THE STORE FOR J. C. PENNEY COMPANY MASSACHUSETTS IN FRAMINGHAM, BY KYU LEE SUBMITTED IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT DEGREE OF BACHELOR OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE IN ARCHITECTURE AT THE MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY 1957 JUNE, SIGNATURE AUTHOR OF . . . . o4 ARCHITECTURE, JUNE DEPARTMENT CERTIFIED . BY . . . . . . . . . THESIS ACCEPTED BY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1957 . SUPERVISOR . . . . . . . . . . CHA IRMAN, DEPARTMENTAL UNDERGRADUATE COMMITTEE THES IS ON . . . * 27-A MCLEAN STREET MASSACHUSETTS BOSTON, JUNE, PIETRO BELLUSCHI, DEAN SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE AND MASSACHUSETTS INSTITUTE OF CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS DEAR DEAN PLANNING TECHNOLOGY BELLUSCHI: IN QUIREMENTS 1957 PARTIAL FOR THE FULFILLMENT OF DEGREE, BACHELOR THE RE- IN I HEREWITH RESPECTFULLY SUBMIT A THESIS ENTITLED, "THE STORE FOR J.C. PENNEY COMPANY IN FRAMINGHAM, MASSACHUSETTS. ARCHITECTURE, SINCERELY LEE YOURS, ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I RECEIVED TO THANK FOR THE ADVICE, CRITICISM, AND ENCOURAGEMENT DURING THE PROCESS OF THIS DESIGN, THE MEMBERS OF THE THESIS OF ARCHITECTURE, I WISH COMMITTEE OF DEPARTMENT OF THE DEPARTMENT OF THE MEMBERS OF THE FACULTY OF THE ARCHITECTURE AND CITY PLANNING, OF THE THE MEMBERS AND CONSTRUCTION, MR. OF DANA L. FACULTY BOWIE, MANAGER FRAMINGHAM, OF OF THE MASSACHUSETTS, THE DEPARTMENT WHO J. C. ACTED BUILDING PENNEY COMPANY AS MY SUPPOSED CLIENT, MR. OF MELVIN CITY AND F. LEVINE, GRADUATE OF M. REGIONAL PLANNING, CONSULTANT, THE MEMBERS OF MY CLASS. WHO I. T., ACTED AS DEPARTMENT MY PLANNING THESIS ABSTRACT THE STORE FOR J. C. PENNEY COMPANY IN FRAMINGHAM, MASSACHUSETTS KYU LEE THE ITIES IN OF BACHELOR OF ARCHITECTURE THESIS M.I.T. JUNE, 1957 INTENT OF RELOCATING ACCORDANCE WITH BUSINESS DISTRICT THE THIS THESIS THE IS PRESENT THE FUTURE OF J. C. BECAUSE OF STUDY AND OPERATIONAL CHARACTERISTICS. BETTER SITE ZATION OF DESIGN THE THE AND DISCUSSION MADE TO VITAL ARE STORE AS OF BEEN THE MEANING A IN J. C. ON RELATION AND HOW COMPREHENSIVE AS WELL PENNEY COMPANY THE HAS BEEN HISTORICAL PLACED WHOLE OF POSSIBIL- CENTRAL HOW TO TO THE SELECTED BACKGROUND SELECT SPACIAL TO COORDINATE STORE PLANNING AS TO ENHANCE FOR INTERIOR A ORGANI- REQUIRED TO GIVE SPACE STORE. GENERAL ARE THE TOWN ELEMENTS CHARACTER OF FOR ITS PARTICULAR HAS THE MASSACHUSETTS. PENNEY COMPANY THE EMPHASIS OF REDEVELOPMENT FRAMINGHAM, MAJOR EXAMINE STORE OF STORE TO TO DESIGN OF OBJECTIVES THE CENTRAL SOLVE PLANNING STORE PLANNING. INTRODUCED ARE FORMULATED BUSINESS DISTRICT. PROBLEMS DESIGN AND DISCUSSED. AFTER BRIEF SUGGESTIONS ON CIRCULATION WHICH OBJECTIVES FOR THE STORE IS THE SC LUTIONS FOLLOWING ARE PRESENTED: FOR GENERAL DESI GN OBJECTIVES: A) CONCORD CIRCULATION STREET IS PLACED BY RATING AUTOMOBILE BLOCKED PEDESTRIAN AND AND WALKWAY RESEPA- PEDESTRIAN CIRCULATION. B) TWO PARKIAG LEVEL .iAVELING THEIR PARKING DISTANCE AUTOMOBILES GIVING TO TO MINIMUM SHOPPERS THE FROM SHOPPING AREA. I. FOR STORE A) CREATION MATE B) DESIGN OF SPACE OBJECTIVES: COLUMN-FREE F OR AND CREATION OF INTI- CONTRAST. COORDINATION OF ELEMENTS INTRODUCED. ARE SPACE STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS AND MECHANICAL TABLE OF CONTENTS PAGE INTRODUCTION CBD LOCATION . . . . . . . . . AND DESCRIPTION GENERAL CONSIDERATION FOR . OF . . THE . . . . . TOWN . . . . . . 