Program Director Self-Study Report For Program: MASTER OF SCIENCE IN VOCATIONAL REHABILITATION (MSVR) Submitted by Program Directors: MICHELLE HAMILTON (CAMPUS) AND DELEANA STROHL (ONLINE) Year: 2013-14 Planning and Review Committee PREAMBLE TO MSVR PROGRAM The MSVR program is based on a cohort-model. Within this model, students are admitted to the program once yearly in the fall and the cohorts typically proceed through sequenced coursework together graduating at the same time. The 48-credit MSVR program offers two distinct full-time learning cohorts: 1. A 2-year campus-based learning cohort offering two concentration options: Rehabilitation Counseling – 48-credit CORE accredited RCE Dual concentration in Vocational Evaluation and Rehabilitation Counseling (Dual VE/RC) – 50-credit CORE accredited RCE 2. A 3-year online learning cohort (asynchronous delivery) offering one concentration option: Rehabilitation Counseling – 48-credit CORE accredited RCE. MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 1 1. UW-STOUT’S STRATEGIC PLAN 1.1 UW-Stout's Strategic Plan: 1.1.1 Describe early and ongoing experiential learning opportunities to students within the program. Experiential learning opportunities are a significant strength for the MSVR program. Since the 2006-07 PRC, the program has added a 100-hour supervised practicum to the rehabilitation counseling concentration. The addition of the supervised counseling practicum provides rehabilitation counseling students with an earlier opportunity for applied learning and ensures equivalency of skill development between the campus concentrations and between the online and campus cohorts. At program completion students will have acquired over 700 hours of supervised site-based experiential learning. As an accredited competency-based program, MSVR curriculum follows a prescribed sequence of coursework ensuring students initially gain foundational knowledge and competencies that predict skillful application of learning content within community client-based settings. Within first-year coursework, students in both cohorts are offered multiple service learning opportunities to explore, interview, observe and report on various aspects of the rehabilitation profession. For instance, the first class in the program requires students to interview a person with a disability and a working rehabilitation professional; students conduct an accessibility survey of a community building using Americans with Disabilities (ADA) guidelines; and students explore professional community resources such as Workforce Resource Centers, Centers for Independent Living, and Community-based Rehabilitation Programs. Mid-program, students enroll in lab-based pre-practicum type experiences which offer supervised individual and group counseling skill-building opportunities with peers and limited access to community members. Pre-practicum experiences and evaluation ensure students possess minimal knowledge and behavioral competencies to meet professional role functioning required in advanced practicum and internship. During the final year in the MSVR program, students enroll in 12-16 graduate credits of sitebased experiential learning opportunities which include: practicum (3-5 credits) and internship (10 credits) earning a minimum of 700 hours supervised site-based experiential learning. 1.1.2 Describe program initiatives employed to support and/or increase student enrollment, retention and graduation rates? The program conducts a variety of recruitment efforts. For example, the program web page is continually revised with updated information, and new videos have been added that include testimonials from current students and alumni working as rehabilitation professionals. Program directors continue to collaborate with institutional supports such as the Graduate School, Provost’s Office, Stout Online and Marketing to develop materials, plan recruitment activities MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 2 and expand dissemination of same. Efforts to use social media such as Facebook, linking program information from accreditation and professional organization websites and online graduate school portals such as Gradschools.com increase overall exposure to program information. Yearly targeted recruitment efforts include the electronic dissemination of program materials sent to over 1,500 supervisors and service personnel in state-federal VR offices and community rehabilitation programs. Yearly email blasts are sent to over 2000+ undergraduate seniors from complementary undergraduate programs at other UW-institutions. Targeted yearly recruitment includes direct efforts at UW-Eau Claire, UW-River Falls and UW-Stevens Point programs in communication disorders. Internal campus recruitment efforts include participating in career fairs, guest-speaking opportunities within undergraduate classes and relevant student organizations such as the Psychology club. Activities focused on recruiting individuals from diverse ethnic groups have included purchasing advertisements in the conference packet for the annual conference of the National Association of Multicultural Rehabilitation Concerns (NAMRC) and recruitment/exhibit booth at the Consortia of Administrators for Native American Rehabilitation (CANAR). Student interest in the MSVR degree is significantly enhanced by accreditation through the Council on Rehabilitation Education (CORE), continued ranking within the top 10 rehabilitation counseling programs in the USA as well as the online asynchronous cohort option. Maintaining strong collaborative relationships with program alumni, satisfied employers and advisory board members promotes ongoing word-of-mouth recruitment. Over this 7-year PRC period, total yearly student enrollment between both cohorts ranged from a high of 85 to a low of 69; an average of 80 students were enrolled in the program at any given point. A slight 15-18% enrollment decline over the past two years mirrors national and campuswide enrollment trends in graduate programs particularly impacting campus-based programs. Poor economic conditions, demographic shifts, as well as an increase in the number of postsecondary competitors most notably the proliferation of online degree opportunities contribute to lower enrollments. Additional factors influencing enrollments specific to MSVR program include decreased funding from Rehabilitation Services Administration (RSA) and an increase in the number of online programs offering rehabilitation counseling degrees. Internally, enrollment in the campus cohort experiences some siphoning-effect as a consequence of offering parallel online delivery. Strong graduation and retention rates are a hallmark of the MSVR program. Program completion time varies by cohort where campus students typically graduate in two years and online students typically graduate in three years. The table below summarizes admission, retention and graduation rates of MSVR students admitted between 2007-2011. MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 3 Year 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 Cohort Admitted N= Graduated N= Graduation Rate Actual Anticipated (on track) campus 13 13 100% N/A online 12 12 100% N/A campus 17 17 100% N/A online 12 12 100% N/A campus 17 16 94% 100% online 19 17 89% 100% campus 11 9 82% 82% online 18 15 83% 100% campus 16 15 94% 100% online 16 87% 1.1.3 Describe, provide examples and explain how the program intentionally integrates diversity efforts, functions and contributes to the program in support of Inclusive Excellence: “UW-Stout’s plan to intentionally integrate diversity efforts into the core aspects of everything we do. Diversity is broadly defined and includes, but is not limited to, race/ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, age and disability status.” The MSVR program supports and contributes to Inclusive Excellence at UW-Stout