Urban Policies
and the Right
to the City
in India
2011
Rights, Responsibilities
and Citizenship
Social and Human
Sciences Sector
8QLWHG1DWLRQV
(GXFDWLRQDO6FLHQWL¿FDQG
&XOWXUDO2UJDQL]DWLRQ
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
November 2011
Published by the
!
"
New Delhi 110029
India
And
#
$
%&
New Delhi 110011
India
'(
)*+,*
-.*/34*4-
5
6
7
#
)&6
8%
'(
:
;
4-
4
<'(
(
"'8:
3
4%<'#$"
8-
4-<
=(>:
(
)$*;
-(>
<7>(-
(>(#?>56
=
$-"
@BC)CE)CEC)F)G
5-
#4<
-4
#
---4%
#4<-H4
<46-
"-4
-
of any country, territory, city or area or of its authorities, or the delimitation of its frontiers or
%
>
5-
-
4%--
-4
-
-%K
-4H4-6--
<-
##-
>
4
-4%
#
<%4
<#%<
<#
6--6
4#>
$<##
-4%
#
<%
'
(
:
#
63-
)
!
"
New Delhi 110029, India
5'LEEEMBEGOOO
:
H'LEEEMBEGOOEEGOO
#
'#>
Q>6-Q>
R%'666>>6-
Printed in India
Supported by Sir Dorabji Tata Trust.
Urban Policies
and the Right to
the City in India:
Rights, Responsibilities and
Citizenship
Scientific Editors
Marie-Hélène Zérah, Véronique Dupont, Stéphanie
Tawa Lama-Rewal
Publication Editor
Marina Faetanini
2011
Supported by Sir Dorabji Tata Trust
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Acknowledgements
ii
5-4%
--#
<"-6EM
4
4%<-6EF
-
4
'4
H#
87
6"<R
6KS
#!
#@4&
-
%
S&
#>-
8
34
#(
%
@
@84
T(#%
US-
-6#K3
8
5
@
T(#%
US
%-
-3T63-US
&
"3
5
-$
<
@
8
-4
8<8TR
-3US
.*/34&
-:6
:-@&
-3"4#
T8
USV<
;-@4&
-S
(?-
:#4
&
44
$/
#
&-
H"3
7
&-6KT63-US3<
(-
8)
:6T63-US?
"<
(-<8
3--
#S-"
6
&
#
8)
:6:-@T8-<US*4-
5
6
7
#
)&6
&
-:6
34<
3WXW@W$
T&)8
US
(
)*+
,*
-&
-:6T63-U
@&
-3"4#T8
U>
5-
-
#
-7
;
<
8
-
(K-4
-<
<-
"
%##
6
(<$-<
"$4
(
$
-
>
4
-
K
-4
4
-)@&8#
<
(-C%OEO
-8
&"6(-G(
-OEET6
3-%-
U-%
4
',
$-#
Gautam Bhan, Banashree Banerjee, Alison Brown,
<
-6-<"
!;(>$>V
6
3%
?3
-(
-
"
-
&
#
-
$6
-
-
.!
<-V>>
5-
K?
4
.6
->
:--4%
-
<%
#-4
8
##4
@
(
(
8
#
/
(
:
4
##4
#
63-
6--
-6K
4%
editor, assisted by Daniela de Simone and
&K#5
K-
-
&
-
4
##
-<<
4)
(
)$*;
->
5-4%
-
%#-
%
-@
&
-T@&U#
%<'
3>V
"$
#H)-
43>&
!-
(#%
<
3>?>>V-
H)
3)
>
34
-3
%!5
56-
44-
#
-
4%
4%>
Foreword
$
6)4-4-
R##
3"4#E
%6-)$@5$5-
#"
4#-
"4#%
4%46--
44
4#"
-
#
<>
<
""--K%6
-
4<#
K%
"
<
4<
#
"
"
-K%
-
"<%
>
$6%
#6K
<#
@
6-%<OO-%
44
6
4#-
-
-44
-<
F>4
#-
CB#446-#-right
to the city4
46
%
---
-
#
>
<--H
-4
4-4%
----
"
@
-#4<<
4-right to the city as a vehicle for social
%
"4#
@
>@
#
44-
"4#
-)%
44
-
%
@
-4
-
4
6
allocation favorable to the most vulnerable
4
"
-
-%
4
#
6#
->
@6-4"4<#
K
<
4
6-
##
6
%
4
-
6-
-
4%
-
tolerance, and reinforce the inclusion of the most
"
%%
#
#>
We trust Urban Policies and the Right to the City
in India: Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
6
44<
#
K
"
6
%
-
H-
K6%6
-<
4
-%
">
@6--
K#6
#<
-H4
6--
"%-#4-
#4#
4
-
#
63-
-"
%44-<-
"H
the right to the city initiative, and the Sir Dorabji
5
56-
44#
4%>
@K
8
"K
3
&4
"
>>
@
-
(
"
7
K
iii
Contents
1
12
16
21
31
39
43
48
58
63
76
98
Right to the City and Urban Citizenship in the Indian Context
(
)*+,*
-*4-
5
6
7
#
&6
.*/34
%-
-
The Constitutional and International Framework
(?-
A Philosophical Reading of the RTTC
4
H
Urban Governance: How Democratic?
*4-
5
6
7
#
)&6
Women’s Right to the City: from Safety to Citizenship?
*4-
5
6
7
#
)&6
Caste and Class in Indian Cities: Habitation, Inequality and Segregation
3<
(-
Muslim Neighbourhoods and Segregation in the City
V<
;-
Migrants’ (Denied) Right to the City
&
#>-
Urban Spatial Exclusion: A Historical Perspective
3<
(-
Claiming Land: Rights, Contestations and the Urban Poor in Globalized Times
#!
#
-"
6
&
#
The Challenge of Slums and Forced Evictions
.*/34
Urban Livelihoods: the City versus the Informal Economy
-
-6#K(
)*+,*
-
%-
-
109
122
133
143
Water and Sanitation: Barriers to Universalization
(
)*+,*
-
Urban Transport and the Right to the City: Accessibility and Mobility
?
"<
(-<
The Retreat of the State in Healthcare Policy and the Right to the City
&
"3
A Human Rights’ Perspective for the Right to the City
(?-
150
Notes on Contributors
154
References
172
List of Websites
175
List of Boxes
176
List of Tables
176
List of Figures
177
List of Abbreviations
Introduction
Right to the City and Urban
Citizenship in the Indian Context
Marie–Hélène Zérah, Stéphanie Tawa Lama-Rewal, Véronique Dupont, Basudeb Chaudhuri
5-]R-
-&--<^
4_OOF
-
:#
for the Americas and later that year at the
R%
:#T
4#%
OOFU#
%<
"
#"#
4#
-)%
44
--
-
%
>5--
"
-44"
"#6--
K4-
K"4<-
)$@5$5
6---
-
-/%
-4
---<>@OO
)$@5$5
4!
]%
8
-&--
<'&-&4%
-4^
T6
?
OOU
-6
6%<-)$@5$54
the state of the world’s cities which articulates
-#4
K6
--
-<
"-
T)
$@5$5OEOU>
3%
-"
-&--<-
@
H%-"
"
for a series of reasons that are discussed in this
44
4>R--@
;"#
-
"!
--&
!"$6
`!
8
##T8
#):U
4
-
%
8"<&
<TOEO)OOU
44
#<4
4-%
>
5-%!"-46%6'TU
-&--<T&55U
44
-
H
#
<
4
#
"
@
S
TU
KK-H
4%#-
-
H
4<
#6K>5-6%
--
#%-#'6#-
<
-
%
"
#
"-
#-
K
--
-%
K4#
!>$4
-
H-46
#
"
4%4#-"
1
-#
644
##
>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
1. The Concept of RTTC
5-4-&--<T&55U
46<"
"<
#%"
-
##S%<
<
#
<-4
<#4
<#
"
>The Right to the City is the title
%K6EMC%<7%"
:-(
H
6-#
it to be a radical call to all inhabitants in the
<%-]4g%
k
4
^T7%"EEU
444
>@-EO7%"6
"
%<$#
)(
H-
-
3
"
"<6-----
7%"p--
<p%
>5---<-EMO
-
#4
<<
<%-
7%"
"<-
"-
%-
#
64
4
-
4
-<>@-
4
-&55
4
/-
4
#
#
S"
)
"-6
")%
#
-
-
"
#
-4%6
-
-4"
"<
-6">]5---<gqk
#-
-"
-
-
-<#%)
-
-
-<#
-
p
^T
"<OOC'GU>#-
#"#-
4--
--
-<
<
4-
-
-4%
4
1
-"%<
<
#%
#
%6>@--#"#
#-
-
1
4%<-
“7%"
^
-<
<
%<-
%
>@--%
6K
of associations and social movements, such as
the International Alliance of Inhabitants2 or the
%
@
G
-
->
5-
44
-4
#
#4
-&55
%--
%%
<%<
6---
"4#
>-$
-
8
8
-
-
&55
4"<
H%
%
T8
8OEOU>5-<-
-T#"
4
-
-
<
"
%
#"--
--%
"6--
<%
-"U-
%%#-
)#4
&55>
$-
-]-
-
-#%
4"<
-
-
-
"#"-
/
-"4"<
>^
T8
8OEO'EU>
54#<-#
4
-&55
-in the city, while its radical
4
-
-&55
-
-#4
>@%-#
-6"-4&55/"
-4>:<
-
#
:
-]R
^
#4
6`K6--4
-&-<$
-
T
666>--<>U>
2
5-@
$
@-
%
T666>-
%
>U
4
"##
-6
--##644
44#6K
-%-
4
-
#
--->
G
666>-)>>5-
%
@
6
EBM#<-%
-
H4
"
##%-47
$#
$
$
-
%%
#--ECO6
>5-@
)4
FOO
T#4
#"#
-)"#
"<
>U
"
6-
%
#>@#
"
"
44--
-
">@<
-
%
#4
K--
#4
-R
-
-&--<>
2
time, to entitlements and to claims, that is, to
-#
-
-
-#
>
@6-H-T-
-
-"#4
U%
6-
#-T-
--4%
4U>5-
%6#
%
"->
5--"-<6K-<
#"-<>6#
4<#
-<#
%T
-U4
%
%T
4U
T -4>U
"
%T%
"U>
5-<-6
-
6--#-"%
%6"
"->
$7%"
-
6
-&55
"-6-H
##-4--
>5-
H4
-
%6-4
&55
-6%
#"#
)#
-
<
#"#T8OOOOGU>`
-)
%
44
-
4#"
-'4%4
4
4
4
T
%
U
<%
%
-<>
5-6
44
--
%
#4#
<'-
#%
#%66-
-
#4"
#-
#
4>(%
#%6--
#4"4
%
4
4%
-4"-"
"-
6
6%
6
7%"4]#^-<>5-
#4#
%
%<8
(
>:-#-
-4%6-
-<
-&55
%
-
"-<))
<T6--4
#
-
%
KU-<)-
)
-)%T--
#
#
-U'](
<-
#
4
#--
#
'
-
-S4
%6
S
<
%"#S4
4
)#
KS#4<#S
S
#
4-
#%<>
5-
4
-
-<
<
6--#
-]^-
<-
<6--7%"#
>6"-<
4
S7%"p#
#-
<>
%
#4
4--%-<
6-
#
^T(
OEO'CCU>
5-
<
"
-&55
4
-6-#--
4">
%"
-&55
46political
4>5-/
-
series of social movements, in India as elsewhere,
-
-
"--T-
-
-
>>>U
-
#>
6"6--#%46-
4"
"
"4-/#4#
44
6--
4>
5-
--<
by Indian social movements, and it would be
#4
-
-"#-
6-
-6-p>
@-46-466
4-#4
-&55
>>66
--
-<-
>5-#4-
6
K<-
-<6-
<
K-4%
#%<
#
<
%>
5--
#
"
-
%<-4&556
%4
-%
K>@-
#4%-
-"<
-4-
-&55
"
<6--
%
4
6
4
%<"6
-<
]^>
2. Urban Citizenship in India
-4&55-@
H%--
%
-4>-4
%
%
<
%
<%6
3
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
->>-6-
-
6-
-##<>
-4
T--
-U%
""
4
T-
%
4%U>5-
%
-4#%
<
#-
-46--
'K-
-
S
%
-4#-
%
<
-
%#
<>(4<%
-4
44
"<%"<
4%
<%6-446-
4#
-<
->@
-4#
4
T
<6-44
#"#4
-U#
K
#
4
4"6
-#4#
4>
$
$44
TEMU
]q8
#
#
-4%#
##%-4<
qq
4
<4"-
-4^T4>ECU>
5-
-<
-
6-
-"
4
]4#
-4^T4>EU->
4
5--4#-
-6--
@
%--
-%!H4
%<
"<"
#<-<4%<
-%-
>5-
<4-#"
]
6
%
H4
<^-#4<
-
-4<Kp44<
p#>5-
-4-
<>8
<p
H
<-#4
4%
--4
%
#
<--%">5-
#4-
4%<-%-
-#%<K-
-
-%
#
-
-<4
"
#%K-%
4
TV
OOCU>@-4
@
"
4
6---
4"
%64"<
4
4
"#K'-%
4-
"
#---
4
4
-
-
>
8
-
-
!p%6]4
<^
]"<^T-
!OOFU
%#
H-
%6-]"4^
-]
H)4
<
-^>5-6
%<6K4
%<-H-
--
-
%-
-
#-
"-T
4%)
44<
H4
<U6---
"
">@4"-4
-4
##
#
"---/#-
"
%
@
>
:
<#4
-
4
<-
%
4!<%
--<x%
--"
--
%---8%3%
<#T83U--#6-
#
#-x-6-
-
"
4
>5-
-
%
-4-4"
%
--<H
#
-%
4#
--#
4-
-
-<%-
<
#
!6
<
-#
-4
6KH
#4><-
6
-464"#4
"H"
44T6#
-
U"
H-
-6-
%<
%/
-4>5-
4#
/
%
-4
<K%
#
-
4<-
4@
>
3. Positioning India’s Urbanization
and Urban Poverty
34#
K
%)
GBB#
44
<x-%
44
4
-
)--
@
44
TGEz
-OEEU>$
H4
<-@
6-
44
<4
E>EO%TOEE
U4
4
46-
-"%
6
-"4##4
>@@
4%
-#%
4
#
-6%--
than the numbers of current urban dwellers,
-6-
-
6
4
4<#
K>
%
@
"-
H<<
-
%<
-%
44
#
"
-%>@EE-
#
-
@4@
-
#
"
#-
%
4Ez-
%
44
SOEE-6G
FGz-
%
44
#-##
46-#-
E
#44T(#%
3-U>
Box 1. Towns and cities as per the Census
5-
#
%
6-EME@
%
-6'
T
U $4
6--
6
administrative criteria, such as the
#4
<
4
#%
6
##>5-
-
<6>
T%U $-4
6--
<-
6-
#
<'
U
###44
OOO
-
%
SU
44
<
FOO44/
K#S
U
B4-#
6K44
>5-
-
6>
#6-
44
EOOOOO
#
#
]^
-6-
#44#
]#4
^
%
#
>
6-
4
%%
#
-##4
%
6->5--
#
-
6-%
44
-
"
%6Ez
Fz#EME
OOE6-
T-H
%-"
-U
%MOz
#ECEOOET"
#
K-
?
>OOU>5-%
#"
-
6
-Hp%
-
-#4%
6-%
<-4%
4
6>
5-
#
<
#-4"
-OEE"
#
4-6-6-
#4
T6--
%H4
U-
--
"%#
6#44"#
6--
%H
<%
T?OEEU>$"
%
444
%6
<6-H#4
>
5-#
THEU
-/-%#4-
>
5-
#
"%
%
#
4
%
4
>5-#
-#4
%
6
-
6--%
4
"
-%>
@4
-"4#4)%
""
4
#
6-
#4
)
"#
"
%<#
K
/
4)
#
"!>
.
"
44
%
-
"</-
"
%
>$
44
--
%
4-<
#
6-
EOOOO-
%
#-
%"
T3(
);
OEEU>5-#%
%
-OOE6
%6-
#%"
#4%
5
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
"%
GBz
<
EO44
%"-OOE
>5-
4
4
]H#4
^
#<
%
4
-#4
6
as secondary cities than is shown by the census
>$#-
-44
6-
-
"#
town of 50,000 or more, estimates the level of
%
%zT-
44
OOMU
4-
#
4T-
OOCU>@
-<
4"
OEE
#
4-
-%
4'
BG6OEE
BBF
66-
-
"%
2001F>
@
-
#
%
44
-
""
-
4-
-
"4###
-#
#%<-
"4"%
4#
-<>@
-&55-
-
44
]%
^
#4
<#
#
S
-
4"%#"
%
---<
<
"K%<
%
4"<>
8"<@
#
64
%
--
44
--<%
THU>5-"%
4"<
<%<-|
%
8"<&
<OEO)OOp8
4
T(
-OO'EMU#H']
measured by the headcount ratio5-
44
#FzEBG)BF>BzOOF)Og
#4
M>Fz
C>Gz4"<
k%-#%-%
F
4-
"#MO#CO>C#
4
--
%
4-
g#%4k#EC>BzM>Cz"
-EBG)BFOOF)O4^M>5--
#
-
OOF)O]"<%
@
""-
&>Eg
}O>Fk4
<^T%'GMU>56#
%
4"<"#>:
--
%
4
#6
%/
##
#4-#
"%H4-4"<@
><%
4--
4#
<
)6
#
#4<#><4
K-
%
4"<"-
%"
47S"-
H#
K%<
-
%-
4T%6U-"
-
4"<
>
4. The Changing Landscape of Indian
Cities
R64
#4"
"#
4
4
<
--)"
K
%>
#
#
#4%4>@@
-
%
-4-#<
EE64"
]
6-^'"#6
"
6
6
K>5-
<-
-%
#<-@
;38TMz
)MGzOO)OEOU8
-H4
%6-
%
4"<-
"
4
#->
-#)EO#
T-
?
K
$-
8
-
5
#
U-
"
4
-
"
-4
6#>
<
-BBF66<F
<6T-"%<
%
%<U6--#
G
6
"%<
4
-
<
TU>
5
5--
%
4"<-44%
44
"%6-4"<>
M
#
%<-8
##>
7
5-%
4"<6
<6--6-
-#%%
4H-6-
%
44)
'--
@
"-4-%
44
-
%<EMEz#EBEOOE
6--#%%
4-
"
%<Gz#EBG)BFOOF)>
8
5-4#-
-%
-
-;38>:-
H
#<#
>6"--
6
#
GB>BzEBO)EBEzE)OOO
H4
-Bz-@
;38%<OGO>
6
Box 2. How many poor in Indian cities?
@OO-8
##
K6-"4
#-#
4"<
44--5K
##-
%#4OO>5-6
4"<
%<-5K
4-
@
%
4"<%
K
-
#
6%
4"<
-
)
%
4>5-##-
6%
4"<
64>5--
%
4%<-8
##$4OEO>5-4
4%
#
-
#
-
-#-<>>>Bz
OOF)OO>6"-
"4
-
-
-64
%<-5K
##>$#4
-EG)EF
-5K
4p
#-<%
4"<-
#GE>Cz>Bz%
>5-"
#
66-
%
4"<
#F>Mz#
-
8
-E>z3-
>Mz(
-
-
GB>Mz
FG>Bz-
T#
-OEO'FFU>
"---5K
p
#--
-6-@
)"
-
#%4
GBzT
#4
B>z6--4"#-<U
/<
-6-
-#%4---
4"<
K6-
"<
%6-
-4>:
3>>>
H
##6--6
4
%<-(<&
3"4#
#46-
O4444-
6-@
-<
OOF)OO>:-#-
#<
-$!4
4
-RK
8#7"--
4
BB
4-#%4
6
"
%44>8
-"
H4
%<
--
-
%
##T&
-
OEEU>"--
4
%
"#-#->
45K
4-8
##-
4
-%
--%6
4"<
&>G
<%
>5-%
<#
-}E>4"<
%<-R
KT888
U
4"<#4
>-%64"<
%
#%
4
##
%
"
"
6-#
<-
-
%<#
<6
6
-
4%<
-44
%H#-
"
%
<
4
##-<%%
>
'
:-44"<5-ECV
<OEE-4'666>-->#4
EEOOFF>
#
-TOEOU56
68"<7@
#
8
RK<€7.E44>GC)FC>
V-
>TOEEU&4<5-6@
H4EV<OEE-4'H4%>#44))
)4<)OOO>-#>
8
##BV
OEE
"
%
-4'4
##>>4484"BV
EE>4
&
->TOEEU(
#4"<'4
44#
8
RK<€7.@F44>FO)FG>
-#
4-%
###
-
;"#--
-4
4
##-V&(THGU>:#
#4"6
#
<
#
#
4
%
--44
)
"#
#4"-
-
-
#
K>@-#4<
#
K--
"
#4"/
<%--
K
#4<#44>6"
#
4
-H
#%
#6->5--
#
#4<#6-4#
7
Box 3. The Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission (JNUURM)
7
-%<-(<%
3"4#3#%OO
4"
<
-
4
###46%#'U%
"
#%<-(<%
3"4#S
U
"-%
8
T8U-(<
%
8"<$"
>5-
#-V&(
]
#
K4
"4#>:%
<%
""<#-
###<4
4
-
%<7T%
%U4
6
>^#4
#-
-V&('
E> 5-
##%T%--G#)4
4C)
4
S
-
U>
> 5-
%
#
T&>EOOOO GGG%
US$U>5
-
"44
<3"4#8
>5-
%-G""#'
%"F#44
Gz
;"#Ez
;"#
Oz%
7
S%6EF
#44
-
OzOz
GOz4"<>
G> 5-H4#4
"-K
%6
"
%
"4"
%
6
>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
F> 5-#4EG#
<#%-7
"#T
4
-%
7
&
$#44<
H
-
)"
4""-4U>
> 5-#4
"
---
44
-BF-
$##$T$$U-
#
##<4
4
6
4%
6
4
#
<#>
5-V&(p
#-
-4
%<
%
"4#4
#-
#4
-
-"
4%<
4-4
>$--6###
</
-
"
"#
#-V&(-
##"
#<-#
-")„)"-
-
K
-%
4T4
%#
"-%
8U
-
/
-4
4
-7>
'-4'!#>>
#4<#-
6>5-
-
4#/
-
<
!%-
#"
%<4<#
K><"
H-#4
-#
#%46--
#
>-
<-<-
#
<
#-
4%<-
8
#
#<T--4
-
6K
#
K6
#
<U-<
-
-
%<4#
-4!-
4
#">
&-%
#<#
<
%-
#
-H
%
4
-46%
4
>--
##
#4H
#4HT
-6
-#-44
-
-44-UH4
#
4
T-
#
<"--6
<U
64-<
4
@
]6
^>-
--
#4
4
slum demolition and resettlement sites, when
#
"
%-
""-4#-
<
-4
6K>("-
4"
4%4
---4"
#
#4
K
H
#4%#44
-
H"
4
%
-
-<>4
4-#-
4
6
#4
/4
>%
4"<
<
#--H"<#
>
#6-6-%
4"<
-
-
4%4<
<%<
#
#4"#
-
-<
-&
!"
$6
`!
T&$`U>
:
<
#
4
H4
#
6
K
"%
#>5-BFth
$##E
4
6
#
K
"#
<
4%--"#>
@
#-
#46-
%
4%#
--%-
-
#
"-%<-4
#
>5--
44
46
"#-
6-
-
##46
%-#
-6"4#
<
4
-
%
<>
--
-
#
#
#
%
4
"##
%
%>
---
-
""#
%
4"
T%-K)
K
#
U
"<
K-
T;6
##<)%
U-
"-
#4
)#
K4>:
<
-
-#
K
4#
industries or slum evictions, is at variance with
6
4%
#
<
6--44%
K<#-
V&(
%
"
>
5-
4
#
-
"
#
-6
<
6--6-
-
"%
%>
#
-
%
>7
#
"<
"#
#
#
%
>5-<
6-#
44H-<4#
<#<
###
#>6"-
%<@
"<
-64
<#
H6-
"
%<-
/
%%4
>5-H
%
%<4!)%
urbanism and the collusion between decision
#
K
464"
T4
-
</
6--
]
#
^U>
(4
<-
#4
-
4
#<%
<
)4
)#
4
<
#)
"#>5-
"
6
#
#<3-
(#%
4
%-
#
%<
%
#4<#
-%
#6-"
6
H
%
<>5-4
%
"
6
-K-
#
-
T
#
U
are issues that could alter the terms in which
---4
#
4>
5-
<-
--<
#4
-
4
"
9
44%4>-
<
%
6
"4
4
-
-
-#
K-<"
---4
<-|<p
"
#
K-4
"%>@
#4
6-
<4
>$--<
#
-#<4#
made to the Indian State for a more substantive
%
-4>
5. Structure
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
5-4%
-#
4
4
-
#-#
!
K
---###)
<-
&55>@
#
4"
/
44"@
<
-
4%4
-6
">
R-
-/%
4"<
#%-44
/
-
-/
/
-
/
%6
4S6
will, therefore, not restrict ourselves to a focus on
-%
4>
$
4<#-#
%!"
-#4#
-
-4-&55
4%46--
-
-4
%
/
%-
-%6->
$
4
-%
-4
4
H4-H
4<
#6K
6-%
4
%
%
6-
4<##
>
5-
#6K!%<-
#%
6-
4<%
S"
4
#"#
<
-""---
%<"
->-%-
4
-
@
>
5-4
#%H-
"%
%
%%K
6
10
%
-
-""-
4<
#
K
">:<-
%
-
##4
-#-
<
S
-6"--44"
--
-
4
4
"
6K
%<
%<%
#><
4%#4
44-
-
6-
"
4
4
--
%
4
-#>
5-<-#
%
6
#4
%6--
%
"
%>6"-
%!%<-44
-@
H'%
-
-%
44
S-<
--#%
-<
H4
4-
%
S-<
-#
-V&(S
<-<-
"
#4
-6
<-<#
>5-
#4#6-#4
<
<
6
--
#
the foundation and fabric of the Indian city (that
6#
<
%
#<-
U-%
K>-6
-4
!-
#6>
5-4
6>5-
-4
44-
#6K"
-
-
-<-@
H>5-<
on international charters adhered to by India,
6
-"
-
T?-
US-&55
#
-T
HUS
-"
#4
<
T5
6
7
#
)&6
U>5-6%<
4
4-
-T5
6
7
#
)&6
U
T(-
UT;-U
#
T-
U6-
--
-<>5-4
4----
-
)##
%
%4"<)
%
H>5-H64
4
6-
"
#
#%
4
%
>(-
--
#
@
-
6
%
-#4
<#
4
/
6K6-!
#
&
#
#
-
<%
-&55>8
4%<34
-
-6#K,*
-
-
-
%
"--46-
%<
-6#
#---<>
5-
4
4
#
!%
"-
6
T,*
-U
4T(-<U
-
-
T3
U>5-
%-%<?-
%-6--#
-
#6K
%
K-|&--<p6
>
"
-4%
-6-
--
India is endowed with a rich and mostly
4"
"
#6K6--4"
%
4--&556
-#
#%
-#4#
-
#6K>#-#
%
-
>5-
latter is evident when one considers the condition
-%
4
-#
6K'
---<
-]<#
K^-#
-
#-]--<^
-]--<^
-#
%
S
-<
/<
!4
">:-#
6-"<
<
"
in many areas in India cities, their modalities
of intervention do not necessarily favour the
#46#-%
4>@-
H7%"p
-&55-
"
@
<>R-
K
transformation of attitudes and frames of mind,
<>5-&55#4
-
!
-
<#>@-6-&55
44
-
6
%<-]"^
>
5---4%
6--4
#
K-#%46-&55
6-#4<
#
"
>
:
<--4<#
4
4
4%
>5-
""6H4%<-"
-
6--"644>:
%-"
#
-
----H
###
4
#
-
6-
--
%
6>-<
current debates that all those concerned by the
@
4<)#
K
6->
11
The Constitutional and
International Framework Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Miloon Kothari
5-#"#-]&--<^-
%"4%<
4
"
<
#4
%44"<"
4
<-##
4"
>5---<%"6
6
-%
-#
6-<4
-
#4-#
-
<
<>@
#
<
#%
-H
<"4#
"%-
#
#
-
#4
<>
@-
4
<4
#
-
-
4<
"
#
--#
-
#6K-
6#-@
-
-#
-#
-
@
-
>
5-
#4#
"
-44-
4-#
-#-
)#
"%<46#
K
12
-64-#
<-
#
@
>:
H
#4-"%<
44
-
/
-x
--
-&55x
6//
--#
-
---<--#
<-4
---
-
6
"->$<
"
4<#
--
%6--6%6-
-#
-%
>
1. Domestic Obligations
Several articles of India’s constitution are
4
<
-&55>$-
$E
O
-&55
#<--#
-<--
6K
--
/
--
<>5-$E
-
]$-
-
"--TqUTU#"<--
-<@
STU
<4
-<@
S
TU
4
<4
<
<
4
%^>&
--
/
-
---
H4<-
%-
#
->$E4"-
4%
4"--
4
%<>
5-4#
#-
--
<#4
%
#>
5-
--
/
-
>
-4
forced eviction results in the loss of livelihood, it is
4#
$E>
@
$EF
E
%
"/
<%-
K
#
"
44
-
"
4-%#
-
H4
%->&
--4"<
4-%-H-#
#
%
-
-%
#4
-4"
>
@
p###!
/
<
international level is enshrined in Article 51 of
->5-4#-
-
-4"!-
4
4#-
6>
@4
---
"
H"
##-44
%-
"
>
2. International Commitments
-
4-"
3
#
&-TEFCU@
-
-#
-#
"
-&55THFU
H4
4
<-
<%
-
#
&-
"
8&"6<##
-#4#
>
@
-
<%
%"@
-
4
4
##
###
-#
--
-3
8
##$
-R#
&-
Box 4. International human rights
† 5-@
"
#
&-T@&EMMU>
† 5-@
"
"
8
&-T@8&EMMU>
† 5-"-#
:#&
3#
T&3
EMU>
† 5-"#
$
#3#
R#
T3$REBU>
† 5-"$
5
-
@-#
3
5
#
8-#T$5ECFU>
† 5-"-&--
T&ECU>
† 5-"-&-8
6-3
%<TOOMU>
T.
EGU6--#
K
#4
%
-"%<
4
-#
->
5--
/
-x
K-
-#
-
-&55x#
#4-"<
%
-$EETEU
-@
"
#
&-T@&U']5-
4
-4"
--
"<
/
"
-#
-
#<-
-
-#4"#
"q^
It must be noted that India’s commitment to
/
--@&H4<
4-4
">;
##B-###
&--
%
%<!<
4"
<
"
-#
-
6>5-
###
&--
"
"
-#
13
-4
<--
/
->
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
;"-
#4
-
-#
--6#
-
@
"
K
-#
-
4---
-"
-#
3#
$
R#
-"&--
->R#p#4H6--
#<
----
%-
%-
]
/
-^#
44">34-#
4
46#--
#
#H-
<6#-6-4
-
>
@
-%
6#p
--
-
]4
/4
women who are more vulnerable than others, at
--K%#-#
#-/
/
->^
5-"#4
6#
#
-"
-
%---%<-
###
&->
14
("$EM-"-
#
3#
$
R#
T3$RU
<6-
p%
/
<
%-#
6#44<-6-4
#
>##-
#--
--
/
-
6#
p-)
#
>
5-/"
%<-#
#4-"<
-"
-&--->5--
"#
-
-%
-
--#-
#
--p#
"4
"4#>$BTGU
4
4
4"--
6-44-
->$
EMTEU4--#
6
%
<
6---4"
<
#<-#
4>5-%"
-##-&---
-
@
p#4#
6-
4---
"%
/
---4
-"
/
-#
-
">
@
-4"-
#
%"#4
-4
"#-
-"
<%-
""4>:
-###
&--
;
##F-
---
-%#4
--
"<4
<4"
---p#
#>5-%
-
#4--
/
-
<
"
%<
essential services, affordability, habitability,
reasonable location and cultural sensitivity in
-"4#4>-
4
-;
###6K
-
"-
4
-
-
#
--
/
-#
-
--4"
<4
4
##4>
3. Apathetic Implementation
$
<%-
#4#%
>5#<#4#
4"
-#
#
##4
">
5-<%
4
#"
H4<6
-
#
-6-
-
p"#-
->
6"4
de jure
#-
%
"<
#4"-
"/-4
">5-"
-#%6
H
#
-
<
-@
<<#4#
4
-<#4#
%
>5-
-
%4
<4%<#
%-
-###
&-
%"
@
T(
<OOCU>
%
-
<"
-
"
-&55@
>
#
K
-%
##
-
>
.
--
/
-4
in India today, in contravention of international
6>5--##-#
$:#&
3#
-
"-
)
based discrimination and directed State action
-
%<]
K4"4-%
#
4
##%)%
##
-
#4<#^>
6
46--
%
-#
-
"
4"-@
-
)"
<
)%
<
6
/
6-%4
>
-"
4-#
-<;
##>B-###
&-4"
4<
"#
>R--
"
"
-#
-
the event that relocation is unavoidable General
##B
<-4
#-<
"
-#4
-#
#<
444
4%4
4
-
%
-#
-%
4"
%#4
>@
-
84
;
3"4#)%
"
34
#
4"
K4
##4
#<
#4"
""S
4"
/
#-"
-
-
)-
S
/
#4
-
)
>
4. Recommendations
5--#
-
44
--&55
#
#-
#
%<4"
#
H>@@
-
p4%
%<-
#-
#-
%
/
>5-4
#-#4"#>8#4#
#
%
4
56@
-6-
6
6-
$EMTEU3$R>5-
$
4%-
4
K#
#
#
6#
#<
#
#--
]-
#-%-44
-6-4
/#
#
#
!<#
4
44<>^@
p
#-
6
%%<
-4"x]<
-
6-]4<)
-4
<##<^)
#4#-#-
-
/
-4
>
5-"<##
K
"
--#
-
#6K6--
#
#
"
<6KK"
->#4-#
-
-
#4
%
|<-p
-6-
%
6---
#6K>@
44
--
"
-
#4
<-#
-#<
-
"--
%
44"
society to raise objections to state actions and
4%<
"
>$"#-
6K"
-#
-
"4#
@
<"<
contribute to the structure and use of a human
-
#6K-
#"-
4"
#
->#
-
"
-
of a common sentiment imbued with human
->
15
A Philosophical Reading of
the RTTC
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Upendra Baxi
5-|&--<p
#
K
%<
ethical invention of our times, if only because
%
4
-K
%
6-
#
<#
<|-#
p
|-
"p
->
%<|#p
--
|4
p
-
%
<-#
-
S-64
%
#
-#
-
%
#
4-<<
-6
<6--4
-
4--
!-
"
<%<H4>
4-<
<""T#<
EFS3
<OOGOOFU%<6--
&55-<
#"#-
-K
%-#
-
K
<4
>
$
%"
6
#7%"p
4-6%
#
-#
"
#%46
>
7%"p|4
p
|4
4
pT-|4-<
4
16
"<
<6K
4
-6
<pUS-
4
|4
4
pT#
%
K6
%<#
44
46
-
4
U
-|4
4
p#4
-
#
<
|-
%
p4
--6--
|#4H<#%
K)-#
#
"4
TOO'GOU>@
-
--
"|4
p
6
<
socially constructed and the contestation always
-
H-44
4
4
>@
<
K
#
44p"-4
4
>@-/4%<-
-<#
>
1. The Right to City
-6-
&55
4
!
->$
OO-
)$@5$5#
6-
<
-
-]--<^
4"-
'->>>-
"-
4#
6
#9>^
5--
"6
#
->
6#
<6%-#
&55‡3
"
"<
"
##
-p&-p6--
<-
'
]5---<
#-
-)
"
%<
%
'
--
"%<-
-<>@
is, moreover, a common rather than an individual
--
#
"
%<4
4-H
"46-
4
-4%
>5-#
#
K
#
K
"q
-#4<#
-#
-^T
"<OOC'FU>
5-
-
-&55
-]-
"%<-
-<^
>@
--
%<%-46S
"
6
"##-S
-
-"-
"4
">6"-
|6)p
#
"%
-
%
%
only because those who wield economic, social,
4
#
4
6
<6
#
-#|6)>p@
---&55
|-p
#
>$
<-
-4444
#4-
H4
"
<
#"#
#%<-44
4
<
->@#-
#
&55
#
4
-"
<
"
4
-#
->
5-)$@5$5
-&55)
#6-
"<<
#
-]H
"46
-
4-4%
^T
"<
OOCU>@#4
-
#
#
-
K
<4
-#
&55
K-
-
<>
2. Understanding the City as a Site of
New Rights
5#
<#
-<6-
4##<>%-
<
"
6--
->
:6-
%%
-4
6
6K%
4
>5-H
-#
&55
#
#4H-
-4-66
-6
#
<6
6%6-|%
p
|6p
|#
p<10T4EBU>
@66
%
|#
-p
-4
%
4
p-&55
4#
<
#%
#
4
4
>
5-#
<4
4
4
-
6---6
%46#
"-44--<>
K-#
&55<"
"
4-
6>
A much debated instance concerns the limits
46%4
4
4>@#
-
--K
%-&55
-
#-"-#
-4
)
>
5-
"4
-
#
&55
#
<-<
|#
"p
>@|
/<-<-
-
644
#
-R'-#
-4T"
U
%#T%Up-
<4"-6|44"-
9
%
8
-&--<'&-&4%
-4(5)8<8
4TOOU
4>G>
$--
K
%-#
"
4
6--
<%#%
)
T
%EMU
6
%-
"TOOU>
10
17
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
18
##
<S-6-<
-#
<pT`):5
ECC'GEMU>5-
idea of a city as a moral universe accentuates
"
>@
#--
)$@5$5&55"
-
"
-
-4)
4%##6-----
#
#%6-
-%-
##<
-
-#
<
>
5-
-4
6K66#
4
%<4x!
6---
4
<4#
4%<6
-
6-#
##%6-#
-
%
4#"-#
<
4-
<
-#
->5-
-
##
Hx
46-
!>)%
#
6--
<#)K
46-4%<
-#
6
#4
"-
-
#
&55T-@
&<OEOU>
5-
6K-&
|
pp-
#
--
/
<4
<)%
-46-#&55>
-
-4-6-)
#
44
ˆ"#
H
|"4#p4
44>
:--&55
K
K#
<-
-
6--
<"-
##
)
4
)"
>$
-44"-
-4
#
#4
/
<-|
<p
|
p
46>$
-/-4%<&55
K
#"#
-<-
4
-#
--#<
-
#
architecture for at least the constitutionally
4
>5-@
-6-6>
:--6
<
4
4
6#
%
#
4
-
"
"4
#,6<<>
$"
%-"%
4
#
)
T4
U
4#
4
<
##<"
"#
K>$
K@
%/<#
-
K
'
|p4
|"#p
#->--
distance between moral and juridical human
-#
<%H
"
<#
%
-#
---#
"-6-<4
K%->$6
/
-4'-6
&55
K#
<
#
-
<
/
-
K
#|4p
<‡5--4
4-"
"
T
HOEO
U#
<%"-#4H
<#"
&55
--<>
H--6#
<6<
4
6&55
|#4-px6---<
#"#
"
4
6#
4-
|4p|4
p
|-4px
6
6|4
-4p
-#
%
#4"-‡@
<
@-#|#4"-#pT
|4"<pU%
#""<-
4
#"4#
4
--
<
<
#
K
K444|4>p5-#
4
-@
|%
pp%
p4
-
"
-#4"-
6)@
6-
%<
&55
##
"
%
4#
<
#
!>
5-#
&55-#
<%
4#
<#<
#
4<T
"#-%
-
US
rather, it invites labours of theory and movement
%-
6-
%
-#
-
6
#
#
!>--"
<
the dominant idea of a city made, in the main,
4%%<
6%
|"
6-pˆ<
@
#
4->
|@"6-p
44-#
<
|/
%"4#>p@#
K#
"H>8
K<-
44<%-
have little choice but to allow the unconscionable
H4
-
%46
-4
-<
-
644<-#
#
#<46----">@
-
-
|<p<
)
4
>
"--6
"|#"6
p
-&55K
"
-
>
5-<-
K%
K"
<#
that relate the idea of city to the notions of
"
%ˆ-
<4
"<
<T"#
K##
4U-4
"|"
p
T#
K4
<
"
"6-6"6x
4
4U>@K6-
#-
-&55H-
T--
"U
%@%"-
->
3. The Specific Vicissitudes of RTTC in
Indian Constitutionalism
5-@
%<#
"%6
#
T"
4
U-
-8
@@@
8
@.#%3"84
8<T
#-U%
unfavourable conditions for democratic judicial
---
"-44-%
#4"->
:-4
%
6)
K6
<
"--
-%
#
-
-
%
44<
"4>
5-4-
-#
-
#4<#
"
>5-"
--#
-%
#4"-4"
#"
%-
<<)
#
--#
--
->
@-H-
-
!
