Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design Year: 2013- 2014 DEPARTMENT: ART AND DESIGN A. DEPARTMENT SERVICES/ACTIVITIES REPORT IN 2013-14 1. Department-sponsored services (fall and spring semesters combined) Area of Service Student Exhibition Visiting lecturers/workshops Number Served 2500 of which 1700 were students and their families 100 Equipment Loan Program for students Full schedule of open lab hours in computer, ceramics, photography and sculpture labs 100 500 Area of service (for example): a department-run learning laboratory (not laboratories for which students register as part of their courses), the reference desk or reserve area of the Library, department tutoring program, etc. (Note: Do not report courses or laboratories for which students register.) 2. Department-sponsored faculty/staff development activities Type of Activity and Topic NA Date Number Attending Note: Faculty and staff development activities (grants, presentations, exhibitions, performances, publications, instructional improvement activities, laboratory development, curriculum development, etc.) INSTRUCTIONS: For each activity, please indicate 1. whether department members organized the activities or gave presentations or both 2. the topic and type of activity and name of organizer/presenter, if applicable 3. the date (if not the exact date, indicate the month) 4. the number attending the event B. COURSE CHANGES IN 2013-14 INSTRUCTIONS: For each course that changed, indicate: 1 Year-end Report – Art and Design Queensborough Community College 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Year: 2013- 2014 whether the course is new, revised, or deleted the course number the course title the semester the change was approved at the Academic Senate for revised courses, in the Comments section, describe the type of change(s)—i.e., course title, description, pre/co-requisites, credits, hours, designation New, revised, or deleted Revised Course number ALL Course title Semester approved Comments See attached schedule of changes - Appendix A Spring 2014 Revised See Appendix B See attached schedule of classes - Appendix B Fall 2013 All course numbering changed to reflect the contemporary trends in course numbering Studio art courses that were previously 2 credits were revised and changed to 3 credits C. PROGRAM CHANGES IN 2013-14 Program Program change* Photography Certificate Program (b) Effective Date (Semester and year) 6/2014 A.A.S. in Digital Art and Design (d) Fall 2013 A.S. in Visual and Performing Arts (d) Fall 2013 Comments Closed based on recommendation of Program Review Modified to reflect changes in studio course credits Added: Art History Concentration *Key: (a)=initiated, (b)=closed, (c)=renamed, (d)=modified INSTRUCTIONS: Use the full title of the program, i.e. A.S. in Visual and Performing Arts. Indicate whether the program change is initiated, closed, renamed, or modified. (If a new program has been approved by the CUNY Board (or is expected to be approved by June 2013), use fall 2013 as the effective date.) Describe the exact status (i.e., proposal submitted to CUNY Board; approved by CUNY Board; etc.) in the Comments. 2 Year-end Report – Art and Design Queensborough Community College Year: 2013- 2014 D. DEPARTMENT CHANGES IN 2013-14 Type (see menu below) Facilities Equipment Description of Change New Drawing Studio and office space Reason for Change Recommended by consultant as a requirement for NASAD accreditation Various photo Cyclical equipment, enlargers replacement of easels, tables, etc. resources Date/Semester Evaluation of Change* Scheduled for summer 2014 TBD Fall 2012 N/A *Please note that, if change has been too recent to evaluate, you may indicate NA. Type of change Personnel or organizational change Facilities/space Equipment Other MENU Description New hires, retirees, resignations, promotions, department name changes, etc. Renovations or development of office space or new facilities (i.e., computer laboratories) Acquisition of new or disposition of old equipment Other changes affecting the department not included above and including interactions with other departments E. DEPARTMENT ASSESSMENT IN 2013-14 1. Departmental procedures for conducting assessment The fundamental elements of standard 14 (assessment of student learning) of the Middle States Commission on Higher Education include: clearly articulated statements of expected student learning outcomes…at all levels (institution, degree/program, course) and for all programs that aim to foster student learning and development; a documented, organized, and sustained assessment process to evaluate and improve student learning; evidence that student learning assessment information is shared and discussed with appropriate constituents and is used to improve teaching and learning. 3 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design Year: 2013- 2014 Describe below the department’s ongoing procedures for assessing student learning and using assessment results to improve teaching and learning. In your description, please explain how the department fulfills each of the Middle States fundamental elements above. Four faculty members are currently overseeing assessment in the four areas of the department: Digital, Photography Studio and Art History. They have each completed the Assessment Institute. As part of their assessment procedures they continue to develop clearly articulated statements of expected student learning outcomes. Subsequent to developing their protocols and continuing to assess classes using this structure, they prepared a report of the results as well as offering their conclusions and recommendations. The four have met regularly with Dean Corradetti and are working closely with him. They have reported on their work at every department meeting keeping the department apprised of their efforts and sharing with the department the tools and results they have developed. Prof. Pete Mauro will participate as the departmental representative in the General Education Assessment task force. Four other faculty members were engaged in preparing program reviews in the four major areas of the department: Visual and Preforming Arts, Digital Art and Design, Gallery and Museum Studies, and the Photography Certificate Program. 2a. Departmental participation in self-study/program review during 2013-2014, if applicable Program(s) reviewed: A.A.S. Degree Program in Digital Art and Design (DA2) External Agency or Reviewers: Jillian McDonald, Associate Professor, Pace University. Date of site visit: May 7-8, 2014 4 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design Year: 2013- 2014 Major conclusions of self-study The strength of the program at QCC lies in the success and depth of the studio program as a whole, where the digital portion of the department is integrated and built upon classes in the traditional studio arts. The faculty teaching in the program all have experience in the digital industry as well as training in studio art. Our students have demonstrated strong transfer interest and success from the A.A.S. program, as well as above average retention and graduation rates when compared to the college as a whole. Despite these successes, there are areas that could show improvement. The classroom lab space, while adequate now, could quickly become strained or insufficient if we continue to see the enrollment gains we have witnessed over the past decade. The department as a whole is in need of additional space although it is anticipated that this will be addressed during the coming summer as we seek to receive NASAD accreditation. This addition of classroom space is critical to further program development as it will offer students more adequate studio space for drawing and painting and a digitally enabled workroom for photography. As detailed previously, many of our classes are 2 credit/4 hour courses despite content that has increased to keep pace with the technology over the past decade. This fact is holding our graduates back in their transfer progress. This becomes a weakness, even in an A.A.S program, as the majority of our graduates currently transfer to a 4-year degree program. If students do not believe that the classes they are taking will count towards their major once they transfer, they may transfer early or drop out of the program altogether. The pace of change in both the software we teach and the industry that we are preparing students for continues to increase at an astonishing pace. The school technology fee covers the update of hardware every two years, but no plan or funding is in place to assist the faculty in keeping up-to date. Funding to attend classes or seminars might help to mitigate the difficulty of balancing a heavy teaching workload, increasing assessment demands, and artistic careers. 