STRATIGRAPHY AND CORRELATION OF 1,HDDLE DEVONIAN STRATA IN THE JASPER SAG, NORTHEASTERN INDIAr-TA by William D. Rebuck Submi tted to Dr. R. William Orr and the Honors Irogram, Ball State Uni versi ty, Mun61e, Ind ia..l1a in .ful.fillment o.f ID 499, Senior Honors Thesis. June 1, 1970 ;::' - f. Coi i n1e~~,1 :~ l-D ""'l i..i '~, cJ.' ; ,Cf'lO Od~ • 1\ 7"; I recommend this thesis o~ ~or acceptance by the Honors Program Ball State University for graduation with honors. Thesis Adviser nAJ~( I. ~9.t?) Geography-Geology Department ICf70 CONTENTS Introduction. • • • • • • • Page • • • • • • • • • • • • .1 Figure 1. • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 2 Geologic structure ••••••••••• • • • • • • Figure 2 • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • Devonian stratiGraphy OI northern Indiana • • • • • • • • 5 Devonian rocks of Jasper County • • •• Figure 3. Figure 4 The ........ ••• conodo~'lt ••• ••• 10 . . . . . . . . . . . • 11 • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 12 fauna • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 13 Table 1 • • • • • Table 2 • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • .14 • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • .15 Correlation • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • .16 Figure 5 • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 18 References cited • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 19 INTRODUCTION This paper concerns research pertaining to the investigation o~ Devonian strata in Jasper County near Rensellaer, Indiana (Fig. 1). Strata o~ Middle Devonian age are exposed in the Northern Indiana Stone Inc. quarry (locality 1) at Pleasant Ridge and at the W. C. Babcock Construction Company quarry at Rensellaer (locality 2). At both localities Upper Devonian black shale is absent and the bedrock sur~ace is on the llIiddle Devonian carbonates. These rocks uncomormably overlie Silurian carbonates and crop out in the structural depression known as the Jasper Sag. The Mid6le Devonian strata have hereto~ore been unassigned as to geologic ~ormation. Field work and sample gathering was done in the autumn and winte!r o~ 1969. Dr. R. William Orr o~ the Department o~ Geography and Geology, Ball State University, accompanied the writer on several ~ield excursions and assisted the writer in numerclus ways. For this lowe him a debt o~ gratitude. It should. be noted that this paper is an outgrowth paper to be prepared by Dr. Orr ~rom the Indiana Academy o~ ~or o~ which a research grant Science was awarded. My gratitude is also Elxtended to the Indiana Geological Survey who did the initial processing recovery o~ conodonts. a o~ the rock samples ~or the 2 JASPER COUNTY R R. 6 2 w. 1 R. 5 w. T. 29 N. X oL--l----l 10 20 30 ! +0 I SO H' I Figure 1. Map of Jasper County showing collecting localities of Middle Devonian dolomite Wlits in the Jasper Sag. ~ tS 3 GEOLOGIC STRUCTURE The Cincinnati Arch is an intracratonic positive structure that trends northwest-southeast ~rom east-central Indiana to Lake County. The Arch separates the Illinois Basin to the southwest northeast. Most o~ ~rom the Michigan Basin to the the Cincinnati Arch is a plat.form with gentle monoclinal .folds on its ~lanks. In the crestal area of the Arch the dip of the strata is very small or imperceptible in the outcrop; however, on its ~lanks the dip is 35 .feet or more per mile (Pinsak and Shaver, 1964). The crestal area o~ the Arch is interrupted by two depressions, the Logansport Sag and the Jasper Sag (Fig. 2). Both depressions trend northeast-southwest and have structural relie.f of generally less than 100 .feet. The Jasper Sag is the more northern o.f the two depressions and is situated in Newton, Jasper, and Starke Counties. The Logansport and Jasper Sags are separated by a culmination or positive anomaly called the FranceSVille Dome (Pinsak and Shaver, 1964), which is located in White, Jasper, l'ulaski, and Fulton Counties. 