<
-4--
4
-4#@
T@
-
U5-6K-6
-4)#<
6--4#
@
<-"
4#
"
#
4@
T:#
OOCU>5-
-)"x
6---@%'
U "8
@.-
%8
@@@
-S
%U "%
-#
!
-#
-S
U &
<#
--!
#"
T$7U
#
#
4%
T8@7US
U 3"4
4
-4%6
4
-#
-
#"#4
-#
-
4!
"
4%4<
H"
>
@-H-
-4#
@
-
5 case #
-
"
-
--H-#%
<
4
"#66-6%"
--#4--
#"<4%
>@""
4-%-
-#
->5-!-
5#
OEO
%<-3---
#
->@
H#4
<#-
p#<4<-"
%
4<%
<#
-
-
;
##BTEBU-##
#
--
19
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
&4-4
&
44$/
-384>
-
-
#4#%<"-
%
#4"->@--
<
necessary relocation shall be consistent with the
4"-
-
|%
"
#6---
<
--p
-
"<|
>p
20
$
<
!
<
-4
4
<
%<-!
>@OOO-4#$#
>8
">@
-3-
Government and other authorities to remove
|#
-p|4%p
4
#
G>#
44>@
-6
4
-#)6
|
-p6-
|#
p
##4
4#-!-
#
|4K)4Kp-
H4
<‰@
3-
-!#T8
#4
-
#">
;"#
4
5<3-
x
##!#MG4
%<-#
##<---
4"6
U3-
#)6
|!
-
-
!#
-<
p%
-
|-
‰p
5-6
<@
!
"#66
-4
--664-#!
!
%
x
#6---
-#
--4
-#
<
T;
OEOU
#4x"
4<x"--|6-
-
->p@-H@%"-
-
&55#
-%-4-
--#
-
%6>
4. Conclusion
-
-4of4
6-
4for4
>5-##
<
4
#
6---
and new forms of veneration of the sacerdotal
-#44<
"
-46#
#
-
>
-
rule of law sanction various forms of violent
H"
4
--6)
44
<
-
#4
<
<-#
-
"-
-%
#4"->
@
4for4
K|4p
6-4%
|4-p6-
<
-4
#
>@-
#
#
"4>5-|&-
-<p-
-|
p
--#
-#44<
-6
<"<-
-#<<##
46>
5--#<
44p
everywhere, we witness the battle cries for the
#
|4%p4
4
#
-#
-
x6---
-#"#44-
%
#4"--<
#
"-#
-T
6
<
4<
U>$
#<
-&55#"###
#6
%
#%<
|6
"pˆ-
#%
-#
-
and social movements which remind us that
#
<"
K-#
-<
6-
K-#
/
<<>
Urban Governance:
How Democratic?
Stéphanie Tawa Lama-Rewal
5-"
@
-
%<
#4H<#
4
>
-
#4H<-#
!
'TU-
-@
-
<
-
%<
STU-
economic reforms launched in the early 1990s,
6---
"
6#
#x6-
%
x
-@
#<S
TU-
4<
4E>@-H-
-4%6%
"
-
--<
%##4-
4
4
'6-
-44
-
-
4
<
%
6#
<4
4
-)#
K4-
-
-<‡$#4-
/#4--6
)#4
#46
#46
-H
"4
4
S%
/
-
-4%6"
#4
4
)#
K4
>
1. Facts
5-"
""
#4<
%-4%
T#4
4
4
4-
-
"#-U
4"
T-
4
"<U>-
#4<
%
%
4
<
%<>#-
K
4%
"
46--#
K
<-
-
4%
"4%#-
delivery of urban services, and therefore to
44<-
-"
>5-
""#-4
--
4%)4"
4
-4T888U
"
-4
<--
4%<>:
<
-
""#-T%-
--
-4#U-
21
#
!-
4
#
#
>
5-"
4-#-"
%
"
#4
"<
-"<>5-%"<
-#4
6--
-%4"
%<-(4
8
##T(8U
-
444-
#6K-
4<
4
E>
-6"<
xR
(
-
-
#<$-
8
-
;!
)-
"#4#-
4"11>@#@
-6"-
%
(8
6-
"#
K44
<
#
!%
"
<K<-
"4#
4
6
>
5--
"
<%6--"
"#T"
#
K-
Š(
OO'MU-#4
%<
"
<
-"%64
"
>8
%
T6--#
-
K<
-
6
<
4>U
#
6
<#4
#
!<
#<4
"
-
"
-
46"
%
"
>-%!"
-
4<
%
%<&
!"
;
-p"#-
ECO
#4##EG6
6
4<
#
"##
K#
4
"
#4"-
44
>
5-#4#
-
4<-6"6
<%--
#%
-BGrd
BFth ##>
5-
-
##
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
!"#
context
5-
4<
K-#6
##-BGrd$$
6-
@
-BFth$$
6-%
@
>5-4<-"
>
E> @
]
<^T
H-"#U--"
#'
-
"
K4
6-H#-#--#
-4"
-4"
##>
> @#
K
#
<#4
"'"
T>>
/
U-
-%6---
"%#4#
-"%--
4
#
p
"
#%4
6H-
">5-"
44-
#
4-6-5>$
#4
"
"
6#6--
%--#TGGz
U>
G> 5-4<
#
K
#
<#4
4
"'-BFth$$
4
4
<4
x-6
##x#
4#-4
4
-#
#%
>
F> @""
4%%
%--
%
)"#x-56-->
11
5--?K
(4
8
##T?(8U#EC#
44
"-
%
%-
-#4
T6-U
T-U>
22
#4#
%4<6
---
#<
-
-
4
#EG6
>5-4"
#
-4
"4
"
466">$
"#6
K@
"
>-
#4
4
T#%-
U
#-
<"#
<
K-
--€@@-->
56-#
#4
#
]##<#^12H"
46-H"6-
4
S-#
-#4
4
--##x
@
$#
""T@$U
#
%<-
"#
--
the mayor, who is usually indirectly elected and
<-
#
>5-%
the reservations system, many councillors are
6#6--#
K-##4
"
H-
4
">$
#4
4
K
-<6--H4
-
-
-
#
<-
<K6
#<6
many of whom are also unaware of the name of
-
>
5-
"#H4
-6
4
4
-
-
#4
>#
-6"-
4
4
-
level is even more determined by class than it is
6-@
TV
OOCU'6-
-
#
%
##4
4"4
4
en massex
#4
4-6-
4%
6K6-6-#
-<
4"#
6-
4%
-%
-#4
--"T;--Š5
6
7
#
)&6
OO
-OEOU>
R-
-#4
4
--
4%
6‡5-BFth
$$4#-
6
##
%)#4
4
%6
-"
-#
<x-6
>
-4"-
%4
in a restrictive way, and in most cities ward
committees are really wards##'-<
H
-"
6
x
-
/
<
>@
6
##
<#
K4
"<x
4#H4%
(#%
6-6
##G
;x%<->@4
therefore wards committees only add one
level of interaction between councillors and
>(4
"#-
6--
<
"
<4
p
4
4
%<>
6"
"
"4
4
%
-
"#-4
6
>#-6
46
<
#'--
6-4
4
<
4
##
%<
"#
T-
--
-#x%6U
%<(4
4
TK-$"
7
<(
#;4
OOE
(#%
U>--
4
4
#%#4'
#
#4
T---U4%
4%
>
2. The Legal and Policy Framework
5-BFth$$TEU
%
K--
-4
!<4@
6
'TU4
6--BGrd$$
-
#%
4<
#
%"STU
-
)"##
-
-"
-
6-4
46--
-%
12
5-
"#4
#
‹(
<))<#Œ#4#<R
(
-<
8
->@
-
<#--
-H"6-(
<%<#4
#
#-#"6--#
#
#%6-
"-
-#
4T-
6
>U
#-
]^-#
%-R#<#>
23
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
-
>6"-BFth$$-
%<
4
<#4#'#4
4"
-
-#4
6
##-
"%4
"<
"6
<S6-##
<4"
-
-#
(4
8
##-
"#4<%#
>
-
%!"-V
6
-
-
%
&6
(
TV&(U)
-OO
44
#4#
-BFth$$-M
>5-V&(4
<4
-4
4
<#
democracy, yet its contribution in the matter has
%"
>:
-
%%-V&(
6
-
%
<3"4#8
T38U>>
#4-"#<
-%
4!-
-
%"4<
4"
#
4"%
"4#>38644
-4
K-6--#4
H"
6-<)6%
-
44"%H#<
6#
'
#
6
-
6
<-
-<#
-
4
4
-4-
"<
S6--<
K4
#
<-
64
-
38T
OOU>
5-V&(
#
K#
<%
#4#
##<8
4
7
6T87U#
-"6-
6
##
#<
4
4
<4
-
sabha (or
#%<U6--
#4
6
%
6-4
"-
EG>
5-
%-
6%#4
"
"4%-T
4%-U
4
"
6%##%-6
##>5-
87-
%<%<
->:<-]#87^
%<-V&(4<6---
4
"6%#
%<-><
6
<-
%-
4
"#-
<")
4-4"-
44
6-6%%/44
#
>:
<
-
###%-4-%
6
H#
6-#
K
4
%
44
#
area sabhasEF>
<
-
%-
-
%<
%<)4
#-
#44
4
-
--(3-
-87
-
%#4#<
'$-
8
-$
#;!
?
K
>
$44
<
-%!"-
4<
#<-7
$
3"4#
-#T7$3EGU6--
4
"
-
"T>>(#%
7
"$#%<(7$U
-
"T>>(#%8
#
(8U
44
<K6
-(8
(7$>5-4<
6
-(8(7$
4
"
#T
<"U
--<
4)
#-
6
4#4>
@%
-#4#
<-
#4
4
>5-4"
#4%6T6-
-
"
%4-<U
4
"
--"S
#
)
4
"
"
-
<
>5-4"-
EG
--
4
"
<H#
%
)
4
<'-#4
-
]%#
^6-#-##%6-
"<4"
6-4
#
K-#
###4
#
%6#
4
TV-
&
RKOOU>
EF
:
%
/-87$(
%
"-$"
#-<%
#--(H
(
##<8
4
7
6T87U>R-
8
4
‡R-##<‡$"
%
-4'
##>>64>
#OOCO##<)4
4
)
6>4
24
4
<%T6
%
#
-<%<(8
(7$U<
"#-
%6
T?#
Š7
<OOU>
:
<-&-@#
$T&5@U
%<
#
!
"%-
#
<>5-&5@$
#-
"
<-
(
?
-
K
-
T(?U
;%
&
!
-
6
4
OO
at the national level15%-
%
4
"
"%-
>5-&5@
#
K#
<
"
"#4"
<#/
%<
T6-
6H4U6-
GO
<-
44
T-4'-#
>">U>@
46##
-
%%<"
4
H44
-<46
%<4%
->
3. Political and Academic Debates
5-#]"
^-
</
%/6-#-#
#
of urban affairs, has been the object of an
international academic debate, in which
@
4
-
"%#4
%>5-"
#4
#-"
%
<-
4
-
-6#4
#
4
#
<TV
<
EB-
-KOOGU6---#
<
--<#-
-#
)#
K>
5-
#%
--K
#
"-]
"
^>
$#@
)%
6#-
V-
8
-
-
!6
-46K@
6-
4
4
4
4
Box 6. The undemocratic governance of
Special Economic Zones (SEZs)
5-4
-,$OO
-@
"#p4<
6
-
4
H
H4
>5-,
4<#
4#4"
T
#U"#
-
H4
!%6-#
%
6>5-
"
%
H
4<#,
"%-"4,
T6-66U
#-
4
,>,
%"4-%<-
4"
"#
--
8%8"
8
-4T888U>
5-4-
%"<4"6-
#-
BOO44
"
>
,-
"4
#4
%
@
>(,
<
"4H
>5-<
-4
-6--#
-
-<
%#4"
6-4>@
<H4-
,6
into 50 to 70 new satellite towns (with a
44
#4%6-
#
#-
%
U"-
H
>
5-,4<-%!
"<
"
4>-#-
-
,H#4<#
"
'
-
4<
44
%,--
%
!<
<-4
4
-
"
%<--
4
"TVK?<
(K-4
-<
<-#U>
-%
H%
<#>
TOOB'BEBU
-]44
4
-#
#"#4
<
>>>
44#
<
"6K4
^
-]64>>>%4
15
5-&5@
44
%-
V
##
?
-#>
25
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
"
<
"<
--
4
4
6
#"#q
--
%
q##
--
6K4
^>#
<-
!TOOFU
--]4
<^%<
4
4
-#
#-]"<^#4
]44^6-#%-#"
--
>-4
---
4%6
#%
>
5-
#%
--
#4
#-4-
H4
-#"@
>-4
##<
-#-
%
-
-
-
-4
%6-"
-
>@@
<T%
U-4
#
%
%<
44
-6%<4
4-
4
#>--
-%-
-
#<4#
-
-<-obligations
%<-4S-
#-4-
-
]
6
%
H4
<^>
---
4
4#6-rights,
-%
-#
-
"
H4-
]-44-##
#
^><--
-
4%
64
4
#-#
-
<"K
-4S<
"
<
#
!4
-4
-4
-#
-"@
-
4"
44<]4#^--4
T
ŠECMU>
Another debate concerns the role of civil society
TU-#
-
%
"
>$#%-
"
4
<
-x
6)46
-
>x<6>$#-(?
T-(
?
-
K
-
;
26
%
&
!
-
U-
--
-#
>5-
#
-
"4%
x
#
%6
44
4%
-
"
6--"
"<
#
%<>8%
/
-""#
;
3-
8
"
(%+-V
#-
-
"
6--4
#
"
6-
6--/
%
">@(#%
-<-
8#$
&T8$&U
-
%#-""-#%
#6-->5-
is now a debate, both in the activist and in the
#4-"-/-
;
#%
"
>3
%4%
#
<
T$44
OOEU]
6<4
%
%
#
<^TROO'
FOU‡-
<
-
#
4-
-
%
6
T&<OO%U‡
4. Good (and Bad) Practices
$
"%
"
4
<>:
EM-
;"#
?
-
/H4#'-
84p
#4
3
8
>
K"<6-@
#
<
6
"<
H
4
T6"
6
4U%
4
4
>
:#EMOOE-
446
#%4
4
<4
>?
p
H4#6
/'-
6
<
44-
"S
6
"</K<S
%
44-%6
%
--4
4
<4
T-
#
OOGU>
6"6--73#
:
OOE-H4#6
4%<-6)#
"#>
.#
-#
!#4
4
$%&$'*+-
@OO-;"#@
4-/@
$-<@
T@3$@U
<-
#4#-/@
4!-<>
-4!"<
6%"
E#%
4-
4-
%#
T4U
#
K-
-@3/>5-@3#
#
K
44"%-
-"
%!"'TU
-
-4
%
6
4
##STU44]
K
^4
#
K
-
-4"%
--%
STU-
ST"U-#>
5-@3
4!-
"K
#T
&
#
-
OEOU
-
4'-
%<<
#
>:-
%
--
%<-4!
-
-
6%4>6-
"
#
/
H4-
#
!
%
%
K
-##
6
/@3
#-#>5--@3
%
6%K6--<
%
6--#
-
-46"
"-44
6
#
>
-
-
@
$-<@
T8
#
3#%OEOU-
<
-
4"
<-6%
4#-#
6-
%
T-@3$@U#
->
#
<>@-
6
%"
-
"
##
4
--#
"
%">-6
-
-OOB#4
3-'
-#
6
#%
4<%
6
ration cards are not an individual document
T-
4
#<6--
%"U>#
"
<#T-
8$
"
4-%U#4
"#
6--%<
%
">
5-|/@
p#%-
-4%
%-6-
44
@
#-4"
%
->
In India as in many other countries, there are
#4
"4
#4
4
"
#
<
--
4-
-
"%##/
-4
-]"
^
"
44p4
4
>5-6
"-#46
-
@
%
#'
-(
8
>H4
-
3-(
8
"
#4#
-4
4
44-4>
46"
H4-"6x6---<S%-
(
8
#-BOOO4
##
"T
OOU>
8
4
--
4
4
<-#-
-
3-
-$"
7
<(
#T$7(U
4(#%
>
--
-$7((#%
-
"
%
%
#
%
4S
-6-<#46-
<46>`--#-
"
4""
%<-
%!"
%<-
44
#<-#
>:
27
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Box 8. The Bhagidari scheme
5-%
4
4
<"
-
OOO%<--(3--
3K-4"
-H
#4-
4
#4-
4
4
<
"
>5--#
]
x"#4
-4^EM is
%6
residents and city administrators in order
"4
#4
4
4#
<%
">5-
-
T|4
-4pU-#
<
#
]"4
#
#6K6--4
##
4
-46-
"#"
"#4
<4%#^17>@4
--#
#H"<-
"
&
R
$
#
-
T
6
U>
5--
-##4
<
-#
6K-4T
<
-
<U--6--
4
"&R$
-"
#
6-%
"
meet and debate, with the intention that
-<
%
T
--
U
|5
#3-p"##4%#%<
<|
44p
K<
--#>5--
-#
6
%4
%<-
%-
-
<
%
-#4
-
%
4
"<
<3->
3-&R
$
T&R$U-
"""
4-
<-
"#
-#4
4
-<-
"
6-
4-%
4
#"#-4"
6
"<6--#
<4"
EM
T5
6
7
#
)&6
OOBU>@(#%
#$7(4-
"!#4
elections in 2007, and their candidate has been
T,*
-OOBU-
-
4
4
<4
##
-4--
electoral abstention of the middle classes, which
<#4
-#
<
-<
"#>
$#-
"]4--
-#^T
3-p-(18U
("'-4
##6
OOC%
-
6
4
#-3-"#
-
)66<#
--6--%
<
-#-
4
>@OEO-4
##66
#
#-##6
-$
8%$#
(
#
T$8$(U6
%
"
>6"("!
K--
-#<
%<4
"6--
-
%
T
U
6--4"-#-
#
%6-6
4
#
%
>
$#%/4
-4"
-
%<
#%
#
6-3-
$-
8
-x6
6--(-
"
4
<
-###]
"
^>-
#
-K<-"
4
K
#<
4
<>5-
"
%<
#4"
#
4-
K#
!%
as well as the name, function and contact of the
4-
<
#4
4
towards a true accountability of administrations
>6"-
#4
-
-
#
<4TU-
4
<
-44
-
-4'-">>
3-#T%---
-#3-;"#OOBU
18
:OGOOEO>
17
28
-#x6--
/-""#
"
<;
]#<<
44
^--
T
!OOM'EEUS
TU-H
<"
#-
#x
6--<
-#4#
-&-@#
>
:
<
##%
-
4bandhT
KU
dharnaT)UgheraoT
4
4-
-<U
-
"-6-4
-
<>:
--
-K
3-OOM
-#4#
-6(
8
4
"
#4-"
#"
#
%"'4
#4
8@719 street
4>#
<6
-K
demonstrations called by the traders, and joined
%<
-446---
"#
4#H
"
-
#4
#-(
8
-
66-
<->5-
4H#4-66-
-
%#%
44
--%<4>R-44
#4#
-(
8
T>>
-44U
"
"
-
-(
8
6
%%<
6
44"K-
!-
-!<-44
-44#H
>
5. Barriers
5-#
%
#4#
-
4-
4<#%
-
---
46
%<
"4
>R-
--
44
-
"#
-
"<6K6
-
4
-BF-$$#-
-
%
46>
$-%
"%
"
#
'-6
<"
"4
4
#%<
>
$##4
4
#4
46-#4
4
4
4
<-#
#
>
6. Policy Recommendations
"4%6
<#46
)"#
#
K#4"
<6>#46
6-
#
K%
"
#"%
-#
44
-
%4
"
4%
-4<6>
At the same time, it is necessary to create
4
%6
4
"-
44
-
would involve middle class residents as well, in
"
-#-#
6K%<->5-6-
%<"%-
"
T6-
-)OEO)
]%K
4
^U6
T
U##>
E> 5-(
<))<#-%
20'5-#4
#
<#4#6
"
H"
-<--
-
(
<>"-(4
##
#
%<-
4
<
#
!
-#4#
-(4
4
p--4%
-(
<))-
"#>
19
5-8%@7
4
%--
<ECO@
6-%<
4
44
--
K
#<
6-4%
K"---
4
"4
<>
20
5-##
4--
-‹((4
7
6Œ44
%<-(<%
3"4#
-
#6K-V&(6--
"
']H"46"6-#46
##^S]:"<
#
(
<-
#
^S
]8"6
6
##^>
29
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
30
> 5-(
<-%<%<
"
"<
>3
as well as a tenure that matches that of the
#4
4
6
-"%<-(
<"
--
4
"
)"#")„)"
-6%<-5
#
H4-
>
F> 5-(8(7$7
$
3"4#
-#-%44
"
-
"%4%<
#%
%">-%-<
4
"6-
-<>
$
-#
6-
credibility in the eyes of voters and
>
G> -%<#
<4"
6-6
!
%>5-
-
-
TU#
<-#
are newcomers (because of the rotation of
"U
TU-<-
"
6K6-
6-
#
H4-
-<
>$
6#46#
K-%
-4
">
> 5-##<8
4
7
6-%
#4"x
6
#
4
-"
4
4-
<x
#4#>
5-"4#-%-
"#
-4
-
-6-
#
class residents are concerned with local
-#>:
area sabhas are much needed to channel this
<
##
6
<>
Women’s Right to the City:
from Safety to Citizenship?
Stéphanie Tawa Lama-Rewal
R#
4
6-#
%
4
-%
)
-
-
#
!#4
-">$
close analysis of these constraints reveals that
6-
K--
-6>>-
<
H>;#%
4
%<%
4
-
##-4"
-
])4
^
<%<!
TECOU
-
4-Right to the
City>@-@
H]#4
q6#p#%<
4%
4
q#44
4
#4
g6--
K
k-H
<
4
%<^T?-
OOB'EU>$
-]<4
%<^T.6
-Š
(-
OOC'U-
#
@
6#%-4"
4--
4"
4
>
5-66
6#
4"--
-6-
<6#46#6#
#
6#6-
%
4
<"
%>@
<-
H-
K%
#
<-
46--
x-%x">5-
"
6#
6--%"
##4"
4%4
-
#-#-
6K4
"
4%
4
4%
4
>
1. Facts
5-
<x
--
Kx
-
-4%66#
-<>@-H
<#
4#H
"
K
<#
#
--/"
#-
>.
6#
K#
<
#>
<]#
6#^T
31
#
"
<
EU
4K
44-#6<6<
T4-<
#
U#
H
-
#T]"
^U#4
##
-#
4
6#
sati21 (National
#&
OO'FEU>5-
##
-6
-<4
-
-
<
%##/
"-
$
>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
$-
#&
-G
@
3-#
#
6#'OO
GG>z
4
GB>FzK
44
%
E>Ez6<
-
G>Ez#
-
443-
T4>FMU>5-%
-4
@
p
4
<
%
6#>
(#%
<4%
6#
)<-6-
-
"#
-
Cz6#4%%
4
-
<T8-
KOOB'EEEU6--"
"-]6#
)^>
@#4"
</
-
'TU%
STU%
4
STU44>:<-
#4%
-
<6#>
† -
/
#4
#@
K
6#
-
"
-
-
K#-
">
† 8%
/
<
/
-#%
6
-/
<>5-
#4-
6#p4
-#
evident from the fact that the ratio between
6#p
#p3-EEO>
3#
K
-#(#%
6-4%
#H4"
6#-
#>@4
T#
#U6-
%
4-%
44
-
are often only collective toilets, which women
%
-<
H4"
%
<#
>$
6#
-6--<
#H4
H
>R--
-
/#
will miss school every month when they are
#
>
† 8%
4
-
<
/
'%
"
%<66--
H
-
#>
#--
-
K-
4%
4%
4
K
T-
%
4%<
"-#"
<
6#U
T
-
K
#
")6
%
U<-
-
-<"K
"6-#<
H
>
<%
4
4
<
#4
6#p
<>@@
6-
6#
4
>5-<#
#
%4
<
-
4
4%<4#
-
-
6K>
5--6-
x
44-
4#
<%
4
x%
#4
<#6#p
%
4
>@
%<;]
6
K-
#4%-
-
<%6
-
"<%<-
-44|4
p6#
6-
-<#
-
|4
p
|
-#p>^22
6"-@
H64
/
<
%<6#>]@@
%-
"<64
44%#
6#S-
4"#
H
44<H
-
#^G>
21
5-
-666-##
--
4<-
-%
><H]
^-
#-
4
66##
>
22
'-4'666>>4
4
-)H<-#
"
%<>-#
G
@"66-?
4
.6
-V
EEOEO>
32
5-<44#
6#
<
/
>$%-4
)
6-<
-#"
""-#>@-6-
6#4#
4-
#'-<-4
-4-#4-
-<
-4
>5-
-446#
#4
'
<3--@
<6-
-
446#4
TBz%-##6
-;
#EOz
U
44GFz-TBz
(#%
U>
5-
K
<
-
6#p#%<-
-
#
!
#4
-
%<
"
-#"
44%<<
6-
>5-%"
-
"--]-
K
<
-46K
#"<
6#-
""4
#4#--
"-%
K
4
-4
6K>@6#
4
#
<<6-
6
-
-#-%
-
H
"-6
<-4
<
%<%>$
--
"
%#
/-"
->^T.6
-Š(-
OOC'U
5-<
4
44>5--
#<@
#44
<-"4#
the service sector, offers new jobs to women,
%#-#""6K
-T
instance journalism, call centres, malls and
--4
<<U6--46#
%<
-<-
"
%--
-
#<
-6
>
:
<-<
4
-
<4
6#H4-#)4"
4
#4-
*#
-
#
x6---6"
<4<
6#
T8-
KOOBU>
-6-
x
4
#
%
6x
444
6#6-
#
<4<4%4
<6-
#4"
4
-T&
OOBU>
2. The Legal and Policy Framework
5-
--
%-
4
-@
6#p
#"#6-6
"#-
EBO
4
4>5-
women’s movement really consisted in a series
#4
-#
#
-"-
--
>6"
-
66
#-EO
onwards, as it became clear that those laws
44-#"#p
%%<-
--
4
6%
<#4#>7
#
6#
44
%
/
6'4
>
$
-4
-
6
&K#-
-6-6-
-@
8
T
#
ECMOU
<44
6-
K6-
6#
-"#
#>]6
-4"
#
H
-
#
%Kg
-#<
6#
k^TOEOU>;"-
-
---!
46-
|#<p
4
%
"
<4
6#
p
444
%-
"
T_@OEOU>5-.
-
@
8
T@8U--
6-
#%46#p"
--T#4-#"#
>U>@H
%%<
-@8
TGFU
TOU-#<
6#
x
-#4<
-
6#
4
<#<>-
6!<
33
#
4%<"
H4
-
-(8:6
4
%
#
]4
(
!^
OO6-%<
4
4
K-#4
<%
-#4TOEOU>5--
-
-
-
6
#
#6#p-
#"
#-
">
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
$-#
!
/
<H
-6%<:
"
$>]8<
4
6-
GB-@8>5-
4
6
%6-4
6--
-4
q>$H
%
4
-
<GF6--
#
KH
6-
|#<p
6#
4-
%6-
4#
H##<
>$4
#
4
4--<-
@86--
6-H
>^T_@
OEOU>
U-#4
4
#4
nagar
panchayats24>5-
6#
-
#6K-
"
been limited in their effectiveness by various
4
<<
-
%<4H<-
K
/
-)""##
>("6-#
-%
#
4
4
4
#"6#
councillors are constrained by fears for their
-4
>"--
6#
"46#
#
4
"-
4"
'%-
-##
444
46
#
#
4"
#
44
-
%
mediation resource for women voters, which
#-#4T;--Š
5
6
7
#
)&6
OOU>5--4
-R#p&"
%<-&
!<
%-
OEO-
#
#4##
women’s reservations in Parliament and in state
#%-
#--4>
(
<]-4<
"
#6K6--
%
"4%4
x%6-#
4
6KqK-3#.
$6--4"
#%
4
%
"-#
4
-
#
"
#6Kq4%4
>^T_@
OEOU>:
-
8<
-#46#R#
4%<-
;"#@
OOE-
of women’s safety in the city, and the section
"
6#<4
<"K
"4%4
>
3. Experiments
6"6
"%
K--
%#->5--
BFth
$##$6--
%-"
6#TGGz
$4%
25-
-
4
6---
in India as elsewhere, since the late 1990s, also
#4
-@
6#p#"#>
5-%
K---].-
K
;^%<-4#
EB
#
K!#H
-
#
6K>5-8R#
H
#
-RK4
OEO%
->"-#
)
6
#
--
4"
-
-
-
"
<-##
4#4
##
>
F
$
4
-
<
T<U-%
%<"
#
<T6-
44
#4%6GOOOO
EOOOOO-
%
U>
25
-
#4-4%
4-<4
>
<-]&"6
R#^4%-6
<
%<-6<
#
8
RK<6--
6
<"
-%
6--
##4-6#p#"#6
<"-
-4%66#
%
4
$4OOB>
34
.-
6
<%
-
#"#<]-
-
%
-#
4
">>>g5-k-6
-
4%4
4
4%#^M>5-6
6
K-
6#--
<
THU-
64
44
-
-#6#p
-
"
6K
the intersectionality of both discrimination and
"
>
5-];
4
^4!TOOG)OOMU
%<-4
8-
K
#
?-
-4
&
(#%
4
<
4
4->5-
4!6
6-8?$&T8
%
?6$
&
-U
%
-"
Box 9. Safety auditing as research and
action
5-#-<6
<"4
%<-(4
$##
.$
R#
-
T(5&$U
;%
%
-
%
4-@
H
%<8?$&T8
%
?6
$
&
-U(#%
V
3->
<
]"#
44
H^T8
OEO'MCU]6--""
6
K--
4
<
6--
%
>
5-
-%"#
T-4
"#
4
KU-
4%-
4%4--4
-"
<4
-
#
#
--
#
%6#^
T.6
-Š(-
OOC'U]5-
4
4
<>>>%
-4#
-
-
4
H4
-4
^TV
OEOU>
<H
#-
H4
-<4
<4%4
(#%
>
Another major collective study was conducted by
V
3-)%
;6-
44
-6
#
#
)>
As a result we now have a series of innovative
6K-#
<6
<]4
4
^T8
OEO'MU
@
>&
-
(#%
3-
?K
-
%-%<"
"#-x
<#4
<
#H#-
-
-
4-%"
%
4
-"#
44
4"6x
%<H
-
->5-<
%
<
-#
<#)T
6-
clothes and ornaments to wear, what to carry,
6-6
KU-
<#
%<
6##
H#-
<6-
-<4<4%4
>$##
#
--
'
<<
4
%<
-%4%-
6-6#-#"']5-4
>>>
<K-#
%-
44
4
%<#
6#p44%4
^T8-
K
OOB'EEEU>
5-#-
-4
%
-%6-4"
discourse on safety and the conservative,
4
-
%-4
#
#4
6#p4
%<
#<<-6-6
<%
]
H
"4%"%<^
T8-
KOOBU>5-6K-6-
-
<
4
-
4
6#p-
#-6
<6#p/
%
>]@-#"#--
4
6#4-#
#<4
<-
4
%
#<^6&
TOOB'EU6-
8-
K-#
<
M
@"66-?
4
.6
-V
EEOEO>
35
-
]6-
6#
4%4
#-
-4"
<
--
KK^
T8-
KOOBU>
(<HpTECU%6
]4
^
]
^
-4
-")„)"
-
->
<-
the need for safety (which can be assimilated
#
4
8-
KOOB'EEMU
practical
'-<
#
##
4
-
6#p%
4
<K-
K
#
4
-4x6--
strategic>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
4. Good (and bad) practices
(
<-
"
6#p
<%
4
-
"
K
4
3-
6
>:<3-|4
<
women has been recently reinforced by several
#
6K6#%
#
-6---
"
#
x-4
#
-
@
p
4
<>$-
%<-###
6#p--4
-
3H3-p
-(EC>
5--3-4
#H
>--
##
-
#4<4-%
#
"
6#6#
-#">]:H
#4OOF-3-
8
|p
pp-
-
K
K
"<
>
(<-3-8
"6#
#--)
-6
"H
harassment which included advice about dress
%-
"^T.6
-Š(-
OOC'
U>---
-3-8:-
%""
4"
"
6--TR#pU#
K4
ECG6--6
]-
444
<6#
@
qg6"k-p"
#
##
4
6-
institutions (schools, residents associations, local
4U>^T
6
OEO'EU>
Another, more visible initiative is Parivartan, a
4
##
-OO
<-
-R33--
4
#"%<4<6#4
%
6#p"
6-
-##<>5-
4
##
6
--
4
##4#
6K-46-
4
-
-
K->@OOM
-4
##6
H-6-
3-%4%
-H"
years27>
Parivartan was associated with the Safe Delhi
#4
-OO%<V
6-
-44-3-;"#>V
6#p-
6K3-
ECF
4-#-<
<
-3-H
"<
%6#p
<-<>5-
#4
4%
6
T--
%#
K-#-6
#
-
-
U]%4%4%
-
-
4
%K
^28>V
%
4
-4
6-K<
4%
4'
4"
%OOO#4<)
"
4"x
-3-5
44
>5-
#4
#--3-;"#
#
]6K##^6#p
27
5K6#
%-4
##-4'666>-4>>4
"
4
"
>-#>5-
""-
]R%%
"<^@
$6
OOM]/
<
6#^%<-@
$
-8
R
-3>
28
@"66-?
4
.6
-V
EEOEO>
36
<6--"
4
#
3-83-##
R#>
:
<-(
K3-
R#
#4
6
#4
%<-;/<
@
T_@U
--"
#OO6---
##-
%<-
-
(
6#p
<
3->5-
#4
4#
<#
%<-4
|#
<p
4"%-
"
-
>
#-6"-
4-
series of initiatives that testify to the sensitivity
)#
K6-
-4%#
of women’s safety in the city, such concerns
#
#-
"
44
#>5--
<3"4#8
44
OOM-
#6K-V&(#
K#
of the fact that urban infrastructure must be
6#
)<>
@
"--(#%
4-4
%-OOC
-
"
<6K
%<-;
$K-
6-E-6#p
>
5-
#4
-
-
-)4-44#
6#-
>
]$K-
K4-
"OOC
-#---4%<
-4
-
#
#4
%
6--
"
<7
4
6
%--4q
R-"
6#
--4
4
"
"
-6-EO#>5-
4#4
%<-4-
#
<-
%
####
6#^>29
5-4"
"-
#4"-
</;
-"<
6K
4
-46-#
!
"%-4-
%#4
>4-
###4"%
6--
K-
###
4
>
<
<-%
#4-
Indian women’s movement also contributes in a
#
!6
<
6#p
#
-4
"
<6
<>$#
!
-'-
"
;-
"
-
)-4
4-
#%6#"#
-4-#
---
K-(
-
-
(
-3->#
6#p
T-
-3-)%
&
-U
4"
"x6---
need in all citiesGO>
5. Barriers
]-
<
-"%
-<
-6
#
4<)-
#4
%6#p<^
6
;GendersiteT-4'666>
>U>5-
"
-
this statement, as shown by studies on Indian
-%<6#>5-6
?K
--)
#4"
##
#%<6--
<K
4
6-
#
6#>(
4
4
4]#
-
-#
6#
4
<
-
4%4
>
>>>(
4g-6#
pk4
6---#>>>-#4<#
<#
4
-#--
K
29
]86&^:(
-B)$4OOEO>
@V
<OEE-3---"#%6-4
<6#6-
4)
>
GO
37
#
!44>
#
--
#
4-<
"
%<S
#
###K4-
6
<#4%4
^
T8
OEO'MFU>5--4
4
women slum dwellers in the same city, concludes
-
]-<6#
-##
K
%/-
"6-6#
#%4"
"6--
4"-<
-"#>&
--<-
#^TE'EU>
6. Policy Recommendations31
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
-6##
-
#
#4"6#p
<
-
-
%!"-4>5-6%!"
%"<#4#
--']R-6#
#
<4%4
-<
#---4^
T$OEO'GU>5-64
-#
%"%64
>
In order to increase safety for women, a number
"
-#
'
† %
4
-4##H
-
6K
-#
KS
† @
4"-TU
-/
</
<
%<4%
STU-S
TU4%
4S
† @#%
"
-
-4#6#
)<
T
%<#6#
GE
4S%<-
"
4
46K
4
"<6
46#
4
<64
S%<
-4
#
6-
;
6-6#
that they feel comfortableGU>("4
H4#-
/
K<%
T%
"-4U
6
<
#4"6#p
<>
A second set of recommendations stem from the
-
6-6#
4
##
-)#
>@
/#-46#p
hostel (economically more affordable, and
<#
4
%-
T)U
US
%/
<+-S%
-
#-
##4
%6-
)#
!%>
:
<#-
-
446#p-
-<
-
6>@
]-<H^T;EFU@
on women in the city, as well as research on
H
#T
Š-
OOMU4
-#
<
H#
-
H
6--6-
-@
<
-#4-%>5-4<
recommendations listed above are therefore
K<-
"
#4
%<6#
>$
8-
K4T8-
KOEO'EGU]-4
%4%4%
4
4%4
K
a city that is friendly not just to women but also
-#
x-4-<
-4-<
<-
-^>
:
#
##
6
6#p
<V
OO>
5-6##
6%<3&
4
/<4%<-63-
]
<R#
%
$
^H-
T;##<UEM%OOT-4'666>H)
-
)>>>-#U
G
38
Caste and Class in Indian
Cities: Habitation, Inequality
and Segregation
Diya Mehra
5--4
4H
#-<
#
-
%
/
<
6@
6-
4
4
)%
4
>
4
)%
4
-
<
4"4
4
##S
<
4
#
K
4
4>5-4
4
based on evidence available in the secondary
literature in relation to Indian cities and
4
<-4
3
-
TU6--#6-#
--
<
"
4-
-%T5U
#
-%
K6
TUGG>R--
"
%-4
-4
4
6H
#4---K<
4>
1. Caste in Urban Spaces
5-@
#
4"
/
-
44
-)#
>$<
|-
p
|-
%pT
%<-@
U6-
%-
<44
)#
<
"
#%
|4"
"4#
p#
-
"
%
K
#-<
4#
-]
#^
T5-
OO'BU>
#
#4"
)%
discrimination and violence, to reservations in
"#4#
justice and mobility for members of these
##>
In the case of India’s cities, studies from the
<
4
)%
GG
V
<
<6--
-6"-
##44"
>
%<
>
39
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
#4
6-<-%-
6-
<6
--
"
in the centre of the city and lower castes on
-44-<T&
!
OOMU>5-#
44
%#6-
#
--##%
"4#>
5
<-
%-
)
based distinctions are less visible in Indian
>@--4#-#
<4
<
@4)4"
6#
4
#%<
4H#<
"
%
T
<OOEU>
40
While it is certainly true that Indian cities,
4
H
"
4
<#<"<
#%<
6
and communities, at the same time, it has to
%
K6-
)%
4
#
4
%
H>@#4
to remember in the case of Indian cities, as
--
<
##<
%6
distinction and discrimination based on class
")„)"
>5-4#
|
p
%-#
-%6
4
44
<
%
@
#
<
-
-
"T:EMU
-
H%
--<
#
"%6
4
not obviously visible in urban environments
6-#
4
4
H">6"
-
-
)%
4
remain salient to urban status distinctions
TEMU>@%%-"6
the hybridity of class and caste in urban India,
-4
464#"-
44%#
)%
#/
<
T
6-4
U#
"<4
to the continued discrimination in access for
3
-
"
4-
<>
2. Housing Segregation Based on
Caste
@-4)@44
#-
%
%
44
%#
%<#
#%
"4#>-
<
-4
%
##
4
4
#
%
4
6-
--<6
residents to be located in low class areas of
T34OOFU>@-
<6
#
#
<%#H%<
-<6-
-
##%K
-%--
#>5-
-
-
%
4
and residence, what is seen in the more recent
decades is the cohabitation of low castes/classes
4
6--6
6-%
4H#
6
-44
6-#6
#4"
#
"<
<"T-KECMU>
"<
#
"
4
-
#--#
@
4%<--
>-#
44
%/<-<
#<
%#4%
%
#%
>5-H4
%<-
44
%6
4
-##
-
-<
#6--|4%#p
6----
<
4-#>
6"
)"-
"
enumerated that individuals from low castes
4<#
#%-
-4#
<>
-4OOEK-
TOOCU
4-
"
#5##
##-
z-44
#
3-
-K
4
-4
-
V
4
8>(
"<
of selected slum settlements in Delhi (Gidwani,
OOMU4#%
--
MOz>@
$-#
%
-
--
Ez6-
(#T)$@5$5OOGU>
@#
<
<-%
4
-
#
"<-<#4#
<5
4
(#>3-4
TOOGU
4-
-<
OOO5
(#-
Ez-
%
]%6-4"<^T87U44
>
%
-H-
44
-
%644
44
")„)"6
#<44
>
3. Poverty, Access to Urban Basic
Services and Employment
;"-
#
4
-%
4
4--
-##
have lower access to urban water and sanitation
#-
4K6
%
-#
)54
%
>@--Mth
-
#4"<TOEO
U
-6-65
44
#
##<)%
6-#
#
--
"
6
-
K
6
-%
#>
-6
-
-|H"pK6
-%
-#
"
%
households, who also have the least amount of
TOEO
U>5-6-Fz
|-p---
Gz
6-
#%>
8-
4--
"
%
/
<%
-
%!4"<
#4<#
"->@
-
4-
-4)#4--
%
%
4"<T-
K-
(K-4
-<
<OOCU6--
%
4"<%6EG)F
OOF)
O>R--4OOO<
-
---
4"<
<4@
%
T(K
OOU>
4<-
"
#
!<
6K
%-#
6-
4
-#%#4<
"
4
6K
%>R--%
#
#4<#
6K-
%---
#
4-
<6K-
"
-#4<#
-
--
>#
<6--6K
4
4
%
#
-
-)5
-
#
<-
56#T#
-
OOCU>
6K
<#
%
!%T
#
U/
K
6K|
p6)
4
-
64
-6K
#%>
6K
44
%<#-6"
-
--
)#4<#
4-4
K
-
4#
<%
-
K
4
>5-#4
B>Bz%
#
#-|-p
<
6-6
<C>Mz"
-
-"
#>5-
4
"%%
6#6-
6
%65
|-p44
T#
-OOCU>
5-
%6K#-6
4
44
<
@
x
4%<
#%
x"#-K%6
#
T5-
6#
OEOU>$#%T##
(
K-
!
