(c) crown copyright Catalogue Reference:CAB/65/1/8 Image Reference:0001 ML (895 o TQVB1 UliaER LOCK A N D KEY. It is requested that special care may be taken to ensure the secrecy ol this document. W A R ' CABINET.. 8 CONCLUSIONS of a Meeting of the War Cabinet held at 19 Downing Street, S. W. 1, on Friday, September 8, 1939*, a t 11 - 30 A . M . Present: The Right Hon. NEVILLE CHAMBERLAIN, M.P.,. Prime Minister (in the Chair), The Right Hon. Sir JOHN SIMON, K.C., M.P., Chancellor of the Exchequer. Admiral of the Fleet the Right Hon. LORD CHATFIELD, Minister for Co- ordination of Defence. . The Right Hon. L. HORE-BELISHA, M.P., Secretary of State for War. The Right Hon. Sir SAMUEL HOARE, B t , M P . , Lord Privy Seal. [ifi The Right Hon. VISCOUNT HALIFAX, Secretary Affairs! The of Right State Hon. for Foreign WINSTON CHURCHILL, M.P., First the Admiralty. Lord S. of The Right Hon. Sir KJNGSLEY WOOB, M.P;, Secretary of State for Air. The Right Hon. LORB Minister without Portfolio. HANKEY, J The following were alsp present The fRight Hon. Sir JOHN ANDERSON, MjP., Secretary of State' for the Home Department and Minister for Home Security. The Right Hon. ANTHONY EDEN, M.P., Secretary of Affairs. State for Dominion The Right Hon. WALTER ELLIOT, M.P., The Sir M.P., First Commissioner of Works (Item 5). A i r Chief Marshal Sir CYRIL L. N . NEWALL, Chief of the A i r Staff (Items 1-4). Minister of Health (Item 5). HORACE J . WILSON, Permanent Secretary to the Treasury. Admiral of the Fleet Sir DUDLEY POUND, First Sea Lord and Chief of Naval"Stalpg^s;i^.". Right.' Hon. General Sir W. H. RAMSBOTHAM, EDMUND IRONSIDE, Chief of the Imperial General Staff (Items 1-4)1 W. S. DOUGLAS, Under-Secretary, Treasury (Item 5). - Secretariats . Sir/ErawARD-BRIBJGES.: , : 1 Air'Operations... ' . . . . . . . . . . . . ... V. 2 The Naval Situation ... ... ... 3 The Army Situation ..... ... ... 4 Assistance from India... ... ... 5 Evacuation of Government Departments 6 Turkey . ... ... ... v 7 Italy: Internal Political Situation ... ... ... ... 8 Naval Operations. : , a 9- : ­ ... *. ... ... f .... . ... h ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... . . . . . . Question of despatch to Gibraltar of certain units from the, H o m e Fleet. ' Italy: Commercial Contacts 10 The Balkans 12 United States Naval Patrol in the Western Atlantic 13 The Far Eastern Situation 14 Poland: the Military Situation 15 ObscuratiM of Lightihg 16 Acti ? taken by the Dominions 17 Eire: Representation of the UnitedKihgdomin... 18 Meetings of the WarGabmetoh Sundaysi ... 0 ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... . . . . . . . . . ... ... ... '.. . .. .. . . . . . . . . . . . ... ... ;,. . El ' SSmimte'lilt.,;, .-!., . A to i m t h m -m on H diseusjkia L o o t ,]L'C. n ' sd: , LJ - - iho di'KMkw' m - .- c o D k a t o f c t V^ffis good rease^ k\ OD ..xn"!i ^ ou. i k u j p ^ r-fe &k I c 2 3 ^ '.louiS-fie ojiwa J a m ­ : . ities fe - I &hs eneet ot our propaganda, £in. J - Ias'j that o u r ; T xsraffi were able .to fly with, impunity .^1 over & e North-West of Germany would" have a depressing effect oh"'the;-morale Of; the German peopkv. : , - " I t "was;generally; agreed that -the Material which should be incorporated in theieaiets was a matter, which could best be left to the discretion of the. Ministry; of; Information, but: that the suggestion that the- Prime. Ministers Broadcast. to the^ German people would form a suitable leaflet should be brought to the notice ; % f Of V m - M i t i M ^ y p ' ' - ' (V'.I 1 - T . , The W a r Cabinet agreed :— That the distribution of propaganda leaflets by the Boyal Air Porce was a-"valuable operation which shbulttbe repeated from time to time as and when - oppbr^unfty 2. The First Lord of the Admiralty reported that, in the previous twenty^four hburs, four British merchant ships had been Sitnationu 8n^;.'oat'of/a- fplal,.