GEOPHYSICALRESEARCH LETTERS, VOL. 14, NO. 8, PAGES804-807, AUGUST1987 CORRELATION OF A 3,200 YEAR OLD TEPHRA IN ICE CORES FROM VOSTOK AND SObWH POLE STATIONS, ANTARCTICA J.M.Palais 1,P.R.Kyle 2,E.Mosley-Thompson 3 andE.Thomas 4 Abstract.Tephralayersin two Antarcticicecoresare correlatedon thebasisof theirchemicalcompositions and estimated ages.We believethetephrawasproduced about of theirchemicalcomposition andestimated age.We believe thatthetephraoriginated in a majorexplosive eruption from 3,200yearsagofroma majorexplosiveeruptionof Candlemas years ago. Candlemas Island in the South Sandwich Islands about 3,200 Island in the South Sandwich Islands. This is the first time that SamplingandAnalysis tephralayershavebeencorrelated betweentwo widely separated ice coresanddemonstrates thattephralayersmay serveasstratigraphic markersfor correlating, andperhapsin somecases,datingAntarcticice cores. Ice samples containing thetwo tephralayersweremeltedand filtered ontoNucleopore tm(0.4gmdiameter poresize)filters in a Class 100 clean room. Introduction A section from each filter was examinedby scanningelectronmicroscope(SEM) andenergydispersivex-ray analysis(EDAX). A polishedmicroprobe sectionof eachsamplewaspreparedby washingtheparticles off of thefilter andmountingthemin epoxy. Studiesof ice coresamplesfrom GreenlandandAntarctica providedetailedinformation aboutpastclimateandthe chemicalcomposition of theatmosphere, for at leastthelast 150,000years(Dansgaardet al., 1981, 1982; Loriuset al., 1979, 1985;Oeschger,1985). The preservation of volcanic deposits (bothsolubleacidsandinsolublevolcanicash particles)frombothlocalanddistantvolcanicsources in Theenergy-dispersive x-rayanalyses use"ZAF" corrections AntarcticandGreenlandice (Hammeret al., 1981;Kyle et al., 1982, 1984; Hammer, 1984; Palais,1985;De Angeliset al., 1985;Delmaset al., 1985) is of particularinterest. Eruptions fromAntarcticvolcanoes in theMcMurdoVolcanic GroupandMarie ByrdLand(Keyset al., 1977;Kyle et al., 1981) andvolcanoesin the SouthSandwichIslands(Nishioet al., 1984 a,b) arerecordedprincipallyasvisibletephra (volcanicash)layersin theice cores,whereaseruptions originatingfromvolcanoes in themoredistantregionsof Indonesia, SouthAmerica,andNew Zealandhaveproducedonlylayersof to calculateoxidepercents(normalizedto 100%), from elementpeakintensitiesandtheoreticalstandards.The accuracyof the analyseswascheckedagainstglassandmineral standards andtheprecisionof theanalyses wasdetermined by repeatedanalysesof thesesamestandards.The microprobe analyseswerecorrectedusingtheBence-Albeematrix correctionprocedure(BenceandAlbee, 1968)andglass standards were usedto checkanalyticalprecisionandaccuracy Themicroprobe analyses aremoreprecisethantheEDAX analyses, ascanbe seenby comparingthestandard deviations of the analyses(Table 1). Results elevated acidity(e.g.H2SO4),recognized bydetailed analyses VostokTephra of the chemicalcompositionof the ice (Delmaset al., 1985). In Greenland,eruptionsof nearbyIcelandicvolcanoeshave producedwell-definedlayersof elevatedacidity,identifiedby increases in theD.C. electricalconductivityof theice, butno insolublevolcanicashparticleshaveeverbeenidentified (Hammeret al., 1981;Hammer, 1984). The only well confirmedevidenceto date,for long-distance (> several thousand kilometers)transport of volcanicashparticlesto the polarice sheets,in eitherhemisphere,is the studyby De Angeliset al. (1985), in whichvolcanicashparticlesoriginatingin the 1982eruptionof E1Chichon,Mexico,werefound The Vostoktephrais theinformalnameproposed by Kyle et a1.