For Information
S.02-81
45
Annual Report on Student Discipline Matters
avmv-dEcL
oj-
2001/2002
University Board on Student Discipline **
Senate Committee on Disciplinary Appeals **
Statistical Summary - Registrar *
Statistical Summary - Director, Campus Community Services *
.
Section 11.1 of Policy T10.01 states: "The Registrar and the Director of Campus
Community Services shall maintain a statistical summary of cases which are
handled through their offices each year, and these data shall be included in the
Annual Report on Student Discipline Matters."
** Section 11.2 of Policy T10.01 states: "In addition to the data in 11.1, the Annual
Report on Student Discipline Matters will contain a summary of the UBSD
Tribunal's decisions, the President's decisions, SCODA's decisions and the penalties
imposed. This report will be accessible to the University community and will be
submitted to Senate for information.....
L
University Board on Student Discipline
Reporting Period: September 2001 to November 2002
S
The University Board on Student Discipline dealt with fifty-one cases involving
allegations of academic dishonesty in the period covered by the report.
In addition, three cases are currently outstanding; one matter was received by the Board
but referred to the Registrar for action; and three cases which were originally referred to
the Board were withdrawn by the referring Department.
A summary . of the cases dealt with by the UBSD is attached for the information of
Senate.
UBSD Membership
Faculty
Students
Staff
Joan Brockman
Co-Ordinator
(to October 2003)
Terri Lacourse
(to July 2003)
Caryn Cameron
(to October 2002)
Eng Choo
(to October 2002)
Reza Pourvali
(to August 2003)
Barbara Leighs
(to July 2004)
Tina Loo
(to October 2003)
Leeanna Simons
(to July 2003)
Yvonne Tabin
(to October 2003)
Howard Trottier
(to October 2004)
Harry Yang
(to November 2002)
Professor Joan Brockman
Co-Ordinator
University Board on Student Discipline
I.
tN
0
z
0
—I
C
4)t
a
• .-•
IQ)
-0 cu
'•D
0
Cl)
Q•)
U)
E-
UU)
cs
to4).E
E
4)0
E-z
Cl).
4)
Ivu T
CJUO(L)
4)0U
.
I•
2
4)
-Q)
-
-
'
E
S
4)
2
Uu
4)
L
E
U0
IF.
Q)C.
C'
4).0
0
-DCl)
U
P.0
(4
w
-I
(40
U'
E
Q)
0 4)
w-
2')
cn Cl)
.tj
U-_
-. a) a)
Q)•
€
SCl)
cu 2
Cl)O)
4)Q)C•
2d
(4
CA
cu
"a
4)
) 0
-•
U)
(l)
I
•°
E4. bO -U
• '-.E
0,
4) .
c40)0
(1)4)
0 to
0
CUE
0)
(fl
(44)
4)4)
-Q•.
-CC'
C4
4)
41(1)
a)
-
0)
00
5
E
Q)
.0C
'
L.4)
U
1) L)
a)
CI)
E
00
-0o-.0
E2
C')
0)
a W)
Cl))'
•4)U
C12
4)
Cl) Wtv
U
E•
0)E -
<
—
I
-
(J
<U
I
-
CU
Udj
I. .
T
0
at
-
CU
Cl)CU
CUb
(JO)
<)
4)4
U
om
a)
(44)
ClE)
4)
-d
i.
2
U
a)
4)
bO
4)
E
U0
Cl)
CU
U
0)
-0
cu
-CU
-dCU
-
-
Thft
bo
cu
U
Cl)
rift
a)
0
4)
Cl)
Cl)
Cl)
a)
0
C')
0
z-
rn
to
•E
U
I-
cj
r.
0
U
E
U
0
i)-
*
I
ri
0
*
14
*
*
I)
cJ.J
a)
*
*
-
•
a)
-
L-
Cl)
•_0
h
••
04)
ba
•c
-
—
Q4 V)
41(4
(4
0
n E
2
E
•,
-
0
cz
EU
00
U
U.•
Ln
4)
ICI)
E
U's
4)
C4)
C4
n
a)
E
Cl)
Cl)
tz
Cl)
Cl)
0)
(4
bO
CU
• ClE)
— bb
0)
0
• (4
Cl)0
0)0)
CU
U
<5
o•0
-0
•'
3dLI
U
4).'dE
CU
Ux
<*3)
C
$
e'1
Cl
a)
N
I
(-'I
0
CU
I-.
a)
UJ.
