Martlets Hospice Quality Accounts 2012-2013 Part 1 CHIEF EXECUTIVE STATEMENT Statement by Caroline Lower, Chief Executive Welcome to the Quality Account Report, 2012-13, of the Martlets Hospice. The Martlets Hospice continues to fulfil its vision for supporting all those in Brighton & Hove who are facing the end of life, in particular those with complex needs regardless of their diagnosis. Through its ability to generate significant income from a variety of sources the Martlets also continues to supplement the NHS in providing end of life care to the level of over £3.4m a year. On behalf of myself and the Board of Trustees, I would like to thank all of our staff and volunteers for their achievements over the past year. Despite the huge challenges arising from the on-going economic austerity in the country the Hospice has continued to provide high quality services to a greater number of people. Our report provides you with a summary of our performance against selected quality measures for 2012/13 and our initiatives and priorities for 2013/14. The Martlets Hospice is highly committed to quality improvements at all levels of its services. We have developed this approach to quality over many years and have worked hard to embed a culture of clinical improvement within all our services. This is achieved in two ways through the Clinical Governance Group, made up of representatives from all of the services, which meets bi monthly and undertakes all audits and ensures implementation of desired quality improvements. Secondly a formal Sub-Committee of the Board, chaired by a Trustee maintains a watchful overview of all clinical governance and quality improvement processes. This report demonstrates our continued commitment to ensuring patients receive the best possible care. Within the clinical practice of the Hospice there is a culture of continuous quality improvement, in which shortfalls are identified and acted upon quickly and complaints used as opportunities for learning. Our priorities last year included: 1. Increasing volunteer involvement. 2. Becoming more proactive in gaining service users views. 3. Increasing the safety and well-being of patients by the installation of an updated nurse call system. This report demonstrates how these priorities have been achieved and also features the work of the Bereavement Counselling Service with particular emphasis on the experiences of the users of the service. I am very pleased to have the opportunity to convey all that we are trying to achieve and to confirm my personal commitment to continuous improvement. I am responsible for the preparation of this report and its contents. To the best of my knowledge, the information reported in this Quality Account is accurate and a fair representation of the quality of healthcare services provided by our Hospice. Caroline Lower Chief Executive June 2013 Part 2 LOOKING FORWARD: PRIORITIES FOR IMPROVEMENT 2013 – 2014. 2.1 Priorities for improvement Throughout the previous year we have identified many quality improvements that could be made over the next 12 months. In selecting our priorities we have been mindful of national and local policy as well as those issues which are of concern to our service users, our workforce, our partners and our Trustees. The priorities we have selected will impact directly on each of the priority areas: Patient safety; Patient experience; Clinical effectiveness Following our assessment the top priorities for the year 2013-2014 are set out below:Priority 1: Achieving access to the NHS electronic network. Priority 2: Improve access to hospice services Priority 3: Increased engagement with service users. Priority 1: Patient safety Achieve access to the NHS electronic network (N3/COIN). Access to N3/COIN will greatly improve information flow and subsequently the quality of care provision. How was this identified as a priority? The Hospice is now working closer with NHS providers than ever before. Access to N3/COIN will improve efficiency between teams and ultimately improve the patient/carer experience. For example all teams caring for a person will be able to electronically access blood tests; X-ray and scan results, which will have direct benefit to the effectiveness of patient care. How will this be achieved? The Hospice needs to be compliant with all information governance requirements. To evidence this, the Hospice needs to successfully complete the NHS Information Governance Toolkit annually. Priority 2: Clinical Effectiveness Improve access to Hospice services The Palliative Care Partnership is a partnership between Sussex Community NHS Trust and the Martlets Hospice. The partnership started in April 2013 and provides a 7 day week specialist palliative care visiting service, and 7 day a week central telephone access point (hub) with a single telephone number for advice, support and referrals. The partnership will give access to wider support services for palliative and end of life care patients, irrespective of diagnosis, including pre and post bereavement support, welfare benefits advice, spiritual care, social worker, creative therapies, complementary therapies and volunteer visiting services. How was this identified as a priority? Although there has always been a close working partnership between Sussex Community NHS Trust and the Martlets Hospice, this partnership formalises the arrangement which will include shared electronic patient records and a single telephone number for access to end of life care