(
,
,
,
.
,
/
$
!
% &
' %(
"#
/,
0
,
1
,
)
)**+
,
,
Take subtrees of the recursion tree (breath first) and automatically perform them
on connected machines in usual fashion (depth first).
.2
3
5
6%
&
4789:6
1
1 4788+6
; < 1
&478896
=
1
478896
! 1
5
4788:6
%
>
&4)**06
"#
2
. ! 5!< !.. 4)**+6
%%%
)**+
,
4
recursion
tree
single
machine
-
connected machines
(LAN and/or Web)
0
)**+
+
$
5
,
"
A
,
>
2
4
6
,
,
, B
,
6
,
,
,
4@
,
4
,)
5G
H (1G5
5G
5G
H1 I
I
G5
HJJG5
6
(
4
,
%C
D Aimplements SerializableB%
D ,
4
6
,
2
,
,
,
K
D
,
4
4
,
6%
6%
%
%
,
D
D ,
,
,
,
%
=
D&
%
,
D
6 E7
4
?
)**+
6
%
F
)**+
D
=
,
,
4
3
6
D
L
;
,
,
,
,
4
A
,
,
,
/
/
%%
,
%
D
%
>
,)
, D
L
1
4
6
,
5G
,
0
2
,
6%
-
D
(
%
4
1
D
H
G5
%%%
D
>
,
,
%%%
B6
,
%
4)*G
M
(
,
4
NE
/
,
J&
J(
6
6
.
/,
, O
.
,
,
)*
,
/
D
,
,
,
,
2
,
&Adata transfer time’ < ‘CPU-timeB
,
/,
,
,
,
D
, ,
4
B
,
3
,
6
M
,
, A
)**+
,
%
,
,,
B%
8
.
/,
,
,
(4 )6
2
4
E7
"
K
"
P
,
!2
/ ,
4
.
,
A
,
=
6D
1
%
B
$
7%
,
6
%%%%
D
&
,
,
,
D 7 ) %%%%
, 6 Q
)*G4
4@
)%
.
0%
!2
,
,
6%
,
M ,
D(
,
(, 1 '
M (4 06 4 % %/
% 0986
D
L
)**+
,
,B ,
,
4) @ 7R )6
7)
Data partition/full fanout (Goldbach) and recursive decent (Hamiltonian) problems
compared with IDEAL: T1 / (#machines - 1)
&
6
4S
"
,
@)
1
L
=
)*
,
,
0
8
0)6
3000
Hamiltonian
,D
2500
IDEAL
%
Goldbach 2-1300000
2000
,B ,
,
D
=
7R ) @
@ ) + F %%% 70*****
, = %1
Seconds
L
,
,
$
1000
M
1
,
&
((
1500
4
, 54S
6D
,
500
76
0
S
1
2
4
8
16
32
# Worker machines
70
)**+
&
&
6
.
M 79
,/
,
,
Number of parameter sets handled by each Worker machine - 24 equal machines
100
92
91
89
90
80
17 cities w ith local cutoff
70
Seconds
8000
# parametersets
10000
Homgen. machines
Heterogen. machines
6000
60
50
40
30
25
4000
20
16
12
2000
14
14
12
8
4
7
5
6
14
15
7
12
13
13
22
23
24
9
8
3
2
0
0
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
1
35
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
Worker machine number
# m achine s
)**+
13
12
10
7?
16
17
18
19
20
21
&
&
&
6 ,
4
,
%! B
,
$
M
M
,
M
6
79
)**+
4 2
6@
@ ,
2
(
A B
M
6
4
! ,/
,
! ,
,
@ 7***
,
M
iD
i-1
,
,
,
i
k
4
k
K 6
M
$
1
,
(4
6
,
G@
%
2
,
)**+
,
D
D (4 6
D (4 )6
78
%
)**+
)*
Improving performance of STEP/EXPRESS
(A. Næss) – handcoded, not ‘pure’ PRP
. ! 5!< !..
!" &;
"
D. &
"LT
&D. &
"LT
/=! !I H D
4&U
7VE@ WW "$&U
7VN@ W
K
W
6(
4&U
7VE@ WW "$&U
7VN@ W
XW
6T
!"$H!" &;T
2
,
4!
6
6
-
4
,
4
6
! ,
,
!" &;J
4
.'C ; !(J4
6T
=
D( &
(" I
!"$H!" &;T
6
, ,
, -
"
!" &;
!
,
,
4
,
1 '6
.'C ; !(J4
6T
&
" ! .!
DJ
J( =
!"$H!" &;T
=
,
T
))
)**+
J
4+
C
T
,
7*
,:1 '
% . K D ) 0 M 7))
6
5
%
D
!
4!
"#
J
,
R
D
,
6D ! ,
,
,
1'
&
4
%%6
DJ%
)**+
,
,
4
,
,
,
,
-
6
)0
)**+
)+
0
,
C-
1
)**+ )**?
Y
D
,
K
, planet-lab.org
1,
D
%
%
. ,
.
,
4
,
C
1S
=
(4 6
%"!
6
D$
4
"
5
6
(4
K
)**+
>
%
I
,
'
,
)?
)**+
7%?6
,
+?
,
, %
)F