in the presentation. No more than two article presentations per class will be scheduled, time permitting. This bonus opportunity is available through the November 12th class, assuming our schedule permits. CLASS FORMAT (including expectations for participation) I will introduce each of our topics with a lecture, but I expect that you will have read the material in advance and will be prepared to discuss the topic. (See the end of this syllabus for our tentative schedule.) Active participation in the discussions is expected and is a key factor in grading. Auditing is as much about technical ability as it is about knowing how to research problems and how to communicate with clients and other professionals. Beginning with our fourth class, the format will include presentations by class members. Your responsibilities are explained below: Narrative Case Studies: Several narrative case studies have been assigned. One team of students will make an oral presentation of their findings. Students who are not presenting will be responsible for a written solution to the case study, individually for the first case and as a team for subsequent cases. Generally, solutions should be approximately 5-6 double spaced pages in length. Case study summaries should be written using the following outline: o Briefly summarize the key facts from the case – this can be done with bullet point outlines. o Cite (only) the professional standards applicable to the case, using the title of the standard and the codified reference to Page 3 of 9 pertinent paragraphs in the professional literature (i.e., AU and AU-C section; QC section, SOX section, PCAOB standard etc.). Key facts and cites should be limited to one page o Respond to the specific questions listed with the case study material, citing applicable standards (which you would have listed above) to support your answer. o After completing your response, write a question that comes to mind concerning the case. If you think critically about the case material, I am sure something will come to mind. These questions will be used as the basis for further class discussion. Also, it will help your participation grade by asking these questions in class. You are encouraged to use technology tools such as PowerPoint and to add any other relevant research material available. Presentations should not be read from a paper and should be at least 30 minutes in length, but with discussion, can be for up to one hour. Audit Practice Case Modules: The case concerns the audit of a hypothetical newspaper publisher, the Valley Publishing Company. You will work in teams to prepare the solutions to seven of the nine scheduled assigned modules. For each module (as with the narrative cases), one assigned team will have the opportunity to present their findings. By the end of the semester, each team will have made one presentation. The format for the presentation is as follows: o Discuss client’s assertions for the area and the related auditor objectives, emphasizing those that are of most concern for the financial statement segment. o Describe the typical audit procedures performed by auditors in the segment of the audit and any relevant auditing standards. Your textbook and the PowerPoints will be helpful for this. o For your particular segment of the audit, discuss: Last year’s (20x1) audit procedures and results. Anything new or unusual about the current year (20x2) Description of the audit procedures you performed. Conclusion For your presentations, I suggest that you use the excel templates that are distributed with the case material to prepare the majority of your workpapers, or scan the workpapers as a pdf file. Also, use PPt slides to describe client assertions, audit objectives, findings, conclusions, etc. Active participation is encouraged during these presentations. Assignments should be completed before they are presented in class. I will evaluate participation in the classroom discussions of new material and assignments and periodically take notes to award course points. This grade will be based on the frequency and relevance of communication and is a critical component of your overall grade. This is a graduate level course and active student engagement is expected. Just coming to class regularly (on time) and not hindering others in their quest to learn will earn you a C for this component of the grade. Page 4 of 9 ATTENDANCE and CLASSROOM CONDUCT Each student is responsible for the material covered and assignments given during each class. If you are not in attendance, it is your responsibility to determine what was covered in class. At the end of this syllabus is a tentative schedule to help you plan your time. I will attempt to follow this very closely and I will announce changes, if necessary. A seating chart will not be used; however, I would appreciate if you take a regular seat. As mentioned above, one of the