OOS:
#-
OOMU6--"<-@5
H
#44
6K-4
6K>$
4
-<
<TOOBU
5-
6#
-6
#-6K--)
4#
#
!%-@5
-4
"
#
44
)
%
K6-
K
%
4
T
-
|
#<p
444
K4#
|4
<pU> -4"
41
%
<<4
<
6-4%<4-
%%<"
##
<44
)
%
K>
5-
-6-
#
#4
"<#H
)-
%
-6K4
)
-
4
-%-)
-6
-)#4#6-
4
#
%<
#-4
-6K>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
:
<-
<-
<
#4
4<
4
T6-4
%6
%
-
#4-
6
4U
%
%
H"
6-H
>7
:
H
#4-
#4
<#
#4"-%
4#-
-%-
#|4
p
42
T:
OOMU>-
-#
-4%6
#4<
-6)
"
4
-#4
4<
4
#
-
>5-#
---#4<p#
|
p
6
|4<
4p
%#
-|
%-
#
of bathrooms, clothes, dishes’ if shared with
"
-4--6K
|<pT_
<#OOGU>
#
"<-4
4
#44
)
#-6
)
%
4
6-
<#"
4
4
6"
@
p
H4
"<
<
4
##
44>
Muslim Neighbourhoods
and Segregation in the City
Joyita Ghose
5-4
4%-"
H
<4
-@
6
|#pGF%
4
>
@4
-K
%6
##
in Indian cities and communal violence and
#
>R--4
4
6-
@
"--
64H
#44
#
4#x4
#H<-
<%
>@#%6-
K6-#
%<-
#<@
-
-4
4
<H4(#
6
'TU##
"
-
4
##<
HTRKOO'EBU
TU-
#H"<6-)
(#>
1. The Legal and Policy Framework
5-6-@
6
%<
-
"<-
H@
-
#4>-K<#4
-
6
-K
"
#6-/
<"
##>5-$-
"
##--
44
44
->
$
<-@
64
64"
##
"
#<#
>
$(##6
EBC
-(<#$
--#
T%-
U
6
-
4
4"-6
GF
5-;"#@
TU-
##($E(#-
K--
,
#@
>5-@
OOE-6-
-#
%EC>Fz-44
6--EG>Fz
(#>Gz
-
E>z
K-O>Cz
-
O>OOBz
,
T8
U>
43
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
-4
-
-"]
^>$-E3
-&-8
-&
7(-
##($TEU
6
-
##
(T(U%
#
<
%<EG>5-(4%-
4"
-
#S
#
K##
-"
#4#
-4
-#-
"#S"
4
#4
-"
-
#
-<
%<
444
-
#->
44
:
<-(<(<$
OOM-
<-]"
4
"
"6
-
<
"4#
4
##
-#<##^G>5-
4<#
6--
"#
issues related to minority communities in
-%
6-
-(<H
$
-x#
#
6-
#
#4<#44
#"#
4"
#->5-#<6K6--
##(-
R
KGM-(
$
:
-
(
3"4#
:
4
>
#
#-8"
##
5
.T$
G
V
&4
U
8
#-##OEE>5-
#
4"4#-
-
K
(#;!
OO
4"
"#-">
2. Current Debates
5-%
-"44"
#-
-
-4
%6#
-&-
-<xH
#<
#
4
S<
-
/)-
"%<H
#
4
S
-<-#4
-)#
-#46-
-
#6K-)%
#4
<@
>
$K
-#
6--#-
"#
to educational, social and economic institutions
%
4
--#4
"
TV-
(
K
OOU>5-
-
##
&4T;"#@
OOM'GU4
-
-"%
6--(#
44
-
-
<%---
-
44
6-
#
>GB`-
"4"
(#
%
#---
#4
6-
>@<-4-
#4H4%6
(#
(#--#
6T6-44
-
OOOO
%6OOOO
OOOOOUT;@OOM'EGU>
@
-4"<--
#
(##
6T6-44
%6OOOOU>GC5-4
-
-
4
-4'#<
>">6#
%!
>
4
@(#
66
K44<
-
%44>5-
R
K6
%-%<-;@EMF
-44
"#
-
#
R
K
-<>
R
K
4%-#
#
4R
K44---
%-#3R
K##)
(
R
K##
##"
R
K44>5-R4%6#
!"4#
"S-"4#%
R
K44
44>
GB
@EME6-ECz-44
"%
B>Ez-(#44
OOEG>Bz-(#
44
6
%
#4
B>Cz
<>
GC
V-
(
K
TOO'EGFGU-<#4"
(#-
K-
-#)
@
-
-
"
#-<4
4
#H4T(8U(#-6%-
%
@
>---
-
"
(8K-
-
-
---
%
@
4"<>:
<
-4"
4"<
#(#
K-#%
@
-
@
>6"-"
-
-|-p>
GM
%6
<"(#
|$-p
--%
-
"
"--
<"
<--%
TBO>EzU-
T>EzU
>G
"#
-
-
<
4%6(#
-
"
%
womenFO>
-H
#-
/-)"
%
4
%<x#
"
%>.
-<TOO'MxBU
-
-)T%6
(#U4#
<
%
4-#FE>
----#4
##
"
#
4
T
44"<
<U
#
-
-4
T.
-<OO'CEU>
-
-
%
#T-#4%#%
4
U-
#
K#
#44
##
">
"<
<#
#
--
-"
"
4""
%
-
44
>F
R-.
-<4
#4-
-
K
"<
<#
#%6##
K<
%4>
-
|
p
|4p%<
6KK64
-<6>4-
##
-
-
&-
#4
<@
T
OOGU>RKTOO'EBU-
#
!
##
#
@
'
4#
K
4
<-
"
"#
6
K4">
"#
%64#
%
-<<#
<)4
-#6--"#4
#
>:
<-4
<
#4
-"
-
"#
4
(#6"6--
6---"#6
-4"
#
4
-#>
-
"
#
!
>&-#4H
6
<6--#
]entre soi^
T>>)#4
K6-
H44
<6-##%
p6##<U
4
?#
-4
4
--
"-
#4
<%
-
-###
-"
](#
^-
4
)%
T?#
OOC'BU>FG
(<-
"%"
-#4
#
4
%
-)#
-
#4>@-<$-#
%
p
-
)4
(
-
"
TOOU
-
-$-#
%
(4
G
&
(###>
Š(TOOU>
FE
4-
%6EO
E%
@
6--<--44
#
-
Mz-
-##
">$
<"6-%
@
-T$-#
%
(#%
$
-
<
%
(
?K
3-U-
"
44
<
-
%
"
Fz
%
-x(#">5-4
%z-
44
6--#
-
z
-44
-
%4>
F
-
-KH4-4-H"<-H-
"<
4##
"-<$-#
%
OO
-
-4
#"<
%
--
-%--6K4
4
>6""-
%")
#--#<"<S-H"<
6
<
#
4
-
6-]<#
<6-
"
K-
6
6--
4-^T-
-KOO%'EOBU>
FG
@-"66-#,
K
3-?#
-
<6
-#
K
44pH4-%
4
-
6
#4
-
>
FO
45
%
%6###
-<"4#4
%
#
<H
<>-H4
-%6
##
#
%
-<
--
%
H']5-4H
#
-#<6--6
#-%
%6-
%
^T(
-
"
OO'FCEU>
3. Experiments Promoting Socio –
Spatial Diversity in Cities
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Mohalla Committees in Mumbai,
Maharashtra
46
@-6
K-E#-
%
(
!$<-<
8
--<
(#%
H4-
%
K
of communal violence in its history, with over
EOOO44
"
-
-<T#
&-R
-E'MxBU>
(-
T]-%-^U##6
%--
#
--(#%
##
ExG6-6#
!
#'TU44-
##
%6-4
4
<
-%-(###<S
TU4#
x4
#H
%6
(#T5-
KK
OOF'
CEU>
@
<--(#%
-
4!4)4##
-B4
4###
-
#<>@6
--
6-
minority communities was the way forward, to
both increase levels of trust in state structures,
-#"#44
<|-p%
4
>(-
##
-
#4
small areas, usually determined by the local
4
-
%<
%
>
(#%-4444
##
"-
>$
44
%<-
-%
-
-##>5-K<
"
-##"#4
--
4S
"-
-
-K
6
%
4
S#
S
4###
-
#<---%
"
4">T5-
KK
OOF'CU>@
EF(
-#
6-
-<##
"6
-
<
(-
##>-"
%<
-##6
6#4
the theme of communal harmony for the school
--
>$#%##
-
"
K#
-
#
##
<>7
""6-(-
##-
"
44
>5-
(-
##-
""
-"#
--4
4
<-"
%<##
#4"H-
%6##
|-
p>@:%
<
OO-;!
-(#%
4
"
-(-
##6K
---<
#-
#"
(#%
-
4
-
-#6
TOOM'U>
Disha, Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh
.
-<TOO'xGU%-
#4
"
#%66#
(###
-
4
8
----
;
Disha, involved in the state’s Mahila Samakhya
4
#>3-
p6#6K--
-
6-6##%-(#
mohallas bastis T-%-U
%6-
6##>5-(
-
#
K-<
4
TEE'BExBGU4-
-
6##-(#mohalla did
4
K6##-basti in the
>5-6#6K -#4
4#H-
%6
-6##%%6-
!#-
6
<>$
-<
4
#-6
>;
<-<%
#%--
#
%
#4-
>"
<-<6
%#%
both communities on common issues such
as ration cards so that ultimately collective
#6-%-
>.
-<
4-
-
#
--
%
(
!#6
-%6
the women from the two communities that
-4
##
-
#<>
Shanti Sena, Uttar Pradesh
5-
-
T4
#<U6
4%<;
-pH6
!T@
#&U
4
%<6
!8-
;6K4###
-
#<
--;
-
>$-
##<x%
"
4
4
K4
4"-
##
>6OO
OOCEBO
#
6#K4
-4
##
M6
"
#
#<6K
6
-
-#
-"
>6
!8-
-
%-H
-
R
8
->@OO--
"
-<
4
(
%
"-
(#
4
6-
#4H
T.
.
OOCU>
4. Key Challenges and
Recommendations
"--#
-<
"
%
##
"
in India, there is broad consensus on the idea
-
]-
<#<
4
<
%
4
<
##
4)4@
^
T4
OO'OFMU>
<
#%
-
#
|-
p#
4
<(#-<>3
6--
#/
44
-6--
"-#4H#
6--
#4
#
4%-
as education and health on the one hand, and
-->5-#4"
4%--#4"
44-
-
S
4#x4
"<
-
community level must be the two cornerstones of
<4<
#
K-#
#"
"%
4
#4
<@
>
47
Migrants’ (Denied) Right to
the City
Ram B. Bhagat
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
1. The Context
5--<-@
%)
-#--
##6--#K
44
(-!3
-@"
<
T-
#4
K
K-#OOM'CU>3
4-
@
-<#
<6-
"
#
#
<-
"-
4-
-<@
T&
#
-
EU>5-
<
#<6--6-
#
-
%
"<#4
#4
6
#
">
5--
"%
6-#
#
%>84
#
<6K%
%
#
>
$-
"""--"
#
"
4#-<
-
%<"<#-
4
-
%
>@
-<-
48
-
#
K
"
x6--
#
-
"4
<
"<
x
-H>
(
4
<
#
%
<-6-@
>5-@
freedom of movement and freedom to settle
within the territory of India as a fundamental
-
T$EU> `#
face several barriers in terms of access to civic
#-
#4<#
6
-4
-
%
>
5-#
"
4
@
--<‘sons of the soil’,
6--"K
#
#TR
EBC
OOEU.(
-#
"
%#
H4
#
<-#
4
"
#
-
4
#>$--
#
%
/
<
%
4
4
##>
(
--
-<x>>--"<
#
-%-
-<-
)
-6%4#
6
4
#
6--
<T
%OOC'EGU>5-&--<
44"K#4"-
#
%<4"
""64
-
")%
4T8OOU>@
"
4
"
#
-
#
K4-%
"
%
>5-4
44
<
-
#
p-
-<S"6-
4
#
%
--<
"
%"-H
<
44
@
#
#
-
#
%
"@
>
2. Migration, Urbanization and Cities:
Spatial Pattern and Exclusionary
Processes
(
-
%-#
#4
%
>@@
%)--
44
"%
TGE4U
OEE>5-%
44
#4GBB#-
44
EEO##
%<-
OEE4
"
%COOO
6>5-
6
-
-
<
K6-
--%4#
<
#%-4
-
#<>5-4
-@
#<-
4%<-4
#<?K
(#%
-
%-
T&
%%EBU>3-
4
<
#4
%
#-
4
<EEE>
5--#
-%
4
-)
6#
>
5-OEE-6-
-%
4"%
-R
-
@
6---
#<3-
(#%
-
#
-
4"><
%
$-#
%
-4%-
-
4-
4
%
>
---
-)
@
%-6--#4
?K
-
K
<-#
<-
>5-H
K<
-)
East India is Patna, which is about 7 times smaller
-
?K
>5-H
-)
@
-#
4%
"-
-
-
6-
-
%<--)
)#
6--
<-
K"%
->5-
#
-
-
8
-
(
-<
8
---
-
&
!
-
>
@
-
-
4<#%
EE>3-4%
4-
-#4
%
@
p#"4#-
%
6>:H
#4-%%
areas to India’s GDP has increased from 29
4EO)EFB4ECOxCE
M4MG4%<OOB
H4
B4%<OE
T8
##OOC'GFU>@
%
#4-
-
EO46-
;38
#
<4#
K@
#"
%
"T8
##;">@
OOC'GFU>6"
6-
#6-6
-
%#
%
-
4%6
%
@
#"6
#4<#
446>:-#
#6-
6-6
4
<
4
%
>(
<-
"
-
-4
%
-4%
4-
-
%H
<T?OOBS
-
OEOU>@<H
<-
%
4
46--<
6%4
-#
%
>
49
3. Internal Migration: Trend and
Pattern
@
6--
#
K#"4
6-
#
-
%
"<
#4>
-
"%<
#
R
#
-
""
more attention from researchers, international
>@6
-
-44
#
x
-6-#"6--
<x
"
#
-
-6-#"%<
%
>$-#
3"4#&4OO-#%-
6-#"
-#
!
#
within their countries was nearly four times
TBFO#U-
-6-#"
<TEF#UT38OO'
EU>6"6
K#
-
"
6
4-
#
#
6
#
<
GO#
@
%
-4
2001, out of which 101 million were enumerated
in urban areasFF>
3.1 Migration to urban areas
@
p%
44
6
B#EME
-
<GBB#
OEE><OGOK<
-
%
MOO#T$-6
OEEU>5--
)#
T
U-
44
%
-
#
GE>M4ECGGG4E)
OOOG4OOB)OC6---
"
%#
#4
"<TOEOU>5-
-
#
F%
-
4#
<
-#
#
T
:EU>$--#
#
#
#
<-#
K46K
!-4
#
6K%
>
---
-#
#
urban areas has remained constant (between
50
45.6
41.8
39.6
35.4
32.9
31.6
30
38.4
38.2
36.6
40
27
30.7
26.8
25.7
Percent
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Figure 1. Migration rates in urban areas, India, 1983 to 2007-08 (in percent)
25.9
20
10
0
1983
Male
1987-88
Female
1999-2000
2007-08
Total
'TOEOU>
FF
#
-
#%#
%
%CC#OOB)OC6--F#6"%
>
5-
-<H-4
>>
46-
""
H#--
4
%
"
-44
>-/-
#
%
-
4
T-
OOCU>
F
5-#
-#%
#
4
<
"%<-4"44
>@
4
#%#
4EOO4>
50
Figure 2. Employment-related reasons
for migration by streams of migration,
India, 2007-08.
80
70
60.9
60
48.2
Percent
50
40
30
29.1
28.8
20
10
1
2
3
3
0
Rural to Rural Urban to Rural Rural to Urban Urban to Urban
Male
Female
'TOEOU
M
B4U%#4<#)
#
#
#F
4EG4E)OOO
M4OOB)OCTOEOU>5--6
-
#4
#4<#)
#
%
>R-6
-
#
"
#
#
-
%
%
%
%
#4<#
--
M4-
#
%
#
T
OEOS
:U>:-6--
%
#
#--
#4
)
%
#
#4<#)
T-
OEOU>
/64#-%
#
4@
>$-%-6-
<?K
/-
#
4<6%<(#%
EEE><EE
3--
<
%
!-
K
-#4><OOE-6G
#4@
6--
%GC
4-
%
44
>5-
#%#4-
G
-44
-#-
FG4%<OEET-4'666>
>
">OEE)4")4
4OEE
4
4>-#U>5-#4
#
4%-#%
6
--
%
44
6--#
-
#
-<
4
>5--
)#
T
U-44
"
#-
E4#4
K$
-
%
$
4
#
K
7-
:
%
>
(#%
3--
%F4
#
OOE>R-6K
--
-#
-#4
/"-
--
<
-#4
"%
<
T-
3
-
OOU>
(
%
4#
<
-#
"
<6K-
6K
-
6K
"#"
K-
64"
4#%
#
<4>5-#
!<
-#4<
6K>$%
GO4#
6K
6K
6K
-/
"
%-"
-
%#
K
K
4><G4
#
6K
#4<
6KTOEOU>
3.2 Migration to cities
As mentioned in the earlier section, internal
#
@
%<-
4
<""4#
%-
><6
#
%
###4
#4
3.3 Seasonal and temporary migration
(
""-
-
4#
#)4#
%
%
-
#%446-#"
for a short duration in the lean season from
51
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
-4
<>-
#
K6
#4
<
#
<
4%<-
"
%
-
#4<%<-4
%-
4
>$
#
-
%%<
4
#4
<#
>
$
#4
<#
]---##%6--
<
6
<
#-"
6
4#-
#%-
H#--
GM
<#4<#
-
#4<#^TOEOU>5-
#
#4
<#
EF#FM
<
4
#4
"<MFth&OOB)OC>5-
#4
<#
4#
<TMG
4U6
%
T?-
-
-#U>
"
-
"4-
#4
<#
#4"
#
-)#
<4"4-
-
%
#-
4-4
-->@
is mostly driven by distressed circumstances and
#"-
<-
4
T3-K
$KOOS?-
-
OEOU>
4. Migrants’ Exclusion and Denial of
Rights
R-#4<-
4
##-
%#%##
%--
T38OOU>(
%#
4
-"
4"<-
%
###4-
%
#
K>(
%6K
"
"
4
6
KK6--
"
>$-4
#4
#
-%
@
p;386%4%6-
#
#
6K>#4<
#
<
4#
6K6-
-
6K4
4
%
4
>
(
%-"<
-<><6
"H
#4'
successful actors or actresses and other artists
-#
-#"-4
-
"#
-<(#%
>R-
#
-<6-#
<-
"%#
>#
<
-%
##K-
8
(
6
;!
>4#
trade and commerce in several Indian cities has
%4%-6
K-#
>
$#
<@
p
#-
(
-
#
;
-V
6
-
-
>&
$#%K
-
#
%-
4-
-<
<@
>5-
#
<-
6--4-
-
#
-%#4<
4
%
#-
4
-44>@-
K
"4#%
44p
44>
K-##
"
#4"
-"#-->
In India, almost all households use remittances
--H4#4"
-/
<>$"<--44
--#
#TBM
4U6%<-
-
TGC4U
TGE4U
T
OEOU>$4
#
#
#
%%
K
"
<K
"
K6K6
remittances, which contribute to the social and
#-
-
>5-
H
#4-6-
#
%%
%-
>
FM
8<
3-K
-
-$KTOOU#
EOO#
#
%
-
-<
-
"#
-
-#
%EO4-
;38>
52
34-#%#
4"64"<
#
#
-<-
%6T
-ECMS&
!
OEEU>$
#
"
<H
<
%-<
<>@@
H
<4
#
%K-
6-#
%
#
-%
---
<#ThukouU>@
-
#
4
-%
hukou
#
#4<#
4--
-
>5-
has been a matter of intense debate in recent
<
TES7OEOU>--
-
@
-H
#
#
K4
--4
#
"4#
K#-
#
)#4
%6#
-
-
>@
<
6--
%<
>(
<
#-6#
6--
<#---
#
6--"#
>
5-#
p--<#<
-4
|sons of the soil’
6--
#
"%
K
-
""#
##-6-%-
T
#4U
-#
#-
T4UFB>
5-
-#
#
-#
K4-<
H
%
-"
%-"
-
%#
K-K#
"-
-K
-K
#K
-4
-%
"
%6--<>$
44
##
-
<
6
#
-<%4
H4S-<
K44-
#4"K6
-
-">5-
-#%
%
44"#FC>#
#
4"
-
#
6-"#
-<
%<-
---4
%
K6
-
-
T
4
4|5--
#
:"pU>
$<%<-TOEO
UOOC
-6-
4-%
--
-
"
K6
6--
4#4-
"%
-#E
4-
"
<
EE4"-
"
<
<>
<-)-%
--6
-6OOC)O>5-
%
6-
44
4"
-
"
-
"
%4-
#
6--
<>5-<
%
6
4-
)%
4<
#-
--4
#
#
"#
#6--<#>("
/
#4#
#
-<#4
-
<%!
">5-
H
#4%
"
---
6
--#
-#
>
(
<#
K4<
4
-<>5-%-
%%
->3
K
4#
<
-"p
H--
">7
K
4
FB
&
!
TOEEU4H
#4]-^#"##"
@
-
(
-
-
$
#
(-
<
;
>
FC
$4@
F>M#44"#OOE>5-#
%<-56
<8
)
T58U6
ME>C#T@
@84
OO'EU>---
)
%
TOOM'EGU-6
#44
EC#@
OOE6--6
#
%ECF#OEO>#
"
<
4#44
>
53
Box 10. Mobile Crèches in Delhi and
Mumbai
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
(%+-4"-
"
MOOO-
<
E
<
centres at construction sites across Delhi,
@3$T
8
-U
;
T
<
U#>OO
>#>>OO4>#>
H
<
6K>@
ensures child
care services for another 5000 children
<
%<4-%-
+-
4%"
-#3-
%
4
##<6#
<--
3"4#T3U-@
>(%
+-6K6-4
4
#4
"#T-4'666>
#%->U>@(#%
(#%
(% +-4"44
related to health, education and the safety
--6K
<4
<6K#
%
T-4'666>##%
#%->U>
H#4
%
K
"
6--
"<#4
#-<
/%#
"#4
##>@6-6-
-
444
#
p
ability to either own a house in his/her name or
--
#<##%p
#
-
"
#>5-
@3T/@
U4!
4F>
5-
4
-T"U
#
<K-
-
---<>3-
K
44-#
<#
"#
#
%
/4
>@
#-#6K
-#
-<-
"44<
F
4
4]%
;"
'63#
‡^
54
4<#-#4<
K-4
6-6K-#
>
3
K<
4
#
%)-<>
5-<
%!4-
#
#4
#
>5-<
-
K
4-<
<
<
-6K
6
-4
<>R#6-
<#
-<
#4
-#
4
K
H>R#
<6K
6K#
<6
6K>5-<
4
66
#4
#
#
-
"
#
K6
-6K
-K
H
-
#>5-
%
+-
K
-<-
#-6KTHEO#
4
U>
5--#
--
K
#-
#%#
-
%
"#>5-#
p
<
#-
-
-%
-
"
>
5-H#
#
-
-
"
"<>8%-
-
"
"
%
4"
-
-
"
<%>(
#
-
%
4-%
-
-
-#-<
4"
6--
-
%<-#4<>5-<
K@.$@3T
(
-
4
6
-
6
OEEU>
5. Challenges of Migrants’ Inclusion
5-H#
---4
"
6
-4#
%
>---
#
#4-4
4
-"
4
##
-;"#>5--
-
44
-
#4-
#
4>R-
-#
<%4
<-
#4-
%-#
##
-"4#
-<>5-
-#4#
4<
"4#
%
#
"46-
vulnerability is determined not only by economic
%
%<
#%)
#
>5-
4
46-
-
-<>@
#4
-
4#-#
p
6---##<6%
-4%
4
44<>
$-%
44
-%
"
<4"
4-4-<
%
whom to include, how to include and where to
>@-
%%#-
-
-#
p4-
-4H4
--#
/<6--
"<4#
-#
-
-
--<4
>@#
<%
-
---<K
%
4
#
#4--
-6K
#
-
<>:-#
%
#4
>
5.1 Inclusive urban policies and migrants’
right to the city
Creating a positive attitude towards migration
and migrants
@%"
4#
#
p
-
44
-#
p--<
%<"%
"#
-
K-
#
>
4"
6
#
#
-%
-<
--
#4
>$
4
##<
#4
%
<--6K-4
%<
4#
6%-4>
$4"
6
#
64
"
-6
<-4
#
inclusion in the city, reduce discrimination in
-""#
"
"-##4
-
#>
City planning and migrants
<4
"
<
@
>3
-
#
<%
#
<-"
#%
#
-<p6>5-<
"
%"
-
"6
#
><
4
"<#4
#6-
6--
-#
p--<>
#--#
4
%
/
-
%
to address the needs of the city inhabitants
#
4
>5-
<#
4
-
<6-
"%
-
<44
and bureaucratically envisioned with little
""#>$&--<
44
-6#
-44
-#
4
%"
<
"4#
<
4"44
<
--
%
|-
T#
pU6--<T>>--
---6
-
-
-
-U%
]-
--
-<
--
p
^50>36/#
%
4
--<"4#
>
Migration and governance
(
%
##
4%#
6
-<>##
-<
"4"
-
<>5-#
-
44
50
$
"<TOOC'GU-
K##
K
#
K
"-#4%-#
-#
->
55
Box 11. Citizen’s Charters declared by Urban Local Bodies
&<"
(4
4
K'
63-T-4'666>#>">$%3(-
>
4HUS.-
K-
4
#
T-4'666>"#>">
%"#
)-
E>-#U
#%
T-4'666>#>">#H>4-4‡4˜#Š"6˜
Š˜CEŠ@#˜GBU
-
"44
p-
-6%>5-#
-
4""%-->4<-6%-4-
#
6>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
-
#
<#
<#-
<%
K<
%
-4>5-4
#
%#
%<""
;
##%--%-6-
could be allowed to certify the residential status
-#
-
"#
#
-
-<
%
K
-">
6--
6
<%
-451>
$4
"#4
%6
--4-4
#
-<>@-4-p-
44
%<"
#4
%
4""4#THEEU>
Government policies and programmes
;"#4
4
##
-#
4-
-#
>5-"-:"`
8
#>--EEth:"`
8
TOOB)OEU
-3
$44
-8
4
the 12th:"`
8
TOE)OEBU
%
4"
#6K<
-
%#
-#
-#
-
#
p--<>
%
"4#
%!
@
%-#
-%
51
"4#4
##"44<
-
K
"
-#>5-
V
6
-
-%
&6
(
TV&(U
&
!"$6
`!
T&$`U
6#4
H
#4>5-
"
%
8T8U#4V&(
&$`
"<
4
--%
4
#6>
@K<-
-6--
"
/#
/
T
#U
6%>6"
-4
##
-#
H4<>:H
#4(#%
-6--
"%"#%
"
-<
OOO6--
-#-
%
4
##>
5-
"-#
6--%
4
4
##
#
<
#
>5-
%-
%--<
6--44&--
<
-"
"
<>
6. Policy Recommendations
(
-%
K6
4
"4#>;"#4
--%K
#
>@-#-
<4
-<"4#
5-H4#6--
(#
#
6
%6
4;6K6-#
6K)
K6
-
<(
RK
-/@
$-<@
T@3$@U
-#
6K-@34
##
44
%
4>-4'
>">
T
-%OEEU>
56
-K
#
4
<#
<
<
<
4
<>5-/
#-
-
-6-
444
#
6
-4#
%
>$-
-
4#
%
-
#
p%6
way, but it needs to be communicated
44
--6K-4
4
#
%-%6#
##>
Policy documents such as the 12th:"`
8
V&(
<3"4#8
-
-"
#
"<H4
#
-#
--/"
<>
@%#4-
-
-
#
<"
-
4
#
)#
K
4
64
"<>
$-%
44
-<"4#
would usher in a new era of freedom and human
"4#S#%-<
#
%6-#
>
57
Urban Spatial Exclusion:
A Historical Perspective Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Diya Mehra
58
5-4
4H
#4
4
4
H
%
<-@
-
4
4>@
K4-
#
"
-4
-6-<#
<-
"-
-#4-<
@
-
#>R--
#
<H
#44
H-
%H
#
4
4T
4"4
4-4U
-
<6-|4%#p
-%
#
>@-
4
H
#4H-6%
#
<#
-
-
"%4<H
#4
4
-<
%--
<
#4
<>5-
4
4-H
#6<
#-
-
4|
<p#
#4
<@
p
%
"4#
<
4
4"
>
1. The Historical Problem of Informal
and Indigenous Urbanism
;
<-%6-
#
4
@
<
-
#
4
<##-
p"4
%
4
>5-6
4#
<---
-
#4#
%
4
6-
6
x
-##4
6--%<)
6
%
"4#4!
4
-#>
-
-
"%
4
###
#%>
:
#
-
-#@
<
|<-<
-
<4
"
4
pT?
"
!EBU
4
#
"#-
#H
%'
|"
4%-
-
even certain ideas of beauty related to the
#
#4% 4
an order of aesthetics from which the ideals
4%-
-
-<
%
4
pT-
K
%<EE'EMU>
@--@
6K4)(<
TECBU-6-6-
##
<6-
%
#
#
!
446
-#4
#
6-#
4%-
-
-
--4-#"#"
4
-<#
T%
ECFS;4
EBEU>3
4"
-
-#
-<
44
#4%
4<>
@-
-x6--
aesthetic or to do with health or security
x-
#%4
44
-
-
4
4
-
%
@
"%
6
)-
-
4
T?
"
!EBS$
ECBS-
K
%<EES-
OOMU>
5-44
6--
44
-
#4
#
<%
"-
H
#
%
<#%
-44
6-
"4
#6
<
4"<
H
|
p
%
%->5-H
<6
4
<#
-
"%
4
6-#4
64
#
|4p"
6K4"%4
and infrastructure for local and everyday city
activities, even as wealthier Indians came to
464
%
#>
@-
4-
"
4"6
446
<
#-6
<"-#4"%
>-#4
K4
#|
"p
4
##
-"
44
%
/##64
>5-
"
%-6"6#
-
"#4<
%4
<
4
#
44
#%
-4
@
H4
6
-
%
"
>
5-"-
/-|
"p
4
-
K4
6-#4
T4"
<
4%<U6
#K
#4-""
"
4%--
@
#4
46
<
#>
$-
###4
6
#
6-"
46"-<
/
%
"#
-
#4
4
6#>
-#
#
#
-#"-4%<
#
"x
H--#"
>5-
H
#44
<##
-
6K#"
%--
4
>(4
-#
-#"
]
-#^
of trades and services onto the street (a habitual
4
|
"p
U
#4
"
T
-
EBS-
OOMU>
@-
<#4
8
-p6%6EE)EG
;4TEMU-6-6-#4
#46#6KH
-%
4
-#
4
>-#<"
-
4
-/
4
"
8
-p
6"4#
%#>5-6
%<
<
|
/#
p drives in
-
6-"4
59
6-#->$)
-# drives
6
#
"
%<-4>
Such actions led to the removal of the formerly
6K4-44-
cities, to areas that could not be commercially
"4
"-
6"#--<>
$
44
%-
4
#%
<
-4"H
#4
|#
--
6
#4p><
-
--
#
-%
4-
#
- /
%<-46
#
%<-
K
of civic infrastructure for slum areas which
6
-
##%H4
>@%
#
-
|4%#p-%
4
#4
#
<
44
<4"
4%#>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
5-"
-#-4)
@446)>
<4
#
%
4
#-
#%
#
#
"
-
6K
--
-
#4<-%
4
-#
#<x6
not-
6-
"
H
)
4
4>`
-#
#
#4"4
<#6"<
4
-4
<-TEBMU>5-
latter continued to be derived from colonial
#4
6
-|#p6
4
"-
K4
|<-<-
<
4
"p%
4
>
<
4
<--4
-
#
4|#p6--
52
60
#
#
-4
4
%
#"
%
<
/
<
<4%4
>
@-4)@44#
H4#6%-
|#pand/
%%
4
>@-
#H
#4
-3-
(
8
4-
K4
-
EO4
#4-
6%
"4#6
%-<
)%"
-
-66
#3->5-6
%<
#
-
)%
-
4#4
#
#/
%"
4">6"-#-
#%<
#%
6--
include scarcity of resources and those subsidies
-4
<#)
->$#
#
6
4
3-
<)"4
|
-
%
p were
4
<"#6"
-#%/
6#
4
3-p%
4>:-
-(
8
K
#
%-#-
/
%
4
-
#64
<
4
-|
p-%
4>5
%"
<
-%
#
#
"
%4
#"
-
T33$EMOS
(-
OOC).
#
<-
6K
#
--
<%OEO524-
-
%/<-
6K"@
>8"<
---#
<-
"%
#
"
H
)
4
6-
6K-
#-
#%H4
"K
#4
6-
<
K#|
p-
6K#%>@
##--#%-
6K
4#V#;
&
#"(4
4
3-C%OEO>
H-#%
"
%
#
K
<H-#6-/>@
(#%
H
#4-
6Kp-
"
%EBCT?
-
OOBU>
2. Continuing Segregation and
Exclusion of the Urban Informal in
Contemporary India
@-#4
<4)%
4
-
<#
#
-
#-%
)
"
#"
-%
4
#
#4
K3-T34
&
#
-
OOCS(-
OOMU
?K
T&<OOGU
(#%
T(
-
"
OOCU
#->"-
"
#
<##-#"
-
6K#
-4
"
#|
-p>-
mass evictions have come at a steady rate after
a lull and there are numerous case studies of
-6"-
"
-64
4
@
-4)
%
4T34
&
#
-
OOCS(-
OOMS:
OOMS
"K
OOGS(
-
"
OOCU>
In the case of evicted slum settlements
#
##4
<
#
-
44---!
#%
4
#
'
† 5--
%
--
6K-
-#
<
H4
S
† 5-H
)
4
44
urban informal economies, which increases
-"
%<S
† 5-<#%
-
6K%
%
#
6
|<
4
-
</
p
%
4
<
#
"#
!#
-#
#)
"
which cumulatively and effectively resurrect
4
S
† 5-
#
"
)
-%
4--
-
6
4
T#
#
4
K
U
6
|"
p
##
real estate, that raises demand for land
4
%<-%
#
4S
† 5-
-
6%<-%
4>
4
#"
H-
44
4<###
K
"#"4
-<%
-
"4
4
#)
class urban residents, their civic associations,
-!
<T34
&
#
-
OOCS:
OOMU>5-
6
-
4%
4<6-
)#
-4"
4
%
%
x"
-#
H
64
6
-6--#"#
#x
<4#
K<
6)
#4
>@--
4
6-
#4
#
#
<x##4
#
H#
%
4
#-
#4%#
-
and orderly cities, at a time when cities are
H4
4
<
#
<
4
>@-#4
<4
%<#4
4-
-
446--6/#
4
<6
"4#
#-
>
The privatization of space
6#
H%6
#
)#
4)-
"%-4"
6%
4
61
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
62
%4#
<#)
>-
4"
-%/
<
#
-
<
-%-#
6--
#
<
H4
<-%
4>5-
#%-#)4%
<4"
4
6K"
#4x-
#
#4H
x-
"
<6-
6
<%
#H6-
#
-4
-#
H4
"6K
-<
-#
#-6
4
6K-#
>:-
##
"4#
--4"
"4#T6--
-
#
U
#<"
-
-4
64->@
-"4#|<p
-
%%6#
<
wealthier urban residents, their new ambient
"#
-4-
|-
p<4
#TOO
R
4OOFU>$#4
-%
4"
-#"
#
6
-
6K
"##4%
>
3. Conclusion and Recommendations
<-
"
#"
4
<-%
4
the informal in Indian cities is based on the
<"
#4
6%
4
6--
"
#
4
444
%
4
>
5-<#
<
4
-
<
<
6-
-
##%#
<
%-%
4
#
H
<>:-#-4)#
4-
-
)
6)
-6--H
-4
#
%
<#
-
4
"TH4
"6KU
--4
%
<#
)K4>
;"--<%
H-%
4
#
4%
<-
%
4
|p
4<<
#
-
"#
<#%
#
#
-%
#
<>$#
-
/
--
#
#6K
#)
%<#6--6
#4<
4"
-%
4
#
H!%#6->@#
<#
4"#
%"
6
-<>8"
/
4
-6K
-6
#%-
<
4
---<>
Claiming Land: Rights,
Contestations and the Urban
Poor in Globalized Times
Solomon Benjamin and Bhuvaneswari Raman
A consideration of urban land is central to the
-#-&--<T&55U-6
<
6
">5-
&55#-
44"<
%
%
%/
6-6-
-6>5#"%<
#4#-
44
-6#%
7%"p4|-p
#)
#
4
-
4--"<
<
4#
4
-<>@
#4
K
-#
4
-
4"
<44
-6-4
-
4-4
T7%"EEU>5-4
6
44
-
#
4
)
>
1. Facts and Conceptions: Interpreting
the ‘Rights’ to Land
1.1 Crises in facts and conceptions
Globalisation and urban land
7
"
<
4<"4%
44-
"<-
4-
#44
4-<
<4
4
#<4
<6-
#
44#%#4
<-
%
)
>@#4
here to carefully consider the nuanced ways in
6--
##
%<44
->(H4<-#4
"
%<44-#
K(#%
3-
#
>8
H
<
H4
%6
--
6--
---
!<4
##>5-
<
6
K-
#44
63
%
"
6
<>
;%
-
4&55#-
44"
6
<>8<#
K
#%
3TOOOUp
-
-
4
"#"4#
#"4-%
6--
><-6
-
%<>5-6
%<<<"
4<
and institutional structures for clear titles and
6
6
)
/-
become the centre of several new laws and
#6K6-
K<4
<
%<464
4>5-
7
)
5TOOB)OEOU-#
<
4<
"->5--
form the basis for central city urban renewal
%<#-
-5
3"4#&-T53&UG and new land
/4#
4!-
H46
<6
4
4
#,T,U>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Climate change and competing claims to the
urban environment
$
#6-#
-
-"#4
#
K
4
#
66
<'
#
K%
<#4""
)
%
6
-
#K(#%
-
"#
/4%<
>@(#%
-
K-
-#%<4
44
T8
-
K
8
OOU
6
"T
;4
OEOU>5-
4-%
"#
#-
44"
-
"#
""#
<"6
>
new metro level institutional forms allow for easy
"4%
-
-#
6
-4
@5
##
#4H>7
-6"
-
)-44"
#
4
-<
4
#
#
#
)
>5-
4K
discussed below, to the mobilisation of the term
#>
‘Slums’ as a language of disempowerment
:#-#)"-
<
-
<
--
"4--6--
6
"4"6
<>5-
44"-
-
(
8
44"-
)4
|#p>"
-
-
"4-4%#
4
)#
4
#T&
OOMS&<OEES!
