Special Education Field Experience Assessments and Scoring Guides Candidates complete three field experience that require them to teach two or more lessons. In SPED 430 (Fieldwork in Elementary Classrooms) and SPED 445 (Fieldwork in Secondary Classrooms), candidates implement a unit of instruction that was developed in conjunction with the corresponding methods class that is a co-requisite for the field experience. This unit becomes one component of a Teacher Work Sample, which is completed in both settings. Candidates are also observed and evaluated by their WIU supervisor and the classroom mentor teacher during SPED 430 and SPED 445. SPED 420/430 and 440/445 Teacher Work Sample Overview: Candidates will develop units of instruction based on the needs and characteristics of the students with whom they work in SPED 430, Elementary Fieldwork. Instructional content will be determined by the IEPs of the students, Illinois State Learning Standards, district curriculum, and the input of the mentor teacher. Each unit of instruction must contain a minimum of 8 lesson plans. These lesson plans must be complete plans, using the format shown in the document in this packet titled, “Lesson Plan Evaluation and Feedback”. Do not use another format for your lesson plans. Each student will teach at least 5 of the 8 lessons. (Most candidates will have many opportunities to teach during the field experience that are not connected to the unit of instruction in the Teacher Work Sample [TWS]). You may NOT develop a TWS for spelling. You may NOT develop a TWS for a single student. When the TWS is turned into your SPED 420 instructor, all of the following should be included together in one neat package. Please put the TWS in a notebook (binder) with tabs to separate the sections and lessons. Please do not use plastic covers except when including materials that have multiple pieces, such as a puzzle. The following must be included in the following order: 1. Context of the Classroom (Description). Identify any elements in the class, school, or community that may impact the learning of your students. Examples include, but are not limited to, economic factors, any areas of conflict in the community or school, the neighborhood in which the school is built, family factors, etc. Describe your classroom specifically: How many students are in the class? What percentage of your students are boys? Girls? What disabilities are present? (A label is not necessary. What academic or behavioral difficulties are being addressed in the class?) Describe the physical layout of the class. (Also include a diagram of the physical layout). What are class rules? What is the class schedule? Are there elements in the classroom that seem to enhance student learning? Are there any elements that seem to get in the way of student learning? (This is not a question about the teacher). 2. Rationale. Briefly describe the content and skills of the unit and the reason(s) why you think the content you have chosen is worth the children’s time. What information about student characteristics and needs did you use in planning the unit? How does the content you have chosen fit into the district curriculum? 3. Connection of the unit to the student’s IEP. What goals and objectives that are listed on the students’ IEPs are connected to the lessons you teach? You may list these separately by child or list the together if several of the children have similar goals and objectives. If you are not allowed to see the children’s’ IEPs, address the connection between the instructional unit and State testing (ISAT or PSE). 4. Assessment Plan. Do not plan instruction before assessing your students. Include a copy of the preassessment tool. Explain why you chose to assess the content/skills in that manner. What information guided you to choose this approach? 5. Materials. Please list the materials you used for the unit. Include both materials that you used to prepare for instruction and those materials that you chose to use with the students. You must use at least 3 materials that are not available in the classroom in which you teach. Please asterisk (*) those items. Use APA format. Write a brief narrative about why the materials chosen are appropriate for the students you teach and for the content you have chosen. 6. Lesson plans. Include the following items: State Standards Objectives for the lesson Materials to be used with the students and the materials you used to prepare the lesson Anticipatory Set Input Modeling Checking for Understanding Guided Practice Independent Practice Lesson Closure Lesson Reflections Lesson Plan Reflections: The purpose of these questions is not for you to be overly critical of your performance but to help you identify which elements of your teaching need improvement and which successful elements of your teaching you can build upon. Use as much space as you need. a. Evaluate your preparation for the lesson. Did you have all the materials, directions etc. ready to teach? What organizational elements were successful? What organizational elements would you change? b. Evaluate your behavior management skills