Fire Effects and Fuel Management in Mediterranean Ecosystems in Spain1 Ricardo Vélez2 The 1977 forest fire season was considered a successful one in Spain. The number of fires did not reach 50 percent of the average for the 3 previous years and the total area burned was less than 40 percent of that burned in each of the previous years (table 1). In contrast, 1978 presented an extremely prolonged fire season. Over 150,000 ha of forest and nearly 300,000 ha of brushland and pastureland were burned by 8,324 fires (table 1). These contrasting years reemphasized the fire danger in the Mediterranean ecosystems of Spain. They revealed the necessity for a fire prevention program which considers the factors determining the magnitude of the fire hazard (Vélez 1980a). In 1976 and 1977 the Forestry Service (ICONA) was able to carry out pruning and clearing on over 120,000 ha of reforestation areas. This was achieved with special funds provided to reduce unemployment amongst agricultural workers. Moreover, in 1977 Spanish foresters had two opportunities to compare techniques with experts from other countries and thus to reflect on their fire prevention policy. These were the Technical Consultation (FAO/UNESCO) on Forest Fires in the Mediterranean Region, held in France (ICONA 1978a), and the Symposium on the Environmental Consequences of Fire and Fuel Management in Mediterranean Ecosystems, held in Palo Alto, California (Mooney and Conrad 1977). The concern over the need to protect Spanish forests, together with exposure to the ideas and practices of other countries led to an active program of fuel management and research. In this paper I review the progress and development of the early years of this program. DEVELOPMENT OF A FUEL MANAGEMENT ACTION AND RESEARCH PROGRAM A fuel management plan for all danger areas as well as a program of research on the effects of 1 Presented at the Symposium on Dynamics and Management of Mediterranean-type Ecosystems, June 22-26, 1981, San Diego, California. 2 Doctor Ingeniero de Montes, ICONA - Forest Fire Section, Madrid Spain. 458 Abstract: Forest fuels in the Mediterranean ecosystems of Spain are characterized by generalized pyrophytism and large accumulations of woody shrub vegetation. The Forest Service prepared in 1978 a fuel management plan and a program of surveys including: A study on the vegetation's evolution in forests after fires; the experimental use of prescribed burning and grazing to reduce forest fuel accumulations; a study of the evolution of fuel accumulations in areas treated in 1976 and 1977 in Southern Spain; and a study of economics of slash chipping. fire and preventive silviculture techniques has been developed (ICONA 1978b). The goal is to enable forest treatment methods to be perfected through an improved knowledge of fire's role in Mediterranean ecosystems. Fuel Management In The Forests The fuel management plan developed for Spain can be summarized as follows: Fire prevention (Vélez 1977) has the basic purpose of controlling the fuel load in strategically important places, either by reducing or removing it. The technique used most commonly is that of fuel breaks, areas from 60 to 100 m wide which divide the forest into 300 to 1,000 ha stands and on which natural vegetation is modified to reduce biomass and flammability. To the extent possible, fuel breaks should link up with agricultural crops, recreational areas, campsites and natural barriers, so as to form a system dividing the forest into compartments, making it easier to stop fires from spreading. Preventive work projects are designed to reduce fire danger. They must specify the work to be done, techniques used, the area to be treated and the area to be protected. The work to be included in such projects is varied. It must be remembered, however, that unlike extensive forest treatments directed towards improving production, the intent of fuel management is to establish fire barriers. This means intense action in small areas, strategically located to prevent ignition and contain the fire from spreading. The work includes pruning, thinning and clearing in auxiliary strips along roads, and removing slash. It may involve construction of roads and lanes, accompanied by the relevant auxiliary strips, as well as the preparation and maintenance of areas with a humid microclimate, such as watercourses and gullies. This may include the restoration, on a small scale, of mesic vegetation. Reduction of brushland by hand or mechanical clearing or by controlled fire, and the opening up of spaces, including the improvement of natural pasture for use by cattle and wildlife are also involved. Fuel management also includes the removal of slash by burning or chipping. Classifying an area as protected does not by itself assure that it is fire proof. It does mean it is less likely for a fire to start, and should a fire be started, damage should be kept to a minimum. Gen. Tech. Rep. PSW-58. Berkeley, CA: Pacific Southwest Forest and Range Experiment Station, Forest Service, U.S. Department of Agriculture; 1982. Table 1--History of forest fires in Spain, 1961-1980. Burned area (ha) Year No. fires Forested 1961 1962 1963 1964 1965 1966 1967 1968 1969 1970 1971 1972 1973 1974 1975 1976 1977 1978 1979 1980 ............ ............ ............ ............ ............ ............ ............ ............ ............ ............ ............ ............ ............ ............ ............ ............ ............ ............ ............ ............ 1,680 2,022 1,302 1,645 1,686 1,443 2,229 2,109 1,494 3,203 1,714 2,148 3,765 3,980 4,242 4,596 2,148 8,324 7,167 7,000 34,506 23,911 13,279 17,671 21,777 24,644 33,930 20,547 19,296 34,330 13,194 18,048 40,559 58,789 111,091 79,853 26,454 159,264 119,579 101,086 UnForested 12,195 31,571 9,400 13,727 16,241 24,710 42,645 36,081 34,423 52,994 21,751 39,235 54,698 81,422 76,223 82,447 41,086 275,603 152,139 156,638 In the last two years fuel management work has accomplished the following: Action: Fuel Break Preparation Fire Break Maintenance Road Building Area Protected Losses (millions pesetas) 1979 31,050 ha -375 km 1980 17,356 ha 2,661 ha 140 km 500,000 ha 200,000 ha Research on Fire Effects and Prevention Techniques The research program on fire effects and preventive silviculture comprises these projects: A. A study of forest succession following fire. Its aims are to study the effect of summer fires on forest soils, to analyze the effect of fire on regeneration, and to establish the grounds for future prescribed burning. Work on this project commenced in 1978, with data being collected from burned areas in the provinces of Gerona, Tarragona, Valencia, Madrid, Avila and Pontevedra. B. Experimental use of prescribed burning to reduce forest fuel accumulations. Work on this project began in Galicia (NW Spain) in 1978 and has progressed from initial burning of plots less than 1 ha in size to burns of over 200 ha in pine plantations. Objectives include perfecting prescribed burning techniques as a means of controlling brushland and for forest fire prevention, and understanding the atmospheric and vegetation features most suited to prescribed burning. TOTAL Commercial 46,701 55,482 22,679 31,398 38,018 49,354 76,575 56,628 53,719 87,324 34,945 57,283 95,257 140,211 187,314 162,330 67,541 434,867 271,718 257,724 C. D. 928 598 311 372 412 446 575 549 484 764 334 559 1,118 1,992 4,121 3,974 981 9,205 6,790 6,000 Environmental 575 507 312 546 599 700 858 695 656 1,176 657 1,016 1,574 7,709 13,855 12,575 3,393 17,639 16,819 12,000 TOTAL 1,503 1,105 623 918 1,011 1,146 1,433 1,244 1,140 1,940 991 1,575 2,692 9,701 17,976 16,549 4,374 26,844 23,609 18,000 Experimental use of grazing to reduce fuel accumulations. Work on this project began in Galicia in eucalyptus plantations. The idea was to use goats to remove Ulex and Erica brush. The goal is to determine the possibilities of using grazing to reduce fuel accumulations in areas covered with brush and in pine, eucalyptus and hardwood forests. Study of fuel accumulation in Andalusia (South of Spain). The aims of this project are to determine the rate of brush regeneration, including the time at which it reaches a level at which brush removal is needed, determining the effectiveness of different methods of destroying brush, and comparing success in reducing fuel buildup by mechanical or manual clearing, and prescribed burning. These studies are being carried out in pruned and cleared forest areas where debris has been burned in piles, in unforested areas where fire and grazing have maintained the herbaceous vegetation, and in pruned and cleared forests where the branches have either been left on the ground for weathering or have been burned. PRELIMINARY RESULTS Fire Effects Plant Survival Surface fires that consume brush and herbaceous vegetation without reaching tree tops make up 70 459 percent of all fires in Spain (ICONA 1968-1979). The fire generally consumes the herbaceous vegetation and destroys most of the above ground brush, with only the thickest lignified stems left standing. These fires usually burn the soil, reducing litter to cinders and forming a layer of ash of variable thickness. Tree damage is a function of fire intensity and the amount of fuel accumulated on the ground. In general, the bark is burned on the outside but this does not necessarily signify cambium damage. The thermal effect on leaves seems more important. If the fire is rapid and the trees have been pruned, only the lower levels of foliage will be burned and the upper branches will survive. If the fire is slow burning and the hot air envelopes the crown, survival is unlikely. Isolated trees frequently survive fires in pine groves. Unfortunately, it is difficult to collect this type of information since to simplify forestry operations, surviving trees are usually felled wherever fires have occurred. Data