in multiple ways. On average, 20-25% of students in the MSVR program are students with disabilities. The program, faculty and students promote disability awareness, inclusion, social justice and equitable learning environments for all students. Between academic years 2007-08 and 2012-13, approximately 10% of MSVR students identified with a racial minority group. Traditional and nontraditional students are well represented in the MSVR program where campus students average 28 years of age and online students average 39 years of age. Gender representation in the program is approximately 15% males and 85% females which emulates the larger female dominated profession. MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 4 1.1.4 Describe environmental sustainability initiatives embedded and supported by the program: “UW-Stout’s attempt to make students, faculty, and staff more aware of the importance of sustaining our environment through energy conservation, waste reduction, and other measures that will not bring harm to the environment, and to provide students with innovative research opportunities in these areas.” The MSVR program strives to uphold practices consistent with UW-Stout’s overall sustainability plan. Administrative and instructional efficiencies have increased through digitized recordkeeping and online delivery methods using lecture capture methods such as Tegrity. Computerized labs, software and ubiquitous Wi-Fi access significantly reduce reliance on natural resources. We encourage responsible sustainable practices on the part of our students and promote the concepts of reduce, reuse and recycle at school, home and in the community. 2. DESCRIPTION OF THE PROGRAM 2.1 Curriculum Design 2.1.1 State the approved program objectives. The MSVR program is designed to prepare qualified professionals in the field of Vocational Rehabilitation. Accreditation requirements and evidence-based role and function studies largely drive expected outcome objectives. The program offers two concentration options to students providing specialized rehabilitation counseling services and/or vocational evaluation services to persons with disabilities. Upon successful completion of the program each student will: 1. 2. Develop and demonstrate an identity as a rehabilitation professional. Integrate rehabilitation philosophy and principles of independence, integration, choice, self-determination, empowerment, access and respect for individual differences into rehabilitation planning and service provision. 3. Promote the inclusion of persons with disabilities in employment and/or the community. 4. Demonstrate ethical behavior and ethical problem-solving consistent with the code of ethics for rehabilitation professionals. 5. Understand disability-related legislation, public policy, and attitudinal and access barriers affecting persons with disabilities and their families. 6. Understand the influences and implications of chronic illness and/or disability across human development and lifespan. 7. Identify the functional impacts of chronic illness and/or disability. 8. Evaluate environmental, social and economic influences that create barriers for persons with disabilities. 9. Examine psychosocial, cultural and diversity issues that may affect the rehabilitation process. 10. Establish positive, productive relationships. 11. Communicate effectively with persons with disabilities, families, and other rehabilitation professionals. MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 5 12. Select and apply counseling techniques to promote informed vocational decision-making and adjustment to chronic illness or disability. 13. Conduct and integrate vocational assessment into rehabilitation planning. 14. Analyze jobs, employment trends and career opportunities to assist in rehabilitation planning and service provision. 15. Identify community resources and other services which promote independence. 16. Plan and coordinate effective rehabilitation services designed to help persons with disabilities reach their vocational potential. 17. Apply research findings to improve services to persons with disabilities. Additional objectives for students in the Dual Concentration in Vocational Evaluation and Rehabilitation Counseling prepare each student to: 1. 2. 3. Understand the vocational evaluation process and the role of vocational evaluators in assisting persons with disabilities reach their vocational potential. Use work-related activities (real or simulated work) and principles of behavior observation to facilitate client vocational decision-making. Acquire practical experience in vocational evaluation through practicum and internships in approved sites. 2.1.2 Describe processes and initiatives employed in determining the need for program revision? Multiple factors inform and guide MSVR program and curriculum revision. CORE accreditation standards and evidenced-based role and function studies are the foundation upon which the MSVR curriculum is based. Other primary sources that inform program decisionmaking include: feedback from employers, program graduates, program advisory committee and faculty; internal and external program assessment measures such as program comprehensive exam and certification examination pass-rates, Assessment in the Major (AIM), Program Review Committee (PRC), results of Midpoint student review, site-supervisor evaluations and intern critical analysis of MSVR program. Criticisms of the program curriculum largely echo the professional landscape where ongoing tension exists between the public and private sector rehabilitation applications, as well within group inconsistencies regarding professional identity (i.e., counseling subspecialty versus a unique profession). As evidenced later in this document, consistently strong preparedness ratings from employers and graduates demonstrate the MSVR program provides a solid common core of professional competencies for application in a wide variety of rehabilitation employment settings. The most recent program revision approved by the University in 2012 was the result of a comprehensive two-year departmental curriculum review process. All MSVR courses and learning objectives were mapped onto new CORE accreditation standards to identify gaps, reduce overlap and ensure equivalency between campus and online learning cohorts. In total, the program revision included revised program objectives, five course revisions and the MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 6 development of two new online courses and the addition of one course to the campus program plan, and minor changes to the student midpoint review. 2.1.3 Check all that apply regarding the program: X Traditional, on campus program X Online program 2.1.4 Briefly describe the components of your program where students participate in scholarly activity such as: research, scholarship, experiential learning and creative endeavor. “Programs are presented through an approach to learning which involves combining theory, practice and experimentation” (UW-Stout’s Mission Statement) The MSVR program engages students in a variety of scholarly activities. The program is anchored in a scientist-practitioner model where students learn to be consumers of empirical evidenced-based research which is used to generate questions, ideas and solutions to problems faced by persons with disabilities. Students are actively involved in classroom research and scholarship opportunities as well as professional knowledge translation/transfer (KT) opportunities at local, regional and national training conferences (National Rehabilitation Association, 2013; Wisconsin Rehabilitation Association, 2009-2013; Stout VR Conference 2008; 2010; 2012). Students in the online cohort combine research, scholarship and knowledge transfer by preparing and delivering ‘in-service’ presentations to local disability agencies; over 100 agencies have