4 ., I - J, ~ , , o I z ~ i' I l( \C • .L CL,,,rLl/r "'~''Wal C'Olu rT , If' iH): th,'I" :1 ~', ;. rn~C:1 25C· C;t:O 40 MI'rs __ ~.J Itf-I f .. 1:"1 '- r ....~. oj' tile 'frell ton Li:rrestol,e an -, !lamed structural fea.turec an 1 localities. Str'ucture fro::! 1952. awson, 5 DEVONIAN STRATIGRAPHY OF NORTHERN INDIANA Devonian strata in northern Indiana were first recogniz~~d by Owen (1839) who compared carbonate rocks underlying the Antrim Shale in Cass County with similar rocks in southern Indiana. The usage of nomenclature for Devonian strata in northern Indiana was summarized by Thornbury and Deane (1955). In the same report a comparison of the l:i thologies of Devonian strata of Miami County was made with the Traverse Group of Michigan. It was noted that the northern Indiana Devonian carbonate section appeared more correlative with the Traverse Group than with the North Vernon Limestone of southern Indiana and the Illinois Basin. Northeast of the crestal area of the Cincinnati Arch, the pre-:Pleistocene subcrop of Devonian strata in Indiana extends as a belt having an east-west orientation along the southern flank of the Michigan Basin. The strata in this belt attain a maximum thickness of about 200 feet. In the Logansport Sag (Cumings and Schrock, 1928) Middle Devonian strata lithologically more closely resemble equivalent strata of the Michigan Basin than those of the Illinois Basin (Orr, 1969). In the Jasper Sag Devonian rocks extend across the broad crest of the Cincinnati Arch into the Illinois BaSin, where they lie at the bedrock surface and extend in a northwest-southeast belt along the northeastern flank of the Illinois Basin. In northern Indiana there are two main divisions of !vUddle D.avonian carbonate rocks: the Detroit River Formation 6 (SchneidElr and Keller, 1969) and the Traverse Formation. The Detroit River Formation is separated f'rom the overlying Traverse Formation by an unconi'ormity. These two units are correlative with the Detroit River Group and Traverse Group of' Michigan, respectively. The Detroit River Formation unconforulably overlies the Salina Formation (Silurian) in the northern part oi' the state. It lithologically resembles the Lucas Dolomite of' Michigan and pinches out westward in Porter County and has its f30uthernmost extension in Adams and Cass Counties. In the northernmost part oi' Indiana, the Detroit River Formation attains a thickness oi' 140 i'eet (Pinsak and Shaver J 1964). It ranges in thickness i'rom 12 to 40 i'eet in cores stuoied by Orr (1967). Devonian strata are .found overlying every major component part oi' the Salina and Wabash ,1;'ormati0tlS (Pinsak and Shaver, 1964). The Silurian-Devonian inter.face is uncon.formable throughout the area with no Lower Devonian strata present. None of' the faunas recognized to be (' ei'ini tely Devonian have been shown to be older than Middle Devonian in age. This relationl3hip is demonstrated in the Geneva Dolomi te J Fendleton SandstonE!, and Je.fi'ersonville Limestone of the southern Indiana outcrop area. In many localities it is dii'ficult to distinguish Silurian i'rom Devonian rocks. Detailed faunal and lithologic studies ~~e required to elucidate the age relationships in these areas. In areas where the Wabash Formation is the 7 uppermost Silurian unit, argillaceous, silty dolomite is domiruUlt in eastern portions of the area and coarse textured:, vUggy or cherty dolomite in western sections. In northern Indiana, north o.f the crest of the Cincinnati Arch, basal Devonian rocks most commonly consist o.f gray to light brown, .fine-grained to dense, more or less arenaceous dolomite. This basal Devonian zone generally averages about 10 feet in