4/7/16 PracticeExam Mon4/11at6:00pmtoapprox.7:00pm bringlaptop composeresponseasaWorddocument tobemailedtomduncan@uh.eduat completionoftest proctoredbyProf.Simpson AdvancedTopics A. PrivityofContract B. FailuretoAct C. PureEconomicLoss D. NegligentInflictionofEmotionalDistress E. WrongfulLifeandWrongfulBirth F. OwnersandOccupiersofLand 1 4/7/16 OwnersandOccupiersofLand Trespassers Licensees Invitees OtherCategories ChildrenandAttractiveNuisances LessorsandLessees Sheehanv.St.Paul&DuluthRy. trespassers unlawfullyonthepremises nodutyunlessdiscoveredorknown 2 4/7/16 Barmorev.Elmore Licensee enterswithpermissionforthelicensee’sownpurpose dutytowarnofhiddendangersaboutwhichlandowner hasactualknowledge Invitee entersinfurtheranceoflandowner’sbusiness/purpose dutytokeepthepremisesreasonablysafefrom dangersactuallyorconstructivelyknown Campbellv.Weathers Licensee enterswithpermissionforthelicensee’sownpurpose dutytowarnofhiddendangersaboutwhichlandowner hasactualknowledge Invitee entersinfurtheranceoflandowner’sbusiness/purpose dutytokeepthepremisesreasonablysafefrom dangersactuallyorconstructivelyknown 3 4/7/16 OwnersandOccupiersofLand Trespassers Licensee Invitee OtherCategories ChildrenandAttractiveNuisances LessorsandLessees Pinegarv.Harris attractivenuisancedoctrine ahiddentraporinherentlydangerous instrumentalityonpremises presenceofchildrenforeseeable exceptiontotrespassersnodutyrule narrowlyapplied 4 4/7/16 OwnersandOccupiersofLand Trespasser • • unlawfullyonthepremises nodutyunlessdiscoveredoranticipated • Licensee • • enterswithpermissionforthelicensee’sownpurpose dutytowarnofhiddendangersaboutwhichlandowner hasactualknowledge • Invitee • entersinfurtheranceoflandowner’sbusiness/purpose • dutytokeepthepremisesreasonablysafefromdangers actuallyorconstructivelyknown OwnersandOccupiersofLand Trespassers Licensee Invitee OtherCategories ChildrenandAttractiveNuisances LessorsandLessees 5 4/7/16 Klinev.1500Mass.Ave.Apts. Lessordutytolessees tousereasonablecare toprotectlesseesfrom • reasonablyanticipateddangers • incommonareas Batrav.Clark out-of-possessionlessor liablewhenlessorhas actualknowledgeof presenceofanimal withdangerouspropensitiesand abilitytocontrolthepremises 6 4/7/16 Torts I. IntentionalTorts II. NegligenceActions III. StrictLiability A. Animals B. Activities Irvinev.RareFelineBreedingCtr. “wildanimal” strictliability≠absoluteliability limitedtoharmcharacteristicofwild animalofthatclass potentialdefenses AOR (perhaps)comparativefault 7 4/7/16 StrictLiability A. Animals B. Activities Rylandsv.Fletcher HouseofLords– naturalvs.non-naturaluseofland ExchequerChamber– “anythinglikelytodomischief” Defenses AOR Vismajor 8 4/7/16 StrictLiability 1. QualifyingAnimal/Activity 2. Causation 3. TypeofHarm RestatementViews “Ultrahazardous”--(1st) “Abnormallydangerous”-- (2nd&3rd) 9 4/7/16 IndianaHarborv.Am.Cyanamid Rest(2nd)ofTorts§520 1. Existenceofriskofharm 2. Likelihoodthattheharmwillbegreat 3. Inabilitytoeliminateriskbyreasonablecare 4. Whetheractivityismatterofcommonusage 5. Inappropriatenessactivitytotheplace 6. Whetheritsvaluetothecommunityis outweighedbyitsdangerousattributes 10 4/7/16 Damages Nominal Compensatory Punitive Damages Nominal Compensatory Punitive 11 4/7/16 McGeev.ACandS,Inc. 12