-d
C
0)
E
CUI-I
0)
ClE)
(UI-I
CU
Cl)
4)
C
0
Cl)
-d
U
E
0)
CU
U
C14
0
.
.
L
.
.
.
N
r1
4)
4)
0
z
0
tL
4)
CJj
(U
E
(rJ
Ln
°
I..
4)
I..
/)
-
—
4),
.n
-
44
-
44
0)
t
4)
14
(U
U
(U
2
O
'4
U
.
0
U)(8
0
'4
I-.
I..
-;
9
I..
?9
I..
-
0
0
9I..
-
I..
0
4)
.
-
-
(U
.
u 4)
4) a..
U
0E
4)
(U
.54
0
.& .
cu
(U
.t
4) 44
0
U
E
4)
M
0
(U
0
U
E
4)
(U
0
-
.
-
.9
(U
4)
E
0
U
4)
2
4) •
(U
.
-
.9
44
-
-
.9
4..
(U
4)
E
0E
V
4)
-td
.
2
4)
.9
4-a
(6
d
4)
E
E
0.
4) U)
u 4)
(U
.
'
n...
(44)
U'
-;
I..
0
F--
4)
(U
.944
-
0.
-t:$
4) U)
U)O
(44)
U4j
(U
..... 4)
4)(1)
U)
-i
U)
(U
'4
•4)
I..
4)
I..
4)
14
.4)
4)
(1)4)
c)....
'4
U)4)
.4)
•U)
U)
O)
4)
(44)
U
(U
(1)4)
E
04)
(1)4)
E
U)4)
(1)4)
4)..
.-..
E
U)Q)
.c:In
(1)4)
4)..
...
(44)
V
t1
4)
4)U)
-
4)
U)
-t
4)U)
....
-
O)U)
(1)4)
4)....
.I..
..
4)
U)
(1)4)
4)..
.,..
(U4)
Ud
(U
'dU)
4)
•-d
U)
ih
.2
(I)
-
(1) (U
I-
4)
00.
U
0
'h
(fl (13
2
.
(fl (U
(1) (U
h
E.2
4)....
. 4)4-.
(44)
U
(U
(U
...
4)
.
.9
.1-.
-
(U
0U)
'4
U)4)
4)
.
.9-S.
- tt
0
'4o
.9
-
E
4)4)
VU)
1.'..
8
UI..
_44
U)
.
U)
'4
(1)0
4)4-.
(1)0
-2j
. -fl..
4)
..
(64)
(U
4)(1)
4)
U)
.
4)U)
4)
U)
•d
4)
(44)
U
4)
Ud
(U
'd
Ei
4)U)
'J) (4
Cf
(U
(I) (U
4)
5.
(U
0
CJ
4)
14
4)
14
0
0
4)
'4
0
.54
(U
-
(U
—
(U
-
(U
6
U
I-.
0
F- -
F-
bO
6
U
(4
0
F-
LI
I-.
U
'4
Z
F-
u
cn
2
U)
cn
(U
(4
U)
(U
U)
(U
_.•
.
...
• bo
cz
4)
M
to
(U
U)
4)
•
• to
(U
4)
4)
.
'4
(U
0.
4)
4)
.5.
.2
E
0
4)
3
I-•
14
)
4)
m
4)
4)
(U
E
• I-.
0)
(U
•U)E
•
-
U)....
4)
0 0
'.
U)....
4)
U)
0(6
U)
U)
0)
U)
0
J
U
<U)
Ln
N
U(U
<0..
4),..
N
-0
0
•
0
4)
0.
U(U
<0..
()0
4)
0"a
.
CI
U:
4)
(U0.
U(U
<0.
ri
U
4)
0 -ICI
4)
4)
0 'IC3
En
.
N
4)s.
4)
(U0..
U(U
<0..
ri
-
•
4)
0-0
..2
U)
0)
U
o
.
00
. &o
-
.
. 4)..
. 4)s.
. 4)
d
.,
4)
(UQ
U(U
<0..
4)
(U0..
V
<CL
4)
4)
(U0..
U(U
<0.
(U
U0.