benefitted from in-service presentations since 2007. Applied classes such as Psychological Testing and Applied Vocational Assessment and Evaluation require students to research psychometric properties of testing instruments using the Mental Measurement Yearbooks (MMY) and Tests in Print (TIP) and apply learning to clinical practice in the selection, administration and interpretation of psychological tests. Case Coordination class uses client-based case studies to teach students to use research to find resources to apply to problems in an effort to develop individualized services and solutions. Later in the program, direct and indirect supervision methods are used as a means to promote integration and experimentation in clinical practice where students are required to demonstrate professional competencies and ethical work behaviors. As a thesis-option program, graduate students can choose between two options to apply research skills to meet graduate research expectations. The traditional thesis option requires students to take a 4-credit Research Foundations class providing research knowledge and competencies necessary to complete the 2-credit plan B thesis. The second option, referred to as the comprehensive exam option, allows students to choose from among four 700 level research course offerings: Research in Rehabilitation and Counseling, Program Evaluation, Research in Psychotherapy or Research Foundations. Each research course corresponds to one of four versions of the MSVR comprehensive exam. Research skills and knowledge acquired in coursework and applied on MSVR comprehensive exam satisfy the graduate research requirement. All research courses focus on teaching students how to evaluate and use research to think critically, generate questions, ideas and solutions in relationship to problems faced by persons with disabilities and the larger VR profession. MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 7 2.1.5 Does your program currently have an accreditation or certification agency that reviews the program? If so, which agency and to what extent does it influence the structure of the curriculum? Yes. Since 1995 the MSVR rehabilitation counseling concentration (RCE) has been accredited by CORE. As a competency-based pre-professional program, accreditation standards wholly influence the structure of the curriculum ensuring program graduates meet/exceed coursework and competencies necessary for professional practice, certification or licensure. In July 2013, the MSVR program successfully obtained the maximum 8-year full accreditation by CORE. Increasingly prescriptive accreditation standards result in zero flexibility for any elective coursework within the 48-credit curriculum. A shifting professional landscape sees strong movement toward 60-credit degree programs. To meet future accreditation and licensure requirements, the MSVR program anticipates the need to revise the curriculum to 60 credits in the near future. 2.2 Faculty/Academic Staff Expertise 2.2.1 List key instructors in the program. A key instructor is one who teaches at least one required professional course in your program (this should be the combined faculty of Key A and Key B who were surveyed by the PRC). Instructor (combined key A & B) Degree Courses Taught Julie Bates Ph.D. Coun 750; Coun 752; Coun 788 Kathleen Deery (core faculty) Ph.D. Rehab 620; Rehab 714; Rehab 715; Rehab 717 David DeLambo (core faculty) Rh.D. Rehab 787 Susie Eberhard (core faculty) Ph.D. Rehab 714; Rehab 764 Debra Homa (core faculty) Ph.D. Rehab 701; Rehab 704; Rehab 708; Rehab 723; Rehab 783 Michelle Hamilton (core faculty) Ph.D. Rehab 620; Rehab 713; Rehab 723; Rehab 724; Coun 788 Casey Lubinsky M.S. Rehab 707; Rehab 708; Rehab 783; Rehab 787 John Lui Ph.D. Rehab 764 Kara James M.S. Rehab 783; Rehab 787 Daniel Kelsey (core faculty) (.50 FTE MSVR; .50 CMHC) Ph.D. Rehab 701; Rehab 715 MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 8 Robert Peters (core faculty) Ph.D. Rehab 701; Rehab 787 Stephen Shumate Ph.D. Coun 750; Coun 788 DeLeana Strohl (core faculty) Ph.D. Rehab 704; Rehab 708; Rehab 764 2.2.2 What additional faculty/academic staff expertise is needed? In theory, the program possesses the faculty expertise to deliver the MSVR curriculum. However, in application the program is significantly constrained by two faculty FTE positions which are not ‘available’ due to ongoing extenuating circumstances (long-term administrative secondment; medical leave; grant release). These extenuating circumstances require the program use adjunct instructors to fill behind the 2.00 unavailable faculty FTE. Qualified terminallydegreed graduate level adjunct instructors are not readily available for hire. Further reducing instructional flexibility in the graduate program is the fact that all MSVR core faculty have teaching responsibilities in the undergraduate BSVR program (N=275) housed with the Department. Increasing instructional pressures on all VR faculty are certain to continue in the near future. The already large, well-enrolled BSVR program is positioned to launch a new stand-alone major in criminal justice in fall 2014; large enrollments are anticipated. Further exacerbating the adjunct-hiring challenges are the abundance of applied lecture/laboratory classes within the MS and BS VR curriculum which result in scheduling classes over multiple days each week to meet 5-6 hours/week of face-to-face instructional time. Specialized equipment and resources necessitate scheduling lab classes in designated laboratory space further limited by physical capacity due to room design and inflexibility of current lab furnishings which do not allow optimization of available space. 2.3 Facilities 2.3.1 Describe the facilities and or capital equipment currently used and how it supports or strengthens the program. What program specific facilities (unique classrooms, labs, additional space involving minor construction) have been requested and provided? The MSVR program (campus cohort) relies extensively on two specialized laboratories located in the Vocational Rehabilitation (VR) building: Shirley K. Stewart Vocational Evaluation Laboratory (VR310) and the Clinical Services Laboratory (VR220). Both laboratories are critical resources necessary to meet program learning outcomes and CORE accreditation requirements. The Department maintains the Shirley K. Stewart Vocational Evaluation Lab (VR310) to facilitate student learning of in-depth analysis of vocational rehabilitation processes and vocational evaluation techniques consistent with the program’s hands-on, minds-on philosophy. Four core graduate courses utilize the lab as an integral part of applied learning: Psychological Testing, Occupational Analysis and Job Placement, Procedures of Vocational Evaluation, and MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 9 Applied Vocational Assessment. Additional courses in the graduate and undergraduate program are also scheduled in the VR310 lab as multiple classes require students to use specific lab equipment or resources to complete assignments. Due to copyright and licensure requirements of lab instruments, the Department must offer weekly open laboratory hours with graduate assistant support to facilitate student access to lab resources. The VR310 Lab houses over 200 different assessment instruments along with multiple professional handbooks and textbooks, and many assessment manuals specific to the vocational rehabilitation process. Computers are used extensively in lab-based classroom assignments. They are most often used for hands-on assessment activities requiring the installation of specialized licensed assessment software that cannot be downloaded or copied to a student computer. Multiple lab printers are essential as many lab assignments require immediate access to printed computerized assessment results or occupational information. Maintaining an updated