The University of Georgia Cooperative Extension Service College of Agricultural and Environmental Sciences Transplant Growing Facilities Paul E. Sumner Extension Engineer General Greenhouses and plant growing facilities include three main categories of components: 1. Structures 2. Coverings 3. Environment Certain data and information concerning these three categories are summarized. Several Extension publications and blueprints are available giving more comprehensive information on these topics. STRUCTURES Location and Orientation Proper greenhouse site selection, location, and orientation are very important for profitable commercial production or satisfactory hobby or part-time operations. The following factors should be considered: - Orient and locate the house for maximum sunlight. In southern latitudes, the ridge should run north-south and northern latitudes east-west. - Avoid placing the house near objects east, west or south which will shade the house. Keep away a distance equal to at least three times the height of the object. - Place in an area sheltered from northerly and north-westerly high winds if possible. - Locate on a soil which is well drained and where surface water does not run into the house. Use drain tile if necessary. - Avoid sloping beds or floors in the greenhouse. - Locate the greenhouse near adequate and reliable sources of utilities -- electricity, water and gas. - Provide good access roads, parking, and turn-around area. - Position headhouses or supporting facilities on the north side. - Arrange initial construction so that the range can be expanded. Uses and Types The basic purpose of a greenhouse structure is to provide a reliable enclosure within which an environment favorable to plant growth and production can be created. This section summarizes some of the main features and data on Greenhouse Structures. There are several types of greenhouse structures and methods of construction with special characteristics that are widely adaptable or sometimes suited only for certain uses. Most all houses should have the following basic features. BASIC FEATURES DESIRED Strength - To be structurally adequate and resist local wind and snow loads. - Usually recommend design for 70 mph winds and 12 p.s.f. snow load. - Adequate foundation to support the structure. Covering - Easy covering attachment and proper support, sometimes with double-layer covering for heating economy. Light - Minimum overhead structural members, or size of members to minimize shading. Openness - Clear-span design desirable for easy working and easy equipment or operating maneuverability. - Wide doors and height as necessary for equipment and crop operations. Environment - Capable of utilizing efficient and economical heating and ventilation systems. Cost/Life - A cost/life ratio that is most suitable for your needs. Maintenance should be considered. Insurance and Taxes - These values vary depending on temporary or permanent structures and flammable or nonflammable materials. Wood Types, Life, and Preservative Treatment Wood is commonly used in construction of benches, flats, doors and structural frames for greenhouses. Since its life and durability are important for long-term usage, proper species and/or treatment can be most valuable in initial construction. The following information should be considered. TABLE 1. TYPICAL LIFE OF UNTREATED HEARTWOOD IN GROUND CONTACT Type____________________________________________________________________ Black Locust Osage-Orange RY RESISTANT (Over 15 Years Average Life) Red Cedar Redwood Cypress White Oak RESISTANT (7 - 15 Years Average Life) Ash Beech Birch Cottonwood Douglas Fir Hemlock SLIGHTLY RESISTANT (2 - 7 Years Average Life) Hickory Larch Maple Red Oak Pine Spruce Yellow Poplar Proper preservative treated wood has a much longer life than most untreated species and does not interfere with normal construction, painting, or management procedures. The oil borne preservatives such as creosote and penta are not recommended due to toxicity to plants and covering materials. Instead, the water-borne salt-type preservatives, which are just as effective, readily available, and