services. How will this be achieved? The partnership has only just started but by collecting accurate statistics and feedback from service users we aim to evidence increased numbers of people dying in their preferred place; an increase in patients accessing care with conditions other than cancer; and reduction in inappropriate hospital admissions. Priority 3: Patient Experience Increased engagement with service users. The Martlets Hospice values the views of all its service users. We already gain feedback from patients and carers about their experiences of the Hospice services. Generally the feedback is excellent although there are times where we do not get it right and there are always things that we can improve upon. How was this identified as a priority? It is essential that the hospice works with service users to ensure that the hospice is delivering what service users need and want. How will this be achieved? We would like to form a users group who advise the Hospice on any userrelated matters. The group will use its experience to provide feedback on potential changes and to propose enhancements to existing services and facilities. The group would also be involved in reviewing patient/carer feedback and reviewing documentation. LOOKING BACK: PROGRESS MADE 2012 – 2013. Following our assessment the top priorities for the year 2012-2013 were as follows: Priority 1: Increasing volunteer involvement. Priority 2: Becoming more proactive in gaining service users views – both positive and negative. Priority 3: To increase the safety and well being of patients by the installation of an updated nurse call system. Priority 1: Increasing volunteer involvement. This is an ongoing aim of the Hospice but in the last 12 months we have made progress. We now have a volunteering visiting service which started in January 2012 and to date the service has had 37 referrals and made contact with 35 people. Within the Hospice itself we have volunteers facilitating art activities to In-Patient patients and carers. This has been especially poignant when patients and families work on a piece of art together that then becomes a lasting memorial after their loved one has died. Priority 2: Becoming more proactive in gaining service users views – both positive and negative. One of the ways we wanted to gain feedback from those who use our service was through a simple focussed discussion. This is valuable in that it puts the feedback into context and face to face discussions are always more meaningful. To do this the person in charge of the In-Patient unit was going to meet with patients and families a few days after admission onto the In-Patient unit. The person in charge is meeting with the majority of patients/carers early in their admission. This was originally purely to gain feedback however the focus has changed and it has also become a valuable way of forming a very basic but important relationship with patients/carers early on in their stay with us. Priority 3: To increase the safety and well being of patients by the installation of an updated nurse call system. The new nurse call system has been installed and is working well. The greatest visible benefit is for patients who want to remain as independent as possible and are able to walk in the garden or other parts of the Hospice but still need the security of a mobile nurse call bell system where they can call for nurse assistance when needed. PART 3 STATEMENT OF ASSURANCE The following are statements that all providers must include in their Quality Account. Many of these statements are not directly applicable to palliative care providers, however, we are still required to include specific statements. 3.1 Review of Services During 2012-2013 the Martlets Hospice supported the NHS commissioning priorities with regard to the provision of end of life care by providing: Hospice at Home services which includes end of life care as well as respite care. 18 bed In-Patient Unit which also includes NHS Continuing Healthcare Funded Beds In addition the Hospice has provided the following services through charitable funding: Bereavement Support Services through professional counsellors and bereavement volunteers. Volunteer visiting service 3.2 Income generated The income generated by the NHS services reviewed in 2012-2013 represents less than one third of the total income generated by Martlets Hospice for 2012-2013. The NHS provided funding through a grant for the partial running costs of InPatient beds. Through contracts, funding was also provided for two NHS continuing healthcare beds and the Hospice at Home services. The remaining income is through charitable donations and through fundraising events, shops and lottery. 3.3 Participation in Clinical Audit During 2012-2013 no national clinical audits or confidential enquiries covered NHS services provided by the Martlets Hospice. The Martlets Hospice only provides palliative care. During the 2012-2013 period the Martlets Hospice participated in no national clinical audits and no confidential enquiries as it was not eligible to participate in any. The national clinical audits and national confidential enquiries that the Martlets Hospice was eligible to participate in during 2012-2013 are as follows: None. The Martlets Hospice was not eligible in 2012-2013 to participate in any national clinical audits or national confidential enquiries and therefore there is no information to submit. As a provider of specialist palliative care the Martlets Hospice is not eligible to participate in any of the national clinical audits or national confidential enquiries. This is because none of the 2012-2013 audits or enquiries related to specialist palliative care. The Hospice will also not be eligible to take part in any national audit or confidential enquiry in 2013-2014 for the same reason. 