5 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design Year: 2013- 2014 Major conclusions of external reviewers The faculty are eager to make changes and develop. Students are hard working and career focused. In my visit to a design class, I saw evidence of engaged student learning, both through the semester’s clear arc of project progression and the students’ comfort with software and communicating their concepts. Program/Area Strengths The program’s strengths are the students and faculty. The 2D digital design courses are strong, well considered, and focused. Art History is linked to and building a great foundation for the students’ studio learning. Students are ambitious and hard working, the projects I observed were technically and conceptually good. The existing computer labs are of sufficient size and receive natural light, which is important. Program/Area Weaknesses Students and faculty have identified a need for better advisement. Students and faculty see the need for additional computer lab hours this is crucial not only in offering students more time to complete homework and succeed, but also in fostering community. QCC professors and students are challenged in getting students to experience artwork outside the institution’s walls and use the tremendous resources of New York City’s art worlds, however this is an extremely effective way to connect pedagogy to the real world and should be addressed. There are some gaps in the curriculum such as contemporary new media production and history, and design-focused web design. Some courses could be redesigned, and some added. Web Design course could be taught in the Art Department. Motion graphics courses seem weak, in terms of curriculum, although I did not have the opportunity to see the student work in this area, nor talk to the students. QCC has a diverse student body, but that diversity is not reflected in the faculty. 6 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design Year: 2013- 2014 Resulting action plan The department has already begun the process of addressing the most important of these issues, transferability of classes. Curricular and course changes to adjust all classes to the 3 credit level are currently before the curriculum committee. Approval of these changes is critical to the continued success of this program. The data clearly points to the desire of our students for further instruction beyond the A.A.S degree, and the more we can do to foster this goal, the stronger and more desirable our program will become. Beyond the credit changes, we have initiated an articulation agreement with Queens College for transfer into the BFA program in Graphic Design. In the spring of 2014, we will begin research into changes to the degree itself from an A.A.S program to an A.S. transfer degree to further facilitate career and educational success for our students. With these changes also comes the opportunity to increase advisement through our portfolio class. Encouraging student enrollment in this capstone class will likely increase their confidence and success in transfer and job readiness. Other actions will be developed in response to this Program Review. Program(s) reviewed: A.S. Degree Program in Gallery and Museum Studies External Agency or Reviewers: Gary Wood, Gary Alan Wood, Director Regina A. Quick Center for the Arts, Fairfield University Date of site visit: May 6-7, 2014 7 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design Year: 2013- 2014 Major conclusions of self-study The Gallery and Museum Studies Program at QCC is a unique program within the City University of New York since no other CUNY community colleges offer such a program. It is both enhanced and supported by the strong Studio Art and Art History curricula in the Art and Design Department. Moreover, the small class sizes enable individual guidance and advisement to students. Although the program has various strengths, enrollment has been decreasing. This is due to a number of different reasons, but it largely reflects the current situation of the field of museum studies and museum practices. A majority of museums and galleries across the nation have been downsizing, while few prominent museums and commercial galleries have been expanding and hiring. These museums and galleries require a B.A. or B.F.A. degree, and more often, an M.A. degree in Art History or Arts Administration for entry-level positions. Our program is a rare A.S. degree in Gallery and Museum Studies; students who wish to pursue the field have the advantage gaining hands-on experience early on in New York City, the “global center” of the art world, facilitating a move to a four-year program with this advantage. Furthermore, QCC provides major academic services including the Campus Writing Center, which provides invaluable support especially for those new to the discipline of art and art history. To increase enrollment, these aspects of the program should be promoted and informed to prospective students. While students who wish to major art administration and museum studies are likely to also look into four-year college programs, our program provides the advantage of comparatively low tuition and smooth transfer to Queens College as long as the student maintains a grade point average of 3.0. This could be advertised to potential students at college open houses and in CUNY catalogues. Student advisement could also help increase enrollment as seen in the sharp increase of enrollment in Fall 2009 when the Academy was first implemented and students received their first academic advisement from the Academy. While the current curriculum consisting of one-hour 800-level courses has allowed a single faculty member to manage all three courses, the instructor was able to bring more in-depth course materials and incorporate various exercises and student-led discussions into a lecture-based course. This also allowed students to bring more questions and comments to class while enhancing their learning experience. This curricula change to include an online class may also make it possible to attract experienced part-time faculty members in the field. 8 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design Year: 2013- 2014 Major conclusions of external reviewers The program is replete with upside possibilities; a point-of-view built on the existence of several critically important and already-existing components: 1. Faculty The arts faculty in general—and the current faculty member heading this program—offer students the crucial and contemporary information of an exciting, evolving field of study in a highly-informative, well-organized and supportive learning environment. Attention to the individual learner and their unique needs is present; thus, each student is poised to find the strength of confidence to continue their training, as well as their own, unique arts management voice. 2. Facilities The classroom facilities and on-campus galleries, museum and arts center provide strong, hands-on learning opportunities. While Queens in the immediate area—as well as Brooklyn and Manhattan—provide exceptional learning opportunities in the field, it is a significant selling point for potential students to understand that skill building and resume-enhancing opportunities are at their doorstep. 