3 PLAN . . . . 6 TOWN AS . . . . . 13 . 14 . . 17 . 19 REDEVELOPMENT DESIGN OBJECTIVES FOR GENERAL PLAN OF THE A WHOLE . . . . . . . .. ... . . . . . . SOLUTIONS TO THE OESIGN OBJECTIVES HISTORICAL BACKGROUND PROGRAM DESIGN . . . . OBJECTIVES IMPROVEMENTS ARE SOLUTIONS TO DESIGN . . FOR SITE MADE . . . . . . . . . . THE STORE ... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . AFTER GENERAL . . . . . . . FOR SITE OBJECTIVES FOR ...... . . SELECTION OBJECTIVES FOR TO DESIGN BIBLIOGRAPHY . a DESIGN OBJECTIVES SOLUTIONS . . C. PENNEY COMPANY J. OF I . . SELECTION . 20 . 21 . . . . . 23 THE STORE . . . . 26 . . . . . . 3 . . . . . . . I INTRODUCT ION POPULATI ON RAPID HOUS ING HAM, MASSACHUSETTS, FOR BOSTON, PRODUCES NEW YORK, PROBLEMS CONGESTION, CONTINUED OF PARKING, UNHEALTHY URBAN THE COMMUNITY FEELING PAST BY THE OF ELEMENTS BEST IN AND INTEGRITY UNITY AND COMMUNITY'S EACH USE THE THE TO VARIETY, COMMUNITY RAD ICAL CITY BE THE TASK CONTROLLED PLAN OF EXISTING TOWN THE AND, ABOVE ALL, BEAUTY HAS ECONOMIC, ITS HEREAFTER CENTRAL ABBREV IATION, CBD. AND BUSINESS OF PROCESS DISTRICT A OSTLY, CH ANGE THE IN QUESTION0 TO USE IS BY T HE ETC., THEM. THEIR A RCH ITECTS AND PLANNER S CREATING MODERN TO GOVERNMENT, ELEMEN TS ACH IEVE AESTHETIC, EXPRESSED STOP TC POSSIBLY CITY CONTINUITY, SUCH T RAF F IC INEFFICIENT CAN IN THE AN D CHANGES AUTOMO BILES, COMMUNITY, FRAMING- YEARS RE GULATIONS, TODAY ARCHITECT'S VARIE TY, TO OR OF COMMUNITIES RECENT IN EXISTING OF TOWN REDEVELOPMENT NEIGHBORLINES S TOWN NOT ALL GOAL COMMUNICATION, I A ND BRING IN THE R AILROADS, WITH HAVE TO HARMONY, ETC. AND AND COOPERATING REALITY HO USING, INDUSTRY, ADVANTAGE PLANNERS, ZONING PARTICULAR PLANNER'S THE RE VISING STR UCTURE AND OR METROPOLI TAN ETC., OF THE AND BUSI NESS DISTRICT. OH ICAGO, DETERIORATION OF EXPANSION MANY INDUSTRIAL INCREASING CENTRA L DOWN-TOWN IN AND PROX IMITY FORECAST OCCURING IS PHENOMENA AS THE THE IN DEVELOPMENT PROPOSAL GROWTH TO BALANCE, COHERENCE, A DDING EXPRESSING T HE TOWN AS WILL W HOLE. BIOLOGICAL, SOCIAL, GOALS, A AND BE SOLUTION INDICATED BY 2 OF THE NITY AS PROBLEM AND WELL HAS DIFFERENT AS TO THE TO BE OF GENERAL ORGANIZATIONS MANAGER OF J. INTEREST INVOLVED 0. PENNEY IN TO THE STUDIES COMPANY. OOMMUOF 080 5 CBO LOCATION AND DESCRIPTION OF THE TOWN THE rOWN FOR ACTIVITIES EDGE OF OF THE FRAMINGHAM A SMALL BOSTON OF OF THE THE HAVEN, NORTH-SOUTH AROUND OF THE 9, THROUGH MAJOR COMMERCIAL THE AREA ABOUT TRANSPORTATION TOLL ROAD, COMPLETED THERE OF COULD SERVE HISTORIC, AS TOWN A IS CBD EASILY ZATION OF WESTERN BETWEEN THE IN THE OB: LINE OF THE BOSTON FREIGHT AND RAILROAD, STATE LINE THE THE AND OF THE NEW INTERSECTION 135 HIGHWAY ROUTE WITH INDICATED TURNPIKE, MILE NORTH THE IT HAVE IN CONCENTRATED THE WHICH OF (B ). MAP RUNS THE EAST-WEST CB0 IS MASSACHUSETTS FURTHER NORTH, NOW THE TURNPIKE, AND WILL BE YEAR. NUCLEUS AND PEDESTRIAN USE A A TOWN CIVIC, MOTIVE WAY THE OCCUR MAIN FACILITY. THIS AT ON AND WORCESTER. ACTIVITIES PARALLEL TO EXISTS GROUP THE RUNS WITHIN AS WORCESTER FRAMINGHAM HALF COMMERCIAL 126. ROUTE THE AREA, NORTH-SOUTH HARTFORD OF COMMUNITIES JUNCTIONS THE CENTER OF BOSTON MASSACHUSETTS JUNCTION ROUTE OF EAST-WEST AND EAST-WEST MOST A THE RAILROAD WITH NEW YORK, CITIES TRANSPORTATION INTERSECTION ALBANY GROUP THE METROPOLITAN MAJOR MASSACHUSETTS TWO IS ELEMENTS. AND OF A HALL, A TOWN COMMON, COMMERCIAL BUILDINGS, WITH A WHICH COMMUNITY. GRASPED CUSTOMERS VISUALLY, BECAUSE OF BOTH ITS BY THE CLOSE AUTOORGANI- MAs wuA -~~~~~~~ -T--(4-4Ak P HIa MA5AC5USTTS 2.HA- 90STO Lo1391 AAP 6.A - E-D. 5-rumLL meM Plaiw ..........