(1982)for a 0.05 m thick,diffusetephralayerfoundat 100.8 m in an ice core drilled in 1979 at Vostok Station in East Antarctica(Figure1). The depth/agerelationship (Parkeret al., 1982)for theVostokcoresuggests an ageof about3,200 a B.P. The Vostoktephrais composed of 55 % lithicmaterial (mainlywell-rounded, brown,cryptocrystalline glass),40 % clearglassshardsand5 % crystals(mainlyfeldspar)(Figure2 c,d). in surface snow of the Greenland ice sheet. Further evidence thattephracanbe transported f'•r from source,andis therefore usefulfor correlationpurposes, is the studyby Kyle and Seward(1984), in whichtephrafrom New Zealandwas identifiedin deep-sea pistoncoresfromtheSouthPacificsector of the SouthernOceannearthe BallenyIslands. In thispaperwe reportthefirst correlation of tephralayers between twoicecoresin Antarctica.The,visible tephr, a layers in icecoresfromVostokStation(78ø 28 S, 106ø 48 E) and SouthPoleStation(90ø S), havebeencorrelated onthebasis Kyle et a1.(1984)considered threepossiblesourceregions (theSouthShetlandIslands,the SouthSandwichIslandsand theSouthern Andes)for theVostoktephraandconcluded that the SouthSandwichIslandswere the mostlikely source. Rocks from the South Shetland Islands and the Southern Andeshavehighertotalalkalicontentandlowerironcontents, respectively, thantheVostoktephra.TheVostoktephra(I able 1, sample3,4) is mostsimilarin composition to anaphyric andesitefrom thenorthernpartof Candlemas Islandin the SouthSandwichIslands,which is one of the youngestof the SouthSandwichIslands(Table 1, sample5)(Baker, 1978; Tomblin,1979). Lavasfrom Candlemas Islandareexception- 1Graduate School ofOceanography, Univ.ofRhode Island, allylowinpotash (K20),a characteristic feature oftheVostok Narragansett,R.I. 2 Dept. ofGeoscience, NewMexico Institute ofMining and tephra. CoPyright1987by theAmericanGeophysical Union. Grainsizeanalyses of theVostoktephraindicate initial deposition of coarse particles (meandiameter of about45 gm) followedbydeposition of muchfinerparticles (meanof about 7 gm),composing thebulkof thetephra(Figure3) Themass concentration of tephrain meltwatersamples gradually increases froma background of about1 gg/mlto a peakof about14 gg/ml. The originalthickness of thetephrais Papernumber7L7157. makes it difficult to calculate a mass accumulation rate T•chnology, Socorro, N.M. a Byrd PolarResearchCenter,Ohio SateUniversity, Columbus, Ohio 4 Lamont-Doherty Geological Observatory, Palisades, N.Y. unknownasthe diffusenatureof the Vostoktephrain thecore (mg/cm2/1000a), asisdone indeep seacores. 0094-8276/87/007L-7157503.00 804 Palaiset al.-Correlation Of TephraIn Ice Cores South Atlantic '•Ocean' ':South Sandwich •o Islands 805 Table1.Majorelement analyses (wt.%)of tephra fromtheSouth Pole andVostokcores,anda rock from the SouthSandwich Islands. ß n - '•'•'•,t• • i R Mt Ex 4 Mt o Te ice•,•/ c•s•[,•n•rc•,,c • •Shelf• / ........ • Indian Ocean x Tephra exposed in blue ice ß Cenozoic volcanic rocks 0 • 3 5 11 9 SiO2 E•slAnarctic T 3 2 4 5 . ........ AU o•n_e•,•/• TARCTIC"•,,,•. 