is being collected on tree survival in pine groves after fires. In Lanjaron (Granada), where there were fires in successive years (1973, 1974), all the pine trees died in areas which burned during the daytime. On the other hand, on areas which burned at night, the fire became less intense as the wind dropped and humidity increased, and only litter was burnt. A stand of Pinus sylvestris with diameters of 5 to 10 cm and branches from the base of the trunk survived the fire as only the lower branches dried up. In Musques (Vizcaya) incendiary fire in an unpruned stand of P. radiata, with diameters of 10-15 cm, burned at night, with high atmospheric humidity. The fire slowly consumed the Ulex brush, leaving the pine grove clean, as if it had been a prescribed fire. In evaluating the effects of fire on broadleaved species we must distinguish between the typically summer-drought Mediterranean (Quercus ilex, Q. suber, etc.) and the more mesic species (Q. robur, Castanea sativa, Fagus sylvatica, Betula sp., Populus sp. etc.). The former usually grow in sites similar to pine forests, forming either open "dehesas" (the typical case of Q. ilex) or closed formations as in Q. suber. In the "dehesas" fire is the creeping, rapid type, burning the dry grass, often allowing the oaks to survive. In closed formations there is usually a large amount of brush and branches so that the fire easily gets to the tree tops, defoliating the trees. Statistics indicate that on a scale from 1 to 10 the flammability of hygrophytic broad-leaved species equals 1 while that of conifers equals 10 (Vélez 1980a). Thus the former are considered as species which "do not burn". Indeed, on a yearly basis formations of hygrophytic broadleaved species suffer little from fire, both in numbers of fires and area burned. But, what happens when fire does occur? Without exception, the above ground part of oaks (Quercus robur), chestnuts (Castanea sativa), and beech (Fagus sylvatica) die. Their tender leaves cannot withstand 460 the heat and the bark is not sufficiently thick to insulate the cambium. However, it is noted that these trees generally form a fire barrier. The plants that are in front have perished, but the forest has been saved. The reason is that these species exist only in areas with abundant moisture. The fire is stopped because it spends its heat evaporating water, and in the end there is more water than heat. Naturally, if the fires were to occur often enough these stands could be eliminated. But, more commonly, they serve as an effective fire barrier. Plant Regeneration Observations made in recent years indicate that, contrary to public opinion, fire does not sterilize an area but instead stimulates the sprouting of vegetation after the first rainfall. These sprouts usually consist of a larger number of species than that present before the fire. Subsequently, the variety of species diminishes or at least is masked as some predominate over 3 others . The case of spurge flax (Daphne gnidium) is typical in that it appears on all kinds of burned ground with enormous vitality (it grows up to 50 cm in a year) but becomes much less obvious in later years. Woody brush also regenerates strongly, sometimes sprouting from a stump (Erica, Calluna, Ulex, Genista, Quercus coccifera, Juniperus, Chamaerops, etc.), and sometimes from seeds (Cistus). Pines seem to regenerate from seed easily after fire as long as the stand was sufficiently old to have fertile cones. In the Ayora-Enguera fire (July 17-21, 1979 which burned 22,796 ha of pine forest in Valencia (the most extensive fire recorded in Spain to date) regeneration of Pinus pinaster and P. halepensis was abundant one year later. The autumn following the fire was quite favorable with frequent, non-torrential rainfall, so that seeds had germinated when spring arrived. They rooted well with that seasons rain and most were able to survive the summer. Pine trees 20 cm high were found in November, 1980, together with others which had just germinated. All the burned area had been logged, as the burned timber could be commercially exploited. Over a 4,000 ha area of Pinus pinaster was burned in 1976, near the Ayora-Enguera fire. Total regeneration of the pines was observed, reaching over 50 cm in height after 4 years. Regeneration is at present being aided by manually cleaning out around each tree. In a drier area of Valencia, (Serra, Portaceli fire, 1978), a lag of approximately one year in regeneration has been observed. In addition, little if any regeneration occurs on the driest, 3 1980 Internal Report by Ruiz del Castillo on the study on fire effects in vegetation, Inst. Nac. Investigaciones Agrarias, Madrid. stoniest sites, which have a steep slope. The influence of exposure is not clear but sunny slopes seem to be less favorable than shaded ones. Regeneration appears to be greatest where the most ash has accumulated. This might be because of the high carbon content which