<
N
U
<
N
09
N
U
<
N
3.
CD
I-
c4
a)
0
a)
0
z
Ca
Cr)
Cr)
-
.
Ca
Ca
Ca
.0
Ca
0
Ca
.
Ca
Ca
Ca
0
14.
.0
,.D
SE.
—
Ca
.0
td
a..
Ca
0
0
0
0)
..o
to.
0
a..
Ca
0)
to..
-
S1-.
0
0
E.4
0
0
0
0
44
C.)•
0.
L.4-
Ca
0)
ua)
0.
U.
E
U
Ca
0)
0.
Ll.
E
Ca
Ql..
u
vO)
0
C)
(1)4)
a)
Ca
U
0.
V
0.
CJ-
0
0
0
U-
0)
uQ)
E..2
Ca
0..
ca
a)U..
(1)0)
4)
4)
(1)0)
4)
a)
.l..
4).....
-lz
0
cio
.l..
E2
0).....
Ca
u0
0
.4..
E 12
4)....
Caa)
Cj
Ca
..2
a)
C)0)
a)
a)
..2
0)
ua)
U
Ca
4)
(1)4)
..2
O)
Q)
LIa)
a)LI
a)r'
r.
Q
a)
Cal..
a)
(l)a)
F--
0
E
I...
0
F-
a..
Ca
0)
L
0
E
-o
.
F.
a..
Ca
0)
F.
.4..
Ca
E
0E
F-
.4.1
Ca
a)
F.
Ca
4.
a)
F.
'
0
0
a)
Io
Ca
SJ
Ca
d
a)
E
a)
Ua)
çJCl)
a)
Q)Z•4
a)
al..
•
0)r.0
Cl)4)
o
Q)U
(/)0)
0
-
o
-o
•l-.
E12
a)a..
Ca 0)
U
0
oa)
-o
Cl)0
0)a.
.l..
CaQ)
00)
Cl)0
.l..
a)....
Ca
-
.l..
2
a)....
Caa)
U-
0
c
bO
CT) Ca
W
Cl)
0)
C!) Ca
-
0
a-.
-
U
4..
2
F-
CT) Ca
.
cJ
.
CJ
a)
0)
U
co
0)
Cl)
Cl)
-
Ca
-
Ca a)
U
Ca
-tie
Ca0
Cl)
C/) Ca
Ca
0
bt
-i
Cl)
C/) Ca
0
0
0)
M
Ca
41
Ca
{l)
bO
0)
Ca
'
0
Cl)
lCa
.
Cl)
Ca
.?
Cl)
bO
0)
Cl)
r.
Ca
U)
0
.?
r)
4.4
CO
lz
0)
Cl)
bo
Ca
Cl)
r)
4.4
Ca
C/)
C))
bO
Ca
U)
Ca
U)
Cl)
bD
Ca
9b
Ca
Cl)
4)
C
1.4
ta
U)
4)
(l)
a)
0)
0-0
U....
-
U)
91)
Ca
Oo
a)
CI
-
4.4
Ca
Cl)
0)
Cl)
a)
00
-ta-.
rn
'
Ca
Cl)..)
Cl)
4)
00
....
0
.
W
.
00
..-.
-
C
00
.c:...
4)
U Ca
<0..
a)
d4)
UCa
<0..
N..
N
Q)
<0..
'0
N
N
0
U
.
v
-4
0)
0)
E
0)
<0..
LI)
N
N
0
CO
ñ
Ca
<0..
N
N
0
U
c)
N
N
0
N
0
UCa
Ca
N
NN
N
0
<
N
0
m
Ca
<04
E
a)
Ca
w
(..)
;
Ca0)
U
c(1
bC
Ca
12
4)
0
.
U)
U)
- TO
Ca
*
Cl) Ca
-bO
0
bO
Ca
U
N
N
0
-tj
Ca a)
C)
Ca
0)
a)
oa)
Cl)
l)0)
a)
0
U
i..
2
Q)
Cl)a)
0
0
o
a)
a)
U.
M-.
0
0
Ca
a)
E
0.
E
o
U
ca
8
a)
UQ)
c.
0)
ca
8
U.4
0)
3f.L.
Q)Q)
4)
U)0
oa)
Cl)a)
a)
0
.L
E..2
0)..-.