3. Location and regional opportunities Queens has its own historic reputation for distinctive and exhilarating arts activity, with numerous individuals and organizations of national and international distinction. Affiliation of the A.S. degree program with such notable entities is invaluable to growing its own reputation and capacities. The program has a work-to-career character; that is, the study of core principles is interesting, yet has little benefit without their creative and firsthand application. But as a selling point, it is true that the program as it is structured—and as it will surely continue to evolve—is very much classroom to career oriented, both practical and purposeful by its very nature (that may not be apparent in its current title). Program Challenges 1. Program name While the program’s current name is industry appropriate, it does not convey the inventive, hands-on, management/leadership, and contemporary flair characteristic of the profession today. A process of name change will create substantial opportunity to entice greater enrollment and re-brand it within the industry as a fresh and innovative training program. 9 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design Year: 2013- 2014 The process itself—if it involves a number of diverse stakeholders—can serve to strengthen the program by way of a deep examination of the programs existing strengths and its potentialities. 2. Advising There appears to be a gap in knowledge about the program and all that it has to offer amongst the advising program. The title notwithstanding, the advisors need to be fully informed and equipped with the knowledge, incentives and materials to comprehensively and effectively convey the program’s benefits and its inherent creative, fulfilling nature. Periodic discussions and training with the program’s faculty—and tips from students within the program—is advised. 3. Low enrollment Low enrollment denies students within the program to interact with others to test their ideas, share experiences and work in teams. Given the exceptional diversity of the student population and the cultural heritages thereof, the program and its learners are denied the richness of learning the program is poised to offer. 4. College support It is imperative that the financial and management resources are made available to launch and sustain a strategic and marketing initiative designed to raise attention to the program’s uniqueness and increase enrollment. A well-designed strategic and executable plan with stretch, yet achievable outcomes will help formulate a required budget and nudge everyone to success. Resulting action plan An on-line section of AR-804 will be developed over the summer and offered in Spring 2015. Other actions will be developed in response to this Program Review. Program(s) reviewed: Certificate Program in Photography External Agency or Reviewers: No external review or site visit Date of site visit: No external review or site visit 10 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design Year: 2013- 2014 Major conclusions of self-study The AP program in photography is pedagogically solid with an exemplary faculty. While student enrollment numbers are currently too small to reveal statistically significant results in terms of the program’s Data Packet, it is clear that the commercial photography world is rapidly changing due to quickly evolving technology. The program once served a student cohort bent on attaining full-time employment in the field, but more recently the emphasis has switched to technical and aesthetic training as opposed to job-specific skills. It is recommended that the Certificate program therefore be discontinued and that the photography program should take its place within the new Pathways curriculum as an AAS degree and transfer program. Major conclusions of external reviewers No external review Resulting action plan Program eliminated 2b. Program review follow-up (from 2012-13 to 2013-14) Action item from program review Timeline for completion Accomplishments during current year NA Note: If your department was involved in a program review in the previous academic year, the table above must be filled in. 3a. Course assessment follow-up (from 2012-13 to 2013-14) Courses assessed from previous year AR 310 Action plan from previous year Evaluation of results Follow-up Currently, students are prepared for the term paper assignment by “scaffolding,” a writing training technique that entails giving shorter, lower stakes writing assignments and/or rough drafts earlier in the semester in an effort to accustom them to writing art historically. At the discretion of individual professors, classes are taken to the QCC library at the beginning of each semester for an Information Literacy session with a reference librarian. Most professors hand out detailed instructions for writing assignments that also serve as a template for students in terms of crafting both the form and content of their papers. These instructions also contain a section on plagiarism and its consequences. 1. Term paper assignment: Students doing the term paper assignment for AR 310, as for other art history classes, must utilize skills necessary to meet several of the above listed QCC Educational Objectives as well as the above listed Curricular Objectives. In our departmental Learning Outcomes, we break these skills down into two main categories: form and content. “Form” refers to the primarily formal aspects of putting together a college-level research paper. Thus, students must exhibit mastery of relevant skills as measured in the four following sets of rubrics in order to get a high grade on the assignment: In regards to student performance in the selected subcategories of the Student Learning Outcomes, students need extra support in the areas of research in general. These specifically include identifying scholarly sources, critically evaluating and synthesizing information, and using the research to support a thesis. Students at Queensborough are of the Internet age where all information is literally available at their fingertips, and therefore students need more direction in understanding the importance of proper academic research, citation, and bibliographic reference. Faculty teaching Art History courses in the Department of Art and Design will be meeting in January to discuss these results further and to devise a plan to help students improve in these areas. For example, faculty could scaffold an additional research and citation assignment before the main research paper, or include examples of proper citation format Students are prepared for all exams through rigorous in class lectures and classroom discussion of both course readings and PowerPoint presentations. Students are 1. 2. 3. 4. Proper use of grammar, spelling, and syntax Proper formatting and use of illustration Proper citation and bibliographic reference Logical compositional structure (intro, body, conclusion, etc.) 11 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design strongly encourages to participate in classroom discussion in an effort to develop their oral and verbal argumentation skills. Some professors also post study guides for all exams on course Blackboard sites, as well as posting all Powerpoint presentations given during the semester, so that students may begin studying weeks prior to an exam. Professors in the department are regularly enhancing their pedagogy with the use of ePortfolio, museum visits, oral presentations in class, and peer evaluation of writing assignments between student cohorts. Some also include High Impact practices such as SWIG, the Common Read, Learning Communities, and Writing Intensive sections. These actions have proven successful in improving areas of weakness, most notably those mentioned above: citation of sources, critical use of sources, and the memorization of dates on slides. While the current set of rubrics does cover all basic areas of competence in the field of art history, the department is involved with the QCC Assessment Institute to refine the writing assessment instrument and to better explicate