suitable for greenhouses should be used. Brush-on treatment is rather ineffective for long-term protection and not recommended. Proper "pressure" treatment by a commercial company is recommended. Expected life of pressure treated wood is 20 to 40 years. Southern Yellow Pine and Douglas Fir are most generally treated but other softwood species and some hardwood can be equally treated. GREENHOUSE COVERINGS One of the most important parts of a greenhouse facility is the covering. Since sunlight is generally the limiting factor in wintertime greenhouse production, a covering that transmits maximum sunlight in the plant growth spectrum is essential. Physical durability and optical stability are other critical factors. Several types of covering materials are presently available. Which one is best, or most economical over the long term, is not easy to state. Glass has been the long-time standard and is still the most stable but other film and rigid plastic materials are offering lower cost coverings but with varying levels of dependability and life. TABLE 4. TYPES OF COVERING MATERIALS Types Films Rigid Plastics Name Polyethylene, UV Acrylic/Polyester Polyester "Fiberglass" Acrylic Polycarbonate Glass Description 4 and 6 mil "Flexigard" "Mylar" or equal Weatherable Fiber reinforced Polyester "Plexiglass" or equal "Lexan" or equal Regular Double Strength Low Iron General Characteristics and Performance of Coverings for Greenhouse Use Polyethylene (Regular and U.V.) 1. Lowest cost covering 2. Widely available, some manufacturers report recently they have stopped production of this product for greenhouse use. (Thus, be cautious of buying any product of unknown quality for greenhouse use.) 3. Relatively short life in sun: 9 to 11 months for regular, one to three years for U.V. 4. Splits more easily at the folds. Should use unfolded or lay-flat rolls for maximum life. 5. Transmits approximately 85 to 88 percent for solar energy available at the earth's surface. 6. Transmits all wavelengths of action spectra required for plant growth. 7. Transmits the wavelengths of thermal radiation which allows the house to cool more rapidly at night. 8. The strength of new 4 and 6 mil film is one to two times that of 1/8 inch standard glass. 9. Permits double-layer covering which results in 35 to 40 percent reduction on heat loss, reduced condensation, and only 8 to 10 percent reduction in light due to the second (if clean) layer. 10. Provides a "tighter" house with less air leakage which causes somewhat higher inside humidity conditions. 11. Film most useful for low cost temporary or seasonal coverings. 12. Polyethylene film reinforced with synthetic fibers is also available at a cost four to five times that of regular film but generally this material is not used for greenhouses. 13. Double-layer covering on top side of structure with centrifugal fan developing pressure between the two layers is a way to reduce labor and installation costs. Life equal or better than conventional installation methods. Acrylic/Polyester 1. Combine weatherability of acrylic with high service temperature of polyester. 2. Good transmissivity. 3. Nonreversible, acrylic must be installed to the outside. 4. Susceptible to wind flapping. 5. Estimated life 10 years plus. Polyester 1. Excellent transmissivity. 2. High service temperature. 3. Low impact resistance. 4. U.V. degradable unless treated. 5. Estimated life 7 to 10 years. Polyvinylflouride 1. The Tedlar® film has proven to have excellent weatherability but is too costly to compete with existing films as a covering. It is now being used as a surface coating which is molecularly bonded to fiberglass panels to improve their weatherability. Plexiglass® 1. An acrylic plastic which has been available for many years but has not been widely used as a greenhouse covering due to high cost except for special Climatic or Conservatory type facilities. 2. It is more resistant to impact than glass. 3. Transmits approximately 90 to 92 percent of available sunlight and is available in UV transmitting and absorbing types. 4. Has long life and weathering resistance comparable to glass. 