#
OOFU>34-/"
4-
"
6-#4
"<--6
"4#
>:-#-
-#-
-%
/<"
>6"
-#6%4"
44
%<%<"
4-4
H--<
'-
-|&R
$
p
times the senior judiciary, and many researchers
"
4
#
>(
<-4
that slums create deviant behaviour and fuel
H4
"|4
#p>5-4
"
%
"-
<6K
-6>
#
-
T:
OOEUH4#-
#
G
53&
4
#"#--$#
H-
64
-
/
<
%<4#4"
"4#4
6H
"4#-#H
44)
>5-#4
-
#%
-
-
<
"<#
4
-
/
4>(#4
<53&
4
#4<
/-4%
-<
%
#
44<4
#6-#-#
46
"4>@@
--
%#-"<6-53&(#%
>
64
4
<>-K
6
<
-#%
#
T3-
-6
ECU>&
--
4-<"
-
4
<""
4
4#%
4
#
level bureaucracy to claim land and services in
"<
"
44
T!
#
&
#
OOEOOMU>5-
circulation of the term slum also facilitates a
4"
"
<>
$-
"<#%";
#4
4-4#"#4>
5-##4
-6;
#
#4
"
4>#
#
44
#-
4
#
4
4
<4
6;
K-
#4
6--
444<
4
"#
<
6--
#--#44>
84-
"
6-
#;6--644
4T
#U
4
#-
4
>
-#
<
-4
-
--"4
#
"
-
%%%%
-K<%
-6
-
#
"
)%<
4
#%
6
>
@-
4
-
-
4-H""
-4
4
#%
#
-##
<4
4>-#
#%<
-
"
-6-
6<-
#%
>5----"6#
-#
#
#
K>
5--6
-/
<
-%<"#
<>R--
"
|-%
<p#
%
4"<4%"
)4
#6-%
"
#>--K
6"
%4%
6
<
>5-#
<
6
#
"
<%
<
<#
K#4H-
4
-#
4--6--
@
-4
>@
--
#
--##
4-
-K)#-
#
4
H
<4-6
<-
H-46-
44%
#-#
"44">
Poverty alleviation programmes miss out
crucial land dimensions
8"<
"
4
##-
"
6
4'4"
-6-
44
4-
">--
6K
4<
#<-
>@-H#%
#
#--
%
#
K
44
-<-
"
>$-H4%6
street traders and the state in different Indian
-6
4
"
#
#
"-
"
"
-4
-
<T&
#
OEOS$!
OOMU>
#4
-6#
#
-
""
444
#
medium economies in the cityF>@<
-#-
---
4
##%
#
)
-
(#%
6--
)
4
#
"4>
F
5-%
6
4
##
#
<4
###4#K
-
(#%
3-
%-
6-
-
%-
>5-%6#
#
"
-H>
65
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Rehabilitation and Resettlement (R&R)
induced displacement
@
4
-
4"<
4
#
#
4
4
#>-K6-
#4!-#&Š&
4
44"<")
-
-%
44-<>5-
%KK-
%
-<
#
<
)
sale, are located away from livelihoods and
#4
>5-
%-"<
;4-
"
#
%4"
-4>;
#
-4%)4"
4
-4#-
%
&Š&"<
lists as an instrument of social control in a
#4H46<
#6-44
T
<
(K-!
OOES(:
OOFU>
5-%#"##4
6-
--4
4
44
KK%
K"
T(K-!
OOGU
4
<6-#
;
#4-
46-6
T&<OO
S!
#
&
#
OOEU>@
#4
-
--
-"
)-"4--
44
6
<#<"
#)
>"
-
<
6K-"
"#%<6
#)
4----
"
"%<
6
T&R$UH-4
-4
#
"4
55>
5--
44-6#
-%-#
#-
#
#
4
6-#
4
|
/
p%<-T,
-OOBS5
6
7
#
)
&6
OOBS!
#OEOU>
55
$-
<"
-
|-
6K>p5-4
#
4H#-
#4"
"%<&R$
#"
-
6K##
<4")
T!
#OEOU>5--
4
<
#@
-#4
--
#44<4
644">5-6-
H
-
4-
4%
4
%<
-----
#
"
#
"
4
4
>
4<-
#
#
-<
"%
%-
#
"
4
)
4
##>5---
"%"6
6--
#
#
"
4x
6
-4
4>-
#4
-"<
#>
1.2. A nuanced understanding of land:
interpreting the rights to land
From slums to more accurate descriptions of
territorializations
5-
-4%6
4"<
%"
#44
>-
-#)-
-
"6#-$
7
$#
-"
<
)
"-
-
4
"
#
"4#T
!
OOS&%OOS
.
7
ECS!
#
&
#
EU>@-@
-)
-
4"
%""
</
#)#"
%
<%)"6
-6K#)chawls (in
(#%
U
6
6
':
TOOMU-4-6#
-
K4
"
4"<#4%4
S$!
)
TOOMU
&
!
4
TOOEU-%6
-<(#%
S!
#TOEOU
;--TOOU
-
$
5
K:
S$
%TOOU-
#
#%
>
66
<
>(
<-
#-
"
#'"
<?
K
"<#
-"4#4
|)
-p3-x-
4%<
#
"
>
What binds these various forms is that they
""-(
8
4
--4<%<
#4#
4-
-
4
#-
--"
)
#>
5-4
<""
"#
"4-
-
%!>5-6-
#4
!
4#
4%
4
-
>5-
-4%<
#
"4#
#H
that remain common to these settlements in
"
4%T!
#OOFU>
Land regularization as a central progressive
intervention
7
-
6
-
6-4
%
">$--
#
<%%<
"
-#"
"#
4%<6-
"
4
<#<44
-"#4"#
">-4)44
middle level bureaucracies, many of whom stay,
-
"
"#6-
%
>5-
)4"
"
such terrains across cities and towns coalesces
4
4#"--"
#
>
5-%#)4
-#
#
%
|
p
(
8
#
#
-
-%<4<
and are accommodated via administrative
4-
-|)
p>
7
-
%
#4#
%
-%<
4
#4
#
"
4
-
#%%<%<"
4
#
4>R-
-
"
#
)
#H4#
)-)
"
subversion by the elite who lobby for stricter
(
8
4
#-
53&>
5-
"-
-
46
6--#4
<
"
4
-
46
--"
#
>
5-
-
-46
"%
"
"4#>"
bureaucrats retain their alliances with decision
#
K
4
#%--
"
4<
#
T&
#
OEOU>
5-4
-
"T<#
-
444U)
>#-
H4
"6-
#%<
-44-<
-
"<
K-
#4
often turn out to form the basis for evictions and
#>-
6)
4
#4
6-
#
<
#%%<
"
)
%
4
<%
-%<%
44
#4H
6-
K
4##-#46
>
Diversity of land territorialization and tenure
forms underpins an economy of the poor
5--#
"
-
44"
-
6
%
4-%
#<'-444p-%
#
#
<--
#<-
6K-
">5-6-
%
"-
!%
4
##
%<
-
%<;#
67
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
-
>7
%#
-K
%-<#<
6--4
4"
>4
-4
-
%
-4-
"
#
6
<%K#
6-
44"6-#-4
<
%#<>5-#<
##
-4
4-
"
-6#
)
#%
#T"6
-#
U
6-
6
<
4
4
#
#
<4
T!
#OOFU>5-6
<
4"<4<-4
%
#"#)#4
who are connected to varied small economic
">@
-
%<
"<4#6---%K
#4<#
%<
"
<#
#
"TOOU>(
<-
#
6---
6-"#T!
#
&
#
OOES!
#OOFU>:H
#4
44#
@
p|"
<p
-
-
Fz#4<#
%<
-@5T#
-<U
-
44K<%-#
T(
-
"
OOMU>6"-@5
-<"%4<
--
#
"
%<-4
4
T!
#OEOU>(
<-
"-6
<
--4
4T
ECS!
#OOFS&
#
OEOU
-
4%<
4
<
6>5-"
-
6
"
<#
4H#<
-
#K
#4
4
4
>
5-%#
<
-
6
<6--<4
"
#-
#44#-
--44
#4
4
6K>-
68
formations constituted for economic activities
#
@
x%-#-
%%
#
6>5-
#-
x4"<
-4
6<
#<"6---
-
#-64%<6--
-<>-
44"K6-
<
6
#
44<"
->8-
4
--
6-<--/
#
-4
--
K<-
#
44@
T!
#
&
#
EU>5-
%6
4"<
%%"
-6
<'
† Access to productive locations: Areas with
#4#4<#44
6
44#
4>
† to economies of different scales:R-
#4<
4
"
-4
#
K
#
#<
#4
#>
Similarly, investment in land as a way of
-K
<##
"
<
%--
4""
<4#
">
† Diversity of land tenure forms observed in some
localities allows poorer groups, among others, to
claim land and consolidate it over time::#
"4#---
4
<4
)%
)4
-<4#
-
""
"4
4
4
T!
#
&
#
OOES!
#OOFS
&
#
OEOU>
5-
4"<<6-
-%##4
<6-
-44p
#4<
4"
>
Competing land territorialization between
-"
)
>
:#-44"4"<4
land claims and the issue of access are related
-
%<
"<44
4<<#x-
-#
4
4T!
#
&
#
EU>
"<<
-
-
-%<
different economies differ, and relate to very
4
>
#
)##4"
#
%
#4<#-4
#)#
4>5-<#
-4
<
6-6
#
level bureaucracy and are able to mobilise local
"#>5-
6
<-
64#""4
-4
H4
#
<4##
K
T!
#OOFU>"<%
#4""#
%-#
#
--%-
#H
>
5-#4#4-
4K
#
<"
%
<4
%-
4
4
%"<6
<>
-
-
"#
-
K
%6
44p
%
"/3p
#
#4
4"
6)##T;%
OOS
)K#
T"U:
OOGU>
5-
-
%
"
4
-
#4<#%<4
-
K
!%6--
-
remains at crisis level accentuated by the 1998
%
>5--
&55---
"
-
4%<%
#4-
#
--
-4"-
6
>
@
#44%
--4-#
4
6-
--/
<
>
-#
#
#K
4#4"#
-
#
"
4
x%"<6
<
|4
<%
#pT!
#OOCU>#
##%-"#
T"6<
#%U
%
4-
#
K<
4
>@
#
-
#%
"<
'-4!
%
4%4
-##T!
#OOCU>
5-44--""#
4
K#
#
6-#
44##
#4
#-
46
2. Academic debates
5-
-4-
%
-"6
<-4
#-4
#
>5-#44"
the need to consider the social construction of
land claims, and in turn, to have institutional
4
#-"-
--
6----
44>5-##K
6
'#%
4-<
-4<
64%
4<
#"4#
"4#>5-H"
K
-6
%<
"
<
"4#4-
6-
4
(
8
>$
4
x
<
-
EO6-
H%%
-66K
-
x#
#
>
-4<4"6-)4
view, with an entry into both a construction of
6
-
4%<-
<4
land in an incremental way, and also the nuances
69
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
-6K4%
#
>5-
"6%7%"p84
TEEU%
"<
<4
>5-
-4<
644%
-
44<
-
4
#%%
#
K
)#
K4T
ECU>
#4"6-
<-
#4
-4%6
#<#
#
#
-
#
<#<>-
4-<4<-
#
-
44%
#
6
%
<""4K
#
"##
#4H>$
consideration of the city economy around land
-#
4<4
6--
4
#
6
-4
4%<
6--4<-
44>
70
@H4
"6
4
6
%
>@-EBO
-
mid 1980s, closely connected with what can be
#|%
"4#
#p-
#
!6
--"
44<
->5-#
-
#
--
EMO
<EBO>:6-ECO
4
<@
4
7
$#
-#4-
6
4
6%
%
-
44
-#
territorial formations into the liberal notions of
<#
#>5-
44
-6-
#
#(
8
#%<#4
>
-#"4%4<6
#4
-6
<6'#-
EMO)BO-#4-
|#
Kp
"-ECO
4%
>7
-<
4
46KH"<-
->/-
%"
44
-
-"4#
-<>
@-EO-6#"6
#
K
%
<#4">5-
#
#4%<3TOOOU
#4#6-H"4
#4
>5-
-
4"
-
6-
-
#
4--
44x
6-
-4-
4-
#
%
%-4
#4
">
It was in the late 1990s that a distinct turn away
#%
6--
4
radical transformation via urban renewal and
#
4!)-
4
4
4
"-
>
<OO-6
#4
%<-
"
6
-4%
/>
-4
%<44
#
-
"
>$K<
4
%<
4
64%<"
#6K>5-4-
-4%%
-
#%
4-#-#
##4
<-6
--
44>-
#
#
"#<
44<
H%
K
#6-
444#%#
<#
T3
OEOU>"
<#
K;
/
4!K,%
#
#
<4
>$-
#%"###4
-
444
#
"4
"
##
4TOOCU>5-
)
-
6--
-6
"#
4%
<
4-)
T!
#OOFU>
$
4
-
--4
4-
4--</6--
-)
%
44
-
<#
K%
4
#4"6
-4>@
-#4
H
6#
44
#
4
4
"
recommendations for individual titles, biometric
"<
-)
6--6-
#<TOOGU#
-"-|
"<p>5-
-
<4
"6-
#
%
%
6
4
##
"
4
##>
$/4"<
4
##
4
#>5-
"
of Indian society and their different avenues
#6--
-4-
"
%#-
T!
#OOOS-
!OOFS
%OOS:
OOES&
#
OEOU>5-6K----#4
#4
4
44<#-
#
%
<
#
"
-
>;"4"
46
-4
#
%<-4
#
#
!<-%
-H4
#4
4
<4
%
-4<
-|"<
<
pT:
OOES%
OOU4"
>5--<
-
#4H4
46--
-
<%-)#
4
4<446-
6
"%<-
H<-
#%#
%
<#4">
3. Inclusive and Exclusive Practices
7
%
#4#
4-
6
-"6
4
%>@-
6!--)#
4-4"4
%-
4
H>R
that the trend of simultaneous, selective
#4<
---"
-#
-
"
#
"-
6
4>
-
46--)
#
6
<4-44
6
<#
#4<#
<
>
"-6-#<-46K
-4"
44-
6
<
-46--#
#>
5-#
<-4H4
4
H
6-%<#44
#
##
>#
-64
##
-
6
4
44
"4#
-
-#4-
4%4<-
#)
M>$--
44
a climate of fear of eviction and the trauma of
#
/
<
#4
>$-
-
#4-
4
|p
-
6-#4
#
are confronted with what seems to be inevitable
"
##-
64"-#6-###
"
-
-
6>$-#-
#4-
|4%)4"
4
-4p
4#-
44">5-
4
<
#6
-%
6-
4
#
4
#-
%"%
6-4
-#
K>
At one end, the diversity of forms of tenure and
-
4
#
#
#
"6
-
-#
M
5-
44
-&
!"$6
`!
-
4%4"
4
-4#
"4#)%
--
-<4
>$-4
-
;
5<T;@OEOU
%"
-6%>
71
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
#
K%
-
K
<#T3<
>OOMU>$
-/<
/
6-4"
-4
>
:6#-
#
#%#4#
4
##
;@#
444
##
#
"
57>5-4
H
<
-44-"#
44
-4-
evidence that such interventions affect adversely
"<44
-#
6---<
T&
#
OEOS
!
#
&
#
OOEOOMS(-OOFS
#<OOGU>
@
-4
H
6
<
"4
-
4
%%<)
-
<
"#>6"6-#
/6-
"#
K
-
#4
-)#46#
">-
<OOO
-
4-64%4<-
4
%<464"
-K
K-
4
T!
#OEOS;--OOU>5-
44
4<-%
|-p
<
#
-
#-4
-<>@
#4-"6
<
"-4
4
--4>:#-44"
4K-&
!"$6
`!
4
##
#
<H
<-4>@
-
6-)#
44"
-4%4<6%
-44<
#
-
%#
K
#
6
#
>5-
44"
#4
%<-
---&Š&4
##T3<
>
OOMU>
Such a view dominates the discussions of the
R
K
4<>6-
K
"
-6
#
K
#
#6-"
#
-46
%
-44"
"
>5-
#4-%-
6-
#
K6K6%
-4-
6
""
#%
-6
-
#
%<44>
7K-#
4
<4
<4
>
!
4)/
"
#
K
>585-"6
-
<#4#
4
##;@#
4459-7
5
7
5$-<
%
K
6
#4
"
%<
#4"-4
#
4
-
%6--6
-
"--#
#
K>
5-
4
##
#4
%<>
R-4
##-
"%
4)%
#
<
%
44<-V&(H4
44<
<#>
K&
!
-
3-?
K
$-
8
-
<
<6K
-#
>5--
"
"-#4
tools, laws, and institutions need to be seen
-
-#4
4
4>@V<OEO#4#
<#
57
-6%-;V
-
T-4'666>!
-
>U
4
4
##@
%
4
:
T-4'
4>U>
58
$H
#4--5
#
%
@
:
4
T5@:@U4#%<-R
K
4"
4
@
7
:
"T@7Š:U$<@
3"4#
T$@3U>
59
-
7
5OEO>
72
;
84<5T;75U-
%#
-#
<#-V&(>
5-
-(<%
3"4#
-
"4
##
87$5@(T8
-47
5@#4#
%
(
#U
6--
%<-@
3"4#:
4
T@3:U
%#4#%<-@
%
4
:
T@:U%<
"
4
%
>MO@<-
@:44
-#4#
;75>@
-4
constitute new territories for the new economies
--
)
/-
44-<,
6
-"44
-<
#K53&T!
#
&
#
OOEU>
@-
%"
!
-
-
#
44
6-
-
--4!"
-#>
6-<-
-
-
4"
4-#4#
)
4
##
-
-
6---
-
<-
4%<
"
%<>5-
4
##
-
"/
-
%<
%4-<p
44
4
<44
#
-4
##-6'
† 5--#
#
diverse small and medium economies are
4
<
#
#-
#6->5-
-H4
H<4
-<
/
--<
#
%-
#
4
ME>5-"<#
"6
K-4
)#
"4#
/-
"4"%
K>
5--<
/
@
"
#
4
4
%
-
%<
/
>
† 5-#
-#4
or the local institutional level is viewed as a
-
>@-H4)%
areas, many of which fall under the rural or
%
4
-
<
#
-
bureaucrats of revenue administration had
K6
T$-!
-
OOU>
#
-
the control of information at the local level
-#4
"<
--%
>
† 5--
-
4!-44">
#4
"
"%<-
H<%
4
%%
-46"
small local institutions and to undermine the
4
"-
4>5-4
6
-
-
<
4
-4
to control local institutions as well as local
4
6###6-
%
>
† 8
6%
"
6#-6
%
4<#>@<#
44
4
<"
"
#6-
there have been mass demolitions since the
-<
|
p
-#6-
4"
#
#>
5--
#4
-#
discourse, actors and institutions associated
6--
#4
#
K
MO
-4'666>>#
4<
%

4!>-#>
-4'666>!
-
>
ME
73
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
444
6-
46%
"#-
4
p
%<
4
<
#4
"
T$-!
-
OOU>5--4K
#%<
-
"6--#
K
senior bureaucrats to control street bureaucrats
4<#
K4
"<T7%
K-
OOU>-
#4
/#-
4
##6---
"%
#4#%<-;"#?
K
OOG>5--6
%%
T&
#
6
OEEU>
-44
4<
documents, we see a central issue in the trend
6
4!)%
4
#
4
##)%
-#
>
<-K<6--6-
#
4%4<--
|<
/<p
4
"4#
#
4"
#
%<
4
4>$-
##
#
"#
-4
44#%
>:
K4
#
%
#
>@
4
#
--
44#4
freedoms, in fact restructures institutions, which
6-
4<>
5--
--<
%
<
<
<-46-
-
4
4<
>
4. Policy Implications at Different
Levels
R"K<4-
4
"
'
E> Land regularization as a policy for shelter and
pro-poor, job-centric economic development.
5-#
#
44<-
#<-
44"
#
74
"4##
6
"
#44-
>
> Political empowerment of local government
(municipal/ panchayats).5-%-
4
#
"4
6-
T
H
"
%
U
#
"4#-
">-
#46#
#
4)/4#H"
)4
%
">
G> De facto tenure via in-situ upgrading promoted
by local government.5--444
%-
--
#
S--
-
#<>
F> ‘Job-centred economic development’,
employment and value addition#4
4
"H
concentrations of usually small home and
-%-)%
#>@-
4"#4
<
##
%<#
#
#H
>
> Strengthening pro-poor political management
of land in contested urban settings>5-
-
44
"#
#-
4
4
>
5-
%""4<4/
"
##<-
#4'
† The ‘housing fetish’ 6--#4-
#4|-p)
-##4
#
>
7
4%
/"
#
4<
44"
#<'U|--
p
!<|#
-p%<4
-
-S
U)!
4)/"4#
">
† Local governments as mainly ‘administrative/
maintenance’ bodies: their role would be
##4#
-#
#
4#
|
#<p%<--"
"#>
† Hi-Tech zones such as SEZs, or IT/BioTech corridors, or ‘urban renewal as a
prerequisite for economic development’:
5-"/
/4
#-
53&
<
%-
#--"4>
† Advocacy politics as the sole political space
favourable to poor groups:5-4
;&R$
-
-
4
"
"4
"#
4
"44>;
4
<
|-
-p%-#
"
#46#>
75
The Challenge of Slums and
Forced Evictions
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Véronique Dupont
$
/
-
--
4
46--
4---
--
ECO%<-@
#4
&-
]-
-"<6#
#
-
4
"4
<^T?-
OOG'
U>5-
/
-x
44
H#x#4
%-
4-<
-
>
1. Facts: Shortage of Decent Housing
and Recurrent Evictions
1.1. Shortage of decent housing
@
4
<-
6-
-
-6--
-
K#
%
--T4
%)
6
K
#U
-
6-4
#>5-H
M
-%
44
"#4"
<-
-'
† $4-OOEMFG#44
4Gz-44
6-"OOOO-
%
"#>
5-44
-
'
Ez-
3-GGz?K
Fz(#%
>6"-OOE
THEGU#
-"#%
of slums and slum dwellers, as towns below
OOOO44
6--
MO--6">
† %/<-###
T;@OEO%UK
-
EME6
#
-#
44
T
MO--U
B>G#
M>Gz-
%
44
>5-4!OEEG
#>
$-#6-OEE
%#
-Š--
#6
"
%>
76
† $4-##4-"
)$@5$5THEU@
p%
#
44
6
#
EC>F#
%<#)<
OOEz-
%
44
>
@OOC)OFGz-6#
6<
T>>6katcha or
semi-paccaU
Oz-6-
%)
<)#K6>
TOEO%
HEFU>"-<
-
consolidation of structures, the addition of a
<
-"4#
-
"%
<
#
<
"
%<-6>$-OOE
GBz%
---
<
#"-44Gz
3-FEz-
Mz(#%
>@
OO-4
4
"
%6
F>M
/>#>#
C>F/>#-%
TOOFU>
/
%
-
H#4%<-
%>@
(#%
T(4
4
UOOEM>
##6
%-
-44
4<Cz
>
In Delhi in 1998, before the massive demolition
"
#/
#
-G#-
%
Bz
-
%
44
%4<
-
Mz-
T?OOFU>
(-
K
/
-
structures and amenities is combined with the
Kx#4-
-]/
#^THEU
%<"4
>@
4
"
#6-
%
-<4-%
4
-6
%
"-#
>
@
-#
K-
-
%)
%
%
"-/
4<#
-
%
not meant for
<
-
--
and that were
K<
-
"4
-##
>-
"%
K446<
#
-<
%
6
#4
6
<
K
%6-->
5-
%FOOO##
%
@
OOC)OFz6
nallahs Ez
6
<>
$%FCz-#6
<
%<6
-#T
OEO%U>5-#6
4
<
vulnerable to industrial and natural disasters, as
#
<-6%<-H4-
%4
<-4
ECF
-OO(#%
>
5-4@
#
<
-#44
"#S
#
-#-
-#"
%>`-
-#
<%<-
T--#6
EEU>@
Delhi they were estimated at between 100,000
OOOOO-#EOEz
-
%
44
>5-#%-
#
<6
)
#
Box 12. UN-HABITAT operational
5-4
#
##%<
H4
;4(T
%C)GO%
OOU
slum as an area that combines, to various
H-64-<
-
T)$@5$5OOGU'
† /
6
S
† /
-
S
† 4
/
<-S
† "6S
† >
77
57'!+
Census of India
5';
<+<=>&;<<>*
:-#OOE-@
collected data about slum areas in cities/
6-
"
44
OOOO#
%
-EE
6'
5-
4-6
"<'
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
]$4
|#p
%<
7
;"#
5T5U$#
<
$S$
]#p%<
7
;"#
5$#
6--#
<-
"%#
<
|#p
<$S$#4
GOO44
%MO)
BO--4<%
#
-<"#
<6-
/
K44
<
K6
>^
$%
#4#
6
44-#OEE
#<'
<#4
-
settlement of at least 20 households with a
4<%#6--
#<#4
<
6
-
<6-
/
<
K6
-<
>
#'%<Gz3-%6OOO
OOCT5
Š?#
8
<OOCU>(
!
demolitions, with similar effects, also affected
(#%
-#>
5-RK;4%
6-:
##
-
M>G#-
6/%%
-4OOB)OE
<
#
<R
KTRU
76
@#;4T7@;UT;@OOM
'GU>
MG
]$#
#4
#6-
4<%##<
#4
<
6-
<
6-
/
<
K6
-<^>-
6
)
slum if a least 20 households lived in that
>$
#%<4"
#4
4
%
"4#
-6
]#>^
1.2. Extent of slum eviction in large
metropolises
-EO
@
#4-
"
H4
-%
4
6--/#%
>
5-#4#
%
4!4
<
H4
%
6
4!
]%
^4
-
"
#
<#4
-
settlements and forced evictionsMG>
† @(#%
%6"#%OOF
(
-OOOOOO-6#-
FOOOO4FF
>5-#
%<-@
84p5%
"#
#
&-MF#
<%#4
-
-
OOOO->
† @?K
BBOOO4464
OOF)OOT
4%<&UM>
† @3-OOF)OOM##
6--"4#-
")
--$-p
.
-OEO##6
-;
#
%
@
x
7
&-6Kx-$
&
8
##T@)7&OEO
OEEU
-4'666>-)
4>>
MF
666>4
>
M
&-
"'666>->>
78
5<%@
5-#$
T@#4"#
U$EM#
#
4
"6-6--%]
<4-#
-
%
^
-
]
%<
4
"6
<
#
-%
6
<
#
K"
-
<
#%
-
#
<-
-#
^>g#$
T@#4"#
$UEM-
4@@k>
5-#
<
44<--
%%<
446-
-
-
-%
3-6--6
#
>5-$6
#4#3->-
-
"
-6#$
$6-
#-
#
<"
<#
%
<%
#
>
5--
T
U-#$
$>@
-
%
-
-!
<
]/
#^#
#
4
%46--4#-
6
<>5-
-
]
#^
<
!-)!-#43-!-4
4
(#%
-
-
>
#
<
#
-
#%
K#-`
#
"
-
"
%GOOOOO44x
OOOOO44#:%
<(
<OOFMM>
2. Legal and Policy Framework
2.1. Urban and housing policies and the
urban poor
3-6
6-
@4@
TEFBU4<#
K
4
6-
(
-
#
;
-p
"
<
"
)
#"4#
4%
44
<
)%
%
>
-ECO%
-6
4
-4%<-:"`
8
-64%-4
##
-
%<-
"#6--44
-
6
%#-
--%
44
4
<
-4>
-
-#
%
-
4-6#
-4
##-
"%-#
T(%ECCU>5-EO-
#4%<
--
-
4"66
"<-#
%
<-4
-
/
#>$-
#
#%
4"<6
<4"
/
4"<6--4
#
4#
4-#
!
#46#6-
6%
%
-T(K-!OOMU>:
with this fear, until the early 1980s, authorities
"
#
%<#
K
%
">@
"4#
6
<---
<#S
--
6K
6S
#
#6
-
T
OOU>
5-&4-
##
%
ECC
-
MM
'(5@)7&V$$44
@3):OOOF>3-;"
'R
5)
%
@
)
7
&-6K(
<OOF>
79
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Š
%
8<TEFU #
K
>5-6%
"4#
<6
%
-4
4"
T;@ECCŠ
EU>@
#6-
-#
<4#-"4#
-
%4
-#
>8%)4"
4
-4-
--4"
-
44"<6
#-
%
4
##
--#-4>"
#
-
"
-H%
"4#4
'-
the cement sector, which boosted the construction
S-
%-<#-
#
!<
4
S
-4
-EBM%
7
T
U$
T#4
6%
44<U
E6-
"6#
#
K>
5-#
!---"#
#%
4"-
#
%
%6-4#4%)
4"
4
-4-
%#
-%/
%
4
4
##-
-OOV
6
-
-
%
&6
(TV&(U>$
4
V&(-%)#]
"
-%
8^T8U-(<
%
8"<$"
MB,
#
/
%
"<
"4#
#4#
-
"---4"%
6#)#4H
-#
<6
K>-
"
-6"H44#
%
-"-
-%
4
---4
##T(
-
"
, OOMU
-
<-H--
###
4
#K
-#4#
4!
MB
|
p"-T@)7&
OOU>
]$
%$^-
-
-T
U
%
%
8<TOOBU6---
K6
-
-
]-
"%
%<"#---
4
<-#
<6
K
TRU
6#4T7@;U^
T;@OOM
'F)U>5--
#-4<]
%<
"
-6-R
7@;
^T@%'EFU>5-
-
4<##
#
KOzz
the land to be made available at affordable rates
-R
7@;>@-##
#
-
%
>]5-#
#
K#-
#
#
4
"4#
-
44<---5
3"4#&-MC
:
4
@H^Mx6--K(#%
-
"
%T(
-
"
OO'EU>5-4<
-
"
-
-
to slum dwellers in situ or in relocation sites, and
#4-
-44
4
4
#6>
5--4"
"4
%<4#6--
"#%
>
6"-#K<-
-
-46%"4-%
44-6--6/
%#
4%
4<#
%
-#
#4<#
#
4
-<>("-
-#-K<#
-
-]-6)##
-
"
/
#
"^6-
-4'#-4
>">Š-4'!##>>!#-4
H>-#T
EO)OC)OEOU>
5
3"4#&-53&
#-<
#
"-
6T
"4
%UH
%4
>@
6-%"4
-
-4
-<T6-
-
-
(#%
U---%>
M
5-:4
@HT:@U:$
&
-
-
%
4
-
-
4>
MC
80
]6"/
#^
T@%'EMU>
$---
%
%
84"-
#
"-
@
-
<#"#
-
4%<
#
#
%
"4#>5-
-
4-
4
%<-4
#
#6
6
%
4
#4H46-
6%<
"#
>
5-
4
5<T5U3-
4
'-
"#
-
4
6
>5-
-3-3"4#$-<T33$U-
<4%#-4
"4#-
4
<-
4"6-
"#>
2.2. Slums and squatter settlements:
historical and legislative background
V
@4TEFBU-4
#-
4
<6
#
!>5-8
#
-#
$
T@#4"#
U$
EM
4
6-
#
#4"--K
#
4
%
-THEU>5-$6
#4#
3-
H-
>@6
conceived to address the issue of unauthorised
#
]
--gk446
#4"---
/<%4
"
#
"^T@)7&OOF'
BU>5-
#44"-4
/
#
-
#
4
6T-
-OOE$##
-(
-
-
#$
$U
!#
-
-#
%T
%6U>5-#$
$
%6-
)
#K<
6
H-4"%
">
2.3. Main ad-hoc strategies implemented till
date70
:
6--H
4#
/
#-"#
6
--
"#4#"
<4ad hoc"'4"%
"
4
4"<
"
4
##S#
"
6--)
)"4
##S
)-
%
>5-4
##
may be initiated and funded by the central
"#-
"#
4%<
>
6"-
<
-#66-#
<-
#
-#/
-
"%-"#
#"6-
<#4
S
--<
<-<#4#-
4"<6-"--4%#>
A Draft National Slum Policy was formulated by
-
(<%
3"4#
8"<$"
$4E>@
4"
-
-4"
-#6
wherever feasible, and where this was not
%-4"44#>
-4<6
44"%<-
"#4
#4
<-
6
6--#
<#
#
-
"4-
-
6
<4
%-#T
OOU>
/<-;"#@
"
-4<-
%
#%6-
-
"-6
<]#):<
8
^OEOT%6U>
Environmental improvement of urban slums
5-#4"#-"
-H#---4"
%
"6
<
46
70
-'$TEOU
!TOOU
TOOU34TOOCU34
)`
#K<TOOU
&%TOOGOOU>
81
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
-
4%-
-
>@EB-
;"#
--"#
@#4"#
%
#-#
#
4"
%
<
#>--#6-#
#
#4-"%!"6
4
%<-%
"
-#-%
4
%<@:
66-ECO>5-EM
#
3"4#8
##T38U
#-
;"#-
#44-
#K
<>$-
<44
##
"#x-.
#K$#%K
$6
`!
T.$($`U
-OOE
-
4"#6
44"%64"<%
#>7
<-4"|
"
-%
8p6-
#
4
-
-OOV&(>
5-4
#
---)#
44
-x
#4"-"#6
6--<
%
--
)--#x-6"
-#-4
<4
-###
"-
)
6
<#46-4!]%
4%^<4>
T-4
ECF(#%
ECU-
-6"
-
-#4)
4
##>
Resettlement schemes and site-and-service
programmes – a focus on Mumbai and Delhi
$
8<&#
&-
%
T&Š&U4!
4
6
4OOF6%<
6
&Š&8<
&Š&OOB (yet to be
U>$---4-
"%
%
%<-(<&
3"4#
-#
<
44<-"
<
4
#44-H
of slum demolitions in urban areas due to the
#4#
4!4%44>
71
5-#
<%
4"
#]4"
%
"
#
K4"
%#-
#^
]
-
%
-"4#4
#4#
4^>
(-%-#
&Š&
8<(
-
-
6
-
@
#
TEBM
#ECMU
-
-
"
44<%
'-]8<
&#
&-
%
8
$%<%
8!%
K4-
(#%
(4
&-gR
Kk(#%
%
5
48!^
TEBU6--6
H
%
-
EC>
@(#%
K3--#"
#
/
#44#
%6-
/
4!4%<>@)
)"
4
##4
#-
"%
4
-
<
4"6-%
6--<
-
%-66>
-#
-
6-">&
#6--6
-
44
-
"%<-3-
-
#-
EOOEO
6-/
#>@-/
%#%
#T@&BOO
x}EMBx-EO
OOOU>("
--46
%<
#CO/>#>--#EMO
EC/>#>
"E>/>#>-EO
the 2000s, which resulted in the recreation of
")6#x
-
-
#
>-
#-##4#3-
#EOOOC
MOOO/
#6
<
71>@(#%
#
4<6
#-
'#
V-)V-#434
#(4
4
3->
82
ECO%<-R
K4
##
##
#
with-
<
4
#%K
T#-
6-
#
#U>7
<OEO-;"#3-
#4<-
#
dwellers, with a shift towards the allotment of
4>
5-#4
&Š&4
##T)
-
%
H
#%6U#
eradication has been seriously limited by the
%<
)
"
-#>34
!#
-
--44-
-"
#%#
#
6-
<#4
>
&#4
###
#44-
##-
<
>
5-
%6-6
-4"
"<
-
#4<#
6K
#
<
-<
44T3-()
-
OOCU>$
4
-
4
-
"%%<-#
#6-
-4#
"#4
"--<-
"
%
4%<4
>
In-situ rehabilitation – the example of Mumbai
@)4)
-
%
-
%
44
-##"
4<#-
<>
@(#%
)"4#
of secure tenure to rehabilitated slum dwellers
6
-4
<-EO6-
-""#4"
%
6
"<
>5-44
4"
%#)
<%-#
#-
#
<4
-
-
rest of the land thus cleared for residential or
##
"4#-4#
K
-64>$
"-
:4
@H
5
3"4#&-T53&>>H
%
4
U
4"-%)
%--4>
5-#&"4#-#6
EE#
4"
S6
"
HE
slums on land owned by institutions of the state
"#6--
#%4"
COOOOO#E/>#F#
#6><#OO
%EOOOO
-6%
4-
E#&-
%
-#
Ez-
%!"72>
#
!<6
"
4%
-#4
<
#
#S
-#
#4%
#
|4#
p>5--#6
"--
%%<
T
OOU4
#
4-
%
#
TROOCU
6
]"
#^>
2.4. The new strategy for “slum-free city
planning”
$6
<#):<8
x
-&
!"$6
`!
4
##T&$`UBG, was
OEO
4
-V&(
"-%
8%)#
-
%
8"<&
<
OEO)OOT(
-OOU>5-4
66--
"%<V&(
-@
#3"4#
8
##-
4
-4"
4
##T38
.$($`U>
5-
44
-&$`-
-
%
#
--
-
#>
72
'#
&-
%
$-<(#%
(
-
-
$
3"4#$-<>
&
!"$6
`!
>;#):<8
;"@
(<Š%
8"<$"
>
g-4'#-4
>">Š-4'!##>>!#-4
H>-#T
EO)OC)OEOUk
BG
83
]&$`-#6
-%
4
"
|#)@
p--
K-4%#
#
"#
>@
#)
4
44
-'
E> -H#6--#
<#
%-#
"
-
#
level of basic amenities as the rest of the
6S
> &-
-#
<#
-
%--
#S
G> 5
K--
%
--
K4-
--
%
4
-#H
)
%
-
"-
#4<#>^T;@OEO
'
EU
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
@4
#464
'
† 5-4
H#
6-
44<-'
4"<#"4#
-
%
4
##
%#T>>]-6--
|
<p|-
--
p--
%
--%-""4^x
@%OEO
'ŠECUS
† $4"6#
"
--%
4>
5-4
"4#
<
4%)
4"
)4
-4#%
%
->@
4###<
4
4
'
-#
-)#
K4
"4#4
]-
<%
6--""#-##<^]6-
-
#
;^T@%
OEO
'ŠECU>
5-]6
-%
4^T(
-
OOU""
##4-"
44
-
-
-4"
%-6
<
6--6%#4#%<
|p#
%64>
$--
-"
-
-#6-4
#
<"K'-%
#-<
#4
<%
K
-
6--
H4#-#
##
<"
<H-
4#-4
##6-
4
---#%<--#4
T
%"4"-#
-
6#4U>&
%<-4<
#
K#4
/
#6--##-
-!
<>
2.5. The changing role of the courts vis-à-vis
slums and squatters
@
-
4!
<<#
--
"#
<
#4
%
"
4
<
---8%@7
T8@7U
4>-EO-
4
<-
4"
"#6T$-!
EBU
4
!#-6#
-"-4
-
4%#4
--
##-
4"""
#6T;-OOCU>
<
]-4#@
-
TqU"
!#4----
-
#%----6-
<--
K6
--"->^BFT?-
>OOM'
EBU>-@
--
-
#
-6--4#--
$ETEUTU
--
$E>
&"
4
4"!#-
4#
---
"
4
#%
)4>"-
]!#-@
!
<-
"
%-"
-
BF
:
"5<3-ECES-
#-
-"
8EMS
5"#%
<(4
4
^ECTHEMU>
84
5K<"O'
@-ECO-]
5"#%
<(4
4
^
TECU#
K
#>
@K4
H6--#
-#"#
-
#4
--
-#%
"<
"T
!OOU>|
5p
6
8@7
%---4
"#6p-
4
">5-!#-4#-%
---#
4
"#6
6
--"-
4
--"
K6
-
<%64
"-
4
"#
#6>---
"-6
4#46-
--4
-4
"#
4
-
"4>5--
-
-/
p-#%#--
6-
/
4">$---4"
"%"6
#
#
<
-
-#4#
#4(#%
->
5---
-OOO>#!#4
4
<
3--
"%-44#6
/
4
-#"K"-#
#6
4K4K6-
-#
"#
-4<
%
"4#>5-#6-)
%
-4%#
-]6
^
]-4#
<#-
#%<6--##
K4
4^3-T;-
OOCU>5-"%<-!
<-
EC<
-
#-3-#4<
H>@EG
-/
#
6
4%%<
-3--
%4
%<
<#>#K<
!#-$#
8
"@
T4#OOOU
-K-
:
<
6p$
";"#53-
T3--OOU-
-%
-
4"#
"-"
#T&
#
-
OOMS34
&
#
-
OOCU>
@#
<
-"-6
444-
6
#
<44
##46-46
"#
--
4%
K-#"
-%#-H
%
-
#%6---4
-
4
]
^
3->
5-"-!
<
"#
4"%#"3-x
-
4
<
-
;"#
6
-4#>"-#
!#%<-3---6#
-4--#
4
"#6>:
-V
-
-"3-3"4#$-<
T33$U
T3--OOMU-!#
-
%#
-@
-%
--#
#4%#<6--
S-'
† -
<%
33$4"--R
4-4
-(
8
3-S
85
† -
-4
33$4#-
<<S
† -#-R6--#6#-%
#
4
->
7
%
"<
6#-]4
-%
K^!#
"
#6"%<
"%--3--:%
<EOEO-
#
-";"#3-
-#
>3#-
#
-3-;"#
-(4
4
3--
-!-6
"%
-<-
4-!-4%
-"
-
|-6
<p-%--
]!-6
%
<>
TqU5-<
-6--4-<"
-<"4
-4--
<6---
-#^>5-!#
-
-!#%<-
#4
!