(if. eight attacked; There had been no loss of . (Previous life, as the ships had been sunkby; gunfire after the crewshad been would enable W . M . ( 3 9 ) , 7th removed. .He(proppsed t o prepare;a a comparison to be made between the present losses and those Conclusions, sustained at the height of the German submarine campaign in 1917 Minute 2.) W rektipn to the total tonnage involved in each case. This, he thought, would show that the present campaign, "though- intense, was not- comparable in its results to the previ'Qus';bhe. possible';'steps were being taken-'fo introduce the convoy system, and' the Admiralty were proposing' to' restrict the sailings of valuable fast ships until they had been'armed. There were numerous n srorts of attacks on enemy suhia; nes by our Destroyers' though n : , c i a could,not Be assessed wife cjftainty. ' It, wag proposed, subject-to THE-concurrence of the A i r Ministrv Jhat iwo'-.'-'8qiuadrons- "of ' iohg^ange'- lyiW-b0tsnow -in M^-'-- - ' 2 c t / 3 ;t e ' i) z they could ;asilst : ; ; : Z J : ! : : TLa GIzwl of, ike Ait &Cc J ozgrnSed his ^neuifence T 5e T T / / : 2 i v Cabinet; n^ie "TIIH of iiuc ' zjrs State-ncnt. this CONTENTS. No. -Subject. I A i r Operations... 2 The Naval Situation ... 3 The Army Situation ... 4 Assistance from India... 5 Evacuation of Government Departments ... ... ,... 6 Turkey ... :.. ... ... 7 Italy: Internal Political Situation ... ... ... ... 8 Naval Operations .... .... ... * ... ... ... ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .... ... ; ... . . . . . . ... ... ... ... \.. . . . . . . Question of despatch to Gibraltar of certain units from the E o m e u-;.;.. Fleet; :. / ; '.'. 9 10 Italy: Commercial Contacts The Balkans ... ... . . . . . . II Egypt 12 United States Naval Patrol in the Western Atlantic 13 The Far Eastern Situation 14 Poland: the Military Situation ... ... 15 Obscuration of Lighting ... ... ... 16 Aption taken by the Dominions ... 17 Eire: Representation of the United Kingdom in '..\ ; 18 Meetings of the W a r Cabinet on Sundays ... ... ... ... ... ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. ... '.. . ... . . . . . ... . . . . .. j O T ^ W D iSHOALS D - . ' IIG \ o: ^ S C A - O - HA S O M E : --i-- - EONFKDA (QIMAATARS , T F j - r : ME E O A I D I U A O D . FESLKJG 7 D' j L .1 JC B I S - - IHC,u it, , uL - ; ; S A O T RIGIAE I i ^ : . ; A :'A. 0a uL .A i OWN, TIJMII i, j.i J&J i i ".,LS 3 WAC D " A A , -\ADDA " * H A D ; i. a^ionf Pad^AA : (AX -AD I N A N D "S to flv v^th ihiounrtv a l^ORFCH-^^est-. - O F -Gei^MMv W O I X L D D ' have a depressing effect' oh -thedmpiMe of the"-German-pspple.. : ^ ' It- wasgenerally - agreed that the material which should he ^incorporated' in the -leaflets -was a-matter which---could bestfoeleft to the discretion o f the -Ministry 'o£. Information,-* but; that tha suggestion that the Prime Ministers Broadcast to the German people would form a suitable leaflet should be brought to the notice of the Ministry. , . The W a r Cabinet agreed :—That the distribution of propaganda leaflets by the-Royal A i r Force was a valuable operation which should ,foe repeated from time to time as and When opportunely -. $ * $ - ' " " ' ' ';' .''