during this lesson. Were the students on task? Were they respectful of you and each other? Did you think that you were aware of what was happening in all corners of the room? Describe what was successful, what you’d like to change. c. Evaluate your time management skills during this lesson. Did you have enough time to do what you’d planned? Did you have back up materials for students who did not understand or who finished more quickly than anticipated? Was time wasted in any way? d. Evaluate the quality and quantity of feedback you provided for your students. Did your questions help students participate in the lesson? Were you able to clarify the lesson content/skills for students? Did you provide feedback to all of the students prior to measuring their progress? e. Were your students successful in meeting the stated objective(s) of the lesson? If your answer is “yes”, what do you think contributed to their success? If your answer is “no”, what do you think might have helped the students succeed? 7. Post- assessment and explanation. Include a copy of the assessment tool, a graphic or visual display that demonstrates student achievement on identified objectives, examples of student work, and an explanation of the objectives on which students were most successful and those objectives where additional instruction would be desirable. 8. Unit Reflection. (Please note. Candidates must reflect after each lesson taught. Those reflections must be included in the lesson plans. The unit reflection requires different information and is a separate component of the TWS). Please address the following as specifically as possible: a. How did your teaching change over the course of the unit? For b and c, please address your preparation for the content of the unit, your daily preparation and organization, classroom and behavioral management skills, your ability to adapt instruction for the varying needs of your students, and use of instructional time. b. c. d. e. What are you most proud of in your teaching of this unit? What gains did you make, as a teacher? What areas of teaching were most challenging for you? If you were to teach this unit again, what would you change? If you were to choose a unit to follow the unit you just taught, what content or skills would you choose? Why? f. What did you learn about your students during the course of the unit? g. How did teaching this unit impact your understanding of the TEP Dispositions? SPED 420/430 and 440/443 Teacher Work Sample Evaluation Student: Unit: Demonstrates novice performance – 2 CATEGORY Demonstrates no skill/proficiency—1 1 State Standards CEC Standard 7 CC4L, CC4Q, LBS3G, LBS4O Too few standards are listed and/or standards are inappropriate in more than one area Standards (2-3) are inappropriate in at least one area: grade level, exceptional conditions, learning objectives 2 Behavioral objectives CEC Standard 7: Instructional Planning One or more instructional/behavioral objectives do not meet criteria for writing objectives and are inappropriate given students’ grade levels, exceptional conditions, selected standards, assessment information One or more instructional/behavioral objectives do not meet criteria for writing objectives or are inappropriate given students’ grade levels, exceptional conditions, selected standards, assessment information 3 Essential Questions CC4Q, CC4R, CC4S, LBS4O, LBS4P, CC6M, LBS6H Essential questions do not relate to unit instruction Essential questions relate to unit but do not relate to long-term instructional goals 4 Choice of Content CEC1, 2, 3, 5, 7, 8, 10, LBS2A, CC2Q, LBS3B, LBS3E, LBS3G, LBS3N, CC4L, CC4N, CC4P, LBS4C, CC4Q, CC4R, CC4X, CC4Z, LBS4O, LBS6A, CC6C, CC6M, LBS6S Choice of content seems unrelated to best practice or learners’ needs Choice of content is based on collaboration with other educators &/or related service providers, and learners’ grade levels but shows little awareness of evidence-based best practice; laws & policies; or learner’s primary language, grade levels, knowledge, problemsolving & performance skills, or exceptional conditions Demonstrates proficiency w/assistance – 3 Selected standards (2-3) are appropriate, in terms of grade level, exceptional conditions, and learning objectives; have been selected with teacher/instructor assistance All instructional behavioral objectives meet criteria for writing but one or more are initially inappropriate given students’ grade levels, exceptional conditions, selected standards, assessment information Essential questions relate to long term student learning and this unit as a part of that learning; assistance was required in developing essential questions Choice of content is based on evidencebased best practice; laws & policies; & collaboration with other educators & related service providers, but does not reflect learners’ primary language, grade levels, knowledge, problem-solving & performance skills, or exceptional conditions Demonstrates proficiency – 4 Selected standards (2-3) are appropriate in terms of grade level, exceptional conditions, and learning objectives All instructional/ behavioral objectives meet 