2 1 km 1000 59.98(1.21)t 60.1(3.02) 60.56(0.42) TiO2 0.78(0.9) 0.3(0.22) 0.74(0.07) A1203 16.03(0.94) 17.6(3.40) 14.92(0.82) FeO* 7.37(1.14) 9.0(3.79) 9.15(0.57) 0 MnO 0.16(0.8) 0.23(0.04) MgO 1.71(0.28) 3.5(1.91) 2.39(0.34) 6.72(0.26) CaO 6.79(0.42) 5.5(•.35) Na20 5.94(0.83) 3.6(0.89) 3.31(0.38) 0.44(0.05) K20 0.39(0.09) 0.](0.]5) n.d. P205 0.08(0.09) 0.3(0.13) Total South Pacific 99.23 100 98.46 37 59.73(1.79) 0.90(0.16) 14.84(0.66) 10.25(1.23) 0.15(0.12) 2.44(0.48) 6.64(0.76) 4.46(0.57) 0.63(0.19) 60.9 0.95 14.8 8.34 0.11 2.35 6.09 3.67 0.39 n.d. 0.12 100.04 97.72 Ocean 180 ø I Fig.1.Mapof Antarctica showing corelocations andprobable pathsof atmospheric transport fromtheSouthSandwich Islands to the Antarctic ice sheet. Key: * FeO, total Fe as FeO; ? one standarddeviation.d. indicatesnot detected;n is number of samples. 1. SouthPoleTephra-Electron microprobe analyses, Univ.of RhodeIsland,(Analyst, J. Palais). SouthPol• Tcphr• 2. SouthPoleTephra-Energy-dispersive x-rayanalysis, In 1983/84 a 361 m ice core was drilled at the South Pole with a distincttephralayer(3mmthick) at 303.44m. The tephrais composed primarilyof vesicular glassshards and lithicmaterial witha smallpercentage of crystals, including quartz,pyroxene andplagioclase of intermediate composition (Figure2 a,b). Majorelement analyses of theglassshards in theSouthPoletephra(Table1,analyses 1,2)compare well OhioStateUniv.(Analyst, T. Leonardi). 3. VostokTephra-Electron microprobe analysis, LosAlamos NationalLaboratory (Analyst,J. Palais)(Kyle et al., 1984). 4. VostokTephra-Energydispersive x-rayanalysis, Arizona StateUniversity(Analyst, E. Thomas)(Kyle et al., 1984). 5. Candlemas Island-Aphyric andesite, Cauldron Lakelava, northern Candlemas Island.Wetchemical analysis (Tomblin, •979). I Fig.2. Scanning electron micrographs oftephra fromtheSouth PoleandVostok icecores. a)South Pole tephra blocky, moderately vesicular, partially altered shard withshallow spherical vesicles. Fineadhering dust. 2400x; 1cm=4gm.b)South Poletephra highly vesicular, fresh shard withdelicate square to rectangular vesicles. 2400x;1cm=4gm.c)Vostok tephra subrounded, blocky, moderately vesicular shard, partially altered, withshallow spherical vesicles. Fineadhering dust. Compare witha).l110x;1cm=9 gm d)Vostok tephra blocky shards withfineadhering dust, fewvesicles. 1110x; lcm= 9 gm. 806 Palaiset al.: CorrelationOf TephraIn Ice Cores al. (1982), suggests an ageof 3,250a B.P. at 300 m in the SouthPolecore. Thiscompares well with theestimated age (3,200a B.P.) for theVastoktephra(Parkeret al., 1982). Total Mass Concentration(•g/ml) 0 4 8 12 Ioo.75 I,,,,,, ] NO3- SO,• II ! L I 30- ,1. 20- 40- -- 5 7 9 li L : • •; Discussion i- 30- ...................... ! 0o 1• , ,';- , , , , .s • •• • 100.80 • 2.': Total Mass I :............... ,o: • 30 5 7 0 I : II :1 9 II -- o ,oo.s5[• -,..... , I I I 8 layers in theYamatoMountains arenotwellconstrained, they areof thecorrectorderof magnitude to becorrelative withthe associated withthesetephralayers,suggest thattheageof the 3o579II I (theMeteorite IceField)of theYamatoMountains, Queen MaudLand,EastAntarctica(Figure1) (Nishioet al., 1984; Katsushima et al., 1984).Althoughtheagesof thetephra Vastok andSouth Pole tephras. 