- ; -' -d /d'-'-''d'' 'l'd',d, a ; 4 1 o n : : : ! ;; ;: 1 ; :i! 2. The First Lord of the Admiralty riepprted that, in the previous twenty^four hours, four British merchant ships had been sunk out of a tot,al of eight attacked; There had been no loss o f life, as the ships had been sunk, by gun-fire after the crews had been removed. H e proposed to prepare a calculation which would enable a comparison to be made between the present losses and those sustained at the height of the German submarine campaign in-1917, in relation to the total tonnage involved in each case. This, he thohght, would show that -the present-campaign, though intense, was not comparable in its results, to the previous..bne. . A l l possible steps were Being taken to introduce the convoy - system, "and -the "Admiralty were proposing-to restrict the sailings­ of valuable F A S T ships until they had-"been armed. There were n U M E R O U S reports of &ttacks.-pn e^^y subm^rin^''bj our Destroyers, -monin I h e "resu^^ It, was proposed, subject.t0'the concurrence of the Air Ministry, . that two Squadrons o f ' long-range flying-boats, now in the "MedyisrraiQieand S H O E I D - b e moved -to stations wb "they could- assist. - 1 4 ' L H A pirflii&GDDA/OF laa-ds O H the Boatk-Wssdidaapproaekes and O N ( 5 1 v ; liz c^ssl The. OL C Cfcief :aia of ike -.- suggestion;;--- a-.- Ah\ cignilietahis ccncarrencs with this .. - - ;'..- ... .. -..',-(.d.'-:\d' d dd SLicff - . -;.:-:: ', v D r : A ^ D ; I A S D A C : J- , ' On Armies had fiiw^acesBtjW^ . o/f Inreplytb ap-:ehqMry -hyi^-Erime- l ^ a j ^ ^ ^ t h e - ChiCTr?if-,^s -Iihperial-i j&ener^ Staffi saM^tiMt Y T H S Y ^ ^ N ^ i ^ E T E , fully /f^R^r$& agaiast a possible turning movement tlirougb-HdHand and-B^gjuj^n. e r j n : The W ^ ' ! C ^ ^ L : I ^ ^ W C ^ ! A I I ' " ­ iifo^lifcatemeiii f 4. The Chief of; the Imperial General Staff read to the War Cabinet a telegram which had been received by,,the Secretary of State for India: from the Indian Government, a copy of which is annexed to these Minutes (Annex)., India. - The W a r Cabinet agreed : That an expression of their appreciation of this generous offer of assistance should be conveyed to the Government of India. ; 5. The W a r Cabinet had under consideration a Note by the Minister of Home Security on the Evacuation of Government Departments (W.P. (39) 10). Emanation of Departments. (Previous Reference: W . M . (39), 6th Conclusions, Minute 2.) The Minister of Home Security said that the Inter-Depart­ mental Committee, which had.been set up by the desire of the W a r Cabinet to consider the moves of certain special staffs in advance Their recommendations of the general move, had now reported. were given in his Note, and he drew particular attention to their .. views :— . ' . (a) that first priority should be given to the m o v e s of the Supply organisations of the A i r Ministry and Admiralty to HarrOgate and Bath respectively, - (6) that none of the moves should be ordered before the Office Of Works reported that arrangements were ^reasonably " .... ready.' ' The First Commissioner of Works reported that instructions had been issued on Wednesday night to carry pht the requisitioning of the premises required for the whole move.- A s regards the move of the A i r Ministry. tP Harrpgate, accommodatipn would be available on Monday, the ilth September, but under conditions which might be somewhat chaotic, and he Would prefer that the move should be postponed, at least until Wednesday, the J.3ih September. The accommodation for the Adhliraliy ai Bmh could also be got ready by Monday, but here again he would p r e f e r to postpone it until later : n e x t week. In that event, however,-owing to railway difficulties,, the. move could not, take,place.before Thursday, and would then h a v e to be carried butIff^o^ejcEwpn^' extending over-. Friday. The 1,500 Ministry of Supply staff f r o n t Woolwich, which was second' on the list