lab is vital to promote professional skill development of MSVR students. Since the 2006-07 PRC, one lab modification and two additional requests for equipment were funded by the College of Education, Health and Human Sciences (CEHHS) totaling approximately $29,903 to support continued lab improvements. The financial support successfully assisted in updating electronic equipment necessary to ensure high quality of instructional delivery in the classroom. Despite current professional equipment, the aged furnishings (half circa 1970; half circa 1990) contribute to ongoing student perceptions that the lab itself is outdated. In addition, most lab furnishings are inconsistent with the ergonomic approach promoted by the curriculum and professional rehabilitation applications. An internal catch-22 exists for the VR310 Laboratory, in that, needed updates to physical space and furnishings do not fall within existing criteria for either lab modification or classroom update funding. The Clinical Services Laboratory (VR220) is an essential laboratory resource in the development of student counseling competencies and clinical supervision as required by CORE accreditation. VR220 is a shared laboratory resource among multiple graduate counseling-related programs. The Clinical Mental Health Counseling (CMHC) program in our Department oversees five rooms within the Clinical Services area. The primary function of laboratory space is to provide supervised experience in the development and practical application of basic counseling skills, assessment procedures and administration, and supervised clinical work with children and families. Through observed laboratory practice and work with clients, students use basic and advanced counseling skills to develop effective therapeutic relationships and clinical competencies. In the MSVR program, one core course offered twice per year relies exclusively on the VR220 Laboratory; two additional core courses also utilize the lab for counseling-related applications such as recording client interviews and assessment feedback sessions. The VR220 Laboratory experiences chronic equipment failure as a result of aged audio and video equipment. Ongoing equipment failure leads to significant student and faculty frustration and reduced clinical supervision opportunities due to poor recording quality or total failure to record. Since the last program review, limited improvements have been implemented all of which have been reactive but failed to provide any sustainable resolution or recommendations for state-of-the-art equipment to meet instructional needs. The MSVR program fully supports the MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 10 CMHC’s request for an immediate and comprehensive upgrade to the audio and visual recording equipment in the VR220 Lab. 2.3.2 What added facility needs (if any) such as unique classrooms, labs, additional space involving minor construction exist in the program? The Shirley K. Stewart Vocational Evaluation Lab (VR310) is in need of portable and adjustable classroom furniture suitable for the increasingly diverse class needs of the laboratory. Current courses require unique furniture configurations more conducive to counseling applications, team and small group work. The current laboratory furnishings are stationary, rendering one side of the laboratory a classroom style configuration, while the other side is restricted to heavy (immovable) 35” standing height tables (circa 1970). The laboratory needs modular and heightadjustable tables, allowing greater flexibility in classroom configuration. The majority of classes scheduled in the lab are 90-180 minutes. Most of the chairs are hard plastic stacking chairs which are uncomfortable for extended periods of static positioning and inconsistent with ergonomic considerations promoted by program and rehabilitation profession. Modern chairs and tables designed for flexibility are needed to provide an environment enhancing student learning in team and small group work, as well as experiential counseling applications within the classroom. As noted above, the VR220 Laboratory experiences chronic equipment failure as a result of aged audio and video equipment. The MSVR program fully supports the CMHC’s request for an immediate and comprehensive upgrade to the audio and visual recording equipment in VR220 Lab. In addition, programs with specialized laboratories would benefit from additional support and services from Learning Technology Services (LTS). Limited staff resources within LTS are not adequate to meet specialized laboratories housed within a Polytechnic environment. We advocate on behalf of LTS for increased staff allocations to help meet the instructional needs of multiple programs across campus who rely on specialized laboratory equipment. In particular, LTS would benefit from additional experts who can provide proactive consultation and research to help faculty meet instructional needs and additional equipment specialists to provide responsive, timely and proactive monitoring and maintenance of specialized laboratory equipment. 2.4 Resources for the Program 2.4.1 Evaluate the quality, relevance, and quantity of the library resources to support the program. Include a brief statement as to how these needs have been met by the library. The library facilities are adequate to meet the needs of the program. The library has numerous professional journals and books on hand. If any faculty member or student requires a resource that is not directly available, the resource can be quickly available via Illiad. The library also provides the program with $2,000 annually to help purchase resources faculty identify that increase their effectiveness in the classroom. MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 11 A valuable resource that has been developed by library staff are several guides that aid our students in their academic endeavors. They developed a specific guide for our online cohort (Vocational Rehabilitation Graduate Resources), general guide (Vocational Rehabilitation), an APA Style and a Graduate Research Guide. These guides help provide our students with a quick access to library resources. Most recently the library has secured digitized videos via Filmmakers Library, Alexander Street Press, and Films on Demand. These sites allow program faculty access to streaming videos that are close-captioned and transcribed that provide equal access to all students served. These are valuable resources contributing to our university’s goal of inclusive excellence. Perhaps the greatest resource from the library to our program is the collaborative efforts with library staff. The library staff is very accommodating in helping to meet our program objectives. They allow our program to use their computerized lab (room 111) to host orientation for both on campus and online cohorts. During each orientation, library staff provide a 4-hour orientation describing library services. Students feel very prepared to utilize library services in meeting their course assignments after orientation. In particular for the online cohorts, the students leave campus with decreased anxiety about their ability to meet program needs and they have already established working relationships with key ancillary departments. Our program also uses the library lab to administer our comprehensive examination offered three times a year in spring, summer and fall. The library lab provides a quiet, accessible, computerized space for exam administration. 