5. Softer than glass, it is easily scratched and is sensitive to some solvents. 6. Cost appreciably more than glass and other possible covering materials. 7. Flexible enough to be used as curved panels in glasshouses. 8. Strong enough to resist snow and ice loads near gutters of connected houses. 9. Expands and contracts greatly with temperature changes and should not be directly nailed or screwed down, but held under a cover strip with soft mastic sealer to allow movement. Fiberglass Reinforced Rigid Plastics (FRP) 1. Many brands of the basic polyester resin reinforced with fiber glass are available in flat and corrugated forms. Corrugated form adds strength. 2. Made in "weights" from 4 to 8 ounces per square foot, widths up to 51 1/2 inches (48 inch coverage ) and lengths pre-cut up to 30 or more feet (special order). Use minimum number of joints and laps to reduce chances of dust and dirt accumulation between panels and also air/water leakage. Use proper clear sealer on laps for tightness. 3. Two to four times more resistant to impact and lateral loading than glass. Crazing (not shattering) usually results from impact, but this crazing has no harmful effect unless the panel surface is cracked or broken. 4. The polyester of the panels burns freely and rapidly; entire houses have burned in approximately 10 minutes. Flame retardants and good weatherability have not been successfully used together. Insurance on fiberglass is not easily obtainable. 5. Clear or "frosted" panels of greenhouse quality material transmits approximately 78 to 90 percent of available light when new. Non-greenhouse formulations, especially colored panels, should be avoided. 6. Panels with 15 percent acrylic additive have proven more durable than straight polyester formulations. 7. Acrylic modified polyester panels need cleaning at least annually, and generally re-surfacing with an acrylic liquid sealer every 4 to 5 years to restore weathered surfaces to near-new transmission and surface condition (except Tedlar Coated). The durability of the sealer coat is questionable and undergoing more study at present. 8. Some manufacturer's guarantees are rather nebulous. Until accurate evaluation procedures and quality standards are established, judge a product more on its performance and company reputation rather than the "guarantee". 9. Proper attachment to the structure and sealing/fastening of lapped joints is essential for resistance to wind forces. (Use fasteners every 8 to 12 inches on ends and sides, or per manufacturers specifications.) Regular Glass 1. Single strength and small panes not used much on newer designs and constructions. Replacement of panes in existing houses could be double-strength for more resistance to breakage. Tempered Glass 1. Two or three times stronger than regular glass. 2. Frosted or "hammered" types available for better light diffusion, reduced shadow, and non-seethrough properties. 3. Larger pane sizes for reduced structural members, hence less shadows. 4. Requires special structural members and glazing methods to give water and air-tight construction. ENVIRONMENT The successful operation of any greenhouse requires the maintenance of an inside temperature near the optimum level for plant growth. The exact inside temperature to be maintained will depend on the crop being grown. Generally, designs are for 65oF inside capability with thermostatic adjustment for exact conditions per horticultural recommendations. Other climatic factors include relative humidity, air movement, and carbon dioxide. Temperature and relative humidity are normally controlled by the heating and ventilation equipment. Continuous air circulation, especially in the wintertime, is important for distribution of heat and uniformity of inside conditions by preventing air stagnation and stratification. Carbon dioxide enrichment of the air for greater plant growth and production is sometimes profitable. Heating Heat Requirements and Fuel Costs Factors primarily affecting the heat requirements of a greenhouse are: 1. The external environmental condition 2. The size of the greenhouse. 3. The structural nature of the greenhouse. 