of priority, was an entirely new demand, which had not been included in the original scheme, and he asked to foe given a;.few, days grace,;to',find. t h e , necessary a c c o i E E i i o d a t i o n . : s J The Minister of Health reported that biUeting,noticss were now ­ being served, and that he was satisfied that the necessary room was everywhere available, though in certain cases it might at first be cramped and involve clcphg on ifora. A -"dh^cuissioh^en^il^ ^ 1 ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ % ^ V : mmmmm$ N I ------" ^ M T v.;v-..-:--^.v­ I f I S S I I f ' i PPSIlSiSsil ered i ul IS is 1816 i led a tge -'of ^preparation: to - enable;' the stiffe/csoa:- ­ sufficient ^ ... tosi ^ 3e(lc c j ^ I U ' : l o iv LL " ­ cerned J ^ llttllfll 111188 ^ If] I I J wJ l ?$&ir ' rjjs Bcswyf^i TO-ar jwfoa (L (T) ( V r id (TD) c" V/ P, (tB) ;0), Sk? l i t e £ e H o a o C o ;/a:-v'&!ppl^^ -. ':' l: 'tMs" : M f i i s i i ^ (a) that it was imdadisble Shaft pmbMeity ahorfd be given to thio m^tte-by questions m Parliament,, &ad feat fcSp acyasct of the isa&Csr. shonld fee careMly watched. (The Prime Minister undertook to bear this point in mind.) h r ;; : 1 ' /^r'': ;vlV-l?V.v;:v/-:^. '^deeS ; Q. F 3 Secretary of SiaAe fzv Foreign A fairs said "that, ia accordance with the d oi e^c of the Wk Z jinet noted M iim ms gin, he L sle -d ' o Hie I I ? i " b 7 c Aiatessadc iLdkara,, r , (Previous Preferences: W . M . (89), 5th r o 1 5 Stifr-Conclusion^ I 0 p q t e $ ) * i,. .;regard-4o-film feflS/iMb/sao qaes&ion, - ^-Tlae^jabassadoi had-since. reposied (Tebr 2 13c &oo£ A cslj^ t^st !he Ih&d seea ihe- Ti^Msh -.' M'3L S-& W(m%g%'h&SMm-mi hs^^-ssi^^md- him tfo3&"*m.-m&&­ j.ros t h e i s o i C i oan I: a " : . / c . . '-.LC x. 1,. Tibs fcbe i L i f : : '-- ' -'; Tev^fe" yfjalsfesr; f o r - i ^ e i g a - . A k i f e -kadk-..wmk%3&-- MmmiiiZ/m­ 'J T l ' i C-^o f /-G the 1 r : T C ; n ; M ' .;- L ' y - - K v. ' " , -vii: ^A^assado^at tm * . K - * q . ' - ; - "- , II" . - I/. . \ ? "l - " , 1 ----- 'h^f ^ 1; vdppoaT - , i i , i!,,)^;. / - ^ ' - - - " V H i Question' of des­ patahlto; febreltM'' of - certain units'­ from the Home tPeei"^^ ' f ' /Ssli-Q : - ' l , - v The W a r Cabinet a g r e e d ­ l -* **** * - - - - ­ 1 ^T^^g&SS 1 W-Mi "(39), 7th Conclusions, Minute 2.) : Si T h e C U n c e l l m ' : o f t h e E w f a q v e r informed the -WOE OfflbraeJ that the diWJtoJ^; f F^tacatoMto/.,^ establishing c m m i m ^ - m ^ ^ lt,aly shpwed:v I t a l y : GommraB­ t o (previous . Reference M . W ­ (39), .5th -Conohjisipns, e r (1) That as refolds possible p u t a , - to A t - i M i t f f t f t BJe3y and *to.Mm*add be jflfpsw.^, it TO dihicult Awr £hem to e?y whoi ttey-"of3 ' - lipnute 5-) : 1 s ^'^-pff^^ 'IB r ; -v! - - f . , - -i . ; - v j , : Mat Si ^i^m^Mm^:^:. y^WmMmM- W e ^ a h B l i g P B ^ : 1 im '"iiisiili^SilBsfe x '* . f l i f :­ -ipaMsies;:: ;^l^f; ; - ^ired'to'nmke v ' m ^ a e l u ^ ^- -1 ; the Befenee : S - 2 1 raa-.a&s7a IKIB ; : ^T&*v* - % s m & m f . : - d he ^KHT T ddressed a telegram TO u r % ^ n r s i i u i z t i t z e ito eadb ml fcfine Balkan countries s d d i a g f o r d l i B T u d a s- da J:gaiM'!to-fee pi^etieabiMty of establish-­ $PGDSIDJN^ ddV- dv / ^ad '-V '.'d d ThedWarCabinet took note of this statement. 