2.4.2 List any special resources used to meet program and/or student needs such as: Learning Technology Services for curriculum materials development, ASPIRE, Research Services, Advisement Center, Disability Services, Multicultural Student Services, etc. Learning Technology Services has been an integral part of supporting both the on campus and online programs via the learning platform, Desire to Learn (D2L). Both on campus and online cohorts rely heavily on the learning platform to support all courses. LTS staff and student workers have always been responsive to the needs of faculty and students. They are quick with responses and easy to engage in problem solving to achieve program needs. LTS has been very supportive in meeting one of the recommended objectives from last PRC review, increasing counseling component for online program. They listened to faculty needs in teaching counseling courses online. LTS staff identified Blackboard Collaborate as a great resource to meet course objectives. LTS staff trained faculty and problem solved with faculty and students to promote the highest level of utilization of the platform. Blackboard Collaborate was a very helpful resource for the course but it still had a few drawbacks. LTS staff did not give up and this past summer, staff helped faculty with the utilization of Tegrity in recording distance counseling sessions and increasing the effectiveness of supervision. Tegrity allows faculty to supervise students in one of two ways. Faculty may leave feedback as ‘bookmarks’ embedded in the recorded counseling session so the student can know exactly what they did well and what they may improve on. A second option while using Tegrity allows the faculty member to be talking to a student via telephone while both faculty and student watch the recording from their MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 12 respective offices. Thus, Tegrity allows supervision to occur as if the student is in the faculty member’s office. Needless to say, Tegrity has added increased quality of supervision for online learners. Continuing Tegrity availability and support is imperative to the MSVR program’s ability to deliver online counseling classes to meet supervision requirements consistent with CORE accreditation standards and ethical responsibilities to protect confidentiality. Research Services and CEHHS have helped to support our students in disseminating research via poster presentations at the Wisconsin Rehabilitation Association annual conference for the past three years. It is expected they will continue to do so. All students who have been able to attend the conference leave with a firmer commitment to the field of rehabilitation and a greater sense of how valued they are professionally in the state. Disability Services is an integral part of assisting our students and faculty with accommodations that support the learning environment. Additionally, the office now serves our program as a Practicum site for our on campus students enrolled in the counseling concentration. Disability Services supports the MSVR program by employing alumni (N=2). The MSVR program values its longstanding collaborative relationship with the Stout Vocational Rehabilitation Institute (SVRI). In the VR profession, SVRI is internationally recognized as a leader in cutting edge technology, quality services, training and research which positively impact the future of persons with disabilities. Our students enjoy multiple learning opportunities within SVRI and significantly benefit from the quality training, research and SVRI reputation. SVRI embodies the Polytechnic institutional mission and clearly contributes to the UW-Stout advantage. Some examples of how SVRI supports the MSVR program include: Provision of supervised clinical practicum site for campus-based students in the dual concentration in VE/RC Adjunct instructional staff to the MSVR program Evidence-based research and knowledge translation which promote the learning objectives of the MSVR program Collaboration with faculty in grant writing, research and publications Provision of affordable professional development training opportunities for faculty, students and alumni including continuing education credits toward certification renewal Collaboration with Department of Rehabilitation and Counseling to offer a bi-annual campus-based VR Conference. The VR conference brings alumni back to campus and builds professional networking opportunities to local and regional community service providers. Assistive technology and technical assistance to students with disabilities Employment of MSVR graduates (N=6) The Graduate School has been an integral part of our program’s recruiting and marketing efforts. The Graduate School has expanded online presence through social networking and other online marketing opportunities. Our program gets consistent inquiries from potential candidates via the Gradschools.com website that the Graduate School monitors and maintains. The Graduate School works with graduate program directors developing a chart that identifies what MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 13 undergraduate degrees correlate with particular graduate programs. The chart becomes a resource for recruiting undergraduates across campus. The Planning, Assessment, Research and Quality (PARQ) office (Susan Greene) supports the MSVR program through ongoing data analysis of comprehensive exam results. In addition, PARQ provides research design and data interpretation expertise assisting program directors to publish learning outcomes based on comprehensive exam results. 2.4.3 Describe other resources (if any) needed to meet the program objectives. Despite the current high level of expertise with LTS staff, the department could benefit from having additional specialized staff trained in instructional design. Our program would benefit from specialized instructional design staff that could be more proactive in searching and researching strategies that could increase our effectiveness in the classroom and bring them to us. Program faculty does not have the time or the knowledge to know where to seek out strategies to use in the classroom. Currently LTS staff can help greatly if program faculty knows what they want to do or to create new instructional materials; however often times program faculty are not aware of options that could enhance instruction. Faculty need help converting existing content into updated instructional design formats. LTS does a good job at offering training for current resources in instructional design but too often the training is offered when faculty are not on campus. Making sure that training is offered at various times and days once the semester starts would be beneficial. 3. Quality of the graduates of the program. 3.1 Describe program graduate demand and/or anticipated changes or trends impacting the future demand. The demand for our graduates is strong. Across the nation, employment opportunities for qualified rehabilitation professionals are abundant due to critical personnel shortages within the state-federal vocational rehabilitation system. Shifting population demographics (aging; retirements) and recent military activity have significantly increased the need for qualified rehabilitation counselors. The Bureau of Labor Statistics predicts employment for rehabilitation counselors to increase by 28 percent (estimated at 36,000 counselors) from 2010-2020. Simply stated by Chan in 2003 – demand exceeds supply - the supply of qualified personnel generated by educational institutions will not be sufficient to meet the needs of the rehabilitation field. Our graduates enjoy an employment placement rate of 95% or above in positions within the vocational rehabilitation profession. 