expectations of writing assignments by sharing rubrics with students prior to assignment due dates. The current examination rubric will continue to be used as faculty continue to emphasize the value of factual historical knowledge as well as critical interpretive tools in understanding the meaning of works of art. The majority of students in the AR 310 classes for the Spring 2013 semester scored either “Excellent” or “Good” in all four formal categories. Specifically, the breakdown is as follows: Category spelling) 1 (Proper use of grammar, syntax, and Year: 2013- 2014 specific to art historical sources as part of course assignments (students do receive a guide on citations from the library). Art History faculty will also be discussing the effectiveness of the new Student Learning Outcome rubric in efforts to further refine our assessment instrument. Excellent: 41 Good: 91 Fair: 50 Poor: 12 Category 2 (Proper formatting and use of illustrations) Excellent: 56 Good: 90 Fair: 35 Poor: 15 Category 3 (Proper citation and bibliographic reference) Excellent: 37 Good: 41 Fair: 24 Poor: 19 Category 4 (Logical compositional structure: intro, body, conclusion, etc.) Excellent: 49 Good: 95 Fair: 40 Poor: 7 Overall, students performed well on the “formal” aspects of the term paper assignment. Category 3, as compared to Categories 1,2, and 4, regularly proves to be the most challenging for QCC students writing term papers. That said, significant improvement has been noted in this skill over the past several semesters, due in part to the incorporation of information resource educational supplements as part of the course curriculum. The second main area evaluated for art history term paper assignments is “Content.” This refers to the actual written prose in the paper, as opposed to the formal aspects of putting a paper together. The 12 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design Year: 2013- 2014 rubrics used to measure such skills are as follows: 1. 2. 3. 4. Proper use of art historical terminology Critical use of research sources Conduct a descriptive analysis of the visual aspects of an artwork Conduct analysis and evaluation of stylistic and historical contexts of a work of art Students tended to do very well on numbers 1, 3, and 4 with almost all falling into one of the top two categories of evaluation. Number 2 proved to be more challenging, as is often the case with QCC students writing term papers, although most students still scored in the top two categories of evaluation. The breakdown is as follows: Category 1 (Proper use of art historical terminology) Excellent: 43 Good: 88 Fair: 51 Poor: 12 Category 2 (Critical use of research sources) Excellent: 35 Good: 76 Fair: 41 Poor: 15 Category 3 (Conduct a descriptive analysis of the visual aspects of an art object) Excellent: 46 Good: 98 Fair: 44 Poor: 8 Category 4 (Conduct analysis and evaluation of stylistic and historical contexts of a work of art) Excellent: 38 Good: 84 Fair: 60 Poor: 13 Students have shown steady improvement in all four “Content” categories in recent semesters; especially in Categories 1,3, and 4. Category 2 has traditionally been a sticking point in relation to the 13 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design Year: 2013- 2014 other Categories, although extensive departmental use of information literacy programs on campus have produced improvements. Recommendations will be discussed below. In addition to satisfying all relevant Curricular Objectives, the skills required in our term paper assignment Learning Outcomes also satisfy QCC General Educational Objectives 1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 8, and 10. 2. Exams: exams challenge students from multiple perspectives. Art history exams commonly require students to answer slide identification, multiplechoice, and short essay questions. In the departmental Learning Outcomes, we break necessary skills down into three main categories for exam assessment evaluation: 1. Demonstrates command of factual historical knowledge pertinent to the meaning and execution of works of art 2. Demonstrates recognition of art historical terms and concepts and their respective meanings 3. Demonstrates analytical thinking through the written expression of historical facts and art historical concepts in order to derive meaning in works of art In this semester’s AR 310 classes, the breakdown is as follows: Category 1 (Demonstrates command of factual historical knowledge pertinent to the meaning and execution of works of art) Excellent: 54 Good: 77 Fair: 73 Poor: 43 Category 2 (Demonstrates recognition of art historical terms and concepts and their respective meanings) Excellent: 56 Good: 86 Fair: 66 Poor: 38 14 Year-end Report – Art and Design Queensborough Community College Year: 2013- 2014 Category 3 (Demonstrates analytical thinking through the written expression of historical facts and art historical concepts in order to derive meaning in works of art) Excellent: 57 Good: 82 Fair: 66 Poor: 40 A majority of students generally recognize terms and concepts and can sufficiently express this understanding more fully in the longer essay questions. However, results from this semester’s 310 classes indicate a large minority who have trouble mastering these basic skills. One area of special difficulty for many students, and this is characteristic in many art history classes at QCC, is that students often have trouble memorizing titles, names, and dates for the slide identification portion of the exam, skills embodied in Category 1. However, there have been some improvements in this area over the past few semesters. Actions and recommendations are discussed below. Course(s) assessed from previous year Action plan from previous year Evaluation of Results Follow-up NA 3b. Course assessment: current year Course(s) assessed (list individually) Relevant General Educational Outcomes Relevant Curricular Outcomes AR461 1. Communicate effectively through reading, writing, listening and speaking. Student will be able to demonstrate the ability to produce a roll of film that has been properly exposed and developed. 2. Use analytical reasoning to identify issues or problems and evaluate evidence in order to make informed decisions. Student is able to consistently produce an 8x10 photographic print with a full tonal range between shadow and highlights with proper contrast and focus. Evaluation of Assessment Results Action plan Weighted score: 302. The students performed very well on the technical aspects of operating a 35mm camera. 70% of the students scored either excellent or good which means a large majority of them have mastered the skill set. Weighted score: 283. For the second learning outcome there was a noticeable drop in the students achieving a score of excellent. Additionally, there was a marked increase in students performing fair or poor. This may be indicative of many students having difficulty working in the darkroom environment for the One area the students struggled technically was working in the darkroom using photographic enlargers. Specifically, they struggled with the contrast of a print often times producing work that was either too gray lacking 15 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design first time. The student performance for the first learning outcome demonstrates they know the basic technical information of aperture, shutter speed and focus. However when they are placed in an environment where they have limited visual references it may be difficult for them to make the transition. Year: 2013- 2014 true blacks and whites, or produced too much contrast lacking a full tonal range. In order to achieve the correct contrast students must use filters, which are not supplied and can be cost prohibitive for some. Currently the Art & Design Department is in the process of upgrading the black and white enlargers so that they will have a built-in filter system. There are 11 enlargers and only 2 have the filter system, but as annual upgrades continue the new enlargers should allow the students to have more technical control over their photographic prints without the financial burden of purchasing a filter pack. 16 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design 5. Integrate knowledge and skills in their program of study. Student is comfortable using appropriate terminology to describe technical, aesthetic, and conceptual elements of a photographic print. Weighted score: 273. One area of difficulty for many students is being able to articulate the conceptual ideas that are portrayed in their own photography or the photography of their peers. Of the four learning outcomes students scored lowest on the third learning outcome based on their ability to describe basic technical, aesthetic, and conceptual ideas portrayed in a photographic print. They know the who, the what, the where—but when it comes to the why they struggle. In addition, when it comes to complex photographic terminology such as ‘depth of field’ students know what it means technically when they are using the camera, but struggle to articulate those same ideas when speaking about work in a critique setting. 