--.... .... ....- IGkL'GROV CEMEERY\ XT AUBURNNAUBTRSST EDGEL GROE C-::.iAs ELL - WORESTRTEARYY 44 RDEENR S t;A3 AAELL Fd . AllW. | PToR CA T REW F 4or 1erf$ I. LEG LEVINE Q BEiRSA- OR R ) NER ooP 6 GENERAL CONSIDERATION FOR REDEVELOPMENT PLAN 2 I. POPULATION: IN VIEW OF PAST THAT MATED FROM 60 THUS THE THE PER PAGE 2. OVER TRADE WORLD, POPULATION RATES OF POPULATION CENT NEW SHOPPER'S GROWTH ESTIMATES AREA WOULD FIGURES CONTAIN ARE ELEVEN INDICATED IN ESTI- INCREASE INFLUENCE OF COMMUNITIES. THE GRAPH ON 8. INCOME: A RECENT STUDY OF FRAMINGHAM AREA THE $100 itOVER REGIONAL 41.7 WITH INCOME PER CENT INCOME" WEEKLY DISCLOSED IN MASSACHUSETTS. ITS IN FAMILIES THE THAT TO TOWN PER IN 27.4 CAPITA DATE. FAMILIES BRACKET WAS SECOND INCOME FOR FROM INCOME THE PROBABLY BE FOR 1948 INCREASED SHARP RISE ATTRIBUTED GROWTH IN THE QUANTITIVE FIGURES FROM MELVIN INCOME "EFFECTIVE THE TO TOWN THE PER STATE THIS PER INCOMEit HAS ONLY RESPECT CENT OF CENT QUALITY SHOWS RELATIVE WHOLE FROM VALUE WHILE DATA RISEN AS A IN FRAMINGHAM TO THIS IN CATEGORY. 1955, 63.5 IN 44.4 HAD BUYING THE THE ITS AREA FOR MASSACHUSETTS PERIOD. DENTIAL LATTER SAME INCOME PER CENT CAPITA THE ITSELF, PER CAPITA UP TO THE THAT OF TO THE WEALTHY WELLESLEY-BROOKLINE AREA 2 IS 1970. BY CONSIDERING THE AREA, IT POPULATION, THE 1955 THE WOULD OF 1948 INCREASED FRAMINGHAM PER OVER THE SAME INCOME LEVELS CAN OF NEW RESI- THE AREA. LISTED IN THIS SECTION WERE LEVINE'S M.C.P. THESIS, 1956. OBTAINED 7 Tr~*w 29 t~wsAvor ~ Mrniy~.. Izs DI ~*%.. '5OLTON $TO SLA.ee/ 9 I HUI ~OM .U .. i 1 I \1(4 0 I L0OE OZ4 or ~~-=-4 a AI It Iff-&I A .ru U PTO ( C AMTO K l.FO12 WA -,2 jr 1 12( f TAE AREA MAP' SCAL1 INhi L. 0 z o 6o 4 o FRAMINGHAM CBD QBD'e o NEARBY * SHOPPERSt WORLD MAJoR FRAMINGH|AM FUTURE T An 8 000 170, 130 140 10 l40o 4o so 4-0 20 0 194S l'rso lqC 19("06 19'T0 9 CBP, HOWEVER, 4. BENEFIT SUCH TO LAND USE: DIAGRAM ON PAGE AROUND THE CBD. PUBLIC OPEN EXCEPT FOR OF RECREATIONAL GENERAL TO AND ONLY PLAY THE AREA AS ORIENTED BE INCOME LOW GROUPS. USE THIS DEVELOPMENT TO THE THIS PLANNING RE-ROUTE FREIGHT THE HARTFORD RAILROAD AND THE PUBLIC OPEN INCORPORATED IN AREA FOR FACILITIES ARE SPACE OF OPEN GROUNDS. TOWN NEW HAVEN NEW YORK, POND FARM THE IS SCHOOL RECOMMENDING OF AND SOUTH SPACE: CATEGORY TRACKS TO AND 10 SHOWS APPROXIMATE LAND USE PATTERN GROUND IS INCOME HIGH COMMON BOARD 5. BOTH NORTH HAS AND GROUP TOWN THE FROM SHOPPERS TO MID-INCOME OF' LOW 3. DRAWS TO BE EAST SPACE. THE PLAN. CIRCULATION: 1949, 69 As OF BY AUTOMOBILE, 23 BY BUS. MOST WHICH TRADE NEW CBD, THE CREASE AT SINCE SING. PER OF WILL IF TRADE IS TO ESTIMATED 44 OF CENT ANALYSIS INCREASE OF THE ORIGIN IN 1949 TRAFFIC PER CENT IN AREAS OUTLYING CIRCULATION CAME FROM INCREASE CONVERGES AT A AT WITH ON RAILROAD THROUGH TRAFFIC OF AND 10 CAME WILL FROM IN- IN PROPORTION. TRAFFIC AUTOMOBILE INCREMENT BE