"6>
-4
<-4^
%<
--#"#T?-
>OOM'
FGS&OOCU>-"6-
#
"
%----
4
44
#!#TH
EMU>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
3. Current Political and Academic
Debates – Policy and Research
Questions
3.1. Which conditions for effective housing
and slum policies?
5-
-
-4-44
"<6%#-%
<-
-
%#4#-EO>5-
-
-5-:")`
8
TOO)OOBU]
4---
F>B#
TqU4
-R
7@;^T;@OOB'GU>
5-
-6"""6
-
#
444
6
<"#--
-
-#4%#>
Which role for the market?
5-<)%
%
-4T&$`U
-
#4-
#
K-
%%<
#"<
-
T@)7&OOS(
-
"
OOM
OO
86
!#
OOCU>5-<-<
-
4%
K
4%<
4"
-
-#
<6
K<>@
contrast, other academic circles advocate an even
-#
KT$
>OEOU>
5-<
-
"#"-
#
K-#
K4
%
##
#
TU4"
4"
66
%
#6STU#"
<
STU#"
%
"
%
S
T"U-
44<-
>
-4"--<%
-#6
4"">$444
##<%#&Š&
446--
44%<#"
<
-
-(#%
%
|$
p4#
#
%
#-
#--
##<p#46###<
%)4
4%<T
OO'BU>
`6-
#-
%
4
-
"<-4"
#
%4
--#
"<--
4>
R--
#
K
6-<4"#
"
<#4"
%>("-
)"4#%
interested only in certain lucrative locations
T!#
OOCU>
5---
&
K-(-
)
(#T666>
#-#>#U
"
4
-#
rental, each with user contributions and based
%<4
<
--
-])))
##^>5-
#-
<
variety of solutions can address the diverse needs
-%
46--
--<)#
4>@-#
%<
"<
-%#%>
Slum upgrading: problem or solution?
5-
#
"#4
%##
6>##
-%
-
%
"4%<-
%
4
-%
444
-"-
">5-4%4<
-6K#4"--
-
%
#
-4
%-#>5-"##
%<-%
4-6
T
#-@"$-#
%
OEO
HEBU>
`-#
<-#
44
--
#4#
K#
4#
-<
4'-
44
-
<%
-
%6-4%#
-T36
.#
OOS34
&
#
-
OOU>
#-
"4
6--4
4
<>5-H#-
H
-4
H
-4
>5-)
-"#
-K-R-
)
H--4
##
%
-4
#S
4
in situ6<#
K
4#
-4%#6--
4
H4
-<>@
-"6-4%#-4
-
>5-6-
-
#
4%
6
#"-
6
-
6%
#
<
4
S
#"644
-H#<
/
%<-%
4>
5-"
#
----
#4H<#)
6--/
6--
)#>
3.2. Cumulative impoverishment generated
by forced evictions
5-"75-
#4
<
-#
4<
&Š&4
##
/-
4<
#
K#>5-
K
tenure in most slums or, in other words, the
H#-]
^<
K
"
/
#
homelessness, urban nomadism and further
#4"-#>5-#"
%
-
#6-
&Š&
4
##>R---"
4
"
##4"-#
#
<#%!<-
--
4
<-#
>5-6
<<4
T-#
4
%<
<-4)H
#4U
-<4
-T
#U
-#4#
4
%>@
---
#
%"#
<
#
"--
-
-
4"
'4"
resettlement and rehabilitation entitlement, loss
-
"-%
!%-
#>$-!4
75
:6-
p-#
-
44
-"
]-#"
"
###)
#--#
-%-
-6<<
%
%-
^T&);EM'
@U>
87
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
---<
--"6-
<>:#
/
-)
-
%
4
#%#)
<)6>
88
`#
#6-]%^#
resettlement scheme also suffer from the loss
of livelihoods in relocated sites, usually situated
-<K>(
<
-44
4<#
#
/
%
"
4-#
#
#
<
K"
<
%4
4
>@#4"-#%
-
#%
-
K
access to basic urban services and social facilities
--
-
/
->5--6-
4
--4%
-p
6
-#>$
-
4
-
#
H4
T<
6
%U!%
K
6-H4
>/<
--#
4
###
<---
4
"--
-
-<--#
)
44>5-
#
44
--
-
6-
-
K
)#
"-
#
>
"<
H46"
affect all households in demolished slums,
4"6---<
#4
##>@
H
#-
#
%</
"
4
%<"-4
"#T%
-
K#
UH4-#"-K
-">&4
#
<4#4
#
#
4
4
that reveals the inability of evicted families to
rebuild their lives over time and recover from the
-K#T34OEOU>
5-4
<
%" /-
]
#^#
/
#%<
"#
-'
-
"4
<-
-/
6---
#-
4H‡$--4
may mention inclusiveness in their objectives,
-<
6#H--
-#-
#>H#-
##
#-"<#&Š&
4
##%
4
<-
%<
'-
44
])
^
"
-#S
-
%/#-->
5-#&Š&
%
%4-
--%
4><
-
-%<-H
mechanisms, which stem from the conditions
6---4
##
#4#,
-H
#%%
#
6T34OEOU>5-H
##&Š&-#
##4-#>@-4
-
%
#/
>
5-/
#6-
/
-
%
-
4
-H4
H#>5--
4
-
%/##@
>:
#
%%
4"<
4
##
#
4#
#%
4-
-<#4#
-4"<-#"%%
4
>
@
-<-#4"--
#%
#)66-
H#&Š&
4
##>5-/-
-4%4
--
#4#
>
@-H@
-]#)<^
H4
44'-4--4#%
"x4
<-xS#
66--"K
-
#6-44-
%
S
the real estate lobby and builders, there is an
H4
-
-
##
6%4
%<4"
-
6-
H
S
-%
#)
]#)<^#
--#
-6
#
%"
<>:-#
-6]#^]
%
-4-<
4%#4
/
<-6---
-
44"-^T;%OOB'MBU
%/<"-
K
64
#">
"##T@)
7&OEEU
)%
<
6T-
-
#%
<8"$EU6
-#44|
p
-<#--%-
event, which entailed arrests, detention in
]%
-#^#
!
4
-<x-
access to the city for the homeless, which was
denounced by national as well as international
;
-#
-
T
OEOS@)7&OEOS$#<
InternationalBMU>
3.3. Identification of “worst” practices
&444
%<-
7
&-6KT-4'666>-)
4>U-
#
&-##-
:#&-@
84p
5%
"#
#
&-
T666>4
>U-&-
"T666>->U4"#
%
--64
"""
-#
-%<-
@
-H##
"4-
#
-44
"
6>-"
]
!--#
-
/
-%
--#
-"--
-
6
--
"6-<^-
%#-6
6#
-T?-
>OOM'BU>
5##
-
p64
4
#6-
<
"
44"6-4
#
6-#"-
44
"-%%-
houses are destroyed, and above all with the
"
#>
5-
"
-6
%#46-#-H
-OEO##6
-;
#3-'
4. Initiatives Aiming at a Better
Inclusion of Slum Dwellers in the City
"<
TU-
"%
"--#6
--#
K-"-
-4-##4"-"
&#
&-
%
T&Š&U
4
##6--6"#H6-
">-
"-
"
##-
4#-
6
#-"#>
4.1. Human rights and housing rights
movements
#
x-
%
@
x
7
&-6K-
:#
&-x
-
--
4
"
<
-4
#-#
->5-<-
-#
-
#6K-
6#-
@
T
%"U
#-
-#
-%#
-
@
-
4
<-@
"
#
&-
-
%
-##4-"6
<
--
/
-
H4<
4-4
">
BM
]@
#
"
--#
-
%3--##6
-;
#^$#<@
)
#FEOOEOT$@H'$$OOOEOU7>
89
-
]de jure
instruments has not substantively translated
#4"-
"
/-4
"^-<
further denounce “the vast schism between
H
#
-
<
-@
<^T?-
OOG'MU>@-6-
"
#
K#
-
>>
#-#
%
"->
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
5-$
&-
6K
;-
4
<
--
ECO>8###<))##<
H-
4
4H4
K66-
---6K
-
-'
]#
"
4
6)#6#TqU##<)"
enumeration of local residents, surveys and
#
44##-
#
#
-
-
4-#"##<
#
K
6-#4
"#
-
>5-
"6%##<)
%
-%
4>Tq>U>
@"
"
-
#
"TqU
64
<^T8
>OOE'FBŠMU>
5-@
$
;-<-
8#$
&T8$&U
6
-
#
36:
T3:U
(
-
(
T
6K
"p"
#%<6#
4
"#6U77, was
4
<
"-6K
-
%"
-
"%#4#(#%
#4
-@
TH
ECŠOU>5-#"#
%<
>5-|$
p also
"%<-
#6--
77
-!
Urbanization
and EnvironmentT
OOS8
>OOE
OOOOS$4-
#
8
OEOU>
4.2. Civil society organizations’ mobilisation
#
"
#
#
4
<
4"
4
44
%<
4
#"-4
4
>5-4%-
-
%
"-4
#
$-#
%
-
#THEBU>5-
<4
4
%<
##
/
#
4%#
)--%
K-#/
46-
4-
6
#4
T-
3--
#4
-&-7"6-3<
-%<3-
-
#K
-
-
-V
)]4"
#4
^
(#%
-];-
%
-
-
%
$
^x|
"-#%-#p
#"#U
6--
#46#
4
<%
#
44>
@(#%
--3-
"
&"4#8
OOF
4%)
4"
4
-4
44
#"#'
]
"#3-
"pp
##<)%
-"<4-
"-
-
-
#
<
>5--
%
#x
-
4
H4##6-"<
4
%<--
S
4
-
#4-"
household survey, and discussions about
#
##<)"
4
^T$4-
#8
OEO'OEU>
p#%
-<-H#4
"
#
-##<
4
4
-H4
-4
:-#
%-]$
^T
-U'-4'666>4
>
90
"4-OOO%6-
"#;
-4"
#&Š&4
##>5-;-
<
#4
<#4
"#
4
-<4"%
#
-4
#6-
#
%#
""
"4&Š&-#THEC
ŠEU>
#K< ##-
H4
#<x
]-#4
6)#--
-##%
-<-
"%%
%
-"4#-
#
T
U
-
"
#
!
#-
-
#">76)##
4
"##<
-
#4
##
-
4
%-##%S-
#
K-
4"
#
everyone affected by the resettlement, and
that can oversee the move and be there to
46--6---<
#"^T8
Š
>OO'EBOU>
5-;
-#6
-
-&Š&4"
-"
(#%
6-4)4
"
-
#
-
TH
EU%-
#4
p>$
#6
%
#x
#4
H
#4-
3-4
x
6--
K-4%
6
4"
-%
-T34Š
)`
#K<
OOS?#
OOCU>5-
----
"<%
H>
#H4#%
--
#
%6
);"#
T;U
##<)
TU6-
#
-
4
-46--
Box 17. Public hearing on habitat and livelihood displacement in Ahmedabad
$#
#]@"$-#
%
^6
4%<$-#
%
>@
##%-###
"p4"
6K6-
-%
4--;-#
-
"
#%444
6<>5-:#
4%-
3#%EthOO%-
-"
%
"4#
4
#
H4%<-4-<
$-#
%
"%
"4#-
6
-"
"--4>-
4%-
!<
4#-<"-44
%<4
#
-
6--#
K
#4-""6
<>$%MOO444
4
-
4%-
6--"#4
"6
">
5-6
--<"
"4--<-
6
-
>5-466#'--
-"#-4
#S
-""4
%<4
<"
44-4%
K
-4-<p"4#4!>
5-!<p""
-"
6--%<-H
$-#
%
<
%
4<##
>
Sources:@"$-#
%
TOEOUg&7'-4'666>44>
>6
#8%)
)&4)OEO>4k
91
Box 18. Displacement from the railway tracks in Mumbai: an example of people managed
resettlement
5-#4"#(#%
p
4#4-(#%
%
5
4
8!6-
#-R
K6--(#%
(4
&
3"4#$-<T((&3$U
-4!#4#
<>5-4!
-
4
#6)#/
#
-
6
<
K>5-((&3$
-;8$&
$
4
-&
6
<#36:
T&3:U#-&Š&-#>
5-4
#MOOOO446
6-%6$4OOO
VOOE
##
-%%<-(#%
$
3"4#$-<>5-#
#8$&
&3:#%#
6
6
<
-ECO
446#4
"4
-4"%
/K<#
-#4>5-
#4
##6
-4%<"##<
#
-44
%
"6#p4
4
>5-##<""#
'44
-%
#"<--%#"T
-)-#
44#%
"<
--"<
#
4U-
##
6---<#"
#
-
4-
-6-
4
-4
-->@-#
6
"##--6-
6
>
@#4
<-R
Kp
&Š&4<#4-
6
<
-
%%<-
%
-
-<#-<#>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Sources'8
p>
TOOUS
!TOEOU>
92
-
-
]
^x
4
"
%<-$
>6"]-
4
4
<
44
-
H
K
K
%"4
<
-44
6-
"^T
!OEOU>@
-
#;p"-
K%--"
""#&Š&4
6"T36
.#
OOU>
;#
<
K-
<-
K-
4%
-#>5-6
%<-R
K@48
TOOU
-#4#
-
##4-(#%
%
5
48!>:-#-
%<
x-)
-
H
#
<6#-&Š&4
##x
#
)
"-
H4##%<
;
>RK6--
4<
#6K"<
p
""#&#
&-
%
4
##
-"
<"
4
>
5--
4#-
"
4
"6-
4
--
"
#4
6-
-
##-
#
#4
K
K<
6Kx
%<-">
4.3. Initiatives by “social enterprises”
@-]
4^#
"
#
4"
%
-4-
]()#
^6--"
4#
Box 19. The Chandivali resettlement project in Mumbai
5-
H
#4
#4(#%
#%<
;"
KK
K-
#TU-H-"#6#
!
<;
-
8
KT;8U6
-#%
<-(
<EB
8@7>-
-
4
#
#(#%8
#-
44
--
;"#(
-
-
-(
">#
<
4"
%T##4
U44
4
#4!-
%%-
"
EOK#--;8>5-C
4
-<%
6
-
#
4"
/
<#4
<
-
<
""
"4#4
>
5-(%---
###
6-
4-OOO
E/>#6--EOBO6%-8
Kp#
6>
-"4
-4!p
->5-44
6
4%<--OOO>5-
#-##4H
-
T-
"
-Up"
-"#-#6
<
!
>
5--4!6
---
#53&-%%
-
#>5-""#-;-4!6
#4
-
"<4-4#-
-"<%
#
-
6%4
-#S
<
-
"4-4!>5-#
-#6p%<#
%<K4
6--6
-;p4">@
--#&-
%
$-<T&$U6
#
6
%<>
5-
--
(#%
-
-
#6--
/
#4!-<>5--#4H
OO>5-/
<-%K
-4"
#4
%<6
---
-
/%<-&$>6"OOB
#
%6
-4"
%6-4
%
<"---/
<
#-
%
4!
<
446
->%/<-4
6
%<#
-
#4
-OOO
"
4
>
5-H4----#4
;""#%
4
%
%44
"#4!%-
4
#6x6-
-"#
-
>
-6-#
-;p464#
#4"-#
-"
-4"
%-
#6K4%)4"
4
-4-#-
&$>
Source'.
/TOEOU>
93
Box 20. Experiences with surveying and mapping Pune and Sangli slums on a geographical
information system (GIS)
5-;-$
-
T]%-^U
6#
##66K-#
---##
8
T(
-
-
U
#
4-
6-
"4"
-#p46--<>5-4#
#%4#4
-p"4#4
%<
;@>5-4"
#4
#
%
#4"
"6-#
#<)6
4
>
5-
H4-#
%<-6
"#-
#
>@8-#4!6
%
#-
#4
%6
#
#
<
%
-(4
4
44>@
-#4
4
4
-"<
-""#-
"#4"%
K<
--H4>
5--6-
-""#
-4
x-##;
"#x
-###
#%
4
"4#>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Source:V-
%TOOU>
T666>#-#>#U>"K
]
4%<^-
7
;4-
-6#
]4!
%444
--/
<-
%
^
"
%<
<<4%<-;4x
$
%-@
'
#
T
&4
%OEOU>`-
"
-6
-4
#
K>5-<6""
#
-
4<
S-
%-#
%
-4
6644>
4.4. Monitoring by funding agencies
5-
T-
-
R
K
-$
3"4#
KU
-
&Š&4@
-
<"
/
-
%
-
44
>:
H
#4-4
3"F>GO-
94
R
KTEOU4
-6
'"
<4
#-%
"##S6-
"
%
#4
-%-
4!S##<4
4
4
#4##-
%
S
-
-#4
-%4"-
44
>
@EG
44
6
4#-
#
%<
K4
6-44<
4S"/-
44>@-(#%
%
5
48!
#4#%<-((&3$-
K4
%
-44
4
4"
#4
-
K%<
4!)
44
>5-8
-
#-#4
6!TR
K@48
OOU>5-4
"-R
K
-@4
8
4"
##
%
#-
#4#
#4
-
#4-4!)
44p
6
"
#-
#
6
6>3
-
-
K)
4!
4"#
-
44-
-%
4
%<-
K
""">5-
#
<
4
<
#
#
the inhabitants of a same city, as in the case of
(#%
TR
K@48
OOU>
4.5. Government initiatives
)"
#
<%
4#
4#%
#
%
4
<--->:
the recently established Delhi Urban Shelter
@#4"#
V<OEO
-;"#-53-
46%T-4'-->>
U
#
4#-#
4#4
>`-
#
4
<
#%-#%
4!
4
<%-#4#
>5-
-(#%
(&
8!x4-
@@
#
6
-
"-&-
@#
6
6--
#
-
]-
#
6%
-
-
<-
^>78
5-]8H4
&7
^
T8$&7UV&(
"#>
@4
"]44
"<4
"#4#
4!
#^TqU]@-
V&(
6K
#
-#"
-
H4-"<#
-^T666>
%
4
>U>5-
")#
]%
4
^---4
%
6
&Š&>6-
4
]%4
^#-4"6-
78
%
-
#4#
#
<%4"-
#6
<%<-
K-4
<-4!
4>:
-
%
#
&":
3"4#8!$-#
%
T
-
OOFU#-4
%
4
%
6
6--
#
4%-
THEBU-
OO"4#4
#
"
#
<
6
"
>$
46
##4-"
K6-8$&7
"%
#4"%<44
4
"66%>
5. Barriers to Achieve a Better
Inclusion of Slum & Pavement
Dwellers
3<4%
#
%
'
5-#
S#
-%46
4%
%6-
"#
-
"#>5-
-
#
%
"4#
-%]-"-H
%<-
"#
"#4#
-H
4--
-
^T@)7&OO'US
-
-###
-@
#-
of international conventions and covenants are
4>
%
4"%"<'
4!
H<4
44#
"<
#6
/
-
#
-
44
6T34
&
#
-
OOCS
?-
>OOMU>-44-
%<-4#4
%
-
#4
"
]@
'#368
<(#%
(8-
@@^EG(
<OO-4'666>
6>
E>-#
95
T
"K
OOGU
-4#
>5-<
4"
-%
"
'
-#6
4"
-<6%
"4-%4%
4>
5-
K
4
K6
about slum dwellers, and even more about
4
"#6
-44
%--
4!
%
44
---
-
%
-p4<%>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
@-4
-<-
%6
K-
"
#-
-44
#
4
"#
6>5-
K#46#
#%
4--
6-
4
-
-
%#
4
"#6
-%
4
4>
"
-4
##%
4"<
"
-
"%
<
T;@)8
##OOS(
-OO'
)GOU>5-<'/-
-
#
K)4
#4-4
##
6--6"
<<#
"
S
-
44"#4
6
6-
-%
4
-#S
K
4
<%
#-
##4
%S
<
#
##4"#4
##
-
K
of a coordination mechanism between local urban
%
6-
"
%<4"
]4
-4-64
4^>
5-
%
-
4#&Š&
4
##
--##
R
7@;%<--#4S
<
-4%#4
-#4#
-4
##>5#
H#
<-
K
###
-
%4
6>
79
6. Policy Recommendations79
† #4-%%
44
-4
%
#
6
-
6
-K%6-
"4##
#
-
K
%
/
--
6#4>5-"
%6--
%
-%
4
-
access to their means of livelihood should also
%
K
>5-&Š&
4
##
-4
should be articulated to facilitate the access
#4<#44%
"
#>/<-
-
%
-%
4-%6
6-
%
4%
4<#>
† 5-%
4"<
"
4
##-%
>8<
-%"
-
44<-%
44%
--#>5--%44%<
#-
#4"-
4%<--
#4-
#
4
>7
"
%
K-
-%
46%
<>5-
#
K
-
-
-44<
4%
6
4"
<-
4!R
7@;-%#
4%#-
&$`4
##>
† 4-#4
4#-))
#
-
#
<
-#6-4>5-<-
K
-
>5
-4
##
--#
/
--%
4
-6#
->6"--
%
5-#-4<##
#
%<-#
-#"#T-
@)7&U
"
<
T-
@"$-#
%
U>
96
#<#
"-
#4"-#>@
%
%
4"<
"
46--#
--4%#
#4
%-
%
-K
>
† $---"<-
%
#
-4-
be based on the notion of universal entitlement
-4>5-<
-%4"
#6
4"-
"
-<>
† 4
])
^
"
-
#
%<&Š&
4
##-%#
>5-
based on any substantial rationale and creates
-4p##
-->(")
can sanction the demolition of houses thereby
-#
<"
%%
-H
#4"-#>
† (
4
<
%<
<4
4
<4
"<46-
"
K--%#%
%
4
-#4#
%
4!>@-
4!
4
#
]"#4
#^
-%
K6--
"#
##4
%
<"
>
† R-4
#
"
%-
"##
%-
444
4
6-
international law and international human
-
>
† #
-
"
")-6
4
4<#
K
64
4
%
%)-
4!")„)"-%
4
#6-4
-4
4
4
4#-#
->
K-#%
<
8"$E
-
6-%
%-
-<"<#
-4
-
-#
-#>5
-4
--
4
<#
6)-
%
6--
>
† &4%'--
/
-<
#
4%4%
-
4%<
-
-"<>5-
%-
K%<K
6-
<
-#
-
#6K-
>
97
Urban Livelihoods:
the City versus the Informal
Economy
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Sharit Bhowmik, Marie-Hélène Zérah and Basudeb Chaudhuri
In the last two decades Indian cities have
6
-
6-
)
--
6
-
<
64
%
6
4!>5-
4#
H4
%#
K
4"
-4"<
/
-4#"
6->
#4<#
%#
/
#
K
<K
-6-
#
#4
-/
<
-
/
<#4<#>
5----#
#<
6#
>:<OOBz
-
#%6K%
6
<-
"-#
T
U80><-6%
4<#p-<T
U
80
6
-#
#<4<-
%
"-
/<--
-<
-%
44
>
1. The Facts
5-
@
p!%6-
44<-%
#<>5-
#4<#6-
6-#
-OOO
44
<
"
-!%6--
-
-4)
%
4%-
-6
-4"6--
#
-TOEEU#-6<
!%6#6-
!%
>#4<#
K
!%
"
%
%#
K>
("-
%6
#
-#<
R-
%<#
6K
66-
6K"%<-
TOOB'FU']
6K-6K-
--H
6K6-
<%4"%<-#4<
-6K-#
6-
<#4<#
<
%4"%<-#4<>^
98
and a constant reduction in the number of
6K>5-
##
4-
TU
6
4OOF%<-;"#@
H
#-4%#
%<-
sector, which has indeed absorbed most of the
#4<#6-><-
K
%4
4
<-
--%%6-
#%
6KT
U
-
)#4<6KT-U
4
4#
-#
>
$
#%#
<
%
#
#
#
)#4<6K6--%
!%
<TOOB'FU>
-
<-
#
-TOEEU
-6-
E>M#%
#
-#
E)OOO
6K
-#
OOF)OO>@#
6H4
-
-4
>
$K
4
4"
"4
6K
6-H)
6)4
#6
6K>#481
<6K4"
%
--#4-44
-
--
6K-4
"
%4TOzU---
-
-
)#4<6KTBF>BzU
6KTOOB'CU>@#
6
@
6K
-
times more than casual labourers and these
/
"
<
#
T%
#
-
6K
6K
6
----
F>M
-6
?
E>U-%<
-
4-
46
-4
-
-<
4
<
-
%
%#
K>
:
<-
"<-#
6--#4"
44
6-6#>5-
%64"<
#
6K
-#46--
"
such as the level of education, which is critical
%!%44>5-
44
-
(#
5#4<-#
T
OOB'U>R#T
4
<-U
<#4<4)
6K
#6K6--
"-#"<
4#
>5-
K!%
444
-6
#
#
!%6#
T-
K-
OEEU>5--"
%<
KH4%<#
6K
%-##
<>
2. The Legal and Policy Framework
5-
-4#4
-
#6K>5----6K
#
-
ETEUTU
-
-
-]4
<4
<
<4
%^>7
%
the concurrent list and both central and state
"#
4
>
5-
4-
682
%
T4
<
6U%"<6-#
"6K"
<>5-
6
6--
6K
#4
<'TU-
-4%6#4<
#4<CG,
TU6
#
CF
TU
<%85>#
4
<
"
-%
-
-
-RK$EM
-<4
3#RK$
OOC>6"-
6
#4#
%
%%
#4<
6
81
5-
644"##
%--
4
%
")
#4H44
4
4
<>
82
5-"-H-
"
-
%<
>
CG
5-7
%<#T$%U$EBMS5--7
%T8-%
&
U$ECMS5-:
$EFCS
5-@
(
RK#$EBS5-
7
%$EBOS5-5
$EM>
CF
5-(##R
$EFCS5-8
<#R
$EGMS5-/
&#
$EBM>
85
5-8:$ES5-RK##4
$EG
#4<
@
$EFC>
99
"<-
4
4
%
4
<4"
THE
H
#4U>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
7
6
4
-4#
#4<#
K>5-(#
(#4T((U3"4#$
OOM
#
-
-#4"
##
##46--
-
"6
4<
%Fz-
#
4
FOz-
H4>5-K3"4#(
-#%K6K>
5-
#4
4-
%
"--
4
#%
%--
<T#
)%U
<T
"U
4
#-"%
#
%
"-
"
6--
4%
44
THU>
@-H-/
%
&-RK-
%
<
and a series of consultations were held by the
UNDP and Government of India in 2005, which
concluded that there was a need to focus on the
]&-RK^
%
H>5-
4-
##4
-
TU%<-
;"#@
-
-
RK
<$TOOCU6--
-%
H>@-
--
%
#
4<
-
6"
4
#
<T-
-%
%<"
6
#
<
"U-
6K-
6-#4<#
4"<
-
/
4>
%<#
#
#
K
44%<-
#"
6
"
-)%
44
->
@--4
%"
6
-4"
<
%K-#
K
#
"-4"4%
100
-%-4<
#
-
#-
#T
$#
<
-
#
<
U>
%
-
-T%
U6
#-
"
4
%6
-
%44
/
#%<>
:
<
-/%
"-
-#4
#
4
"4#
%
%<)
6
-
#%-
<-
<>5-
#4%<
#<#
4
T
"#3-
6--(
8
-
-
6U
#4<-
#
<#
#
"
-<
#-(
8
>#
<-
44
%
%<)
64"-<
##
%
>5-
-#
6--%
"
"
-44-<6--
%<)
6
44<%#4
6-
-
-
4
##
%
4>@##
<
<-
4
)4%
6--4
#
"->
3. Policy and Academic Debates
3.1. Livelihoods, employment conditions and
social protection
Since the informal sector has absorbed most of
-6#4<#6-H4
!%44
#4"%
"-
>@%--
(#
(#4T((U
)#4<
6K
44
constraints limit their ability to create solid
>&
#4
#%#
#)#%
44
H4
<#%
>6"-H
#
<
#6K-
%"<
effective either because it is not feasible or it
%#"T--
#
%%U>5-
K"
4
<H4
-
46--
and its ability to create jobs, which relates to
%
-
/
%
6--"%
<-
###
T
4U>6"4
4<
-%
-
"
"
"
T-
-4
#
U
4"
-
#
#
K
%<K>
:-#%
#
#
#6-
6--H4-#--
of demolition, or where institutional tertiary
>$6)
K6H
#4-
3-
"-
-
-#
-"4)
--
4
#)
-%-
-
-
"
%
K
6<
4%
<-
;38(#%
>5-
%
6-4-
-#
-
K
4
4#
-
%
%
K
#4%>5
##
#43TECU
-#4
4"
6-4
-%
4"
>5-
44
-
<
-@
H%
%<-
6#
K
forces that would evict these clusters (see
!
#
&
#
-"#U>
$K<"
-4
!%
44
#4"
-"K
4
<
"46
6
/
%6K
K
6KCMT$6
-?
-<
4
`
KOOU>
$---%<--4
6K
-%#-6K
-
-<-
-
"#-
6"
>TOOU
-
"6-
6K
%
4#
-
%<"
4
6
K
#4
"<%-#4<
%<
46
#%<>5-#-6--
-
K6K
#<--#
6K
-
K
"
@5@T@
5
@U-
-"#
4-
K>@#4"K
T---#4#
-K
3"4#(-4
4"
<"
4%)
4"
4
-4>U
6-
4#
<
-
%<
6K%
#6!%44>@-##
-6%
46
#4"
-%
466K%
%
6
6K-
%
#
K>
@-/6
#
#4
#/
-
"
%
@
>R
/
-
4
4)
4
->
&
TOEE'
FU-6-
FO>CzT4"<GCz
#
FO>Cz6#U%
6K
4
%6-
###
6
>$%
H%6-6-
-
44
###6
-
44
-H
#6K
T
&
OEEU
-6-
6
<#
-
<
-
%#
K
4%
4
##
/
<
#
K""
<
4
%<4>:-#6--
6#%
#-
6
-
4
#,#
<
6--
-#4
%%<
%
64-
--KT-OOU>$
CM
5---"
%
%
">
101
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
H
#4-;"#
<
p
-K%<6K
-
(
<(
T3-(4
&U-
"-
6Kp-
%
4<-
%
#4
#<>
5--
-
-4%#
<-#
%-
4
%<4"
T
-
K#4<#6
6
as other factors such as health and education
"U
-
%
<>(
-
6K
4
#
6K%
K-4
-
;TOOU-
"-6K-
6
#
K3->@-%
H-
-4%6#4<)#4<T
6
<H4
"U
#4H
%
4"
<-#"
%
4>R<<
4
-#
4!%
-
4-
<<#>5%
-4
<<#
-#
4
K
#4-""6
#
]
insecurities related to the failure to meet basic
economic and social needs as well as those related
-
-6^T)@&
OEO'U>@----#4
#-
#46---K
and vulnerability87>
3.2. The relationships between the city and
the informal economy
(
<
"-%
#
#<
6K-4
-44
##
>
5-<
K4
--
4
"#
-#
4
-
#
K>
:
z#6K
z6K-64
-6
EGz6K-6
6>RK#-#-
Fz
-6#
-#
>
--EO
H4
%<
(-
T-"#U4#4
#-4<
"<
6
--6K
4%
4%4
>5-EO-
"
-
-4%6-<
-#
#<>5-
4
-
#
T3(OOS
#
OOGU-
"4
#
#%4"<6K>5-
4
#
<
%
#
]6
^
%-4>5-%
6K
4
<4"
6-
-<#
>`
-6K#
K
#
!%
-<p#%<T"<K-
6
K-
6
"
H"U#<
T-#)%
"#
#
4U
#
6%"#T6KU
<"<T-
U>
$%"
-
KK6
4
-6
T
44U%6
the formal and the informal economy that
-
-%
#<>$
/4
-T6--
-
<
"U
%
6--
-#
#<<4
>$
(K-4
-<
<TOEEU-<
-<
the informal economy as dysfunctional while on
87
&-#4
<
/
4<#-
<#-H"
TU<
4$4OO]-
8:@
"^T8:@U
K<44
6--%
>$)
<
"-8:@4
"
-
"<6--!<-
--#%-#
-
>@%!"
4#
44TU-#4#
%
-
K4
-4
"
%
4"####<
-
-
TU-
"
%<
"-
-
-
/
6
>
102
Box 21. Struggles for implementation of better working conditions: the case of construction
and domestic workers
4#
-6K4
6
%
#4#
/
6
#
<%
+->
%
-
"#%
<z-
46--%
>6"%#-
-6K#
%#
##%-%
>(6K
6
-H-%
-<K66-
>5---4%<-
%4
#
6K---
<>@
-46K>56-
-
"%#4
6K
<4<)#
K
#4"6K>
5-RK:
@
886
EC
4--
#4#
#%--
-
-RK
$EM-@)
(
$EB-4"-
6K
6#p--
/
6
44
-(
<7
6
EE
-"<466>
@(
-OEE-4#
#%
44<-
-
RK$
/"#
44
<-
#4#
-$-#
>5-6
4
8@7%<-
#4
##7
%>
5-#4<R#p$
TR$U89-#
"
-6Kp--#
#<
4
-
#
6K90>@3-%
--
#4
6K
#6K6--%
>R$-
6
-#6#
#
#4<#>
#
#-
3#RKp("#-
6K6-#
6KT-
#
U>5-
#"#--#4#
H
6-)#4#
6
4
<
"-
%
<p
>5<4
<-#"#
#-
]"
^
]#
^6--#4<
<
4--
#6K-
%
6T6--
44<U
-
6K-
%>
$#H
"-
-@
-
%H#6K
--&
-<
6
-<
#
`!
44"
#-
%V
OEE>@6"
FB>O
K-#6K>5-
<:
RK6-#4"-
-
"4&>GOOOOTMMM>MM
}U--
-#
>6"K<-
-
"
6%
-OE>
88
-4'666>6>
666>6
>
90
-4'666>#6K->
89
103
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
-
<6K
"
-<>
If there was no demand for what the informal
#<4"#4
"6#4<
44
>
TOO'OU-6-6-<
3"4#8
$-#
%
-
4
%4
-K%
6K6-4
"4"
H#p
S-
"
-
-EFE
H#
KS-
<4"
4"%
#6-
Ez-6K6#4
4<>5-%
#
<-
@
>5-H
#4-3-
"
&"4#8
#
#
<
-%-<#%
-
4
#<#4H--
4"#4
>@
-
%<#
K
4-
##
-
4
<@
4"
6--
<
%#
6K>(
4<-%6-
-
<
-%
#
#<
K
"
-
4>
:-4%4
%-
4
--
#4
"
->34-"-
#
<4#
%
%-4
-H
%
----
%
4-
"%<"
-6--
446
T$!
OOMU>$-6#KTOEOU-6
#%
6-
#4"K
-
"4"
<"#
--
4
<4
T%%4#<U
"4
#
4
-<#>`
authorities remain very reluctant to include these
"-4
H>
5--
--
-
$-
8
--
"
4"
4
">
104
Box 22. Urban Street Vending Bill
5-<
8<
%
.TOOU
-
"-
%4"
@
####
>@-
-%<-
4#---
6K
-
"4"
####44
-
%
4T-6#KOEOU>6"-
44
-
#%
of recommendations that were framed by
-
8<%
.T-
4
<K
-"64
#"#K
-
$
.
@
THGUU>5--
4
%64<#
K
6
#
4-
%<-4#
%OEO--%
"
-
#4"#
-
-
4>
5-4
OO"#-
8<
OOF
#%4-
'
† -4"
#
K
T%<-OOUS
† -4<H"
%66--
-
#
4
%
)
4
#
S
† "
#
-
8<6--4
#"--
-
%
<
-
""S
† -4
""'
-<
#
4z-
%
44
-H4
"-
%##
6-
-44>
'-6#KOEO>
@-%
6
)--4
"#
allotted to street vendors and harassment by city
--
44
#"T-6#KOEOU>5-
%
.
6KT&
&
U<7
6OEO--
-
6
--
8<
-$-
8
-.pT8
7"-
&
.U
OEO4"-%<
-
"
%
-
"%
-
>
5-4"44--
"
6-
-
3-(#%
?K
6-"
"4%
-
6K
and reluctance by the city authorities to allow
-
6K-
"%->R
(
-
-
-
""<"
44
-6
">:
-(
-
-
;"#-
4
6
OEO-
-
#4
">@4"<-
"6--
"4E<
#-
>(""4
6-
-)-
6K
6%&>OOO
!
#H
#->
-4%
(slum eviction, rehabilitation schemes and
U
-#4#
4!
#"
4
##
>--
#
<#
"
#><
4"-
4-<
#4<##
#
-#)%
6K4
<6#>
In the worst cases, slum eviction without notice
<%--
"
-
%
-K--#%
6K#-6K
6K
T34-"#U>@-
Box 23. The National Alliance of Street
Vendors of India91
5-$.@
6KEC
#
OOG>
@4-#
-
-#
"4<
">@
<5
##<
;"#
4
##-
"p-
6
>5-6K
44
%--
%
K6
-
#4#4"-
"->$.@
"<
"
"
4
4
"
#
K
#
%4
>@
6
-
situations which threaten the livelihood of
">8<$.@-
F
##%#GBG
4
6K
"
>
rehabilitation, more often than not, rehabilitation
#%-
<4"4
44
6K-%<
-"
%<
#6>5-
"
-
44-
#
--
%
4
K
K
of arrival in the residential location, or for women
6-
#4<
#6K
-
"
"#-
--4
6K
<-
44-<>
@
6-
"
%-
-H#(#%
--
-6K
#--
"%#
"
H<
4
##4HT$
K
8-
KOOU>$-
##
#%
91
666>
">
105
informal economic clusters are under threat
-%
4!4#
4
<"#
>5--
6--
(
<#
K6-
-
#%4
T;OOU
-
#
4
-
%
K-(-"(#%
6--%
6
4-OO
>@#4
--
#
--
"#
%/
46
-4%6
actors92>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
5--4
%<
-
-44-%
4
-
#
#<-
#
""
4
4
-<%<"<6-
-"6K
#-<
-
>5-
-
##6
-;
#3-
)
"
#
"%
-"
--
6K6-
<
#
THFU>5-
4
%
%#
#-"
%
46--
4%#-#
-<
#
#
6
%
<
>5-'-#4
<
S-
)-#
/<]
^#S
-
#
>5-#
p#4
<
4
-##-%"
4
-4%%
<#T83U
-%-
44
##>5-
6##
"#4
%
-<
"66
-
#T
"
/
4
</
6KU>7
%#
4-
<
)
<
#
#
<
->As
--<
and are often considered as a burden on the
resources of the city by the #
K
#-%
>@-#
-6
<
]<6-#^
%"--
-
"%
-4
#4
<->
Box 24. Violation of workers’ rights at the Commonwealth Games construction sites in Delhi
and civil society organizations’ campaign
$-#-EC$
;
#3-T-$
U-46K
"
%<
%
8%@7
T8@7U-4#
>5-!#
-
-
%<#4<"
4"-
7
%7
6
#-"
-6Kp
#
-
@
$EFE
G->@OOB-H-
44
-OEO##6
-;
#TR;U-
6
]&--R$
p
C^
"
-
##6
-;
#p
"RKR#
-TR;)RU
-6K
"
-EOOOOOH4K6K#<#
-
4
<>
5-
%!"-
#4
'
† 6
-
#-
4%#4
-
;"#
-6K-#"S
† 8--#4#
-
-RK$EMS
92
5<4
<-#
--(-"-(#%
(4
&
3"4#$-<
-
6-">
106
† 8
6-#4##
K
-
6
->
K'
† $"
<-
6K6--6K6
%
-
6Kp
-%#-R
:S
† 4+--S
† @#
#4
T--6%6
)-4)
-#
US
† $4%-
6Kp3-
%EGOOS
† $<-
<
<6K
#
!R;
"
4!3->
6"
-"#
-#4"#-6Kp4"%#
'
† <OEO
%MOOO6K6--6K6
%
<
BBB6--6|
"p
>
† 5-R
:
&>FEOT3E>EE#U4#%OEO-
K-
%4
#<%<"#
-3-(&
6
<4
>
6"<&>ET3OOOU6%-6
-
6K
-
#T
#<
-
-4U>
† "
4"
6
4
%TEBO$U
#
6K#TEB$U
6K#H4
%
%TEBM$U
6"
%<-#4<'6K64
-
-
###6
S-<6
#
6K"#6-"-4
%
S
444
<#
-6S-<64"6-
%-<
>
5-"
6-#4<-6Kp-
-R;-
8%@7
V
<OEO--3-x84
3#
&-T83&U
-"@
->5-4-4%
-
#-6K"
6%#
44
->
6"-6K-
%
4
<-#
6--
"
<%
K-4
>
$#%
4"-R;)R
#4
#%>5-"
4<
<
44
#
!%
4-6
-
-"
%
4
-#
6K4
<>
Source'#4%<.*/34#"66-
"
(%+-T;
R;)RUSR;)
R6
)-S83&TOOU@)7&TOEOU>
4. Policy Recommendations
3#4<#
/
4
--4
-
#
#<
K<#
#4"%
"-
-
44
#!<>
@#4"#4<
%<
-
6Kp
4
4
%-
6
%4>
-#-#"
"
-4
#6-
46
need to be debated for different sectors of
">5-<'TU-#
H
#%<6K
<%STU
%
#-
#
#
4-#
%
6-"%
<STU--
4
107
4-
-4
!%
44#
)#4<
6K>5-6#44
#-
#
%
#4"
K"4#ST"U
4K
"
4
<#
6
-<
-/>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
$-
##
#
<%
4>$
#%
%4
-
"
--
#
6K4"-
6K#4"
#
K
%
4"+-6K
6#-
-
4
#H%
4<#><-#
6--
4
""
-
<#H
-6%
4
#6--
108
"--4%
%<)
6
6--
-
"4#4
4
4
<#
-#4#
#
)
44!