3.2 Interpret the data provided by Planning, Assessment, Research, and Quality (PARQ) office of the alumni follow-up surveys. Overall, the feedback from program alumni in both 1-year and 5-year follow-up is excellent. One hundred percent of graduates surveyed were employed full-time in a variety of rehabilitation settings. Ninety-five percent of respondents reported employment in positions directly related to MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 14 professional degree earning salaries consistent with experience and venue. Reported yearly earnings ranged from $25,000-$75,000 with averaged earnings of $45,000/year. Both groups are satisfied to very satisfied with their educational experience, career preparation and overall effectiveness of the program. Perhaps most telling about the value placed on their training from our program is that the majority of alumni in both groups would definitely enroll in the same program if they had it to do over again. Common strengths identified from both alumni groups included praise for the small class sizes, knowledgeable faculty and staff, and hands on experience. Alumni feedback validates the emphasis the program places on maintaining quality faculty, low faculty to student ratio, and our program mission that mirrors UW-Stout mission of hands-on, minds-on philosophy. Qualitative comments about potential areas of improvement fell under two broad categories: curriculum and delivery. The curriculum comments focused primarily on fewer adherences to CORE accreditation standards and a desire for expanding curriculum topics relevant to employer and venue needs such as private rehabilitation and forensic applications or agency-specific interviewing techniques. The MSVR curriculum provides a common core of professional competencies and functional skills suitable in a variety of rehabilitation settings. The curriculum is anchored in evidence-based role and function studies and CORE accreditation standards to allow program graduates to meet or exceed existing professional certification and licensure. In the future, where possible, the faculty will infuse expanded topic areas into existing MSVR curriculum. Increasingly prescriptive accreditation standards result in zero flexibility for any elective coursework within the 48-credit curriculum. Likewise, other curriculum recommendations of the program largely echo the professional landscape where ongoing tension exists between the public and private sector rehabilitation applications, as well within group inconsistencies regarding professional identity (i.e., counseling subspecialty versus a unique profession). The second area of alumni feedback was related to program delivery methods most specific to online learning applications. Alumni of the MSVR online cohort desire increased face-to-face type interactions with faculty and peers. The online cohort program model is asynchronous and what inevitably draws most candidates to the program. The asynchronous approach facilitates students’ maintaining their full-time work status while seeking their degree. It is recognized that there will always be some students in each cohort that, despite preferring the online format, will miss the personal connection with faculty afforded to on campus students. 3.3 Interpret program specific surveys (students, faculty and advisory committee) conducted by the Planning and Review Committee. Assessment of feedback from major stakeholders (current students, faculty and Program Advisory Committee [PAC]) largely echos the feedback from alumni cited above: high degree of positive attitude regarding quality of instruction, quality of faculty, advisement and communication and program quality. The consistency of highlighting current program strengths by our stakeholders is particularly meaningful as program faculty strive to maintain and promote continuous improvement to quality instruction. One data point that captures the essence of the integrity of the program comes from the PAC survey that committee members believe they can talk freely and make any recommendation and know it will be heard and valued. MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 15 Stakeholder recommendations for strengthening the program fell into two main areas: available technology and curriculum. As outlined previously, two lab modifications have successfully assisted in updating electronic equipment necessary to ensure high quality of instructional delivery in the classroom. However, current classroom furniture is outdated (half circa 1970; half circa 1990) contributing to ongoing student perceptions that the lab itself is outdated. The feedback on curriculum reflected those of our alumni, noted earlier: less adherences to accreditation standards and expanding particular topics. We encounter increasingly prescriptive accreditation standards resulting in zero flexibility for any elective coursework and other curriculum recommendations largely echo the professional landscape where ongoing tension exists between the public and private sector rehabilitation applications, as well within group inconsistencies regarding professional identity (i.e., counseling subspecialty versus a unique profession). MSVR faculty will make efforts to infuse recommended topic areas into existing curriculum and advise students of additional coursework available outside of 48 credit requirements. Other recommendations for strengthening the program have already been implemented, specifically: A counseling specific Practicum of 100 supervised hours for students enrolled in the Counseling concentration was added beginning academic year 2012-2013. Offering a Pre-Practicum course to both cohorts. Previously, Counseling Process Laboratory (CPL) served as a Practicum for students enrolled in the rehabilitation counseling concentration. Currently, CPL now serves as a Pre-Practicum course. To maintain equality and consistency between the online and on campus cohorts, an online Pre-Practicum course was added to the curriculum starting in summer 2013. 4. Program evidence of continuous improvement 4.1 Describe program strengths distinguishing it from similar programs. Describe and explain program weaknesses? The MSVR program is only one of two rehabilitation counseling programs in the state of Wisconsin. Our program has been consistently ranked in the top 10 by U.S. News and World Report in the country for several decades. A major strength of the program identified by alumni, current student, and advisory committee responses is the quality of faculty. The Rehabilitation and Counseling Department has been very focused when hiring new faculty to ensure that the faculty has practiced as a qualified rehabilitation professional. Experienced quality faculty enhances the program’s ability to meet its overall objective in the preparation of qualified rehabilitation practitioners. A key component that separates our educational approach from other programs involves the amount of student exposure to multiple professional learning opportunities throughout their tenure in the MSVR program. The UW-Stout hands-on, minds-on philosophy promotes student involvement with professionals and consumers/clients in the community. Campus-based students are continuously involved with service providers and consumers at the Stout Vocational Rehabilitation Institute (SVRI) housed in the VR building. Many graduate classes include service learning components that require students to conduct informational interviews with MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 16 community-based agencies, rehabilitation professionals and consumer or advocacy groups. Students are further exposed to the rehabilitation counseling profession through guest lecturers (classroom or discussion board). Students are encouraged to join professional organizations at the local and national levels and to collaborate with faculty on research and conference presentations. Online students are working professionals who apply knowledge and competencies gained in the program in their daily interactions with clients in professional rehabilitation settings. We have an ongoing collaborative effort with SVRI to help accomplish our mission and promote professional growth and development of our students. SVRI, a high quality service provider, serves as an excellent training site and Practicum for students enrolled in the Vocational Evaluation concentration. During