4. The number of layers of glazing material used to cover the house. The following permit determination of heating requirements and annual fuel costs for a particular greenhouse type, size, and single or double-layer covering. Heat Requirement Calculations for Greenhouses It is useful to know some heat loss calculation procedures to predict heating loads and identify areas of the greenhouse with the most heat loss. Heat loss by conduction may be calculated with the following equation. Q = U A (Ti - To) where Q = heat transfer rate, BTU/hr. U = heat transfer coefficient, BTU/hr.-ft.2 oF A = surface area, ft.2 Ti-To = air temperature difference between inside and outside, oF. Sometimes "R" values (the resistance to heat flow) are listed instead of "U" values. The relation between "U" and "R" is: U=1 R The conduction heat transfer equation using "R" can then be written as: Q = A(Ti-To) R Frequently, it is more convenient to work with "R" values when dealing with insulation, as the added effect of insulation can be determined quickly by simply summing the "R" values of materials in the heat flow path. For example, from Table 5., the "R" value for a single layer of glass is equivalent to 0.88 and for 1-inch-thick styrofoam, 4.00. Adding styrofoam to a single-layer glass surface will give the wall an insulation value of R = 0.88 + 4.00 = 4.88 (or a "U" value of 1/4.88 = 0.204). Note that high "R" values and low "U" values indicate less heat flow. TABLE 5. HEAT TRANSFER COEFFICIENTS FOR CONSTRUCTION MATERIALS R Value** Materials (hr.oF sq.ft./BTU) Glass, single layer 0.88* Glass, double layer, 1/4 in. space 1.54* Glass, triple layer, 1/4 in. space 2.13* Clear polyethylene film, single layer (2, 4, or 6 mil) 0.87* Clear polyethylene film, double layer, separated(2, 4, or 6 mil) 1.43* Polyethylene film, double layer, separated over glass 2.00* Fiberglass 1.00* Double acrylic (Acrylite SDPTM) 1.78* Double polycarbonate (Tuffak-TwinwallTM) 1.61* Face Brick, 4 in. thick 0.44 Concrete block, 8 inch 1.96 Concrete block, 8 inch plus l inch foamed urethane 7.69 Concrete block, 8 inch plus 1 inch foamed polystyrene 5.55 Concrete, poured, 6 inch 1.33 Cement asbestos board, 1/4 inch 0.91 Cement asbestos board, 1/4 inch plus l inch foamed urethane 7.14 Cement asbestos board, 1/4 inch plus l inch foamed polystyrene 4.76 TM Microfoam 1/4 in. thick 1.08 Polystyrene (beadboard or loose fill), 1/2 in. thick 2.10 Polystyrene (beadboard or loose fill), 3/4 in. thick 3.05 Polystyrene (beadboard or loose fill), l inch thick 4.00 Extruded polystyrene (Styrofoam) 1 inch thick 5.40 Polyurethane foam (applied at site), 1 inch thick 7.30 Plywood 1/2 inch 0.62 Plywood 1 inch 1.25 1 inch nominal softwood 1.79 Expanded vermiculite (6-6 lb./cu.ft., 1 inch thick) 2.20 Curtain Materials Al/TempTM, aluminum down aluminum up Al/BlacTM Duracote #2425 (FoylonTM) Black Sateen Black poly, 6 mil 1.43 1.18 1.37 2.63 1.54 1.05 ReemayTM, spunbound polyester, 2016 0.83 Vinyl (aluminized polyester laminated vinyl) 4.5 mil 2.15 ** The R value represents the resistance to heat flow at the thickness listed. The higher the R value the better the insulating property. * Includes effects of surface coefficients. Acrylite S.D.P., TM CY/RO Industries Microfoam, TM DuPont Al/Blac, TM Simtrac, Inc. Reemay, TM DuPont Al/Temp, TM Simtrac, Inc. Styrofoam, TM Dow Chemical Foylon, TM Duracote Corp Tuffak-Twinwall, TM Rohm and Haas Co. Infiltration heat loss can be significant and should be calculated and added to conduction heat losses. The equation for infiltration heat transfer is: Q = 0.02 x Vol x NC x (Ti-To) where: Q = heat transfer rate, Btu/hour Vol = greenhouse volume, ft3. NC = number of air exchanges per hour (Table 6). Ti-To = air temperature difference between inside and outside, oF. TABLE 6. NATURAL AIR EXCHANGES FOR GREENHOUSES Construction System Air Exchanges per Hour* New Construction, glass or fiberglass 0.75 to 1.5 New Construction, double layer plastic film 0.5 to 1.0 Old Construction, glass, good maintenance 1 to 2 Old Construction, glass, poor condition 2 to 4 * Low wind or protection from wind reduces the air exchange rate Once dimensions are known and