4 criteria: condition(2) stated, student(s) named, target behavior clearly identified, means of measuring success are clear and are are appropriate given students’ grade levels, exceptional conditions, selected standards, assessment information Essential questions relate to long term student learning and this unit as a part of that learning Explanation for choice of unit content is clear & appropriate given evidence-based best practice; laws & policies; learners’ primary language, grade levels, knowledge, problem-solving & performance skills, exceptional conditions, & collaboration with other educators & related service providers 5 Pre-instruction assessment + explanation CEC 2Q, LBS3B, LBS3C, LBS3E, LBS3G, LBS3K, LBS3N, LBS4H, CC4Z, LBS4P, CC6H, CC6K, LBS6I No pre-assessment included; assessment is not designed to yield information to help in instructional decision making Assessment instruments used prior to instruction show little understanding of measurement theory & practice, do not include needed supports and adaptations, are not part of ongoing analysis of individual progress, and may be inappropriate given learners’ strengths & needs; decisions are clearly described but may be inappropriate given learner needs 7 Materials CEC 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 CC2Q, LBS3G, LBS3N, CC4M, CC40, CC4P, LBS4H, CC4Q, CC4R, CC4Z, LBS4P, CC6A, LBS6E, CC6C, CC6H, CC6M Instructional materials list is incomplete; materials are not listed; materials are inappropriate given lesson objectives & abilities & behaviors of individuals with exceptional learning needs Instructional materials to be used by T and SS are listed, are inappropriate given lesson objectives and/or abilities & behaviors of individuals with exceptional learning needs, & are not modified appropriately LESSON PLANS: 8 Anticipatory Set CEC 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 LBS2A, LBS2B, CC2Q, CC4R, CC4X, CC4Z, LBS40, CC5B, CC5D, CC5L, CC6A, CC6C, CC61, CC6K, CC6M, LBS6H, LBS6Q, LBS6T 9 Input CEC 4, 6, 7, 8, 10, LBS2A, LBS2B, CC2Q, CC4Q, CC4R, CC4S, CC4X, CC4Z, LBS40, LBS4P, CC6A, LBS6A, LBS6E, CC6C, CC6I, CC6K, CC6M, LBS6G, LBS6H, LBS6I, LBS6Q, LBS6S Formal and/or informal assessment instruments used prior to instruction show understanding of measurement theory & practice, include supports and adaptations as necessary and are part of regular monitoring of student progress; decision made do not reflect ongoing analysis of individual progress, are not clearly described, &/or are inappropriate given student strengths & needs Instructional materials to be used by T and SS are listed and are educationally sound, but materials do not reflect varying abilities & behaviors of individuals with exceptional learning needs, & are not modified appropriately as needed by learners Purpose of lesson was not clearly stated, no minimal attempt to engage student interest was made, connection to previous learning was not made known or made clear. One or more of the following were not accomplished at the beginning of each lesson: purpose was clearly stated, student interest was engaged, connection to previous learning was clear The following were included at the beginning of each lesson: purpose was clearly stated, student interest was engaged, connection to previous learning was clear, one or all of these were provided by other educators or related service providers Lesson cannot be followed as written Instructional strategies may not be evidencebased; explanation of lesson/activity steps is confusing to students or demonstrates a lack of prior preparations; examples & nonexamples are inappropriate Evidence-based instructional strategies are used but are selected by other educators; steps are explained but students do not fully understand; examples and non-examples may be confusing to students Formal and/or informal assessment instruments used prior to instruction show understanding of measurement theory & practice, include supports and adaptations as necessary and are part of regular monitoring of student progress; decisions related to instruction are based on ongoing analysis of individual progress, are clearly described and are appropriate All instructional materials to be used by T and SS are listed, are appropriate given varying abilities & behaviors of individuals with exceptional learning needs, are educationally sound, and are modified appropriately as needed by learners All of the following were included in the beginning of the lesson: purpose clearly stated, student interest was engaged, connection to previous learning was clear Evidence-based instructional strategies are used; lesson/activity steps are clearly explained & can be easily followed. Examples & nonexamples are predetermined & appropriate 10 Modeling CEC 4, 6, 7, 8, 10, LBS2A, LBS2B, CC2Q, CC4Q, CC4R, CC4S, CC4X, CC4Z, LBS4O, LBS4P, CC6A, LBS6A, LBS6E, CC6C, CC6I, CC6K, CC6M, LBS6G, LBS6H, LBS6I, LBS6Q, LBS6S Little/no modeling of knowledge/skills occurs; lesson proceeds without clarification; SS have no opportunity to ask questions/seek clarification; SS demonstrates confusion/lack of understanding Modeling