the supervised SVRI practicum experience, all students conduct six complete vocational evaluations (VE) from initial intake through report writing. Working with consumers referred to SVRI for VE services, referral information and diagnostic interview information are used to develop a consumer-centered VE plan. Assessments are conducted using a wide range of tools, techniques, and assistive technology. Culminating in a final staffing with the consumer, referral counselor, and significant others, the VE findings are communicated through an oral and written report. The vocational evaluation program at UW-Stout is the only one of its kind in Wisconsin. In our region, vocational evaluation graduate coursework has been available at Southern Illinois University and at Illinois Institute of Technology. In both cases, enrollment has been significantly less than that of UW-Stout. In addition to increasing the availability of personnel in our region, it is important to note that graduates of the Stout vocational evaluation program have helped meet personnel shortages throughout the U.S.: Connecticut, Washington, Arizona, Florida, Oregon, Idaho, Texas, and Nevada are a few examples. A unique feature of the MS VR curriculum is the opportunity to add coursework and obtain a second emphasis (dual concentration) area within the 2-year program. By and large, the most common dual concentration is the on-campus emphasis in vocational evaluation combined with the on-campus rehabilitation counseling concentration (CORE-accredited). This inherent flexibility within the MS VR program offers rehabilitation graduate students options for future careers within State agencies or other public or nonprofit rehabilitation agencies. All data point to the fact that the MSVR program meets/exceeds its mission of training highly qualified practitioners prepared for meeting the expectations of employers. We have a longstanding focused curriculum adhering to all aspects of the vocational rehabilitation process versus just a counseling focus which promotes a strong professional identity. The strengths identified in previous program reviews remain evident: competent instructors passionate about their work; instructors that make time to mentor students; strong program directors; relevant competency-based curriculum that provides depth and breadth of content and an abundance of applied hands-on experience; national and international reputation; CORE accredited program; high employment rate of graduates; and quality online delivery. Our program is currently experiencing two areas of weakness. The first is availability of faculty. The program is significantly constrained by two faculty FTE positions which are not ‘available’ MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 17 due to ongoing extenuating circumstances (long-term administrative secondment; medical leave; grant release). These extenuating circumstances require the program use adjunct instructors to fill behind the 2.0 unavailable faculty FTE. Qualified terminally-degreed graduate level adjunct instructors are not readily available for hire. Further reducing instructional flexibility in the graduate program is the fact that all MSVR core faculty have teaching responsibilities in the undergraduate BSVR program (N=275) housed with the Department. All MSVR faculty have teaching responsibilities in BSVR, therefore, increasing instructional pressures on all VR faculty are certain to continue in the near future. The already large, wellenrolled BSVR program is positioned to launch a new major in criminal justice in fall 2014; large enrollments are anticipated. While the growth of the undergraduate program is welcomed, the growth is stretching all available resources. Further exacerbating the adjunct-hiring challenges are the abundance of applied lecture/laboratory classes within the MS and BS VR curriculum which result in scheduling classes over multiple days each week to meet 5-6 hours/week of face-to-face instructional time. The program’s second weakness is the needed updates of the VR310 Lab facility and furnishings. The lab situation is further compounded by growing enrollment of the BSVR program and lab course needs. As the undergraduate enrollment rises, more lab class sections will need to be added which in turn increases the demand/use of laboratory equipment and lab space. In addition to the core program courses utilizing the labs for quality instruction, there are five core undergraduate courses that also rely on the lab and lab equipment. The program needs to maintain equipment in good working order as usage increases and we need lab furniture that allows flexibility in configuration of the lab space to meet the needs of increasingly diverse class offerings. 4.2 Submit evidence of program response to the concerns and recommendations from previous program review. Recommendations for Program Directors: Work with the department chair and dean to address staffing needs addressed by CORE accreditation recommendations of FTE student-faculty ratio and studentadvisor ratio. The program director worked closely with the department chair and the Dean of CEHHS to add one FTE that is split.50 for online MSVR cohort and .50 for Clinical Mental Health Counseling program. The position enabled the program to meet CORE faculty/student ratios (5:1) in experiential courses (Rehab 708 & 787). Current FTE student to FTE faculty ratio was approved by CORE in their site visit in spring 2013. Having more faculty has also allowed the program directors more time to assist students in academic advising ensuring matriculation through the program and improved compliance with CORE recommended student-advisor ratios. MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 18 Work with PRC, D2L staff, and others, as deemed appropriate, to develop an independent evaluation for the online program to address specific online issues. The PRC survey was revised to include items which better reflect diverse course delivery methods. The MSVR online program director worked with staff at PARQ to separate the survey so that data could be disaggregated between online and campus cohorts to better identify areas of strength and weaknesses between the delivery method. Since the separation, the data has been helpful to assure that both cohorts’ voices are heard. Review concentrations with low-enrollments and evaluate viability. The School-to-Work concentration could provide a collaborative partnership with the School of Education. Program directors reviewed enrollment data in the School-to-Work concentration and the Rehabilitation Leadership concentration. The enrollment data and employment outlook for the concentrations were provided to the MSVR faculty and department chair. Faculty agreed to eliminate both concentrations to focus faculty and department resources on the rehabilitation counseling and vocational evaluation concentrations that consistently demonstrate strong enrollment patterns and high employment demand for graduates. The Department Chair and Dean of the College supported the faculty decision. Investigate the possibility of including more field experiences and counseling coursework in both the online and on-campus program. The program directors have made multiple concerted efforts to increase counseling coursework in the on campus and online curricula. The efforts have been a collaboration within the entire department with the support of the Dean of CEHHS. Specific examples include: 1. During the 2011-12 academic year, the program completed an extensive program review to ensure compliance with the new CORE standards and to determine the best strategies to strengthen the program. A major addition to increase counseling skills and practice involved adding two additional courses: one course for the on campus curriculum and one course for the online curriculum. The on campus curriculum now offers CPL (COUN 788) as a counseling skills preparation course, followed by a separate Practicum course (new addition of Rehab 707) in which students have the opportunity to apply these skills in working with individuals with disabilities in a supervised setting. The online course added a Pre-Practicum (REHAB 704) course to mirror the CPL course in the on-campus curriculum. The debut of Pre-Practicum was this past summer 2013 as a microcounseling skills development course. Students will subsequently take the Practicum course as before, but the emphasis will be on case conceptualization and advanced counseling skills versus just microcounseling skills. 