#4"#>
%"
4
#-#-H
#]6-#^
]6
^>%
4
<4
K
-
functionality of the informal economy and its
K
#-
6--
#
#<T6--6/
#
4
"
-#%
the informal sector in terms of its contribution to
;38
<
HU>--
-6
-4"H4
#
"4>---
64--
-%
4
-
#
6K
<)%
<#
K
--
<
>
Water and Sanitation:
Barriers to Universalization
Marie – Hélène Zérah
1. Facts: Inequalities and Vulnerability
5-(#3"4#;
#%<
OE-
"-44446-
K6
<
K#
-4@
6
"
>
1.1. Water data: an apparent success
@-%-EO
#
Oz-%
44
-
K6
#4
>GzOO>$-;"#
@
-(3;%!"6
-OOB>
<OE-"
6
-
Cz-%
44
T
OO'CFU>@-6"
6-
->
6"-<<K
-4
--6-
-
-/
<"4">
5--4
)-
#zFCz-
O
<
#
-6
KK%6--
"#
%"-4
T(-
(-
OEOU>$
4-
6
44<@
>
@-4
"
#
'
-OOEEG
4"
6
#
%6
Oz>8#
"
%<##
>$
#%
4"
46
#
-
Oz-44
T?
K
V
##
?
-#KK#(-
<
<)
K8-<
-
-U6--
4#%
<T-
'z$
#'GMzU
"
T
8
-
?
6-
46
4"FBz
FEzUG>
G
3
#OOE>OEE
<
"
%>
109
<
#
F>846
OOE"
#BGz
@Cz
-
@.
.@%
KTR
KOOM'EGU95>:--
@@
.@<
(
-
-
-
---
4
446
"
T
MOzU6-
--
-6
4#
44
GOz
44
6-446
>3
#
"4
"
-
-#
64
>
:
<@
-
%<
%
44<#
6-4
<"--6-)
->8%#/
<"
T4
%<44<#44<U
6
/
<
/
<6
44
%T,*
-OOOSR
K
OOMU>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
1.2. Sanitation data: an evidently
unsatisfactory situation
&
-
#-6>
5-(3;6%
-
-"
#4"
-
4
4<->
.
4"
#4"
'BB>z
-OOM:
Fz
-R@:
TV(8OEOU>
-
-6-
4
#
##4
EBz)ECz%
6><
%Cz-%
44
-
6
%MGBGz
has a household toilet connected to a sewer
4
TR8OO'U>5-"
/
T
#U#
M>Fz-@
p
;38
/
<#%
4
TR8OEOU>
Another concern is the low level of wastewater
4
#<#>
5-
#
4
<-6
6
-Ez#4
TE#4UGz6-
44
%"EOOOOO
Cz<6-
44
#4%6OOOO
EOOOOO-
%
T8OOU>.
##4
'-
6
#
4
<<
%
EOOz
#4
Mz3-Mz
4
EEz7K6>8
-
6
6
6
%
4
-
"
"
#4
-"#
4%-
->
#
##
-#
#6
>
<#
"
Bz6-
"
>
5-%4#
?
<
T<"CzU
-6
4#
-
;!
Tz
MEz4"<U>$#(#%
-
Mz<
#4
z(
Ez
#M>5
4
4
<
#T
BOzU
#
-
#
64
4
4
"##-
#
-<
<
>:
<
/
4
6
T4
#4
%
<4
U
"#
>
5-%
-
"<-
#4
6
-#
-/
<
#
<#%#>
34
%64
"
%<44
%/
#
#
<4
4
<-@
<
as far from inclusive in terms of access to urban
%
>
F
84
)
6'
@'EOOOOO
%"S
@@'OOOOS
@@@'OOOOFS
@.'EOOOOES
.'OOO
.@'7-
OOO4>
95
5-
-"-8
-;"#@
>
M
5-"
T
6
<6U-
"%#4
<%<-
-<
>TOOCU>
110
1.3. The ground reality: distributional
inequalities and cumulative vulnerabilities
(
"#4
-
%
/
->5-6")-6
-
%
446
44<#
4
>8%4"6
---
4#4
44
6T
#<--6
KU>-
"
%
#
T
K##U"<
4"
<#
#
6K>44<
from these sources is limited in time and
#4</
6
4
#4-
#
%6BO4
4
4
<
T-
%
-
#
OOBU>/<
6
#4
-
G6
44<>
"--#6
-
444"
"#)
%<
#4
-
"<
#44<>(
<
-
"#
-
44
-#4444
<#6
-
-TR8)$EU'-<<<
"
"
#
6
K4
<##4<
4%44<
4
<
4#-4>5--
-
"#
#4
-#
%%<-4>@
]-4
4
##4
/
-4OzMOz#-
-%
"
^TR8OOU>
Beyond the low level of access and the related
#-
#4-
-
%<"
-4
%
"
/
4#
!>
"
<H4
6
44<
%
#<-H
K
97
security and fear related to the denial of basic
->-/
4
<
6#
-
6
6K
""
">
1.4. A focus on vulnerable groups
3-4%-
#<
6
6#
-4#"#
46
44<>$
-
-#
"-6
T
#
-4
6KU
6
4/
6
6
--46-6
T-
#
EU>:--<-#
#
/
'6#
H
-
#
6
4
S6-
-<
4-<
-#
"4
<#
absence of toilet facilities also force women
-#
4
%
-46-#
-
#K
-#--
-<
'
-H
%
-
#>"
6--
%K4%#4'
4
44
-
%
%
4%#
6#-
menstrual cycles97>$4
#-
#46)
4
-
-
K
"4%<
4%6--6
4
#
6-4
>
-4
-"
%4>
$6-6#<
-
-
K6
"%
->5-
K-
-#>3
-
/
6
-6%6"<
>5
)4">5
46
4"
BCz]-^-44
Mz
5
-
%
Fz-4
Gz
Ez5TOEOU>
8
%<V
M-"#%OEO-6K6#3->
111
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
RK
#4<-
6-
"<4
6K"#>5-"
<
6K6-
<4"/4#x
fact that leads to both injuries and diseases
T"
OOMU>8#
#4<
--
)
%
-
<6
%
/
6K>5-
4K
-6"-6
-
#-6
-<6KT
"
U
>#
4%#
%<-""-4
#
">5-<#4
<
K
T4
-U
--
--6
#
#<#-
6K
"<6
%
-#
4%
4>:
<-#
--
!%
4
#--)
4
<>
H#
#
"4
#-4
#"
%
-
-><
"H
-
#4#T#
#
U6--%
-
#"
6K
<
#
!
>
2. The Legal and Policy Framework
5-
-4%6-
"
4<#
#4H>$#
-
-
"TOOU6
4<
-4<#
"6
6>5-
#%
/#-
#4
#
#4H
%--
#
-#4#
6
4
6-
##
"
44>
2.1. Legal framework
5-/--6
-
%
-#%
/-
-
6
>@V<OEO-
General Assembly of the United Nations voted
6
-#
->5-6
consensus on this resolution since some states
66
<-4%##
#4
>"-"
4
6K#
<6
--6--
6
#4
--6
98 by
;>
6"-
#%
#-
/--
-
"
-6
>
KKTOOB'FGC)FGU
##
#-/--
6
'TU--6
#%#4#
#-
)%
<
TU-H
-
#
<
#4"
TU
#
###-44"
--#
-6-
-
<
#4#
--
6
#-
--<
)<#T"U
<--6
%
4-"
->
the one hand, this is not in itself contradictory
6--44"
##
#-
-##-
%
4##<
#
#
"4%<>
5-%
4-
/-
#
6---
-
%"T"
"U
6
"
#4"-
>
In the case of India (who voted in favour of this
U--6
#4%<
98
-
#4
%<;@
T-4'666>
>U-
%
#4
T-4'666>-6
>
U-"#T-4'666>-6
>U
#->
112
!
<4
-$ET-
U
---
"#TOOU>$
H
TOEO
U-@
4#]
"<
4-$E
--
%<-
4
6#
-#
6
-^>34-#
-
-
-
-
water in all its dimensions (cultural, symbolic,
-
"#
"U
very limited in the Indian laws that mostly deal
6-
6
44<>/<
-
%
-
#4
&-R
-
-
!"T
HOEO
U
R
7
6-
6%%
-
6
44>
7
-
"
#-(4
R
T(
#
U&
OOO%<-(<"#
:4
-##
#4
4#!#>5-
!#6
-4
8%@
7
EM
-
%<
%
%-
-6
>5-
4#4
H4##6-
-(R&
OOO>$"
"T-
4-%4
6
#4<64
#
#4"
4
#<#U
6-
#4
>
4%
-
%
%
#4#
/
4>
2.2. Public policies
R
%!>5-
-
"
4
<T
-4
"-
#
U
6
44<#
##
444
-
#
%
%<
%<-E--
-BF-
$##>
At the national level, the National Water Policy
TR8UOO
-
%
Sanitation Policy of 2008 are the two main
#4
->
5-R8OO
#4
-
#
"<4
>@
4"
#%44
-4<K6
>
@#-#4
##<
4
4
-4%<
4"
4
4
6--
-
6
##<>
6"-4<-
"<#4
6-
#4#
-
"
%4
6--<
-
R
8<>
@OOC-;"#@
4
National Urban Sanitation Policy whose objective
-
]$@
6%#
<
-
-<
"
%
4%-
-
"#
#
-6-
4
-<
%
-%
4
6#^T;@OOC'U>5
#4"
4
#
"
-)
%
<6K>@
-
4
%#
-
"<]%
6-%4"6-
###"
4"
-
-
6----
64<4
#
^T;@OOC'EU>5-#
44
"<4"-#
#>
4%
4
<
4
%
%#>"44
-
6
-#>
:
<4"6
-
%
4-#
<#
-4"%<-V
6
-
-
%
&6
(6--
-
#%6
44<
-#>6"-V&(
-#-
"#<
6-%
new infrastructure such as traditional water
113
Box 25. The stakes of providing 24 hours water supply
@
<4"F-44<>
%6
44<-
"#
44
<6K
6
#
--4>8-
-#
#
6
44<
4<%!"-
;"#>
-#-OOO
64H4-K6
44<6
#<-?
K
4>5-4!
--
4%
4"
4
-4
%-
-
"%
6
:-
6
#4
<>5-#
#H
#4-
?
K
6-OOG-
;"#6--
-
44-R
K
-
44!
#;%
%)3
6
4-
4
EOz-
<
#H-44
>4
$4OOC>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
R-
-
--4!#
-
#
"
44"‡
:#
-
4"6
-4-
%
%4"6-
44<>5-6-%6KT
K
%
--4U-
%
4
)-64
#>-4!
6
'TU-
44
-<6T-6-F-
-
-U
K6%6
F--4
STU---%--6-%<#
%6-H
>5-4-4-
%6
TK-
%
4
#<U
<H
-
F-44<6
-"-
K#4"#
-%6K
44<>@44!
per se, cost
%<%--<
<
-#
-6#
H#-H6K6
4!>
:#
4"6
%
#"<#
%K
<#6
%-4
<#%"6-%-4>
"
-6<
4
<46
-4"%
6
44<6-
-4
T4
--
-<%4#46
KU"--#
<--K4-
K
<#4---6
/
<>4#4-
6K
-
"%#">&
64
<
-
H4%<
-4!
#>@
#--#46/446-
">$-
4
6--6"4"6--6--
"
-
44<6--6
>:#44<#
/%-<
6%6--
#
4
4
--#>--"
<6
#4"-%
%<>@-
"44
-4!-
%
-p#
-44"-F
-44<
<H4
#
4!>
:
<#
<-4!-
"
-#
6---%
%
?
K
6%<4
%<-4!#4#
-
-
"<-
;"#>@-
4-(4
##6
-#
"-
6--4"
4
>:#
"
44"
4
<%
#
4
"
6
-""#-6
##4#
4/>
114
44<-#
6
6
<#
#4
>
$-
"
#%
-
"4
6
4%?
K
-
T
<U-
"
%
R
8<>5-4<
#"
#4"#"-%
4
#
%!">6"
6-#-
H#
-6
#%<44>$-
-6
#
#-
"<
6
##
6
4-6
4"F-44<
THU>$-
-
#6K6--6
-
4
R
&
<$-<T-
-
(
-
-
8
-U
"---
--
"-
46>$--4
-
4
4
4
6
#
#%
%
"@
4%6
#
#>@-
6
44<
sanitation, water boards or other city or state
4
4%6
44<
%)
6--BFth
##6--
6
44<-%
%>
:
<#4
-
6
#6---
"-
6
6
4
-#
-
->5-#-
"%
<%<
-
<44#
%">5-
6-6
issues stems from a number of international
@
-#
-EO>
"#
#
K4##
4
<
-
<"%
>
6"%
<#%#
6
##
%
-6%
"
%4"
>
3. Current Debates Regarding the
Existing Mechanisms of Exclusion
&#
%<
44
--
#-
6"
%
%<4#
"
"<#-
#>6"
"
#6K6-
##
#6K#
%<-<4-
%<#
TV
,*
-OEEU>5-H4
-%
-
#
-
4
#
-
<#-#
--
4--
-4"
---
->
3.1. Legal and administrative procedures as a
tool of exclusion
8"%
"/4
6-4>344
4----#4
<
#
<
settlements in Indian cities are still located on
4
6-
<
>(
#4
H"-
#6--
--
%
">@"6-#4H4
<
#
4
4"
-
4-
6
K-/
#"4">##4
@
-
"#
4--
THMU6--
#4#4
##-
"4""-
-#
8
#(#%
THBU>
7-<
#4H4"6-
<H
-%
/
"">:
4-BFth
$##
4
#
"<#4
-
<%
#
115
Box 26. Bangalore – delinking land tenure and service provision
OOO-
R
44<
6
-K
#4""#>$#4
#
-6
-/#
"4"##
##444
<T
<%U>@
"
4-
6
T-"
-
U
-
#
4%
44>:
<
3"4#-
#
<4
#6--##
%-K
6K6-K6;>
<-6K
6--
)"]#6-^>
-
<#
-
'TU--
%<
#-
#
#-##4H-
<%%<
>K
#
%
K
--
#4<%6-
]##^TU%
#"
K##-
-
4!
K6
TU
6-
4
--
#4<
<
-
>
'TOOBU
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Box 27. Contradiction of slum policies and land ownership – the case of Slum and Sanitation
Program (SSP) in Mumbai
5-#
8
##T8U6
%6-R
K
-
(4
4
>@
E6--%!"GOOO
6-
4
4
<
44
->5-(4
4
44
;
6
4"6
<>&
--
#4#
-
-R
K
#H%
%;%>56
4"
4
8$&6
6
>5-
-
6
#
6--##
-44
H#
>5-4!4
""##
-
-4>
-<4
4
--
-
"%-
4
T
BOz-
#-
"
U>5-6<#4-6K>
$-#
-#
-
>
@6
#-R
8
#----4%#-
#>:)#"
4"
-#
K<%#"
-8
%
44>:#-
p#
$
$--
"
]-6^%-#4<<-
-4>5-
%-
-4%<"4#-#6--
#4#-86
K>:--"<
#4H<
6-4
"
4-
4
</
#4#
-
8>@(#%
FCz#
4"
Ez
"#
EBz
#4
-#
#<6-
;"#
-@
6
<
6
<#>8
###-8
#
<
#4###4
6-4"
%!
TU/-#4
4
">
'
K
>TOOM')EOU>
116
4%<-6
6
THCU>
-#4H4
#
>5-<
also lead to the incidence of intermediaries
KK%
K
4--
/44
6-#4H%
#
->()
---
K
to their social and class status, can access
%
K-#
/
6-
4-44
other modes of intermediation to access the State
T
OOU>/<#4<
#4
44
Box 28. Procedure to get a new water
connection in Puri
† 8-
66
44
##-8%
-
T8U
† %#
44
6-
44#--
V8
† $44
#6
-
VTVU
† V
K
"#
%<
66
connection
† @-
%-V
6
-
44
-
$
T$U
† $
"6-
44
44#
-
%<
4
† @$-#-
44
#
6
-
44
† $44
4
44
/
K--
4-V
'T@$OEO'GEU
#4
#
RT6
44<
U"
%
%
44"
4
<
-
>:
<-/
-
%
-
/
%<>
3.2. Are services affordable for the poor?
"
Oz<6-
"
)-><"
"4
6--<-
T-
4-
#-
%6
%<Gz%
--U
/#--
%44444
<#
6
-
--TR8)$
EU>:-%<
#
"
%
--
4
<#
of water are a deterrent to shift to a more
#
44<>5-/-
-
R"
-
%
#-#6-
#<
-#
6-
/<>
8)#-
"
-
6
K
structure contributes to a vicious circle of low
6"
-6
"#->5-<-
"4-
#
-
6
6>6"
%
-4
>
5--
#%%
-
#4
4>
$/
-<4
-
#%>&#-
"
-#4
)%>
5-4
--
"
#
46-
-%
>5-
-H)%
#
-%>R-
##4#)%
%
"-6-
--#4
">@-
##4
117
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
%
-
%K
T@5U<#T-
"
%GCz-
%
44
U-6
%K
-]^%K>5--
%K
>@-%K6
6
"#4
-
#%#%
#-%>$-6)K64%#
6--@5--
#<4
>V
4-4--4
>@-
-
6K%
H>@
-%%
<
--#4"
-44
6-
-
-"%
%>
@-
4<"<#4<
%>5
/<"
4%-->:
6
4"%<4%
4
6)#
-#"
%
4%>-<<
4zEOz-%-
-T:
>OOU>-
#-EO#
<THMU-
"
-#
4%
4%#
6K
4#-%#
"--6
-
#
|4"p>
@#4#--6
#-$
p
"
-H%#
4"
---
-
)
#4#46-
"-
->8
<#
#4%<
many utilities can also be used but they still
#-
-
<6>5-
!
H
#4-%
-
K4
44"-
-
<%<
#
>
:
<-/"##4
-
6
6
>-
--
<%
118
4--%
#6
-<
>86
4
<#
6
-]#4
^%
-46
>@
6
"
#-
6-
>"-4%
4%
4H4
6
6
6
#4
6
%
"#%<4%6--
-
6<%#
<>5-
#4
-<
#
-K-
--
6%->
:
<-
<
-%
around tariff increase and shift in subsidies
4
-
"%-#-
-]#^>@-
%<4
-%
<>5-
%<4
<>5---
%<
4%#4"-%
-#4
<#
6
-
4%
-
>5-----
ambivalence of this shift that could also be seen
##46
-/
">
3.3. Understanding demand: accountability,
incentives and voice
$
%<
4
<
-
4
4
-
"%#"
#4
#
#4"-
%<%6
4"
">
$
4%<#
<-
%
<@5T#
##
-<U
4
<#%
#4
<#
#
#
><
%
4
#4-
-
46--
##
66
-
>$-
"#%
6-
4%
-4#4"
%<#-
#
-#
-%
##
%%6
-<T
<
OOFU>(
<-
"6#
'-
"#
cell and increased its number of bill collection
S-4
p6%4"
increased information on urban services, as well
-4%<
44<
#
K#4
>6"--
6
#<-
"
6
<
#4"#-
"">5-
4%#
<H4%<-
<
%
H
#4-4
disjunctions between customer services and
"4"><--
-
"#<%-#)
>
$#4
-
4
4
<-#.:
-
4
4
4<
%
#
"<
-
"#
K-"
-
4!6-4>@
4#4
#
#46#>(
<
"
p4%<4
6-
4%
->
8KH
-
"%
#%-/-)#
%<T%-
U#
>
(
</-
"%
4
4
<-#
4
<-
"
-
4
4
%
6
<6->:
#
<4
4
<-#-#
-
%4
<#%<##
--
)#
4
<)
%6-##T,*
-OOU>
Secondly, as mentioned before, it has often been
#4K6--
6--##
4
-
/
#%
#
>5-<
"-4%<
"
-##-#"
4-
"
H
#%
THMU>
$--
"<
4
#
""
4>5-]--<^#4
--4
4
)#
K
4
%
-4%
>-
-
"-%
%<-"##-"
;%
-K
K6K
4
&
R
$
>%
6
services are often a concern civil society
6-----
4%
"%<%4
)#
K4"
T#6
#
%
4
#
%
U>%
"-
"%-
6-]#)
^4-
"%
%
#
K-
#-<><
-
-66#4"#
%
"#4
4
44#%<-4%
-
"
-
#
-#
-<>
3.4. Reforming the government vs. claiming
the right to water
Water reforms have been mostly based on
#4"<>$
4""6]%
4
^-@
%
8
T666>
%
4
>U#<4"H
#4
#-
6-
T
6
-
"#4"
#
#U
4
4
#
<
F%<B6
44<-#>.<6H
#4
6--
/#4""-4>
5-
#-"#-
"
<%%
-
-R%
<4%
<
H
-
4/
>5-#
-
4-)%
"
4"%
6#
-
#4
"<
<4
#
4
4
%K
T-OEOU"<%<-4>
@-
-#-
"#
<#"4"%
-
-
R%
%
<4"
119
"#
4
<
T-|"<p8>-
!U
-
|4%
<pT!
#OOCU
%
-|4
<p>-
<-
!6--4"#H
de
facto-"-
%#%<4)
#
6K
T?
?-#
OOFU>
/<-#-
"
<464
K
---44
)
-4
<
->-
<6
6-
--
<4<
%
"
6--4%-
-
-<"
-
%
-
#
4
6
-
4
-
/
H>
5
#
%
"
%
4
<#-
H
<%#H
#
>
@-H-#4
6
#"##4<4
#-
--<
-/%
"#%<4
%<
4%4>@<
-
"
-#%
4
#"#
4
-
6
4"
-
##
-##
%TH
GOU>
5-
-
-6
%<;
-
4#>-H
#4
-4
4)4
6
#(#%
-
<-
%--/--6
T
-##-
6
U
---<
#6
-
<>(
<
-
-)%
#
-4(#%
6<6
-448-V-
%-
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Box 29. Anti water privatization campaigns in large Indian cities
|4"
p#-
#
#%
@
6-4!6-4"
4
4
-
"%>
$H
#4-
3-6-
6
-"
<
8
"
44-4!6
4"
4#%<-R
K>5-4#
-
4-
%<
4%<<
#
>5-<
|)H4p
#4
6
-4!-"
-4!
-/
-
4">5-#"#
%<]#
^6
-
4#6-6
-%
4>
$H
#4#%
-
(#%
6-
#
"
-4"
4!
##4
6
T##
6--
6K-
U
##<)%
<44
<
#4
4"
>
#
H
#4?
K
H6--""#@.@
4
)4"
#4
#"#
84
#4
-
&-R
4:
%K
#
#
>
'3--%
%68
"
T-
?!6
OOU
-R
KTV
-
OOMUS
(#%
6
TOOU
-84p
#4
-&-R
>
120
Box 30. The Safai Karamchari Andolan: a
movement for the elimination of manual
scavenging
5-
?
#-
$
#"#--
#
">:6-
K
#4#
-
(
"
3<7
T$%U$
EG-$
3#%OOG
4-4#
#4#
-
%<"
>344"%<-
-4
H#<
6>5--
-#"#
-
#4
OOC
]$OEO^-
#
-
4#<-
>"--
-
-
actions by the Andolans are related to the
-
-4
--6K
<
--
44
%
--)%
#"#>
'-4'
K
#
-
>
$
#
/>5-#
the embeddedness of the debate on water with
-
%
---<
%
>
4. Policy Recommendations
&##
%#
-
#
#
'T-
#
6U
"
>
%--/"#
6
-
#4
#4
<)
-
>
† 5
K
-
#
66-""
<
6-
>5-#4
"#-6
6
-#46#
4
<%
-
#
>
-#
/
#4"""<#-
#
--
4%#-
%
--
-
<"'
† 3)K-/
"#
-/
>
† &<%
---
-6K'#4<
4
-
4
<#
#>
† (
66K
4%
4
--
#
-#>
† "%--
44
-/
!>
† 5
K#
#
K#
<
"-
%<-4'
#
6-
##
-
4
-4##
-
6-##>
@-#
"
$
-/
† #46
>
† <-
-4%6
6
4<
%<-K--H6
6
-
%
4>
† 3#
)#
K4
discuss the contents of water reforms lest they
44
<
#4
#4"
"%K>
† 8
6
6
6--
66-#4
"#
4%-
-H
>5-
† &-4
##
-#
#-##-
H
->
121
Urban Transport and
the Right to the City:
Accessibility and Mobility
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Kavya Murthy
122
5
4-@
<
S<%4
##
<%<4
<
#)
%
#%<>-"
%<
%%<4%
4"
%<
-
-#
<6-<
#
4
#>5-
%<
4
4
4%)
4"
4
-44#-
-
44%"
<
%<
#4
-
--#
!<>
5-
-%##4%<
-%6accessibility and mobility
solutions, -
"4
44
<-
#"#
>&
--
-
K
<
%<
4-
activities, mobility in and of itself becomes a
4#
%!"4
6-
4%"#
<
%
by car users rather than modes that facilitate
multimodal access -4%>
5-"##
-@
4
6-#%<
%<>
1. Context
%
"
-4
<
-
H-@
%
6--%
4
<#<
<-)#
-
4
-
#4<#
44
<>5-#
4
4
-
|#
p#/
#4
#
-
-4%
<#
-#4
--
#
#
>5-#
!<-44
in transit is accounted for by users of low cost
"#-
%<
6
K6-
|
4"p-#%<<
#4>
%
"-
%
%-|
4"p
low cost travel modes, and users of intermediate
4%
4-
#4<K-
6
%%--#
)
4
4>5-
"#
4OBOz##4
-
#
##
4%<
4%
4%
O
Mz
4T56
OOBU>
-66
%
46-
-H--
#%6-"
"-"
%
-<
4
-<‡3-%
4
4
@
<
-
-8
6-
H
-8
64
6
<6--
4H#H
)
#
"-‡
5-
@
6#
4
4%
6-
%
>7
4
<
#4
commercial and residential localities in urban
44-
4"
#"-
-6-
%
/
4%
4
##
-%
4
6>5-#4
%#H#
)##
4
-
>5-
6
-
#-6-
4"
#
"-H6--4
6
4
4%#>&
4
<
#4"
#"-
"
-
#4
K
4
<#6#4>
8"
#
4-
%4
to have increased twenty fold in the last decade,
6-
6-4
"#
ECEOO>@
#
4%
4
6(#%
6
-
4EF)
%%
">(#%
%6EO
OOO
6
CMz
-%6--
Cz
3-
%-
Cz>6"-
#
6-
-
4"
#"-
6-%/
4
cars and motorcycles increased nearly seven
>
%4
4%
4@
6-
#"
K-
6
<K-
6-
#
4
"
%-4%
GOz%
4%6E
#Fz6-44
#
MGz6-
44
"#>-<44?K
%<4%
4
MOz(#%
Fz-
3-4"<T6--
4<
6<U>@3-
Ez
3-"
4"
#
<K-
6
>5-COOOO
<
%
-6--
4
#<
%<>
8-)
#
"44
"-#%<
4
<"
6
T8-
OOU>$#4
4#%<
-#4
"44-4
6-
"
<
##
4
#
!<6K
##
/#>5-
4
4
4%%<--
<%4
"4
>
2. Policy Framework
5-
%
5
48<
T58UT;@OOM%U
4%<-
%OOM
#
4<-
that seeks to address the mobility needs of
-4>5-58
#
4
4
6
<#4"
<6
)%
#%<T56
OOBU
-K<
#
#"4#
6
4"4%
4<#>5-
4<4#-#4
-%
#
4#
6-<
">5-6-
-44
6--4#4"
#%<
-6
44
4<-
#
K#%<
123
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
6)#
">R-
-4
44)#4-
-
#
K"
%as #
6->5-584-%
4
4
#4
--
4)
%
4
6>3
6
#
#6K|
%<pK
4
"-6-44
%
#4"4%
4
)#
#
##
<#6--#
K
room for safety, affordability and access to jobs,
>8<%!"
4%)4"
4
-4
44
%
4
4
4
-
--
#6K>
124
<
K
44
%
#"-4#
<
-58-
-
6-
<
4)4
46K
--
"4
4<#
4
6-
K4
>5-
%
4-/
%%
4
-
44<44
"->5-"4
4%
4
)##-
<
6
K"
4
-
"-
58p
#6
%44)
4<-
K
%
"-4
>
5-4<-#4
"
4
%-6-4"
)4%
4
-4
--4
-#
4%
4#-
#
K
-
-
-%
44
>
$4
#%
"
%
-4##"--/
<
-#-44
%
6
6
<#-4"
4
">$-V&(-58
4
#4-
4<#-
#
4
#
"S-#H"
#
4/%
4
4%
44
6--%"
#4>$6-4
-
<
#4"<#"
4
!6-4
%
-
-4#
4%
4
<#>
5-58#4
"-4
6
4
%
@
<
-
H4
%
44
>@-
-
#4"
#
4
"4#4!
%<
"#-
58p
44)"
44"%/<
<
#
%<-#
4"
#
4>6"-#4#
-4<%!"#
%6-
"#/-
%
44
%
#
4>
5-V
6
-
-%
&6
(
TV&(U%
4
-
M-4
6-44%
4#4
6--58>8%
44
%<
-
&
45
<#g&5k
-
4"6
4
>&5
%<)
"4
/#<
H4
-#
"
-M
6--4"
%T56
OOBU>
3. The Experiments
5--
4
<<#gk-
%%
4
H
4
#
<
44#
4-#%
#)#
6K6-
%
4
"4#>
4
%<#
6K#%<--
4
6--%
#
44->
5-"-#
K#4#
<
4%
4
)#"-
4
4
#4
6
-
44
<#-
<4"
#"-
>5-
6K
-4%#
-
#H)
#
>5-
#4
##
4
6K-
#4
6
%<
4-<
<"
-
#
K4
-
"
4#
4-
%
%<
4
>
3
6#-H4-
-7
$#
-
#
%
%<
#
#<>$44
to the metro rail, held to be unsuitable in itself to
#-#%</#
#
!<
<"-#H
4
@
-
"
%
#
4<#
6#6-6K>
3#!
%
"-6
<%
4#
6#4
4-4g44-4k
<
#
%#"#>4
%6-6
<
->
5-&
45
"-
%
-<--
<4
-
##
-#)
6K
)
<#6-
#4#"-6
<T8
OOM'OGU>
5-#4-
-&5
##
-
convenient and economical movement of public
transport, and in addition to a dedicated corridor
%#-4
%<-
##
-4#
<
COz-##-
>$
H
#
-4
T
KU-
&53-$-#
%
(#%
6-4"
-H6--
<
/<
6-
-4!spatially
#4#
-%44'
#4
>
5-%
"4#""
%<-
V&(#
K#--
&5$-#
%
-4
3-@V
4
8
.-
K
4
#>-4"
-3-@
()(
5
4
<#6--6
#OOM3--
--%M&5
"
-GEOK#%<OO>5-
V&($-#
%
4!
&>CCO#
4EK#>@
-4%
4
#
"
%%<-$-#
%
(4
5
4
"T$(5U-V&()&5
4!
"-
K#4"
4-<>
$-#
%
-
6
6-
EOz4"
"-6-44<
6-
#
-4%
4
4"%<-$(5>R-
OOOO4
4
<
GO
%$-#
%
-
@
8%5
<#-4-
6-
44&5#
4
-
>5-&56
%6-
-
6KE
K#6-
4-
CK#"4
-$-#
%
(4
4
T$(U
>5-4!
#4#
-4%
)#
4
#4"
>@6
-
%4!/
<6K-%-
4
-##
OO>
5-$(
6-#H)
#4S-R
<
--<44
of low income households in industrial areas,
-64#
<#4
-4
--#
6-44
<>5-
%
#
&"6
4
#
K-#
duality of Ahmedabad city, with the eastern city
distanced from the educational centre and other
125
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
6$-#
%
>
R$-#
%
#
which was scarred by the communal riots of 2002
6-
--#46K
(#
6
4>76#4
46)----
6--$(p!6---#
4<Bz>8&5-<-
4
MFzp
4"4%
46
K
%<
>5-&56
##
<6
K
--
4
#
%<%<
<#-
#
#
)##%<>
126
6
?-
p
<-
4-
/<
4-&5
$-#
%
K
-H6---
44%-%%-
#4
<#
"
#"#6-
--44
"
#
"
"#"-4
--#46-
%
##
-#4
"<
>;"-4
6#
slum and chawl dwellers of the eastern city,
6-FOz-
44
$-#
%
-%-&56
44
<6-4-
#
--#4>-
#4"<#4#
-
--#46
&56-
BOC##
-&5
6#4
-
CMB#T?-
OOU>5-
6-&56%
-64
$-#
%
-
&5>
@-4
-64
"&5
"G>K#-&5
%<$-#
%
V
#
7#
6-
"MOO
#
#<
R
!)
"
R
!-
7
K3
#
?-<
-
-$
#V
#
4
-
>5-
<
-
$-#
%
>$-
##
#4"#-
64
-<
-#4
-
?
K
7
K
-
%
6
--#4>5-&5
"
&5#
;
(
--<-
%-(
?
--<
>
@
#4
-
-4%)
4"
4
-4#-
6-
"4#-&5$-#
%
4#4
&>EOOTMMM#}U
<
-O%4
"-4-
-&5>$-
##-MO
$(5%
<"<&>
K-T
-
}U-
##
4&CCT
E>
#}U
<
4
>5-
#4"#4%
4---
$(56
6-
"
%4"
4
-
-&5
>
5-$-#
%
V
#
&
45
System has been widely hailed as one of the best
#
<#-<4
<#
-#%
%
-
-<#-
-<>&
-4-&5<#6-%
4
#4-
-
44
/
<
"
-%"##4
-
4!>5-
"%"#4
4
<
-
4"%
%
%<
6
K>(6K
%
--4
from modal shifts than from infrastructure
#4"#>6"-
-
-
$-#
%
&5-
""6--OEO
%5
4$6
-H"
44#-;!
"#
H4
"---4%
6%<--
&563->
5-&53--
%-4
%
K
EC%"#46-
-##6
-%-
6
44!$4OOC>@
<6-
EGz
6-4%6EM
OOM
4
4<%
#
-K
4-
#
#6-
EOOOOOFT
#OOU>K-3-
(&
-&56
%!
H"
4"
>5-&56
-!
K
4
6
<#
6-4>5-
-
4#
<
-<#
%#
%<]
%<46
6)#
""
4
"
4"
]H4^^
-
"
%
<
7
8#_
#-
7&
!_
499>5-&5
#
]6K
#^-
#
]
<-
6-
4%
^T;4
Grd(
<OOCU>
In a city such as Delhi which over the last
6H"<
6-4#
"
)
T<"U#-
6
and control of vehicular emission of cars that
"<
#<-
##
44
-#
<#-
6
-
-4
)<#%
)
4"
"--
g
k6
%)6>@
(#%
O<"6%
EOO6-3-4GO<6
<
6%
-
#H4>&
6
--6
<
4%#
4"
#"-
6-
4
<
%<>
--
-EOO4#4
#4"#
<"%<-V&(4
MBFT
EOOO#}U
%
%
#
M
#
)6--
%
&5
B
##"OT
MM
#}U>@#4
4
<FT
E#
}U>
4. The Affordability Question
<
6
K44B
GCz4"<
4##
@
>5-
-#
6-<6-
--#
#4"#><
""4
EOz
4
%Fz-
<"#
>76#--6-
4-#<S
<K3-
GOz---
"
#-<#-
&>OOO#
K
#4%
4
%
4-%"<H4">5-
4K#
-#T&>O>MOU3-5
4
4
%T&>O>OU
#-
Ez
#<#T56
V
OOCU>-6"
"
44H#
<-
"#
%
"
>5-"
%
6
<
-#
!<-##
44
44%
4
%<4-
)
#%<>
5-
-6)
<-
%-
%--
#
(#%
p
>5-4-
4-
the vision and reinforces the very subjective
H4
4
>5-
<44#)
-#
446-4%
-#
466
K<>:-
4-4"-
%%6--
%<4%
4>5-<<6K-
"##%6-
"
--4
#-
%6
K%#-
#4
4##>-
of mode of travel, of either bus or rail is also
#%<
-<6--4
6-6%#
-
-
4-
%"-
6
<#
99
5--4-4
@
#<6-
#4H<#
6
-
-#<
#
4
6>
127
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
4%--
-
6
<>$)6
<OK###-
6-
&>FTO>O}U
<
44-&>O%<%T
K
>OO'
GOU>
5-;"#(
-
-
"-
-
"-
R
)
7K-(#%
%
5
48!
g(58k-(#%
((
8
-&5
-(#%
(
(
8
6--
"
<">34
-%%
6
<
FOOO
<
H#
"6
#>7
K
4
<
-
and that conjoined with the railways has led to
#
<-
>5-(586--6
4"GO8
;
4
-#
-
6--6--#4<
>5-
#
(#%
|6)
<p6--4!/H"
6%#4#
-
6
66-4
-4
>
-#<T$
OOM'
GFFU
-
)#-)6%
<#"
-<<#
<H
#
!<-44
>@(#%
%
-
"%
-<
#
K##
K-
6
K
%
%#
-
<-
<>"
#"-
%#
-
#46
T$
OOMU>
5-5100%(#%
4
F>E#4
4
<
-
6
<
4M#"GOGK#
KS
FBz(#%
p44
#"
%<
Bz
#4
%<
4%
4T44
-
-
<
OOBU>6"-##4"#%<
still focus on rail based systems as solutions to
46--
100
5--
##%
44<Š5
4
K
128
-&5-%
K>5-&5
(#%
6K
#"#
4
)##%<
%<#-
-
6
<>
5-%%<-4
"-(#%
((
8
<"
K<6
K4!"%<-(#%
(4
&3"4#$-<
%<4#-)-
)6&5>-
44
-#
6%#--
4-
H4
T
#OOM'FBMU>
5-
(#%
-
-
6
-
-<4"-
6
<4
%</
-<%
4-#
S%
-"-#<-#
p
%
-&5
3---
H"#
-|4%p%<4
4
6-4-4
/<-#4#
4
>
5-
-
444
"4#@
4%
#
-
"#
#
%-#
|4)#
p6--%
4
%
#4!#%%
44
of a successful venture in an advanced country
T-#
EMB'U>5-5
#
6---
%-4
H#4
<
##%
4
4
"4#4
<-
@
#
/<
4%#"%
-
4#4
#6--
H4"
%-
%
<#4
%<
#H4"
<#
-5
#-
6
%<4"
#4
>
5-#
<#-
4<%
44@
#
)
4
-"4#
-
##-
#<#--)#4
-
-44
"
6K-@
%
>
R--
--<6K
6
4
<
4<#
-
#-
-
<4
-#
#
%
#
4
4
>5-"
<#
-
6--&>M%-
6-
--
-
%#
4
<
-
-<-%<
"
<H>5-
<
#
6
<?K
6--
6
%MG>B#4
%<OOO
6<)"-4!#>
H4#-3-
?K
#
-
-4!#4
-
4!
<
4
T>
#4
4
<-
-3-
(8-
EOOU
%
4&>EOOOFOOOO444<
#
4
H4T(-
OOBU> 34
#4
"-
6%
K---
4
"#%%
K6--
-4-#-
4
-#
%
"4#@
>
R--3-(-
<
4
##%
-
"4EOK#4-
-%44-
-
>]5#
K
-4!
44
#
"-
6
-
4#
-/6
4
>%
6
"46
<"
3-p
4
4%#^
T(
OO'MU>5-H4-
-3-
(6/
"#&EFOO
T
G#}U-
-3-
(&
4
K#-33$
-V
4
@
4
$<
TV@$U
-M>BK##--
H6>$&>C&>GOTO>EBO>MM
}U
--#%
6-
%"%
%
-44
>6"
&
-#
]
<#%
-#-
<#6
<>>>TU
#%"4
"4#S
4-
3-
6)
<4
6
]4
)@
-#^T
OEO'BCU>
5-
##
(4!