course objectives is to develop as a professional. I commit to doing my best to help you achieve this objective – I believe that my 30+ years in the “real world” of business, including 23 years as a partner in a national CPA firm helps qualify me to do this. I think we can achieve the objective and have fun at the same time. Your lack of attendance will not directly lower your grade – my opinion is that you are only hurting yourself, assuming your goal is to be successful in this class. It will be difficult to achieve a good grade for participation if you don’t attend class regularly. Expectations concerning classroom behavior are as follows: Side conversations during class, other than as part of the general classroom discussion, are considered rude and unprofessional. Success in the business world requires many attributes; one of which is exercising appropriate conduct to fit the situation. The classroom is the equivalent to professional meetings that occur every day in the real-world of business. In these situations, individuals are expected to come prepared, participate when appropriate, and not to exhibit behavior that is disruptive or disrespectful of others. This includes excessive talking in class that is not a part of our overall discussion, passing notes to others, and creating other forms of distractions that are disruptive in the classroom. These behaviors are strongly discouraged and will be considered in awarding your classroom participation grade. If a student is notified of this more than once, 50 points will be deducted from your course total, along with the opportunity for any bonus points. If the behavior continues, additional points will be deducted. Therefore, the best that can be expected for the course is a “B+” even if such student scores 100% on all exams and other requirements. I feel very strongly about this – my concern is that side conversation hurts the chances of others to concentrate and to learn For UNCG and Bryan School policies see http://sa.uncg.edu/handbook/studentcode-of-conduct/ and www.uncg.edu/bae/faculty_student_guidelines.pdf . Cell phones are to be turned off and put away before class and are not to be used for any reason during class or exams. The same rules apply here as above for other disruptions. Please be on time for class – chronic lateness is disruptive to the class and will be considered in awarding your class participation grade. MAKE UP POLICY If, for what I determine to be good cause, you must miss a quiz/exam, provisions can be made for an early quiz/exam, but I must be notified at least 48 hours in advance of the scheduled time and the make-up (early quiz/exam) must be taken prior to the regularly scheduled time. Good cause is generally restricted to death of a family member, severe illness, or similarly acute personal exigency, impairing your ability to take an exam. Documentation is required in all cases. Page 5 of 9 If a mid-semester quiz/exam is missed, the points for that (those) quiz/exams will be assigned to the final exam, only with my permission given in advance of the scheduled quiz date. Permission for skipping a second quiz/exam will be granted only in rare (documented) circumstances and is dependent on the student’s otherwise active participation in class and completion of assignments. Late case study assignments and or a late take-home exam will not be permitted. UNFORESEEN CANCELLATION OF CLASS If a class is canceled because of an unforeseen event then all assignments for that class meeting, including quizzes, carry over to the next class meeting. In the case of inclement weather, I will make every effort to be in class if UNCG is not closed. You must assess the risks involved in your situation and decide what you should do. Also you must accept the consequences of your decision and be responsible for the material covered if you choose to miss class. The University of North Carolina at Greensboro will remain open during adverse weather conditions unless an administrative decision on changing work and class schedules is made by the chancellor. Students can receive inclement weather details on the UNCG home page (www.uncg.edu), or by dialing three campus telephone numbers: Adverse Weather Line (336-334-4400); Campus Switchboard (336-334-5000); and university police http://police.uncg.edu/. (336-334-5963). COMMUNICATION Outside of class, I will communicate with you via Canvas and/or email. This syllabus (including revisions during the semester), as well as other documents will be posted on Bb. Prior to each class, I will post PowerPoint files to be used in lectures and homework solutions will be posted after we discuss them in class. I encourage you to check your email and Bb often for these communications. POLICY ON DISABILITIES UNCG is committed to a policy of equal opportunity and affirmative action in education and employment and complies with the