listed, the area and volumes can be calculated with the following equations for the appropriate greenhouse style: Single gable greenhouse (Figure 1.) Wall area = 2 (F x C) End area = (2xFxB) + (GxB) Roof area = 2 (DxC) Foundation Area = 2 (ExC) + 2(ExB) Volume = AxBxC + 1/2 (BxG)xC Gutter-connected gable greenhouses (N = number of greenhouses) (Figure 2) Wall area = 2 (FxC) End area = [2 (FxB) + 2(GxB)] x N 2 Roof area = [2 (DxC)] x N Foundation area = 2 (ExC) + [2 (ExB) x N] Volume = [AxBxC + 1/2 (BxG) x C] x N Gutter-connected, curvedroof greenhouses (N = number of greenhouses) (Figure 3) Wall area = 2(AxC) End area = [1.3(HxB) + AxB] x N Foundation area = 2 (ExC) + [2 (ExB) x N] Roof area = (DxC) x N Volume = [4/3 (HxBxC) + (AxBxC)] x N Quonset-style greenhouse (Figure 4) End area = 4/3 (HxB) Roof area = DxC Volume = 4/3 (HxBxC) Estimating Annual Heat Cost for Greenhouses It will be useful for the grower to estimate annual heating cost in a typical heating season. Fuel usage can be determined by the following equation. Fuel Usage = 100 x A x HD x T R x HC x EFF where: Fuel Usage = Units, gallons, cubic feet A = Surface area, ft2 HD = Heating degree days per year T = Number of hours heating per day, hrs. R = Resistance to heat flow, hr x ft2 x oF/Btu HC = Heat capacity of fuel used, Btu/units, gallons, cubic feet EFF = Burning Efficiency, % Table 7 presents heating degree days for various locations in Georgia at various base temperatures. Also, Table 8 gives heat content and burning efficiencies for typical heating fuels. Knowing fuel usage, the cost of heating a greenhouse can now be calculated. Cost = Fuel Usage x UC Where UC = fuel unit costs, $/unit TABLE 7. ANNUAL HEATING DEGREE DAYS AT VARIOUS BASE TEMPERATURES County 70oF 65oF 60oF 55oF Bacon Bibb Charlton Chatham Clay Fulton Muscogee Stephens Thomas Tift Walker Wilkes 2705 3233 2204 2806 2810 4115 3311 4149 2499 2891 4787 4226 1835 2279 1417 1921 1922 3021 2356 3018 1672 1993 3617 3104 1168 1512 861 1242 1227 2128 1575 2104 1059 1299 2636 2188 693 948 491 753 733 1417 997 1370 625 796 1830 1447 TABLE 8. HEAT CAPACITIES OF VARIOUS FUEL AND BURNING EFFICIENCIES Fuel Coal Natural Gas LP Gas Fuel Oil Electricity Heat Content 13,000 BTU/LB. 1,000 BTU/Cu.Ft. 92,000 BTU/Gallon 38,000 BTU/Gallon 3,413 BTU/KWH Burning Efficiency 60% 80% 80% 70% 100% Heating Equipment and Cooling Systems The most popular heating equipment now used in many greenhouses are gas-fired unit-heaters or comparable furnaces. Oil-fired units are sometimes used if fuel prices and availability are more favorable but maintenance of this equipment is greater than gas. For large greenhouses or greenhouse ranges of 1/2 acre or more, centrally located hot water or steam systems with gas, oil or stoker coal fired burners can be feasible. Air Circulation Continuous wintertime air circulation is recommended in greenhouses to prevent air stratification and thereby provide more uniform temperature and humidity control. Definite patterns of air movement should be provided. Air velocities of 30 to 60 feet per minute within the crop zone are adequate. An air circulation rate of 30 to 40 percent of the total house volume (cfm) is recommended. The use of smoke or dust producing devices may be used to determine if circulation and air movement are occurring throughout a house. Ventilation Warm season and summertime ventilation of greenhouses is essential for temperature control. Modern, thermostatically controlled fans are the heart of present day ventilation systems. Poorly planned systems or inferior equipment often result in serious crop damage or failures by inadequate air exchange and high temperatures. Figure 5 shows the effect of air exchange rate on control of temperature rise within the greenhouse on sunny days. An air change rate of 3/4 to 1 or 1 l/4 volume per minute is recommended depending on the type of covering and management used. From the heat requirement section the volume of the greenhouse can be calculated. Total air flow rate of house fans can be determined. Figure 5. The influence of air exchange rate on temperature rise in greenhouses. Evaporative Cooling Evaporative