thickness. This arenaceous zone is signi:ficant in the identification of the Silurian-Devonian boundary. The arenaceous zone grades upward into more normal tan and gray, granular, somewhat argillaceous dolomite and lime:stone. The basal Devonian arenaceous zone is probably equivalent to part of the Detroit River Group of Michil~an, most likely the Lucas Dolomite. This sandy zone is included with the overlying carbonate rocks in the manner o.f Landes (1951) who included the Sylvania Sandstone in the D,etroit River Group. The Detroit River Group in Michigan is composed of four formations. They are in ascending order: Sylvania S~ilostone, Amherstburg Formation, Lucas Dolomite, and Anderdon Limestone. This nomenclature for the Detroit River Group was proposed by Ehlers (1950). The middle portion of the Detroit River Formation contains dolomite, dolomitic limestone, evaporites (gypsum and anhydrite), ano thin shale partings in order of decreasing abundance. In the upper portions of the Detroit :~iver Formation the rocks are generally gray to tan, subli thographic to lithographic li'r.estone. This upper 8 portion resembles similar beds in the Anderdon Limestone that lies at the top of' the Detroit River Group of' Michigarl. The Detroit River group thins to the south and is composed o:f carbonates, thin shale partings and evaporites. Lithographic limestone is f'ound near the top of' many sections. The AmhElrstberg Formation of' the Detroit River Group pinches out southward and does not enter Indiana. It is likely therefore, that the Indiana portion corresponds only to the Lucas Dolomite. ThEl Traverse Group (Middle Devonian) of Michigan consistEJ of about 10 formations. A complete discussion of the Traverse Group in its type area near Thunder Bay, i¥1ichigan can be found in Warthin and Cooper (1943). In northernmost Indiana, southward thinning rocks equivalent to the ~~raverse Group, are found overlying the Detroit River Formation. It is probable that these younger rocks extend farther south than the Detroit River in which case the name TraversH Formation could be extended to strata in Howard, Cass, },itami, and Carrol Counties. In northern Indiana strata equivalent to portions of the Traverse Group have been called the Jeffersonville Limestone (lower j,lIicldle Devonian), Logansport Limestone (Hamiltonian in age), Sellersburg Limestone (also Hamiltonian in age, and the Hamilton Group (Thornbury and Deane, 1955). In portions of Jasper, Benton, Tippecanoe, Newton, and White Counties r.1iodle Devonian strata consist of dark-brown, medium to coarse-grained, detrital dolomitic limestone with arenaceous, argillaceous, ana brecciated faCies. These rocks 9 appear to be correlative with the Traverse Group and are most likely Hamil ton in age (IJinsak and Shaver, 1964). The Traverse Formation of northern Indiana is a carbonat{~ succession consisting predominantly of limestone, argillacE~ous limestone, dolomite, and thin shale beds in oreer of decreasing abundance. Cooper and Warthin (1941) correlated similar bens which crop out near Logansport with the Hamilton Group of New York and proposed the name Logansport Limestone for these rocks. In the same report similarities of the Logansport Limestone with the Four Mile Dam Limestone was noted. Studies of conodont successions show that the northern Indiana ~eraverse Formation includes strata equivalent to a sub-Squaw Bay Limestone portion of the Traverse Group o.f Michigan (Orr, 1967). Orr (1969) extended the name Traverse Formation to 25 feet of strata in the Logansport Sag. Traverse rocks of the Sag and those of the Michigan Basin of equivalent late Middle DHvonian age have similar lithologies, similar depositional histories, and have almost identical conodont faunas. ~~he strata of the Logansport Sag have previously been separated into the Little Rock Creek Limestone, Logansport Limestone, and Miami Bend Formation in descending order, by Cooper and Phelan (1966). 