DETAIL DESIGN PRESENTATION RUBRIC
Team/Student: ________________________________________
Reviewer:____________________________________________
Reviewer Instructions: Mark the box that best applies in each category. Then assign an overall grade based on your best judgment
Topic
Introduction &
Background
Project Goals
Design Process
Test Plan
Project Management
Progress
Slide Quality
Presentation Ability
Unsatisfactory
Below Expectations
They gave me some idea of
what their project was
about, but I wanted more
context
Meets Expectations
Exceeds Expectations
They did a good job
They did an exceptional job
It was unclear what
explaining the problem, as
explaining the big picture
problem they are trying to
well as the background and and relating their project to
solve or why
context
a real need
The end goal is clear and
The specifications for the
The end goal is described in
It is unclear what “success”
described in terms of
end goal were derived using
broad terms but the details
looks like for this project
reasonable and verifiable
extensive research or
are fuzzy
requirements
analysis
The approach was
The approach was
Extensive analysis or
There is no evidence of a
methodical but some of
methodical and decisions
preliminary experiments
methodical design approach
their decisions seem
all based on sound technical were used to guide design
arbitrary or unsound
reasoning
decisions
Testing is only described in They have a solid test plan
They have not considered
general terms, and/or there which should validate their
They have a thoroughly
testing yet
are significant safety issues design, and they addressed
detailed test plan
that are unaddressed
all significant safety issues
They described a
Resource allocation is
There are a few milestones
There is no evidence of
reasonable plan for
mapped in detail and
or an overall budget, but the
project management
resource (time & money)
reflects a complete
plan is vague
allocation
understanding of the task
They have made some
They have begun work on
They are ahead of where I
They have made no
substantive progress and
the project but they are
expected them to be at this
substantive progress
are on target for their
already behind
time
planned completion date
The slide deck is a mess—
Slides are okay, but they
The slides looked good and
One of the best sets of
it’s full of typos and hard to
didn’t add much to the
helped to explain the
slides I’ve seen
follow
presentation
project
Hard to understand—
I understood them, but I
They gave a dynamic and
Exceptional poise and
mumbling or no eye contact struggled to stay engaged
engaging presentation
delivery
Recommended Grade (A,B,C,D,F scale): __________