.l..
(U_
•..
-o
-
E
0.
•
.
a)r
Uil0)2 72. —2o •h. 2 Uo '. 2 2 il
Ua)
Ca
a)ç1
.—
Cl)0)
a) r
c
o a)
Cl)
Cl)a)
r.
a)..-.
.l..
a)_
Q)
it
U
co
E
Caa)
U
Ca
-
Ca0)
c)
Ca
E
-t
CaQ)
ca
Ca
U)
(0
u)
Ca
Cl)
•tj
a
Cl)
..
-
(J Ca
.-
Cl)
b$)
Ca
U)
-
Cl)
-i
Cl)
-i
bO
(I) Ca
Cl)
Ca
-id
Cl)
-t
a)
o
X.
I..
2
Ca
0
U)
.
0
FCl)
Ca
a)
U)
U
a)
rn
I..
Ca
bO
Ca
1.4
Ca
bO
Ca
.4
bO
Ca
U)..)
Qo
-—
U....
..?
U
0)
OIzl
Cl)
0)
U)...
00
.—
U)
a)
.
-
Cl)
a)
Qo
-c ..-.
•
U
4)
Q)
0-0
.
U...
a)
a)
a)
0)
4)
Ca
Ca
<0..
N
0
Ca
Ca
<0..
a)
N..
N
0
Ca
<0..
4)
'C
N
o
Ca
<0..
N
C>
Ca
<0..
0) 4
..
da)
co..
.
-
a)
CT)
Cl)
.
FU)
4..
Ca
.
Cl)
4..
Ca
I..
Ca
.
*
*
.
.
c4
CD
('4
Q).
0
0
z
0.
E
Cl)
C')
-a 2
F.
¼4_.
0 c
0
Th:
ECl
o .
aj
cn
2
asO
Q) U
Z:1
-
-
F.
-
-
-
-
0
0
4
0
0
Q)
-
0
0
QJ
c
E
E
J
.
o
u- .
E
E
o
2
QJCI
o
Q)Q)
c
.
.
-
-
as
F.
-
-°
'a.
0
0
-
oE
l)
-
&2
•-. 2
E.--g
o .
—0
0
CI
0•
0
o .
u'.
2
——
.
Cfl
E
2
aso
as
o
o
•.•0
0
øJ-t
o .
v2
C/
2
c
ao
8.
2
o
I..
o
ca
E
E
o
u- .
CI
Q)
clQ)
G)
.J
E
uQj
cu
.Q)
E.2
clQ)
./)
0)
o
•81)
v0
E
Cl)
(0
(11
(00)
.2
En
U)
CO
Ii
800)
u
c
Cl)
- 0)
0
a..
to
0
a..
-
0
a-.
(0
81)
.Q)
.?'()
cflO.j
Gj
00)
XCI)
u0
o
E
(0.2
E
-
E
.t
Cl)
Cl)
-
0)
Cl) (0
.
.Q)
•a
Q)
o U)
81)0
0)..s
u)
o 81)
81)0
Q)as
.
OQ)
CI)
...0
0) as
QJ
o° 81)
c0
(las
.
o
4JV
CC
'2
oJ 1
.
.
81)0
Q)as8
0)..
o 8fl
81)0
E2
las
(00)
cJ
.2°
co
10
2
OJas
as
M
-0
0)a.00
ba
.
Q)
it
80
r. L)
tO (I)
0
E°<
•
811<
0)
Cl)
-
(00)
u
(0.2
cn
E
•dj
U)
80
0
bO
-
as
bO
-
0
bD
as
0
-
0)
d
-
0)
Cl)
E
Cl)
0)
-
Cl)
U)
—
-
E
I..
to
(0
C
1!)
0
(OO.
co
<o.
)
..2
0 0
bO
(0
Cl)
•8...
.
p1..
0)
.?
h
0)
COO.
-'80
Q.
r
C
-
(1)
.
0)
-
Ci)
.
• Ci
•
.4
80
bO
..
bO
(0
.
E
0)
Cl)
.
•I
bo
(0
U)
•1
I-.
.
bo
..2
h
..2
..2
h
ci
C
Qa
'to
<o.
4)
0)
80
Q.
(OQ..
Qi
•.2
Oii...
