What I’m going to talk about
New approaches to implementing
mental health programs in
primary care
Professor Helen Lester
Academy Health, Orlando, June 2007
ƒ
ƒ
Background to UK Mental Health issues
Two stories of programme implementation
1. Stepped care models for depression and
Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT)
schemes
2. Health checks in primary care for people
with serious mental illness
Primary care policy context
ƒ
ƒ
ƒ
ƒ
NHS budget for 2006–07 is $190 billion
1.33 million employees
Services are free at the point delivery
Primary care has a gate keeping role
ƒ Primary care has been viewed as
increasingly important in mental health policy
terms since 1999
ƒ NSF (1999) and 5 year review (2004)
ƒ National Plan (2000)
ƒ Tackling Health Inequalities (2003/6)
Treatment of depression: the
problem
Self care 1-2 million
Shared care
300,000
„
„
Primary care
3.75 million
Specialist services
600,000
„
„
Prevalence of 2.1-9.8% (NICE, 2004)
40% of people have a chronic relapsing illness
(Lloyd, 1996)
5,000 deaths p.a.
Economic costs particularly in terms of
unemployment and state benefits
1
Incapacity Benefit recipients by
medical condition in the UK (2004)
The evidence base: NICE
guidance on depression (2004)
ƒ Uses a stepped care framework
Nervous system
10%
Musculo-skeletal
20%
CVD and RD
9%
Mental disorder
38%
Injury
6%
ƒ Recognises that depression can be a chronic
illness and therefore borrows from chronic
disease management models of physical
health problems (Wagner, 2004)
Others
17%
Over view of the stepped care system
Step 5: Inpatient
care, crisis team
Step 4: Mental health
specialists including
crisis team
Step 3: Primary care team,
primary care mental health
worker
Step 2: Primary care team,
primary care mental health
worker
Step 1: GP, practice nurse
Risk to life, severe
self-neglect
Treatment-resistant, recurrent,
atypical and psychotic
depression, and those at
significant risk
Moderate or severe
depression
Mild depression
Recognition
The implementation gap?
Medication,
combined
treatments, ECT
Medication, complex
psychological interventions,
Case management and
collaborative care
„
The NICE guidance has few ‘teeth’ in terms of
implementation
„
Lack of therapists so 6-9m waiting lists for
people from step 2 onwards…
Medication, psychological
interventions, Case
management and collaborative
care
Watchful waiting, guided
self-help, computerised CBT,
exercise, brief psychological
interventions
Assessment
Recent implementation levers
ƒ Bad publicity
- ‘NHS failing to act on talking therapies clinical
guidance, says new report’
- ‘Depression: the great happiness pill betrayal’
ƒ Pledge to IAPT as part of the 2005 Labour
election manifesto
The vision: Lord Layard and the
LSE’s ‘New Deal’
ƒ
ƒ
ƒ
ƒ
ƒ
ƒ
ƒ
ƒ
High profile media coverage
10,000 more therapists by 2013
Cost of $120 million
Working in teams in 250 centres
Centrally funded and commissioned
Providing 16 weekly sessions lasting 1 hour
‘Should more than pay for itself’
Focused on return to work issues
2
The practical strategy: IAPT programme
Early findings
ƒ 2 very different demonstration sites
ƒ Some new monies but mainly service
reconfiguration
ƒ Cooperation between sectors
ƒ Mental health champions
ƒ Doncaster is using a high volume low
intensity model with case managers as part of
a stepped care framework
ƒ Newham is using specialist CBT providers
ƒ 10 new sites this Summer recognising the
advent of different funding mechanisms for
commissioning within the NHS
Doncaster:
ƒ Need: 2,000 people referred in 5m
ƒ Referral pathways: 95% from GPs
ƒ Workload: Mean number of sessions = 3 (211)
ƒ Stepped care model: 10% of people stepped
up to CBT
ƒ Outcomes: access (including waiting times)
and inclusion (including employment)
ƒ Waiting times: 1 week
Serious mental illness in primary
care: the problem
Serious mental illness in primary
care: the evidence base
ƒ Lifetime prevalence of 3.48% (Perala et al,
2007)
ƒ Often starts at a young age so a lifetime of
consequences
ƒ Societal exclusion including 4% employment
rates
ƒ Higher morbidity and standardised mortality
rates (151) than the general population
(Social Exclusion Unit, 2004)
Implementation gap
„
„
„
NICE guidance (2002/7) includes roles for
primary care but has few teeth
Educational gaps (only 2% of practice nurses
and 30% of GPs have postgraduate mental
health experience)
Primary care practitioners can be as narrow
minded as the rest of the world
„
„
„
„
Variable/poor health promotion and health
prevention in primary care (Brown 1997; DRC
2005)
SMR of 156 (Harris and Barraclough, 1998)
GPs’ view that the work is too specialised
Patients’ view that primary care is the
cornerstone of care (Lester et al, 2005)
Implementation levers
ƒ Networked grass roots support for change led
by local and national mental health champions
ƒ Financial incentives in primary care through the
Quality and Outcomes Framework (2004)
3
The vision: Quality and Outcomes
Framework
25% of GPs’ income relates to a set of evidence
based quality indicators that apply to primary care
ƒ Chronic disease management (18 areas- 4%
of the overall points/money focused on SMI)
ƒ Practice organisation (5 areas)
ƒ Additional services (4 areas)
ƒ Patient experience (consultation length and
patient surveys)
Early findings: points achievement
in 2005/6
The practical strategy: reorganisation
of care for people with SMI
„
„
„
„
-
Register of patents with a psychosis
Lithium levels monitored and therapeutic
Annual relevant physical health check up and
medication review
Liaison with secondary care e.g.
Follow up if the patient doesn’t attend
Care plan to include social networks, early
warning signs and crisis plans
Generalisable lessons
ƒ Alignment of an agreed problem + evidence
base + policy levers + a clear vision + practical
strategy
100.0%
99.0%
98.0%
97.0%
96.0%
95.0%
ƒ Variable amounts of new monies
94.0%
93.0%
92.0%
91.0%
I
a
M
S
As
th
m
Ca
nc
er
PD
H
yp
ot
hy
ro
id
CO
pil
ep
sy
E
P
be
te
s
Dia
IA
B
/T
C
VA
D
C
H
LV
D
90.0%
ƒ Reconfiguration and co-operation e.g. across
the interface has occurred with some new but
mainly existing staff rather than whole new
systems
“Although vision is important for initiating
change, it is not enough to organise and
maintain a system of care. Vision must be
translated into practical strategies.”
(Alan Rosen,The mental health matrix.1999)
4