11; The Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs informed the W a r Cabinet that he had received a telegram from His Majesty's Ambassador, Cairo,reporting that he bad received an intimation W.M. (39), 7th from the Egyptian Government that, if he was to inform them in Conclusions, writing that the measures so far taken, including the declaration Minute 4.) f martial law, were not sufficient, they would declare a state of war between Egypt and Germany. Action was accordingly being taken on these lines. (Previous Reference: 0 The War. Cabinet took note of the above statement. STEAL PATEOL to THE WESTERN MANMO. ' 12. The Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs informed the W a r Cabinet that a. telegram had been received from His Majesty's Ambassador, Washington, giving particulars regarding the naval atrol in the Western Atlantic which the United States Government ad decided to establish. The Admiralty had been asked to consider the information supplied, and to inform the Foreign Office whether they were satisfied with the action proposed to be taken by the United States in this matter. E Tine W a r Cabinet took mote of the above statement. THE FAS EASTERN 13. The Secretary of State for Foreign AffairsmioiMeA the US&NGSISOH.' W a r Cabinet that two or three days previously the Japanese Government had addressed a note to theBritjs^iEjcench and United States Governments, suggesting that to "preventincidents in China during the present conflict in Europe each of those Governments should withdraw their military forces and their warships, and offering, if this suggestion were adopted, to look after the interests in China of the Governments concerned. Previous to the outbreak of war, consideration had been given to the practicability of withdrawing, these- forces, but with the exception of the General Officer Commanding, Hong Kong, the local authorities had all been opposed to such a course. The garrisons in Tientsin and Peking had been in existence since -1901, and that hithe International Settlement in Shanghai since 1927.' In each case the size of the garrison had been progressively reduced, and in his (the Secretary of State's) opinion these garrisons, would have to be withdrawn whenever the time eanmito secure a general se^emept of the posi^on.,. in,Cl&i&. " ' pjfe^ffhe ^prjjii^ tkeaSepretary \of .S^e*. rdjepatelr^ " t : ; I M DD '- -' ;. a v i a r j ^ a R . i ^ a a MVM& : - & i . a .. ^ a -...' 4 . 77 , ;A"D-AFE:V dWf C, after 'BfelfeEDl fatoaaMaTJai' nurify toot A Koto to £ £ 3 Efcs and stating ffiaft s a l e s O e j ( a a d ( £ 3 Illfcntoa States (m) 1 i p q p n n s f l to t i d t o a ^ g o r : be no akanaMfics to sslztjII (BaBCTSgi—-v^g) woold safe all on ttofl H li ifto coo erf t&3 Wsar fiT-nft;, sjsa 511 ^ ^ E P B to­ Sa t£to IFar 1£B&\ -me should 1 d e d . d e om w i t h d r a s H o d l r f s n ^ o f a n r mot c o n c e d e o u r leg^liE^^fiffiiffio^nc^pssiA (a) That the Swistaury off States far ffferaajsn A U n s s should j a o s Sa t f t o JFEJT ffitok to ( £ t o J q p c c s s a t o l tSto 15=33 a£ Ibis sflrfisrszl ,o to I&Sffidh War w i s e of ft&e MriiftiBi&i w w " n ^ j - imillBM^iify farces i n t h e Far Easfi A w M Dsn tanaa anttaaat f s n r i t e r B t f e r e n e e to the W a r C G S 3 E t o L 14. 7*ftff tffrmmry erf ^rdrfmr Wrr iwfia - i i j t h r W a r TVMnH that an emissary had jg&it ffapn faadk fiai Inland! uralfcfa at message from General CaBtan die Waasd, m^pa&zg osa t£be TViSisEb sniSItaiy E L t o a t i o B , which n r r ' - ^ w i t l y aggssBSBs, a i d aa^gggesdaiig that (Previous Great Britain aadTXfcaaee atanlil lane to find, atrto Jnnagivlftf Reference: conveying mil£tarj aa^pDfss tarJMandb; tian a n s e t a s t n a l o B ^ l w B r e W . M . (39), 7th a a r o p l a n s s , mae&iiEs gaas a n d anaaahntiaau HlriBasaaoe mas alsoConclusions, MSIDLS to prifaKs a^tofza Sa ffi^ktl ozjsr tSto cCitoj ^aafia Ito.il tofea Minute 3.) place HtstaESiiL Gito ( E t o a a a a itototoa to? tStoto ( E r a c t o j azi. feto­ : pTn^jCTtatiofi o£ the ^fctSiiiafe MBBniMaBiiiiiii . Members of iflte W a r