cooling pads are quite effective and useful in lower humidity climates but their use and value in Georgia depend on the crop and other factors. Recommended Greenhouse Heating-Ventilation Equipment Specifications Ventilation Fans A.M.C.A. (Air Moving Conditioning Association) rated to provide required CFM at 1/10 to 1/8 inch static pressure. Totally enclosed motors, with ball bearings, thermally protected, direct or belt-drive, one or two-speed as required. NOTE: Non-A.M.C.A. rated fans are not recommended but if used should be over-sized 35 to 50 percent to compensate for reduced air flow under static pressure operating conditions. Shutters Aluminum or enamel-painted steel frame, reinforced aluminum vanes tie rod connected, bronze or nylon pivot bearings, gravity or motorized wall type as required. Unit Heater A.G.A. approved vented type with aluminized or stainless steel heat exchanger. Propeller type fan with ball-bearing or permanently-lubricated continuous-duty sleeve bearing motor, thermal or impedance protected. Pilot with 100 percent safety shut-off controls, 115/24 V control transformer. LP or natural gas as required for fuel available. Heater to have Btu/hour output as required. Heat Thermostat 24 V SPST heat-anticipator or line voltage type, temperature range approximately 50 to 80oF. Suitable for greenhouse dirt and humidity conditions. Mercury-bulb type to be firmly mounted to prevent movement and erratic heater operation. Ventilation Thermostat Heavy duty, snap action, line voltage type, amperage of Hp rating larger than fan motor, SPST or two-stage (2 SPDT switches) as required, suitable for greenhouse dirt and humidity conditions. Evaporative Cooling Pads Some evaporative cooling systems can cool air to 85 percent of the difference between its original temperature prior to cooling and the coolest temperature which could be achieved if the air were cooled to the dew point or to the point of 100 percent relative humidity. Evaporative coolers are more effective when the humidity is low. Fortunately, relative humidities are usually low during warm periods. Solar heat entering the house offsets some of the cooling effect. A well designed ventilation system providing one air exchange per minute is essential for good evaporative cooling system. Many pad materials have been successfully used for evaporative cooling. Table 9 gives recommended air flow through various pad type materials. TABLE 9. RECOMMENDED AIRFLOW RATE THROUGH VARIOUS PAD MATERIALS Pad Type (CFM/ft2) Airflow Rate Through Pad Aspen fiber mounted vertically (2-4 in.) thick Aspen fiber mounted horizontally (2-4 in.) thick Corrugated cellulose (4 inches) thick Corrugated cellulose (6 inches) Thick 150 200 250 350 Pads are usually confined in a welded wire mesh. Water running through a pipe with closely spaced holes allows water to run down a sheet metal spreader onto the pads. The flowrate of the water supplying header pipe is listed in Table 11. Water that does not evaporate in the air stream is caught in the gutter and returned to a reservoir for recycling. The reservoir should have the capacity to hold the water returning from the pad when the system is turned off. Table 10 presents recommended reservoir capacity for different types pads. TABLE 10. RECOMMENDED WATER FLOWRATE AND RESERVOIR CAPACITY FOR VERTICALLY MOUNTED COOLING PAD MATERIALS. Minimum Flowrate per Length Pad Type of Pad (gpm/ft) Aspen fiber (2-4 inches) Corrugated Cellulose (4 inches) Corrugated Cellulose (6 inches ) 0.3 0.5 0.8 Minimum Reservoir Capacity Per Unit Pad Area (Gal/ft2) 0.5 0.8 1.0 Cooperative Extension Service, The University of Georgia College of Agriculture offers educational programs, assistance and materials to all people without regard to race, color, national origin, age or handicap status. AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER ENGINEERING Mis.Pub. No. ENG00-003 Jun, 2000 Issued in furtherance of Cooperative Extension work, Acts of May 8 and June 30, 1914, The University of Georgia College of Agriculture and Environmental Sciences and the U. S. Department of Agriculture cooperating. Gale A. Buchanan, Dean and Director