'c% (u
(OCL,
CJ (0
('4
<0.
—
r1
C
oCL
C)80
C4
<0
O)
h
80
.
0)
bi)
-
.o..
U)
0)U)
-d
10)as
-
ci)
))l)
80)
i -0
(0
811 <
ci
0
(1)
bt,
0)
-
0
Cl) (0
to
a-.
80
0
C!)
-
bO
.4..
U
tO Cl)
-rj 0
•
00)
c.i
(0
0)
-<
-
o
0)
.Cl)
a..
0)
-
0)
0)
Cl)
•
Cl)
.
Cl)
•
.
(4rI
cq) c)
'•
0 0
I
bb
z
0
8)
•
.
..2
h
5
a
bO
Cl)
E
• U)
bb
(0
..2
•
CI)
I-.
bo
CO
.5
(OQ.
-'tO
0)8..
0)
<Q
0)
(O
c)80
e)
i
<0..
C14
c4
•Cj
('4
e4
(OQ_
4
57
C14
(.9
V
V
C
z
C
r'1
V
E
E
(I)
crj
g
V0
UVr.
0)
-CU)
cu
UU)
r.
U)(O
°
L10
0
V
'1:sQ)
t8
0)
VU)
Lfl
(1)
ct,
-
0
U
2
FI.
(0
CO
-U)
W
(0Ø.
<
1'
-tv
—
tt
0
0
0
CO
0
-
0
0
-
0
0
-
'.
0
0
0
F0
0
0)
0
-
E
CO
-
0)
CO
-
E
0
CO
0)
0
CO
E
0
C.)
0
CO
E
0.
QJU)
Q)U)
.(.•
J
C E
0 )
4)
o
)CI)
0
2-!
2
8
E
uQ)
V
2
O
Q
Ln
(1)0)
E
aj
1.
cu
2
0)
E
E
Q)U)
V
2
(O
U)
(0
WJL.
I..
8
V
E
30)
-20
-
0) ..-.
0)
(1)
U)
CO
-
g
0)
2
o
VU)
CO
00)
0)
o
0Q)'j
(zO)
cJ
0 z
0) ..-.
.I..
U C..
COO)
V -
(JçQ)
.
U)
C0
0)
CI)
I..V
0
C!)
VI..
0
CO
F--
U
.
(0
U)
E
F-
U
(0
CO
CO
0w
.
E 12
V ..-.
CJ
ui..
E 1
0) —
9
0) ....
COW
'J!
CO
€00)
U)
U)
COW
U(O
(JT
0
U)
€00)
CJ(0
(1)0)
(1)0)
03
(1)0
V ....
1i
€00)
'-,-j
C0
d
MW
'
mw
g
m w
U)
E
E
mo
C..
t0C..
V
(0 (0
0)4
00)
:S
F-0
o
—2
Q)U)
-
U
uij
?
-
U)
bo
CO
CO
9b
(0
U).....
W
CTJ2
O-
V
V
.
0-
0•
W
.U)
0)U)
CO
.
0 -0
(1)
(..
q)
U)
i..
U)
VCO
c
O
.
(0V
.
EoU) C04CO4
(0
U).
O-V
u
(0
L(U)
O
CT) CO
0)
U)
CO
U)
V
(I)
4.
0
0
U)
V
h
C!) CO
0
VU)
ICO
.
(OU
..C..
(00
0
t
UE
CO
c.E..9
V
V,
C0 V U(0
COCV
U,
<C.. <c..
EO)
V..2
'dV
COØ..O
U (0 0)
<o..
CI)
LI)
(.'
0)
C0
<
('1
LI)
C14
0)-'
CO .2
<c..2
—
cq
0)U)
COU)
<o..o
L
(4
LI)
('4
IT
('1
U)
(1) I...
2-
V.,
0))-.
COC.0
<c..
U)
0-
U).
V
'V
4-.
F-
—4-.
coi
-
0
(1)0)
8
2
0)
E
V
.
.
U)V
0
(1)0
0) ..-.
U)
€00)
CO
V
I
CT) €0
cn
0
40
•—.
-CO
r
CO
_U)
E
o
Q)CO
C
(1)
.
-
W.
(0
<o..
1'It
('1
(4
(C.