CSaaJaet least TOJuimiwgi^r cM&atL easily sees oay. £d y ^ S s q csszllfl a n ^ f c t o i 3a. t h e n^-ttsnae w a s ­ '"" TheCMgf&ef Staff tos- Y T n r r (Danfant "4 CartaedeWfefc; i iat Jmyif' a^d Minister \Jtlrvto; . .mmsider' the in crafiSffllftatsGsa-i withj$ie., Ijlome; Secrefeary ;Home Security a l ^ w JS6p!HPk^&B' War ? IS. The War Cabinet took notei of a Memorandum by the (WJ?. (Gi)"$l9):5) covering :a statement showing the,nf^cip^-ac^ taken by the Dominions, Newfoaaiiidlahd" and. SmAfegm iMnbdesia, in regard to defence measures immediately preceding and since the outbreak of war up to the 4th September, 1939. tlsa-BemMosss. Secretorj.o£StatefmlA^m^JkM^^ (Previous ' Reference: \ "W.M. ( 3 9 ) , 2nd -exclusions, Minute 4.) : 17. The Secretary of State for Dm&immAffairsr reported that sakafion of the Mr. de Valera had mow espm^^i Mssaself as willing to receive a United Kingdom representative of the United Kingdom Government in Dublin. He in. had proposed that this representative should have the title of (Previous Ambassador, but it had been intimated that this was impossible Reference: from our point of view and the title " Representative " had been W . M . (89), 3rd agreed. Conclusions, The Secretary of State thought that, until our representative had been appointed to JMfeMm, it would be undesirable that the Minute 6.) Defence Departments should raise with the Eire Government, the grant of any major defence facilities (e.g., the use of Berehaven). The War (DaMffi^s thnrlk wmfkB casf fiM$ statement. Eire:. ;,Renie­ Meetings of the "Mas Cabinet on Sundays. (Previous Reference: WM. ( 3 9 ) , 7th -Conclusions, Minute 16.) 18. Some further disEanssoini teziz place on this matter. It was pointed out that although only three Ministers would normally be on dhmty each Sunday under the arrangement proposed, the remaining Ministers would not be far away and would be available at short notice. There was every adtemteflgg in an areangememt which would enable members of the War Cabinet, while available at short notice, to spend two Sundays in three out of JLendon. The Prime Minister said that the three groups of Ministers which he proposed were as follows:— : Group!. T h e IPteiiiime EBiaiDfcai?. T h e SsBV^a^-ofiEttpte' g a i s - g ^ ^ w a f c t r of the ; The:' on : amusser -: iaMtoaaf "(S3­ Group III. T h e Lord P r i v y SeaL T h e . Secretary of The £fret,.%aaA of the Irks Onafcib-ai.' Portfolio. it Group'iH- should be on duty on Sunday, ANNE5L Decipher of Telegram dated September-6^193% from Gqpernment of India, , . Defence Department, to Secretary ^Immediate. Wo. 2$!^/6/9.) ' ' V' N O W that we are at war, we are anxious to take timely steps to render further aid to His Majesty's Government to meet certain eventualities which, in bur judgment, may well have to be met by India from time to time during the course of the war. As a first-step in this direction, we have already arranged to increase output of our munitions factories to maximum extent possible dniorder not only to meet our own probable needs but, if possible/ all outside "demands? which, judging from our recent experiences, are likely to be considered %sie]si\ considerable. We now propose to take immediate action, with such material resources as we have at our disposal, to carry out the fbllbwihg :--- ; : (a) to form two additional Srigade groups for external defence purposes. The first suitable for reinforcing Burma, and second for employment for protection of Anglo-Iran oilfields or elsewhere where conditions of role are similar. (6) to simultaneously replace such troops, as arerequired for (a) aboye^by form­ ing equivalent number of new units for our own needs. . ..