3.4 Hospice Clinical Audits Clinical audit is a way in which the organisation can learn and improve the delivery of its services, the outcomes for patients and the experience they have. The Martlets Hospice has undertaken a programme of audits during 2012/13. Clinical staff are involved in the audit processes and a number of staff have led audits; in particular infection control audits. If issues are identified during audit an action plan is developed and reviewed. Progress on the action plans is monitored through the Clinical Governance Group to ensure that they are completed. We will then undertake a further audit to see if the actions we have taken have resolved any issues that were identified. Audit/review Date reported Electronic record keeping audit July and September 2012 Achievement of preferred place of care Recording of informed consent May 2012 June and October 2012 Medication – controlled drugs April 2013 Medication – general April 2013 Medication – accountable officer Medication – syringe driver Medical gases audit. Infection control audits Hospice at Home feedback from carers audit Ongoing May 2012 November 2012 May 2012 May 2012 Uniform audit November 2012 In-Patient Unit carers feedback report September 2012 Discharge process audit September 2012 Reviewing of all complaints whether informal or formal Reported every 4 months Reviewing of all accidents, incidents and near misses recorded Reported every 4 months Reviewing of all drug errors/near misses Reported every 4 months 3.5 Research The number of patients receiving NHS services provided or subcontracted by the Martlets Hospice in 2012-2013 that were recruited during that period to participate in research approved by a research ethics committee was: None. 3.6 Use of the Commissioning for Quality and Innovation (CQUIN) payment framework The Martlets Hospice income in 2012-2013 was not conditional on achieving quality improvement and innovation goals through the Commissioning for Quality and Innovation payment framework because it is a third sector organisation and as such was not eligible to participate in this scheme during the reporting period. 3.7 The Care Quality Commission The Martlets Hospice is required to register with the Care Quality Commission. The Martlets Hospice is required to undertake only regulated activities at the following location: Martlets Hospice, Wayfield Avenue, Hove, East Sussex. BN3 7LW. The Martlets Hospice is subject to periodic reviews by the Care Quality Commission and the last on-site inspection was 31st October 2012. The report can be viewed on the Care Quality Commission website. The Martlets Hospice has not participated in any special reviews or investigations by the Care Quality Commission during 2012-2013. 3.8 Data Quality The Martlets Hospice did not submit records during 2012-2013 to the Secondary Users service for inclusion in the Hospital Episode Statistics which are included in the latest published data. This is because the Martlets Hospice is not eligible to participate in this scheme. However, the Martlets Hospice does submit data to the Minimum Data Set (MDS) for the Specialist Palliative Care Services collected by National Council of Palliative Care on an annual basis, with the aim of providing an accurate picture of Hospice and specialist palliative care service activity. The service activity for the Bereavement Counselling Service is in Part 4. 3.9 Information Governance Toolkit attainment levels The Martlets Hospice achieved Level 2 compliance for the year 2012-2013. This means that we are compliant with Connecting for Health’s standards and this should provide patients with the confidence that their information is dealt with correctly and safely. 3.10 Clinical coding error rate The Martlets Hospice was not subject to the Payment By Results Clinical Coding Audit during 2012-2013 by the Audit Commission. Part 4 QUALITY OVERVIEW We have chosen to present an evaluation of the Bereavement Counselling Service. It is very important that we get feedback on all our services and counselling is no exception. Bereavement counselling is offered to all families that have been in contact with the hospice via the In-Patient unit or Hospice at Home. Most people are supported through bereavement by their family and friends, but some people may need input from a specialist, like a counsellor. Data collected from January 2011–December 2012 Evaluation sent 1-2 weeks following ending of counselling/assessment sessions included. Number of evaluations sent: 119 Number of client responses: 63 (52%) Length of counselling: 2011 2012 Up to 3 months: 17 21 3-6 months : 4 11 Over 6 months : 5 4 Average number of sessions per client: Approx 9 [this number not completely accurate it is only an estimate based on data given by clients which in some cases has been guessed] Number of evaluations received back per counsellor: **** 15 **** 29 **** 18 1 returned blank Client’s impressions on number of sessions received: Too many: Too few: About right: 1 0 62 Impressions of the counselling Number of Clients Rating 0 not at all Percentage 10 very much Average To express feelings 35 13 10 3 1 10 9 8 7 6 56% 21% 16% 