S
S
CA
CD
I-
0a)
E
0
z
0
0
(I
•
a)
OX
-ti
U)
faa)
a
0_
';-F
-;
0 V.0
(a
C "o
ca'-
20
•U)•a)..
-
a)Q)—
S
U) 0.
.—0
0
5
3
••
-
.
Q)
0
0cj
0. a)
t_4
-
E
E
3
— .1-.
i
53
2
5
Q-.
)-•
0
.-
0.
a)
a)
a)
0
a)
38
.E
W
a)
1..
0
u_
<
8
•.
.
w..
U)
u
(a.
-
'0
'
0
a)
0
0
-
-
.
a)
0
r.
8
a)U)
2
0.
J-
Q)
'4-• —
-
I.
.U)
Q)
_•I_;
.
-
0
CIS
.9—
E
LI
0
a)
Q)
Qa)
I
V)
v)0
0W
XCi)
-
a)(1)
U)
-5
..-•
(a;
(U
LI
a•'_
caa)
u(a
_a)
0.
-5 <
'<
a)
.?
Cl) (ar.
-
tu
ci
1..
2
a)
U).....
(a
bo
(a
U)
10
0
1..
U)
a)
U)
a)
a)
(a
00
(a
.?
0)
0
bo
CI) (a (F)
Q)U)II
--o
U
.
.
.
1,
_a)
.
a)I
cQ)
U
(aQ
E
0a)
jU)
-
J
u-ti
9
'i-.
-
E
0.
2
0jU)
I..
0 cu
r.E
o
U)0
LI
Th2
aa)
-
LI
(a 42
"0 'n
.— a)
E
-5
(a
a)U)
E
(0
a)
..
C!)...
0
(
.Ei
-
(a
•NO
U)
Li
1..
2
.
Cl) (a
-
Q)
E
-5
(a
U)
Q)U)
2
(I) (a
a)
L
CJU)
?-5
U)—
a)
Ci)....
0
U)
(a 0
.
(I)
a)
U
L
02
ca.
-
(a
••o
(a
E
L
...
-
U)
5-
-E
(a
•
.a)
-•
U)QJ
-
.
(a
LI
Q)
.
(F) to U)
a)U)
.4U)_
caa).u-
a)
Th9
a)
o0
.
oG.
XCI)
-•.
I-.
a)
U)
Q)
U)a)
uIa
a).-.
-'
-
-5
(a
(a
a)U)
a)
IJI
-
0
.s
(a
0
sw
2
Li
F-
•
-a:)
0
U)...
a)
(a
(a
• Eb
E
. 1..
1..
2
Q)
I—
. 1..
(a
• b
(a
'
rI).
a)
U)
Q)..
Q)
a)
(aQ
U(a
<0.
U(a
<0.
a)E..
c0Q0
U(a
<0.....
(aQ.
U
<0.
a)..
da)
(aQ
U10
0.4
C'1
'0
L.
_a)
(aQ
LJ(a
<0.
0
_a)
(aQ
U
<0
'0
Q
r4
0
as
Er)
r1
0
00
Er)
0
LO
CD
CD
Er)
r
rJ
'0
E
U)
0
-
a)
a)
U)
0
U)
(a
U
-
(a
U
M
Er)
('1
1.
File #
01-6
*
Nature of Offence
Outcome
Academic dishonesty. Plagiarism.
See Senate document S.5-1, https://docushare.sfu.ca/dsweb/Get/Document-358060/S05-1.pdf.
01-7 *
Non-academic dishonesty. Misuse of University
documents.
Referral to UBSD withdrawn by applicant.
02-1 *
Academic dishonesty. Plagiarism – 3 Undergraduate
courses and a major paper for MA Degree
Student admitted academic dishonesty. President accepted the recommendation of the Tribunal
and permanently suspended the student from the University. The student will receive Fs for each
of the papers submitted in the three undergraduate courses and for the major paper submitted for
the MA degree. In addition, recommendation will be made to Senate to revoke the BA and the
MA degrees. Degrees revoked by Senate and student requested to return degree parchments.
02-21 *
Academic dishonesty. Plagiarism.
Case pending. Unable to contact student. Note placed on student’s file – unable to register or
obtain an official transcript until case has been resolved.
* Note: UBSD case outcomes posted following the December 2, 2002 Senate meeting.