AUTOMOTIVE DIRECTIONS, MEETING THE AND POPULATION COME WILL THE ANOTHER WAS PER THE CBD OF THE PATRONS CENT WALKED, OF SIX OF THE CENT VOLUME PRESENT, FROM PER 56 PER THE GRADE FROM CENT, DESTINATIONS DESTINATION DATA FROM CBD CROS- ONE AREA TO- LEAVING IN THE OBD. A SURVEY N Soo 1 1 iZoo 3Rvmwl===X 0 II MADE 1950 IN 53 ABOUT DESTINED THE PER CENT FOR THE ORIGIN AND MOST OF AUTOMOBILE FROM MAP SOUTH USING 16,725 THE WILL SHOPPERS WAS CENT THROUGH 1950 IN FOR A TWELVE- VEHICLES. ARRIVE BOSTON ALBANY THE WILL THE 08 IN FLOW CUSTOMERS 126 ROUTE INFLUENCE OF OF AREA 5 -) ON PAGE PER SURVEY CONDUCTED APPROXIMATELY NORTH-WEST EAST 6. DESTINATION WAS AREA 47 THEN CBD. PERIOD THE TRAFFIC THROUGH TOTAL, LEAVING THE OF HOUR FROM THE THAT AVERAGE DAILY THAT SHOWED DISCLOSES TO CBD AND RAILROAD FRAMINGHAM CENTER. AREA (SEE FROM NORTH- APPROACHING BECAUSE BE DEPRECIATED OF THE SHOPPER'S WORLD. PARKING: PRESENT i,168 PARKING PARKING TRAFFIC THEN. 3.5 TO IN FACILITIES FACILITIES CBD HAS THE OVER FOR 6 ,o0)CARS, ENOUGH 500,000 PROPORTION 5,200 PARKING RECOMMENDATION BLIGHTED AREA SHOPPING SHOPPERS, SPACE SQ. TO FT. ASSUMED REGIONAL 3,100, ESTIMATE, 20 PER CENT WHILE PARKING SINCE OF SELLING DEMAND INCREASE POPULATION AND IN WILL SPACES. WAS BOTH MADE BY MELVIN EAST DISTRICTS CREATING SYSTEM. BASIC AS PARKING RATIO I, ROUGH PARKING INCREASED A 1949 OF HAS IS THE SHORT ESTIMATED SHOPPERIS WORLD SPACE BE ARE AND AND SIMILAR LEVINE TO CLEAR WEST SIDE PROVIDE EFFECT ONE OF THE AREA BEHIND LEVEL PARKING TO SHOPPER'S WORLD FOR 12 7. THIS SYSTEM HAVE TO PING AREA. HAS DISADVANTAGE WALK QUITE (SOME DISCUSSION GRADE OF AND CROSSING BOSTON ALBANY SHOW CROSSES THE PER CREASE 5 EFFORTS FOR TO THE INTERSECTION OF HAVE BEEN DISTRIBUTION 66 AREA CROSSES OF THE AT THAT TRAVEL. 29 HAVE SHOPPERS RAILROAD SUMMATION AND CBD DISTANCE TO SINCE REACH TO 800 WALK THEY THE FEET.) SHOP5 ELIMINATION OF THE CONCORD AND STREET CONTINUALLY IN PROCESS 1895. SINCE DATA LONG SHOPPERS, CROSSING: RAILROAD THE A TO THE PER THE TRACKS; THROUGH RAILROAD TRACKS THROUGH CENT CROSSES OF CENT OF THE OF ORIGIN AND OF THE CBD TRACKS. TRAFFIC TRAFFIC IN THE COURSE TRAFFIC THE TOTAL DESTINATION IN THE ORIENTED AREA THE THE THEIR 93 PER TRAFFIC, PREDICTED SUGGESTS OF IN ONLY FUTURE ELIMINATION CROSSING. REFER TO MELVIN LEVINE'S THESIS, CBD MASTER PLAN. CENT INOF 13 DESIGN OBJECTIVES FOR GENERAL PLAN OF THE TOWN AS A WHOLE I. IMPROVE ACCESS IN MUNITIES FACILITIES, 2. REINFORCE 3. CLEAR 4. SEPARATE THAT THE TRADE PARKING, 5. PROVIDE ADEQUATE 6. MAINTAIN 7. PROVIDE MENTS TO OF FIRM THE A GENERAL RESIDENTIAL CHARACTER PEDESTRIAN, AREAS. CD. OF CBD, so THE AUTOMOBILE, AND BE CLEARED. 080. FOR OF THE CORE OF THE TOWN AND TRY CONDITION. ELEMENTS WITH AUTOMOBILE A THE SITUATION. TRAFFIC WITHIN OF PATTERS CHARACTER IMPROVE THE COPE ALL, TRANSPORTATION OF TRAFFIC IMPROVE PARK ING CREATE CONTRASTING TO 8. THE MEANS FROM NEARBY FORMS FOR CIRCULATION TO AND CONFLICTING SERVICE BY TRADE AREAS CIRCULATION AREA COM- ADJOINING FROM THE AREA AND CLEARED PEDESTRIAN BLIGHTED CBD TO THE SHORT 080 LAND TO BE USE SCALE RANGE THE IN TOWN CORE AND PEDESTRIAN PLAN FOR IMMEDIATE IMPLEMENTED WITHIN PLAN FOR THE CBD IN ORDER SCALE. IMPROVE- THE CONTEXT AREA. SOLUTIONS TO THE DESIGN OBJECTIVES 1. TRAFFIC SOUTH AS ON OF THE AUTHOR AND SYSTEM WILL