-
<
%
(&
4
6-
64
8%@7
>5-<444
<---
K4%
"
4
#
"#
-
4"#
<">
5-8@7%<-"#44;4
T;U
<%
4
#44
-
7
%
-
-
4
"
-4%4
K
-%-
6%4%<-
##
(4!>
5-8@76
<
"-
<
4%##-
6
6%4
%<
>5-
%<---
(
in November 2010 demanded that metro rail
<#%"4#4
6-
-?
K
56
<8
$
6--/4%
<
4
>@-8@7
that which the metro needed to address as
6'-44
-(
8
4%
%
4
<
%>6"--|4%p
#%-;p44
6-
-
%%
%
"#
#S-46
#
not by the concern for the metro as a mode of
4
%<
%<
%%<-
8@7
-
<4%##S-
<
-"4#-#-
6--<4%4
K!<
%<#
>
5-!
-#
-%
-
"%%
%-
#4"
-<#
129
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
4
"
#
">6"
-
-
44
6-
"
<)
<
H4>;
#56
-
-
#-44
6-
|)p
#-H4
#4
-#4!>5-#4
-3-
(4--6--4H#<
-4!-
%%<$"
Arora, who documents the commercial and
"4
<6#
#%<-3-(
>$
p--"<%
4#
<
"
-
---
that were not evicted by the metro line, there
was reduced accessibility to bus services, and
for those households relocated by the metro,
6K
-
"
6-
4
%<T%
4
6K
U>3
#
-
"
4CGz
---"6>5-6#
resident could also not afford the metro without
GOz
#<#
">5-
%
4
-
4
K--#"
44
"<
%<
4
-#T$
OOBU>
$K
-|
p4
---<6--
4
-4
#
%-<-6-
-K
%6-
"--4
<
%
"
>:6#%
slums from low income households the situation
#4
6-4"<
##%<><
4
4
@
<#-
%<
%<H@
4
-4
101
4>5-KH
-
#
-"6#
-
based restrictions on mobility with the added
%
K
%#
"
for women in urban slums have barely been
>
5. The Law
$-4-
-3--8%@
7
101%<(
-
-@
"
5
4
3"4#-
6--#H%<-(4
4
3-T(3U-
<K-
6
6--
OOO
-%<)
6EMO-
#
-
<<K-
6
|6)4p>5-#%<-(3
6--#
#4
<K-
6#!
-
4
6
<4"-6
<)
##
4K-<
K-
6T-3-OEOU>
5-4#-8@76
%
-
<
6<K-
64<
6--"<
<H4
-
#
%<K-
6)4>
5-#4<4COOOOO
#
6K
/
6
4
"##4""->(
-#
4
#4
#-4%
4
-
##-4>5-
-#%%<-8@7
hostile discrimination since no such licenses are
issued to motor vehicle owners, which are also
"4#
-4
(.>5-(3p
4
"
3-(
8
OE6--#
-
(.>5-6-44<-%<)
6
5-8%@7
T8@7U6
-EBO
--%<-4
<6
44-
K4
#
-#
-%->:#-#)ECO
6
#%8@7
"#
#
%
"
6%--4#
--
#!
"#-
6
<%<-#
6
#
<
"-)
-4>
130
--
-4
<K-
6-
%-6
-8@7--
"-
#
!<K-
64
#4"-
K#
/"-
--#-44<
-
"-
#
>
5-
)<
-
K
4
<
#
-#<K-
64%
>5-
K4
K4
4
4
<
6--6
6
K-
64<
<
%
%<-"#4"
6K
>
;"-
#"-
6
4<-#6--
4-%-4<<K-
6#
-
6"-
-
4
##>R--
"
%<---
K
#
#
>5--4%
-
%#
"
#
4
%
444
#4%<
#
44
<6--%K
-44
4%
4>5-
<
K%<-3-
(
8
6--%6--
#
#
#6"
4#
<
<
"->
5-
#-<K-
66--
#-<%<-<4
-
%
K#-"4
#
/
44<-
6
#%
K--"-%<
-
4<K-
6
%
<S
not only does it stress the need to allow cycle
K-
64<<-
%
-#4
-
"<
#4<#-4>;"-
%
<4"
#"-
--
4
-
/
<
%
%
<>@4
#4-
-4#)
#
44
<#-
K
-<4"4%
4>@
--4-#
"-44
3-p44
-
4<K-
64"
#4""
#
4%
44"#4<#
#4"-4>5-
-
6--#4
<
4
<-
4%
4
#-
#
)##
-%
##
-"6
K--
>
6. Conclusion and Recommendations
5-444"4-
-
%
5
48<
6
-4
4
--
46--<--##
6K-
%-4
4-
#<>6"-
4!
K4"
%
4-@
"
K
K
%6#
">
R-
-
44
4
4
-##
-#<4
"
#
)
"4#
##
#%<6-
-
#4-
#)#
<>R-
-
4%<#
4!-44-8
4
>
-%
#"4#4!
4
-
-4%
4
##
"
4
>
$H4
-#
#
4<4"%<-4%)
4"
4
-4#"
K
/
<%
#
%<
6-##
4
#6-
<%>5-#
H-
4%6-#
4
-
%
"
>8%
4
6K#-
6
4
%<
131
4"
<)#
<
4#
6--
%<-58
%4"6-"<
4-
<>R-
<
K
-H-
-4<#4
%<-
;"#6-H4#6-
-#
--
4
<%<#
"-#/
%
<
%<>R-
44
%<
6K
#4-
4%
4
"
"4"
#"-
>5-
%K"6
%"-4
/
<4"
-@
%
6--#
!<
4
)4"
"->
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Given the diversity of Indian urban forms,
4
4
<
-K%6"-
4
6-)
132
4!
4%#
-%
>$
%<%
<
"
-
#4
)@
/
<
>
$4%<;
#-
-
]
#
<
%%
-4)%<6-
6-
6-
6"<#^
T-
OOCU>5-4%#
-
%6-8
-
-
infrastructure as it stands, and infrastructure as
4!-%
4
#
>
5-4
"6-8
#4
"<-
!
4H%
#"-
#
>%
4
4
4<
#4#
"%
-6
6-
H-4%4-
4#
##6-
H-
-
-#-
#
<#-<
|4%p>
The Retreat of the State in
Healthcare Policy and the
Right to the City
Ravi Duggal
1. Context
5-4%-
-<#%
@
6
<%--->5-
"-4
6
-
-
-4
4
<-4
#6%
H
-
-
>5-
6
#-<6>5-
-
-
6--<>@
-
<
-4
-
#
4
<#
-
<%
#
-%
"4
$
$
>-4%-
-
%
@
6
<
-
-<
-4%-4
-
"
6-
<4!
#
>
-6
6-4%-4
4#
-
#-%
#
H4
>5-
#4%
4"
%
6---
%-
<-
-
adjustment reforms of the early nineties under
4#-R
K-
->5-
6
%
"64%-4
-
as well as in many districts, became victims
-##--%
<
>3"#
H4
4%-
-%#4E>z
;38-
-
-6O>Cz
;38%<#)T3
OOU
---4
<
#%
#-
-
4"
6K--4
>$-
##
4"
-
-
<6)-
4
4#
<
H4
4<-4
-
-4%
-4
6
>
5-4"
6-6
%<
46-#
-4"
-<-4"
133
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
-
-
-4
-
-
>5--
-4
#<
%
-
-
>:#
"/<
H4"-4
-6
-
/<6--%
#
44%<#4<
#"-4"
>5-
#
"##4<
6-"4%-
-
%-
H4"
-
-
"#
6-
6-
6
-
44
-4%-
-
<#
-4%
-
-%#4"-
4>@6-
4%<#
functions best when it is based on universal
<-6--%#
-#-4%#
4<#>
$-%6-4%-
-<#
#
6--)
-
-#4!
#<%<-R
K
%
K
3:@3
$@3>5-4!-
4%-4
---46--
%#-#
->
134
5----
-6
##-%
4%-
-
<#
<
#
><
#
-"
-
-
-)%
44
-
"-4>5-4
46
-%
-
-
-
-
H>
2. Policy Framework
5--
-%
-
-
-4)--
44%
-6
%
-
-4<"
%
-
->5-EC
-
8<T8UT;@OOU6
<
%
4#
<
>-6
"4#
-
-
-4
6--
#
K>
#
-
--
-#
-<>5---4
6##4
-
-4
6--4"
4#
<
/<6
4#
<
-4
>5-%
4"
<
<
-<
%
#-4#
<-
-6-
-
4
K4#
<
<
"6--4
>5-
/
"#4#
<
-
4"-"4#
<#
--
-
/
--4%-
-<#
%
>6"%
6-
--4
%
-
-6
4
H-#
p
4""
#4
#
4"#4-"4#
<
%
4KT8
>
EMU>5-6
-
#4
%
4#
<
%
""-
-<%
#
#
<4
#
>
:-"
%
4<
4%#
>
<-
%
%6-
"#
-
%T-
6EMU>6-
-
BF-$##-@
-
tension continues and in most urban areas the
"#4#
--
"%
4<
"4#
#>
6"-
4
--
!<%
-
-4<6
-
44--R
K>5-%
-
"
%
-
-4<#
K>5-6
-:-
@
84
8!T@88.U6--
4-.?-
##
TECU-
-46##
(#%
-
T
@88.@@@
3-
?K
<
%
U>5-
-
-446
-4-
4#
<-
-
%
%-
44<6
-%4%
6
<>@
<
%#4-"
4#
<-
-
4!-@88.
.@@@
%
#
#<4
&T&4"
-
-U4!
-
-#
4-
--
-
Table 1 Trends in urban hospital utilization rates (%) and average medical expenditure per
hospitalization (Rupees) across 42nd (1986), 52nd (1996) and 60th NSS rounds (2004)
5<44
4
T4U
4
H4T&>U
MO-
52nd
F
MO-
52nd
F
Public
GC
FG
MO
GCBB
2195
GC
Private
M
57
FO
EEG
GFF
EOM
'MO-&xOOF&4>OB63-OOM
->5-<6
#
<
#
6
-4
-6
-
-<"4
44#
<-
-
<#>@-#
#@
6
!#6--%
<
-
-
4-
-H4
-4"
-
-
4
<-4
>5--
!<
6-
#4"<
TU#%<
TEC
OOMU>
5-
-
-H4
-FndTECBx4
!#UndTEMx
<4
!#U
MOthTOOFx#4
!#U-6
"<
#T5
%EU>
5-"
)--
4%-
-
-4
%
/<
"
Oz-4"
-
-
>
R-<-‡8
<-
66--
#
>5-K
#"
4%-4
-
")>
3-
#4-4-
46
-4
-
-
<
%
6
<
/-nd
MOth-6--"
#%<
6
%6
T%UK-4
4
<
#-44>5-
!<
-
-
%-
4<-
#-
%<-
-
>
5--4
-
6-
"#
H4-4%-
-
6#E>z;38ECBO>Cz
OOF>8<-6"
#Ez
-4--
-4-
&
-(T&(U4
##>@
&(-
-
"/
%
-
-x6-
%
4#4
-
-
"6-
%
<
-4%-
--%
-
-
"6-
-
46-
""-
>&
--
;"#
%
-(
T(OEOU%%
K-%
-
-"%"6<
-
"4
#
--
-
<>
6""-(6#4#
one is not sure if the situation would have
-
-%%
-4<
44
#6K#
4%#
']5-
%
-(
aims to address the health concerns of the urban
4--
/
%
"
%-
-
%<
--H
4
<-
-
"<#4"--
-
-
%
4>5-6%
#
-
6)
4
-#-
44
6--
%
#
->^:--
#-
#%K4%)4"
4
-4T888U##<K4
-#
<)
<
4
#-"<
<
H-"
44
-
6---@884#>$-
44
-
6<-
#
-4%-
-<#
%
T3
4
-OEOU>
135
Box 31. Public health resources
availability
8%-
-%
44
%<
/
6-
6-
--
-
--6H4%
<
%66-
-
4
-
-
%
6-4K%EO
#-
6-
-
4
-
-
>(4
K(#%
%-
-4%-
-
-
%FOz4"
-
->5-6-64<
"%
-
-
6
#
"
%<
"---
>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
3. Debates and Key Challenges
%
##
-/
--
-
4")
-4
%H4>%
<-
"-
-
4
6-"4<
"
<6--
#6K%<
-R>5-6%
"<"-
-
%<
%
44
6-
"-
-#>4EO
-H4
"#
%--4%-
-
<#
4
<-%
-
-<#
6--6-#-6%
<
-
6#46--
64"
-
->
!#
4
##
4
"6
#
K
--
-
4<6
x##4-"
4"")
""-#%
4%4%<
-
%
-#
-4"
-
->
@
%
-
-
<
K6--64#-
-#<-#)ECO6---
"
136
-
6--
4"
-
-4
<4
-
-
4"
"
"
4%-
-
>5-6-
-6-
#
K4-4#S
-
4H4
4"
#
#
K#-
#
6
-
46-4"
-
-
-6
K
4"
/<-"
6
K4%-
-<#>
$-
<-
44%<
"
%<-
-4<
#444"
6->@
--
nineties, the state reduced its role by virtually
44
<6"#4%-
-
-6
4%%
%-
4
"#%
6
-
;38>5--#
-
-
-
6
K
4%
-
-6--H
6-
"#--#6-
--
---"
4"<--
4
#<
K46--/
6-
-->5-/--
"-
4
#
K%
-
-
6-
"
%"6-
%-
-
/#
6
-44
ailments as revealed by the trends from the NSS
-
-
"<>
34&(-4%-
-
<#
@
"#-
%
>%
OEO
%MOz-&>MO%TEF>F%
}U4%H4-
-
%<
"##%>5-
6K
%&>EEGOT
}U4
4
-%
44
T
#G>#
-
T&>Gx
B})4
4
U6--
-
-
UT3
OEEU>
@
6
-
"#4
"#4-
-
>
:
(#%
(4
4
6-
%&>E>MB%T
FCE#
}UOEE6%4"&>EGOTGO
}U4
4
-
-
6-
-
"#4T(;(OEEU>`
(#%
<p4%-
-
<#
##-
ECz
#%
<
#
GMz-4
#
T34
3
OOFU>5-
K
%<-
4"
)4
))4
#
"&>GOOOT
MM}U
4
4
6)-
%%<
---#">
`
44-4
6
6#
-
"
/
-
-
%
>R-<-
‡%
-
-
%-4%
4"
"#
>8""
4#"
care, as well as environmental health in urban
<
/
>5-
unnecessary medical care and hence a waste of
"
%>-%
/
<%
<
6
%--4%
4"
#
>5-4%"
/
<4%-
-
-4"
%
6-
"
%#
>5-%
-
-
#4<)>$
"-
-
4#
<6-
"
">8%-
-#
<
/
-4-<
4
"#
-
->:-
44#
<"
4"
%-
-4%#>5-
"
%#
H4>5
%4"
"
-
-
Box 32. Healthcare delivery in Puducherry – pride of public healthcare
8-<p4%-
-<#4%
-
6--F
"
-
>@
<%
6-"6)--
44
"
6>5--
-
"
6-
<
-"
4"#4<-
>5-4
4
4%H4-
-
"&>EMCE>z;
3#86--
<
"FC
K-)4
T44
4
4<
U
E>
K-)4
TE-4
4EOOO44
<U4-
4---#
<6--<>5
44-6--4%-
-4
%'44
E'OO'
44
E'OOO
'44
E'EOOO
FHB
#%
">
/<8-<p"
-
-
-%-<x@
(
<&
(
<(
<&
G
%-
EM>F>8-<-
"
4
-
-
"K
4
4
##
-
-
4
#
%64"<4
K
<
-5<
K<
4
<
>8-<4<
-
Oz%
>Cz"-
44>@-<
(
-
`
#6-
<4%
/
-
-
4
##
%
#4"
-
<
<
#4&>>
K-
%
>6-<8-<
‡R-
44
-
/
4%
"#-
"-
44
K44
6-
#
%
<###
-
-
--
/<
"%>R-
4%
%<
-
<
-"#--44
#46
4
6
-
4"
%-
-<->
'8-<(<
--4'-
->4-<>">
137
4%
-H
%
"
>@6
-
-
"
%5
%-H
<
%"-
-4-
health outcomes for urban India are certainly not
##
"--#
-
"
"
>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
6
-
"-H
#48-<
5<6---
#<%
44
-
#
%
4%-
-<#%<
-
/
4"
-
-
-
-#T
HGU>
Urban health resources as we have seen above
<-
#
>5-
4%-
-
/4#
%
4-"#4%
4"
-
-##%
>8#
<-
-
-4%
<
/
%
-%4#
<
%
4%-4
4
#-
"
<4"
4">5-
determinants of health and environmental
-
-K6
6
<#
%
4
-
4
"
4"<
--
6--%<-#
of the healthcare system and at the same
##4
-
%
<>#
-
#
-
-
%
-V&(>4<
"%
K%<-4#4
for these social determinants or environment
-
-
"
%
6
#4
%
-
-4"<>5-
"
6--
-<4
##-
-R-
%4#THGGU>
6"%
-
-
%-4#
<
"-4
T6--
"#
H4U#
6
K4<"">
5-(46
K
be sidelined and one can only conclude that
138
%
-
-4<<
4<6-
-"#6--4
-
-
-%
-
-
-4
#>5-<
#4
-
#4
"#-
#4
"#--
-#
K64"%
-
-
6--
4<64"
-
-
#
K>5-#
%<
-(4<#-
>
;"-
%"%%
-
-4<
"#
44%-
-
<#
<
-#<4
<
-4>5-
4
6-
"
<
"#
H44%-
-4
-
<
4
!#
4
##4-#
>R--4%
-
-<#-44"
%
#
%%>$
-"-4"
-
-
H4
4<
-4
<-4"
-
-
>5--
--
-
%
<>@
"4%-
-
-
-
"%
%
<>5-#
K
-
-
"#<-4%
-#
>$6-
/
6--4%-
-<#
"-4
%#
-%#4"
-
-
-%
/>
5-4"
-
-4
<
%
-
4
#4<
##
"#
/<4
%<
)
#
4
<"
>-
-
#
4"
-
-
#K<
#
%>
5-
H4
4
p
"
%<
"
%
-
-4">5-#4
K-
)
6--4#
K
matters worse and has affected the status of the
#
46--
<
%
-
T
U
%
4>
"-"#-
%
%
-4"
-
->"
<4-
"-"#
-K
%-
<
6
%#
%
%
-
-
44
<>5--
6-
-4"
#-43-p4"
-4
>5-<"
4"
-4
6"
%<-
Delhi Government under the condition that
-<6"z-)4
4
#
4
<
EOz%
#-4>:6-
)#4
-
#
4
6<
4--
3-6-
"
!#OOB
--4
%%<-
6---<-
>5-6
-
-4#%<-
-4
-%
-
-<4""<
4
#-
<
%">6"-4#
4#%OEE4---
-
--4
4"
#-4>#
<-
(#%
-%<-
-
"4#
%<
-4
-8%-
%
5$6--#
--4
4"Oz4
EOz
4
-4>5--4
6--
#-#6K6
-4
@
"#4#
H6
"-
%"
%
>
5--4
-
""4-
%
-
-
""#
%<#-#>
5---
-
-4"
%#4#%
<-
#-
#--
%
>
\$+&"
percent unless otherwise stated)
.
%
Urban
.
Urban
$"
T#U
8%4
™4
K-
108
>O
$4
-3™4
K-
EM
EF
-@
"
EO>F
F>B
8%:
<
GO
O>CE
8"
:
<
70
E>EE
(
<
52
E>C
@
(
<&
F
E>FC
$.
-
58
E>FC
$)
GL
BF
E>B
Institutional Delivery
M
>G
$)
%<3
77
E>CC
Delivery by Doctor
M
>GC
3"<8%:
<
29
>OB
)3"<
17
>CG
8)
ME
>EC
Ultrasound Use
FF
>B
-
Wasted
6-
Anaemia
FO
17
GG
MG
E>
E>G
E>G
E>EF
<(
@H
E)F<EC>
Women
(
25
M
E>MF
E>FM
$
#
E)F
Women
(
52
17
E>EE
E>M
@
-3"4#
")
<"
)44#)-
)44#x#-
G
82
CG
O>MM
O>CB
O>
846
71
>F
5
<
CG
G>E
;
<
K:
MO
B>
GE
EGBC
EFCC
BGF
E>B
O>F
E>EC
O>G
3
47
K5%
Diabetes
Asthma
3™
'™@x
-8OEO
#)
-4'%-->>H>
4‡˜EEŠ%K˜S
-
@@8&(
):)G)-4'666>-)
>
->-#
139
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
4. Policy Recommendations
† @%
-
<
<
4
<"
4#
<
%>"4%
-
-""
/
4#
<
>:
4
-
-4-(#%
(4
4
-
-%<Mz-
>34
"
CO4
4
<6--
a reasonable number, and this shows that we
H4
-4
<
#
T"<-6-
<EO)Ez
83T4
34
#U
6-%<-4%<#U>5--
-4
<)>3#
"<
-6-
4444%"
4"-<%##
%>
4
444
<#
<
<">5-6
#4"-
<-4%-
-<#>5-
#%"4#
<
"K4
-
-4
6--%
%
K%<
4
<#-
%-
6
"
>
† 8%-
-#
"#
health issues need immediate attention and
increased investments because they cause a
44-
-
-
-"#
#)">
:
(#%
--@
city both in terms of income as well as its
%-
H-/%
-K4
#4%
-
-"#>@4%-
-
"#
#4"#-
-
-4%
4"
#
%
">5-"
-
-<4
#
K-
#4"#>
† &
#
4
>&
--
-4
<4"
-
-
140
4<
>3
%%
%-
<
-
-
#4#
#>
5-
%
-#
4
#
!-
--
-
"
-->
† (##/
<
4
#4
-
"%
44
>5-
6/4
%
"<#/
<#
>5-4-
%
6--4-
_
<
-
4
$
%%"
<
%<%<
-
-
>5-
-
#
K
#
<>
† #4-"%
-
-
4<>8
#4
%
-
-#
-
"
<
#-
#---
"
44
-"
-
-
-
44
-6--
4-
-#%
@
4
<-4
-#6>
5-(
#6K
#
-
44
-
%
<
-
6--
#6K
"
-
-
<#>
† @%
7
-
""4)
%
4-
-
#<#
4<
##4#
%
4>:--"
#
%
-
-
#4"-
'
TU-%
H4
#4-"
4#
<
"-
4
-
-4TU4%-4
%!"
-
K
<##
K-#"#
%-
-<64-ECOp
TU"#
-
-
the various social determinants of health
4
##
<-
#
<
Box 33. Healthy Cities
What is a healthy city?
$-
-<<6---
-"
4
-
-
>$-
-<<
-
-
"#4">5-
<<
%
]-
-<^<
current health
>R-
/
###-
-
4
-">
5-R
-<8
##-
#4-
-
-
K6-%
>@6
---
$
&EF>5-R
4
##
#
%!"--4
-4%64%4"
"
<
>
Healthy Cities approach
5-
44
-K4-
----4
%
#"#4%-
-
-
">@<#4-
/<4
4
<"
<)
%
-#
-
->
#4#
-
44
-/"
"
4
-
-
"
H"6K%6
-<
>5-
'H44
###S
-4S
-
S
)
4
-4>
5-
-<
44
--#
-
-
-6K
%
4%4"
"
<
##<
>@
-4%
#4
-#>
Framework for action
-<--
$
&
#6K
-
-<4!6
"4>5-
#6K
%
4-
%<%->
† 3"4#
K>5-##%-
"#-
#
"
;##<4
>
† $6
%4%44>
† @<4<>
† %
44"
#-;"#>
† $44#
4
-4
K
4
6K
##
4<>
† 84
-8
##8
6
%>5
6-%
-%>/
<6%#4
-
-
6%
<
#4>
† 8
#4#
>$-"4#-4
-4
6
%##%#'-##<"#
4"
#4#-4
>
† "
#-%4
<
#4-4#
K
<
!#
#4"#-4
#4#
>
'
E>-4'666>>6->6-
)6)-
-)4"#
)-
-%
)-
-
"-
-<)6-)
4
)-
-<))6K6-
))
)-
-<)<
>-4'666>
>6->GF>-#
141
4"
%
K
-#
#
/<
>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
† (#4
<-%
-
-
<#
-%
-
H
4%#
H
"6--
4
4
<#-
#>$-"#
K-
##<
>%44>
142
† @
-
%"-
-
-
<#%-4"
4%
6-
"%
<#-
#
%<4%
6
#-#
-
-
$
>@
"
#4-"-
-
#
%<
6
%<
4%4
-$>5-4
6--4
#
H
>
-
-
>
A Human Rights’
Perspective for the Right to
the City
Miloon Kothari
5-<
<"<
/
<>-#
K
"
%
"%44
>5-
##
-4
-
-
-#>#%
-
)%
4
--4"
""
-
4/
#
44<%6
6->5-
in turn has led to an increase in the number of
444<
/
-
"
6-"<
%"-4>
@
-
"%#4
#
K
%<%
/
<
6|-
p
>R-64!T
###
##4HU
-
"
#
%6|-p
|4p
#
4
66-
""4
<6
<
>5-4
%%<"#--##
K6
<
-%--
-
"%#
4
<-->5-H
<
@
-
-
%
)
%
-
#4
right to the city
-#
-4>
1. The Right to the City within the
Human Rights Framework
5-#4"
-#
-"
@
-
4
#4#
-#
-%
44
-
-<6
<4"
4-
-<
-<
-#4"
4%#
%<#>
As already mentioned earlier in this volume,
-#"#-]&--<^-
"4
4%<
4
"
<
#
-6
#4%
44
"<"4
<-#
143
#
4">5-
to the elaboration of a World Charter on the
Right to the City.5-&55%"6
6
-%
-#
-
#4-#
-6-<4
>
5-4
#4#
-&55
%-%
-#
-
44')#
S"%<
-#
-S/
<S4"
S)S%
<S
<S
4
>@#4-
-
4
4
"
%<-%"4<
4%<
%<
44>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
2. Expanding the Right to the City
144
While the Charter #4-"#
4"
4
44
K6
#
K
<
--6"
%<
-
-#
-
-
"
K"<4
6-
4
-#
"
%
4>5-&55#4
-
"
/
<>@
#<--
<<4
<
<-6
<6K6
<%
<%
#
4
#
<
!
6--4
-6
44'
<US6
SS-
-S
6K)"-S
S<-
4
-#S%<S/
<S4
4
S
#
S
S"###
-#
#
-
##"#
#%<
>
5-&55-
#4
--
#
-#
#%<
--"4#
x
4
4
#x
%-4
<
"<>
@#4
-
-&55--
--
!
"
-%
"->
5---4"<
6
%#4
44
">@
#4
--##
44<
6
4%4
>
-#
-
4
#4
-
"4
4
#H
#4>5-
K%6-
"-
-
-#%
%6K4
%
4
>:
-#)%
6K4
<6#-%4">
--4
#
K-
%
>-
not be situated in locations where residents face
"#
-
-
4
<
K>
Indivisibility of human rights
5-%
44-&55-
-#
-
4
"%>5-
-#
-#
-
-<>5-#
-
-#
-ˆ"4
#
"#
-ˆ
#"/
4<<"
4
#
#
#4#
>
5-
-#
--
#%4
4
inter alia, the
-
/
"
/
-T
%
"K
Non-discrimination and inclusion
#
-#%
-
women, men, youth and children who choose
#
K-<--#x4"
their economic status, identity, caste, class, race,
H
6K"
4"6---<
]-
%
^]>^
--%
4
%
/
>@
K-
<
-%
<>
"<#-
"/
#
!<#-<p"4
%
6
-"!<#
>
@"
-
4
"#<4
"4#
6
-
#H
#
#H
-%-
4"
4
-
-
]-
^<4
>("-
4
-##%#
subjected to forms of abuse and violence by the
#
-<>$)"
<
)
%
<
6%
%-
-%-6K4
-<#<>
5-44)#
-
#4
"
##
%
%44%<
#
K
-
>5-44
-%
#4#
<
6--444"
%6>5-&55#%
-
-
"
4
4
4
>
Priority to vulnerable and marginalised
groups
5-44)#
4
4
4<%"
---##
4>
5-4%46--
-
"%-
<#
such as the Dalits and nomads, the homeless,
-46-
%
6#"#"#6K
#
6KH6K4"
6-#
@.$@3
H
#6K-#
<4
4
-
-"4
>R-
--44
#%"-6#
4>4
#
%
K
4--
--4>:
4"%#
4
6-
%x
%-/
<4
4
4
<>5-
6""#
K
6
K-
%4%4
4%
%
46-
%>:
--#---<6#
4#
-6-
/
""
444
4
#4<#>$#
"
#
#
<
%/4#-
-
#
4>
5-&55#
###
4"<>5-#"
#
<4"
6
4
-
-4
#
<6
K
>:
"%
4<-6-<
#%4"
-"
/
-
<-
6-">
Gender equality
5-&55-
%4
--
<-
-/
4
6#p-#
-><
4
<#
%<4
-
4
%>
#46#p--4"
<
<
##">5-
""4
6-6##
K
-
6#-
"/
%-
4%
4"
4
4%
4
6
K#
K4
KT%-
4%
4"
U6K4
4
4
##<4
>5--6#
"--#)
%
6K-
%46-
<4
>5-
4#
-"6#
4
victims of domestic violence, and hostels for
#-
6K6#>R#p
4
4
<4
4
"
6
4#
%
/
%"4#-<>
145
Interdependence and sustainability
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
5-&55#
-
4
x-
-
4-
"-
-#
-->@44-
44
-6-
4
6-
H"#%<
<
!4
--%
->5-%
-
"-<
4
-%--#"
the detriment of those from a lower income, or
-
4>5-44#
4%<
%<#%4-
4
<6-
-"#
use of land, water, electricity, and other basic
>5-%
%-K
4
H>
146
5-44
-
%
4%#
#
<-<
>5-&55--
"
%<6--4-
-
-
-<
"#>;"-
-
#
-
-
#
44
4#%
#4<4
"4#>R-44-
"%
4-
-
-
--
/
##%
4
>
Participation and consultation
"#
4
4
)#
K
4
-
-#
-
<>
$/
6-
4
4
#
<K<%
"
#
<4
>5-
444##"
4
)#
K6-
<>
7
"#
#
6-
-6-6%<
<
%<-
>5--
4
4
--4
4
4
-<>$-
<--
"--
"#
4
>5-44-
4
4
-/
%%
-<>:
<"#
must include civil society and social movements
-"4#
#4#
<
4
>
Social function of the city and property
5-<
4
must ensure that it meets the needs of all its
>5-44-]
44<^-
4
to ensure that land is not diverted to meet
---
-H4-
4>5-|4%44p#
%%<"#"
|4"
4p>:H
#4-44
#
#%
6#4
"4%-4%-
-4
>5-
44<
#4-
--%#-
-4#/
<
6-4>
5-right to land#
%
4-/
<6-4
<
<4
>5-
--"<6
#
44<>5--
<
K-4"
<
"-
>5-6
4
"
-K
4
%%
and accumulation, enable the sustainable
"4##
6
4
>7
6
4-
4%
4"-
K"
#
44
-"K-44
##
<#%<
>4
4"%
"
6-
"
%<
%
4-%4"
-4
#
<6
K
-/
>
Recognition and respect of diversity in
economic, social, political, spiritual and
cultural life
5-<#"<
#
4#
#
4>@#
446--
%
"
4"4
-4
>
5-&55
--
"
"<>
Progressive Realization
###-)#
-#
->5-<###
#4"#-
-#
-
-6%
>5-
means that, at all times, states must be able
#
-
-<
K4
4#
/
"
#4"#"
4
4
-
6-
<"
/
>
7
K
%!<-
#4#-#
->7
<"##
4-44
###
#4"#
-
"
<66-
%-#
K#-4
-"
-#
-
>
Non-retrogression
<"#
#4
-
"
4<
K
"#
-
6!4
-
-%
-#
--
#4-&55>3%
#
---
##
or omission, that lead to an increase in those
"
/
"
-###-#
->
3. Need for a Sensitive Interpretation
of the “Right to the City”
R-
-44#4
---<
#4
#
6-
-&55
4"#4
>H4
#
-
-6
<-&55<
%#4##
K46--#
-44>5-
-
-&55%
>
5--#
-
44
--&55>
$<"
-#
-
#
"
-&55>
@#4
-
-&55
%
4
4
%-K#4
6--#
K>8
%-
"44<"4#>5-&55
is also not about concentration of wealth and
--
6>@
<
-#
K
4"
K-
%)4#---
K
%-"%
@
p
>$###&55#
-
#"6-4
-
<#
K
6-
<"-
#
K
-"
%<6)#
-#
44-#
K">$<
#%
##-#
-4#-
##
--
6
-4"
">8"
"#
-
-
"<
%
"-
%-&55
%
-#
->
5-&55
-%
#
"4#>5--
#H-%->@
%
4#
##--
-
-4->
@#4#
-&55#-
]<%
^
%
6
#
K4
-H4-4>5-
<p6K
-6-%
#
-#--<#
%"
/
-
%
">
147
5-"#%4"<
ameliorated, in situ
4%>5-<
must not be subjected to forced evictions and
4
#>5-%-<p4
-<p#<#%
K6
6-#
-#
"-->
4. Countering Obstacles
† 5-44%<-4-
K-&556
>5-&55
in our current reality, however, is limited to
<x-6--
"
-#
4
46%
#-<>(
<4
##
"
<
-#
-
<
/><--
such dynamic actions will we be able to ensure
-
-&55
-4
#
--#
-
4
<-#
#
#4#
-6>
<
"#'-
Box 34. The World Charter on the Right to the City
5-R-
-&--<
"6
-
H
%4
#
>@46
44
-K-#
-
#
#>$<--
-&--<
]-/
%
6--44
%<#
</<
!^>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
5---
%
H44
-&--<'
TEUH-4
#
#
#-<STU
-<
%
44<STGU/
<
)#
STFU4
44
4"
%
STU
###-4"
S
TMU4#
-
<#<
4"
H
4>
$/--
-
]g>>>k
--###
#
-
#%
#%<"<
"###%4
#
-
44#
<"6-<>^
<#
<-
"-
#"-R-
-&--<
<##
"#4;
#
4
4
--
"#
>
-
-87@@-
:#%
&#-
%
@
-7
$#
$
8#$$$#
-%"
<(4-@
%"
<<&--&-
"
)$@5$5
6K
"4
#4"--
>
5-R-
-&--<-4<
6--
-)4-E
-##&V
>5-
--
6
"OOO
-R
:#8$
>:6-R
:#OO;
#"#
-"--
>
$#4""--
6
%
-OOF
:#-
$#
_
>@6
-44#%OOF
-R%
:#
4
V
<OO
-R
:#8$>
'
6$>
?
$>%
8
-&--<'&-&4%
-4>$@)
5$5OO44>)M>
7>5-R-
-&--<)$@5$5@OOM>
148
#4#
-#
-###S
† #
66-
-#
-
S
† @#4#
-#
-%
!#
##
#-
-#
-<#-
-
<%
-#
&-
-4
&
44>
† -#
-%
#<
4
"4#4
#
<S
† 4
6<"#
#4#-#
-
4
adhere to the World Charter on the Right to the
CityS
† 3"4#
4
-#
""4#
46-
4
-
##
--#
#
S
† @#4#
<#
-K
6--#
K>
5. Conclusion
As elaborated above, in order to counter the
%
<-4
H-6K
-
%
4-|--<p
4
#4
%-#
-
%#
46
44
#%
"
<>$
#"#
-4
-#
"<x-
-#
-
%
/
<#
4
#
!>
Across the world today, individuals, movements
#4
--#
-
/
-
"-6K-
-
<
%
4
"
-
%"-44
##"
/
#>5-
"
<
-4
#-&55
44-
#4
-#
-
-
<
-<
#
-6x6--<4
#
-
"4<
4<>
149
Notes on contributors
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
Upendra Baxi
Emeritus Professor of Law,
University of Warwick
150
4
H<#8
7
6
-"<R
6K
-
"<3-
-6
87
6
3-TEBG)EMMU
R
6KTEM)
OOU>-
"
.-
Universities of South Gujarat, University of
3-
<35-@
7
6@>8
H-
-
#4
"
-<-#
-
transformative constitutionalism, law, science
-<
-"<<<
6`K"<;%
7
68
#
R
-7
6$#
"<
3K7
6-
"<5>
-
%--%K
O
--#
6
#>
#6K'5-:#
&-S#
&-
8-#
R'
<>6K4%
'$5
5-'$4V
5-
$!#@
V
$"#>
Solomon Benjamin
Independent Researcher and Urbanist
#!
#
4
-
%
>)-
@$"
T@$U&
-
8<8
#T&88U>!@$
he was a member of faculty at the University
5p348
>-
8-3
(
p3#(@5
#%
(
->
-K
6%
"
"4#
#4
%
4"<4
#<>
-
K
@
-%
#
-
"#
4##
##
-
#4
#
)%
>-
-
%K%
#4<#4%-
%<-7@7
8<
#%
(
-
6
4
4"6
!
-$&$@
&
6
4
!
6-
:-;#
4
->
Ram B. Bhagat
Professor and Head, Department
of Migration and Urban Studies,
International Institute for Population
Sciences, Mumbai
&
#>-
6K
8
34
#(
%
@
@84
T#%"<U(#%
@
>
-
#
%
"##
4-<-<
4>-
4%-F
-
-
!
K;$
84
84
"#
4V
54
;
4-<$
8@
V
$-4<$
8
84
V
$
8
(
V
"
#
8
RK<>-
%
6--@8RK;4
%
#-
"
(
4OOE)
OOG>-
%
##%-@8
4
-3#
4-<$#
OOM)OEO
#-
8-
4-
(
K-OOG)OO>
<6K
)
-
"#
@#
<#
T.@U84
"#
@@8%<-(<"#
:;"#@
-4!
-"
&
-(>
Sharit Bhowmik
Dean and Professor, Tata Institute of
Social Sciences, Mumbai
-
-6#K6K
3
8
5
@
(#%
@
-
--(
#
Š7
%>-
8-3<#
-"<3-
(
p3
<#-"<#%
<T6
(#%
U>
-K
-<
4
%-%
#
the industrial labour and trade unions, the
4%#
#6K
-6K)4
"
#
<>4%
']<
@#
#4<#(
-
-
^TUS
](
#@#
#4<#'5-
(#%
^-%
@R
-
OOBSš%
8"<@8<"
8%8
4
(#%
š$&8
4%<--
@)
@
<
@3$OOM>
Basudeb Chaudhuri
Director, Centre de Sciences Humaines
(CSH), New Delhi
%-
-3-
#
-&
--
:-(<:
4
$
&T
&--
/U63-
$!3
of the combined social sciences research unit of
&@
T
@:8U>6
$
8#
-"<
:
&
-:6
-
p@p$8
>-
8-3
#-"<8
E8
-*%
$
($#-"<
>
4
4%#
%
"4##
4
#<>
Ravi Duggal
Senior Trainer and Health Analyst,
International Budget Partnership,
Center on Budget and Policy Priorities,
Washington, DC
&
"3
!-@
8
-4%OOC
-
8
-4@
"
-
-
<>-(
p3<
(
##-"<
#%
<>-
%""
-
-
-"6
-
"
%<46K-
-
#-4"
-
-
-
-<#
4>
include health economics, health systems, health
4<%
"
-#
----
-
4"-
->6K<
6-
)"#
-
:
&
-##<
-
R@$@3
/<
-
$5-#T$5U--
-
"4#>OO--
%
4
%
"
EE$
>
Véronique Dupont
Senior Research Fellow, French Institute of
Research for Development (IRD), Paris
.*/34
-6
#
4-<
-:-@
&
-3"4#T@&3U-
-
]3"4#
^T(&OE
@&3x"<8
E8
-*%
8
:
U>-
##%
-@
-$
T8
U
6
-3-
#
63-#OOG
OOB>#
--#-
"%-
151
interrelations between the transformations of
#4
44
#%<
%
4
6
-4
)4
H@
6-
3->4%
'3->
%
4
#
3T)
6->5
Š3>.
(
-
x3-
OOOUS7
.$g5-<-
$
kT)6-3>;>*8
OOBUS]5-3
#3-
;%
<^
T@
V
%
&
&
-OEEU>
Joyita Ghose
Independent Researcher
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
V<
;-
4
-
%
4
>-
-
(
p3#4
<@
#-"<H
-p
38
#-"<
3->-
6K
-
-@#
3"4#6
3->
152
Miloon Kothari
Former Special Rapporteur on Adequate
Housing, United Nations Human Rights
Council and Executive Director, Housing
and Land Rights Network, New Delhi
(?-
6
444#%
OOO%<-#
&-
-
4
&
44$/
>
#
""4
<
-##T6-#
&-
U-
---6
-
---
--
/
-
<
4
4
6
->(>?-
-
H"
H4-
-
->-
--$
&
8
##-
%
@
p
7
&-6K
##%-
@
;###
&-5
@"#T@&@5@U>@
<
--
%4
<
"
-
6#p-
-
44<-
%
%
-#4
-
-
/
-
-
->
Diya Mehra
Post-doctoral Fellow, Centre de Sciences
Humaines (CSH), New Delhi
3<
(-
-6%
3<
#
-#
TU63->-"-8-3
$-4<#-"<
5H
$OEE>-
6K
-
-
-
<3"463-
-
)-
63->-
6K
-
-<"<
6`K>4%-6K-
44
in a number of different edited volumes on
urban India and focuses on the historical and
#4
<"4#@
4
<3->
Kavya Murthy
Postgraduate Student,
Delhi School of Economics
?