10 DEVONIAN ROCKS OF JASPER COUNTY Middle Devonian rocks at localities 1 and 2 are almost exclusively fine-grained, dark gray dolomite. Figures 3 and 4 are stratigraphic sections from localities 1 and 2 respectively. Approximately 33 feet of I'fliddle Devonian strata are exposed at the Northern Indiana Stone Inc. quarry (locality 1). ~his quarry is located on the north side of state road 114, east of Pleasant Ridge, Indiana, C S i, NE i, sec. 19, T. 29 Ii., R. 6 W. (211cCoysburg quadrangle). About 11 feet of Midc11e T)evonian rocks are exposed at the W. C. Babcock Construction Company quarry (locality 2) on the southeast edge of Rensellaer, Indiana, SE !, SE i, sec. 30, T. 29 N., R. 6 TN. (Rensellaer quadrangle). The strata at both localities display very similar lithologies. The most notable c1ifference is the presence of a 4 inch shale unit at locality 2. The carbonates at locality 2 were much less pyritiferous than at locality 1. A greater abundance of phosphatic .fish bone fragments was noted in the processed heavy mineral samples from several beds at locality 1. All cited topographic maps are from the U. S. Geological Survey 7.5 minute series (1:24,000). 11 f ./ / / ./ / ./ ./ ./ ./ ./ ./ L / ./ ./ / / ./ "/ L ./ L L / / / ./ ~. ./ / ./ ./ / ./ ./ ./ ./ /. L ./ / / ./ /. L L / ./ L ./ ./ /. L L L L ./ 5 • l / -"\ ./, ./ / ./ ./ ~ /l .,. -/ / / / / - /.-./-./--/. ./ ./ 1 ./ ./ / ./ A 10 ./ L /. ./ /. ./ / / ./ / .// / L / / ~ /'\. ./ ./ / / ~" / ./ ./ ./ ./ ./ /. ./ ./ ./ ./ L ./ ./ ./ ./ / 15 ./ ./ / ./ '/ ./ ./ ./ ./ ./ ./ /' " ./ ./ ./ L / I' / / / / ./ ./ /// r4 H ./ / ~ 7///// // // / /// / L / / -,~L V / / / L / L /r / 4 L / /1 / / // / , / . / /r //1 / / 7 , -"""l L / ./ ./ I / L ./ ./ Z / L / ./ o L ./ / / /. H ./ / ./ / ~ L L / gray; thin bedded, weathers to light brown; contains molds and casts of fossils (brachiopods, corals, stromatoporoids), scattered vugs and slitlike cavities previously occupied by .fossile (brachiopo ': sj pockets of massive white calcite, dolomite crystals on weathered surfaces; limonite, pyrite and marcasite; lowermost part is argillaceous. 6' 10" ./ / ./ ./ /. LL' " ./ ./ ./ ./ ./ L~ L~ L ./ o Dolomite, fiDe-grained, very dark ./'\ / ./ /L L ./ ./ ./ / ./ / / / ....... 10 [f} '~ (.) [f} 11 Dolomite, as above; weathers to medium brown with contrast to unit above; upper boundary is prominent undulating bedding plane; upper part contains pockets of ~casite 20 and is distinctly lisonitic; argillaceous in part; intervals 12 and 13 are conspicuously fossiliferous with brachiopods &Ad colonial corals; thin bedded in upper half becoming increa.singly thicker towards toe base. 25' 6" 25 12 /-'L-/-/-~ -/-/-/- ,/ //// L / / / /-/-/-/-/- 30 //// / / / / ./ ./ / ././ /./ . / -Dolomite, very :fine grained to sublithoGra~hic; grades ~rom pure /-/-/-/and laminated at the top to distin~ ./ -" - L - / - . / 35 ly argillaceous and platy in lower part; to several feet above quarry floor. 2' 4" Fig. 3-Stratigraphic section of Midr'lle Devonian strata at the Northern Indiana Stone Inc. quarry, Pleasant Ridge, Indiana. ./ L ./ ./- 12 ,...... 7 / / / / 7 -/ / / o 7~ / / / / / ~ / / / / / / / 1 / / fine to medium grained, aark gray weathering to brown, sparingly fossiliferous (mostly corals), argillaceous in part with 4" shale 38"-42" below top; measured from highest bedrock to top quarry bench; base of unit is several feet above oase of Devonian strata 11' • //// Dolomite~ :-I / / / -, / / ~ 7 Z / ~ -/-/-/-/-/-. ';:'7-/ -/--/-/- I%l H - / - / -/-./-'--/- H / 0 ~ PI A H ~ -- / / / / / / / / / / / / / / /// / / //// / / -7 / / 7 / / / / / / / / / / / / / L / / / / / / 10' / Fig. 4-Stratigraphic section of Middle Devonian strata at the W. C. Babcock Construction Company quarry, Rensellaer, Indiana. 