10. Apply aesthetic and intellectual criteria in the evaluation or creation of works in the humanities or the arts. Student is able to consistently express their own artistic vision through technically proficient photographic prints that utilize symbolism and metaphor to express conceptual ideas through multiple layers of meaning. Weighted Score: 309. More students scored excellent on the fourth learning outcome than any other category with the highest weighted score of all learning outcomes. Although a significant percentage (39.8% based on the second learning outcome) of students struggle with the technical work in the darkroom, the fourth learning outcome demonstrates that they are successful when it comes to imbedding conceptual meaning into their photographic images. Overall the fourth outcome should be considered an area of strength for the AR461 course. Year: 2013- 2014 Although students excelled at using complex conceptual elements in their photographic images, they often had trouble identifying and articulating those concepts in the critique setting. Students inherently understood what they wanted to achieve conceptually while photographing, and had the technical skills with the 35mm camera to achieve those goals. However what they lack is the appropriate vocabulary and terminology to articulate those concepts when speaking about work. A greater emphasis should be placed equipping students with vocabulary they need to speak articulately about their work. Providing course study guides focusing on photographic terminology, assigning low stakes writing assignments to augment the photographic work, and stressing appropriate concepts and terms in a lecture setting will enhance the students knowledge and understanding. Additionally, prioritizing in-class discussions and critiques will allow students to feel more comfortable speaking about their work in front of an audience. While the current set of rubrics was successful in identifying areas of competence for those enrolled in the AR461 course, further refinement will be necessary in future assessment. Currently there were four student learning objectives associated with the rubric, two focused on technical knowledge and two focused on conceptual ideas. Future assessment instruments should be refined and broaden these two categories to include additional student learning objectives in order to better evaluate student work. 17 Queensborough Community College Courses assessed AR311 History of Art I AR315 History of Modern Art AR316 History of American Art AR317 History of Photography AR325 History of Graphic Design AR326 Asian Art Relevant Gen Ed Outcomes Communicate effectively through reading, writing, listening, and speaking Use analytical reasoning to identify issues or problems and evaluate evidence in order to make informed decisions Use information management and technology skills effectively for academic research and lifelong learning Use historical or social sciences perspectives to examine formation of ideas, human behavior, social institutions, or social processes Apply aesthetic and intellectual criteria in the evaluation or creation of works in the humanities or the arts Year-end Report – Art and Design Year: 2013- 2014 Relevant curricular outcomes Evaluation of assessment results Action plan In written work, discussion, and creation of art, students will appropriately utilize the vocabulary of their respective discipline The first Student Learning Outcome: “Students will be able to conduct and write a formal analysis and evaluation of stylistic and historical contexts of works of art using art historical terminology” was subdivided into four distinct categories: conducts a descriptive formal analysis of the visual aspects of an art object, proper use of art historical terminology, describes the stylistic elements of works of art, and describes the historical and cultural contexts of works of art. Under all of these subcategories, most students scored in the Excellent and Good categories illustrating that most students learned to complete a formal visual analysis while using proper art historical terminology and could define stylistic elements as well as the historical and cultural contexts of works of art. Future improvements could focus on guiding students to describe the stylistic elements of works of art. Under the second Student Learning Outcome: “Students will demonstrate a critical use of sources by evaluating and synthesizing research to support their thesis and analysis,” students performed less well in each of the three subcategories: student has identified scholarly resources, student critically evaluated and synthesized the research information into the text, and research supports thesis and analysis. Despite regular training on matters of research in these Art History courses, students still struggle in this area. Students in all sections of these art history courses performed reasonably well on the next Student Learning Outcome: “Students will demonstrate analytical thinking through the written expression of historical facts and art historical concepts in order to derive meaning in works of art” which was divided into the categories: historical facts and art history concepts are used to present meaning in works of art, and analytical thinking is identifiable in the presentation of art historical facts and concepts. In demonstrating a command of factual knowledge, students at Queensborough have generally needed support in this area. In the final Outcome: “Students will demonstrate proper use of grammar, syntax, and spelling; In regards to student performance in the selected subcategories of the Student Learning Outcomes, students need extra support in the areas of research in general. These specifically include identifying scholarly sources, critically evaluating and synthesizing information, and using the research to support a thesis. Students at Queensborough are of the Internet age where all information is literally available at their fingertips, and therefore students need more direction in understanding the importance of proper academic research, citation, and bibliographic reference. Faculty teaching Art History courses in the Department of Art and Design will be meeting in January to discuss these results further and to devise a plan to help students improve in these areas. For example, faculty could scaffold an additional research and citation assignment before the main research paper, or include examples of proper citation format specific to art historical sources as part of course assignments (students do receive a guide on citations from the library). Art History faculty will also be discussing the effectiveness of the new Student Learning Outcome rubric in efforts to further refine our assessment instrument. Students will form and defend fundamental value judgments about works of art within their major area of concentration 18 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design Year: 2013- 2014 logical