Northwest Commission on College and Universities (NWCCU) Annual Update for WSQA Academic Year 2014, 2015 Due November 6, 2015 College Name: North Seattle College Contact Person: Dr. Kristen Jones, Vice President for Instruction Contact Phone: 206-934-3701 Contact email: Kristen.jones@seattlecolleges.edu Name of College: North Seattle College Accreditation recommendations to the College and year of recommendation The evaluation committee recommends that the College take the steps necessary to implement the recommendations of the 2011 Facility Condition survey to adequately support the academic and support programs that are integral to core themes (Standard 2.G.1). [July 29, 2013 letter to NSC President Mark Mitsui from NWCCU president Sandra Elman] Actions taken by the college to address recommendations The 2011 Facilities Condition Survey (FCS) identified a number of items that needed attention. The items fell into two categories: infrastructure and buildings. In the FCS, “infrastructure” refers to the property outside of the building itself, things such as drainage, walkways, parking lots, grounds, etc. The college has not addressed the infrastructure items identified in the 2011 FCS because historically such items have not been included in funding provided by the SBCTC, and the college has not had local resources to address the concerns. However, beginning with the 2017-19 biennium, the FCS process will 1 Improvement results Item: Portable freezer and refrigerator in the kitchen need to be replaced with built-in models. Status: These were replaced when the kitchen was remodeled in 2013. Item: A deteriorating 3-pot sink needs to be replaced. Status: This was replaced with the kitchen was remodeled in 2013. Item: A concrete slab near the entry has a low spot that allows rain water to pool. A drain should be installed. Status: This was completed in the 2013-15 Name of College: North Seattle College Accreditation recommendations to the College and year of recommendation Actions taken by the college to address recommendations include funding for infrastructure items. At that time, the college will submit a request for funding. However, its request will have to compete with infrastructure requests from the other colleges in the state. Requests are expected to exceed available funds, so the college is not assured that its request will be funded, either in whole or in part. In addition to infrastructure items, the FCS (pp. 4-5) identified a number of repairs that were needed within various campus buildings. Many repairs have been complete, others will occur within the current biennium (2015-17), and others will be ongoing into 2017-19 and beyond. The table in the next column summarizes the status of each of the items cited in the FCS. Improvement results biennium. Item: Fire/smoke dampers in several buildings need replacing. Status: Two-thirds of these have been replaced. The remaining one-third have been purchased and will be installed in the 2015-17 biennium. Item: Several electric duct heaters from the original 1969 construction need to be replaced. Status: Two-thirds of these have been replaced. The additional ones are deferred until the 201719 biennium. Item: Air dampers and electric actuators on four buildings need to be replaced. Status: Pneumatic actuators have been replaced with electric in the College Center, Library and Instruction buildings. Dampers have been replaced in the College Center and Library. The old Technology Building was completely remodeled which effectively addressed the problem. Item: Pneumatic control air compressors and refrigerated air dryers need to be replaced at three locations in science and HVAC labs. Status: This work has been completed. Item: Aluminum handrails, balusters and post bases on the elevate walkways and stairwells need to be replaced over the next several years. 2 Name of College: North Seattle College Accreditation recommendations to the College and year of recommendation Actions taken by the college to address recommendations Improvement results Status: This work has been completed on the handrails above the central courtyard. This represents approximately 20% of the entire project. More work has been funded and is planned for 2015-17, and yet more work will occur in 2017-19. The work is likely to continue into the 2019-21 biennium. Item: Original door hardware on several buildings is old, worn and failing. It needs to be replaced. Status: Work on this item is ongoing. The worst, most-worn hardware was replaced in 2013-15, but funding for the remainder of the project has been deferred by SBCTC. In the meantime, when possible left-over RMI (repair and minor improvement) funds will be used to continue to address the item. 3 Name of College: North Seattle College Accreditation recommendations to the College and year of recommendation Actions taken by the college to address recommendations The evaluation committee recommends that for each year of operation, the College undergo an external financial audit and that the results from such audits, including findings and management letter recommendations, be considered in a timely, appropriate and comprehensive manner by the Board of Trustees (Eligibility Requirement 19 and Standard 2.F.7). In August 2014, the college submitted an Ad Hoc report, as requested by NWCCU, describing actions taken in response to this recommendation. The report noted that addressing the recommendation required that the college 1. Develop financial statements in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles 2. Contract with professional qualified personnel to audit the financial statements; 3. Ensure that the college administration and board review and consider the results of the financial statement audit in a timely, appropriate and comprehensive manner. [July 29, 2013 letter to NSC President Mark Mitsui from NWCCU president Sandra Elman] Develop financial statements . . . The State Board for Community and Technical Colleges (SBCTC) convened a pilot group consisting of nine colleges, including North Seattle College. In August 2014, North Seattle completed its initial statements under the new accounting standards. These statements were for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2013 (FY2013). Contract with qualified personnel . . . The Seattle Colleges contracted with the Washington State Auditor’s Office (SAO) to audit their financial statements. Washington state law establishes SAO as the auditor of public accounts. SAO employees are 4 Improvement results The following excerpts from the minutes of the March 12, 2015 board meeting are apropos the commission’s recommendation: The audit determined that there have been no material misstatements in Seattle Colleges' financial statements, no significant deficiencies in internal control over reporting, no instances of noncompliance. Ms. Li also confirmed that this audit meets the requirements of the accreditation process. Seattle Colleges is committed to improving their financial reporting and compliance, and is a leader in this area-being the 5th community college in the state to undergo this process. As Dr. Jones noted in her August 18, 2015 letter to NWCCU, “North Seattle College anticipates that this audit report will meet the criteria for accreditation requirements for Recommendation 2, and we look forward to receiving a report from NWCCU after the Commission reviews this material at their January 2016 meeting.” Name of College: North Seattle College Accreditation recommendations to the College and year of recommendation Actions taken by the college to address recommendations experienced in auditing public universities’ business-type activity financial statements, having audited several public colleges since GASB 34 became effective in 2002. The audit of Seattle Colleges—including North Seattle, its sister colleges, and the district office—was conducted during Fall Quarter 2014 (September-December 2014). Ensure timely review of audit . . . The 2013 Financial Report, which included the Washington State Auditor’s “Independent Auditor’s Report on Financial Statements” was presented to and approved by the Board of Trustees at its meeting on March 12, 2015. The presentation was made by Kurt Buttleman, Seattle College District’s Vice Chancellor of Finance & Technology, and June Li, Assistant State Auditor. The Financial Report and the board meeting minutes were sent to the NWCCU on August 18, 2015, by Dr. Kristen Jones, Vice President for Instruction and Accreditation Liaison Officer. The college will report on these two recommendations in its Year Seven Self-Study Report that it will be submitting in March 2016. 5 Improvement results