13 THE CONODONT FAUNA :';liddle Devonian strata o£ the Jasper Sag display a pauci ty o.f conodont s:f€ cimens. Approximately 200 specimens were recovered £rom 19 samples averaging 1 kilogram in weight. Due to the £ragmentary, poorly preserved state o£ many o£ the speci:nens, specific taxonomic assignment was illpossible in many cases. The strata o£ the Jasper Sag have a characteristic association o£ upper l'Uddle Devonian conodonts. In the material studied, platform conodont species are represented by Icriocus latericrescens, l..£!:iodus expansus, Icriodus ~iformis, and Polygnathus varcus. Cone conodonts identi£ied are Acodina curvat~ and Hindeodella B~lodella devonicus. The only bar recovered is ~ The conocont faunas at localities 1 and 2 are identical except for the absence o£ Belodella devonicus and Icriodus cymbilormis at locality 2. Icriodids are by far the most prolilic constituent o£ the conodont faunas with Icriodus latericrescens latericrescens and Icriodus expansus predominant. Tables 1 and 2 show the stratigraphic distribution of conodont species at localities 1 and 2 respectively. It can be Obl:lerved £rom the tables that the exposed Devonian strata at both quarries lie within the }olygnathus varcus Zone (Givetian). This zone is characterized by the association of Polygnathus varcus and Icriodus latericrescens latericresc~. 14 Table 1. Stratigraphic distribution o£ conodont species at the Northern Indiana Stone Inc. quarry. Conodont Species Icriodus cymbi£o~nis L.. latericrescens Sample (top) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 X X X X X I.:. eXI1ansus Acodina X X X X ~vat§l: Hindeodella §.12.!. X X X X X Po l;y:gnathus varcus X Belodella devonicus X X 15 Table 2. Stratigraphic distribution of conodont species at the W. C. Babcock Construction Company quarry. Conodont Species Sample (top) 1 2 3 4 Icriodus expansus ~ latericrescens Acodina curvata x xX X X X X X Polygnathus varcus X Hindeodella X ..§.ll.=.. 16 CORRELATION From the conodont faunas previously described it has been shown that the Devonian strata of the Jasper Sag lie within the polygnathus varcus Zone Orr (1969) extended the name Traverse Formation to 25 feet o:f strata in the Logansport Sag. The Miami Bend Formation, Logansport Limestone, and Little Rock Creek Limestone are downgraded to the rank of lithofacies. These Devonian strata lie between subjacent Silurian strata and the superjacent New Albany Shale. The conodont £aunas £rom the Traverse Formation o£ the Logansport Sag show that two conodont zones are present there. The lower zone is marked by the presence o£ Icriodus latericrescens !..atericre~q~~ and the upper is the ;!?olye;nathu.Q varcus Zone which contains both Icriodus laterierescens and Polygnathus varcus. The lower portion of the Traverse rocks of the Sag (i.e. the Miami Bend and the lower part o£ the Logansport Lithofacies) lie within the Icriodus latericrescens later1crescens Zone below the lowest position af Polygnathus yarcus. The upper portion of the Traverse Formation (i.e. the upper part of the Logansport Lithofacies and the Little Rock Creek Lithofacies) lie within the Polygnathus varcus Zone. In northern Indiana the Traverse Formation unconformably overlies the Detroit River Formation and lies within the Icriodus latericrescens later1crescens and Polygnathus varcus Zones. In the Michigan Basin o£ northern Indiana 17 the lower part of the Traverse Formation lies within the zone of Icriodus latericres~ latericriscens while the upper part lies within the F'olygnathus varcus Zone. (Orr, 1967). In southern Inc1iana the Beechwood Member of the North Vernon Limestone lies on the intertonguing Speed and Silver Creek Members of the North Vernon Limestone. The Beechwood Member lies within the Iolygnath!!