36C1 analyses ofice d, 20- 4 Tephrasimilarin composition tothatin theVastokandSouth Polecoresalsooccursin layersat thesurfacein blueiceareas ice in the Meteorite Ice Field of the Yamato Mountains is less than one36C1 half-life (3x 105 a)(Nishiizumi etal.,1979). The14Cterrestrial ageofchondrite Yamato 75102, collected near tephra layer C-32, indicates anage of3.0+1.2x 103a I (Nishio,personal communication, !985).Theterrestrial ages 12 of four otherYamato meteoritesare believedto be in the range concentration (pEq/I) Fig. 3. Depth variationof massconcentration of tephrain a 0.10 m sectionof the Vastokcore.Histogramsshowthegrain sizedistributionof tephrain the samplesthatwereanalyzedfor massconcentration.Sulfateandnitratedatafrom Kyle et al.(1982). with thoseof the Vastok tephra(Table 1, analyses3,4), which suggests thattheymightbe fromthesameeruption.Thisis furthersupported by theestimatedageof theice enclosing theselayers,asdiscussed below. of 3,000-22,000a. Calculation of flow linesin theMeteorite IceFieldsgivesanagefor theiceupstream of MotoiNunatak, neartephralayerC-32,in therangefromoneto several thousand yearsold (Nishioet al., 1984). Tephra layersinpiston cores fromtheSouthAtlanticOcean (Ninkovich et a1.,1964; Federman et al., 1982)werebelieved tobeerupted fromtheSouthSandwich Islands withinthelast 30,000years.Basedona sedimentation rateof 8 cm/1000a, a tephralayerat0.20m in coreV 14-56wouldbe2,500years old (Federman et al., 1982). Thisis probablya minimum estimate,however,sinceerosionby AntarcticBottomWater mayhaveremoved someof thesediments in thecore(Ledbetter Depth-AgeRelationships andCiesielski,1986).The tephrahasa similarcomposition Thereis no absolutedatingof eitherthe SouthPoleor Vastok cores,but two linesof evidencesuggestthatthe tephra theYamatoMountainsandmay correlatewith them. andageto thetephralayersfromVastok,SouthPoleandfrom layers(Vastoktephra-100m; SouthPoletephra-3oom) are coeval. First,a roughestimateof the ageof thesetwo layersis madeby assuming a similardepth-density profilefor thetwo locations andaccumulation rates v•hich differbyafactor of aboutthree(Vastok2.0-2.5 g/cm•/a (Younget al., 1982; Lorius etal.,1985);South Pole7-9g/cm2•(Jouzel etal., 1983)).Secondly,ourestimated depth-age profilefor the SouthPolecore(Figure4), basedondepth-age estimates of Schwander (1984),Mosley-Thompson (1980)andKuivinenet Depth/Age 104• Profile-South Conclusions Theseanalyses andinferences areconsistent withthe conclusion thatthetephralayersin theSouthPoleandVastok coresarecoevalandrepresent deposition froma [najor explosive volcanic eruption in theSouthSandwich Islands (probably fromCandlemas Island)about3,200aB.P. Forthe firsttimetephralayersfromtwowidelyseparated icecores havebeencorrelated,whichreinforcestheutility of tephrochronolgy foricecorestudies. Thistephralayer provides anexcellent stratigraphic markerforAntarctic ice coresandshouldbe soughtat otherlocations.Furthermore, a detailed studyof thedispersal of thistephralayermayprovide information onthetransport of atmospheric particles in thispart of thesouthern hemisphere. Theoccurrence of anapparently widelydispersed tephra layerin EastAntarctica, possibly originating fromtheSouthSandwich Islands, is consistent withthepathsof atmospheric transport proposed byAlt et al. (1959),Carleton(1981)andThompson andMosley- Pole - n'103= Thompson(1982). • 02 = )-1 Acknowledgements. We wouldliketothankthePolarIce CoringOffice(PICa), University of Nebraska for drillingthe - -- [] Schwander (1984) I ßMosley-Thompson (1980) lOOm Vastok and South Pole ice cores. We also wish to thank Grant