of knowledge/skills is evident but needs further clarification of demonstrates inadequate prior preparation; SS have few opportunities for feedback and questions/clarification; SS demonstrates confusion/lack of understanding Understanding of content and directions are monitored infrequently for both individuals and the group; T responds to varying abilities and behaviors of SS; questions/responses to facilitate monitoring are inadequate/fail to clarify learning; T responds minimally to SS confusion/lack of understanding Instructional plans emphasize modeling of knowledge and skills; modeling supports maintenance and generalization but has been selected/directed by other educators; SS have limited opportunities for feedback and questions/clarification 11 Checking for understanding CEC 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 LBS2A, LBS2B, CC2Q, LBS4H, CC4R, CC4Z, LBS6C, LBS6E, CC6C Understanding of content and directions is not monitored; SS confusion/lack of understanding is not or is inadequately addressed 12 Guided practice CEC 3, 4, 6, 7, 8 LBS2A, LBS2B, CC2Q SS have no/little opportunity to practice new skills or interact with content; SS are given no feedback/correction; feedback is general, no based on specific SS performance; practice activities are used as assessment SS have little opportunity to practice new skills or interact with content; SS are given minimal feedback/correction; feedback is general, not based on specific SS performance; practice activities are used as assessment Instructional plans provide for efficient guided practice to ensure acquisition and fluency as well as maintenance and generalization; SS are given immediate feedback/correction based on SS performance, using effective language models; guided practices activities suggested by other educators 13 Assessment/Independent CEC 3, 4, 6, 7, 8 LBS 2A, LBS3B, LBS3E, LBS6E, CC6K, LBS6T Target objectives are not/inadequately assess; rubrics do not provide usable information; assessment provides little information for decision-making Target objective is assess, rubrics do not provide adequate/usable information; assessment provides little information for decision-making; assessment does not include appropriate supports and adaptations to meet learners’ needs Target objective is assessed as stated, rubrics are used appropriately, assessment is nonbiased, meaningful, & provides information for subsequent decision-making; assessment includes appropriate supports and adaptations to meet learners’ needs; assessment/rubric/instructional decisions are designed/made in collaboration with other educators 14 Post –instruction assessment + explanation CEC 7, 8 No pre-assessment included; assessment does not yield information to Assessment instruments used prior to instruction show little understanding Formal and/or informal assessment instruments used following instruction show understanding of Understanding of content and directions are monitored repeatedly for both individuals and the group; T responds to varying abilities and behaviors of SS; questions/responses to facilitate monitoring have been suggested by other educators; T responds minimally to SS confusion/lack of understanding Individualized Instructional plans emphasize explicit modeling that supports maintenance and generalization of knowledge and skills; SS have many opportunities for feedback and questions /clarification Understanding of content and directions are monitored continuously for both individuals and the group; T responds to varying abilities and behaviors of SS; T demonstrates understanding of language enhancement strategies and facilitates understanding of subject matter Individualized instruction plans emphasize efficient guided practice to ensure acquisition and fluency as well as maintenance and generalization; SS are given immediate feedback/correction based on SS performance, using effective language models Target objective is assessas stated, rubrics are used appropriately, assessment is nonbiased, meaningful, & provides information for subsequent decision-making; assessment includes appropriate supports and adaptations to meet learners’ needs Formal and/or informal assessment instruments used CC2Q, LBS3B, LBS3E, LBS4O help in instructional decision making of measurement theory & practice, do not include needed supports and adaptations, are not part of ongoing analysis of individual progress, and may be inappropriate given learner’s strengths & needs; decisions are clearly described but may be inappropriate given learner needs measurement theory & practice, include supports and adaptations as necessary, and are part of regular monitoring of student progress; decisions made do not reflect ongoing analysis of individual progress, are not clearly described , &/or are inappropriate given student strengths & needs 15 Student work samples + explanation No work samples attached or explained Student work samples attached; relationship to student learning and to instructional decision-making are unclear; student work includes materials provided by other educators, but inadequately/inappropriately used by T 