5% 1% 9.2 To feel listened to 38 10 11 2 1 10 9 8 7 6 61% 16% 18% 3% 1% 9.5 To explore worries and concerns 38 11 11 2 1 10 9 8 7 6 61% 18% 18% 3% 1% 9.3 To cope with loss 31 10 12 5 1 1 1 2 10 9 8 7 6 5 3 blank 51% 16% 19% 8% 2% 2% 2% 8.9 Overall was the counselling helpful 46 8 5 1 1 10 9 8 7 3 75% 13% 8% 1% 1% 9.5 Rating of the service in general Number of Clients Rating 0 poor 5 excellent Percentage Average Initial Impressions 49 12 1 1 blank 5 4 3 79% 19% 1% 4.7 Ease of access 52 6 3 2 blank 5 4 3 85% 10% 4% 4.8 Waiting times 53 9 1 blank 5 4 85% 14% Frequency of sessions 47 11 3 2 blank 5 4 3 77% 18% 4% 4.7 Environment in which counselling took place 48 13 1 1 blank 5 4 3 77% 20% 2% 4.7 4.8 Clients were asked to add anything else about how the counselling has helped: I found it comforting and nice to speak to someone other than family. I found the book - A Time to Grieve that ***** loaned me extremely helpful and it helped me to address and discuss many of the emotions I was feeling. I will continue to refer to the copy I then bought for myself as time goes on. It was just lovely to have someone to talk to who was very understanding to how I was feeling, as not having anyone close to me that I could really talk to it was great that **** got me on the start of the road to recovery. Thank you again x When I first went to see **** I was in a very BAD place. She was absolutely EXCELLENT. I did approach CRUSE before I phoned the Martlets and was told I had to wait 3 months, I saw **** within 1 week. Many thanks. I have many friends and family to talk to but if I cry with them I cut it off fairly quickly. With **** I could just cry for the whole hour if that was how I was feeling. A marvellous service - can't thank you enough - **** is an excellent counsellor. It normalised and contextualised my experience. I am enclosing a donation. **** has helped me see me for myself, to understand life and how to cope with it. Without her help I would have given up, she is a total credit to your team and I will always be grateful to have had **** as my counsellor at the worst time in my life. **** made me feel normal I thought I was going mad, but I felt very safe seeing **** thank you. The counselling has helped me move on with my life, I can now move forward. I would like to thank **** for helping me through a difficult time. Although I only saw **** twice (absolutely enough) the experience was so positive that even three months on I still reflect on some of the issues we went through and because of her amazing skills I feel so positive and have moved on considerably thanks to ****. I am young and the fact that the counselling was free meant that I was able to have the help I needed when my Mum died without worrying about the cost. I was also grateful that the Martlets was so easy to contact, they always called me back and were flexible with dates and times for appointments. The first session was helpful. I left the second session feeling angry and upset. I felt relieved to express my feelings, emotions and fears to someone not connected to my family and friends and reassured that should I ever need it there is someone to turn to. I think it would have been better to have one more session, but 1 has made me feel good. The Counselling helped by taking some of the weight of the loss, it enabled me to share out the load rather than keeping my grief all in or loading it into those close to me. It has been a safety valve and a safety net. I am very grateful that I was able to access **** support and advice and counselling skills over the last year or so. For my particular circumstances, her support has been crucial in helping me deal with the death of my partner. I still feel I have a long way to go, but knowing that **** was there when things were really bad has made a significant difference and helped me to feel less alone. Good to feel you could talk without having to take anyone's feelings into consideration. Family members are also grieving and so being entirely honest is sometimes difficult. **** was a good sounding board and helped me a lot. It helped because she wasn't anything to do with the family. It was private. I am so impressed with the counsellor's skills in bringing out my feelings. It has helped me think about life and carrying on without the sadness that was weighing me down. An extremely good service. I'm very grateful. It was a big support. Gave me 'tools' and skills to cope. Taught me to 'live in the moment' and not to race ahead. Allayed any fears of how I'd cope in the future as help would be available for me. Helped me sleep better as I could offload. Invaluable to me, excellent service, thank you so very much. I was awash with grief. I can't thank **** enough for the counselling. She was superb - as is the service provided by the Martlets. It helped me to quantify my grief and get things into perspective. I was made to feel I could continue past 6 sessions if I needed it and ending the sessions was mutually agreed. Without the counselling from **** I don't know what I would have done. **** has helped me re-integrate with the world around me and made me positive about the future. I found it very helpful in so many ways, it's a wonderful service you provide and it's nice to know it's still there if I feel like I need to go back. It was very kind of you to help me! I miss my mum and will never stop. I look at life differently now and it has made me feel half the man I was but we must carry on! Maybe she is watching, but thank you for taking the time out for me, I would like to do some work for you but not until the summer. Maybe you need a driver to pick up and take people home after visits. I would love to help! Q 1: Due to not contacting me earlier. 