"<
(-<
4
<#-3--#
66K
-8
##
3>-
6#4
<-
#-
]
^6--%
-4H4
#-
<
%
->
Bhuvaneswari Raman
Post-doctoral Fellow,
French Institute of Pondicherry
-"
6
&
#
-
%
4
>--
-
-4
-7-
#
8
T7U?
-
#
the University of Amsterdam, Netherlands, and
-"<#-
#?
6
"4#
-
R
K
->--
H4
6-#4#%
4"<
"
-#-
"6K6--
%
8"<$"
8
##>
--4
#<
%
"
/
<
"4>3>&
#
%
-
8-3#7?>
Stéphanie Tawa Lama-Rewal
Research Fellow and Deputy Director,
Centre d'Etudes de l'Inde et de l'Asie du
Sud, Paris
*4-
5
6
7
#
)&6
-6
4
4<-
8
)%
WXW@W$
T&)U>
-
%
#
<@
>
4%
|<@
'
8
3%
p-$
(4
<$
#V
GOO
|;"@
W(4p3-&
OOT)6-V›&U>
Marie-Hélène Zérah
Research Fellow and Head Urban Studies,
Centre de Sciences Humaines (CSH), New
Delhi and the French Institute of Research
for Development (IRD), Paris
(
)*+,*
-
8-3-%
#-8
@%
>
She is currently a senior researcher with the
@&
-3"4#T8
U
4-#
63->-6
""4!
<
#%
-4
-R
8
#-R
K
>
--
6KH"<-
6
44<
@
6
-%
"
4%-
%K
6
3->#
-
--%
"
@
>
153
References
$
K
>8-
K.?>&<(7
'5#H4(#%
>#
8
RK<.FOEOO4>GM)MC>
$-6
(>>|84
8<-
-56-8
p#
8
RK<.
FMEOEE4>CC)EO>
$-!
(>-$8>#4
7
&'@)
.
>@'7
&#@
>
EO'#4
7
&63-
8%
OO>
$-!
>847
6
V>
%K8%@7
>63-7#
EB>
$>#6-#'$<&#3->63-
)$
Š.K
EO>
$
>3H4'(
KR)
&
(#%
>#
8
RK<.FEGEOOM4>GF)GF>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
$:>R)38)_@);
#-4
#
;)
.8%4
'-
%3-OEO>
$!
V>
6K
8%4
(#%
>#
8
RK<.FEE
OOM4>EFO)EFM>
$8>
$>8
>8-
K.?>RK6--(
K>$44
-&%
#@
)8<&
-RK8
4FB>R
KOEO>
$
$>5
4
8!
--%
8'@
@#4
$#(-<>@
@5-<63->OOB>8-3>
$
%8>:
4
-(
‡-%-5
#
8)%
-
>
3"4#
-
.FOOO4>CB)OE>
$3>5--<'84"-@
8
>@'%
>&;-
T>U
63-H"<8ECB>
$4-
#V>8
>&3"4#8
3-
"
-$4#(#%
>
"#
%
.OEO4>OE)OF>
#>%
5
4(#%
>#Š8
RK<.FEFMOOM4>EC)F>
#;>%
5
48<
84
-"#(
'8
$%<
-:4>#
8
RK<.FFGGOO>
154
KV>
&>44(>7
>
5
K-$K>%
8"<
5
4'5-
(#%
>(#%
R
KOO>
KK?>8
<R
'R
8
/<
R
>5
-
@-;
4-.MOOE4>EFG)EMF>
%(>@
(
&--<>OOC4>E)EG>
!><5@
>@'-;'7
5
-%
83"4>$3
7
"
7>&<T>U4>GB)C>7
-
8%
7OO>
!>;".-8(4
8
'7
#-$-
8
-%
"-8>@'%
;"
(
#'@
@
">4>EG)G>8>>>&
>
T>U63-@@8$OOM>
!>@
>;
8
&
"$/H44
#4
>48
4)$@5$5-3"
;75@
%
3"4#$#
#OEO>
(-
>#3#
-84
%
3->@'@
5
#%
$
'88
8%$>(
-
"
T>U63-4
OOC>
"K
$>6.
3'4
86
@<-(
K(4
3->@
V
.EBOOG4>C)C>
6
,>?>
R3@8
<|5-.<36%
;"
>8
4
(%
7
3#
<x#4
@
-$
3%
p
#
34
#"
8
(#%
"<OO>
H>(
&#
KR
8<&#S;"
&-V
3"4#'$4>@'R
;"
('56
<
"#
<
%R
7
6>4>EE)GO>8-44$>;6
);
&>(
-
"
>
&
#
-
>T>U
@
#%"<8OEO
>
H>R
%@#4<
"#'-|"V%p--4
4->V
#
&-
-"#.EEOEO%4>G)FF>
8>&
>H-"
(##R
@
'#
#-
3
>#
8
RK<.FMOEE4>FB)M>
)K#
T"U:>(<
4
(<
7
84<‡4
V
$-4<.FEOOG4>ECB)EE>
!
#>&
#
>%
;"
8"<
>RK8
4E>#-
#
@
3"4#34
#-8%8<"<#-
#E>
!
#>;"
#
8"<
>"#Š%
.
EOOO4>G)M>
155
!
#>&
#
>%
;"
8"<)RK8
4M>#-
#@
3"4#34
#-8%8<"<#-
#OOE>
!
#>%
7
5
#
8)4#>;#.GOOF4>EBB)
ECB>
!
#>&
#
>%
:8;4-
'65-
-
4%<-&
-468
7
>@'7
;"
@
'
3
<>>V
<
$>8
K
-8>-
#
T>U63-H"<8
OOM>
!
#>(
%
#'7<@
%
<>@'$#
%<
34'5
#
"-6;%
>>
!);-
>T>U63-
OEO>
-R>"<
<(
'5-88%"3"<;!
@
>
3"4#
-
.FEOEO4>CCG)O>
$>
#4
<@
>@'
5
<>>:>T>U63-H"<
8EM>
-
$>?!6
$>%
R
44<>&#-&#>#
8
RK<
.FOOO>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
-
&>>|$-(
#@
(
@
p$
8
(
V
.EBEOOC4>E)EO>
-
&>>3
?>>
(
-
8>>8
%
(4
;6-@
4%-8!&4@
@84
(#%
OO>
-
&>>|@
(
@
'$-4"(
(‡p$
)8
84
V
.EOEO4>GE)F>
-
;>
'5-(-@
-%
>OOC>
-
;>5-7-<@?6'"5-%
8
-&--<
(
3->"#
%
.EEOO4>EB)EF>
-6#K?>7
8.>#
8
RK<.FEOEO4>
E)EF>
#<>7
64
-;
4-86>7;8>EF>
#<>7
684<
-;
4-<.'5-:-"<
-;>$
-$
$#
;
4-.GEOOG4>EE)FE>
(>RK
-"#'7#-#
@
>
%
@
.GEE4>)EC>
8>8(#.#4
<@
>R
-3"<
R
-8OOG>
156
#
V>5-(
K
#
K
@
RK
'36-#5-
7
%
-<$-#
%
@
>$#
#H"<8OOG>
>5-;
&#
@
-'.
%
7<@#
&
3"4#>@'84
;%
@
>$&
>4>EBF)EE>(;K
R#
3
<
KT>U7&OO>
6$>?
$>%
8
-&--<'&-&4%
-4>(5)8<8
4))$@5$5>8
OO>
>56
8)4:
#6K#4
(#%
@
>"#
%
.EBEOO4>MB)CC>
>
7
-84
>
Š7
.ECGEGOO>
<V>8%&#
4>#
8
RK<.GEEOOF4>
EEE)EEM>
>(#3"4#;
'@
<&4OO'()5#
$44
63-'
(<
8
##
@#4#
;"#@
OO>
_@>48
4;
.8%4
'-
63-R)38)_@OEO>
-
K
%
<3>44
8%8
';
%
(<
@
>-$
.EFEEE4>
E)GE>
-
#4
K
K-#&>5
@<
%
H"<863-OOM>
-
-K>;"
-8
-
>@#4
3#
-4>
#
8
RK<OOG4>B)MC>
-
-K>"<>#
8
RK<.FFOO4>)EOC>
-
K-
>(K-4
-<
<$>(43#%
R)'"#@
)
8"<;
`->6`K84
OOC>
-
K-
>(
%
@
>(#OEE>
-
!8>5-8-;">&84
8(-R>
#%
"<8OOF>
&>;%
"<:"&-
">;"
OOC>
;>R
-#'6
<
)7"
-8
>(
-@5-<>OOB>8->3%
&
8
>
%>-
';"
;"#
<@
>
#%6`K
#%"<8OO>
157
8>
R
44<R
6
;
5
#
)@Š
)@@56
@
>3-
8
OO4>G>
44(>-
-
<
>8%5
4%
$
%<(#%
@
>8<
&
-RK8
4R
KOOBFG>
8>R
7
68"<
3"4#'R
&#@
>H"<8
OO>
3p#3>&44-:
%'5-3(#%
@(>(#%
H"<8
OO>
3
4
&>-&>5-((
->#
8
RK<.FMOEO4>
EM)EC>
33$>3-3"4#$-<TEMOU3
(
8
3-63-'3-3"4#
$-<>
3-K
8<
$K>(
#
3"4#@
#
3"4#
&
-8
4>EGOO>
3"4#8
##>
3>5--8
-'5-#$65#>76`K'
4
EC>
3>5-(<<
4
>R-<
4
#5#4--R
:
"<6->
7
K6
KOOO>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
3
<>5
34
#'"-#4->"#
8
3'<
4
.OOG4>CFB)MO>
3
<><-R'7
6
5-5-R'7
6
;
4-<>4>MB)CG>V>
>T>UHH"<8OOF>
3>(
);
?>56
$44
%
@
>RK8
4
@:
œ
8-*<>8-<OEE>
3-4
>#4
<@
'$
.6>63-8OOG>
36
.
#
;>##@
>$-#
-
">3-8K@
OO>
3<8>-
#
$>
#
>7
5<'@5-‡@$RK8
4OM)OG
@%
$
>63-OOM>
3-
-6
.>&6<-'$
<%
<
8>%
@€>
-
K
%
<3>-
-$>T>U63-H"<8EC>
345>3
&>8%
-
"(#%
@
>$
8
84
V
.EOOF4>B)FO>
3
(>5-
<4'(#%
EMMO85#>63-H
"<8OEO>
158
3
&>K:
-4
-@
>#
8
RK<.FFGG
OO4>EF)EB>
3
&>:
/<
"
$
-
>5
K.C
OEE4>)EE>
34.>)4
3
&
3-'
_
‡
;#.GOOF4>EB)EB>
34.>#3#3--EO'$$44
>#
8
RK<.
FGCOOC4>B)CB>
34.&
#
-
>
-/
#3->-@"-
V
<%
];"
^>@'6:#%
;"
@
>-(6K
>4>GE)GFG>@>>$>
V4RT>U63-
OOC>
34.
)`
#K<(>>8
#3
&
#%
:
"
'3-(#%
>&"
3$"
.GMMOO4>CG)GO>
34.>*
#
%
44
"#>@#4
4/p*
#4/
„3->&"5(.OE$4OEO4>)F>
&4
%>$
%@
'
#OEO>:
7>
@
p6(
'3#
8
#&#>(
"<
(
8OOM>
:.>8
<
K>8K4<7>R
5
%-$
3R
%&
--8‡R
8
#>R
-3>>OO>
:#
>'#
&-5
#'8"&-
8"3>63-H
"<8OOC>
:>
5
<>63-H"<8EM>
:V>
V>:
$-4<@
>@'5-"<
<
<(
@
>>V>:./>T>U7Š#4
<OOE>
:V
4<
#-
>|H4p
@#
5-<
8
5
#
>#
8
RK<.FFGOOM4>C)M>
;--$>8%)8"
8"
8%‡8#8
-4-
$
5
K:>
#
8
RK<.FO"#%EOO4>FEF)F>
;--$>5
6
7
#
)&6
>3#
8>R#
7
8%
@
>
63-5K
KOO>
;6
.>%
#4
#
8>$4.GCEOOM4>B)E>
;%$>-(<<
4
-(<-
'R-
337
5(
K‡@
3"4#8
&"6.FEOO4>E)O>
159
;%$>5-&-#'37
(
‡@
V
%
&
&
-.GEFOOB4>MB)BEG>
;?>8"<
8
'
"
45
4@
p%
@#
#<>63-H"<8OO>
;@>(<%
3"4#
(<%
#4<#
8"<$"
>
V
6
-
-
%
&6
(x""6>;"#@
>$"
%
'
-4'!#>>64)4
OEEOE@;""6>4
;@>(<%
3"4#>
##%
'&463-'
(<%
3"4#;"#@
>EC>
;@>(<%
3"4#>
8<63-'(<%
3"4#;"#@
>E>
;@>
-8<OO63-'(<
-
:
#<R
;"#
@
>OO>
;@>&4-EE-:"`
8
TOOB)EURK;4%
6-:
#&4(<
%
8"<$"
;"#@
>63-
OOM
>
;@>(<%
3"4#>
%
5
48<63-'(<%
3"4#;"#@
>OOM%>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
;@>
#
-(###<@
'$&4>;"#
@
>OOM>
;@>(<
%
8"<$"
>
%
%
8<
OOB63-'(<
%
8"<$"
;"#@
>OOB>
;@>
%
8<'(<%
3"4#-;"#@
OOC>
;@>(<%
8"<$"
>&
!"$6
`!
;#):
<8
>63-'(<%
8"<$"
;"#@
>
OEO
>
;@>(<
8"<$"
>&4-###
63-'(<
8"<$"
;"#@
>OEO%>
;4>5-8%#-%
88<
37
$#
>#
8
RK<.GEOEM4>GF)GG>
;
$>&#
&-':
--
4
7
#
<>7
8
"((
OEO>
;>8
-)H<'-#@
"
<>
;4
>(
<<
%
3"4#'$
<3-ECB)EE>($
.EEBE4>ME)BB>
160
;4
>5-7
8#_
&
!>3-@
H4G(
<OOC>
(>@'5-#%84<>@'84<&
'&6-
$-4
5
>E)FB>(
T>U
#%
#%"<8EC>
5-#
#R
.>
#
@<8
#%
<8
8"<8>OOE>
V>8
8
4
&4
-%
8:#&
-3->
#
8
RK<.FO(
-EOO4>EOFE)EOF>
V>$##46#>%"
"<8
%
;"
@
>#
8
RK<.FMOOB>
"<3>5-&--<>67&"6.G4#%)%OOC4>G)FO>
,>(&>T>U@
(<'
<(#R#@
>63-H"<
8OO>
%(>|5-
-RR-'$$-<p>EM>
R>R>5-3#
&'%
8
4
-@
p$
"<>$
"<.MECM4>FE)C>
>
;
#'
4-3%>63-
8%
OEO>
>3?K
‡>
63-OO>
->
(#
-:
68
#%
&6
'-"
3"4##%
<<EOO)E>%
<.COOE4>Gx>
@)7&>:
):(&4'&63-p%
%
$4
-<‡
%
@
)
7
&-6K>63-OO>
@)7&>$##>$##>
7
&@-
-@
>$
&4-#
&->
%
@
)
7
&-6K>63-OOF>
@)7&>$##>$##>
7
&-
-@
>
%
@
)
7
&-6K>63-OO>
@)7&>5-OEO##6
-;
#'R-R
-‡R-##‡
%
@
x-$
&
8
##
7
&-6K>63-OEO>
@)7&>8
34':"
-OEO##6
-;
#>:
:
&4(EF
%
@
x-$
&
8
##
7
&-6K63-OEE>:
):&4(EF>
#
->#4<#
R
3
>63-6K4
4OOC>
#
->56
68"<7@
>#
8
RK<.€7.OEO4>GC)FC>
161
-#
$>5-84-
>8%@.EMB>
V>$44
$>
-4>8%.CEM4>ECB)OF>
-
V>33#
3
'
%
#3-4>ECB)EEO>
"<
K<>EB>
(>&%<&'5-H44
7
-(
444
7
@
#
%
<>$#
-.GFOOC>
#
&-R
->8
<-|##
p'##
.
#
&->6`K
#
&-R
-E>
@
@84
OO
-
7"-
@
:
#<
-"<T:)GUOO)OM(<
-
:
#<R
;">@
>
@
84p5%
"#
#
&->&-x$&4-
:"
8-8(#%
>@85&>(#%
OO>
V
>|R-<-R.p‡5-@
(
-:-Rp7
3#
<>@'8
()
#4@
-
>G)F>>V
8>.
.T>U63-
OOC>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
V
-
.><
>R
<
-&#>#
8
RK<.FEEE-(
-OOM>
V
>,*
-()>@>&"5(.OG!)4#%OEO
"'
4"#
<"<V
(
)*+,*
-OEO4>
B)>
V
>(
K3-
R#V
>63-OO>
V
>
R#p
<>56
;@"<>&
-:>3-V
OEO>
V
<
;>5-;"
$
>(
K3#
3"4#34
%>#
8
RK<EB4>FOB)FE>
VK&>?<7>(K-4
-<
<8>5-84
#,63-H
"<8-#>
V-
>&8<3>5-6@
H4OEE>
"
%
'-4'H4%>
#44))4<)OOO>-#
V-
>&.RK(>;"
-;'3#
&4"
7
-43-p
#>R
K8<&
-RK8
4OO>
V(8>#
-@#4"3K)R
@
V(
8
##R
44<
R@:OEO>
162
V-&((
K
&>
6#
8"<$#&;4@
>#
8
RK<.FOEGOO4>EGGBxF>
V-8>>%V>H46-"<
(
448
#
;
4-
@#
<#>"#
%
.EFOO4>)FO>
?
-
$>@#4
(
#
-4
6K>#
8
RK<.F
OOB4>OMG)MM>
?
"
!>:-
-8%4
'4
8
%4
>8%.
EOEEB4>CG)EEG>
?-?
-
&>>|5#4
<
(
@
p;.MGOEO4>)F>
?-?
-
&>>T-#U|5#4
<
(
@
'&
8
-
$
:
p
44%
#
8
RK<>
?-
>
-(-
>H@<
(#R#(#%
#
8
RK<OOB4>EB)EGG>
?-
>|R-
-$
;
-&5‡$-#
%
'$<-4
3%5
43"4#8!p>OO>
?#
><(#<
7
@<>#
8
RK<
.FGEOOOC4>B)MF>
?-
(>5-#
&-$/
)@
p###
-56
&
>V
-
#
&-##.OOG4>EGG)EFB>
?-
(>?
#
>-
-<>#
&-$/
7
#
&-##63-OOM>
?#
;>7
<:>.
;"
'K
8
4@
(4>
@';"@
p(4>*4-
5
6
7
#
)&6
V›&T>U3-&OO>
?#
&>;%
-
8
(%
%
@
>
("#
.BEOOC4>BB)M>
?$>|(
H
<%
;6-@
p-M-3-
K
(#
7@@86.FCGŠFOOB4>F)F>
?$>8"5
<-%
83-'&5
:
84">
%
@
.COOF4>)BF>
?$>8
#%
;6->#
8
RK<.FMOOEE4>
EO)E>
7%">5-84
>H
K6EE>
7%">7„
"G+#*8
>#
$-4OO>
163
7>]@&
)%
(
-
)@&#"-K-^6
-
@"@
(
'.
K-p.6
)$@5$5OEO4>EB)EG>
7%$
K-
>&4
"-#?K'$$#%<
-#47
&<#?
K
8%$
ŠR
K
OO>
(
-
"
3>##
4
74
'
@
.
%<$-#
%
#
8
RK<.GBFCOO4>FCO)C>
(
-
"
3>&(
-8;%
(
>#
8
RK<.FEGE
OOM4>GG)GFOG>
(
-
"
3>@5
#%
$
'88
8%$>63-
4OOC>
(
-
"
3>%
7
(
K
$-8>%
8"<&4(<
%
8"<$"
3"4#8
#63-OO>
(
-
#
K-<
>(
-
#
K-<
8
-$
&4EEx(
-
#
K-<
7K6>
(
$>5-84-
&"'$
<3-(&
@
"$
OO>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
(
8>&-
-&--<‡@'$'84
H4
6
-&--<)F>$>
<
>(
-">T>U
%
@
OEO>
(
-8>#):>$63
-%
8>
%
8"<&
<OEO)OO$>3>63-'
@8%:
8<;"#
@
OO>
(:
>;
4-
@#
4
8
#'H
#4#-@
$
>$4.GMOOF4>CO)EM>
(;(>(4
4
;
(#%
TOEEU#
$Š;(#%
'
;"#(
-
-
>
(-
>%
3-'5---7-`
#
8-
#3#>@'
(
'$44
-(4
@
>>
$-!
&>T>U%
3
4
.
OOM>
()?>;
#>64-(
4>"""
&#3->63-
`
KOOC>
(%@>8/4%/#4
#%@>&"5)(.
EEMECC4>EECG)EEF
(-5>5-84(
K>@#
4
#p(<<>
8
#<RK8
4@$"
(
#
"<7
>7
OOF>
164
(-
3>5-8(%<>#
'5
47"
%'$<#4#-
8%#%
5
4.BOOB>
(<H(>(%
6-#
4
‡R#p@
&"
>:#@@.EC>
(K-!>(
%
3
<>$
H4>V
463-&
6
8%
OOM>
(K-!
.>/
$3"4‡#&"4#@(#%
>$-
8%-OOG>
(K-4
-<
8>:#
<
:
<@
>#
.MEBOEE4>)C>
(
K
&>
;434
8"<@
>RK8
4>R8)OO)OOF
@
;
-@3"4#&
-OO>
>;4
3>5
'3<3"<#4
3%>
%
:<Š%
;.OEO4>E)EGB>
6
>8&4;)%
.8%8
>3-%OEO>
<$>$$#%V<55-<'5-.
-&5-@
@#
>63-H"<8OOE>
$>-
;>
@
"
.'_8@
>63-`
8OOM>
-.>]%
@
'&"6
84^#
8
RK<.ECECM
4>GG)G>
#&
>(<#$
;"#@
>63-#
@
OO>
>RK
8#7"--
63-'
##4-
;"#@
OOB>
>(<7
%Š#4<#>&4-
##4-
TU63-;"#@
OO>
K-
.>;6.
%<|R#"&@#4"‡p'$
#@
>@'
.
%'
"
>5>?K>T>U5K<4OOC>
8>"
7V>$44
-76)#-5-R'###>
@
V
%
&
&
-.EC4>GEE)GE>
@$>8%
R
6
@
'
<:">
@
$<3"4#
@%
$
63-
OEO>
8>3
3"'"
#@#
8"<
-@R66`K
#%"<8OO>
165
>(<
Š8
##@#4#
#4"<
>
&xEM63-';"#@
EC&4>FFE>
>
#4"<
(<
Š8
##@#4#
>
(
@
E)OOO>63-';"#@
OOE&4>FBO>
>
#4"<
(<
8
##@#4#
>
@
>K
63-';"#@
OOF
&4>FCC>
>@#
#4<#@
OOF)OO
#4"<
(<
Š8
##@#4#
;"#@
63-
OO>&4>E>
>
#4"<
(<
8
##@#4#
>
MO-&xOOF63-'OOM&4>OB>
>
$#@
OOC)OO(<
8
##
@#4#
;"#@
63-OEO
>
>#-
%
#OOC)OO>&4GF)M-&TV<
OOC)VOOU
;"#@
>63-OEO%>
>(
@
OOB)OC(<
8
##@#4#
;">@
63-OEO>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
(>
%
-(x3
3(<
-
:
#<R
;"#@
>63-OEO>
&);>--###
&-:
->:"
#
&-;"
'
>
%.5>
7K6ECM)ECBB>88"<8ECF>
##>
(
K-
!
$>
#
4
-6;%
RK@
6;%
RK
.
RK4
'
@$"
$E)EGOO>
7>5-R-
-&--<$@5$5@OOM>
@"$-#
%
T$:#$-#
%
U>&4-8%
%
7"-34
#$-#
%
$-#
%
OEO>
8
3>
>"
("8"%<%
->
-
84
)
84"
@.EEEM4>FE)F>
8
>8>5-|&--<p'@
@#4
"
3"4#
>
@
V
%
&
&
-.GFEOEO4>EFM)EM>
8
>
>p>#-
K36@
T3@Ux:
54>
"#
%
.EGOOE4>F)>
166
8
>p>
><"
;%
<'84)(
&#(#%
>
"#
%
.EFEOO4>E)EB>
8
>$4-
#V>
>
"-K?>;-@#
3-
"p&"4#>
"#
%
.EEOO4>FE)E>
8
>$"
&
45
<#>#
8
RK<.FEOOOM>
8
-
K.>?>8
>R3
"(
3‡#
8
RK<.
FOGMOO4>GO)GOF>
8
5>8%4
"<
<7"';-(<?K
>@'3
;3;
4-<>O)M>
6
&
!Š?
7
-3T>U3-&OEO>
8-
K>3
7
>R#
('&K
&4
(#%
#
8
RK<OOB4>EEO)EEC>
8-
K-4
];
8%4
'$
<(#%
^R)38)_@
;
.8%4
'-
3-
%%M)BOEO>
8
##;">@
"-:"`
8
.@@@'4>GF)F>'$&
3"4#@<"
8-<
@
H"<863-'OOC
8
##88"<#
-4'4
##>>4
484"BV
EE>4
GE%OEE>
83&>@-
#
8T
.
RK&-
-##6
-;
#
U>84p3#
&-OO>
8(>@
8
-(
3%
'6
(<-
#
;
4-<>8#
;
4-<.BGOOG4>GEB)GG>
8(>|H
"
7%"'-&--<
%
8-@-
%
;!
.COO4>)EOC>
_
<#>;
446-(<'@
p&4
%
-3#">
-
4-.FFFOOG4>O)>
&
!
4
$>5-.##<$->
6K3#&
6&#
#4>
5H.MCE>GOOE4>E)EEG>
&
!
>@?
.>
-<#
&>|8
(
p>@
<
&
!
T>U
(
@<
8&7>OEE>
&
!?>
-(>%>
8)
;
4-@
>63-
>
&
#
-
&>%
%
<#@
H"<83-'E>4>
)BF>
&
#
>5
8
8'$
<
>7-#
8
7>OEO>8-3>
167
&
#
>
6
,>@
6--
"
@#
##
5-x-
##
?
?
K
>(
$
V
.GCOEE4>)MF>
&
#
-
>@
<
-%
8>#
8
RK<.FEOOM4>GEG)
GEB>
&
#
-
>$/@<>#
8
RK<.FGOOEO4>EO)EF>
&
>5-R
<-(">(
44-"<
<8;)4
>#
8
RK<.OOB4>EE)EM>
&
.>#
5-<'--$
<
;%
>@
V
%
&
&
-.GOEOOM4>)G>
&
->(
#4"<'4
44#
8
RK<.FMF
OEE4>FO)FG>
&
(>
%%$>-
%
)$
<
|8#
<p
TECO)EEU>(
$
#
.>.>8K--"K<T>U%
3"4
#
"<<
%
EBM4>EC)EC>
&%>5-8
(4-<>%
8"<&4OO(<
%
8"<$"
3"4#8
##>63->H"<
8>OO>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
&%>5-
(#%
@
>@'
#'
-;%
&4
#
#>)$@5$5>OOG>
&<$><&/#
';
-88"<>(
4"<(
8OOG>
&<$>";"#
<'5-8@
(#%
>$4.FEE
OO
4>E)EB>
&<$>R-<@
8
@'@#
<@
-@#%
>
8
5-<.CEOO%4>BM)CB>
&<$>(
44-4@
>63-H"<8OEO>
&<$>#'&-K%
%
#>@
V
%
&
&
-.GOEE4>G)GC>
&>-3-('$-
4-.6>#
8
RK<.€7.FMOEO
4>BB)CG>
>(
-
4
>6
>>
(>-
6
>
$>](
@.
@
'<3>^63-'38$
84
OEE>
<
>(K-!
.>@
8
#
3"<'$
(#%
@
>R3"4#.EOOE4>OFGxOB>
168
(>%
8
-5-R'5--
-H47(
8EC>
K
>(K;>>5-(#%
#
8
#>8
6-###
%
(
4R
8
#)-$
63-OOM>
-K>&
@##%<%
@
>;
4-
&"6.BMECM4>ECF)EF>
V>5-<#
.OOEB4>GG)FO>
8>:68
-8
#
K5#
.3-$-K
OOM>
&>p
p7
6|(
p
&
H
@#
R)38)
_@;%
.8%4
'-
3-
%OEO>
4
&>##
.@
>#
8
RK<.FOOOO4>OFM)
OO>
4
$>5--
#4<#@
'$@#
#<84"'$@#
#<84".>@
@@63-$
#:
OO>
-
%
$>-
#
&>R
#48
3#-(
!>#
8
RK<.FGOOB4>EO)EB>
-
$>@-<8
'"#
(<3-ECMOEMO>#
8
RK<.FEFBOOM4>FO)EE>
-
-<(>$-#
?>
>(4
R
(
#@
)$&"6>R
(
#.COOC4>F)FMB>
-
#
?>R
R
>(#%
<-8#$
E>
-
#
&>?
p3
>@
8
>#
8
RK<.OOG4>GCG)
GCO>
-
#
&>"<
6K(4
7
(#%
>5
@
(#%
EC>
-V>7
%7
6
4
#,@
>7;RK8
4-
<7
6
;"
V63-OO>7;R8OOE
"
#
K-
?>?$>->>
%K%
@
63-H
"<8OO>
"
#
K-
?>(
$>(4
;"
@
>$""6
8<&
-63-OO>
!
>5-)4
3
>$
-$
$#
;
4-.BOECO
4>OB)>
3>V>-4%
-
'-8
(
-
-7-
(
K"<
8K<E>
169
4>5-&
R5
3"4#
;%
#<>7
6`K
;EB>
"
?>8%8"
.
<$R
(
#'$<-
<>#
8
RK<.FEOOM4>)B>
5
6
7
#
)&6
>-%-$
7
3#
<'3-(4
OOB>
#
8
RK<.FFBOOB4>E)MO>
5-
KK
>(-
##(#%
#
8
RK<.GMOOF4>CO)CM>
5-
>44
3
'3
3#
-EO>#
8
RK<.
GBMOO4>B)BC>
5-
>6#
>K%<
'#3#
(@
>HH
"<8OEO>
5
3>?#
8
<.>5-?6K6'$<-#843->3-@
;%
"<OOC>
56
;>%
5
48
>#
'5
47"
%'$<#4#-
8%#%
5
4.BOOB>
56
;>V
><%
@
>%
5
4V
.BOOC4>)MC>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
-
>$>$#
@H'56
6(
%
>R
3"4#&4OO>&-
4#;
4-<>
K8
4OOC>
38#
3"4#&4)"#
'#
(%<
3"4#
3"4#8
##6`K>OO
)@&>##
<&4'&
-('
88-$
ECxE
(
-OEO63-OEO>
)$@5$5>5--
#x;%
&4#
#7
-
8%
OOG>
)$@5$5>5-
-RpOOMOOB
-
7>OOM>
)$@5$5>5-
-RpOEOOEE'-%
3">7
R
-3>>
-
OEO>
V>5-
%
8"<'@7"->@'@
'%
8"<
&4OOBM)G>;>8
(<
%
8"<$"
>T>UH
"<8OO>
4
-<
<>#4<#H
|(p-@
@5@<>#
8
RK<.FOOOB4>ECMG)ECMC>
.
/3>@#4
#&#8!%
@
5--$#4<#'
5-
-
"
(#%
>
8
4M#
63-OEO>
170
.
-<$>-
"7'
(#@
>6
"`
"<
8OO>
.6
-?(-
>
-<>#
CG.OOC4>E)F>
.
>.
&>6
!3
;
--
>@'83#
OOx$4
OOC63-6
!8-OOC>
R
4$>;
&
'-
63-|<p><
<.EM
OOF4>G)EEM>
R(>-'(
-@
8"<86
V<EBC>
R7>3#
<-;%
@
<'
#8
<
-
;%
(#%
>8Š<.GBBOO4>GB)FB>
RK>8;!
84">#
8
RK<.GBEBOO4>EB)
ECG>
R
K>@
>R
44<
>-;
46@
">
K8
4'%
R
44<
5-R
K>63-OOM>
R
K@48
>@"
&4>@
'(#%
%
5
48!T@&37
>FMM)@S@3$>GMM)@U>OO>&4GFB>
R8>@#4"R
44<
"-%
8@
>;
'
R
8
#)-$
MO>OO>
R8>5-#@#4
@
/
@
R
8
##>6
3-OEO>
R8)$>R
@
p8'R-8
<-8K8#‡R
8
#)-$
>63-E>
`):5
>4
5#'5-84"H4>"<(
8ECC>
,*
-()>R
>
%44<3->63-(
-
8%-OOO>
,*
-()>(
-%-$
8
8
<(#%
>#
8
RK<.FFBOOB4>ME)MC>
,*
-()>8
4
<;"
%
(
#
--;#<86
(#%
>3"4#
-
.FOOO4>CG)CBB>
171
List of Websites
-@'
-4'%-->>H>
4‡˜EEŠ%K˜
@
'
-4'
>">
&-
"'
-4'666>->
3-%
-@#4"#
'
-4'-->>
3-;"#'
-4'-">>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
3#RKp&-'
-4'666>#6K->
;
-"#3
%
'
-4'666>>
;@
'
-4'666>
>
5-@
$
@-
%
'
666>-
%
>
%
@
'
666>-)>
7
&-6K'
-4'666>-)
4>
@
%
8
T
@%
$
ŠV&(U'
666>
%
4
>
@
%
4
:
'
-4'
4>
@
84p5%
"#
#
&-'
-4'666>4
>
172
@
3"4#:
4
'
-4'666>>#
4<
%

4!>-#>
V
-
'
-4'666>!
-
>
V
6
-
-
%
&6
('
-4'!#>>
(#'
-4'666>#-#>#
(<Š%
8"<$"
;"#@
'
-4'#-4
>">
(<(<$
;"#@
'
-4'666>#<
>">
$
-.@
'
666>
">
:
#<
-"<'
-4'666>-
>
->-#
--###
&-
@
#4
'
-4'666>-->$
&8
@@H>
4H
--###
&-
'
-4'666>-->
8
"
#4
3-8'
-4'666>-4>>4
"
4
"
>-#
8
-
#'
-4'4
-
#>
&-@#
'
-4'-#
>">
&--<'
666>--<>
&-R
'
-4'666>-6
>
&-R
'
-4'666>-6
>
?
#
-
$
'
-4'
K
#
-
>
173
)#4<R#p$
'
666>6
>
<-8#$
&T8$&U'
-4'666>4
>
H-
@
'
-4'666>H-
>>
)$@5$5'
-4'666>-
%
>
/@
$-<@
;"#@
'
-4'666>
>">
'
666>>
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
R
-<'
-4'666>
>6->GF>-#
174
List of Boxes
HE>
56
4-@
p
H>
6#
<4@
‡
HG>
5-V
6
-
-
%
&6
(TV&(U
HF>
@
-#
-#
%<@
H>
5-BF-
$##$'
-%
H
HM>
5-#
"
4
#,T,U
HB>
5-/@
T@3U4!
HC>
5--
-#
H>
<
-
HEO>
(%+-3-
(#%
HEE>
p-
3
%<%
7
HE>
)$@5$54
#
HEG>
3'#
4-@
HEF>
3#%<
#4"<TU
HE>
#
/
#
%<-
6@
HEM>
#
(#%
3-
HEB>
8%
%
7"-34
#$-#
%
HEC>
34
##-
6
<
K(#%
'
H
#444#
resettlement
HE>
5--
"
#4!(#%
HO>
H46-"<
#
448
#
4-
#
<#T;@U
HE>
#4#
%6K'-
#6K
H>
%
.
HG>
5-
$
.@
175
HF>
.
6Kp-
-##6
-;
#3-
"<
p
#4
H>
5-
K4"F-6
44<
HM>
xK
"4"
HB>
#4
6-4x-
#
8
##T8U(#%
HC>
8
66
8
H>
$)6
4"
#4
@
HGO>
5-
?
#-
$
'
#"#-#
#
"
HGE>
8%-
-
"
%<
HG>
-
"<8-<x84%-
-
HGG>
-<
HGF>
5-R-
-&--<
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
List of Tables
5
%E>
5%
-4
TzU
"
#
H44
-4
T4U
F
MO-xECMEMOOF
5
%>
%
-
-4
List of Figures
:E> (
%
@
ECGOOB)OCT4U
:> #4<#
#
%<
##
@
OOB)OC
176
List of Abbreviations
$7(
$"
7
<(
#
$(
$-#
%
(4
4
$(5
$-#
%
(4
5
4"
5
5--
##%
44<Š5
4
K
87
68"<7
&5
&
45
"
BSUP
Basic Services to the Urban Poor
$$
$##$
$8$(
##6
-$
8%$#
(
#
##<
38
<3"4#8
_@
/<
@
@.@
p.
<@
"-<
&
&-
"
8
8
87
##<8
4
7
6
"<
R
R
K
R;
##6
-;
#
33$
3-3"4#$-<
3:@3
?34
#@
3"4#
;
"#44;4
R
#
<R
K
GDP
Gross Domestic Product
;@
;
4-
@#
<#
;75
;
84<5
;@
;"#@
GSDP
Gross State Domestic Product
177
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
178
-
4
<<#
7&
7
&-6K
IAS
Indian Administrative Services
@5
@
K5
@5
@#
##
5-<
@3:
@
3"4#:
4
IGSSS
Indo Global Social Services Society
@7Š:
@
7
Š:
"7#
@7
@
7
%
@&
@
&4
@8
@
8
@88
@
84
8!
@85&
@
84p5%
"#
#
&-
@5
@#
5-
@:
@
%
4
:
V@$
V
4
@
4
$<
V&(
V
6
-
-
%
&6
(
?@$3
?
K
@
$
3"4#
?(8
?K
(4
8
##
7$3
7
$
3"4#-#
7@;
76@#;4
(3
(4
4
3-
(;(
(4
4
;
(#%
(3;
(#3"4#;
(5&$
(4
$##.$
R#
-
(;&;$
(
-
#
;
-
&
#4<#;
$
(
(#
(?
(
?
-
K
-
(7$
(#%7
"$#%<
((&3$
(#%
(4
&
3"4#$-<
(8
(#%8
#
(8
(4
8
##
(8
(-<8
4
#H4
((
(#
(#4
(R
(4
R
(58
(#%
%
5
48!
$.@
$
.
##4-
(
##(
5
4
5<
:
:
#<
-"<
;
;"#
8
-8<
"
KK
K-
#
NIUA
National Institute of Urban Affairs
(.
(.-
%!
&(
&
-(
3:
#36:
38
#3"4#8
##
#4"<
#4"<
(
%
-(
58
%
5
48<
NWP
National Water Policy
-
K6
83
4
34
#
PAN
Permanent Account Number
PDS
Public Distribution System
8$&7
8H4
&7
8
8%
-
8@7
8%@7
87$5@(
8
-47
5@#4#
%
(
#
888
8%)8"
8
-4
83&
843#
&-
8?$&
8
%
?6$
&
-
8R3
8%RK34
#
&Š&
&#
&-
%
&$`
&
!"$6
`!
179
Urban Policies and the Right to the City in India :
Rights, Responsibilities and Citizenship
180
&
&4"
-
-
&3:
&
6
<#36:
&5@
&-@#
&55
&--<
&R$
&R
$
$7
$
@
4#@
5
-
-5%
R$
#4<R#p$
,
4
#,
:
:
##
;8
!
<;
-
8
K
(
#
(#4
8$&
<-8#$
&
&$
#&-
%
$-<
8
#
8
#
@3
/@
@3$@
/@
$-<@
7
%
7
UN
United Nations
38
3"4#8
##
)$@5$5 #
#8
##
@:
@
-p#<:
$@3
$<@
3"4#
53&
5
3"4#&-
5@:@
5
#
%
@
:
4
.$($`
.
#K$#%K
$6
`!
R
R
-
R
R
44<
Urban Policies
and the Right to
the City in India:
Rights, Responsibilities and
Citizenship
Social and Human
Sciences Sector
8QLWHG1DWLRQV
(GXFDWLRQDO6FLHQWL¿FDQG
&XOWXUDO2UJDQL]DWLRQ