16 Self evaluation CEC 9, 10 CC8A, CC9C, CC9D Written reflection is missing or inadequate & provides little to no reflection on instructional practice Some student work samples attached; relationship to student learning and to instructional decisionmaking are notinadequately explained; decisions made to not reflect results of student work Written reflection demonstrates little awareness of own attitudes, behaviors, and ways of communicating that influence practice; shows no awareness of limits of practice; shows little to no attention to professional & instructional development Written reflection demonstrates inadequate exploration of own & others’ attitudes, behaviors, and ways of communicating that influence practice; limited awareness of limits of practice; demonstrates limited attention to professional & instructional development following instruction show understanding of measurement theory & practice, include supports and adaptations as necessary, and are part of regular monitoring of student progress; decisions related to instruction are based on ongoing analysis of individual progress, are clearly described and are appropriate Student work samples are attached; relationship to student learning and to T decisionmaking process are clearly described Written reflection demonstrates awareness of own and others’ attitudes, behaviors, and ways of communicating that influence practice; helps to identify own limits of practice and demonstrates ongoing attention to professional & instructional development Western Illinois University SPED 430/445 Practicum WIU Field Supervisor Evaluation Rubric (Observation) Student: ______________________________________ Grade Level: __________________________ School: ______________________________________ Date: ________________________________ Evaluator: ____________________________________ Semester: Fall ________ Spring _________ Criteria for ratings: 1 – (D) Demonstrates no skill/proficiency: Performance indicates little awareness or knowledge of appropriate professional behaviors or strategies related to instruction, collaboration, or appropriate interactions with students. 2 – (C) Demonstrates novice performance: Performance demonstrates some knowledge of appropriate professional behaviors and/or instructional strategies, although further practice and development are needed. 3 – (B) Demonstrates proficiency with assistance: Performance indicates adequate knowledge of professional behaviors and strategies that are used appropriately under the guidance of a supervising teacher. 4 – (A) Demonstrates proficiency: Performance indicates awareness, knowledge and use of appropriate professional behaviors and strategies; student demonstrates readiness to independently perform tasks with little or no supervision Skills Demonstrates effective overall professionalism in the following areas: Manages preparation tasks (10) Manages student-student and student-teacher interactions (5) Responds to feedback appropriately (9) Practices within one’s skill limit and obtains assistance as needed (9) Proficient in oral and written communication (9) Conducts activities consistent with the law (9) On time/dependable (9) Demonstrates regard for and responds appropriately to student differences: Culture, religion, gender, linguistics, sexual orientation, and chronological age (1) Develops and selects resources and materials appropriate for student needs (4) Adapts methods, curriculum, materials to needs of individuals with disabilities in all Environments (7) Uses varied methods and specialized strategies appropriate for individuals with disabilities. Please indicate abilities in the following areas that apply: Reading (4) Math (4) Oral language (4) Written language (4) Content areas : Social Skills (4) Vocational (4) Study skills (4) Spelling (4) Develops appropriate lesson plans that incorporate curriculum and instruction strategies with individual education goals and benchmarks (7) Implements instruction and integrates general education and specialized curricula (4) Gathers and utilizes evidence of student performance in making instructional decisions (8) Selects, designs, and uses appropriate technology required to educate individuals with disabilities (7) Creates environment that promotes learning including: Rapport with learners (5) Communication skills (6) Serving as positive role model (5) Pace of instruction (4) Consistent routines and structure (7) Creates and maintains records (8) Uses strategies for group and individual behavior management, crisis prevention, and intervention (5) Comments: 1 2 3 4 N/A NA NA NA NA SPED 430/445 Practicum Mentor Teacher Mid-Term/Final Evaluation Rubric Student: ______________________________________ Grade Level: School: ______________________________________ Date: __________________________ ________________________________ Evaluator: ____________________________________ Mid-Term Eval ________ Final Eval _________ Criteria for ratings: 1 (D) – Demonstrates no skill/proficiency: Performance indicates little awareness or knowledge of appropriate professional behaviors or strategies related to instruction, collaboration, or appropriate interactions with students. 