retains a greater amount of water, and thus favours seed germination. In areas where former charcoal furnaces were located regeneration is noticeably better, both in terms of the number of trees and the height reached in one year. For certain species, used for reforestation, like Pinus radiata, fire seems almost necessary for regeneration, since the cones require heat to open. In some reforested areas, mainly P. pinaster and P. halepensis, little regeneration occurs. It is not clear whether or how this might be related to site quality. Among the broad-leaved species, Quercus ilex and Q. suber regenerate by crown sprouting. Chestnuts are weakened as they may suffer wounds in their roots when the fire goes deep into the surrounding thick litter. Poplars sprout readily and even withstand repeated, low intensity fires. Birches disseminate their seeds better after fire. In any event, not much information is available on these species since they are seldom burned. Introduced eucalyptus trees are able to withstand fire. Even when the above ground part is killed, they sprout readily, often growing more than 2 m the next year. They also disseminate seed readily after fire. In Galicia E. globulus is extending its area due to the large number of fires occurring in that region (Dalda 1978a). In light of these preliminary observations, generalized pyrophitism of the Mediterranean forest vegetation seems to be confirmed. In truth, the story of our forest formations would be incomplete if the role of fire was not included. Fire is not and never has been a rare event in these forests. It is now, apparently, more frequent than a few years ago and has more intense effects. However, it has always been there. The vegetation can tell us whether fire burned recently in an area. Chestnut and beech are clear signs that there have been no fires for a prolonged period. A pine grove or Cistus shrub are, on the other hand, probable indications of a relatively recent fire (Martín Bolaños 1949). The very name of the forest sometimes gives an indication of fire history. Magnificent pine stands are known as "El quemado" (the burnt one) in many places. Controlled Fires Experimental fires were burned on test plots in unforested areas and eucalyptus plantations with 2 dry matter accumulation over 2 kg/m in the former 2 and 1 kg/m in the latter (Vega 1978). The slope varied between 10 and 15 percent. In some cases brush height came to 3 m. Burning was carried out several days after rain in the spring. The majority of the fires were started with no brush preparation. Only on one eucalyptus plot was the brush cut first and left on the ground. In the first fire fuel reduction ranged from 55 percent in the unforested areas to 50 percent in the eucalyptus groves. In the latter, all trees over 10 cm in diameter survived without damage. The influence of fire intensity on the trees was also studied. The second burning, one year later, produced less fuel reduction, but the effects on the trees were similar. It was not found that the increased cost of cutting the brush significantly increased fuel reduction. Birch and oak (Q. robur), with diameters less than 10 cm, were common on the plots. Practically all survived or sprouted after the fires. The same happened to the few pines that were associated with the eucalyptus grove. Fires were used on a greater scale in 1980 on pruned Pinus pinaster and P. radiata plantations with diameters of 10 to 40 cm and where brush cover was from 1 to 4 m high. In one case, the flash fuel was a thick layer of pine needles. Burning was carried out in March and April, several days after rain. The burned areas varied between 3 and 170 ha in size. The following are presented as tentative conclusions. Additional studies will extend these findings and check future effects: a) Six months after fire the forest is easy to travel through and little fuel is on the ground. This makes it difficult for fire to start as well as facilitates the suppression thereof. b) It does not appear that P. pinaster or P. radiata with diameters over 10 cm suffered appreciable damage. c) Burning should be carried out so that brush is consumed as completely as possible. If the brush is thick, it may be advisable to first fire under high moisture conditions and then remove the rest with a second burning. d) Trees should be pruned to a height above 2 m. The low branches dry and drop a large number of pine needles. If there is a large accumulation of needles they should be raked away from the base before burning. e) Burning should be carried out with the support of roads or fuel breaks at the top and bottom. Butane lighters or diesel torches are good ignition tools. Stirring up the pine needles with rakes aids fire spread. f) An average of 1 ha can be burned per day in mountainous terrain. This is notably cheaper than clearing by manual methods. g) The possibility of keeping the burned land clear by introducing horses, cattle