2. An experiential component was added to Applied Vocational Assessment and Evaluation class to include an assignment that requires students to utilize their microcounseling skills to interpret the results of the assessments given to a ‘client.’ MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 19 3. A Group Counseling class was added to the curriculum. This course also includes an experiential component that provides more practice into theory and counseling practice with direct feedback from faculty. 4. Starting in the summer of 2012, MSVR faculty collaborated with the program director of the Clinical Mental Health Counseling (CMHC) program, Department Chair, with the support of the Dean of the College to provide a Graduate Assistant (GA) from the CMHC program to assist faculty teaching online counseling courses. The addition of a GA helps to expand and diversify the type of feedback students get to build their counseling skills. The feedback from the online cohorts about having a GA has been overwhelmingly positive. Recommendations for the Chair and Dean: Work to address staffing needs addressed by CORE accreditation recommendations of FTE student-faculty ratio and student-advisor ratio. The Chair of the Department of Rehabilitation and Counseling and the Dean of CEHHS worked very closely with the program directors to identify faculty needs and added one FTE that is split.50 for online MS VR cohort and .50 for Clinical Mental Health Counseling program. The position enabled the program to meet CORE faculty/student ratios (5:1) in experiential courses (Rehab 708 & 787). Current FTE student-faculty ratio was approved by CORE in their Spring 2013 program review. The additional faculty position expanded the shared responsibility of program faculty in mentoring students to support and promote professional development and identity. Both the Department Chair and the Dean of CEHHS provided continued support for expanded program leadership with two program directors to ensure mentoring and ongoing advisement to meet CORE program faculty/student ratios. The improvement is evident with both cohorts having strong retention and graduation rates (82% to 100%) attributed to consistent program advisement and mentoring. Work to support resources for online technology and on-campus labs. The Department’s Chair and the Dean of CEHHS supported and helped develop one lab modification and two additional requests for equipment to make improvements to the Vocational Evaluation lab (VR 310) during the past seven years. These requests were funded by CEHHS for a total of $29,903. This financial support successfully assisted in updating electronic equipment necessary to ensure high quality of instructional delivery in the classroom. Maintaining an updated lab is vital to promote skill development of students in the program. Additionally, the Department Chair and the Dean of CEHHS were an integral part of helping to provide training to seven (7) department faculty to increase their skills in online course delivery. In the Spring of 2010, the program director and department chair wrote a Curricular Incubation Grant for media technology, software licensing, and instructional design support and to revise online course material. The grant was supported by the Dean and funded by Curricular Incubation Center for $8,983. MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 20 4.3 In the next seven years, what major improvements or changes are planned for implementation to improve program quality? Program revisions approved by the University in 2012 were the result of a comprehensive 2-year departmental curriculum review process. All MSVR courses and learning objectives were mapped onto new CORE accreditation standards to identify gaps, reduce overlap and ensure equivalency between campus and online learning cohorts. In total, the program revision included revised program objectives, five course revisions and the development of two new online courses and the addition of one course to the campus program plan. Despite these recent revisions and successful CORE re-accreditation for the next eight years, we anticipate needing to make more program changes based on potential state legislation and new accreditation standards. Anticipated specific improvements include: 1. Revising program curriculum requirement from 48 credit hours to 60 credit hours. In July 2013 our accrediting body, CORE, has recently joined with the Council for Accreditation of Counseling and Related Educational Programs (CACREP) accreditation body to develop a new Clinical Rehabilitation Counselor program. The new program standards require 60 credit hours and will be jointly accredited by CORE and CACREP. Similarly, the Wisconsin Department of Safety and Professional Standards (DSPS) is moving toward a 60 credit requirement for graduates to be eligible for Licensed Professional Counselor (LPC). The state legislation is currently being finalized with the expectation of allowing programs four years to comply with the 60 credit hour mandate. 2. Meeting the new 60 credit hour standards will include stricter clinical requirements for students when enrolled in experiential courses. Currently, students are able to meet accreditation standards via completing their practicum and internship experiences in a variety of vocational rehabilitation settings. It is anticipated that the new standards will place limits on what settings meet clinical requirement. As such, it is expected that a Clinical Practicum Coordinator position may be needed to facilitate appropriate opportunities for students enrolled in Practicum and Internship classes to meet the new clinical standards. In addition to the anticipated improvements to the program as noted above, there are a couple of external threats to the program that requires ongoing advocacy and monitoring. The first is a decline in Request For Proposals (RFP) from the Rehabilitation Services Administration (RSA) which provide funding scholarships for long-term training of qualified rehabilitation professionals. There is also current proposed federal legislation that, if passed, has the potential to restructure educational requirements for vocational rehabilitation professionals within StateFederal vocational rehabilitation environments. These external threats may impact the number of qualified candidates seeking training nationwide. Program faculty are actively involved in professional organizations that continue to monitor these external threats. MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 21 Attachments Current Assessment in the Major Report: https://info.uwstout.edu/Pages/DetailList.aspx?Category=Quality&Subcategory=Universi ty+Assessment&SurveyType=Graduate+Assessment+in+the+Major Program Plan Sheets: Campus RC Concentration: http://www.uwstout.edu/programs/msvr/oncampus/upload/msvr_campus_rc-seq.pdf Campus Dual Concentration: http://www.uwstout.edu/programs/msvr/oncampus/upload/msvr_campus_rcve-seq.pdf Online RC Concentration: http://www.uwstout.edu/programs/msvr/online/online.cfm Program Facts: http://www.uwstout.edu/admin/provost/upload/VocRehabProgramFacts.pdf Current Program Advisory Board: http://www.uwstout.edu/curr/committees/progradvisory/index.cfm MSVR PRC Self-Study 2013-14 Page 22