requirements of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973 and the American Disabilities Act of 1990. If you require special accommodations, please contact me at your earliest convenience. Also, I urge you to check the UNCG website at http://ods.dept.uncg.edu/ to arrange any special accommodations. CPA EXAM - HELPFUL WEBSITE If you plan to sit for the CPA exam during or after this course, you might be interested in the following website: http://www.cpareviewforfree.com/. OTHER Audio or video recording of classes is not permitted, unless a request is supported by approved authorization from the Office of Accessibility Resources & Services. If permission is granted, you must sit in the front row of the classroom. For more complete documentation of UNCG faculty and student guidelines concerning the expectations of all of our learning community members, see http://bae.uncg.edu/assets/faculty_student_guidelines.pdf. Page 6 of 9 ACC 631 – Advanced Auditing Tentative Schedule – Fall 2015 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Date Topic Aug 18 Introduction 20 Auditing introduction & The Sarbanes-Oxley Act; Code of Professional Conduct; Legal environment for CPAs 25 Intro; SOX; Code (continued) 27 Case 1 due Sept 1 Audit objectives & evidence 3 Client acceptance; audit risk model & materiality 8 Client acceptance; case 2 due 8. 10 Internal control; control; fraud risk; audit planning 9. 15 Identify inherent, control & fraud risk; case 3 due 17 Catch up & review 10. 11. 12. 13. 22 24 Take-home exam due; Acquisition & payment cycle, Accounts receivable and Cash (tests of details of balances) 29 Review exam and continue topics from September 24th Class agenda Introduction; preliminary exercise Lecture – complete Chapters 1, 2, 4, & 5 Assignment (planning) for future class(es) Ch. 1, 2, 4, & 5 Case 1 (ethics) – individual assignment (due Aug 27th) Lecture (continued) Ch. 6 & 7 Student presentation Case 1 Lecture – Ch 6 & 7 Ch. 8 & 9 Lecture – Ch 8 & 9; Case 2 – team (client acceptance, due Sept 8th); Ch. 10, 11 & 13 Student presentation Fraud & internal control Case 2 articles (Drew 2012; Tysiac 2012a, 2012b; PwC 2013; Tysiac 2013) Lecture – Ch 10,11 & Case 3 – team (fraud, due 13; distribute takeSept 15th) home exam (due Sept 24th) Student presentation Ch. 14,16, 18 and 23 Case 3 (fraud) Introduce VPC case Quiz 1 Lecture – Ch 14,16, 18 and 23 Page 7 of 9 VPC preliminary assignment (due October 1st ) Chapter 21 14. Date Topic Oct 1 VPC preliminary assignment due 15. 16. 6 8 17. 13 15 18. 20 19. 22 20. 27 21. 29 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. Class agenda Student presentation (VPC preliminary assignment) Inventory cycle Lecture - Chapter 21 Dual purpose testing; Student Presentation VPC #1 due; (VPC #1); lecture continue inventory Chapter 21 discussion Fall Break Auditing cash & Student presentation accounts receivable; (VPC #2 or 3) VPC # 2 & 3 due Other asset & Lecture – Ch 19 liability accounts Inventory; VPC # 4 Student presentation due – VPC #4; Ch 22 Capital acquisition & Lecture – Ch 22 payment cycle PP&E; VPC # 6 due Student presentation – VPC #6 Nov 3 Other assurance services 5 Audit Completion 10 Quiz 2 – covering Ch 19, 21, 22 & 25 12 VPC # 7 or 5/8 due 17 Audit Reporting 19 Auditing operations; audit completion; VPC #9/10 due 24 TBD Dec 3 FINAL EXAM – 12:00 – 3:00pm Lecture – Ch 25 Assignment (planning) for future class(es) VPC assignment 1 (due October 8th) VPC assignment 2 or 3 (due October 15th); Chapters 19 & 22; VPC assignment 4 (due October 22nd ) VPC assignment 6 (due October 29th) VPC assignments 7 or 5/8 (due November 12th) Chapter 25 CSR articles (Jones III and Jonas 2011; Lynch 2013; Schneider 2013) Chapter 24 Lecture – Ch 24 Chapter 3 VPC; assignment 9/10 (due November 19th ) Student presentations – VPC #7 & 5/8 Lecture – Ch 3 Student presentations – VPC #9/10 Page 8 of 9 REFERENCES Drew, J. 2012. Criminal minds. Journal of Accountancy (August):26-31. Jones III, A., and G. A. Jonas. 2011. Corporate social responsibility reporting: The growing need for input from the accounting profession. CPA Journal 81 (2):65-71. Lynch, N. C. P. 2013. The assurance market for sustainability reporting. Journal of Accountancy 215 (5):35. PwC. 2013. Internal control - integrated framework: Executive summary. Committee of Sponsoring Organizations (COSO) [cited August 8, 2013]. Available from http://www.coso.org/documents/990025P_Executive_Summary_final_may20_e.pdf. Schneider, B. A. 2013. Assurance opportunities broaden. Journal of Accountancy 215 (5):32-36. Tysiac, K. 2012a. Internal control, revisited. Journal of Accountancy (March):24-29. ———. 2012b. Small businesses, big risk. Journal of Accountancy (August):38-43. ———. 2013. Newly released COSO framework a frest look at internal control, August 8, 2013 [cited. Available from http://www.journalofaccountancy.com/News/20137970. Page 9 of 9