compositional structure (intro body conclusion); and proper use of citations and bibliographic reference” students show a weakness in the area of proper citation and bibliographic reference while doing well in the two other areas of logical compositional structure and proper use of grammar, syntax, and spelling. The use of illustrations in research papers was not required across all courses. In written work, discussion, and creation of art, students will appropriately utilize the vocabulary of their respective discipline Students will be able to place works of art in historical and stylistic contexts and demonstrate appreciation of the cultural milieu in which they were created Examine different manifestations of cultural symbolism within a work of art in relation to geographic, historical and cultural contexts Recognize and discuss social, psychological, emotional, and aesthetic implications of works of art in our culture, as well as other cultures or times Students will be able to place works of art in historical and stylistic contexts and demonstrate appreciation of the cultural milieu in which they were created Students will form and defend fundamental value judgments about works of art within their major area of concentration Use design principles, theories and practice, and art historical analysis to approach and apprehend the diversity of human culture and expression in theory and life 3a. Course assessment follow-up (from 2012-13 to 2013-14) 19 Queensborough Community College Course(s) assessed from previous year ART 253 Drawing 3 Illustration Year-end Report – Art and Design Action plan from previous year Action Plan • Failure of some students to hand in work on time is an ongoing problem More emphasis on importance of deadlines in school and in the industry. More severe grading penalties for late work • Students have an ongoing problems planning work in stages. More emphasis conceptualizing and planning through thumbnails , small preparatory sketches Grading the planning stages will be instituted. Evaluation of Results Year: 2013- 2014 Follow-up Note This course comprises only one class each semester. The instructor has changed and the may change some of the action plan. • More emphasis on the importance of doing many thumbnails for optimum design solution • Students have a persistent problem explaining their work. Grading class participation is also helpful. • More emphasis on thinking about overall composition Lectures showing the work of famous illustrators with explanations of why their compositions are successful. • More emphasis on the relevancy of assignment to client demands This will be instituted through actual cases of client artist interaction 20 Queensborough Community College Art 148 Color Theory Year-end Report – Art and Design 5. Action Plan We will institute the following: • Students will be quizzed regularly on use of terminology • Students will be shown more design by famous artists and designers. Using specific color combinations by well know artists in an assignment is a possibility, • Students will be given low intensity papers to write in class during critiques to help the entire class participate is discussions. This will allow us to get feedback from everyone and provide opportunities for students to use color theory/art related vocabulary • Students will be quizzed regularly on the history, physiology, concepts, models and systems as they relate specifically to color theory. • Students will be given more complex prompts during critiques. Year: 2013- 2014 Only one section of this course will be offered each semester and the teaching of theories of color will be incorporated into ARTS 121 and Advanced studio courses where appropriate We are giving some thought to giving out standard responses using propr terminology. Students will fill in the blanks to describe what they see. In this way, proper terms are used to describe the visual content. • Students will be shown how to organize their workplace, materials, glue, brushes etc. Instructions will be given on working methodically step by step. Current course assessment for this year follow below: Course(s) assessed (list individually) ART 121 Two dimensional design Relevant General Educational Outcomes Relevant Curricular Outcomes a. Integrate knowledge and skills in their program of study 1.Students will demonstrate progressive development and competency in the technical skills requisite for artistic self expression in at least one major area. 2. Students will demonstrate a progressive understanding of the various elements and basic interrelated processes of creation, interpretation, and execution within their discipline. 3. Students will integrate personal observation and objective b. Apply aesthetic and intellectual criteria in the evaluation or creation of works in the humanities or the arts c. Differentiate and make informed decisions about issues based on multiple value systems Evaluation of Assessment Results Action plan Action Plan We will institute the following: • Students will be given low intensity papers to write in class during critiques. This will allow us to get feedback from everyone. • Students will be quizzed regularly on use of terminology • Students will be given short low intensity quizzes using rulers and right angles. • Students will be shown more design by famous artists and 21 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design criticism in the evolution of their artistic work. 4. Students will demonstrate ability to write about their artwork. ART 122 Three dimensional design intro to sculpture Integrate knowledge and skills in their program of study a. Apply aesthetic and intellectual criteria in the evaluation or creation of works in the humanities or the arts b. Differentiate and make informed decisions about issues based on multiple value systems ART 230 Sculpture 2 a. Integrate knowledge and skills in their program of study b. Apply aesthetic and intellectual criteria in the evaluation or creation of works in the humanities or the arts c. Differentiate and make informed decisions about issues based on multiple value 1.Students will demonstrate progressive development and competency in the technical skills requisite for artistic self expression in at least one major area. 2. Students will demonstrate a progressive understanding of the various elements and basic interrelated processes of creation, interpretation, and execution within their discipline. 3. Students will integrate personal observation and objective criticism in the evolution of their artistic work. 4. Students will demonstrate ability to write about their artwork. 1.Students will demonstrate progressive development and competency in the technical skills requisite for artistic self expression in at least one major area. 2. Students will demonstrate a progressive understanding of the various elements and basic interrelated processes of creation, interpretation, and execution within their discipline. 