2 (C) – Demonstrates novice performance: Performance demonstrates some knowledge of appropriate professional behaviors and/or instructional strategies, although further practice and development are needed. 3 (B) – Demonstrates proficiency with assistance: Performance indicates adequate knowledge of professional behaviors and strategies that are used appropriately under the guidance of a supervising teacher. 4 (A) – Demonstrates proficiency: Performance indicates awareness, knowledge and use of appropriate professional behaviors and strategies; student demonstrates readiness to independently perform tasks with little or no supervision. Skills 1 2 3 4 Demonstrates effective overall professionalism in the following areas: Manages preparation tasks (10) Manages student-student and student-teacher interactions (5) Responds to feedback appropriately (9) Practices within one’s skill limit and obtains assistance as needed (9) Proficient in oral and written communication (9) Conducts activities consistent with the law (9) On time/dependable (9) Demonstrates regard for and responds appropriately to student differences: Culture, religion, gender, linguistics, sexual orientation, and chronological age (1) Develops and selects resources and materials appropriate for student needs (4) Adapts methods, curriculum, materials to needs of individuals with disabilities in all Environments (7) Uses varied methods and specialized strategies appropriate for individuals with disabilities. Please indicate abilities in the following areas that apply: Reading (4) Math (4) Oral language (4) Written language (4) Content areas: Social Skills(4) Vocational (4) Study skills (4) Spelling (4) Develops appropriate lesson plans that incorporate curriculum and instruction strategies with individual education goals and benchmarks (7) Implements instruction and integrates general education and specialized curricula (4) Gathers and utilizes evidence of student performance in making instructional decisions (8) Selects, designs, and uses appropriate technology required to educate individuals with disabilities (7) Creates environment that promotes learning including: Rapport with learners (5) Communication skills (6) Serving as positive role model (5) Pace of instruction (4) Consistent routines and structure (7) Creates and maintains records (8) Uses strategies for group and individual behavior management, crisis prevention, and intervention (5) Comments: Please comment about the student’s experience in your classroom. You may write on the back. N/A NA NA NA NA Western Illinois University SPED 460 Alternative Practicum Mentor Teacher Evaluation Rubric Student: Disability(s) School Grade Level Mentor Teacher Date Please evaluate the teacher candidate on the following competencies: 1 (D) – Demonstrates no skill/proficiency: Performance indicates little awareness or knowledge of appropriate professional behaviors or strategies related to instruction, collaboration, or appropriate interactions with students. 2 (C) – Demonstrates novice performance: Performance demonstrates some knowledge of appropriate professional behaviors and/or instructional strategies, although further practice and development are needed. 3 (B) – Demonstrates proficiency with assistance: Performance indicates adequate knowledge of professional behaviors and strategies that are used appropriately under the guidance of a supervising teacher. 4 (A) – Demonstrates proficiency: Performance indicates awareness, knowledge and use of appropriate professional behaviors and strategies; student demonstrates readiness to independently perform tasks with little or no supervision. 1 Student attends when scheduled; arrives promptly; notifies teacher prior to absence (9) Student conducts instructional or other professional activities consistent with the requirements of law, rules and regulations, and local district policies and procedures (CC1S2) (9) Student demonstrates proficient written, verbal, and non-verbal communication techniques (CC8-S5; CC4-S16) (9) Student understands the importance of the teacher serving as a model for individuals with exceptional learning needs (CC8-K12/CC9K2) (9) Student recognizes the effects of teacher attitudes and behaviors to all students (CC5D) (5) Student demonstrates approaches to adapting environments to meet specific learning and developmental needs of individuals (CC5H) (5) Student demonstrates ethical practices for confidential communication to others about individuals with disabilities (CC7C/CC10S1) (10) Student is able to establish and maintain rapport with individuals with and without exceptional learning needs (CC5S7) (5) Student practices within own scope of practice and seeks assistance as needed (LBS8B) (9) Comments: Please comment about the student’s experience in your classroom. 2 3 4 N/A SPED 460 WIU Field Supervisor Final Evaluation Name: TEP-Category Semester: 5Unacceptable 10Acceptable with Concerns 15Acceptable 20 - Target Collaboration Honesty/ Integrity Respect/ Emotional Maturity Commitment to Learning Responsibility 100 possible points