Senate Committee on Disciplinary Appeals
Reporting Period: September 2001 to November 2002
.
The Senate Committee on Disciplinary Appeals dealt with one appealsin the period
covered by the report. The case was appealed on the basis of University Policy T10.03,
Section 8.1c "that the penalty imposed was excessive".
During the reporting period SCODA held an orientation meeting for the full
membership and elected a new Chair. In addition, the Registrar appointed a new
designate as Secretary to the Committee.
A summary of the casdealt with by SCODA is attached for the information of Senate.
SCODA Membership June 1, 2001 to May 31, 2002
•
Faculty
Students
Joseph Peters *
David Paterson **
Karen Kavanagh
Peter Kennedy
Colleen Collins-Dodd
Chris Steinbach
Peter Dempster
Jaideep Gupte
Gina Fernandez
Wojtek Gerwel
Secretary: KC Bell
*
**
Chair to May 31, 2002
Vice-Chair to May 31, 2002
SCODA Membership as of June 1, 2002
Faculty
Students
Karen Kavanagh *
Joseph Peters
Colleen Collins-Dodd
Sam Black
Cathy D'Andrea
Brynn Bourke
Danny Chen
Michelle Kemper
Gina Fernandez
Secretary: Richard MacLeod
Chair to May 31, 2003
Dr. Karen Kavanagh
Chair, Senate Committee on Disciplinary Appeals
Summary - SCODA Appeals
Case Number
Outcome
Nature of Offence
02-1
Academic dishonesty.
Plagiarism in three essays in the
same course (UBSD 02-3).
Grounds of Appeal: Section 8.1c,
Policy T10.03 - excessive penalty.
SCODA denied the appeal and
upheld the three semester
suspension imposed by the
President.
02-2
Academic dishonesty.
Plagiarism. Tutor co-authored
paper with student.
(UBSD 02-57)
Grounds of Appeal: Section 8.1c,
Policy T10.03 - excessive penalty.
SCODA denied the appeal and
upheld the one semester
suspension imposed by the
President.
02-3
Academic dishonesty.
Plagiarism. Student bought
paper from tutor.
(UBSD 02-28).
Grounds of Appeal: Section 8.1c,
Policy T10.03 - excessive penalty.
SCODA upheld the appeal and
varied the two semester
suspension to one semester
suspension.
02-4
Academic Dishonesty.
Plagiarism. Student bought
paper from tutor. (UBSD 02-41)
Grounds of Appeal: Section 8.1c,
Policy 110.03 - excessive penalty.
SCODA upheld the appeal and
varied the two semester
suspension to one semester
suspension.
02-5
Academic Dishonesty. Aided the Case outstanding
commission of plagiarism by a
fellow student.
Grounds of Appeal: Section 8.1c,
Policy T10.03 - excessive penalty
imposed by Department.
02-6
Case outstanding
Academic Dishonesty.
Plagiarism. Student bought
paper from tutor. (UBSD 02-61).
Grounds of Appeal: Section 8.1c,
Policy T10.03 - excessive penalty.
02-7
Case outstanding
Academic Dishonesty.
Plagiarism. Tutor co-authored
paper with student (UBSD 02-54)
Grounds of Appeal: Section8.1c,
Policy T10.03 - excessive penalty.
q
.
Non Academic Student Discipline
January 2002 - October 31, 2002
Type of Incident:
No. of Cases:
Resolve:
Shoplifting/Theft @ SFU
Bookstore
4
Informal resolve.
Harassment/Misconduct
2
Informal resolve
Disruptive Behaviour
6
Informal resolve
Computer Misconduct
1
No action
Property Damage
1
Informal resolve
Total: 14 students
Mike Dinni gi, Director
CapmutSes
.
/0.
I
Academic Student Discipline
March 2001 - August 2002
Type of Offense
# of cases
.
Departmental Penalty
plagiarism
9
F for the course
cheating
7
F for the course/ assignment
altering exam once corrected
1
0 for first midterm and 25 for
second midterm
failing to report prior academic
performance at different
universities
1
formal reprimand from the
Registrar s Office
submitting same work in two
courses without prior approval
1
letter of reprimand
.
Total:
W. Ron Nkh
Dean of Sfudent Services and Registrar s Office
November 14, 2002
S
1/.