Discovery Institute, WA
05-22-07
Iowa State Promotes Atheist Professor Who Equates Bible with Mein Kampf
While Denying Tenure to ID Astronomer
While Iowa State University denied tenure this spring to gifted pro-ID
astronomer Guillermo Gonzalez, it turns out that it decided at the same time to
promote to full professor outspoken atheist Hector Avalos, religious studies
professor and faculty adviser to the ISU Atheist and Agnostic Society.
Avalos has led the charge against Gonzalez and intelligent design on ISU's
campus, helping to draft a 2005 petition denouncing intelligent design that
ultimately was signed by more than 120 ISU faculty.
Apparently ISU professors who are horrified by the supposed mixing of
metaphysics and scholarship on the part of ID proponents have no qualms about
supporting Avalos's explicit anti-religious propaganda, including his effort to
equate the Bible with Hitler's Mein Kampf (for more on Avalos's view of the Bible,
see below). It is worth pointing out that ISU issued a press release a few years
ago boasting about Avalos's appointment as the executive director of a group
affiliated with the Council for Secular Humanism that seeks to debunk religion.
Avalos's promotion to full professor comes just in time for the publication of his
new book on the Bible later this month. According to the publisher's description,
Avalos argues in the book
that our world is best served by leaving the Bible as a relic of an ancient
civilization instead of the "living" document most religionist scholars believe it
should be. He urges his colleagues to concentrate on educating the broader
society to recognize the irrelevance and even violent effects of the Bible in
modern life.
Just how extreme Avalos's view of the Bible is can be seen in his previous book,
Fighting Words: The Origins of Religious Violence (2005), in which he repeatedly
equates the Bible with Hitler's Mein Kampf. Indeed, in a section of the book titled
"Scripture: A Zero-Tolerance Argument," Avalos actually suggests that the Bible
is worse than Mein Kampf:
In fact, Mein Kampf does not contain a single explicit command for genocide
equivalent to those found in the Hebrew Bible... Thus, if all of Mein Kampf is to
be rejected simply for its implied genocidal policies, we should certainly reject all
of the Bible for some of its explicit and blatant genocidal policies. [p. 363]
At other points, Avalos appears to blame Jewish people for Hitler's attempt to
exterminate them, locating the origins of the Holocaust in what he calls "Hebrew
racism." Consider the following passages:
"The purpose here is to show that the Nazi policy of genocide was based on
premises quite similar to those in the Hebrew Bible." [p. 316]
"the Nazi Holocaust represents the synthesis of attitudes found in both the
New Testament and the Hebrew scriptures." [p. 318]
"[Scholars Katz and Wolpoff] fail to see the parallels between certain practices
promulgated in the Hebrew Bible itself. Indeed, the supreme irony of the
Holocaust is that the genocidal policies first systematically enunciated in the
Hebrew scriptures were reversed by the Nazis. Nazi ideology simply had better
technology to do what biblical authors had said they would do to their enemies."
[pp. 318-319]
"Hitler saw himself as trying to counteract Hebrew racism, which he saw as the
main counterpart and enemy of the German race." [p. 319]
As if these statements were not enough, Prof. Avalos has equated creationism
with Nazism, denounced religion-inspired acts of love, and even suggested that
we "eliminate religion from human life altogether":
"Nazi ideology is similar to creationist ideology, which believes that scientific
findings support the biblical stories of Creation and the Flood." [p. 318]
"any act of love based on religion is immoral." [p. 369]
"Mother Teresa... advocated policies that helped to generate the very pool of
poor people she was attempting to help. Religious beliefs are largely responsible
for arguments against contraception, which helps to perpetuate poverty and
conflicts over scarce resources. So in the end, did Mother Teresa help more
people than were harmed by her religious belief?" [p. 370]
"until the Abrahamic religions overthrow the master-slave model in which they
were born, we see little progress to be made. Since all religious beliefs are
ultimately unverifiable, the greatest scarce resource of all is verifiability. And one
way to remedy or minimize unverifiability in any decision-making process,
especially that leading to violence, is to eliminate religion from human life
altogether." [p. 371, emphasis added]
Iowa taxpayers can be relieved to know that ISU is making sure their tax dollars
will be spent on worthy scholars like Prof. Avalos rather than disreputable
astronomers like Dr. Gonzalez.