5: How to deal and help my children in their grief. Without this service I'm sure I would have ended up having a nervous breakdown. I cannot thank and praise the Martlets enough. It was really helpful that my first counselling session took place before my father's death. I was able to explore how I was coping with my father's terminal illness as well as looking at how I would take over full-time caring role of my mother. **** helped me through life changing events and has taught me the importance of taking care of myself. **** has also made it possible for me to contact her in the future should I feel the need of her counselling service again. The support was very helpful. I feel that having counselling at the time I did was a great help - it is wonderful that it is available at any time, placing 'no limit' on the length of time grieving takes. The counselling helped me through a very difficult period of facing the reality of the death of my husband. This continues to be helpful in facing my loss and changes to my life. **** is very kind and is a great listener. I felt I could talk about anything. **** helped me understand a lot of how I was feeling, and took the time to explain why. I have found my sessions with **** incredibly constructive. Thanks again. Excellent service - I am grateful for the concern and care I received- thank you very much. Counselling has helped me move on. To have had it at the Martlets. I don't feel alone in my sadness, I know I can call anytime and an appointment will be arranged for me to see someone. This helps me a lot. I feel that this is a wonderful service offered by the Martlets – thank you very much. It has helped me immensely after losing my Dad. The counselling also helped me address other problematic areas in my life that I was finding hard to cope with whilst grieving. Counselling helped me greatly to understand and cope with the process of grieving. The support I feel that the counselling process has enabled me to accept and live with my sadness and loss. Question 4a & 4d were difficult to answer so I have left them blank. I have always been able to express my feelings and I am still unsure as to how I am coping with my loss. I am extremely grateful to the service. Thank you very much. I thought that **** was a very caring and understanding counsellor. She was extremely professional in her approach. **** helped me through a very difficult time in my life, not only was I grieving my mother I was in trouble with the police and other problems. I couldn't have got through this difficult period of my life without the help and understanding of ****. Sorry for the delay in my reply... I found my whole experience at the Martlets truly amazing... Especially as I was only a friend of the bereaved, I feel really grateful to have been offered counselling. It got me through some very difficult times, as I am a single parent and found the support and understanding invaluable and I felt the counselling really empowered me in helping the bereaved family and also helped me support my own daughters in their grief too! Thank you so much for offering me this service. It was good to be asked if I would like the counselling - I probably wouldn't have initiated it myself and it has been very beneficial. You do not need to improve the service you provide. You are angels and help everybody you meet. With the help of **** and her wonderful insight I was able to feel a sense of strength and clarity through the grief and confusion in the early days of my loss. Coming in to see her for our regular sessions over this year has been like having a safe harbour to come in to from the turbulent seas all around. I honestly believe that it has helped me and my children to cope so much better and to truly believe that we can go on to a future of meaning and fulfilment. I was at the lowest time of my life and at breaking point myself, so heartbroken. **** has taught me how to live a day at a time and to look to the future but to still hold on to all my precious memories. I appreciated the flexibility - occasionally re-arranging and agreeing to continue for rest of year although less frequently. Might be good in central Brighton re access but maybe it is more appropriate in Hospice. Clients were invited to comment on anything they felt had not helped: You cannot improve on perfection. I left the second session feeling very angry and upset. N/A Suggestions for how the service might be improved: Because of my part-time working hours it was sometimes difficult to arrange a mutually convenient time, but **** did everything she could to accommodate me. I really can't think of anything that could improve this wonderful service except more funding to help even more people. Thank you. Counselling should be more understanding. I think you have it just right because I have options to ring **** up to have more if I want. In relation to e) above, it was difficult returning to the place where my Mum died - but **** was aware of how I might be feeling and, in the end it gave me a 'safe' place to cry and explore my feelings of loss and fears. SUPPORTING STATEMENTS As required by the regulations, this document has been sent to the Brighton and Hove Clinical Commissioning Group for comment.