THE PLAN WAY STREET THE CBD STREET HALL THE PLAN, BE ALL MAP IS FROM ELIMINATION CREATION WAY 15. ABOVE, IS AND TO THE BETTER OBJECTIVE BY MR. LEVINE THE No. 2, EXCEPT AROUND THE PEDESTRIAN CIRCULATION THEREFORE, UNDERPASS HAS TO BE CREATED BEHIND IN THE THE PEDESTRIAN BRIDGE ACCESS ON TO IS THE PEOPLE MET SPACESPOSSIBLY OF DOUBLE AND WEST OF THE SHOPPING MAP IN PAGE 15. CONFLICTING ON MAP IN OBJECTIVE PARKING PAGE 15, FORM 15, PAGE No. SPACES OF 5 IN BY CLOSER OF TO ONE IN DISTRICT, IS THE AP- THE TOWN ORDER TO RAILROAD TO DISTRICT. OF BAND PARKING AREA INDICATED SEPARATED ARE OF NORTH, AND BLIGHTED AS ONE DISTRICT. IN SOUTHERN LEVEL, TRAFFIC WHICH OVER THE 15, FROM INTRODUCING IS CAHRIED INSTEAD PAGE CONSTRUCTED IS No. IN CIRCULATION 3 OBJECTIVE MAP THAT PREFERY RESIDENTIAL BRING PEDESTRIAN REALIZED. WITH INDICATED THE SINCE CIRCULATION SOUTH AS THROUGH RAILROAD, BY AND HALL, OF PEDESTRIAN MALL ACCEPTED PLAN, SIMPLIFIED OF DOWN PAGE IN THIS SATISFIES PROPOSED BY THE ON GREATLY CONFLICTS AND STATED SYSTEM OUT NORTH GIVE 5. CARRIED INCORPORATED PEDESTRIAN 4. ON ALSO PROACHING 3. TOWN LEVINE'S CIRCULATION 2. IS CONCORD INDICATED MR. I No. OBJECTIVE AS EAST ON THE INDICATED SELF-EXPLANATORY. OUT THE LEVEL BY CBD PROVISION AREA, PARKING SHOWN OF ON SUGGESTED DOUBLE MAP BY IN U,! / II) ~~2W -~ II El 1j~i r I- C' 0 4 '4 -t 10 1. TOWN HALL 2. <H UC4 S. U1.S. PosT WFICE TOWN 4:0Mo THEATER 0'. q. ?AMW. IN0. 6. - A LANDfUSX WA HOTEL doICHEI5TU I.. . sTrTio, FUTUI PACK 16 MR. LEVINE, LEVEL THE UPPER THE SHOPPING VIDED AS INTO SERVICE WATER RATIO 4 : OF BE WILL DISTANCE HAS P-ULLED THE WHILE STREET, ONE TWO AREAS, OF THE PARKING THE HAS SYSTEM SERVICE LEVEL PARKING TOWN AREA TO PARKING THE AREA. 50 PER CENT NEXT TO THE WILL TO THIS AREA BE DI- BE USED IT. CONSIDERED; SALES OF BACK SHOPS THE DEPRECIATES I AT FIRST STAGE AND 2 : I CONSIDERING BEEN THE LEVEL LOWER TO BE MINIMIZED. TO TO CLOSER CLOSER CIRCULATION AND UNDERGROUND HIGH WALKING SINCE HOWEVER, APPROACH. WILL BE IN COMPLETE DEVELOPMENT, EXPANSION OF STORES TOWARDS 17 HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF J. C. PENNEY COMPANY, ESTABLISHED IN 1902 FORTY SMALLER CHAIN ARE YEARS AGRICULTURAL STORES SUBURBAN THE SPREAD 1,720 ABOUT J. C. AGO, PENNEY TOWNS IN IN ALL STORES IN THE STORES FAR WERE SINCE NEST. FORTY-EIGHT COMMUNITIES FOUND STATES, LARGE THEN AND AND IN NOW SMALL THESE THERE AND IN DEVELOPMENTS. UNIQUE FEATURES OF THE COMPANY'S OPERATION ARE AS FOLLOWS: I. A 2. 3. MANAGER, ASSISTANT FIFTEEN REGULAR EMPLOYEES DO MILLION DOLLARS A A THE COMPANY FOR CASH IT DOES YEAR NONE IN OF A A BUSINESS SMALL MAIL STAFF CITY ORDER OF OF OR PERHAPS SOME HALF A TOWN. BUSINESS BUT SELLS ONLY. NOT JEWELRY, HAS AND MANAGER, IMPULSE CARRY BUT MOSTLY DRY DECISION MAKING IS GOODS SOTT SUCH GOODS OF AND COSMETICS AS MIDDLE TO LOW PRICES. 