3. Students will integrate personal Year: 2013- 2014 designers. Action Plan We will institute the following: • Students will be given low intensity papers to write in class during critiques. This will allow us to get feedback from everyone. • Students will be quizzed regularly on use of terminology. • Give students more complex prompts during critique • Students will be given short low intensity quizzes using rulers. • Students will be given short low intensity quizzes where students must draw right angles according to specifications. • Students will be use only a few materials during the semester instead of using three or four different materials. In this way, students gain a thorough experience using the materials. • A checklist of design principles has been prepared. The instructor will check off to see if these design principles have been used. Action Plan Additional emphasis needs to be placed on the nature of the structure of the head and it's planar development. Students must understand the architecture of the form and develop that architecture before they begin building individual shapes. Additional emphasis needs to be placed on the techniques of clay modeling and surface development. Most students are lacking in their capacity to 22 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design systems Year: 2013- 2014 observation and objective criticism in the evolution of their artistic work. 4. Students will demonstrate ability to write about their artwork. verbally describe what it is they have done and wish to do. Students should have some modest capacity to do so. Additional focus will be placed in this area; concentration on terminology and the capacity to express aesthetic experiences. Course assessment: current year Course(s) assessed (list individually) ART 148 Color theory Relevant General Educational Outcomes c. Integrate knowledge and skills in their program of study d. Apply aesthetic and intellectual criteria in the evaluation or creation of works in the humanities or the arts e. Differentiate and make informed decisions about issues based on multiple value systems Relevant Curricular Outcomes 1.Students will demonstrate progressive development and competency in the technical skills requisite for artistic self expression in at least one major area. 2. Students will demonstrate a progressive understanding of the various elements and basic interrelated processes of creation, interpretation, and execution within their discipline. 3. Students will integrate personal observation and objective criticism in the evolution of their artistic work. 4. I Students will demonstrate ability to describe their artwork in written work Evaluation of Assessment Results Action plan We will institute the following: • Students will be quizzed regularly on use of terminology • Students will be shown more design by famous artists and designers. Using specific color combinations by well know artists in an assignment is a possibility, • Students will be given low intensity papers to write in class during critiques to help the entire class participate is discussions. This will allow us to get feedback from everyone and provide opportunities for students to use color theory/art related vocabulary • Students will be quizzed regularly on the history, physiology, concepts, models and systems as they relate specifically to color theory. • Students will be given more complex prompts during critiques. We are giving some thought to giving out standard responses using propr terminology. Students will fill in the blanks to describe what they see. In this way, proper terms 23 Queensborough Community College ART 253 Drawing 3 Illustration Year-end Report – Art and Design a. Integrate knowledge and skills in their program of study b. Apply aesthetic and intellectual criteria in the evaluation or creation of works in the humanities or the arts c. Differentiate and make informed decisions about issues based on multiple value systems .Students will demonstrate progressive development and competency in the technical skills requisite for artistic self expression in at least one major area. 2. Students will demonstrate a progressive understanding of the various elements and basic interrelated processes of creation, interpretation, and execution within their discipline. 3. Students will integrate personal observation and objective criticism in the evolution of their artistic work. 4. I Students will demonstrate ability to describe their artwork in written work . 4. Year: 2013- 2014 are used to describe the visual content. • Students will be shown how to organize their workplace, materials, glue, brushes etc. Instructions will be given on working methodically step by step. Action Plan • Failure of some students to hand in work on time is an ongoing problem More emphasis on importance of deadlines in school and in the industry. More severe grading penalties for late work • Students have an ongoing problems planning work in stages. More emphasis conceptualizing and planning through thumbnails , small preparatory sketches Grading the planning stages will be instituted. • More emphasis on the importance of doing many thumbnails for optimum design solution • Students have a persistent problem explaining their work. Grading class participation is also helpful. • More emphasis on thinking about overall composition Lectures showing the work of famous illustrators with explanations of why their compositions are successful. • More emphasis on the relevancy of assignment to client demands Results of certification examinations, employer and alumni surveys, student surveys, advisory board recommendations (if applicable, please use the table below) 24 Year-end Report – Art and Design Queensborough Community College Data Source Results Year: 2013- 2014 Action plan Certification exams Employer/alumni surveys, including graduation and placement survey Student surveys (current students) Advisory Board recommendations 5. Other assessment activity (if applicable) F. DEPARTMENT GOALS AND OBJECTIVES 1. Goals/objectives for 2013-2014 (Please indicate [Yes or No] if the objectives were part of the College’s Strategic Plan for 2013-2014.) Departmental goals/objectives 2013/2014 Seek Possible Accreditation with NASAD Continue Departmental-level Course Assessment Hire new, full-time Art History Professor Develop a World Art History Course to complement AR-310 Introductory Survey of Art Strategic Plan Y/N Y Evaluation of achievement Resulting action plan Ongoing Y Ongoing Y Ongoing Await completion of recommended studio renovations and approval from administration to proceed with formal application process More assessment focused on Gen Ed learning Hired Y Under continued discussion Continue conversation 25 Queensborough Community College 2. Year-end Report – Art and Design Year: 2013- 2014 Goals/objectives for 2014-2015 (Explain how these goals/objectives align with the College’s goals and Strategic Plan for 2014-2015) Departmental goals/objectives 2014-2015 Continue to seek possible NASAD accreditation Mission/Strategic Plan Y Planned method of evaluation N/A Continue to seek facilities modification recommended by NASAD consultant Y N/A APPENDIX A- Schedule of Course Numbering Changes FROM: TO: [AR-121] Two-Dimensional Design ARTS-121 Two-Dimensional Design [AR-122] Three Dimensional Design: Introduction to Sculpture ARTS-122 Three Dimensional Design: Introduction to Sculpture [AR-148] Color Theory ARTS-221 Color Theory [AR-230] Sculpture ARTS-182 Sculpture [AR-231] Ceramics I ARTS-186 Ceramics I [AR-232] Ceramics II ARTS-286 Ceramics II [AR-251] Drawing I ARTS-151 Drawing I [AR-252] Drawing II ARTS-252 Drawing II [AR-253] Illustration ARTS-253 Illustration [AR-261] Painting I ARTS-161 Painting I [AR-262] Painting II ARTS-262 Painting II [AR-263] Painting III ARTS-263 Painting III [AR-271, 272] Art for Teachers of Children [AR-280] Introduction to Art Therapy ARTS-130, ARTS 131 Art for Teachers of Children ARTS-132 Introduction to Art Therapy 26 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design [AR-310] Introductory Survey of Art [AR-311] History of Art I [AR-312] History of Art II [AR-315] Modern Art [AR-316] American Art [AR-317] History of Photography [AR-320] Contemporary Art [AR-325] History of Graphic Design [AR-326] History of Asian Art [AR-328] History of African Art [AR-461] Introduction to Photography [AR-462] Advanced Photographic Skills [AR-463] Large Format and Studio Photography [AR-464] Photography as Fine Art [AR-465] Creating the Documentary Image [AR-466] Color Photography [AR-468] Photographing People [AR-469] Illustration and Fashion Photography [AR-473] Electronic Imaging [AR-474] Digital Photography [AR-480/481] Special Problems in Studio Art [AR-510] Printmaking: Relief and Stencil Year: 2013- 2014 ARTH-100 Introductory Survey of Art ARTH-101 History of Art I ARTH-202 History of Art II ARTH-115 Modern Art ARTH-116 American Art ARTH-117 History of Photography ARTH-120 Contemporary Art ARTH-225 History of Graphic Design ARTH-126 History of Asian Art ARTH-128 History of African Art ARTS-141 Introduction to Photography ARTS-242 Advanced Photographic Skills ARTS-343 Large Format and