or goats should be considered. h) A survey should be started on the effects of burning on tree growth since these are basically plantations for timber production. i) Apart from surveys on the effects of fire prevention, it would be of interest to study the effects of fire on the natural regenera- 461 tion of pines. It is probable that the lack of regeneration in many stands is due to the absence of fire. be removed as soon as possible. The burying of slash calls for the use of machinery which is not easy in forested stands. Combining the manual fuel removal system with other techniques appears more promising. Use Of Grazing The first grazing experiments were carried out in eucalyptus plantations (E. globulus) in Galicia. Goats were the primary animal used although some horses and cows were included. The plantations consisted of mature trees with diameters over 10 cm. The understory is mainly Ulex, Erica and Calluna. The vegetation removal capacity of goats is such that at certain times of the year natural pasture does not suffice and their intake has to be supplemented with concentrated feed. Animal densities needed to keep the forest clean without erosion are estimated at one goat per 1 to 1.5 ha or one horse for each 4 ha (Rigueiro 1979). Impacts on the flora are being studied since the animals eat selectively, leaving the least appetizing species alone. For example, removal of leguminous species may influence nitrogen fixation. The influence of fertilization from manure must also be considered. It is interesting to connect this work with that of using controlled fire, bearing in mind results from Santander where efforts are being made to rationalize the traditional practice of burning meadows and brush in order to "renew the pasture" (Montserrat 1978). The intention is to avoid extensive controlled burning which makes the vegetation uniform, creating a continuous fire danger. It has been recommended that mosaics of 2 small areas (maximum 200 m ) he burned by shepherds and grazed over the following years. Fuel Management It must he recognized that the budget for fuel management has also had the aim of reducing unemployment. This forced manual methods to be employed wherever feasible. The common approach has been pruning and clearing with hand tools, followed by piling of brush and branches for burning. In areas with young trees and sparse canopy cover it is estimated that further clearing will be required every 2 to 3 years. If the trees are older and give more shade brush regeneration is less important. Some species, like Pinus sylvestris, inhibit brush growth in mature stands. In any event, sufficient information is not yet available to establish clearing rotation periods. This system involves very high costs. To reduce costs in areas with poor access it was decided to deposit slash on the ground and leave it for humification. In dry areas, this process is slow and the danger arising from the fuel is much greater than before, although it is true that the branches prevent development of new brush. The conclusion is that the slash should generally 462 In the province of Jaen fire breaks are combined with roads and open spaces in burning brushland. Wildlife comes down to eat the sprouting brush, thus keeping biomass low. Burning may be needed every five years in such situations. Another possibility is to find a commercial use for slash in order to make removing it from the forest profitable. This has been studied for Pinus sylvestris forests (Puig 1980). It requires a chipper drawn by a tractor and a second tractor to drag away the slash and pile it in strips along the forest road. The potential profits are variable since the conditions in the forest and slash to be chipped are heterogeneous. Products derived include chips for particle board (pine) and chips for fuel briquettes (oak, pine or brush). This use is limited by the chip market which is low at this time, and by the fact that there is only one briquette factory in Spain. In any event, it is an interesting alternative to the burning of piles. RECOMMENDATIONS Observations on fire effects indicate that to protect the forests (Vélez 1980b) it is necessary to: a) recognize that fire is a natural ecological process that is only harmful in excess or when it conflicts with man-created values: b) recognize that genetic diversity produces morphologically diverse ecosystems which in turn are the most apt to be perpetuated by fire; and c) recognize that fire must be managed as a recurring process. In short, forest fire protection and management requires the bringing together of a variety of principles and types of knowledge. This must consider the advisability of mixing species, introducing hygrophytic species and alternating forest and grazing lands (Gonzalez Vazquez 1950). In some places fire can be controlled with hygrophytic species. They should be respected where found and introduced where ecologically desirable in order to