4.. ALL BRANCH MANAGER MERCHANDISE TO CARRY RESPONSIBLE FOR FIXING, 5. A STORES. WITH OTHER FIGURE BELOW WORTH, RESULTING LITTLE REAL IS ESTATE MANAGERS CORRECTLY WHEN TO CARRY IT. BUDGET ON ADVERTISING, HE WHAT IS STORE RELOCATION. CHAIN PART OF EACH IN JUDGE AND AS OF TO PENNEY'S IN HANDS HAS AND FIXING REMODELING, COMPARED ON STORES, THE MOST HIGH PROFIT PER FROM A POLICY POSSIBLE. FIRM NOTEWORTHY DOLLAR OF OF NET OWING AS %OF EARNING PA ID EARNINGS % OF SALES EARN ING AS OF NET WORTH NET WORTH SEARS 500,489,000 22.o6 5.6 41.7 WARD 4L4,226,000 12.2 4.9 37.9 144,705,000 27.7 5.0 54.9 276,042,000 14.7 6.8 57.3 97,983,000 15.3 3.8 42.9 PENNEY WOOLWORTH ALLIED ST. 1946 - 1949 6. AMONG AND THE J. MISCELLANEOUS, REPORTED STORE DEPARTMENT C. COMPANIES, PENNEY COMPANY SALES STORES DEPT. CORP. H. MACY '4 5 FIELD IN MILLION 440 389 321 & CO. 291 GIMBEL BROS. MARSHALL TH E HIGHEST 417 STORES FEDERATED;DEPT.STORES R. HAS $950 J. C. PENNEY MAY ESPECIAL LY APPAREL FIGURE:5 SALES COMPANY ALLIED AVERAGE & 00. 225 101-132, FORTUNE MAGAZINE, SEPTEMBER 1950 ISSUE. FROM PAGE 338, TABLE 12, CHAIN STORES IN AMERICA, 1859 ROM 1950 PAGE BY GODFREY M. LEBH.AR, NEW YORK 1952 19 PROGRAM PRESENT SQ. FT. A. BASEMENT BASEMENT 3,000 SELL ING NONSELLING 270 To ILET FOR OEPT 30 ING i,196 STOCKROOM EX- HEAT- EQUIPMENT ROOM. 200 H & V MAIN IS ELIMINATED LAYAWAY B. NOTE PROPOSED SQ. FT. FLOOR 4,500 SELL I NG 12,500 NONSELLING LAYAWAY 350 TOILET 100 2,550 STOCKROOM LOAD I NG 70 200 PROV IS ION FOR 2 TRUCKS C. MEZZANINE SELL ING 810 4,150 270 450 NONSELLING OFFICE I MANAGER'S OF- F ICE 10,146 TOTAL D. PARKING REFER TO AREA ON LAND USE MAP OF OBD ON PAGE 15 B I SECRETARY I FILE ROOM 20,450 35,000 2:1 RATIO PARK- ING TO SELLING. THE PLAN DESCRIBED IN PREVIOUS SEOTION ON PARKING. 20 DESIGN OBJECTIVES FOR SITE SELECTION AFTER GENERAL IMPROVE- MENTS ARE MADE. 1. THE STORE MUST BE OTHER SPECIALTY SHOPS ALONG ORDER TO CRE.ATE BALANCE AND OF LOCATION STORE THE SUCH AS J. C. LOCATION SOUTH JORDAN OF END OF STREET. THE OF STORE PROPERLY THE MOVIE 3. C. LOW LOCATED FUNCTIONAL OTHER THE NEW 6 KELLEY, FROM CLOSER TO ROUTE TO FURTHER THE 9 THAT THE DEPRESSED END OF THE THE SHOP- ELEMENTS TO MUST INCOME ENHANCE AND MUST THE HOTELS, SPECIALTY STORE MIDDLE OF DEALS WITH MASS COMPANY, WHICH PENNEY SO AS COMMODATE PROPOSED SELLING INDICATES COMPANY DEPARTMENT STORE AT MARSH TO A WHOLE THEATERS, AND SHOPPERIS WORLD PROJECT J. FROM TOWN AS CATEGORY, STORE 6 OF PEOPLE AMONG OOMPANY, SHOULD BE CENTRALLY LOCATED. OF CUSTOMERS CIRCULATION PING THE IN DISTRICT. FAIR COMPETITION OFFER DEPARTMENT CHAIN PENNEY EXPERIENCE AT PAST 2. A OWNERS, SHOPPING THE TO RELATION IN CONSIDERED BE THE SUCH HAS TO SPACIAL GROUPED TOWN, BANKS 9 GROUP AS CHURCHES, BE QUALITY OF WITH OTHER RESTAURANTSs OPEN SPACES, SHOPS. BE LOCATED FIRST FLOOR ON SUCH A SITE AS TO ACSPACE WITH NO BASEMENT AREA. EUGENE PAGES J., 80-83 LOCATING CONTROLLED SHOPPING CENTERS, 21 SOLUTIONS TO DESIGN OBJECTIVES FOR SITE SELECTION. OBJECTIVES DISCUSSION WITH MANAGER SETTS, OF THE WHO POTENTIAL IS OF THE CATE THE TAKING THE STORE PART OF STORES ALONG THE OF THE THE TO THE B) FRONTAGE VALUE SITE IS THE SITE IS LOCATED BY ARE PRESENT RIGHT DEPRESSING IN IN THE THE IN PEDESTRIAN CATED OF HABITS, FEET IT HOWARD AND BUYING FRONTAGE WAS AND AGREED OFFERS TO CONCORD AND DEMOLISHING ADVANTAGES LOCATED. PER FOOT, RELO- STREETS, SMALL OF THIS RELOCATION SEE MAP INSTEAD ON PAGE OF 22. |14.00 LOCATION. THEATERS, THE BE RELOCATED NEW 45 OPPOSITE TO EXISTING WOULD THE WITH STREET THE CHURCH, THE FOR BOWIE, THE THE TOWN COMMON STORES, AND CHAIN PUBLIC NUCLEUS OF AND STORES9 BUILDINGS. THE TOWN. (SEE 22.) PAGE CLOSED L. DANA THE AREA. OTHER DEPARTMENT LOCATED VISUALLY NEEDS, OF $17.00 is THE ON THE CENTRALLY AT RESTAURANTS, D) AND FOOT MAP AFTER