Studio Photography ARTS-344 Photography as Fine Art ARTS-345 Creating the Documentary Image ARTS-346 Color Photography ARTS-348 Photographing People ARTS-349 Illustration and Fashion Photography ARTS-291 Electronic Imaging ARTS-243 Digital Photography ARTS-381, ARTS-382 Special Problems in Studio Art ARTS-270 Printmaking: Relief and Stencil [AR-511] Printmaking: Intaglio ARTS-271 Printmaking: Intaglio [AR-512] Printmaking II ARTS-272 Printmaking II 27 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design [AR-541] Advertising Design and Layout ARTS-290 Advertising Design and Layout [AR-543] Design for Desktop Publishing ARTS-292 Design for Desktop Publishing [AR-544] Design for Motion Graphics ARTS-293 Design for Motion Graphics [AR-641] Introduction to Video Art ARTS-191 Introduction to Video Art [AR-642] Web-Animation ARTS-192 Web-Animation [AR-801] Art Administration ARTH-150 Art Administration [AR-803] Art Curating ARTH-251 Art Curating [AR-804] Art Institutions and the Business of Art [AR-901] Gallery Internship I [AR-902] Gallery Internship II [AR-903] Artist Apprentice Internship I [AR-904] Artist Apprentice Internship II [AR-483] Portfolio Project in Studio Art Year: 2013- 2014 ARTH-252 Art Institutions and the Business of Art ARTH-380 Gallery Internship I ARTH-381 Gallery Internship II ARTS-380 Artist Apprentice Internship I ARTS-381 Artist Apprentice Internship II ARTS-390 Portfolio Project in Studio Art APPENDIX B - Schedule of Course Credit Changes From: AR-230 Sculpture 4 studio hours [2] credits Prerequisite: AR-122 TO: AR-230 Sculpture 4 studio hours 3 credits Prerequisite: AR-122 (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-231 Ceramics II 4 studio hours [2] credits AR-231 Ceramics II 4 studio hours 3 credits (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-232 Ceramics II2 4 studio hours [2] credits Prerequisite: AR-231 AR-232 Ceramics II2 4 studio hours 3 credits Prerequisite: AR-231 (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-253 Illustration 4 studio hours [2] credits Offered as needed Prerequisite: AR-251. AR-253 Illustration 4 studio hours 3 credits Offered as needed Prerequisite: AR-251. 28 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design Year: 2013- 2014 (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-252 Drawing II 4 studio hours [2] credits Offered as needed Prerequisite: AR-251, or permission of the Department AR-252 Drawing II 4 studio hours 3 credits Offered as needed Prerequisite: AR-251, or permission of the Department (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-261 Painting I 4 studio hours [2] credits AR-261 Painting I 4 studio hours 3 credits (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-262 Painting II 4 studio hours [2] credits Prerequisite: AR-121 and AR-261 AR-262 Painting II 4 studio hours 3 credits Prerequisite: AR-121 and AR-261 ( additional material included in the syllabus) AR-263 Painting III 4 studio hours [2] credits Prerequisite: AR-262, AR-263 Painting III 4 studio hours 3 credits Prerequisite: AR-262 (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-271, 272 Art for Teachers of Children 4 studio hours [2] credits AR-271, 272 Art for Teachers of Children 4 studio hours 3 credits (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-280 Introduction to Art Therapy 1 class hour 2 studio hours [2] credits Offered in Spring Prerequisite: BE-112 (or BE-205) and BE-122 (or BE-226), or satisfactory score on the CUNY/ACT Assessment Test. AR-461 Introduction to Photography 4 studio hours [2] credits AR-462 Advanced Photographic Skills 4 studio hours [2] credits Prerequisite: AR-461, or permission of the Dept. AR-280 Introduction to Art Therapy 1 class hour 2 studio hours 3 credits Offered in Spring Prerequisite: BE-112 (or BE-205) and BE-122 (or BE-226), or satisfactory score on the CUNY/ACT Assessment Test. (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-461 Introduction to Photography 4 studio hours 3 credits (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-462 Advanced Photographic Skills 4 studio hours 3 credits Prerequisite: AR-461, or permission of the Dept. on 29 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design on review of portfolio review of portfolio AR-463 Large Format and Studio Photography 4 studio hours [2] credits Offered as needed. Prerequisite: [AR-121, and 462 or 474] (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-463 Large Format and Studio Photography 4 studio hours 3 credits Offered as needed. Prerequisite: AR-121 and 462 Year: 2013- 2014 (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-464 Photography as Fine Art 4 studio hours [2] credits Offered as needed. Prerequisite: [AR-121, and 462 or 474] AR-464 Photography as Fine Art 4 studio hours 3 credits Offered as needed. Prerequisite: AR-121 and 462 (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-465 Creating the Documentary Image 4 studio hours [2] credits Offered as needed. Prerequisite: [AR-121, and 462 or 474] AR-465 Creating the Documentary Image 4 studio hours 3 credits Offered as needed. Prerequisite: AR-121 and 462 AR-466 Color Photography 4 studio hours [2] credits Offered as needed. Prerequisite: [AR-121, and 462 or 474] (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-466 Color Photography 4 studio hours 3 credits Offered as needed. Prerequisite: AR-121 and 462 AR-468 Photographing People 4 studio hours [2] credits Offered as needed. Prerequisite: AR-462 [or 474]. (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-468 Photographing People 4 studio hours 3 credits Offered as needed. Prerequisite: AR-462 (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-473 Electronic Imaging 4 studio hours [2] credits Prerequisite or corequisite: AR-121 AR-474 Digital Photography 4 studio hours [2] credits. AR-473 Electronic Imaging 4 studio hours 3 credits Prerequisite or corequisite: AR-121 (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-474 Digital Photography 4 studio hours 3 credits. 30 Queensborough Community College Year-end Report – Art and Design Prerequisite: AR-473. Year: 2013- 2014 Prerequisite: AR-461. (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-480/481 Special Problems in Studio Art 4 studio hours [2] credits Offered as needed Prerequisite: 6 credits in elected art discipline and approval of the Department AR-480/481 Special Problems in Studio Art 4 studio hours 3 credits Offered as needed Prerequisite: 6 credits in elected art discipline and approval of the Department (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-510 Printmaking: Relief and Stencil 4 studio hours 2 credits Prerequisite or corequisite: AR-121, or AR-251, or AR-261 AR-510 Printmaking: Relief and Stencil 4 studio hours 3 credits Prerequisite or corequisite: AR-121, or AR-251, or AR-261 (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-511 Printmaking: Intaglio 4 studio hours [2] credits Prerequisite or corequisite: AR-121, or AR-251, or AR-261 AR-511 Printmaking: Intaglio 4 studio hours 3 credits Prerequisite or corequisite: AR-121, or AR-251, or AR-261 (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-512 Printmaking II 4 studio hours [2] credits Prerequisite AR-510 AR-512 Printmaking II 4 studio hours 3 credits Prerequisite AR-510 (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-541 Advertising Design and Layout 4 studio hours [2] credits Prerequisite or corequisite: AR-121 AR-541 Advertising Design and Layout 4 studio hours 3 credits Prerequisite or corequisite: AR-121 (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-543 Design for Desktop Publishing 4 studio hours [2] credits Prerequisite: AR-541 Offered as needed AR-543 Design for Desktop Publishing 4 studio hours 3 credits Prerequisite: AR-541 Offered as needed (additional material included in the syllabus) AR-544 Design for Motion Graphics 4 studio hours [2] credits Prerequisite: AR-541 Offered as needed AR-544 Design for Motion Graphics 4 studio hours 3 credits Prerequisite: AR-541 Offered as needed (additional material included in the syllabus) 31