§. varcus Zone (Orr and }'ollock, 1968). The superjacent basal limestone of the New Albany Shale in southern Indiana lies within the Schmidtognathus hermanni-t.Q.lygnathus cristatus Zone and occupies a problematical position between the !iliddle and Upper Devonian (Orr and Klapper, 1968). The conodont fauna of the Beechwood Member contains as important elements Polygnathus varcus, F. linguiformis, and Icriodus latericrescens latericrescens as well as a few specimen~3 of ~ beckmanni, ~ foliatu~ and P.? variabilis. The presence of the latter three taxa suggests that the Beechwood Member is in the upper part of the Polygnathus varcus Zone. Fi~~re 5 shows the biostratigraphic equivalence of strata in the Jasper Sag with units in the Logansport Sag, the rocks of the Michigan Basin of northern ano with Middle Devonian strata in the Illinois Basin of southern Indiana. 18 .I NORTH AMERICAN JASPER SAG LOGANSPORT SAG CONODON~I ZONES FOLYGNATHUS VARCUS NORTHERN INDIANA MICHIG Al1 BASIN BEECHWOOD MEMBERNORTH VERNON LIMESTONE UNDIFFERENTIA.TED UPPER MIDDLE DEVONIAN SOUTHERN INDIANA ILLINOIS BASIN TRAVERSE FORUTION ~ At--------I A H 21 TRAVERSE FORMATION ICRIODUS LATERICRESCENS LATERICRESCENS SILVER CREEK MEMBER- Figure· 5.· ·Correlation of Devonian strata of' Jasper County with equivalent units in Logansport, northern Indiana and southern Indiana. 19 REFERENCES CITED Cooper, G. A. and Vlarthin, A. S., 1941: New Uiddle Devonian stratigraphic names: J. Washington Acad. Sci., v. 53, p. 1729-1794. Cooper, G'. A., and Phelan, Thomas, 1966: Stringocephalus in the Devonian of Indiana: Smithsonian Misc. ColI., 151 (1), 20 p. Cumings, E. R., and Schrock, R. R., 1928: The geology of the Silurian rocks of northern Indiana: Indiana Dept. of Conservation Pub. 75, 226 p. Dawson, ~:. A., 1952: Map showing generalized structure of TrEmton Limestone in Indiana: Indiana Geol. Survey 111isc. Llap 3. Ehlers, G. 1,1., 1950: Revised classification of the Middle Devonian Detroit River Group (abs.): Geol. Soc. America Bull., v. 61, p. 1455-1456. Landes, K. K., 1951: Detroit River Group in the IUchigan Basin: U. S. Geol. Survey Circ. 133, 23 p. Orr, R. VI., 1967: Conodonts froiG Middle Devonian strata in the Michigan 13asin: Unpub. Fh.D. thesis, Indiana Univ., 169 p. Orr, R. W., and IQapper, Gilbert, 1968: Two new conodont species from middle-Upper Devonian boundary beds of Ind:iana ancl New York: Jour. Paleontology, v. 42, p. 1066-1075. Orr, R. W., and Pollock, C. A., 1968: Reference sections and correlation of Beechwood ;\jember (North Vernon Limestone, illidl~le Devonian) of southern Indiana and northern Kentucky: Am. Assoc. l'etroleurn Geologists Bull., v. 52, p. 2257-2262. 20 Orr, R. W.,1969: Stratigraphy and correlation of Middle Devonian strata in the Logansport Sag, north-central Inoiana: Proc. Indiana Acad. of Sci., v. 78, p. 333-341. Owen, D. D., 1838: SeconCl report of a geological survey of the State of Indiana, made in the year 1338, in conformity to an order of the legislature: Indianapolis, Osborn and Willets, 54 p.; (revision) Continuation of a report of a geological reconaissance of the State of Indiana, maoe in the year 1838, in conformity to an order of the legislature: Indl.anapolis, John C, Walker, 69 p., 1859. Pinsak, A. P., and Shaver, R. H., 1964: The Silurian formations of northern Indiana: Indiana Geol. Survey Bull. 32, 87 p. Schneider, A. F., and Keller, S. J., 1969: Geologic map of the Chicago lOX 20 quadrangle, Indiana, Illinois, and !Uchigan, showing bedrock geology ana unconsolidated deposits: Indj.ana Geol. Survey Regional Geol. Map 4. Thornbury, W. D., and Deane, H. L., 1955: The geology of Miami County, Indiana: Indiana Geol. Survey Bull. 8, 49 p. Warthin, A. S., and Cooper, G. A., 1943: Traverse rocks of Thunder Bay region, 1,:lichigan: Am. Assoc. Petroleum Geolog'ists Bull., v. 27, p. 571-595.