Kuivinen lO I 100 I et al. (1982) I I 200 I 200m I 300 I 400 Depth (m) Fig.4. Estimated depth-age relationship fortheSouthPole core basedon data from Schwander(1984), Mosley- Thompson (1980)andKuivinenet al (1982). Heikenfor useof theElectronMicroprobeat theLosAlamos NationalLaboratory andPeterBusekfor useof theScanning ElectronMicroscope at theArizonaStateUniversity.Dave Mann(MannPetragraphic Inc.)madethemicroprobe mounts of bothtephrasamples. TonyLeonardi of theOhioState University andDavidBrowning of theUniversity of Rhode Islandassisted with theSEM andEDAX analyses of the South Poletephra.Thisworkwassupported bytheNationalScience Foundation grantDPP-8021402,DPP-8519122 Palaiset al.: CorrelationOf TephraIn Ice Cores References $07 Lorius, C., J. Jouzel, C. Ritz, L. Merlivat, N.I. Barkov, Y.S. KorotkevichandV.M. Kotlyakov, A 150,000-yearclimaAlt, J., P. Astapenko,N.J. Ropar,Jr., Someaspectsof the Antarcticatmospheric circulationin 1958,IGY General ReportSeries4, 1959. Baker, P.E. The SouthSandwichIslands:III Petrologyof the volcanicrocks,Brit.Antarct.Surv.Sci.Rpt.93, 1-34, 1978. Bence,A.E. and A.L. Albee, Empiricalcorrectionfactorsfor the electronmicroanalysisof silicatesandoxides,J. Geol., • 382-403, 1968. Carleton,A.M., Monthly variabilityof satellite-derived cyclone activityfor the southernhemispherewinter, J. Climatol., _1, 21-38, 1981. Dansgaard,W., Ice corestudies:datingthe pastto find the future, Nature, 290, 360-361, 1981. Dansgaard,W., H.O. Clausen,N. Gundestrup,C.U. Hammer, S.J. Johnsen,P.M. Kristinsdotir, and N. Reeh, A new Greenlanddeepice core,Nature, 218,1273-1277, 1982. De AngelisM., L. Fehrenbach,C. Jthanno,and M. Maurette, Micrometre-sized volcanicglassesin polaricesand snows, Nature, 317, 52-54,1985. Delmas,R.J., M. Legrand,A.J. AristarainandF. Zanolini, Volcanicdepositsin Antarcticsnowandice, J. Geophys. Res., 90, 12,901-12,920, 1985 Federman,A.W., N.D. WatldnsandH. Sigurdsson,Scotia Arc volcanismrecordedin abyssalpistoncoresdownwind from theislands,in AntarcticGeoscience,editedby C. Craddock,pp. 223-228, Universityof WisconsinPress, Madison, Wisc., 1982. Hammer, C.U., H.B. Clausen, W. and Dansgaard, Greenlandice sheetevidenceof post-glacialvolcanismand its climatic impact, Nature, 288, 230-235, 1981. Hammer, C.U., Tracesof Icelandiceruptionsin the Greenland ice sheet, Jokull, 34, 51-65, 1984. Jouzel,J., L. Merlivat, J.R. Petit and C. Lorius,Climatic informationover the lastcenturydeducedfrom a detailed isotopicrecordin the SouthPole snow, J. Geophys.Res., 88, 2693-2703, 1983. Katsushima, T., F. Nishio, H. Ohmae, M. Ishikawa and S. Takahashi,Compositionof dirt layersin the bareice areas nearthe Yamato Mountainsin QueenMaud Land and the Allan Hills in Victoria Land, Antarctica, Mem. Nat. Inst. PolarRes. Spec.Issue34, 174-187, 1984. Kuivinen, K.C., B.R. Koci, G.W. Holdsworth and A.J. Gow, SouthPole ice coredrilling, 1981-1982,Antarct.J. U.S., 17, 89-91, 1982. Kyle, P.R., P.A. Jezek,E. Mosley-Thompson andL.G. Thompson,Tephralayersin theByrd Stationice coreand the Dome C ice core, Antarctica and their climatic importance,J. Volcanol.Geotherm.Res.,11, 29-39, 1981. Kyle, P.R., J. M. PalaisandR. Delmas,The volcanicrecord of Antarcticice cores:Preliminaryresultsandpotentialfor futureinvestigations, AnnalsGlaciol.,3, 172-179, 1982. Kyle, P.R., J. Palais,J. andE. Thomas,The VostoktephraAn