STREET. PER IS MR. OUT AS FOLLOWS: THE IT CARRIED EXPANSION, HOWARD FOR THE CORNER SAME STORE ARE ARE CLIENT, SITE FUTURE THE THE SURROUNDED IN PRESENT A) C) WITH PUBLIC REASONS NEW AUTHOR'S FAMILIAR OF 3 AND C. PENNEY COMPANY OF FRAMINGHAM, MASSACHU- J. EVEN THOUGH POSSIBILITY I, 2, Nos. STORE TOWN. NEW SMALL STORES EVENT THAT CONCORD CIRCULATION; AND HOWARD LAND USE WILL ENHANCE MAP THE ALONG HOWARD STREET STREET PARKING FACILITIES STREET CLOSED, ON PAGE VISUAL 22. IS AS INDI- THEREFORE, QUALITY OF THE CORE E K f N P A ISO.# in- 52. *, 52 I4OTEL K' I-i-A rzx I~i !AI~K - '1 1THEATEE .i '9' -~ s 2 tf "~ '9 'I - THE ATKI. ' 'F~41- 5..s. -A. n9t.- .D 7s 5 ml ATE TO0 -- - (,0MMON 2 -4 -p /A -A 0 - V2~A E P WOOL WOR.'T 4 V '53 rlI L CH . -LP 7 - ~ z4,~~AL4- I5T'3 S 1- T E 57'LP 23 DESIGN OBJECTIVES FOR THE STORE I. 2. 3. CREATE SELLING SPACE VOLUME, AND 6. BUYING MERCHANDISE. ADJUSTABLE TO SEASONS, BE TO BE DURABLE AND IN CONTROL MEANS ENHANCE FUNCTIONAL QUALITIES MEANING ORDER RELATE RACKS ON VERTICAL AND CEILING SCULPTURAL TO MERCHANDISE THE COMMUNICATION SYSTEMS WALL ABOVE COMPETE WITH SHOE TO SPACES. THEM TO FALSE EQUIPMENTS. OF EACH ELEMENT. TO STRUCTURE. AS THE AND STORE THE AS MUCH HAS IF POS- POSSIBLE ON ONE OR EXCEPT DECORATION TO TIE FIRST MEZZANINE VISION HAS TO SYSTEM BE CUSTOMERS t AND CREATED SUCH AS EIGHT FEET, MEANS LETTERING FROM MERCHANDISE, OR BY IN POSSIBLY ORDER MOVE- NOT OF AND ALONG TO MERCHANDISE DISPLAY. DEPARTMENT LET AWAY SEVEN INTIMATE CUSTOMERS1 BEHIND PIPING IN SYSTEM ELEMENTS CUSTOMERS1 MENT OPEN AND AND TOGETHER. TO BLE OF MINIMUM ACCESS CREATE HIDDEN DUCT EXPOSED EASY THE SALES TABLES. HAVE TWO PROVIDE BE ECONOMICAL THAN THESE ELEMENTS OR TO INTERIOR TO SHOULD MERCHANDISE RATHER MECHANICAL OF THE TRENDS. CEILING COLORING 8. OF ITS NONVERBAL 7. TO FOR DISPLAY EXPRESS OPEN 5. SPACES HAS STRUCTURE HAS SIBLE, 4. FLEXIBLE FLOW STAY SPACES THIS FOR CUSTOMERS IS PARTICULARLY AND CHILDRENtS HAS TO IN THE BE IMPORTANT FLEXITO DEPARTMENT. CONTROLLED STORE WELL AS AS AS LONG AS AS SUCH IN ORDER POSSIBLE. PREFERRED PORTION 9. OF LET THEM TOWARDS STORE IS PASS THEM FRONT TO LET SIDE HAS TO THEM AREA SELLING THE THAN OF 10. FLOW THROUGH MOVE THE CENTER SIDE AISLES RATHER OENTER AISLES AND FROM THE TOWARDS DIRECT AISLES. BE DESIGNED SO AS TO GIVE SUGGESTION OPENNESS. STORAGE CHAIN SPACES STORE. ARE KEPT IN MINIMUM FOR THIS TYPE OF 25 k ( 4 4, .4' 4 Y ' 4. 4 £ A~ A J1IL~.'E I' liii! HIlL U I~L&. I Polo- / -:. ' 4. 4 26 SOLUTION TO DESIGN OBJECTIVES FOR THE STORE I. COLUMN-FREE PORTION 2. OF CONCRETE ING SPACES WAS THE SELECTED SYSTEMS THE AIR IS AND IN SHOWCASES AND OF SKETCH ON 6. IBID. 7. IBID. 8. OBJECTIVE FINAL DRAW- SPACE DUCT FOR WORK. CONCRETE CEILING, WI rH DUCT THE WORK, STRUCTURAL 0 PEN I NGS INDICATED, META PAGE ON TA BLE S ARE PAGE AND SYSTEM 27. DUCT WORK . CASEMENTS. CIRCI ILATION AIR SPRINKLER DIAGRAM IS ALSO 27. DESIGNED FOR MAXIMUM MERCHANDISE. DRAWINGS PAGE No. ON INTERIOR ED OUT DECORATION AND 28. 