create "fire resistant places." Generally, the areas available for forest restoration are degraded, dry and stony, and are hardly suitable for hygrophytic species. But there will always be watercourses nearby and often scattered broad-leaved species of trees. Respect for them and promotion thereof must prevail. The practice of planting birch trees in water courses and at the side of forest roads is being practiced in Galicia. Birch does not resist fire but it does retain moisture and contributes to retarding the fire's advance (Dalda 1978b). Poplars, willows (Salix) and ash (Fraxinus) are common wherever there is moisture and may also be used. We must not hesitate to promote mixed stands which in addition to being more natural, defend themselves better from fire. In areas with high fire danger it is not advisable, for instance, to replace cork oaks (Quercus suber) since their thick bark makes them fire resistant, as well as being able to sprout back after burning. On the other hand, there is some evidence that the eucalyptus plantations in Galicia are turning out to be more and more attractive in view of the recent wave of incendiary fires. They suffer little from fire, vigorously sprouting from the stump. In any event, defense against fire cannot be based primarily on replacing species with other less combustible ones. Indeed, pyrophytism, so generalized in the Mediterranean area, reveals that natural fire defense includes the mechanisms that stimulate reproduction after fire. Forest fuel management should be directed primarily towards the idea of reducing flammability. This should be based on the creation of breaks which transform the forest into a mosaic of species and biomass, conifers mixing with broad-leaved species, mixed ages, spaces being opened up between forest areas, etc. The even aged single species stand, ideal for exploitation, is only ecologically possible in limited areas of this country due to its high susceptibility to fire. Thus, the traditional concept of fire breaks, which are costly to preserve, should be replaced by the idea of fuel breaks as defined above (Vélez 1977). Likewise, low cost practices like controlled fires, and techniques which produce an economic yield like grazing and slash chipping, must be brought into forest fire preventive treatment. The development of these programs must bear in mind criticism (Folch 1977) against the removal of fuel from forests for ecological reasons. Experience up to now shows that those areas where fuel has been reduced are less liable to suffer from wildfires. In addition, if fire occurs, the intensity is noticeably decreased, facilitating suppression. Nevertheless, it is necessary for the "ecology + economy" binomial to be carefully analyzed in order to obtain valid results based on scientific findings. Literature Cited Dalda González, J. Los efectos del fuego en la vegetación forestal de Galicia. Madrid: ICONA; Naturalia Hispanica; 1978a. 53 p. Dalda González, J. Conveniencia y utilidad del abedul para diversificar la cubierta forestal del noroeste ibérico. Madrid: ICONA; Técnicas españolas de lucha contra incendios forestales; 1978b; 65-68. Folch Guillén, R. Sobre ecologismo y ecología aplicada. Barcelona: Ketres, Ed.; 1977. 309 p. González Vázquez, E. La riqueza forestal española. Madrid: Dossat, Ed.; 1950. 63 p. ICONA. Técnicas españolas de lucha contra incendios forestales. Madrid. 1978a. 91 p. ICONA. Programa de estudios sobre ordenación y control del combustible forestal para prevención de incendios. Madrid: Bol. Est. Cent. Ecología (14). 1978b; 93-97. ICONA. Los indencios forestales en España durante 1968-1979. Reports published yearly from 1968 to 1979. Madrid. 1968-1979. 75 p. each. Montserrat Recoder, P. El incendio de pastizales y sus peligros. Madrid. Rev. Pastos (8), 1978; 31-36. Martín Bolaños, M. Jaras y jarales. Madrid: Instituto Forestal de Investigaciones y Experiencias; 1949. 228 p. Mooney H. A. and Conrad, C. E. (Eds). Proceedings of the Symposium on the Environmental Consequences of Fire and Fuel Management in Mediterranean Ecosystems: USDA Forest Service Gen. Tech. Report WO-3; 1977. 498 p. Puig Sales, R. Aprovechamiento de residuos forestales. Soria: Seminario sobre recuperación de recursos de los residuos; 1980. 73 p. Rigueiro Rodríguez, A. Control de la vegetación mediante pastoreo. Madrid: Rev. Agricultura; 1979; 871-873. Vega Hidalgo, J. A. Utilización del fuego controlado en las comunidades vegetales de Galicia. Madrid: Bol. Est. Cent. Ecología, (14). 1978; 3-19. Vélez Muñoz, R. Prevención de incendios mediante ordenaci6n del combustible forestal. Madrid: Bol. Est. Cent. Ecología (12). 1977; 41-52. Vélez Muñoz, R. Criterios para la elaboracien de mapas de peligro de incendios forestales. Madrid. ICONA. Report. 1980a. 22 p. Vélez Muñoz, R. Fire prevention alternatives in reforestation. Madrid: FAO/ECE/ILO Seminar on afforestation and reforestation machines and techniques. 1980b. 13 p. 463