importantenglacialstratigraphic marker?,Antarct.J. U.S., 19, 64-65, 1984. Kyle, P.R. and D. Seward,Dispersedrhyolitic tephrafrom New Zealandin deep-seasedimentsof the SouthernOcean, Geology, 12, 487-490, 1984. Ledbetter, M.T. and P. F. Ciesielski, Post-Miocene disconformities andpaleoceanography in theAtlanticsector of the SouthernOcean,Paleogeograph., Paleoclimatol., Paleoecol., 52, 185-214, 1986. Lorius, C., L. Merlivat, J. Jouzel,and M. Pourchet, A 30,000-yearisotopeclimaticrecordfrom Antarcticice, Nature, 280, 644-648, 1979. tic record from Antarctic ice, Nature, 316, 591-596, 1985. Mosley-Thompson, E. 911Yearsof Microparticle Deposition at theSouthPole:A ClimaticInterpretation, OhioState Univ. Inst. Polar Studies,Ohio StateUniv., Rpt. 73, 1980. Ninkovich, D., B.C. Heezen,J.R. Conoily and L.H. Burkle, SouthSandwichtephrain deep-seasediments,Deep Sea Res., 11, 605-619, 1964. Nishiizumi, K., L.R. Arnold, D. Elmore, R.D. Ferraro, H.E Gove, R.C. Finkel. R.P. Beukens,K.H. Changand L.R. Kilius.36C1and53Mnin Antarctic meteorites and 10Be_36C1 dating ofAntarctic ice,Earth Planet. Sci.Lett., 45, 285-292, 1979. Nishio, F., T. KatsushimaandH. Ohmae, Volcanic ashlayers in bareice areasneartheYamatoMountains,Dronning Maud Land and the Allan Hills, Victoria Land, Antarctica., Annals Glaciol., 7, 34-41, 1984a. Nishio, F., T. Katsushima, H. Ohmae, M. Ishikawa and S.Takahashi,Dirt layersandatmospherictransportation of volcanicglassin bareice areasneartheYamatoMountains in QueenMaud Land andtheAllan I-hllsin Victoria Land in Antarctica,Nat. Inst. Polar Res. Spec.Issue,34, 160-173, 1984b. Oeschger,H. The contributionof ice corestudiesto the understandingof environmental processes,in, GreenlandIce Core:Geophysics,Geochemistry_, andtheEnvironment, editedby C.C. Langway,Jr., H. Oeschger,andW. Dansgaard, 9-17, Am. Geophys.Union,Geophysical Monograph33, Wash.D.C., 1985 Palais,J.M., Tephra layersand ice chemistryin the Byrd-Stationice core,Antarctica,PhD. dissertation,516 pp.The Ohio StateUniv., Columbus,Aug. 1985. Parker, B.C., E.J. Zeller and A.J. Gow, Nitrate fluctuationa in Antarctic snow and fun: Potential sources and mechanisms of formation, Annals Glaciol., • 243-248, 1982. Schwander, J. Lufteinschluss im eis von Gronland und der Antarktis,messungder elektrischenleit fahigkeitvon eisprobenfur ldimatologisheanwendungen, PhD. dissertation, Univ. of Bern, Switz., 1984. Thompson,L.G. andE. Mosley-Thompson,Spatial distributionof microparticles withinAntarcticsnow-fall, Annals Glaciol., 3, 300-306, 1982. Tomblin, J.F., The SouthSandwichIslands:II The Geology of Candlemas Island, Brit. Antarct.Surv.Sci.Rpt.92, 1-33, 1979. Watkins, N.D. andT.C. Huang,Tephrain abyssalsediments eastof North Island,New Zealand,chronology,paleowind velocity and paleoexplosivity,N.Z.J. Geol. Geophys., 20, 179-198, 1977. Young, N.W., M. Pourchet,V.M. Kotlyakov, P.A. Korolev andM.B. Dyugerov, Accumulationdistributionin the IAGP area,Antarctica:90øE-150øE,AnnalsGlaciol.,3, 333-338, 1982. J. Palais,GraduateSchoolof Oceanography, U.R.I., Narragansett,R.I., 02882. P. Kyle, Departmentof Geoscience,New Mexico Instituteof Mining and Technology,Socorro,N.M., 87801. E. Mosley-Thompson,Byrd PolarResearchCenter,Ohio StateUniversity,Columbus,Ohio, 43210. E. Thomas,Lamont-DohertyGeologicalObservatory, Palisades, N.Y. 10964. (Received accepted March 17, April 27, 1987; 1987.)