8 IS CARRI ENTRY TION MERCHANDISE, GOODS. THE I )RAWING ON DRAWING TROLLED OF THE THE IN US ING DISPLAY FINAL TO REFER THE AT BOTH EN DS A REQUIREMENTS. TOG ETH ER WITHOUT IN CONDITIONING ON AND SPACE. AIR C OND ITION ING THE MEZZANINE PROVIDE ADEQUATE AIR THE VENTILATING INDICATED EXHIBIT 5. THROUGH THE INDICATED REQUIRED INDICATED SIMPLIFIED HEATING 4. AS ON SELLING TO AND IS COMBINED ROOF PASSES ORDER SATISFY WIRING, ARE FLOOR PIPING WOULD ELECTRICAL OF OF INTRODUCED SYSTEM IN FIREPROOFING STRUCTURE 3. FIRST STRUCTURAL INSTALLMENT SINCE ARE OF IMP ULSE, BY THE PROVIDING SINGLE STORE DISTRIBU- AND CONVENIENCE, AND CON- DEMAND 27 F1'TUEES VII MTOIJ SYZ T. DUC.T NO7LK- WARJ4 AMt A..40Pw 4A PLAN4 N I 19AN gOI suic'rou. AA. -A dm d"4,03orhia I1 co C'j -oil I I, 11>"'.*. 22-' 11 1 4 I N 'N 29 9. THE OF FRONT SYSTEM, AS THE INDICATED FACADE FACES PROV IDED TO MEET IN DESIGNED THE FINAL WITH AND GLASS DRAWINGS. SINCE SUN CONTROL CONSIDERATION THE FOLLOWING LOUVER THE IS ALSO 6 7 REQUIREMENTS 1 2 3 4 5 AZIMUTH 380sw 620sw 77.5 0 sw 88-5 0 sw 84w 18Ow 67.50 58.50 480 360 250 150 150 SW 29 0 sw 41.5 0 SW 52.5 0 sw ALTITUDE 230 180 STORAGE SPACE ALTITUTE DECEMBER IN ORDER IS FREE TO SOLUTIONS OTHER 11.50 RESTRICTED THE PERTAINING THE SURROUNDING BUILDING ROOF OTHER HEIGHT STRUCTURE BUILDINGS FUNCTIONAL PORTION TO GENERAL BUILDINGS ARE OBTAINED LINES SIMILAR THE AREA RATHER THE STORE OBJECTIVES: NEW STORE FLOOR OF AREA. THE SHOWS MEANING ONE OF AND IN SUNSET TO SELLING COHERENCE CHARACTERISTICS OF P.M. 22: AzIMUTH A) WEST, IS 22: JUNE 10. STORE OF THAN BY ADJACENT EFFECT OF EXCEPT WITH THE USE REST OF BUILDINGS. CORNICE LINES THIS WILL ALSO MERE DECORATIVE OF GIVE EXPRES- S ION. CANOPIES AS B) TO ARE APPLIED FOR SUN CREATE CONTINUITY ALONG BETWEEN THE WALKWAY IS NEW STORE ESTABLISHED AND TO CONTROL THE SHOPPING GILCHRISTtS TIE PURPOSES AS WELL STREET. STORE, PEDESTRIAN THE PARKING AREA UNIVERSAL SUN CHART, ARCHITECTURAL EDITION, NEW YORK, 1956. GRAPHIC STANDARD, AND CENTRAL MALL. 7 FIFTH 30 C) PLANTED ON AREA SECOND IS PROVIDED FLOOR PARKING TRANSITION BETWEEN ZONE D) AND PEDESTRIAN STRUCTURAL ENTER THE HIGH AT THE LEVEL EASTERN IN TO OF THE STORE CREATE A SPEED AUTOMOTIVE CIRCULATION ZONE. SYSTEM GIVES DIRECTION STORE. ORDER END TO SHOPPERS AS THEY 31 B IBL IOGRAPHY DESIGN FOR NEW MERCHANDISING. MODERN F. YORK: W. DODGE RECORD. ARCHITECTURAL CORPORATION, 1954, Pp. 7-30. FRAMINGHAM YOUR T OWN YOUR PROBLEM. PUBLISHED BY PLANNING STUDENTS IN THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF DESIGN, HARVARD CAMBRIDGE, 1948 UNIVERSITY. GIEDION, SIGFRIED, SPACE, TIME AND CAMBRIDGE, ARCHITECTURE. 1956,~PP. 232KELLEY, EUGENE, REGIONAL TRAFFIC SHOPPING CENTERS. CONTROL. CENTERS; THE ENO LOCATING FOUNDATION CONNECTICUT, KETCHUM, MORRIS, SHOPS AND STORES. CORPORATION, N.Y., 19L3. CONTROLLED FOR HIGHWAY 1956 REINHOLD PUBLISHING KRAUSE, BENJAMIN L., A DEPARTMENT STORE FOR GRAND RAPIDS, MICHIGAN. ARCHITECTURAL THESIS, M. I. T., 1939 M., CHAIN STORES IN AMERICA, 1859 - 1950, PUBLISNING CORPORATION, NEW YORK, 1951. LEBHAR, GODFREY, CHAIN STORE LEVINE, MELVI N F., A REDEVELOPMENT PLAN FOR THE FRAMINGHAM CENTRAL BUSINESS DISTRICT. M.C.P. THESIS, M . I. T., AUGUST, 1956. ORGANIZATION AND OPERATION OF BRANCH STORES, DRY GOODS ASSOCIATION, NEW YORK, 1952. "PENNEY'S, PP. RAMSEY KING B. ZAR THE SOFT GOODS", FORTUNE RETAIL (SEPTEMBER 1950) 101-132. AND SLEEPER. EDITION, TURNER, OF NATIONAL NEW JUDITH, ARCH. INA-HANER, STREET, ARCHITECTURAL YORK, ASTRA, STANDARD, FIFTH 1956. DECENTRALIZATION OF THE DEPARTMENT STORE, 194d. THESIS, BOSTON. GRAPHIC A LADIES APPAREL SHOP ON BOYLSTON M. ARCH. THESIS, M. I. T., 1955